Barcelona Design Network Dynamics
a method to analyze creative network’s complexity
Esther Rovira Raurell, Tilburg University, NL
What is this research about?
INTRO
TESTsthe CAPACITYof actors in design NETWORKS…
INTRO
INTRO
…TO GENERATE a sufficient CONSISTENT group…
INTRO
…to reach INTERNATIONAL COMPETITIVENESS from WITHIN
What can be considered an EFFICENT network?
THEORY
Efficietn NW?
What can be considered an EFFICENT network?
CONDITIONS
6
THEORY
Efficietn NW?
THEORY
Efficietn NW?
THEORY
Efficietn NW?
THEORY
Efficietn NW?
THEORY
Efficietn NW?
THEORY
Efficietn NW?
THEORY
Efficietn NW?Efficietn NW?
THEORY
How was tested?
METHOD
METHOD
METHOD
METHOD
METHOD
CONSERVATIVE:
INNOVATIVE:
Excellence
Experimentation
Product Process
Tendency No
tendencies
Quality
Progress
INTEREST towards design
excellence flexible experience
1 2 3 4 5
METHOD
mono-
discipline
Mono-discipline multidiscipline Project interest Project diversity
1 2 3 4 5
ATTITUDE towards creative work
METHOD
100% LOCAL 75% local 50%-50% 75% global 100% GLOBAL
1 2 3 4 5
DIMENSION of action
METHOD
me & my
work
Few collab
Collabs within
same scale &
Interes
Collabs of
different sclae
BUT same
interest
Learning from
diversity
1 2 3 4 5
CONNECTIVITY capabilities
METHOD
1-3 4-6 7-9 10-12 13-15
1 2 3 4 5
POPULARITY in the network
What was found?
RESOULTS
RESOULTS
?
RESOULTS
2/3 of power positions CONNECT
!
RESOULTS
?
RESOULTS
conservative innovative
Design Power Positions interest is
CONSERVATIVE
WHILE
Design Professionals interest is INNOVATIVE
INTEREST
RESOULTS
balanced Multi-disciplinar
Design Power Positions attitude is BALANCED
WHILE
Design Professionals attitude is MULTI-disciplinar
ATTITUDE
RESOULTS
local local
Design Power Positions dimension is LOCAL
WHILE
Design Professionals dimension is LOCAL
DIMENSION

RESOULTS
!
Design Power Positions &
Design Professionals
ONLY SHARE
the local DIMENSION
local local

balanced Multi-disciplinar
conservative innovative
RESOULTS
‘The creative scene?.. (…) I am interested in many things, but not interested in another designer that makes a chair.(…) In the last ten years I have lost a little bit of interest’
‘I see everything very homogenic. Well, there are some people that capture my attention for what they do, but the scene in general I see it very flat.’
‘The creative scene?.. (…) I am interested in many things, but not interested in another designer that makes a chair.(…) In the last ten years I have lost a little bit of interest’
‘I see everything very homogenic. Well, there are some people that capture my attention for what they do, but the scene in general I see it very flat.’
?
RESOULTS
Barcelona Design network is:
- balanced in Interest
- open in Attitude
- local in Dimension
‘The creative scene?.. (…) I am interested in many things, but not interested in another designer that makes a chair.(…) In the last ten years I have lost a little bit of interest’
‘I see everything very homogenic. Well, there are some people that capture my attention for what they do, but the scene in general I see it very flat.’
‘The creative scene?.. (…) I am interested in many things, but not interested in another designer that makes a chair.(…) In the last ten years I have lost a little bit of interest’
‘I see everything very homogenic. Well, there are some people that capture my attention for what they do, but the scene in general I see it very flat.’
RESOULTS
Barcelona Design network is:
- balanced in Interest
- open in Attitude
- local in Dimension
‘The creative scene?.. (…) I am interested in many things, but not interested in another designer that makes a chair.(…) In the last ten years I have lost a little bit of interest’
‘I see everything very homogenic. Well, there are some people that capture my attention for what they do, but the scene in general I see it very flat.’
‘The creative scene?.. (…) I am interested in many things, but not interested in another designer that makes a chair.(…) In the last ten years I have lost a little bit of interest’
‘I see everything very homogenic. Well, there are some people that capture my attention for what they do, but the scene in general I see it very flat.’
ACTORS COMMENT:
‘The creative scene?.. (…) I am interested
in many things, but not interested in
another designer that makes a chair.(…)
In the last ten years I have lost a little bit
of interest’
‘I see everything very homogenic.
Well, there are some people that
capture my attention for what they
do, but the scene in general I see it
very flat.’
!
RESOULTS
?
RESOULTS
?1st
 SEIZE
popularityVSconnectivity…
POPULARITY
CONNECTIVITY
POPULARITY
CONNECTIVITY
RESOULTS
Barcelona Design agents DO NOT value
enough CONNECTING capacities
!
RESOULTS
?
RESOULTS
interest
CONSERVATIVE
attitude
MONO-DISCIPLINAR
dimension
LOCAL
ARQUI
ARCHITECT ACTOR COMMENTS:
‘In these days, there is a group of architects
setting out an association from quality not
quantity. From excellence in the manner of
facing the profession (…) the name is AxA:
Architects for Architecture. At this moment
they are the only alternative that I know of
another type of association related to the
professional interest of architects’
RESOULTS
interest
INNOVATIVE
attitude
MULTI-DISCIPLINAR
dimension
less LOCAL
MIX
MIXED SCALE ACTOR COMMENTS:
‘My ultimate goal is (…) be capable of
linking us to other institutional agents,
private foundations which will stimulate
contemporary art and craftwork focusing
on the maximum connection with other
disciplines. Something very open’
RESOULTS
MIXARQUI
Barcelona Design network IS NOT
COHERENT within its different disciplines
!
RESOULTS
?
RESOULTS
1st
 SEIZE
the network…
?
The Barcelona Design Network
THANKS to the help of: Andrés Ortiz from Bestiario
The Barcelona Design Network CLUSTERS
THANKS to the help of : Andrés Ortiz from Bestiario
RESOULTS
Found!
RESOULTS
RESOULTS
Barcelona Design network has
FEW actors CONNECTING
!
SO…,
Is the Barcelona design network EFFICIENT?
(…to turn design capabilities INTO a distinctive value from within?)
Efficietn NW?
THEORY
2/3

Efficietn NW?
THEORY
2/3

NOT sufficient
How to use this findings to IMPROVE?
CONCLUSIONS
Found!
RESOULTS
MAY 2011
Found!
RESOULTS
Barcelona Design Network ?
WORKING
on being
BETTER!
Barcelona Design Network ?
THANK
YOU
for your
attention!
COMMENTS
&
QUESTIONS
esther@estherrovira.com

Barcelona Design Network Dynamics