SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 5
NGS: Negotiating a Path to the Future William Auberle, P.E., BCEE
Many challenges to plant operations, e.g. RHR decadal updates of SIP/FIP Site lease expiration with Navajo Nation Water service contract expiration LADWP withdrawal from ownership Mine Lease / Coal contracts expire Transmission contract expires 323 Grants expire
Many challenges to the region, e.g. Health & environmental impacts of pollutants GHG emissions and global warming impacts Environmental & cultural impacts of mining Economic impacts on communities and tribal governments of potential mine / plant closure Water delivery/water rights issues
Financial considerations Costs of BART (SCR+??) Costs of inaction:  pollution = health costs & environmental impacts Funds for regional “transition” and “economic development” and “visibility improvement” Water costs; water delivery; water rights
“Glide Path” emissions 2010 Years

More Related Content

More from en3pro

Forgotten People and NGS - Securing Economic & Climate Justice
Forgotten People and NGS - Securing Economic & Climate JusticeForgotten People and NGS - Securing Economic & Climate Justice
Forgotten People and NGS - Securing Economic & Climate Justiceen3pro
 
NGS Owners Initial Proposal 1 21-2011
NGS Owners Initial Proposal 1 21-2011NGS Owners Initial Proposal 1 21-2011
NGS Owners Initial Proposal 1 21-2011en3pro
 
Gila River Indian Community and NGS Impacts
Gila River Indian Community and NGS ImpactsGila River Indian Community and NGS Impacts
Gila River Indian Community and NGS Impactsen3pro
 
Navajo Nation EPA - Comments to ANPRM for BART FIP for FCPP and NGS
Navajo Nation EPA - Comments to ANPRM for BART FIP for FCPP and NGSNavajo Nation EPA - Comments to ANPRM for BART FIP for FCPP and NGS
Navajo Nation EPA - Comments to ANPRM for BART FIP for FCPP and NGSen3pro
 
Arizona Coal: Economic Development for the Hopi Tribe
Arizona Coal: Economic Development for the Hopi TribeArizona Coal: Economic Development for the Hopi Tribe
Arizona Coal: Economic Development for the Hopi Tribeen3pro
 
USEPA 2011-01-07 presentation
USEPA 2011-01-07 presentationUSEPA 2011-01-07 presentation
USEPA 2011-01-07 presentationen3pro
 
Black Mesa Water Coalition - Green Economy
Black Mesa Water Coalition - Green EconomyBlack Mesa Water Coalition - Green Economy
Black Mesa Water Coalition - Green Economyen3pro
 
CAP and the Navajo Generating Station
CAP and the Navajo Generating StationCAP and the Navajo Generating Station
CAP and the Navajo Generating Stationen3pro
 

More from en3pro (8)

Forgotten People and NGS - Securing Economic & Climate Justice
Forgotten People and NGS - Securing Economic & Climate JusticeForgotten People and NGS - Securing Economic & Climate Justice
Forgotten People and NGS - Securing Economic & Climate Justice
 
NGS Owners Initial Proposal 1 21-2011
NGS Owners Initial Proposal 1 21-2011NGS Owners Initial Proposal 1 21-2011
NGS Owners Initial Proposal 1 21-2011
 
Gila River Indian Community and NGS Impacts
Gila River Indian Community and NGS ImpactsGila River Indian Community and NGS Impacts
Gila River Indian Community and NGS Impacts
 
Navajo Nation EPA - Comments to ANPRM for BART FIP for FCPP and NGS
Navajo Nation EPA - Comments to ANPRM for BART FIP for FCPP and NGSNavajo Nation EPA - Comments to ANPRM for BART FIP for FCPP and NGS
Navajo Nation EPA - Comments to ANPRM for BART FIP for FCPP and NGS
 
Arizona Coal: Economic Development for the Hopi Tribe
Arizona Coal: Economic Development for the Hopi TribeArizona Coal: Economic Development for the Hopi Tribe
Arizona Coal: Economic Development for the Hopi Tribe
 
USEPA 2011-01-07 presentation
USEPA 2011-01-07 presentationUSEPA 2011-01-07 presentation
USEPA 2011-01-07 presentation
 
Black Mesa Water Coalition - Green Economy
Black Mesa Water Coalition - Green EconomyBlack Mesa Water Coalition - Green Economy
Black Mesa Water Coalition - Green Economy
 
CAP and the Navajo Generating Station
CAP and the Navajo Generating StationCAP and the Navajo Generating Station
CAP and the Navajo Generating Station
 

Bill Auberle - NGS Project - A Path to Agreement 2 18

  • 1. NGS: Negotiating a Path to the Future William Auberle, P.E., BCEE
  • 2. Many challenges to plant operations, e.g. RHR decadal updates of SIP/FIP Site lease expiration with Navajo Nation Water service contract expiration LADWP withdrawal from ownership Mine Lease / Coal contracts expire Transmission contract expires 323 Grants expire
  • 3. Many challenges to the region, e.g. Health & environmental impacts of pollutants GHG emissions and global warming impacts Environmental & cultural impacts of mining Economic impacts on communities and tribal governments of potential mine / plant closure Water delivery/water rights issues
  • 4. Financial considerations Costs of BART (SCR+??) Costs of inaction: pollution = health costs & environmental impacts Funds for regional “transition” and “economic development” and “visibility improvement” Water costs; water delivery; water rights