SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 72
Download to read offline
Avdelning, Institution
Division, Department
Institutionen för kultur och kommunikation
581 83 LINKÖPING
Datum
Date
11 June 2014
Språk
Language
Rapporttyp
Report category
ISBN
Engelska/English
ISRN LIU-IKK-MOE-D--14/005--SE
Master’s Thesis Serietitel och serienrummer
Title of series, numbering
ISSN
URL för elektronisk version
Titel
Title
Teachers’ Perceptions and Practices regarding the Implementation of the Course “Environmental Education-Education for
Sustainable Development (E.E.-E.S.D.)” in Cypriot Primary Schools
Författare
Author
Rafailia Katsioula
Sammanfattning
Abstract
Educating children to become active and responsible citizens and live sustainably is one of the primary educational
goals for the 21st
century, in many countries around the world. Cyprus decided to move towards a similar direction,
within a context of a wider effort to revitalize its educational system. Therefore, in 2011, a course called
Environmental Education–Education for Sustainable Development (E.E.-E.S.D.) was officially included in the
curriculum for Cypriot primary schools. The current qualitative research aimed to investigate issues related to the
implementation of E.E.-E.S.D. during those three years of existence. The focus was on teachers’ point of view and
therefore, the sample consisted of eight primary-school teachers from different schools and districts in Cyprus. Those
teachers were chosen after a combination of purposive and snowball sampling. Interviews, documents, photos and
informal conversations were used for the collection of the data. Data for analysis was analyzed using a thematic
approach and the four themes which arose as results were related to teachers’ practices regarding the implementation
of the course and their opinion on organizational aspects of it. More specifically, the findings demonstrated that the
first step of implementation, which is the choice of the topic for the course in each school, depends on the special
circumstances of each case and is mainly decided by teachers. Regarding the actual implementation, teachers pointed
out active participation of students, involvement of outsiders in the course and outdoor activities as the main ways to
preserve students’ interest for the course. Moreover, all of them appeared to be aware of the importance and benefits
of a cross-curriculum approach for the purposes of the course but depending on their experiences, some of them
spoke about barriers while others about auspicious factors and specific examples of such an approach. Finally, the
teachers mentioned the time dedicated for the course, the advisory support offered to the teachers and the criteria of
choosing the teacher in charge for the course as factors that need to be changed or improved. However, due to the
limitations of data and sample in the current research, its findings are expected to be perceived as an opportunity for
further investigations and not as general truths.
Nyckelord
Keywords
Cyprus, Curriculum, primary school, environmental education, sustainable development, implementation, teachers’ opinion,
teachers’ collaboration, barriers, procedures, practices, outdoor activities, experiential learning
INDEX
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS 1
CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION 8
E.E.-E.S.D. AND THE CYPRIOT NATIONAL CURRICULUM 10
THE AIM OF THE RESEARCH 15
RESEARCH QUESTIONS 17
ΤHE NEED AND IMPORTANCE OF THE RESEARCH 20
CHAPTER 2: LITERATURE REVIEW 28
ENVIRONMENTAL EDUCATION AND EDUCATION FOR SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT 31
ENVIRONMENT AND ENVIRONMENTAL AWARENESS 31
SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT 36
THE ROLE OF EDUCATION 41
E.E.-E.S.D. IN CYPRUS 47
THE BEGINNING OF E.E. - E.S.D 48
THE GOALS OF THE COURSE 51
THE CONTENT OF THE COURSE 54
VITAL PRINCIPLE OF THE COURSE 59
METHODS OF IMPLEMENTATION OF THE COURSE 61
EXPERIENTIAL LEARNING 63
THE IMPORTANCE OF EXPERIENCE 65
THE QUALITY OF EXPERIENCE 67
OUTDOOR ACTIVITIES 70
OUTDOOR EDUCATION AS A TEACHING METHOD 71
THE NEED FOR OUTDOOR ACTIVITIES 73
BENEFITS OF OUTDOOR ACTIVITIES 76
TEACHER AS A CRUCIAL FACTOR IN EDUCATIVE PROCEDURES 80
THE IMPORTANCE OF THE TEACHER 80
THE ROLE OF THE TEACHER 84
BEING AN EFFECTIVE TEACHER 88
THE POWER OF COLLABORATION BETWEEN TEACHERS 94
CHAPTER 3: METHODOLOGY 103
THE PROCESS 106
THE SAMPLE 110
SELECTION OF PARTICIPANTS 115
PROFILE OF PARTICIPANTS 121
QUESTIONNAIRE 130
INTERVIEWS 131
ACTION PLAN 139
INFORMAL CONVERSATIONS AND PHOTOS 143
ANALYSIS OF DATA 145
THEMATIC ANALYSIS AS AN ANALYZING STRATEGY 148
THEMES 153
THE THEMES OF THIS STUDY 156
ETHICAL ISSUES 162
PREVENTION FOR ETHICAL ISSUES 164
ETHICAL PROBLEM 168
CHAPTER 4: RESULTS 171
THEME 1: E.E.-E.S.D. AS PART OF THE SCHOOL REALITY 175
THE CHOICE OF THE TEACHER IN CHARGE FOR THE COURSE 176
ADVISORY SUPPORT FOR THE TEACHERS 186
THE SUITABILITY OF THE TIME DEDICATED TO THE COURSE 202
THEME 2: THE ANNUAL TOPIC OF THE SCHOOL FOR E.E.-E.S.D. 210
THE INFLUENCE OF CIRCUMSTANCES 212
THE ROLE OF THE STUDENTS REGARDING THE TOPIC 219
THE ACTION PLAN 229
THEME 3: IMPLEMENTATION OF A CROSS-CURRICULUM APPROACH 244
BARRIERS IN IMPLEMENTATION 246
CROSS-CURRICULUM APPROACH IN PRACTICE 259
AUSPICIOUS FACTORS OF IMPLEMENTATION 272
THEME 4: PERSISTENCE OF STUDENTS’ INTEREST FOR THE COURSE 279
ACTIVE PARTICIPATION OF STUDENTS 282
INVITING VISITORS AT THE SCHOOL 288
OUTDOOR ACTIVITIES 294
CHAPTER 5: DISCUSSION 303
THE ACTION PLAN AND ITS MULTI-DIMENSIONAL USE 310
THE SUCCESS OF ALTERNATIVE LEARNING 319
THE IMPORTANCE OF STUDENTS’ OPINION IN DECISIONS 331
THE DESIRABLE SUPPORT TO THE TEACHERS 339
THE EFFECT OF INTERPERSONAL RELATIONSHIPS ON THE PERCEPTIONS OF PROCEDURES 348
CHAPTER 6: CONCLUSION 359
SUMMARY OF THE RESULTS 361
SUGGESTIONS FOR USING THE RESULTS 367
SUGGESTIONS FOR THE MINISTRY OF EDUCATION AND CULTURE 369
SUGGESTIONS FOR THE PRINCIPALS OF THE SCHOOLS 373
SUGGESTIONS FOR THE TEACHERS 375
LIMITATIONS OF THE RESEARCH 378
SUGGESTIONS FOR FURTHER RESEARCH 382
REFERENCES 386
APPENDIX 409
TABLE 1: TEACHERS’ INFORMATION COLLECTED WITH THE QUESTIONNAIRE 410
QUESTIONNAIRE 424
INTERVIEW PROTOCOL 431
CONSENT FORM 438
INFORMATION SHEET 445
MAP OF CYPRUS WITH THE MAIN DISTRICTS 452
PHOTO 1: CONVERSION OF BROKEN COMPUTERS INTO DECORATIVE OBJECTS 455
PHOTO 2: CONVERSION OF USED CASKS INTO DECORATIVE SCULPTURES 458
PHOTO 3: CONVERSION OF A SPACE IN THE PARKING OF THE SCHOOL INTO A GARDEN 462
PHOTO 4: PICNIC TABLES USED AS AN OUTDOOR CLASS 464
1
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
I would like to use this chance to give my acknowledgements to all those who contributed to
this effort in one or another way. I believe that the people I mention bellow had a vital role in
the accomplishment of the current thesis project, either individually or collectively.
I would like to begin with my supervisor, Katarina Johansson and thank her for the immediate
responses to my questions, for all the suggestions for improvements and for the time she
dedicated to read my work.
Secondly, I would like to thank the team of professors of the master program “Outdoor
Environmental Education and Outdoor Life”. Our interaction and collaboration this year
offered to me useful knowledge, practical and mental skills and the ability to create a well-
rounded opinion of their way of working.
Also, I want to acknowledge the help and support of my classmates during the whole
procedure. I enjoyed sharing opinions, deadlocks, fears, jokes, achievements and big smiles
during our talks about our thesis in every chance.
But this work would not exist without the participation of the eight teachers who constituted
the sample of the current research. I would like to sincerely thank them for their willingness
to contribute to my effort, for their responsible and flawless collaboration until the end and
for all the information they shared with me.
My last and biggest acknowledgment goes to my family and friends. This thesis came to an
end thanks to their selfless and full support, both psychologically and practically. I
appreciated every single action, word and thought that came from them. The encouragement
and motivation they offered me has been a precious and inexhaustible source of power.
2
CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION
Summary
In this chapter, I describe the topic as well as the aim of this research which is to bring up
information regarding the implementation of the course of Environmental Education-
Education for Sustainable Development (E.E.-E.S.D.) in the Cypriot school reality. Also, the
research questions that lead the whole research procedure will be presented. An argument
regarding the need and the importance of the current research completes the chapter.
E.E.-E.S.D1
. and the Cypriot national curriculum
The course of E.E.-E.S.D. was officially included in the Cypriot school schedule in 2011. It is
considered to be a revolutionary change due to its special organizational characteristics and
the philosophy it relies on. It is a novelty for the Cypriot educational circumstances. Its
inclusion could be characterized as a vital need if we take into account the skills and attitudes
required in the 21st
century. As it is said, we are at a point in human history where we struggle
to maintain a balance in coexistence of human and natural world (Sandell, Öhman and
Östman, 2003).
The course has been framed by a very powerful curriculum with obvious elements from
theories which support the active participation of students in issues related to the society of
their school, the wider society of the country and finally, the world. Primary-school teachers
are expected to transform the ideas of the curriculum from theory into practice. Having in
mind that the course counts only three years of existence this task can be a quite challenging
one. During these three years, in order to track weaknesses and make improvements, there
have been several efforts to get feedback from the teachers as the main responsible for the
implementation of the course. I consider this research as a part of those efforts.
1
E.E.-E.S.D. is the abbreviation used for the course of Environmental Education–Education for Sustainable
Development.
3
The aim of the research
The aim of the present research was to investigate the Cypriot teachers’ views and practices
regarding the course of E.E.-E.S.D.. More specifically, the participants were asked to describe
methods and practices they use in order to approach the course, both individually as teachers
and collectively as members of their school teaching staff. In addition, I aimed to find out
their opinion on different issues related to the course, since I consider the teachers to be the
most suitable to evaluate the plan for its implementation.
Research questions
In order to fulfil the aim described above, I chose to have the following four research
questions:
 How do teachers teach the course of E.E.-E.S.D. in Cypriot public primary schools?
 Which is the teachers’ opinion regarding the organizational issues of the course E.E.-
E.S.D.?
 How can the teachers’ opinions be connected to the course aims and the implementation of
the course?
 What improvements can be made in the implementation of the course?
The first two questions were my point of reference in every step of the research procedure in
order to remain focused in the desirable direction while the other two questions occurred
because of the results. Of course, the findings of this research give answers to those four
questions at the extent that this was feasible, due to the existent limitations.
Τhe need and importance of the research
As it was mentioned before, the course of E.E.-E.S.D. counts only three years of existence in
the national curriculum of Cyprus and still the effort is not fully completed. The people who
are involved, from those that are asked to organize the course to those who are called to
implement it in practice, are still trying to find what works and what does not. The realization
of such a research is necessary since the results can work as a feedback that will lead to
4
further improvements of the course and of the Cypriot education in general. Even if this is
considered to be a small study I believe that it will contribute to this effort as it can become
the reason for further related research.
5
CHAPTER 2: LITERATURE REVIEW
Summary
This chapter presents a combination of information and ideas that were found after a review
of literature related to the findings of the research. It begins with an effort to define
environment and sustainable development and describe the role of education regarding them.
A trace back to the beginning of E.E.-E.S.D. in Cyprus is presented and then its curriculum is
briefly described with a reference to its most important aspects. Furthermore, theories and
arguments regarding experiential learning, and outdoor activities are mentioned. The chapter
draws to an end with a discussion on the role of the teacher.
Environmental education and education for sustainable development
Environment and environmental awareness
Firstly, I should try to explain the term “environment”. Dewey’s (1997, p.44) approach of
environment defines it as “(...) whatever conditions interact with personal needs, desires,
purposes, and capacities to create the experience which is had”. In a similar way, Sandell,
Öhman and Östman (2003) include in the term “environment” everything that is around us,
including both natural and human creations.
Being environmentally aware, means that you are able to realize and deeply understand the
elements that constitute the environment around you, as well as the interactive relationships
between them. Sobel (1996), and Dahlgren and Szczepanski (2005) argue that such
realizations can work as a transitional stage which will lead to a protective sense toward
environment. In the 21st
century, the need for developing such a sense is very important, for
most of the countries around the world. That is due to the increase of environmental, social
and economic problems, the continual human tend to measure and adapt everything in human
terms and needs and our progressive disconnectedness from nature (Sandell, Öhman and
Östman, 2003). Louv (2008) expresses his fears, especially for the new generations. More
specifically, the author presents a varied collection of research results, most of them showing
the benefits of interaction with nature from the one hand and the serious nature-deficit
disorder that characterizes today’s children from the other (Louv, 2008).
6
Sustainable development
There are plenty of definitions given for sustainable development, as it has been a matter of
discussion and contradictions due to the complex of the term (Sandell, Öhman and Östman,
2003). However, the definition that explains sustainable development as “the ability to make
development sustainable, to ensure that it meets the needs of the present without
compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs” (Kates, Parris and
Leiserowitz, 2005, p.10) despite its brief meaning, seems to cover the needs of this research.
From the very beginning of our existence, our relationship with the natural resources of the
earth has been a crucial matter of discussion and examination, even if the reasons and our
actions have changed a lot (Sandell, Öhman and Östman, 2003). According to Sobel (2005,
p.17), by making efforts towards sustainability, “(…) means that we accept a concept of
limited resources and start to look for ways to simultaneously enhance economic vitality,
environmental quality, and school improvement at local level.”
Orr (2004) claimed that a sustainable living requires a shift regarding the products we
consume and he underlines the importance of choosing products that are durable, recyclable,
useful, efficient and sufficient. Also, Orr (2004, p.62) pointed out the importance of making
this shift promptly by arguing that “if we are not to turn the earth into a toxic dump or
bankrupt ourselves by expensively undoing what should not have been done in the first place,
moderation must eventually replace self-indulgence”.
The role of education
Seymor (2004), claims that there is a high need in starting educating our children differently.
“It is not education, but education of a certain kind that will save us”, agrees Orr (2004, p.8).
More specifically, Orr (2004) borrows the Greek word Paideia to speak about the necessity of
an education oriented towards a mastery of one's person, instead of a master of subject matter.
Sandell, Öhman, and Östman (2003), point out three kinds of knowledge that a teacher who
undertakes environmental issues and issues of sustainable development should have and those
are: a) actual knowledge of those issues, b) experience of different ways of teaching and
learning and c) related skills that have been developed in previous experiences.
United Nations have dedicated a whole decade in order to orient Education towards a
sustainable development and 2014 is the final year (UNESCO, n.d.). As Scott (2013, p.182)
described “the UN decade encourages schools to take sustainability seriously in what they do
7
across buildings and grounds, in what they teach, and in how they link with local
stakeholders”. Scott (2013) explained that this decade has given schools the chance and the
obligation to contribute to the global effort towards a sustainable way of life, or a less
unsustainable one. Orr (2004, p.32) came to the conclusion that the difficult situation we are
in “(…) can be resolved only if enough people come to hold a bigger idea of what means to be
a citizen. This will have to be carefully taught at all levels of education”.
During the last years there has been a critical discussion about the relation, the differences and
the similarities of environmental education and education for sustainable development
(Sandell, Öhman and Östman, 2003). However, the focus of the current study is on the case of
Cyprus. In the context of Cyprus, it has been decided to officially refer to the course with both
terms in one title and that is Environmental Education–Education for Sustainable
Development. Therefore, in this study, there is no need to discuss the different opinions
regarding the general controversy on their comparison.
E.E.-E.S.D. in Cyprus
The beginning of E.E. - E.S.D
In 2008 the Cyprus Ministry of Education and Culture (MOEC) decided that it is time for
dramatic changes in education. Since the previous Curriculum, there have been a lot of social,
economic, political and environmental changes on the island. These changes, and in
combination with several suggestion by European programs, exposed a vital need for retrofit
of education in order to conform to the other aspects of life. After realizing the importance
and need of educational changes, several discussions and actions were done. Finally, in 2010,
the new curriculums were composed and ready for use. The change in Cypriot education has
become a reality since 2011 when the implementation of the new curriculums for the school
subjects has gradually started and still continues (MOEC, n.d.).
The course of E.E.-E.S.D. was introduced in the primary school reality occasioned by those
changes. More specifically, the course is given 80 minutes per week for the grades one to
four, during the same day and consecutively, and 40 minutes per week for the grades five and
six. For grades one to four, the curriculum has decided to share alternately those 80 minutes
between E.E.-E.S.D. and another course with the name Treatment of Life (MOEC, 2012).
8
The goals of the course
The main aim of the course of E.E.-E.S.D. is the development of a sustainable school, which
will be able to create autonomous and active citizens (MOEC, 2010). All the effort is
navigated towards the goal of a holistic perception of environmental issues and issues of
sustainability. Vital requirement for the achievement of that goal is the combination of
knowledge, action and participation (MOEC, 2010). The curriculum analyses the aim
mentioned above with the suggestion of a number of general goals to be achieved. Those
goals go beyond the students since some of them are uniquely designed for the teachers,
others for the school and others for the community (MOEC, 2010).
The content of the course
Regarding the content, or the things that are supposed to be taught, the Curriculum is very
flexible. In fact, each school is encouraged to create its own planning each year, by choosing a
topic or topics to work with for the whole year. The topic should emerge as a need by the
special circumstances of each school (MOEC, 2010). The organization of the course is
suggested to be done with the composition of an action plan. The action plan is a document
composed by the teachers of each school and includes information such as the purpose and
the goals of the topic. Neither the structure nor the action plan itself is officially compulsory
but its composition is highly recommended and additionally, with the collaboration of all the
teachers of the school (MOEC, 2012).
As a result, the course does not have a book. However, there is a guide book for the course
which is addressed to the teachers and is organized in twelve indicative thematic units i.e. the
forest, the biodiversity, the litter, the poverty, etc. (MOEC, 2010). Each one of them includes
basic concepts and vocabulary, the expected learning outcomes in local, national and
international level and also, interconnections with the other thematic units (MOEC,
2012).Those topics aim to work as the base for further planning. The Ministry of Education
and Culture encourages each school and moreover, the teachers to select issues appropriate to
a) the age, the knowledge, the interests, the experiences and the needs of their students, b) the
special social and political circumstances, c) the particular environment of the area and d) the
environmental and sustainable issues that concern the local community or are in general in the
limelight (MOEC, 2012). It is though underlined that the main target is not the quantity of the
topics approached but the promotion of a political thinking in the framework of a social,
democratic, based on values education and the conjunction of the natural sciences along with
9
the humanitarian sciences and the art (MOEC, 2010).
Vital principle of the Course
The revolutionary principle of the curriculum for E.E.-E.S.D. is the utilization of the local
environment of each school or of other places that can contribute to learning (MOEC, 2010).
Any place that can be used as a tool for the course can work as a class. The emphasis is
transferred from the book to the place and students are asked to investigate environmental
issues or issues of sustainability within their close environment (MOEC, 2010).
Methods of implementation of the course
The two main methodological guidelines that are suggested by the Ministry of Education and
Culture of Cyprus are a) the project and b) the cross-curriculum approach of the course
(MOEC, 2010). The importance of approaching the topic in a holistic way within the entire
school with collaboration is pointed out as a new element of great value for the needs of the
course (MOEC, 2012). With that directive, didactical practices, based on the active and
interactive learning, on the exploration and on the group work, are proposed. Some of them
are the problem solving, the debate and the role play (MOEC, 2010). Finally, Information and
Communication Technology (ICT) is recommended as well to be combined with the strategies
mentioned above.
Experiential Learning
Literature offers a wide range of theories connected to learning procedure. One of them with
many supporters is experiential learning. Beard and Wilson (2006, p.19), in an effort to define
experiential learning, argue that it is “the sense-making process of active engagement between
the inner world of the person and the outer world of the environment”.
The importance of experience
Dewey (1997), points out the need for a philosophy of education based on a philosophy of
experience. Dahlgren and Szczepanski (2005) discuss the deep difference between knowing
about something and knowing something, presenting the second one as more effective, due to
the involvement of emotions and actions. They believe that “when we meet the world around
10
us, we learn how it works, how it tastes, smells, and feels” (Dahlgren and Szczepanski, 2005,
p.25).
The quality of experience
For Dewey (1997), the nodal point is the quality of the experience. He developed a whole
theory, trying to give the “correct” idea of experience. He discriminates experiences in good
and bad. Good experiences are characterized by continuity and interaction, providing students
with a positive feeling for further learning. Bad experiences, as the author says, fail to provide
