Why
No-one Wants
Creativity
Paul Iddon
Managing Director
KernelSimpatico
19th July 2014
3
People Desire, but Reject
Creative Ideas….
We are taught that
creativity will be celebrated
- if we have good ideas, we
will succeed.
RUBBISH!
Creativity is rarely
acknowledged: Most
people don’t actually like
it.
What does this mean?
“Even people who say they are
looking for creativity react negatively
to creative ideas”*
It is not Overt – A bias activates as a
response to reduce uncertainty - Risk
It also causes people to not even
recognise a creative idea….
*The bias against creativity – why people desire but reject creative ideas University of
Pennsylvania 2011
What does this mean?
“In terms of decision style, most
people fall short of the creative
ideal … unless they are held
accountable for their decision-
making strategies, they tend to find
the easy way out—either by not
engaging in very careful thinking or
by modeling the choices on the
preferences of those who will be
evaluating them.”
6
People are risk averse – when it
comes to possible gains.
Given a choice people will
generally choose a 90%
chance of winning £1000
over a 10% chance of
winning £100,000..
Unless..
They are in a losing
situation where they will
take risk..
7
People are risk averse
The same principle applies
in following the majority
prevailing view…
Even if it means
abandoning evident
truths…
And especially when the
majority view is backed
by an authority
figure……
8
Organisations can also follow this
strategy….
They may celebrate
innovation, but few
managers are willing to
take the risk…
It means breaking
every ‘rule’ from
recruitment to policy
and investment….
9
Organisations can also follow this
strategy…
Creativity means chaos,
opposition, non-conformity,
uncertainty and ‘waste’ –
Risk
“Creative people do
not ‘mesh well’ with
the proclivities of the
average person”
10
In Conclusion
A Cornell study makes the case that social rejection
is not actually bad for the creative process—and can
facilitate it….BUT in any case:
Know your organisation, your line management -
know their pains – their situation
Make them look good – but not too risky
Creativity is a sliding scale – small victories –
small moves
Thank You
Presented by:
Paul Iddon
Managing Director
KernelSimpatico UK
31 Blackfriars Rd
Manchester M3 7AQ
T: +44 161 834 3935
M: +44 7977 283038

Innovation and Risk - July 2014

  • 2.
    Why No-one Wants Creativity Paul Iddon ManagingDirector KernelSimpatico 19th July 2014
  • 3.
    3 People Desire, butReject Creative Ideas…. We are taught that creativity will be celebrated - if we have good ideas, we will succeed. RUBBISH! Creativity is rarely acknowledged: Most people don’t actually like it.
  • 4.
    What does thismean? “Even people who say they are looking for creativity react negatively to creative ideas”* It is not Overt – A bias activates as a response to reduce uncertainty - Risk It also causes people to not even recognise a creative idea…. *The bias against creativity – why people desire but reject creative ideas University of Pennsylvania 2011
  • 5.
    What does thismean? “In terms of decision style, most people fall short of the creative ideal … unless they are held accountable for their decision- making strategies, they tend to find the easy way out—either by not engaging in very careful thinking or by modeling the choices on the preferences of those who will be evaluating them.”
  • 6.
    6 People are riskaverse – when it comes to possible gains. Given a choice people will generally choose a 90% chance of winning £1000 over a 10% chance of winning £100,000.. Unless.. They are in a losing situation where they will take risk..
  • 7.
    7 People are riskaverse The same principle applies in following the majority prevailing view… Even if it means abandoning evident truths… And especially when the majority view is backed by an authority figure……
  • 8.
    8 Organisations can alsofollow this strategy…. They may celebrate innovation, but few managers are willing to take the risk… It means breaking every ‘rule’ from recruitment to policy and investment….
  • 9.
    9 Organisations can alsofollow this strategy… Creativity means chaos, opposition, non-conformity, uncertainty and ‘waste’ – Risk “Creative people do not ‘mesh well’ with the proclivities of the average person”
  • 10.
    10 In Conclusion A Cornellstudy makes the case that social rejection is not actually bad for the creative process—and can facilitate it….BUT in any case: Know your organisation, your line management - know their pains – their situation Make them look good – but not too risky Creativity is a sliding scale – small victories – small moves
  • 11.
    Thank You Presented by: PaulIddon Managing Director KernelSimpatico UK 31 Blackfriars Rd Manchester M3 7AQ T: +44 161 834 3935 M: +44 7977 283038