August 2020 - SIMPLE HOMOEOPATHY WINS IN COVID CASES

1. 1
Allen College of Homoeopathy
Simple Homoeopathy wins in
Covid Cases
DR. SUBRATA KUMAR BANERJEA
GOLD MEDALIST
B.H.M.S. (Honours in Nine Subjects of Calcutta University)
Fellow: Society of Homoeopaths, U.K
Fellow: Homoeopathic Medical Association of the United Kingdom.
Fellow: Association of Natural Medicine, U.K
Fellow: Akademie Homoopathischer Deutscher Zentralverein, Germany.
Director: Bengal Allen Medical Institute
Principal: Allen College of Homoeopathy, Essex, England
ALLEN COLLEGE OF HOMOEOPATHY,
"Sapiens", 382 Baddow Road,
Great Baddow, Chelmsford CM2 9RA
England
T: 44 (0) 1245 505859
E: allencollege@btconnect.com
W: www.homoeopathy-course.com
© Any duplication/reproduction without prior written consent of the Author is strictly forbidden.

2. 2
Patient – S.C. Female; 59 years, from Calcutta (India).
Diagnosis – COVID-19 Infection-- Tested Positive.
Treating Homoeopathic Doctor – Dr Subrata Kumar Banerjea, U.K.
Statement from Patient
On Monday the 29th of June 2020, it was supposed that the patient came in close
proximity / contact with a carrier of the COVID-19 virus, through domestic worker or the
two attendees who visit her to repair an electronics.
On Friday the 3rd of July, the patient developed high fever. However, it was not
constant. Whenever it came the body temperature was nearly 102 to 103◦F. So
continued until Tuesday-7-July until we consulted a local homoeopathic doctor who
prescribed some medicines and asked for developments in the next two days. There
was no appreciable changes with those medicines and patient's condition was
deteriorating. On Friday-10-July, the COVID test was done and the patient was found
positive. She was kept in isolation from Wednesday-8-July which continued until
Saturday-25-July-2020.
Added symptoms: the sense of smell and taste were lost. Dryness of mucous
membranes with pain in chest (could not describe the type of pain though Dr. Banerjea
questioned few times); pain was better by lying on that side. Constipated ++.
Then we consulted Dr Subrata Kumar Banerjea in the U.K and shared the blood report
and COVID positive test report. His medication was continued until July-25-2020.
She was advised by Dr. Banerjea to take Ferrum Phos 3X (Tissue Salt), Justicia
Adhatoda Q (Tincture) and Bryonia 30C: 1 dose to sip for 3 days followed by 200C, to
sip for 3 days. We also gave her coconut water, fruits, lime juice etc. She was also
breathing-in vapour and saline water gargle was continued. Post shower, cleaning with
Dettol was followed. Clean rooms and proper hygiene was maintained.
By the 4th day with the infection, the patient had developed chest pain when asleep
along with breathing troubles. This was accompanied with poor bowel movement,
headache and the patient was observably coughing continuously. It was a short, tickling
spasmodic type of coughing; exertion aggravates; also aggravated by slight cold air and
from lying down. Dr. Banerjea stopped Justicia and replaced that with Coccus Cacti 6X
Trituration; which worked miraculously and reduced the cough.
From Patient's Diary:
11th July, 2020 (Saturday):- Homoeopathy. Doctor - Dr. Subrata K. Banerjea; Fever -
None; Temperature - Normal; Dry Cough with Chest pain; Tiredness – Yes; Bowel –
Constipation; Thirst – Above Normal; Appetite – Normal; Smell – Lost; Taste – Lost;
SPO2 // Average – 93; Breathing – Normal; None; Headache – +; Coconut Water –
None; Lime – Supplement; Red Fruits – None.
12th July, 2020 (Sunday):- On Medication. Doctor - Dr. Subrata K. Banerjea; Fever -
None; Temperature - Normal; Dry Cough – High; Tiredness – Yes; Bowel –

