SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 7
Download to read offline
Apparel Retail
Discussion Materials
Consumer Retail Group
February 15, 2011
Market Trends
US Retail Industry Update
 Current market trends in Retail Industry:
 Pent-up demand, a rising stock market and incremental improvements in the overall economy led to a solid holiday
season in 2010. The combined November/ December sales roses 4.1%, representing the best holiday comps since
2006
 The level of consumer confidence is moving in two directions: with higher-income consumers spending again but still
seeking value, and lower-income consumers remaining cautious on spending. Clothing sales were particularly strong,
posting gains of 11.2%
 Apparel goods are likely to skyrocket due to increasing cotton prices and labor costs in China. The retailers will likely
have no choice but to pass along increased costs to consumer, which would negatively impact unit volumes.
2
NAICS Code 4481 Adjusted Annual Sales for seasonal variations and holiday and trading-day differences, but not for price changes.
Source: US Census as of February 15, 2011 http://www.census.gov/retail/mrts/historic_releases.html
US Retail Industry Structure
Internet Retail Discount Stores
Department Chains
Food Retail
Restaurants & Food
Services
Catalog & Specialty
Distribution
Specialty Foods & Food
Products
Furniture & Furnishings
Retailers
Apparel & Footwear Manufacturers
Footwear & Accessories
Retailers
$3,386 $3,467 $3,618
$3,841
$4,093
$4,313 $4,454 $4,409
$4,129
$4,398
2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
US Retail Industry Annual Sales 2001-2010…
Market Trends
US Apparel Retail Sector Overview
3
 Current market trends in Apparel Retail Sector:
 Apparel sales were particularly strong during the 2010 holiday season, rising 11.2%, more than 10 times pace of the
previous year. Consumers have been continuing to invest in trusted brands
 Rising cotton prices are expected to impact end consumer prices in 2011. While hesitant to raise prices in a difficult
economic environment, both retailers and wholesalers appear to have recognized the need to take pricing action in
order to limit margin declines
 The M&A sector has focused mainly on strategic buyers who continue to target opportunities to grow via acquisitions
NAICS Code 4481 Adjusted Annual Sales for seasonal variations and holiday and trading-day differences, but not for price changes.
Source: US Census as of February 15, 2011 http://www.census.gov/retail/mrts/historic_releases.html
$119 $123 $128
$136
$145
$154
$162 $159
$152
$159
2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
US Apparel Retail Sector Annual Sales 2001-2010 in Billion
Work Casual Denim Going Out
American Eagle American Eagle
Abercrombie &
Fitch
Abercrombie &
Fitch
Urban Outfitters Urban Outfitters
Forever 21 Forever 21
H&M H&M
Express Express Express Express
Guess Guess
Bebe Bebe
Gap Gap
Banana Republic Banana Republic Banana Republic
J. Crew J. Crew
Teens
Late 20’s/
30’s +
20-30s
Source: Company data, UBS EXPRESS Equity Research Report.
Market Trends
Apparel Retail Market Activity
4
Observations
 M&A activity in Apparel has been more than halved in
2010 compared to 2005.
 However, M&A activity in Apparel Retail sector is not
expected to remain at current levels as we continue to see
signs of a healthy backlog of transactions building in the
space.
 Large strategic buyers continue to target opportunities
to grow via acquisitions, as organic growth continues to
face headwinds, given that consumers are cautiously
increasing their spending.
Source: Capital IQ*
As of February 15, 2011
Source: Capital IQ*
As of February 15, 2011
36
30
39
28 24
18
2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
Apparel Retail M&A Activity
Number of Transactions
8.6x
7.1x 7.4x
2.7x
5.3x
8.2x
2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
Apparel Retail Multiples
EV/EBITDA
3
6
2 2
3
7
Q3 2009 Q4 2009 Q1 2010 Q2 2010 Q3 2010 Q4 2010
Apparel Retail Private Placements
Number of Transactions
Source: Capital IQ*
As of February 15, 2011
Market Trends
Nov. 2010 Acquisition of J. Crew Group
5
Analyst Commentary
 “The acquisition of J Crew would make a highly
appealing LBO, as the core company concept
maintains growth opportunities”
 “It’s a great deal for J. Crew shareholders since
estimated takeover value represents a 28%
premium to stand-alone fair value estimates.
There are not many ways to grow the firm other
