CEPEJ: Найбільше зростання бюджетних асигнувань на суди спостерігалося в Україні

European judicial systems
CEPEJ Evaluation report
2020 Evaluation cycle (2018 data)
Part 2
Country profiles
Council of Europe

French edition:
Fiches pays (Partie 2)
All requests concerning the reproduction
or translation of all or part of the
document should be addressed to the
Directorate of Communication (F-67075
Strasbourg Cedex or publishing@coe.int).
All other correspondence concerning this
document should be addressed to:
xxxxx
Cover and layout:
Documents and publications
production Department (SPDP),
Council of Europe
Photos: Council of Europe, ©shutterstock
© Council of Europe, September 2020
Printed at the Council of Europe
The CEPEJ Report on the
evaluation of judicial systems is
composed of three parts :
f Tables, graphs and analyses (Part 1)
f Country Profile (Part 2)
f The CEPEJ-STAT dynamic database
(https://www.coe.int/en/web/
cepej/dynamic-database-of-
european-judicial-systems)

CONTENTS
ALBANIA 8
ARMENIA 10
AUSTRIA 12
AZERBAIJAN 14
BELGIUM 16
BOSNIA AND HERZEGOVINA 18
BULGARIA 20
CROATIA 22
CYPRUS 24
CZECH REPUBLIC 26
DENMARK 28
ESTONIA 30
FINLAND 32
FRANCE 34
GEORGIA 36
GERMANY 38
GREECE 40
HUNGARY 42
ICELAND 44
IRELAND 46
ITALY 48
LATVIA 50
LITHUANIA 52
LUXEMBOURG 54
MALTA 56
MONACO 58
MONTENEGRO 60
NETHERLANDS 62
NORTH MACEDONIA 64
NORWAY 66
POLAND 68
PORTUGAL 70
REPUBLIC OF MOLDOVA 72
ROMANIA 74
RUSSIAN FEDERATION 76
SERBIA 78
SLOVAK REPUBLIC 80
SLOVENIA 82
SPAIN 84
SWEDEN 86
SWITZERLAND 88
TURKEY 90
UKRAINE 92
ENGLAND AND WALES 94
NORTHERN IRELAND 96
SCOTLAND 98
ISRAEL 100
KAZAKHSTAN 102
MOROCCO 104

HOW TO READ THE GRAPHS FOR
QUANTITATIVE DATA?
Most of the graphs in these country profiles present numerical indicators that read as follows:
f the value of the country is presented by the blue dot
f the European median is presented by the yellow line
f the European minimum and maximum range (without the extreme values) is presented by the light blue bar
HOW TO READ THE GRAPHS
FOR QUALITATIVE DATA?
The graphs below provide information on the country’s answer in relation to the trend in Europe.
For example, in the graph below, the country is in line with the general trend (43 participating states replied in
the same way) pointing out that the authority responsible for recruitment is a mixed authority.
Memb
GDP per capitPopulation 11 431 406,00
Professional judges 13.3
Non-judge staff 43.5
Prosecutors 7.7
Non-prosecutor staff 22.0
Lawyers 163.2
17,7
60,9
11,2
14,9
123,0
Human Resources
(per 100 000 inhabitants)
Judicial Sys
Financial
In Euros, per
↳ Cou
↳ Leg
↳ Pros
Court Taxes
Case-law of the higher court/s Legal texts
http://www.juridat.be; https://justice.belgium.be/fr/ordre_judiciaire/cours_et_tribunaux/cour_.. http://www.e
Judiciary related websites
Recruitment and promotion of judges Recruitm
Recruitment
authority
By an authority made up of judges
only
By an authority made up of
non-judges only
By an authority made up of judges
and non-judges
Promotion authority Same authority as for recruitment
of judges
Promotion criteria Criteria for promotion: Years of
experience
446
455
43 7
1832
1139
Recruitme
authority
Promotion
Promotion
European Median
Selected
country
European Min
(excl Outliers)
European Max
(excl Outliers)

ALBANIA
MemberState/EntityProfile:Albania
CEPEJ(2020)11CountryproﬁleE
Dataupdatedon17/07/2020141304
Exchangerate133,07Avggrossannualsalary4717,00GDPpercapita4460,00Population2870324,00
Professionaljudges12.1
Non-judgestaff30.9
ProsecutorsNA
Non-prosecutorstaffNA
Lawyers86.2
17,7
60,9
11,2
14,9
123,0
HumanResources
(per100000inhabitants)
JudicialSystemNA€
61,30€
FinancialResources
InEuros,perinhabitant
↳Courts5.9€
↳LegalAidNA€
↳ProsecutionServices4.2€
40,79€
2,67€
11,78€
CourtTaxesNA€
7,67€
Judges
Prosecutors
4,2
2,9
3,4
2,4
Salariesofjudgesandprosecutors
Ratiowithaverageannualsalaryatthebeginingandtheendofcarreer
Case-lawofthehighercourt/sLegaltextsOtherdocuments
www.qbz.gov.alwww.pyetshtetin.alwww.gjykataelarte.gov.al
Judiciaryrelatedwebsites
RecruitmentandpromotionofjudgesRecruitmentandpromotionofprosecutorsICTinjudiciary
(indexfrom0to10)
Recruitment
authority
Byanauthoritymadeupofjudges
only
Byanauthoritymadeupof
non-judgesonly
andnon-judges
PromotionauthoritySameauthorityasforrecruitment
ofjudges
PromotioncriteriaCriteriaforpromotion:Yearsof
experience
Criteriaforpromotion:Professional
skills
Criteriaforpromotion:
Performance
Criteriaforpromotion:Assessment
results
Criteriaforpromotion:Subjective
criteria
Othercriteriaforpromotion
Nocriteriaforpromotion
446
455
437
1832
1139
1139
2030
1832
2030
3614
464
Recruitment
authority
prosecutorsonly
non-prosecutorsonly
prosecutorsandnon-prosecutors
PromotionauthoritySameauthorityasforrecruitmentof
prosecutors
experience
skills
Criteriaforpromotion:Performance
results
criteria
3416
464
1733
1535
464
464
2129
1238
1634
3119
49
0246810
DeploymentrateCIVIL4,1
CRIMINAL4,2
ADMIN4,1
Communication
withcourts
CIVIL0,3
CRIMINAL0,3
ADMIN0,3
Courtsandcase
management
CIVIL7,7
CRIMINAL7,7
ADMIN7,7
DecisionsupportCIVIL5,6
CRIMINAL6,2
ADMIN5,6
6,5
5,8
6,0
5,8
4,1
5,4
7,5
7,5
7,4
6,7
7,1
6,7

MemberState/EntityProfile:Albania
CEPEJefficiencyIndicators
ClearanceRate(CR)=(ResolvedCases/IncomingCases)*100|DispositionTime(DT)=(PendingCases/ResolvedCases)*365
IncomingCases=Allnewcasesatthatinstancewithintheyear|ResolvedCases=Casesfinalisedatthatinstancewithintheyear|PendingCases=UnresolvedCasesonthe31stofDecember
ClearanceRate
Civilcases1stInstance97.6%
2ndInstanceNA
HighestInstanceNA
Criminal
cases
1stInstance97.6%
2ndInstance136.5%
HighestInstanceNA
Administrat
ivecases
1stInstance99.0%
2ndInstanceNA
HighestInstanceNA
1,01
1,02
0,99
1,00
0,99
0,98
1,00
0,97
0,98
DispositionTime
171days
NA
NA
80days
280days
NA
89days
NA
NA
200,57
140,51
207,44
121,88
103,62
114,16
241,36
208,57
228,10
IncomingCases/100inhabitants
0.623
NA
NA
0.494
0.141
NA
0.596
NA
NA
2,23
0,23
0,05
1,62
0,16
0,02
0,33
0,10
0,04
ResolvedCases/100inhabitants
0.607
NA
NA
0.482
0.193
NA
0.590
NA
NA
2,14
0,24
0,05
1,58
0,15
0,02
0,35
0,11
0,03
PendingCases/100inhabitants
0.286
NA
NA
0.106
0.148
NA
0.145
NA
NA
Prosecutioncasesper100inhabitantProsecutioncasesperprosecutorCourtrelatedmediation
Received1.63
Discontinued1.13
ConcludedbyapenaltyNAP
Chargedbeforethecourts0.41
2,07
1,04
0,20
0,59
ReceivedNA
DiscontinuedNA
ChargedbeforethecourtsNA
189,65
74,55
16,07
51,61
Note:Therearedifferentmethodologiesoncalculatingnumberofcasesinprosecutionstatisticsbyeventorbyperpetrator.CEPEJcollects
datapercase(event)butsomecountriespresentitbyperpetrator.
Doesthejudicialsystemprovideforcourt-relatedmediation
procedures?
464
Mandatorymediationbeforegoingtocourt
Mandatorymediationorderedbyajudge
3614
2921
AlternativedisputeresolutionArbitration
Conciliation
Mediation(otherthanjudicial
mediation)
OtherADR
482
1337
464
3119

