2. Agenda: Re-thinking the ILS
Re-thinking the ILS
Aligning technology choice with library mission
Importance of choice in the library ecosystem
User Research improves technology
Discovery Services Platform and a true next-gen
ILS
3. Re-thinking the ILS
Started with post in EBSCO Discovery
Pulse blog
http://discovery.ebsco.com/pulse/article/re-re-
thinking-the-integrated-library-system
10. Re-thinking the ILS: Changing Needs
The academic library collection is evolving
and traditional ILS functions represent a
smaller part of the library workflow
11. The Changing Library Collection
1.0 million volumes
15K print serials
250K circ
OPAC and Databases
Via native interface or
federated search
12,000 FTE
1.0 million volumes
100K circ
No growth. Increased offsite
storage
Declining
eBooks
50,000 titles via subscription,
DDA and purchase
eJournals
Via EBSCONet
Discovery
100s of millions of articles
searched via discovery (EDS)
Monographs
No growth, Increasingly
automated (e.g. OCLC, YBP)
New
collection
means new
workflow and
technology
focus
13. New Paradigm
Diverse selection of content
that is accessed on a myriad
of devices
“Digital native” users with
modern expectations, different
needs, across disciplines
Unique technology mix within
the library ecosystem
15. Supporting the Library Mission
The mission statement of your library is
probably focused on serving your users
The value of the library is tied directly to
the end user’s experience with the library
and its resources
Library Success = User Success
16. Strategic Goals of One Academic Library
Source: presentation by Don Gilstrap, Dean of Libraries,
Wichita State University @ NISO ODI Jan. 28, 2015
17. Focus on the user and all else
will follow…
Google: 10 things we know to be true
www.google.com/about/company/philosophy
18. Has Your Automation Strategy Evolved?
In RFPs for ILS, 80% of requirements are
concerned with “traditional” library workflows, e.g.
Cataloging and Circulation
User research tells us providing access to content
and improving the user experience are the highest
priorities for the academic library
Shouldn’t 80% of the technology selection
process should be focused on user success and
outcomes?
23. Title Slide
“Libraries need the ability to set
Discovery and Resource
Management strategies
independently and expect these
systems to have mutual
interoperability.”
Marshall Breeding
February 2015
NISO White Paper, “The Future of Library Resource Discovery”,
Feb 2015, Marshall Breeding
http://www.niso.org/apps/group_public/download.php/14487/future_li
brary_resource_discovery.pdf
24. EDS Integrates with your Technology
ILS
Knowlegebase / Link Resolver
Learning Management System
Institutional Repository
25. EDS fully integrates with the ILS
Via full ILS partnerships
Koha
Innovative Interfaces (Sierra, VTLS, Polaris)
OCLC (WMS)
SirsiDynix (Horizon, Symphony, BLUEcloud)
Kuali OLE
Via customer technical collaboration
Ex Libris (Aleph now fully integrated;
Voyager & Alma in development)
26. 30 ILS partners worldwide,
+Others via customer technical collaboration
ILS Partnerships
27. EDS Discovery Deployment Options
EDS as the front end user experience
Library catalog metadata integrated into EDS
Patron functionality delivered via API from ILS
ILS as the front end user experience
EDS content integrated into vendor-provided
platform via API
Open source as front-end user experience
Koha, VuFind or Blacklight
28. EDS as the front end with OCLC
WMS:
Patron account with Holds and
Checkouts
OCLC and EDS
Editor's Notes
The blog post got quite a bit of attention – and soon will be expanded into a full-length article
What are some broad characteristics of an ILS
--integrates data – content – and provides access to that content
--has staff and user functionality
--has content, technology and software designed to work together
The blog started from the point of view of let’s take a different view of the ILS
What if Discovery and related software are the new ILS? – A Discovery Services Platform?
To take another view “what if we start why”? – the WHY here is to better user outcomes
Start from the user experience – and then look inwards to see how the ILS can serve the user
ILS role is to support the discovery and user experience – due to
Number of volumes added to collection has actually gone up over the last 8-10 years – but mostly due to e-books
Ebooks in 2006 – 16M; ebooks in 2012 – 52M
Circulation is dropping – 20% over last 5-6 years
Here is another presentation that was given at the NISO ODI conference. NISO is the standards organization designed to set precedents and parameters for best practice and the ODI piece is the Open Discovery Initiative that is focused on this rethinking of the ILS…moving the focus towards better user experiences by having better collaboration. This slide really proves the point that so many thousands of libraries make…having an ILS is important, but the focus of the decisions must be centered around a superior user experience.
If I was giving this presentation in front of a live audience I would ask you: Where is this quote from?
The blog started from the point of view of let’s take a different view of the ILS
What if Discovery and related software are the new ILS? – A Discovery Services Platform?
To take another view “what if we start why”? – the WHY here is to better user outcomes
Start from the user experience – and then look inwards to see how the ILS can serve the user
ILS role is to support the discovery and user experience – due to
So, as the market and Marshall Breeding have articulated, they want interoperability of best in breed solutions. In Europe, we are faced with the increasing need to go through the tender process. Many institutions have been bullied into thinking that they must tender for an ILS and throw in the discovery decision as part of the ILS decision. Representatives from institutions who took a bundled discovery layer with an ILS have been very clear at conferences, tweets and discussion boards that having a compromised discovery experience is something that they regret and have since upgraded to EDS either as the discovery layer, or the index that sits behind a configurable discovery layer such as Blacklight, VuFind or the ILS provider’s catalog interface.
And these are not wild, unsubstantiated claims. They are as irritating as they are misleading. Here are some live (available today) examples.