Spray Rodeo Day: A Calibration Field Day for Large-Boom Commercial Sugarcane Spray Rigs
                   Ronald W. Rice (FACAA/NACAA), Palm Beach County Extension, 2976 State Road 15, Belle Glade, Florida 33430 / email: rwr@ufl.edu
                       Leslie E. Baucum (FACAA/NACAA), Hendry County Extension, PO Box 68, LaBelle, Florida 33975 / email: lbaucum@ufl.edu

                                          Abstract                                                                                                    Spray Rodeo Day                                                                                        Station 1: Verifying Ground Speed

National surveys indicate that >50% of pesticide application errors are due to                                                                                                      Expand impacts of annual                                                                          Assumption: Operator’s
improper equipment calibration. Since 2006, the UF/IFAS Sugarcane Extension                                                 Objectives                                               Spray-Smart Workshops                                                                             perceived ground speed
program has organized 5 Spray-Smart Workshops to emphasize hands-on
                                                                                                      Calibrate eight (8) large-boom sprayers
calibrations on multi-nozzle booms, including drift management, nozzle                                                                                                              Provide the opportunity for
                                                                                                      servicing one-fifth (≈ 80,000 acres) of                                                                                                                                Ground Speed Calibration Station
technology, and calibration math demonstrations. Objectives: Expand Spray-                                                                                                           applicators to calibrate their
                                                                                                      Florida’s sugarcane acreage
Smart Workshop impacts with a Spray Rodeo event, where operators calibrate                                                                                                           sugarcane spray rig                                                                   Targeted ground speed (mph)
their own spray rigs, targeting at least 8 large-boom sprayers servicing one-fifth
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           Distance of Run (feet)                            400
(80,000 acres) of Florida’s sugarcane acreage. Methods: Operator/supervisor                                                                                                                     Methods
teams navigated rigs through 4 stations (ground speed verification, nozzle                                                                                                                                                                                                              Run #1 time (seconds)
                                                                                                                                                                       Spray rigs visited 4 stations:
output/pattern calibration, spray pump calibration, and sprayer safety). All                                                                                                                                                                                                            Run #2 time (seconds)
                                                                                                                                                                         1) ground speed verification
calibration data were documented to improve spray records. A 25-question
survey summarized operator/supervisor knowledge regarding their spray rig                                                                                                2) nozzle output/pattern calibration                                                                           Run #3 time (seconds)
performance and knowledge gained at the 4 stations. Results: 18 spray rigs                                                                                               3) spray pump calibration                                                                         Average ground speed (mph) †
servicing 200,000 acres of sugarcane were calibrated, with rig-specific gallon-per-                                                                                      4) sprayer safety issues                                                                                   Given: 1 mph = 88 ft/min = 1.467 ft/sec
acre (GPA) quantified. All operators expressed confidence they were accurately                                                                                         25-question survey (knowledge                                                                       † Ground speed (mph) = Distance (ft) ÷ Time (sec) ÷ 1.467
calibrated for groundspeed, nozzle outputs, and pump pressure. Before the Spray                                                                                         gained; prizes to top 3 survey scores)
Rodeo event, 6 of 18 spray rigs emitted acceptable nozzle spray patterns while the
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      Fact: Operator’s actual
remaining two-thirds had significant errors. Comparing target GPA vs. actual GPA,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      measured ground speed
5 rigs were within 5% accuracy, 12 were within 10% accuracy, and 5 exceeded a
10% error rate. Conclusions: By quantifying calibration errors, this Spray Rodeo
                                                                                                                                            Station 2: Nozzle Calibration
event identified appropriate adjustments, allowing spray operator/supervisor
teams to accurately calibrate their large-boom sprayers for the 2011 spray season.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 Station 3: Pump Calibration
Savings (costs and environment) are significant. One large-boom rig servicing
60,000 acres/season, spraying 10% over target rate, would over-apply roughly
$150,000 of unnecessary pesticide.                                                                                                                                                                                                        The John Deere SPRAYSTAR system auto-
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           calibrates to provide optimal control for
                                     Why Calibrate ?                                                                                                                                                                                       many spray event set-ups
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          Calibration is needed if display shows
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           either A or B parameter as out-of-range:
      Over                 increased
                         chance of crop
                                                 environmental
                                                  impacts from
                                                                        wasted product
                                                                          (increased                    Spray Rodeo Day
                                                                                                                                                          Spray Operator:
                                                                                                                                                              Supervisor:
                                                                                                                                                                             xxx
                                                                                                                                                                             yyy
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             • A range = 2500 – 3600
   applications              injury              off-label rates             costs)                                                                       Company/Farm:      zzz