ARMENIA
MemberState/EntityProfile:Armenia
Non-judgestaff66.7
Prosecutors11.1
Non-prosecutorstaff10.6
Lawyers72.2
17,7
60,9
11,2
14,9
123,0
HumanResources
JudicialSystem8.2€
61,30€
FinancialResources
↳Courts5.2€
↳LegalAid0.2€
40,79€
2,67€
11,78€
CourtTaxes0.9€
7,67€
Judges
Prosecutors
6,0
4,1
2,5
www.e-draft.amwww.datalex.amwww.arlis.am
(indexfrom0to10)
Recruitment
authority
only
non-judgesonly
andnon-judges
ofjudges
experience
skills
Performance
results
criteria
446
455
437
1832
1139
1139
2030
1832
2030
3614
464
Recruitment
authority
prosecutorsonly
non-prosecutorsonly
prosecutors
experience
skills
results
criteria
3416
464
1733
1535
464
464
2129
1238
1634
3119
49
0246810
CRIMINAL2,3
ADMIN2,3
Communication
withcourts
CIVIL0,5
CRIMINAL0,5
ADMIN0,6
Courtsandcase
management
CIVIL3,4
CRIMINAL3,4
ADMIN3,4
CRIMINAL4,8
ADMIN4,4
6,5
5,8
6,0
5,8
4,1
5,4
7,5
7,5
7,4
6,7
7,1
6,7

MemberState/EntityProfile:Armenia
ClearanceRate
2ndInstance102.4%
HighestInstance91.3%
Criminal
cases
1stInstance104.3%
2ndInstanceNA
Administrat
ivecases
1stInstance117.9%
2ndInstance90.9%
1,01
1,02
0,99
1,00
0,99
0,98
1,00
0,97
0,98
DispositionTime
194days
58days
98days
215days
NA
50days
119days
302days
77days
200,57
140,51
207,44
121,88
103,62
114,16
241,36
208,57
228,10
2.847
0.143
0.053
0.099
NA
0.067
0.470
0.135
0.031
2,23
0,23
0,05
1,62
0,16
0,02
0,33
0,10
0,04
2.866
0.147
0.049
0.103
NA
0.066
0.554
0.123
0.028
2,14
0,24
0,05
1,58
0,15
0,02
0,35
0,11
0,03
1.525
0.023
0.013
0.061
NA
0.009
0.181
0.102
0.006
Received0.34
Discontinued0.24
2,07
1,04
0,20
0,59
Received30.9
Discontinued22.0
189,65
74,55
16,07
51,61
procedures?
464
3614
2921
Conciliation
mediation)
OtherADR
482
1337
464
3119

AUSTRIA
MemberState/EntityProfile:Austria
ExchangerateNAPAvggrossannualsalary35240,00GDPpercapita43680,00Population8822267,00
Non-judgestaff56.3
Prosecutors4.3
Lawyers73.5
17,7
60,9
11,2
14,9
123,0
HumanResources
61,30€
FinancialResources
↳CourtsNA€
↳LegalAid2.2€
↳ProsecutionServicesNA€
40,79€
2,67€
11,78€
CourtTaxes135.4€
7,67€
Judges
Prosecutors
3,7
1,5
3,7
1,6
www.ris.bka.gv.at;www.findok.bmf.gv.atwww.ris.bka.gv.atwww.justiz.gv.at;www.findok.bmf.gv.at;www.vwgh.gv.at/service/formulare
(indexfrom0to10)
Recruitment
authority
only
non-judgesonly
andnon-judges
ofjudges
experience
skills
Performance
results
criteria
446
455
437
1832
1139
1139
2030
1832
2030
3614
464
Recruitment
authority
prosecutorsonly
non-prosecutorsonly
prosecutors
experience
skills
results
criteria
3416
464
1733
1535
464
464
2129
1238
1634
3119
49
0246810
CRIMINAL8,3
ADMIN8,1
Communication
withcourts
CIVIL9,9
CRIMINAL9,4
ADMIN9,2
Courtsandcase
management
CIVIL7,3
CRIMINAL6,6
ADMIN6,6
CRIMINAL10,0
ADMIN9,3
6,5
5,8
6,0
5,8
4,1
5,4
7,5
7,5
7,4
6,7
7,1
6,7

MemberState/EntityProfile:Austria
ClearanceRate
2ndInstanceNA
HighestInstanceNA
Criminal
cases
1stInstance101.5%
2ndInstance100.4%
Administrat
ivecases
1stInstance89.7%
2ndInstanceNA
1,01
1,02
0,99
1,00
0,99
0,98
1,00
0,97
0,98
DispositionTime
137days
NA
NA
120days
43days
122days
449days
NA
118days
200,57
140,51
207,44
121,88
103,62
114,16
241,36
208,57
228,10
0.945
NA
NA
0.794
0.109
0.021
0.811
NA
0.077
2,23
0,23
0,05
1,62
0,16
0,02
0,33
0,10
0,04
0.953
NA
NA
0.805
0.110
0.022
0.727
NA
0.077
2,14
0,24
0,05
1,58
0,15
0,02
0,35
0,11
0,03
0.360
NA
NA
0.265
0.013
0.008
0.896
NA
0.025
Received5.28
Discontinued4.22
Concludedbyapenalty0.21
2,07
1,04
0,20
0,59
Received1242.5
Discontinued992.6
189,65
74,55
16,07
51,61
procedures?
464
3614
2921
Conciliation
mediation)
OtherADR
482
1337
464
3119

AZERBAIJAN
MemberState/EntityProfile:Azerbaijan
Non-judgestaff26.7
Prosecutors12.0
Lawyers15.7
17,7
60,9
11,2
14,9
123,0
HumanResources
61,30€
FinancialResources
↳Courts5.1€
↳LegalAid0.1€
40,79€
2,67€
11,78€
CourtTaxes0.2€
7,67€
Judges
Prosecutors
7,2
4,4
3,3
1,1
justice.gov.az;jlc.gov.aze-qanun.azcourts.gov.az
(indexfrom0to10)
Recruitment
authority
only
non-judgesonly
andnon-judges
ofjudges
experience
skills
Performance
results
criteria
446
455
437
1832
1139
1139
2030
1832
2030
3614
464
Recruitment
authority
prosecutorsonly
non-prosecutorsonly
prosecutors
experience
skills
results
criteria
3416
464
1733
1535
464
464
2129
1238
1634
3119
49
0246810
CRIMINAL5,8
ADMIN6,9
Communication
withcourts
CIVIL8,0
CRIMINAL4,0
ADMIN6,5
Courtsandcase
management
CIVIL7,3
CRIMINAL7,3
ADMIN7,3
CRIMINAL7,2
ADMIN6,7
6,5
5,8
6,0
5,8
4,1
5,4
7,5
7,5
7,4
6,7
7,1
6,7

MemberState/EntityProfile:Azerbaijan
ClearanceRate
2ndInstance98.2%
Criminal
cases
1stInstance100.9%
2ndInstance98.6%
Administrat
ivecases
1stInstance98.5%
2ndInstance96.9%
1,01
1,02
0,99
1,00
0,99
0,98
1,00
0,97
0,98
DispositionTime
51days
68days
47days
72days
38days
121days
76days
59days
97days
200,57
140,51
207,44
121,88
103,62
114,16
241,36
208,57
228,10
2.334
0.310
0.091
0.125
0.059
0.017
0.178
0.058
0.028
2,23
0,23
0,05
1,62
0,16
0,02
0,33
0,10
0,04
2.320
0.304
0.092
0.127
0.058
0.017
0.175
0.056
0.025
2,14
0,24
0,05
1,58
0,15
0,02
0,35
0,11
0,03
0.325
0.057
0.012
0.025
0.006
0.006
0.036
0.009
0.007
ReceivedNA
Discontinued0.07
2,07
1,04
0,20
0,59
ReceivedNA
Discontinued6.3
189,65
74,55
16,07
51,61
procedures?
464
3614
2921
Conciliation
mediation)
OtherADR
482
1337
464
3119