than aggressive cost cutting and expanding into
bridal and men’s segments, as well as the
Madewell brand”
Leveraged Acquisition Loans Asset Based Credit Facility
Investment Considerations
 J Crew is a leading retailer with multiple sales
channel: 220 retail stores, 85 factory outlets, 20
Madewell stores and online venue
 The company made $1.7 billion sales in 2010
 A top industry management team (Millard
Drexler) that can deliver great results
 Acquiring the firm at an attractive price at
$43.50 per share (52-wk high of $50.96 in April)
(1) Premium to October’s average stock price.
(2) LTM on date of acquisition.
has been acquired by
Transaction Value: $3.0 Billion
Offer Price/Share: $43.50
Premium: 24.6%(1)
Cash Consideration: Equity (38.7%)
Debt (61.3%)
PF Ownership: TPG (75%)
LGP (25%)
2010E EBITDA Multiple: 9.6x
LTM(2)
's EBITDA Multiple: 8.6x
Financing: Term Bridge
Underlying: NA Sr Unsecured Notes
Proceeds Raised: $1.2 Billion $400.0 Million
Maturity: 1/26/2018 NA
Feature: NA 1YR SC@101%
Coupon: L + 350 L + 800
Price: 99.25% NA
S&P Rating: B CCC
Moody's Rating: B1 Caa1
Proceeds Raised: $ 250.0 Million
Maturity: 2016
Coupon: L + 250
 Acquirers took
advantage of cheap
debt and increasingly
regard the stock
market as good value
 J. Crew Group was
acquired at it’s top
performance stage
as a result, this
acquisition strategy
depends on potential
future growth rather
than a simple
management
turnaround strategy
Market Trends
Recent M&A Activity in the Apparel Retail Sector
6
Source: Capital IQ as of February 15, 2011.
Closed Date Acquiror Target Target Description
Enterprise
value
EV/ EBITDA
11/23/10
(Announced)
Leonard Green & Partners,
L.P. and TPG Capital
J. Crew Group, Inc. (NYSE:JCG)
J.Crew Group, Inc. is a multi-brand, multi-channel, specialty
retailer. The company offers an assortment of women's, men's
and children's apparel and accessories. The company conducts
its business through retail, factory, clearance, crewcuts, and
Madewell stores, catalogs, and on its Website.
$2,679.4 8.4x
1/4/11 LF USA Inc.
Oxford Industries Inc.,
Substantially All of Oxford
Apparel Business
Oxford Apparel Business produces branded and private label
dress shirts, suited separtes, sport shirts, casual slacks,
outwear, sweaters, jeans, swimwear, westernwear, and golf
apparel.
$121.7 NA
11/17/10 Lodis Accessories, Inc. Another Line, Inc.
Another Line, Inc. designs, manufactures, and sells belts, and
hangbags for women, offering chain and beaded, fabric, and
leather and woven style belts. The company was founded in
1988 and is based in Lake Forest, California.
$6.8 NA
11/15/10 Signature Eyewear Inc. Rough Justice
Rough Justice manufactures designer footwear for women. The
company's products include platforms, wedges, dress footwear,
sandals, and flats. The company was founded in 2007 and is
based in Inglewood, California.
NA NA
11/4/10 KarpReilly, LLC Adrianna Papell, LLC
Adrianna Papell, LLC designs, sources, and distributes day and
occasion dresses under the Adrianna Papell, Aidan Mattox, and
Hailey Logan labels.
NA NA
11/1/10
Hanesbrands Inc. (NYSE:
HBI)
GFSI Holdings Inc.
GFSI Holdings, Inc., through its wholly owned subsidiary, GFSI,
Inc., engages in designing, manufacturing, and marketing
sportswear and active wear bearing names, logos, and
insignias.
$225.0 7.5x
10/28/10
(Announced)
Charles Komar & Sons, Inc.
Carole Hochman Design Group,
Inc.
Carole Hochman Design Group, Inc. designs and manufactures
sleepwear, loungewear, and daywear for women. The company
was founded in 1930 and is based in New York, New York.
NA NA
Selected M&A Transactions for the Last 2 Years
Market Trends
7.9x 7.9x 7.8x
6.6x
7.9x
8.2x 8.1x
8.9x
10.2x
8.8x
7.2x
12.2x
14.1x
Tommy Hilfiger Claire's Stores Deb Shops Charlotte Russe Tommy Hilfiger Gymboree Barney's May Neiman Marcus Linens n Things Burlington Coat
Factory
Michaels Stores Barney's
Recent M&A Activity in the Apparel Retail Sector
7
Selected M&A transactions for the last 2 years, Source: Capital IQ as of February 15, 2011.
Apex Apollo Lee Equity Advent V. Heusen Bain Jones Federated Consortium Apollo Bain Consortium Istithmar
12/05 3/07 7/07 8/09 3/10 10/10 11/04 2/05 5/05 11/05 1/06 6/06 6/07
$1,547 $2,581 $259 $312 $3,136 $1,761 $400 $17,260 $4,981 $1,305 $1,958 $5,604 $942
Acquiror
Date Announced
Transaction Value
Specialty Apparel Branded
Specialty Apparel Median: 7.9x
EV/ LTM EBITDA
Branded Median: 8.9x
Private Equity Buyer Strategic Buyer

