SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 3
Download to read offline
QuickTimeª and a
TIFF (Uncompressed) decompressor
are needed to see this picture.
Grin and bear it: One of the council signs.
Don't worry, be happy!
By CHRIS TINKLER and MATTHEW SCHULZ
12feb06
COUNCIL spies are counting smiles on
Melbourne's streets as part of a bizarre
ratepayer-funded program to foster
friendliness.
Green "smiles per hour" signs have also
been placed across Port Phillip.
The smile spies -- council staff and
volunteers -- have spent hours analysing
faces in 28 streets to establish each hub's
grin rate.
The initiative, which may spread to other councils, is aimed at prompting
residents to acknowledge each other more, improving their sense of
community, self-esteem and health.
But some residents have dismissed it as a bad joke and an insult to
struggling ratepayers.
The average rates bill in Port Phillip has risen to $1060.
Port Phillip Mayor Janet Bolitho said the study was important.
"These might be trivial issues to some people, but we take them very
seriously as they indicate just how connected a community we are," she
said.
But Elwood resident Andy Lear was not convinced, saying: "This is total
nonsense spending. I wish I had a few thousand dollars to throw away. It
makes me really angry."
After the first round of smile studies, Albert Park and Middle Park have
emerged as the friendliest areas, with an average of 18 smiles per hour,
QuickTimeª and a
TIFF (Uncompressed) decompressor
are needed to see this picture.
while in serious St Kilda Rd, you won't find a smile anywhere.
A Sunday Herald Sun survey of local government found the state's chief
executives are earning nearly 25 per cent more than they did four years
ago.
Top earners include Melbourne City Council chief David Pitchford, on
more than $310,000 each year; Boroondara's Peter Johnstone, $290,000
and Greater Geelong's Kay Rundle, $280,000.
EDITORIAL
The joke is on us
12feb06
THE campaign to count smiles is a demonstration of contempt for
Victorian ratepayers – an unfunny exercise in giving residents the
raspberry as their taxes are flushed down the drain.
To read the Sunday Herald Sun report on Port Phillip Council's secret
army of smile counters is to realise how over-governed we really are.
This municipal government has the resources to assign staff and organise
volunteers to check what it laughingly calls smile rates and to erect signs
pitting one precinct's sense of humour against another.
No wonder its rates are among the highest. No wonder residents are fed
up.
If other municipalities are giving thought to following suit, as the smile
checking coordinator indicates, then we want an investigation into the
shamefully wasteful ways of local government in Victoria.
Councils are slugging property owners far too much if they have funds to
measure mirth.
If they think they can go off on more of these Monty Pythonesque
tangents while raising rates this year and boosting the salaries of their
chief executive officers, voters should wipe the silly grins from their faces
come the next local government elections.
We would rather they simply emptied the bins and swept the gutters.
Sunday hs smiles article and ed

More Related Content

What's hot

2010 The good, the bad and the ugly
2010   The good, the bad and the ugly2010   The good, the bad and the ugly
2010 The good, the bad and the uglyRichard Colwell
 
Women's Markets Initiative PNG
Women's Markets Initiative PNG Women's Markets Initiative PNG
Women's Markets Initiative PNG David Week
 
Credit Crisis? Cash Crumble is the Reality!
Credit Crisis? Cash Crumble is the Reality!Credit Crisis? Cash Crumble is the Reality!
Credit Crisis? Cash Crumble is the Reality!Sabine Kurjo McNeill
 
What If Danville Gets a Casino? Risks, Rewards, Uncertainties
What If Danville Gets a Casino? Risks, Rewards, UncertaintiesWhat If Danville Gets a Casino? Risks, Rewards, Uncertainties
What If Danville Gets a Casino? Risks, Rewards, UncertaintiesDanville Regional Foundation
 
Urban Growth and Decline
Urban Growth and DeclineUrban Growth and Decline
Urban Growth and DeclineAshish Sood
 