BELGIUM
MemberState/EntityProfile:Belgium
Non-judgestaff43.5
Prosecutors7.7
Lawyers163.2
17,7
60,9
11,2
14,9
123,0
HumanResources
61,30€
FinancialResources
↳CourtsNA€
↳LegalAid9.0€
40,79€
2,67€
11,78€
CourtTaxes2.7€
7,67€
Judges
Prosecutors
3,0
1,6
3,0
1,6
https://www.tribunaux-rechtbanken.be;https://justice.belgium.be/fr;https://justice.belgium.be..http://www.juridat.be;https://justice.belgium.be/fr/ordre_judiciaire/cours_et_tribunaux/cour_..http://www.ejustice.just.fgov.be/cgi_loi/loi.pl;https://justice.belgium.be/fr;https://justice.belgi..
(indexfrom0to10)
Recruitment
authority
only
non-judgesonly
andnon-judges
ofjudges
experience
skills
Performance
results
criteria
446
455
437
1832
1139
1139
2030
1832
2030
3614
464
Recruitment
authority
prosecutorsonly
non-prosecutorsonly
prosecutors
experience
skills
results
criteria
3416
464
1733
1535
464
464
2129
1238
1634
3119
49
0246810
CRIMINAL4,0
ADMIN5,6
Communication
withcourts
CIVIL1,3
CRIMINAL1,3
ADMIN5,4
Courtsandcase
management
CIVIL5,9
CRIMINAL5,9
ADMIN5,9
CRIMINAL7,5
ADMIN5,6
6,5
5,8
6,0
5,8
4,1
5,4
7,5
7,5
7,4
6,7
7,1
6,7

MemberState/EntityProfile:Belgium
ClearanceRate
2ndInstance104.0%
Criminal
cases
1stInstance99.9%
2ndInstance96.1%
Administrat
ivecases
1stInstance118.8%
2ndInstanceNAP
1,01
1,02
0,99
1,00
0,99
0,98
1,00
0,97
0,98
DispositionTime
NA
NA
472days
NA
NA
144days
370days
NAP
316days
200,57
140,51
207,44
121,88
103,62
114,16
241,36
208,57
228,10
6.712
0.224
0.008
2.261
0.257
0.012
0.146
NAP
0.004
2,23
0,23
0,05
1,62
0,16
0,02
0,33
0,10
0,04
7.548
0.233
0.008
2.258
0.247
0.012
0.173
NAP
0.003
2,14
0,24
0,05
1,58
0,15
0,02
0,35
0,11
0,03
NA
NA
0.010
NA
NA
0.005
0.176
NAP
0.003
Received4.79
Discontinued2.98
2,07
1,04
0,20
0,59
Received623.4
Discontinued388.0
189,65
74,55
16,07
51,61
procedures?
464
3614
2921
Conciliation
mediation)
OtherADR
482
1337
464
3119

BOSNIAANDHERZEGOVINA
MemberState/EntityProfile:BosniaandHerzegovina
Non-judgestaff96.0
Prosecutors10.8
Lawyers49.1
17,7
60,9
11,2
14,9
123,0
HumanResources
61,30€
FinancialResources
↳Courts25.3€
↳LegalAid2.1€
40,79€
2,67€
11,78€
CourtTaxes6.3€
7,67€
Judges
Prosecutors
5,1
2,9
5,1
2,9
www.ustavnisud.ba,https://www.pravosudje.ba/predm/faces/login.jsp;http://www.parlament.ba/,
(indexfrom0to10)
Recruitment
authority
only
non-judgesonly
andnon-judges
ofjudges
experience
skills
Performance
results
criteria
446
455
437
1832
1139
1139
2030
1832
2030
3614
464
Recruitment
authority
prosecutorsonly
non-prosecutorsonly
prosecutors
experience
skills
results
criteria
3416
464
1733
1535
464
464
2129
1238
1634
3119
49
0246810
CRIMINAL4,6
ADMIN4,1
Communication
withcourts
CIVIL0,4
CRIMINAL1,9
ADMIN0,4
Courtsandcase
management
CIVIL7,5
CRIMINAL6,8
ADMIN7,5
CRIMINAL6,6
ADMIN6,0
6,5
5,8
6,0
5,8
4,1
5,4
7,5
7,5
7,4
6,7
7,1
6,7

MemberState/EntityProfile:BosniaandHerzegovina
ClearanceRate
2ndInstance102.7%
Criminal
cases
1stInstance102.1%
2ndInstance101.8%
Administrat
ivecases
1stInstance94.4%
2ndInstance108.8%
HighestInstanceNAP
1,01
1,02
0,99
1,00
0,99
0,98
1,00
0,97
0,98
DispositionTime
483days
466days
215days
293days
64days
63days
392days
470days
NAP
200,57
140,51
207,44
121,88
103,62
114,16
241,36
208,57
228,10
3.237
0.953
0.147
4.345
0.409
0.124
0.220
0.137
NAP
2,23
0,23
0,05
1,62
0,16
0,02
0,33
0,10
0,04
4.064
0.979
0.175
4.435
0.416
0.125
0.208
0.149
NAP
2,14
0,24
0,05
1,58
0,15
0,02
0,35
0,11
0,03
5.383
1.252
0.104
3.566
0.073
0.022
0.223
0.192
NAP
Received1.53
Discontinued0.28
2,07
1,04
0,20
0,59
Received141.9
Discontinued26.2
189,65
74,55
16,07
51,61
procedures?
464
3614
2921
Conciliation
mediation)
OtherADR
482
1337
464
3119

BULGARIA
MemberState/EntityProfile:Bulgaria
Non-judgestaff89.5
Prosecutors21.8
Lawyers194.9
17,7
60,9
11,2
14,9
123,0
HumanResources
61,30€
FinancialResources
↳Courts25.1€
↳LegalAid0.6€
40,79€
2,67€
11,78€
CourtTaxes6.7€
7,67€
Judges
Prosecutors
5,2
2,9
5,2
2,9
www.compensation.bghttp://www.sac.government.bg;http://www.vks.bghttp://dv.parliament.bg
(indexfrom0to10)
Recruitment
authority
only
non-judgesonly
andnon-judges
ofjudges
experience
skills
Performance
results
criteria
446
455
437
1832
1139
1139
2030
1832
2030
3614
464
Recruitment
authority
prosecutorsonly
non-prosecutorsonly
prosecutors
experience
skills
results
criteria
3416
464
1733
1535
464
464
2129
1238
1634
3119
49
0246810
CRIMINAL3,3
ADMIN3,4
Communication
withcourts
CIVIL0,6
CRIMINAL0,6
ADMIN0,6
Courtsandcase
management
CIVIL6,2
CRIMINAL6,2
ADMIN6,2
CRIMINAL3,5
ADMIN4,1
6,5
5,8
6,0
5,8
4,1
5,4
7,5
7,5
7,4
6,7
7,1
6,7

MemberState/EntityProfile:Bulgaria
ClearanceRate
Civilcases1stInstanceNA
2ndInstanceNA
Criminal
cases
1stInstance99.3%
2ndInstance100.5%
Administrat
ivecases
1stInstance99.7%
2ndInstance100.8%
1,01
1,02
0,99
1,00
0,99
0,98
1,00
0,97
0,98
DispositionTime
NA
NA
183days
51days
49days
75days
112days
59days
140days
200,57
140,51
207,44
121,88
103,62
114,16
241,36
208,57
228,10
NA
NA
0.116
2.176
0.183
0.018
0.445
0.210
0.227
2,23
0,23
0,05
1,62
0,16
0,02
0,33
0,10
0,04
NA
NA
0.111
2.161
0.184
0.018
0.443
0.212
0.228
2,14
0,24
0,05
1,58
0,15
0,02
0,35
0,11
0,03
NA
NA
0.056
0.307
0.025
0.004
0.136
0.034
0.088
Received1.64
Discontinued1.12
2,07
1,04
0,20
0,59
Received75.3
Discontinued51.2
189,65
74,55
16,07
51,61
procedures?
464
3614
2921
Conciliation
mediation)
OtherADR
482
1337
464
3119

CROATIA
MemberState/EntityProfile:Croatia
Non-judgestaff143.0
Prosecutors14.6
Lawyers116.7
17,7
60,9
11,2
14,9
123,0
HumanResources
61,30€
FinancialResources
↳Courts41.6€
↳LegalAid3.2€
40,79€
2,67€
11,78€
CourtTaxesNA€
7,67€
Judges
Prosecutors
3,9
1,7
3,9
1,7
www.pravosudje.hrhttps://sudskapraksa.csp.vsrh.hr/homehttps://narodne-novine.nn.hr/search.aspx
(indexfrom0to10)
Recruitment
authority
only
non-judgesonly
andnon-judges
ofjudges
experience
skills
Performance
results
criteria
446
455
437
1832
1139
1139
2030
1832
2030
3614
464
Recruitment
authority
prosecutorsonly
non-prosecutorsonly
prosecutors
experience
skills
results
criteria
3416
464
1733
1535
464
464
2129
1238
1634
3119
49
0246810
CRIMINAL4,8
ADMIN3,7
Communication
withcourts
CIVIL2,7
CRIMINAL1,0
ADMIN0,8
Courtsandcase
management
CIVIL7,5
CRIMINAL7,5
ADMIN6,1
CRIMINAL9,0
ADMIN5,6
6,5
5,8
6,0
5,8
4,1
5,4
7,5
7,5
7,4
6,7
7,1
6,7

