SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Prepared by Oxford Financial Group, Ltd. Page 1 of 3 JWS/LEB08182016
 
By: Julia Weaver, J.D., Director, Family Office Services and
The Trust Company of Oxford
Kara Talbott, CPA/PFS, CFP®
, Senior Wealth Strategist
Scott Simmons, J.D., LL.M., Wealth Strategist
Highlights and Planning Considerations
 On August 2, 2016, the Treasury Department issued its proposed regulations under
Section 2704 that, when and if finalized, could greatly alter the availability
of valuation discounts for family-controlled entities.
 In our January, 2016, article, "Estate Planning Freeze and Squeeze Strategies", we
mentioned the Treasury had publicized its intentions to issue these restrictive
regulations. After months of silence, it finally released these long awaited
proposed regulations that are much more restrictive than originally anticipated.
 The impact on many current and future estate planning strategies could be
significant and would greatly impair the ability to receive valuation discounts on
interests in a family-controlled entity. This could potentially cause a significant
increase in some families federal estate exposure.
 Several estate planning considerations should be assessed in determining the
proper course of action for each client's unique situation.
The current strategy of transferring discounted interests in a family-controlled entity
typically enables more overall wealth to be transferred to heirs, free of estate
taxation. By way of example, consider the following: Rather than passing only $10.9
million worth of actual value with the $10.9 million exemption (for 2016), it is far
better to pass $15.5 million of interest (reduced by a 30% valuation discount),
thereby “squeezing” more value through the $10.9 million exemption portal.
Simply put, less of the taxpayer’s gift and estate tax exemption is utilized when
transferring a discounted value of interest, leaving more exemption remaining to
apply to subsequent transfers. Valuation discounts also serve to potentially reduce
the taxable value of the estate.
Key Provisions in the Proposed Regulations
Immediate reactions to the proposed regulations include concerns that nearly all
minority and lack of control discounts could be disallowed in certain circumstances,
and that operating entities may be impacted as well as investment entities. The
following is a summary of five things you should initially know about these proposed
regulations.
1. Certain restrictions that previously resulted in valuation discounts on interest in
family-controlled entities would be disregarded when valuing a transferred
interest. This provision could cause the interest to be valued at a minimum value
which could potentially be the fair market value of the property held within the
entity, reduced only by outstanding obligations.
2. Certain transfers of interest in family-controlled entities occurring within three
years of the transferor's death would be treated as a lapse of voting and liq-
uidation rights occurring on the transferor's date of death. This would cause the
value of the reduction attributable to the minority status to be includible in the
gross estate.
 Example – John gifts, after the regulations are finalized, 20% of the Family
Limited Partnership to each of his three children. John dies two years later.
The value reduction is brought back into John's estate.
3. Certain interests held by non-family members would be disregarded unless they
meet specific requirements.
 The non-family member must have held the interest more than three years.
 The interest must be more than 10% of the value of equity interest or capital
and profits interest.
 The interest held when combined with other non-family interests must total
more than 20% of equity interest or capital and profits interest.
New Proposed Regulations Restricting Valuation Discounts for Family-Controlled Entities
August 2016 Issue WWW. OFGLTD.COM
Prepared by Oxford Financial Group, Ltd. Page 2 of 3 JWS/LEB08182016
 