Trends in Urban Humanitarian Context in Asia _2014
Trends in Urban Humanitarian Context in Asia _2014Trends in Urban Humanitarian Context in Asia _2014
Trends in Urban Humanitarian Context in Asia _2014Sajjad Mohammad Sajid
 
GM Living Wage Campaign (John Hacking)
GM Living Wage Campaign (John Hacking)GM Living Wage Campaign (John Hacking)
GM Living Wage Campaign (John Hacking)Julia Shepek
 
"Connecting with carless abandon" (Transit + Active Transportation) - Robin P...
"Connecting with carless abandon" (Transit + Active Transportation) - Robin P..."Connecting with carless abandon" (Transit + Active Transportation) - Robin P...
"Connecting with carless abandon" (Transit + Active Transportation) - Robin P...Aaron Antrim
 
C2C forum no2 Jeremy Leggett final
C2C forum no2 Jeremy Leggett finalC2C forum no2 Jeremy Leggett final
C2C forum no2 Jeremy Leggett finalPhilip Locke
 
Dave Rocker: How Tech Industry Helps Lower Unemployment Rates for Veterans
Dave Rocker: How Tech Industry Helps Lower Unemployment Rates for Veterans  Dave Rocker: How Tech Industry Helps Lower Unemployment Rates for Veterans
Dave Rocker: How Tech Industry Helps Lower Unemployment Rates for Veterans Dave Rocker
 
Houston 1Q2013 Land Market Presentation
Houston 1Q2013 Land Market PresentationHouston 1Q2013 Land Market Presentation
Houston 1Q2013 Land Market PresentationScott Davis
 
Jim Power New Ideas Conference March 2009
Jim Power New Ideas Conference March 2009Jim Power New Ideas Conference March 2009
Jim Power New Ideas Conference March 2009revolutionaries
 
Giving Albania: Philanthropy's Response to COVID-19 (November, 30)
Giving Albania: Philanthropy's Response to COVID-19 (November, 30)Giving Albania: Philanthropy's Response to COVID-19 (November, 30)
Giving Albania: Philanthropy's Response to COVID-19 (November, 30)Catalyst Balkans
 

What's hot (20)

2010 The good, the bad and the ugly
2010   The good, the bad and the ugly2010   The good, the bad and the ugly
2010 The good, the bad and the ugly
 
Women's Markets Initiative PNG
Women's Markets Initiative PNG Women's Markets Initiative PNG
Women's Markets Initiative PNG
 
Credit Crisis? Cash Crumble is the Reality!
Credit Crisis? Cash Crumble is the Reality!Credit Crisis? Cash Crumble is the Reality!
Credit Crisis? Cash Crumble is the Reality!
 
Brigitte-Perreault
Brigitte-PerreaultBrigitte-Perreault
Brigitte-Perreault
 
What If Danville Gets a Casino? Risks, Rewards, Uncertainties
What If Danville Gets a Casino? Risks, Rewards, UncertaintiesWhat If Danville Gets a Casino? Risks, Rewards, Uncertainties
What If Danville Gets a Casino? Risks, Rewards, Uncertainties
 
Urban Growth and Decline
Urban Growth and DeclineUrban Growth and Decline
Urban Growth and Decline
 
ADM Tendências (Episódio 06) Case Grow: Empreendedorismo e Negócios com Respo...
ADM Tendências (Episódio 06) Case Grow: Empreendedorismo e Negócios com Respo...ADM Tendências (Episódio 06) Case Grow: Empreendedorismo e Negócios com Respo...
ADM Tendências (Episódio 06) Case Grow: Empreendedorismo e Negócios com Respo...
 
Trends in Urban Humanitarian Context in Asia _2014
Trends in Urban Humanitarian Context in Asia _2014Trends in Urban Humanitarian Context in Asia _2014
Trends in Urban Humanitarian Context in Asia _2014
 
GM Living Wage Campaign (John Hacking)
GM Living Wage Campaign (John Hacking)GM Living Wage Campaign (John Hacking)
GM Living Wage Campaign (John Hacking)
 
"Connecting with carless abandon" (Transit + Active Transportation) - Robin P...
"Connecting with carless abandon" (Transit + Active Transportation) - Robin P..."Connecting with carless abandon" (Transit + Active Transportation) - Robin P...
"Connecting with carless abandon" (Transit + Active Transportation) - Robin P...
 
