SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 32
Download to read offline
Survey of B2B Buyers’
use of Social Media
Report on the survey findings
March 2010
‘Interesting survey and a subject which will
become more and more commonplace over
the next year or so’
Chief Information Security Officer
Financial services




‘Very interesting questions which enabled
me to formulate some thoughts I have been
marshalling in recent weeks’
Procurement Manager
Construction




‘Enjoyable and topical survey - thank you’
Senior Project Manager
Business services
Contents

1 Introduction                                        1
2 Sample Profile                                      2
3 Attitudes to and trends in usage of Social Media    3 - 10
  3.1 Trends
  3.2 Relative Time Spent
  3.3 The Pros And Cons Of Social Media

4 Actual usage of Social Media, in context            11 - 26
  4.1   The Purchase
  4.2   Stage 1 - Identifying And Defining The Need
  4.3   Stage 2 - Identifying Potential Suppliers
  4.4   Stage 3 - Final Selection of a Supplier
  4.5   Summary Overview Of The Whole Process

5 Looking to the future                               27 - 29
1.



Introduction

Base One have commissioned a research study to explore the extent to
which B2B decision-makers are using social media tools and channels to
help them in the process of refining their needs and identifying suitable
suppliers for major business purchases. The survey was conducted
online, administered and analysed by market research specialists
McCallum Layton, among business respondents provided by online panel
provider Toluna.


In order to qualify, respondents had to have been personally involved in
the decision-making process for any type of purchase over £20,000 that
had been completed on behalf of their business in the last 12 months
- questions focused on this particular purchase, in order to ensure the
findings are specific to actual experiences and decisions. The survey was
carried out in December, and 503 decision-makers took part.




1
2.



Sample Profile

The survey respondents represent a wide range of companies across
the UK, including those operating in manufacturing, business and
professional services:




    Main Business Activity                   No.       %

    Manufacturing                            86        17%
    Business Services                        73        15%
    Financial Services                       68        14%
    Public Administration                    46        9%
    Health                                   43        9%
    Retail / Wholesale Trade                 39        8%
    Transport / Storage / Communication      38        8%
    Education                                32        6%
    Construction                             31        6%
    Utilities                                19        4%
    Community / Social / Personal services   14        3%
    Hotel / Restaurant / Catering            11        2%
    Other                                    3         1%




2
Around half of companies represented have over 1,000 employees:


                                                 Organisation Size
                         6%
                               9%
                                                    Up to 100

                                                    101-250

                                                    251-500
                                     18%
    51%
                                                    501-1000

                                                    1000+



                               16%




The respondents themselves are decision-makers working in a range of
job functions, including IT and finance:



    Respondent Job Role                    No.         %

    IT                                     221         44%
    Finance                                113         22%
    HR                                     33          7%
    Operations / Production                27          5%
    Sales / Business Development           11          2%
    Procurement / Purchasing               11          2%
    MD / CEO / Senior Management           11          2%
    General Management                     11          2%
    Office Manager / Admin                 8           2%
    Project Management                     5           1%
    Other                                  52          10%




3
A broad spectrum of age groups was represented, as illustrated.
While over two fifths of respondents were over 40, a fifth were aged up
to 30:
                   1%


                                                   Respondent Age

          16%                  19%                      Up to 30

                                                        31-40

                                                        41-50

                                                        51-60
    26%
                                                        60+


                               38%




Younger respondents were particularly likely to be responding on behalf
of smaller organisations. While the up to 30s account for 19% of the
sample overall, they amount to a third of spokespeople for companies
employing up to 250, and just 10% for the largest companies, those with
over 1,000 people:



                                                                           Respondent Age
Up to 250 Employees           33%                          67%

                                                                              Up to 30
       All Companies     19%                         81%
                                                                              31+

    1000+ Employees     10%                       90%




There were no real differences in the extent to which older or younger
respondents were replying on behalf of companies in different industry
sectors. In terms of job role, those aged up to 30 were more likely than
the rest to be working in HR (15%, compared to 5% of older respondents)
and less so in IT (36% compared to 46%).




4
3.



Attitudes to and trends
in usage of Social Media
 3.1 Trends
 Respondents were asked how the extent to which they use a range of
 communication channels for any aspect of business decision-making has
 changed, over the last year or so:


                                 Change in usage over last 12 months

           Web searches                  26%                         39%                       34%          1%        Greatly
                                                                                                                      increased
     Supplier websites                 19%                     44%                             35%          2%
                                                                                                                      Somewhat
         Industry press           11%                 34%                              46%                 7%    1%   increased
      Events/Seminars              14%                   30%                           48%                 6%    2%   Same
    Online video/Webinars etc.   7%                33%                                   55%               3%    2%
                                                                                                                      Somewhat
     Press advertising            10%           22%                              57%                   8%        1%   decreased
Other online community sites      9%           22%                                 63%                     4%    2%   Greatly
                                                                                                                      decreased
              Direct mail         10%          20%                           53%                     13%         4%


                     Blogs        10%          17%                               66%                       3%    3%

                 Linkedin        6%          21%                                 65%                       5%    3%


                  Twitter         8%     11%                                71%                       5%         5%


                Facebook          8%     9%                                72%                        6%         5%




 Overall, more respondents stated an increase in their use of any given
 channel than mentioned a decrease, meaning that all sources had seen
 a net increase over the last 12 months. This increase was greatest for
 web searches (use was up for a net 64% of respondents) and supplier
 websites (up for a net 61%). Social networking sites Facebook and
 Twitter experienced 6% and 10% net increases respectively, but
 LinkedIn saw stronger growth with a 19% net increase. Online videos/
 webinars/podcasts saw an even greater increase in usage (36% net).


 Younger respondents (up to 30) were more likely to report their use
 of social media having increased in the last 12 months; over a third
 are making more use of Facebook (38%), blogs (46%), other online
 community sites (44%) and Twitter (42%). However, LinkedIn saw
 equivalent increases in use across all age groups, suggesting this channel
 is more appealing to older professionals than other forms of social media.


5
3.2 Relative Time Spent
 When asked how much time they tend to spend in a typical month using
 each channel to source information for their business, respondents
 gave the following average numbers of hours. This is clearly unlikely
 to be accurate, collected off the tops of their head rather than by means
 of a daily diary or equivalent, but gives a useful indication of how
 respondents perceive their relative usage of each, overall.


                                Average hours spent per month using each channel

          Web Searches           11.3

     Supplier Websites           5.1


      Events/Seminars            4.1

Industry Press (print)           3.5

    Online video/Webinars etc    2.0

     Press Advertising           2.0


               Direct Mail       2.0

Other online community sites     1.8

                     Blogs       1.6

                Facebook         1.3


                 LinkedIn        1.3

                   Twitter       1.0




 The up to 30s spend considerably more time on Facebook, blogs and
 Twitter (2.6, 2.5 and 1.9 hours a month respectively) than their older
 counterparts. They also spend more time, though, on press advertising
 (3.0 hours a month) and direct mail (2.9).




6
3.3 The Pros And Cons Of Social Media
Respondents were asked to indicate what benefits, if any, they felt online
community sites, videos, webinars or podcasts provide, when looking for
business related information. As illustrated below, a little over half reported
some form of benefit of these social media sources with just over one
fifth actively seeing no benefits. However, a further sizeable proportion
(25%) had no real view either way as far as benefits are concerned,
perhaps through ignorance of, or inexperience with, these channels.




              14%
                                                       Benefits of social media

                                                            Any benefits mentioned
    11%
                                                            No benefits
                                      54%
                                                            Don’t use them

                                                            Don’t know/no reply
       21%




Interestingly, the up to 30s were no more likely than the over 30s to cite
benefits. While it is the younger age group that is increasingly making
more use of social media, older respondents are still seeing (potential)
value to a similar extent.


    Benefit                                 % of all respondents

    Access to other people’s experiences    17%
    Honest/unbiased views                   6%
    Saves time/quick to access              6%
    Ability to interact                     6%
    Easy to access/use                      5%
    Up to date information                  4%
    Access to wide ranging information      4%
    Volume of information available         2%
    Access to similar minded people         2%
    Price information/saves money           2%
    Detailed product information            2%


7
At the same time, three fifths reported weaknesses or difficulties to using
social media for business related information:



              14%
                                                         Weaknesses/difficulties with social media

     3%
                                                             Any weakness mentioned

                                                             No weaknesses

                                          59%                Don’t use them
    24%
                                                             Don’t know/no reply




Here the up to 30s were twice as likely (at 40%) than older ones, to say
there are no weaknesses. 63% of over 30’s actively cited any weakness,
compared to just 44% of the younger group.


Key concerns were the reliability of the information obtained from social
media sources - views found within sites and forums may be biased or
from sources that it is impossible to verify. There were also issues over
the sheer volume and diversity of information generated, and the time it
can take to sift through it all:



    Weakness                                     % of all respondents

    May not be reliable/trustworthy              12%
    Biased information                           10%
    Too much to wade through                     6%
    Cannot tell what the information source is   6%
    Quality/accuracy of information              3%
    Not specific enough                          3%
    Too wide a range of opinions                 3%
    Not relevant for my business                 3%
    Time consuming                               2%
    Security concerns                            2%
    Prefer face to face                          2%



8
Overall, the proportions of respondents that we might call ‘fans’ of social
media (seeing benefits and no weaknesses) and ‘critics’ of these tools
(seeing weaknesses and no benefits) were similar, at 14% and 19%
respectively; a further 40% could see both sides (citing both benefits
and weaknesses). The remaining 26% are perhaps reserving judgement,
with no view either way.




 Fans 96         See both sides 203         Critics 96




As would be expected, respondents falling into the up to 30 age band
were more likely than the rest to be fans and less likely to be critics, and
particularly more so when compared to the over 40s:


                                                                                     Fans
            Up to 30        24%               33%           11%             32%

                                                                                     See both sides
    All respondents     14%              40%                 20%               26%
                                                                                     Critics

            Over 40    8%             40%                  26%                 26%   Reserving
                                                                                     judgement


Interestingly, though, the proportion of up to 30s who had no real
views either way (32%) was broadly similar to that seen among older
respondents - it is not the case that younger buyers are universally
experienced in, and in favour of, these media.


Indeed, while users of social media in real-life purchase situations
(described in detail in the next section) are more likely to be fans, and



9
non-users to be critics, as we might expect, this is not entirely cut and
dried. 38% of all respondents made use of any social media at any
of the three stages of the decision-making process for the business
purchase they had been involved in - of these, 23% cited benefits and
no weaknesses and 8% weaknesses but no benefits. At the same
time, while 26% of non-users cited weaknesses and no benefits, 9%
suggested benefits but no weaknesses.