 The non-family member must have the right to "put" the interest to the entity
and be paid the minimum value as determined under the regulation, in cash or
other property, which cannot be a note issued by the entity, holders of interest in
the entity or a person related to the entity or any holder of interest in the entity.
In the case of an entity engaged in an active trade or business, if 60% or more of the
entity's value consists of non-passive assets of the trade or business and the
liquidation proceeds are not attributable to passive assets then proceeds may include
a note.
Families with operating businesses should discuss with legal and tax counsel to verify
that buy-sell agreements comply with the proposed regulations.
 Example 1 – John and his brother's wife, Dana, own an active business equally.
However the proposed regulations would treat them as family members forcing
John's estate at his death to value his business interest without regard to
discounts for lack of control.
 Example 2 – John, Bill and Susan are not related by blood or marriage. Each own
1/3 of an active business. Their buy/sell agreement calls for the entity to
repurchase a deceased owner's interest and issue a promissory note over a five
year period. They executed this agreement in order to allow for the continued
viability of their business without burdening its cash flow. They should consult
with legal and tax counsel to determine if their entity value and assets comply
with the regulation as finalized. If not, it is possible that no lack of control
discount would be available for their 1/3 interest at their death.
4. Also potentially disregarded would be certain restrictions created by transfers to
an assignee rather than a partner, as well as certain restrictions that are imposed by
state law.
5. The proposed regulations contain very broad family attribution rules, further
impacting the use of closely held entities as a planning strategy for minimizing estate
and gift taxes.
Control of an entity is defined as having at least 50% of the equity or capital and
profits interest. It would also include any equity interest held with the ability to cause
a full or partial liquidation. For determining control, interests held by members of the
transferor's family, defined as the transferor's spouse as well as the transferor's
ancestors, descendants, siblings and the spouses of all listed, are included in
determining control.
It is important to note that the proposed regulations are not effective immediately.
They will be effective after they have been adopted as final regulations. A public
hearing has been scheduled for December 1, 2016, suggesting that December will be
the earliest the new regulations would become effective.
Planning Considerations: Absence of Federal Estate Tax Exposure
Ironically, for many taxpayers the best planning strategy may be to simply do nothing
at all. As we highlighted in our July article, "Income Tax Planning with Family Entities
- The Quest for Basis Step-Up", many families have been relieved of exposure to the
federal estate tax due to the increasing exemptions amounts since 2002.
As we stated, "[t]he focus for these families is squarely upon income tax planning [and
the ability to obtain] a step-up in basis to the asset's fair market value on the date of
death. Consequently, when the value of an asset is reduced by valuation discounts,
the basis step-up potential is equally reduced... [S]hould heirs liquidate interest after
Senior's death, the heir must recognize that difference as gain for income tax
purposes."
In that article, we discussed strategies to eliminate valuation discounts in these
certain circumstances. The Service, however, may have just provided the ideal
mechanism to accomplish this strategy, to wit: do nothing at all.
Planning Considerations: Clear and Present Danger of Federal Estate Tax
For families where federal estate tax remains an ongoing threat to their legacy
wealth, there are certain planning strategies that may be considered in light of this
potential change in current laws. As always, any such strategies should be thoroughly
discussed with legal and tax counsel.
In some respects, currently discounted family-controlled entity interest is somewhat
akin to an appreciating asset. Once the regulations become final, the discounts may
fall off, resulting in a rapid increase in the value of the interest. Various planning
techniques may be structured so that this increase in value occurs outside of the
taxable gross estate, thereby avoiding the 40% federal estate tax on the increase in
value.
Such strategies may include sales to Intentionally Defective Grantor Trusts ("IDGTs") or
Grantor Retained Annuity Trusts (GRATs), as well as some asset titling opportunities,
all of which should be thoughtfully analyzed for each taxpayer's individual situation.
Additionally, the loss of discounts may cause a significant increase in a taxpayer's
federal estate tax exposure. Taxpayers should consider having their federal estate tax
analysis updated, along with a liquidity analysis for payment of any increased tax
obligations.
Caveats and Cautions
As with any estate planning strategy, caution must be exercised to avoid structuring
any potentially abusive transactions, including a transaction considered to have
pre-planned "steps" to achieve tax avoidance. A good estate planning attorney should
review any strategy so as to avoid this “step-transaction” doctrine, wherein the entire
strategy would be collapsed.
Additionally, the proposed regulations contain a potential three (3) year claw-back
period wherein any transfers made within 3 years of the transferor’s death could be
Prepared by Oxford Financial Group, Ltd. Page 3 of 3 JWS/LEB08182016
 
treated as a lapse causing inclusion in the gross estate of the value of the reduction of
the transferor’s interest attributable to certain previous discounts.
Next Steps
As discussed, there are vastly differing strategies for each taxpayer's specific situation
particularly depending upon whether there is current or anticipated federal estate tax
exposure. Along with coordinating the appropriate legal and tax review of the issues
discussed above, your Oxford advisors can assist with determining the proper course
of action for each client's unique situation.
*The Federal Estate Tax Exemption for 2016 is $5.45 million per person/$10.9 million per married couples,
above which all wealth is taxed at the rate of 40% upon any non-marital transfer.

More Related Content

What's hot

2 3 4 Financial Concept
2 3 4 Financial Concept2 3 4 Financial Concept
2 3 4 Financial Concept
darienward
 
2016 Individual Tax Planning Supplement
2016 Individual Tax Planning Supplement2016 Individual Tax Planning Supplement
2016 Individual Tax Planning Supplement
CBIZ, Inc.
 
