Download free for 30 days
Sign in
Upload
Language (EN)
Support
Business
Mobile
Social Media
Marketing
Technology
Art & Photos
Career
Design
Education
Presentations & Public Speaking
Government & Nonprofit
Healthcare
Internet
Law
Leadership & Management
Automotive
Engineering
Software
Recruiting & HR
Retail
Sales
Services
Science
Small Business & Entrepreneurship
Food
Environment
Economy & Finance
Data & Analytics
Investor Relations
Sports
Spiritual
News & Politics
Travel
Self Improvement
Real Estate
Entertainment & Humor
Health & Medicine
Devices & Hardware
Lifestyle
Change Language
Language
English
Español
Português
Français
Deutsche
Cancel
Save
Submit search
EN
Uploaded by
Иван Иванов
9,547 views
гдз английский язык 5 класс афанасьева, верещагина
ГДЗ Английский язык 5 класс Афанасьева, Верещагина
Education
◦
Read more
0
Save
Share
Embed
Embed presentation
Download
Download to read offline
1
/ 158
2
/ 158
3
/ 158
4
/ 158
5
/ 158
6
/ 158
7
/ 158
8
/ 158
9
/ 158
10
/ 158
11
/ 158
12
/ 158
13
/ 158
14
/ 158
15
/ 158
16
/ 158
17
/ 158
18
/ 158
19
/ 158
20
/ 158
21
/ 158
22
/ 158
23
/ 158
24
/ 158
25
/ 158
26
/ 158
27
/ 158
28
/ 158
29
/ 158
30
/ 158
31
/ 158
32
/ 158
33
/ 158
34
/ 158
35
/ 158
36
/ 158
37
/ 158
38
/ 158
39
/ 158
40
/ 158
41
/ 158
42
/ 158
43
/ 158
44
/ 158
45
/ 158
46
/ 158
47
/ 158
48
/ 158
49
/ 158
50
/ 158
51
/ 158
52
/ 158
53
/ 158
54
/ 158
55
/ 158
56
/ 158
57
/ 158
58
/ 158
59
/ 158
60
/ 158
61
/ 158
62
/ 158
63
/ 158
64
/ 158
65
/ 158
66
/ 158
67
/ 158
68
/ 158
69
/ 158
70
/ 158
71
/ 158
72
/ 158
73
/ 158
74
/ 158
75
/ 158
76
/ 158
77
/ 158
78
/ 158
79
/ 158
80
/ 158
81
/ 158
82
/ 158
83
/ 158
84
/ 158
85
/ 158
86
/ 158
87
/ 158
88
/ 158
89
/ 158
90
/ 158
91
/ 158
92
/ 158
93
/ 158
94
/ 158
95
/ 158
96
/ 158
97
/ 158
98
/ 158
99
/ 158
100
/ 158
101
/ 158
102
/ 158
103
/ 158
104
/ 158
105
/ 158
106
/ 158
107
/ 158
108
/ 158
109
/ 158
110
/ 158
111
/ 158
112
/ 158
113
/ 158
114
/ 158
115
/ 158
116
/ 158
117
/ 158
118
/ 158
119
/ 158
120
/ 158
121
/ 158
122
/ 158
123
/ 158
124
/ 158
125
/ 158
126
/ 158
127
/ 158
128
/ 158
129
/ 158
130
/ 158
131
/ 158
132
/ 158
133
/ 158
134
/ 158
135
/ 158
136
/ 158
137
/ 158
138
/ 158
139
/ 158
140
/ 158
141
/ 158
142
/ 158
143
/ 158
144
/ 158
145
/ 158
146
/ 158
147
/ 158
148
/ 158
149
/ 158
150
/ 158
151
/ 158
152
/ 158
153
/ 158
154
/ 158
155
/ 158
156
/ 158
157
/ 158
158
/ 158
More Related Content
PDF
Gdz ladyzhen(1)
by
robinbad123100
PDF
3678
by
Makson4ik
PDF
24234
by
Makson4ik
PDF
русский язык 9кл разумовская 2001_ответы
by
Иван Иванов
PDF
юнг архетип и символ
by
Катерина Сахно
PDF
гдз. русский язык 5кл ладыженская 2000
by
Иван Иванов
PDF
106 himiya9 gabriel
by
Razon Ej
PDF
русский язык 8кл разумовская 2001_ответы_new
by
Иван Иванов
Gdz ladyzhen(1)
by
robinbad123100
3678
by
Makson4ik
24234
by
Makson4ik
русский язык 9кл разумовская 2001_ответы
by
Иван Иванов
юнг архетип и символ
by
Катерина Сахно
гдз. русский язык 5кл ладыженская 2000
by
Иван Иванов
106 himiya9 gabriel
by
Razon Ej
русский язык 8кл разумовская 2001_ответы_new
by
Иван Иванов
What's hot
PDF
Pillars of Islam - (Urdu)
by
Martinkay99
PDF
Maqalat al hadith
by
Muhammad Nabeel Musharraf
PDF
Ghaflat aur jahalat by sikander naqshbandi
by
SikanderNaqshbandi
PDF
Mardane arab 1
by
sunninews92
PDF
гдз. русский язык 6кл ладыженская, тростенцова, баранов 2000
by
Иван Иванов
PDF
146
by
guest09eda4
PDF
47 химия 8кл гузей-гдз_2000
by
rosgdz
PDF
русский язык 8кл бархударов 2000_ответы_new
by
Иван Иванов
PDF
русский язык 8кл бархударов 2000_ответы
by
Иван Иванов
PDF
гдз. физика. учеб для 8кл громов, родина 2000 -83с
by
Иван Иванов
PDF
85 1 гдз. физика. учеб для 8кл-громов, родина_2000 -83с
by
rosgdz
PDF
русский язык 8кл разумовская 2001_ответы
by
Иван Иванов
PDF
химия 9кл
by
robinbad123100
PDF
Мъртвият Бог?
by
Vasil Penchev
PDF
гдз. физика 9кл перышкин гутник_2001
by
Иван Иванов
PDF
February 2017
by
sunninews92
Pillars of Islam - (Urdu)
by
Martinkay99
Maqalat al hadith
by
Muhammad Nabeel Musharraf
Ghaflat aur jahalat by sikander naqshbandi
by
SikanderNaqshbandi
Mardane arab 1
by
sunninews92
гдз. русский язык 6кл ладыженская, тростенцова, баранов 2000
by
Иван Иванов
146
by
guest09eda4
47 химия 8кл гузей-гдз_2000
by
rosgdz
русский язык 8кл бархударов 2000_ответы_new
by
Иван Иванов
русский язык 8кл бархударов 2000_ответы
by
Иван Иванов
гдз. физика. учеб для 8кл громов, родина 2000 -83с
by
Иван Иванов
85 1 гдз. физика. учеб для 8кл-громов, родина_2000 -83с
by
rosgdz
русский язык 8кл разумовская 2001_ответы
by
Иван Иванов
химия 9кл
by
robinbad123100
Мъртвият Бог?
by
Vasil Penchev
гдз. физика 9кл перышкин гутник_2001
by
Иван Иванов
February 2017
by
sunninews92
More from Иван Иванов
PDF
Gdz geometriya-7kl.-didaktich.-mater.-ziv-b.g. 2003-272s
by
Иван Иванов
PDF
5 6kl klementeva
by
Иван Иванов
PDF
Gusev medyanik 9kl
by
Иван Иванов
PDF
Gdz geometria 9_klass_atanasyan_tetrad
by
Иван Иванов
PDF
Gdz algebra 9_klass_ershova_3
by
Иван Иванов
PDF
учебник химия 10 кл баз. ур. габриелян
by
Иван Иванов
PDF
Variantyi algebra8klaprel2015
by
Иван Иванов
PDF
Gusev medyanik 8_kl
by
Иван Иванов
PDF
Otvetyi algebra8klaprel2015
by
Иван Иванов
PDF
Gdz algebra 8_klass_ershova
by
Иван Иванов
PDF
m1ben1
by
Иван Иванов
PDF
Gdz algebra 8_klass_ershova
by
Иван Иванов
PDF
Gdz geometria 8_klass_dudnizin_tetrad
by
Иван Иванов
PDF
Gdz geometria 7_klass_dudnizin_tetrad
by
Иван Иванов
PDF
учебник проф. ур. 10 класс габриелян
by
Иван Иванов
PDF
Gdz algebra 9_klass_ershova_2
by
Иван Иванов
PDF
Gdz algebra 9_klass_ershova_1
by
Иван Иванов
PDF
Gdz algebra 8_klass_ershova
by
Иван Иванов
PDF
химия 11 класс габриелян баз.ур
by
Иван Иванов
PDF
химия 11 класс габриелян проф.ур
by
Иван Иванов
Gdz geometriya-7kl.-didaktich.-mater.-ziv-b.g. 2003-272s
by
Иван Иванов
5 6kl klementeva
by
Иван Иванов
Gusev medyanik 9kl
by
Иван Иванов
Gdz geometria 9_klass_atanasyan_tetrad
by
Иван Иванов
Gdz algebra 9_klass_ershova_3
by
Иван Иванов
учебник химия 10 кл баз. ур. габриелян
by
Иван Иванов
Variantyi algebra8klaprel2015
by
Иван Иванов
Gusev medyanik 8_kl
by
Иван Иванов
Otvetyi algebra8klaprel2015
by
Иван Иванов
Gdz algebra 8_klass_ershova
by
Иван Иванов
m1ben1
by
Иван Иванов
Gdz algebra 8_klass_ershova
by
Иван Иванов
Gdz geometria 8_klass_dudnizin_tetrad
by
Иван Иванов
Gdz geometria 7_klass_dudnizin_tetrad
by
Иван Иванов
учебник проф. ур. 10 класс габриелян
by
Иван Иванов
Gdz algebra 9_klass_ershova_2
by
Иван Иванов
Gdz algebra 9_klass_ershova_1
by
Иван Иванов
Gdz algebra 8_klass_ershova
by
Иван Иванов
химия 11 класс габриелян баз.ур
by
Иван Иванов
химия 11 класс габриелян проф.ур
by
Иван Иванов
гдз английский язык 5 класс афанасьева, верещагина
1.
hfZrgyy jZ[hlZ ihZg]ebckdhfmyaudm aZ deZkk d
mq_[gbdm©:g]ebckdbcyaudmq_[gbd ^ey 9deZkkZ rdhek m]em[e_gguf bamq_gb_fZg]ebckdh]hyaudZebp__ ]bfgZabcdhee_^`_cª _j_sZ]bgZBG :nZgZkv_ZH²FIjhk_s_gb_ mq_[ghijZdlbq_kdh_ ihkh[b_
2.
KH?J@:GB? %22. /HVVRQ /HVVRQ
/HVVRQ /HVVRQ /HVVRQ /HVVRQ /HVVRQ /HVVRQ /HVVRQ /HVVRQ /HVVRQ /HVVRQ /HVVRQ /HVVRQ /HVVRQ /HVVRQ /HVVRQ /HVVRQ /HVVRQ /HVVRQ /HVVRQ /HVVRQ /HVVRQ 5($'(5 Mjhd Mjhd Mjhd Mjhd Mjhd Mjhd Mjhd Mjhd Mjhd Mjhd Mjhd Mjhd Mjhd
3.
Mjhd Mjhd Mjhd Mjhd Mjhd Mjhd Mjhd Mjhd hihegbl_evgucfZl_jbZe 3(5621$/,'(17,),$7,21 /HVVRQ /HVVRQ /HVVRQ
/HVVRQ /HVVRQ /HVVRQ /HVVRQ /HVVRQ /HVVRQ /HVVRQ /HVVRQ /HVVRQ /HVVRQ /HVVRQ /HVVRQ /HVVRQ /HVVRQ /HVVRQ /HVVRQ /HVVRQ /HVVRQ
4.
%22. /HVVRQ ²+L+HOOR
5.
²1LFHWRPHHWRX ²+RZROGDUHRX ²,DPILQH ²:KHUHDUHRXIURP ²:KHUHGRRXOLYH ²3OHDVHGWRPHHWRX ²+RZDUHRX +HLV0U$GDP:HEVWHU 7KHDUH7RPDQG%HQ%URZQ
6KHLV0V1HOO3RVWHU 6KHLV0LVV%HWW:LOOLDPV 6KHLV0UV*UHHQ 0U0UV0LVV0V0U GDQFHU GRFWRU SROLFHPDQ VLQJHU VDLORU SRVWPDQ GULYHU WDLORU PLONPDQ DFWRU ILVKHUPDQ EDNHUJURFHUJUHHQJURFHUWSLVWVHFUHWDUVDOHVPDQQXUVHEXWFKHU D
6.
F
7.
²+HOORZKDW¶VRXUQDPH ²3HWHU ²6RUU ²,W¶V3HWHU ²DQRXVSHOOLWSOHDVH ²3HWHU:KDW¶VRXUQDPH
8.
²,W¶V2OJD'RRXOLYHKHUH ²HV,GR,OLYH DW QXPEHU
/HVQDD 6WUHHW )ODW :KDW¶V RXUDGGUHVV3HWHU ²,OLYHDWQXPEHU6KLURNDD6WUHHW0IODWQXPEHULV$UH RXRQWKHSKRQH2OJD ²HV ²:KDW¶VRXUWHOHSKRQHQXPEHU ²7KDW¶V jm`gZyk_fvy M DZjhebgIhjl_j[hevrZyk_fvydhlhjZykhklhblba^_ylbq_ eh_dKZfZyklZjrZy k_fv_[Z[mrdZug_ih_jbl_gh_cihqlb HgZ `bzl g_[hevrhf ^hfbd_ ^_j_g_ ;Z[mrdZ DZjhebg hq_gvbgl_j_km_lky`bagvxHgZme_dZ_lkykZ^hh^klhf _zfZ e_gvdhfhijylghfkZ^mhq_gvfgh]hdjZkbuob g_h[uqguop_lh Dh]^Z[Z[mrdZ[ueZfheh^hchgZ[ueZa_e_gsbp_c b jZ[hlZeZ fZe_gvdhffZ]Zabg_g_ih^Zezdm FZfZb iZiZDZjhebgZjobl_dlhjuBfhdhehghhgbu]ey ^ylgZfgh]hfheh`_Hgbme_dZxlky^j_gbfbjmkkdbfbp_jdyfb b qZklh_a^yl JhkkbxHgbihk_sZxldjmigu_b g_[hevrb_]hjh ^ZHgbgZklhysb_ki_pbZebklub fgh]hagZxlHgbqZklhjZkkdZ auZxlkh_ck_fv_h khboiml_r_klbyo FZfmDZjhebgahml_[[bHgZukhdZykljhcgZyk_lehheh kZy`_gsbgZhq_gvmfgZyb fbeZy?zfm`ZahmlIbl_jHggb`_ kh_c`_guHgom^hcb lzfghhehkucHghq_gvkf_eucHgb`_ gZlue_lb gZklhysb_^jmavy M _[[b_klv[jZlbdlhjb k_kljZG_eebdhlhjZyjZ[hlZ_lf_^ k_kljhc [hevgbp_G_eebg_aZfm`_fb mg_zg_l^_l_cbdlhj ijh^Z_pHg`_gZlb mg_]h^h_^_l_c;h[b IheebHgbmqZlky gZqZevghc rdhe_ Dma_gu DZjhebg hq_gv kihkh[gu_ hgb g_ fZ e_gvdh]hjhklZghb g_ukhdb_Bfihk_fve_lhgbk_lehheh ku_fbeu_b _`ebu_Bojh^bl_ebbfb]hj^ylkyGhbgh]^Zbo ^_lbe_gylky Dma_guex[ylb]jZlv Zdlbgu_b]juHgbgbdh]^Zg_mklZxlb j_^dh_^mlk_[ylbohM gbohq_gv[h]Zlh_hh[jZ`_gb_Hgbex [ylfgh]hqblZlvb kemrZlvkdZadb [Z[mrdb@_gZ bdlhjZ Fwjb fZrbgbkldZHgZjZ[hlZ_l djmighcnbjf_ k_ qe_gu k_fvb hq_gv ^jm`gu b ]hkl_ijbbfgu D gbf qZklh ijboh^yl ]hklb^jmavyb hgbmkljZbZxlqm^_kgu__q_jbgdb DUROLQH¶V PRWKHU LV'HEELH+HUIDWKHU¶VQDPH LV 3HWHU DUROLQH DOVRKDVDJUDQQ+HUPRWKHUKDVDVLVWHU1HOODQGDEURWKHU9LFWRU
9.
ZKRVH ZLIH LV
0DU 9LFWRU DQG 0DU KDYH WZR FKLOGUHQ %RE DQG 3ROO :KHQ *UDQQ ZDV RXQJ VKH ZDV D JUHHQJURFHU +HU IDWKHU DQG PRWKHUDUHDUFKLWHFWV +HUDXQW1HOOLVDQXUVH$QG KHUXQFOH9LFWRULVDVDOHVPDQ +LV ZLIH0DULVDWSLVW DUROLQH¶VPRWKHULVDWDOOZRPDQ VOLPDQGIDLUKDLUHGYHUFOHYHU DQGQLFH DUROLQH¶VIDWKHULVWKLQDQGGDUNKDLUHG+HLVYHUEUDYH DUROLQH¶VFRXVLQVDUHYHUEULJKW7KHDUHQRWVKRUWEXWWKHDUHQRW WDOOHLWKHU7KHDUHERWKVHYHQIDLUKDLUHGSUHWWDQGSROLWH6RPHWLPHV WKHDUHOD]7KHOLNHWRSODDFWLYHJDPHV7KHDUHQHYHUWLUHGDQG DUHVHOGRPTXLHW7KHKDYHJRWDUHDFKLPDJLQDWLRQ7KHOLNHWRUHDGD ORWDQGWRWKHLU*UDQQ¶VIDLUWDOHV 1HOODUROLQH¶VDXQWLVDWDOOVOLPGDUNKDLUHGRXQJZRPDQ6KH KDVORQJKDLU +HUXQFOHLVVKRUWIDLUKDLUHGPDQZLWKDURXQGIDFH+HKDVUHGOLSV DQGORQJDUPV 7KH%URZQIDPLO7KHKHDGRIWKHIDPLOLVIDWKHU+HLVDWDOOIDLU KDLUHGPDQRI+LVQDPHLV-RKQ+HLVDWHDFKHU+LVZLIHLV-DQH6KH LVDVKRUWSUHWWGDUNKDLUHGZRPDQRIIRUW6KHZRUNVLQDGHSDUWPHQW VWRUH6KHLVDVDOHVZRPDQ7KHKDYHJRWDGDXJKWHUZKRLVILYH6KHLV DJRRGTXLHWJLUOZLWKORQJKDLU7KHDUHDYHUIULHQGOIDPLO GRFWRUEDNHUEXWFKHUJURFHUJUHHQJURFHUQXUVHWSLVWVHFUHWDU D
10.
:KDWLVRXUQDPH E
11.
:KHQZHUHRXERUQ F
12.
:KHUHZHUHRXERUQ G
13.
+RZROGDUHRX H
14.
:KHUHGRRXOLYH I
15.
:KDWDUHRX J
16.
+RZODUJHLVRXUIDPLO K
17.
:KDWLVRXUDGGUHVV L
18.
:KDWLVRXUWHOHSKRQH QXPEHU
19.
3DWULFN%DUORZ +LJK6WUHHW0DQFKHVWHU*UHDW%ULWDLQ 7KLVWKHDWUHKDVJRWPDQDFWRUV
7KLVWRZQKDVQRZLGHVWUHHWV 'RWKHPXVHXPVKDYHDQZRRGHQFXSV 7KHZRPDQKDVJRWDYHUZHDNYRLFH 7KHROGVTXDUHKDVQRWRZHU 7KLVSODFHZLOOKDYHQRQHZVHWWOHPHQWV 1HOOOLYHVLQIODWDWQXPEHUHQWUDO6TXDUH0RVFRZ5XVVLD 0LFKDHOOLYHVLQIODWDWQXPEHUDEORFKQDD6WUHHW.OLQ5XVVLD 9LFWRUOLYHVLQIODWDWQXPEHU3RUWRYDD6WUHHW7YHU5XVVLD 3HWHUOLYHVLQIODWDWQXPEHU=HORQ3DUN6WUHHW3VNRY5XVVLD ,OLYHLQIODWDWQXPEHU7YHUVNDD6WUHHW0RVFRZ5XVVLD /HVVRQ 3HRSOHXVXDOOFRRNIRRGLQWKHNLWFKHQ 3HRSOHXVXDOOZRUNRUUHDGLQWKHVWXG 3HRSOHXVXDOOHDWLQWKHGLQLQJURRP 3HRSOHXVXDOOZDWFK79LQWKHOLYLQJURRP 3HRSOHXVXDOOWDONWRKHLUJXHVWVLQWKHVLWWLQJURRP 3HRSOHXVXDOOSXWRIIWKHLUFORWKHVLQWKHKDOO 3HRSOHXVXDOOVOHHSLQWKHEHGURRP 3HRSOHXVXDOOZDVKKDQGVLQWKHEDWKURRP WDEOH VRID EHGFKDLU DUPFKDLU VRID EHQFKGHVNSLFWXUHV SKRWR JUDSKV FDUSHW FXUWDLQV FXSERDUG IULGJH ERRNFDVH HOHFWULF FRRNHU ZDVKERZOZDUGUREH 7KHUHLVD ZDUGUREHDFDUSHW DVRID D VWDQGDUGODPSLQ WKH VLWWLQJ URRPRQWKHZDOOVWKHUHDUHSLFWXUHV7KHUHDUHDEHGDODPSDZDUGUREH DQGFXUWDLQVLQWKHEHGURRP 7KHUHLVDFRRNHUDVLQNDWDEOHLQWKHNLWFKHQ 3HWHULVUHDGLQJDPDJD]LQHDQG%HQDQG7RPDUHZRUNLQJLQWKHVWXG $QQLVVLQJLQJXSVWDLUV6KHVLQJVYHUZHOO
20.
