SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 1
Download to read offline
The Challenge
Home of the Original Double Decker - a famous Big Boy restaurant required some energy
efficiencyupgrades.Propertyowners,JoeDiequezandJonathanMarsh,werelookingforan
innovativewaytofinancebuildingimprovementsandreplaceinefficientcookingequipment.
Likemanysmallbusinessowners,theywerelookingforalong-termfinancingsolutionthat
would ensure that building improvements pay for themselves in 10 years. Project goals
included:
•	 Improve overall building performance and comfort
•	 Upgrade kitchen equipment
•	 Reduce utility bills
•	 Reduce operating costs
•	 Improve the environment
Case Study No. 2
Big Boy restaurant takes advantage of PACE financing.
The Solution
PACE was an obvious solution for the Big Boy owners. The program offered low-cost, low-
risk capital and an opportunity to be good stewards of the environment. Sustainability is
a City-wide priority in Ann Arbor. In fact, City of Ann Arbor Mayor John Hieftje is an avid
supporteroftheprogram:“Ourcity’sClimateActionPlancallsforreducinggreenhousegas
emissions8percentfrom2000levelsby2015,andtheseprojects–andotherslikethem–are
animportantpartofhelpingAnnArborreachitssustainabilitygoals.”Thefollowingunique
advantages of PACE financing motivated Big Boy owners to act:
•	 Long-term financing (up to 10 years under Michigan PACE law)
•	 Low interest rates
•	 Greater long-term property value because of energy efficiency
•	 Preservation of borrowing capacity
Project Success
Experienced program administrators conducted a preliminary analysis of utility bills and
building credentials and determined that the Big Boy property was an excellent candi-
date for PACE financing. While the terms of the program required that a pre-qualified
auditor perform the energy analysis, the property owners were free to use contractors
of their choice to complete the project. Ann Arbor’s PACE program, administered by
the Clean Energy Coalition, ensured that Big Boy owners, as all local business owners,
received clear and effective education about energy efficiency improvements proposed
by the auditor. Lender consent was a swift and simple process as the lender recognized
the advantages of PACE.
As a result of this project:
•	 Annual utility costs are expected to be reduced by 19%
•	 $8,300 in annual savings
PACE in Ann Arbor
Ann Arbor’s PACE program
enablespropertyownersto
save energy using a special
propertyassessment.Ifyou
want to update your build-
ing at a low fixed interest
rate with a 10-year term,
contact the program.
Contact Information
Ann Arbor’s PACE Program
734.585.5720 x15
pace@a2gov.org
www.a2energy.org
Project Financing
PACE Assessment: $88,488
Term: 10 years
Rate: 4.75% fixed
Building Details
Size: 5,000 sq. ft.
Year built:1981
Assessed Value: $500,000
Improvements
Building controls system
High efficiency HVAC
Lighting system overhaul
ENERGY STAR cooking
equipment
HVAC overhaul
© 2013 PACENow
PACE

More Related Content

What's hot

Deep Retrofit: IERC & Enabling collaborative and Industry Driven Energy Rese...
Deep Retrofit:  IERC & Enabling collaborative and Industry Driven Energy Rese...Deep Retrofit:  IERC & Enabling collaborative and Industry Driven Energy Rese...
Deep Retrofit: IERC & Enabling collaborative and Industry Driven Energy Rese...SustainableEnergyAut
 
Energy Management at Unite Students: it is Up to uS…
Energy Management at Unite Students: it is Up to uS…Energy Management at Unite Students: it is Up to uS…
Energy Management at Unite Students: it is Up to uS…EMEX
 
Overview: MN Guaranteed Energy Savings Program
Overview: MN Guaranteed Energy Savings ProgramOverview: MN Guaranteed Energy Savings Program
Overview: MN Guaranteed Energy Savings ProgramUniversity of Minnesota
 
RE:NEW Programme
RE:NEW ProgrammeRE:NEW Programme
RE:NEW ProgrammeEMEX
 
Bemidji Guaranteed Energy Savings Program
Bemidji Guaranteed Energy Savings ProgramBemidji Guaranteed Energy Savings Program
Bemidji Guaranteed Energy Savings ProgramUniversity of Minnesota
 
EMA Energy Management Awards 2017
EMA Energy Management Awards 2017EMA Energy Management Awards 2017
EMA Energy Management Awards 2017EMEX
 
Business Case for Green Buildings
Business Case for Green Buildings Business Case for Green Buildings
Business Case for Green Buildings Ibrahim Al-Hudhaif
 
Presenting Mojave Solar
Presenting Mojave SolarPresenting Mojave Solar
Presenting Mojave SolarAbengoa
 