MemberState/EntityProfile:Croatia
ClearanceRate
2ndInstance121.7%
HighestInstanceNA
Criminal
cases
1stInstance100.3%
2ndInstance126.2%
Administrat
ivecases
1stInstance115.9%
2ndInstance85.8%
HighestInstanceNA
1,01
1,02
0,99
1,00
0,99
0,98
1,00
0,97
0,98
DispositionTime
374days
279days
NA
147days
160days
135days
197days
194days
NA
200,57
140,51
207,44
121,88
103,62
114,16
241,36
208,57
228,10
2.856
0.915
NA
4.580
0.536
0.047
0.329
0.148
NA
2,23
0,23
0,05
1,62
0,16
0,02
0,33
0,10
0,04
3.212
1.113
NA
4.593
0.677
0.047
0.382
0.127
NA
2,14
0,24
0,05
1,58
0,15
0,02
0,35
0,11
0,03
3.294
0.854
NA
1.855
0.297
0.017
0.207
0.068
NA
Received1.52
Discontinued0.60
2,07
1,04
0,20
0,59
Received104.0
Discontinued41.1
189,65
74,55
16,07
51,61
procedures?
464
3614
2921
Conciliation
mediation)
OtherADR
482
1337
464
3119

CYPRUS
MemberState/EntityProfile:Cyprus
Non-judgestaff48.7
Prosecutors14.0
Lawyers458.0
17,7
60,9
11,2
14,9
123,0
HumanResources
61,30€
FinancialResources
↳Courts42.9€
↳LegalAid2.0€
40,79€
2,67€
11,78€
CourtTaxes8.7€
7,67€
Judges
Prosecutors
6,0
3,4
1,5
xwww.leginet.eu,www.cylaw.comwww.leginet.eu,www.cylaw.com
(indexfrom0to10)
Recruitment
authority
only
non-judgesonly
andnon-judges
ofjudges
experience
skills
Performance
results
criteria
446
455
437
1832
1139
1139
2030
1832
2030
3614
464
Recruitment
authority
prosecutorsonly
non-prosecutorsonly
prosecutors
experience
skills
results
criteria
3416
464
1733
1535
464
464
2129
1238
1634
3119
49
0246810
CRIMINAL1,3
ADMIN1,3
Communication
withcourts
CIVIL0
CRIMINAL0
ADMIN0
Courtsandcase
management
CIVIL2,5
CRIMINAL2,5
ADMIN2,5
CRIMINAL1,9
ADMIN2,2
6,5
5,8
6,0
5,8
4,1
5,4
7,5
7,5
7,4
6,7
7,1
6,7

MemberState/EntityProfile:Cyprus
ClearanceRate
Civilcases1stInstanceNA
2ndInstanceNA
HighestInstanceNAP
Criminal
cases
1stInstance96.1%
2ndInstance82.0%
HighestInstanceNAP
Administrat
ivecases
1stInstance219.2%
2ndInstance84.1%
HighestInstanceNAP
1,01
1,02
0,99
1,00
0,99
0,98
1,00
0,97
0,98
DispositionTime
NA
NA
NAP
273days
753days
NAP
486days
2155days
NAP
200,57
140,51
207,44
121,88
103,62
114,16
241,36
208,57
228,10
NA
NA
NAP
7.769
0.041
NAP
0.223
0.022
NAP
2,23
0,23
0,05
1,62
0,16
0,02
0,33
0,10
0,04
NA
NA
NAP
7.468
0.033
NAP
0.488
0.018
NAP
2,14
0,24
0,05
1,58
0,15
0,02
0,35
0,11
0,03
NA
NA
NAP
5.589
0.069
NAP
0.651
0.107
NAP
ReceivedNA
DiscontinuedNA
ConcludedbyapenaltyNA
2,07
1,04
0,20
0,59
ReceivedNA
DiscontinuedNA
189,65
74,55
16,07
51,61
procedures?
464
3614
2921
Conciliation
mediation)
OtherADR
482
1337
464
3119

CZECHREPUBLIC
MemberState/EntityProfile:CzechRepublic
Non-judgestaff92.6
Prosecutors11.6
Lawyers105.0
17,7
60,9
11,2
14,9
123,0
HumanResources
61,30€
FinancialResources
↳Courts46.1€
↳LegalAid2.0€
40,79€
2,67€
11,78€
CourtTaxes4.2€
7,67€
Judges
Prosecutors
5,5
2,4
4,7
2,2
www.nsoud.czwww.mvcr.czwww.justice.cz
(indexfrom0to10)
Recruitment
authority
only
non-judgesonly
andnon-judges
ofjudges
experience
skills
Performance
results
criteria
446
455
437
1832
1139
1139
2030
1832
2030
3614
464
Recruitment
authority
prosecutorsonly
non-prosecutorsonly
prosecutors
experience
skills
results
criteria
3416
464
1733
1535
464
464
2129
1238
1634
3119
49
0246810
CRIMINAL6,8
ADMIN5,6
Communication
withcourts
CIVIL6,9
CRIMINAL8,0
ADMIN6,2
Courtsandcase
management
CIVIL5,4
CRIMINAL5,4
ADMIN5,4
CRIMINAL7,7
ADMIN4,1
6,5
5,8
6,0
5,8
4,1
5,4
7,5
7,5
7,4
6,7
7,1
6,7

MemberState/EntityProfile:CzechRepublic
ClearanceRate
2ndInstance101.7%
Criminal
cases
1stInstance100.8%
2ndInstance100.5%
Administrat
ivecases
1stInstance88.0%
2ndInstanceNAP
1,01
1,02
0,99
1,00
0,99
0,98
1,00
0,97
0,98
DispositionTime
148days
74days
166days
65days
26days
44days
412days
NAP
261days
200,57
140,51
207,44
121,88
103,62
114,16
241,36
208,57
228,10
3.251
0.554
0.045
0.696
0.230
0.015
0.111
NAP
0.039
2,23
0,23
0,05
1,62
0,16
0,02
0,33
0,10
0,04
3.303
0.563
0.049
0.701
0.231
0.015
0.098
NAP
0.033
2,14
0,24
0,05
1,58
0,15
0,02
0,35
0,11
0,03
1.344
0.115
0.023
0.126
0.017
0.002
0.111
NAP
0.024
Received2.00
Discontinued1.04
2,07
1,04
0,20
0,59
Received171.9
Discontinued89.7
189,65
74,55
16,07
51,61
procedures?
464
3614
2921
Conciliation
mediation)
OtherADR
482
1337
464
3119

DENMARK
MemberState/EntityProfile:Denmark
Non-judgestaff28.5
Prosecutors11.6
Lawyers113.0
17,7
60,9
11,2
14,9
123,0
HumanResources
61,30€
FinancialResources
↳Courts44.0€
↳LegalAid19.4€
40,79€
2,67€
11,78€
CourtTaxes10.0€
7,67€
Judges
Prosecutors
5,9
3,4
2,4
1,4
www.retsinformation.dkhttp://www.hoejesteret.dk/hoejesteret/nyheder/Afgorelser/Pages/default.aspxhttp://www.domstol.dk/Selvbetjening/blanketter/Pages/blanketter.aspx
(indexfrom0to10)
Recruitment
authority
only
non-judgesonly
andnon-judges
ofjudges
experience
skills
Performance
results
criteria
446
455
437
1832
1139
1139
2030
1832
2030
3614
464
Recruitment
authority
prosecutorsonly
non-prosecutorsonly
prosecutors
experience
skills
results
criteria
3416
464
1733
1535
464
464
2129
1238
1634
3119
49
0246810
CRIMINAL5,0
ADMIN3,3
Communication
withcourts
CIVIL9,0
CRIMINAL5,1
ADMIN3,0
Courtsandcase
management
CIVIL6,0
CRIMINAL5,3
ADMIN3,9
CRIMINAL4,2
ADMIN2,7
6,5
5,8
6,0
5,8
4,1
5,4
7,5
7,5
7,4
6,7
7,1
6,7

MemberState/EntityProfile:Denmark
ClearanceRate
2ndInstance95.8%
Criminal
cases
1stInstance99.0%
2ndInstance97.3%
Administrat
ivecases
1stInstanceNAP
2ndInstanceNAP
HighestInstanceNAP
1,01
1,02
0,99
1,00
0,99
0,98
1,00
0,97
0,98
DispositionTime
206days
168days
187days
41days
103days
236days
NAP
NAP
NAP
200,57
140,51
207,44
121,88
103,62
114,16
241,36
208,57
228,10
0.721
0.083
0.004
2.886
0.107
0.001
NAP
NAP
NAP
2,23
0,23
0,05
1,62
0,16
0,02
0,33
0,10
0,04
0.685
0.080
0.004
2.857
0.104
0.001
NAP
NAP
NAP
2,14
0,24
0,05
1,58
0,15
0,02
0,35
0,11
0,03
0.388
0.037
0.002
0.322
0.030
0.001
NAP
NAP
NAP
Received8.15
Discontinued4.32
2,07
1,04
0,20
0,59
Received705.2
Discontinued373.4
189,65
74,55
16,07
51,61
procedures?
464
3614
2921
Conciliation
mediation)
OtherADR
482
1337
464
3119