                                                                                                                                                                                                          Manually enter nozzle
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             • B range = 5500 – 7300
                                                                                                                                                             Spray Rig ID:   John Deere 6
                                                                                                               Station #2                                           Date:    11 January, 2012             volumes into the Excel
                                                                                                             Volume Nozzle status                                                                         spreadsheet                                                             Calibration is needed if any of these
                                                                                                     Nozzle
              Under                  poor pest
                                                             need for re-         yield losses to   number
                                                                                                            collected High / Low Limits                                                                                                                                            have been modified, repaired, or
                                                             application               pests                 ounces     10%      5%
            applications              control
                                                            (higher costs)         (less income)       1        27       ok       ok                    General Info - Manual Entry
                                                                                                                                                                                                          Manually enter nozzle                                                    replaced:
                                                                                                                                                                                                          specifications
                                                                                                       2        29       ok       ok                              Pressure (psi)      40                                                                                             • Solution pump/hydraulic motor
                                                                                                       3        29       ok       ok                        Nozzle type/brand        A.I.
                                                                                                       4        27       ok       ok                                Nozzle size     11008                                                                                            • Proportional valve
Nebraska:        66% of the pesticide applicators                                                      5        28       ok       ok                     Nozzle capacity (gpm)       0.8                                                                                             • Hydraulic pump
                 had GPA errors > 5%
                                                                   Spray applicators that              6        28       ok       ok
                                                                                                       7        27       ok       ok                 Calibration Data - Manual Entry                                                                                                 • Spray rate controller
                                                                   calibrated > 1 time per
North Dakota: 60% of tested sprayers had                                                               8        29       ok       ok                Average run time, seconds        21
                                                                                                                                                                                                          Equations in the                                                        Calibration takes 2 minutes
                                                                   year …..                            9        25     LOW      LOW                        Ground speed (mph)       12.75
              calibration errors > 10%                                                                10        28       ok       ok                    Nozzle spacing (inches)      20                   “Nozzle Status” column
                                                                                                                                                                                                          indicate status after
Most errors were due to improper calibrations                      ….. 75% were within 5%             11        31     HIGH     HIGH           Nozzle collection time (seconds)      15
                                                                                                                                                                                                          manually entering
                                                                                                      12        29       ok       ok
and/or worn nozzles                                                of their target GPA                13        29       ok       ok                 Nozzle Volumes - Auto-calculated                     nozzle volume                                                  Results / Impacts
                                                                                                      14        28       ok       ok                         Number of nozzles        48
                                                                                                      15        28       ok       ok             Total volume sprayed (ounces)      1,343
                                                                                                      16        30       ok     HIGH           Average volume/nozzle (ounces)        28.0                                                 Eighteen (18) large-boom sprayers servicing ≈ 200,000 acres of Florida’s
                                                                                                      17        30       ok     HIGH                    Plus/minus range (%) =    10      5               All entries in this               sugarcane acreage were calibrated at Spray Rodeo Day
                                                                                                      18        30       ok     HIGH         HIGH LIMIT nozzle volume (ounces) 30.8 29.4                  section are calculated
                                                                                                      19        27       ok       ok         LOW LIMIT nozzle volume (ounces) 25.2 26.6                   on-the-fly when nozzle          706 nozzles tested were tested (≈ ¼ mile of boom length was calibrated)
                               Spray Smart Workshops                                                  20        27       ok       ok                                                                      volumes are entered
                                                                                                      21        29       ok       ok             Spray Application Rate - Auto-calculated
                                                                                                      22        28       ok       ok                                  Constant           5,940            Values in the “Nozzle
 Traditional Annual Calibration Training - Everglades Agricultural Area                               23        28       ok       ok               gpm (single average nozzle)           0.874            Status” column are re-          Table 1. Percentage of nozzles that were bad (out-of-range)
                                                                                                      24        27       ok       ok                                       mph           12.75            calculated as new data