C2C forum no2 Jeremy Leggett final
C2C forum no2 Jeremy Leggett finalC2C forum no2 Jeremy Leggett final
C2C forum no2 Jeremy Leggett final
 
We can solve poverty in the UK endorsers
We can solve poverty in the UK endorsersWe can solve poverty in the UK endorsers
We can solve poverty in the UK endorsers
 
Brexit and the voluntary sector: Preparing for change
Brexit and the voluntary sector: Preparing for changeBrexit and the voluntary sector: Preparing for change
Brexit and the voluntary sector: Preparing for change
 
State budget 2016
State budget 2016State budget 2016
State budget 2016
 
Challenging The Recession
Challenging The RecessionChallenging The Recession
Challenging The Recession
 
As15
As15As15
As15
 
Dave Rocker: How Tech Industry Helps Lower Unemployment Rates for Veterans
Dave Rocker: How Tech Industry Helps Lower Unemployment Rates for Veterans  Dave Rocker: How Tech Industry Helps Lower Unemployment Rates for Veterans
Dave Rocker: How Tech Industry Helps Lower Unemployment Rates for Veterans
 
Houston 1Q2013 Land Market Presentation
Houston 1Q2013 Land Market PresentationHouston 1Q2013 Land Market Presentation
Houston 1Q2013 Land Market Presentation
 
Jim Power New Ideas Conference March 2009
Jim Power New Ideas Conference March 2009Jim Power New Ideas Conference March 2009
Jim Power New Ideas Conference March 2009
 
Giving Albania: Philanthropy's Response to COVID-19 (November, 30)
Giving Albania: Philanthropy's Response to COVID-19 (November, 30)Giving Albania: Philanthropy's Response to COVID-19 (November, 30)
Giving Albania: Philanthropy's Response to COVID-19 (November, 30)
 

Viewers also liked

Philip k Dick
Philip k DickPhilip k Dick
Philip k Dickpersi95
 
Giulio cesare
Giulio cesareGiulio cesare
Giulio cesarepersi95
 
The temptation against humanity
The temptation against humanityThe temptation against humanity
The temptation against humanity翰泓 李
 
Cuba's health care system
Cuba's health care systemCuba's health care system
Cuba's health care system翰泓 李
 
Wallacestone PS - Reading Comprehension in Primary 5, 6 and 7
Wallacestone PS - Reading Comprehension in Primary 5, 6 and 7Wallacestone PS - Reading Comprehension in Primary 5, 6 and 7
Wallacestone PS - Reading Comprehension in Primary 5, 6 and 7Wallacestone Primary School
 
Gravidity and parity - recording system
Gravidity and parity - recording systemGravidity and parity - recording system
Gravidity and parity - recording system翰泓 李
 
Death of large stars , the black hole
Death of large stars , the black holeDeath of large stars , the black hole
Death of large stars , the black holepersi95
 
Wallacestone PS - Reading Comprehension in Primary 3 and 4
Wallacestone PS - Reading Comprehension in Primary 3 and 4 Wallacestone PS - Reading Comprehension in Primary 3 and 4
Wallacestone PS - Reading Comprehension in Primary 3 and 4 Wallacestone Primary School
 
Healthcare system in taiwan
Healthcare system in taiwanHealthcare system in taiwan
Healthcare system in taiwan翰泓 李
 
Border conflicts
Border  conflictsBorder  conflicts
Border conflicts翰泓 李
 
Stress urinary incontinence - case and brief
Stress urinary incontinence - case and briefStress urinary incontinence - case and brief
Stress urinary incontinence - case and brief翰泓 李
 