ESTONIA
MemberState/EntityProfile:Estonia
Non-judgestaff62.1
Prosecutors12.8
Lawyers78.9
17,7
60,9
11,2
14,9
123,0
HumanResources
61,30€
FinancialResources
↳Courts35.7€
↳LegalAid3.1€
40,79€
2,67€
11,78€
CourtTaxes14.2€
7,67€
Judges
Prosecutors
3,7
2,8
3,7
1,6
riigiteataja.eeriigiteataja.eee-toimik.ee,kohus.ee
(indexfrom0to10)
Recruitment
authority
only
non-judgesonly
andnon-judges
ofjudges
experience
skills
Performance
results
criteria
446
455
437
1832
1139
1139
2030
1832
2030
3614
464
Recruitment
authority
prosecutorsonly
non-prosecutorsonly
prosecutors
experience
skills
results
criteria
3416
464
1733
1535
464
464
2129
1238
1634
3119
49
0246810
CRIMINAL9,6
ADMIN9,6
Communication
withcourts
CIVIL10,2
CRIMINAL9,6
ADMIN9,8
Courtsandcase
management
CIVIL10,0
CRIMINAL10,0
ADMIN10,0
CRIMINAL8,1
ADMIN7,8
6,5
5,8
6,0
5,8
4,1
5,4
7,5
7,5
7,4
6,7
7,1
6,7

MemberState/EntityProfile:Estonia
ClearanceRate
2ndInstance97.2%
Criminal
cases
1stInstance97.8%
2ndInstance100.8%
Administrat
ivecases
1stInstance100.0%
2ndInstance111.0%
1,01
1,02
0,99
1,00
0,99
0,98
1,00
0,97
0,98
DispositionTime
143days
119days
65days
35days
20days
68days
118days
81days
206days
200,57
140,51
207,44
121,88
103,62
114,16
241,36
208,57
228,10
1.166
0.146
0.012
1.696
0.156
0.005
0.188
0.099
0.006
2,23
0,23
0,05
1,62
0,16
0,02
0,33
0,10
0,04
1.173
0.142
0.012
1.657
0.157
0.004
0.188
0.110
0.006
2,14
0,24
0,05
1,58
0,15
0,02
0,35
0,11
0,03
0.460
0.046
0.002
0.161
0.009
0.001
0.061
0.024
0.003
Received2.06
Discontinued0.28
2,07
1,04
0,20
0,59
Received160.5
Discontinued21.9
189,65
74,55
16,07
51,61
procedures?
464
3614
2921
Conciliation
mediation)
OtherADR
482
1337
464
3119

FINLAND
MemberState/EntityProfile:Finland
Non-judgestaff38.6
Prosecutors7.1
Lawyers71.8
17,7
60,9
11,2
14,9
123,0
HumanResources
61,30€
FinancialResources
↳Courts50.3€
↳LegalAid16.5€
40,79€
2,67€
11,78€
CourtTaxes8.2€
7,67€
Judges
Prosecutors
3,2
1,5
1,2
http://www.finlex.fi,http://korkeinoikeus.fi/fi/index/ennakkopaatokset.htmlhttp://www.finlex.fihttp://oikeus.fi/fi/index/lomakkeet.html,http://www.suomi.fi/etusivu/
(indexfrom0to10)
Recruitment
authority
only
non-judgesonly
andnon-judges
ofjudges
experience
skills
Performance
results
criteria
446
455
437
1832
1139
1139
2030
1832
2030
3614
464
Recruitment
authority
prosecutorsonly
non-prosecutorsonly
prosecutors
experience
skills
results
criteria
3416
464
1733
1535
464
464
2129
1238
1634
3119
49
0246810
CRIMINAL8,6
ADMIN8,9
Communication
withcourts
CIVIL8,7
CRIMINAL9,4
ADMIN9,6
Courtsandcase
management
CIVIL8,2
CRIMINAL8,2
ADMIN8,9
CRIMINAL7,1
ADMIN6,7
6,5
5,8
6,0
5,8
4,1
5,4
7,5
7,5
7,4
6,7
7,1
6,7

MemberState/EntityProfile:Finland
ClearanceRate
2ndInstance106.8%
Criminal
cases
1stInstance95.4%
2ndInstance94.5%
Administrat
ivecases
1stInstance112.3%
2ndInstanceNAP
1,01
1,02
0,99
1,00
0,99
0,98
1,00
0,97
0,98
DispositionTime
273days
176days
130days
139days
182days
87days
234days
NAP
207days
200,57
140,51
207,44
121,88
103,62
114,16
241,36
208,57
228,10
0.149
0.039
0.014
1.063
0.101
0.016
0.445
NAP
0.112
2,23
0,23
0,05
1,62
0,16
0,02
0,33
0,10
0,04
0.153
0.042
0.015
1.014
0.095
0.019
0.500
NAP
0.107
2,14
0,24
0,05
1,58
0,15
0,02
0,35
0,11
0,03
0.114
0.020
0.005
0.387
0.048
0.005
0.321
NAP
0.061
Received1.65
Discontinued0.53
2,07
1,04
0,20
0,59
Received231.7
Discontinued74.6
189,65
74,55
16,07
51,61
procedures?
464
3614
2921
Conciliation
mediation)
OtherADR
482
1337
464
3119

FRANCE
MemberState/EntityProfile:France
Non-judgestaff34.1
Prosecutors3.0
Lawyers99.9
17,7
60,9
11,2
14,9
123,0
HumanResources
61,30€
FinancialResources
↳Courts49.9€
↳LegalAid7.2€
40,79€
2,67€
11,78€
CourtTaxes0.4€
7,67€
Judges
Prosecutors
3,4
1,3
3,4
1,3
https://www.service-public.frhttps://www.justice.gouv.frhttps://www.justice.frhttps://www.pr..https://www.legifrance.gouv.frhttps://www.conseil-constitutionnel.frhttps://www.conseil-etat...https://www.legifrance.gouv.fr
(indexfrom0to10)
Recruitment
authority
only
non-judgesonly
andnon-judges
ofjudges
experience
skills
Performance
results
criteria
446
455
437
1832
1139
1139
2030
1832
2030
3614
464
Recruitment
authority
prosecutorsonly
non-prosecutorsonly
prosecutors
experience
skills
results
criteria
3416
464
1733
1535
464
464
2129
1238
1634
3119
49
0246810
CRIMINAL4,2
ADMIN7,2
Communication
withcourts
CIVIL1,9
CRIMINAL0,6
ADMIN7,1
Courtsandcase
management
CIVIL8,2
CRIMINAL7,5
ADMIN7,5
CRIMINAL5,6
ADMIN6,0
6,5
5,8
6,0
5,8
4,1
5,4
7,5
7,5
7,4
6,7
7,1
6,7

MemberState/EntityProfile:France
ClearanceRate
2ndInstance104.7%
Criminal
cases
1stInstance100.0%
2ndInstance95.0%
Administrat
ivecases
1stInstance98.4%
2ndInstance97.3%
1,01
1,02
0,99
1,00
0,99
0,98
1,00
0,97
0,98
DispositionTime
420days
465days
336days
NA
309days
141days
285days
327days
200days
200,57
140,51
207,44
121,88
103,62
114,16
241,36
208,57
228,10
2.236
0.290
0.026
1.458
0.070
0.010
0.318
0.050
0.014
2,23
0,23
0,05
1,62
0,16
0,02
0,33
0,10
0,04
2.141
0.303
0.032
1.458
0.066
0.011
0.313
0.049
0.014
2,14
0,24
0,05
1,58
0,15
0,02
0,35
0,11
0,03
2.465
0.387
0.030
NA
0.056
0.004
0.245
0.044
0.008
Received6.64
Discontinued4.54
2,07
1,04
0,20
0,59
Received2201.0
Discontinued1503.0
189,65
74,55
16,07
51,61
procedures?
464
3614
2921
Conciliation
mediation)
OtherADR
482
1337
464
3119