401K Rollovers
401K Rollovers401K Rollovers
401K Rollovers
RMAC378
 
Financial planning strategies for 2013
Financial planning strategies for 2013Financial planning strategies for 2013
Financial planning strategies for 2013
Robert Tomaszewski, MBA, CFP®
 
Accountable Advice_Jan-Feb-2015_1stNat_B
Accountable Advice_Jan-Feb-2015_1stNat_BAccountable Advice_Jan-Feb-2015_1stNat_B
Accountable Advice_Jan-Feb-2015_1stNat_B
Jude Sandvall, 720-255-1021
 
How to transform a family business: insights from the trenches
How to transform a family business: insights from the trenches How to transform a family business: insights from the trenches
How to transform a family business: insights from the trenches
Browne & Mohan
 
2016 tax review hints
2016 tax review hints2016 tax review hints
2016 tax review hints
Kelly O'Donnell
 
2017 Individual Tax Planning Supplement
2017 Individual Tax Planning Supplement2017 Individual Tax Planning Supplement
2017 Individual Tax Planning Supplement
CBIZ, Inc.
 
Counterpoint no on buffet rule v6
Counterpoint no on buffet rule v6Counterpoint no on buffet rule v6
Counterpoint no on buffet rule v6
Sally Hamilton
 
Estate Planning for Owners of Closely-Held Businesses
Estate Planning for Owners of Closely-Held BusinessesEstate Planning for Owners of Closely-Held Businesses
Estate Planning for Owners of Closely-Held Businesses
Moskowitz LLP
 
Passthrough tax summary
Passthrough tax summaryPassthrough tax summary
Passthrough tax summary
MojoFinancial
 
Passthrough tax summary
Passthrough tax summaryPassthrough tax summary
Passthrough tax summary
Social Agent Four
 
Kfs stretch ira's
Kfs stretch ira'sKfs stretch ira's
Kfs stretch ira's
roowah1
 
1Q2018 Results & Supplemental Information
1Q2018 Results & Supplemental Information1Q2018 Results & Supplemental Information
1Q2018 Results & Supplemental Information
InfraREIT
 
Tax Planning with Moskowitz LLP
Tax Planning with Moskowitz LLPTax Planning with Moskowitz LLP
Tax Planning with Moskowitz LLP
Moskowitz LLP
 
The Buffett Rule | Under The Hood October 2014
The Buffett Rule | Under The Hood October 2014The Buffett Rule | Under The Hood October 2014
The Buffett Rule | Under The Hood October 2014
The 401k Study Group ®
 
A WAY OUT
A WAY OUTA WAY OUT
A WAY OUT
Jason P Santos
 
2010 year end tax planning
2010 year end tax planning2010 year end tax planning
2010 year end tax planning
dhess0
 
Increase Profit and Make Better Business Decisions through your Tax Services
Increase Profit and Make Better Business Decisions through your Tax Services Increase Profit and Make Better Business Decisions through your Tax Services
Increase Profit and Make Better Business Decisions through your Tax Services
Moskowitz LLP
 
Employee Retention Credit
Employee Retention CreditEmployee Retention Credit
Employee Retention Credit
Moskowitz LLP
 

What's hot (20)

2 3 4 Financial Concept
2 3 4 Financial Concept2 3 4 Financial Concept
2 3 4 Financial Concept
 
2016 Individual Tax Planning Supplement
2016 Individual Tax Planning Supplement2016 Individual Tax Planning Supplement
2016 Individual Tax Planning Supplement
 
401K Rollovers
401K Rollovers401K Rollovers
401K Rollovers
 
Financial planning strategies for 2013
Financial planning strategies for 2013Financial planning strategies for 2013
Financial planning strategies for 2013
 
Accountable Advice_Jan-Feb-2015_1stNat_B
Accountable Advice_Jan-Feb-2015_1stNat_BAccountable Advice_Jan-Feb-2015_1stNat_B
Accountable Advice_Jan-Feb-2015_1stNat_B
 
How to transform a family business: insights from the trenches
How to transform a family business: insights from the trenches How to transform a family business: insights from the trenches
How to transform a family business: insights from the trenches
 
2016 tax review hints
2016 tax review hints2016 tax review hints
2016 tax review hints
 
2017 Individual Tax Planning Supplement
2017 Individual Tax Planning Supplement2017 Individual Tax Planning Supplement
2017 Individual Tax Planning Supplement
 
Counterpoint no on buffet rule v6
Counterpoint no on buffet rule v6Counterpoint no on buffet rule v6
Counterpoint no on buffet rule v6
 
Estate Planning for Owners of Closely-Held Businesses
Estate Planning for Owners of Closely-Held BusinessesEstate Planning for Owners of Closely-Held Businesses
Estate Planning for Owners of Closely-Held Businesses
 
Passthrough tax summary
Passthrough tax summaryPassthrough tax summary
Passthrough tax summary
 
