SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 23
ALTERNATIVES TO THE F E D ?
Bennett T. McCallum
I must begin by saying that I have been extremely
disappointed—
the word "appalled" may be more accurate—by several develop-
ments over the last two years involving tlie Federal Reserve. It
was,
I believe, appropriate that the Fed would respond widi
expansionary
monetary policy in the face of a major macroeconomic
downtum,
which it did. But it did not have to do so by means of operations
tliat
incorporated major excursions into credit policy, as weU as
monetary
policy, and thereby into the unauthorized exercise of fiscal
policy. ̂ By
engaging in such operations on a very large sctile, die Fed's
actions
are iJmost certain to have detrimental effects on tlie Fed's
independ-
ence—and thereby on its resulting ability to focus attention on
what
shotild be its principal objective, namely, price level stability.
Furthermore, tlie Fed has not been moving quickly—if at all—to
explain and correct this situation.
AH in aU, die recent experience has had flie effect of moving
the
Fed away from die type of policy behavior tliat niixinstream
academic
analysts have been promoting over tlie past 15 years—namely,
an
activist but mle-based monetary stabilization policy fliat
emphasizes
Catojounwl, Vol. 30, No. 3 (Fall 2010). Copyright © Cato
Institute. All rights
reserved.
Bennett T. McCiilhtin is Professor of Econotnics at Carnegie
Mellon University.
He thanks Marvin Coodfriend for helpful cotntnents.
'Coodfriend and McCallum (2009) distinguish between pure
monetary policy
(changes in base money by central bank purchase or sale of
Treasury securities),
pttre credit policy (changes in the cotnposition of central bank
assets witli no
change in base tnoney), and ititerest-on-reserves policy (with no
balance sheet
changes). Since the Fed returns to the Treasury the interest
received on the
Treasury securities that it holds, it is the case that when the Fed
sells Treasuries
to fund expansionary credit policy the net results are the satne
as if the Treasury
fttianced credit extensions by selling its securities to (i.e.,
borrowing from) the
public.
439
CATO JOURNAL
die avoidance of significant inflation while also avoiding
deflation. In
saying this, I do recognize that the term "inflation targeting"
has been
gradually corrupted so as to pemiit excessive aspects of "fine
tuning"
relating to output and employment levels, but by and large I
believe
that the academic literature has been mosdy constructive and
that
much ofthe commentary tending to discredit it on the basis of
recent
events has done so mistakenly.
Monetary Policy and Exchange Rates
In previous writings, I have argued that monetary policy and
exchange rate policy are linked togedier so intimately that diey
should be considered as two sides of the same coin. From that
per-
spective, it seems an unfortunate anachronism that official
exchange-
rate responsibility is assigned to the Treasury or Finance
Ministry in
many economies, including the United States, Japan, and— t̂ o a
small
extent—even the European Union. But, in any case, this topic in
turn leads us to contemplate other types of monetary regimes—
arrangements other than fiat money, managed by a national
central
bank, in the context of floating exchange rates.
In this regard there are, I believe, three main alternatives that
need to be discussed. These are the gold standard, private
competi-
tive supply of money, and the Yeager-Greenfield plan for an
auto-
matically stabilized unit of account. For all three of these, a
major
outlet for sympathetic and scholarly discussion has been the
Cato
Joumai. For this, tlie Cato Joumai deserves much credit, even
from
readers who are basically supporters ofthe fiat-floating regime.
I will
attempt to provide some relevant considerations in the
remainder of
my presentation.
The Cold Standard
There are many critics of the gold standard among economists
who are ardent believers that any monetary arrangement should
have
price stability as its overriding objective; one might mention
AHan
Meltzer, Anna Schwartz, and Leland Yeager. One reason for
criticism
is that while a traditional gold standard tends to protect an
economy
from major inflations or deflations over a decade or more, it
pennits
a substantial amount of variability at die business-cycle
frequency
(see, e.g.. Bordo 1981). The difficulty that I wish to emphasize
here
440
ALTERNATIVES TO THE F E D ?
is different, however; it is one stressed in Friedmtin (1961)—
one of
his less-famous papers. My own way of diinldng about diis
point
begins widi die assumption that any gold-standard arrangement
today would be one in which the nation's monetary audiority
(MA)
stiuids ready to exchange gold, at a fixed rate and in botli
directions,
for the principal paper medium of exchange—let us use the term
"dollars" and also assume that die medium of exchange (MOE)
is the
medium of account (MOA).^ This fixed price is supposed to be
main-
tcüned indefinitely. But if the MA has die capability of
adjusting this
price, dien diere is no permanent anchor for die price level even
if
dollars are at each point of time convertible into gold. The
problem
is that die population of die United States—like diat of odier
coun-
tries—is full of congressmen, businessmen, union leaders,
nonprofit
organizations, voters, television commentators, and
miscellaneous
individuals who will be frequendy clamoring for the MA to
raise or
lower die medium-of-exchange price of gold (or whatever is die
stan-
dard commodity). An increase would then possibly be
stimulative but
only temporarily and would be followed by price increases for
goods
in genenil, diat is, by a burst of inflation. Historically, the gold
stan-
dard provided a reasonable degree of price level stability over
long
spans of time because the population at large had at diat time a
semi-
religious belief diat die price of gold should not be varied but
should
be maintained "forever."'̂ But today die same political forces
tliat
impinge upon die Fed to be inflationary under our present
arrange-
ment would work dirough this alternative channel under the
sug-
gested gold system. Friedman (1961) referred to such a system
as a
"pseudo gold standard" and pointed out diat it amounted in die
United States of 1913-1961 to a price-support arrangement for
gold
producers radier dian as a desirable monetary standard.''
^ In this regard, I would like to point out that a recent piece by
James Grant
(2009)—two full pages in the Wall Street Jounml—in efTect
adopts the same
position (in its Final paragraph). This WSJ piece has,
apparently, been adapted
From Grant's highly enjoyable presentation at the Cato
Monetary Conference
(November 19, 2009).
•̂ Tiniberlake (1989: 317) reports tliat the London mint price of
gold was kept
nearly constant from 1665 to 1914.
•* It should be noted tliat the present discussion, which focuses
on changes over
time in the dollar price of gold, does not consider possible
variations in the
reserve ratio. For an analysis that emphasizes such variations
(in a somewhat dif-
ferent model than the one presumed here), see Goodfriend
(1988)
441
CATO JOURNAL
Of course, there is die logical possibility of what Friedman
called
a "real" gold standard, under which actual physical coins or bars
of
gold would serve as the primary MOE despite the costliness of
main-
taining such a stock. But as Friedman (1960:5-7) says, there is a
very
strong tendency for such a system to evolve into one with
"fiduciary
elements" and eventually to degenerate into a commodity
currency
in which tlie commodity is paper—or, today, digital storage
capacity.
In any event, I have (for simplicity) ruled out diis possibility by
assumption.
Competing Private Money Suppliers
The second alternative that should be mentioned is the provision
of media of exchange by competing private suppliers. The most
prominent of writings on diis topic is probably the monograph
by
Hayek (1978), but the most comprehensive review of ideas that
I
have seen is provided by White (1989). The bulk of his
discussion
pertains to arrangements under which private issuers of notes
and
deposits used as MOE are convertible into gold or some other
com-
modity (or bundle). If such convertibility were required by law,̂
there seems to be Htde reason why a system of tliis type would
not
be viable, but there is also no reason why die legal par value
would
not be subject to the same pressures as those discussed in tlie
previ-
ous section. These wotild be pressures not on individual banks
(i.e.,
private issuers), but on the national monetary authority.
Next, to change the perspective, suppose that there were no
legtil
restrictions on private note-and-deposit suppliers who could
then
offer purely fiduciary (i.e., inconvertible) currencies. Regarding
this
case, Friedman (1960: 7) argued:
Such a currency would involve a negligible use of real
resources to produce . . . and would therefore seem to avoid
any pressure to undermine it arising frotu the possibility of
saving real resources. This is true for the community as a
whole but not for any single issuer of currency. So long as the
fiduciary currency has a tTiarket value greater than its cost of
production—which under favorable conditions can be com-
pressed close to the cost of the paper on which it is printed—
' I assume that such a requirement would include specification
of a minimum
gold/paper reserve ratio.
442
ALTERNATIVES T O T H E F E D ?
any individual issuer has an incentive to issue additiotial
atnounts. A fiduciary currency would thus probably tend
through increased issue to degenerate into a cotntiiodity cur-
reticy—into a literal paper standard—there being no stable
equilibrium price level short ofthat at wbich die money value
of curreney is no greater than that ofthe paper it cont;üns.
In die intervening half-century diere have been some formal
studies
of this conjecture, several of which have been summarized by
Wliite
(1989). The key analytical result seems to be diat of Taub
(1985),
who finds that, because ofthe dynamic inconsistency involved,
such
a system could only be sustainable if die issuer were to provide
potential users with a contractual commitment to redeemability
in
some acceptable medium—and diis would require, I would add,
general belief that die legal system will enforce such contracts.
Given
recent experience, it may be difficult to generate such belief.
Nevertheless, diis last possibOity seems wordiy of additional
con-
sideration. A governmental agency widi die sole responsibility
of see-
ing diat redeemability contracts are specified and enforced—and
without the power to modify par vtilues itself—might provide a
type
of arrangement diat could widistand political pressures for
monetary
stimulus and also eliminate die possibility of private bank over-
issuance.
The Yeager-Creenfield System
The diird alternative to be considered is an intriguing but some-
what elusive proposal developed in a number of papers by
Leland
Yeager (1983, 1985, 1992), plus otliers diat are coautliored widi
Robert Greenfield (1983,1989,1995). The most prominent of
diese
has been Greenfield and Yeager (1983), in which they refer to
their
proposal as the "BFH" system, as a consequence of its
relationship to
earner writings by Fischer Black, Eugene Fama, and Robert
HaU. It
is my opinion diat the system should neverdieless be attributed
to
Yeager and Greenfield, as diey combine various features of die
odier
writers and have championed die resulting product extensively
and
over a substantial period of time. I wdll, accordingly, refer to it
as the
Yeager-Greenfield system.^
^ This terminology was also used by Dom (1989).
443
C A T O JOURNAL
The central ingredient of the Yeager-Greenfield proposal is the
suggestion that genuine price level stability can be brought
about by
the appropriate designation of a broad-based consumption
bundle as
the unit of account in a monetary system in which there is little
or no
role for government involvement. ^ In this system the unit of
account
(UOA)— t̂ he unit in terms of which prices are quoted in most
trans-
actions—is based on a commodity bundle defined quite broadly
so
that movements in the cost of one such composite-commodity
bun-
dle closely represent movements in the "general price level."
Stabilization of an index number representing the cost of a
standard
bundle will then amount to general price level stability, and
move-
ments in UOA prices of individual commodities will represent
move-
ments in the real prices of the respective goods; thus
fluctuations in
output and employment will not be generated by "monetary
disequi-
libria." A second cmcial ingredient is the specification of
indirect
redeemability oí money—^that is, note and deposit claims to
standard
