4. Strategic Choices in Mature
Markets
It is not always easy to tell when a market has
reached maturity
Variations in brands, marketing programs, and
customer groups can mean that different brands
and market segments reach maturity at different
times
5. Strategic Choices in Mature
Markets
As the maturity stage progresses, a
variety of threats and opportunities
can disrupt an industry’s stability:
◦ Shifts in customer needs or preferences,
◦ Product substitutes,
◦ Changes in government regulations,
◦ The entry of low-cost producers
6. Strategic Choices in Mature Markets
Success in mature markets requires
two sets of strategic actions:
◦ The development of a well-implemented
business strategy to sustain a competitive
advantage, customer satisfaction, and
loyalty;
◦ Flexible and creative marketing programs
geared to pursue growth or profit
opportunities as conditions change in
specific product-markets
7. Strategic Choices in Mature
Markets
Both analysers and defenders can attempt
to sustain a competitive advantage in
established product-markets:
◦ Through differentiation of their product
offering or
◦ By maintaining a low-cost position
8. Strategic Choices in Mature
Markets
Dimensions of product quality:
◦ Performance
◦ Durability
◦ Conformance with specifications
◦ Features
◦ Reliability
◦ Serviceability
◦ Fit and finish
◦ Brand name
◦ Make
9. Declining Market
Three set of factors help determine the strategic
attractiveness of declining product markets :
Condition of demand,
Exit barriers , and
Factors affecting the intensity of future competitive
rivalry
10. Declining Markets
Conditions of demand
◦ Technological advances produce substitutes
often with higher quality or lower cost
◦ Demographic shifts
◦ Change in needs, tastes, or lifestyles
◦ Cost of inputs or complementary products
Exit barriers
◦ The higher the exit barriers, the less hospitable a
product-market will be
11. Declining Markets
Intensity of future competitive rivalry
◦ Size and bargaining power of the customers who
continue to buy the product
◦ Customers’ ability to switch to substitute products
or to alternative suppliers, and
◦ Any potential diseconomies of scale involved in
capturing an increased share of the remaining
volume
12. End game strategies for declining industries
There are four strategies for declining industries which
vary greatly, not only in their goals but also in their
implications for investment
They must be pursued individually or sequentially
Leadership Strategy
A company following this strategy tries to reap above-
average profitability by becoming one of the few
companies remaining in a declining industry
Once a company attains this position, depending on the
subsequent pattern of industry sales, it usually switches
to a holding position or controlled harvest strategy
13. The underlying premise is that by achieving
leadership the company can be more profitable as
it can exert more control and avoid destabilizing
price competition
The company’s dominant position will give it cost
leadership or differentiation that allows recovery of
assets even after reinvestment
14. Managers can achieve a leadership position via
following tactical steps:
Ensure that other companies rapidly retire from the industry
Eg. H.J. Heinz and Gerber Products took aggressive competitive
actions in pricing, marketing, and other areas that built market share
and dispelled competitors’ dreams of battling it out
Reduce competitors’ exit barriers
Eg. GTE Sylvania built market share by acquiring competitors’
product lines at prices above the going rate
15. Develop and disclose credible market
information
Eg. Reinforcing other managers’ certainty about
the inevitability of decline makes it less likely that
competitors will overestimate the prospects for the
industry and remain in it
Raise the stakes
Eg. Precipitating the need of other competitors to
reinvest in new products or process improvements
makes it more costly for them to stay in the business
16. Niche Strategy
The objective of this focus strategy is to identify a segment of the
declining industry that will either maintain stable demand or decay
slowly, and that has structural characteristics allowing high returns
A company then moves to gain a strong position in this segment
while disinvesting from other segments
Eg. Armira followed a niche strategy in leather tanning
To reduce either competitors’ exit barriers from the chosen segment
or their uncertainty about the segment’s profitability, management
might decide to take some of the actions listed under the leadership
strategy
17. Harvest strategy
Undergoing a controlled disinvestment, management seeks to get
the most cash flow it can from the business
Eg. DuPont followed this course with its rayon business
To increase cash flow, management eliminates or severely curtails
new investment, cuts maintenance of facilities, and reduces
advertising and research while reaping the benefits of past goodwill
Other tactics include reducing the number of models produced,
cutting the number of distribution channels, eliminating small
customers and eroding service in terms of delivery time, speed of
repair, or sales assistance.
Companies following this strategy often have difficulty in maintaining
suppliers and customers confidence, however, and thus some
businesses cannot be fully harvested.
18. Harvesting tests managers skills as administrators because it
creates problems in retaining and motivating employees
These considerations make harvest a risky option
Quick divestment Strategy
Executives employing this strategy assume that the company can
recover more of its investment from the business by selling it in the
early stages of the decline
The earlier the business is sold, the greater is potential buyers
uncertainty about a future slide in demand and thus the more likely
that management will find buyers either at home or in foreign
countries for the assets
19. In some situations it may be desirable to divest the
business before decline in the maturity phase
Divesting quickly will force the company to confront its
own exit barriers, such as its customer relationships and
corporate interdependencies
For example, a company can arrange for remaining
competitors to sell its products if it is necessary to
continue to supply replacements, as Westinghouse
Electric did for vacuum tubes
20. Strategies for Declining Markets
Maintenance Strategy
◦ The business continues to pursue the
same strategy that brought it success
during the market’s mature stage
◦ Often results in reduced margins and
profits in the short term
21. Strategies for Declining
Markets
Profitable survivor strategy
◦ Investing enough to increase share
position and establishing itself as the
industry leader for the remainder of the
market’s decline
◦ The key to the success is to encourage
other competitors to leave the market
early