0DUDQG6XVDQDUHFRXQWLQJDWWKHPRPHQW1LFNFRXQWVEDGO 7KHGRRURSHQVZHOO3HWHULVRSHQLQJWKHGRRUQRZ /RRN7KHEXVLVOHDYLQJ,WDOZDVOHDYHVDW 0DULVVLQJLQJDVRQJQRZ
21.
6KHDOZDVVLQJVZHOO 3HWHULVOHDYLQJIRU0RVFRZQRZ
22.
.DWHLVORFNLQJWKHGRRUZLWKWKHNHQRZ
23.
-RKQLVZDVKLQJWKHIORRUQRZ
24.
+HZDVKHVWKHIORRUVHOGRP KLOGUHQDUHGRLQJWKHOHVVRQVQRZ
25.
%RVDUHVSHQGLQJWKHLUKROLGDVQRZ
26.
:KGRPDQSHRSOHOHDUQIRUHLJQODQJXDJHV :KDWDUHWKHFRXQWLQJ :KHQGRHVWKHSODQHOLYHIRU/RQGRQ
+RZRIWHQGRWKHZULWHOHWWHUVWRWKHLUIULHQGV :KHQGRHVLWEHFRPHGDUNKHUH :KRLVMRLQLQJXV :KDWRIWHQKDSSHQV 7KHPRGHUQFRQYHQLHQFHV DUHKRWHOV79PRGHUQ IODWV DQGFDVWOHV ,QGLDQVHWWOHPHQWV0U3RUWHU¶VRWWDJHDUHQRW +RZGRRXIHHO 'RRXNQRZZKDWKHLVUHDGLQJ ,GRQ¶WXQGHUVWDQGZKDWVKHLVVDLQJ +HGRHVQ¶WVHHZKDWWKHSUREOHPLV +HLVVOHHSLQJQRZ+HOLNHVWRVOHHSDIWHUGLQQHU 6KHVDVVKHKHDUVQRWKLQJ 'R RXVHHWKHPDQZKRLVVWDQGLQJQHDUWKHZLQGRZ+HZDQWV WRVSHDNWRRX 8VXDOO,IOWR/RQGRQ 6KHQHYHUWXUQVRQFHQWUDOKHDWLQJLQVXPPHU :HDUHRIWHQODWH 0U0ROHUHDGVKLVQHZVSDSHUHYHUPRUQLQJ 6KHLVVHOGRPDQJU 0 EURWKHUDOZDV KHOSV KLV PRWKHU FOHDQ WKH FDUSHW ZLWK WKH YDFXXPFOHDQHU
27.
1HOOLVDQXUVH6KHZRUNVLQKRVSLWDO ,VRXUEURWKHUZRUNLQJLQWKHJDUGHQ²HV+HLVZDWHULQJ IORZHUV 0U*UHHQ¶VVHFUHWDUVHQGVOHWWHUVWR/RQGRQHYHUZHHN
7KHGRQRWRIWHQZDWFK79 ZKDWLVKHUHDGLQJ²+HLVUHDGLQJDQHZVSDSHU+HDOZDV UHDGVLWLQWKHPRUQLQJ 0DULVFOHDQLQJWKHFDUSHWZLWKWKHYDFXXPFOHDQHU6KHGRHV LWRQ0RQGD ,WLVGDUNLQWKHURRP7XUQWKHOLJKWVRQ ,WLVFROGLQWKHURRP7KHFHQWUDOKHDWLQJLVQ¶WRQ ,WLVYHUKRWKHUHWXUQWKHHOHFWULFILUHRII ,QVXPPHUWKHFHQWUDOKHDWLQJLVXVXDOORIILQRXUKRXVHV 0OLWWOHEURWKHUFDQ¶WWXUQRQWKHOLJKW+HLVYHUVPDOO (DUOLQWKHPRUQLQJZKHQ LWLVQRWGDUNRXWZHWXUQWKHOLJKW RQ 0LNHLVGRLQJKLVOHVVRQV7XUQWKHWHOHYLVLRQRIISOHDVH -RKQ+HOOR0DU1LFHWRVHHRX+RZDUHRX 0DU,¶PDOOULJKWDQGZKDWDERXWRX -RKQ,¶PILQHRXNQRZZHKDYHERXJKWDQHZIODW 0DU+DYHRX:KHUHLVLW -RKQ,W¶VIODW 1XPEHU $SSOH 6WUHHW 7KHIODW LV PRGHUQ DQG FRPIRUWDEOHZLWKDOOPRGHUQFRQYHQLHQFHVJDVHOHFWULFLWKRWDQGFROG UXQQLQJZDWHU 0DU,¶PJODGWRKHDUWKDW DZgbdmeuIbl_jZ Fbkl_jb fbkkbk=j_c`beb [hevrhf]hjh^_Fbkl_j=j_cjZ [hlZe [Zgd_ b ijhh^be fgh]h j_f_gb gZ jZ[hl_ Fbkkbk =j_c me_dZeZkvfmaudhcb bkdmkklhfM =j__[uekugihbf_gbIb l_j Ibl_j ohjhrh mki_Ze ih k_f ij_^f_lZf rdhe_ gh hg g_ ex[befulvkyHgg_gZb^_eh^m Fbkl_jb Fbkkbk=j_caZohl_ebijh_klb dZgbdmeu ^_j_g_ Hgb gZreb g_[hevrhc fbeuc ^hfbd g_^Ze_dh hl hnbkZ Fbkl_jZ =j_y Fbkkbk b Ibl_j ih_oZeb lm^Z gZ uoh^gu_ gZqZe_ bxgy Iha`_Fbkl_j=j_caZohl_eijbkh_^bgblvkyd gbfIbl_jk fZfhc
28.
m_oZeblm^ZgZ^_g_^_eb;uehm`_iha^ghdh]^Zhgbijb_oZeb ^hfbdFbkkbk=j_ckdZaZeZIbl_jm ²Fuijh[m^_fa^_kvq_lujgZ^pZlv^g_c FZevqbd[_`Ze ^hfaZ`z]k_lb aZ]eygmehk_dhfgZluHg mb^_edmogxk
[_eufoheh^bevgbdhf^mfyk_jZglZfbieblhcb jZdhbghc ^hf_[uehwe_dljbq_klhb ]Za?szhgmb^_eiue_ khk m]em=hklbgZyk ^ebggufa_jdZehfb djZkbufdZfbghf[ueZ _ebdhe_igZ g_cfh`gh[uehb]jZlv nml[he Ibl_jih[_`ZegZaZ^d fZf_b aZdjbqZe ²FZfZWlha^hjhhGhy g_b^_eZggmx=^_hgZ ²A^_kvly`_eh^hklZlvh^m²kdZaZeZfZfZ²b a^_kvg_l]h jyq_cb oheh^ghch^u ²Wlhhq_gvohjhrhfZfZ²kdZaZeIbl_j²DZgbdmeu^_c klbl_evgh[m^mlaZf_qZl_evgu_ 3HWHUZDVVXUHWKDWKHZDVJRLQJWRKDYHDQLFHKROLGDEHFDXVHWKHUH ZDVQRKRWDQGFROGUXQQLQJZDWHULQWKHKRXVHDQG3HWHUGLGQ¶WOLNHWR ZDVK+HKDWHGZDWHU 7KHKDGHOHFWULFLWDQGJDVLQWKHLUVXPPHUFRWWDJH 3HWHUZDV DYHU MROOER+H ZDV DFOHYHU SXSLOEXWKH ZDV YHU VWUDQJHWRR+HGLGQ¶WOLNHWRZDVK 0UDQG0UV*UDZDQWHGWRJRWRWKHFRXQWUWRVSHQGWKHVXPPHU WKHUH7KHKDGDVRQ3HWHUZKRGLGQ¶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
29.
/HVVRQ 0IDWKHU¶VKREELVZDWFKLQJIRRWEDOO 0IULHQG¶VKREELVFROOHFWLQJFRLQVDQGFRPSXWHUJDPHV 0PRWKHU¶VKREELVJDUGHQLQJ 0IDYRULWHKREELVUHDGLQJDQGZKHQ,ZDVDOLWWOHERPIDYRULWH KREEZDVSODLQJZLWKWRV 7KH5XVVLDQ$UPZRQWKHEDWWOH 7KHVROGQHZVSDSHUVMXVWLQWKHVWUHHWWKHRWKHUGD
7KHERDSSHDUHGYHUVRRQ +HDOZDVWROGWKHWUXWK 7KHVXQURVHDQGHYHUWKLQJJRWVREULJKW +HJRWXSDWILYHDQGFDXJKWWKHEXV FZjdL_g
30.
@be rlZl_FbkkmjbgZ[_j_]mFbk kbkbib IbkZe h
Lhf_ Khc_j_ gZqZe jZ[hlZlv e_l ;ue fhjydhf KlZeagZf_gbluf ]h^m;ueibkZl_e_fdhjhldbojZkkdZahb _ebdbf Zf_jbdZgkdbf kZlbjbdhf Me_dZeky dhee_dpbhgbjhZgb _f_s_cdhlhjuogbm dh]hg_[ueh `_dEhg^hg
31.
;uekughfn_jf_jZjZ[hlZegZjZa guo jZ[hlZo JZ[hlZe
ijh^Zphf ]Za_l f_qlZe h lhf qlh[u klZlv ibjZlhfKhxi_jmxdgb]mgZibkZe ]h^mIbkZejhfZgub bklhjbbh `bhlguo DZdh_lh j_fy `be gZ :eykd_ gZibkZe jZkkdZaZh k__j_ bevyf R_dkibj
32.
@be Klj_lnhj^_
gZ Whg_ mqbeky ]jZffZlbq_kdhcrdhe_jZ[hlZeZdlzjhfb]jZe ehg^hg kdhfl_Zlj_ ©=ehm[ªGZibkZeiv_kfgh]hdgb]b ihwfIbkZe ahehlhc_dZg]ebckdhcebl_jZlmju :]ZlZ Djbklb
33.
IhemqbeZ ^hfZrg__ h[jZahZgb_ IjbgbfZeZmqZklb_
hcg_]h^ZureZaZfm` ]h^m ]h^mgZqZeZibkZlv^_l_dlbgu_bklhjbb ]h^mklZeZ agZf_gblhcGZibkZeZjhfZghiv_kb [he__khlgbjZkkdZ ah `_cfkO_^ebQ_ca
34.
Jh^beky Ehg^hg_GZqZeib kZlv ]h^m
wlhf`_]h^mklZeagZf_gblufJZ[hlZeijh^Z phfdgb]GZibkZedgb]
35.
6KDNHVSHDUHZDVERUQLQ +LVQDWLYHFLWZDV/RQGRQ 07ZDLQZDVIURP0LVVRXUL
$KULVWLHEHFDPHIDPRXVLQ 0DUN7ZDLQZDVDVDLORU6KDNHVSHDUHZDVDQDFWRUKDVHZDV DVHOOHU $JDWKDKULVWLHZURWHQRYHOV -DFN/RQGRQGUHDPWRIEHFRPLQJDSLUDWH 0DUN7ZDLQZDVWKHJUHDWHVW$PHULFDQKXPRULVW 6KDNHVSHDUHZURWHLQWKHJROGHQDJHRI(QJOLVKOLWHUDWXUH $JDWKDKULVWLHWRRNSDUWLQWKHZDURI 6KHJRWHGXFDWLRQDWKRPH :KROLYHGLQ6WUDWIRUGRQ$YRQ :KRDFWHGLQ©7KH*OREHª :KRZURWHLQWKHJROGHQDJHRI(QJOLVK :KRZDVERUQLQ :KRJRWPDUULHGLQ :KRZURWHPRUHWKDQDKXQGUHGVWRULHV :KRVHIDWKHUZDVDIDUPHU :KRKDGDORWRIMREV :KRZURWHVWRULHVDERXWDQLPDOV 7KHFKLOGUHQSODHGYROOHEDOO DW WKHVSRUWVJURXQGWKUHHGDV DJR 0DUSODHGSLDQRDIWHUFODVVHVWKUHHGDVDJR 1HOO DQG9LFWRU SODHG EDGPLQWRQ DW WKHVSRUWV JURXQG WKUHH GDVDJR 0HOGHUVLVWHUSODHGWKHJXLWDUDIWHUFODVVHVWKUHHGDVDJR DUROLQHSODHGWKHYLROLQDIWHUFODVVHVWKUHHGDVDJR 7KHERVSODHGKRFNHDWWKHVSRUWVJURXQGWKUHHGDVDJR 0IULHQGJRHVLQIRUVZLPPLQJ %RE:KHUHVKDOOZHJRWRQLJKW 0DU $V RX NQRZ ,¶P D WKHDWUHJRHU , ZRXOG OLNH WR JR WR WKH WKHDWUH:KDW¶VRQDWWKH©6DWLULFRQª
36.
%RE©$WKUHHSHQFHRSHUDª 0DU:KRLVSODLQJ %RE,GRQ¶WNQRZEXWRIFRXUVH5DLNLQ 0DU2K,OLNHWKLVDFWRUYHUPXFK,ZRXOGOLNHWRJR %RE2./HW¶VKXUUXS 0DU/HW¶VJR Qlh`_kemqbehkvk ^y^xrdhcHkdZjhf Y ohl_e[uZfjZkkdZaZlvqlhkemqbehkvk
fhbf^y^xrdhcHk dZjhfbeby ihiulZxkvihgylvwlhb h[tykgblvZf Fhc^y^yHkdZj[uehq_gvijbylgufq_eh_dhfDZ`^h_mljh ihg_^_evgbdlhjgbdkj_^mq_l_j]b iylgbpmhgh[uqghkZ^beky gZZlh[mk b m_a`ZegZjZ[hlmHg_a^be [ZgdjZghmljhf lZd dZd hg [ue [mo]Zel_jhf dklZlb hq_gv ohjhrbf
37.
Hg mk_j^gh jZ[hlZep_euc^_gvb ijboh^be^hfhc^hhevghiha^ghFh_fm^y ^_[uehkhjhdk_fvhg[ue`_gZlb
mg_]h[ueh^h_^_l_c ?]h`_gmaZeb:]ZlZLzly:]ZlZex[beZih]hhjblvb hgZk_ ]^Zkebrdhffgh]hb ]jhfdh]hhjbeZIhwlhfmy ^mfZx^y^yHkdZj j_^dh]hhjbeBo^_lbWebaZ[_lb `mebZg[uebg_hq_gvfbeu_ H[Z[ueblZdb_`_[hevrb_b ]jhfdb_dZdb bofZlv?szhgb[ueb `Z^gu_b w]hbklbqgu_Hgbhkh[hg_^mfZebh khzfhlp_Hg[ue lbobcfZe_gvdbcq_eh_ddhlhjucfZeh]hhjbeb oh^beg_aZf_lgh Hgex[befmaudmghg_b]jZegbgZibZgbghgbgZkdjbid_gbgZ ne_cl_gbgZdZdhf^jm]hffmaudZevghfbgkljmf_gl_HgijZdlbq_ kdbgbdh]^Zg_oh^be dbghb l_Zljg_ihk_sZeuklZdbb fma_b y^yHkdZjg_aZgbfZekykihjlhfHgg_me_dZekygb ieZZgv _f gb eu`Zfb gb ]hevnhf u [u gbdh]^Z [u g_ mb^_eb _]h ]hklbghcgZijhlbl_e_bahjZkfhljys_]hkihjlbgu_ijh]jZffu y^y HkdZj gbdh]^Z g_ `ZehZeky gZ khx kdmqgmx `bagv Y agZxqlhm g_]h[uehoh[[bM g_]h[ueZhq_gvohjhrZydhee_dpby fZjhd b hg [ue kqZkleb lhevdh lh]^Z dh]^Z jZ[hlZe gZ^ kh_c dhee_dpb_c fZjhd Hg [ue gZklhysbc dhee_dpbhg_j ?]h ^_lb g_ bkiuluZeb gbdZdh]h bgl_j_kZ d _]h oh[[b Gh y _]h ie_fyggbd bkiuluZe y^y HkdZj ihdZauZe fg_ g_dhlhju_ fZjdb b h[tyk gyeqlhhgb^_cklbl_evghhq_gv^hjh]b_ hdly[jy]h^Z^y^yHkdZjijhkgmekydZdh[uqgh r_klv khjhdiylvijb]hlhbek_[_aZljZdlzly:]ZlZWebaZ[_lb `meb Zgkz_sz[ueb ihkl_ebhgbg_klZZebjZgvr_hkvfb
38.
ur_e ba^hfZb ihrzegZZlh[mkgmxhklZghdmG_dhlhju_ex^bdhlh ju_[uebgZhklZghd_ lhl^_gvhh[s__]hg_b^_ebjm]b_g_ [ueblZdm_j_guHgbg_fh]ebkdZaZlvgbq_]hhij_^_ezggh]hGh
39.
^y^yHkdZj[uelZdhcq_eh_dqlh^jm]b_ex^bj_^dh_]haZf_qZeb H^gh[uehykghhggbdh]^Z[hevr_g_ihybeky [Zgd_ +HZDVQ¶WKDSSEHFDXVHKLVIDPLOGLGQ¶WSDPXFKDWWHQWLRQWRKLP 7KHQDUUDWRURIWKHVWRULVDERZKRLVQHSKHZRI8QFOH2VFDU
7KHUHZHUHIRXUPHPEHUVLQ8QFOH2VFDU¶VIDPLO 8QFOH2VFDUZDVIRUWVHYHQ +HZDVDQDFFRXQWDQW $XQW$JDWKDWDONHGDORWDQG8QFOH2VFDUZDVDOZDVTXLHW ,GRQ¶WWKLQNWKDW8QFOH2VFDU¶VFKLOGUHQORYHGWKHLUIDWKHUEH FDXVHWKHORYHGRQOWKHPVHOYHV +LVKREEZDVFROOHFWLQJVWDPSV +LVOLIHZDVERULQJEHFDXVHQRERGORYHGKLP 8QFOH2VFDUGLGQ¶WJRLQIRUVSRUWV +HZHQWWRWKHEDQNEXWKHQHYHUJRWWKHUH D
40.
,WKLQNWKDW8QFOH2VFDUZDVDQLFHPDQ+HZDVYHUNLQGDQG ORYLQJKXVEDQG E
41.
+LVZLIHZDVQ¶WDSROLWHZRPDQ DQGVKHGLGQ¶WORYHKLP6KH DOZDVWDONHGWRRPXFKLQDYHUORXGYRLFH6KHZDVLQWHUHVWHGRQOLQ KHUVHOI F
42.
7KH FKLOGUHQ ZHUH
QRW YHU SOHDVDQW 7KH GLGQ¶W ORYH 8QFOH 2VFDUHLWKHUDVWKHRQOORYHGWKHPVHOYHV G
43.
,WZDVDYHUERULQJOLIH6RXQFOH2VFDUFRXOGQRORQJHUVWDQGLW DQGWKDW¶VZKKHGLVDSSHDUHG 2QWKHWK RI2FWREHU8QFOH2VFDUJRWXSPDGHKLVRZQEUHDNIDVW DQGOHIWWKHKRXVHIRUWKHEDQN%XWKHQHYHUJRWWKHUHWKDWPRUQLQJ 8QFOH 2VFDU JRW
RQ WKH EXVDQG URGH WR WKH VHD SRUW +H ERXJKW D WLFNHWWRVRPHORQHOSODFHZKHUHKHGHFLGHGWRVSHQGWKHUHVWRIKLVOLIH $QGVRKHGLG+HVSHQWKLVOLIHLQDVPDOOKRXVHEWKHVHD$QGWKHUH ZHUHQRWDQSHRSOH$QGZKHQKHGLHGQRERGOHDUQWDERXWLW D
44.
9LVLWLQJPXVHXPVH[KLELWLRQVJDOOHULHVLVPIDWKHU¶VKREE E
45.
