1. Project Implementation and
Closure(PPM 552)
Dereje Teklemariam, PhD and Asst. Professor
Chapter One
Concepts and Approaches to
Project Implementation
Dereje Teklemariam, PhD Feb 2018 1
2. What is a Project?
Dereje Teklemariam, PhD Feb 2018 2
4. The Project concept
• A project is a unique venture with a
beginning and an end, conducted by people
to meet established goals within parameters
of cost, schedule, and quality.
Buchanan & Boddy
• Projects are goal-oriented, involve the
coordinated undertaking of interrelated
activities, are of finite duration, and are all,
to a degree unique.
Frame
Dereje Teklemariam, PhD Feb 2018 4
5. The project concept
A simple precise definition is not easy to give,
nor is it absolutely necessary.
A project is a problem scheduled for solution.
‘ ....A temporary endeavour undertaken to
create a unique product (= Good or Service)
(PMI)
Dereje Teklemariam, PhD Feb 2018 5
6. What do we mean by …
Dereje Teklemariam, PhD Feb 2018 6
Turner defines a project as: “ ..... An endeavor in
which human, (or machine), material and
financial resources are organized in a novel
way, to undertake a unique scope of work, of
given specification, within constraints of cost and
time, so as to deliver beneficial change defined
by quantitative and qualitative objectives."
8. Project Concepts Summarized
A project can be considered any series of
activities and tasks that have various features
such as:
• Specific objectives to be completed within
certain specifications,
Defined start and end dates,
Funding limits,
Human and nonhuman resources, and
Multifunctional focus.
Dereje Teklemariam, PhD Feb 2018 8
9. ....features
• Complex, one-time processes
• Limited by budget, schedule, and resources
• Developed to resolve a clear goal or set of
goals
• Customer-focused
• Ad-hoc endeavors with a clear life cycle
• Building blocks in the design and execution
of organizational strategies
• Responsible for the newest and most
improved products, services, and
organizational processes
• Provide a philosophy and strategy for the
management of change
Dereje Teklemariam, PhD Feb 2018 9
10. Why are Projects Important?
1. Investments! Resources! Changes!
2. Shortened product life cycles
3. Narrow product launch windows
4. Increasingly complex and technical products
5. Emergence of global markets
6. Economic period marked by low inflation
Dereje Teklemariam, PhD Feb 2018 10
12. What is PM?
“ ..... the application of knowledge, skills,
tools and techniques to project activities
in order to meet stakeholders’ need and
expectation from a project." (PMBOK,
2005)
Stakeholders = Internal + external
Three different perspectives:
Dereje Teklemariam, PhD Feb 2018 12
How the project fits into the organization?
How the project will evolve over time?
What skills are required to successfully manage the
project?
13. What is PM?
Dereje Teklemariam, PhD Feb 2018 13
Peter Moms described PM as: “ ..... the
process
needs
of integrating everything that
to be done (typically using a
number of special pm techniques) … in
order to meet the project's objectives. "
14. PROJECT MANAGEMENT: PM
• Can be seen as dealing with a series of
Phases
• Can be envisioned as a bunch of Knowledge
areas
• Can be considered as the amalgamation of
skills
CAN YOU EXPAIN THESE?
Dereje Teklemariam, PhD Feb 2018 14
15. PM as a series of Phases
• Origination
• Identification
• Initiation
• Design/Preparation
• Appraisal
• Planning (or scheduling)
• Implementation/Execution
• Monitoring and ‘E’
• Evaluation
• Closure
Dereje Teklemariam, PhD Feb 2018 15
16. PM as a series a group of Knowledge
Areas
• Integration Management
• Scope
• Time
• Quality
• Cost
• HR
• Communications (= Stakeholder)
• Risk
• Procurement
Dereje Teklemariam, PhD Feb 2018 16
17. PM : as composition of skills and tools
Dereje Teklemariam, PhD Feb 2018 17
19. Project Implementation
Dereje Teklemariam, PhD Feb 2018 19
Project implementation can be referred to as
a process whereby: “project inputs are
converted to project outputs”.
The PI process involves a series of activities,
which need to be planned, operated and
controlled, and which will inevitably involve
the utilization of resources.
20. Project Implementation
Dereje Teklemariam, PhD Feb 2018 20
Project implementation may be looked at as:
Putting in action the activities of the project.
Putting into practice what was proposed in the
project document i.e. transforming the project
proposal into the actual project.
Management of the project or executing the
project intentions.
21. Project Planning and Implementation: Are
they separate issues?