More Related Content

What's hot

Food & Beverage Industry Snapshot
Food & Beverage Industry SnapshotFood & Beverage Industry Snapshot
Food & Beverage Industry SnapshotGrant Thornton
 
Restaurant Monthly Update - November 2016
Restaurant Monthly Update - November 2016Restaurant Monthly Update - November 2016
Restaurant Monthly Update - November 2016Duff & Phelps
 
H.J. Heinz M&A Board meeting On the Proposed Acquisition
H.J. Heinz M&A  Board meeting On the Proposed AcquisitionH.J. Heinz M&A  Board meeting On the Proposed Acquisition
H.J. Heinz M&A Board meeting On the Proposed AcquisitionDebiprasad Dash
 
Us gaap v ifrs dec 2011
Us gaap v ifrs dec 2011Us gaap v ifrs dec 2011
Us gaap v ifrs dec 2011Vanessa Parks
 
Alexia Howard | Transforming Packaged Food | 2016 #FarmToLabel | Keynote Pres...
Alexia Howard | Transforming Packaged Food | 2016 #FarmToLabel | Keynote Pres...Alexia Howard | Transforming Packaged Food | 2016 #FarmToLabel | Keynote Pres...
Alexia Howard | Transforming Packaged Food | 2016 #FarmToLabel | Keynote Pres...★ MIKE SHUR
 
Celebrity Brand Valuation 2017
Celebrity Brand Valuation 2017Celebrity Brand Valuation 2017
Celebrity Brand Valuation 2017Duff & Phelps
 
The Power of Brand in Radical Times of Uncertainty
The Power of Brand in Radical Times of Uncertainty The Power of Brand in Radical Times of Uncertainty
The Power of Brand in Radical Times of Uncertainty BAV Group
 
Ralph Lauren Pitch Book
Ralph Lauren Pitch BookRalph Lauren Pitch Book
Ralph Lauren Pitch BookBrandon Jonas
 
Apparel Quarterly Update - Late Fall 2017
Apparel Quarterly Update - Late Fall 2017Apparel Quarterly Update - Late Fall 2017
Apparel Quarterly Update - Late Fall 2017Duff & Phelps
 
Specialty Retail Clothing Industry Evaluation
Specialty Retail Clothing Industry EvaluationSpecialty Retail Clothing Industry Evaluation
Specialty Retail Clothing Industry Evaluationjschiff47
 
J.Crew Presentation
J.Crew PresentationJ.Crew Presentation
J.Crew PresentationRyan Lagasse
 
Monster Beverages 2011 Investor Presentation
Monster Beverages 2011 Investor PresentationMonster Beverages 2011 Investor Presentation
Monster Beverages 2011 Investor PresentationNeil Kimberley
 
J Crew in 2014: Will it turn around Strategy improve Its Competitiveness?
J Crew in 2014: Will it turn around Strategy improve Its Competitiveness?J Crew in 2014: Will it turn around Strategy improve Its Competitiveness?
J Crew in 2014: Will it turn around Strategy improve Its Competitiveness?Tran Thang
 
Starbucks Financial Conference
Starbucks Financial ConferenceStarbucks Financial Conference
Starbucks Financial Conferencetangtanghku
 
FTC Complaint Sysco US Foods Acquisition
FTC Complaint Sysco US Foods AcquisitionFTC Complaint Sysco US Foods Acquisition
FTC Complaint Sysco US Foods AcquisitionMark Moreno
 
Consumer Foodservice in South Africa
Consumer Foodservice in South AfricaConsumer Foodservice in South Africa
Consumer Foodservice in South AfricaReportsnReports
 
Home Furnishings Industry Insights - December 2017
Home Furnishings Industry Insights - December 2017Home Furnishings Industry Insights - December 2017
Home Furnishings Industry Insights - December 2017Duff & Phelps
 

What's hot (20)

Food & Beverage Industry Snapshot
Food & Beverage Industry SnapshotFood & Beverage Industry Snapshot
Food & Beverage Industry Snapshot
 
Starbucks SWOT analysis 2020
Starbucks SWOT analysis 2020Starbucks SWOT analysis 2020
Starbucks SWOT analysis 2020
 