3ODLQJWKHSLDQRLVPPRWKHU¶VKREE F
46.
*RLQJLQIRUVSRUWVLVPEURWKHU¶VKREE G
47.
3DLQWLQJLVPJUDQGIDWKHU¶VKREE H
48.
/LVWHQLQJWRWKHUDGLRZDWFKLQJ79LVPJUDQGPRWKHU¶VKREE
49.
I
50.
:DWFKLQJYLGHRILOPVLVPVLVWHU¶VKREE J
51.
9LVLWLQJMD]]FRQFHUWVLVPIULHQG¶VKREE :KDWLVRXUIDYRULWHIDPRXVSHUVRQ :KHQZDVKHERUQ :KDWGLGKHGR :KHUHGLGKHOLYH :KDWZDVKLVKREE :KLVKHRXUIDYRULWHSHUVRQ :KDWHOVHFDQRXWHOODERXWKLP :KRJRHVLQIRUVSRUWVLQRXUJURXS²0IULHQGGRHV :KROLNHVWRJRWRGLIIHUHQWH[KLELWLRQV²,GR
:KRLVOLVWHQLQJWRWKHRSHUDQRZ²0PRWKHULV :KRLVLQWHUHVWHGLQSROLWLFV²0IDWKHULV :KRZLOOJRWRWKHFRQFHUWQH[WZHHN²2XUIDPLOZLOO :KRFDQSODWKHJXLWDU²0EURWKHUFDQ :KRPXVWOHDUQWKLVSRHPEKHDUW²,PXVW :KDWPXVHXPKDVJRWDJRRGFROOHFWLRQRIVFXOSWXUHV²7KLV PXVHXPKDV ,ZHQWWRWKH7UHWLDNRY*DOOHUODVWZHHNEHFDXVHLWKDVJRWDJRRG FROOHFWLRQ RISLFWXUHV, ZHQW WKHUH ZLWK P IDPLO :H VDZ PDQ ID PRXVSLFWXUHV:HDUULYHGWKHUHLQWKHPRUQLQJ:HDUULYHGWKHUHEFDU 7KHRSHQLQJKRXUVZHUHRCFORFN ,W ZDV YHU LQWHUHVWLQJ :H DUULYHG KRPH LQ WKH DIWHUQRRQ :H DUH JRLQJWKHUHQH[W6DWXUGDDJDLQ :KHUHGLGKHJR :KHQGLGKHJRWKHUH :LWKZKRPGLGKHJRWKHUH :KDWGLGKHVHHWKHUH +RZLQWHUHVWLQJZDVLW 'LGKHOLNHLWWKHUH :KHQGLGKHDUULYHKRPH /HVVRQ 3HRSOHFDQWUDYHOEFDUEDLUEWUDLQEVHDEERDWEIHHWE EXV
52.
7KHTXLFNHVWPHWKRGRIWUDYHOOLQJLVWUDYHOOLQJEDLU 7UDYHOOLQJEWUDLQLVWKHPRVWFRPIRUWDEOHRQH 7KHFKHDSHVWZDRIWUDYHOOLQJLVWUDYHOOLQJEIHHWDQGWKHPRVWH[ SHQVLYHLVWUDYHOLQJEDLU 7KHPRVWFRQYHQLHQWPHWKRGRIWUDYHOOLQJLVWUDYHOOLQJEFDU 7KHPRVWLQWHUHVWLQJRQHLVWUDYHOOLQJEFDU :DVLWDEXVLQHVVRUDWRXULVWWULS :KHQGLGRXDUULYHDWWKHDLUSRUW 'LGRXKDYHPXFKOXJJDJH 'LGRXEXDUHWXUQWLFNHW :KLFKFODVVGLGRXIO +RZPXFKWLPHGLGLWWDNHRXWRIOWR,QGLD +RZZDVRXUKROLGD 'LGRXJRWRWKHVHDVLGH +RZGLGRXJRWKHUH :DVLWDIDVWWUDLQ +RZPDQGDVGLGRXVWDWKHUH :DVRXUURRPDGRXEOHRQH +RZZDVWKHZHDWKHUOLNH YRDJH E VHD
RQ ERDUG WKH VKLS ZHDWKHU ZLQG WULS H[SHQVLYH WRXULVWFODVVDVLQJOHWLFNHWESODQH 2QFHRXUIDPLO GHFLGHGWRJRWRWKHVHD7KHFKHDSHVWZD WRJHW WKHUHZDVWRWUDYHOEWUDLQWKRXJKLWWRRNPXFKWLPH7KHZHDWKHUZDV ILQH7KHVXQZDVVKLQLQJDOOWKHWLPH$QG,HQMRHGWKHYLHZ,WWRRNXV WZRGDVWRJHWWKHUH$QGZHKDGUHWXUQWLFNHWV:HVSHQWWZRZHHNVDW WKHVHDVLGHDQGUHWXUQHGWR0RVFRZLQ$XJXVW WKLQN WKRXJKW WKRXJKW GULQN GUDQN GUXQN VLW VDW VDW KDYH KDG KDG KHDU KHDUG KHDUG VOHHS VOHSW VOHSW ILQG IRXQG IRXQG VD VDLG VDLG
53.
IO IOHZ IORZQ UHDG
UHDG UHDG JLYH JDYH JLYHQ WHOO WROG WROG WDNH WRRN WDNHQ XQGHUVWDQG XQGHUVWRRG XQGHUVWRRG FRPH FDPH FRPH JHW JRW JRW ZHDU ZRUH ZRUQ IRUJHW IRUJRW IRUJRWWHQ QHYHUUHFHQWODOUHDGODWHOUHFHQWODOUHDGHWQHYHU +DYHRXSODHGWHQQLVUHFHQWO +DYHRXJRWDQH[FHOOHQWPDUNODWHO +DYHRXERXJKWDQHZERRNUHFHQWO +DYHRXKHDUGIURPRXUJUDQGSDUHQWVUHFHQWO +DYHRXWUDYHOOHGUHFHQWO +DYHRXZRUNHGKDUGODWHO 6XVDQKDVDOUHDGERXJKWWKHWLFNHWWR%RVWRQ 6XVDQKDVDOUHDGWDNHQERRNVWRWKHOLEUDU 6XVDQKDVQ¶WPDGHOXQFKHW 6KHKDVQ¶WZULWWHQDOHWWHUWR*UDQQHW 6XVDQKDVDOUHDGJLYHQDFDOOWR%HWW 6XVDQKDVDOUHDGVHQWDWHOHJUDPPHWR'DGG 6XVDQKDVQ¶WVZXPLQWKHSRROHW 6XVDQKDVQ¶WUHDGWKHQRYHOXSWRWKHHQG 6XVDQKDVDOUHDGGUXQNWKHPHGLFLQH
54.
«KHKDVIORZQWR3DULVZLWKKLV'DG
55.
«VKHKDVEHHQWRPDQFRXQWULHV
56.
«VKHKDVQ¶WUHDGWKHVWRUXSWRWKHHQG
57.
«KHKDVIDOOHQLOO
58.
«VKHKDVZDVKHGLW
59.
«KHKDVIDOOHQRYHURQWKHJURXQG
60.
«KHKDVQ¶WZRQWKHSUL]H 7KHKDYHDOZDVOLYHGLQWKLVFLW
61.
7KHDOZDVEXUHWXUQWLFNHWV +HDOZDVWDNHVSLFWXUHVZKHQKHWUDYHOV 6KHKDVDOZDVNQRZQWKLVSKRWRJUDSKHU
:HKDYHDOZDVZDQWHGWRJRWR3DULV 0IULHQGKDVDOZDVOLYHGLQ3DULV ,KDYHDOZDVKDGDQDOEXPZLWKVWDPSV ,KDYHDOZDVFROOHFWHGVWDPSV RXDOZDVWDNHOLWWOHOXJJDJHZLWKRX ,KDYHDOZDVEHHQSURXGRIPSDUHQWV Fhc^jm]bghieZg_lygbg Fbkl_jDbjdijh]mebZeky hkdj_k_gv__q_jhf iZjd_k kh [Zdhc^jm]hgmkeurZermfb mb^_ekljZggh]hq_eh_dZi_j_^ kh[hcWlh[ueAZj^Zdk ieZg_lubdhgAZj^Zdijbe_l_e Ehg^hg ihha^momGhhgijbe_l_eg_ Zwjhihjlhgg_aZj_]bkljbjhZeky b g_ijhrzeiZkihjlgucdhgljhevb lZfh`gx Fbkl_jDbjdaye_]hd k_[_^hfhcghhg g_kdZaZe gbdhfm h ijb[ulbb AZj^ZdZ AZj^Zdm ihgjZbeky fbkl_j Dbjd b hgb klZeb ^jmavyfbGhAZj^ZdmklZehldZjlbjufbkl_jZDbjdZHgaZohl_e ihiml_r_klhZlvihkljZg_bebohly[uihkfhlj_lv]hjh^ AZj^ZdGmfhc^hjh]hc^jm]Dh]^Zfuihc^zfkfhlj_lvlhc ]hjh^ Fbkl_j DbjdGm«wlhkeh`ghAZj^ZdWlhg_hq_gvohjhrZy b^_y AZj^ZdGhy a^_kvm`_^Z^gyb _szgbq_]hg_b^_e Fbkl_jDbjdLukfhlj_el_e_bahj AZj^ZdY fh]mkfhlj_lvl_e_bahjgZkhzfdhjZ[e_bebdh]^Zy ^hfZgZieZg_l_bdhgIh`ZemcklZfhc^jm] Fbkl_jDbjdY l_[_m`_kdZaZeWlhiehoZyb^_y Gh AZj^Zd ohq_l ihkfhlj_lv Ehg^hg Hg me_dZ_lky iml_r_kl byfbHgfgh]himl_r_klhZeIml_r_klb__]hoh[[bBaaZwlh ]hhgijb_oZegZieZg_lmA_fey M AZj^ZdZgZ]heh_^ZfZe_gvdbok_j_[jyguojh]ZIjbihfh sbwlbojh]hhgfh]aZklZblvex^_c^_eZlvlhqlhhgohq_l?]h jh]ZklZghylkyyjdha_ezgufbb k_lhlgboaZklZey_lk_o^_eZlv b ]hhjblvkzqlhgjZblkyAZj^ZdmB AZj^Zdk_]hebrvkfhljbl gZfbkl_jZDbjdZFbkl_jDbjdb^bla_ezguck_lb ]hhjbl Fbkl_jDbjdGmy kh]eZk_gIhc^zf p_glj]hjh^Z_cklb l_evghihq_fm[ugZfg_ihclbY dmibel_[_iZevlhb reyimIh `ZemcklZgZ^_gvbo AZj^ZdGhihq_fmreyimLugbdh]^Zg_ghkbrvreyim
62.
Fbkl_jDbjdOhjhrhY h^_gmlh`_ Fbkl_j Dbjd
b AZj^Zd b^ml ih mebp_ d Zlh[mkghc hklZghd_ Hgbklj_qZxlfbkkbkWZgk FbkkbkWZgkA^jZklmcl_fbkl_jDbjdY lZdjZ^ZZkklj_ lblvDlhwlhlfheh^hcq_eh_d Fbkl_jDbjdWlhfhcdma_gbaDZebnhjgbb FbkkbkWZgkHDZdih`bZ_l_DZd^Zghua^_kv Fbkl_jDbjdHga^_kvk q_l_j]ZHga^_kv^Z^gy Fbkkbk WZgk Qlh u ^mfZ_l_ h[ :g]ebb ^hjh]hc Wlh Zr i_jucijb_a^ :g]ebx AZj^ZdZi_jucY jZgvr_a^_kvgbdh]^Zg_[ueA^_kvhq_gv fbeh Fbkkbk WZgk: fg_hq_gv gjZblky ZrZ kljZgZ Y [ueZ lZf ljbjZaZuagZ_l_Fhyk_kljZ`bzl Ehk:g`_e_k_ DZebnhj gbbHgZk_]^Zohl_eZlZf`blv: ]^_bf_gghu`bzl_ AZj^Zd bdhg_ FbkkbkWZgkY hlZdhfg_keurZeZ=^_wlh Fbkl_jDbjdWlhhq_gvfZe_gvdbc]hjh^hdHq_gvfZe_gvdbc FbkkbkWZgkAZ[Zghm Zkg_lZf_jbdZgkdh]hZdp_glZ Fbkl_jDbjdkfhljblgZkhbqZku
63.
H^hjh]ZyM`_lZdiha^ ghGmfbkkbkWZgk^hkb^ZgbyFu^_cklbl_evghki_rbf FbkkbkWZgkhkb^ZgbyIjbylgh[uehihagZdhfblvky 0U.LUNKDVERXJKWKLVQHZ IULHQGDKDW EHFDXVH=DUGDNKDGOLWWOH VLOYHUKRUQVRQKLVKHDG
HV=DUGDNDUULYHGLQ/RQGRQRQ7KXUVGD =DUGDNOLYHVRQSODQHW9HFRQ =DUGDNKDVQHYHUEHHQWR(DUWK,WLVKLVILUVWYLVLW 0UV(YDQVKDVQHYHUKHDUGRI9HFRQ 9HFRQLVDSODQHW =DUGDNKDVQ¶WJRWDQ$PHULFDQDFFHQW 0U.LUNDQG=DUGDNDUHQRWUHDOOLQDKXUU 0UV(YDQVKDVEHHQWRDOLIRUQLDWKUHHWLPHV 0U.LUNPHW=DUGDNLQWKHSDUN =DUGDNZDVDQDOLHQIURPSODQHW9HFRQ+HZDVIRQGRIWUDYHO OLQJ+HKDGOLWWOHVLOYHUKRUQVRQKLVKHDG =DUGDNKDVVHHQQRWKLQJLQ/RQGRQHWEHFDXVHKHKDVQ¶WJRQH RXWHW 0U.LUNKDVERXJKW=DUGDNDKDWEHFDXVH=DUGDNKDGOLWWOHVLOYHU KRUQVRQKLVKHDG$QGSHRSOHFRXOGVHHWKHP
64.
=DUGDNPDGH0U.LUNDJUHHWRJRWRWKHFLWFHQWUHZLWKWKHXVH RIWKHVHKRUQV 0U.LUNH[SODLQHGWR0UV(YDQVWKDW9HFRQZDVDWRZQLQDOL IRUQLD EHFDXVH
KH GLGQ¶W ZDQW 0UV (YDQV WR NQRZ WKH WUXWK DERXW=DUGDN +HGLGQ¶WWHOO0UV(YDQVWKHWUXWKEHFDXVHVKHZRXOGQ¶WEHOLHYH LW 6KHZDQWVWRDVN©:KHUHLVLWVLWXDWHGª 0U .LUN ZDQWHG WR ILQLVK WKHLU WDON EHFDXVH =DUGDN FRXOG WHOO 0UV(YDQVWKDWKHZDVIURPWKHSODQHW9HFRQ$QG0U.LUNVDLG WKDWWKHZHUHLQDKXUU ,¶OOWDNHKLPWRWKH7RZHURI/RQGRQWRWKH7UDIDOJDU6TXDUHWRWKH %LJ%HQWRWKH:HVWPLQVWHU$EEH 7KHZHDWKHULQ/RQGRQZDVUDLQHVWHUGD ,WLVDILQHZHDWKHULQ0RVFRZQRZ ,WKDVEHHQVQRZLQJLQ1HZRUNVLQFH0RQGD 7KHZHDWKHULQ3DULVKDVEHHQFORXGVLQFHWKHWK RI2FWREHU 1R,GRQ¶WWUDYHORIWHQ/DVW,WUDYHOOHGLQVXPPHU ,WUDYHOOHGWRWKHVHDVLGH ,WUDYHOOHGWKHUHEWUDLQ 7KH TXLFNHVW PHWKRG RI WUDYHOOLQJ LV WUDYHOOLQJ E SODQH 7KH PRVWFRPIRUWDEOHWUDYHOOLQJLVWUDYHOOLQJEWUDLQ 3HRSOHXVXDOO WUDYHO EDLULIWKH ZDQWWRJHWWRWKH IDUWKHVW SODFHVRIWKHHDUWK ,WKLQNWKDWLWLVLQWHUHVWLQJWRWUDYHOEVHDEXW,KDYHQ¶WGRQHLW 0 SDUHQWVGRQ¶WRIWHQ WUDYHO EDLU 7KHEXWLFNHWV IRU WKH IOLJKW DWWKH DLUSRUW ,W LV H[SHQVLYH WR WUDYHO E SODQH 3HRSOH SUHIHUWUDYHOOLQJESODQHEHFDXVHLWLVWKHTXLFNHVWZDRIWUDY HOOLQJ 3HRSOH XVXDOO UHDG QHZVSDSHUV ZKHQ WKH DUH RQ WKH SODQH 7KHXVXDOOVOHHSZKHQWKHDUHRQWKHWUDLQ$QGWKHXVXDOO ORRNWKURXJKWKHZLQGRZZKHQWKHDUHRQWKHEXV HV ,RIWHQWUDYHOOHGEFDU,WKLQNWKDWLWLVFRPIRUWDEOHDQG FRQYHQLHQW3HRSOHWUDYHOEFDUEHFDXVHLWLVFKHDS 3HRSOH XVXDOO VWD DW KRWHOV ZKHQ WKH WUDYHO WR IDUDZD SODFHVHV,KDYHVWDHGDWWKHKRWHO,WZDVYHUFRPIRUWDEOH 7KHURRPVZHUHQRWYHUELJ7KHIRRGZDVUDWKHUWDVW
65.
0U.LUNZDVLQWKHSDUNRQHQLJKW =DUGDNFDPHIURPWKHSODQHW9HFRQ 0U.LUNWRRN=DUGDNKRPH
=DUGDNKDVQ¶WVHHQDQWKLQJRQWKH(DUWKHW =DUGDNFDQZDWFKWHOHYLVLRQIURPKLVVWDUVKLS =DUGDNZDQWVWRPDNHDWRXUDERXW/RQGRQ 0UV(YDQ¶VVLVWHUOLYHVLQ/RV$QJHOHV 0UV(YDQ¶VVLVWHUKDVOLYHGWKHUHIRUHDUV 0U.LUNDQG=DUGDNDUHLQDKXUU $ EHGURRPILUHSODFHVHDSRUWPLONPDQEODFNERDUG % UDLOZD VWDWLRQ WUDIILFOLJKWV WKURXJK WUDLQ UHWXUQ WLFNHW VLQJOH WLFNHW 0U1HOVRQLVDQDUFKLWHFW+HKDVEXLOGVRPHPRGHUQFRWWDJHV 0U.LUNLVDEDNHU+HKDV EHFRPHIDPRXV IRU KLV ZRQGHUIXO EUHDG 1HOOLVIRQGRISDLQWLQJ6KHKDVGUDZQIXQQSLFWXUHVRIDQL PDOV -DFN LV D SRVWPDQ +H KDV EURXJKW PH VR PDQ OHWWHUV DQG PDJD]LQHV $QJHODLVEDGDWPDWKHPDWLFV6KHKDVQRWOHDUQWKRZWRDGGZHOO 6WHYHLVVRLOOQRZ+HKDVQRWIHOWVREDGVLQFHWKHRSHUDWLRQ 2QHGDRXUIDPLOZHQWWRWKHULYHU,WZDVDYHUVXQQGD(YHU ERGZDVKDSS:HVZDPDQGSODHG%XWZKHQZHZDQWHGWRKDYHRXU EUHDNIDVWLWVWDUWHGWRUDLQ6RZHZHQWKRPH$QGZKHQZHDUULYHGKRPH HYHUERGZDVDQJU /HVVRQ SDUWVRIWKHFLW SODFHVRILQWHUHVW SODFHVWRZRUN PRQH URDG H[KLELWLRQ IDFWRU URXEOH VWUHHW JDOOHU VKRS QLFNHO VTXDUH PXVHXP KRVSLWDO SHQQ SDUN FKXUFK EDQN SRXQG EULGJH PRQXPHQW DLUSRUW GROODU UDLOZDVWDWLRQ WRZHU VHDSRUW GLPH TXDUWHU
66.
5HG6TXDUHWKH7UHWLDNRY*DOOHUWKH.UHPOLQWKH0RVFRZ=RR *RUN3DUN :HVWPLQVWHU $EEHWKH 7RZHU
RI /RQGRQ 6DLQW 3DXO¶V DWKHGUDO 7UDIDOJDU6TXDUH1HOVRQ¶V0HPRULDO :KLWH+RXVH/LQFROQ0HPRULDODSLWDO 7KHFHQWUHRI/RQGRQLV7UDIDOJDU6TXDUH 7KH1DWLRQDO*DOOHULVVLWXDWHGLQ/RQGRQ 7KH%ULWLVK0XVHXPKDVJRWDELJFROOHFWLRQRISDLQWLQJV 7KHODUJHVWSDUNLQ/RQGRQLV+GH3DUN 7KHUHLVDPRQXPHQWLQWKHFHQWUHRI7UDIDOJDU6TXDUH E
67.