Dereje Teklemariam, PhD Feb 2018 21
22. Project Planning: A key to successful
implementation
22
NASA’s Rule:
No. 15
‘The seeds of problems are laid down early.
Initial planning is the most vital part of a
project. The review of most failed projects or
project problems indicate the disasters were
well planned to happen from the
start’(Madden and Stewart, 2014:3 ).
One Hundred Rules for
NASA Project Managers
= Read the 13 page
document summarized by
Jerry Madden and Rod
Stewart
Dereje Teklemariam, PhD Feb 2018
24. Project Implementation Process [PIP]
Dereje Teklemariam, PhD Feb 2018 24
The PIP provides guidance on the main phases
in the delivery of a prescribed project.
Experience has shown that all of “the steps” in
the PIP need to be completed to achieve a
successful project, but it is not necessary to
follow the steps consecutively or to go into the
same level of detail for every project.
How many steps should we have in PIP?
Discuss.
25. Project Implementation Process[PIP]
Dereje Teklemariam, PhD Feb 2018 25
Involves:
Project activation, and
Project operation
Project activation
This means making arrangements to have the project
started.
It involves coordination and allocation of resources to make
project operational.
Project operation
This is practical management of a project. Here, project
inputs are transformed into outputs to achieve immediate
objectives.
27. Approaches to Project implementation
Dereje Teklemariam, PhD Feb 2018 27
Top-down approach
Implementation mainly done by agencies from
outside the community with limited involvement by
the beneficiaries.
Bottom-up approach
Beneficiaries implement the project. Outside
agencies may provide the financial resources and
technical assistance.
Collaborative participatory approach
Both top-down and bottom-up approaches to
project implementation are applied in the process.
29. Responsibility Assignment
Dereje Teklemariam, PhD Feb 2018 29
of a project rests
of a project manager
on the
among
The success
performance
others.
Hence, proper selection and assignment of
responsibility is a major task in project
implementation.
But what factors determine the selection
of a project manager? /Discuss/
Answer: Deliverables and Stakeholders
30. Responsibility Assignment
Dereje Teklemariam, PhD Feb 2018 30
The person ultimately assigned as the
project manager may very well be
assigned based upon the size, nature, and
scope of the deliverables.
Deliverables are outputs, or the end result
of either the completion of the project or
the end of a life-cycle phase of the project.
Deliverables are measurable, tangible
outputs and can take such form as:
31. Responsibility Assignment
Dereje Teklemariam, PhD Feb 2018 31
Hardware Deliverables
Software Deliverables
Interim Deliverables
Stakeholders are individuals or organizations
that can be favorably or unfavorably impacted by
the project.
Hence, project managers must interface with
these stakeholders, and many of the
stakeholders can exert their influence or
pressure over the direction of the project.
33. Responsibility Chart:
Dereje Teklemariam, PhD Feb 2018 33
Also Called: RACI Chart
•Responsible
•Accountable
•Consulted
•Informed
RESPONSIBLE: In charge of a particular activity
ACCOUNTABLE: Make the responsible persons to
properly executed the task
CONSULTED : As they may have information/feedback
INFORMED: To make aware of them
34. Project implementation is beyond
RA (Responsibility Assignment)!
SO WHAT IS IT???
Of Course! Implementation begins with the
formation of the project team and follows with the
scheduling and assignment of work packages.
As work progresses the project manager utilizes
a system of reports and controls to keep the
project on schedule and within budget.
Implementation is complete when the project
deliverables have been accepted by the client
and made operational and all final reports have
been filed.
Dereje Teklemariam, PhD Feb 2018 34
35. Project implementation is beyond ...
• Of Course it requires Continuous improvement:
Dereje Teklemariam, PhD Feb 2018 35
37. Pillars in Project Implementation
Dereje Teklemariam, PhD Feb 2018 37
LEADERSHIP
PEOPLE
PROCESSES
SYSTEMS
• In a nut shell, It is the transformation of a theoretical and
planned concept into physical and material structures.
38. The Pillars.....
Dereje Teklemariam, PhD Feb 2018 38
The actual site preparation, buildings,
Equipment, machinery, facilities….etc, and
Being ready to functioning to deliver objectives.
SYSTEM
PEOPLE: Employees
The Organizational framework and structure,
Personnel are hired and trained
Adequate ‘soft institutions’ for managing and operating
PROCESSES
Supply Chain Management ( Procurement),
Maintenance management
Accounting, Marketing and public or stakeholder relations
39. The Pillars
Dereje Teklemariam, PhD Feb 2018 39
A good project leader must have gained prior experience
across the three main areas in the execution of a project, for
example the case of an industrial project:
1. Construction,
2. Commissioning, and
3. Operations activities.
There must also be overlapping skills and knowledge by the
construction, commissioning, and operations leaders.