SB11 - GE Ecomagination - Katherine Brass
SB11 - GE Ecomagination - Katherine Brass SB11 - GE Ecomagination - Katherine Brass
SB11 - GE Ecomagination - Katherine Brass Sustainable Brands
 
Wbc16 presentation-jenni-back
Wbc16 presentation-jenni-backWbc16 presentation-jenni-back
Wbc16 presentation-jenni-backJenni Bäck
 
Deep Retrofit: Energy Cultures and the Importance of Energy Practices Within ...
Deep Retrofit: Energy Cultures and the Importance of Energy Practices Within ...Deep Retrofit: Energy Cultures and the Importance of Energy Practices Within ...
Deep Retrofit: Energy Cultures and the Importance of Energy Practices Within ...SustainableEnergyAut
 
Aes 10sldk De Edits 12 5 10
Aes 10sldk De Edits 12 5 10Aes 10sldk De Edits 12 5 10
Aes 10sldk De Edits 12 5 10Tim Robinson
 
03391_DS_CAFlats_NA_11FEB15
03391_DS_CAFlats_NA_11FEB1503391_DS_CAFlats_NA_11FEB15
03391_DS_CAFlats_NA_11FEB15Dawn Legg
 

What's hot (18)

Deep Retrofit: IERC & Enabling collaborative and Industry Driven Energy Rese...
Deep Retrofit:  IERC & Enabling collaborative and Industry Driven Energy Rese...Deep Retrofit:  IERC & Enabling collaborative and Industry Driven Energy Rese...
Deep Retrofit: IERC & Enabling collaborative and Industry Driven Energy Rese...
 
Energy Management at Unite Students: it is Up to uS…
Energy Management at Unite Students: it is Up to uS…Energy Management at Unite Students: it is Up to uS…
Energy Management at Unite Students: it is Up to uS…
 
City of Orlando
City of OrlandoCity of Orlando
City of Orlando
 
Overview: MN Guaranteed Energy Savings Program
Overview: MN Guaranteed Energy Savings ProgramOverview: MN Guaranteed Energy Savings Program
Overview: MN Guaranteed Energy Savings Program
 
RE:NEW Programme
RE:NEW ProgrammeRE:NEW Programme
RE:NEW Programme
 
Bemidji Guaranteed Energy Savings Program
Bemidji Guaranteed Energy Savings ProgramBemidji Guaranteed Energy Savings Program
Bemidji Guaranteed Energy Savings Program
 
Incentives nr can-jim clark-gbf2007
Incentives nr can-jim clark-gbf2007Incentives nr can-jim clark-gbf2007
Incentives nr can-jim clark-gbf2007
 
EMA Energy Management Awards 2017
EMA Energy Management Awards 2017EMA Energy Management Awards 2017
EMA Energy Management Awards 2017
 
Business Case for Green Buildings
Business Case for Green Buildings Business Case for Green Buildings
Business Case for Green Buildings
 
community retrofit
community retrofitcommunity retrofit
community retrofit
 
Presenting Mojave Solar
Presenting Mojave SolarPresenting Mojave Solar
Presenting Mojave Solar
 
SB11 - GE Ecomagination - Katherine Brass
SB11 - GE Ecomagination - Katherine Brass SB11 - GE Ecomagination - Katherine Brass
SB11 - GE Ecomagination - Katherine Brass
 
Wbc16 presentation-jenni-back
Wbc16 presentation-jenni-backWbc16 presentation-jenni-back
Wbc16 presentation-jenni-back
 
Project Liberty
Project LibertyProject Liberty
Project Liberty
 
NZC - Ben Taube
NZC - Ben TaubeNZC - Ben Taube
NZC - Ben Taube
 
Deep Retrofit: Energy Cultures and the Importance of Energy Practices Within ...
Deep Retrofit: Energy Cultures and the Importance of Energy Practices Within ...Deep Retrofit: Energy Cultures and the Importance of Energy Practices Within ...
Deep Retrofit: Energy Cultures and the Importance of Energy Practices Within ...
 
Aes 10sldk De Edits 12 5 10
Aes 10sldk De Edits 12 5 10Aes 10sldk De Edits 12 5 10
Aes 10sldk De Edits 12 5 10
 
03391_DS_CAFlats_NA_11FEB15
03391_DS_CAFlats_NA_11FEB1503391_DS_CAFlats_NA_11FEB15
03391_DS_CAFlats_NA_11FEB15
 

Similar to 7.24.2013 ann arbor pace big boy case study

EIC Annual Members Meeting 2019
EIC Annual Members Meeting 2019EIC Annual Members Meeting 2019
EIC Annual Members Meeting 2019Energize NY
 