                                                                                                      25        27       ok       ok               W (nozzle spacing in inches)             20            are entered
PowerPoints                                                Hands-on Calibration Activities                                                                                                                                                 No problems            < 5%                5% to 10%                    > 10%
                                                                                                      26        26       ok     LOW
 • 1/128 calibration method (with math                         • large boom sprayer                   27        28       ok       ok
                                                                                                                                                                                                          Based on the nozzle                  6 rigs             4 rigs                 4 rigs                    4 rigs
                                                                                                      28        28       ok       ok
                                                                                                                                                    Target gallons/acre (GPA) =             18.64         specifications entered
   exercise worksheets)                                        • backpack spot-sprayer                29        29       ok       ok
                                                                                                                                                                                                          under “General Info”
                                                                                                      30        27       ok       ok                                                                                                           33 %               22 %                    22 %                      22 %
 • banded vs. broadcast applications                           • math worksheets                      31        28       ok       ok
                                                                                                                                                    Actual gallons/acre (GPA) =             20.37
                                                                                                                                                                                                          Calculated on-the-fly
                                                                                                      32        29       ok       ok                                                                      when nozzle volumes
 • pesticide drift and                                                                                33        27       ok       ok
                                                                                                                                                 Actual vs. Target GPA % Difference         9.3%
                                                                                                                                                                                                          are entered
   droplet size demos                                                                                 34        27       ok       ok                                                                                                                                         Spray Rodeo addressed this 44% error
 • new chemistries
 • label updates                                                                                                                          John Deere Rig 6
                                                                                                                                                                                                    Graph is auto-generated               Table 2. Comparing Actual vs. Target GPA % Differences
 • surfactants                                                                                                                                                                                      when nozzle volume data
                                                                                                                                                                                                    are entered into the Excel               Within 1%          1% to 5%               5% to 10%                    > 10%
 • container recycling                                                                                                                                                                              spreadsheet
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                1 rig             4 rigs                  8 rigs                    5 rigs
                                                                                                                                                                                                         Total of 48 nozzles
                                                                                                                                                                                                       Using ± 10% error limits:                6%                 22 %                   44 %                      28 %
                                                                                                                                                                                                    2 nozzles out-of-range (4.2%)

 Grower Feedback: “Spray Smart Workshops are great … but we                                                                                                                                             Using ± 5% error limits:
                                                                                                                                                                                                    6 nozzles out-of-range (12.5%)
                  want to calibrate OUR large-boom spray rigs”                                                                                                                                                                                                               Spray Rodeo addressed this 72% error
                                                                                                                                                                                                        Spray Rodeo Product
                                                                                                                                                                                                    The spray operator receives a
                                                                                                                                                                                                    hard-copy of the spreadsheet         One large-boom spray rig,
                                                                                                                                                                                                    as well as the graph
                                                                                                                                                                                                    Nozzle corrections can be made
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           servicing 60,000 sugarcane acres/season,
                                                                                                                                                                                                    on the spot followed by                    spraying 10% over desired Target GPA rate,
                                                                                                                                                                                                    another nozzle testing to
                                                                                                                                                                                                    finalize the spray rig calibration             would over-apply ≈ $150,000/season of unnecessary pesticide

Rice 2012 nacaa poster spray rodeo sugarcane

  • 1.
