SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 35
Download to read offline
Email: lidingshan@gmail.com
Blog: http://www.agileinone.net/
Twitter: @lidingshan
I am a …
And I am supposed to …
My enemy is …
The first challenge is …
The second one is …
A Story
A COOL Product Team
We heard a lot about …
Survey & Interview



               In which stage, did
               you feel there were
               significant waiting


             If you could do
             anything, please tell
             ONE thing that you
             want to improve
Value Stream for Check-in procedure
                       Each Dev will has
                                           What will happen
                       a different build
                                            if there were
                         version in the
                                            conflicts after
                        queue that wait
                                              code sync?
                            for test


Change                      Test on         Sync                       Install
         Local Build                                      Check-In
 Codes                     Test Farm       Codes                        Build

         2 hr.                    6 hr.
                                                              2 days

                  12 hrs.                    ?
  The team will get the feedback after 3~4 days
       when complete some codes update
There were huge waste on …




Averagely there will be about 1.5 hours wasted in
     each working day for each developer
• Productivity
• Quality
• Team Motivation
We must convince the BOSS to …
We tell boss that …


Average Wasted Time / Per Day / Per 1.5 hours
Dev
Total Wasted Time for Team / Per Day 70 * 1.5 = 105 hours
Total Wasted Time for the Team in    105 * 20 * 10
One Release (about 10 months)        = 21,000 hours
                                     = 131 man month
Average Cost / Per Man Month         $$$$$
                Total Wasted Money…
Proposed solution …

High                                               Refactor legacy      High
                                                     system and
                                                automation test cases




                                                                        Cost of Change
                               Optimize
Improve Quality




                              integration
                                process
                                                  Increase test farm
                                                     performance




                                       Increase team’s
                                     machine performance

Low                                                                     Low
                  Low   Improve Productivity                     High
Estimated Return of H/W Investment




     Waste time     Productivity

Can save about USD $$$$$$ in ONE release
Half a Year Later …
Total test time for retrieval                   Average test time / per case
                           tests                                   for retrieval tests
              80000.00                                        1500.00




                                                Time (sec.)
Time (sec.)




              60000.00                                        1000.00
              40000.00
              20000.00                                         500.00
                  0.00                                           0.00
                           New          Old                                New        Old
                           Farm        Farm                                Farm      Farm
                 Series1 28876.37    68501.59                   Series1   437.52    1037.90



                         Productivity Increase: 57.9%
total test time for smoke test                   average test time / per test
              60000.00                                             case for smoke test
Time (sec.)




              40000.00                                         150.00




                                                 Time (sec.)
                                                               100.00
              20000.00
                                                                50.00
                  0.00                                           0.00
                             New         Old                              New          Old
                             Farm       Fram                              Farm        Farm
                 Series1   33585.04   51436.06                  Series1   89.32      136.80




                         Productivity Increase: 34.7%
Average Time of Complete Build(mins.)
         160
         140
         120
         100
          80
          60
          40
          20
           0
                  New Workstation   Old PC
Average Time of
   Complete             50           150
  Build(mins.)



Productivity Increase: 66.7%
• Quality
• Team Motivation
1st learning is …
So, don’t just complain but …
2nd learning is …
It is NOT the END …
Code base is growing bigger & bigger
Next …

High                                               Refactor legacy      High
                                                     system and
                                                automation test cases




                                                                        Cost of Change
                               Optimize
Improve Quality




                              integration
                                process
                                                  Increase test farm
                                                     performance




                                       Increase team’s
                                     machine performance

Low                                                                     Low
                  Low   Improve Productivity                     High
How does scrum master remove org impediment
How does scrum master remove org impediment

More Related Content

Similar to How does scrum master remove org impediment

AddQ Testautomatiseringserfarenheter
AddQ TestautomatiseringserfarenheterAddQ Testautomatiseringserfarenheter
AddQ TestautomatiseringserfarenheterAddQ Consulting
 
The Art of Testing Less without Sacrificing Quality @ ICSE 2015
The Art of Testing Less without Sacrificing Quality @ ICSE 2015The Art of Testing Less without Sacrificing Quality @ ICSE 2015
The Art of Testing Less without Sacrificing Quality @ ICSE 2015Kim Herzig
 