Nuclear weapon
Nuclear weaponNuclear weapon
Nuclear weapon翰泓 李
 
媒體報導與互動(陽明大學)
媒體報導與互動(陽明大學)媒體報導與互動(陽明大學)
媒體報導與互動(陽明大學)翰泓 李
 

Viewers also liked (16)

Philip k Dick
Philip k DickPhilip k Dick
Philip k Dick
 
Hellomelo.hu
Hellomelo.huHellomelo.hu
Hellomelo.hu
 
Giulio cesare
Giulio cesareGiulio cesare
Giulio cesare
 
The temptation against humanity
The temptation against humanityThe temptation against humanity
The temptation against humanity
 
Cuba's health care system
Cuba's health care systemCuba's health care system
Cuba's health care system
 
Who is who game
Who is who gameWho is who game
Who is who game
 
軍訓報告
軍訓報告軍訓報告
軍訓報告
 
Wallacestone PS - Reading Comprehension in Primary 5, 6 and 7
Wallacestone PS - Reading Comprehension in Primary 5, 6 and 7Wallacestone PS - Reading Comprehension in Primary 5, 6 and 7
Wallacestone PS - Reading Comprehension in Primary 5, 6 and 7
 
Gravidity and parity - recording system
Gravidity and parity - recording systemGravidity and parity - recording system
Gravidity and parity - recording system
 
Death of large stars , the black hole
Death of large stars , the black holeDeath of large stars , the black hole
Death of large stars , the black hole
 
Wallacestone PS - Reading Comprehension in Primary 3 and 4
Wallacestone PS - Reading Comprehension in Primary 3 and 4 Wallacestone PS - Reading Comprehension in Primary 3 and 4
Wallacestone PS - Reading Comprehension in Primary 3 and 4
 
Healthcare system in taiwan
Healthcare system in taiwanHealthcare system in taiwan
Healthcare system in taiwan
 
Border conflicts
Border  conflictsBorder  conflicts
Border conflicts
 
Stress urinary incontinence - case and brief
Stress urinary incontinence - case and briefStress urinary incontinence - case and brief
Stress urinary incontinence - case and brief
 
Nuclear weapon
Nuclear weaponNuclear weapon
Nuclear weapon
 
媒體報導與互動(陽明大學)
媒體報導與互動(陽明大學)媒體報導與互動(陽明大學)
媒體報導與互動(陽明大學)
 

Similar to Sunday hs smiles article and ed

Community development a look at a city - wrap up lecture and seminar discus...
Community development   a look at a city - wrap up lecture and seminar discus...Community development   a look at a city - wrap up lecture and seminar discus...
Community development a look at a city - wrap up lecture and seminar discus...Michael Latin
 
The Death of Public Data in Canada
The Death of Public Data in CanadaThe Death of Public Data in Canada
The Death of Public Data in CanadaThomas Barakat
 
The Horizon IT Scandal: A Systemic Failure and the Cruelty of Injustice
The Horizon IT Scandal:  A Systemic Failure and the Cruelty of InjusticeThe Horizon IT Scandal:  A Systemic Failure and the Cruelty of Injustice
The Horizon IT Scandal: A Systemic Failure and the Cruelty of InjusticeDaniel Martin Councillor
 
TIF_poster-27th_Ward
TIF_poster-27th_WardTIF_poster-27th_Ward
TIF_poster-27th_WardTom Tresser
 
Cp dev col_apr_2006
Cp dev col_apr_2006Cp dev col_apr_2006
Cp dev col_apr_2006noogle1996
 
Flint Water Crisis Presentation
Flint Water Crisis PresentationFlint Water Crisis Presentation
Flint Water Crisis PresentationSandraJMartin
 
Council Minutes - October 05, 2011
Council Minutes - October 05, 2011Council Minutes - October 05, 2011
Council Minutes - October 05, 2011Adam Stout
 
Community revitalization - Final
Community revitalization - FinalCommunity revitalization - Final
Community revitalization - FinalDarin Hall
 