10
4.



Actual usage of Social Media,
in context
This report goes further than just exploring overall views on and trends
in the use of social media. We focused respondents on one specific,
significant business purchase they have made in the last 12 months, and
went through with them, step by step, which channels and media types
they used to help in their decision-making process and how influential
these were in providing them with the information they needed.


4.1 The Purchase
A screening question had confirmed that respondents had been involved
in the purchase of a B2B product or service worth at least £20,000 in the
last year. They were asked to further describe this purchase, by way of
context.


The single largest category of purchases referred to by buyers in this
survey was IT equipment or systems, with consultancy services and
support service contracts between them accounting for a further 28%:



               6%                                  Category of purchase

        9%
                                                        IT/Telecoms equipment/systems

                                                        Consultancy services

 13%
                                    42%
                                                        Manufacturing equipment

                                                        Support Service Contract

                                                        Property/Land
     15%

                                                        Other

                    15%




Overall, these items were balanced between being one-off purchases
(48%) and ongoing contracts (52%). IT-related purchases were
particularly likely to be ongoing contracts (66%).




11
The value of a little over half of purchases was up to £50k. The average
purchase value came out at £2.9 million; however, when 8 individual
‘outliers’ (quoting figures in excess of £20 million) are excluded, the
average purchase value falls to a perhaps more representative figure of
£348k.

                     2%
                                                    Purchase value


                5%                                      £20–25k
          5%
                               23%                      £26–50k

     9%
                                                        £51–100k

                                                        £101–250k

 14%                                                    £251–500k

                                                        £501k–1m
                               29%
                                                        £1.1m–20m
          13%

                                                        £20m+



The ongoing contracts tended to be higher value, on average, than the
one-off purchases (£411k vs £284k, excluding outliers), and the larger
organisations, with over 1,000 employees, were spending more (£462k,
on average) than smaller ones (£229k). Respondents aged up to 30
tended to be responsible for rather smaller purchases, on average (£249k)
than those older than this (£371k) - likely to be linked to the generally
smaller companies they represent as well as, possibly, their level of
seniority within the organisation.




12
4.2 Stage 1 - Identifying And Defining The Need
In nearly two thirds of cases (63%), the need for this business purchase
was at least in part identified or recognised following some element of
external impetus. The incidence of solely internal drivers was slightly
greater among smaller companies and for smaller purchases.




           13%

                                                    How was the need for this purchase identified?

                                     36%                As result of internal feedback, analysis or consultation

                                                        A bit of both

                                                        As result of viewing or sourcing external information



        15%




Information sourced or found externally was especially likely to have
played a part in the instigation of IT related purchases.


86% of all respondents surveyed were personally involved at this initial
stage of identifying the product or service need for their organisation.
IT functions were involved in a little over half of cases, reflecting
the predominance of IT and telecoms equipment and systems being
discussed.

                               Functions involved at Stage 1

                 IT Function   53%

                  MD/Board     35%


       Operations/Production   32%

     Purchasing/Procurement    26%


                     Finance   22%

Sales/Business Developement    16%

         External Consultant   10%

                         HR    7%

                      Other    17%




13
Board level and purchasing/procurement involvement increased with
the value of the purchase, as might be expected. Of all respondents
personally involved at this stage of the process, 74% were the sole or
main driver, leaving 26% in the role of influencer.


Respondents were asked to indicate which communication channels from
a given list (illustrated below) they had made use of at all, in identifying
and defining their need.

                                    Channels used at Stage 1

         Supplier Websites          62%

              Web Searches          51%


  Industry Press (print)            46%

             Word of Mouth          44%


          Events/Seminars           38%

                  Direct Mail       22%

         Press Advertising          19%

  Other Online Community Sites      16%

     Online Videos/Webinars etc..   12%

                         Blogs      11%

                      Twitter       10%

                    Facebook        10%

                     LinkedIn       9%

                         Other      8%




Established web methods were the most commonly used at this
stage (supplier websites and search engines each used by over half
of respondents). Traditional media sources and personal discussions
followed, with the social media resources mostly recording usage levels
of around 1 in 10.


Younger buyers, however, consistently make more use of social media
and other online media, in addition to being substantial consumers of
traditional direct mail and press advertising. Those aged up to 30 said
they had used on average 4.7 of these sources, compared to 3.4 selected
by older respondents. Those involved in IT related purchases also cited
more sources than the rest, along with those representing the smaller
companies (up to 1,000 employees) and those who were the main or sole
driver at this stage of the purchase process.



14
Social media use specifically was also rather higher in the 31-40 age
group compared to older respondents, but it is the up to 30 group where
the difference is most marked:

                                    Channels usage by age at Stage 1


         Supplier Websites
                                    58%                                   Up to 30
                                    62%

                                    51%                                   31+
              Web Searches
                                    52%

                                    51%
  Industry Press (print)
                                    45%

                                    49%
             Word of Mouth
                                    43%

                                    44%
         Events/Seminars
                                    37%

                                    35%
                  Direct Mail
                                    20%

                                    36%
         Press Advertising
                                    16%

                                    32%
  Other Online Community Sites
                                    12%

                                    12%
     Online Videos/Webinars etc..
                                    13%

                                    25%
                         Blogs
                                    7%

                                    25%
                      Twitter
                                    6%

                                    30%
                    Facebook
                                    6%

                                    13%
                    LinkedIn
                                    9%

                                    4%
                         Other
                                    9%




One exception was LinkedIn, where the 31-40s are using this medium
as frequently as the younger age group. Buyers aged over 40 typically
relied more on word of mouth (47%) and supplier websites (59%), web
searches (44%) and other traditional media channels.




15
For each source they had used, respondents were asked how influential
this had been, in providing them with information to help define their
need:

                                     Influence of each channel at Stage 1

                    Blogs (48)                                   71%                          23%     6%            Very
                                                                                                                    influential
       Word of Mouth (191)                                   69%                              28%     2% 1%
                                                                                                                    Fairly
                  Twitter (42)                              67%                               29%         4%        infuential
               Facebook (43)                               60%                     26%              14%             Not that
                                                                                                                    influential
     Events/Seminars (165)                            55%                               40%           4% 1%
                                                                                                                    No reply
   Supplier Websites (268)                           52%                           42%                6%


                LinkedIn (41)                        51%                          37%               12%

Other online communitiy Sites (69)                   49%                           46%                    5%

              Direct Mail (97)                       49%                     36%                    15%

        Web Searches (223)                        48%                             45%                 7%

  Online Videos/Webinars etc. (54)              44%                          46%                     10%


       Industry Press (198)                     43%                          49%                      7%       1%


     Press Advertising (84)                    38%                          52%                      10%




Word of mouth and blogs (in effect, the online equivalent) were most
frequently cited as having been ‘very influential’. Print media were far
less likely to be seen as having been an important source of information.


Twitter and Facebook were also frequently perceived as ‘very influential’.
While usage of these may be relatively low, their power among the
converted is clearly significant. At the same time, though, Facebook and
LinkedIn attracted ratings of ‘not that influential’ from over 1 in 10 users
of these sites.


Of the most commonly used channels - those used by over a third of all
respondents at this stage - word of mouth and events/seminars were
accorded the highest levels of perceived influence.


4.3 Stage 2 - Identifying Potential Suppliers
423 (84%) of all respondents surveyed were personally involved in
identifying potential suppliers for the product or service required,
once the need had been identified and defined. While the function
predominantly involved in identifying potential suppliers was the
organisation’s IT department, still reflecting the nature of the purchases



16
under discussion, Board level involvement in this stage of the process
was lower (from 35% at Stage 1):

                                          Functions involved at Stage 2

                        IT Function       53%

                         MD/Board         19%


         Operations/Production            23%

      Purchasing/Procurement              26%


                             Finance      21%

Sales/Business Developement               15%

             External Consultant          6%

                                    HR    8%

                                  Other   17%




Of all respondents personally involved at this stage, 75% were the sole or
main driver when it came to identifying potential suppliers.


Established web methods remained the most commonly used channels at
this stage. Industry press, though, was rather less likely to be referred to
here than was the case at Stage 1, but traditional media sources (industry
press, events/seminars, direct mail, press advertising) continued to show
greater usage overall than the social media channels:


                                    Channels used at Stage 2

        Supplier Websites           58%

             Web Searches           46%


   Industry Press (print)           39%

            Word of Mouth           45%


         Events/Seminars            34%

                 Direct Mail        19%

        Press Advertising           22%

   Other Online Community Sites     10%

Online Videos/Webinars/Podcasts     8%

                        Blogs       9%

                     Twitter        9%

                  Facebook          9%

                   LinkedIn         7%

                       Other        8%




17
As was the case at Stage 1, younger respondents and those dealing with
IT related purchases used more sources of information, on average, than
did the rest. There was no significant difference, though, between the
number of sources used by drivers and influencers at this stage.


As seen at the previous stage in the purchasing process, buyers aged
up to 30 consistently made more use of social media over any other
age group, although the use of LinkedIn and online videos, webinars or
podcasts was more balanced over age groups. Buyers aged 50+ continued
to rely more heavily on word of mouth.


                                  Channels usage by age at Stage 2


        Supplier Websites
                                  60%                                     Up to 30
                                  58%

                                  46%                                     31+
             Web Searches
                                  46%

                                  50%
   Industry Press (print)
                                  36%

                                  52%
            Word of Mouth
                                  43%

                                  39%
         Events/Seminars
                                  32%

                                  32%
                 Direct Mail
                                  16%

                                  32%
        Press Advertising
                                  20%

                                  18%
   Other Online Community Sites
                                  9%

                                  9%
Online Videos/Webinars/Podcasts
                                  8%

                                  22%
                        Blogs
                                  6%

                                  26%
                     Twitter
                                  5%

                                  27%
                  Facebook
                                  5%

                                  9%
                   LinkedIn
                                  6%

                                  4%
                       Other
                                  9%




18
Among users of each channel, blogs, and Twitter and Facebook, again
recorded strong levels of perceived influence when it came to providing
buyers with information to help in identifying potential suppliers:


                                      Influence of each channel at Stage 2

                  Twitter (37)                                          81%                           14%     5%            Very
                                                                                                                            influential
                     Blogs (39)                                    74%                            23%             3%
                                                                                                                            Fairly
                Facebook (39)                                     69%                             31%                       infuential
        Word of Mouth (191)                                   67%                               30%           2% 1%         Not that
                                                                                                                            influential
     Events/Seminars (142)                                   62%                            34%                   4%
                                                                                                                            No reply
              Direct Mail (81)                              59%                           32%                9%


Other online communitiy Sites (44)                          57%                           36%                 7%

     Supplier Websites (97)                             54%                               42%                     4%

         Web Searches (195)                             54%                           37%                    8%        1%

                LinkedIn (28)                         46%                           46%                     4%         4%

  Online Videos/Webinars etc (35)                     45%                           49%                       6%


       Industry Press (164)                       42%                               52%                       5%       1%


     Press Advertising (95)                     32%                           56%                           11%        1%




4.4 Stage 3 - Final Selection of a Supplier
86% of all respondents interviewed (435) had been involved in the
final selection of a supplier for their purchase. At this point, Board level
involvement in the process rises again:


                                          Functions involved at Stage 3

                        IT Function       52%

                         MD/Board         29%


         Operations/Production            22%

      Purchasing/Procurement              29%


                             Finance      22%

Sales/Business Developement               15%

             External Consultant          4%

                                     HR   8%

                               Other      17%




19
In all, 70% of all respondents personally involved in the ultimate
selection of supplier had been the sole or main driver at this final stage.


