SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 37
Download to read offline
UPA 495 Capstone
Undergraduate Class of 2016
University of Illinois at Chicago
May 5th, 2016
Affordable Housing After
The 606 in Logan Square
and Humboldt Park
Why Are We Here?
Overview
606 Trail (Bloomingdale Line)
west of Western Avenue
1. Reaction from community
2. Hard data collection
3. Policy proposals
Research
Community Concerns
What issues would you like to see addressed in your neighborhood?
• Rent increases
• Safety
• New condominium development
Who owns the land?
Field Research
Policy Recommendations
Community Education
Demolition Fee
Fee Waiver
Land Banking
Community Land Trust
Community Education
Stigma attached to affordable
housing
Misconceived notions about it
We must present our initiatives in a
way that also educates everyone
Community Education
Proper education is the best
method to defeat potential
opposition
General studies detailing the
benefits of diverse-use
housing
Specific studies on California’s
Low-Income Housing Tax
credit
Demolition Fee
Developer Charged before a Demo-Permit is Issued
Applies only if demo isn’t replaced with affordable home
Revenue collected for Special Housing Fund
Single Family Home Multi-Unit Residential
Increasing costs to remain in home
Loss in affordable homes
Kicking-out community families
Fee Waivers for
Affordable Housing
S.M.A.R.T Housing
Incentive for developers to build units that
remain affordable--contractual obligation.
Includes fast-track project approval.
Land Banking
• Acquire and hold Vacant and Underutilized properties
• Future goal is to turn them into Community Assets
• Government organizations hold and maintain the land for 3-5 years
Areas of Interest
Land Banking - Model 1
The Genesee County Land Bank (2002)
Created by Michigan State
Partnership agreement between Genesee County and the City of Flint, Michigan.
Genesee County Land Bank
Land Banking - Model II
• Earliest Land Banks
• Land Reutilzation Program
• Diminished taxes on foreclosed lots
• Collaborated with local community development
corporations (CDCs)
Community Land Trust
● The concept is to preserve public
investment and recycle and protect
the affordability of housing.
● CLT’s acquire land through
donation or purchase
CLT Structure
● Nonprofit, 501(c)(3) community-based organizations
● Structured as subsidiaries of established nonprofit community
organizations
● Missions and plans are focused on long-term sustainability
Purpose
CLT Board Members and Governance (Tri-partite)
Community Land Trusts in U.S, 2008
Number of CLTs in the U.S
Champlain Housing Trust
• Largest and Longest Running Community Land Trust
• Average household served on an initial sale of a house or condominium
earned 69.4%of area median income
• Average household served on the resale of these same homes earned
68.6% of area median income
Homeownership Portfolio
● 435 Resale restricted owner occupied homes
● 60%Condominiums
● 40%single family homes
● NO LAND ORHOMES HAVE EVER BEEN LOST TO FORECLOSURE
Example of Resale Formula
Original appraised value (land & improvements) $200,000
Minus affordability subsidy ($50,000)
Original CLT purchase price $150,000
CLT homeowner’s share of appreciation 25%
Appraised value (land & improvements) at resale $300,000
Increase in value during ownership ($300,000 - $200,000) $100,000
Seller’s share of appreciation ($100,000 x 25%) $25,000
Resale price to next CLT homebuyer ($150,000 + $25,000) $175,000
Questions
UPA 495 Capstone
Undergraduate Class of 2016
University of Illinois at Chicago
May 5th, 2016
Presenters: Abby Dompke,Seth McClerklin, Ozie Cardenas,Annette Barbato
Land Survey Data Method
- Step 1: Determine the address and PIN of the property
(http://cookviewer1.cookcountyil.gov/jsviewer/mapviewer.html)
- Step 2: Determine property classification,2015 assessed value, and square
footage of property (http://www.cookcountyassessor.com/)
- Step 3: Determine current and previous owner of the property
(http://cookrecorder.com/search-our-records)