bundles. The proposal specifies tliat holders cannot insist on
convert-
ibility of notes or deposits into actual, physical standard
bundles, but
instead only on payment in terms of some agreed-upon
"redemption
medium" such as gold or securities (Yeager 1992). Accordingly,
I
would describe the system as one involving a commodity-bundle
standard with indirect convertibility—an acronym name might
be
CBIC. By stabilizing a broad index of prices such a system
should
provide much more price level stability than a monometallic or
bimetallic system; indeed this aspect represents an extended
version
of Alfred Marshall's (1887) "symmetalHsm" or Friedman's
(1951)
"commodity reserve currency"—that is, what one might refer to
as
"symmetallism on steriods."^
^ In Creenfield and Yeager (1983), the emphasis is on a
econotnies in which elec-
tronic accounting systems have replaced tangible tnedia of
exchange, making
them in a sense nonmonetary. The present discussion will ignore
that feature,
which is sotTiewhat extreme and irrelevant to tlie points at
issue.
* In my (1985: 32-38) discussion of Greenfield-Yeager (1983), I
was under the
tnistaken impression that it did not call for any redeetnability at
all, and conse-
quently I made sotne incorrect statements. My misreading
resulted from state-
ments on their p. 303, lines 15-21; p. 304, lines 10-11; p. 305,
lines 37-39; and
p. 306, lines 7-11. I did not, incidentally, claitn (1985: 34-35)
that the Yeager-
Creenfield system fails to produce a determinate price level;
what I argtied (in an
admittedly confusing way) was that it would be indetenninate if
there were no
specified link between the standard bundle and the unit of
account.
444
ALTERNATIVES TO THE F E D ?
The workings of tlie Yeager-Greenfield system are, experience
suggests, not etisy to understand, especially for economists who
have
not spent years in tlie stiidy of monetary systems widi private
money
provision. It is dierefore interesting to find die following
passage in
a paper of Yeager's entided "Toward Forecast-Free Monetary
Institutions" in wliich he is discussing possibilities for central
banks
such as the Federal Reserve:
A modified version of Irving Fisher's . . . compensated dollar
would furtlier limit any [monetary] autliority's discretion,
circumvent tfie prohlem of lags, and lessen the need for fore-
casts or even for continuous diagnosis. The authority would
he required to maintain two-way convertibility between its
money and whatever changeable amount of some redemp-
tion medium was actually worth, at current prices, tlie bun-
dle of goods and services specifying the target price index.
(More exactly, the bundle would deñne tlie dollar.) If the dol-
lar always exchanges against just enough redemption
medium (possibly gold, but probably securities) to be worth
the bundle, then the dollar is worth the bundle itself. The
audiority's obligation to redeem its money in this way at the
holder's initiative puts teeth into its commitment to a dollar
of stable purchasing power [Yeager 1992: 57].
Suppose then that dollars are paper bills and deposits at tlie
MA.
Imagine an episode in which tlie quoted prices of several
commodi-
ties rise and none fall, so that the dollar price of a standard
bundle of
goods and services rises above 1.0. Then a doUar will be worth
less
than a bundle of the standard composition, so private agents
will
send dollars to the MA for redemption. The MA will redeem
diem
and in the process of doing so wul reduce the supply of dollars,
thereby adjusting die money supply in die appropriate
direction.^
Since it would be infeasible to store actual bundles of goods and
serv-
ices to match die bundle defined by die chosen price level
index, die
MA wül redeem die dollars by paying (to tlie dollar-selling
agents)
securities whose current market value (at current prices) just
equals
the value of a standard bundle.
" This statement assumes that "money" refers to the medium of
account, which
is also the medium of exchange.
445
CATO JOURNAL
In the initial 1983 Greenfield-Yeager article, the dollars were
not
tangible bills but, instead, electronic bookkeeping entries—an
aspect
of the presentation that had been featured in papers by Black
(1970),
Fama (1983), and Hall (1982). But it does not matter, from die
per-
spective of monetary theory, what the physical form is for die
evi-
dence that one owns claims that the system is designed to keep
very
nearly equal in value to die market price of standard bundles.
Greenfield and Yeager had a good reason for focusing upon
cases in
which there was no tangible medium of exchange—namely, so
that
it would be easier to imagine diat the medium of account would
dif-
fer from any traditional medium of exchange—but that focus is
not
essential to the logic of dieir system's monetary design.
It seems clear diat the arrangement just described would, if
implemented and maintained, keep die value of dollars, in terms
of
the broad price index adopted, essentially constant. It is also
clear,
however, that the same problem as diat outlined in my
discussion of
die gold standard would again be present. Then the next issue
would
again be whedier such a system—^with competing private
money
providers instead of a central authority—^would be immune to
diis
problem and also the temptation for private suppliers to
overissue.
The latter difficulty could perhaps be overcome by means of die
type
of redeemability requirement mentioned at the end of the
previous
section.^"
In an earlier discussion of the Yeager-Greenfield system, I
consid-
ered the possibility diat the redemption medium could be
Treasury
securities (McCallum 2004: 87-89). In diat case, since the price
of
such securities is definitionaUy related to die interest rate
earned by
their holders, a MA's policy behavior could be expressed in
terms of
an interest-rate policy rule, widi the rate (and dius die price of
secu-
rities) adjusted in response to departures of the price level from
its
target value. One attraction of such a formulation is diat it
would
make possible—at least in principle—quantitative studies of die
type
used currently by mainstream monetary economists.^ ̂ A second
fea-
ture is that it would indicate a strong formal similarity between
the
Yeager-Greenfield system and an interest-rate policy rule, for
an
^̂ Greenfield and Yeager (1983) suggest that the ordinary
enforcement of con-
tracts would suffice.
^̂ In practice, however, such studies would be difficult since
the relevant time
periods would presumably be a few days or hours, rather than
the usual quarter-
years for which macroeconomic data are available.
446
ALTERNATIVES TO THE F E D ?
inflation-targeting central bank, provided diat tlie latter
incorporates
a zero inflation rate as its sole objective and adjusts its
instmment
very frequendy (e.g., day by day) to achieve that objective.
Conclusion
The results of the foregoing discussion can be summtirized
briefly.
There are two problems associated with a govemmentally
operated
gold standard. The first is diat stabilizing tlie price of gold is
not a
good substitute for stabilizing a broadly defined price level
index.
The second is that there wee political forces continually at work
that
tend, whatever the index, to undermine maintenance of the stan-
dard. Widi respect to tlie first problem, it seems clear diat
adoption
of a much broader index for stabilization is entirely feasible and
desirable. For the second the problem is more difficult. It would
seem that competing private suppliers of money would not have
the
same type of temptation to devalue the standard (i.e., inflate) as
does
a nationíü monetíiry authority, but a temptation of a different
type
clearly exists for private suppliers. Some form of regulation
might
tlierefore be required, in which case the regulator might be
faced
with die same temptation to inflate as with a standard monetary
autliority. The best diat can be done, probably, is to adopt
institu-
tions that are less subject to temptation than otliers and diat
promise
to provide stability of a broad price index.
In any event, it is highly unlikely tliat major movements toward
elimination of the Federal Reserve as the dominant monetary
authority of tlie United States will become viable in the
foreseeable
future. Gonsequently, it would seem diat obtaining a clear
mandate
for the Federal Reserve to make price stability its overriding
objec-
tive should be regarded as a leading agenda item. From diat
perspec-
tive, it might be judged that die best practical strategy for tlie
United
States at present is to strive to protect die Federal Reserve from
die
type of politically based reorganization that is currendy being
consid-
ered by Gongress,^^ and to campaign for recognition diat a
central
bank/monetary authority should be given a clear lexicographic
man-
'^ Current suggestions are designed to take policy influence
away from region;J
reserve bank presidents, wlio have been less inflation-prone
than Federal
1-ieseive Board members, and to give Congress more influence
over the selection
of reserve bank presidents (i.e., to increase politicization of
monetary policy).
447
C A T O JOURNAL
date for price level stability. I confess, however, that I have
Htde hope
that the present U.S. Congress can be persuaded to take such a
step.
References
Black, F. (1970) "Banking and Interest Rates in a World widiout
Money." Joumal of Bank Research 1 (Autumn): 9-20.
Bordo, M. J. (1981) "The Classical Gold Standard: Some
Lessons for
Today." Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis Monthly Review
(May): 2-17.
Dom, J. A. (1989) "Introduction: Altematives to Government
Fiat
Money." Cato Joumal 9 (Fall ): 277-94.
Fama, E. (1983) "Financial Intermediation and Price Level
Control." Joumal of Monetary Economics 12 (July): 7-28.
Friedman, M. (1951) "Commodity Reserve Currency." Joumal of
Political Economy 59: 203-32.
(1960) A Program for Monetary Stability. New
York: Fordham University Press.
(1961) "Real and Pseudo Gold Standards." Joumal
of Law and Economics A (October): 66-79.
Goodfriend, M. (1988) "Central Banking under the Gold
Standard."
Camegie-Rochester Conference Series on Public Policy 29
(Autijmn): 85-124.
Goodfriend, M., and McCallum, B. T. (2009) "Exiting Credit
Policy
to Preserve Sound Monetary Policy." Carnegie Mellon
University
(21 October).
Grant, J. (2009) "Requiem for the Dollar." Wall Street Joumal
(5-6
December): W1-W2.
Greenfield, R. L., and Yeager, L. B. (1983) "A Laissez Faire
Approach to Monetary Stability." Joumal of Money, Credit, and
Banking 27 (August): 302-15.
Greenfield, R. L.; Woolsey, W. W.; and Yeager, L. B. (1995)
"Is
Indirect Convertibility Impossible? A Comment on Schnadt and
Whittaker." Journal of Money, Credit, and Banking 27
(Febmaiy): 293-97.
Hall, R. E. (1982) "Explorations in die Gold Standard and
Related
Policies for Stabilizing the Dollar." In R. E. HaU (ed.)
Inflation:
Causes and Effects. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Hayek, F. A. (1978) Denationalization of Money. 2nd ed.
London:
Institute of Economic Affairs.
448
ALTERNATIVES T O T H E F E D ?
Marshall, A. (1887) "Remedies for Fluctuations of General
Prices."
Contemporary Review 51 (March): 355-75.
McCallum, B. T. (1985) "Bank Regulation, Accounting Systems
of
Exchange, and tlie Unit of Account: A Critical Review."
Camegie-
Rocliester Conference Series on Public Policy 23 (November):
13-45.
(2004) "Monetary Policy in Economies witli Little
or No Money." Pacific Economic Review % (June): 81-92.
Schnadt, N., and Whittiiker, J. (1993) "Inflation-Proof
Currency?
The Feasibility of Variable Commodity Standards." Joumal of
Money, Credit, and Banking 25 (May): 214-21.
(1995) "Is Direct Convertibility Impossible? A
Reply." JoumaJ of Money, Credit, and Banking 27 (Febmary):
297-98.
Taub, B. (1985) "Private Fiat Money witli Many
Suppliers."/oiirn¿i/
of Monetary Economics 16 (September): 195-208.
Timberlake, R. H. (1989) "The Govemment's License to Create
Money." Cato Joumal % {¥ú 1989): 301-21.
White, L. H. (1989) "What Kinds of Monetary Institutions
Would a
Free Market Deliver?" Cato Joumal'è (Fall): 367-91.
Yeager, L. B. (1983) "Stable Money and Free-Market
Currencies."
Cato Joumal 3 (FalJ): 305-26.
(1985) "Deregulation and Monetixry Reform."
American Economic Review Papers and Proceedings 75 (May):
103-07.
(1992) "Toward Forecast-Free Monetary Institu-
tions." Cato Joumal 12 (Spring-Summer): 53-73.
Yeager, L. B., and Greenfield, R. L. (1989) "Can Monetaiy
Disequilibrium Be Eliminated? Cato Joumal 9 (Fall): 405-21.
449
Copyright of CATO Journal is the property of Cato Institute and
its content may not be copied or emailed to
multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the copyright
holder's express written permission. However, users
may print, download, or email articles for individual use.