In final supplier selection, use of all sources decreased overall, suggesting
that buyers are relying on fewer different sources and focusing on a
select few by this stage - citing 2.6 sources each on average, compared to
3.6 at Stage 1 and 3.2 at Stage 2.


                                  Channels used at Stage 3

        Supplier Websites         45%

             Web Searches         25%


   Industry Press (print)         26%

            Word of Mouth         40%


         Events/Seminars          27%

                 Direct Mail      18%

        Press Advertising         14%

   Other Online Community Sites   7%

Online Videos/Webinars/Podcasts   8%

                        Blogs     6%

                     Twitter      7%

                  Facebook        7%

                   LinkedIn       6%

                       Other      18%




Supplier websites and word of mouth remained favoured sources of
information, followed by other traditional media (industry press, events,
direct mail, press adverts, plus web searches). While social media
channels still recorded lower usage overall, the proportions using these
at this stage did not fall off to the same extent as other channels did - to
users, their value appears to remain more constant from start to finish in
the buying process.




20
The age difference in usage of social media at this stage remains
apparent:


                                  Channels usage by age at Stage 3


        Supplier Websites
                                  44%                                          Up to 30
                                  45%

                                  32%                                          31+
             Web Searches
                                  23%

                                  32%
   Industry Press (print)
                                  25%

                                  46%
            Word of Mouth
                                  39%

                                  37%
         Events/Seminars
                                  24%

                                  33%
                 Direct Mail
                                  14%

                                  30%
        Press Advertising
                                  10%

                                  15%
   Other Online Community Sites
                                  5%

                                  9%
Online Videos/Webinars/Podcasts
                                  8%

                                  19%
                        Blogs
                                  4%

                                  23%
                     Twitter
                                  3%

                                  22%
                  Facebook
                                  4%

                                  7%
                   LinkedIn
                                  5%

                                  4%
                       Other
                                  21%




The ‘other’ category selected by a relatively large proportion at this stage
is mainly accounted for by the incidence of formal tendering processes
run by the larger organisations in the sample.




21
In this final stage of supplier selection, word of mouth and social media
were still felt, by users, to be the most influential of all sources used in
decision making:


                                     Influence of each channel at Stage 3

                Facebook (31)                                        87%                        10% 3%   Very
                                                                                                         influential
                  Twitter (31)                                    77%                         23%
                                                                                                         Fairly
                    Blogs (28)                                 75%                            25%        infuential
       Word of Mouth (176)                                   72%                          27%       1%   Not that
                                                                                                         influential
Other online communitiy Sites (31)                           71%                         26%        3%


     Events/Seminars (116)                                  69%                          30%        1%


              Direct Mail (77)                              66%                         31%         3%

        Web Searches (108)                               63%                        35%             2%

   Supplier Websites (195)                            56%                         39%               4%

                LinkedIn (24)                         54%                         46%

     Press Advertising (61)                        48%                        50%                   2%


  Online Videos/Webinars etc (35)               43%                         51%                     6%


       Industry Press (113)                  42%                            54%                     4%




Practically all Facebook users rated this source as having been ‘very
influential’ in providing them with information to help finally select a
supplier. Twitter, blogs and other online communities also came out
strongly here.




22
4.5 Summary Overview Of The Whole Process
Amalgamating the usage data from each stage of the purchase process
demonstrates the extent to which buyers seek information from a wide
range of sources when seeking to define their needs, then narrow this down
to a shorter list of options as they progress through to selecting a supplier:


Usage funnel                                    62%
                     Supplier Websites          58%
                                                45%

                                                51%
                          Web Searches          46%
                                                25%

                                                46%
                                                39%
                 Industry Press (print)
                                                26%

                                                44%
                                                45%
                         Word of Mouth
                                                40%

                                                38%
                                                34%
                      Events/Seminars
                                                27%

                                                22%
                                                19%
                              Direct Mail
                                                18%

                                                19%
                                                22%
                     Press Advertising                          Channels used at each stage
                                                14%

                                                16%
                                                                     Stage 1 – Identifying the need (434)
                Other Online Community Sites    10%
                                                7%

                                                12%
                                                                     Stage 2 – Identifying potential suppliers (423)
                  Online Videos/Webinars etc.   8%
                                                8%
                                                                     Stage 3 – Selecting a supplier (435)
                                                11%
                                     Blogs      9%
                                                6%

                                                10%
                                  Twitter       9%
                                                7%

                                                10%
                                Facebook        9%
                                                7%

                                                9%
                                 LinkedIn       7%
                                                6%

                                                8%
                                     Other      8%
                                                18%




In particular, usage of web resources and industry press falls off from one
stage to the next. While use of social media is less common, reliance on
these among proponents, however, remains more stable.



23
Influence funnel
The chart below illustrates the proportion of respondents involved at
each stage of the process who gave ratings of very or fairly influential to
each channel:


Channels rated very/fairly influential at each stage

60%




50%



                                                                                       Supplier Websites

40%                                                                                    Word of Mouth




30%
                                                                                       Events/Seminars
                                                                                       Industry Press (print)
                                                                                       Web Searches

20%
                                                                                       Direct Mail

                                                                                       Press Advertising


10%                                                                                    Online Videos/Webinars etc.
                                                                                       Other Online Community Sites
                                                                                       Twitter
                                                                                       Blogs
                                                                                       Facebook
                                                                                       LinkedIn
0%

                                  Stage 2 - identifying suppliers       Stage 3 - choosing suppliers



There is a notable decrease in the influence of supplier websites after the
early stages of the buying process. At the need identification stage 58%
described websites as influential or very influential, a figure that dropped
to 43% by the final supplier selection stage. The same pattern is true of
industry press and events/seminars. For social media, on the other hand,
the level of overall influence from one stage to the next, while lower
because usage is lower, remains fairly constant.




24
Focusing specifically in on users of each type of social media, a further
interesting pattern emerges:


Social media channels rated very influential at each stage - by users

100%


90%
                                                                                        Facebook


80%
                                                                                        Twitter
                                                                                        Blogs
                                                                                        Other Online Community Sites
70%


60%

                                                                                        LinkedIn
50%

                                                                                        Online Videos/Webinars etc.
40%


30%


20%


10%


 0%

                                  Stage 2 - identifying suppliers        Stage 3 - choosing suppliers


The perceived influence of Facebook and other online community
sites actually increased steadily for users of these media through the
purchasing process.




25
Usage/influence map
Combining together the usage and influence data from across all stages of
the process, it is possible to map how the various channels sit alongside
each other:

Total usage and influence, plotted


          3




                         Twitter
                                   Blogs                                                                             Word of Mouth
                                   Facebook

                                                                                          Events/Seminars
                         Other Online Community Sites
         2.5
                                                        Direct Mail                                               Web Searches             Supplier Websites
                    LinkedIn


                                     Online Videos/Webinars etc.                                        Industry Press (print)

                                                           Press Advertising




          2

               0%                                                                   30%                                                                   60%

                                                              Incidence of usage at any stage



Among the up to 30 age group, the pattern is markedly different,
underlining how the landscape may change in future:

Total usage and influence – respondents aged up to 30


           3

                                                                          Twitter
                                                                      Blogs                                        Events/Seminars
                                                                               Facebook                                               Word of Mouth

                                                    Other Online Community Sites          Direct Mail

                                                                                                                       Web Searches

                                      LinkedIn

                                                                                                                                                  Supplier Websites
         2.5

                                     Online Videos/Webinars etc.                                                         Industry Press (print)

                                                                                          Press Advertising




           2

               0%                                                                   30%                                                                    60%

                                                               Incidence of usage at any stage



26
5.



Looking to the future
Finally, respondents were asked what factors they felt would change
the way they research business purchases and suppliers in the future.
Common themes included the following:


The increasing importance of the internet
•	   Becoming central to the business research process
•	   Increased use of, and reliance on online methods
•	   Increased influence of the information gathered online


The decline of traditional sources
•	   Particularly paper based media
•	   The comparative cost of face-to-face meetings or traditional seminars
     to online methods is expected to drive down their use


Access to other buyers via social media
•	   Shift towards impartial end-user reviews and recommendations
•	   Sales-free information sharing
•	   Empowerment


Access to suppliers online
•	   Allowing greater choice and levels of detail
•	   Creating more transparency and openness
•	   Suppliers coming to buyers instead of vice versa

Technological advances
•	   Development and validation of new business/industry specific
     online resources
•	   Accessibility, flexibility and mobility of resources (e.g. mobile
     technology, multiple applications)

Cost implications
•	   Financial restrictions on budgets will drive more rigorous scrutiny of
     purchase decisions
•	   Efficiency of online research methods in both time and money




27
Generally there appeared to be a broad expectation among buyers that
online methods (including social media) will play an ever important role
in how they research business purchases:
“Use of the internet will increase greatly and industry online press will
become more influential.”

“Information on a much wider range of suppliers, including international
suppliers, will be readily available.”

“There will be increased use of online tools, in all possible forms, less direct
mail, seminars, etc.”

“Probably blogs and online community websites will play a bigger part in the
decision making process.”

In particular, many respondents highlighted the advantages or opportunities
afforded by social media:

“Forums, panels and blogs are the way ahead, using Google for searches can
be a tedious task, taking up too much time. Comparison websites are mainly
useless and filled with unwanted information and supplier/manufacturer
websites take up time. Going straight to user forums or specialized blogs
saves time.”