Passthrough tax summary
Passthrough tax summaryPassthrough tax summary
Passthrough tax summary
 
Kfs stretch ira's
Kfs stretch ira'sKfs stretch ira's
Kfs stretch ira's
 
1Q2018 Results & Supplemental Information
1Q2018 Results & Supplemental Information1Q2018 Results & Supplemental Information
1Q2018 Results & Supplemental Information
 
Tax Planning with Moskowitz LLP
Tax Planning with Moskowitz LLPTax Planning with Moskowitz LLP
Tax Planning with Moskowitz LLP
 
The Buffett Rule | Under The Hood October 2014
The Buffett Rule | Under The Hood October 2014The Buffett Rule | Under The Hood October 2014
The Buffett Rule | Under The Hood October 2014
 
A WAY OUT
A WAY OUTA WAY OUT
A WAY OUT
 
2010 year end tax planning
2010 year end tax planning2010 year end tax planning
2010 year end tax planning
 
Increase Profit and Make Better Business Decisions through your Tax Services
Increase Profit and Make Better Business Decisions through your Tax Services Increase Profit and Make Better Business Decisions through your Tax Services
Increase Profit and Make Better Business Decisions through your Tax Services
 
Employee Retention Credit
Employee Retention CreditEmployee Retention Credit
Employee Retention Credit
 

Viewers also liked

Unidade5 2012 csa_v2_gabarit_op171a175
Unidade5 2012 csa_v2_gabarit_op171a175Unidade5 2012 csa_v2_gabarit_op171a175
Unidade5 2012 csa_v2_gabarit_op171a175
ProCLAUDIA/LUCIANE MEIJON/SOARES
 
Etica civil
Etica civilEtica civil
Etica civil
murillo96
 
El foro.
El foro.El foro.
El foro.
dunull
 
Resistencia en plantas1.1
Resistencia en plantas1.1Resistencia en plantas1.1
Resistencia en plantas1.1
wags0583
 
Pri mates y la reforma hacendaria...
Pri mates y la reforma hacendaria...Pri mates y la reforma hacendaria...
Pri mates y la reforma hacendaria...
danibethh
 
Mate
MateMate
PowerPoint 1° ''A''
PowerPoint 1° ''A''PowerPoint 1° ''A''
PowerPoint 1° ''A''
Maritzaa123
 
Seguridad en la informática de empresa
Seguridad en la informática de empresaSeguridad en la informática de empresa
Seguridad en la informática de empresa
Lore Cruz Sanchez
 
Radioatividade
RadioatividadeRadioatividade
Medios de transmision_Lucely Lorduy
Medios de transmision_Lucely LorduyMedios de transmision_Lucely Lorduy
Medios de transmision_Lucely Lorduy
lorduyrincon
 
El juego en el nivel inicial
El juego en el nivel inicialEl juego en el nivel inicial
El juego en el nivel inicial
35291283
 
Elementos de vinculación de las estrategias 2
Elementos de vinculación de las estrategias 2Elementos de vinculación de las estrategias 2
Elementos de vinculación de las estrategias 2
Wilmelia Bravo
 
Aula1 - INTRODUÇÃO
Aula1 - INTRODUÇÃOAula1 - INTRODUÇÃO
Aula1 - INTRODUÇÃO
giumf
 
Carmen laforet
Carmen laforetCarmen laforet
Carmen laforet
croquetascuac
 
Leonardo da vinci
Leonardo da vinciLeonardo da vinci
Leonardo da vinci
Flávia Borges
 
Além do que se vê
Além do que se vê Além do que se vê
Além do que se vê
Matheus Sampaio
 
Release cooklovers
Release cookloversRelease cooklovers
Release cooklovers
Marcelo Nogueira
 
Copasa doenças
Copasa doençasCopasa doenças
Copasa doenças
Med. Veterinária 2011
 
Portfólio Dtalhe 2011
Portfólio Dtalhe 2011Portfólio Dtalhe 2011
Portfólio Dtalhe 2011
Dtalhe Comunica
 

Viewers also liked (20)

Unidade5 2012 csa_v2_gabarit_op171a175
Unidade5 2012 csa_v2_gabarit_op171a175Unidade5 2012 csa_v2_gabarit_op171a175
Unidade5 2012 csa_v2_gabarit_op171a175
 
Etica civil
Etica civilEtica civil
Etica civil
 
El foro.
El foro.El foro.
El foro.
 