Releasing fast code - The DevOps approach
Releasing fast code - The DevOps approachReleasing fast code - The DevOps approach
Releasing fast code - The DevOps approachMichael Kopp
 
ALE15 The real value of a definition of done
ALE15  The real value of a definition of doneALE15  The real value of a definition of done
ALE15 The real value of a definition of doneChristian Vos
 
有了 Agile,為什麼還要有 DevOps?
有了 Agile,為什麼還要有 DevOps?有了 Agile,為什麼還要有 DevOps?
有了 Agile,為什麼還要有 DevOps?William Yeh
 
Test Automation and Innovation with Open Source Tools
Test Automation and Innovation with Open Source ToolsTest Automation and Innovation with Open Source Tools
Test Automation and Innovation with Open Source ToolsMichael Palotas
 
Modern Functional Test Automation Through Visual AI - webinar w/ Raja Rao
Modern Functional Test Automation Through Visual AI - webinar w/ Raja Rao Modern Functional Test Automation Through Visual AI - webinar w/ Raja Rao
Modern Functional Test Automation Through Visual AI - webinar w/ Raja Rao Applitools
 
Brave New World - A wider perspective of our opportunities
Brave New World - A wider perspective of our opportunitiesBrave New World - A wider perspective of our opportunities
Brave New World - A wider perspective of our opportunitiesJayathirtha Rao
 
Automation roi microsoft e4 d event
Automation roi microsoft e4 d eventAutomation roi microsoft e4 d event
Automation roi microsoft e4 d eventEyal Vardi
 
Continuous Deployment – Nextdoor.fi released every day at Scan-Agile 2011
Continuous Deployment – Nextdoor.fi released every day at Scan-Agile 2011Continuous Deployment – Nextdoor.fi released every day at Scan-Agile 2011
Continuous Deployment – Nextdoor.fi released every day at Scan-Agile 2011Marko Taipale
 
ALM Summit 3 - Setting up a Continuous Delivery Deployment Pipeline with TFS
ALM Summit 3 - Setting up a Continuous Delivery Deployment Pipeline with TFSALM Summit 3 - Setting up a Continuous Delivery Deployment Pipeline with TFS
ALM Summit 3 - Setting up a Continuous Delivery Deployment Pipeline with TFSJose Luis Soria
 
JIRA Enterprise Webinar - 15 Aug 2012
JIRA Enterprise Webinar - 15 Aug 2012JIRA Enterprise Webinar - 15 Aug 2012
JIRA Enterprise Webinar - 15 Aug 2012Atlassian
 
Technology Roadmap
Technology RoadmapTechnology Roadmap
Technology Roadmaprobduvall
 
Testing in an Open Source Middleware Platform Space The WSO2 Way.
Testing in an Open Source Middleware Platform Space  The WSO2 Way.Testing in an Open Source Middleware Platform Space  The WSO2 Way.
Testing in an Open Source Middleware Platform Space The WSO2 Way.WSO2
 
Continuous delivery while minimizing performance risks
Continuous delivery while minimizing performance risksContinuous delivery while minimizing performance risks
Continuous delivery while minimizing performance risksa32an
 
Keynote AST 2016
Keynote AST 2016Keynote AST 2016
Keynote AST 2016Kim Herzig
 
Ethan huang 全民qa
Ethan huang   全民qaEthan huang   全民qa
Ethan huang 全民qaOdd-e
 
Final Presentation for SMEDA-JICA
Final Presentation for SMEDA-JICAFinal Presentation for SMEDA-JICA
Final Presentation for SMEDA-JICAshahir20
 

Similar to How does scrum master remove org impediment (20)

AddQ Testautomatiseringserfarenheter
AddQ TestautomatiseringserfarenheterAddQ Testautomatiseringserfarenheter
AddQ Testautomatiseringserfarenheter
 
The Art of Testing Less without Sacrificing Quality @ ICSE 2015
The Art of Testing Less without Sacrificing Quality @ ICSE 2015The Art of Testing Less without Sacrificing Quality @ ICSE 2015
The Art of Testing Less without Sacrificing Quality @ ICSE 2015
 
Releasing fast code - The DevOps approach
Releasing fast code - The DevOps approachReleasing fast code - The DevOps approach
Releasing fast code - The DevOps approach
 
ALE15 The real value of a definition of done
ALE15  The real value of a definition of doneALE15  The real value of a definition of done
ALE15 The real value of a definition of done
 
有了 Agile,為什麼還要有 DevOps?
有了 Agile,為什麼還要有 DevOps?有了 Agile,為什麼還要有 DevOps?
有了 Agile,為什麼還要有 DevOps?
 