This overlapping expertise is best demonstrated in the
following figure
LEADERSHIP
41. The Pillars: the leadership environment
Dereje Teklemariam, PhD Feb 2018 41
42. Project Implementation Structure:
Dereje Teklemariam, PhD Feb 2018 42
A good project leader must have gained prior experience
across the three main areas in the execution of a project, for
example the case of an industrial project:
1. Construction,
2. Commissioning, and
3. Operations activities.
There must also be overlapping skills and knowledge by the
construction, commissioning, and operations leaders.
This overlapping expertise is best demonstrated in the
following figure
LEADERSHIP
43. Pillars:
Dereje Teklemariam, PhD Feb 2018 43
Leadership: Creating and sharing the vision,
To create shared vision, leaders should show
commitment to the project in a visible manner, and
these leaders must have the ability to articulate clearly
what the project is designed to do and how to arrive at
that end.
Effective Communication
Incentivize performance (= Motivation skills)!
Honesty and integrity
Team-building
Being Front Line Leader is a key asset in implementation
44. Requirements of frontline leaders
Dereje Teklemariam, PhD Feb 2018 44
COPs= Codes of Practice
SOPs= Standard Operating Procedures
PSM= Process safety mgt stds
46. Implementation Organization
• It refers to creating a structure to the project in
order to fit and integrate it with the parent
organization.
• There are different and hybrid ways of
organizing projects within the parent
organization.
• For instance,
1. The project is part of the functional organization or
pure line organization
2. The project can be free standing part of the parent
organization (project organization)
3. Matrix organization
Dereje Teklemariam, PhD Feb 2018 46
47. Pure line organization or functional
organization
Top management
Division Division Division
Department
Employee
Employee
Employee
Department
Employee Employee
Employee
Project manager
Dereje Teklemariam, PhD Feb 2018 47
Department
49. Matrix organization
Top management
Division Division Division
Department
Employee
Employee
Employee
Department
Employee Employee
Employee
Project mgr
Team leader
Team leader
Dereje Teklemariam, PhD Feb 2018 49
Department
50. Project Organizational Structure
Selection
• Group Assignment 1 (15%):
Explore the different Forms or types of
Organizational structure for Projects,
Identify the merits and demerits of each
structure
State one PRACTICAL example for any
one of the structures you identified.
(Group: Maximum of 6 colleagues)
Dereje Teklemariam, PhD Feb 2018 50
52. Resource Planning
Dereje Teklemariam, PhD Feb 2018 52
The nature of the project and the organization will
affect resource planning
Some questions to consider:
How difficult will it be to do specific tasks on the project?
Is there anything unique in this project’s scope statement
that will affect resources?
What is the organization’s history in doing similar tasks?
Does the organization have or can they acquire the
people, equipment, and materials that are capable and
available for performing the work?
53. RM: Basic Concepts
Dereje Teklemariam, PhD Feb 2018 53
RM is the process by which an organization
acquires and manages the financial, human and
logistical resources it needs to fulfill its mission
[accomplishment of a project].
RM can be defined as a management process of
identifying people who share the values of your
organization and take steps to manage this
relationship.
54. Some tips on resource mobilization
• Supporting conceptual and analytical
skills with:
• Tools
• Programs
• Software
Dereje Teklemariam, PhD Feb 2018 54
Examples:
Microsoft Project :
55. Factors affecting project
implementation
Dereje Teklemariam, PhD Feb 2018 55
Factors that lead to
success of projects
Political Commitment
Simplicity of Design
Careful preparation
Good management
Involvement of
beneficiaries/community
Factors and problems
that lead to failure of
projects
Financial Problems
Management problems
Technical problems
Political problems
56. Factors affecting project implementation
Dereje Teklemariam, PhD Feb 2018 56
Other typical implementation problems
Poor scheduling of projects leading to delays in
Poor scheduling of projects leading to delays in implementation.
Misallocation of funds
Delay and sometimes lack of counterpart funding
Lack of accountability and transparency
Bureaucracy in decision-making.
Selfishness/nepotism/favoritism by some project managers.
57. Factors affecting project
implementation
Dereje Teklemariam, PhD Feb 2018 57
Other typical implementation problems (cont.)
Weak monitoring systems
Natural calamities like drought, earthquakes,
landslides, and hailstorms.
Policy changes
Migration of beneficiaries
Lack of team work
Lack of incentives for implementers.
etc