Restaurant Monthly Update - November 2016
Restaurant Monthly Update - November 2016Restaurant Monthly Update - November 2016
Restaurant Monthly Update - November 2016
 
H.J. Heinz M&A Board meeting On the Proposed Acquisition
H.J. Heinz M&A  Board meeting On the Proposed AcquisitionH.J. Heinz M&A  Board meeting On the Proposed Acquisition
H.J. Heinz M&A Board meeting On the Proposed Acquisition
 
Us gaap v ifrs dec 2011
Us gaap v ifrs dec 2011Us gaap v ifrs dec 2011
Us gaap v ifrs dec 2011
 
Alexia Howard | Transforming Packaged Food | 2016 #FarmToLabel | Keynote Pres...
Alexia Howard | Transforming Packaged Food | 2016 #FarmToLabel | Keynote Pres...Alexia Howard | Transforming Packaged Food | 2016 #FarmToLabel | Keynote Pres...
Alexia Howard | Transforming Packaged Food | 2016 #FarmToLabel | Keynote Pres...
 
Celebrity Brand Valuation 2017
Celebrity Brand Valuation 2017Celebrity Brand Valuation 2017
Celebrity Brand Valuation 2017
 
The Power of Brand in Radical Times of Uncertainty
The Power of Brand in Radical Times of Uncertainty The Power of Brand in Radical Times of Uncertainty
The Power of Brand in Radical Times of Uncertainty
 
Ralph Lauren Pitch Book
Ralph Lauren Pitch BookRalph Lauren Pitch Book
Ralph Lauren Pitch Book
 
Apparel Quarterly Update - Late Fall 2017
Apparel Quarterly Update - Late Fall 2017Apparel Quarterly Update - Late Fall 2017
Apparel Quarterly Update - Late Fall 2017
 
Specialty Retail Clothing Industry Evaluation
Specialty Retail Clothing Industry EvaluationSpecialty Retail Clothing Industry Evaluation
Specialty Retail Clothing Industry Evaluation
 
J.Crew Presentation
J.Crew PresentationJ.Crew Presentation
J.Crew Presentation
 
Monster Beverages 2011 Investor Presentation
Monster Beverages 2011 Investor PresentationMonster Beverages 2011 Investor Presentation
Monster Beverages 2011 Investor Presentation
 
Analysis of Starbucks
Analysis of StarbucksAnalysis of Starbucks
Analysis of Starbucks
 
J Crew in 2014: Will it turn around Strategy improve Its Competitiveness?
J Crew in 2014: Will it turn around Strategy improve Its Competitiveness?J Crew in 2014: Will it turn around Strategy improve Its Competitiveness?
J Crew in 2014: Will it turn around Strategy improve Its Competitiveness?
 
Starbucks Financial Conference
Starbucks Financial ConferenceStarbucks Financial Conference
Starbucks Financial Conference
 
FTC Complaint Sysco US Foods Acquisition
FTC Complaint Sysco US Foods AcquisitionFTC Complaint Sysco US Foods Acquisition
FTC Complaint Sysco US Foods Acquisition
 
Consumer Foodservice in South Africa
Consumer Foodservice in South AfricaConsumer Foodservice in South Africa
Consumer Foodservice in South Africa
 
Smucker Project
Smucker ProjectSmucker Project
Smucker Project
 
Home Furnishings Industry Insights - December 2017
Home Furnishings Industry Insights - December 2017Home Furnishings Industry Insights - December 2017
Home Furnishings Industry Insights - December 2017
 

Viewers also liked

Nyssa 2010 presentation
Nyssa 2010 presentationNyssa 2010 presentation
Nyssa 2010 presentationSai Summer
 
Cost Seg Training 10 2010
Cost Seg Training 10 2010Cost Seg Training 10 2010
Cost Seg Training 10 2010costsegpartners
 
Gilt groupefinal
Gilt groupefinalGilt groupefinal
Gilt groupefinalSai Summer
 
Paper scrubs medici ai primi ferri
Paper scrubs medici ai primi ferriPaper scrubs medici ai primi ferri
Paper scrubs medici ai primi ferriDavide Stucchi
 
Aldo Giovanni E Giacomo
Aldo  Giovanni E  GiacomoAldo  Giovanni E  Giacomo
Aldo Giovanni E GiacomoDavide Stucchi
 
Aldo Giovanni E Giacomo
Aldo  Giovanni E  GiacomoAldo  Giovanni E  Giacomo
Aldo Giovanni E GiacomoDavide Stucchi
 
