2. Contemporary geopolitics closer to classical geopolitics
Cold War geopolitics Contemporary geopolitics
International competition bipolar Multipolar (?)
Logic of Competition Centered on one clear
topic – ideological
competition between two
superpowers
Not centered on one clear topic
– competition is determined by
a variety of factors
Centers of power and
competition
• Two superpowers
• Competition in the
whole world (the
worldwide balance of
power)
• Last superpower, rising
powers, revisionist states
• Global geopolitics +
regional geopolitical issues
4. What is contemporary geopolitics?
No universally accepted definition
The environment within which, and in response to which, the state must
act
An objective reality, independent of state wishes and interests, that is
determined by routes and centers of resources
All definitions focus on the relationship between politics and geographical
factors
5. Geography – the physical reality; describes the geological features of the earth
Geopolitics – the human factor within geography; distribution of centers of
resources and lines of communication, possessing a strategic importance (not
constant)
Geostrategy – the geographic direction of a state’s foreign policy: where a state
concentrates its efforts by projecting military power and directing diplomatic
activity
6. What is contemporary geopolitics?
A scientific approach that provides instruments (theories) to study
international relations and recommendations for policy-makers
Deals with distribution of power, security and strength of states
In contrast to realism, focuses on geographic characteristics of states and
their power
Studies redistribution of power, rise of new sources and centers of power,
and how they change the geopolitical picture of the world
7. Geopolitics and Hard Power
The legacy of Cold War geopolitics
Balance of power
Idea of balancing a potential threat
Security of resource supplies and trade routes
Main sources of power
Military security of the state, its territory and borders
Alliances
Ability to project power in certain places
8.
9. What is the source of power in contemporary geopolitics?
Many scholars believe that in contemporary geopolitics, competition between
states has moved to the economic sphere
Strong economy is needed
To ensure technological progress
To ensure domestic stability
To attract allies or to pay in different form to the other states for their assistance and/or
international support
12. Geopolitics in the economic sphere
“For some decades now the dominant elites of the
greatest powers have ceased to consider war as a
practical solution for military confrontations
between them, because non-nuclear fighting
would only be inconclusively be interrupted by the
fear of nuclear war, while the latter is self-
inhibiting”
“The logic of conflict in the grammar of
commerce”
Competition moves to the economic sphere
Edward Luttwak
(born 1942)
American political
scientist
13. On geoeconomics
Edward Luttwak
States remain territorial entities, spatially defined
They seek to maximize outcomes within their boundaries, restrict advantages to their own residents
and aim for domestically optimal decisions
“in the geo-economic arena… the instruments of conflict must be economic”
Geo-economics = geopolitics by economic means
"Just as in war the artillery conquers territory by fire, which the infantry can then occupy, the aim here
is to conquer industries of the future by achieving technological superiority."
Samuel Huntington
“In a world in which military conflict between major states is unlikely, economic power will be
increasingly important”
Although major powers have common interests in promoting trade, they would clash over benefits
from increasing trade
14. Geo-economic aspects of international
competition
Is it the same as geopolitics?
States, even economically successful, do not necessarily struggle for power and act
geopolitically
State remains the main actor in international relations but goals are also achieved
indirectly (through commercial companies)
With new actors, policy of a state becomes more limited as it has to find
compromises between its geopolitical goals and commercial interests of private
companies
Geo-economic influence may work in both directions (creating interdependence
between states)
15. Contemporary issues in geopolitics
War by Other Means (2016)
Geo-economics is the use of economic
instruments to promote and defend national
interests, and to produce beneficial
geopolitical results; and the effects of other
nations’ economic actions on a country’s
geopolitical goals
16. Economic security and resources
Resources are limited and finite
A state’s economy depends on resources – they are the main tool to produce
power and weapons
Access to extraction of resources and market is needed
Geo-economics of inclusion: International trade and development of economic
relations with other states
Geo-economics of exclusion: sanctions and embargoes