a connection of the skills with future experiences- if there are any, since students are usually
dissatisfied and repelled Dewey (1997). In any case, as Beard and Wilson (2006, p.7) argue,
“the more senses we use in an activity, the more memorable the learning experience will
become because it increases the neural connections in our brains and therefore will be more
accessible”.
Outdoor activities
Outdoor education as a teaching method
By accepting experiential learning as an efficient way to learn, it turns out that, actually, the
environment is the most proper place to learn about the environment. So that is how a need
for outdoor education emerges. Again, the literature offers a wide range of suggested
definitions regarding Outdoor education. However, I consider the literal definition of Outdoor
Education as sufficient. So, literally, outdoor education is described as the teaching procedure
that occurs in an environment outside the classroom (Hammerman, Hammerman and
Hammerman, 2000).
The need for outdoor activities
Beard and Wilson (2006, p.6) claim that “learning is literally and metaphorically breaking out
of the traditional classroom”. At the same time, Dahlgren and Szczepanski (2005) argue that
the indoor environments of a classroom can often be perceived as too strict and not enough
exciting for some students. Orr (2004, p.14) expresses a similar opinion by arguing that
“courses taught as lecture courses tend to induce passivity. Indoor classes create the illusion
that learning only occurs inside four walls, isolated from what students call, without apparent
11
irony, the ¨real world¨”. For Sobel (2005), the interaction between school, community and
environment, any type of environment, is very important as he believes that students should
get to know their close environment first in order to be able to offer later in a wider extend.
Of course, as Dahlgren and Szczepanski (2005) underline, outdoor activities do not intent to
cancel indoor learning but, instead, to complete it, having the child always in a central
position.
Benefits of outdoor activities
“Going outdoors is immediate and real; it sparks questions; it offers avenues of exploration
and investigation; and it is available, at little or no expense, to everyone” claims Bourne
(2000, p.5). The author continues by explaining that students who are used to work outdoors
in regular base are able to point out characteristics of each environment such as cycles of
procedures and patterns (Bourne, 2000). Furthermore, Beard and Wilson (2006) believe that
outdoor activities can offer several learning opportunities, due to the integration of the learner
with nature, other learners and facilitators at the same time. Dahlgren and Szczepanski (2005,
p.24) come to add that “the natural environment offers a wide range of visual impressions,
scents, movements, sounds, and shapes, appealing to all of the child's senses in a way which
no other environment is capable”. Finally, Dahlgren and Szczepanski (2005) argue that if
outdoor activities are applied in a proper way, not only knowledge can be achieved but also
close relations between the learner and the culture, the society and the nature. Regarding the
latter, the authors argue that through outdoor education the current detached relationship
between man and eco-system can be restored, a fact which should be our main objective as
human beings (Dahlgren and Szczepanski, 2005).
Teacher as a crucial factor in educative procedures
The importance of the teacher
According to Day, et al. (2007, p.1) “no educational reform has achieved success without
teachers committing themselves to it”. As Hattie (2012, p.25) said, “(...) teachers’ beliefs and
commitments are the greatest influence on student achievement over which we can have some
control (…)”. Richmond, et al. (2008, p.259) recognize the vital role of a teacher as well,
due to her/his “(...) control over children who have not yet formed their attitudes and ideas”.
12
As the authors explain, a teacher can work either as an auspicious factor or as a barrier in
students' learning, depending on the motivation that she/he offer through communication,
control, supervision, help and entertainment (Richmond, et al., 2008). Teachers are able to
influence the learning of the students and therefore, it is their responsibility to determine “(…)
that environment which will interact with the existing capacities and needs of those taught to
create a worth-while experience” (Dewey, 1997, p.45). In relation to the importance of
teachers in educational procedures, Day, et al. (2007, p.233) claim the following: “Teachers in
all countries need support for their commitment, energy and skill over their careers if they are
to grapple with the immense emotional, intellectual and social demands, as they work toward
building the internal and external relationships demanded by ongoing government reforms
and social movements”.
The role of the teacher
For Hattie (2012), teachers should be experts. According to the five dimensions that Hattie
gives to the term “expert”, a teacher should be able to a) form and introduce new knowledge
by taking in account students´ previous knowledge and needs, b) create an atmosphere that
allows active involvement and interaction of students, c) adapt the teaching plan and goals to
students current understanding while providing them with meaningful feedback which
promotes growth, d) respect the students and interact with them and e) have a positive
influence on students. Dewey (1997) is also a supporter of the crucial role of teacher in the
learning procedure. He believes that the teacher ought to use her/his own experiences very
carefully, in order to help students with their own from the position of leader (Dewey, 1997).
However, at the same time the author recognizes the difficulty of teachers’ role in finding the
required balances between freedom and control of students (Dewey, 1997). Regarding this,
Kahn (2002) considers children as active human beings that have the ability to take advantage
of their interaction with the environment in order to construct knowledge and values. Also,
Muijs and Reynolds (2001) support the importance of involving students in decisions for their
learning. More specifically they argue that “Giving students responsibilities helps build up a
sense of personal power, which will enhance self-esteem. Students should be given the
opportunity to make choices and should be allowed to make an active contribution to lessons”
(Muijs and Reynolds, 2001, p.108).
13
Being an effective teacher
To begin with, as Killen (2003) argues, there is not a teaching strategy that will always work
successfully no matter the learners. Hattie (2012, p.44) explains that “as well as bringing their
prior achievements, students bring many other dispositions to the classroom. These include
motivation to learn, strategies to learn, and confidence to learn.”, issues that a teacher should
consider.
According to Killen (2003, p.2), “(…) students will learn more when they are motivated than
when they are not motivated. This means that learning will be more effective when you make
it interesting, enjoyable and challenging for learners”. More specifically, the author argues
that an effective teaching includes activities that awake curiosity, emphasize in understanding
of concepts and relations than memorization of information, are adapted in the skills, the
attitudes and the knowledge of the students and have a relation with students’ everyday life
experiences (Killen, 2003).
In addition, as Richmond, et al. (2008, p.259) point out, “teachers must know how to present
material in an interesting and entertaining fashion. Students will then attend to it and retain it
longer”. Killen (2003, p.20) adds that “(...) learning is enhanced when the learners can see
how the things they are learning are relevant to them. This can be achieved by linking to their
background knowledge, connecting learning to the real world beyond the classroom; and
integrating knowledge across subject boundaries”. For Beard and Wilson (2006), the more a
student is involved in an activity the more he learns while in the meantime the effect on his
way of thinking as well as on his behavior will be bigger.
The power of collaboration between teachers
As Sobel (2005, p.67) argued “Teachers listen to other teachers. (…) When a teacher sees that
another teacher can do something, she is more willing to try it herself”. Teachers in a school,
have the chance to collaborate in order to achieve their educational goals. Burton and
Dimbleby (2006, p.247) explain that “we often join and form groups because we believe that
“two (or more) heads are better than one or because ¨many hands make light work¨”.
According to the authors, when the members of a groups are also an effective team then they
increase their productivity, improve the communication between them, achieve goals that
ordinary groups might not be able to achieve, use the available resources in a better way,
14
become more creative and affective when it comes to problem solving situations, provide
services of a higher quality and increase the level of processes (Burton and Dimbleby, 2006).
15
CHAPTER 3: METHODOLOGY
Summary
This chapter aims to describe the actions and explain the choices that were made, regarding
the methodological decisions of the research. It starts with a brief description of the process.
Then, some vital information about the sample of the research is presented, including
description of the contact procedure, demographic characteristics and relevant explanations.
After that, the focus is transferred on the data of this research. Therefore, information and
reasoning about the stages of collection and analysis are given. The chapter draws to a close
with a reference to the ethical concerns regarding the research and my actions in order to deal
with them.
The process
Because of the nature of my research questions and my intention to focus on teachers'
personal experiences and opinions regarding the teaching of the course of E.E.-E.S.D, I
decided to substantiate a qualitative research and more specifically, a case study. A qualitative
study offers access to a wider range of empirical data, comparing to a quantitative (Punch,
1998). A case study constitutes a qualitative method in which the researcher uses several data
sources in order to describe and understand a case with case-based themes (Creswell, 2007).
A case can vary a lot, from a single child to a whole classroom as Silverman (2010) explains.
In the current case study, I consider the implementation of the course E.E.-E.S.D. as the case I
am willing to explore. Of course, the implementation of a school subject has multiple
dimensions and several aspects which I do not wish to investigate at this point. Therefore, I
have limited the case of implementation to teachers’ perception of it.
Firstly, I started searching for participants corresponding to the needs of my case study and as
soon as I had my sample, I informed them about the research. Then, I composed an interview
protocol and after a pilot interview, I started collecting the data. The next stage was the
analysis of the data in order to get the results. Finally, through a combination of the findings
with related literature, I came up with some conclusions.
16
The sample
My thoughts regarding the sample came after I had decided my topic and specified my
research questions. Having them as a reference point, and in order to pick my participants, I
used a generic purposive sampling in combination with convenience sampling and in one case
snowball sampling. In generic purposive sampling, “the researcher establishes criteria
concerning the kinds of cases needed to address the research questions, identifies appropriate
cases, and then samples from those cases that have been identified” (Bryman, 2012, p.422).
Creswell (2007, p.125) adds that “the inquirer selects individuals and sites for study because
they can purposefully inform an understanding of the research problem and central
phenomenon in the study”. From the hand, the kind of sampling that is “simply available to
the researcher by virtue of its accessibility” (Bryman, 2012, p.201), is called convenience
sampling. In this case, the researcher chooses the participants that are promptly available and
is used when there are many limitations in a research (Patton, 2002). However, this type of
sampling can cause expense of information, as well as credibility (Creswell, 2007).
Regarding my other method, snowball sampling is the technique where “the researcher makes
initial contact with a small group that is relevant to the research topic and then uses these to
establish contacts with others” (Bryman, 2012, p.202).
Finally, my sample was small in size with only 8 participants. Silverman (2010) argues that
small samples tend to be a characteristic choice of qualitative researchers since “generally
speaking, qualitative researchers are prepared to sacrifice scope for detail” (Silverman, 2010,
p.104). In my case, with the circumstances under which this research was substantiated, the
number of 8 participants seemed to be satisfactory.
Selection of participants
For the needs of the research and having in mind my research questions, I thought about
concrete characteristics that the sample should have and characteristics that it would be better
to have. I decided that the participants of my sample must be primary school teachers that are
working in a school this year. Also, they should be teaching the course E.E.-E.S.D. this year
or have taught it during the last three years, when the course E.E.-E.S.D. was officially
included in Cypriot school curriculum. Other than these, I wanted to find teachers from
different schools and different environments, representing urban, semi-urban and rural
schools to see what kind of differences there might be in teachers’ approach since “each
school aspires to uncover and cultivate the unique genius of the local environment and
17
community through the school’s curriculum” (Sobel, 2005, p.22). That differentiation is
highly underlined in the curriculum as well (MOEC, 2012). My choices regarding schools
were not completely random. I had a practical issue in my mind and that was the distance
between teachers' working or living place. Due to the limited time of the four working days I
had for collecting my data, I contacted schools that were close to each other, at least each two
or three of them, so that I could visit those in one day. Also, I just chose the teachers that were
available for an interview when I needed them. The investigation of differences and
similarities between male and female teachers or between different teaching grades was not in
my intentions and therefore I did not have those factors as criteria.
My contact with the sample group in most of the cases was via the headmaster of the schools.
I was sending an e-mail or I was making a phone call to the headmasters, asking them to share
the information with the teachers of the school. Teachers who were willing to participate,
answered me back. To those teachers, I sent at a later stage, an official information sheet with
the latest details that I thought they should know regarding the research (Appendix, p. 63). In
the case where a teacher suggested me another teacher, the information sheet was sent after an
informative phone call between the teachers.
Profile of participants
The eight teachers, six women and two men, come from eight different schools in different
districts (Appendix, p. 64), two2
urban, three rural and three semi-urban schools. Also, five of
them are the E.E.-E.S.D. teachers of the classes they referred to while three of them are the
principal teachers3
. Regarding the annual topic of those schools for the course E.E.-E.S.D.,
five of the schools have chosen topics related to abatement of litter and recycling, one has
chosen as topic the “litter and energy”, one has chosen “the forest” and one has chosen “the
formulation of the school”. The working experience of the sample varies from seven to
twenty-four years. Specifically for the course of E.E.-E.S.D., which is officially included in
the curriculum since three years, one teacher has experience of three years, three of the
teachers have experience of two years and for four of the teachers, this is the first year of
teaching the course. Furthermore, five of the participants claimed that it was their personal
2
There was an effort to have a balance in the sample regarding the representatives from urban, rural and semi-
urban schools. However one of the participants from an urban school made a last minute cancelation of his
participation due to personal reasons.
3
Explanations for this differentiation can be found in the Appendix, page 59 (*).
18
choice to teach the course this year and six of them have participated to educative seminars
related to the course (Appendix, p. 58).
Collection of data
I collected my data using a questionnaire, interviews, official documents, photos and informal
conversations with the teachers. The use of multiple sources for data collection is a common
strategy in case studies, in order to achieve detailed and in-depth data collection (Creswell,
2007). Data was collected in four days. To do that, I travelled to Cyprus and met each
participant at a time and place of her/his choice. I met four of the participants at their school
during morning hours and four of them at their house during afternoon hours. In most of the
cases, the whole procedure lasted approximately 40 minutes.
Observations would have been a very strong tool of data collection for this research. As
Cohen, et al. (2011, p. 289) explain about case studies, “(…)one of their strengths is that they
observe effects in real contexts, recognizing that context is a powerful determinant of both
causes and effects and that in-depth understanding is required to do justice to the case”.
However, the limited time I had to collect my data and complete this research, in combination
with the fact that the course is taught only once per week, did not allow the use of
observations.
Questionnaire
Questionnaire was used in order to collect some demographic information about each
participant (Appendix, p.60). This information was intending to create a profile of reference
for each participant. The questionnaire was given to the participants immediately before the
interview so that the questions could be adjusted to their personal characteristics.
Interviews
The use of interviews is quite common in qualitative research as “it is a very good way of
accessing people's perceptions, meanings, and definitions of situations and constructions of
reality.” (Punch, 1998, p.175). There are many kinds of interviews and one way of
19
discrimination is their level of structure. Related to this, Cohen, et al. (2011, p.412) claim
that “the more one wishes to gain comparable data - across people, across sites - the more
standardized and quantitative one's interview tends to become; the more one wishes to acquire
unique, non-standardized, personalized information about how individuals view the world,
the more one veers towards qualitative, open-ended, unstructured interviewing”.
I chose to use semi-structured interviewing within a guided interview, with four main
questions and ten sub-questions regarding the following categories: the content and the
procedural characteristics of the school’s topic, the teacher’s teaching approach and practices,
the teacher’s reflection regarding her/his teaching and the teacher’s critique regarding the
curriculum (Appendix, p. 61). Guided interviews combine a freedom for the interviewee to
speak about what is important to her/him, rather than to the interviewer, and an assurance to
the interviewer that all the topics that she/he consider as crucial for the study will be covered
(Bell, 2006). Also, during a semi-structured interview “the interviewer is prepared to be
flexible in terms of the order in which the topics are considered, and, perhaps more
significantly, to let the interviewee develop ideas and speak more widely on the issues raised
by the researcher” (Denscombe, 2010, p.175). I had informed the participants that we would
need 30-40 minutes so I made an effort to create questions that were possible to be answered
during that time. The basic thought behind this was the option of doing the interviews during
school time in a spare hour. Each school period in Cyprus lasts 40 minutes, except the last
one that lasts 35 minutes (MOEC, n.d.).
For the needs of my research, firstly I did a pilot interview which later I decided to include in
my data because of the importance of the information I got from it. The pilot interview helped
me to realize some weak aspects of my questions and therefore make all the possible
improvements. The order of the questions was defined by the participant, depending on
her/his answers. Bell (2006) agrees that a capable interviewer can take advantage of the
adaptability that interviews offer to access resposes, feelings and motives that he couldn't
access with a questionaire. However, Bell (2006) considers interviews as a highly demanding
tool, considering time and effort in construction, while at the same time he points out the high
possibility of prejudices of the reseracher due to the subjective character of their nature.
Furthermore, as Punch (1998, p.61) claims, “It is inevitable that the words we use to record
data from the field will reflect, to some extent, our own concepts” since the text describing
the transformation of data into word is a creation of the researcher (Punch, 1998).
20
Action plan
The action plan is a document which is expected to be composed by the teachers of each
school at the beginning of every school year. It is the result of a teachers’ meeting regarding
the course of E.E.-E.S.D. (MOEC, 2010). After they have decided about the topic, they are
supposed to compose a plan with goals and guidelines which refers to all the teachers of the
school. The extent and the details included in the plan depend on the teachers. In addition to
the interviews, Ι asked the participants to provide the action plan of their school for the
current school year. My purpose was to have an extra source of information for each case. In
that way, I could also examine the relevance of the plan with each teacher’s sayings, find
some similarities as well as differences between the plans of the different schools and see to
what degree each school follows the guidelines of the curriculum regarding the action plan.
Such documents can be useful when they are used in combination with interviews or
observations but at the same time, it is important to keep in mind their ontological distinctive
status and therefore not take everything as an underling reality (Atkinson and Goffey, 2011
cited in Bryman, 2012).
Informal conversations and photos
Having in mind the need for deep understanding of my case, I tried to collect as much
information as I could. Therefore, I took advantage of my conversation with the participants
before and after the interview and noted some of their comments that I considered as
important and useful for my later analysis and results. Also, in cases where the interviews
took place at the school of the participants, after the interview we made a walk around the
school and the teachers showed me samples of the work they mentioned in their interviews. I
asked and took photos of those samples and some of them have been included to this report as
Appendix.
Analysis of data
For the purposes of my research, and after a first study of my data to be analyzed, I decided
that the most proper strategy for me to follow was the thematic analysis. As Crabtree and
Miller (1992) mention, the strategies of data analysis consist of a continuum that goes from
21
standardized strategies that have pre-determined concepts, categories and issues to strategies
that emerge during the analysis among the emerging concepts, categories and issues. In
research, the design and plan for a particular analysis depends on the analytic purpose (Guest,
MacQueen and Namey, 2011). Bryman (2012, p.565) argues that “there are few well-
established and widely accepted rules for the analysis of qualitative data”, but this can also be
considered as a benefit too.
Thematic analysis as an analyzing strategy
Thematic analysis belongs to the research analyzing strategies and is broadly considered as
one of those being emerged from the data of each case. More specifically, as Guest,
MacQueen and Namey (2011) explain, thematic analysis describes implicit, as well as explicit
ideas within the data, themes, while it can also include comparison of code frequencies,
identification of code co-occurrence, and graphically display of relationships between codes