More Related Content

Similar to ALTERNATIVES TO THE F E D Bennett T. McCallumI must b.docx

Sound Money Sound Society
Sound Money Sound Society Sound Money Sound Society
Sound Money Sound Society Wealthbuilder.ie
 
Monetary policy institutions
Monetary policy institutionsMonetary policy institutions
Monetary policy institutionsjramuguis
 
Kristoffer Hansen LSC Presentation
Kristoffer Hansen LSC PresentationKristoffer Hansen LSC Presentation
Kristoffer Hansen LSC PresentationKristofferMoustenHan
 
Asia Paul Krugman What Happened To Asia
Asia Paul Krugman What Happened To AsiaAsia Paul Krugman What Happened To Asia
Asia Paul Krugman What Happened To AsiaFaizul Hyun Jea
 
2001 12 india indira gandhi institute_ keynote address_13_dec2001
2001 12 india indira gandhi institute_ keynote address_13_dec20012001 12 india indira gandhi institute_ keynote address_13_dec2001
2001 12 india indira gandhi institute_ keynote address_13_dec2001William White
 
Michael Durante Western Reserve 1Q029 review
Michael Durante Western Reserve  1Q029 reviewMichael Durante Western Reserve  1Q029 review
Michael Durante Western Reserve 1Q029 reviewMichael Durante
 
Fasanara Capital | Investment Outlook | May 3rd 2017
Fasanara Capital | Investment Outlook | May 3rd 2017Fasanara Capital | Investment Outlook | May 3rd 2017
Fasanara Capital | Investment Outlook | May 3rd 2017Fasanara Capital ltd
 
Crisis actual erturk 54
Crisis actual erturk 54Crisis actual erturk 54
Crisis actual erturk 54Antonio Paiva
 
Covered interest parity a law of nature in currency markets
Covered interest parity a law of nature in currency marketsCovered interest parity a law of nature in currency markets
Covered interest parity a law of nature in currency marketsGE 94
 
Endogenous money within sraffian framework and its implication for SME in Ar...
Endogenous money within sraffian framework and its  implication for SME in Ar...Endogenous money within sraffian framework and its  implication for SME in Ar...
Endogenous money within sraffian framework and its implication for SME in Ar...Grupo de Economia Política IE-UFRJ
 
Ss china the us & currencies harvard kennedy school presentation
Ss china the us & currencies harvard kennedy school presentationSs china the us & currencies harvard kennedy school presentation
Ss china the us & currencies harvard kennedy school presentationMarcus Vannini
 
Krugman IS-LM Model
Krugman  IS-LM ModelKrugman  IS-LM Model
Krugman IS-LM Modelmasterr1
 
CashflowFluiDynamics.icv_dino
CashflowFluiDynamics.icv_dinoCashflowFluiDynamics.icv_dino
CashflowFluiDynamics.icv_dinoDino, llc
 
Cashflow fluiddynamics 1
Cashflow fluiddynamics 1Cashflow fluiddynamics 1
Cashflow fluiddynamics 1Dino, llc
 
Azhar Mohamad & Imtiaz Mohammad Sifat
Azhar Mohamad & Imtiaz Mohammad SifatAzhar Mohamad & Imtiaz Mohammad Sifat
Azhar Mohamad & Imtiaz Mohammad Sifatidmac2015
 
Professor Alejandro Diaz-Bautista Effects of the Economic Crisis in Latin Ame...
Professor Alejandro Diaz-Bautista Effects of the Economic Crisis in Latin Ame...Professor Alejandro Diaz-Bautista Effects of the Economic Crisis in Latin Ame...
Professor Alejandro Diaz-Bautista Effects of the Economic Crisis in Latin Ame...Economist
 
1 financial development
1 financial development1 financial development
1 financial developmentkate_bullock99
 

Similar to ALTERNATIVES TO THE F E D Bennett T. McCallumI must b.docx (20)

Sound Money Sound Society
Sound Money Sound Society Sound Money Sound Society
Sound Money Sound Society
 
Monetary policy institutions
Monetary policy institutionsMonetary policy institutions
Monetary policy institutions
 
Kristoffer Hansen LSC Presentation
Kristoffer Hansen LSC PresentationKristoffer Hansen LSC Presentation
Kristoffer Hansen LSC Presentation
 
Asia Paul Krugman What Happened To Asia
Asia Paul Krugman What Happened To AsiaAsia Paul Krugman What Happened To Asia
Asia Paul Krugman What Happened To Asia
 