Resistencia en plantas1.1
Resistencia en plantas1.1Resistencia en plantas1.1
Resistencia en plantas1.1
 
Pri mates y la reforma hacendaria...
Pri mates y la reforma hacendaria...Pri mates y la reforma hacendaria...
Pri mates y la reforma hacendaria...
 
Mate
MateMate
Mate
 
PowerPoint 1° ''A''
PowerPoint 1° ''A''PowerPoint 1° ''A''
PowerPoint 1° ''A''
 
Seguridad en la informática de empresa
Seguridad en la informática de empresaSeguridad en la informática de empresa
Seguridad en la informática de empresa
 
Radioatividade
RadioatividadeRadioatividade
Radioatividade
 
Medios de transmision_Lucely Lorduy
Medios de transmision_Lucely LorduyMedios de transmision_Lucely Lorduy
Medios de transmision_Lucely Lorduy
 
El juego en el nivel inicial
El juego en el nivel inicialEl juego en el nivel inicial
El juego en el nivel inicial
 
Elementos de vinculación de las estrategias 2
Elementos de vinculación de las estrategias 2Elementos de vinculación de las estrategias 2
Elementos de vinculación de las estrategias 2
 
Aula1 - INTRODUÇÃO
Aula1 - INTRODUÇÃOAula1 - INTRODUÇÃO
Aula1 - INTRODUÇÃO
 
Carmen laforet
Carmen laforetCarmen laforet
Carmen laforet
 
Fracciones
Fracciones Fracciones
Fracciones
 
Leonardo da vinci
Leonardo da vinciLeonardo da vinci
Leonardo da vinci
 
Além do que se vê
Além do que se vê Além do que se vê
Além do que se vê
 
Release cooklovers
Release cookloversRelease cooklovers
Release cooklovers
 
Copasa doenças
Copasa doençasCopasa doenças
Copasa doenças
 
Portfólio Dtalhe 2011
Portfólio Dtalhe 2011Portfólio Dtalhe 2011
Portfólio Dtalhe 2011
 

Similar to August 2016 - New Proposed Regulations Restricting Valuation Discounts for Family-Controlled Entities - JSW

US Tax Reform - Jan. 2018
US Tax Reform - Jan. 2018US Tax Reform - Jan. 2018
US Tax Reform - Jan. 2018
Mark MacIsaac
 
CMV.TAX NOTES.10.22.12
CMV.TAX NOTES.10.22.12CMV.TAX NOTES.10.22.12
CMV.TAX NOTES.10.22.12
Cory Vargo
 
FATCA MNC Checklist final 2015
FATCA MNC Checklist final 2015FATCA MNC Checklist final 2015
FATCA MNC Checklist final 2015
George Kyroudis
 
A WAY OUT KOLBIN
A WAY OUT KOLBINA WAY OUT KOLBIN
A WAY OUT KOLBIN
Stas Kolbin
 
AALU Washington Report: The Big Six’s “Unified” Tax Framework: Potential Impa...
AALU Washington Report: The Big Six’s “Unified” Tax Framework: Potential Impa...AALU Washington Report: The Big Six’s “Unified” Tax Framework: Potential Impa...
AALU Washington Report: The Big Six’s “Unified” Tax Framework: Potential Impa...
Fulcrum Partners LLC
 
Mercer Capital's Value Matters™ | Issue No. 3, 2022|
Mercer Capital's Value Matters™ | Issue No. 3, 2022|Mercer Capital's Value Matters™ | Issue No. 3, 2022|
Mercer Capital's Value Matters™ | Issue No. 3, 2022|
Mercer Capital
 
Commercial Real Estate: Hot Topics October 2015
Commercial Real Estate: Hot Topics October 2015Commercial Real Estate: Hot Topics October 2015
Commercial Real Estate: Hot Topics October 2015
CBIZ, Inc.
 
Tax changes for private corporations
Tax changes for private corporationsTax changes for private corporations
Tax changes for private corporations
Paula MacLellan, FMA, FCSI,CIWM
 
TOPIC: Survey Says: Tax Reform & Client Planning - What Advisors Are Seeing &...
TOPIC: Survey Says: Tax Reform & Client Planning - What Advisors Are Seeing &...TOPIC: Survey Says: Tax Reform & Client Planning - What Advisors Are Seeing &...
TOPIC: Survey Says: Tax Reform & Client Planning - What Advisors Are Seeing &...
theBurgessGroup
 
Life Insurance Planning in an Era of Estate Tax Uncertainty - 5 Things To Know
Life Insurance Planning in an Era of Estate Tax Uncertainty - 5 Things To KnowLife Insurance Planning in an Era of Estate Tax Uncertainty - 5 Things To Know
Life Insurance Planning in an Era of Estate Tax Uncertainty - 5 Things To Know
theBurgessGroup
 