within the data set. Ezzy (2002, p.88), characterizes a kind of thematic analysis as inductive
and explains that “while the general issues that are of interest are determined prior to the
analysis, the specific nature of the categories and themes to be explored are not
predetermined” and therefore they come up after the coding of data.
Bryman (2012) mentions that thematic analysis is one of the most used approaches in
qualitative research, although, as he claims, most of the times is not identifiable, due to its
lack of identifiable heritage and distinctive cluster of techniques. Guest, MacQueen and
Namey (2011, p.11) come to add that in thematic analysis, reliability is a risky affair because
of the interpretation of the researcher in “defining the data items (i.e. codes) as well as
applying the codes to bigger parts of text”. However, the authors argue that thematic analysis
is still the most useful approach in showing the complexities of meaning within a data text
set.
Themes
Bryman (2012), in an effort to explain the meaning and the use of a theme, defines it as a
category that among other things, is identified in the collected data by the researcher, relates
to the research questions and contributes to the related literature that already exists.
Researchers who are willing to use thematic analysis are encouraged to search across their
data for noticeable patterns such as repetitions of topics, transitions of topics, and similarities
and differences in the way of speaking about a topic, in order to create their themes. (Ryan
22
and Bernard, 2003 cited in Bryman, 2012). Braun and Klarke (2006) argue that there is no
correct or wrong way of determining themes as it can be done in many different ways but they
underline the need of explaining the way of thinking and the decisions being made in order to
end up to those themes.
The themes of this study
The thematic analysis I followed was inductive and therefore is based on themes emerging
from the data. To do so, I followed approximately the steps that Braun and Klarke (2006)
suggest to researchers who are interested in doing a thematic analysis.
Firstly, I became familiar with my data via consecutively and active readings of the
interviews’ transcriptions, once all of it together and then each interview separately. During
this step I also made a list with information from each interview that I considered as
interesting or/and popular. Then, mainly based on my list, I tried to generate initial codes and
while reading each interview again, this time more carefully, I tried to find as many extracts
that would fit in the codes as I could. During this step I used a table for each code where I was
writing the name of the participant, the line of the transcription where I could find the extract
and key words describing her/his saying. After that, I tried to group my codes with the
extracts under potential themes, a procedure which was occurred several times until I ended
up to my final themes. Of course, not all the codes or the themes that could be created were
used. I had to make a selection among quite a lot of information. The criteria I used for that
decision were the relation of the information with my research questions, the coherence of the
information in each theme regarding the content and the frequency of the information in the
data as I used codes and themes that were discussed from at least five out of the eight
participants. The final step was the production of my chapter with results and the presentation
of the themes. Before I compose the text for each theme I made sure that I would use in my
text at least one extract from each interview in each theme in order to represent all of the
interviewees.
After this process, four themes and several subthemes were found. Those are a) E.E.-E.S.D.
as part of the school reality, b) The annual topic of the school for E.E.-E.S.D, c)
Implementation of a cross-curriculum approach, and d) Persistence of students’ interest for
the course. Those themes will be presented and discussed in following chapters.
23
Ethical issues
I took ethical issues into consideration during the whole research procedure. Bryman (2012)
explains that a researcher should respect the participants, insure them about confidentiality of
records and identities, share with them all the information that they should know about
content and procedure and respect their desire not to answer some questions. Also, he
underlines the importance of preventing deception, which means presenting the research as
something different to what it is (Bryman, 2012).
Prevention for ethical issues
Having in mind the ethics above, I composed two documents, an information sheet and a
consent form, based on the examples that were presented by Bryman (2012). The information
sheet (Appendix, p. 63) was sent by e-mail to the participants that showed interest after
reading the e-mail I sent to their Headmaster/Headmistress. It included details regarding the
content and the procedure of the research and participants’ role in it. I tried to give enough
information so that a teacher could decide if she/he wanted to participate but not too much in
order not to affect their future answers during the interviews. In that sheet I also ensured the
participants that their identities and records were confidential and that I would make all the
actions needed so that no one could identify them in the final result of the research. Finally, I
mentioned their rights to skip any question they would like to, leave the research at any stage
for any reason without any explanation and take back any information they would have shared
with me until then, as well as their right to get informed about the findings of the research.
The consent form (Appendix, p. 62) was given at a later stage, when I met each participant for
the needs of the interview. Each participant was asked to read and sign it before the
realization of the interview. I kept the signed forms and I provided the participants with a
copy. By signing it, the participants were confirming that they were informed on crucial issues
of the procedure such as the recording of interviews and anonymous publication of extracts as
quotes, as well as on their rights mentioned above.
24
Ethical problem
Despite the actions to prevent ethical issues, an ethical problem came up. During the process
of collecting the data, I had to deal with an ethical dilemma, as a result of my inexperience.
During a telephone conversation in order to arrange the place for meeting with a participant, I
revealed the name of the school of another participant. After realizing my mistake, I started
thinking about the ethical and practical issues of informing the other participant about that
incident. Finally, I decided to admit my mistake to the participant. When we had our meeting
and before the beginning of the interview, I explained to the participant what had happened, I
apologized and I asked if she still wanted to participate in the research. Her answer was
positive.
25
CHAPTER 4: RESULTS
Summary
This chapter presents the results of the thematic analysis conducted on the data. I tracked
down four main themes in the answers of the interviewees and those are a) E.E.-E.S.D. as part
of the school reality, b) The annual topic of the school for E.E.-E.S.D, c) Implementation of a
cross-curriculum approach and d) Persistence of students’ interest for the course. Each of
those themes consists of subthemes which will be described below. Quotes4
of the interviews
are used in order to support and complete the presentation of the findings. The action plans of
the schools have been studied too and here are presented basic comments regarding the
content, the similarities and differences between them.
Theme 1: E.E.-E.S.D. as part of the school reality
The data exposed a common tendency across the participants to express their opinion on
nodal issues regarding the structure of the course of E.E.-E.S.D.. Basically, they argued on
who should be the responsible teacher for the course, what support is essential for the teacher
in charge and how much time in needed for the course.
The choice of the teacher in charge for the course
Interviews exposed a matter of discussion that assailed the majority of participants and that is
the choice of teacher in charge for the course E.E.-E.S.D.. A number of interviewees described
a general avoidance to undertake the teaching of the course. Interviewee 7 undertook the
course to complete her working hours, even if for her, the course should be taught by the
principal teachers:
E.E.-E.S.D. occurred due to the need of covering the last 40 minutes of my working time, so
which course is 40 minutes? (...) It is the second year I teach the course and last year happened
the same, the teachers of sixth grade, the principal teachers, did not want the course. We were
discussing who would take it but nobody volunteered to engage with the course, and I got
upset and I said ‘I will be responsible for it’. (…) The course should be entrusted to someone
4
The interviews were in Greek and therefore the quotes had to be translated to English. During this procedure
there was a high attention to the translation and presentation of the actual meaning of the original sayings.
26
that really wants it or otherwise, we should try to give it to the principal teachers, no matter if
he wants or not. (I.7)
5
The teacher described a tense by the principal teachers to avoid undertaking the course of
E.E.-E.S.D.. In addition, her own motivation was the completion of her working hours, and
E.E.-E.S.D was the only option in terms of time. As she stated in the questionnaire, the
teaching of the course was not a personal choice. Also, she believes that in cases where
nobody volunteers for the course, it must be entrusted to the principal teacher.
Another interesting statement came from Interviewee 6. Even if she belongs to the teachers
that undertook the course to complete her working obligations rather than from a personal
interest, she supported that the principal teacher has an advantage regarding the teaching of
E.E.-E.S.D:
(...) I consider the teaching of this course by the principal teacher as a significantly helpful fact.
It is rather a course of attitudes than a course of knowledge. Therefore, the most suitable one to
achieve cultivation of attitudes best is the teacher of the class. (…) you spend much more time
with them; it is you that they consider as responsible for them, the acceptance to whatever you
tell them, is bigger than to any other teacher who is visitor. (I.6)
According to this participant, a principal teacher has the advantage of affecting the attitudes of
students. This fact can help the teaching of E.E.-E.S.D, since, as she said, it is a course of
attitudes.
Finally, Interviewee 1 enhanced the need of changing the criteria of choosing the teacher in
charge for the course:
There must be an organization regarding who will teach the course because it is a course of
only 40 minutes per week and mostly, the course is entrusted to teachers with only criterion the
maintenance of the school schedule. Therefore, we end up entrusting E.E.-E.S.D to teachers
who do not have any idea of environmental issues, teachers who do not like E.E.-E.S.D., and
teachers who have practical difficulties to teach this course, like me this year, that I go only
one day to the school and is very difficult to organize it. (I.1)
Based on personal experience, this teacher claimed that in order to complete the time
schedule, incompetent teachers can end up teaching the course. He places himself in those
teachers as well, since the practical difficulties do not allow him to work as he would like to.
Advisory support for the teachers
The interviewees mentioned two main resources of support for a teacher who deals with the
5
. For purposes of better understanding, each quote is followed by a code. For example the code I.7, clarifies
that the specific quote belongs to Interviewee 7.
27
course and those are: the guide book6
of the course and the seminars organized by the
Ministry of Education and Culture (MOEC). The participants were critical about the existent
resources and expressed their suggestions.
In relation to the guide book, almost all the participants argued that there is a need for a more
concrete book with the possibility of diversification and enrichment. Interviewee 2 expressed
this opinion via a reference to her circumstances:
(...) to have a guide book, to follow a series and maybe to add our own activities of
enrichment. Something like this. Because it is very difficult. This year I teach this topic. The
next year I will be doing another topic so this means that you have to start again from the
beginning. (...) all this work is for 40 minutes of teaching. Here, we do 12 lessons; it is
difficult to find material. (I.2)
A guide book with the possibility to add things would make the annual preparation easier,
argued the Interviewee 2. In addition, in her case, the need for more guidelines seems bigger,
since her obligations are multiplied due to the multi-grade7
nature of the classes in her school.
Interviewee 5 supported the creation of a more concrete book but at the same time she
appeared to be sceptical regarding the degree of particularity of such a book:
It would not be bad to have something more concrete, even for the students (…). (...) it is just
that the philosophy does not help you to end up in something like this. The philosophy says
that you should consider the needs of your school and then decide which your topic will be.
That means that you cannot limit yourself to a book. (I.5)
That teacher argued that the current philosophy of E.E.-E.S.D. does not leave much space for
a concrete guide book since the whole topic of the school should be based on the needs of
each school.
Also, there was one participant, Interviewee 4, who believes that the current book is helpful
enough, even for beginners:
They have a book which gives directions (...) it helps. You can give it to someone that will
teach it for the first time, that will have this topic for the first time and he will understand more
or less towards which direction he should work. (I.4)
For this teacher, the guide book, with the twelve suggested topics and the general goals can
cover the needs and answer the questions of a teacher regarding the course, even if she/he
teaches it for first time. However, this was the only interviewee to support that the current
book is fully effective.
6
The current guidebook of E.E.-E.S.D. consists of some general guidelines regarding the procedures related to
the course and a list of intended results for each of the twelve topics that are presented as suggestions.
7
The term “Multi-grade” class refers to situations where students of different grades are mixed in one class. That
happens in situations where the number of students, usually in small villages, does not support the employment
of many teachers.
28
Regarding the seminars about the course of E.E.-E.S.D. organized by the Ministry of
Education and Culture, data brought up different opinions, depending on the personal
experience of each participant.
A number of participants pointed out organizing problems. More specifically, and as
Interviewee 1 explained, not all the teachers who teach E.E.-E.S.D. have attended seminars:
There are seminars organized, but many times the teachers who participate in them, do not
teach the course. They go because otherwise, the schedule of that day (the day of the seminar)
should change. (...) when there will be a seminar organized, it is compulsory to send someone
from each school. But (he laughs), for example if the seminar is on Wednesday, I will not go
because I am at the school only on Thursdays. (…) I have not been to any seminar yet, I have
not been asked to go to any seminar yet. (I.1)
The Interviewee argued that the criterion for a school to send a teacher to a seminar is
practical and not educational. His case is such an example, as he has not been to any seminar
yet, even if he is expected to teach the course.
However, the interviewees who did not face any organizational problems appeared to be
satisfied with the seminars they have participated in. Interviewee 8 was one of them and as he
commented, the seminars give the chance to the teachers to exchange ideas and discuss with
their colleagues:
I have been to a lot of lessons the last two years. Across these seminars, the two of them were
sample lessons. So there, you can see the ideas as well, you can discuss with your colleagues
who are there, because all of them are teachers of the Environmental Education, I mean they
teach the course of Environmental (Education) too, so you can get ideas. (I.8)
This teacher referred to the practical seminars he has participated in and claimed that there he
can meet with other teachers that also teach the course, discuss all together and share their
experiences and practices related to the course.
There was only one critical comment regarding the content of the seminars, and that came
from the Interviewee 2. As she said, even if she got some advice, she could not apply all of
them in her school:
(…) it was a sample lesson, it was quite helpful and also regarding the end, the evaluation,
about what we do at the end. (…) It was more about giving us some ideas on how we should
work with the course… But that does not change the fact that it was an 80 minute sample
lesson, because it was in a school that they have 80 minutes, we, we just have 40 minutes, that
was 80 minutes so there is a significant difference, even more with 25 students in a bigger
school. (I.2)
This interviewee pointed out that the content of the seminars referred to schools with 25
students in each class and an 80 minute lesson. In contrast, her school has 27 students in total
and 40 minutes for the course. Therefore, she cannot use all the ideas in her class, as she said,
29
due to the differences.
The suitability of the time dedicated to the course
The presence of the course in the curriculum, in terms of time, appeared to assail the teachers,
as all of them mentioned that they would like to have more time for it. Interviewees who
teach in grades fifth and sixth, and that means a 40 minutes period per week, give more
emphasis on it as a problem.
Interviewee 3 claimed that the time dedicated to the E.E.-E.S.D. is too little and is something
that should and could change:
I think those 40 minutes, since we are speaking about the future because the environment is the
future; I think that is too little time. I believe that this course should be taught at least in 80
minutes per week, the minimum. (I.3)
For this interviewee, the course appears to be crucial enough for the future, to deserve more
time than 40 minutes in the school time schedule. In fact, she suggested using one of the
hours being offered for consolidation8
, for the needs of the course of E.E.-E.S.D.
Something similar was mentioned by Interviewee 7 who believes that the distribution of time
should change for the higher grades:
For me, the distribution of time is not correct. For example in small grades it is 80 minutes.
You will tell me that for them the time is shared between the courses E.E.-E.S.D. and the
course Treatment of Life, ok I can understand it. But with the older, that we have more things
to discuss with them and they can be productive, we should have more time, not only 40
minutes per week. For me the time is too little. (I.7)
This teacher believes that especially with the older students the teachers should get more time
for this course as there are many things to discuss and do with them.
However, despite the full agreement of lack of time regarding the course, there were some
teachers that mentioned that now environmental education at least exists as a lesson.
Interviewee 5 was one of them:
There is a lack of time. But the fact that now, at least, there are those 40 minutes per week and
some things are emphasized during this time every week, is important, because before, it didn’t
exist at all. It was a matter of personal interest if someone would do something similar. (I.5)
The teacher characterized the official inclusion of the course in the curriculum as a significant
progress even if this means a 40 minutes period per week. However, she would like to have
8
The term “Hour of Consolidation” refers to the last period of each school day which is used at the will of each
teacher. The purpose of its existence is to work as spare hour where teachers have the chance to explain again
parts of the daily lessons that perhaps where not fully understood by the students.
30
more time as well.
In conclusion, data showed that a more detailed book that would still offer the freedom to the
teacher to make choices would be welcomed from the majority of participants. They also
asked for better organization regarding the seminars since they mentioned that they can be
very helpful. Finally, the time given for the course is appreciated by the teachers but it was
clear that they all need more.
Theme 2: The annual topic of the school for E.E.-E.S.D.
When the participants were asked to speak about the annual topic of their school for the
course of E.E.-E.S.D., their answers brought up some common lines regarding the decision of
the topic, the role of the students in it and the planning of their actions.
The influence of circumstances
All of the interviewees mentioned the circumstances of the school as the main determinant
factor in the decision of the topic. The school of Interviewee 5 for example, chose as topic
the litter management and recycle due to the amount of rubbish they noticed in the school:
It is very important that the topic will occur from the existent problems of the school. That
means that we do not decide suddenly a topic and then ask the students to work on it. (…) it
was decided that we had a problem with the management of trash. We are a big school with
400 students, so there is a lot of rubbish and there was a need to start recycling. Therefore, we
chose that topic. (I.5)
The teacher mentioned that the topic they chose at school is directly related to an actual
problem that was noticed in the school. In her opinion, the large number of students is the
main cause of that problem.
Also, Interviewee 7 mentioned the independence of actions in addition to the circumstances
of the school as a determinant factor:
If there are problems which we can solve inside the area of the school, we chose those ones, in
order not to implicate other services such as the municipality. If there were broken pavements
for example, (…) we could not fix it by ourselves, so our topic would not have any progress.
(...) We choose something that we can solve easily. We could buy a trash compactor, we did it
(…) we could do recycling of paper in the class; we could reduce the use of paper. It is
something that depends on us. (I.7)
31
In the case of that teacher, after they point out problems of the school, they try to see which of
those problems they could solve by themselves as a school community.
Interviewee 3 was the only interviewee that even if she mentioned dependence of the topic on
the circumstances of the school, the focus was on its spatial characteristic and not on an
existing problem:
Since our school belongs to a community in a woodland area, and the surrounding environment
is full of pine forests etc., we decided that it is something that could be optimized both by us in
the course and by students. They could come closer to the forest, explore it deeper and in a
greater extend. So the location of our school was determinant. (I.3)
The interviewee explained that they tried to utilize the surrounding environment of the school
for the purposes of the school, in order to achieve a connection between the students and the
forest next to their school.
In addition, another interesting finding was that while the teachers from the urban and semi-
urban school focused on the solution of a problem in the area of the school, the 3 teachers of
the rural schools added the broader area of the village in the targets for improvement. “The
topic was decided considering the needs of the school as well as the needs of the village.”
explained Interviewee 2.
The role of the students regarding the topic
Interviewees' descriptions regarding the procedure of choosing a topic, showed a variation in
students' participation in it. The majority of the teachers argued that the students contribute
with ideas on the content, after the topic has been decided by the teachers. More specifically,
those interviewees mentioned that all the teachers of the school discuss to end up in a topic
and then, another meeting is organized between the E.E.-E.S.D. teachers and the
Environmental Council of Students9
. The teachers announce the topic and give guidelines to