3. 3
Constipation; Thirst – Above Normal; Appetite – Normal; Smell – Lost; Taste – Normal;
SPO2 // Average – 93; Breathing – Difficulty when asleep; Chest Pain – Complaining;
Headache – When Sleeping; Coconut Water – None; Lime – Juice; Red Fruits – Juice.
13th July, 2020 (Monday):- On Medication. Doctor - Dr. Subrata K. Banerjea; Fever -
None; Temperature - Normal; Dry Cough – Rare; Tiredness – Yes; Bowel –
Constipation; Thirst –Normal; Appetite – Normal; Smell – Lost; Taste – Normal; SPO2 //
Average – 93; Breathing – Difficulty when asleep; Chest Pain – Complaining; Headache
– When Sleeping; Coconut Water – Yes; Lime – Supplement; Red Fruits – Juice.
14th July, 2020 (Tuesday):- On Medication. Doctor - Dr. Subrata K. Banerjea; Fever -
None; Temperature - Normal; Dry Cough – Yes; Tiredness – No; Bowel – Normal; Thirst
Constipation; Appetite – Normal; Smell – Normal; Taste – Normal; SPO2 // Average –
93; Breathing – In certain position; Chest Pain – None; Headache – Yes; Coconut
Water – Yes; Lime – Supplement; Red Fruits – Juice. Call came from Admin Executive
Alo Das, Health Department and Send Doctors Report + Individual / Self Declaration
Contact # 9123941018.
15th July, 2020 (Wednesday):- On Medication. Doctor - Dr. Subrata K. Banerjea; Fever -
None; Temperature - Normal; Dry Cough – Yes; Tiredness – No; Bowel – Normal; Thirst
–Normal; Appetite – Normal; Smell – Normal; Taste – Normal; SPO2 // Average – 93;
Breathing – Normal; Chest Pain – None; Headache – Yes; Coconut Water – Yes; Lime
– Supplement; Red Fruits – Yes. Call came from Dr. Sukti Mukhopadhyay, Health
Department and asked patient development contact # 9830225902. KMC Dept. Came
and sanitised building externally.
16th July, 2020 (Thursday):- On Medication. Doctor - Dr. Subrata K. Banerjea; Fever -
None; Temperature - Normal; Dry Cough – Yes; Tiredness – No; Bowel – Normal; Thirst
–Normal; Appetite – Normal; Smell – Lost; Taste – Normal; SPO2 // Average – 93;
Breathing – Normal; Chest Pain – None; Headache – None; Coconut Water – Yes; Lime
– Supplement; Red Fruits – None.
17th July, 2020 (Friday):- On Medication. Doctor - Dr. Subrata K. Banerjea; Fever -
None; Temperature - Normal; Dry Cough – Minimised; Tiredness – Yes; Bowel –
Normal; Thirst –Normal; Appetite – Normal; Smell – Lost; Taste – Normal; SPO2 //
Average – 93; Breathing – Normal; Chest Pain – None; Headache – Yes all day;
Coconut Water – Yes; Lime – Supplement; Red Fruits – Yes.
18th July, 2020 (Saturday):- Medication change. Doctor - Dr. Subrata K. Banerjea; Fever
- None; Temperature - Normal; Dry Cough – Minimised; Tiredness –No; Bowel –
Normal; Thirst –Normal; Appetite – Normal; Smell –Normal; Taste – Normal; SPO2 //
Average – 93; Breathing – Normal; Chest Pain – None; Headache – None; Coconut
Water – Yes; Lime – Supplement; Red Fruits – None.
19th July, 2020 (Sunday):- On Medication. Doctor - Dr. Subrata K. Banerjea; Fever -
None; Temperature - Normal; Dry Cough – Minimised; Tiredness –No; Bowel – Normal;
Thirst –Normal; Appetite – Normal; Smell –Normal; Taste – Normal; SPO2 // Average –
93; Breathing – Normal; Chest Pain – None; Headache – None; Coconut Water – Yes;
Lime – Supplement; Red Fruits – None.