GEORGIA
MemberState/EntityProfile:Georgia
Exchangerate3,06AvggrossannualsalaryNAGDPpercapita3587,00Population3723500,00
Non-judgestaff40.4
Prosecutors11.3
Lawyers123.0
17,7
60,9
11,2
14,9
123,0
HumanResources
61,30€
FinancialResources
↳Courts6.6€
↳LegalAid0.5€
40,79€
2,67€
11,78€
CourtTaxes1.5€
7,67€
Judges
Prosecutors
www.supremecourt.gewww.matsne.gov.gewww.hcoj.gov.ge;www.ecourt.ge
(indexfrom0to10)
Recruitment
authority
only
non-judgesonly
andnon-judges
ofjudges
experience
skills
Performance
results
criteria
446
455
437
1832
1139
1139
2030
1832
2030
3614
464
Recruitment
authority
prosecutorsonly
non-prosecutorsonly
prosecutors
experience
skills
results
criteria
3416
464
1733
1535
464
464
2129
1238
1634
3119
49
0246810
CRIMINAL6,3
ADMIN6,3
Communication
withcourts
CIVIL8,7
CRIMINAL6,2
ADMIN6,3
Courtsandcase
management
CIVIL6,8
CRIMINAL6,8
ADMIN6,8
CRIMINAL5,2
ADMIN4,4
6,5
5,8
6,0
5,8
4,1
5,4
7,5
7,5
7,4
6,7
7,1
6,7

MemberState/EntityProfile:Georgia
ClearanceRate
2ndInstance97.7%
Criminal
cases
1stInstance101.3%
2ndInstance95.1%
Administrat
ivecases
1stInstance94.4%
2ndInstance100.3%
1,01
1,02
0,99
1,00
0,99
0,98
1,00
0,97
0,98
DispositionTime
273days
143days
203days
63days
97days
200days
185days
157days
231days
200,57
140,51
207,44
121,88
103,62
114,16
241,36
208,57
228,10
1.939
0.172
0.058
0.395
0.068
0.022
0.326
0.110
0.044
2,23
0,23
0,05
1,62
0,16
0,02
0,33
0,10
0,04
1.766
0.168
0.046
0.400
0.065
0.020
0.308
0.110
0.034
2,14
0,24
0,05
1,58
0,15
0,02
0,35
0,11
0,03
1.324
0.066
0.026
0.070
0.017
0.011
0.156
0.048
0.022
Received1.85
Discontinued0.73
2,07
1,04
0,20
0,59
Received164.0
Discontinued64.5
189,65
74,55
16,07
51,61
procedures?
464
3614
2921
Conciliation
mediation)
OtherADR
482
1337
464
3119

GERMANY
MemberState/EntityProfile:Germany
Non-judgestaff65.1
Prosecutors7.1
Lawyers198.9
17,7
60,9
11,2
14,9
123,0
HumanResources
61,30€
FinancialResources
↳CourtsNA€
↳LegalAid7.8€
40,79€
2,67€
11,78€
CourtTaxes52.1€
7,67€
Judges
Prosecutors
1,6
0,9
1,6
0,9
www.rechtsprechung-im-internet.de,www.bundesverfassungsgericht.de,www.bundesgeric..www.justiz.de/bundlaender/index.php,http://www.justiz-bw.de,http://gerichtsentscheidunge..regardingfederallaw:www.gesetze-im-internet.de;regardingthelawofthestates("Bundes..
(indexfrom0to10)
Recruitment
authority
only
non-judgesonly
andnon-judges
ofjudges
experience
skills
Performance
results
criteria
446
455
437
1832
1139
1139
2030
1832
2030
3614
464
Recruitment
authority
prosecutorsonly
non-prosecutorsonly
prosecutors
experience
skills
results
criteria
3416
464
1733
1535
464
464
2129
1238
1634
3119
49
0246810
CRIMINAL8,3
ADMIN8,0
Communication
withcourts
CIVIL9,8
CRIMINAL9,8
ADMIN9,3
Courtsandcase
management
CIVIL6,5
CRIMINAL6,5
ADMIN6,5
CRIMINAL8,9
ADMIN8,7
6,5
5,8
6,0
5,8
4,1
5,4
7,5
7,5
7,4
6,7
7,1
6,7

MemberState/EntityProfile:Germany
ClearanceRate
2ndInstance98.9%
HighestInstanceNA
Criminal
cases
1stInstanceNA
2ndInstanceNA
Administrat
ivecases
1stInstance97.1%
2ndInstance93.6%
1,01
1,02
0,99
1,00
0,99
0,98
1,00
0,97
0,98
DispositionTime
219days
262days
NA
NA
NA
106days
435days
442days
228days
200,57
140,51
207,44
121,88
103,62
114,16
241,36
208,57
228,10
1.520
0.112
NA
NA
NA
0.004
0.901
0.061
0.007
2,23
0,23
0,05
1,62
0,16
0,02
0,33
0,10
0,04
1.478
0.111
NA
1.435
0.076
0.004
0.875
0.057
0.007
2,14
0,24
0,05
1,58
0,15
0,02
0,35
0,11
0,03
0.890
0.080
NA
NA
NA
0.001
1.044
0.069
0.004
Received5.92
Discontinued3.37
2,07
1,04
0,20
0,59
Received836.2
Discontinued475.2
189,65
74,55
16,07
51,61
procedures?
464
3614
2921
Conciliation
mediation)
OtherADR
482
1337
464
3119

GREECE
MemberState/EntityProfile:Greece
ExchangerateNAPAvggrossannualsalaryNAGDPpercapita16736,00Population10741165,00
Non-judgestaff38.9
Prosecutors5.4
Lawyers399.9
17,7
60,9
11,2
14,9
123,0
HumanResources
61,30€
FinancialResources
↳CourtsNA€
↳LegalAid0.7€
40,79€
2,67€
11,78€
CourtTaxes12.0€
7,67€
Judges
Prosecutors
http://www.ministryofjustice.gr/site/el/ΑΡΧΙΚΗ.aspxhttp://www.areiospagos.gr/,http://www.adjustice.gr/http://www.adjustice.gr/,http://www.nsk.gr/
(indexfrom0to10)
Recruitment
authority
only
non-judgesonly
andnon-judges
ofjudges
experience
skills
Performance
results
criteria
446
455
437
1832
1139
1139
2030
1832
2030
3614
464
Recruitment
authority
prosecutorsonly
non-prosecutorsonly
prosecutors
experience
skills
results
criteria
3416
464
1733
1535
464
464
2129
1238
1634
3119
49
0246810
CRIMINAL3,8
ADMIN5,5
Communication
withcourts
CIVIL4,6
CRIMINAL3,5
ADMIN3,8
Courtsandcase
management
CIVIL4,9
CRIMINAL4,9
ADMIN7,8
CRIMINAL1,0
ADMIN3,3
6,5
5,8
6,0
5,8
4,1
5,4
7,5
7,5
7,4
6,7
7,1
6,7

MemberState/EntityProfile:Greece
ClearanceRate
2ndInstance97.0%
Criminal
cases
1stInstance59.0%
2ndInstance58.2%
Administrat
ivecases
1stInstance163.5%
2ndInstance114.3%
1,01
1,02
0,99
1,00
0,99
0,98
1,00
0,97
0,98
DispositionTime
559days
662days
331days
NA
NA
5days
601days
563days
1264days
200,57
140,51
207,44
121,88
103,62
114,16
241,36
208,57
228,10
1.987
0.209
0.022
4.364
0.529
0.015
0.562
0.178
0.034
2,23
0,23
0,05
1,62
0,16
0,02
0,33
0,10
0,04
1.714
0.203
0.021
2.576
0.308
0.021
0.918
0.203
0.036
2,14
0,24
0,05
1,58
0,15
0,02
0,35
0,11
0,03
2.627
0.368
0.019
NA
NA
0.000
1.513
0.313
0.125
ReceivedNA
DiscontinuedNA
2,07
1,04
0,20
0,59
ReceivedNA
DiscontinuedNA
189,65
74,55
16,07
51,61
procedures?
464
3614
2921
Conciliation
mediation)
OtherADR
482
1337
464
3119

HUNGARY
MemberState/EntityProfile:Hungary
Non-judgestaff88.9
Prosecutors19.7
Lawyers132.6
17,7
60,9
11,2
14,9
123,0
HumanResources
61,30€
FinancialResources
↳Courts40.8€
↳LegalAid0.1€
40,79€
2,67€
11,78€
CourtTaxesNA€
7,67€
Judges
Prosecutors
3,4
1,8
3,2
1,6
www.birosag.hu;http://www.birosag.hu/ugyfelkapcsolati-portal/anonimhatarozatok-tarahttp..http://njt.hu/http://igazsagugyihivatal.gov.hu/download/4/c9/11000/aldozatsegito_%20tajek..http://igazsagugyihivatal.gov.hu/download/2/c9/11000/A%2BB_%C3%A9krelemnyomtatv..
(indexfrom0to10)
Recruitment
authority
only
non-judgesonly
andnon-judges
ofjudges
experience
skills
Performance
results
criteria
446
455
437
1832
1139
1139
2030
1832
2030
3614
464
Recruitment
authority
prosecutorsonly
non-prosecutorsonly
prosecutors
experience
skills
results
criteria
3416
464
1733
1535
464
464
2129
1238
1634
3119
49
0246810
CRIMINAL9,9
ADMIN8,9
Communication
withcourts
CIVIL9,3
CRIMINAL11,1
ADMIN8,8
Courtsandcase
management
CIVIL9,1
CRIMINAL9,1
ADMIN9,1
CRIMINAL8,8
ADMIN8,2
6,5
5,8
6,0
5,8
4,1
5,4
7,5
7,5
7,4
6,7
7,1
6,7

