The American Innovation Index (AII) is an ambitious project to rate and rank U.S. companies across a variety of sectors based on their level of innovativeness, as viewed through the eyes of their customers. The study examines how consumers experience innovation from the leading companies they do business with, including how the companies interact with customers and their perceived social innovativeness. Innovativeness is an important feature for companies to address in their strategy because it correlates with loyalty, differentiates them from competition and drives growth. Indeed, a company may actually invest too much in ensuring high satisfaction and not enough in new and innovative ways of meeting customer needs. Social innovation is also an area of emerging importance in a business environment where consumers (particularly Millennials) expect companies to broaden their focus to solve social and environmental problems.
This presentation will introduce the project and describe insights from the 2018 baseline AII (expected to be released in the second quarter). The AII is conducted by Rockbridge Associates, Inc., a market research firm that specializes in services and technology, in partnership with the Social Innovation Collaboratory at Fordham University and the Center for Innovation at the Norwegian School of Economics (NHH). The study is based on the methodology of the Norwegian Innovation Index (NII), with the inclusion of additional metrics to capture social innovation. NHH is recruiting partners around the world to conduct local innovation index tracking studies, so that ultimately comparisons can be made across markets.
This project is unique in its scope. Most innovation listings of companies in the U.S. rely on financial metrics or “upstream” features such as R&D and technology investments. Using the NII methodology, the AII relies on “downstream” results, that is, what customers actually experience from service providers when they do business after innovation investments have had an impact. In addition, many innovation indexes rank countries instead of companies, usually based on macroeconomic measures. The true measure of innovativeness of a country is how its consumers perceive the companies they rely on for services and products.
1. American Innovation Index™
PRESENTED TO:
SEPTEMBER 7, 2018
PRESENTED BY
Gina Woodall, President, Rockbridge Associates, Inc.
Lerzan Aksoy, Professor of Marketing at Gabelli School Of Business, Fordham University, Social Innovation Collaboratory
Tor W. Andreassen, Professor at NHH-Norwegian School Of Economics, Center For Service Innovation
Charles L. Colby, Founder and Chief Methodologist, Rockbridge Associates, Inc.
Tim Keiningham, Associate Professor at St. Johns University and Chief Strategy Officer, Rockbridge Associates, Inc.
3. Can a non-technology based company be
considered highly innovative?
INTRODUCTION
Apple
Amazon
Ikea
Toyota
Netflix
Airbnb
Southwest Airlines
Samsung
John Deere
Honda
01
02
03
04
05
06
07
08
09
10
10 Most Innovative Companies
5. VISION, SCOPE & METHODOLOGY
• An ambitious research program that quantifies the
innovativeness of nearly 200 companies in 20
industries from the customer point of view
• The idea originated in Norway – researchers at the
Norwegian School of Economics (NHH) believed the
true indicator of innovativeness in a market is
what can be gleaned from the actual experiences
of consumers
• Rockbridge partnered with the Gabelli School of
Business at Fordham University and NHH to
implement the study in the United States
About the American Innovation Index™ (Aii)
6. VISION, SCOPE & METHODOLOGY
• Nationally representative online survey of over 7,000 U.S. adults,
comprising over 30,000 customer relationships
• Customers rated companies on key metrics:
Innovation
Social innovation
Customer Loyalty
Attractiveness
• For top companies, we also collected emotional experiences
(arousal and pleasure) and perceived change in how the company
does business.
The Aii™ Methodology
7. VISION, SCOPE & METHODOLOGY
American Innovation Index: Aii™
• Perceptions of the company:
Being innovative
Being creative
Changing the market with its
products and services
Being a category pioneer
Key Metrics
Social Innovation Index: Sii™
• Perceptions of the company:
Having innovative offerings that
benefit society
Prioritizing the social good
Creating innovative solutions to
benefit society
Metrics are based on scientifically validated scales and converted to 0-100 scores.