2001 12 india indira gandhi institute_ keynote address_13_dec2001
2001 12 india indira gandhi institute_ keynote address_13_dec20012001 12 india indira gandhi institute_ keynote address_13_dec2001
2001 12 india indira gandhi institute_ keynote address_13_dec2001
 
Michael Durante Western Reserve 1Q029 review
Michael Durante Western Reserve  1Q029 reviewMichael Durante Western Reserve  1Q029 review
Michael Durante Western Reserve 1Q029 review
 
Fasanara Capital | Investment Outlook | May 3rd 2017
Fasanara Capital | Investment Outlook | May 3rd 2017Fasanara Capital | Investment Outlook | May 3rd 2017
Fasanara Capital | Investment Outlook | May 3rd 2017
 
Crisis actual erturk 54
Crisis actual erturk 54Crisis actual erturk 54
Crisis actual erturk 54
 
Covered interest parity a law of nature in currency markets
Covered interest parity a law of nature in currency marketsCovered interest parity a law of nature in currency markets
Covered interest parity a law of nature in currency markets
 
Endogenous money within sraffian framework and its implication for SME in Ar...
Endogenous money within sraffian framework and its  implication for SME in Ar...Endogenous money within sraffian framework and its  implication for SME in Ar...
Endogenous money within sraffian framework and its implication for SME in Ar...
 
Ss china the us & currencies harvard kennedy school presentation
Ss china the us & currencies harvard kennedy school presentationSs china the us & currencies harvard kennedy school presentation
Ss china the us & currencies harvard kennedy school presentation
 
Krugman IS-LM Model
Krugman  IS-LM ModelKrugman  IS-LM Model
Krugman IS-LM Model
 
CashflowFluiDynamics.icv_dino
CashflowFluiDynamics.icv_dinoCashflowFluiDynamics.icv_dino
CashflowFluiDynamics.icv_dino
 
Cashflow fluiddynamics 1
Cashflow fluiddynamics 1Cashflow fluiddynamics 1
Cashflow fluiddynamics 1
 
Economics & politics
Economics & politicsEconomics & politics
Economics & politics
 
Azhar Mohamad & Imtiaz Mohammad Sifat
Azhar Mohamad & Imtiaz Mohammad SifatAzhar Mohamad & Imtiaz Mohammad Sifat
Azhar Mohamad & Imtiaz Mohammad Sifat
 
208 gwes unit 4a
208 gwes unit 4a208 gwes unit 4a
208 gwes unit 4a
 
208 gwes unit 4
208 gwes unit 4208 gwes unit 4
208 gwes unit 4
 
Professor Alejandro Diaz-Bautista Effects of the Economic Crisis in Latin Ame...
Professor Alejandro Diaz-Bautista Effects of the Economic Crisis in Latin Ame...Professor Alejandro Diaz-Bautista Effects of the Economic Crisis in Latin Ame...
Professor Alejandro Diaz-Bautista Effects of the Economic Crisis in Latin Ame...
 
1 financial development
1 financial development1 financial development
1 financial development
 

More from nettletondevon

Your NamePractical ConnectionYour NameNOTE To insert a .docx
Your NamePractical ConnectionYour NameNOTE To insert a .docxYour NamePractical ConnectionYour NameNOTE To insert a .docx
Your NamePractical ConnectionYour NameNOTE To insert a .docxnettletondevon
 
Your namePresenter’s name(s) DateTITILE Motivatio.docx
Your namePresenter’s name(s) DateTITILE Motivatio.docxYour namePresenter’s name(s) DateTITILE Motivatio.docx
Your namePresenter’s name(s) DateTITILE Motivatio.docxnettletondevon
 
Your nameProfessor NameCourseDatePaper Outline.docx
Your nameProfessor NameCourseDatePaper Outline.docxYour nameProfessor NameCourseDatePaper Outline.docx
Your nameProfessor NameCourseDatePaper Outline.docxnettletondevon
 
Your name _________________________________ Date of submission _.docx
Your name _________________________________ Date of submission _.docxYour name _________________________________ Date of submission _.docx
Your name _________________________________ Date of submission _.docxnettletondevon
 
Your NameECD 310 Exceptional Learning and InclusionInstruct.docx
Your NameECD 310 Exceptional Learning and InclusionInstruct.docxYour NameECD 310 Exceptional Learning and InclusionInstruct.docx
Your NameECD 310 Exceptional Learning and InclusionInstruct.docxnettletondevon
 
Your Name University of the Cumberlands ISOL634-25 P.docx
Your Name University of the Cumberlands ISOL634-25 P.docxYour Name University of the Cumberlands ISOL634-25 P.docx
Your Name University of the Cumberlands ISOL634-25 P.docxnettletondevon
 
Your Name Professor Name Subject Name 06 Apr.docx
Your Name  Professor Name  Subject Name  06 Apr.docxYour Name  Professor Name  Subject Name  06 Apr.docx
Your Name Professor Name Subject Name 06 Apr.docxnettletondevon
 
Your muscular system examassignment is to describe location (su.docx
Your muscular system examassignment is to describe location (su.docxYour muscular system examassignment is to describe location (su.docx
Your muscular system examassignment is to describe location (su.docxnettletondevon
 
Your midterm will be a virtual, individual assignment. You can choos.docx
Your midterm will be a virtual, individual assignment. You can choos.docxYour midterm will be a virtual, individual assignment. You can choos.docx
Your midterm will be a virtual, individual assignment. You can choos.docxnettletondevon
 
Your local art museum has asked you to design a gallery dedicated to.docx
Your local art museum has asked you to design a gallery dedicated to.docxYour local art museum has asked you to design a gallery dedicated to.docx
Your local art museum has asked you to design a gallery dedicated to.docxnettletondevon
 
Your letter should include Introduction – Include your name, i.docx
Your letter should include Introduction – Include your name, i.docxYour letter should include Introduction – Include your name, i.docx
Your letter should include Introduction – Include your name, i.docxnettletondevon
 
Your legal analysis should be approximately 500 wordsDetermine.docx
Your legal analysis should be approximately 500 wordsDetermine.docxYour legal analysis should be approximately 500 wordsDetermine.docx
Your legal analysis should be approximately 500 wordsDetermine.docxnettletondevon
 
Your Last Name 1Your Name Teacher Name English cl.docx
Your Last Name  1Your Name Teacher Name English cl.docxYour Last Name  1Your Name Teacher Name English cl.docx
Your Last Name 1Your Name Teacher Name English cl.docxnettletondevon
 
Your job is to delegate job tasks to each healthcare practitioner (U.docx
Your job is to delegate job tasks to each healthcare practitioner (U.docxYour job is to delegate job tasks to each healthcare practitioner (U.docx
Your job is to delegate job tasks to each healthcare practitioner (U.docxnettletondevon
 
Your job is to look at the routing tables and DRAW (on a piece of pa.docx
Your job is to look at the routing tables and DRAW (on a piece of pa.docxYour job is to look at the routing tables and DRAW (on a piece of pa.docx
Your job is to look at the routing tables and DRAW (on a piece of pa.docxnettletondevon
 
Your job is to design a user interface that displays the lotto.docx
Your job is to design a user interface that displays the lotto.docxYour job is to design a user interface that displays the lotto.docx
Your job is to design a user interface that displays the lotto.docxnettletondevon
 
Your Introduction of the StudyYour Purpose of the stud.docx
Your Introduction of the StudyYour Purpose of the stud.docxYour Introduction of the StudyYour Purpose of the stud.docx
Your Introduction of the StudyYour Purpose of the stud.docxnettletondevon
 
Your instructor will assign peer reviewers. You will review a fell.docx
Your instructor will assign peer reviewers. You will review a fell.docxYour instructor will assign peer reviewers. You will review a fell.docx
Your instructor will assign peer reviewers. You will review a fell.docxnettletondevon
 
Your initial reading is a close examination of the work youve c.docx
Your initial reading is a close examination of the work youve c.docxYour initial reading is a close examination of the work youve c.docx
Your initial reading is a close examination of the work youve c.docxnettletondevon
 
Your initial posting must be no less than 200 words each and is due .docx
Your initial posting must be no less than 200 words each and is due .docxYour initial posting must be no less than 200 words each and is due .docx
Your initial posting must be no less than 200 words each and is due .docxnettletondevon
 

More from nettletondevon (20)

Your NamePractical ConnectionYour NameNOTE To insert a .docx
Your NamePractical ConnectionYour NameNOTE To insert a .docxYour NamePractical ConnectionYour NameNOTE To insert a .docx
Your NamePractical ConnectionYour NameNOTE To insert a .docx
 
Your namePresenter’s name(s) DateTITILE Motivatio.docx
Your namePresenter’s name(s) DateTITILE Motivatio.docxYour namePresenter’s name(s) DateTITILE Motivatio.docx
Your namePresenter’s name(s) DateTITILE Motivatio.docx
 
Your nameProfessor NameCourseDatePaper Outline.docx
Your nameProfessor NameCourseDatePaper Outline.docxYour nameProfessor NameCourseDatePaper Outline.docx
Your nameProfessor NameCourseDatePaper Outline.docx
 
