Enhancing and Restoring Safety & Quality Cultures - Dave Litwiller - May 2024...
ACU 2010 Conference
1. Utilising AI in improving research
outputs and service delivery
Dr. Renalde Huysamen
Mrs Marietjie du Plessis
Departement Sentrum • Department Centre
UNIVERSITEIT VAN DIE VRYSTAAT • UNIVERSITY OF THE FREE STATE • YUNIVESITHI YA FREISTATA
Tel (051) 401 3000 • E-mail: info@ufs.ac.za • www.ufs.ac.za
2. Agenda
Agenda
Introduction and background
Definition of a Leadership Learning community
Methodology
Part 1: The Authentic Leadership Journey:
Diversity
Inner core
Overcoming fear
Establishing support networks
Findings
Departement Sentrum • Department Centre
UNIVERSITEIT VAN DIE VRYSTAAT • UNIVERSITY OF THE FREE STATE • YUNIVESITHI YA FREISTATA
Tel (051) 401 3000 • E-mail: info@ufs.ac.za • www.ufs.ac.za
3. Agenda
Agenda
PART 2
•Theoretical Foundations of AI
•The 4- D Cycle
•Overall Results of the AI Process
•Practical Application
Departement Sentrum • Department Centre
UNIVERSITEIT VAN DIE VRYSTAAT • UNIVERSITY OF THE FREE STATE • YUNIVESITHI YA FREISTATA
Tel (051) 401 3000 • E-mail: info@ufs.ac.za • www.ufs.ac.za
4. Background and history of the University of
the Free State
1945 – 1980
28 January 1904 1950: University of the 1999
GREY University College Orange Free State Growth Period
7 Faculties
2009 M I
2001 STUDENT SUCCESS RATE:
STUDENT HEAD COUNT 71 %
Name Change to University 2009 27241
of the Free State GRADUATES: 5379
PERMANENT STAFF: 2055
UFS VISION
EXCELLENCE
EQUITABLE
INNOVATIVE
5. Introduction and Background of the
Leadership Learning Community
PURPOSE:
Improvement of employees research outputs and service delivery
•MAIN OBJECTIVES:
•Utilise Training and Development to develop academic /non academic staff
•Improvement in Research Outputs and Service Delivery
Departement Sentrum • Department Centre
UNIVERSITEIT VAN DIE VRYSTAAT • UNIVERSITY OF THE FREE STATE • YUNIVESITHI YA FREISTATA
Tel (051) 401 3000 • E-mail: info@ufs.ac.za • www.ufs.ac.za
6. Definition of a Leadership
Learning Community
Six to twenty members year
long program
Leadership , AI, Community
Building
Departement Sentrum • Department Centre
UNIVERSITEIT VAN DIE VRYSTAAT • UNIVERSITY OF THE FREE STATE • YUNIVESITHI YA FREISTATA
Tel (051) 401 3000 • E-mail: info@ufs.ac.za • www.ufs.ac.za
7. Methodology
Phase 1 Jan – June
RETREAT 1 (2days)
3 x 4 hour meetings
Part one: Examine your own leadership journey
Part two: Discover you authentic leadership
Part three: Put your authentic leadership into action (Bill
George).
Phase 2 July – Nov
RETREAT 2 (2 days) Appreciative Inquiry
3x 4 hour meetings: Appreciative Inquiry - research articles
(David Cooperrider).