TAXES MAG_10-16_The Forgotten Variable
TAXES MAG_10-16_The Forgotten VariableTAXES MAG_10-16_The Forgotten Variable
TAXES MAG_10-16_The Forgotten Variable
Brian T. Whitlock
 
Individual tax reform resource
Individual tax reform resourceIndividual tax reform resource
Individual tax reform resource
RSM US
 
Mercer Capital's Value Matters™ | Issue 2 2021
Mercer Capital's Value Matters™ | Issue 2 2021 Mercer Capital's Value Matters™ | Issue 2 2021
Mercer Capital's Value Matters™ | Issue 2 2021
Mercer Capital
 
A WAY OUT - GRichards
A WAY OUT - GRichardsA WAY OUT - GRichards
A WAY OUT - GRichards
Gregory J. Richards
 
Investment Insights for January 2018
Investment Insights for January 2018Investment Insights for January 2018
Investment Insights for January 2018
Cornerstone Wealth Management MWP
 
Client Alert: November 2007
Client Alert: November 2007Client Alert: November 2007
Client Alert: November 2007
SES Advisors
 
New_Tax_Clients_Schwartz
New_Tax_Clients_SchwartzNew_Tax_Clients_Schwartz
New_Tax_Clients_Schwartz
Michael L. Schwartz, RFC, CWS, CFS
 
A Way Out
A Way OutA Way Out
A Way Out
A Way OutA Way Out
A Way Out
A Way OutA Way Out

Similar to August 2016 - New Proposed Regulations Restricting Valuation Discounts for Family-Controlled Entities - JSW (20)

US Tax Reform - Jan. 2018
US Tax Reform - Jan. 2018US Tax Reform - Jan. 2018
US Tax Reform - Jan. 2018
 
CMV.TAX NOTES.10.22.12
CMV.TAX NOTES.10.22.12CMV.TAX NOTES.10.22.12
CMV.TAX NOTES.10.22.12
 
FATCA MNC Checklist final 2015
FATCA MNC Checklist final 2015FATCA MNC Checklist final 2015
FATCA MNC Checklist final 2015
 
A WAY OUT KOLBIN
A WAY OUT KOLBINA WAY OUT KOLBIN
A WAY OUT KOLBIN
 
AALU Washington Report: The Big Six’s “Unified” Tax Framework: Potential Impa...
AALU Washington Report: The Big Six’s “Unified” Tax Framework: Potential Impa...AALU Washington Report: The Big Six’s “Unified” Tax Framework: Potential Impa...
AALU Washington Report: The Big Six’s “Unified” Tax Framework: Potential Impa...
 
Mercer Capital's Value Matters™ | Issue No. 3, 2022|
Mercer Capital's Value Matters™ | Issue No. 3, 2022|Mercer Capital's Value Matters™ | Issue No. 3, 2022|
Mercer Capital's Value Matters™ | Issue No. 3, 2022|
 
Commercial Real Estate: Hot Topics October 2015
Commercial Real Estate: Hot Topics October 2015Commercial Real Estate: Hot Topics October 2015
Commercial Real Estate: Hot Topics October 2015
 
Tax changes for private corporations
Tax changes for private corporationsTax changes for private corporations
Tax changes for private corporations
 
TOPIC: Survey Says: Tax Reform & Client Planning - What Advisors Are Seeing &...
TOPIC: Survey Says: Tax Reform & Client Planning - What Advisors Are Seeing &...TOPIC: Survey Says: Tax Reform & Client Planning - What Advisors Are Seeing &...
TOPIC: Survey Says: Tax Reform & Client Planning - What Advisors Are Seeing &...
 
Life Insurance Planning in an Era of Estate Tax Uncertainty - 5 Things To Know
Life Insurance Planning in an Era of Estate Tax Uncertainty - 5 Things To KnowLife Insurance Planning in an Era of Estate Tax Uncertainty - 5 Things To Know
Life Insurance Planning in an Era of Estate Tax Uncertainty - 5 Things To Know
 
TAXES MAG_10-16_The Forgotten Variable
TAXES MAG_10-16_The Forgotten VariableTAXES MAG_10-16_The Forgotten Variable
TAXES MAG_10-16_The Forgotten Variable
 
Individual tax reform resource
Individual tax reform resourceIndividual tax reform resource
Individual tax reform resource
 