E
68.
F
69.
F
70.
D
71.
D
72.
5XVVLDQIODJLVZKLWHEOXHDQGUHG $PHULFDQIODJLVZKLWHUHGDQGEOXH ,¶PJRLQJWRSODWKHSLDQR 0DULVJRLQJWRSODWKHJXLWDU
-RKQLVJRLQJWROHDUQWRSODWKHYLROLQ 1LFN¶VVLVWHULVJRLQJWRZULWHVRQJVIRUXV 0IDWKHULVJRLQJWRSDIRUWKHLQVWUXPHQWV 7LPLVJRLQJWRRUJDQL]HRXUFRQFHUWV :HDUHJRLQJWREHFRPHIDPRXV ZLOOZLOOZLOOZRQ¶WZRQ¶WZLOOZRQ¶WZLOOZRQ¶WZLOOZLOOZLOO ,¶PJRLQJ ,ZLOOJR ZLOO DUHRXJRLQJWRGR ZLOO LVJRLQJ 7KHSODQHLVDUULYLQJKDOIDQKRXUODWHU 0IULHQGVDUHFRPLQJWR0RVFRZIRUWKHZHHNHQG 0JUDQGSDUHQWVDUHPRYLQJLQDQHZIODWQH[WZHHN
73.
:KHQDUHWKHDUULYLQJ 6KHLVOHDYLQJ6W3HWHUVEXUJLQWZRGDV FDYLDUKRQHVRXUFUHDPSDQFDNHV D
74.
E
75.
F
76.
D
77.
D
78.
FDYLDUSDQFDNHVYLOODJHVSDFHVKLSVFLHQWLVWVFLHQFH FEhfhghkh
79.
Jh^beky k_e_
Ohefh]hju g_ih^Zezdm hl :joZg]_evkdZ ?]h hl_p [ue fhjyd Khz h[jZahZgb_ gZqZe hajZkl_ e_l KlZe i_jufjmkkdbfZdZ^_fbdhf ]h^ZHkghZeFhkdhkdbcMgb _jkbl_l ]h^m;ue_ebdbfmqzgufk^_eZefgh]hhldjulbc jZaebqguoh[eZklyogZmdb Fhkd_ihklZe_giZfylgbdEhfh ghkhm X:=Z]Zjbg
80.
Jh^beky fZe_gvdhc^_j_g_ih^Kfhe_gkdhfMe_dZekykZfh ezlZfb dhkfbq_kdbfb
dhjZ[eyfb jZd_lZfb KlZe i_juf fbj_ dhkfhgZlhf hajZkl_e_lIhe_l_e dhkfhkZij_ey]h ^ZgZ[hjlmdhkfbq_kdh]hdhjZ[ey©hklhdª Fhkd_gZiehsZ^b =Z]ZjbgZ_fmihklZe_giZfylgbd `_cfkDmd
81.
Jh^beky Zg]ebckdhc^_j_g_?]hhl_p[ue[_^gufn_jf_jhf KlZefhj_ieZZl_e_fiml_r_kl_ggbdhfb i_jhhldjuZl_e_fKh _jrbe
ljb djm]hk_lguo iml_r_klby hldjue fgh]h hkljhh Lbohfhd_Zg_hklhqgh_ih[_j_`v_:kljZebb `hj^`Zrbg]lhg
82.
Jh^beky :f_jbd_
rlZl_ bj`bgby ;ue kughf [h]Zlh]h ieZglZlhjZ hajZkl_e_lklZe]_g_jZehfIjbgbfZemqZklb_ hcg_aZg_aZbkbfhklvijhlb;jblZgbb ]h^Zoub] jZefgh]h[blI_jucij_ab^_glKR:
83.
0/RPRQRVRYZDVERUQLQ *DJDULQZDVWKHILUVW5XVVLDQFRVPRQDXWDQG$/HRQRYZDVWKH ILUVWPDQLQWKHRSHQVSDFH 0/RPRQRVRYZDVWKHILUVW5XVVLDQDFDGHPLFLDQ
84.
0/RPRQRVRYIRXQGHG0RVFRZ8QLYHUVLWLQ *DJDULQZDVIURPDVPDOOYLOODJHQHDUWKHFLWRI6PROHQVNDQGKH ZDVLQWHUHVWHGLQSODQHVVSDFHVKLSVDQGURFNHWV -DPHVRRNZDVDVHDPDQWUDYHOOHUDQGGLVFRYHUHU +HPDGHWKUHHYRDJHVDURXQGWKHZRUOG +HGLVFRYHUHGDORWRILVODQGVLQWKH3DFLILF2FHDQ *HRUJH:DVKLQJWRQZDVWKHILUVW86SUHVLGHQW +HWRRNSDUWLQWKH:DURI,QGHSHQGHQFH ?szh [jblZgkdbob jmkkdboljZ^bpbyo DZ`^ucgZjh^b
dZ`^ZykljZgZbf__lkhbljZ^bpbb b h[uqZb ;jblZgbb ljZ^bpbb b]jZxl [hevrmx jhev q_f ^jm]bo kljZgZo =hhjylqlh`bl_eb;jblZgbbhq_gvdhgk_jZlbguHgb]hj^ylky khbfbljZ^bpbyfbb [_j_`ghboqlylDh]^Zfu]hhjbfh ;jblZg kdboljZ^bpbyogZ^hk_]^Zihfgblvqlh ;jblZgbbq_luj_qZklb :g]eby RhleZg^by Mwevk b K__jgZy BjeZg^by wlbo qZklyo ljZ^bpbbjZagu_ um`_agZ_l_g_dhlhju_Zg]ebckdb_ljZ^bpbbb ijZa^gbdbFu gZ^__fky qlh u ihfgbl_ ^_gv Kylh]h Ze_glbgZ ^_gv Kylh]h IZljbdZ O_eehmbg dhlhju_ lZd`_ klZeb ljZ^bpbhggufb Zf_jb dZgkdbfbijZa^gbdZfbhlg_dhlhju_nZdluh klZjuoZg]ebckdbo ljZ^bpbyo H^gZ klZjZy e_]_g^Z ]eZkbl qlh Ehg^hg fh`_l [ulv klhebp_c kljZgu [h]Zluf b _ebdbf ]hjh^hf ^h l_o ihj ihdZ ^_gZ^pZlv qzjguohjhgh`bml LZmwj_M dZ`^h]h_klvkhzbfyb kfhljb l_eb gbfZl_evgh ke_^yl aZ gbfb ?keb h^gZ ba ilbp mfbjZ_l lh ^jm]hcfheh^hchjhgaZgbfZ_l_z f_klhEhg^hgpu_jyl wlme_ ]_g^m b k_]^Z ijbghkyl dZdmxgb[m^v _^m dh]^Z b^ml LZmwj Kfhljbl_eb ih^j_aZxl djuevy hjhgZf lZd dZd hgb [hylky qlh ilbpufh]mlme_l_lv jm]ZyklZjZyZg]ebckdZyljZ^bpby²wlh_gv=ZyNhdkZIy lh]hghy[jy^_lbuoh^ylgZmebpmk nb]mjZfbihoh`bfbgZqmq_ ehHgbklhylgZmebpZob iehsZ^yob ijhkyl©I_ggb^ey=ZyªIh lhfgZihemq_ggu_^_gv]bhgbihdmiZxln_c_j_jdbb k`b]Zxl=Zy nb]mjmihoh`mxgZqmq_eh
85.
gZdhklj_ Ex^bkfhljyln_c_j_jdbb g_dhlhju__q_jhfoh^ylgZ_q_ jbgdb M jmkkdbo
khb ljZ^bpbb FZke_gbpZ h^gZ ba gbo HgZ ^eblky g_^_exqlh[uihijhsZlvkyk abfhc?zhlf_qZxl dhgp_n_jZey beb gZqZe_ fZjlZ l_q_gb_ wlh]h ijZa^gbdZ hlf_qZ_lky dhg_p abfu b ijboh^ _kgu klZju_ j_f_gZ ex^b ]hlhbeb [ebgu
86.
`]ebdhkljuk`b]Zebkhehf_ggu_qmq_eZabfui_ebi_kgbb lZg p_Zeb hj_fyfZke_gbqghcg_^_ebex^bk_]^Z]hlhbeb[ebguHgb ijb]eZrZebkhbo^jma_cb _eb[ebgukhkf_lZghcju[hcbdjhc fZkehfkZoZjhffz^hf Ohly
m jZaguo kljZg jZagu_ ljZ^bpbb b ijZa^gbdb ex^b ih k_fmfbjmagZdhfuk g_dhlhjufbbagboWlhIZkoZJh`^_klhb Ghuc=h^ ,Q%ULWDLQWKHUHDUHDORWRIWUDGLWLRQV)RUH[DPSOH*X)DZNHV'D ,Q5XVVLDZHGRQ¶WKDYHVXFKDKROLGDEXWZHKDYH0DVOHQLWVDWKDWSHR SOHLQ*%GRQ¶WKDYH WUXHIDOVHIDOVHIDOVHIDOVHWUXHGRQ¶WNQRZ )URPWKHEHJLQQLQJRIWKHWH[WWRWKHHQGRIWKHVHFRQGSDUDJUDSK² XVWRPVDQGWUDGLWLRQVLQ*% )URP WKHEHJLQQLQJ RIWKHWKLUG SDUDJUDSK WR WKH HQG RI WKH IRXUWK SDUDJUDSK²(QJOLVKFXVWRPVDQGKROLGDV )URPWKHILIWKSDUDJUDSKWRWKHHQGRIWKHWH[W²5XVVLDQKROLGDV D
87.
5XVVLDLVWKHODUJHVWFRXQWU LQWKHZRUOG ,WLVVLWXDWHG
LQWKH 1RUWK7KHORQJHVWULYHULQ5XVVLDLV9ROJD2OG5XVVLDQWRZQVRQWKH 9ROJD DUH 6DPDUD 1L]KQ 1RYJRURG 9ROJRJUDG XU 'ROJRUXN IRXQGHGWKHFDSLWDORI5XVVLDLQ5HGVTXDUHLVWKHKHDUWRI0RV FRZ7KHELUFKWUHHLVWKHPRVWIDPRXVWUHHLQ5XVVLD F
88.
KULVWRSKHU ROXPEXV GLVFRYHUHG
$PHULFD 7KH QDPH RI WKH VKLSWKDWVDLOHGIURP (QJODQGWR$PHULFDZDVWKH©0DIORZHUª7KHUH ZHUHQRZRPHQRQERDUGRIWKH©0DIORZHUª*HRUJH:DVKLQJWRQZDV WKHILUVWSUHVLGHQWRIWKH8QLWHG6WDWHV7KHUHDUHVWDWHVLQWKH8QLWHG 6WDWHV:DVKLQJWRQLVWKHFDSLWDORIWKH8QLWHG6WDWHV +RZPDQSHRSOHDUHRXJRLQJWRLQYLWH :KDWWLPHZLOOWKHSDUWVWDUW :KHUHDUHRXJRLQJWRKDYHWKHSDUW :KRZLOOFRRNWKHIRRG :KDWZLOORXZHDU :LOORXKHOSPHWROHDUQVRPHWKLQJDERXWWKH$PHULFDQDQG%ULWLVK VPEROV6XUH,ZLOO
89.
:LOOSHRSOHODXJKDWWKLVLGHD1RRIFRXUVHWKHZRQ¶W :LOORXWHOOPHVRPHWKLQJDERXWWKHPDLQFLWLHVRI5XVVLDHVRI FRXUVH,ZLOO :LOORXWDNHPHWRWKHFHQWUDOVTXDUHRIRXUFLWHVRIFRXUVH, ZLOO :LOORXWHOOPHDIHZZRUGVDERXWIDPRXV5XVVLDQSHRSOHHVRI FRXUVH,ZLOO -DQHLVDUULYLQJLQ0RVFRZDW -LOOLVDUULYLQJLQ0RVFRZQH[W0RQGD )UHGDQG%LOODUHDUULYLQJLQ0RVFRZWRPRUURZ (OL]DEHWKLVFRPLQJWR3DULVQH[WZHHN *HRUJH¶VSDUHQWVDUHFRPLQJWR3DULVQH[W)ULGD 7KHDUHFRPLQJWR3DULVDWWRPRUURZ 6KHLVOHDYLQJIRUWKHDLUSRUWDWWRPRUURZ %RELVOHDYLQJ0RVFRZDW 7KH%URZQVDUHOHDYLQJIRU/RQGRQDW 7KHODUNVDUHOHDYLQJWRDQHZIODWQH[WHDU 6KHLVPRYLQJWRKHUVXPPHUFRWWDJHWRPRUURZ 7KHDUHPRYLQJWRWKHFRXQWUQH[WZHHN :HDUHKDYLQJDSDUWDWWRPRUURZ 7KHDUHKDYLQJDFRQFHUWWRGD 7KHHQJLQHHUVDUHKDYLQJDFRQIHUHQFHDW 7KH*UHHQVDUHJRLQJDZDQH[WPRQWK +HLVJRLQJWR$IULFDWRPRUURZ :HDUHJRLQJWR,QGLDLQGDV /HVVRQ D
90.
ZDWHUV E
91.
SODQWV F
92.
SODFHVRQWKHHDUWK RFHDQ IRUHVW PRXQWDLQ ULYHU
WUHH ILHOG VHD JUDVV VWRQH ODNH ELUFK URDG ZDWHU IORZHU JDUGHQ UDLQ OHDI KLOO SODQW FRQWLQHQW JURXQG LVODQG ODQG VHDVLGH
93.
IORZHUIRUHVWULYHUWKHVXQWKHPRRQ 7KH9ROJDWKH/HQDWKH(QLVHWKH$PD]RQULYHUWKH1LOH 7KHUHDUHIRUHVWVPRXQWDLQVODNHVULYHUVVHDV
:HFDQVHHSODQWVWUHHVDQLPDOVLQWKHIRUHVWVDQGILHOGV ,FDQVHHFORXGVELUGVLQWKHVN (QJODQGLVVLWXDWHGRQWKH%ULWLVK,VODQGVDQGDQDGDLVVLWXDWHG RQWKH1RUWK$PHULFDQFRQWLQHQW 7KHUHDUHPRUHWKDQFRXQWULHVLQWKHZRUOG 0IDYRULWHVHDVRQLVVXPPHU,WLVKRWLQVXPPHUDQG,FDQVZLPD ORW,QVXPPHU,KDYHPKROLGDVWKDW¶V ZK ,JRWRWKHVHDVLGH7KH ZHDWKHULVXVXDOOILQH7KHUHDUHDORWRIIORZHUVDQGIUXLW,QVXPPHU ZHFDQVSHQGDORWRIWLPHLQWKHRSHQDLU:HFDQSODPDQJDPHVRXW VLGH,OLNHVXPPHUYHUPXFK OHQJWKORQJVWURQJVWUHQJWKZLGHZLGWKZDUPZDUPWK FXULRXVQDWLRQDOLWVHSDUDWHVLQWRH[SORUHVHWVFXULRXVULVHVZLOO FRQWLQXH $FKDQQHODQRFHDQFDQVHSDUDWHWZRFRQWLQHQWV ,¶P5XVVLDQ HVWKHDUH 1R LW GRHVQ¶W 7KH (QJOLVK KDQQHO VHSDUDWHV (QJODQG DQG )UDQFH :HFDOODSHUVRQFXULRXVZKHQKHDVNVDORWRITXHVWLRQV ,GRQ¶WNQRZ 7KHVXQULVHVYHUHDUOLQVXPPHU ,W¶VYHUORQJ ,XVHGWRHDWDORWRIVZHHWV /DVWVXPPHUPIDPLOXVHGWRKDYHKROLGDV 0IULHQGXVHGWRZHDUZDUPFORWKHV D
94.
+HXVHGWRKDYHDQH[SHQVLYHFDU +HXVHGWRWUDYHODORW
95.
+HXVHGWRHDWDORW +HXVHGWRZHDUH[SHQVLYHFORWKHV +HXVHGWRJRWRWKHVHDVLGH +HXVHGWRJRWRWKHUHVWDXUDQW E
96.
+HGLGQ¶WXVHWRVDYHPRQH F
97.
'LGKHXVHWRKDYHDIDPLO KljZgub dhglbg_glu Fu`bzfgZieZg_l_A_feyA_feydjm]eZy?kebuihkfhljbl_ gZg_zba dhkfhkZlhu
mb^bl_ kmrm fhjy dhglbg_glu b ^Z`_ kljZguBgh]^Zufh`_l_mb^_lvboq_j_ah[eZdZHgbu]ey^yl djZkbhdh]^Zkhegp_klZzlbebkZ^blky GZgZr_cieZg_l_q_luj_hd_ZgZb r_klvdhglbg_glh?jZaby K__jgZyb X`gZy:f_jbdZ:njbdZ:kljZeby:glZjdlb^ZDhg lbg_gluhq_gv[hevrb_Fhjyb hd_ZguhfuZxlbob hl^_eyxl^jm] hl^jm]ZH[uqghgZdhglbg_glZofgh]hkljZgGZijbf_j :njbd_ [he__ khjhdZkljZg gh :kljZebb lhevdhh^gZkljZgZ HgZ ghkbl bfydhglbg_glZ:kljZebyhq_gv[hevrZykljZgZghg_dhlhju_kljZ gufZe_gvdb_ BkeZg^by hq_gv fZe_gvdZy kljZgZ HgZ jZkiheh`_gZ gZhkljh_ k__jghc?jhi_ZZcl_i_j_qbkebfg_dhlhju_kljZgu gZdZ`^hfdhglbg_gl_Jhkkby_ebdh[jblZgbyNjZgpby=_jfZgby BkiZgbyBlZebygZoh^ylky ?jhi_DblZcBg^byv_lgZf :abb DZgZ^Zb F_dkbdZ K__jghc:f_jbd_?]bi_l :njbd_ KZfZy[hevrZykljZgZ fbj_wlhJhkkbyKZfZyfZe_gvdZyZ lbdZg dZ`^hc kljZg_ _klv bgl_j_kgu_ ex^b f_klZ jZkl_gby b `bhlgu_ wlbokljZgZo`bmlex^bjZaguogZpbhgZevghkl_cHgb]hh jyl gZ jZaguo yaudZo M dZ`^hc kljZgu _klv khc gZpbhgZevguc neZ]]bfgljZ^bpbbb h[uqZb 7KHVPDOOHVWFRXQWULQWKHZRUOGLVWKH9DWLFDQ 7KHSODQHWZHOLYHRQLVWKH(DUWK RXZLOOEHDEOHWRVHHODQGVHDVRFHDQVFRQWLQHQWVDQGHYHQ FRXQWULHV 7KHUHDUHIRXURFHDQVRQRXUSODQHW 7KHUH DUH VL[ FRQWLQHQWV (XURSH DQG $VLD 1RUWK DQG 6RXWK $PHULFD$IULFD$XVWUDOLD$QWDUFWLF 6HDVDQGRFHDQVVHSDUDWHFRQWLQHQWVIURPHDFKRYHU HVWKHUHDUH PDQ FRXQWULHV RQFRQWLQHQWV EXWWKHUH LV RQO RQHFRXQWULQ$XVWUDOLD
98.
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¶PIURP)UDQFH,¶P)UHQFK0ODQJXDJHLV )UHQFK 0QDPHLV7RQ,¶PIURP,WDO,¶P,WDOLDQ0ODQJXDJHLV,WDOLDQ 0QDPHLV/LVD,¶PIRUP*HUPDQ,¶P*HUPDQ0ODQJXDJHLV *HUPDQ 0QDPHLVDUPHQ,¶PIRUP6SDLQ,¶P6SDQLVK0ODQJXDJHLV 6SDQLVK 0QDPHLV+DQV,¶PIRUP*HUPDQ,¶P*HUPDQ0ODQJXDJHLV *HUPDQ 0QDPHLV*HRUJH,¶PIRUPDQDGD,¶PDQDGLDQ0ODQJXDJHLV (QJOLVK 0QDPHLV$KPDG,¶PIRUP(JSW,¶P(JSWLDQ0ODQJXDJHLV $UDELF :HFDQVHHWKH(DUWKIURPWKHVSDFH:HFDQVHHVHDVRFHDQVFRQWL QHQWV7KHUHDUHVL[FRQWLQHQWVRQWKH(DUWK(XURSHDQG$VLD$PHULFD 6RXWKDQG1RUWK
99.
$IULFD$XVWUDOLD$QWDUFWLF7KHVPDOOHVWFRXQWULV WKH9DWLFDQDQGWKHELJJHVWLV5XVVLD,QFRXQWULHVOLYHSHRSOHRIGLIIHUHQW QDWLRQDOLWLHVDQGWKHVSHDNGLIIHUHQWODQJXDJHV RXQWU DSLWDO 1DWLRQDOLW
/DQJXDJH DQDGD 2WWDZD DQDGLDQ (QJOLVK)UHQFK
100.