More Related Content

Similar to Barbatoetal_Final

State and Local Solutions for Expanding the Availability of Homes for Working...
State and Local Solutions for Expanding the Availability of Homes for Working...State and Local Solutions for Expanding the Availability of Homes for Working...
State and Local Solutions for Expanding the Availability of Homes for Working...Lynn Ross
 
City of Bridges Community Land Trust
City of Bridges Community Land TrustCity of Bridges Community Land Trust
City of Bridges Community Land Trustnado-web
 
Moving ohio forward grant program for demolition funding piqua
Moving ohio forward grant program for demolition funding piquaMoving ohio forward grant program for demolition funding piqua
Moving ohio forward grant program for demolition funding piquagreaterohio
 
Journey Aplying Tnd Prnciples To Workforce Housing Fapa 6.11.10
Journey   Aplying Tnd Prnciples To Workforce Housing   Fapa 6.11.10Journey   Aplying Tnd Prnciples To Workforce Housing   Fapa 6.11.10
Journey Aplying Tnd Prnciples To Workforce Housing Fapa 6.11.10Bill Compton
 
ULI Terwilliger Center - Ten Principles for a New Era of Multifamily Rental H...
ULI Terwilliger Center - Ten Principles for a New Era of Multifamily Rental H...ULI Terwilliger Center - Ten Principles for a New Era of Multifamily Rental H...
ULI Terwilliger Center - Ten Principles for a New Era of Multifamily Rental H...ULI Terwilliger Center for Housing
 
Moving ohio forward grant program for demolition funding
Moving ohio forward grant program for demolition fundingMoving ohio forward grant program for demolition funding
Moving ohio forward grant program for demolition fundinggreaterohio
 
Sandra Stipe's Housing Summit Presentation
Sandra Stipe's Housing Summit PresentationSandra Stipe's Housing Summit Presentation
Sandra Stipe's Housing Summit PresentationRobert Voigt
 
Defying Conventional Wisdom: A Mixed-Use Intergenerational Housing Success St...
Defying Conventional Wisdom: A Mixed-Use Intergenerational Housing Success St...Defying Conventional Wisdom: A Mixed-Use Intergenerational Housing Success St...
Defying Conventional Wisdom: A Mixed-Use Intergenerational Housing Success St...Virtual ULI
 
Is cohousing right for you? Module 4: Hopes and Fears April 26 2022
Is cohousing right for you? Module 4: Hopes and Fears April 26 2022Is cohousing right for you? Module 4: Hopes and Fears April 26 2022
Is cohousing right for you? Module 4: Hopes and Fears April 26 2022Kristopher Stevens
 
City of Bryan Neighborhood Protection Ordinances
City of Bryan Neighborhood Protection OrdinancesCity of Bryan Neighborhood Protection Ordinances
City of Bryan Neighborhood Protection OrdinancesCity of College Station
 
Cht belgium brenda torpy
Cht belgium brenda torpyCht belgium brenda torpy
Cht belgium brenda torpyCecileCLT
 
Pat conaty. clt presentation (17032015, seoul)
Pat conaty. clt presentation (17032015, seoul)Pat conaty. clt presentation (17032015, seoul)
Pat conaty. clt presentation (17032015, seoul)Eunho Chun
 
Community Land Trusts and Social/Neighborhood Outcomes in Athens, GA
Community Land Trusts and Social/Neighborhood Outcomes in Athens, GACommunity Land Trusts and Social/Neighborhood Outcomes in Athens, GA
Community Land Trusts and Social/Neighborhood Outcomes in Athens, GAAndy Carswell
 
Know your housing market
Know your housing marketKnow your housing market
Know your housing marketSue Beecroft
 

Similar to Barbatoetal_Final (20)

State and Local Solutions for Expanding the Availability of Homes for Working...
State and Local Solutions for Expanding the Availability of Homes for Working...State and Local Solutions for Expanding the Availability of Homes for Working...
State and Local Solutions for Expanding the Availability of Homes for Working...
 