8. VISION, SCOPE & METHODOLOGY
Sectors Covered in the Aii™
Airlines Health Insurers
Auto Insurers Investment Services
Auto Manufacturers Life and Disability Insurers
Banks Lodging
Consumer Durables Restaurants
Credit Card Providers Specialty Retailers
Delivery and Shipping Supermarkets and Drugstores
Energy Utilities Technology
Fuel Companies TV/ISPs
General Merchandise Retail Wireless/Cellular
9. John Deere
Toyota
Ford
USAA
Honda
Chrysler
Nissan
General Motors
Chick-fil-A
Ikea
VISION, SCOPE & METHODOLOGY
The most innovative sectors are automotive, big ticket
manufacturing and technology
Apple
Amazon
Ikea
Toyota
Netflix
Airbnb
Southwest Airlines
Samsung
John Deere
Honda
01
02
03
04
05
06
07
08
09
10
Most Innovative Companies (Aii™) Most Socially Innovative Companies (Sii™)
Indicates company
is Top-10 in both
lists
11. • Successful companies are able to ensure their innovation assets – R&D, culture, people,
technology, IP – shift downstream and influence the customer experience
• Science shows that innovation is a strong driver of customer loyalty (and hence, the
bottom-line), influencing the customer experience, emotions, brand attractiveness, loyalty
and sales
Innovation Influences Loyalty
WHY INNOVATION MATTERS
COMPANY
INNOVATION
Customer
Experience
Arousal
Pleasure
Innovative-
ness
Attractive
-ness
LOYALTY
Customer Experience
• Value Proposition
• Value Delivery
• Customer Treatment
• Interaction Space
12. WHY INNOVATION MATTERS
In travel, the most innovative companies have the most
loyal customers
Airbnb Southwest Airlines
JetBlue
Hilton
Priceline
Choice Hotels
MarriottAlaska Airlines
Expedia Inc.
Delta Airlines
IHG/IntercontinentalBest Western
American Airlines
Amtrak
Wyndham
LaQuinta Inns
Motel 6
Frontier Airlines United Airlines
Most Loyal CustomersLeast Loyal Customers
LeastInnovativeMostInnovative
13. WHY INNOVATION MATTERS
The most socially innovative companies also have the
most loyal customers
Airbnb
Southwest Airlines
JetBlue
Hilton
Priceline
Choice Hotels
Marriott
Alaska Airlines
Expedia Inc.
Delta Airlines
IHG/Intercontinental
Best Western
American Airlines
Amtrak
Wyndham
LaQuinta Inns
Motel 6
Frontier Airlines
United Airlines
Most Loyal CustomersLeast Loyal Customers
LeastSociallyInnovativeMostSociallyInnovative
14. JetBlue
Airbnb
Hilton
Southwest Airlines
Choice Hotels
Delta Airlines
Alaska Airlines
Best Western
Wyndham
LaQuinta Inns
IHG/Intercontinental
Marriott
Amtrak
American Airlines
Priceline
Expedia Inc.
Motel 6
United Airlines
Frontier Airlines
WHY INNOVATION MATTERS
The most successful travel companies are
perceived to be innovative and socially innovative
TRANSFORMATIVE
DISRUPTIVE
BENEVOLENT
STAGNANT
Most Socially InnovativeLeast Socially Innovative
LeastInnovativeMostInnovative
15. CASE STUDY
JetBlue: A successful startup according to
the numbers
40 MILLION CUSTOMERS
ANNUALLY
1
2$1.2 BILLION IN INCOME
(2016)
3$759 MILLION IN PROFIT
(2016)
• Ranked #2 on Aii and #1 on Sii among
travel companies
• Overall (out of 163 companies)…
• #13 on Aii
• #14 on Sii
16. How JetBlue Innovates
• Implements customer service training that
focuses on the end-to-end customer experience
• Relies on partnerships for entertainment and food
and beverage to provide brands customers want
• JetBlue Technology Ventures, a VC fund that
invests in travel tech startups focused on the
customer experience
• Leverage cutting edge facial recognition
technology to improve the boarding experience in
partnership with TSA
• Focus on environmental sustainability, from
investing in NextGen tech to reduce greenhouse
gas emissions to partnering with environmental
non-profits and mentoring natural product
companies for sourcing
CASE STUDY
17. What JetBlue Customers
Experience
• JetBlue touts the fastest free in-flight WiFi
with several content partnerships
• The most legroom in coach of any carrier
• Unlimited free brand name in-flight snacks
and drinks
• Unique and numerous in-flight
entertainment options, 100+ channels with
DirectTV and Sirius XM
CASE STUDY
18. WRAP UP
• Your industry doesn’t determine your innovativeness
• You need to ensure your effort and investments reach customers
“downstream” to impact the bottom line
• Innovation is a powerful strategy to drive growth in a crowded sector where
satisfaction is not enough
• Even if you are innovative, you need to consider social innovation in order to
be “transformational” rather than “disruptive”
• Sometimes you can innovate without changing
• Customer focused innovation instead of excessive focus on the bottom line
wins
Key Learnings from the Aii
19. WRAP UP
• Next wave of the Aii planned for early 2019
• Correlate to financial data
• Expand industries
• Launch the program in other countries
Next Steps
20. FOR MORE INFORMATION ABOUT Aii, PLEASE CONTACT:
Gina Woodall
President, Rockbridge Associates
gwoodall@rockresearch.com
+1 703 757 5213 ext. 11
Charles Colby
Chief Methodologist & Founder
ccolby@rockresearch.com
+1 703 757 5213 ext. 12
THANK YOU!