“The information required will become more portable, thus leading to more
rapid response to customers seeking information.”

“Increased use of webinars and getting suppliers to come to us.”


....with many mentioning a focus on peer recommendation and
communities:
“I think communities of buyers will come together and may even pool their
buying power.”

“Recommendations from current suppliers or customers will become more
critical via all communication channels.”


A number of respondents also highlighted the greater need for more
reliable information generally, from all sources, given the current
economic climate and a pressure to optimize purchasing decisions:
“[There is a] need for greater cost efficiency, leading to wider reviews.”

“Tightening budgets within the company may need more extensive [pre-
purchase] searches.”




28
A small number of comments highlighted concerns over the consistency
and reliability of business information gathered via social media and the
difficulty in identifying quality sources:
“I will always sample new methods but it’s the reliability and context that is
important in order to understand the accuracy of the information.”

“Too much information, it may become difficult to find the best places to
research.”


Some see the shift to online media as an all encompassing movement,
whereas others are more reserved, envisaging that they will incorporate
more new online methods into their existing research toolkit:
“More people [will become] tuned into social media after those who don’t get
it leave/retire.”

“I will utilize more web areas but generally be careful and limit to particular
proven sources.”


However around 15% felt there would be no change to the way they
research business purchases, suggesting a significant minority are not as
romanced by social media or other online sources. In some instances this
was attributed to formal tendering processes or because they did not see
how online methods could be relevant to their business area, or simply
that they didn’t see anything dramatic on the horizon that might alter
their research habits:
“Utilising unbiased web based research is still achievable for lower value
purchases but in our business everything else needs to follow a strict
procurement regime.”

“Nothing will change dramatically, small incremental improvements in web
capability will be evident.”


That said, most respondents appear to be looking forwards with few
directly expressing sentimentality or defending traditional methods.




29

More Related Content

What's hot

Net Citizens in Vietnam 2012 (Cimigo)
Net Citizens in Vietnam 2012 (Cimigo)Net Citizens in Vietnam 2012 (Cimigo)
Net Citizens in Vietnam 2012 (Cimigo)Maple Aikon
 
Nghiên cứu Người dùng Internet Việt Nam 2012
Nghiên cứu Người dùng Internet Việt Nam 2012Nghiên cứu Người dùng Internet Việt Nam 2012
Nghiên cứu Người dùng Internet Việt Nam 2012ISC Marketing Corporation
 
[Cimigo VN] Net citizens Việt Nam -2012
[Cimigo VN] Net citizens Việt Nam -2012[Cimigo VN] Net citizens Việt Nam -2012
[Cimigo VN] Net citizens Việt Nam -2012Thuy-Vy Pham
 
Cimigo net citizens-2012
Cimigo net citizens-2012Cimigo net citizens-2012
Cimigo net citizens-2012Bui Hang
 
Cimigo net citizens-2012
Cimigo net citizens-2012Cimigo net citizens-2012
Cimigo net citizens-2012action.vn
 
Cimigo net citizens 2012
Cimigo net citizens 2012Cimigo net citizens 2012
Cimigo net citizens 2012Duong The Vinh
 
2009 Internet Strategy Forum Corporate Internet Executive Research Study -- 4...
2009 Internet Strategy Forum Corporate Internet Executive Research Study -- 4...2009 Internet Strategy Forum Corporate Internet Executive Research Study -- 4...
2009 Internet Strategy Forum Corporate Internet Executive Research Study -- 4...sgehlen
 
icon Venture Capitalists’ Predictions for 2010
icon Venture Capitalists’ Predictions for 2010icon Venture Capitalists’ Predictions for 2010
icon Venture Capitalists’ Predictions for 2010Diego Túlio Tomaz Gomes
 
Com score state of the internet southeast asia march 2011
Com score state of the internet southeast asia march 2011Com score state of the internet southeast asia march 2011
Com score state of the internet southeast asia march 2011Juan Sanchez Bonet
 

What's hot (12)

Net Citizens in Vietnam 2012 (Cimigo)
Net Citizens in Vietnam 2012 (Cimigo)Net Citizens in Vietnam 2012 (Cimigo)
Net Citizens in Vietnam 2012 (Cimigo)
 
Nghiên cứu Người dùng Internet Việt Nam 2012
Nghiên cứu Người dùng Internet Việt Nam 2012Nghiên cứu Người dùng Internet Việt Nam 2012
Nghiên cứu Người dùng Internet Việt Nam 2012
 
[Cimigo VN] Net citizens Việt Nam -2012
[Cimigo VN] Net citizens Việt Nam -2012[Cimigo VN] Net citizens Việt Nam -2012
[Cimigo VN] Net citizens Việt Nam -2012
 
Cimigo net citizens-2012
Cimigo net citizens-2012Cimigo net citizens-2012
Cimigo net citizens-2012
 
Cimigo net citizens-2012
Cimigo net citizens-2012Cimigo net citizens-2012
Cimigo net citizens-2012
 
Cimigo net citizens-2012
Cimigo net citizens-2012Cimigo net citizens-2012
Cimigo net citizens-2012
 
Vietnam NetCitizens 2012 (Cimigo)
Vietnam NetCitizens 2012 (Cimigo)Vietnam NetCitizens 2012 (Cimigo)
Vietnam NetCitizens 2012 (Cimigo)
 
Cimigo net citizens 2012
Cimigo net citizens 2012Cimigo net citizens 2012
Cimigo net citizens 2012
 
Os números da Internet no Brasil
Os números da Internet no BrasilOs números da Internet no Brasil
Os números da Internet no Brasil
 
2009 Internet Strategy Forum Corporate Internet Executive Research Study -- 4...
2009 Internet Strategy Forum Corporate Internet Executive Research Study -- 4...2009 Internet Strategy Forum Corporate Internet Executive Research Study -- 4...
2009 Internet Strategy Forum Corporate Internet Executive Research Study -- 4...
 
icon Venture Capitalists’ Predictions for 2010
icon Venture Capitalists’ Predictions for 2010icon Venture Capitalists’ Predictions for 2010
icon Venture Capitalists’ Predictions for 2010
 
Com score state of the internet southeast asia march 2011
Com score state of the internet southeast asia march 2011Com score state of the internet southeast asia march 2011
Com score state of the internet southeast asia march 2011
 

Similar to B2B buyers and social media

Bill Stankiiewicz Copy 4 2011 Social Media Report
Bill Stankiiewicz Copy 4 2011 Social Media ReportBill Stankiiewicz Copy 4 2011 Social Media Report
Bill Stankiiewicz Copy 4 2011 Social Media ReportBillStankiewicz
 
HP SME Index January 2012
HP SME Index January 2012HP SME Index January 2012
HP SME Index January 2012Edelman
 
2012 Connell & Partners Fall Pulse Survey Participant Report
2012 Connell & Partners Fall Pulse Survey Participant Report2012 Connell & Partners Fall Pulse Survey Participant Report
2012 Connell & Partners Fall Pulse Survey Participant ReportConnell & Partners
 
Nielson Social Media Business Benchmarking study
Nielson Social Media Business Benchmarking studyNielson Social Media Business Benchmarking study
Nielson Social Media Business Benchmarking studyHeidi Allen
 
Highlights of 2011 SMB Social Business Study
Highlights of 2011 SMB Social Business StudyHighlights of 2011 SMB Social Business Study
Highlights of 2011 SMB Social Business Study SMB Group
 
The Shifting State of Endpoint Risk: Key Strategies to Implement in 2012
The Shifting State of Endpoint Risk: Key Strategies to Implement in 2012The Shifting State of Endpoint Risk: Key Strategies to Implement in 2012
The Shifting State of Endpoint Risk: Key Strategies to Implement in 2012Lumension
 
European Social Media Marketing ROI Study
European Social Media Marketing ROI StudyEuropean Social Media Marketing ROI Study
European Social Media Marketing ROI StudyAdobe
 
Survey results: The age of unbounded data
Survey results: The age of unbounded dataSurvey results: The age of unbounded data
Survey results: The age of unbounded dataMoxie Insight
 
The age of social influencer
The age of social influencerThe age of social influencer
The age of social influencerAna Garcia
 
The Age of Social Influencer
The Age of Social InfluencerThe Age of Social Influencer
The Age of Social InfluencerInitiative Spain
 
Marketing Trends & Analysis: 2011 Higher Education Survey Results
Marketing Trends & Analysis: 2011 Higher Education Survey ResultsMarketing Trends & Analysis: 2011 Higher Education Survey Results
Marketing Trends & Analysis: 2011 Higher Education Survey ResultsSparkroom
 
Symantec 2011 Information Retention and eDiscovery Survey Global Key Findings
Symantec 2011 Information Retention and eDiscovery Survey Global Key FindingsSymantec 2011 Information Retention and eDiscovery Survey Global Key Findings
Symantec 2011 Information Retention and eDiscovery Survey Global Key FindingsSymantec
 
Webinar presentation-for-web
Webinar presentation-for-webWebinar presentation-for-web
Webinar presentation-for-webBoni
 
Social Stats and Communications Trends
Social Stats and Communications TrendsSocial Stats and Communications Trends
Social Stats and Communications Trendsbrookeshepard
 
Public Engagement - Reality and Evolution of Public Relations by Richard Ede...
 Public Engagement - Reality and Evolution of Public Relations by Richard Ede... Public Engagement - Reality and Evolution of Public Relations by Richard Ede...
Public Engagement - Reality and Evolution of Public Relations by Richard Ede...Edelman Digital
 
Webmarketing123 digital marketing-report-2011 (1)
Webmarketing123 digital marketing-report-2011 (1)Webmarketing123 digital marketing-report-2011 (1)
Webmarketing123 digital marketing-report-2011 (1)Dario Salvelli
 

Similar to B2B buyers and social media (20)

Bill Stankiiewicz Copy 4 2011 Social Media Report
Bill Stankiiewicz Copy 4 2011 Social Media ReportBill Stankiiewicz Copy 4 2011 Social Media Report
Bill Stankiiewicz Copy 4 2011 Social Media Report
 
HP SME Index January 2012
HP SME Index January 2012HP SME Index January 2012
HP SME Index January 2012
 
2012 Connell & Partners Fall Pulse Survey Participant Report
2012 Connell & Partners Fall Pulse Survey Participant Report2012 Connell & Partners Fall Pulse Survey Participant Report
2012 Connell & Partners Fall Pulse Survey Participant Report
 
Senior Executive Social Networking Survey ( November 2009)
Senior  Executive    Social  Networking  Survey ( November 2009)Senior  Executive    Social  Networking  Survey ( November 2009)
Senior Executive Social Networking Survey ( November 2009)
 