$XVWUDOLD DQEHUUD $XVWUDOLDQ
(QJOLVK 86$ :DVKLQJWRQ $PHULFDQ (QJOLVK 6SDLQ 0DGULG 6SDQLVK 6SDQLVK ,WDO 5RPH ,WDOLDQ ,WDOLDQ (JSW DLUR (JSWLDQ $UDELF *HUPDQ %HUOLQ *HUPDQ *HUPDQ DQDGD5XVVLDKLQD)UDQFH,WDO$XVWUDOLD %HUOLQ3DULVDLUR/RQGRQ2WWDZDDQEHUUD 7KH6XQULVHVLQWKHHDVWDQGVHWVLQWKHZHVW 7KHFRQWLQXHGWROLYHLQDVPDOOYLOODJH :KHQZHZHUHOLWWOHZHXVXDOOSODHGZLWKWRHOHSKDQWVDQG ZLWKRWKHUWRDQLPDOV :KDWPRXQWDLQVVHSDUDWH(XURSHIURP$VLD :KHUHLVVKHIURP6KHLVIURP)UDQFH6KHZDVERUQLQ3DULV )UHQFKLVKHUQDWLYHODQJXDJH :KDWLVWKHFRORXURIWKHQDWLRQDOIODJRI5XVVLD 2QHGDD3DULVQHZVSDSHUJDYHDQDGYHUWLVHPHQWDERXWDYHUFKHDS ZDRIWUDYHOOLQJ0DQSHRSOHEHOLHYHGLWDQGVHQWWKHPRQH $IHZ GDVODWHUHDFKRIWKHPJRWDOHWWHU7KHOHWWHUUHDG©6LUUHVWLQEHGDQG UHPHPEHUWKDWWKH(DUWKWXUQV3DULVWXUQVWRJHWKHUZLWKWKH(DUWKRX WUDYHOPRUHWKDQNLORPHWHUVDGDRXPDORRNRXWRIWKHZLQ GRZDQGHQMRRXUMRXUQHª /HVVRQ 7KH86$(QJOLVK$PHULFDQ *UHDW%ULWDLQ(QJOLVK%ULWLVK $XVWUDOLD(QJOLVK$XVWUDOLDQ DQDGD(QJOLVK)UHQFKDQDGLDQ -RKQ*UHDW%ULWDLQ 0DU$XVWUDOLD 0DRKLQD 0DULH)UDQFH 0RQLFDDQDGD
101.
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
WDNH D KROLGD LQ WKH PRXQWDLQV LQ ZLQWHU EXW QRZ KH GRHVQ¶W 0DUXVHGWRZDWFKWKHVXQVHWLQWKHHYHQLQJEXWQRZVKHGRHVQ¶W 6KHDOVRXVHGWRZDWFKWKHVXQULVHLQWKHPRUQLQJDQGVKHGRHVQ¶WGR LWHLWKHU
102.
-RKQXVHGWRJRILVKLQJZLWKKLVIDWKHUHDUOLQWKHPRUQLQJEXWQRZ KHGRHVQ¶W *HRUJHXVHGWREHYHUFXULRXVZKHQKHZDVDFKLOGEXWQRZKHLVQ¶W 7RPXVHGWRH[SORUHQHZWHUULWRULHVZKHQKHZDVRXQJEXWQRZKH GRHVQ¶W 2KQRKHGLGQ¶W+HXVHGWRFUDOLWWOH 2KQRWKHGLGQ¶W7KHXVHGWRH[SORUHWKHIRUHVWVZKHQWKH ZHUHLQ6RXWK$PHULFD
2KHVVKHGLG6KHXVHGWROLNHILVK 2KHVKHGLG+HXVHGWRZRUNLQDWFRPSDQ 2KQRZHGLGQ¶W:HZHUHQRWJRRGIULHQGV 2KQRVKHGLGQ¶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
103.
3HRSOHWUDYHOESODQHQRZDGDV 0RVWSHRSOHWUDYHOEWUDLQQRZDGDV 0DQSHRSOHWUDYHOEVHDQRZDGDV 3HRSOHZDWFKFDUWRRQVQRZDGDV 0RVWSHRSOHZDWFKYLGHRVQRZDGDV 0DQSHRSOHZDWFKIHDWXUHILOPVQRZDGDV 3HRSOHUHDGDORWRIERRNVQRZDGDV 0RVWSHRSOHUHDGDORWRIQHZVSDSHUVQRZDGDV 0DQSHRSOHUHDGDORWRIPDJD]LQHVQRZDGDV :HXVHSHQVWRZULWHOHWWHUV :HXVHERRNVWROHDUQIRUHLJQODQJXDJH :HXVHNLWFKHQWRFRRNGLQQHU :HXVHFXSVWRGULQNFRIIHH :HXVHJODVVHVWRGULQNPLQHUDOZDWHU :HXVHVSRRQVWRHDWVRXS ,¶PIRQGRIERWKWHDDQGFRIIHH ,¶PIRQGRIERWKPLONDQGZDWHU ,¶PIRQGRIERWKFRXQWUDQGWRZQOLIH ,¶PIRQGRIERWKVKRUWVWRULHVDQGORQJQRYHOV ,¶PIRQGRIERWKFDUWRRQVDQGIHDWXUHILOPV ,¶PIRQGRIERWKWUDYHOOLQJEVHDDQGESODQH ,¶PIRQGRIERWKZRUNLQJDWKRPHDQGDWWKHOLEUDU RX,GRQ¶WOLNHIRRWEDOO ODVVPDWHRXGRQ¶WVDVR RX,¶YHQHYHUWUDYHOOHGESODQH ODVVPDWHRXGRQ¶WVDVR RX,¶YHQHYHUEHHQWRWKHVHDVLGH ODVVPDWHRXGRQ¶WVDVR :g]eh]hhjysb_kljZgu bZgZIjb_lO_e_gKlhe_ll_[yg_b^_eZDZdm l_[y^_eZ O_e_gOhjhrhkiZkb[hZ ml_[yIjhrehfgh]hj_f_gbdZdy b^_eZl_[y
ihke_^gbcjZa bZgZZfgh]hijhrehj_f_gb ihke_^gbcjZay l_[yb^_ eZ [b[ebhl_d_ Lu ]hlhbeZkv d ^hdeZ^m ih kh_fm ex[bfhfm ij_^f_lm²Zg]ebckdhfmdhg_qgh
104.
O_e_gZGhihq_fm lukf_zrvkyY kqblZx
qlh Zg]ebckdbc kZfucihimeyjgucyaud gZklhys__j_fyGZZg]ebckdhf]hhjyl ex^bihk_fmfbjm Jhkkbbb hNjZgpbb =_jfZgbbb BlZ ebb BkiZgbbb ?]bil_mqZlZg]ebckdbcdZdbghkljZggucyaud bZgZY agZxDklZlb]hhjylqlhZg]ebckdbcklZef_`^mgZ jh^gufyaudhf ^Z^pZlhf_d_ O_e_gZdhg_qghL_[yihcfmlihqlb_a^__keblu]hhjbrv gZZg]ebckdhfhfgh]bokljZgZo]hhjylgZZg]ebckdhfb dhg_q ghgZkhzfjh^ghf bZgZ: dZdbokljZgZoZg]ebckdbcgZpbhgZevgucyaud O_e_g _ebdh[jblZgbbKR:DZgZ^_:kljZebbb Ghhc A_eZg^bbWlhZg]eh]hhjysb_kljZgu bZgZB hk_owlbokljZgZoex^b]hhjylgZh^ghfb lhf`_ yaud_g_lZdeb O_e_gFhchl_l²b ^Zb g_lOhlyhgbk_]hhjylgZZg]ebc kdhf_klvg_[hevrh_jZaebqb_ wlbokljZgZo bZgZ G_ fh`_l [ulv Y gbdh]^Z g_ agZeZ qlh Zf_jbdZgpu b Zg]ebqZg_]hhjylgZjZaguoyaudZo O_e_g G_l g_ gZ jZaguo h[_bo kljZgZo ]hhjyl gZ Zg]ebc kdhfgh KR:]hhjylgZZf_jbdZgkdhfZg]ebckdhfZ _ebdh [jblZgbb ]hhjyl gZ [jblZgkdhf Zg]ebckdhf QZklh h^gm b lm `_ _svh[hagZqZxljZagu_kehZ bZgZQlhlubf__rv b^m O_e_gY bf_x b^mqlhIODWh[hagZqZ_ldZjlbjm :g]ebbZ DSDUWPHQW KR: KR:]hhjylFRRNLHVb FDQGLHVZ ;jblZgbb ELVFXLWV b VZHHWVbf_y b^mh^ghb lh`_Hk_gv :f_jbd_gZau ZxlIDOOZ :g]ebbDXWXPQ bZgZWlhhq_gvbgl_j_kghgZkZfhf^_e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
105.
'LGVKHUHDOOXVHWRFRRNIDQWDVWLFSDQFDNHV 'LGKHUHDOOXVHWREHDVFLHQWLVW 'LGVKHUHDOOXVHWREHYHUPXFKLQWHUHVWHGLQVFLHQFH
'LG WKH UHDOO XVH WR OHDUQ D ORW DERXW +LVWRU DQG WKH PDLQ FLWLHVRI5XVVLD 'LGVKHUHDOOXVHWROLYHLQDVPDOOYLOODJH 'LGKHUHDOOXVHWRJHWLQWHUHVWLQJLQIRUPDWLRQDERXWVSDFHDQG VSDFHWULSV :KLOHWKHFKLOGUHQZHUHUXQQLQJWKHLUPRWKHUZDVUHDGLQJDQHZVSD SHU :KLOHPIDWKHUZDVORRNLQJWKURXJKWKHPDJD]LQHPPRWKHUZDV FRRNLQJEUHDNIDVW :KLOH$QQZDVUHDGLQJDQRYHOKHUVLVWHUZDVSODLQJ ,ZDVZDONLQJZKHQ,VDZWKHPLQWKHVWUHHW ,ZDVVOHHSLQJZKHQWKHWHOHSKRQHUDQJ )DWKHUZDVZDWFKLQJWHOHYLVLRQZKHQ3HWHUFDPHEDFNKRPH $QQZDVSODLQJWKHIOXWHDWR¶FORFNHVWHUGDDQGKHUEURWK HUVZHUHSODLQJWKHYLROLQ :KLOH)UHGZDVVZLWFKLQJRQWKHYDFXXPFOHDQHUKLVZLIHZDV VZLWFKLQJRQWKHZDVKLQJPDFKLQH :KHQ,ZDVEXLQJIUXLW,ZDVWDONLQJWRWKHVHOOHU 0IDWKHUZDVUHSDLULQJWKHFHQWUDOKHDWLQJDWR¶FORFNHVWHU GD :KRZDVSODLQJWHQQLVZKHQRXHQWHUHGWKHKDOO /LWWOH 7RP ZDV ORRNLQJ DW WKH PDS RI (XURSH ZKHQ KLV VLVWHU WROGKLPDERXW(QJODQG :KDWZHUHRXGRLQJZKHQRXUJUDQGPRWKHUZDVFRRNLQJSDQ FDNHV :KLOHFKLOGUHQZHUHOLVWHQLQJWRWKHPXVLFWKHZHUHZDWFKLQJ WKHVXQULVH 0RVFRZLVLQ(XURSH 7KH$XVWUDOLDQVSHDN(QJOLVK 7KH8UDOVVHSDUDWH(XURSHIURP$VLD (JSWLVLQ$IULFD 7KHQDWLRQDO5XVVLDQIODJLVZKLWHEOXHDQGUHG -RKQLVDWSLFDO(QJOLVKQDPH
106.
/HVVRQ 7KHERVDUHSODLQJZLWKWKHEDOO 7KHERVDUHSDLQWLQJ 7KHERVDUHZDVKLQJWKHGLVKHV 7KHERVDUHHDWLQJ 7KHERVDUHVZLPPLQJ ,ZDVKDYLQJEUHDNIDVWDWR¶FORFNHVWHUGD ,ZDVZDWFKLQJ79DWR¶FORFNHVWHUGD ,ZDVUHDGLQJDQHZVSDSHUDWR¶FORFNHVWHUGD ,ZDVZRUNLQJLQWKHRIILFHDWR¶FORFNHVWHUGD ,ZDVOHDUQLQJWKHIRUHLJQODQJXDJHDWR¶FORFNHVWHUGD :KHQKH ZDVFOHDQLQJKLVWHHWKLQWKHEDWKURRPWKHWHOHSKRQHUDQJ ,WZDVKLV*UDQQ+HVSRNHWRKLV*UDQQIRUDIHZPLQXWHV
:KHQKHZDVKDYLQJKLVEUHDNIDVWWKHGRRUEHOOUDQJ,WZDVKLV IULHQG :KHQ WKH ZHUH OHDYLQJ IRU VFKRRO WKH VDZ 5REHUW¶V XQFOH IURPDQRWKHUFLWDWWKHGRRU5REHUWWRRNKLPLQ :KHQ 5REHUW ZDV VKRZLQJ WKHLU IODW WR KLV XQFOH WKHUH ZDV D WHOHSKRQHFDOOIURPKLVIDWKHU+HH[SODLQHGWRKLPZKKHZDV DWKRPHZLWKKLVXQFOH ,VWKHUHDOLEUDUQHDURXUKRXVH ,VWKHUHWKH)RON$UW0XVHXPQHDURX ,VWKHUHDFLUFXVLQRXUFLW :KHUHLVWKH3LFWXUH*DOOHUVLWXDWHGLQRXUFLW ,VRXUKRXVHVLWXDWHGQHDUWKHYLOODJH ,VWKHUHWKHEXLOGLQJRIWKH$UW([KLELWLRQQHDURXUKRXVH ,VWXGLHGHVWHUGD²,ZDVVWXGLQJHVWHUGDDWR¶FORFN , ZHQW WR P JUDQGPRWKHU ODVW 6XQGD ² , ZDV ZDONLQJ WR P JUDQGPRWKHUZKHQWKHWHOHSKRQHUDQJ 7KHFDPHWKUHHGDVDJR²:KLOH,ZDVUHDGLQJDPDJD]LQHWKH ZHUHFRPLQJKRPHIURPWKHDLUSRUW ,GLGQ¶WXVHWRUHDGERRNVZKHQ, ZDVDFKLOG
107.
,GLGQ¶WXVHWRZDWFK79ZKHQ,ZDVDFKLOG ,XVHGWRFUZKHQ,ZDVDFKLOG ,XVHGWRSODZLWKWRVZKHQ,ZDVDFKLOG
,GLGQ¶WXVHWRJRWRVFKRROZKHQ,ZDVDFKLOG ,GLGQ¶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bhlgu_ hiZkghklb Ex^b`bmlgZgZr_cieZg_l_m`_fgh]he_lHgb`bebb `bml gZjZaguodhglbg_glZob jZaguo kljZgZo Ex^b aZbkyl hl kh_c ieZg_luhlkhegpZhl`bhlguob jZkl_gbchdjm]gboK_]h^gy^Z Zcl_ijhqlzfb ih]hhjbfh g_dhlhjuo`bhlguogZgZr_cieZg_l_
108.
Fgh]b_b^u`bhlguob ilbpbkq_aZxlgZA_fe_ gZklhys__ j_fy
Fgh]b_ ba gbo hiZkghklb Bg^bckdb_ lb]ju b :njbdZg kdb_ kehgu kj_^b gbo Ex^b hohlylky b m[bZxl fgh]h lb]jh Bg^bbb fgh]hkehgh :njbd_Ihq_fm Lb]jub kehguqZklh[uZxlhiZkguLb]jufh]mlm[blvdhjh h_p^jm]bo^hfZrgbo`bhlguoZ bgh]^Zb q_eh_dZG_dhlhju_ ex^b[hylkylb]jhb m[bZxlboqlh[uaZsblblv^hfZrgbo `b hlguob khb`bagbGhg_dhlhju_ex^bhohlbebkvgZlb]jhjZ^b _k_evyb bodjZkbhcrdmjuHgbe_]dhfh]mlijh^Zlvrdmjmb ih emqblvfgh]h^_g_]lZddZdp_gugZgbohq_gvukhdb_ J_amevlZlhq_gvieZq_gucGZA_fe_hklZehkvhq_gvfZehBg ^bckdbolb]jhFgh]b_bagboklZju_b [hevgu_Fgh]b_lb]jug_ hohlylkygZex^_c gZklhys__j_fyZ ijyqmlkyhlgbo ^j_fm qbolzfguoe_kZoBeblhqg__hgbijylZebkv gbojZgvr_k_cqZk hklZehkvfZehe_kh^eylb]jhEx^bujm[bebfgh]h^_j_v_B hijhkhldZdhc©M wlbo`bhlguo_klv[m^ms__ª Lhl`_kZfuchijhkfufh`_faZ^Zlvihihh^m:njbdZgkdbo kehghWlhij_djZkgu_ `bhlgu_Hgbfh]ml ihfh]Zlv ex^yf ijhrehf_d_ :njbd_[uehiheghkehghGh gZklhys__j_fy bog_fgh]h iZjdZo:njbdb Wlh ]jmklgZy bklhjby ijh Bg^bckdbo kehgh b :njbdZgkdbo lb]jhGhfgh]b_f_g__hiZkgu_^bdb_`bhlgu_bkq_aZxl gZ klhys__j_fygZA_fe_Khj_f_ggZy`bagviehoheby_lgZgbo ha^moaZ]jyagzgh^Z]jyagZyM gboqZklhg_lohjhr_cibsbb f_klh[blZgbyBobf_gZufh`_l_gZclb DjZkghcDgb]_GZaZ gbyg_dhlhjuoju[ulZd`_fh`_l_lZfmb^_lv H[hk_ogboex^b^he`guhkh[_gghaZ[hlblvky Fu^he`gukhojZgblv^bdbo`bhlguo Fu^he`gugZclbijZbevguc[ZeZgkf_`^ma_fezcex^vfbb `bhlgufb Fu^he`guaZ[hlblvkyh ijbjh^_ 6RPH DQLPDOV DUH LQ GDQJHU EHFDXVH SHRSOH KDYH KXQWHG WKHP IRU PDQ HDUV $QG DQLPDOV RIWHQ GRQ¶W KDYH IRUHVWV WR OLYH LQ EHFDXVH SHRSOHKDYHFXWGRZQPDQWUHHV9HURIWHQDQLPDOVGRQ¶WKDYHIUHVK DLUDQGFOHDQZDWHU 3HRSOHKDYHKXQWHGDQGNLOOHGPDQWLJHUVLQ,QGLDEHFDXVHWLJHUVDUH YHU GDQJHURXVDQLPDOV DQGSHRSOH NLOOHG WKHP WR VDYH WKHLU GRPHVWLF DQLPDOVDQGWKHLUOLYHV$QGVRPHSHRSOHKDYHRIWHQKXQWHGWLJHUVIRUIXQ DQGIRUWKHLUEHDXWLIXOVNLQ7KHFDQHDVLOVHOOWKHVNLQDQGJHWDORWRI PRQHDVWKHSULFHVDUHKLJK
109.
7KHOLIHRIWKHSHRSOHRQWKH(DUWKGHSHQGVRQWKHVXQRQDQL PDOVDQGSODQWVDURXQGXV 7KH DUH
GLVDSSHDULQJ EHFDXVH SHRSOH KDYH KXQWHG WKHP IRU HDUV HVHOHSKDQWVFDQEHXVHIXO7KHFDQEHXVHGDVWUDQVSRUW 1RWRQO,QGLDQHOHSKDQWVDQG$IULFDQWLJHUVDUHLQGDQJHU 2WKHUDQLPDOV DUHLQGDQJHUEHFDXVHWKH GRQ¶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¶W KDYHFOHDQZDWHUDQGHQRXJKVSDFHWROLYH$QGWKHDLULVQRWYHUIUHVK RXFDQILQGQDPHVRIVRPHILVKLQWKH5HG%RRNWRR 3HRSOHPXVWWDNHFDUHRIQDWXUHDQGDQLPDOV:HPXVWVDYHWKHP ,QWKLVFRXQWUDQLPDOVDQGELUGVDUHDOVRLQGDQJHU$QGZHFDQ¶WVHH DQLPDOVLQWKHIRUHVWVEHFDXVHWKHIRUHVWVDUHYHUGLUW7KHULYHUVDUH QRW FOHDQ $QGRIFRXUVHSHRSOHKXQW DQLPDOV 1RERG LQ WKLV FRXQWU WKLQNVDERXWKRZWRVDYHDQLPDOV ,ZDVZDONLQJLQWKHVWUHHWZKHQ,VDZDGRJ7KHDQLPDOZDVLQGDQ JHUEHFDXVHWKHUHZHUHPDQFDUV7KHFDUVZHUHFRPLQJYHUIDVW$QG VXGGHQORQHVWUXFNWKHGRJ7KHDQLPDOZDVNLOOHGDWRQFH :RXOGRXOLNHWRFRPHWRPELUWKGDSDUW ,¶GORYHWR:KHQVKRXOG,FRPH 7KHSDUWZLOOVWDUWDW :RXOGRXOLNHWRJRIRUDZDONWRPRUURZ ,ZLVK,FRXOGEXW,¶PDIUDLG,FDQ¶W,¶POHDYLQJIRU/RQGRQWRPRU URZ
110.