students and the students make suggestions. Interviewee 1 explained:
There is a teacher as a responsible and there are a number of students that are chosen to
constitute the Environmental Council of the school, together they decide the annual topic. (...)
there is a discussion between the teachers, then the teachers decide and then there is another
meeting with those students and two-three teachers that are responsible for the course, so that
the students can participate in the procedure. (…) After that the topic is decided, they suggest
several ideas. (I.1)
9
The Environmental Council of Students is a group of students with one or two representatives from each class of
the school. The council is created with the occasion of the course E.E.-E.S.D. Their aim is to represent their
classmates during the meetings with the teachers of E.E.-E.S.D.. According to the interviewees of this research,
the Environmental Council of Students runs several actions in the schools such as check of the correct use of the
32
According to the interviewee, after the specification of the topic by the teachers, students'
opinion is taken into account as they express their ideas via the Environmental Council of
students.
There was also one participant, Interviewee 7, who mentioned students' participation in the
decision of the topic as well, by pointing out problems in the school:
Every teacher goes with his students outside and makes a field research
10
in the area of the
school or around the school if it is possible. The students are asked to observe and write down
a list of problems that they notice. After we make an evaluation of the issues of each problem
(…). And at the end I go to the meeting with the teachers and say for example ‘my students
suggested this topic for these reasons’ and the other teacher says ‘my students suggested this
topic for those reasons’ (…) (I.7)
The case of this interviewee differs because as she claimed, the topic is basically suggested by
the students, even if the final decision is taken by the teachers. Also, in this case, it appeared
that at least at the stage of indication of problems, all the students participate directly and not
indirectly via the Environmental Council of students.
The method of field research by the students was mentioned by other participants as well, but
it was taking place after that the topic was decided. Interviewee 6 made a description:
We made observations outside, in the area of the school. Students worked in teams, we
separated the yard in four parts and as a team they went around in their square and wrote down
whatever was disturbing for them, related to our topic. (I.6)
This interviewee belonged to the cases, where the topic was decided clearly by teachers.
Afterwards, students could specify the topic in the aspects they thought as more important, via
the activity of the field research.
The action plan
Participants were asked to provide a copy of the action plan of their school. The action plans
had several features in common but there were some differences as well. Almost all action
plans included themes regarding a) the issues and problems in the school in relation to its
location, b) the issue/problem that will be emphasized the current year c) the reasons why that
specific issue was chosen, d) the general purpose of the topic, e) the goals for the students f)
the subtopics being involved in the chosen topic. In some of them, the theme “Goals for the
students” was described with the subthemes of knowledge, skills, attitudes, participation-
recycling bins of the school.
10
Field research is an activity where the students go outside the class, usually in the school yard, with a specific
purpose: to observe, to collect material or information, etc.
33
action and awareness. Also, some of the action plans had references to expected results
regarding the school and the community. In all the cases, the action plan was mentioned as
point of reference for a teacher who deals with the course of E.E.-E.S.D. in each school. As
Interviewee 5 argued referring to her school:
(…) each teacher has a copy of the action plan for purposes of guidance. But other than this,
each one has the personal freedom to create his own activities, or change the order of the goals,
or choose the way and the methods in use in order to achieve those goals. The point is to cover
the goals (…). (...) other than this, the way in which a teacher will reach at that point differs,
the student of 1st grade differs from the student of sixth grade. (I.5)
Interviewee 5 explained that the action plan has a guiding role. It provides guidelines to each
teacher of the school while at the same time it allows diversification in methods and practices.
A similar situation was described by all the interviewees.
Despite these structural patterns, there were some significant differences that are worth to be
commented. To begin with, there were several action plans that consisted of some unique
themes in addition to the above. There were a couple of action plans that included concrete
activities to be done. Interviewee’s 8 action plan was a notable example as it included 54 brief
activities related to the topic “Abatement of waste”. An example of such an activity is the
following: “collection of used paper and other material or unused objects, in order to use them
in the construction of artistic sculptures, music instruments, theatrical sceneries, curtains,
etc.” (Photos 1 and 2). However, Interviewee 8 pointed out that he will not do all of those 54
activities. As he explained, those 54 activities have been included in their action plan in order
to be used by other teachers too:
From those 54, maybe you can substantiate ten of them; (...) you cannot do all of them. But
they are ideas, for someone who will get this action plan; he could do some of them. (...) All of
them are related to the topic, your choice depends on which of them both the teacher and the
students can substantiate. (…) We send this action plan to the Advisor of Environmental
Education
11
, it is not compulsory to send it but we do. It will be multiplied and given to other
teachers too. If other teachers do the same, in one-two teachers will have in their hands ideas.
(I.8)
The teacher appeared to be aware that it is not possible to make all the 54 ideas happen in a
year. In his school, they use their action plan as a reference point for their actions but it is
something more, as he claimed. According to him, it is also a chance to share ideas and help
11
The Ministry of Education of Cyprus has placed an Advisor of Environmental Education in each province. The
Advisor is responsible for the schools of his province. Her/his job is to offer support to the teachers in her/his
province and supervise them regarding the teaching of the course E.E.-E.S.D. Her/his role is basically advisory.
34
other teachers who deal with the same topic.
Another case of partly unrealistic action plan came with Interviewee 4. A noticeable part of
her action plan, was underlying the need of changes such as the construction of a new school
even if in her interview she said that:
Students cannot change the actions of the Municipality. I mean, the Municipality will not listen
to students and make a new school, even if we are in a difficult situation. (…) They cannot
affect or change the factors of the Municipality (…) or of the Government to achieve what they
want. (I.4)
This teacher is convinced that the influence of students is limited when it comes to decisions
related to the Municipality or the Government, in their case to the construction of a new
school. However, the action plan points out problems that occur from the current situation of
the building by referring to them in several of its themes.
I also considered as interesting the significant brevity of some action plans. The action plan of
Interviewee 6 for example was only one page long, while the rest were six to seven pages and
one was three pages. Its content consisted of two themes, the general purpose of the topic and
few general goals. Also, this interviewee mentioned a delay in the creation of the action plan:
Our discussion about the topic started in the beginning of November. (…) there was a delay
because we have to do and plan too many things at the beginning of the year. (…) at the same
time there are also the difficulties of the inception of the new school year, (…) after two weeks
we had a change in the stuff. All this disruption in the school in combination with other things
that came up, didn’t give us the time to take care of Environmental Education. (I.6)
As the teacher claimed, there were several technical problems which discouraged the teachers
in her school to focus on the course of E.E.-E.S.D. and organize it properly.
Interviewee 3 was the only one who did not present an action plan because, as she explained,
in her school they did not make one. It should be remembered that this teacher was
interviewed about her teaching experience from the course during the previous school year.
However through her interview, there are clear references in most of the themes included in
the action plans.
In conclusion, firstly, all the teachers teaching the course this year had an action plan to
present even if there were several differentiations between them, not only in content but in
structure and in use of it as well. Also all of them took into account the special characteristics
and problems of their school in order to end up with a topic. The decision on the topic
however was mainly taken by the teachers in most of the cases.
35
Theme 3: Implementation of a cross-curriculum approach
Connecting E.E.-E.S.D. with other courses was one of the topics brought up by the
interviewees, either as a reality or as a desire. Data showed that this can be determined by
several reasons. Some teachers mentioned the barriers they have, while some others spoke
about auspicious factors in their school which promote a cross-curriculum approach.
Barriers in implementation
A number of participants claimed that even if they would like to follow a cross-curriculum
approach, they face several barriers that stop them. For Interviewee 1, cross-curriculum
approach is an actual need in the case of E.E.-E.S.D.. Despite that belief, his working
conditions do not allow him to contribute to a cross-curriculum approach:
It is important in the course of E.E.-E.S.D., since its only 40 minutes and since it can be taught
with a cross-curriculum approach, we must work cooperatively. But how possible that is
depends from the E.E.-E.S.D. teacher and the principal teachers. In my case, since I am going
to the school for just one day, we do not. (...) The existence of cooperation is a matter of
circumstances. (I.1)
Interviewee 1 supported that the nature of the course, as well as its limited time in the
schedule, demand a cross-curriculum approach of it, which requires cooperation. However, as
an E.E.-E.S.D. teacher that goes to the school once per week, he does not have the time to
cooperate and therefore to support a cross-curriculum approach for the course.
Interviewee 5 pointed out the barrier of mentality. She claimed that in her school, there is a
preference in keeping the courses separated:
For example, when it was asked from each class to create an ecological code 12
(…) there was a
colleague that told me ‘you are going to do it in E.E.-E.S.D., aren’t you?’ (…) Our topic as a
school was Litter management – recycling, so those who teach E.E.-E.S.D., we undertake it.
The philosophy was like that. (…) To work towards a cross-curriculum approach there must be
cooperation and will for collaboration. (I.5)
According to the teacher, the philosophy of her colleagues does not promote a cross-
curriculum approach due to the belief that everything connected with E.E.-E.S.D., should be
done during the hour of that course, by the teacher responsible for it. As a result, the teacher
argued that the only way to achieve a cross-curriculum approach in her case would be if she
was the principal teacher.
12
The ecological code is a list of advices related to behaviour and attitudes towards the environment, basically
the environment of the school. The list is created by the students and teachers and it addresses to all of them.
36
The same hypothesis was mentioned by Interviewee 7 as well. She claimed that if she was the
principal teacher she could make connections between her courses as the one described in the
example bellow:
Now we are making a small research regarding how many students bring a lunch box and a
bottle. But if I was the principal teacher, I could do something in mathematics, create a graph
about it, every day do something fast, I could dedicate just five minutes every day (…). Now in
40, not even 40, in 35 minutes I have to finish what I have planned. But it never finishes. (I.7)
The interviewee explained that as a principal teacher, she would have the freedom to
“borrow” some time from the other courses under her responsibility, in order to accomplish
her goals for E.E.-E.S.D.. The time that she has as an E.E.-E.S.D. teacher is never enough.
She also explained the reason that she does not collaborate with other teachers in order to
achieve a cross-curriculum approach. In her opinion, collaboration for the purposes of E.E.-
E.S.D. does not seem to be something feasible:
It is difficult because the colleague has another program in his mind. And it is difficult because
the colleague was not present while me and students were discussing and ended up in some
things. So how could I burden him to do something that he did not hear? (I.7)
Interviewee 7 would not ask a colleague to do a part of her work in another course. As she
explained, each teacher has her/his own plans to accomplish and also if a teacher is not
present during the planning of an idea, she/he would not be able or keen to help with it.
Interviewee 2 cannot follow a cross-curriculum approach either but her reason has to do with
the special character of her school. As teachers of multi-grade classes and speaking in terms
of time, covering the syllabi of courses for two or three grades at the same time, does not give
them the option of following a cross-curriculum approach, as she claimed:
Something that normally should happen, but we don’t have the time to do it, theoretically, the
course of E.E.-E.S.D. was constructed in addition to all the other courses.(...) We, since we do
not have the same time as other schools, due to multi-grade classes, we hardly manage to do
the compulsory syllabus. So whatever we do, it is done during the hour of the course. (I.2)
This interviewee explained that even if E.E.-E.S.D. is organized in a way to coexist with the
other courses, her working conditions do not allow her to entangle the goals of E.E.-E.S.D.
with other courses.
Cross-curriculum approach in practice
As was mentioned before, there were a number of participants in the sample, both principal
and E.E.-E.S.D. teachers, who claimed that they have managed to follow a cross-curriculum
approach.
37
Interviewee 3, as a principal teacher, described the connection of E.E.-E.S.D. with two kinds
of courses, those that she teaches in her class and those that are taught by others in her class.
Regarding the first kind of courses, she mentioned the example of mathematics and argued
that she was able to adapt it in the needs of the annual environmental topic, the forest:
You can do the simplest thing, you can use vocabulary related to the forest in mathematical
problems or exercises. So if a problem had to do with Euros for example you can replace
Euros with pinecones (…) or you can show a picture of the forest and then the students can
create problems based on the picture. (…) I was using this kind of techniques. (I.3)
The teacher explained that she chose to combine the content of mathematics with the context
of the forest, which was the topic of the course E.E.-E.S.D. by using relative vocabulary or
pictures for the exercises. Similar practices were mentioned by all the interviewees that have
the role of a principal teacher. Regarding the courses that are taught by other teachers in her
class, the interviewee referred to a situation when she used the course “Design and
Technology” for the purposes of E.E.-E.S.D.. After a visit in the forest sited behind the
school, it was decided to create signposts with environmental messages which would be later
placed in the forest. For that purpose, Interviewee 3 asked the help of the teacher responsible
for the course of Technology and the signposts were created at its time. As she explained:
I had to communicate with the teacher of technology and organize ourselves in order to have
enough time to make all the preparations needed (…) we were finding common spare hours, or
if I had a free hour when my colleague was teaching in my class, I would visit him for example
to see how they work or he would come to my class to see if we have any problem and if he
could help with any way. (I.3)
The teacher said that they started organizing their action in advance, in order to have enough
time and also they were both visiting each other’s classrooms whenever that was possible, in
order to stay informed.
Another teacher, Interviewee 8, also described the way of working in his school, in terms of
cross-curriculum approach. In his case, as the E.E.-E.S.D. teacher, he gives advices and
guidelines to the principal teachers:
The teacher of the class, come to me and tells me ‘I have this text in the course of Greek. How
can I optimize it in order to cover some aspects of Environmental Education too?’ We discuss
together some things, he underlines them during his teaching and this is how the lesson is done.
Usually, the teachers come and ask me, it’s not me the one to go and tell them do this because I
cannot force them. (I.8)
Interviewee 8 said that he has a good collaboration with the other teachers, as most of them
try to connect their courses with the annual topic. However, he pointed out that he has the role
of an advisor, without pressing the teachers to do more than they want.
38
Finally, Interviewee 4 mentioned a different way of trying to connect E.E.-E.S.D. with other
courses which are not under her responsibility. In her school they try to make an annual
planning from the beginning of the year:
There is collaboration between teachers. Teachers that do for example the course of geography
or the course of history, they inform us which parts of their syllabus could be connected with
E.E.-E.S.D.. (I.4)
According to that teacher, all the teachers in her school discuss together in a meeting at the
beginning of the year. During this meeting, each teacher is supposed to announce which
aspects of the annual topic he could cover via the syllabus of the course or the courses of
her/his responsibility. However she also pointed out a weak aspect of this kind of organization
towards a cross-curriculum approach. She claimed that in case of a teacher that deals with a
course for the first year or in case of a new curriculum, as it happens lately in Cyprus, it is
possible that the teacher will not be prepared to present the annual actions required:
If a teacher undertakes a course for the first time, he cannot know, especially now that there are
changes being made, changes in the curriculums, he cannot know what he will do. He has to
read the whole curriculum from the start and teachers usually don’t have the time or maybe
they do not have the books from the start of the school year. (…) therefore we might exclude
some chapters that normally would have been included or try to catch them up later. (I.4)
Interviewee 4 argued that in cases where a teacher is not fully familiar from the beginning
with the syllabus of the course or the courses that she/he teaches, the agreement over a
concrete cross-curriculum approach can be difficult and deficient.
Auspicious factors of Implementation
The interviewees above gave their personal perspective regarding the auspicious factors that
fostered a cross-curriculum approach of the annual topic.
Interviewee’s 3 explanation had two dimensions, a practical and a mental one. Regarding the
practical part, the interviewee claimed that the small numbers, both of students and teachers,
made a cross-curriculum organization possible:
Since it is a small school and there aren’t many teachers, I mean there are seven teachers now
or eight, it is not difficult. If it was a big school with many teachers then maybe there would be
a problem in coordination and programming. (...) also we speak about small numbers in
classes, about 10-12 students so it is easier to coordinate them. (I.3)
According to the interviewee, it was easy to communicate and cooperate with her colleagues
because there were few comparing with bigger schools. Furthermore, the small number of
students per class was enabling the organization and management. Regarding now the mental
factors, the interviewee focused on two, the factor of personality and the factor of voluntary
39
contribution to a cross-curriculum approach:
It is a matter of persons sometimes. (…) But there should be a good will. If someone wants to
take responsibility for something he will accomplish it, if he does not want and he is pressed to
do it then it is difficult. In our case the planning was commonly decided. (I.3)
The interviewee believed that the personality of the teachers and their willing to devote part
of their free time for the work, as well as the fact that all the actions were decided after a
common agreement, promoted the cross-curriculum approach.
Interviewee 8 had a similar opinion as he claimed that the auspicious factor in his school was
the relationship between teachers:
In this school, friendship has a very important role. I have been working here for seven years
now and we have developed very strong relationships between us. So during a break or while
we are drinking our coffee, someone might bring up an idea and we discuss it, that is how we
work. (I.8)
Interviewee 8 justified the ability to follow a cross-curriculum approach with the friendship
that connects him with the other teachers after working together for a long time.
In conclusion, there were some teachers in the sample, E.E.-E.S.D. teachers that do not
manage to apply a cross-curriculum approach even if they want to. At the same time, there
were teachers, both E.E.-E.S.D. and principal teachers that manage to follow a cross
curriculum approach to some extent. That difference seems to exist due to the human factor
and the interpersonal relationships.
Theme 4: Persistence of students’ interest for the course
During the interviews, all the participants referred to practices they use in the teaching of the
course E.E.-E.S.D.. There was a variety of practices mentioned but here I chose to present the
following three: active participation of students, invitations of visitors in the school and
outdoor activities. All of the participants mentioned those three practices with the additional
assertion that they are effective13
.
13
For the purposes of this research, the word “effective” is used to refer to practices that manage to attract the
students and militate their enthusiasm.
Teachers' Perceptions of Cyprus' EE-ESD Course Implementation
Teachers' Perceptions of Cyprus' EE-ESD Course Implementation
Teachers' Perceptions of Cyprus' EE-ESD Course Implementation
Teachers' Perceptions of Cyprus' EE-ESD Course Implementation
Teachers' Perceptions of Cyprus' EE-ESD Course Implementation
Teachers' Perceptions of Cyprus' EE-ESD Course Implementation
Teachers' Perceptions of Cyprus' EE-ESD Course Implementation
Teachers' Perceptions of Cyprus' EE-ESD Course Implementation
Teachers' Perceptions of Cyprus' EE-ESD Course Implementation
Teachers' Perceptions of Cyprus' EE-ESD Course Implementation
Teachers' Perceptions of Cyprus' EE-ESD Course Implementation
Teachers' Perceptions of Cyprus' EE-ESD Course Implementation
Teachers' Perceptions of Cyprus' EE-ESD Course Implementation
Teachers' Perceptions of Cyprus' EE-ESD Course Implementation
Teachers' Perceptions of Cyprus' EE-ESD Course Implementation
Teachers' Perceptions of Cyprus' EE-ESD Course Implementation
Teachers' Perceptions of Cyprus' EE-ESD Course Implementation
Teachers' Perceptions of Cyprus' EE-ESD Course Implementation
Teachers' Perceptions of Cyprus' EE-ESD Course Implementation
Teachers' Perceptions of Cyprus' EE-ESD Course Implementation
Teachers' Perceptions of Cyprus' EE-ESD Course Implementation
Teachers' Perceptions of Cyprus' EE-ESD Course Implementation
Teachers' Perceptions of Cyprus' EE-ESD Course Implementation
Teachers' Perceptions of Cyprus' EE-ESD Course Implementation
Teachers' Perceptions of Cyprus' EE-ESD Course Implementation
Teachers' Perceptions of Cyprus' EE-ESD Course Implementation
Teachers' Perceptions of Cyprus' EE-ESD Course Implementation

