1) The document outlines the timeline of events related to an incident during a basketball game where a player from Cache High School hit an opposing player from Elgin High School in the face with the ball. This led to investigations by Cache and the Oklahoma Secondary School Activities Association (OSSAA) into whether the act was intentional. 2) Over several months, Elgin and others provided evidence to the OSSAA challenging the conclusions of Cache's investigations, but the OSSAA continued to accept Cache's findings without conducting their own thorough investigation. This included interviewing witnesses or reviewing video and other evidence. 3) Frustration grew as the OSSAA failed to properly address the concerns raised about the integrity of

1. Mar
12 1413 1715 16 2018 19 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 3111101 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
Feb 2015
Cache
“1st Investigation”
Plan discussed in practice
(between Jan 26 & Feb 9) (Exh. 1)
• Plan executed (2/10)
• Post game comments -
Lawton Constitution
(Exh. 1)
(Exh. 2)
• Elgin Formal Complaint
• Elgin reiterates (to OSSAA) concern
of pre-meditated intentional act
(Exh. 4)
(Exh. 4)
(Exh. 60, pg. 1)• Cache: "act falls below standard“
• Cache-One game suspension
• Cache Attny secretly involved
(Exh. 60, pg. 1)
(Exh. 3???)
• Cache School Board President (Cheryl Walker) given credible evidence
from J. Bonnarens Mother
• Kenny White tells players to lie for him
• OSSAA refuses to act, saying it is the officials call
(Exh. 7)
(Exh. 40)
(Exh. 8)
• (13-16 Feb) 8 Elgin residents complain
to OSSAA (Exh. 6, 9-14, 16)
• G. Holt & Elgin provide specific details and witness
info to OSSAA; Expresses great concern regarding fidelity
of said “investigation”
• Elgin expresses Continued concern
(Exh. 15)
(Exh. 15)
• Cache verbally reports results of “1st investigation” to OSSAA: “there was
no intent to injure, but rather Coach White had been “ambiguous” in his
instruction”
 OSSAA readily accepts findings without seeing any evidence.
• Lauren Ackley, asst. coach, provides incriminating statements
• Additional two game suspension given coach for the “unsportsmanlike
act of his player and failing to maintain the integrity of the game”.
(Exh. 60)
(Exh. 5.5)(Exh. 5.3)
• Kurt Short emails OSSAA expressing concern and notifying
the OSSAA of his conversation with two Cache girls who
confirmed this was a designed play by the coach
• Elgin reiterates (to OSSAA) parents questions, which have
gone unanswered.
• OSSAA notifies Elgin that they are satisfied with the Cache
investigation. Elgin nor parents were afforded opportunity to
review and respond.
(Exh. 20)
(Exh. 5.4, pg. 48, 53, 58)
• Lauren Ackley called in to speak w/Cache administration
and told the truth
 Said White told her what to say during meeting
 Cried while giving her statement
(Exh. 5.6)
(Exh. 5.1)
• Cache references: "on-going investigation" & "relevant findings";
(no students had been interviewed prior to this date)
• Cache first interview of players; at least 6 girls provide evidence of
an intentional act to injure; NOT DISCLOSED UNTIL FEB 2016 (Exh. 5.2)
(Exh. 17)
• Cache submits formal reply
• OSSAA eagerly accepts, “1st investigation” which concludes no wrongdoing
by the coach (OSSAA did not see, inquire, or investigate the incriminating
evidence or witnesses provided. The simply to Cache’s word)
(Exh. 18)
(Exh. 19)