:HDUHKDYLQJDSDUWRQ)ULGDQLJKWDQRXFRPH ,¶PVRUUEXW,KDYHDORWRIZRUNWRGR ,GRQRWIHHOOLNHZDWFKLQJ79WRQLJKW« /HW¶VJRWREHG DQRXFRPHRYHUIRUGLQQHURQ:HGQHVGD HVZKHQVKRXOG,FRPH /HW¶VJRWRWKHFLQHPDWRPRUURZ 2.:KHUHVKDOOZHPHHW :HZLOOPHHWDWWKHFLQHPD ,OLNHQHLWKHUKRFNHQRUIRRWEDOO 7KHUHDUHQHLWKHUHOORZQRUEOXHIORZHUVDPRQJWKHVH
7KHFRXOGUHVFXHQHLWKHUDQLPDOVQRUELUGV 6KHKLGQHLWKHUEDGJHVQRUVWDPSV 7KHUHZDVQHLWKHUIUHVKPHDWQRUIUHVKILVKLQWKHVKRS 1HLWKHUKH QRU,FDQVDYHPRQH +HQHYHUJRHVGHHSLQWKHIRUHVW 7KHUHLVDOZDVIUHVKDLULQWKHIRUHVW 6KHLVDWDOOJLUO 7KHDOZDVEULQJ IUHVK IORZHUV WR WKH0RQXPHQW RI WKH 8Q NQRZQ6ROGLHU 7KHUHZDVDKLJKWRZHUQRWIDUIURPWKHEULGJH 3DXOZDVZDWFKLQJ79ZKHQKLVPRWKHUFDPHLQWRKLVURRP 0LFKDHOZDVGULQNLQJFRIIHHZKLOHKHZDVUHDGLQJQHZVSDSHU 'RQZDVZULWLQJDOHWWHUDWR¶FORFNHVWHUGD .HQXVHGWRSUHSDUHEUHDNIDVWHDUOLQWKHPRUQLQJ 'RQDQG.LPZHUHWDONLQJZKLOHWKHZHUHSODLQJFKHVV /DVW6XQGD3DWWDQGKHURXQJHUEURWKHUGURYHWRWKHVHDVLGH IRUWKHZHHNHQG /HVVRQ 7KHULYHULVPHWUHVGHHS 7KHPRXQWDLQLVPHWUHVKLJK
111.
7KHWUHHLVPHWUHVKLJK 7KHODNHLVPHWUHVGHHS 7KHKLOOLVPHWUHVKLJK 9HUE $GMHFWLYH WRVHSDUDWH QDWLRQDO WRVDYH
KLJK WRXVH GHHS WRKLGH IUHVK WRH[SORUH FXULRXV WRVHW IRUHLJQ WRULVH WRFRQWLQXH ,¶YHKLGGHQWKHERRNLQWKHERRNFDVH ,¶YHKLGGHQWKHSHQFLOLQPSRFNHW ,¶YHKLGGHQPZDWFKXQGHUWKHFDUSHW ,¶YHKLGGHQRXUVKRHLQWKHZDUGUREH ,¶YHKLGGHQWKHNQLIHLQPURRP RX)UHVKIUXLW ODVVPDWH7KHIUXLWDUHXVXDOOIUHVKDWWKHJUHHQJURFHU¶V RX'HHSVQRZ ODVVPDWH7KHVQRZLVXVXDOOGHHSLQWKHIRUHVW RX+LJKWUHH ODVVPDWH7KHWUHHLVXVXDOOKLJKZKHQLWLVYHUROG 7KHILUHPHQKDYHVDYHGDFKLOG 7KHILUHPHQKDYHVDYHGDQROGODG 7KHILUHPHQKDYHVDYHGDOLWWOHNLWWHQ 7KHILUHPHQKDYHVDYHGDRXQJJLUO 7KHILUHPHQKDYHVDYHGDIXQQGRJ 0RVFRZLVDPRQJWKHODUJHVWFLWLHVRIWKHZRUOG 0H[LFRFLWLVDPRQJWKHODUJHVWFLWLHVRIWKHZRUOG 1HZRUNLVDPRQJWKHODUJHVWFLWLHVRIWKHZRUOG /RQGRQLVDPRQJWKHODUJHVWFLWLHVRIWKHZRUOG 3DULVLVDPRQJWKHODUJHVWFLWLHVRIWKHZRUOG %HUOLQLVDPRQJWKHODUJHVWFLWLHVRIWKHZRUOG
112.
RX:KDWZHUHRXGRLQJDWR¶FORFN 3DUWQHU,ZDVVOHHSLQJ RX:KDWZDVVKHGRLQJDW 3DUWQHU6KHZDVGULQNLQJPLON RX:KDWZDVKHGRLQJDW 3DUWQHU+HZDVUHDGLQJDQHZVSDSHU RX:KDWZHUHWKHGRLQJDW 3DUWQHU7KHZHUHJRLQJWRVFKRRO RX:KDWZHUHWKHGRLQJDW 3DUWQHU7KHZHUHSODLQJIRRWEDOO RX:KDWZDVKHGRLQJDW 3DUWQHU+HZDVEXLQJDSSOHV XVHG
ZDVXVLQJ VDYHG ZHUHVDYLQJ KLG ZDVKLGLQJ H[SORUHG ZDVH[SORULQJ URVH ZDVULVLQJ 7KDWVRXQGVJUHDW ,¶GEHJODGWRFRPH7KDQNRX $OOULJKW 7KDWVRXQGVJRRG 2. ,¶PDIUDLG,FDQ¶W ,¶GORYHWREXW,¶PDIUDLG,FDQ¶W ,ZLVK,FRXOGEXW,¶PDIUDLG,FDQ¶W 7KDQNRXIRU RXULQYLWDWLRQ%XW,FDQ¶W,¶PDIUDLG 7KDQNRXIRURXULQYLWDWLRQ%XW,FDQ¶W,¶PDIUDLG 1HOOOLNHVQHLWKHUEDQDQDVQRURUDQJHV 1HOOOLNHVQHLWKHUEXWWHUQRUVXJDU 1HOOOLNHVQHLWKHUFKHHVHQRUILVK 7KHDWUHVDUHXVXDOOEXLOWLQELJFLWLHV LQHPDVDUHXVXDOOEXLOWLQELJFLWLHV 6KRSVDUHXVXDOOEXLOWLQELJFLWLHV
113.
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¶WVPHOODWDOO ,OLNHDOOWKHIORZHUV 'DIIRGLOVVQRZGURSVSULPURVHVDUHVSULQJIORZHUV /LOGDLVKRQHVXFNOHSRSSDUHVXPPHUIORZHUV KUVDQWKHPXPLVDXWXPQIORZHU )ORZHUVFDQEHSXUSOH RORXUFDQEHSXUSOH ORWKHVFDQEHSXUSOH D
114.
7KHROGZRPDQIHHOVEDG 7KHUHGIORZHUVVPHOOSOHDVDQW 7KHDSSOHVWDVWHVZHHW 7KHOLWWOHJLUOIHHOVEDG 7KHSXUSOHIORZHUVVPHOOSOHDVDQW 7KHPHDWWDVWHVVDOW 7KHVRQJVRXQGVVDG 7KHPHORGVRXQGVEDG
115.
G
116.
7KHDSSOHWUHHVDUHLQEORVVRPLQ0D 7KHIUXLWWUHHVZHUHLQEORVVRPLQ-XQH _gZ^pZlvp_ldh]h^Z Fhy[Z[mrdZhq_gvex[blijbjh^mHgZ`beZ fZe_gvdhc^_ j_g_ kx
khx `bagv HgZ fgh]h agZ_l h jZaguo jZkl_gbyo ;Z [mrdZ]hhjblqlh^eydZ`^h]hf_kypZkms_klm_lkhchkh[_gguc p_lhdHgZqZklhjZkkdZauZ_lfg_h[wlbop_lZolZd`_hgZfg_ ihdZauZ_lbolZddZdk_hgb_klv _zkZ^hhcdhee_dpbb Ih^kg_`gbd p_lhd ygZjy Hg [_euc dZd kg_] b ihyey_lky e_kZob kZ^Zodh]^Z_sze_`blkg_]WlhlfZe_gvdbcp_lhdqZklh fh`ghmb^_lv ?jhi_ IjbfmeZ n_jZevkdbc p_lhd Hg fh`_l [ulv [_euf `zeluf djZkgufjhahuf[Z]jygufb hjZg`_ufWlbp_luu]ey^yldZd aza^uIjbfmeZh^bgbakZfuojZggbo_k_ggbop_lhHgbjZk lml g_dhlhjuokljZgZo?jhiub K__jghc:f_jbdbghfgh`_kl hbofh`ghh[gZjm`blvb DblZ_ GZjpbkkwlhp_lhdfZjlZHglZd`_ihyey_lkyjZgh_kghcWlh p_luh[uqgh[_eu_beb`zelu_Wlhp_lhdk ^ebggufbebklvyfb b ijbylgufaZiZohfWlhihimeyjgucp_lhd kZ^Zo :ij_evkdb_p_luwlhfZj]Zjbldbufh`_l_b^_lvbo_a^_ ihe_kZ^Zob ^Z`_ih^hjh]Zf ;hyjurgbdwlhfZckdbcp_lhdHgjZklzlgZg_[hevrhf^_j__ Z _]hp_lu[_eu_jhahu_bebdjZkgu_M [hyjurgbdZfZe_gvdb_ lzj^u_ieh^udhlhju_ihoh`bgZfZe_gvdb_y[ehdb Bxgvkdbcp_lhdwlh`bfhehklvZ bxevkdb_p_luwlhh^ygu_ ebebb u qZklh fh`_l_ b^_lv bo gZ h^Zo lbobo hazj Ey]mrdb ex[ylbkihevahZlvbo[hevrb_a_ezgu_ebklvydZdklmevyG_dhlh ju_ebebb`zelu_g_dhlhju_jhahu_kbgb_beb^Z`_[Z]jygu_ FZdwlhp_lhdZ]mklZWlhk_lehdjZkgu_beb`zelu_p_lu Hgbihoh`bgZqZrdbHgbqZklhjZklml ]hjZovxghdk_gly[jv kdbcp_lhdwlhiheamq__jZkl_gb_k kbgbfbbebnbhe_lhufbp_ lZfb ?]h a_ezgu_ p_lu ihoh`b gZ fZe_gvdb_ a_ezgu_ k_j^_qdb Wlhlp_lhdjZkimkdZ_lkyjZghmljhfghdh]^Z`Zjdh_khegp_ihy ey_lky lh p_lhd aZdjuZ_lky P_lu ihoh`b gZ dhehdhevqbdb vxghdkeZ^dhiZog_lb fh`_ljZklb ^bdbomkehbyo Of_evhdly[jvkdbcp_lhd?]hbkihevamxlqlh[uZjblvibh Wlh iheamqbc p_lhd dhlhjuc qZklh mdjZrZ_l aZ]hjh^gu_ ^hfZ P_lhdghy[jywlhojbaZgl_fZWlhh^bgbakZfuo^Zghba_klguo p_lhHgjZklzl Yihgbbhdheh^molukyqe_lb yey_lkygZpbh gZevguf p_ldhf b wf[e_fhc wlh]h hkljhgh]h ]hkm^ZjklZ Wlhl
117.
fbeuc p_lhd fh`_l
[ulv [_euf `zeluf djZkguf nbhe_lhuf bebjhahufOjbaZgl_fuihyeyxlkygZqbgZyk iha^g_]hZ]mklZb aZdZgqbZy ^_dZ[jzf dh]^Z [hevrbgklh ^jm]bo p_lh ]hlhu d abf_ _dZ[jvkdbcp_lhdhkljhebklWlhp_lhdJh`^_kl_gkdh]hk_ ahg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¶WVHHWKHPRIWHQLQWKH IRUHVW
118.
:KHQGRHVWKLVIORZHUDSSHDU :KHUHGRHVLWJURZ 2IZKDWFRORXUDUHLWVEORVVRPV ,VLWDELJIORZHU )ORZHUVDUHLQGDQJHUQRZDGDV,WLVLPSRVVLEOHWRVHHVRPHIORZHUV LQWKHIRUHVWEXWRXFDQVHHWKHPRQWKHPDUNHW$QGDORWRIIORZHUVDUH LQWKH5HG%RRN SOHDVDQWVPHOOIUHVKDLUSXUSOHIORZHUGHHSULYHU ,OLNHWKHSOHDVDQWVPHOORIWKHURVH /LWWOHFKLOGUHQQHHGIUHVKDLU :KDWLVWKHQDPHRIWKLVSXUSOHIORZHU 7KH9ROJDLVDYHUGHHSULYHU QLFHSOHDVDQW WDOOKLJK VPDOOOLWWOH
ELJJUDQG KDUGGLIILFXOW WRR YHUWHOOVDEORVVRPIORZHU RIIHHLVJURZQLQ6RXWK$PHULFD%XWWHULVPDGHIURPPLON1HZ KRXVHVDUHEXLOWLQDOOELJFLWLHV7KHURRPLVFOHDQHGHYHUGD$SSOHV DQGRUDQJHVDUHERXJKWLQVKRSV /HVVRQ 7KHWURXVHUVWKHWVKRUWWKHIORZHUDUHSXUSOH ,W¶VYHUSOHDVDQWWREHLQWKHFRXQWUZKHQIUXLWWUHHVDUHLQEORV VRP ,W¶VYHUSOHDVDQWWREHLQWKHFRXQWUZKHQELUGVFRPHEDFN ,W¶VYHUSOHDVDQWWREHLQWKHFRXQWUZKHQIORZHUVVPHOOVZHHWLQWKH ILHOGV ,W¶VYHUSOHDVDQWWREHLQWKHFRXQWUZKHQWKHVXQLVKLJKXSLQWKH VN ,W¶VYHUSOHDVDQWWREHLQWKHFRXQWUZKHQLWGRHVQ¶WUDLQ ,W¶VYHUSOHDVDQWWREHLQWKHFRXQWUZKHQLWGRHVQ¶WVQRZ ,W¶VYHUSOHDVDQWWREHLQWKHFRXQWUZKHQLWLVQRWZLQG :KDWDEHDXWLIXOJLUO
119.
:KDWFOHDUZDWHU :KDWDQLQWHUHVWLQJERRN :KDWEHDXWLIXOQDWXUH :KDWDNLQGIDFH :KDWXVHIXOLQIRUPDWLRQ 1HOO:KDWLVLWDERXW 1HOO 1R ,
KDYH QHYHU KHDUG DERXW LW $QG ZKDW LV WKH HDUOLHVW IORZHU 1HOOHVWKHDUHYHUEHDXWLIXODQGWKHFDQEHRIDOOFRORXUV 1HOO,ZDVERUQLQ0DUFK DUROLQH2KWKHQLW¶VGDIIRGLO :KDWLVRXUIDYRULWHIORZHU :KDWGRRXOLNHEHVWVSULQJRUVXPPHUIORZHUV 'RRXOLNHWRSLFNWKHPXS :KLFKIORZHUVGRRXKDYHLQRXUJDUGHQ 'RRXOLNHWRJLYHIORZHUVWRSHRSOH RFDRODLVQRWRQOHQMRHGLQKLQDLWLVHQMRHGDOORYHU WKHZRUOG KHHVHLVQRWPDGHIURPZDWHULWLVPDGHIURPPLON 0HDWLVQRWERXJKWLQPXVHXPVLWLVERXJKWLQVKRSV )ORZHUVDUHQRWDOZDVJURZQLQYLOODJHVWKHDUHJURZQLQFLW LHVWRR =RRVDUHVRPHWLPHVYLVLWHGLQZLQWHU 3LFWXUHVDUHVRPHWLPHVVWROHQIURPPXVHXPV 6WDPSVDUHVROGLQDSRVWRIILFH KXUFKHVDUHQRWEXLOWHYHUZKHUHQRZDGDV 7KLVWKLQJLVXVHGYHURIWHQ (QJOLVKLVVSRNHQLQ$IULFD 0DQODQJXDJHVDUHVSRNHQLQ,QGLD 0DQ $PHULFDQ SURJUDPPHVDUH VKRZQRQ 5XVVLDQ WHOHYLVLRQ QRZDGDV ,VDURVHUHDOONQRZQDVDQHPEOHPRI(QJODQG $UHVRQJVUHDOOVXQJLQ0XVLFFODVVHV $UHFDUVUHDOOVROGDWVSHFLDOVKRSV
120.
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¶WSODRQWKHURDGRXZLOOJHWXQGHUDFDU 'RQ¶WHDWWRRPXFKRXZLOOIHHOEDG 'RQ¶WJRIRUDZDONLQWKHUDLQRXZLOOJHWLOO 7KHKRXVHZDVEXLOWLQ 7KHURRPZDVFOHDQHGODVWQLJKW 7KHQHZVSDSHUVZHUHUHDGHVWHUGD 7KHVKRSZDVFORVHGDW IeZg_lZA_fey hiZkghklb Zij_ey^_gvaZsbluA_febEx^bhkzffbj_^mfZxlh
gZ r_cieZg_l_Hgb^mfZxlh ha^mo_h h^_h jZkl_gbyob `bhl
121.
guogZA_fe_Hgb]hhjylqlhgZrZieZg_lZ hiZkghklbFgh]b_ ex^bg_agZxldZdaZsblblvfbjjZkl_gbcb `bhlguodZdkhojZ gblvh^mqbklhcb
ha^mok_`bfGhhgb]hlhuk^_eZlvwlhHgb iulZxlkyihfhqvijbjh^_ h^Z hq_gv Z`gZ ^ey `bagb gZ A_fe_ HgZ fhjyo j_dZo b hazjZoGZgZr_cieZg_l_fgh]hh^ugh lh`_j_fygZg_cfZ ehh^uWlhlZdihlhfmqlhhq_gvfZehh^uijb]h^gh^eyiblvy hfgh]boj_dZob hazjZoh^Zhq_gv]jyagZyBgh]^Zex^bg_fh ]ml^Z`_ieZZlv fhj_ihlhfmqlhh^Z gzf]jyagZyhfgh ]bof_klZoh^Zg_ijb]h^gZ^eyiblvyHiZkghbkihevahZlvlZ dmx h^m ^ey ijb]hlhe_gby ibsb Z`_ ju[Z ih]b[Z_l lZdhc h^_ GZijbf_j;ZcdZekZfh_]em[hdh_ha_jhk k_`_c iblv_hc h ^hc?]h]em[bgZf_ljHa_jhhq_gvdjZkbhghk_cqZkhgh [hevrhchiZkghklb baaZ aZh^h jZkiheh`_gguo jy^hf k gbf g_dhlhjuof_klZoh^ZgZklhevdh]jyagZyqlhhgZfh`_lm[blv`b hlguob jZkl_gby ;ZcdZe_b _]hhdj_klghklyo H[jZa `bagb ex^_c baf_gbe debfZl gZ gZr_c ieZg_l_ gZ klhys__j_fyl_fi_jZlmjZjZklzl Fhkd_[hevr_g_[uZ_lgZ klhys_cjmkkdhcabfuGZk__j_?jhiudebfZlklZe[he__fy]dbf b lzieuf ?kebl_fi_jZlmjZujZkl_lgZ]jZ^mkZlhgZgZr_cieZg_l_ klZg_lg_hafh`gh`blv G_dhlhjZy ^_yl_evghklv ex^_c ijbghkbl fgh]h j_^Z e_kZf Ex^bjm[yl^_j_vyqlh[ukljhblvn_jfu^hfZb ^hjh]bFgh]b_ `bhlgu_b jZkl_gbyl_jyxlkhb^hfZWlhiehoh^eyha^moZgZ ieZg_l_Khj_f_ggu_aZh^ub nZ[jbdbu[jZkuZxlfgh]h^ufZ ha^moWlhlh`_hq_gviehohlZddZd gZklhys__j_fy [hev rbo]hjh^ZoklZehly`_eh^urZlv Ijh[e_fZaZdexqZ_lky lhf qlh[u aZsblblv `bagv gZ A_fe_ kiZklbgZrmieZg_lm^eyex^_c 7UXHIDOVHIDOVHIDOVHIDOVHIDOVHIDOVHWUXHWUXHWUXH )URPWKHEHJLQQLQJRIWKHWH[WWRWKHHQGRIWKHILUVWSDUDJUDSK+RZ WRSURWHFWWKH(DUWK )URP WKHEHJLQQLQJRIWKHVHFRQGSDUDJUDSKWRWKHHQGRIWKHILIWK SDUDJUDSK:DWHULVYHULPSRUWDQWIRURXUOLIH )URPWKHEHJLQQLQJRIWKHVL[WKSDUDJUDSKWRWKHHQGRIWKHWH[W)RU HVWVDUHLQGDQJHU
122.