Test Automation and Innovation with Open Source Tools
Test Automation and Innovation with Open Source ToolsTest Automation and Innovation with Open Source Tools
Test Automation and Innovation with Open Source Tools
 
Modern Functional Test Automation Through Visual AI - webinar w/ Raja Rao
Modern Functional Test Automation Through Visual AI - webinar w/ Raja Rao Modern Functional Test Automation Through Visual AI - webinar w/ Raja Rao
Modern Functional Test Automation Through Visual AI - webinar w/ Raja Rao
 
Brave New World - A wider perspective of our opportunities
Brave New World - A wider perspective of our opportunitiesBrave New World - A wider perspective of our opportunities
Brave New World - A wider perspective of our opportunities
 
Automation roi microsoft e4 d event
Automation roi microsoft e4 d eventAutomation roi microsoft e4 d event
Automation roi microsoft e4 d event
 
Continuous Deployment – Nextdoor.fi released every day at Scan-Agile 2011
Continuous Deployment – Nextdoor.fi released every day at Scan-Agile 2011Continuous Deployment – Nextdoor.fi released every day at Scan-Agile 2011
Continuous Deployment – Nextdoor.fi released every day at Scan-Agile 2011
 
ALM Summit 3 - Setting up a Continuous Delivery Deployment Pipeline with TFS
ALM Summit 3 - Setting up a Continuous Delivery Deployment Pipeline with TFSALM Summit 3 - Setting up a Continuous Delivery Deployment Pipeline with TFS
ALM Summit 3 - Setting up a Continuous Delivery Deployment Pipeline with TFS
 
JIRA Enterprise Webinar - 15 Aug 2012
JIRA Enterprise Webinar - 15 Aug 2012JIRA Enterprise Webinar - 15 Aug 2012
JIRA Enterprise Webinar - 15 Aug 2012
 
Technology Roadmap
Technology RoadmapTechnology Roadmap
Technology Roadmap
 
Testing in an Open Source Middleware Platform Space The WSO2 Way.
Testing in an Open Source Middleware Platform Space  The WSO2 Way.Testing in an Open Source Middleware Platform Space  The WSO2 Way.
Testing in an Open Source Middleware Platform Space The WSO2 Way.
 
Chapter 10
Chapter 10Chapter 10
Chapter 10
 
Continuous delivery while minimizing performance risks
Continuous delivery while minimizing performance risksContinuous delivery while minimizing performance risks
Continuous delivery while minimizing performance risks
 
Keynote AST 2016
Keynote AST 2016Keynote AST 2016
Keynote AST 2016
 
Exploratory Testing in Practice
Exploratory Testing in PracticeExploratory Testing in Practice
Exploratory Testing in Practice
 
Ethan huang 全民qa
Ethan huang   全民qaEthan huang   全民qa
Ethan huang 全民qa
 
Final Presentation for SMEDA-JICA
Final Presentation for SMEDA-JICAFinal Presentation for SMEDA-JICA
Final Presentation for SMEDA-JICA
 

Recently uploaded

Enhancing and Restoring Safety & Quality Cultures - Dave Litwiller - May 2024...
Enhancing and Restoring Safety & Quality Cultures - Dave Litwiller - May 2024...Enhancing and Restoring Safety & Quality Cultures - Dave Litwiller - May 2024...
Enhancing and Restoring Safety & Quality Cultures - Dave Litwiller - May 2024...Dave Litwiller
 
The Coffee Bean & Tea Leaf(CBTL), Business strategy case study
The Coffee Bean & Tea Leaf(CBTL), Business strategy case studyThe Coffee Bean & Tea Leaf(CBTL), Business strategy case study
The Coffee Bean & Tea Leaf(CBTL), Business strategy case studyEthan lee
 