Property Assessed Clean Energy (PACE) Program
Property Assessed Clean Energy (PACE) ProgramProperty Assessed Clean Energy (PACE) Program
Property Assessed Clean Energy (PACE) Programlerchearly
 
Energy Savings for Hotel & Lodging Industry
Energy Savings for Hotel & Lodging IndustryEnergy Savings for Hotel & Lodging Industry
Energy Savings for Hotel & Lodging IndustryRayco Energy
 
Connecticut Green Bank Stakeholder Webinar Quarter 4 FY17
Connecticut Green Bank Stakeholder Webinar Quarter 4 FY17Connecticut Green Bank Stakeholder Webinar Quarter 4 FY17
Connecticut Green Bank Stakeholder Webinar Quarter 4 FY17RudySturkCGB
 
Successful Small Business Energy Efficiency Program Practices
Successful Small Business Energy Efficiency Program PracticesSuccessful Small Business Energy Efficiency Program Practices
Successful Small Business Energy Efficiency Program PracticesSeth William Nowak
 
7.16.2013 dcpace hud case study
7.16.2013 dcpace  hud case study7.16.2013 dcpace  hud case study
7.16.2013 dcpace hud case studyKristina Klimovich
 
PACE for Commercial Real Estate Companies
PACE for Commercial Real Estate CompaniesPACE for Commercial Real Estate Companies
PACE for Commercial Real Estate CompaniesPACENation
 
PACE for Commercial Real Estate Companies
PACE for Commercial Real Estate CompaniesPACE for Commercial Real Estate Companies
PACE for Commercial Real Estate CompaniesPACENation
 
Finding the Right Shade of Green Building
Finding the Right Shade of Green BuildingFinding the Right Shade of Green Building
Finding the Right Shade of Green BuildingJudi Farr
 
Keap Green Jobs - A Program Framework Proposal
Keap Green Jobs - A Program Framework ProposalKeap Green Jobs - A Program Framework Proposal
Keap Green Jobs - A Program Framework Proposalkeapgreenjobs
 
New Opportunities in Property Assessed Clean Energy (PACE)
New Opportunities in Property Assessed Clean Energy (PACE)New Opportunities in Property Assessed Clean Energy (PACE)
New Opportunities in Property Assessed Clean Energy (PACE)Abby Johnson
 
C4 Cobleigh PAR for ASFPM 2015
C4 Cobleigh PAR for ASFPM 2015C4 Cobleigh PAR for ASFPM 2015
C4 Cobleigh PAR for ASFPM 2015Wayne Cobleigh
 
Green Finance for Affordable Housing
Green Finance for Affordable HousingGreen Finance for Affordable Housing
Green Finance for Affordable HousingGalley Eco Capital
 
Ethical Energy
Ethical EnergyEthical Energy
Ethical Energyachildew
 
Epa.Globalcon.Mjd.Final
Epa.Globalcon.Mjd.FinalEpa.Globalcon.Mjd.Final
Epa.Globalcon.Mjd.Finalmikedunn2
 

Similar to 7.24.2013 ann arbor pace big boy case study (20)

C-PACE in Connecticut
C-PACE in ConnecticutC-PACE in Connecticut
C-PACE in Connecticut
 
EIC Annual Members Meeting 2019
EIC Annual Members Meeting 2019EIC Annual Members Meeting 2019
EIC Annual Members Meeting 2019
 
What planners need to know
What planners need to knowWhat planners need to know
What planners need to know
 
Property Assessed Clean Energy (PACE) Program
Property Assessed Clean Energy (PACE) ProgramProperty Assessed Clean Energy (PACE) Program
Property Assessed Clean Energy (PACE) Program
 
Achieving Green Savings and Sustainability
Achieving Green Savings and SustainabilityAchieving Green Savings and Sustainability
Achieving Green Savings and Sustainability
 
Energy Savings for Hotel & Lodging Industry
Energy Savings for Hotel & Lodging IndustryEnergy Savings for Hotel & Lodging Industry
Energy Savings for Hotel & Lodging Industry
 
SSC2011_Michael Bodaken PPT
SSC2011_Michael Bodaken PPTSSC2011_Michael Bodaken PPT
SSC2011_Michael Bodaken PPT
 
Connecticut Green Bank Stakeholder Webinar Quarter 4 FY17
Connecticut Green Bank Stakeholder Webinar Quarter 4 FY17Connecticut Green Bank Stakeholder Webinar Quarter 4 FY17
Connecticut Green Bank Stakeholder Webinar Quarter 4 FY17
 
Successful Small Business Energy Efficiency Program Practices
Successful Small Business Energy Efficiency Program PracticesSuccessful Small Business Energy Efficiency Program Practices
Successful Small Business Energy Efficiency Program Practices
 