Mercer Capital's Value Matters™ | Issue 2 2021
Mercer Capital's Value Matters™ | Issue 2 2021 Mercer Capital's Value Matters™ | Issue 2 2021
Mercer Capital's Value Matters™ | Issue 2 2021
 
A WAY OUT - GRichards
A WAY OUT - GRichardsA WAY OUT - GRichards
A WAY OUT - GRichards
 
Investment Insights for January 2018
Investment Insights for January 2018Investment Insights for January 2018
Investment Insights for January 2018
 
Client Alert: November 2007
Client Alert: November 2007Client Alert: November 2007
Client Alert: November 2007
 
New_Tax_Clients_Schwartz
New_Tax_Clients_SchwartzNew_Tax_Clients_Schwartz
New_Tax_Clients_Schwartz
 
A Way Out
A Way OutA Way Out
A Way Out
 
A Way Out
A Way OutA Way Out
A Way Out
 
A Way Out
A Way OutA Way Out
A Way Out
 

August 2016 - New Proposed Regulations Restricting Valuation Discounts for Family-Controlled Entities - JSW

  • 1. Prepared by Oxford Financial Group, Ltd. Page 1 of 3 JWS/LEB08182016   By: Julia Weaver, J.D., Director, Family Office Services and The Trust Company of Oxford Kara Talbott, CPA/PFS, CFP® , Senior Wealth Strategist Scott Simmons, J.D., LL.M., Wealth Strategist Highlights and Planning Considerations  On August 2, 2016, the Treasury Department issued its proposed regulations under Section 2704 that, when and if finalized, could greatly alter the availability of valuation discounts for family-controlled entities.  In our January, 2016, article, "Estate Planning Freeze and Squeeze Strategies", we mentioned the Treasury had publicized its intentions to issue these restrictive regulations. After months of silence, it finally released these long awaited proposed regulations that are much more restrictive than originally anticipated.  The impact on many current and future estate planning strategies could be significant and would greatly impair the ability to receive valuation discounts on interests in a family-controlled entity. This could potentially cause a significant increase in some families federal estate exposure.  Several estate planning considerations should be assessed in determining the proper course of action for each client's unique situation. The current strategy of transferring discounted interests in a family-controlled entity typically enables more overall wealth to be transferred to heirs, free of estate taxation. By way of example, consider the following: Rather than passing only $10.9 million worth of actual value with the $10.9 million exemption (for 2016), it is far better to pass $15.5 million of interest (reduced by a 30% valuation discount), thereby “squeezing” more value through the $10.9 million exemption portal. Simply put, less of the taxpayer’s gift and estate tax exemption is utilized when transferring a discounted value of interest, leaving more exemption remaining to apply to subsequent transfers. Valuation discounts also serve to potentially reduce the taxable value of the estate. Key Provisions in the Proposed Regulations Immediate reactions to the proposed regulations include concerns that nearly all minority and lack of control discounts could be disallowed in certain circumstances, and that operating entities may be impacted as well as investment entities. The following is a summary of five things you should initially know about these proposed regulations. 1. Certain restrictions that previously resulted in valuation discounts on interest in family-controlled entities would be disregarded when valuing a transferred interest. This provision could cause the interest to be valued at a minimum value which could potentially be the fair market value of the property held within the entity, reduced only by outstanding obligations. 2. Certain transfers of interest in family-controlled entities occurring within three years of the transferor's death would be treated as a lapse of voting and liq- uidation rights occurring on the transferor's date of death. This would cause the value of the reduction attributable to the minority status to be includible in the gross estate.  Example – John gifts, after the regulations are finalized, 20% of the Family Limited Partnership to each of his three children. John dies two years later. The value reduction is brought back into John's estate. 3. Certain interests held by non-family members would be disregarded unless they meet specific requirements.  The non-family member must have held the interest more than three years.  The interest must be more than 10% of the value of equity interest or capital and profits interest.  The interest held when combined with other non-family interests must total more than 20% of equity interest or capital and profits interest. New Proposed Regulations Restricting Valuation Discounts for Family-Controlled Entities August 2016 Issue WWW. OFGLTD.COM
  • 2. Prepared by Oxford Financial Group, Ltd. Page 2 of 3 JWS/LEB08182016    The non-family member must have the right to "put" the interest to the entity and be paid the minimum value as determined under the regulation, in cash or other property, which cannot be a note issued by the entity, holders of interest in the entity or a person related to the entity or any holder of interest in the entity. In the case of an entity engaged in an active trade or business, if 60% or more of the entity's value consists of non-passive assets of the trade or business and the liquidation proceeds are not attributable to passive assets then proceeds may include a note. Families with operating businesses should discuss with legal and tax counsel to verify that buy-sell agreements comply with the proposed regulations.  