Voicemail as a science
Voicemail as a science  Voicemail as a science
Voicemail as a science Donato Diorio
 
O voto
O votoO voto
O votoParJov
 
Financing Green Initiatives
Financing Green InitiativesFinancing Green Initiatives
Financing Green InitiativesGobi Canada
 

Viewers also liked (14)

Nyssa 2010 presentation
Nyssa 2010 presentationNyssa 2010 presentation
Nyssa 2010 presentation
 
Cost Seg Training 10 2010
Cost Seg Training 10 2010Cost Seg Training 10 2010
Cost Seg Training 10 2010
 
Presentazione Simpson
Presentazione  SimpsonPresentazione  Simpson
Presentazione Simpson
 
Presentazione Simpson
Presentazione  SimpsonPresentazione  Simpson
Presentazione Simpson
 
Doom 3
Doom 3Doom 3
Doom 3
 
Gilt groupefinal
Gilt groupefinalGilt groupefinal
Gilt groupefinal
 
Paper scrubs medici ai primi ferri
Paper scrubs medici ai primi ferriPaper scrubs medici ai primi ferri
Paper scrubs medici ai primi ferri
 
Aldo Giovanni E Giacomo
Aldo  Giovanni E  GiacomoAldo  Giovanni E  Giacomo
Aldo Giovanni E Giacomo
 
Aldo Giovanni E Giacomo
Aldo  Giovanni E  GiacomoAldo  Giovanni E  Giacomo
Aldo Giovanni E Giacomo
 
Doom 3
Doom 3Doom 3
Doom 3
 
Voicemail as a science
Voicemail as a science  Voicemail as a science
Voicemail as a science
 
Superintendencia Industria y Comercio - Colombia
 Superintendencia Industria y Comercio - Colombia Superintendencia Industria y Comercio - Colombia
Superintendencia Industria y Comercio - Colombia
 
O voto
O votoO voto
O voto
 
Financing Green Initiatives
Financing Green InitiativesFinancing Green Initiatives
Financing Green Initiatives
 

Similar to Retail discussion material

BDO Breakout Session: 2014 Texas A&M Retailing Summit
BDO Breakout Session: 2014 Texas A&M Retailing Summit BDO Breakout Session: 2014 Texas A&M Retailing Summit
BDO Breakout Session: 2014 Texas A&M Retailing Summit Gordon Porter
 
Target Corporation PPP
Target Corporation PPPTarget Corporation PPP
Target Corporation PPPDanGilbreth
 
Banjo & Matilda Investor Presentation
Banjo & Matilda Investor Presentation Banjo & Matilda Investor Presentation
Banjo & Matilda Investor Presentation StanAB
 
Internatioonal business project analysis in us apparel industry
Internatioonal business project analysis in us apparel industryInternatioonal business project analysis in us apparel industry
Internatioonal business project analysis in us apparel industryMohammad Emrul Hassan Emon
 
Apparel Quarterly Update - Winter 2018
Apparel Quarterly Update - Winter 2018Apparel Quarterly Update - Winter 2018
Apparel Quarterly Update - Winter 2018Duff & Phelps
 
Outlook For Commodities
Outlook For CommoditiesOutlook For Commodities
Outlook For CommoditiesRusNewton
 
the biggest Brands by country
the biggest Brands by countrythe biggest Brands by country
the biggest Brands by countrySumit Roy
 
Thor investor presentation 11.30.2015 final
Thor investor presentation 11.30.2015 finalThor investor presentation 11.30.2015 final
Thor investor presentation 11.30.2015 finalThor_Industries
 
2017 06-12 DLA Investor Presentation
2017 06-12 DLA Investor Presentation2017 06-12 DLA Investor Presentation
2017 06-12 DLA Investor Presentationdeltaapparel
 
Journal of Business Case Studies – NovemberDecember 2009 Volu.docx
Journal of Business Case Studies – NovemberDecember 2009 Volu.docxJournal of Business Case Studies – NovemberDecember 2009 Volu.docx
Journal of Business Case Studies – NovemberDecember 2009 Volu.docxchristiandean12115
 
Nihar Patel - DKS HF Report
Nihar Patel - DKS HF ReportNihar Patel - DKS HF Report
Nihar Patel - DKS HF ReportNihar Patel
 
Young & Rubicam Article - Brand Energized Differentiation
Young & Rubicam Article - Brand Energized DifferentiationYoung & Rubicam Article - Brand Energized Differentiation
Young & Rubicam Article - Brand Energized DifferentiationJeremy Kravetz
 