QUESTIONNAIRES: Questionnaires were distributed after
each phase
Departement Sentrum • Department Centre
UNIVERSITEIT VAN DIE VRYSTAAT • UNIVERSITY OF THE FREE STATE • YUNIVESITHI YA FREISTATA
Tel (051) 401 3000 • E-mail: info@ufs.ac.za • www.ufs.ac.za
8. Diversity: The Transformation from “I” to “We”
Appearance / Body
Language
Strengths and
Weaknesses
Values/
Motivation
Understanding life
story/ Shadow
sides and
vulnerabilities
Authentic Self
Departement Sentrum • Department Centre
UNIVERSITEIT VAN DIE VRYSTAAT • UNIVERSITY OF THE FREE STATE • YUNIVESITHI YA FREISTATA
Tel (051) 401 3000 • E-mail: info@ufs.ac.za • www.ufs.ac.za
9. “JUMPING MOUSE”
“• Allegory to apply Theory on Leadership
styles and Power
• Advantages and disadvantages of
Leadership Styles
• The type of Power used has an influence
on people and how they react
Departement Sentrum • Department Centre
UNIVERSITEIT VAN DIE VRYSTAAT • UNIVERSITY OF THE FREE STATE • YUNIVESITHI YA FREISTATA
Tel (051) 401 3000 • E-mail: info@ufs.ac.za • www.ufs.ac.za
10. The Leadership Journey supervisor
cleaner
Bloemfontein
university
unemployed
Domestic
work
restaurant
baby
0-13
Departement Sentrum • Department Centre
UNIVERSITEIT VAN DIE VRYSTAAT • UNIVERSITY OF THE FREE STATE • YUNIVESITHI YA FREISTATA
Tel (051) 401 3000 • E-mail: info@ufs.ac.za • www.ufs.ac.za
11. Departement Sentrum • Department Centre
UNIVERSITEIT VAN DIE VRYSTAAT • UNIVERSITY OF THE FREE STATE • YUNIVESITHI YA FREISTATA
Tel (051) 401 3000 • E-mail: info@ufs.ac.za • www.ufs.ac.za
12. Findings: Phase 1
A Summary of the factors which influenced participants to develop as authentic
leaders on a 4 point Likert scale
BILL GEORGE (2007) Leadership Frequency distribution
Largely: % Completely: % Total: %
Q5: Impact Of Intrinsic motivators 25 75 100
Q21:Passionate about Purpose 33.33 66.67 100
Q7: Support from others 25 75 100
Q13:Identification of Purpose 41.67 58.33 100
Q4:Influence of Extrinsic motivators 25 66.67 92
Q12: Reflect on passion as a person 25 66.67 92
Q18: Influence of others on personal 41.67 58.33 100
development
Q 19:Importance of Honesty 8.33 75 83
Departement Sentrum • Department Centre
UNIVERSITEIT VAN DIE VRYSTAAT • UNIVERSITY OF THE FREE STATE • YUNIVESITHI YA FREISTATA
Tel (051) 401 3000 • E-mail: info@ufs.ac.za • www.ufs.ac.za
13. A Summary of the factors which influenced participants to develop as authentic
leaders on a 4 point Likert scale (continue)
BILL GEORGE (2007) Leadership Frequency distribution
Largely: % Completely: % Total: %
Q2: Defining own values 33.33 58.33 92
Q1:Lead with my heart 41.67 50 92
Q3:Acknowledge weaknesses 50 41.67 92
Q10: Importance of Professional 25 50 75
support network
Q15: Apply different leadership styles 33.33 50 83
Q8: Balanced life 16.67 58.33 75
Q20:Purpose as a leader 33.33 50 83
Q23: Acknowledge strengths 33.33 50 83
Q17:Link between leadership style 75 16.67 92
and power
Departement Sentrum • Department Centre
UNIVERSITEIT VAN DIE VRYSTAAT • UNIVERSITY OF THE FREE STATE • YUNIVESITHI YA FREISTATA
Tel (051) 401 3000 • E-mail: info@ufs.ac.za • www.ufs.ac.za
14. A Summary of the factors which influenced participants to develop as authentic
leaders on a 4 point Likert scale (continue)
BILL GEORGE (2007) Leadership Frequency distribution
Largely: % Completely: % Total: %
Q6: Utilisation of capabilities 58.33 16.67 75
Q11: Develop relationships 41.67 25 67
Q14:Empower other to fulfil purpose 41.67 25 67
Q22:Compassion with myself 33.33 33.33 66
Q16: Followers’ reaction to power 33.33 8.33 42
Departement Sentrum • Department Centre
UNIVERSITEIT VAN DIE VRYSTAAT • UNIVERSITY OF THE FREE STATE • YUNIVESITHI YA FREISTATA
Tel (051) 401 3000 • E-mail: info@ufs.ac.za • www.ufs.ac.za
15. PHASE 2: Theoretical foundations of
Appreciative Inquiry
•
“ Principles of AI: 3 Schools
1) Social constructivism
2) Image Theory
3) Grounded Research
• AI takes this frame work and sets it in a positive frame of reference:
“AI views organisations as centers of Human Relatedness where
people control their destiny by envisaging what they want and
develop actions to move toward it”(Cooperrider, Whitney & Stavros,2003)
Departement Sentrum • Department Centre
UNIVERSITEIT VAN DIE VRYSTAAT • UNIVERSITY OF THE FREE STATE • YUNIVESITHI YA FREISTATA
Tel (051) 401 3000 • E-mail: info@ufs.ac.za • www.ufs.ac.za
16. AI: 4-D Cycle
discovery
'what gives
life'
dream
destiny
'what might
'what will be'
be'
design
'how it can
be'
Departement Sentrum • Department Centre
UNIVERSITEIT VAN DIE VRYSTAAT • UNIVERSITY OF THE FREE STATE • YUNIVESITHI YA FREISTATA
Tel (051) 401 3000 • E-mail: info@ufs.ac.za • www.ufs.ac.za
17. FINDING AND ANALYSIS
• DISCOVERY
• A deeper understanding of exceptional professional experiences.