More Related Content

What's hot

Effects of teacher preparation on students academic achievements in ss2 biolo...
Effects of teacher preparation on students academic achievements in ss2 biolo...Effects of teacher preparation on students academic achievements in ss2 biolo...
Effects of teacher preparation on students academic achievements in ss2 biolo...Alexander Decker
 
Effect of gender on students academic achievement in secondary school social ...
Effect of gender on students academic achievement in secondary school social ...Effect of gender on students academic achievement in secondary school social ...
Effect of gender on students academic achievement in secondary school social ...Alexander Decker
 
SELF-REGULATED LEARNING: A COMPATIBLE ASSUMPTION
SELF-REGULATED LEARNING: A COMPATIBLE ASSUMPTIONSELF-REGULATED LEARNING: A COMPATIBLE ASSUMPTION
SELF-REGULATED LEARNING: A COMPATIBLE ASSUMPTIONH A
 
Assessing the Impact Of Drama Methods On Learners’ Understanding Of Hiv/ Aids...
Assessing the Impact Of Drama Methods On Learners’ Understanding Of Hiv/ Aids...Assessing the Impact Of Drama Methods On Learners’ Understanding Of Hiv/ Aids...
Assessing the Impact Of Drama Methods On Learners’ Understanding Of Hiv/ Aids...IJSRED
 
COMPETENCY- BASED SCIENCE NAT - VI INTERVENTION PROGRAM: ACTION RESEARCH
COMPETENCY- BASED SCIENCE NAT - VI INTERVENTION PROGRAM: ACTION RESEARCHCOMPETENCY- BASED SCIENCE NAT - VI INTERVENTION PROGRAM: ACTION RESEARCH
COMPETENCY- BASED SCIENCE NAT - VI INTERVENTION PROGRAM: ACTION RESEARCHDeped Tagum City
 
Addressing student variability in educational design
Addressing student variability in educational designAddressing student variability in educational design
Addressing student variability in educational designAlan Bruce
 
Perceptions of history student teachers on teaching practice supervision
Perceptions of history student teachers on teaching practice supervisionPerceptions of history student teachers on teaching practice supervision
Perceptions of history student teachers on teaching practice supervisionAlexander Decker
 
EFFECT OF TEACHING APPROACHES IN STEM CAREER ORIENTATION FOR STUDENTS THROUGH...
EFFECT OF TEACHING APPROACHES IN STEM CAREER ORIENTATION FOR STUDENTS THROUGH...EFFECT OF TEACHING APPROACHES IN STEM CAREER ORIENTATION FOR STUDENTS THROUGH...
EFFECT OF TEACHING APPROACHES IN STEM CAREER ORIENTATION FOR STUDENTS THROUGH...ijejournal
 
Influence of concept maps on achievement retention of senior secondary schoo...
Influence of concept maps on achievement retention of  senior secondary schoo...Influence of concept maps on achievement retention of  senior secondary schoo...
Influence of concept maps on achievement retention of senior secondary schoo...Alexander Decker
 
Herrington and kritsonis school collaboration
Herrington and kritsonis school collaborationHerrington and kritsonis school collaboration
Herrington and kritsonis school collaborationWilliam Kritsonis
 
Improving students’ academic achievement in biology subject-Jaffna Hindu Coll...
Improving students’ academic achievement in biology subject-Jaffna Hindu Coll...Improving students’ academic achievement in biology subject-Jaffna Hindu Coll...
Improving students’ academic achievement in biology subject-Jaffna Hindu Coll...The Open University of Sri Lanka
 
Effects of computer based mastery learning on secondary school students’ moti...
Effects of computer based mastery learning on secondary school students’ moti...Effects of computer based mastery learning on secondary school students’ moti...
Effects of computer based mastery learning on secondary school students’ moti...Alexander Decker
 
Effects of computer based mastery learning approach on students’ motivation t...
Effects of computer based mastery learning approach on students’ motivation t...Effects of computer based mastery learning approach on students’ motivation t...
Effects of computer based mastery learning approach on students’ motivation t...Alexander Decker
 
Metacognitive Teaching Strategies on Secondary School Students Academic Perfo...
Metacognitive Teaching Strategies on Secondary School Students Academic Perfo...Metacognitive Teaching Strategies on Secondary School Students Academic Perfo...
Metacognitive Teaching Strategies on Secondary School Students Academic Perfo...ijceronline
 
Attachment 2 habay es-proposal-for-research-re-training-and-conference
Attachment 2 habay es-proposal-for-research-re-training-and-conferenceAttachment 2 habay es-proposal-for-research-re-training-and-conference
Attachment 2 habay es-proposal-for-research-re-training-and-conferencemaecendana
 
Influence of area of specialization and years of teaching experience of geogr...
Influence of area of specialization and years of teaching experience of geogr...Influence of area of specialization and years of teaching experience of geogr...
Influence of area of specialization and years of teaching experience of geogr...Alexander Decker
 
Jessica C.V 2015.DOC
Jessica C.V 2015.DOCJessica C.V 2015.DOC
Jessica C.V 2015.DOCdolorosaa
 

What's hot (20)

20 sarfraz ahmed--140-147
20 sarfraz ahmed--140-14720 sarfraz ahmed--140-147
20 sarfraz ahmed--140-147
 
Effects of teacher preparation on students academic achievements in ss2 biolo...
Effects of teacher preparation on students academic achievements in ss2 biolo...Effects of teacher preparation on students academic achievements in ss2 biolo...
Effects of teacher preparation on students academic achievements in ss2 biolo...
 
EFFECTIVENESS OF HEUTAGOGY INTEGRATED E-CONTENT MODULES ON UNDESTANDING OSMOS...
EFFECTIVENESS OF HEUTAGOGY INTEGRATED E-CONTENT MODULES ON UNDESTANDING OSMOS...EFFECTIVENESS OF HEUTAGOGY INTEGRATED E-CONTENT MODULES ON UNDESTANDING OSMOS...
EFFECTIVENESS OF HEUTAGOGY INTEGRATED E-CONTENT MODULES ON UNDESTANDING OSMOS...
 
Effect of gender on students academic achievement in secondary school social ...
Effect of gender on students academic achievement in secondary school social ...Effect of gender on students academic achievement in secondary school social ...
Effect of gender on students academic achievement in secondary school social ...
 
SELF-REGULATED LEARNING: A COMPATIBLE ASSUMPTION
SELF-REGULATED LEARNING: A COMPATIBLE ASSUMPTIONSELF-REGULATED LEARNING: A COMPATIBLE ASSUMPTION
SELF-REGULATED LEARNING: A COMPATIBLE ASSUMPTION
 
Assessing the Impact Of Drama Methods On Learners’ Understanding Of Hiv/ Aids...
Assessing the Impact Of Drama Methods On Learners’ Understanding Of Hiv/ Aids...Assessing the Impact Of Drama Methods On Learners’ Understanding Of Hiv/ Aids...
Assessing the Impact Of Drama Methods On Learners’ Understanding Of Hiv/ Aids...
 
COMPETENCY- BASED SCIENCE NAT - VI INTERVENTION PROGRAM: ACTION RESEARCH
COMPETENCY- BASED SCIENCE NAT - VI INTERVENTION PROGRAM: ACTION RESEARCHCOMPETENCY- BASED SCIENCE NAT - VI INTERVENTION PROGRAM: ACTION RESEARCH
COMPETENCY- BASED SCIENCE NAT - VI INTERVENTION PROGRAM: ACTION RESEARCH
 
Addressing student variability in educational design
Addressing student variability in educational designAddressing student variability in educational design
Addressing student variability in educational design
 
Perceptions of history student teachers on teaching practice supervision
Perceptions of history student teachers on teaching practice supervisionPerceptions of history student teachers on teaching practice supervision
Perceptions of history student teachers on teaching practice supervision
 
EFFECT OF TEACHING APPROACHES IN STEM CAREER ORIENTATION FOR STUDENTS THROUGH...
EFFECT OF TEACHING APPROACHES IN STEM CAREER ORIENTATION FOR STUDENTS THROUGH...EFFECT OF TEACHING APPROACHES IN STEM CAREER ORIENTATION FOR STUDENTS THROUGH...
EFFECT OF TEACHING APPROACHES IN STEM CAREER ORIENTATION FOR STUDENTS THROUGH...
 
Influence of concept maps on achievement retention of senior secondary schoo...
Influence of concept maps on achievement retention of  senior secondary schoo...Influence of concept maps on achievement retention of  senior secondary schoo...
Influence of concept maps on achievement retention of senior secondary schoo...
 