January 2010 atm
January 2010 atmJanuary 2010 atm
January 2010 atmGreg Meier
 
Global 500 brands by finance and branding
Global 500 brands by finance and brandingGlobal 500 brands by finance and branding
Global 500 brands by finance and brandingbrandsynapse
 
Marketing research eddie bauer
Marketing research eddie bauerMarketing research eddie bauer
Marketing research eddie bauerNancy K
 
Apparel Quarterly Update Spring 2018
Apparel Quarterly Update Spring 2018Apparel Quarterly Update Spring 2018
Apparel Quarterly Update Spring 2018Duff & Phelps
 
ProblemThis is a comprehensive problem all contained on this sprea.docx
ProblemThis is a comprehensive problem all contained on this sprea.docxProblemThis is a comprehensive problem all contained on this sprea.docx
ProblemThis is a comprehensive problem all contained on this sprea.docxbriancrawford30935
 
Deal market digest issue 83_15 february 2013
Deal market digest issue 83_15 february 2013Deal market digest issue 83_15 february 2013
Deal market digest issue 83_15 february 2013CAR FOR YOU
 

Similar to Retail discussion material (20)

BDO Breakout Session: 2014 Texas A&M Retailing Summit
BDO Breakout Session: 2014 Texas A&M Retailing Summit BDO Breakout Session: 2014 Texas A&M Retailing Summit
BDO Breakout Session: 2014 Texas A&M Retailing Summit
 
Target Corporation PPP
Target Corporation PPPTarget Corporation PPP
Target Corporation PPP
 
Banjo & Matilda Investor Presentation
Banjo & Matilda Investor Presentation Banjo & Matilda Investor Presentation
Banjo & Matilda Investor Presentation
 
Internatioonal business project analysis in us apparel industry
Internatioonal business project analysis in us apparel industryInternatioonal business project analysis in us apparel industry
Internatioonal business project analysis in us apparel industry
 
Apparel Quarterly Update - Winter 2018
Apparel Quarterly Update - Winter 2018Apparel Quarterly Update - Winter 2018
Apparel Quarterly Update - Winter 2018
 
Outlook For Commodities
Outlook For CommoditiesOutlook For Commodities
Outlook For Commodities
 
the biggest Brands by country
the biggest Brands by countrythe biggest Brands by country
the biggest Brands by country
 
Thor investor presentation 11.30.2015 final
Thor investor presentation 11.30.2015 finalThor investor presentation 11.30.2015 final
Thor investor presentation 11.30.2015 final
 
2017 06-12 DLA Investor Presentation
2017 06-12 DLA Investor Presentation2017 06-12 DLA Investor Presentation
2017 06-12 DLA Investor Presentation
 
Journal of Business Case Studies – NovemberDecember 2009 Volu.docx
Journal of Business Case Studies – NovemberDecember 2009 Volu.docxJournal of Business Case Studies – NovemberDecember 2009 Volu.docx
Journal of Business Case Studies – NovemberDecember 2009 Volu.docx
 
Nihar Patel - DKS HF Report
Nihar Patel - DKS HF ReportNihar Patel - DKS HF Report
Nihar Patel - DKS HF Report
 
Apparel in colombia
Apparel in colombiaApparel in colombia
Apparel in colombia
 
Young & Rubicam Article - Brand Energized Differentiation
Young & Rubicam Article - Brand Energized DifferentiationYoung & Rubicam Article - Brand Energized Differentiation
Young & Rubicam Article - Brand Energized Differentiation
 
global-consumer-goods-m-a-report
global-consumer-goods-m-a-reportglobal-consumer-goods-m-a-report
global-consumer-goods-m-a-report
 
January 2010 atm
January 2010 atmJanuary 2010 atm
January 2010 atm
 
Global 500 brands by finance and branding
Global 500 brands by finance and brandingGlobal 500 brands by finance and branding
Global 500 brands by finance and branding
 
Marketing research eddie bauer
Marketing research eddie bauerMarketing research eddie bauer
Marketing research eddie bauer
 
Apparel Quarterly Update Spring 2018
Apparel Quarterly Update Spring 2018Apparel Quarterly Update Spring 2018
Apparel Quarterly Update Spring 2018
 
ProblemThis is a comprehensive problem all contained on this sprea.docx
ProblemThis is a comprehensive problem all contained on this sprea.docxProblemThis is a comprehensive problem all contained on this sprea.docx
ProblemThis is a comprehensive problem all contained on this sprea.docx
 
Deal market digest issue 83_15 february 2013
Deal market digest issue 83_15 february 2013Deal market digest issue 83_15 february 2013
Deal market digest issue 83_15 february 2013
 