    Spray Rodeo Day:A Calibration Field Day for Large-Boom Commercial Sugarcane Spray Rigs Ronald W. Rice (FACAA/NACAA), Palm Beach County Extension, 2976 State Road 15, Belle Glade, Florida 33430 / email: rwr@ufl.edu Leslie E. Baucum (FACAA/NACAA), Hendry County Extension, PO Box 68, LaBelle, Florida 33975 / email: lbaucum@ufl.edu Abstract Spray Rodeo Day Station 1: Verifying Ground Speed National surveys indicate that >50% of pesticide application errors are due to  Expand impacts of annual Assumption: Operator’s improper equipment calibration. Since 2006, the UF/IFAS Sugarcane Extension Objectives Spray-Smart Workshops perceived ground speed program has organized 5 Spray-Smart Workshops to emphasize hands-on Calibrate eight (8) large-boom sprayers calibrations on multi-nozzle booms, including drift management, nozzle  Provide the opportunity for servicing one-fifth (≈ 80,000 acres) of Ground Speed Calibration Station technology, and calibration math demonstrations. Objectives: Expand Spray- applicators to calibrate their Florida’s sugarcane acreage Smart Workshop impacts with a Spray Rodeo event, where operators calibrate sugarcane spray rig Targeted ground speed (mph) their own spray rigs, targeting at least 8 large-boom sprayers servicing one-fifth Distance of Run (feet) 400 (80,000 acres) of Florida’s sugarcane acreage. Methods: Operator/supervisor Methods teams navigated rigs through 4 stations (ground speed verification, nozzle Run #1 time (seconds)  Spray rigs visited 4 stations: output/pattern calibration, spray pump calibration, and sprayer safety). All Run #2 time (seconds) 1) ground speed verification calibration data were documented to improve spray records. A 25-question survey summarized operator/supervisor knowledge regarding their spray rig 2) nozzle output/pattern calibration Run #3 time (seconds) performance and knowledge gained at the 4 stations. Results: 18 spray rigs 3) spray pump calibration Average ground speed (mph) † servicing 200,000 acres of sugarcane were calibrated, with rig-specific gallon-per- 4) sprayer safety issues Given: 1 mph = 88 ft/min = 1.467 ft/sec acre (GPA) quantified. All operators expressed confidence they were accurately  25-question survey (knowledge † Ground speed (mph) = Distance (ft) ÷ Time (sec) ÷ 1.467 calibrated for groundspeed, nozzle outputs, and pump pressure. Before the Spray gained; prizes to top 3 survey scores) Rodeo event, 6 of 18 spray rigs emitted acceptable nozzle spray patterns while the Fact: Operator’s actual remaining two-thirds had significant errors. Comparing target GPA vs. actual GPA, measured ground speed 5 rigs were within 5% accuracy, 12 were within 10% accuracy, and 5 exceeded a 10% error rate. Conclusions: By quantifying calibration errors, this Spray Rodeo Station 2: Nozzle Calibration event identified appropriate adjustments, allowing spray operator/supervisor teams to accurately calibrate their large-boom sprayers for the 2011 spray season. Station 3: Pump Calibration Savings (costs and environment) are significant. One large-boom rig servicing 60,000 acres/season, spraying 10% over target rate, would over-apply roughly $150,000 of unnecessary pesticide.  The John Deere SPRAYSTAR system auto- calibrates to provide optimal control for Why Calibrate ? many spray event set-ups  Calibration is needed if display shows either A or B parameter as out-of-range: Over increased chance of crop environmental impacts from wasted product (increased Spray Rodeo Day Spray Operator: Supervisor: xxx yyy • A range = 2500 – 3600 applications injury off-label rates costs) Company/Farm: zzz Manually enter nozzle • B range = 5500 – 7300 Spray Rig ID: John Deere 6 Station #2 Date: 11 January, 2012 volumes into the Excel Volume Nozzle status spreadsheet  Calibration is needed if any of these Nozzle Under poor pest need for re- yield