$SULO LV
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¶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
123.
7KHEORVVRPVVPHOOVZHHW 7KHULYHUVRXQGVQLFH 7KHELUGV¶VRQJVVRXQGZRQGHUIXO 7KHERVIHHOZHOO 7KHPDQIHHOEDG 7KHDSSOHWDVWHVIUHVK 7KHPXVLFVRXQGVZRQGHUIXO ,WLVSRVVLEOHIRUKLPWRUHDG ,WLVLPSRVVLEOHIRUKLPWRGDQFH ,WLVSRVVLEOHIRUKLPWRVLQJ ,WLVSRVVLEOHIRUKLPWRSODFKHVV ,WLVSRVVLEOHIRUKLPWRSODWKHSLDQR ,WLVLPSRVVLEOHIRUKLPWRSODIRRWEDOO ,WLVLPSRVVLEOHIRUKLPWRVZLP ,WLVSRVVLEOHIRUKLPWROLVWHQWRWKHUDGLR ,QVXPPHU,ZHQWWRWKHYLOODJH$LULVDOZDVYHUIUHVKWKHUHDQGLW LVHDVWREUHDWKH)UHVKDLUGRHVDORWRIJRRG7KHUHZHUHDORWRIIORZ HUV LQ EORVVRP
ZKLFK VPHOOHG SOHDVDQW 7KH ZHUH SXUSOH UHG HOORZ DQGZKLWH7KHYLOODJHLVVLWXDWHGQHDUWKHULYHU7KHULYHULVYHUGHHS 7KHFOLPDWHLVYHUPLOGWKHUH 3HRSOHFDQWDNHFDUHRIDQLPDOVDQGELUGVZKHQWKHDUHLQGDQJHU 7KH ZDWHU LQ /DNH %DLNDO LV VRPHWLPHV VR GDQJHURXV WKDW SHRSOH FDQ¶WHYHQVZLPLQLW7KHZDWHULVGDQJHURXVEHFDXVHWKHUHDUHDORWRI SODQWVDQGIDFWRULHVQHDUWKHODNHWKDWGRDORWRIKDUPWRWKHZDWHUDQG WKHDLU 0RVFRZZDVIRXQGHGLQ $PHULFDZDVGLVFRYHUHGLQ 7DEOHVDUHXVXDOOPDGHRIZRRG RIIHHLVJURZQLQ%UD]LO 3RUULGJHLVXVXDOOFRRNHGIRUEUHDNIDVWLQRXUIDPLO EUHDWKHSURWHFWVDYH NLOOWRGRDORW RI KDUP IDFWRUFOLPDWH LQ EORVVRPWHPSHUDWXUHFDUVPHOO
124.
:g^jhde_kb e_ :g^jhde_k[uejZ[hf Hg[_`Zeq_j_ae_kHgohl_ekijylZlvky kj_^b^_j_v_Hgohl_em[_`Zlv^Ze_dhhl^_j_gb]^_hg`beb [uejZ[hfHgkqblZeqlh_]h`bagv[ueZljm^gZ
gZ kZfhf ^_e_ hgZ[ueZg_ughkbfZ:g^jhde_kohl_ekiZklbkhx`bagv e_km ^jm]hgmb^_e[hevrh]hevZGbdh]hjy^hfk gbfg_[ueh:g^ jhde_kbkim]Zekyghihgyeqlhe_g_kfh`_lk^_eZlv_fmgbdZdh]h j_^ZE_ly`_eh^urZeHgohl_eihdZaZlv:g^jhde_kmqlhqlh lhkemqbehkvk _]heZihcE_g_fh]]hhjblvgZyaud_ex^_cgh hg ohl_e kdZaZlv ©KiZkb f_gy AZsblb f_gy Ihfh]b fg_ª :g^ jhde_k ihkfhlj_e gZ eZim lb]jZ b mb^_e [hevrmx dhexqdm HgZ [ueZ ]em[hdh eZi_ :g^jhde_k ulZsbe _z E_ klZe kqZkleb HgbklZeb^jmavyfbb e_ijbghkbe_fmdZ`^uc^_gv_^m Gh h^bg ^_gv hckdZ Bfi_jZlhjZ ihcfZeb :g^jhde_kZ b _]h ^jm]ZevZ Hgb^hklZbebbo Jbfb jZaemqbebboHgbg_^ZZebgbdZdhc _^uevmE_klZehq_gv]heh^gufb de_ldmd g_fm[jhkbebgZ kt_^_gb_ :g^jhde_kZ Gh e_ [ue _]h gZklhysbf ^jm]hf Hg g_ m[be:g^jhde_kZHg[uejZ^b^_lvkh_]h^jm]Z Bfi_jZlhjg_fh]ihgylvwlh]h:g^jhde_kZ^hklZbebd g_fmb hgjZkkdZaZeBfi_jZlhjmkhxbklhjbxBfi_jZlhjijbdZaZe^Zlv evmih_klvb hlimklbeboh[hbo 7KHKXQJUOLRQGLGQ¶WHDW$QGURFOHVEHFDXVHKHZDVKLVUHDOIULHQG $QGURFOHVORRNHGDWWKHOLRQ¶VSDZDQGGLVFRYHUHGDODUJHWKRUQLQLW +HWRRNLWDZD 7KHEHFDPHIULHQGVDQGWKHOLRQEURXJKWKLPIRRGHYHUGD +HEHFDPHYHUKXQJUDQGWKHQWKHJDYH$QGURFOHVWRHDW :KDWGLG$QGURFOHVGRLQWKHIRUHVW :KRPGLGKHVHHWKHUH :KDWGLGWKHOLRQZDQWWRVD :KDWKDSSHQHGRQHGD :KGLGWKH(PSHURUOHWWKHIULHQGVJRDZD $QGURFOHVZDVDVODYH+HUDQLQWRWKHIRUHVWWRVDYHKLVOLIHWKHUH 6XGGHQOKHVDZDELJOLRQ%XWWKHOLRQFRXOGQ¶WGRKLPDQKDUP7KH OLRQ ZDQWHG VRPHWKLQJ WRVD$QGURFOHVVDZ DELJ WKRUQ LQ WKH OLRQ¶V SDZDQGKHWRRNLWRXW7KHEHFDPHIULHQGVDQGWKHOLRQEURXJKWKLP
125.
IRRGHYHUGD%XWRQHGDWKH(PSHURU¶VSHRSOHFDXJKWERWK$QGUR FOHVDQGKLV IULHQGWKHOLRQ7KHGLGQ¶WJLYHDQ IRRGWRWKHOLRQ
DQG WKHQKHEHFDPHYHU KXQJU7KHJDYH$QGURFOHVWRHDW%XWWKHOLRQ ZDVKLVUHDOIULHQG²KHGLGQ¶WHDW$QGURFOHV7KH(PSHURUFRXOGQ¶WXQ GHUVWDQGLW7KHQ$QGURFOHVWROGKLPWKHVWRUDQGWKHHPSHURUJDYHIRRG WRWKHOLRQDQGOHWWKHPERWKJRDZD :KGLG$QGURFOHVZDQWWRUXQIDUIURPWKHYLOODJH :KZDVKLVOLIHKDUG :KDWGLGKHVHHLQWKHIRUHVW :KGLG$QGURFOHVXQGHUVWDQGWKDWWKHOLRQFRXOGQ¶WGRKLPDQ KDUP :KDWGLGWKHOLRQWULHGWRVD :KZDVWKHOLRQKDSS :KRFDXJKWERWK$QGURFOHVDQGKLVIULHQG :KHUHGLGWKHEULQJWKHIULHQG :KDWGLGWKHGRZLWKWKHP :KZDVWKHOLRQKDSSWRVHH$QGURFOHV /HVVRQ ,XVHGWRVZLPODVWVXPPHU ,XVHGYHJHWDEOHVWRFRRNGLQQHU ,XVHGWRULGHDELFFOHODVWVXPPHU ,XVHGSDSHUWRZULWHDOHWWHU ,XVHGWRVOHHSODVWVXPPHU ,XVHGERRNVWRSUHSDUHDWDONRQ+LVWRURIWKH86$ ,XVHGWRWDNHSLFWXUHVODVWVXPPHU ,XVHGSDLQWVWRGRDSLFWXUH :KDWZHUHRXGRLQJDWR¶FORFNHVWHUGD ,ZDVGULQNLQJFRIIHH :KDWZHUHRXGRLQJDWR¶FORFNHVWHUGD ,ZDVZDWFKLQJ79 :KDWZHUHRXGRLQJDWR¶FORFNHVWHUGD ,ZDVGRLQJPKRPHZRUN (QJODQGLVVHSDUDWHGIURP6FRWODQGEPRXQWDLQV,WLVZDVKHGEWKH 1RUWK6HD7KHPDLQFLWLHVRI(QJODQGDUHVLWXDWHGLQWKHFHQWUHRIWKH FRXQWU/RQGRQLWVFDSLWDOZDVIRXQGHGPDQFHQWXULHVDJR,WLVDSRUW
126.
QRZ WRR $
ORW RI JRRGV DUH EURXJKW WR /RQGRQ IRUP PDQ FRXQWULHV 0DQGLIIHUHQWWKLQJVDUHVROGLQWKHVKRSVDQGVWUHHWVRI/RQGRQ/RQ GRQLVYLVLWHGEPDQWRXULVWVHYHUHDU ,WXUQHGRIIWKHUDGLREHFDXVHLWVRXQGHGORXG ,KDYHHDWHQWKHZKROHFDNHEHFDXVHLWWDVWHGJRRG ,GLGQ¶WJRWRVFKRROHVWHUGDEHFDXVH,IHOWEDG ,KDYHSXWWKHVHOLOLHVKHUHEHFDXVHWKHVPHOOSOHDVDQW ,OLNHKRQHEHFDXVHLWWDVWHVVZHHW ,GRQ¶WWDNHDVSLULQHEHFDXVH,IHHOZHOO KULVWRSKHURXORPEGLVFRYHUHG$PHULFD 0PRWKHUKDVWXUQHGRIIWKHZDVKLQJPDFKLQH +LVVLVWHULV6XVDQ 0IDWKHUZRUNVDWWKHIDFWRU 7KHVHURVHVVPHOOQLFH :KRSURWHFWVDQLPDOVRQRXUSODQHW²3HRSOHGR :KLFKRIRXZLOOJRWR/RQGRQ²:HZLOO :KLFKRIWKHPZLOOFRQWLQXHWKHZRUN²3HWHUDQG$QQZLOO :KREXVQHZVSDSHUVLQRXUIDPLO²0IDWKHUGRHV :KLFKRIRXJUHZSULPURVHVLQWKHJDUGHQODVWVXPPHU²0 VLVWHUVGLG :KDWULVHVLQWKH(DVW²7KH6XQGRHV 3HRSOHVDWKDWPDQDQLPDOVDUHLQGDQJHU 1LFN¶VJUDQQDVNVKLPQRWWRGRDQKDUPWRFKUVDQWKHPXPV 7KHWHDFKHUDVNV%HWWQRWWRVSHDNVRORXGO 0JUDQGSDVDVKHOLNHVVSULQJZKHQDOOWKHIUXLWWUHHVDUHLQ EORVVRP %RE¶VFRXVLQVKRXWVWRKLPWRFRPHDQGWREHTXLFN 0WHDFKHUDVNVWRVSHDN(QJOLVKLQFODVV D
127.
0RQGD7XHVGD:HGQHVGD7KXUVGD)ULGD6DWXUGD6XQ GD E
128.
:LQWHU FRQVLVWV RI
'HFHPEHU -DQXDU )HEUXDU 6XPPHU FRQ VLVWVRI-XQH-XO$XJXVW F
129.
0IODWFRQVLVWVRIWKUHHURRPV
130.
1RYRVLELUVN6DPDUD7RODWL 3HRSOHIHHOORQHOZKHQWKHDUHDORQH $XVXDOVLJQRIUDLQLVZLQG
,YDQ ZDV VXUSULVHG ZKHQ WKH ILVK EHJDQ WR VSHDN EHFDXVH KH QHYHUVDZDILVKOLNHWKDW 3HRSOHPXVWEHFDUHIXOLQWKHVWUHHWVZKHQWKHUHDUHDORWRIFDUV D
131.
.LQJGRP E
132.
6WDWH A_feyb ex^b_ebdh[jblZgbb Kh_^bgzggh_ dhjhe_klh
_ebdh[jblZgbb b K__jghc BjeZg ^bb KD
133.
wlh hnbpbZevgh_ gZaZgb_
kljZgu dhlhjZy jZkiheh`_gZ gZ ;jblZgkdbo hkljhZo LZdbf h[jZahf _ebdh[jblZgbx qZklh gZaauZxl;jblZgbmc bebH[t_^bgzggufdhjhe_klhfbebijh klh;HgZkhklhblbaq_lujzokljZg:g]ebbRhleZg^bbMwevkZ b K__jghcBjeZg^bbufh`_l_bob^_lvgZdZjl_Boklhebpu Ehg^hgW^bg[mj]DZj^bnb ;_enZkl _ebdh[jblZgby²hkljhgh_]hkm^ZjklhZhkghguohkljh Z wlh _ebdh[jblZgby ]^_ jZkiheh`_gu :g]eby RhleZg^by b Mwevk
134.
b BjeZg^byA^_kvjZkiheh`_guK__jgZyBjeZg^byb g_aZ bkbfZy
BjeZg^kdZy j_kim[ebdZ Z hkljhZ jZa^_e_gu BjeZg^ kdbffhj_f _ebdh[jblZgby hl^_e_gZ hl dhglbg_glZ ijhebhf EZFZgr Dh]^Zlh;jblZgkdb_hkljhZ[uebqZklvx?jhiu;eb`ZcrZylhq dZd jhi_²ijhebIZ^_DZe_ _ebdh[jblZgbyhfuZ_lky:leZglbq_kdbfhd_ZghfgZk__j_b K__jguffhj_fgZaZiZ^_ DZ`^ucdlhjh^beky ;jblZgbb²;jblZg_pEx^bba:g]ebb Zg]ebqZg_Ex^bbaRhleZg^bbMwevkZbebK__jghcBjeZg^bbg_ Zg]ebqZg_HgbrhleZg^puZeebcpub bjeZg^puEx^bbaRhl eZg^bbb MwevkZg_ex[yldh]^ZbogZauZxlZg]ebqZgZfb ;jblZgbb`bml[he__fbeebhghq_eh_dFgh]b_bagbo `bml [hevrbo bg^mkljbZevguo ]hjh^Zo lZdbo dZd Ehg^hg FZgq_kl_j b Eb_jimev gZijbf_j [hevrb_ bg^mkljbZevgu_ ]h jh^Z p_glj_ :g]ebb Gh bghkljZgpu qZklh m^beyxlky qlh ;jblZgbb hkghghfhldjulZyf_klghklvA^_kvfgh]hh^bghdbo ohefhlboboj_d]em[hdbohazjb n_jf_jkdboa_f_evhkh[_ggh gZx]_kljZgu
135.
k_ ;jblZgbb]hhjylgZZg]ebckdhfGh g_dhlhjuoqZklyo RhleZg^bbb
MwevkZ]hhjylgZ^jm]boyaudZoZeebcpuhkh[_ggh ]hj^ylky khbf yaudhf Hgb ex[yl ]hhjblv gZ Zeebckdhf i_lv i_kgb gZ Zeebckdhf b dh]^Z iml_r_klm_rv fh`gh mb^_lv ^h jh`gu_agZdbgZZeebckdhfyaud_ihk_fmMwevkm k_ dhjhe_kl_]hhjylgZZg]ebckdhfgh]hhjylgZgzfih jZaghfm RhleZg^_p ^he`_g ijbkemrbZlvky qlh[u ihgylv ehg ^hgpZbebZeebcpZ DZduagZ_l_neZ]dhjhe_klZwlhXgbhg`_dHgkhklhblba ljzodj_klhdj_klKylh]h=_hj]Zkylh]hihdjhbl_ey:g]ebb
136.
dj_kl Kylh]h Wg^jx
kylh]h ihdjhbl_ey RhleZg^bb
137.
b dj_kl Kylh]hIZljbdZihdjhbl_eyBjeZg^bb
138.
*UHDW%ULWDLQ%ULWDLQWKH8QLWHG.LQJGRPWKH8.DUHWKHSRVVLEOH QDPHVWRFDOOWKHFRXQWU 7KH8.LVVLWXDWHGRQWKH%ULWLVK,VOHV 7KH8.LVFDOOHG©DQLVODQGVWDWHªEHFDXVHLWLVVLWXDWHGRQWKH %ULWLVK,VOHV
,UHODQGLVVLWXDWHGRQWKH%ULWLVK,VOHV 7KHVSHDN(QJOLVK6FRWWLVK:HOVKDQG,ULVK 7KHUHOLYHPRUHWKDQPLOOLRQSHRSOH ,W LV WKH IODJ RI WKH 8QLWHG .LQJGRP DQG LW FRQVLVWV RI WKUHH FURVVHV (QJODQG /RQGRQ
139.
6FRWODQG (GLQEXUJ
140.
:DOHV DUGLII
141.
1RUWKHUQ ,UHODQG%HOIDVW
142.
7KHUHOLYHWKH(QJOLVKWKH:HOVKWKH6FRWWVDQGWKH,ULVKDQGWKH VSHDN(QJOLVK6FRWWLVK:HOVKDQG,ULVK /RQGRQ0DQFKHVWHU/LYHUSRRO 7KH$WODQWLF2FHDQWKH1RUWK6HDWKH(QJOLVKKDQQHO 7KH(QJOLVKKDQQHOWKH6WUDLWRI'RYHU 7KHODQGRI*UHDW%ULWDLQFRQVLVWVRIORQHO KLOOVTXLHWULYHUVGHHS ODNHVDQGIDUPODQGV 7KHUHDUHWKH6FRWWVWKH(QJOLVKWKH:HOVKWKH,ULVK 7KRXJKWKHDOOVSHDN(QJOLVKRXFDQKHDUVRPHRWKHUODQJXDJHVLQ WKHFRXQWU 7KHVSHDN(QJOLVKEXWWKHVSHDNLWGLIIHUHQWO
143.
6KHLVD%ULWLVKJLUO 6WDWH RXQWU DSLWDO 3HRSOH
/DQJXDJH 6FRWODQG (GLQEXUJK WKH6FRWWV 6FRWWLVK :DOHV DUGLII WKH:HOVK :HOVK (QJODQG /RQGRQ WKH(QJOLVK (QJOLVK *UHDW%ULWDLQ /RQGRQ WKH%ULWLVK (QJOLVK 1RUWKHUQ,UHODQG %HOIDVW WKH,ULVK ,ULVK MXVW@ MX]G@ MXVW@ MX]G@ MX]G@ /HVVRQ 3HWHU¶V EUHDNIDVW FRQVLVWHG RI HJJV D FXS RI FRIIHH EUHDG RUDQJH MXLFH +LVOXQFKFRQVLVWHGRIDSODWHRISRWDWRHVZLWK PHDWDQDSSOHLFH FUHDPDKDPEXUJHUDQGFKHHVH +LV GLQQHU FRQVLVWHG RI NHEDE D SODWH RI VRXS SRWDWRHV WRPDWRHV FXFXPEHUVDQGWHD 30EUHDNIDVWFRQVLVWHGRISRUULGJHHVWHUGD0DU
144.
30DUVDLGWKDWKHUEUHDNIDVWFRQVLVWHGRISRUULGJHHVWHUGD 30GLQQHUFRQVLVWHGRIVRXSDQGPXWWRQ-RKQ
145.
3-RKQVDLGWKDWKLVGLQQHUFRQVLVWHGRIVRXSDQGPXWWRQ 30OXQFKFRQVLVWHGRIDSSOHVDQGLFHFUHDP1HOO
146.
31HOOVDLGWKDWKHUOXQFKFRQVLVWHGRIDSSOHVDQGLFHFUHDP 3 0 EUHDNIDVW
FRQVLVWHG RI RUDQJH MXLFH DQG D WRDVW ZLWK MDP 3ROO
147.
33ROOVDLGWKDWKHUEUHDNIDVWFRQVLVWHGRIRUDQJHMXLFHDQGDWRDVW ZLWKMDP 7KH8.FRQVLVWVRI(QJODQG6FRWODQG:DOHVDQG1RUWKHUQ,UHODQG
148.