Retail discussion material

  • 1. Apparel Retail Discussion Materials Consumer Retail Group February 15, 2011
  • 2. Market Trends US Retail Industry Update  Current market trends in Retail Industry:  Pent-up demand, a rising stock market and incremental improvements in the overall economy led to a solid holiday season in 2010. The combined November/ December sales roses 4.1%, representing the best holiday comps since 2006  The level of consumer confidence is moving in two directions: with higher-income consumers spending again but still seeking value, and lower-income consumers remaining cautious on spending. Clothing sales were particularly strong, posting gains of 11.2%  Apparel goods are likely to skyrocket due to increasing cotton prices and labor costs in China. The retailers will likely have no choice but to pass along increased costs to consumer, which would negatively impact unit volumes. 2 NAICS Code 4481 Adjusted Annual Sales for seasonal variations and holiday and trading-day differences, but not for price changes. Source: US Census as of February 15, 2011 http://www.census.gov/retail/mrts/historic_releases.html US Retail Industry Structure Internet Retail Discount Stores Department Chains Food Retail Restaurants & Food Services Catalog & Specialty Distribution Specialty Foods & Food Products Furniture & Furnishings Retailers Apparel & Footwear Manufacturers Footwear & Accessories Retailers $3,386 $3,467 $3,618 $3,841 $4,093 $4,313 $4,454 $4,409 $4,129 $4,398 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 US Retail Industry Annual Sales 2001-2010…
  • 3. Market Trends US Apparel Retail Sector Overview 3  Current market trends in Apparel Retail Sector:  Apparel sales were particularly strong during the 2010 holiday season, rising 11.2%, more than 10 times pace of the previous year. Consumers have been continuing to invest in trusted brands  Rising cotton prices are expected to impact end consumer prices in 2011. While hesitant to raise prices in a difficult economic environment, both retailers and wholesalers appear to have recognized the need to take pricing action in order to limit margin declines  The M&A sector has focused mainly on strategic buyers who continue to target opportunities to grow via acquisitions NAICS Code 4481 Adjusted Annual Sales for seasonal variations and holiday and trading-day differences, but not for price changes. Source: US Census as of February 15, 2011 http://www.census.gov/retail/mrts/historic_releases.html $119 $123 $128 $136 $145 $154 $162 $159 $152 $159 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 US Apparel Retail Sector Annual Sales 2001-2010 in Billion Work Casual Denim Going Out American Eagle American Eagle Abercrombie & Fitch Abercrombie & Fitch Urban Outfitters Urban Outfitters Forever 21 Forever 21 H&M H&M Express Express Express Express Guess Guess Bebe Bebe Gap Gap Banana Republic Banana Republic Banana Republic J. Crew J. Crew Teens Late 20’s/ 30’s + 20-30s Source: Company data, UBS EXPRESS Equity Research Report.
  • 4. Market Trends Apparel Retail Market Activity 4 Observations  M&A activity in Apparel has been more than halved in 2010 compared to 2005.  However, M&A activity in Apparel Retail sector is not expected to remain at current levels as we continue to see signs of a healthy backlog of transactions building in the space.  Large strategic buyers continue to target opportunities to grow via acquisitions, as organic growth continues to face headwinds, given that consumers are cautiously increasing their spending. Source: Capital IQ* As of February 15, 2011 Source: Capital IQ* As of February 15, 2011 36 30 39 28 24 18 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 Apparel Retail M&A Activity Number of Transactions 8.6x 7.1x 7.4x 2.7x 5.3x 8.2x 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 Apparel Retail Multiples EV/EBITDA 3 6 2 2 3 7 Q3 2009 Q4 2009 Q1 2010 Q2 2010 Q3 2010 Q4 2010 Apparel Retail Private Placements Number of Transactions Source: Capital IQ* As of February 15, 2011