Example 1 – John and his brother's wife, Dana, own an active business equally. However the proposed regulations would treat them as family members forcing John's estate at his death to value his business interest without regard to discounts for lack of control.  Example 2 – John, Bill and Susan are not related by blood or marriage. Each own 1/3 of an active business. Their buy/sell agreement calls for the entity to repurchase a deceased owner's interest and issue a promissory note over a five year period. They executed this agreement in order to allow for the continued viability of their business without burdening its cash flow. They should consult with legal and tax counsel to determine if their entity value and assets comply with the regulation as finalized. If not, it is possible that no lack of control discount would be available for their 1/3 interest at their death. 4. Also potentially disregarded would be certain restrictions created by transfers to an assignee rather than a partner, as well as certain restrictions that are imposed by state law. 5. The proposed regulations contain very broad family attribution rules, further impacting the use of closely held entities as a planning strategy for minimizing estate and gift taxes. Control of an entity is defined as having at least 50% of the equity or capital and profits interest. It would also include any equity interest held with the ability to cause a full or partial liquidation. For determining control, interests held by members of the transferor's family, defined as the transferor's spouse as well as the transferor's ancestors, descendants, siblings and the spouses of all listed, are included in determining control. It is important to note that the proposed regulations are not effective immediately. They will be effective after they have been adopted as final regulations. A public hearing has been scheduled for December 1, 2016, suggesting that December will be the earliest the new regulations would become effective. Planning Considerations: Absence of Federal Estate Tax Exposure Ironically, for many taxpayers the best planning strategy may be to simply do nothing at all. As we highlighted in our July article, "Income Tax Planning with Family Entities - The Quest for Basis Step-Up", many families have been relieved of exposure to the federal estate tax due to the increasing exemptions amounts since 2002. As we stated, "[t]he focus for these families is squarely upon income tax planning [and the ability to obtain] a step-up in basis to the asset's fair market value on the date of death. Consequently, when the value of an asset is reduced by valuation discounts, the basis step-up potential is equally reduced... [S]hould heirs liquidate interest after Senior's death, the heir must recognize that difference as gain for income tax purposes." In that article, we discussed strategies to eliminate valuation discounts in these certain circumstances. The Service, however, may have just provided the ideal mechanism to accomplish this strategy, to wit: do nothing at all. Planning Considerations: Clear and Present Danger of Federal Estate Tax For families where federal estate tax remains an ongoing threat to their legacy wealth, there are certain planning strategies that may be considered in light of this potential change in current laws. As always, any such strategies should be thoroughly discussed with legal and tax counsel. In some respects, currently discounted family-controlled entity interest is somewhat akin to an appreciating asset. Once the regulations become final, the discounts may fall off, resulting in a rapid increase in the value of the interest. Various planning techniques may be structured so that this increase in value occurs outside of the taxable gross estate, thereby avoiding the 40% federal estate tax on the increase in value. Such strategies may include sales to Intentionally Defective Grantor Trusts ("IDGTs") or Grantor Retained Annuity Trusts (GRATs), as well as some asset titling opportunities, all of which should be thoughtfully analyzed for each taxpayer's individual situation. Additionally, the loss of discounts may cause a significant increase in a taxpayer's federal estate tax exposure. Taxpayers should consider having their federal estate tax analysis updated, along with a liquidity analysis for payment of any increased tax obligations. Caveats and Cautions As with any estate planning strategy, caution must be exercised to avoid structuring any potentially abusive transactions, including a transaction considered to have pre-planned "steps" to achieve tax avoidance. A good estate planning attorney should review any strategy so as to avoid this “step-transaction” doctrine, wherein the entire strategy would be collapsed. Additionally, the proposed regulations contain a potential three (3) year claw-back period wherein any transfers made within 3 years of the transferor’s death could be
  • 3. Prepared by Oxford Financial Group, Ltd. Page 3 of 3 JWS/LEB08182016   treated as a lapse causing inclusion in the gross estate of the value of the reduction of the transferor’s interest attributable to certain previous discounts. Next Steps As discussed, there are vastly differing strategies for each taxpayer's specific situation particularly depending upon whether there is current or anticipated federal estate tax exposure. Along with coordinating the appropriate legal and tax review of the issues discussed above, your Oxford advisors can assist with determining the proper course of action for each client's unique situation. *The Federal Estate Tax Exemption for 2016 is $5.45 million per person/$10.9 million per married couples, above which all wealth is taxed at the rate of 40% upon any non-marital transfer.