4. 4
20th July, 2020 (Monday):- On Medication. Doctor - Dr. Subrata K. Banerjea; Fever -
None; Temperature - Normal; Dry Cough – Minimised; Tiredness –No; Bowel – Normal;
Thirst –Normal; Appetite – Normal; Smell –Normal; Taste – Normal; SPO2 // Average –
93; Breathing – Normal; Chest Pain – None; Headache – None; Coconut Water – Yes;
Lime – Supplement; Red Fruits – None.
21st July, 2020 (Tuesday):- On Medication. Doctor - Dr. Subrata K. Banerjea; Fever -
None; Temperature - Normal; Dry Cough – Minimised; Tiredness –No; Bowel – Normal;
Thirst –Normal; Appetite – Normal; Smell –Normal; Taste – Normal; SPO2 // Average –
93; Breathing – Normal; Chest Pain – None; Headache – None; Coconut Water – None;
Lime – Supplement; Red Fruits – None.
22nd July, 2020 (Wednesday):- On Medication. Doctor - Dr. Subrata K. Banerjea; Fever -
None; Temperature - Normal; Dry Cough – Minimised; Tiredness –No; Bowel – Normal;
Thirst –Normal; Appetite – Normal; Smell –Normal; Taste – Normal; SPO2 // Average –
93; Breathing – Normal; Chest Pain – None; Headache – None; Coconut Water – Yes;
Lime – Supplement; Red Fruits – None.
23rd July, 2020 (Thursday):- On Medication. Doctor - Dr. Subrata K. Banerjea; Fever -
None; Temperature - Normal; Dry Cough – Minimised; Tiredness –No; Bowel – Normal;
Thirst –Normal; Appetite – Normal; Smell –Normal; Taste – Normal; SPO2 // Average –
93; Breathing – Normal; Chest Pain – None; Headache – None; Coconut Water – Yes;
Lime – Supplement; Red Fruits – None.
Over the days, with strict adherence to all medications as aforementioned the patient
had the final “feel good factor” from within and requested a return to her normal life.
We remain obliged and grateful to the medication of Dr Subrata Kumar Banerjea.

5. 5

6. 6

7. 7
Discussion: Simple Homoeopathy wins:
Bryonia prescription was based on:
Dryness of mucous membranes with pain in chest (could not describe the type of pain
though I questioned few times); pain was better by lying on that side. Constipated ++.
She was advised by Dr. Banerjea to take Ferrum Phos 3X (Tissue Salt), Justicia
Adhatoda Q (Tincture) and Bryonia 30C: 1 dose to sip for 3 days followed by 200C, to
sip for 3 days. We also gave her coconut water, fruits, lime juice etc. She was also
breathing-in vapour and saline water gargle was continued. Post shower, cleaning with
Dettol was followed. Clean rooms and proper hygiene was maintained.
Coccus Cacti prescription was based on:
Short, tickling spasmodic type of coughing; exertion aggravates; also aggravated by
slight cold air and from lying down.
BRYONIA
Physical Theme:
Dryness of mucous membranes
Effusion of serous membrane Pains: stitching
When warm weather sets in: < movement
days are hot and nights cold
Complaints > rest > pressure
From taking cold Fall weather DRYNESS,
(also ice-cold remedy THIRSTINESS,
drinks in summer, (U.S. autumn) FIRMNESS,
suppressed pers- LAMENESS,
piration) and WEAKNESS,
getting hot in SLOWNESS
summer (sunstroke) Thirst+++
Gourmand Dry-Bry
Food Constipation: Lips: dry,
stool: dry, parched
Bilious Summer hard, knotty
indigestion
Speech: hasty
Look &
Diagnose
Firm Irritability+++
Sycotic: Achy
exploitation (rheumatic
& self-centred diathesis)