Herrington and kritsonis school collaboration
Herrington and kritsonis school collaborationHerrington and kritsonis school collaboration
Herrington and kritsonis school collaboration
 
Improving students’ academic achievement in biology subject-Jaffna Hindu Coll...
Improving students’ academic achievement in biology subject-Jaffna Hindu Coll...Improving students’ academic achievement in biology subject-Jaffna Hindu Coll...
Improving students’ academic achievement in biology subject-Jaffna Hindu Coll...
 
Ej1145141
Ej1145141Ej1145141
Ej1145141
 
Effects of computer based mastery learning on secondary school students’ moti...
Effects of computer based mastery learning on secondary school students’ moti...Effects of computer based mastery learning on secondary school students’ moti...
Effects of computer based mastery learning on secondary school students’ moti...
 
Effects of computer based mastery learning approach on students’ motivation t...
Effects of computer based mastery learning approach on students’ motivation t...Effects of computer based mastery learning approach on students’ motivation t...
Effects of computer based mastery learning approach on students’ motivation t...
 
Metacognitive Teaching Strategies on Secondary School Students Academic Perfo...
Metacognitive Teaching Strategies on Secondary School Students Academic Perfo...Metacognitive Teaching Strategies on Secondary School Students Academic Perfo...
Metacognitive Teaching Strategies on Secondary School Students Academic Perfo...
 
Attachment 2 habay es-proposal-for-research-re-training-and-conference
Attachment 2 habay es-proposal-for-research-re-training-and-conferenceAttachment 2 habay es-proposal-for-research-re-training-and-conference
Attachment 2 habay es-proposal-for-research-re-training-and-conference
 
Influence of area of specialization and years of teaching experience of geogr...
Influence of area of specialization and years of teaching experience of geogr...Influence of area of specialization and years of teaching experience of geogr...
Influence of area of specialization and years of teaching experience of geogr...
 
Jessica C.V 2015.DOC
Jessica C.V 2015.DOCJessica C.V 2015.DOC
Jessica C.V 2015.DOC
 

Similar to Teachers' Perceptions of Cyprus' EE-ESD Course Implementation

Tojde 2017 1463-published
Tojde 2017 1463-publishedTojde 2017 1463-published
Tojde 2017 1463-publishedzakaria Arif
 
From ITT to CPD: research as a process for school improvement - Kevin Hollins
From ITT to CPD: research as a process for school improvement - Kevin HollinsFrom ITT to CPD: research as a process for school improvement - Kevin Hollins
From ITT to CPD: research as a process for school improvement - Kevin HollinsThe Higher Education Academy
 
Implementing assessment of inquiry skills in science education
Implementing assessment of inquiry skills in science educationImplementing assessment of inquiry skills in science education
Implementing assessment of inquiry skills in science education Sails-project
 
Learning environment as a determinant of adult learners' performance in adult...
Learning environment as a determinant of adult learners' performance in adult...Learning environment as a determinant of adult learners' performance in adult...
Learning environment as a determinant of adult learners' performance in adult...Adult Education (Literacy Education)
 
Research1
Research1Research1
Research1josekaw
 
Dynamic Learning Program for Millennial Learners
Dynamic Learning Program for Millennial LearnersDynamic Learning Program for Millennial Learners
Dynamic Learning Program for Millennial Learnersijtsrd
 
Stne seminar phase 2 180308
Stne seminar phase 2 180308Stne seminar phase 2 180308
Stne seminar phase 2 180308Scottish TNE
 
). Reflections on methodology used in assessing teachers´perceptions of colle...
). Reflections on methodology used in assessing teachers´perceptions of colle...). Reflections on methodology used in assessing teachers´perceptions of colle...
). Reflections on methodology used in assessing teachers´perceptions of colle...University of Iceland
 
First-year teacher education students’ reflections and interpretations about ...
First-year teacher education students’ reflections and interpretations about ...First-year teacher education students’ reflections and interpretations about ...
First-year teacher education students’ reflections and interpretations about ...Openmetsa
 
GROUP-8-3A1-FINAL-PAPER____.docx
GROUP-8-3A1-FINAL-PAPER____.docxGROUP-8-3A1-FINAL-PAPER____.docx
GROUP-8-3A1-FINAL-PAPER____.docxJohnMarkPentinio
 
CALL FOR PAPERS, 62 (2020-1) COMUNICAR JOURNAL @Rev_comunicar Special Issue. ...
CALL FOR PAPERS, 62 (2020-1) COMUNICAR JOURNAL @Rev_comunicar Special Issue. ...CALL FOR PAPERS, 62 (2020-1) COMUNICAR JOURNAL @Rev_comunicar Special Issue. ...
CALL FOR PAPERS, 62 (2020-1) COMUNICAR JOURNAL @Rev_comunicar Special Issue. ...eraser Juan José Calderón
 
Pre se nt jurnal (kpr 4063)
Pre se nt jurnal (kpr 4063)Pre se nt jurnal (kpr 4063)
Pre se nt jurnal (kpr 4063)kiahjanda
 
Chec presentation daniela and viv
Chec presentation daniela and vivChec presentation daniela and viv
Chec presentation daniela and vivVivienne Bozalek
 
Lived experiences of educators engaged in contintuing professional developmen...
Lived experiences of educators engaged in contintuing professional developmen...Lived experiences of educators engaged in contintuing professional developmen...
Lived experiences of educators engaged in contintuing professional developmen...GlenCortezano1
 
EE_UNIT_II.ppt
EE_UNIT_II.pptEE_UNIT_II.ppt
EE_UNIT_II.pptSasi Kumar
 
Improvement of students’ history learning competence through quantum learning...
Improvement of students’ history learning competence through quantum learning...Improvement of students’ history learning competence through quantum learning...
Improvement of students’ history learning competence through quantum learning...Alexander Decker
 

Similar to Teachers' Perceptions of Cyprus' EE-ESD Course Implementation (20)

Tojde 2017 1463-published
Tojde 2017 1463-publishedTojde 2017 1463-published
Tojde 2017 1463-published
 
From ITT to CPD: research as a process for school improvement - Kevin Hollins
From ITT to CPD: research as a process for school improvement - Kevin HollinsFrom ITT to CPD: research as a process for school improvement - Kevin Hollins
From ITT to CPD: research as a process for school improvement - Kevin Hollins
 
mohamed thesis
mohamed thesismohamed thesis
mohamed thesis
 
Implementing assessment of inquiry skills in science education
Implementing assessment of inquiry skills in science educationImplementing assessment of inquiry skills in science education
Implementing assessment of inquiry skills in science education
 
Learning environment as a determinant of adult learners' performance in adult...
Learning environment as a determinant of adult learners' performance in adult...Learning environment as a determinant of adult learners' performance in adult...
Learning environment as a determinant of adult learners' performance in adult...
 
Research1
Research1Research1
Research1
 
Dynamic Learning Program for Millennial Learners
Dynamic Learning Program for Millennial LearnersDynamic Learning Program for Millennial Learners
Dynamic Learning Program for Millennial Learners
 
Stne seminar phase 2 180308
Stne seminar phase 2 180308Stne seminar phase 2 180308
Stne seminar phase 2 180308
 
SDO .pptx
SDO .pptxSDO .pptx
SDO .pptx
 
). Reflections on methodology used in assessing teachers´perceptions of colle...
). Reflections on methodology used in assessing teachers´perceptions of colle...). Reflections on methodology used in assessing teachers´perceptions of colle...
). Reflections on methodology used in assessing teachers´perceptions of colle...
 
First-year teacher education students’ reflections and interpretations about ...
First-year teacher education students’ reflections and interpretations about ...First-year teacher education students’ reflections and interpretations about ...
First-year teacher education students’ reflections and interpretations about ...
 
GROUP-8-3A1-FINAL-PAPER____.docx
GROUP-8-3A1-FINAL-PAPER____.docxGROUP-8-3A1-FINAL-PAPER____.docx
GROUP-8-3A1-FINAL-PAPER____.docx
 
CALL FOR PAPERS, 62 (2020-1) COMUNICAR JOURNAL @Rev_comunicar Special Issue. ...
CALL FOR PAPERS, 62 (2020-1) COMUNICAR JOURNAL @Rev_comunicar Special Issue. ...CALL FOR PAPERS, 62 (2020-1) COMUNICAR JOURNAL @Rev_comunicar Special Issue. ...
CALL FOR PAPERS, 62 (2020-1) COMUNICAR JOURNAL @Rev_comunicar Special Issue. ...
 
Pre se nt jurnal (kpr 4063)
Pre se nt jurnal (kpr 4063)Pre se nt jurnal (kpr 4063)
Pre se nt jurnal (kpr 4063)
 
Chec presentation daniela and viv
Chec presentation daniela and vivChec presentation daniela and viv
Chec presentation daniela and viv
 
Pgcap new session 4 powerpoint slides (4)
Pgcap new session 4 powerpoint slides (4)Pgcap new session 4 powerpoint slides (4)
Pgcap new session 4 powerpoint slides (4)
 
Lived experiences of educators engaged in contintuing professional developmen...
Lived experiences of educators engaged in contintuing professional developmen...Lived experiences of educators engaged in contintuing professional developmen...
Lived experiences of educators engaged in contintuing professional developmen...
 
Science primary-2008
Science primary-2008Science primary-2008
Science primary-2008
 
EE_UNIT_II.ppt
EE_UNIT_II.pptEE_UNIT_II.ppt
EE_UNIT_II.ppt
 
Improvement of students’ history learning competence through quantum learning...
Improvement of students’ history learning competence through quantum learning...Improvement of students’ history learning competence through quantum learning...
Improvement of students’ history learning competence through quantum learning...
 