City of Bridges Community Land Trust
City of Bridges Community Land TrustCity of Bridges Community Land Trust
City of Bridges Community Land Trust
 
Moving ohio forward grant program for demolition funding piqua
Moving ohio forward grant program for demolition funding piquaMoving ohio forward grant program for demolition funding piqua
Moving ohio forward grant program for demolition funding piqua
 
Journey Aplying Tnd Prnciples To Workforce Housing Fapa 6.11.10
Journey   Aplying Tnd Prnciples To Workforce Housing   Fapa 6.11.10Journey   Aplying Tnd Prnciples To Workforce Housing   Fapa 6.11.10
Journey Aplying Tnd Prnciples To Workforce Housing Fapa 6.11.10
 
ULI Terwilliger Center - Ten Principles for a New Era of Multifamily Rental H...
ULI Terwilliger Center - Ten Principles for a New Era of Multifamily Rental H...ULI Terwilliger Center - Ten Principles for a New Era of Multifamily Rental H...
ULI Terwilliger Center - Ten Principles for a New Era of Multifamily Rental H...
 
Moving ohio forward grant program for demolition funding
Moving ohio forward grant program for demolition fundingMoving ohio forward grant program for demolition funding
Moving ohio forward grant program for demolition funding
 
College Station Affordable Housing
College Station Affordable HousingCollege Station Affordable Housing
College Station Affordable Housing
 
Preservation - RE:Conference 2014
Preservation - RE:Conference 2014Preservation - RE:Conference 2014
Preservation - RE:Conference 2014
 
Sandra Stipe's Housing Summit Presentation
Sandra Stipe's Housing Summit PresentationSandra Stipe's Housing Summit Presentation
Sandra Stipe's Housing Summit Presentation
 
Defying Conventional Wisdom: A Mixed-Use Intergenerational Housing Success St...
Defying Conventional Wisdom: A Mixed-Use Intergenerational Housing Success St...Defying Conventional Wisdom: A Mixed-Use Intergenerational Housing Success St...
Defying Conventional Wisdom: A Mixed-Use Intergenerational Housing Success St...
 
Affordable Housing Addressing the Issues
Affordable HousingAddressing the IssuesAffordable HousingAddressing the Issues
Affordable Housing Addressing the Issues
 
Cuyahoga Countywide Housing Study
Cuyahoga Countywide Housing Study Cuyahoga Countywide Housing Study
Cuyahoga Countywide Housing Study
 
Is cohousing right for you? Module 4: Hopes and Fears April 26 2022
Is cohousing right for you? Module 4: Hopes and Fears April 26 2022Is cohousing right for you? Module 4: Hopes and Fears April 26 2022
Is cohousing right for you? Module 4: Hopes and Fears April 26 2022
 
City of Bryan Neighborhood Protection Ordinances
City of Bryan Neighborhood Protection OrdinancesCity of Bryan Neighborhood Protection Ordinances
City of Bryan Neighborhood Protection Ordinances
 
Cht belgium brenda torpy
Cht belgium brenda torpyCht belgium brenda torpy
Cht belgium brenda torpy
 
report.ppt
report.pptreport.ppt
report.ppt
 
45109.02 Affordable Housing
45109.02 Affordable Housing45109.02 Affordable Housing
45109.02 Affordable Housing
 
Pat conaty. clt presentation (17032015, seoul)
Pat conaty. clt presentation (17032015, seoul)Pat conaty. clt presentation (17032015, seoul)
Pat conaty. clt presentation (17032015, seoul)
 
Community Land Trusts and Social/Neighborhood Outcomes in Athens, GA
Community Land Trusts and Social/Neighborhood Outcomes in Athens, GACommunity Land Trusts and Social/Neighborhood Outcomes in Athens, GA
Community Land Trusts and Social/Neighborhood Outcomes in Athens, GA
 
Know your housing market
Know your housing marketKnow your housing market
Know your housing market
 