• The identification of a core life-giving factor for each participant; and
• Wishes for improved performance with regard to research outputs or
service delivery projects
• DREAM
• Expression was given to dreams by means of drawings; and
• 5 life-giving themes were identified and prioritised.
Departement Sentrum • Department Centre
UNIVERSITEIT VAN DIE VRYSTAAT • UNIVERSITY OF THE FREE STATE • YUNIVESITHI YA FREISTATA
Tel (051) 401 3000 • E-mail: info@ufs.ac.za • www.ufs.ac.za
18. Dreaming…
Departement Sentrum • Department Centre
UNIVERSITEIT VAN DIE VRYSTAAT • UNIVERSITY OF THE FREE STATE • YUNIVESITHI YA FREISTATA
Tel (051) 401 3000 • E-mail: info@ufs.ac.za • www.ufs.ac.za
19. Design
• Provocative propositions for each individual;
• There was an overwhelming sense of excitement that each individual was in
a position to link their passion and purpose as individuals to their present
work related roles;
• Ascribing of actual behaviours to the five main themes namely;
– Every person can be a leader in his own field
– Person centred approach
– Appreciating innovation in scholarly field
– Passion
– Positive Attitude.
• .
Departement Sentrum • Department Centre
UNIVERSITEIT VAN DIE VRYSTAAT • UNIVERSITY OF THE FREE STATE • YUNIVESITHI YA FREISTATA
Tel (051) 401 3000 • E-mail: info@ufs.ac.za • www.ufs.ac.za
20. Design
• Identification of a new set of behaviours:
– Each person creates a visual image of this behaviour
Now each person has a positive image image of the past and
the future
Facilitator asked:
“How can the research that you need to undertake for the LLC
help you to achieve the identified behaviour?”
• Participants reflected on the implementation of the authentic
leadership principles and their unique capabilities in the context of
their own academic or non-academic work environment
• Participants defined their topics and identified resources needed to
write their articles/implement projects
.
21. Destiny
• Research topics and service delivery projects defined;
• Strategies formulated to:
• Write describe research design, project outcomes,
population and samples, etc.; and
• Where participants were unsure, others provided
assistance/advice.
Departement Sentrum • Department Centre
UNIVERSITEIT VAN DIE VRYSTAAT • UNIVERSITY OF THE FREE STATE • YUNIVESITHI YA FREISTATA
Tel (051) 401 3000 • E-mail: info@ufs.ac.za • www.ufs.ac.za
22. RESULTS OF THE LEADERSHIP LEARNING
COMMUNITY PROJECT
ACADEMIC STAFF
7 Published Articles
National and International Conferences
SUPPORT STAFF
4 projects implemented
2 National Conferences
1 Invitation to present project Internationally
Departement Sentrum • Department Centre
UNIVERSITEIT VAN DIE VRYSTAAT • UNIVERSITY OF THE FREE STATE • YUNIVESITHI YA FREISTATA
Tel (051) 401 3000 • E-mail: info@ufs.ac.za • www.ufs.ac.za
25. Appreciating : HR
• INTERVIEW PROTOCOL
• Appreciate the Past
• 1. Tell me about one peak experience as a HR practitioner that you will always cherish.
What made this so special?
• Appreciate the Present
• 2. What do you value most about HR as a discipline?
• Appreciate the Future
• 3. Imagine you have a magic wand and you would have any three wishes granted what
would your dreams for HR as a discipline be? What do you think future people in the
HR discipline should do?