Your name _________________________________ Date of submission _.docx
Your name _________________________________ Date of submission _.docxYour name _________________________________ Date of submission _.docx
Your name _________________________________ Date of submission _.docx
 
Your NameECD 310 Exceptional Learning and InclusionInstruct.docx
Your NameECD 310 Exceptional Learning and InclusionInstruct.docxYour NameECD 310 Exceptional Learning and InclusionInstruct.docx
Your NameECD 310 Exceptional Learning and InclusionInstruct.docx
 
Your Name University of the Cumberlands ISOL634-25 P.docx
Your Name University of the Cumberlands ISOL634-25 P.docxYour Name University of the Cumberlands ISOL634-25 P.docx
Your Name University of the Cumberlands ISOL634-25 P.docx
 
Your Name Professor Name Subject Name 06 Apr.docx
Your Name  Professor Name  Subject Name  06 Apr.docxYour Name  Professor Name  Subject Name  06 Apr.docx
Your Name Professor Name Subject Name 06 Apr.docx
 
Your muscular system examassignment is to describe location (su.docx
Your muscular system examassignment is to describe location (su.docxYour muscular system examassignment is to describe location (su.docx
Your muscular system examassignment is to describe location (su.docx
 
Your midterm will be a virtual, individual assignment. You can choos.docx
Your midterm will be a virtual, individual assignment. You can choos.docxYour midterm will be a virtual, individual assignment. You can choos.docx
Your midterm will be a virtual, individual assignment. You can choos.docx
 
Your local art museum has asked you to design a gallery dedicated to.docx
Your local art museum has asked you to design a gallery dedicated to.docxYour local art museum has asked you to design a gallery dedicated to.docx
Your local art museum has asked you to design a gallery dedicated to.docx
 
Your letter should include Introduction – Include your name, i.docx
Your letter should include Introduction – Include your name, i.docxYour letter should include Introduction – Include your name, i.docx
Your letter should include Introduction – Include your name, i.docx
 
Your legal analysis should be approximately 500 wordsDetermine.docx
Your legal analysis should be approximately 500 wordsDetermine.docxYour legal analysis should be approximately 500 wordsDetermine.docx
Your legal analysis should be approximately 500 wordsDetermine.docx
 
Your Last Name 1Your Name Teacher Name English cl.docx
Your Last Name  1Your Name Teacher Name English cl.docxYour Last Name  1Your Name Teacher Name English cl.docx
Your Last Name 1Your Name Teacher Name English cl.docx
 
Your job is to delegate job tasks to each healthcare practitioner (U.docx
Your job is to delegate job tasks to each healthcare practitioner (U.docxYour job is to delegate job tasks to each healthcare practitioner (U.docx
Your job is to delegate job tasks to each healthcare practitioner (U.docx
 
Your job is to look at the routing tables and DRAW (on a piece of pa.docx
Your job is to look at the routing tables and DRAW (on a piece of pa.docxYour job is to look at the routing tables and DRAW (on a piece of pa.docx
Your job is to look at the routing tables and DRAW (on a piece of pa.docx
 
Your job is to design a user interface that displays the lotto.docx
Your job is to design a user interface that displays the lotto.docxYour job is to design a user interface that displays the lotto.docx
Your job is to design a user interface that displays the lotto.docx
 
Your Introduction of the StudyYour Purpose of the stud.docx
Your Introduction of the StudyYour Purpose of the stud.docxYour Introduction of the StudyYour Purpose of the stud.docx
Your Introduction of the StudyYour Purpose of the stud.docx
 
Your instructor will assign peer reviewers. You will review a fell.docx
Your instructor will assign peer reviewers. You will review a fell.docxYour instructor will assign peer reviewers. You will review a fell.docx
Your instructor will assign peer reviewers. You will review a fell.docx
 
Your initial reading is a close examination of the work youve c.docx
Your initial reading is a close examination of the work youve c.docxYour initial reading is a close examination of the work youve c.docx
Your initial reading is a close examination of the work youve c.docx
 
Your initial posting must be no less than 200 words each and is due .docx
Your initial posting must be no less than 200 words each and is due .docxYour initial posting must be no less than 200 words each and is due .docx
Your initial posting must be no less than 200 words each and is due .docx
 

Recently uploaded

भारत-रोम व्यापार.pptx, Indo-Roman Trade,
भारत-रोम व्यापार.pptx, Indo-Roman Trade,भारत-रोम व्यापार.pptx, Indo-Roman Trade,
भारत-रोम व्यापार.pptx, Indo-Roman Trade,Virag Sontakke
 
Roles & Responsibilities in Pharmacovigilance
Roles & Responsibilities in PharmacovigilanceRoles & Responsibilities in Pharmacovigilance
Roles & Responsibilities in PharmacovigilanceSamikshaHamane
 
DATA STRUCTURE AND ALGORITHM for beginners
DATA STRUCTURE AND ALGORITHM for beginnersDATA STRUCTURE AND ALGORITHM for beginners
DATA STRUCTURE AND ALGORITHM for beginnersSabitha Banu
 
Software Engineering Methodologies (overview)
Software Engineering Methodologies (overview)Software Engineering Methodologies (overview)
Software Engineering Methodologies (overview)eniolaolutunde
 
Alper Gobel In Media Res Media Component
Alper Gobel In Media Res Media ComponentAlper Gobel In Media Res Media Component
Alper Gobel In Media Res Media ComponentInMediaRes1
 
Introduction to AI in Higher Education_draft.pptx
Introduction to AI in Higher Education_draft.pptxIntroduction to AI in Higher Education_draft.pptx
Introduction to AI in Higher Education_draft.pptxpboyjonauth
 
call girls in Kamla Market (DELHI) 🔝 >༒9953330565🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️
call girls in Kamla Market (DELHI) 🔝 >༒9953330565🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️call girls in Kamla Market (DELHI) 🔝 >༒9953330565🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️
call girls in Kamla Market (DELHI) 🔝 >༒9953330565🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️9953056974 Low Rate Call Girls In Saket, Delhi NCR
 
Solving Puzzles Benefits Everyone (English).pptx
Solving Puzzles Benefits Everyone (English).pptxSolving Puzzles Benefits Everyone (English).pptx
Solving Puzzles Benefits Everyone (English).pptxOH TEIK BIN
 
Presiding Officer Training module 2024 lok sabha elections
Presiding Officer Training module 2024 lok sabha electionsPresiding Officer Training module 2024 lok sabha elections
Presiding Officer Training module 2024 lok sabha electionsanshu789521
 
CARE OF CHILD IN INCUBATOR..........pptx
CARE OF CHILD IN INCUBATOR..........pptxCARE OF CHILD IN INCUBATOR..........pptx
CARE OF CHILD IN INCUBATOR..........pptxGaneshChakor2
 
Enzyme, Pharmaceutical Aids, Miscellaneous Last Part of Chapter no 5th.pdf
Enzyme, Pharmaceutical Aids, Miscellaneous Last Part of Chapter no 5th.pdfEnzyme, Pharmaceutical Aids, Miscellaneous Last Part of Chapter no 5th.pdf
Enzyme, Pharmaceutical Aids, Miscellaneous Last Part of Chapter no 5th.pdfSumit Tiwari
 
Framing an Appropriate Research Question 6b9b26d93da94caf993c038d9efcdedb.pdf
Framing an Appropriate Research Question 6b9b26d93da94caf993c038d9efcdedb.pdfFraming an Appropriate Research Question 6b9b26d93da94caf993c038d9efcdedb.pdf
Framing an Appropriate Research Question 6b9b26d93da94caf993c038d9efcdedb.pdfUjwalaBharambe
 
CELL CYCLE Division Science 8 quarter IV.pptx
CELL CYCLE Division Science 8 quarter IV.pptxCELL CYCLE Division Science 8 quarter IV.pptx
CELL CYCLE Division Science 8 quarter IV.pptxJiesonDelaCerna
 
History Class XII Ch. 3 Kinship, Caste and Class (1).pptx
History Class XII Ch. 3 Kinship, Caste and Class (1).pptxHistory Class XII Ch. 3 Kinship, Caste and Class (1).pptx
History Class XII Ch. 3 Kinship, Caste and Class (1).pptxsocialsciencegdgrohi
 
Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 1 STEP Using Odoo 17
Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 1 STEP Using Odoo 17Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 1 STEP Using Odoo 17
Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 1 STEP Using Odoo 17Celine George
 
KSHARA STURA .pptx---KSHARA KARMA THERAPY (CAUSTIC THERAPY)————IMP.OF KSHARA ...
KSHARA STURA .pptx---KSHARA KARMA THERAPY (CAUSTIC THERAPY)————IMP.OF KSHARA ...KSHARA STURA .pptx---KSHARA KARMA THERAPY (CAUSTIC THERAPY)————IMP.OF KSHARA ...
KSHARA STURA .pptx---KSHARA KARMA THERAPY (CAUSTIC THERAPY)————IMP.OF KSHARA ...M56BOOKSTORE PRODUCT/SERVICE
 

Recently uploaded (20)

ESSENTIAL of (CS/IT/IS) class 06 (database)
ESSENTIAL of (CS/IT/IS) class 06 (database)ESSENTIAL of (CS/IT/IS) class 06 (database)
ESSENTIAL of (CS/IT/IS) class 06 (database)
 