losses to number collected High / Low Limits have been modified, repaired, or application pests ounces 10% 5% applications control (higher costs) (less income) 1 27 ok ok General Info - Manual Entry Manually enter nozzle replaced: specifications 2 29 ok ok Pressure (psi) 40 • Solution pump/hydraulic motor 3 29 ok ok Nozzle type/brand A.I. 4 27 ok ok Nozzle size 11008 • Proportional valve Nebraska: 66% of the pesticide applicators 5 28 ok ok Nozzle capacity (gpm) 0.8 • Hydraulic pump had GPA errors > 5% Spray applicators that 6 28 ok ok 7 27 ok ok Calibration Data - Manual Entry • Spray rate controller calibrated > 1 time per North Dakota: 60% of tested sprayers had 8 29 ok ok Average run time, seconds 21 Equations in the  Calibration takes 2 minutes year ….. 9 25 LOW LOW Ground speed (mph) 12.75 calibration errors > 10% 10 28 ok ok Nozzle spacing (inches) 20 “Nozzle Status” column indicate status after Most errors were due to improper calibrations ….. 75% were within 5% 11 31 HIGH HIGH Nozzle collection time (seconds) 15 manually entering 12 29 ok ok and/or worn nozzles of their target GPA 13 29 ok ok Nozzle Volumes - Auto-calculated nozzle volume Results / Impacts 14 28 ok ok Number of nozzles 48 15 28 ok ok Total volume sprayed (ounces) 1,343 16 30 ok HIGH Average volume/nozzle (ounces) 28.0  Eighteen (18) large-boom sprayers servicing ≈ 200,000 acres of Florida’s 17 30 ok HIGH Plus/minus range (%) = 10 5 All entries in this sugarcane acreage were calibrated at Spray Rodeo Day 18 30 ok HIGH HIGH LIMIT nozzle volume (ounces) 30.8 29.4 section are calculated 19 27 ok ok LOW LIMIT nozzle volume (ounces) 25.2 26.6 on-the-fly when nozzle  706 nozzles tested were tested (≈ ¼ mile of boom length was calibrated) Spray Smart Workshops 20 27 ok ok volumes are entered 21 29 ok ok Spray Application Rate - Auto-calculated 22 28 ok ok Constant 5,940 Values in the “Nozzle Traditional Annual Calibration Training - Everglades Agricultural Area 23 28 ok ok gpm (single average nozzle) 0.874 Status” column are re- Table 1. Percentage of nozzles that were bad (out-of-range) 24 27 ok ok mph 12.75 calculated as new data 25 27 ok ok W (nozzle spacing in inches) 20 are entered PowerPoints Hands-on Calibration Activities No problems < 5% 5% to 10% > 10% 26 26 ok LOW • 1/128 calibration method (with math • large boom sprayer 27 28 ok ok Based on the nozzle 6 rigs 4 rigs 4 rigs 4 rigs 28 28 ok ok Target gallons/acre (GPA) = 18.64 specifications entered exercise worksheets) • backpack spot-sprayer 29 29 ok ok under “General Info” 30 27 ok ok 33 % 22 % 22 % 22 % • banded vs. broadcast applications • math worksheets 31 28 ok ok Actual gallons/acre (GPA) = 20.37 Calculated on-the-fly 32 29 ok ok when nozzle volumes • pesticide drift and 33 27 ok ok Actual vs. Target GPA % Difference 9.3% are entered droplet size demos 34 27 ok ok Spray Rodeo addressed this 44% error • new chemistries • label updates John Deere Rig 6 Graph is auto-generated Table 2. Comparing Actual vs. Target GPA % Differences • surfactants when nozzle volume data are entered into the Excel Within 1% 1% to 5% 5% to 10% > 10% • container recycling spreadsheet 1 rig 4 rigs 8 rigs 5 rigs Total of 48 nozzles Using ± 10% error limits: 6% 22 % 44 % 28 % 2 nozzles out-of-range (4.2%) Grower Feedback: “Spray Smart Workshops are great … but we Using ± 5% error limits: 6 nozzles out-of-range (12.5%) want to calibrate OUR large-boom spray rigs” Spray Rodeo addressed this 72% error Spray Rodeo Product The spray operator receives a hard-copy of the spreadsheet One large-boom spray rig, as well as the graph Nozzle corrections can be made servicing 60,000 sugarcane acres/season, on the spot followed by spraying 10% over desired Target GPA rate, another nozzle testing to finalize the spray rig calibration would over-apply ≈ $150,000/season of unnecessary pesticide