MemberState/EntityProfile:Hungary
ClearanceRate
2ndInstance105.6%
Criminal
cases
1stInstance101.0%
2ndInstance100.2%
Administrat
ivecases
1stInstance101.7%
2ndInstance97.2%
1,01
1,02
0,99
1,00
0,99
0,98
1,00
0,97
0,98
DispositionTime
151days
112days
228days
58days
64days
60days
108days
91days
228days
200,57
140,51
207,44
121,88
103,62
114,16
241,36
208,57
228,10
1.382
0.156
0.026
3.680
0.384
0.017
0.178
0.024
0.023
2,23
0,23
0,05
1,62
0,16
0,02
0,33
0,10
0,04
1.607
0.165
0.029
3.718
0.384
0.018
0.181
0.023
0.020
2,14
0,24
0,05
1,58
0,15
0,02
0,35
0,11
0,03
0.666
0.051
0.018
0.598
0.068
0.003
0.054
0.006
0.013
Received1.97
Discontinued0.23
2,07
1,04
0,20
0,59
Received100.1
Discontinued11.8
189,65
74,55
16,07
51,61
procedures?
464
3614
2921
Conciliation
mediation)
OtherADR
482
1337
464
3119

ICELAND
MemberState/EntityProfile:Iceland
Non-judgestaff21.0
Prosecutors19.6
Lawyers300.3
17,7
60,9
11,2
14,9
123,0
HumanResources
61,30€
FinancialResources
↳Courts65.6€
↳LegalAid30.7€
40,79€
2,67€
11,78€
CourtTaxes13.3€
7,67€
Judges
Prosecutors
2,5
2,0
2,0
www.domstolar.is,www.landsrettur.isandhaestirettur.iswww.althingi.is/lagasafn/andwww.reglugerd.ishttps://www.stjornarradid.is/gogn/log-og-reglugerdir/,www.island.is,www.logbirtingablad.is..
(indexfrom0to10)
Recruitment
authority
only
non-judgesonly
andnon-judges
ofjudges
experience
skills
Performance
results
criteria
446
455
437
1832
1139
1139
2030
1832
2030
3614
464
Recruitment
authority
prosecutorsonly
non-prosecutorsonly
prosecutors
experience
skills
results
criteria
3416
464
1733
1535
464
464
2129
1238
1634
3119
49
0246810
CRIMINAL6,9
ADMIN6,6
Communication
withcourts
CIVIL4,9
CRIMINAL4,9
ADMIN4,3
Courtsandcase
management
CIVIL8,8
CRIMINAL8,8
ADMIN8,8
CRIMINAL8,0
ADMIN7,7
6,5
5,8
6,0
5,8
4,1
5,4
7,5
7,5
7,4
6,7
7,1
6,7

MemberState/EntityProfile:Iceland
ClearanceRate
2ndInstanceNA
HighestInstanceNA
Criminal
cases
1stInstance92.8%
2ndInstance106.2%
Administrat
ivecases
1stInstanceNAP
2ndInstanceNA
HighestInstanceNA
1,01
1,02
0,99
1,00
0,99
0,98
1,00
0,97
0,98
DispositionTime
NA
NA
NA
NA
244days
486days
NAP
NA
NA
200,57
140,51
207,44
121,88
103,62
114,16
241,36
208,57
228,10
5.817
NA
NA
1.117
0.027
0.001
NAP
NA
NA
2,23
0,23
0,05
1,62
0,16
0,02
0,33
0,10
0,04
3.139
NA
NA
1.036
0.029
0.001
NAP
NA
NA
2,14
0,24
0,05
1,58
0,15
0,02
0,35
0,11
0,03
NA
NA
NA
NA
0.019
0.001
NAP
NA
NA
Received1.92
Discontinued0.26
2,07
1,04
0,20
0,59
Received98.2
Discontinued13.5
189,65
74,55
16,07
51,61
procedures?
464
3614
2921
Conciliation
mediation)
OtherADR
482
1337
464
3119

IRELAND
MemberState/EntityProfile:Ireland
Non-judgestaff21.6
Prosecutors2.2
Lawyers270.6
17,7
60,9
11,2
14,9
123,0
HumanResources
61,30€
FinancialResources
↳Courts27.8€
↳LegalAid22.9€
40,79€
2,67€
11,78€
CourtTaxes9.9€
7,67€
Judges
Prosecutors
5,1
3,1
0,8
www.irishstatutebook.iewww.courts.iewww.courts.ie
(indexfrom0to10)
Recruitment
authority
only
non-judgesonly
andnon-judges
ofjudges
experience
skills
Performance
results
criteria
446
455
437
1832
1139
1139
2030
1832
2030
3614
464
Recruitment
authority
prosecutorsonly
non-prosecutorsonly
prosecutors
experience
skills
results
criteria
3416
464
1733
1535
464
464
2129
1238
1634
3119
49
0246810
CRIMINAL5,2
ADMIN1,0
Communication
withcourts
CIVIL4,9
CRIMINAL4,4
ADMIN0,4
Courtsandcase
management
CIVIL5,9
CRIMINAL5,2
ADMIN1,8
CRIMINAL7,6
ADMIN0
6,5
5,8
6,0
5,8
4,1
5,4
7,5
7,5
7,4
6,7
7,1
6,7

MemberState/EntityProfile:Ireland
ClearanceRate
2ndInstance75.0%
Criminal
cases
1stInstanceNA
2ndInstanceNA
Administrat
ivecases
1stInstanceNAP
2ndInstanceNAP
HighestInstanceNAP
1,01
1,02
0,99
1,00
0,99
0,98
1,00
0,97
0,98
DispositionTime
NA
NA
256days
NA
NA
263days
NAP
NAP
NAP
200,57
140,51
207,44
121,88
103,62
114,16
241,36
208,57
228,10
2.700
0.058
0.006
NA
NA
0.001
NAP
NAP
NAP
2,23
0,23
0,05
1,62
0,16
0,02
0,33
0,10
0,04
1.704
0.044
0.005
NA
NA
0.001
NAP
NAP
NAP
2,14
0,24
0,05
1,58
0,15
0,02
0,35
0,11
0,03
NA
NA
0.004
NA
NA
0.001
NAP
NAP
NAP
Received0.24
Discontinued0.09
2,07
1,04
0,20
0,59
Received106.9
Discontinued41.8
189,65
74,55
16,07
51,61
procedures?
464
3614
2921
Conciliation
mediation)
OtherADR
482
1337
464
3119

ITALY
MemberState/EntityProfile:Italy
Non-judgestaff37.1
Prosecutors3.7
Lawyers388.3
17,7
60,9
11,2
14,9
123,0
HumanResources
61,30€
FinancialResources
↳Courts53.2€
↳LegalAid5.3€
40,79€
2,67€
11,78€
CourtTaxes7.7€
7,67€
Judges
Prosecutors
6,4
1,9
6,4
1,9
https://www.giustizia.it/giustizia/it/mg_3.page;http://webstat.giustizia.it;http://pst.giustizia.it;h..http://www.normattiva.it/https://www.giustizia.it/giustizia/it/mg_1_2.page;http://www.senato.i..http://www.italgiure.giustizia.it/sncass/;https://www.portaledelmassimario.ipzs.it/;https://www..
(indexfrom0to10)
Recruitment
authority
only
non-judgesonly
andnon-judges
ofjudges
experience
skills
Performance
results
criteria
446
455
437
1832
1139
1139
2030
1832
2030
3614
464
Recruitment
authority
prosecutorsonly
non-prosecutorsonly
prosecutors
experience
skills
results
criteria
3416
464
1733
1535
464
464
2129
1238
1634
3119
49
0246810
CRIMINAL4,9
ADMIN6,8
Communication
withcourts
CIVIL7,9
CRIMINAL2,0
ADMIN5,4
Courtsandcase
management
CIVIL8,3
CRIMINAL7,6
ADMIN8,3
CRIMINAL6,1
ADMIN6,7
6,5
5,8
6,0
5,8
4,1
5,4
7,5
7,5
7,4
6,7
7,1
6,7

