The document summarizes an article about freedom of speech in Israel. It discusses a summer camp program for children of fallen IDF soldiers that aims to honor those who died defending Israel. It notes that internal divisions in Israeli society make achieving peace difficult. It also argues that while social media allows free expression, not all loud voices are informed and thoughtful discussion is more impactful. In the end, it expresses pride in Israel and its people's resilience and role as a beacon of hope.

1. 7/23/23, 6:58 AM They Died So We May Speak | Andy Blumenthal | The Blogs
https://blogs.timesofisrael.com/they-died-so-we-may-speak/ 1/5
THE BLOGS
Andy Blumenthal
Leadership With Heart
They Died So We May
Speak
ADVERTISEMENT

2. 7/23/23, 6:58 AM They Died So We May Speak | Andy Blumenthal | The Blogs
https://blogs.timesofisrael.com/they-died-so-we-may-speak/ 2/5
Photo adapted from Israel Defense Forces via
https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:1997_Israeli_helicopter_disaster_funeral.jpg
Israel is a blessed nation, and its people are blessed as well. This is evident in
the beauty and resilience of the country, as well as the strength and
determination of its people. The country has overcome many challenges in its
history and has always emerged stronger. The Israeli people are a diverse group,
but they are united by their common faith and their shared history. They are a
people who have faced adversity and come out stronger on the other side.
Israel and Its People are Blessed.
Since 1948, Israel has become not only the single Jewish nation in the world and
the only democracy in the Middle East; it is also a land where the deserts bloom,
and the Start-Up nation has grown into a true hi-tech and innovation
powerhouse. But more than the land and nation being blessed, the people are
actually blessed, and it is visible! Today, in synagogue, there was a group of
teens from the FIDF Legacy Summer Camp program for children from IDF
bereaved families. What a beautiful program to bring these kids to America for a
few weeks of camp and fun, and for us to say thank you for defending us and

3. 7/23/23, 6:58 AM They Died So We May Speak | Andy Blumenthal | The Blogs
https://blogs.timesofisrael.com/they-died-so-we-may-speak/ 3/5
inspiring us. But what I also noticed, and it was amazing, was that the children
literally shone. They had a beautiful, holy aura (and no, I am not imaging it). I
said to my wife, “Do you see what I am seeing?” And we both couldn’t believe it
—the children had a heavenly glow. I said, “The blessings that Hashem bestows
on Israel are literally on the faces of the children.” It made me think of Moses,
when he was granted permission to see G-d’s back at the giving of the Torah on
Har Sinai, and he literally shone afterwards.
How Will Peace Ever Have a Chance?
With the protests in Israel over judicial reform going on for an agonizing 28
weeks now, culminating in a march on Jerusalem, we see such division that it
seems almost like when Israel split into the two kingdoms of Israel and Judah
2,800 years ago. Yes, the protests now are about judicial reform, but underneath
it all, it definitely seems like it is more boiling over antagonism between secular
vs. religious, Peace Now (and trading land for peace) vs. Peace through Strength
(and building the Settlements), and the politics of left vs. right (especially those
that hate PM Netanyahu). Unfortunately, if we can’t work out our internal
divisions as a Jewish people and nation, embrace and love each other, really talk
to each other, and find middle ground, then how can we ever find true and
lasting peace with our Arab neighbors? And peace is what we pray for and want
more than anything!
Big Mouths and Small Brains
Aside from the Israeli protests, with the advent of the Internet and especially
social media, people have the ability and, generally, the freedom to say what
they want, when they want. It has become easier than ever for people to not
only speak sense but to spout off. Whether it is voicing opinions about issues,
politics, officials, or just trolls looking to cast aspersions or conspiracy theories,
there is no shortage of those who spend what is clearly huge amounts of time
and effort to jump up and down, pump their chests, and try to shout the loudest.
But does yelling and screaming with near endless protests or 20+ posts a day

4. 7/23/23, 6:58 AM They Died So We May Speak | Andy Blumenthal | The Blogs
https://blogs.timesofisrael.com/they-died-so-we-may-speak/ 4/5
really accomplish anything? Honestly, I remember this German saying from
when I was growing up about people who do this, and it goes something like
this:
Translated into English, it means a big, big mouth and a little, little head. I
believe there is a similar saying that I heard in relation to the intelligence
community: “Those who know don’t talk. Those who talk don’t know.” In short, I
take these to mean that it’s definitely not the biggest mouth or loudest voice
that either knows what they are talking about or has a real impact, but the
thoughtful sincerity of those who speak from the heart and act in truth and G-
dliness that speaks volumes above all else.
Summing up these three themes, the beautiful Israeli teens from the FIDF
Legacy Summer Camp program are the children and siblings of those who died
to protect Jews rights to live, speak, and have self-determination. Rather than
cower in fear of the next pogrom or Holocaust, we can now use our sovereignty
to grow ourselves and improve the world. Whether or not we like or agree with
other people’s opinions, we should be grateful for the ability to express them.
Israelis are a people who are not afraid to speak their minds, and they are not
afraid to stand up for what they believe in. Regardless of the outcome of the
current controversies, I am proud to be a part of the Jewish people, and I am
confident that the citizens of the Holy Land will continue to be a beacon of hope
for the world.
Ein großer, großer Mund und ein kleiner, kleiner Kopf ”
“

5. 7/23/23, 6:58 AM They Died So We May Speak | Andy Blumenthal | The Blogs
https://blogs.timesofisrael.com/they-died-so-we-may-speak/ 5/5
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Andy Blumenthal is a dynamic, award-winning leader who writes frequently about Jewish life,
culture, and security. All opinions are his own.
ADVERTISEMENT