8. 8
Physical Clinicals:
1. Acute: Cough & Cold; Fever; Sun-stroke; Pleuritic stitches; Angina (use tincture);
Headache.
2. Chronic: Migraine; Gastritis; Osteo-arthritis; Pneumonia; Constipation.
Coccus cacti (6X Trit.): Cough & Catarrh all winter. ECC. Tenacious, ropy, thick
mucus. Short tickling spasmodic. Cough ends in vomiting. Sensation of hair or crumb
behind larynx. Touch in mouth = gagging  coughing. Exertion= Cough. Agg. cold
air (slightest exposure), Night around 2 am, on waking, eating. Agg. entering
warm room (leaves bed clothes off – paroxysms reduces), lying down, warmth of
bed. Amel. open air.
Justicia Adhatoda (Vasaka) Q: Dryness of throat; pain during empty swallowing;
tenacious mucus in the throat which cannot be raised by coughing. Cough with
sneezing; severe dyspnoea with cough; tightness across chest; asthmatic attacks,
patient cannot endure a close, warm room; cough with wheezing sound in the throat.
Destroyer of hoarseness, and a strong arrester of blood. In coryza it is highly
curative where sneezing troubles the patient. The chest seems full of phlegm and there
is audible rattling of mucus, but very little is expectorated or it is loosened only with
repeated hawking. The expectoration consists of tough, yellowish mucus, mixed
with blood. Cough: dry, spasmodic with constriction (++). The cough of it is sometimes
dry, spasmodic, constricted. There is a violent degree of dyspnoea associated with
the cough, so much so that there is great fear of threatened suffocation. Agg. close
warm room, at night, cough with vomiting.
===========================================
Patient – San. C. Male: 38 years, from Calcutta (India).
Diagnosis – COVID-19 Infection.
Treating Homoeopathic Doctor – Dr Subrata Kumar Banerjea, U.K.
Brief Summary / Statement from Patient
On Friday the 3rd of July 2020, it is supposed that the patient cam in close proximity /
contact with a carrier of the COVID-19 virus, through his mother.
By Monday-6th of July, the patient developed fever. However, it was not constant.
Whenever it came the body temperature was nearly 101/2-F. It continued until Tuesday-
7-July until we consulted a local doctor who prescribed some medicines.
13th July, 2020 (Monday):- On Medication but no appreciable change. Changed Doctor
to- Dr. Subrata K. Banerjea; Fever - In night when asleep; Temperature - 99-100; Dry
Cough – High; Tiredness – Yes; Bowel – Loose+++ with spots of blood; Thirst – Profuse
+++; Saliva- lots & lots; Appetite – None; Smell – Lost; Taste – Lost; SPO2 Average –
Normal; Breathing – Normal; Chest Pain – Yes, when out; Headache - – Yes, when out;
Coconut Water – Yes; Lime – Supplement; Red Fruits – None.

9. 9
There was pain felt like in the bones which was bad at night. Also metallic taste in
mouth. Lots of thirst +++ & salivation +++. Extremely bad odour was noted in mouth.
14th July, 2020 (Monday):- On Medication; Doctor - Dr. Subrata K. Banerjea; Fever - In
night when asleep; Temperature - 99-100; Dry Cough – Yes; Tiredness – No; Bowel –
Loose+++ with spots of blood; Thirst – Profuse +++; Saliva- lots & lots; Appetite – None;
Smell – Lost; Taste – Lost; SPO2 Average – Normal; Breathing – Normal; Chest Pain –
Mild always; Headache - Yes, On & Off; Coconut Water – Yes; Lime – Supplement; Red
Fruits – Yes.
15th July, 2020 (Tuesday):- On Medication, Change; Doctor - Dr. Subrata K. Banerjea;
Fever - Rare; Temperature - 98-99; Dry Cough – Increase; Tiredness – No; Bowel –
Loose+: Better and no spots of blood; Thirst – Less ++; Saliva- much less; Appetite –
None; Smell – Lost; Taste – Lost; SPO2 Average – Normal; Breathing – Normal; Chest
Pain – None; Headache – Mild all day; Coconut Water – Yes; Lime – Supplement; Red
Fruits – Yes. New Symptoms May be - Meals Taste Excessively Salty.
16th July, 2020 (Wednesday):- On Medication; Doctor - Dr. Subrata K. Banerjea; Fever -
None; Temperature - Normal; Dry Cough – Yes; Tiredness – Yes; Bowel – Loose+:
Better and no spots of blood; Thirst – Less ++; Saliva- much less; Appetite – None;
Smell – Lost; Taste – Lost; SPO2 Average – Normal; Breathing – Normal; Chest Pain –
None; Headache – Mild all day; Coconut Water – Yes; Lime – Supplement; Red Fruits –
Yes.
17th July, 2020 (Thursday):- On Medication; Doctor - Dr. Subrata K. Banerjea; Fever -
None; Temperature - Normal; Dry Cough – Yes; Tiredness – Yes; Bowel – Loose+:
Better and no spots of blood; Thirst – Less ++; Saliva- much less; Appetite – None;
Smell – Lost; Taste – Lost; SPO2 Average – Normal; Breathing – Normal; Chest Pain –
None; Headache – Mild all day; Coconut Water – Yes; Lime – Supplement; Red Fruits –
Yes.
18th July, 2020 (Friday):- On Medication; Doctor - Dr. Subrata K. Banerjea; Fever -
None; Temperature - Normal; Dry Cough – Yes; Tiredness – Yes; Bowel – Better; Thirst
– Normal; Appetite – None; Smell – Lost; Taste – Lost; SPO2 Average – Normal;
Breathing – Trouble; Chest Pain – None; Headache – Mild all day; Coconut Water –
Yes; Lime – Supplement; Red Fruits – None.
19th July, 2020 (Saturday):- On Medication; Doctor - Dr. Subrata K. Banerjea; Fever -
None; Temperature - Normal; Dry Cough – Low; Tiredness – Yes; Bowel – None; Thirst
– Normal; Appetite – None; Smell – Lost; Taste – Lost; SPO2 Average – Normal;
Breathing – Normal; Chest Pain – None; Headache – Mild all day; Coconut Water –
Yes; Lime – Supplement; Red Fruits – None.
20th July, 2020 (Sunday):- On Medication; Doctor - Dr. Subrata K. Banerjea; Fever -
None; Temperature - Normal; Dry Cough – Low; Tiredness – Yes; Bowel – Poor; Thirst
– Normal; Appetite – None; Smell – Better; Taste – Better; SPO2 Average – Normal;
Breathing – Normal; Chest Pain – None; Headache – Mild all day; Coconut Water –
Yes; Lime – Supplement; Red Fruits – None.