Departement Sentrum • Department Centre
UNIVERSITEIT VAN DIE VRYSTAAT • UNIVERSITY OF THE FREE STATE • YUNIVESITHI YA FREISTATA
Tel (051) 401 3000 • E-mail: info@ufs.ac.za • www.ufs.ac.za
26. Conclusion
Appreciative inquiry can successfully be applied to improve performance in
a Higher Education context, for both academic and non-academic staff.
• The Appreciative Inquiry Process is inclusive, consultative, generative and
energizing.
AI, as a philosophy and process that is based on what is positive and that is
applied through collaboration, may provide a paradigmatically different point
of departure to ensure improved performance
Departement Sentrum • Department Centre
UNIVERSITEIT VAN DIE VRYSTAAT • UNIVERSITY OF THE FREE STATE • YUNIVESITHI YA FREISTATA
Tel (051) 401 3000 • E-mail: info@ufs.ac.za • www.ufs.ac.za
27. Thank
you!
FINISHED
WITH THE
FIMISH
Departement Sentrum • Department Centre
UNIVERSITEIT VAN DIE VRYSTAAT • UNIVERSITY OF THE FREE STATE • YUNIVESITHI YA FREISTATA
Tel (051) 401 3000 • E-mail: info@ufs.ac.za • www.ufs.ac.za
Editor's Notes
Joke: matured ladies
Project: Freshly baked in SA; added some international ingredients
2 concepts, Leadership and AI: The idea was to put together Authentic Leadership as a Concept and the AI process as a concept in a innovative and complimentary wayPROBLEM: HE– isolation, diversity, new demands, lack of leadership capabilities leads to unmotivated staff, self doubt, fear of failure, and poor communication due to silo syndromeMistakes, stress, burnout, poor performance in all areas, job dissatisfaction, low motivation.Leadership – research born or developed, then skills development, latest focus back to discovery of the authentic self. Researchers found that authentic leaders inspire trust and loyalty. They perform at superior levels because they are intensely focused on a powerful purpose for their leadership. They are also able to pick themselves up and keep moving even after the most devastating setbacks.Project focused on uniqueness, authentic capabilities, so that a leader could handle the challenges in a Global Higher Education EnvironmentOUTCOME: Academic and non-Academics need to compete and engage in the global Higher Education Environment
Promote among colleagues a sense that they are involved in ajoint enterprise and that they are members of a team and larger university community;Foster an environment in which colleagues stimulateone another’s intellectual interests and help each other develop and grow as leaders. Theory tells us that there are 2 ages of development:TWO AGES OF DEVELOPMENT:The Age of the Learner (1990-2000). Disadvantage is that the teacher or facilitator is constatnly guiding, directing, and giving the learners all the information they need; it will be very difficult for them to be ever free of you. It is better if the learner embodies new learning personally and physiologically, as you can not do the learning for them. As a facilitator you need to reconstruct their thinking and feeling to gain perspective and become self – directed learners.2. The Age of the Network (2000 +)Miami University: “colleagueship and learning from other participants” – highest impact of all program aspects. This also implies that nobody has all the answers. It is not about ‘I am the expert, let me fix you’ and ‘ you are perfect and whole and have all the answers’; but it is rather about:#LLC enable multidisciplinary participation to enhance learning, in this case, leadership strengths and thereby wellness in the workplace.#Learn from each other, discussions and literature#Development of work related research projects to address shortcomingsLLC is a cross-disciplinary learning opportunity for six to twenty staff membersEngage in an active collaborative yearlong programEnhance leadership skillsFrequent meetings and activitiesProvide learning developmentProvide scholarship of leadershipProvide community building
Bill George: chief executive of metronic (1991 – 2001) Currently professor of management practice at Harvard Bus SchoolNamed as one of the best to 25 business leaders in last 20 years.Sit David se inligting by…David L. Cooperrider, PhD. Case Western Reserve University, Weatherhead School of Management: Appreciative Inquiry. AI an approach to organisational analysis and learning is also intended for discovering, understanding and fostering innovations in social organisational arrangements and process: A Search for knowledge, A theory of collective action designed to evolve the vision and will of a group, an organisation or a society as a whole. AI is deliberate in its life-centric approach. The art of appreciation is the art of discovering and valuing those factors that give life to a group or an organisation.…………………………During Phase 1, one way to to assist people was to interact and engage with the world in new ways, is to ask them to tell their life stories. It has an impact on others in the group. The person himself opens up to the possibility to learn something new and to relate to themselves at a deeper level. It enables the facilitator to understand some of the current issues/perceptions/challenges/patterns of thinking and behaviour.Marietjie will now summarize one of the heart stories of one of the participants -
Another exercise we did was with an onionParticipants had to peel an onion and as they peel it, think about the following factorsExplain layers-Knowing yourself can be compared to peeling back the layers of an onion as you search for your true self.The outer layers of the onion are the visible ways you present yourself to the world: How you look, your facial expressions your body language . Understanding the outer layers is necessary when you want to find out what lies beneath it – the inner core ( authentic self).