Teachers' Perceptions of Cyprus' EE-ESD Course Implementation

  • 1.
  • 2.
  • 3. Avdelning, Institution Division, Department Institutionen för kultur och kommunikation 581 83 LINKÖPING Datum Date 11 June 2014 Språk Language Rapporttyp Report category ISBN Engelska/English ISRN LIU-IKK-MOE-D--14/005--SE Master’s Thesis Serietitel och serienrummer Title of series, numbering ISSN URL för elektronisk version Titel Title Teachers’ Perceptions and Practices regarding the Implementation of the Course “Environmental Education-Education for Sustainable Development (E.E.-E.S.D.)” in Cypriot Primary Schools Författare Author Rafailia Katsioula Sammanfattning Abstract Educating children to become active and responsible citizens and live sustainably is one of the primary educational goals for the 21st century, in many countries around the world. Cyprus decided to move towards a similar direction, within a context of a wider effort to revitalize its educational system. Therefore, in 2011, a course called Environmental Education–Education for Sustainable Development (E.E.-E.S.D.) was officially included in the curriculum for Cypriot primary schools. The current qualitative research aimed to investigate issues related to the implementation of E.E.-E.S.D. during those three years of existence. The focus was on teachers’ point of view and therefore, the sample consisted of eight primary-school teachers from different schools and districts in Cyprus. Those teachers were chosen after a combination of purposive and snowball sampling. Interviews, documents, photos and informal conversations were used for the collection of the data. Data for analysis was analyzed using a thematic approach and the four themes which arose as results were related to teachers’ practices regarding the implementation of the course and their opinion on organizational aspects of it. More specifically, the findings demonstrated that the first step of implementation, which is the choice of the topic for the course in each school, depends on the special circumstances of each case and is mainly decided by teachers. Regarding the actual implementation, teachers pointed out active participation of students, involvement of outsiders in the course and outdoor activities as the main ways to preserve students’ interest for the course. Moreover, all of them appeared to be aware of the importance and benefits of a cross-curriculum approach for the purposes of the course but depending on their experiences, some of them spoke about barriers while others about auspicious factors and specific examples of such an approach. Finally, the teachers mentioned the time dedicated for the course, the advisory support offered to the teachers and the criteria of choosing the teacher in charge for the course as factors that need to be changed or improved. However, due to the limitations of data and sample in the current research, its findings are expected to be perceived as an opportunity for further investigations and not as general truths. Nyckelord Keywords Cyprus, Curriculum, primary school, environmental education, sustainable development, implementation, teachers’ opinion, teachers’ collaboration, barriers, procedures, practices, outdoor activities, experiential learning
  • 4. INDEX ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS 1 CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION 8 E.E.-E.S.D. AND THE CYPRIOT NATIONAL CURRICULUM 10 THE AIM OF THE RESEARCH 15 RESEARCH QUESTIONS 17 ΤHE NEED AND IMPORTANCE OF THE RESEARCH 20 CHAPTER 2: LITERATURE REVIEW 28 ENVIRONMENTAL EDUCATION AND EDUCATION FOR SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT 31 ENVIRONMENT AND ENVIRONMENTAL AWARENESS 31 SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT 36 THE ROLE OF EDUCATION 41 E.E.-E.S.D. IN CYPRUS 47 THE BEGINNING OF E.E. - E.S.D 48 THE GOALS OF THE COURSE 51 THE CONTENT OF THE COURSE 54 VITAL PRINCIPLE OF THE COURSE 59 METHODS OF IMPLEMENTATION OF THE COURSE 61 EXPERIENTIAL LEARNING 63 THE IMPORTANCE OF EXPERIENCE 65 THE QUALITY OF EXPERIENCE 67 OUTDOOR ACTIVITIES 70 OUTDOOR EDUCATION AS A TEACHING METHOD 71 THE NEED FOR OUTDOOR ACTIVITIES 73 BENEFITS OF OUTDOOR ACTIVITIES 76 TEACHER AS A CRUCIAL FACTOR IN EDUCATIVE PROCEDURES 80 THE IMPORTANCE OF THE TEACHER 80 THE ROLE OF THE TEACHER 84 BEING AN EFFECTIVE TEACHER 88 THE POWER OF COLLABORATION BETWEEN TEACHERS 94 CHAPTER 3: METHODOLOGY 103 THE PROCESS 106 THE SAMPLE 110 SELECTION OF PARTICIPANTS 115 PROFILE OF PARTICIPANTS 121
  • 5. QUESTIONNAIRE 130 INTERVIEWS 131 ACTION PLAN 139 INFORMAL CONVERSATIONS AND PHOTOS 143 ANALYSIS OF DATA 145 THEMATIC ANALYSIS AS AN ANALYZING STRATEGY 148 THEMES 153 THE THEMES OF THIS STUDY 156 ETHICAL ISSUES 162 PREVENTION FOR ETHICAL ISSUES 164 ETHICAL PROBLEM 168 CHAPTER 4: RESULTS 171 THEME 1: E.E.-E.S.D. AS PART OF THE SCHOOL REALITY 175 THE CHOICE OF THE TEACHER IN CHARGE FOR THE COURSE 176 ADVISORY SUPPORT FOR THE TEACHERS 186 THE SUITABILITY OF THE TIME DEDICATED TO THE COURSE 202 THEME 2: THE ANNUAL TOPIC OF THE SCHOOL FOR E.E.-E.S.D. 210 THE INFLUENCE OF CIRCUMSTANCES 212 THE ROLE OF THE STUDENTS REGARDING THE TOPIC 219 THE ACTION PLAN 229 THEME 3: IMPLEMENTATION OF A CROSS-CURRICULUM APPROACH 244 BARRIERS IN IMPLEMENTATION 246 CROSS-CURRICULUM APPROACH IN PRACTICE 259 AUSPICIOUS FACTORS OF IMPLEMENTATION 272 THEME 4: PERSISTENCE OF STUDENTS’ INTEREST FOR THE COURSE 279 ACTIVE PARTICIPATION OF STUDENTS 282 INVITING VISITORS AT THE SCHOOL 288 OUTDOOR ACTIVITIES 294 CHAPTER 5: DISCUSSION 303 THE ACTION PLAN AND ITS MULTI-DIMENSIONAL USE 310 THE SUCCESS OF ALTERNATIVE LEARNING 319 THE IMPORTANCE OF STUDENTS’ OPINION IN DECISIONS 331 THE DESIRABLE SUPPORT TO THE TEACHERS 339 THE EFFECT OF INTERPERSONAL RELATIONSHIPS ON THE PERCEPTIONS OF PROCEDURES 348 CHAPTER 6: CONCLUSION 359 SUMMARY OF THE RESULTS 361 SUGGESTIONS FOR USING THE RESULTS 367 SUGGESTIONS FOR THE MINISTRY OF EDUCATION AND CULTURE 369 SUGGESTIONS FOR THE PRINCIPALS OF THE SCHOOLS 373 SUGGESTIONS FOR THE TEACHERS 375 LIMITATIONS OF THE RESEARCH 378
  • 6. SUGGESTIONS FOR FURTHER RESEARCH 382 REFERENCES 386 APPENDIX 409 TABLE 1: TEACHERS’ INFORMATION COLLECTED WITH THE QUESTIONNAIRE 410 QUESTIONNAIRE 424 INTERVIEW PROTOCOL 431 CONSENT FORM 438 INFORMATION SHEET 445 MAP OF CYPRUS WITH THE MAIN DISTRICTS 452 PHOTO 1: CONVERSION OF BROKEN COMPUTERS INTO DECORATIVE OBJECTS 455 PHOTO 2: CONVERSION OF USED CASKS INTO DECORATIVE SCULPTURES 458 PHOTO 3: CONVERSION OF A SPACE IN THE PARKING OF THE SCHOOL INTO A GARDEN 462 PHOTO 4: PICNIC TABLES USED AS AN OUTDOOR CLASS 464
  • 7. 1 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I would like to use this chance to give my acknowledgements to all those who contributed to this effort in one or another way. I believe that the people I mention bellow had a vital role in the accomplishment of the current thesis project, either individually or collectively. I would like to begin with my supervisor, Katarina Johansson and thank her for the immediate responses to my questions, for all the suggestions for improvements and for the time she dedicated to read my work. Secondly, I would like to thank the team of professors of the master program “Outdoor Environmental Education and Outdoor Life”. Our interaction and collaboration this year offered to me useful knowledge, practical and mental skills and the ability to create a well- rounded opinion of their way of working. Also, I want to acknowledge the help and support of my classmates during the whole procedure. I enjoyed sharing opinions, deadlocks, fears, jokes, achievements and big smiles during our talks about our thesis in every chance. But this work would not exist without the participation of the eight teachers who constituted the sample of the current research. I would like to sincerely thank them for their willingness to contribute to my effort, for their responsible and flawless collaboration until the end and for all the information they shared with me. My last and biggest acknowledgment goes to my family and friends. This thesis came to an end thanks to their selfless and full support, both psychologically and practically. I appreciated every single action, word and thought that came from them. The encouragement and motivation they offered me has been a precious and inexhaustible source of power.
  • 8. 2 CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION Summary In this chapter, I describe the topic as well as the aim of this research which is to bring up information regarding the implementation of the course of Environmental Education- Education for Sustainable Development (E.E.-E.S.D.) in the Cypriot school reality. Also, the research questions that lead the whole research procedure will be presented. An argument regarding the need and the importance of the current research completes the chapter. E.E.-E.S.D1 . and the Cypriot national curriculum The course of E.E.-E.S.D. was officially included in the Cypriot school schedule in 2011. It is considered to be a revolutionary change due to its special organizational characteristics and the philosophy it relies on. It is a novelty for the Cypriot educational circumstances. Its inclusion could be characterized as a vital need if we take into account the skills and attitudes required in the 21st century. As it is said, we are at a point in human history where we struggle to maintain a balance in coexistence of human and natural world (Sandell, Öhman and Östman, 2003). The course has been framed by a very powerful curriculum with obvious elements from theories which support the active participation of students in issues related to the society of their school, the wider society of the country and finally, the world. Primary-school teachers are expected to transform the ideas of the curriculum from theory into practice. Having in mind that the course counts only three years of existence this task can be a quite challenging one. During these three years, in order to track weaknesses and make improvements, there have been several efforts to get feedback from the teachers as the main responsible for the implementation of the course. I consider this research as a part of those efforts. 1 E.E.-E.S.D. is the abbreviation used for the course of Environmental Education–Education for Sustainable Development.
  • 9. 3 The aim of the research The aim of the present research was to investigate the Cypriot teachers’ views and practices regarding the course of E.E.-E.S.D.. More specifically, the participants were asked to describe methods and practices they use in order to approach the course, both individually as teachers and collectively as members of their school teaching staff. In addition, I aimed to find out their opinion on different issues related to the course, since I consider the teachers to be the most suitable to evaluate the plan for its implementation. Research questions In order to fulfil the aim described above, I chose to have the following four research questions:  How do teachers teach the course of E.E.-E.S.D. in Cypriot public primary schools?  Which is the teachers’ opinion regarding the organizational issues of the course E.E.- E.S.D.?  How can the teachers’ opinions be connected to the course aims and the implementation of the course?  What improvements can be made in the implementation of the course? The first two questions were my point of reference in every step of the research procedure in order to remain focused in the desirable direction while the other two questions occurred because of the results. Of course, the findings of this research give answers to those four questions at the extent that this was feasible, due to the existent limitations. Τhe need and importance of the research As it was mentioned before, the course of E.E.-E.S.D. counts only three years of existence in the national curriculum of Cyprus and still the effort is not fully completed. The people who are involved, from those that are asked to organize the course to those who are called to implement it in practice, are still trying to find what works and what does not. The realization of such a research is necessary since the results can work as a feedback that will lead to
  • 10. 4 further improvements of the course and of the Cypriot education in general. Even if this is considered to be a small study I believe that it will contribute to this effort as it can become the reason for further related research.
  • 11. 5 CHAPTER 2: LITERATURE REVIEW Summary This chapter presents a combination of information and ideas that were found after a review of literature related to the findings of the research. It begins with an effort to define environment and sustainable development and describe the role of education regarding them. A trace back to the beginning of E.E.-E.S.D. in Cyprus is presented and then its curriculum is briefly described with a reference to its most important aspects. Furthermore, theories and arguments regarding experiential learning, and outdoor activities are mentioned. The chapter draws to an end with a discussion on the role of the teacher. Environmental education and education for sustainable development Environment and environmental awareness Firstly, I should try to explain the term “environment”. Dewey’s (1997, p.44) approach of environment defines it as “(...) whatever conditions interact with personal needs, desires, purposes, and capacities to create the experience which is had”. In a similar way, Sandell, Öhman and Östman (2003) include in the term “environment” everything that is around us, including both natural and human creations. Being environmentally aware, means that you are able to realize and deeply understand the elements that constitute the environment around you, as well as the interactive relationships between them. Sobel (1996), and Dahlgren and Szczepanski (2005) argue that such realizations can work as a transitional stage which will lead to a protective sense toward environment. In the 21st century, the need for developing such a sense is very important, for most of the countries around the world. That is due to the increase of environmental, social and economic problems, the continual human tend to measure and adapt everything in human terms and needs and our progressive disconnectedness from nature (Sandell, Öhman and Östman, 2003). Louv (2008) expresses his fears, especially for the new generations. More specifically, the author presents a varied collection of research results, most of them showing the benefits of interaction with nature from the one hand and the serious nature-deficit disorder that characterizes today’s children from the other (Louv, 2008).
  • 12. 6 Sustainable development There are plenty of definitions given for sustainable development, as it has been a matter of discussion and contradictions due to the complex of the term (Sandell, Öhman and Östman, 2003). However, the definition that explains sustainable development as “the ability to make development sustainable, to ensure that it meets the needs of the present without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs” (Kates, Parris and Leiserowitz, 2005, p.10) despite its brief meaning, seems to cover the needs of this research. From the very beginning of our existence, our relationship with the natural resources of the earth has been a crucial matter of discussion and examination, even if the reasons and our actions have changed a lot (Sandell, Öhman and Östman, 2003). According to Sobel (2005, p.17), by making efforts towards sustainability, “(…) means that we accept a concept of limited resources and start to look for ways to simultaneously enhance economic vitality, environmental quality, and school improvement at local level.” Orr (2004) claimed that a sustainable living requires a shift regarding the products we consume and he underlines the importance of choosing products that are durable, recyclable, useful, efficient and sufficient. Also, Orr (2004, p.62) pointed out the importance of making this shift promptly by arguing that “if we are not to turn the earth into a toxic dump or bankrupt ourselves by expensively undoing what should not have been done in the first place, moderation must eventually replace self-indulgence”. The role of education Seymor (2004), claims that there is a high need in starting educating our children differently. “It is not education, but education of a certain kind that will save us”, agrees Orr (2004, p.8). More specifically, Orr (2004) borrows the Greek word Paideia to speak about the necessity of an education oriented towards a mastery of one's person, instead of a master of subject matter. Sandell, Öhman, and Östman (2003), point out three kinds of knowledge that a teacher who undertakes environmental issues and issues of sustainable development should have and those are: a) actual knowledge of those issues, b) experience of different ways of teaching and learning and c) related skills that have been developed in previous experiences. United Nations have dedicated a whole decade in order to orient Education towards a sustainable development and 2014 is the final year (UNESCO, n.d.). As Scott (2013, p.182) described “the UN decade encourages schools to take sustainability seriously in what they do
  • 13. 7 across buildings and grounds, in what they teach, and in how they link with local stakeholders”. Scott (2013) explained that this decade has given schools the chance and the obligation to contribute to the global effort towards a sustainable way of life, or a less unsustainable one. Orr (2004, p.32) came to the conclusion that the difficult situation we are in “(…) can be resolved only if enough people come to hold a bigger idea of what means to be a citizen. This will have to be carefully taught at all levels of education”. During the last years there has been a critical discussion about the relation, the differences and the similarities of environmental education and education for sustainable development (Sandell, Öhman and Östman, 2003). However, the focus of the current study is on the case of Cyprus. In the context of Cyprus, it has been decided to officially refer to the course with both terms in one title and that is Environmental Education–Education for Sustainable Development. Therefore, in this study, there is no need to discuss the different opinions regarding the general controversy on their comparison. E.E.-E.S.D. in Cyprus The beginning of E.E. - E.S.D In 2008 the Cyprus Ministry of Education and Culture (MOEC) decided that it is time for dramatic changes in education. Since the previous Curriculum, there have been a lot of social, economic, political and environmental changes on the island. These changes, and in combination with several suggestion by European programs, exposed a vital need for retrofit of education in order to conform to the other aspects of life. After realizing the importance and need of educational changes, several discussions and actions were done. Finally, in 2010, the new curriculums were composed and ready for use. The change in Cypriot education has become a reality since 2011 when the implementation of the new curriculums for the school subjects has gradually started and still continues (MOEC, n.d.). The course of E.E.-E.S.D. was introduced in the primary school reality occasioned by those changes. More specifically, the course is given 80 minutes per week for the grades one to four, during the same day and consecutively, and 40 minutes per week for the grades five and six. For grades one to four, the curriculum has decided to share alternately those 80 minutes between E.E.-E.S.D. and another course with the name Treatment of Life (MOEC, 2012).
  • 14. 8 The goals of the course The main aim of the course of E.E.-E.S.D. is the development of a sustainable school, which will be able to create autonomous and active citizens (MOEC, 2010). All the effort is navigated towards the goal of a holistic perception of environmental issues and issues of sustainability. Vital requirement for the achievement of that goal is the combination of knowledge, action and participation (MOEC, 2010). The curriculum analyses the aim mentioned above with the suggestion of a number of general goals to be achieved. Those goals go beyond the students since some of them are uniquely designed for the teachers, others for the school and others for the community (MOEC, 2010). The content of the course Regarding the content, or the things that are supposed to be taught, the Curriculum is very flexible. In fact, each school is encouraged to create its own planning each year, by choosing a topic or topics to work with for the whole year. The topic should emerge as a need by the special circumstances of each school (MOEC, 2010). The organization of the course is suggested to be done with the composition of an action plan. The action plan is a document composed by the teachers of each school and includes information such as the purpose and the goals of the topic. Neither the structure nor the action plan itself is officially compulsory but its composition is highly recommended and additionally, with the collaboration of all the teachers of the school (MOEC, 2012). As a result, the course does not have a book. However, there is a guide book for the course which is addressed to the teachers and is organized in twelve indicative thematic units i.e. the forest, the biodiversity, the litter, the poverty, etc. (MOEC, 2010). Each one of them includes basic concepts and vocabulary, the expected learning outcomes in local, national and international level and also, interconnections with the other thematic units (MOEC, 2012).Those topics aim to work as the base for further planning. The Ministry of Education and Culture encourages each school and moreover, the teachers to select issues appropriate to a) the age, the knowledge, the interests, the experiences and the needs of their students, b) the special social and political circumstances, c) the particular environment of the area and d) the environmental and sustainable issues that concern the local community or are in general in the limelight (MOEC, 2012). It is though underlined that the main target is not the quantity of the topics approached but the promotion of a political thinking in the framework of a social, democratic, based on values education and the conjunction of the natural sciences along with
  • 15. 9 the humanitarian sciences and the art (MOEC, 2010). Vital principle of the Course The revolutionary principle of the curriculum for E.E.-E.S.D. is the utilization of the local environment of each school or of other places that can contribute to learning (MOEC, 2010). Any place that can be used as a tool for the course can work as a class. The emphasis is transferred from the book to the place and students are asked to investigate environmental issues or issues of sustainability within their close environment (MOEC, 2010). Methods of implementation of the course The two main methodological guidelines that are suggested by the Ministry of Education and Culture of Cyprus are a) the project and b) the cross-curriculum approach of the course (MOEC, 2010). The importance of approaching the topic in a holistic way within the entire school with collaboration is pointed out as a new element of great value for the needs of the course (MOEC, 2012). With that directive, didactical practices, based on the active and interactive learning, on the exploration and on the group work, are proposed. Some of them are the problem solving, the debate and the role play (MOEC, 2010). Finally, Information and Communication Technology (ICT) is recommended as well to be combined with the strategies mentioned above. Experiential Learning Literature offers a wide range of theories connected to learning procedure. One of them with many supporters is experiential learning. Beard and Wilson (2006, p.19), in an effort to define experiential learning, argue that it is “the sense-making process of active engagement between the inner world of the person and the outer world of the environment”. The importance of experience Dewey (1997), points out the need for a philosophy of education based on a philosophy of experience. Dahlgren and Szczepanski (2005) discuss the deep difference between knowing about something and knowing something, presenting the second one as more effective, due to the involvement of emotions and actions. They believe that “when we meet the world around
  • 16. 10 us, we learn how it works, how it tastes, smells, and feels” (Dahlgren and Szczepanski, 2005, p.25). The quality of experience For Dewey (1997), the nodal point is the quality of the experience. He developed a whole theory, trying to give the “correct” idea of experience. He discriminates experiences in good and bad. Good experiences are characterized by continuity and interaction, providing students with a positive feeling for further learning. Bad experiences, as the author says, fail to provide a connection of the skills with future experiences- if there are any, since students are usually dissatisfied and repelled Dewey (1997). In any case, as Beard and Wilson (2006, p.7) argue, “the more senses we use in an activity, the more memorable the learning experience will become because it increases the neural connections in our brains and therefore will be more accessible”. Outdoor activities Outdoor education as a teaching method By accepting experiential learning as an efficient way to learn, it turns out that, actually, the environment is the most proper place to learn about the environment. So that is how a need for outdoor education emerges. Again, the literature offers a wide range of suggested definitions regarding Outdoor education. However, I consider the literal definition of Outdoor Education as sufficient. So, literally, outdoor education is described as the teaching procedure that occurs in an environment outside the classroom (Hammerman, Hammerman and Hammerman, 2000). The need for outdoor activities Beard and Wilson (2006, p.6) claim that “learning is literally and metaphorically breaking out of the traditional classroom”. At the same time, Dahlgren and Szczepanski (2005) argue that the indoor environments of a classroom can often be perceived as too strict and not enough exciting for some students. Orr (2004, p.14) expresses a similar opinion by arguing that “courses taught as lecture courses tend to induce passivity. Indoor classes create the illusion that learning only occurs inside four walls, isolated from what students call, without apparent