10. 10
21st July, 2020 (Monday):- On Medication; Doctor - Dr. Subrata K. Banerjea; Fever -
None; Temperature - Normal; Dry Cough – Low; Tiredness – Yes; Bowel – Poor; Thirst
– Normal; Appetite – None; Smell – Mild; Taste – Mild; SPO2 Average – Normal;
Breathing – Normal; Chest Pain – None; Headache – Mild all day; Coconut Water –
Yes; Lime – Supplement; Red Fruits – None.
22nd July, 2020 (Tuesday):- On Medication; Doctor - Dr. Subrata K. Banerjea; Fever -
None; Temperature - Normal; Dry Cough – Low; Tiredness – Yes; Bowel – Better; Thirst
– Normal; Appetite – None; Smell – Mild; Taste – Mild; SPO2 Average – Normal;
Breathing – Normal; Chest Pain – None; Headache – Mild; Coconut Water – None;
Lime – Supplement; Red Fruits – None.
23rd July, 2020 (Wednesday):- On Medication; Doctor - Dr. Subrata K. Banerjea; Fever -
None; Temperature - Normal; Dry Cough – Low; Tiredness – Yes; Bowel – Better; Thirst
– Normal; Appetite – None; Smell – Mild; Taste – Mild; SPO2 Average – Normal;
Breathing – Normal; Chest Pain – None; Headache – Mild; Coconut Water – None;
Lime – Supplement; Red Fruits – None.
24th July, 2020 (Thursday):- On Medication; Doctor - Dr. Subrata K. Banerjea; Fever -
Mild; Temperature - Normal; Dry Cough – Rare; Tiredness – Yes; Bowel – Poor; Thirst
– Normal; Appetite – Normal; Smell – Mild; Taste – Mild; SPO2 Average – Normal;
Breathing – Normal; Chest Pain – None; Headache – Mild; Coconut Water – None;
Lime – None; Red Fruits – None.
25th July, 2020 (Friday):- On Medication; Doctor - Dr. Subrata K. Banerjea; Fever -
None; Temperature - Normal; Dry Cough – Rare; Tiredness – High; Bowel – Poor;
Thirst – Normal; Appetite – Normal; Smell – Mild; Taste – Mild; SPO2 Average –
Normal; Breathing – Normal; Chest Pain – None; Headache – Mild; Coconut Water –
Yes; Lime – None; Red Fruits – None.
Dr Subrata Kumar Banerjea in the UK recommended Ferrum Phos 3X and Mercurius
Sol. We had also consulted friends and family and gave her coconut water, fruits, lime
juice etc. He was also breathing in vapour and gargle continued. Post shower, cleaning
with Dettol was followed strictly. Clean rooms and proper hygiene had to be ensured.
Over the days, with strict adherence to all medications as aforementioned the
symptoms disappeared.
We remain obliged and grateful to the medication of Dr Subrata Kumar Banerjea.
Discussion: Simple Homoeopathy wins:
Merc. Sol. prescription was based on:
There was pain felt like in the bones which was bad at night. Also metallic taste in
mouth. Lots of thirst +++ & salivation +++. Extremely bad odour was noted in mouth.
Loss of smell & taste (psora-syphilitic miasm). Also, Bowel movement was loose+++
with spots of blood; Thirst – Profuse +++; Saliva- profuse.