7.16.2013 dcpace hud case study
7.16.2013 dcpace  hud case study7.16.2013 dcpace  hud case study
7.16.2013 dcpace hud case study
 
PACE for Commercial Real Estate Companies
PACE for Commercial Real Estate CompaniesPACE for Commercial Real Estate Companies
PACE for Commercial Real Estate Companies
 
PACE for Commercial Real Estate Companies
PACE for Commercial Real Estate CompaniesPACE for Commercial Real Estate Companies
PACE for Commercial Real Estate Companies
 
Finding the Right Shade of Green Building
Finding the Right Shade of Green BuildingFinding the Right Shade of Green Building
Finding the Right Shade of Green Building
 
Keap Green Jobs - A Program Framework Proposal
Keap Green Jobs - A Program Framework ProposalKeap Green Jobs - A Program Framework Proposal
Keap Green Jobs - A Program Framework Proposal
 
New Opportunities in Property Assessed Clean Energy (PACE)
New Opportunities in Property Assessed Clean Energy (PACE)New Opportunities in Property Assessed Clean Energy (PACE)
New Opportunities in Property Assessed Clean Energy (PACE)
 
Ncrc green panel 4 15-2011 t.wysocki
Ncrc green panel 4 15-2011 t.wysockiNcrc green panel 4 15-2011 t.wysocki
Ncrc green panel 4 15-2011 t.wysocki
 
C4 Cobleigh PAR for ASFPM 2015
C4 Cobleigh PAR for ASFPM 2015C4 Cobleigh PAR for ASFPM 2015
C4 Cobleigh PAR for ASFPM 2015
 
Green Finance for Affordable Housing
Green Finance for Affordable HousingGreen Finance for Affordable Housing
Green Finance for Affordable Housing
 
Ethical Energy
Ethical EnergyEthical Energy
Ethical Energy
 
Epa.Globalcon.Mjd.Final
Epa.Globalcon.Mjd.FinalEpa.Globalcon.Mjd.Final
Epa.Globalcon.Mjd.Final
 

7.24.2013 ann arbor pace big boy case study

  • 1. The Challenge Home of the Original Double Decker - a famous Big Boy restaurant required some energy efficiencyupgrades.Propertyowners,JoeDiequezandJonathanMarsh,werelookingforan innovativewaytofinancebuildingimprovementsandreplaceinefficientcookingequipment. Likemanysmallbusinessowners,theywerelookingforalong-termfinancingsolutionthat would ensure that building improvements pay for themselves in 10 years. Project goals included: • Improve overall building performance and comfort • Upgrade kitchen equipment • Reduce utility bills • Reduce operating costs • Improve the environment Case Study No. 2 Big Boy restaurant takes advantage of PACE financing. The Solution PACE was an obvious solution for the Big Boy owners. The program offered low-cost, low- risk capital and an opportunity to be good stewards of the environment. Sustainability is a City-wide priority in Ann Arbor. In fact, City of Ann Arbor Mayor John Hieftje is an avid supporteroftheprogram:“Ourcity’sClimateActionPlancallsforreducinggreenhousegas emissions8percentfrom2000levelsby2015,andtheseprojects–andotherslikethem–are animportantpartofhelpingAnnArborreachitssustainabilitygoals.”Thefollowingunique advantages of PACE financing motivated Big Boy owners to act: • Long-term financing (up to 10 years under Michigan PACE law) • Low interest rates • Greater long-term property value because of energy efficiency • Preservation of borrowing capacity Project Success Experienced program administrators conducted a preliminary analysis of utility bills and building credentials and determined that the Big Boy property was an excellent candi- date for PACE financing. While the terms of the program required that a pre-qualified auditor perform the energy analysis, the property owners were free to use contractors of their choice to complete the project. Ann Arbor’s PACE program, administered by the Clean Energy Coalition, ensured that Big Boy owners, as all local business owners, received clear and effective education about energy efficiency improvements proposed by the auditor. Lender consent was a swift and simple process as the lender recognized the advantages of PACE. As a result of this project: • Annual utility costs are expected to be reduced by 19% • $8,300 in annual savings PACE in Ann Arbor Ann Arbor’s PACE program enablespropertyownersto save energy using a special propertyassessment.Ifyou want to update your build- ing at a low fixed interest rate with a 10-year term, contact the program. Contact Information Ann Arbor’s PACE Program 734.585.5720 x15 pace@a2gov.org www.a2energy.org Project Financing PACE Assessment: $88,488 Term: 10 years Rate: 4.75% fixed Building Details Size: 5,000 sq. ft. Year built:1981 Assessed Value: $500,000 Improvements Building controls system High efficiency HVAC Lighting system overhaul ENERGY STAR cooking equipment HVAC overhaul © 2013 PACENow PACE