Barbatoetal_Final

  • 1. UPA 495 Capstone Undergraduate Class of 2016 University of Illinois at Chicago May 5th, 2016 Affordable Housing After The 606 in Logan Square and Humboldt Park
  • 2. Why Are We Here?
  • 3. Overview 606 Trail (Bloomingdale Line) west of Western Avenue 1. Reaction from community 2. Hard data collection 3. Policy proposals
  • 5.
  • 6.
  • 7. Community Concerns What issues would you like to see addressed in your neighborhood? • Rent increases • Safety • New condominium development
  • 8. Who owns the land?
  • 10.
  • 11.
  • 12.
  • 13.
  • 14.
  • 15. Policy Recommendations Community Education Demolition Fee Fee Waiver Land Banking Community Land Trust
  • 16. Community Education Stigma attached to affordable housing Misconceived notions about it We must present our initiatives in a way that also educates everyone
  • 17. Community Education Proper education is the best method to defeat potential opposition General studies detailing the benefits of diverse-use housing Specific studies on California’s Low-Income Housing Tax credit
  • 18. Demolition Fee Developer Charged before a Demo-Permit is Issued Applies only if demo isn’t replaced with affordable home Revenue collected for Special Housing Fund Single Family Home Multi-Unit Residential Increasing costs to remain in home Loss in affordable homes Kicking-out community families
  • 19. Fee Waivers for Affordable Housing S.M.A.R.T Housing Incentive for developers to build units that remain affordable--contractual obligation. Includes fast-track project approval.
  • 20. Land Banking • Acquire and hold Vacant and Underutilized properties • Future goal is to turn them into Community Assets • Government organizations hold and maintain the land for 3-5 years
  • 22. Land Banking - Model 1 The Genesee County Land Bank (2002) Created by Michigan State Partnership agreement between Genesee County and the City of Flint, Michigan.
  • 24. Land Banking - Model II • Earliest Land Banks • Land Reutilzation Program • Diminished taxes on foreclosed lots • Collaborated with local community development corporations (CDCs)
  • 25.
  • 26. Community Land Trust ● The concept is to preserve public investment and recycle and protect the affordability of housing. ● CLT’s acquire land through donation or purchase
  • 27. CLT Structure ● Nonprofit, 501(c)(3) community-based organizations ● Structured as subsidiaries of established nonprofit community organizations ● Missions and plans are focused on long-term sustainability
  • 29. CLT Board Members and Governance (Tri-partite)
  • 30. Community Land Trusts in U.S, 2008
  • 31. Number of CLTs in the U.S
  • 32. Champlain Housing Trust • Largest and Longest Running Community Land Trust • Average household served on an initial sale of a house or condominium earned 69.4%of area median income • Average household served on the resale of these same homes earned 68.6% of area median income
  • 33. Homeownership Portfolio ● 435 Resale restricted owner occupied homes ● 60%Condominiums ● 40%single family homes ● NO LAND ORHOMES HAVE EVER BEEN LOST TO FORECLOSURE
  • 34.
  • 35. Example of Resale Formula Original appraised value (land & improvements) $200,000 Minus affordability subsidy ($50,000) Original CLT purchase price $150,000 CLT homeowner’s share of appreciation 25% Appraised value (land & improvements) at resale $300,000 Increase in value during ownership ($300,000 - $200,000) $100,000 Seller’s share of appreciation ($100,000 x 25%) $25,000 Resale price to next CLT homebuyer ($150,000 + $25,000) $175,000
  • 36. Questions UPA 495 Capstone Undergraduate Class of 2016 University of Illinois at Chicago May 5th, 2016 Presenters: Abby Dompke,Seth McClerklin, Ozie Cardenas,Annette Barbato
  • 37. Land Survey Data Method - Step 1: Determine the address and PIN of the property (http://cookviewer1.cookcountyil.gov/jsviewer/mapviewer.html) - Step 2: Determine property classification,2015 assessed value, and square footage of property (http://www.cookcountyassessor.com/) - Step 3: Determine current and previous owner of the property (http://cookrecorder.com/search-our-records)