Nielson Social Media Business Benchmarking study
Nielson Social Media Business Benchmarking studyNielson Social Media Business Benchmarking study
Nielson Social Media Business Benchmarking study
 
Highlights of 2011 SMB Social Business Study
Highlights of 2011 SMB Social Business StudyHighlights of 2011 SMB Social Business Study
Highlights of 2011 SMB Social Business Study
 
The Shifting State of Endpoint Risk: Key Strategies to Implement in 2012
The Shifting State of Endpoint Risk: Key Strategies to Implement in 2012The Shifting State of Endpoint Risk: Key Strategies to Implement in 2012
The Shifting State of Endpoint Risk: Key Strategies to Implement in 2012
 
European Social Media Marketing ROI Study
European Social Media Marketing ROI StudyEuropean Social Media Marketing ROI Study
European Social Media Marketing ROI Study
 
Survey results: The age of unbounded data
Survey results: The age of unbounded dataSurvey results: The age of unbounded data
Survey results: The age of unbounded data
 
The age of social influence
The age of social influenceThe age of social influence
The age of social influence
 
The age of social influencer
The age of social influencerThe age of social influencer
The age of social influencer
 
The Age of Social Influencer
The Age of Social InfluencerThe Age of Social Influencer
The Age of Social Influencer
 
Marketing Trends & Analysis: 2011 Higher Education Survey Results
Marketing Trends & Analysis: 2011 Higher Education Survey ResultsMarketing Trends & Analysis: 2011 Higher Education Survey Results
Marketing Trends & Analysis: 2011 Higher Education Survey Results
 
Symantec 2011 Information Retention and eDiscovery Survey Global Key Findings
Symantec 2011 Information Retention and eDiscovery Survey Global Key FindingsSymantec 2011 Information Retention and eDiscovery Survey Global Key Findings
Symantec 2011 Information Retention and eDiscovery Survey Global Key Findings
 
Webinar presentation-for-web
Webinar presentation-for-webWebinar presentation-for-web
Webinar presentation-for-web
 
Social Stats and Communications Trends
Social Stats and Communications TrendsSocial Stats and Communications Trends
Social Stats and Communications Trends
 
Public Engagement - Reality and Evolution of Public Relations by Richard Ede...
 Public Engagement - Reality and Evolution of Public Relations by Richard Ede... Public Engagement - Reality and Evolution of Public Relations by Richard Ede...
Public Engagement - Reality and Evolution of Public Relations by Richard Ede...
 
Digital marketing-report 2011
Digital marketing-report 2011Digital marketing-report 2011
Digital marketing-report 2011
 
Webmarketing123 digital marketing-report-2011 (1)
Webmarketing123 digital marketing-report-2011 (1)Webmarketing123 digital marketing-report-2011 (1)
Webmarketing123 digital marketing-report-2011 (1)
 
Structuring a Social Media Team
Structuring a Social Media TeamStructuring a Social Media Team
Structuring a Social Media Team
 

Recently uploaded

Kenya Coconut Production Presentation by Dr. Lalith Perera
Kenya Coconut Production Presentation by Dr. Lalith PereraKenya Coconut Production Presentation by Dr. Lalith Perera
Kenya Coconut Production Presentation by Dr. Lalith Pereraictsugar
 
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Saket Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Saket Delhi NCR8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Saket Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Saket Delhi NCRashishs7044
 
Youth Involvement in an Innovative Coconut Value Chain by Mwalimu Menza
Youth Involvement in an Innovative Coconut Value Chain by Mwalimu MenzaYouth Involvement in an Innovative Coconut Value Chain by Mwalimu Menza
Youth Involvement in an Innovative Coconut Value Chain by Mwalimu Menzaictsugar
 
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Tughlakabad Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Tughlakabad Delhi NCR8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Tughlakabad Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Tughlakabad Delhi NCRashishs7044
 
Ten Organizational Design Models to align structure and operations to busines...
Ten Organizational Design Models to align structure and operations to busines...Ten Organizational Design Models to align structure and operations to busines...
Ten Organizational Design Models to align structure and operations to busines...Seta Wicaksana
 
Islamabad Escorts | Call 03274100048 | Escort Service in Islamabad
Islamabad Escorts | Call 03274100048 | Escort Service in IslamabadIslamabad Escorts | Call 03274100048 | Escort Service in Islamabad
Islamabad Escorts | Call 03274100048 | Escort Service in IslamabadAyesha Khan
 
The CMO Survey - Highlights and Insights Report - Spring 2024
The CMO Survey - Highlights and Insights Report - Spring 2024The CMO Survey - Highlights and Insights Report - Spring 2024
The CMO Survey - Highlights and Insights Report - Spring 2024christinemoorman
 
BEST Call Girls In Old Faridabad ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,
BEST Call Girls In Old Faridabad ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,BEST Call Girls In Old Faridabad ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,
BEST Call Girls In Old Faridabad ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,noida100girls
 
Pitch Deck Teardown: Geodesic.Life's $500k Pre-seed deck
Pitch Deck Teardown: Geodesic.Life's $500k Pre-seed deckPitch Deck Teardown: Geodesic.Life's $500k Pre-seed deck
Pitch Deck Teardown: Geodesic.Life's $500k Pre-seed deckHajeJanKamps
 
Lowrate Call Girls In Sector 18 Noida ❤️8860477959 Escorts 100% Genuine Servi...
Lowrate Call Girls In Sector 18 Noida ❤️8860477959 Escorts 100% Genuine Servi...Lowrate Call Girls In Sector 18 Noida ❤️8860477959 Escorts 100% Genuine Servi...
Lowrate Call Girls In Sector 18 Noida ❤️8860477959 Escorts 100% Genuine Servi...lizamodels9
 
Lean: From Theory to Practice — One City’s (and Library’s) Lean Story… Abridged
Lean: From Theory to Practice — One City’s (and Library’s) Lean Story… AbridgedLean: From Theory to Practice — One City’s (and Library’s) Lean Story… Abridged
Lean: From Theory to Practice — One City’s (and Library’s) Lean Story… AbridgedKaiNexus
 
Call Us 📲8800102216📞 Call Girls In DLF City Gurgaon
Call Us 📲8800102216📞 Call Girls In DLF City GurgaonCall Us 📲8800102216📞 Call Girls In DLF City Gurgaon
Call Us 📲8800102216📞 Call Girls In DLF City Gurgaoncallgirls2057
 
Keppel Ltd. 1Q 2024 Business Update Presentation Slides
Keppel Ltd. 1Q 2024 Business Update  Presentation SlidesKeppel Ltd. 1Q 2024 Business Update  Presentation Slides
Keppel Ltd. 1Q 2024 Business Update Presentation SlidesKeppelCorporation
 
NewBase 19 April 2024 Energy News issue - 1717 by Khaled Al Awadi.pdf
NewBase  19 April  2024  Energy News issue - 1717 by Khaled Al Awadi.pdfNewBase  19 April  2024  Energy News issue - 1717 by Khaled Al Awadi.pdf
NewBase 19 April 2024 Energy News issue - 1717 by Khaled Al Awadi.pdfKhaled Al Awadi
 
/:Call Girls In Indirapuram Ghaziabad ➥9990211544 Independent Best Escorts In...
/:Call Girls In Indirapuram Ghaziabad ➥9990211544 Independent Best Escorts In.../:Call Girls In Indirapuram Ghaziabad ➥9990211544 Independent Best Escorts In...
/:Call Girls In Indirapuram Ghaziabad ➥9990211544 Independent Best Escorts In...lizamodels9
 
Flow Your Strategy at Flight Levels Day 2024
Flow Your Strategy at Flight Levels Day 2024Flow Your Strategy at Flight Levels Day 2024
Flow Your Strategy at Flight Levels Day 2024Kirill Klimov
 
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Kotla Mubarakpur Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Kotla Mubarakpur Delhi NCR8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Kotla Mubarakpur Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Kotla Mubarakpur Delhi NCRashishs7044
 
Organizational Structure Running A Successful Business
Organizational Structure Running A Successful BusinessOrganizational Structure Running A Successful Business
Organizational Structure Running A Successful BusinessSeta Wicaksana
 
Market Sizes Sample Report - 2024 Edition
Market Sizes Sample Report - 2024 EditionMarket Sizes Sample Report - 2024 Edition
Market Sizes Sample Report - 2024 EditionMintel Group
 
Buy gmail accounts.pdf Buy Old Gmail Accounts
Buy gmail accounts.pdf Buy Old Gmail AccountsBuy gmail accounts.pdf Buy Old Gmail Accounts
Buy gmail accounts.pdf Buy Old Gmail AccountsBuy Verified Accounts
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Kenya Coconut Production Presentation by Dr. Lalith Perera
Kenya Coconut Production Presentation by Dr. Lalith PereraKenya Coconut Production Presentation by Dr. Lalith Perera
Kenya Coconut Production Presentation by Dr. Lalith Perera
 
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Saket Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Saket Delhi NCR8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Saket Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Saket Delhi NCR
 
Youth Involvement in an Innovative Coconut Value Chain by Mwalimu Menza
Youth Involvement in an Innovative Coconut Value Chain by Mwalimu MenzaYouth Involvement in an Innovative Coconut Value Chain by Mwalimu Menza
Youth Involvement in an Innovative Coconut Value Chain by Mwalimu Menza
 
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Tughlakabad Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Tughlakabad Delhi NCR8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Tughlakabad Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Tughlakabad Delhi NCR
 
Ten Organizational Design Models to align structure and operations to busines...
Ten Organizational Design Models to align structure and operations to busines...Ten Organizational Design Models to align structure and operations to busines...
Ten Organizational Design Models to align structure and operations to busines...
 
Islamabad Escorts | Call 03274100048 | Escort Service in Islamabad
Islamabad Escorts | Call 03274100048 | Escort Service in IslamabadIslamabad Escorts | Call 03274100048 | Escort Service in Islamabad
Islamabad Escorts | Call 03274100048 | Escort Service in Islamabad
 
The CMO Survey - Highlights and Insights Report - Spring 2024
The CMO Survey - Highlights and Insights Report - Spring 2024The CMO Survey - Highlights and Insights Report - Spring 2024
The CMO Survey - Highlights and Insights Report - Spring 2024
 
BEST Call Girls In Old Faridabad ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,
BEST Call Girls In Old Faridabad ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,BEST Call Girls In Old Faridabad ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,
BEST Call Girls In Old Faridabad ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,
 
Pitch Deck Teardown: Geodesic.Life's $500k Pre-seed deck
Pitch Deck Teardown: Geodesic.Life's $500k Pre-seed deckPitch Deck Teardown: Geodesic.Life's $500k Pre-seed deck
Pitch Deck Teardown: Geodesic.Life's $500k Pre-seed deck
 
Lowrate Call Girls In Sector 18 Noida ❤️8860477959 Escorts 100% Genuine Servi...
Lowrate Call Girls In Sector 18 Noida ❤️8860477959 Escorts 100% Genuine Servi...Lowrate Call Girls In Sector 18 Noida ❤️8860477959 Escorts 100% Genuine Servi...
Lowrate Call Girls In Sector 18 Noida ❤️8860477959 Escorts 100% Genuine Servi...
 