भारत-रोम व्यापार.pptx, Indo-Roman Trade,
भारत-रोम व्यापार.pptx, Indo-Roman Trade,भारत-रोम व्यापार.pptx, Indo-Roman Trade,
भारत-रोम व्यापार.pptx, Indo-Roman Trade,
 
Roles & Responsibilities in Pharmacovigilance
Roles & Responsibilities in PharmacovigilanceRoles & Responsibilities in Pharmacovigilance
Roles & Responsibilities in Pharmacovigilance
 
DATA STRUCTURE AND ALGORITHM for beginners
DATA STRUCTURE AND ALGORITHM for beginnersDATA STRUCTURE AND ALGORITHM for beginners
DATA STRUCTURE AND ALGORITHM for beginners
 
Software Engineering Methodologies (overview)
Software Engineering Methodologies (overview)Software Engineering Methodologies (overview)
Software Engineering Methodologies (overview)
 
Alper Gobel In Media Res Media Component
Alper Gobel In Media Res Media ComponentAlper Gobel In Media Res Media Component
Alper Gobel In Media Res Media Component
 
Introduction to AI in Higher Education_draft.pptx
Introduction to AI in Higher Education_draft.pptxIntroduction to AI in Higher Education_draft.pptx
Introduction to AI in Higher Education_draft.pptx
 
call girls in Kamla Market (DELHI) 🔝 >༒9953330565🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️
call girls in Kamla Market (DELHI) 🔝 >༒9953330565🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️call girls in Kamla Market (DELHI) 🔝 >༒9953330565🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️
call girls in Kamla Market (DELHI) 🔝 >༒9953330565🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️
 
Model Call Girl in Bikash Puri Delhi reach out to us at 🔝9953056974🔝
Model Call Girl in Bikash Puri  Delhi reach out to us at 🔝9953056974🔝Model Call Girl in Bikash Puri  Delhi reach out to us at 🔝9953056974🔝
Model Call Girl in Bikash Puri Delhi reach out to us at 🔝9953056974🔝
 
Solving Puzzles Benefits Everyone (English).pptx
Solving Puzzles Benefits Everyone (English).pptxSolving Puzzles Benefits Everyone (English).pptx
Solving Puzzles Benefits Everyone (English).pptx
 
Presiding Officer Training module 2024 lok sabha elections
Presiding Officer Training module 2024 lok sabha electionsPresiding Officer Training module 2024 lok sabha elections
Presiding Officer Training module 2024 lok sabha elections
 
Model Call Girl in Tilak Nagar Delhi reach out to us at 🔝9953056974🔝
Model Call Girl in Tilak Nagar Delhi reach out to us at 🔝9953056974🔝Model Call Girl in Tilak Nagar Delhi reach out to us at 🔝9953056974🔝
Model Call Girl in Tilak Nagar Delhi reach out to us at 🔝9953056974🔝
 
CARE OF CHILD IN INCUBATOR..........pptx
CARE OF CHILD IN INCUBATOR..........pptxCARE OF CHILD IN INCUBATOR..........pptx
CARE OF CHILD IN INCUBATOR..........pptx
 
Enzyme, Pharmaceutical Aids, Miscellaneous Last Part of Chapter no 5th.pdf
Enzyme, Pharmaceutical Aids, Miscellaneous Last Part of Chapter no 5th.pdfEnzyme, Pharmaceutical Aids, Miscellaneous Last Part of Chapter no 5th.pdf
Enzyme, Pharmaceutical Aids, Miscellaneous Last Part of Chapter no 5th.pdf
 
Framing an Appropriate Research Question 6b9b26d93da94caf993c038d9efcdedb.pdf
Framing an Appropriate Research Question 6b9b26d93da94caf993c038d9efcdedb.pdfFraming an Appropriate Research Question 6b9b26d93da94caf993c038d9efcdedb.pdf
Framing an Appropriate Research Question 6b9b26d93da94caf993c038d9efcdedb.pdf
 
CELL CYCLE Division Science 8 quarter IV.pptx
CELL CYCLE Division Science 8 quarter IV.pptxCELL CYCLE Division Science 8 quarter IV.pptx
CELL CYCLE Division Science 8 quarter IV.pptx
 
History Class XII Ch. 3 Kinship, Caste and Class (1).pptx
History Class XII Ch. 3 Kinship, Caste and Class (1).pptxHistory Class XII Ch. 3 Kinship, Caste and Class (1).pptx
History Class XII Ch. 3 Kinship, Caste and Class (1).pptx
 
Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 1 STEP Using Odoo 17
Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 1 STEP Using Odoo 17Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 1 STEP Using Odoo 17
Incoming and Outgoing Shipments in 1 STEP Using Odoo 17
 
OS-operating systems- ch04 (Threads) ...
OS-operating systems- ch04 (Threads) ...OS-operating systems- ch04 (Threads) ...
OS-operating systems- ch04 (Threads) ...
 
KSHARA STURA .pptx---KSHARA KARMA THERAPY (CAUSTIC THERAPY)————IMP.OF KSHARA ...
KSHARA STURA .pptx---KSHARA KARMA THERAPY (CAUSTIC THERAPY)————IMP.OF KSHARA ...KSHARA STURA .pptx---KSHARA KARMA THERAPY (CAUSTIC THERAPY)————IMP.OF KSHARA ...
KSHARA STURA .pptx---KSHARA KARMA THERAPY (CAUSTIC THERAPY)————IMP.OF KSHARA ...
 