VIP Call Girl Jamshedpur Aashi 8250192130 Independent Escort Service Jamshedpur
VIP Call Girl Jamshedpur Aashi 8250192130 Independent Escort Service JamshedpurVIP Call Girl Jamshedpur Aashi 8250192130 Independent Escort Service Jamshedpur
VIP Call Girl Jamshedpur Aashi 8250192130 Independent Escort Service JamshedpurSuhani Kapoor
 
M.C Lodges -- Guest House in Jhang.
M.C Lodges --  Guest House in Jhang.M.C Lodges --  Guest House in Jhang.
M.C Lodges -- Guest House in Jhang.Aaiza Hassan
 
Progress Report - Oracle Database Analyst Summit
Progress  Report - Oracle Database Analyst SummitProgress  Report - Oracle Database Analyst Summit
Progress Report - Oracle Database Analyst SummitHolger Mueller
 
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Howrah 👉 8250192130 Available With Room
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Howrah 👉 8250192130  Available With RoomVIP Kolkata Call Girl Howrah 👉 8250192130  Available With Room
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Howrah 👉 8250192130 Available With Roomdivyansh0kumar0
 
Eni 2024 1Q Results - 24.04.24 business.
Eni 2024 1Q Results - 24.04.24 business.Eni 2024 1Q Results - 24.04.24 business.
Eni 2024 1Q Results - 24.04.24 business.Eni
 
Call Girls Pune Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Pune Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Pune Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Pune Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableDipal Arora
 
7.pdf This presentation captures many uses and the significance of the number...
7.pdf This presentation captures many uses and the significance of the number...7.pdf This presentation captures many uses and the significance of the number...
7.pdf This presentation captures many uses and the significance of the number...Paul Menig
 
Monthly Social Media Update April 2024 pptx.pptx
Monthly Social Media Update April 2024 pptx.pptxMonthly Social Media Update April 2024 pptx.pptx
Monthly Social Media Update April 2024 pptx.pptxAndy Lambert
 
Keppel Ltd. 1Q 2024 Business Update Presentation Slides
Keppel Ltd. 1Q 2024 Business Update  Presentation SlidesKeppel Ltd. 1Q 2024 Business Update  Presentation Slides
Keppel Ltd. 1Q 2024 Business Update Presentation SlidesKeppelCorporation
 
Ensure the security of your HCL environment by applying the Zero Trust princi...
Ensure the security of your HCL environment by applying the Zero Trust princi...Ensure the security of your HCL environment by applying the Zero Trust princi...
Ensure the security of your HCL environment by applying the Zero Trust princi...Roland Driesen
 
Russian Faridabad Call Girls(Badarpur) : ☎ 8168257667, @4999
Russian Faridabad Call Girls(Badarpur) : ☎ 8168257667, @4999Russian Faridabad Call Girls(Badarpur) : ☎ 8168257667, @4999
Russian Faridabad Call Girls(Badarpur) : ☎ 8168257667, @4999Tina Ji
 
Catalogue ONG NƯỚC uPVC - HDPE DE NHAT.pdf
Catalogue ONG NƯỚC uPVC - HDPE DE NHAT.pdfCatalogue ONG NƯỚC uPVC - HDPE DE NHAT.pdf
Catalogue ONG NƯỚC uPVC - HDPE DE NHAT.pdfOrient Homes
 
Call Girls in Gomti Nagar - 7388211116 - With room Service
Call Girls in Gomti Nagar - 7388211116  - With room ServiceCall Girls in Gomti Nagar - 7388211116  - With room Service
Call Girls in Gomti Nagar - 7388211116 - With room Servicediscovermytutordmt
 
GD Birla and his contribution in management
GD Birla and his contribution in managementGD Birla and his contribution in management
GD Birla and his contribution in managementchhavia330
 
Grateful 7 speech thanking everyone that has helped.pdf
Grateful 7 speech thanking everyone that has helped.pdfGrateful 7 speech thanking everyone that has helped.pdf
Grateful 7 speech thanking everyone that has helped.pdfPaul Menig
 