Lean: From Theory to Practice — One City’s (and Library’s) Lean Story… Abridged
Lean: From Theory to Practice — One City’s (and Library’s) Lean Story… AbridgedLean: From Theory to Practice — One City’s (and Library’s) Lean Story… Abridged
Lean: From Theory to Practice — One City’s (and Library’s) Lean Story… Abridged
 
Call Us 📲8800102216📞 Call Girls In DLF City Gurgaon
Call Us 📲8800102216📞 Call Girls In DLF City GurgaonCall Us 📲8800102216📞 Call Girls In DLF City Gurgaon
Call Us 📲8800102216📞 Call Girls In DLF City Gurgaon
 
Keppel Ltd. 1Q 2024 Business Update Presentation Slides
Keppel Ltd. 1Q 2024 Business Update  Presentation SlidesKeppel Ltd. 1Q 2024 Business Update  Presentation Slides
Keppel Ltd. 1Q 2024 Business Update Presentation Slides
 
NewBase 19 April 2024 Energy News issue - 1717 by Khaled Al Awadi.pdf
NewBase  19 April  2024  Energy News issue - 1717 by Khaled Al Awadi.pdfNewBase  19 April  2024  Energy News issue - 1717 by Khaled Al Awadi.pdf
NewBase 19 April 2024 Energy News issue - 1717 by Khaled Al Awadi.pdf
 
/:Call Girls In Indirapuram Ghaziabad ➥9990211544 Independent Best Escorts In...
/:Call Girls In Indirapuram Ghaziabad ➥9990211544 Independent Best Escorts In.../:Call Girls In Indirapuram Ghaziabad ➥9990211544 Independent Best Escorts In...
/:Call Girls In Indirapuram Ghaziabad ➥9990211544 Independent Best Escorts In...
 
Flow Your Strategy at Flight Levels Day 2024
Flow Your Strategy at Flight Levels Day 2024Flow Your Strategy at Flight Levels Day 2024
Flow Your Strategy at Flight Levels Day 2024
 
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Kotla Mubarakpur Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Kotla Mubarakpur Delhi NCR8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Kotla Mubarakpur Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Kotla Mubarakpur Delhi NCR
 
Organizational Structure Running A Successful Business
Organizational Structure Running A Successful BusinessOrganizational Structure Running A Successful Business
Organizational Structure Running A Successful Business
 
Market Sizes Sample Report - 2024 Edition
Market Sizes Sample Report - 2024 EditionMarket Sizes Sample Report - 2024 Edition
Market Sizes Sample Report - 2024 Edition
 
Buy gmail accounts.pdf Buy Old Gmail Accounts
Buy gmail accounts.pdf Buy Old Gmail AccountsBuy gmail accounts.pdf Buy Old Gmail Accounts
Buy gmail accounts.pdf Buy Old Gmail Accounts
 