11. 11
MERCURIUS SOLUBILIS HAHNEMANNII:
Physical Theme:
Extreme polarity
Leading anti-syphilitic
<< night.
Bone pains < night.
Discharges: offensive (+++)
(mercurial odour). “Salivation is salvation”
Formation of pus.
Skin  suppurates.
Crowns of teeth  decay.
< warmth of bed.
Metallic taste.
Leucorrhoea < night.
Ulcerations.
Human thermometer: sensitive to Profuse+++
heat as well as cold: < cold, < heat
Foetid Coppery
Salivation
Extreme Dry tongue is
Polarity with no thirst Salvation
is a contra- Slimy
Slow in answering Hurried, hasty indication
questions: loss of speech: jobs
memory; will-power: done in haste Foetor oris with flabby tongue
time passes slowly
Physical Clinicals:
1. Suppurative Disorders- ulcers; eruptions; necrosis; bed-sores;
2. Chronic Osteo-arthritis with bone pains;
3. Acute and Chronic Mucus Colitis and Blood Dysentery;
4. Teething problems;
5. Foetor Oris; Mouth ulcers;
6. Hyperdrosis and perspiration disorders.
CONCLUSION: Simple Homoeopathy wins:
"My years of clinical experience in busy Indian Clinics and in my Clinics in England, and
also understanding and reading of Homoeopathic literatures, have brought me to the
conclusion that the totality of the following six methodologies will enable the prescriber
to reach the "Similimum" efficiently and quickly:
I) Emphasis on Aetiologies (search for physical and emotional aetiologies, past
history of disease, conventional medication and/or vaccination: Never Been Well
Since).

12. 12
II) Totality of Physical Symptoms (with special emphasis on generals, modalities
and sensations).
III) Emotional Symptoms (with emphasis on personality profile and the nature of the
person).
IV) Behaviour, Gesture, Posture, Hobbies (how the person speaks, behaves during
the consultation, his nature, inquisitiveness, repetitiveness, abusive tendencies
etc.).
https://www.homoeopathy-course.com/resources/lectures
V) Miasmatic Totality (diagnosing the surface miasm, please refer to my book
"Miasmatic Prescribing" for quick miasmatic diagnosis).
https://www.homoeopathy-course.com/resources/books
VI) Homoeopathic Generalities: (a) Thermal reactions, (b) Food preferences and
appetite, (c) Thirst, (d) Sleep and dream, (e) General eliminations, (f) Diathesis or
tendencies & (g) Allergies."
In my experience, the Totality or a combination of any three of the above
methodologies can get you to the Similimum.
This is a time tested, repeatedly verified, scientific, classical and practical approach
which has been practiced for centuries by Master Homoeopaths including Drs. Kent,
Hering, Lippe, Tyler, Nash, etc.
Post Graduation Programme from England
Details at:
http://www.homoeopathy-course.com/index.php/training-courses/england-
homoeopathy-training/post-graduate-course
2 weeks Clinical Training Programme
(160+ Live Cases are demonstrated in 2 weeks in
Calcutta, every January to demonstrate the
Calcutta method of dependence on Clinical &
Comparative Materia Medica)
Details at:

13. 13
https://www.homoeopathy-course.com/courses/india