Mondelez State of Snacking and Future Trends 2023
Mondelez State of Snacking and Future Trends 2023Mondelez State of Snacking and Future Trends 2023
Mondelez State of Snacking and Future Trends 2023Neil Kimberley
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Nepali Escort Girl Kakori \ 9548273370 Indian Call Girls Service Lucknow ₹,9517
Nepali Escort Girl Kakori \ 9548273370 Indian Call Girls Service Lucknow ₹,9517Nepali Escort Girl Kakori \ 9548273370 Indian Call Girls Service Lucknow ₹,9517
Nepali Escort Girl Kakori \ 9548273370 Indian Call Girls Service Lucknow ₹,9517
 
Enhancing and Restoring Safety & Quality Cultures - Dave Litwiller - May 2024...
Enhancing and Restoring Safety & Quality Cultures - Dave Litwiller - May 2024...Enhancing and Restoring Safety & Quality Cultures - Dave Litwiller - May 2024...
Enhancing and Restoring Safety & Quality Cultures - Dave Litwiller - May 2024...
 
The Coffee Bean & Tea Leaf(CBTL), Business strategy case study
The Coffee Bean & Tea Leaf(CBTL), Business strategy case studyThe Coffee Bean & Tea Leaf(CBTL), Business strategy case study
The Coffee Bean & Tea Leaf(CBTL), Business strategy case study
 
VIP Call Girl Jamshedpur Aashi 8250192130 Independent Escort Service Jamshedpur
VIP Call Girl Jamshedpur Aashi 8250192130 Independent Escort Service JamshedpurVIP Call Girl Jamshedpur Aashi 8250192130 Independent Escort Service Jamshedpur
VIP Call Girl Jamshedpur Aashi 8250192130 Independent Escort Service Jamshedpur
 
M.C Lodges -- Guest House in Jhang.
M.C Lodges --  Guest House in Jhang.M.C Lodges --  Guest House in Jhang.
M.C Lodges -- Guest House in Jhang.
 
Progress Report - Oracle Database Analyst Summit
Progress  Report - Oracle Database Analyst SummitProgress  Report - Oracle Database Analyst Summit
Progress Report - Oracle Database Analyst Summit
 
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Howrah 👉 8250192130 Available With Room
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Howrah 👉 8250192130  Available With RoomVIP Kolkata Call Girl Howrah 👉 8250192130  Available With Room
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Howrah 👉 8250192130 Available With Room
 
Eni 2024 1Q Results - 24.04.24 business.
Eni 2024 1Q Results - 24.04.24 business.Eni 2024 1Q Results - 24.04.24 business.
Eni 2024 1Q Results - 24.04.24 business.
 
Call Girls Pune Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Pune Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Pune Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Pune Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
 
7.pdf This presentation captures many uses and the significance of the number...
7.pdf This presentation captures many uses and the significance of the number...7.pdf This presentation captures many uses and the significance of the number...
7.pdf This presentation captures many uses and the significance of the number...
 
Monthly Social Media Update April 2024 pptx.pptx
Monthly Social Media Update April 2024 pptx.pptxMonthly Social Media Update April 2024 pptx.pptx
Monthly Social Media Update April 2024 pptx.pptx
 
Keppel Ltd. 1Q 2024 Business Update Presentation Slides
Keppel Ltd. 1Q 2024 Business Update  Presentation SlidesKeppel Ltd. 1Q 2024 Business Update  Presentation Slides
Keppel Ltd. 1Q 2024 Business Update Presentation Slides
 
Ensure the security of your HCL environment by applying the Zero Trust princi...
Ensure the security of your HCL environment by applying the Zero Trust princi...Ensure the security of your HCL environment by applying the Zero Trust princi...
Ensure the security of your HCL environment by applying the Zero Trust princi...
 