B2B buyers and social media

  • 1. Survey of B2B Buyers’ use of Social Media Report on the survey findings March 2010
  • 2. ‘Interesting survey and a subject which will become more and more commonplace over the next year or so’ Chief Information Security Officer Financial services ‘Very interesting questions which enabled me to formulate some thoughts I have been marshalling in recent weeks’ Procurement Manager Construction ‘Enjoyable and topical survey - thank you’ Senior Project Manager Business services
  • 3. Contents 1 Introduction 1 2 Sample Profile 2 3 Attitudes to and trends in usage of Social Media 3 - 10 3.1 Trends 3.2 Relative Time Spent 3.3 The Pros And Cons Of Social Media 4 Actual usage of Social Media, in context 11 - 26 4.1 The Purchase 4.2 Stage 1 - Identifying And Defining The Need 4.3 Stage 2 - Identifying Potential Suppliers 4.4 Stage 3 - Final Selection of a Supplier 4.5 Summary Overview Of The Whole Process 5 Looking to the future 27 - 29
  • 4. 1. Introduction Base One have commissioned a research study to explore the extent to which B2B decision-makers are using social media tools and channels to help them in the process of refining their needs and identifying suitable suppliers for major business purchases. The survey was conducted online, administered and analysed by market research specialists McCallum Layton, among business respondents provided by online panel provider Toluna. In order to qualify, respondents had to have been personally involved in the decision-making process for any type of purchase over £20,000 that had been completed on behalf of their business in the last 12 months - questions focused on this particular purchase, in order to ensure the findings are specific to actual experiences and decisions. The survey was carried out in December, and 503 decision-makers took part. 1
  • 5. 2. Sample Profile The survey respondents represent a wide range of companies across the UK, including those operating in manufacturing, business and professional services: Main Business Activity No. % Manufacturing 86 17% Business Services 73 15% Financial Services 68 14% Public Administration 46 9% Health 43 9% Retail / Wholesale Trade 39 8% Transport / Storage / Communication 38 8% Education 32 6% Construction 31 6% Utilities 19 4% Community / Social / Personal services 14 3% Hotel / Restaurant / Catering 11 2% Other 3 1% 2
  • 6. Around half of companies represented have over 1,000 employees: Organisation Size 6% 9% Up to 100 101-250 251-500 18% 51% 501-1000 1000+ 16% The respondents themselves are decision-makers working in a range of job functions, including IT and finance: Respondent Job Role No. % IT 221 44% Finance 113 22% HR 33 7% Operations / Production 27 5% Sales / Business Development 11 2% Procurement / Purchasing 11 2% MD / CEO / Senior Management 11 2% General Management 11 2% Office Manager / Admin 8 2% Project Management 5 1% Other 52 10% 3
  • 7. A broad spectrum of age groups was represented, as illustrated. While over two fifths of respondents were over 40, a fifth were aged up to 30: 1% Respondent Age 16% 19% Up to 30 31-40 41-50 51-60 26% 60+ 38% Younger respondents were particularly likely to be responding on behalf of smaller organisations. While the up to 30s account for 19% of the sample overall, they amount to a third of spokespeople for companies employing up to 250, and just 10% for the largest companies, those with over 1,000 people: Respondent Age Up to 250 Employees 33% 67% Up to 30 All Companies 19% 81% 31+ 1000+ Employees 10% 90% There were no real differences in the extent to which older or younger respondents were replying on behalf of companies in different industry sectors. In terms of job role, those aged up to 30 were more likely than the rest to be working in HR (15%, compared to 5% of older respondents) and less so in IT (36% compared to 46%). 4
  • 8. 3. Attitudes to and trends in usage of Social Media 3.1 Trends Respondents were asked how the extent to which they use a range of communication channels for any aspect of business decision-making has changed, over the last year or so: Change in usage over last 12 months Web searches 26% 39% 34% 1% Greatly increased Supplier websites 19% 44% 35% 2% Somewhat Industry press 11% 34% 46% 7% 1% increased Events/Seminars 14% 30% 48% 6% 2% Same Online video/Webinars etc. 7% 33% 55% 3% 2% Somewhat Press advertising 10% 22% 57% 8% 1% decreased Other online community sites 9% 22% 63% 4% 2% Greatly decreased Direct mail 10% 20% 53% 13% 4% Blogs 10% 17% 66% 3% 3% Linkedin 6% 21% 65% 5% 3% Twitter 8% 11% 71% 5% 5% Facebook 8% 9% 72% 6% 5% Overall, more respondents stated an increase in their use of any given channel than mentioned a decrease, meaning that all sources had seen a net increase over the last 12 months. This increase was greatest for web searches (use was up for a net 64% of respondents) and supplier websites (up for a net 61%). Social networking sites Facebook and Twitter experienced 6% and 10% net increases respectively, but LinkedIn saw stronger growth with a 19% net increase. Online videos/ webinars/podcasts saw an even greater increase in usage (36% net). Younger respondents (up to 30) were more likely to report their use of social media having increased in the last 12 months; over a third are making more use of Facebook (38%), blogs (46%), other online community sites (44%) and Twitter (42%). However, LinkedIn saw equivalent increases in use across all age groups, suggesting this channel is more appealing to older professionals than other forms of social media. 5
  • 9. 3.2 Relative Time Spent When asked how much time they tend to spend in a typical month using each channel to source information for their business, respondents gave the following average numbers of hours. This is clearly unlikely to be accurate, collected off the tops of their head rather than by means of a daily diary or equivalent, but gives a useful indication of how respondents perceive their relative usage of each, overall. Average hours spent per month using each channel Web Searches 11.3 Supplier Websites 5.1 Events/Seminars 4.1 Industry Press (print) 3.5 Online video/Webinars etc 2.0 Press Advertising 2.0 Direct Mail 2.0 Other online community sites 1.8 Blogs 1.6 Facebook 1.3 LinkedIn 1.3 Twitter 1.0 The up to 30s spend considerably more time on Facebook, blogs and Twitter (2.6, 2.5 and 1.9 hours a month respectively) than their older counterparts. They also spend more time, though, on press advertising (3.0 hours a month) and direct mail (2.9). 6
  • 10. 3.3 The Pros And Cons Of Social Media Respondents were asked to indicate what benefits, if any, they felt online community sites, videos, webinars or podcasts provide, when looking for business related information. As illustrated below, a little over half reported some form of benefit of these social media sources with just over one fifth actively seeing no benefits. However, a further sizeable proportion (25%) had no real view either way as far as benefits are concerned, perhaps through ignorance of, or inexperience with, these channels. 14% Benefits of social media Any benefits mentioned 11% No benefits 54% Don’t use them Don’t know/no reply 21% Interestingly, the up to 30s were no more likely than the over 30s to cite benefits. While it is the younger age group that is increasingly making more use of social media, older respondents are still seeing (potential) value to a similar extent. Benefit % of all respondents Access to other people’s experiences 17% Honest/unbiased views 6% Saves time/quick to access 6% Ability to interact 6% Easy to access/use 5% Up to date information 4% Access to wide ranging information 4% Volume of information available 2% Access to similar minded people 2% Price information/saves money 2% Detailed product information 2% 7
  • 11. At the same time, three fifths reported weaknesses or difficulties to using social media for business related information: 14% Weaknesses/difficulties with social media 3% Any weakness mentioned No weaknesses 59% Don’t use them 24% Don’t know/no reply Here the up to 30s were twice as likely (at 40%) than older ones, to say there are no weaknesses. 63% of over 30’s actively cited any weakness, compared to just 44% of the younger group. Key concerns were the reliability of the information obtained from social media sources - views found within sites and forums may be biased or from sources that it is impossible to verify. There were also issues over the sheer volume and diversity of information generated, and the time it can take to sift through it all: Weakness % of all respondents May not be reliable/trustworthy 12% Biased information 10% Too much to wade through 6% Cannot tell what the information source is 6% Quality/accuracy of information 3% Not specific enough 3% Too wide a range of opinions 3% Not relevant for my business 3% Time consuming 2% Security concerns 2% Prefer face to face 2% 8
  • 12. Overall, the proportions of respondents that we might call ‘fans’ of social media (seeing benefits and no weaknesses) and ‘critics’ of these tools (seeing weaknesses and no benefits) were similar, at 14% and 19% respectively; a further 40% could see both sides (citing both benefits and weaknesses). The remaining 26% are perhaps reserving judgement, with no view either way. Fans 96 See both sides 203 Critics 96 As would be expected, respondents falling into the up to 30 age band were more likely than the rest to be fans and less likely to be critics, and particularly more so when compared to the over 40s: Fans Up to 30 24% 33% 11% 32% See both sides All respondents 14% 40% 20% 26% Critics Over 40 8% 40% 26% 26% Reserving judgement Interestingly, though, the proportion of up to 30s who had no real views either way (32%) was broadly similar to that seen among older respondents - it is not the case that younger buyers are universally experienced in, and in favour of, these media. Indeed, while users of social media in real-life purchase situations (described in detail in the next section) are more likely to be fans, and 9
  • 13. non-users to be critics, as we might expect, this is not entirely cut and dried. 38% of all respondents made use of any social media at any of the three stages of the decision-making process for the business purchase they had been involved in - of these, 23% cited benefits and no weaknesses and 8% weaknesses but no benefits. At the same time, while 26% of non-users cited weaknesses and no benefits, 9% suggested benefits but no weaknesses. 10
  • 14. 4. Actual usage of Social Media, in context This report goes further than just exploring overall views on and trends in the use of social media. We focused respondents on one specific, significant business purchase they have made in the last 12 months, and went through with them, step by step, which channels and media types they used to help in their decision-making process and how influential these were in providing them with the information they needed. 4.1 The Purchase A screening question had confirmed that respondents had been involved in the purchase of a B2B product or service worth at least £20,000 in the last year. They were asked to further describe this purchase, by way of context. The single largest category of purchases referred to by buyers in this survey was IT equipment or systems, with consultancy services and support service contracts between them accounting for a further 28%: 6% Category of purchase 9% IT/Telecoms equipment/systems Consultancy services 13% 42% Manufacturing equipment Support Service Contract Property/Land 15% Other 15% Overall, these items were balanced between being one-off purchases (48%) and ongoing contracts (52%). IT-related purchases were particularly likely to be ongoing contracts (66%). 11
  • 15. The value of a little over half of purchases was up to £50k. The average purchase value came out at £2.9 million; however, when 8 individual ‘outliers’ (quoting figures in excess of £20 million) are excluded, the average purchase value falls to a perhaps more representative figure of £348k. 2% Purchase value 5% £20–25k 5% 23% £26–50k 9% £51–100k £101–250k 14% £251–500k £501k–1m 29% £1.1m–20m 13% £20m+ The ongoing contracts tended to be higher value, on average, than the one-off purchases (£411k vs £284k, excluding outliers), and the larger organisations, with over 1,000 employees, were spending more (£462k, on average) than smaller ones (£229k). Respondents aged up to 30 tended to be responsible for rather smaller purchases, on average (£249k) than those older than this (£371k) - likely to be linked to the generally smaller companies they represent as well as, possibly, their level of seniority within the organisation. 12
  • 16. 4.2 Stage 1 - Identifying And Defining The Need In nearly two thirds of cases (63%), the need for this business purchase was at least in part identified or recognised following some element of external impetus. The incidence of solely internal drivers was slightly greater among smaller companies and for smaller purchases. 13% How was the need for this purchase identified? 36% As result of internal feedback, analysis or consultation A bit of both As result of viewing or sourcing external information 15% Information sourced or found externally was especially likely to have played a part in the instigation of IT related purchases. 86% of all respondents surveyed were personally involved at this initial stage of identifying the product or service need for their organisation. IT functions were involved in a little over half of cases, reflecting the predominance of IT and telecoms equipment and systems being discussed. Functions involved at Stage 1 IT Function 53% MD/Board 35% Operations/Production 32% Purchasing/Procurement 26% Finance 22% Sales/Business Developement 16% External Consultant 10% HR 7% Other 17% 13
  • 17. Board level and purchasing/procurement involvement increased with the value of the purchase, as might be expected. Of all respondents personally involved at this stage of the process, 74% were the sole or main driver, leaving 26% in the role of influencer. Respondents were asked to indicate which communication channels from a given list (illustrated below) they had made use of at all, in identifying and defining their need. Channels used at Stage 1 Supplier Websites 62% Web Searches 51% Industry Press (print) 46% Word of Mouth 44% Events/Seminars 38% Direct Mail 22% Press Advertising 19% Other Online Community Sites 16% Online Videos/Webinars etc.. 12% Blogs 11% Twitter 10% Facebook 10% LinkedIn 9% Other 8% Established web methods were the most commonly used at this stage (supplier websites and search engines each used by over half of respondents). Traditional media sources and personal discussions followed, with the social media resources mostly recording usage levels of around 1 in 10. Younger buyers, however, consistently make more use of social media and other online media, in addition to being substantial consumers of traditional direct mail and press advertising. Those aged up to 30 said they had used on average 4.7 of these sources, compared to 3.4 selected by older respondents. Those involved in IT related purchases also cited more sources than the rest, along with those representing the smaller companies (up to 1,000 employees) and those who were the main or sole driver at this stage of the purchase process. 14
  • 18. Social media use specifically was also rather higher in the 31-40 age group compared to older respondents, but it is the up to 30 group where the difference is most marked: Channels usage by age at Stage 1 Supplier Websites 58% Up to 30 62% 51% 31+ Web Searches 52% 51% Industry Press (print) 45% 49% Word of Mouth 43% 44% Events/Seminars 37% 35% Direct Mail 20% 36% Press Advertising 16% 32% Other Online Community Sites 12% 12% Online Videos/Webinars etc.. 13% 25% Blogs 7% 25% Twitter 6% 30% Facebook 6% 13% LinkedIn 9% 4% Other 9% One exception was LinkedIn, where the 31-40s are using this medium as frequently as the younger age group. Buyers aged over 40 typically relied more on word of mouth (47%) and supplier websites (59%), web searches (44%) and other traditional media channels. 15