MemberState/EntityProfile:Italy
ClearanceRate
2ndInstance119.9%
Criminal
cases
1stInstance98.4%
2ndInstance102.3%
Administrat
ivecases
1stInstance136.3%
2ndInstanceNAP
1,01
1,02
0,99
1,00
0,99
0,98
1,00
0,97
0,98
DispositionTime
527days
863days
1265days
361days
850days
156days
888days
NAP
791days
200,57
140,51
207,44
121,88
103,62
114,16
241,36
208,57
228,10
2.550
0.196
0.060
2.145
0.191
0.086
0.083
NAP
0.019
2,23
0,23
0,05
1,62
0,16
0,02
0,33
0,10
0,04
2.624
0.234
0.053
2.111
0.195
0.095
0.113
NAP
0.021
2,14
0,24
0,05
1,58
0,15
0,02
0,35
0,11
0,03
3.789
0.555
0.184
2.089
0.455
0.041
0.275
NAP
0.045
Received4.92
Discontinued3.67
2,07
1,04
0,20
0,59
Received1332.1
Discontinued993.0
189,65
74,55
16,07
51,61
procedures?
464
3614
2921
Conciliation
mediation)
OtherADR
482
1337
464
3119

LATVIA
MemberState/EntityProfile:Latvia
Non-judgestaff89.3
Prosecutors23.5
Lawyers63.4
17,7
60,9
11,2
14,9
123,0
HumanResources
61,30€
FinancialResources
↳Courts32.2€
↳LegalAid0.9€
40,79€
2,67€
11,78€
CourtTaxes6.7€
7,67€
Judges
Prosecutors
4,1
1,9
2,8
2,3
www.likumi.lvhttps://manas.tiesas.lv/eTiesasMvc/nolemumihttp://www.at.gov.lv/lv/judikatura/judikaturas-nolemumu-arhivs
(indexfrom0to10)
Recruitment
authority
only
non-judgesonly
andnon-judges
ofjudges
experience
skills
Performance
results
criteria
446
455
437
1832
1139
1139
2030
1832
2030
3614
464
Recruitment
authority
prosecutorsonly
non-prosecutorsonly
prosecutors
experience
skills
results
criteria
3416
464
1733
1535
464
464
2129
1238
1634
3119
49
0246810
CRIMINAL10,0
ADMIN9,8
Communication
withcourts
CIVIL10,2
CRIMINAL10,2
ADMIN9,8
Courtsandcase
management
CIVIL10,0
CRIMINAL10,0
ADMIN10,0
CRIMINAL9,4
ADMIN9,3
6,5
5,8
6,0
5,8
4,1
5,4
7,5
7,5
7,4
6,7
7,1
6,7

MemberState/EntityProfile:Latvia
ClearanceRate
2ndInstance104.4%
Criminal
cases
1stInstance102.0%
2ndInstance102.4%
Administrat
ivecases
1stInstance105.2%
2ndInstance106.9%
1,01
1,02
0,99
1,00
0,99
0,98
1,00
0,97
0,98
DispositionTime
236days
104days
203days
118days
71days
87days
248days
168days
459days
200,57
140,51
207,44
121,88
103,62
114,16
241,36
208,57
228,10
1.447
0.233
0.056
0.881
0.132
0.038
0.096
0.060
0.044
2,23
0,23
0,05
1,62
0,16
0,02
0,33
0,10
0,04
1.495
0.243
0.061
0.898
0.136
0.035
0.101
0.064
0.040
2,14
0,24
0,05
1,58
0,15
0,02
0,35
0,11
0,03
0.968
0.069
0.034
0.290
0.027
0.008
0.069
0.030
0.050
Received0.68
Discontinued0.06
2,07
1,04
0,20
0,59
Received29.0
Discontinued2.5
189,65
74,55
16,07
51,61
procedures?
464
3614
2921
Conciliation
mediation)
OtherADR
482
1337
464
3119

LITHUANIA
MemberState/EntityProfile:Lithuania
Non-judgestaff95.3
Prosecutors23.8
Lawyers79.2
17,7
60,9
11,2
14,9
123,0
HumanResources
61,30€
FinancialResources
↳Courts28.0€
↳LegalAid2.2€
40,79€
2,67€
11,78€
CourtTaxes3.5€
7,67€
Judges
Prosecutors
3,3
2,2
3,2
2,4
https://www.e-tar.lt;http://www.lrs.lthttp://www.teismai.lt;http://www.teisinepagalba.lthttp://liteko.teismai.lt
(indexfrom0to10)
Recruitment
authority
only
non-judgesonly
andnon-judges
ofjudges
experience
skills
Performance
results
criteria
446
455
437
1832
1139
1139
2030
1832
2030
3614
464
Recruitment
authority
prosecutorsonly
non-prosecutorsonly
prosecutors
experience
skills
results
criteria
3416
464
1733
1535
464
464
2129
1238
1634
3119
49
0246810
CRIMINAL5,7
ADMIN8,5
Communication
withcourts
CIVIL10,2
CRIMINAL3,2
ADMIN9,8
Courtsandcase
management
CIVIL7,7
CRIMINAL7,7
ADMIN7,7
CRIMINAL8,1
ADMIN6,7
6,5
5,8
6,0
5,8
4,1
5,4
7,5
7,5
7,4
6,7
7,1
6,7

MemberState/EntityProfile:Lithuania
ClearanceRate
2ndInstance106.6%
Criminal
cases
1stInstance101.3%
2ndInstance98.4%
Administrat
ivecases
1stInstance87.6%
2ndInstance94.9%
HighestInstanceNA
1,01
1,02
0,99
1,00
0,99
0,98
1,00
0,97
0,98
DispositionTime
83days
107days
159days
54days
60days
94days
128days
385days
NA
200,57
140,51
207,44
121,88
103,62
114,16
241,36
208,57
228,10
3.554
0.447
0.016
0.707
0.192
0.014
0.533
0.139
NA
2,23
0,23
0,05
1,62
0,16
0,02
0,33
0,10
0,04
3.682
0.477
0.019
0.716
0.189
0.014
0.467
0.132
NA
2,14
0,24
0,05
1,58
0,15
0,02
0,35
0,11
0,03
0.844
0.140
0.008
0.107
0.031
0.004
0.165
0.139
NAP
Received2.61
Discontinued1.16
2,07
1,04
0,20
0,59
Received109.7
Discontinued48.7
189,65
74,55
16,07
51,61
procedures?
464
3614
2921
Conciliation
mediation)
OtherADR
482
1337
464
3119

LUXEMBOURG
MemberState/EntityProfile:Luxembourg
Non-judgestaff35.8
Prosecutors9.0
Lawyers487.5
17,7
60,9
11,2
14,9
123,0
HumanResources
JudicialSystemNA€
61,30€
FinancialResources
↳CourtsNA€
↳LegalAidNA€
40,79€
2,67€
11,78€
CourtTaxesNAP€
7,67€
Judges
Prosecutors
1,4
1,4
http://www.luxembourg.public.lu/fr/actualites/2009/01/01-guichet-unique/index.htmlhttp://www.luxembourg.public.lu/fr/actualites/2009/01/01-guichet-unique/index.htmlhttp://www.luxembourg.public.lu/fr/actualites/2009/01/01-guichet-unique/index.html
(indexfrom0to10)
Recruitment
authority
only
non-judgesonly
andnon-judges
ofjudges
experience
skills
Performance
results
criteria
446
455
437
1832
1139
1139
2030
1832
2030
3614
464
Recruitment
authority
prosecutorsonly
non-prosecutorsonly
prosecutors
experience
skills
results
criteria
3416
464
1733
1535
464
464
2129
1238
1634
3119
49
0246810
CRIMINAL6,2
ADMIN4,1
Communication
withcourts
CIVIL3,0
CRIMINAL5,5
ADMIN1,7
Courtsandcase
management
CIVIL6,6
CRIMINAL6,6
ADMIN5,9
CRIMINAL7,1
ADMIN6,7
6,5
5,8
6,0
5,8
4,1
5,4
7,5
7,5
7,4
6,7
7,1
6,7

CEPEJ: Найбільше зростання бюджетних асигнувань на суди спостерігалося в Україні

CEPEJ: Найбільше зростання бюджетних асигнувань на суди спостерігалося в Україні

Recommended

Recommended

More Related Content

Similar to CEPEJ: Найбільше зростання бюджетних асигнувань на суди спостерігалося в Україні

Similar to CEPEJ: Найбільше зростання бюджетних асигнувань на суди спостерігалося в Україні (20)

More from Pravotv

More from Pravotv (20)

Recently uploaded

Recently uploaded (14)

CEPEJ: Найбільше зростання бюджетних асигнувань на суди спостерігалося в Україні