Gerry Folan Brussels May 2009
Gerry Folan Brussels May 2009Gerry Folan Brussels May 2009
Gerry Folan Brussels May 2009peterramsden
 
Tackling Fraudulent Benefit Claims: A Council's Responsibility
Tackling Fraudulent Benefit Claims: A Council's Responsibility Tackling Fraudulent Benefit Claims: A Council's Responsibility
Tackling Fraudulent Benefit Claims: A Council's Responsibility Daniel Martin
 
David Boyle - Localism in the Thames Gateway
David Boyle - Localism in the Thames GatewayDavid Boyle - Localism in the Thames Gateway
David Boyle - Localism in the Thames GatewayTGLP
 
Political corruption
Political corruptionPolitical corruption
Political corruptionJosh Morris
 
New Forms of Urban Governance: Business Improvement Districts and the Challen...
New Forms of Urban Governance: Business Improvement Districts and the Challen...New Forms of Urban Governance: Business Improvement Districts and the Challen...
New Forms of Urban Governance: Business Improvement Districts and the Challen...Helena Villarejo
 
GiellisCoronavirusshutdownoffersopportunitytorethink.docx
GiellisCoronavirusshutdownoffersopportunitytorethink.docxGiellisCoronavirusshutdownoffersopportunitytorethink.docx
GiellisCoronavirusshutdownoffersopportunitytorethink.docxshericehewat
 
thius is the case stuy from here answer the Qustion for mor info .docx
thius is the case stuy from here answer the Qustion for mor info .docxthius is the case stuy from here answer the Qustion for mor info .docx
thius is the case stuy from here answer the Qustion for mor info .docxamit657720
 
Community mapping presentation
Community mapping presentationCommunity mapping presentation
Community mapping presentationlinreid
 

Similar to Sunday hs smiles article and ed (20)

Community development a look at a city - wrap up lecture and seminar discus...
Community development   a look at a city - wrap up lecture and seminar discus...Community development   a look at a city - wrap up lecture and seminar discus...
Community development a look at a city - wrap up lecture and seminar discus...
 
The Death of Public Data in Canada
The Death of Public Data in CanadaThe Death of Public Data in Canada
The Death of Public Data in Canada
 
The Horizon IT Scandal: A Systemic Failure and the Cruelty of Injustice
The Horizon IT Scandal:  A Systemic Failure and the Cruelty of InjusticeThe Horizon IT Scandal:  A Systemic Failure and the Cruelty of Injustice
The Horizon IT Scandal: A Systemic Failure and the Cruelty of Injustice
 
TIF_poster-27th_Ward
TIF_poster-27th_WardTIF_poster-27th_Ward
TIF_poster-27th_Ward
 
Sue Miller, Whitley Bay Big Local
Sue Miller, Whitley Bay Big LocalSue Miller, Whitley Bay Big Local
Sue Miller, Whitley Bay Big Local
 
Cp dev col_apr_2006
Cp dev col_apr_2006Cp dev col_apr_2006
Cp dev col_apr_2006
 
Flint Water Crisis Presentation
Flint Water Crisis PresentationFlint Water Crisis Presentation
Flint Water Crisis Presentation
 
Council Minutes - October 05, 2011
Council Minutes - October 05, 2011Council Minutes - October 05, 2011
Council Minutes - October 05, 2011
 
Newsletter2front
Newsletter2frontNewsletter2front
Newsletter2front
 
Community revitalization - Final
Community revitalization - FinalCommunity revitalization - Final
Community revitalization - Final
 
Gerry Folan Brussels May 2009
Gerry Folan Brussels May 2009Gerry Folan Brussels May 2009
Gerry Folan Brussels May 2009
 
Tackling Fraudulent Benefit Claims: A Council's Responsibility
Tackling Fraudulent Benefit Claims: A Council's Responsibility Tackling Fraudulent Benefit Claims: A Council's Responsibility
Tackling Fraudulent Benefit Claims: A Council's Responsibility
 