  • 19. For each source they had used, respondents were asked how influential this had been, in providing them with information to help define their need: Influence of each channel at Stage 1 Blogs (48) 71% 23% 6% Very influential Word of Mouth (191) 69% 28% 2% 1% Fairly Twitter (42) 67% 29% 4% infuential Facebook (43) 60% 26% 14% Not that influential Events/Seminars (165) 55% 40% 4% 1% No reply Supplier Websites (268) 52% 42% 6% LinkedIn (41) 51% 37% 12% Other online communitiy Sites (69) 49% 46% 5% Direct Mail (97) 49% 36% 15% Web Searches (223) 48% 45% 7% Online Videos/Webinars etc. (54) 44% 46% 10% Industry Press (198) 43% 49% 7% 1% Press Advertising (84) 38% 52% 10% Word of mouth and blogs (in effect, the online equivalent) were most frequently cited as having been ‘very influential’. Print media were far less likely to be seen as having been an important source of information. Twitter and Facebook were also frequently perceived as ‘very influential’. While usage of these may be relatively low, their power among the converted is clearly significant. At the same time, though, Facebook and LinkedIn attracted ratings of ‘not that influential’ from over 1 in 10 users of these sites. Of the most commonly used channels - those used by over a third of all respondents at this stage - word of mouth and events/seminars were accorded the highest levels of perceived influence. 4.3 Stage 2 - Identifying Potential Suppliers 423 (84%) of all respondents surveyed were personally involved in identifying potential suppliers for the product or service required, once the need had been identified and defined. While the function predominantly involved in identifying potential suppliers was the organisation’s IT department, still reflecting the nature of the purchases 16
  • 20. under discussion, Board level involvement in this stage of the process was lower (from 35% at Stage 1): Functions involved at Stage 2 IT Function 53% MD/Board 19% Operations/Production 23% Purchasing/Procurement 26% Finance 21% Sales/Business Developement 15% External Consultant 6% HR 8% Other 17% Of all respondents personally involved at this stage, 75% were the sole or main driver when it came to identifying potential suppliers. Established web methods remained the most commonly used channels at this stage. Industry press, though, was rather less likely to be referred to here than was the case at Stage 1, but traditional media sources (industry press, events/seminars, direct mail, press advertising) continued to show greater usage overall than the social media channels: Channels used at Stage 2 Supplier Websites 58% Web Searches 46% Industry Press (print) 39% Word of Mouth 45% Events/Seminars 34% Direct Mail 19% Press Advertising 22% Other Online Community Sites 10% Online Videos/Webinars/Podcasts 8% Blogs 9% Twitter 9% Facebook 9% LinkedIn 7% Other 8% 17
  • 21. As was the case at Stage 1, younger respondents and those dealing with IT related purchases used more sources of information, on average, than did the rest. There was no significant difference, though, between the number of sources used by drivers and influencers at this stage. As seen at the previous stage in the purchasing process, buyers aged up to 30 consistently made more use of social media over any other age group, although the use of LinkedIn and online videos, webinars or podcasts was more balanced over age groups. Buyers aged 50+ continued to rely more heavily on word of mouth. Channels usage by age at Stage 2 Supplier Websites 60% Up to 30 58% 46% 31+ Web Searches 46% 50% Industry Press (print) 36% 52% Word of Mouth 43% 39% Events/Seminars 32% 32% Direct Mail 16% 32% Press Advertising 20% 18% Other Online Community Sites 9% 9% Online Videos/Webinars/Podcasts 8% 22% Blogs 6% 26% Twitter 5% 27% Facebook 5% 9% LinkedIn 6% 4% Other 9% 18
  • 22. Among users of each channel, blogs, and Twitter and Facebook, again recorded strong levels of perceived influence when it came to providing buyers with information to help in identifying potential suppliers: Influence of each channel at Stage 2 Twitter (37) 81% 14% 5% Very influential Blogs (39) 74% 23% 3% Fairly Facebook (39) 69% 31% infuential Word of Mouth (191) 67% 30% 2% 1% Not that influential Events/Seminars (142) 62% 34% 4% No reply Direct Mail (81) 59% 32% 9% Other online communitiy Sites (44) 57% 36% 7% Supplier Websites (97) 54% 42% 4% Web Searches (195) 54% 37% 8% 1% LinkedIn (28) 46% 46% 4% 4% Online Videos/Webinars etc (35) 45% 49% 6% Industry Press (164) 42% 52% 5% 1% Press Advertising (95) 32% 56% 11% 1% 4.4 Stage 3 - Final Selection of a Supplier 86% of all respondents interviewed (435) had been involved in the final selection of a supplier for their purchase. At this point, Board level involvement in the process rises again: Functions involved at Stage 3 IT Function 52% MD/Board 29% Operations/Production 22% Purchasing/Procurement 29% Finance 22% Sales/Business Developement 15% External Consultant 4% HR 8% Other 17% 19
  • 23. In all, 70% of all respondents personally involved in the ultimate selection of supplier had been the sole or main driver at this final stage. In final supplier selection, use of all sources decreased overall, suggesting that buyers are relying on fewer different sources and focusing on a select few by this stage - citing 2.6 sources each on average, compared to 3.6 at Stage 1 and 3.2 at Stage 2. Channels used at Stage 3 Supplier Websites 45% Web Searches 25% Industry Press (print) 26% Word of Mouth 40% Events/Seminars 27% Direct Mail 18% Press Advertising 14% Other Online Community Sites 7% Online Videos/Webinars/Podcasts 8% Blogs 6% Twitter 7% Facebook 7% LinkedIn 6% Other 18% Supplier websites and word of mouth remained favoured sources of information, followed by other traditional media (industry press, events, direct mail, press adverts, plus web searches). While social media channels still recorded lower usage overall, the proportions using these at this stage did not fall off to the same extent as other channels did - to users, their value appears to remain more constant from start to finish in the buying process. 20
  • 24. The age difference in usage of social media at this stage remains apparent: Channels usage by age at Stage 3 Supplier Websites 44% Up to 30 45% 32% 31+ Web Searches 23% 32% Industry Press (print) 25% 46% Word of Mouth 39% 37% Events/Seminars 24% 33% Direct Mail 14% 30% Press Advertising 10% 15% Other Online Community Sites 5% 9% Online Videos/Webinars/Podcasts 8% 19% Blogs 4% 23% Twitter 3% 22% Facebook 4% 7% LinkedIn 5% 4% Other 21% The ‘other’ category selected by a relatively large proportion at this stage is mainly accounted for by the incidence of formal tendering processes run by the larger organisations in the sample. 21
  • 25. In this final stage of supplier selection, word of mouth and social media were still felt, by users, to be the most influential of all sources used in decision making: Influence of each channel at Stage 3 Facebook (31) 87% 10% 3% Very influential Twitter (31) 77% 23% Fairly Blogs (28) 75% 25% infuential Word of Mouth (176) 72% 27% 1% Not that influential Other online communitiy Sites (31) 71% 26% 3% Events/Seminars (116) 69% 30% 1% Direct Mail (77) 66% 31% 3% Web Searches (108) 63% 35% 2% Supplier Websites (195) 56% 39% 4% LinkedIn (24) 54% 46% Press Advertising (61) 48% 50% 2% Online Videos/Webinars etc (35) 43% 51% 6% Industry Press (113) 42% 54% 4% Practically all Facebook users rated this source as having been ‘very influential’ in providing them with information to help finally select a supplier. Twitter, blogs and other online communities also came out strongly here. 22
  • 26. 4.5 Summary Overview Of The Whole Process Amalgamating the usage data from each stage of the purchase process demonstrates the extent to which buyers seek information from a wide range of sources when seeking to define their needs, then narrow this down to a shorter list of options as they progress through to selecting a supplier: Usage funnel 62% Supplier Websites 58% 45% 51% Web Searches 46% 25% 46% 39% Industry Press (print) 26% 44% 45% Word of Mouth 40% 38% 34% Events/Seminars 27% 22% 19% Direct Mail 18% 19% 22% Press Advertising Channels used at each stage 14% 16% Stage 1 – Identifying the need (434) Other Online Community Sites 10% 7% 12% Stage 2 – Identifying potential suppliers (423) Online Videos/Webinars etc. 8% 8% Stage 3 – Selecting a supplier (435) 11% Blogs 9% 6% 10% Twitter 9% 7% 10% Facebook 9% 7% 9% LinkedIn 7% 6% 8% Other 8% 18% In particular, usage of web resources and industry press falls off from one stage to the next. While use of social media is less common, reliance on these among proponents, however, remains more stable. 23
  • 27. Influence funnel The chart below illustrates the proportion of respondents involved at each stage of the process who gave ratings of very or fairly influential to each channel: Channels rated very/fairly influential at each stage 60% 50% Supplier Websites 40% Word of Mouth 30% Events/Seminars Industry Press (print) Web Searches 20% Direct Mail Press Advertising 10% Online Videos/Webinars etc. Other Online Community Sites Twitter Blogs Facebook LinkedIn 0% Stage 2 - identifying suppliers Stage 3 - choosing suppliers There is a notable decrease in the influence of supplier websites after the early stages of the buying process. At the need identification stage 58% described websites as influential or very influential, a figure that dropped to 43% by the final supplier selection stage. The same pattern is true of industry press and events/seminars. For social media, on the other hand, the level of overall influence from one stage to the next, while lower because usage is lower, remains fairly constant. 24
  • 28. Focusing specifically in on users of each type of social media, a further interesting pattern emerges: Social media channels rated very influential at each stage - by users 100% 90% Facebook 80% Twitter Blogs Other Online Community Sites 70% 60% LinkedIn 50% Online Videos/Webinars etc. 40% 30% 20% 10% 0% Stage 2 - identifying suppliers Stage 3 - choosing suppliers The perceived influence of Facebook and other online community sites actually increased steadily for users of these media through the purchasing process. 25
  • 29. Usage/influence map Combining together the usage and influence data from across all stages of the process, it is possible to map how the various channels sit alongside each other: Total usage and influence, plotted 3 Twitter Blogs Word of Mouth Facebook Events/Seminars Other Online Community Sites 2.5 Direct Mail Web Searches Supplier Websites LinkedIn Online Videos/Webinars etc. Industry Press (print) Press Advertising 2 0% 30% 60% Incidence of usage at any stage Among the up to 30 age group, the pattern is markedly different, underlining how the landscape may change in future: Total usage and influence – respondents aged up to 30 3 Twitter Blogs Events/Seminars Facebook Word of Mouth Other Online Community Sites Direct Mail Web Searches LinkedIn Supplier Websites 2.5 Online Videos/Webinars etc. Industry Press (print) Press Advertising 2 0% 30% 60% Incidence of usage at any stage 26
  • 30. 5. Looking to the future Finally, respondents were asked what factors they felt would change the way they research business purchases and suppliers in the future. Common themes included the following: The increasing importance of the internet • Becoming central to the business research process • Increased use of, and reliance on online methods • Increased influence of the information gathered online The decline of traditional sources • Particularly paper based media • The comparative cost of face-to-face meetings or traditional seminars to online methods is expected to drive down their use Access to other buyers via social media • Shift towards impartial end-user reviews and recommendations • Sales-free information sharing • Empowerment Access to suppliers online • Allowing greater choice and levels of detail • Creating more transparency and openness • Suppliers coming to buyers instead of vice versa Technological advances • Development and validation of new business/industry specific online resources • Accessibility, flexibility and mobility of resources (e.g. mobile technology, multiple applications) Cost implications • Financial restrictions on budgets will drive more rigorous scrutiny of purchase decisions • Efficiency of online research methods in both time and money 27
  • 31. Generally there appeared to be a broad expectation among buyers that online methods (including social media) will play an ever important role in how they research business purchases: “Use of the internet will increase greatly and industry online press will become more influential.” “Information on a much wider range of suppliers, including international suppliers, will be readily available.” “There will be increased use of online tools, in all possible forms, less direct mail, seminars, etc.” “Probably blogs and online community websites will play a bigger part in the decision making process.” In particular, many respondents highlighted the advantages or opportunities afforded by social media: “Forums, panels and blogs are the way ahead, using Google for searches can be a tedious task, taking up too much time. Comparison websites are mainly useless and filled with unwanted information and supplier/manufacturer websites take up time. Going straight to user forums or specialized blogs saves time.” “The information required will become more portable, thus leading to more rapid response to customers seeking information.” “Increased use of webinars and getting suppliers to come to us.” ....with many mentioning a focus on peer recommendation and communities: “I think communities of buyers will come together and may even pool their buying power.” “Recommendations from current suppliers or customers will become more critical via all communication channels.” A number of respondents also highlighted the greater need for more reliable information generally, from all sources, given the current economic climate and a pressure to optimize purchasing decisions: “[There is a] need for greater cost efficiency, leading to wider reviews.” “Tightening budgets within the company may need more extensive [pre- purchase] searches.” 28
  • 32. A small number of comments highlighted concerns over the consistency and reliability of business information gathered via social media and the difficulty in identifying quality sources: “I will always sample new methods but it’s the reliability and context that is important in order to understand the accuracy of the information.” “Too much information, it may become difficult to find the best places to research.” Some see the shift to online media as an all encompassing movement, whereas others are more reserved, envisaging that they will incorporate more new online methods into their existing research toolkit: “More people [will become] tuned into social media after those who don’t get it leave/retire.” “I will utilize more web areas but generally be careful and limit to particular proven sources.” However around 15% felt there would be no change to the way they research business purchases, suggesting a significant minority are not as romanced by social media or other online sources. In some instances this was attributed to formal tendering processes or because they did not see how online methods could be relevant to their business area, or simply that they didn’t see anything dramatic on the horizon that might alter their research habits: “Utilising unbiased web based research is still achievable for lower value purchases but in our business everything else needs to follow a strict procurement regime.” “Nothing will change dramatically, small incremental improvements in web capability will be evident.” That said, most respondents appear to be looking forwards with few directly expressing sentimentality or defending traditional methods. 29