2. • E. Sheakley emails Gary Holt with his decision,
stating:
• “I saw no basis for OSSAA to take further
action, including any direct witness interviews by
OSSAA”
• “I am not planning any other investigation,
action, or report”
• OSSAA accepted the “2nd investigation” again
without seeing a single piece of evidence and
without making a single phone call to the very
credible witnesses offered them.
Jul 2015
15 20 25 30101 5
Mar 2015
• Cache lawyer, Chuck Wade, tells G. Holt “There is
nothing to indicate that the actions of the player who hit
your daughter with the basketball were done with intent
to do bodily harm”… “High School Principal, Corey
Holland, conducted a thorough investigation”…
• G. Holt; Open Records Act request to OSSAA
• Ed Sheakley acknowledges ORA request
• G. Holt request office call w/Ed Sheakley
• ORA request to Cache; requested full game footage, among
others, and clips demonstrating alleged “dirty play”
• G. Holt sent significant supporting evidence (via Mail)
to OSSAA including:
 Comprehensive video, from Cache and Elgin, along
with a detailed narrative (complete with frame by frame
time stamps of relevance).
 Names of witnesses, including a Cache player (Jamie
Bonnarens) that had come forward, through her parents.
 Very detailed explanation of continuing concerns.
• G. Holt again clearly challenges the shell of an
“investigation” that has been conducted to date
• E. Sheakley again acknowledges ORA
request
• G. Holt, again, requests office call w/Ed
Sheakley
• Sheakley denies office call, suggesting a
phone call
MayApr Jun
15 20 25 30105 15 20 25 30105 15 20 25 30105
• G. Holt request anticipated
date for ORA response. E. Sheakley
says info. Will be mailed by Friday,
April 10.
• G. Holt acknowledges receipt of OSSAA ORA
info. and further inquires concerning the OSSAA’s
responsibility and authority
• G. Holt specifically challenges the lack of
fidelity and vigor regarding this “investigation”
• G. Holt follows up due to OSSAA delay for April 29
request for additional information
• E. Sheakley acknowledges and indicates reply with be
forthcoming be the end of the day. However, E. Sheakley’s
letter doesn’t answer any questions but does offer to
evaluate “other evidence that a Cache coach acted
improperly….”
• E. Sheakley confirms receipt of
additional evidence and says it will be a
few weeks before it is reviewed
• E. Sheakley indicates he
will review the info this week
• G. Holt emails E. Sheakley regarding
status of review.
Cache
“2nd Investigation”
• G. Holt delivers letter to Cache School Board President and
also speaks at Cache School Board meeting
• Cache subsequently revises Board policy limiting public
participation for those outside of the Cache district
(Exh. 23)
(Exh. 29)(Exh. 29.1) (Exh. 29.2)
(Exh. 28)
(Exh. 28)
(Exh. 28)
• OSSAA ORA info. mailed on or about April 13
• Among the records produced by OSSAA are the
following that previously had not been seen by Holt
and had not been referenced in any of the OSSAA or
Cache communication to Holt:
(Exh. 41)
(Exh. 41)
(Exh. 33)
(Exh. 30)
(Exh. 43)
(Exh. 45)
(Exh. 25)
• E. Sheakley emails G. Holt, advising OSSAA
has reviewed information and Sheakley has
“visited by phone with Mr. Batt and Coach
White about the incident. The investigation is
still ongoing.” (Exh. 34)
• G. Holt emails E. Sheakley requesting
clarification whether OSSAA has investigated
alleged violation and OSSAA’s final
determination. (Exh. 46)
(Exh. 46)
(Exh. 35)
• G. Holt, ORA request to Cache for video evidence of
bogus claims in 17 Feb letter to OSSAA (Exh. 47)
• G. Holt delivers letter to Cache School Board President and
also speaks at Cache School Board meeting
• Cache subsequently revises Board policy limiting public
participation for those outside of the Cache district
(Exh. 23)
(Exh. 29)(Exh. 29.1) (Exh. 29.2)
• G. Holt emails E. Sheakley
regarding status of review (Exh. 54)
• Cache emails E. Sheakley w/ “final
conclusion” of “no evidence” presented by any
of players or coaches of a specific instruction
“to the players to throw a ball in the face of
an opposing player”. E. Sheakley accepts.
(Exh. 71)
• G. Holt emails E. Sheakley asking if this constitutes
his “investigation and final determination”. (Exh. 36)
G. Holt in Japan
• Cache notifies G. Holt that
their Board Public Participation
Policy has been revised (Exh. 29)

3. • G. Holt makes initial contact w/ D. Rischard (Exh. 63)
G. Holt in Japan
Jan 2015Nov Dec
15 20 25 30105 15 20 25 3010515 20 25 30101 5
Jul 2015 SepAug Oct
15 20 25 30105 15 20 25 30105 15 20 25 31105

4. Nov 2015
15 20 25 30101 5
Jul 2015 SepAug Oct
15 20 25 30105 15 20 25 30105 15 20 25 30105
• G. Holt makes initial contact w/ D. Rischard (Exh. 63)
G. Holt in Japan
Sep Oct
25 30 15 20 25 30105 15 20 25 30105