Russian Faridabad Call Girls(Badarpur) : ☎ 8168257667, @4999
Russian Faridabad Call Girls(Badarpur) : ☎ 8168257667, @4999Russian Faridabad Call Girls(Badarpur) : ☎ 8168257667, @4999
Russian Faridabad Call Girls(Badarpur) : ☎ 8168257667, @4999
 
Catalogue ONG NƯỚC uPVC - HDPE DE NHAT.pdf
Catalogue ONG NƯỚC uPVC - HDPE DE NHAT.pdfCatalogue ONG NƯỚC uPVC - HDPE DE NHAT.pdf
Catalogue ONG NƯỚC uPVC - HDPE DE NHAT.pdf
 
Best Practices for Implementing an External Recruiting Partnership
Best Practices for Implementing an External Recruiting PartnershipBest Practices for Implementing an External Recruiting Partnership
Best Practices for Implementing an External Recruiting Partnership
 
Call Girls in Gomti Nagar - 7388211116 - With room Service
Call Girls in Gomti Nagar - 7388211116  - With room ServiceCall Girls in Gomti Nagar - 7388211116  - With room Service
Call Girls in Gomti Nagar - 7388211116 - With room Service
 
GD Birla and his contribution in management
GD Birla and his contribution in managementGD Birla and his contribution in management
GD Birla and his contribution in management
 
Grateful 7 speech thanking everyone that has helped.pdf
Grateful 7 speech thanking everyone that has helped.pdfGrateful 7 speech thanking everyone that has helped.pdf
Grateful 7 speech thanking everyone that has helped.pdf
 
Mondelez State of Snacking and Future Trends 2023
Mondelez State of Snacking and Future Trends 2023Mondelez State of Snacking and Future Trends 2023
Mondelez State of Snacking and Future Trends 2023
 

How does scrum master remove org impediment

  • 1.
  • 3. I am a
  • 4. And I am supposed to …
  • 7. The second one is …
  • 10. We heard a lot about …
  • 11.
  • 12. Survey & Interview In which stage, did you feel there were significant waiting If you could do anything, please tell ONE thing that you want to improve
  • 13.
  • 14. Value Stream for Check-in procedure Each Dev will has What will happen a different build if there were version in the conflicts after queue that wait code sync? for test Change Test on Sync Install Local Build Check-In Codes Test Farm Codes Build 2 hr. 6 hr. 2 days 12 hrs. ? The team will get the feedback after 3~4 days when complete some codes update
  • 15. There were huge waste on … Averagely there will be about 1.5 hours wasted in each working day for each developer
  • 17. We must convince the BOSS to …
  • 18. We tell boss that … Average Wasted Time / Per Day / Per 1.5 hours Dev Total Wasted Time for Team / Per Day 70 * 1.5 = 105 hours Total Wasted Time for the Team in 105 * 20 * 10 One Release (about 10 months) = 21,000 hours = 131 man month Average Cost / Per Man Month $$$$$ Total Wasted Money…
  • 19. Proposed solution … High Refactor legacy High system and automation test cases Cost of Change Optimize Improve Quality integration process Increase test farm performance Increase team’s machine performance Low Low Low Improve Productivity High
  • 20. Estimated Return of H/W Investment Waste time Productivity Can save about USD $$$$$$ in ONE release
  • 21. Half a Year Later …
  • 22.
  • 23. Total test time for retrieval Average test time / per case tests for retrieval tests 80000.00 1500.00 Time (sec.) Time (sec.) 60000.00 1000.00 40000.00 20000.00 500.00 0.00 0.00 New Old New Old Farm Farm Farm Farm Series1 28876.37 68501.59 Series1 437.52 1037.90 Productivity Increase: 57.9%
  • 24. total test time for smoke test average test time / per test 60000.00 case for smoke test Time (sec.) 40000.00 150.00 Time (sec.) 100.00 20000.00 50.00 0.00 0.00 New Old New Old Farm Fram Farm Farm Series1 33585.04 51436.06 Series1 89.32 136.80 Productivity Increase: 34.7%
  • 25. Average Time of Complete Build(mins.) 160 140 120 100 80 60 40 20 0 New Workstation Old PC Average Time of Complete 50 150 Build(mins.) Productivity Increase: 66.7%
  • 26. • Quality • Team Motivation
  • 27.
  • 29. So, don’t just complain but …
  • 31. It is NOT the END …
  • 32. Code base is growing bigger & bigger
  • 33. Next … High Refactor legacy High system and automation test cases Cost of Change Optimize Improve Quality integration process Increase test farm performance Increase team’s machine performance Low Low Low Improve Productivity High