ALTERNATIVES TO THE F E D Bennett T. McCallumI must b.docx

  • 1. ALTERNATIVES TO THE F E D ? Bennett T. McCallum I must begin by saying that I have been extremely disappointed— the word "appalled" may be more accurate—by several develop- ments over the last two years involving tlie Federal Reserve. It was, I believe, appropriate that the Fed would respond widi expansionary monetary policy in the face of a major macroeconomic downtum, which it did. But it did not have to do so by means of operations tliat incorporated major excursions into credit policy, as weU as monetary policy, and thereby into the unauthorized exercise of fiscal policy. ̂ By engaging in such operations on a very large sctile, die Fed's actions are iJmost certain to have detrimental effects on tlie Fed's independ- ence—and thereby on its resulting ability to focus attention on what shotild be its principal objective, namely, price level stability. Furthermore, tlie Fed has not been moving quickly—if at all—to explain and correct this situation. AH in aU, die recent experience has had flie effect of moving the Fed away from die type of policy behavior tliat niixinstream
  • 2. academic analysts have been promoting over tlie past 15 years—namely, an activist but mle-based monetary stabilization policy fliat emphasizes Catojounwl, Vol. 30, No. 3 (Fall 2010). Copyright © Cato Institute. All rights reserved. Bennett T. McCiilhtin is Professor of Econotnics at Carnegie Mellon University. He thanks Marvin Coodfriend for helpful cotntnents. 'Coodfriend and McCallum (2009) distinguish between pure monetary policy (changes in base money by central bank purchase or sale of Treasury securities), pttre credit policy (changes in the cotnposition of central bank assets witli no change in base tnoney), and ititerest-on-reserves policy (with no balance sheet changes). Since the Fed returns to the Treasury the interest received on the Treasury securities that it holds, it is the case that when the Fed sells Treasuries to fund expansionary credit policy the net results are the satne as if the Treasury fttianced credit extensions by selling its securities to (i.e., borrowing from) the public. 439
  • 3. CATO JOURNAL die avoidance of significant inflation while also avoiding deflation. In saying this, I do recognize that the term "inflation targeting" has been gradually corrupted so as to pemiit excessive aspects of "fine tuning" relating to output and employment levels, but by and large I believe that the academic literature has been mosdy constructive and that much ofthe commentary tending to discredit it on the basis of recent events has done so mistakenly. Monetary Policy and Exchange Rates In previous writings, I have argued that monetary policy and exchange rate policy are linked togedier so intimately that diey should be considered as two sides of the same coin. From that per- spective, it seems an unfortunate anachronism that official exchange- rate responsibility is assigned to the Treasury or Finance Ministry in many economies, including the United States, Japan, and— t̂ o a small extent—even the European Union. But, in any case, this topic in turn leads us to contemplate other types of monetary regimes— arrangements other than fiat money, managed by a national central bank, in the context of floating exchange rates. In this regard there are, I believe, three main alternatives that need to be discussed. These are the gold standard, private
  • 4. competi- tive supply of money, and the Yeager-Greenfield plan for an auto- matically stabilized unit of account. For all three of these, a major outlet for sympathetic and scholarly discussion has been the Cato Joumai. For this, tlie Cato Joumai deserves much credit, even from readers who are basically supporters ofthe fiat-floating regime. I will attempt to provide some relevant considerations in the remainder of my presentation. The Cold Standard There are many critics of the gold standard among economists who are ardent believers that any monetary arrangement should have price stability as its overriding objective; one might mention AHan Meltzer, Anna Schwartz, and Leland Yeager. One reason for criticism is that while a traditional gold standard tends to protect an economy from major inflations or deflations over a decade or more, it pennits a substantial amount of variability at die business-cycle frequency (see, e.g.. Bordo 1981). The difficulty that I wish to emphasize here 440
  • 5. ALTERNATIVES TO THE F E D ? is different, however; it is one stressed in Friedmtin (1961)— one of his less-famous papers. My own way of diinldng about diis point begins widi die assumption that any gold-standard arrangement today would be one in which the nation's monetary audiority (MA) stiuids ready to exchange gold, at a fixed rate and in botli directions, for the principal paper medium of exchange—let us use the term "dollars" and also assume that die medium of exchange (MOE) is the medium of account (MOA).^ This fixed price is supposed to be main- tcüned indefinitely. But if the MA has die capability of adjusting this price, dien diere is no permanent anchor for die price level even if dollars are at each point of time convertible into gold. The problem is that die population of die United States—like diat of odier coun- tries—is full of congressmen, businessmen, union leaders, nonprofit organizations, voters, television commentators, and miscellaneous individuals who will be frequendy clamoring for the MA to raise or lower die medium-of-exchange price of gold (or whatever is die stan- dard commodity). An increase would then possibly be stimulative but only temporarily and would be followed by price increases for
  • 6. goods in genenil, diat is, by a burst of inflation. Historically, the gold stan- dard provided a reasonable degree of price level stability over long spans of time because the population at large had at diat time a semi- religious belief diat die price of gold should not be varied but should be maintained "forever."'̂ But today die same political forces tliat impinge upon die Fed to be inflationary under our present arrange- ment would work dirough this alternative channel under the sug- gested gold system. Friedman (1961) referred to such a system as a "pseudo gold standard" and pointed out diat it amounted in die United States of 1913-1961 to a price-support arrangement for gold producers radier dian as a desirable monetary standard.'' ^ In this regard, I would like to point out that a recent piece by James Grant (2009)—two full pages in the Wall Street Jounml—in efTect adopts the same position (in its Final paragraph). This WSJ piece has, apparently, been adapted From Grant's highly enjoyable presentation at the Cato Monetary Conference (November 19, 2009). •̂ Tiniberlake (1989: 317) reports tliat the London mint price of gold was kept nearly constant from 1665 to 1914. •* It should be noted tliat the present discussion, which focuses on changes over
  • 7. time in the dollar price of gold, does not consider possible variations in the reserve ratio. For an analysis that emphasizes such variations (in a somewhat dif- ferent model than the one presumed here), see Goodfriend (1988) 441 CATO JOURNAL Of course, there is die logical possibility of what Friedman called a "real" gold standard, under which actual physical coins or bars of gold would serve as the primary MOE despite the costliness of main- taining such a stock. But as Friedman (1960:5-7) says, there is a very strong tendency for such a system to evolve into one with "fiduciary elements" and eventually to degenerate into a commodity currency in which tlie commodity is paper—or, today, digital storage capacity. In any event, I have (for simplicity) ruled out diis possibility by assumption. Competing Private Money Suppliers The second alternative that should be mentioned is the provision of media of exchange by competing private suppliers. The most prominent of writings on diis topic is probably the monograph by
  • 8. Hayek (1978), but the most comprehensive review of ideas that I have seen is provided by White (1989). The bulk of his discussion pertains to arrangements under which private issuers of notes and deposits used as MOE are convertible into gold or some other com- modity (or bundle). If such convertibility were required by law,̂ there seems to be Htde reason why a system of tliis type would not be viable, but there is also no reason why die legal par value would not be subject to the same pressures as those discussed in tlie previ- ous section. These wotild be pressures not on individual banks (i.e., private issuers), but on the national monetary authority. Next, to change the perspective, suppose that there were no legtil restrictions on private note-and-deposit suppliers who could then offer purely fiduciary (i.e., inconvertible) currencies. Regarding this case, Friedman (1960: 7) argued: Such a currency would involve a negligible use of real resources to produce . . . and would therefore seem to avoid any pressure to undermine it arising frotu the possibility of saving real resources. This is true for the community as a whole but not for any single issuer of currency. So long as the fiduciary currency has a tTiarket value greater than its cost of production—which under favorable conditions can be com- pressed close to the cost of the paper on which it is printed—
  • 9. ' I assume that such a requirement would include specification of a minimum gold/paper reserve ratio. 442 ALTERNATIVES T O T H E F E D ? any individual issuer has an incentive to issue additiotial atnounts. A fiduciary currency would thus probably tend through increased issue to degenerate into a cotntiiodity cur- reticy—into a literal paper standard—there being no stable equilibrium price level short ofthat at wbich die money value of curreney is no greater than that ofthe paper it cont;üns. In die intervening half-century diere have been some formal studies of this conjecture, several of which have been summarized by Wliite (1989). The key analytical result seems to be diat of Taub (1985), who finds that, because ofthe dynamic inconsistency involved, such a system could only be sustainable if die issuer were to provide potential users with a contractual commitment to redeemability in some acceptable medium—and diis would require, I would add, general belief that die legal system will enforce such contracts. Given recent experience, it may be difficult to generate such belief. Nevertheless, diis last possibOity seems wordiy of additional con- sideration. A governmental agency widi die sole responsibility
  • 10. of see- ing diat redeemability contracts are specified and enforced—and without the power to modify par vtilues itself—might provide a type of arrangement diat could widistand political pressures for monetary stimulus and also eliminate die possibility of private bank over- issuance. The Yeager-Creenfield System The diird alternative to be considered is an intriguing but some- what elusive proposal developed in a number of papers by Leland Yeager (1983, 1985, 1992), plus otliers diat are coautliored widi Robert Greenfield (1983,1989,1995). The most prominent of diese has been Greenfield and Yeager (1983), in which they refer to their proposal as the "BFH" system, as a consequence of its relationship to earner writings by Fischer Black, Eugene Fama, and Robert HaU. It is my opinion diat the system should neverdieless be attributed to Yeager and Greenfield, as diey combine various features of die odier writers and have championed die resulting product extensively and over a substantial period of time. I wdll, accordingly, refer to it as the Yeager-Greenfield system.^ ^ This terminology was also used by Dom (1989). 443
  • 11. C A T O JOURNAL The central ingredient of the Yeager-Greenfield proposal is the suggestion that genuine price level stability can be brought about by the appropriate designation of a broad-based consumption bundle as the unit of account in a monetary system in which there is little or no role for government involvement. ^ In this system the unit of account (UOA)— t̂ he unit in terms of which prices are quoted in most trans- actions—is based on a commodity bundle defined quite broadly so that movements in the cost of one such composite-commodity bun- dle closely represent movements in the "general price level." Stabilization of an index number representing the cost of a standard bundle will then amount to general price level stability, and move- ments in UOA prices of individual commodities will represent move- ments in the real prices of the respective goods; thus fluctuations in output and employment will not be generated by "monetary disequi- libria." A second cmcial ingredient is the specification of indirect redeemability oí money—^that is, note and deposit claims to standard bundles. The proposal specifies tliat holders cannot insist on