,Q5XVVLD0RVFRZ2PVN7XOD.XUVN ,QWKH8./RQGRQ0DQFKHVWHU/LYHUSRRO ,ZDVVXUSULVHGDWKLVDSSHDUDQFH ,ZDVVXUSULVHGDWKHUEHKDYLRXU ,ZDVVXUSULVHGDWWKHLUZRUGV ,ZDVVXUSULVHGDWKLVUHPDUN ,ZDVVXUSULVHGDWKHUVSHHFK 0'DGZDVVXUSULVHGZKHQKHVDZPHRQDKRUVH 3HWHUZDVVXUSULVHGZKHQKHVDZPHRQDKRUVH 7KHEURWKHUVZHUHVXUSULVHGEHFDXVHWKHLUIULHQGVZHUHQRWLQ 1HOO¶V FRXVLQ ZDV
VXUSULVHG EHFDXVH VKH VDZ KHU ,ULVK UHODWLYH LQ 0RVFRZ 0UV*UHHQZDVVXUSULVHGEHFDXVHWKHGRRURIKHUIODWZDVRSHQ 7KH %URZQV ZHUH VXUSULVHG EHFDXVH WKHLU FDU ZDVQ¶W LQ LWV XVXDO SODFH 3DQLQGHSHQGHQWVWDWH 35XVVLDLVDQLQGHSHQGHQWVWDWH 3DXVXDOVLJQ 3:LQGLVWKHXVXDOVLJKRIUDLQ 3DORQHOPDQ 3,¶PQRWDORQHOPDQ 3FDUHIXOZRUN 3+LVZRUNLVXVXDOYHUFDUHIXO 3DFDUHOHVVGULYHU 30IDWKHULVQRWDFDUHOHVVGULYHU 3DSHDFHIXONLQJGRP 3%ULWDLQLVDSHDFHIXONLQJGRP -DQHWHOOV 0U-RKQHVWRFRPHDJDLQ 3HWHUVDVWKDWWKHDUHDOZDVJODGWRVHHKLP 0DUVDVWKDWWKHDUHJRLQJWR:DOHVLQ0D -RKQVDVKHKDVZULWWHQDVWRU %HWWVDVVKHZLOOVSHQGDPRQWKLQ6FRWODQG 3ROOWHOOVKLPQRWWRIRUJHWWRZULWH WKHP 5LFKDUGVDVWKDWKLVELUWKGDLVLQWKUHHZHHNV 'DYLGVDVKHOLNHVIUXLWYHUPXFKHVSHFLDOOEDQDQDV
149.
FDQGRHVGLGZLOOGRHVZDVGRZLOO 3,FDQULGHDKRUVHOLNHDFRZER 36RFDQ, 3,ZLOOJRWRWKHVHDVLGHLQVXPPHU 36RZLOO, 3,IHHOZHOO
36RGR, 3,KDYHDELFFOH 36RGR, 3,ZDVLQ6W3HWHUVEXUJ 36RZDV, 3,ERXJKWQHZVKRHV 36RGLG, 3,OLNHLFHFUHDP 36RGR, 3,KDYHGRQHPKRPHZRUN 36RKDYH, 3,UHDGWKLVERRN 36RGLG, 3,NQRZWKLVJLUO 36RGR, 0U%URZQZDQWVWRNQRZZKDWLVWKHFDSLWDORIWKH8QLWHG.LQJGRP 0DUZDQWVWRNQRZLI6FRWODQGLVDQLQGHSHQGHQWVWDWH %LOOZDQWVWRNQRZZKKLVFRXVLQLVVRFDUHOHVV 7KH'DYLGVRQVZDQWWRNQRZKRZPDQLQGXVWULDOFLWLHVWKHUHDUHLQ WKH1RUWK 7KHWHDFKHUZDQWVWRNQRZLIZHDUHJRLQJWR$IULFD 7KHGRFWRUZDQWVWRNQRZKRZ,IHHO SRZHUIRUPHUWRHOHFWDODZDODZHU 7KHZDVKLQJPDFKLQHEHORQJVWRDUROLQH 7KHSLFWXUHEHORQJVWRDUROLQH 7KHYDFXXPFOHDQHUEHORQJVWRDUROLQH 7KHDUPFKDLUEHORQJVWRDUROLQH 7KHSLDQREHORQJVWRDUROLQH 7KHIOXWHEHORQJVWR-LP 7KHJXLWDUEHORQJVWR-LP 7KHERRNVEHORQJWR-LP 7KHPDSEHORQJVWR-LP 7KHEDOOEHORQJVWR-LP )LVKLVLQFOXGHGLQLW 6XJDULVLQFOXGHGLQLW 2UDQJHVDUHLQFOXGHGLQLW %UHDGLVLQFOXGHGLQLW
150.
9HJHWDEOHVDUHQRWLQFOXGHGLQLW KHHVHLVQRWLQFOXGHGLQLW %XWWHULVQRWLQFOXGHGLQLW $SSOHVDUHQRWLQFOXGHGLQLW 0HDWLVQRWLQFOXGHGLQLW -RKQRIIHUVKLV*UDQQWRZDWHUWKHSRSSLHV -RKQRIIHUVKLV*UDQQWRSXWWKHOLOLHVLQWKHYDVH
-RKQRIIHUVKLV*UDQQWRFOHDQWKHIORRU -RKQRIIHUVKLV*UDQQWRZDVKXS 7KHIRRWEDOOPDWFKZDVGHODHGEHFDXVHRIWKHUDLQ 7KHIRRWEDOOPDWFKZDVGHODHGEHFDXVHRIWKHZHDWKHU 7KHIRRWEDOOPDWFKZDVGHODHGEHFDXVHRIWKHVQRZ 7KHIRRWEDOOPDWFKZDVGHODHGEHFDXVHRIWKHFDSWDLQ¶VLOOQHVV 7KHIRRWEDOOPDWFKZDVGHODHGEHFDXVHRIWKHSODHUV¶FRPLQJODWH Dhjhe_Zb iZjeZf_gl hklZlhqghljm^ghihgylv;jblZgkdbckihkh[mijZe_gbykljZ ghc ;jblZgbbdhjhe_Z]eZZ]hkm^ZjklZghgZkZfhf^_e_dh jhe_Z kbfhe bklhjbb kljZgu b _z ljZ^bpbc HgZ hq_gv [h]ZlZ HgZ_a^blihdhjhe_klmklj_qZ_lkyk ex^vfbb ihk_sZ_lrdheu [hevgbpu b ^jm]b_ f_klZ LZd ihklmiZxl k_ qe_gu dhjhe_kdhc k_fvb fm` dhjhe_u _z kug ijbgp QZjeva ^hqv dhjhe_u ijbg p_kkZ:ggZb ijbgp_kkZFZj]Zj_l gZqZe_klhe_lbyfgh]hkljZgihk_fmfbjmmijZeyebkv;jb lZgb_ck_hgboh^beb ;jblZgkdmxBfi_jbx b [ueb_z dheh gbyfbBg^byIZdbklZgP_cehggZijbf_j[uebkj_^bgboK_c qZkwlbkljZgug_aZbkbfu_]hkm^ZjklZGh ]h^m;jblZgbyb [urb_ dhehgbb h[jZahZeb Kh^jm`_klh gZpbc Kh^jm`_klh dexqZ_lfgh]hkljZglZdbodZdBjeZg^byDZgZ^Z:kljZebyGh ZyA_eZg^byb ^jm]b_Dhjhe_Z;jblZgbbyey_lkylZd`_b ]eZZ Kh^jm`_klZb dhjhe_hcDZgZ^u:kljZebbb GhhcA_eZg^bb J_ZevgZyeZklv kljZg_ijbgZ^e_`bl;jblZgkdhfmiZjeZf_g lm b ;jblZgkdhfm ijZbl_evklm ;jblZgkdbc iZjeZf_gl khklhbl ba^mo iZeZl iZeZlu ehj^h b iZeZlu h[sbg M iZeZlu ehj^h g_fgh]heZklbghhgZhq_gvZ`gZlZddZdfh`_lij_^eZ]Zlvb f_gylvaZdhguhgZlZd`_fh`_laZ^_j`bZlvaZdhguIZeZlZh[ sbgkha^ZzlaZdhguh iheblbd_kljZgugZeh]Zob fgh]bo^jm]bo _sZo
151.
Qe_gu iZeZlu ehj^h
g_ u[bjZxlky Wlh ihklhyggu_ qe_gu QZklhwlhZjbklhdjZlukys_ggbdbxjbklub [urb_iheblbdb Qe_ghiZeZluh[sbgu[bjZxl;jblZgpuu[bjZxlqe_ ghiZeZluh[sbgdZ`^u_iylve_l 7KHTXHHQLVWKHKHDGRIWKHVWDWH 7KHTXHHQGRHVQ¶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¶W UXOHWKHFRXQWU7KH4XHHQWUDYHOVDORWDOORYHUWKHFRXQWU6KHLVWKH VPERORIWKHFRXQWUKLVWRULWVWUDGLWLRQV 7KH%ULWLVK3DUOLDPHQWFRQVLVWVRIWKH+RXVHRI/RUGVDQGWKH+RXVH RIRPPRQV7KHPHPEHUVRIWKH+RXVHRI/RUGVDUHQRWHOHFWHG7KHVH PHPEHUV DUH SHUPDQHQW %XW PHPEHUV RI WKH +RXVH RI RPPRQV DUH HOHFWHG 7KHVWDWHSRZHULQWKH8.EHORQJVWRWKHJRYHUQPHQWDQGWRWKHSDU OLDPHQW7KRXJKWKHKHDGRIWKHVWDWHLVWKH4XHHQVKHGRHVQ¶WUXOHWKH FRXQWU
152.
,OLNHZKHQLWLVVQRZLQJ ,OLNHZKHQLWLVZDUP 1LFNOLNHVZKHQKLVIULHQGVFRPHRYHU
$QQOLNHVZKHQWUHHVDUHLQEORVVRP ZHGRQRWOLNHZKHQRXUHFHLYHVXFKOHWWHUV :HGRQRWOLNHZKHQWKHVSHDNORXG 7KH KHDG RI WKH 8QLWHG .LQJGRP LV WKH 4XHHQ EXW LQ IDFW VKH GRHVQ¶WUXOH$WWKHEHJLQQLQJRIWKHWK FHQWXU%ULWDLQKDGDORW RI FRORQLHV%XWQRZWKHVHFRXQWULHVDUHLQGHSHQGHQWVWDWHV$QGLQ %ULWDLQIRXQGHGWKHRPPRQZHDOWK7KHSRZHUEHORQJVWRWKH%ULWLVK 3DUOLDPHQWDQGWRWKH%ULWLVK*RYHUQPHQW7KH%ULWLVK3DUOLDPHQWFRQ VLVWV RI WZR ©+RXVHVª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¶WYHUELJ ,QIRUPHUGDVWKH%ULWLVK(PSLUHZDVYHUELJ 7KH+RXVHRI/RUGVFDQRIIHUDQGGHODODZV 7KH%ULWLVKHOHFWWKHPHPEHUVRIWKH+RXVHRIRPPRQVHYHUILYH HDUV
153.
,WLVRXWRIKLVSRZHUWRKHOSWKHSRRU ,W LV RXW
RI KHU SRZHU WR KHOS WKH JRYHUQPHQW EHFDXVH WKH SRZHU GRHVQ¶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©7KDQNRXªZKHQRXJHWDFRPSOLPHQW 'RLWHLWKHUWRGDRUWRPRUURZ %XHLWKHUDSSOHVRURUDQJHV +HZLOOEHHLWKHUDODZHURUDVFLHQWLVW (LWKHUPVLVWHUVRUPEURWKHUDUHJRLQJWRRIIHUWKHPKHOS (LWKHUPEURWKHUVRUPFRXVLQVZLOOFRQWLQXHWKLVZRUN ZDVHOGRPKDUGOHYHUGXOONQRZOHGJH RXVKRXOGQ¶WVKRZRII RXVKRXOGJHWGHHSNQRZOHGJH RXVKRXOGQ¶WRIIHQGSHRSOH RXVKRXOGQ¶WOLH
154.
RXVKRXOGORRNUHVSHFWDEOH RXVKRXOGKDYHDVHQVHRIKXPRXU RXVKRXOGSXWDVSRRQDQGDIRUNIRUGHVHUWLQIURQWRIWKHSODWH RXVKRXOGSXWDJODVVWRWKHULJKWRIWKHSODWH RXVKRXOGSXWDEUHDGRUDFKHHVHNQLIHWRWKHULJKWRIWKHSODWHQHDU ZLWKDELJNQLIHIRUPHDWRUILVK RXVKRXOGSXWDVRXSVSRRQWRWKHULJKWRIWKHSODWHQHDUZLWKWKH EUHDGRUFKHHVHNQLIH ;jblZgkdbch[jZa`bagb l_q_gb_q_lujzoe_lbamq_gbyZg]ebckdh]hum`_fgh]hma gZebh[wlhfyaud_b ex^yodhlhju_gZgzf]hhjylhlg_dhlh ju_k_^_gbyh
;jblZgbb_kebu ohlbl_kjZgblvh[jZa`bagb wlhckljZg_b gZdhglbg_gl_ :g]ebb fgh]b_ _sb ijhbkoh^yl gZh[hjhl GZ dhglbg_gl_ ex^bj_^dh]hhjylh ih]h^_?kebhgbkz`_]hhjylh ih]h^_lh wlhhagZqZ_lqlhbfg_q_]h[hevr_h[km^blv :g]ebb_kebug_ ihlhjy_l_njZam©K_]h^gykeZguc^_gvg_ijZ^Zebª^_klbjZa ^_gvex^bm^beyxlkyb ^mfZxlqlhuhq_gvkdmqgucq_eh_d GZdhglbg_gl_hkdj_kgu_]Za_luuoh^yl ihg_^_evgbd :g]ebb kljZgm^_cklbl_evghljm^ghihgylv
155.
hgb uoh^yl
hkdj_k_gv_ GZdhglbg_gl_g_dhlhju_ex^bex[yldhr_d^jm]b_g_lgh :g] ebbdhrdbhq_gvhkh[_ggu_`bhlgu_k_boex[ylb aZ[hlylkyh gbo GZdhglbg_gl_ex^b]hj^ylkyl_fqlhhgbagZxlHgbiulZxlky ihdZaZlvkhbagZgbyb qZklhpblbjmxl]j_q_kdbob eZlbgkdboib kZl_e_c :g]ebblhevdhl_dlhg_agZ_lbobebg_qblZebo^_eZ_l wlh u fh`_l_ h[b^_lv q_eh_dZ k dhglbg_glZ h fgh]bo kemqZyo gZijbf_j_keb[m^_l_kf_ylvkygZ^gbfbebrmlblv gZ^_]h`ba gvxbebjZ[hlhc Gh Zg]ebqZg_ ijbgbfZxl kz k qmklhf xfhjZ u fh`_l_ h[b^_lvbo_kebkdZ`_l_qlhm gbog_lqmklZxfhjZ Ex^bgZdhglbg_gl_]hhjylZfeb[hijZ^meb[heh`v :g] ebbhq_gvj_^dhjmlghb ijZ^mlh`_j_^dh]hhjyl Ihhkdj_k_gvyfgZdhglbg_gl_^Z`_kZfuc[_^gucq_eh_dgZ ^_Z_lkhxemqrmxh^_`^mb iulZ_lkydjZkbhb ij_^klZbl_evgh u]ey^_lv :g]ebb^Z`_kZfuc[h]Zlucq_eh_dh^_Z_lky klZ jmxh^_`^mb g_[j__lky
156.
Fgh]b_`bl_ebdhglbg_glZkqblZxlqlh`bagvwlhb]jZZg]eb qZg_kqblZxlqlhdjbd_lb]jZGZdhglbg_gl_ohjhrZy_^Z :g] ebbohjhrb_fZg_juaZklhehf 7KHZULWHURIWKHWH[WKDVJRWDVHQVHRI KXPRXU FZg_juaZklhehf u^he`gukb^_lvijyfh ug_^he`gu_klviZevpZfb ug_^he`gudeZklvjmdbgZklhe u^he`gudeZklv]jyagu_gh`eh`dmb
bedmgZlZj_edm ug_^he`gu]hhjblvk gZ[blufjlhf ug_^he`guh[ebauZlviZevpu u^he`gu]hhjblvkiZkb[hihke__^u ,Q(QJODQGLIRXGRQ¶WUHSHDWWKHSKUDVH©,W¶VDQLFHGDWRGDLVQ¶W LWªWZRKXQGUHGWLPHVDGDSHRSOHDUHVXUSULVHGDQGWKLQNWKDWRXDUH YHUGXOO ,Q(QJODQGWKHFRXQWULVUHDOOKDUGWRXQGHUVWDQG
157.
WKHDSSHDURQ 6XQGD ,Q(QJODQGFDWVDUHYHU VSHFLDODQLPDOV(YHURQHORYHV WKHPDQG WDNHVFDUHRIWKHP ,Q(QJODQGRQO
WKRVHZKR GRHVQ¶W NQRZ VRPH ZULWHUV RU ZKR KD YHQ¶WUHDGWKHPGRLW %XWWKH(QJOLVKWDNHHYHUWKLQJZLWKDVHQVHRIKXPRXU ,Q(QJODQGWKHKDUGOHYHUOLHEXWWKHGRQ¶WWHOORXWKHWUXWKHL WKHU ,Q (QJODQG HYHQ WKH ULFKHVW PDQ GUHVVHV LQ VRPH ROG FORWKHV DQG GRHVQ¶WVKDYH 7KH(QJOLVKWKLQNFULFNHWLVDJDPH ,Q(QJODQGSHRSOHKDYHJRRGWDEOHPDQQHUV *UDQGPRWKHU/RRWHOOV7RPQRWWROLFNKLVILQJHUV *UDQGPRWKHU/RRWHOOV$OLFHWRSXWKHUGLUWVSRRQDQGIRUNRQKHU SODWH *UDQGPRWKHU/RRWHOOV%REQRWWROLFNKLVNQLIH *UDQGPRWKHU/RRWHOOV-RKQWRVLWXSVWUDLW *UDQGPRWKHU/RRWHOOV-DQHQRWWRHDWZLWKKHUILQJHUV ,Q%ULWDLQWKHVSHDNPXFKDERXWZHDWKHUEXWRQWKHFRQWLQHQWSHRSOH VSHDNDERXWZHDWKHURQOLIWKHKDYHQRWKLQJWRGLVFXVV,Q%ULWDLQWKH DOOORYHFDWVDQGWDNHFDUHRIWKHP2QWKHFRQWLQHQW6XQGDQHZVSDSHUV
158.
FRPHRXWRQ0RQGDEXWLQ(QJODQGWKHFRPHRXWRQ6XQGD2QWKH FRQWLQHQW SHRSOH OLNH
WR SXW RQ WKHLU EHVW FORWKHV EXW LQ (QJODQG WKH GRQ¶WWKHHYHQGRQ¶WVKDYHRQ6XQGD3HRSOHRQWKHFRQWLQHQWWKLQN WKDWOLIHLVDJDPHEXWLQ(QJODQGWKHWKLQNWKDWFULFNHWLVDJDPH ,Q(QJODQGWKH KDYH JRRGWDEOH PDQQHUV 7KH GRQ¶W SXWWKHLU HO ERZVRQWKHWDEOH 7KHQHYHU WDON ZLWK WKHLU PRXWKV IXOO 7KHNQRZ KRZWRXVHIRUNVDQGNQLYHV ,WKLQNWKDWLQ5XVVLDZHKDYHWKHVDPHWDEOH PDQQHUVDQGDOORYHU (XURSHSHRSOHKDYHWKHVDPHWDEOHPDQQHUV RXVKRXOGVLWXSVWUDLW RXVKRXOGQ¶WHDWZLWKRXUILQJHUV RXVKRXOGQ¶WSXWRXUHOERZVRQWKHWDEOH RXVKRXOGSXWRXUGLUWNQLIHIRUNVSRRQRQRXUSODWH RXVKRXOGQ¶WWDONZLWKRXUPRXWKIXOO RXVKRXOGQ¶WOLFNRXUILQJHUV RXVKRXOGVD©7KDQNRXªDIWHUWKHPHDO ,Q(QJODQGSHRSOHRIWHQVSHDNDERXWZHDWKHU ,Q(QJODQG6XQGDSDSHUVDSSHDURQ6XQGD ,Q(QJODQGHYHUERGORYHVFDWVDQGWDNHVFDUHRIWKHP ,Q(QJODQGRQO WKRVHZKRGRQ¶WNQRZRU ZKR KDYHQ¶WUHDG*UHHN DQG/DWLQZULWHUVTXRWHWKHP SROLWHQHVVQHDWQHVVWKRXJKWIXOQHVVSXQFWXDOLW /HVVRQ RXVKRXOGEHPRUHFDUHIXO RXVKRXOGQ¶WOLHLQWKHVXQIRUKRXUV RXVKRXOGQ¶WVKRZRIIRXUNQRZOHGJH RXVKRXOGQ¶WRIIHQGRXUIULHQGV RXVKRXOGVSHDNWRRXUODZHU RXVKRXOGUHVSHFWRXUWHDFKHUV RXVKRXOGQ¶WJRWREHGDWR¶FORFN RXVKRXOGQ¶WVPRNH
Download