Evelyn Mabija’s story is proof that nothing is impossible, for those who put their mind to it and work hard.
The 3d exercise I am going to explain is where people had to work with horses. During this exercise most of the members felt very uncomfortable at first ( out of comfort zone). They did not understand how to work with the horses, and in that sense it was a unknown situation for them. We all know that the unknown creates fear and normally people try to avoid the unknown. They gave feedback after the exercise and told us that it was an eye opener for them to realise their own fear and in spite of that , to be brave enough to follow through even if they have to try several times. Support networks were also established quickly: Some of the activities required the group to work together because they could not be completed individually. They also realised that they could shift leadership roles on a constant basis. Feedback: Members gave feedback that it took a while for them to understand that they should work together to make a success and that you don’t need to work in isolation. Working together was also fun while the focus on differences from a diversity point of view, became less and less.This exercise was scheduled for a Friday afternoon and for us as facilitators it was interesting to note the following Monday how they phoned us to tell us that they slept like babies that night. Even people with sleep disorders!.
Some of the findings of Phase 1 were Impact of Intrinsic Motivators: 100%Passionate about purpose: 100%Support from Others: 100%Influence of others on personal development: 100%They also indicated that the programme assisted them to:Develop their own capabilities (83%)
Defining own values: 92%Acknowledgement of weaknessess: 92%Acknowledgement of strengths: 83%
Follower’s reaction to power had the lowest % of agreement/satisfaction where 42% indicated that the programme had assisted them to a large or complete extent to understand how the type of power they use as leaders could affect follower behaviour.
Discovery: The discovery phase is where the inquiry dimensions of Appreciative Inquiry become pre-eminent. The discovery process starts with paired interviews based on certain generic appreciative questions. These interview questions solicit stories of strength and accomplishments and reveal experiences that are surprising and elevating. On conclusion of the interviews participants are requested to summarise the best stories or quotes that came from the person interviewed. Life-giving discoveries are subsequently shared in small groups. The result of this discovery exercise is the expression of the key strengths/ best stories. The discovery interview generates a desire to articulate bolder possibilities because confidence in the whole system’s capacity to be effective has been elevatedDREAM: When the best of “what is” has been discovered conversations naturally turns to imagining new possibilities. Keeping in mind the key strengths from the Discovery phase already present in the system, the Dream stage extends what is currently possible to “imagining all that could be,” generating images of the ideal state that we really wish for. It is altogether an invigorating exercise. In summary, the Dream phase invites participants to use the knowledge and excitement about possibilities gained from the discovery phase to imagine what could be in an ideal future. DESIGN By brainstorming all the possible actions, changes or opportunities that are reflected in the shared dreams, participants are ready to launch into a more practical design, or action-planning phase. During the design phase, the individual’s understanding of the system shift to accommodate a new future. Participants literally reinvent the system to create a new future. Working in groups, participants construct provocative propositions, also called ‘possibility statements’ or ‘aspiration statements’. These bold, affirmative and exciting statements describe some aspects of the desired organisation as it ‘should be’ and as such serve as guidelines or motivating principles for further action.DESTINY:The aim of the Destiny phase is to ensure that the shared dreams can be realised through the “blueprint” of desired actions. To do this, individuals in AI do specific action planning and also consider how they will expand the involvement in their change initiatives to others in their work environment.
Behaviours:Establish 2 research teams with international acclaimTo be a well known speaker and thought leader on the link between artristry and teachingMotivational speaker using the person-centered approachUsse research results to benefit the larger community in South AfricaTo make research part of my life what I am passionate aboutTo ensure that the disability department becomes a leader in the field in tertiary educationTo get team members on board to be dedicated to medical fieldEstablishment of a research unitIkmprove educatiion to ensure passion for studentsWrite programmes for the department of education on coping and the constant changes of the systemBecome part of a process where we succeeded in establishing proper structuresNetworking in staff development on the campus
Academic performance: National and International Conferences and Publications