  • 12. convert- ibility of notes or deposits into actual, physical standard bundles, but instead only on payment in terms of some agreed-upon "redemption medium" such as gold or securities (Yeager 1992). Accordingly, I would describe the system as one involving a commodity-bundle standard with indirect convertibility—an acronym name might be CBIC. By stabilizing a broad index of prices such a system should provide much more price level stability than a monometallic or bimetallic system; indeed this aspect represents an extended version of Alfred Marshall's (1887) "symmetalHsm" or Friedman's (1951) "commodity reserve currency"—that is, what one might refer to as "symmetallism on steriods."^ ^ In Creenfield and Yeager (1983), the emphasis is on a econotnies in which elec- tronic accounting systems have replaced tangible tnedia of exchange, making them in a sense nonmonetary. The present discussion will ignore that feature, which is sotTiewhat extreme and irrelevant to tlie points at issue. * In my (1985: 32-38) discussion of Greenfield-Yeager (1983), I was under the tnistaken impression that it did not call for any redeetnability at all, and conse- quently I made sotne incorrect statements. My misreading resulted from state- ments on their p. 303, lines 15-21; p. 304, lines 10-11; p. 305,
  • 13. lines 37-39; and p. 306, lines 7-11. I did not, incidentally, claitn (1985: 34-35) that the Yeager- Creenfield system fails to produce a determinate price level; what I argtied (in an admittedly confusing way) was that it would be indetenninate if there were no specified link between the standard bundle and the unit of account. 444 ALTERNATIVES TO THE F E D ? The workings of tlie Yeager-Greenfield system are, experience suggests, not etisy to understand, especially for economists who have not spent years in tlie stiidy of monetary systems widi private money provision. It is dierefore interesting to find die following passage in a paper of Yeager's entided "Toward Forecast-Free Monetary Institutions" in wliich he is discussing possibilities for central banks such as the Federal Reserve: A modified version of Irving Fisher's . . . compensated dollar would furtlier limit any [monetary] autliority's discretion, circumvent tfie prohlem of lags, and lessen the need for fore- casts or even for continuous diagnosis. The authority would he required to maintain two-way convertibility between its money and whatever changeable amount of some redemp- tion medium was actually worth, at current prices, tlie bun- dle of goods and services specifying the target price index.
  • 14. (More exactly, the bundle would deñne tlie dollar.) If the dol- lar always exchanges against just enough redemption medium (possibly gold, but probably securities) to be worth the bundle, then the dollar is worth the bundle itself. The audiority's obligation to redeem its money in this way at the holder's initiative puts teeth into its commitment to a dollar of stable purchasing power [Yeager 1992: 57]. Suppose then that dollars are paper bills and deposits at tlie MA. Imagine an episode in which tlie quoted prices of several commodi- ties rise and none fall, so that the dollar price of a standard bundle of goods and services rises above 1.0. Then a doUar will be worth less than a bundle of the standard composition, so private agents will send dollars to the MA for redemption. The MA will redeem diem and in the process of doing so wul reduce the supply of dollars, thereby adjusting die money supply in die appropriate direction.^ Since it would be infeasible to store actual bundles of goods and serv- ices to match die bundle defined by die chosen price level index, die MA wül redeem die dollars by paying (to tlie dollar-selling agents) securities whose current market value (at current prices) just equals the value of a standard bundle. " This statement assumes that "money" refers to the medium of account, which is also the medium of exchange.
  • 15. 445 CATO JOURNAL In the initial 1983 Greenfield-Yeager article, the dollars were not tangible bills but, instead, electronic bookkeeping entries—an aspect of the presentation that had been featured in papers by Black (1970), Fama (1983), and Hall (1982). But it does not matter, from die per- spective of monetary theory, what the physical form is for die evi- dence that one owns claims that the system is designed to keep very nearly equal in value to die market price of standard bundles. Greenfield and Yeager had a good reason for focusing upon cases in which there was no tangible medium of exchange—namely, so that it would be easier to imagine diat the medium of account would dif- fer from any traditional medium of exchange—but that focus is not essential to the logic of dieir system's monetary design. It seems clear diat the arrangement just described would, if implemented and maintained, keep die value of dollars, in terms of the broad price index adopted, essentially constant. It is also clear, however, that the same problem as diat outlined in my
  • 16. discussion of die gold standard would again be present. Then the next issue would again be whedier such a system—^with competing private money providers instead of a central authority—^would be immune to diis problem and also the temptation for private suppliers to overissue. The latter difficulty could perhaps be overcome by means of die type of redeemability requirement mentioned at the end of the previous section.^" In an earlier discussion of the Yeager-Greenfield system, I consid- ered the possibility diat the redemption medium could be Treasury securities (McCallum 2004: 87-89). In diat case, since the price of such securities is definitionaUy related to die interest rate earned by their holders, a MA's policy behavior could be expressed in terms of an interest-rate policy rule, widi the rate (and dius die price of secu- rities) adjusted in response to departures of the price level from its target value. One attraction of such a formulation is diat it would make possible—at least in principle—quantitative studies of die type used currently by mainstream monetary economists.^ ̂ A second fea- ture is that it would indicate a strong formal similarity between
  • 17. the Yeager-Greenfield system and an interest-rate policy rule, for an ^̂ Greenfield and Yeager (1983) suggest that the ordinary enforcement of con- tracts would suffice. ^̂ In practice, however, such studies would be difficult since the relevant time periods would presumably be a few days or hours, rather than the usual quarter- years for which macroeconomic data are available. 446 ALTERNATIVES TO THE F E D ? inflation-targeting central bank, provided diat tlie latter incorporates a zero inflation rate as its sole objective and adjusts its instmment very frequendy (e.g., day by day) to achieve that objective. Conclusion The results of the foregoing discussion can be summtirized briefly. There are two problems associated with a govemmentally operated gold standard. The first is diat stabilizing tlie price of gold is not a good substitute for stabilizing a broadly defined price level index. The second is that there wee political forces continually at work
  • 18. that tend, whatever the index, to undermine maintenance of the stan- dard. Widi respect to tlie first problem, it seems clear diat adoption of a much broader index for stabilization is entirely feasible and desirable. For the second the problem is more difficult. It would seem that competing private suppliers of money would not have the same type of temptation to devalue the standard (i.e., inflate) as does a nationíü monetíiry authority, but a temptation of a different type clearly exists for private suppliers. Some form of regulation might tlierefore be required, in which case the regulator might be faced with die same temptation to inflate as with a standard monetary autliority. The best diat can be done, probably, is to adopt institu- tions that are less subject to temptation than otliers and diat promise to provide stability of a broad price index. In any event, it is highly unlikely tliat major movements toward elimination of the Federal Reserve as the dominant monetary authority of tlie United States will become viable in the foreseeable future. Gonsequently, it would seem diat obtaining a clear mandate for the Federal Reserve to make price stability its overriding objec- tive should be regarded as a leading agenda item. From diat perspec- tive, it might be judged that die best practical strategy for tlie United States at present is to strive to protect die Federal Reserve from
  • 19. die type of politically based reorganization that is currendy being consid- ered by Gongress,^^ and to campaign for recognition diat a central bank/monetary authority should be given a clear lexicographic man- '^ Current suggestions are designed to take policy influence away from region;J reserve bank presidents, wlio have been less inflation-prone than Federal 1-ieseive Board members, and to give Congress more influence over the selection of reserve bank presidents (i.e., to increase politicization of monetary policy). 447 C A T O JOURNAL date for price level stability. I confess, however, that I have Htde hope that the present U.S. Congress can be persuaded to take such a step. References Black, F. (1970) "Banking and Interest Rates in a World widiout Money." Joumal of Bank Research 1 (Autumn): 9-20. Bordo, M. J. (1981) "The Classical Gold Standard: Some Lessons for Today." Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis Monthly Review
  • 20. (May): 2-17. Dom, J. A. (1989) "Introduction: Altematives to Government Fiat Money." Cato Joumal 9 (Fall ): 277-94. Fama, E. (1983) "Financial Intermediation and Price Level Control." Joumal of Monetary Economics 12 (July): 7-28. Friedman, M. (1951) "Commodity Reserve Currency." Joumal of Political Economy 59: 203-32. (1960) A Program for Monetary Stability. New York: Fordham University Press. (1961) "Real and Pseudo Gold Standards." Joumal of Law and Economics A (October): 66-79. Goodfriend, M. (1988) "Central Banking under the Gold Standard." Camegie-Rochester Conference Series on Public Policy 29 (Autijmn): 85-124. Goodfriend, M., and McCallum, B. T. (2009) "Exiting Credit Policy to Preserve Sound Monetary Policy." Carnegie Mellon University (21 October). Grant, J. (2009) "Requiem for the Dollar." Wall Street Joumal (5-6 December): W1-W2. Greenfield, R. L., and Yeager, L. B. (1983) "A Laissez Faire Approach to Monetary Stability." Joumal of Money, Credit, and Banking 27 (August): 302-15.
  • 21. Greenfield, R. L.; Woolsey, W. W.; and Yeager, L. B. (1995) "Is Indirect Convertibility Impossible? A Comment on Schnadt and Whittaker." Journal of Money, Credit, and Banking 27 (Febmaiy): 293-97. Hall, R. E. (1982) "Explorations in die Gold Standard and Related Policies for Stabilizing the Dollar." In R. E. HaU (ed.) Inflation: Causes and Effects. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. Hayek, F. A. (1978) Denationalization of Money. 2nd ed. London: Institute of Economic Affairs. 448 ALTERNATIVES T O T H E F E D ? Marshall, A. (1887) "Remedies for Fluctuations of General Prices." Contemporary Review 51 (March): 355-75. McCallum, B. T. (1985) "Bank Regulation, Accounting Systems of Exchange, and tlie Unit of Account: A Critical Review." Camegie- Rocliester Conference Series on Public Policy 23 (November): 13-45. (2004) "Monetary Policy in Economies witli Little or No Money." Pacific Economic Review % (June): 81-92.
  • 22. Schnadt, N., and Whittiiker, J. (1993) "Inflation-Proof Currency? The Feasibility of Variable Commodity Standards." Joumal of Money, Credit, and Banking 25 (May): 214-21. (1995) "Is Direct Convertibility Impossible? A Reply." JoumaJ of Money, Credit, and Banking 27 (Febmary): 297-98. Taub, B. (1985) "Private Fiat Money witli Many Suppliers."/oiirn¿i/ of Monetary Economics 16 (September): 195-208. Timberlake, R. H. (1989) "The Govemment's License to Create Money." Cato Joumal % {¥ú 1989): 301-21. White, L. H. (1989) "What Kinds of Monetary Institutions Would a Free Market Deliver?" Cato Joumal'è (Fall): 367-91. Yeager, L. B. (1983) "Stable Money and Free-Market Currencies." Cato Joumal 3 (FalJ): 305-26. (1985) "Deregulation and Monetixry Reform." American Economic Review Papers and Proceedings 75 (May): 103-07. (1992) "Toward Forecast-Free Monetary Institu- tions." Cato Joumal 12 (Spring-Summer): 53-73. Yeager, L. B., and Greenfield, R. L. (1989) "Can Monetaiy Disequilibrium Be Eliminated? Cato Joumal 9 (Fall): 405-21. 449
  • 23. Copyright of CATO Journal is the property of Cato Institute and its content may not be copied or emailed to multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the copyright holder's express written permission. However, users may print, download, or email articles for individual use.