  • 5. Market Trends Nov. 2010 Acquisition of J. Crew Group 5 Analyst Commentary  “The acquisition of J Crew would make a highly appealing LBO, as the core company concept maintains growth opportunities”  “It’s a great deal for J. Crew shareholders since estimated takeover value represents a 28% premium to stand-alone fair value estimates. There are not many ways to grow the firm other than aggressive cost cutting and expanding into bridal and men’s segments, as well as the Madewell brand” Leveraged Acquisition Loans Asset Based Credit Facility Investment Considerations  J Crew is a leading retailer with multiple sales channel: 220 retail stores, 85 factory outlets, 20 Madewell stores and online venue  The company made $1.7 billion sales in 2010  A top industry management team (Millard Drexler) that can deliver great results  Acquiring the firm at an attractive price at $43.50 per share (52-wk high of $50.96 in April) (1) Premium to October’s average stock price. (2) LTM on date of acquisition. has been acquired by Transaction Value: $3.0 Billion Offer Price/Share: $43.50 Premium: 24.6%(1) Cash Consideration: Equity (38.7%) Debt (61.3%) PF Ownership: TPG (75%) LGP (25%) 2010E EBITDA Multiple: 9.6x LTM(2) 's EBITDA Multiple: 8.6x Financing: Term Bridge Underlying: NA Sr Unsecured Notes Proceeds Raised: $1.2 Billion $400.0 Million Maturity: 1/26/2018 NA Feature: NA 1YR SC@101% Coupon: L + 350 L + 800 Price: 99.25% NA S&P Rating: B CCC Moody's Rating: B1 Caa1 Proceeds Raised: $ 250.0 Million Maturity: 2016 Coupon: L + 250  Acquirers took advantage of cheap debt and increasingly regard the stock market as good value  J. Crew Group was acquired at it’s top performance stage as a result, this acquisition strategy depends on potential future growth rather than a simple management turnaround strategy
  • 6. Market Trends Recent M&A Activity in the Apparel Retail Sector 6 Source: Capital IQ as of February 15, 2011. Closed Date Acquiror Target Target Description Enterprise value EV/ EBITDA 11/23/10 (Announced) Leonard Green & Partners, L.P. and TPG Capital J. Crew Group, Inc. (NYSE:JCG) J.Crew Group, Inc. is a multi-brand, multi-channel, specialty retailer. The company offers an assortment of women's, men's and children's apparel and accessories. The company conducts its business through retail, factory, clearance, crewcuts, and Madewell stores, catalogs, and on its Website. $2,679.4 8.4x 1/4/11 LF USA Inc. Oxford Industries Inc., Substantially All of Oxford Apparel Business Oxford Apparel Business produces branded and private label dress shirts, suited separtes, sport shirts, casual slacks, outwear, sweaters, jeans, swimwear, westernwear, and golf apparel. $121.7 NA 11/17/10 Lodis Accessories, Inc. Another Line, Inc. Another Line, Inc. designs, manufactures, and sells belts, and hangbags for women, offering chain and beaded, fabric, and leather and woven style belts. The company was founded in 1988 and is based in Lake Forest, California. $6.8 NA 11/15/10 Signature Eyewear Inc. Rough Justice Rough Justice manufactures designer footwear for women. The company's products include platforms, wedges, dress footwear, sandals, and flats. The company was founded in 2007 and is based in Inglewood, California. NA NA 11/4/10 KarpReilly, LLC Adrianna Papell, LLC Adrianna Papell, LLC designs, sources, and distributes day and occasion dresses under the Adrianna Papell, Aidan Mattox, and Hailey Logan labels. NA NA 11/1/10 Hanesbrands Inc. (NYSE: HBI) GFSI Holdings Inc. GFSI Holdings, Inc., through its wholly owned subsidiary, GFSI, Inc., engages in designing, manufacturing, and marketing sportswear and active wear bearing names, logos, and insignias. $225.0 7.5x 10/28/10 (Announced) Charles Komar & Sons, Inc. Carole Hochman Design Group, Inc. Carole Hochman Design Group, Inc. designs and manufactures sleepwear, loungewear, and daywear for women. The company was founded in 1930 and is based in New York, New York. NA NA Selected M&A Transactions for the Last 2 Years
  • 7. Market Trends 7.9x 7.9x 7.8x 6.6x 7.9x 8.2x 8.1x 8.9x 10.2x 8.8x 7.2x 12.2x 14.1x Tommy Hilfiger Claire's Stores Deb Shops Charlotte Russe Tommy Hilfiger Gymboree Barney's May Neiman Marcus Linens n Things Burlington Coat Factory Michaels Stores Barney's Recent M&A Activity in the Apparel Retail Sector 7 Selected M&A transactions for the last 2 years, Source: Capital IQ as of February 15, 2011. Apex Apollo Lee Equity Advent V. Heusen Bain Jones Federated Consortium Apollo Bain Consortium Istithmar 12/05 3/07 7/07 8/09 3/10 10/10 11/04 2/05 5/05 11/05 1/06 6/06 6/07 $1,547 $2,581 $259 $312 $3,136 $1,761 $400 $17,260 $4,981 $1,305 $1,958 $5,604 $942 Acquiror Date Announced Transaction Value Specialty Apparel Branded Specialty Apparel Median: 7.9x EV/ LTM EBITDA Branded Median: 8.9x Private Equity Buyer Strategic Buyer