Capstone Paper
Capstone PaperCapstone Paper
Capstone Paper
 
Inner City News
Inner City NewsInner City News
Inner City News
 
David Boyle - Localism in the Thames Gateway
David Boyle - Localism in the Thames GatewayDavid Boyle - Localism in the Thames Gateway
David Boyle - Localism in the Thames Gateway
 
Political corruption
Political corruptionPolitical corruption
Political corruption
 
New Forms of Urban Governance: Business Improvement Districts and the Challen...
New Forms of Urban Governance: Business Improvement Districts and the Challen...New Forms of Urban Governance: Business Improvement Districts and the Challen...
New Forms of Urban Governance: Business Improvement Districts and the Challen...
 
GiellisCoronavirusshutdownoffersopportunitytorethink.docx
GiellisCoronavirusshutdownoffersopportunitytorethink.docxGiellisCoronavirusshutdownoffersopportunitytorethink.docx
GiellisCoronavirusshutdownoffersopportunitytorethink.docx
 
thius is the case stuy from here answer the Qustion for mor info .docx
thius is the case stuy from here answer the Qustion for mor info .docxthius is the case stuy from here answer the Qustion for mor info .docx
thius is the case stuy from here answer the Qustion for mor info .docx
 
Community mapping presentation
Community mapping presentationCommunity mapping presentation
Community mapping presentation
 

Sunday hs smiles article and ed

  • 1. QuickTimeª and a TIFF (Uncompressed) decompressor are needed to see this picture. Grin and bear it: One of the council signs. Don't worry, be happy! By CHRIS TINKLER and MATTHEW SCHULZ 12feb06 COUNCIL spies are counting smiles on Melbourne's streets as part of a bizarre ratepayer-funded program to foster friendliness. Green "smiles per hour" signs have also been placed across Port Phillip. The smile spies -- council staff and volunteers -- have spent hours analysing faces in 28 streets to establish each hub's grin rate. The initiative, which may spread to other councils, is aimed at prompting residents to acknowledge each other more, improving their sense of community, self-esteem and health. But some residents have dismissed it as a bad joke and an insult to struggling ratepayers. The average rates bill in Port Phillip has risen to $1060. Port Phillip Mayor Janet Bolitho said the study was important. "These might be trivial issues to some people, but we take them very seriously as they indicate just how connected a community we are," she said. But Elwood resident Andy Lear was not convinced, saying: "This is total nonsense spending. I wish I had a few thousand dollars to throw away. It makes me really angry." After the first round of smile studies, Albert Park and Middle Park have emerged as the friendliest areas, with an average of 18 smiles per hour, QuickTimeª and a TIFF (Uncompressed) decompressor are needed to see this picture.
  • 2. while in serious St Kilda Rd, you won't find a smile anywhere. A Sunday Herald Sun survey of local government found the state's chief executives are earning nearly 25 per cent more than they did four years ago. Top earners include Melbourne City Council chief David Pitchford, on more than $310,000 each year; Boroondara's Peter Johnstone, $290,000 and Greater Geelong's Kay Rundle, $280,000. EDITORIAL The joke is on us 12feb06 THE campaign to count smiles is a demonstration of contempt for Victorian ratepayers – an unfunny exercise in giving residents the raspberry as their taxes are flushed down the drain. To read the Sunday Herald Sun report on Port Phillip Council's secret army of smile counters is to realise how over-governed we really are. This municipal government has the resources to assign staff and organise volunteers to check what it laughingly calls smile rates and to erect signs pitting one precinct's sense of humour against another. No wonder its rates are among the highest. No wonder residents are fed up. If other municipalities are giving thought to following suit, as the smile checking coordinator indicates, then we want an investigation into the shamefully wasteful ways of local government in Victoria. Councils are slugging property owners far too much if they have funds to measure mirth. If they think they can go off on more of these Monty Pythonesque tangents while raising rates this year and boosting the salaries of their chief executive officers, voters should wipe the silly grins from their faces come the next local government elections. We would rather they simply emptied the bins and swept the gutters.