  • 17. 11 irony, the ¨real world¨”. For Sobel (2005), the interaction between school, community and environment, any type of environment, is very important as he believes that students should get to know their close environment first in order to be able to offer later in a wider extend. Of course, as Dahlgren and Szczepanski (2005) underline, outdoor activities do not intent to cancel indoor learning but, instead, to complete it, having the child always in a central position. Benefits of outdoor activities “Going outdoors is immediate and real; it sparks questions; it offers avenues of exploration and investigation; and it is available, at little or no expense, to everyone” claims Bourne (2000, p.5). The author continues by explaining that students who are used to work outdoors in regular base are able to point out characteristics of each environment such as cycles of procedures and patterns (Bourne, 2000). Furthermore, Beard and Wilson (2006) believe that outdoor activities can offer several learning opportunities, due to the integration of the learner with nature, other learners and facilitators at the same time. Dahlgren and Szczepanski (2005, p.24) come to add that “the natural environment offers a wide range of visual impressions, scents, movements, sounds, and shapes, appealing to all of the child's senses in a way which no other environment is capable”. Finally, Dahlgren and Szczepanski (2005) argue that if outdoor activities are applied in a proper way, not only knowledge can be achieved but also close relations between the learner and the culture, the society and the nature. Regarding the latter, the authors argue that through outdoor education the current detached relationship between man and eco-system can be restored, a fact which should be our main objective as human beings (Dahlgren and Szczepanski, 2005). Teacher as a crucial factor in educative procedures The importance of the teacher According to Day, et al. (2007, p.1) “no educational reform has achieved success without teachers committing themselves to it”. As Hattie (2012, p.25) said, “(...) teachers’ beliefs and commitments are the greatest influence on student achievement over which we can have some control (…)”. Richmond, et al. (2008, p.259) recognize the vital role of a teacher as well, due to her/his “(...) control over children who have not yet formed their attitudes and ideas”.
  • 18. 12 As the authors explain, a teacher can work either as an auspicious factor or as a barrier in students' learning, depending on the motivation that she/he offer through communication, control, supervision, help and entertainment (Richmond, et al., 2008). Teachers are able to influence the learning of the students and therefore, it is their responsibility to determine “(…) that environment which will interact with the existing capacities and needs of those taught to create a worth-while experience” (Dewey, 1997, p.45). In relation to the importance of teachers in educational procedures, Day, et al. (2007, p.233) claim the following: “Teachers in all countries need support for their commitment, energy and skill over their careers if they are to grapple with the immense emotional, intellectual and social demands, as they work toward building the internal and external relationships demanded by ongoing government reforms and social movements”. The role of the teacher For Hattie (2012), teachers should be experts. According to the five dimensions that Hattie gives to the term “expert”, a teacher should be able to a) form and introduce new knowledge by taking in account students´ previous knowledge and needs, b) create an atmosphere that allows active involvement and interaction of students, c) adapt the teaching plan and goals to students current understanding while providing them with meaningful feedback which promotes growth, d) respect the students and interact with them and e) have a positive influence on students. Dewey (1997) is also a supporter of the crucial role of teacher in the learning procedure. He believes that the teacher ought to use her/his own experiences very carefully, in order to help students with their own from the position of leader (Dewey, 1997). However, at the same time the author recognizes the difficulty of teachers’ role in finding the required balances between freedom and control of students (Dewey, 1997). Regarding this, Kahn (2002) considers children as active human beings that have the ability to take advantage of their interaction with the environment in order to construct knowledge and values. Also, Muijs and Reynolds (2001) support the importance of involving students in decisions for their learning. More specifically they argue that “Giving students responsibilities helps build up a sense of personal power, which will enhance self-esteem. Students should be given the opportunity to make choices and should be allowed to make an active contribution to lessons” (Muijs and Reynolds, 2001, p.108).
  • 19. 13 Being an effective teacher To begin with, as Killen (2003) argues, there is not a teaching strategy that will always work successfully no matter the learners. Hattie (2012, p.44) explains that “as well as bringing their prior achievements, students bring many other dispositions to the classroom. These include motivation to learn, strategies to learn, and confidence to learn.”, issues that a teacher should consider. According to Killen (2003, p.2), “(…) students will learn more when they are motivated than when they are not motivated. This means that learning will be more effective when you make it interesting, enjoyable and challenging for learners”. More specifically, the author argues that an effective teaching includes activities that awake curiosity, emphasize in understanding of concepts and relations than memorization of information, are adapted in the skills, the attitudes and the knowledge of the students and have a relation with students’ everyday life experiences (Killen, 2003). In addition, as Richmond, et al. (2008, p.259) point out, “teachers must know how to present material in an interesting and entertaining fashion. Students will then attend to it and retain it longer”. Killen (2003, p.20) adds that “(...) learning is enhanced when the learners can see how the things they are learning are relevant to them. This can be achieved by linking to their background knowledge, connecting learning to the real world beyond the classroom; and integrating knowledge across subject boundaries”. For Beard and Wilson (2006), the more a student is involved in an activity the more he learns while in the meantime the effect on his way of thinking as well as on his behavior will be bigger. The power of collaboration between teachers As Sobel (2005, p.67) argued “Teachers listen to other teachers. (…) When a teacher sees that another teacher can do something, she is more willing to try it herself”. Teachers in a school, have the chance to collaborate in order to achieve their educational goals. Burton and Dimbleby (2006, p.247) explain that “we often join and form groups because we believe that “two (or more) heads are better than one or because ¨many hands make light work¨”. According to the authors, when the members of a groups are also an effective team then they increase their productivity, improve the communication between them, achieve goals that ordinary groups might not be able to achieve, use the available resources in a better way,
  • 20. 14 become more creative and affective when it comes to problem solving situations, provide services of a higher quality and increase the level of processes (Burton and Dimbleby, 2006).
  • 21. 15 CHAPTER 3: METHODOLOGY Summary This chapter aims to describe the actions and explain the choices that were made, regarding the methodological decisions of the research. It starts with a brief description of the process. Then, some vital information about the sample of the research is presented, including description of the contact procedure, demographic characteristics and relevant explanations. After that, the focus is transferred on the data of this research. Therefore, information and reasoning about the stages of collection and analysis are given. The chapter draws to a close with a reference to the ethical concerns regarding the research and my actions in order to deal with them. The process Because of the nature of my research questions and my intention to focus on teachers' personal experiences and opinions regarding the teaching of the course of E.E.-E.S.D, I decided to substantiate a qualitative research and more specifically, a case study. A qualitative study offers access to a wider range of empirical data, comparing to a quantitative (Punch, 1998). A case study constitutes a qualitative method in which the researcher uses several data sources in order to describe and understand a case with case-based themes (Creswell, 2007). A case can vary a lot, from a single child to a whole classroom as Silverman (2010) explains. In the current case study, I consider the implementation of the course E.E.-E.S.D. as the case I am willing to explore. Of course, the implementation of a school subject has multiple dimensions and several aspects which I do not wish to investigate at this point. Therefore, I have limited the case of implementation to teachers’ perception of it. Firstly, I started searching for participants corresponding to the needs of my case study and as soon as I had my sample, I informed them about the research. Then, I composed an interview protocol and after a pilot interview, I started collecting the data. The next stage was the analysis of the data in order to get the results. Finally, through a combination of the findings with related literature, I came up with some conclusions.
  • 22. 16 The sample My thoughts regarding the sample came after I had decided my topic and specified my research questions. Having them as a reference point, and in order to pick my participants, I used a generic purposive sampling in combination with convenience sampling and in one case snowball sampling. In generic purposive sampling, “the researcher establishes criteria concerning the kinds of cases needed to address the research questions, identifies appropriate cases, and then samples from those cases that have been identified” (Bryman, 2012, p.422). Creswell (2007, p.125) adds that “the inquirer selects individuals and sites for study because they can purposefully inform an understanding of the research problem and central phenomenon in the study”. From the hand, the kind of sampling that is “simply available to the researcher by virtue of its accessibility” (Bryman, 2012, p.201), is called convenience sampling. In this case, the researcher chooses the participants that are promptly available and is used when there are many limitations in a research (Patton, 2002). However, this type of sampling can cause expense of information, as well as credibility (Creswell, 2007). Regarding my other method, snowball sampling is the technique where “the researcher makes initial contact with a small group that is relevant to the research topic and then uses these to establish contacts with others” (Bryman, 2012, p.202). Finally, my sample was small in size with only 8 participants. Silverman (2010) argues that small samples tend to be a characteristic choice of qualitative researchers since “generally speaking, qualitative researchers are prepared to sacrifice scope for detail” (Silverman, 2010, p.104). In my case, with the circumstances under which this research was substantiated, the number of 8 participants seemed to be satisfactory. Selection of participants For the needs of the research and having in mind my research questions, I thought about concrete characteristics that the sample should have and characteristics that it would be better to have. I decided that the participants of my sample must be primary school teachers that are working in a school this year. Also, they should be teaching the course E.E.-E.S.D. this year or have taught it during the last three years, when the course E.E.-E.S.D. was officially included in Cypriot school curriculum. Other than these, I wanted to find teachers from different schools and different environments, representing urban, semi-urban and rural schools to see what kind of differences there might be in teachers’ approach since “each school aspires to uncover and cultivate the unique genius of the local environment and
  • 23. 17 community through the school’s curriculum” (Sobel, 2005, p.22). That differentiation is highly underlined in the curriculum as well (MOEC, 2012). My choices regarding schools were not completely random. I had a practical issue in my mind and that was the distance between teachers' working or living place. Due to the limited time of the four working days I had for collecting my data, I contacted schools that were close to each other, at least each two or three of them, so that I could visit those in one day. Also, I just chose the teachers that were available for an interview when I needed them. The investigation of differences and similarities between male and female teachers or between different teaching grades was not in my intentions and therefore I did not have those factors as criteria. My contact with the sample group in most of the cases was via the headmaster of the schools. I was sending an e-mail or I was making a phone call to the headmasters, asking them to share the information with the teachers of the school. Teachers who were willing to participate, answered me back. To those teachers, I sent at a later stage, an official information sheet with the latest details that I thought they should know regarding the research (Appendix, p. 63). In the case where a teacher suggested me another teacher, the information sheet was sent after an informative phone call between the teachers. Profile of participants The eight teachers, six women and two men, come from eight different schools in different districts (Appendix, p. 64), two2 urban, three rural and three semi-urban schools. Also, five of them are the E.E.-E.S.D. teachers of the classes they referred to while three of them are the principal teachers3 . Regarding the annual topic of those schools for the course E.E.-E.S.D., five of the schools have chosen topics related to abatement of litter and recycling, one has chosen as topic the “litter and energy”, one has chosen “the forest” and one has chosen “the formulation of the school”. The working experience of the sample varies from seven to twenty-four years. Specifically for the course of E.E.-E.S.D., which is officially included in the curriculum since three years, one teacher has experience of three years, three of the teachers have experience of two years and for four of the teachers, this is the first year of teaching the course. Furthermore, five of the participants claimed that it was their personal 2 There was an effort to have a balance in the sample regarding the representatives from urban, rural and semi- urban schools. However one of the participants from an urban school made a last minute cancelation of his participation due to personal reasons. 3 Explanations for this differentiation can be found in the Appendix, page 59 (*).
  • 24. 18 choice to teach the course this year and six of them have participated to educative seminars related to the course (Appendix, p. 58). Collection of data I collected my data using a questionnaire, interviews, official documents, photos and informal conversations with the teachers. The use of multiple sources for data collection is a common strategy in case studies, in order to achieve detailed and in-depth data collection (Creswell, 2007). Data was collected in four days. To do that, I travelled to Cyprus and met each participant at a time and place of her/his choice. I met four of the participants at their school during morning hours and four of them at their house during afternoon hours. In most of the cases, the whole procedure lasted approximately 40 minutes. Observations would have been a very strong tool of data collection for this research. As Cohen, et al. (2011, p. 289) explain about case studies, “(…)one of their strengths is that they observe effects in real contexts, recognizing that context is a powerful determinant of both causes and effects and that in-depth understanding is required to do justice to the case”. However, the limited time I had to collect my data and complete this research, in combination with the fact that the course is taught only once per week, did not allow the use of observations. Questionnaire Questionnaire was used in order to collect some demographic information about each participant (Appendix, p.60). This information was intending to create a profile of reference for each participant. The questionnaire was given to the participants immediately before the interview so that the questions could be adjusted to their personal characteristics. Interviews The use of interviews is quite common in qualitative research as “it is a very good way of accessing people's perceptions, meanings, and definitions of situations and constructions of reality.” (Punch, 1998, p.175). There are many kinds of interviews and one way of
  • 25. 19 discrimination is their level of structure. Related to this, Cohen, et al. (2011, p.412) claim that “the more one wishes to gain comparable data - across people, across sites - the more standardized and quantitative one's interview tends to become; the more one wishes to acquire unique, non-standardized, personalized information about how individuals view the world, the more one veers towards qualitative, open-ended, unstructured interviewing”. I chose to use semi-structured interviewing within a guided interview, with four main questions and ten sub-questions regarding the following categories: the content and the procedural characteristics of the school’s topic, the teacher’s teaching approach and practices, the teacher’s reflection regarding her/his teaching and the teacher’s critique regarding the curriculum (Appendix, p. 61). Guided interviews combine a freedom for the interviewee to speak about what is important to her/him, rather than to the interviewer, and an assurance to the interviewer that all the topics that she/he consider as crucial for the study will be covered (Bell, 2006). Also, during a semi-structured interview “the interviewer is prepared to be flexible in terms of the order in which the topics are considered, and, perhaps more significantly, to let the interviewee develop ideas and speak more widely on the issues raised by the researcher” (Denscombe, 2010, p.175). I had informed the participants that we would need 30-40 minutes so I made an effort to create questions that were possible to be answered during that time. The basic thought behind this was the option of doing the interviews during school time in a spare hour. Each school period in Cyprus lasts 40 minutes, except the last one that lasts 35 minutes (MOEC, n.d.). For the needs of my research, firstly I did a pilot interview which later I decided to include in my data because of the importance of the information I got from it. The pilot interview helped me to realize some weak aspects of my questions and therefore make all the possible improvements. The order of the questions was defined by the participant, depending on her/his answers. Bell (2006) agrees that a capable interviewer can take advantage of the adaptability that interviews offer to access resposes, feelings and motives that he couldn't access with a questionaire. However, Bell (2006) considers interviews as a highly demanding tool, considering time and effort in construction, while at the same time he points out the high possibility of prejudices of the reseracher due to the subjective character of their nature. Furthermore, as Punch (1998, p.61) claims, “It is inevitable that the words we use to record data from the field will reflect, to some extent, our own concepts” since the text describing the transformation of data into word is a creation of the researcher (Punch, 1998).
  • 26. 20 Action plan The action plan is a document which is expected to be composed by the teachers of each school at the beginning of every school year. It is the result of a teachers’ meeting regarding the course of E.E.-E.S.D. (MOEC, 2010). After they have decided about the topic, they are supposed to compose a plan with goals and guidelines which refers to all the teachers of the school. The extent and the details included in the plan depend on the teachers. In addition to the interviews, Ι asked the participants to provide the action plan of their school for the current school year. My purpose was to have an extra source of information for each case. In that way, I could also examine the relevance of the plan with each teacher’s sayings, find some similarities as well as differences between the plans of the different schools and see to what degree each school follows the guidelines of the curriculum regarding the action plan. Such documents can be useful when they are used in combination with interviews or observations but at the same time, it is important to keep in mind their ontological distinctive status and therefore not take everything as an underling reality (Atkinson and Goffey, 2011 cited in Bryman, 2012). Informal conversations and photos Having in mind the need for deep understanding of my case, I tried to collect as much information as I could. Therefore, I took advantage of my conversation with the participants before and after the interview and noted some of their comments that I considered as important and useful for my later analysis and results. Also, in cases where the interviews took place at the school of the participants, after the interview we made a walk around the school and the teachers showed me samples of the work they mentioned in their interviews. I asked and took photos of those samples and some of them have been included to this report as Appendix. Analysis of data For the purposes of my research, and after a first study of my data to be analyzed, I decided that the most proper strategy for me to follow was the thematic analysis. As Crabtree and Miller (1992) mention, the strategies of data analysis consist of a continuum that goes from
  • 27. 21 standardized strategies that have pre-determined concepts, categories and issues to strategies that emerge during the analysis among the emerging concepts, categories and issues. In research, the design and plan for a particular analysis depends on the analytic purpose (Guest, MacQueen and Namey, 2011). Bryman (2012, p.565) argues that “there are few well- established and widely accepted rules for the analysis of qualitative data”, but this can also be considered as a benefit too. Thematic analysis as an analyzing strategy Thematic analysis belongs to the research analyzing strategies and is broadly considered as one of those being emerged from the data of each case. More specifically, as Guest, MacQueen and Namey (2011) explain, thematic analysis describes implicit, as well as explicit ideas within the data, themes, while it can also include comparison of code frequencies, identification of code co-occurrence, and graphically display of relationships between codes within the data set. Ezzy (2002, p.88), characterizes a kind of thematic analysis as inductive and explains that “while the general issues that are of interest are determined prior to the analysis, the specific nature of the categories and themes to be explored are not predetermined” and therefore they come up after the coding of data. Bryman (2012) mentions that thematic analysis is one of the most used approaches in qualitative research, although, as he claims, most of the times is not identifiable, due to its lack of identifiable heritage and distinctive cluster of techniques. Guest, MacQueen and Namey (2011, p.11) come to add that in thematic analysis, reliability is a risky affair because of the interpretation of the researcher in “defining the data items (i.e. codes) as well as applying the codes to bigger parts of text”. However, the authors argue that thematic analysis is still the most useful approach in showing the complexities of meaning within a data text set. Themes Bryman (2012), in an effort to explain the meaning and the use of a theme, defines it as a category that among other things, is identified in the collected data by the researcher, relates to the research questions and contributes to the related literature that already exists. Researchers who are willing to use thematic analysis are encouraged to search across their data for noticeable patterns such as repetitions of topics, transitions of topics, and similarities and differences in the way of speaking about a topic, in order to create their themes. (Ryan
  • 28. 22 and Bernard, 2003 cited in Bryman, 2012). Braun and Klarke (2006) argue that there is no correct or wrong way of determining themes as it can be done in many different ways but they underline the need of explaining the way of thinking and the decisions being made in order to end up to those themes. The themes of this study The thematic analysis I followed was inductive and therefore is based on themes emerging from the data. To do so, I followed approximately the steps that Braun and Klarke (2006) suggest to researchers who are interested in doing a thematic analysis. Firstly, I became familiar with my data via consecutively and active readings of the interviews’ transcriptions, once all of it together and then each interview separately. During this step I also made a list with information from each interview that I considered as interesting or/and popular. Then, mainly based on my list, I tried to generate initial codes and while reading each interview again, this time more carefully, I tried to find as many extracts that would fit in the codes as I could. During this step I used a table for each code where I was writing the name of the participant, the line of the transcription where I could find the extract and key words describing her/his saying. After that, I tried to group my codes with the extracts under potential themes, a procedure which was occurred several times until I ended up to my final themes. Of course, not all the codes or the themes that could be created were used. I had to make a selection among quite a lot of information. The criteria I used for that decision were the relation of the information with my research questions, the coherence of the information in each theme regarding the content and the frequency of the information in the data as I used codes and themes that were discussed from at least five out of the eight participants. The final step was the production of my chapter with results and the presentation of the themes. Before I compose the text for each theme I made sure that I would use in my text at least one extract from each interview in each theme in order to represent all of the interviewees. After this process, four themes and several subthemes were found. Those are a) E.E.-E.S.D. as part of the school reality, b) The annual topic of the school for E.E.-E.S.D, c) Implementation of a cross-curriculum approach, and d) Persistence of students’ interest for the course. Those themes will be presented and discussed in following chapters.
  • 29. 23 Ethical issues I took ethical issues into consideration during the whole research procedure. Bryman (2012) explains that a researcher should respect the participants, insure them about confidentiality of records and identities, share with them all the information that they should know about content and procedure and respect their desire not to answer some questions. Also, he underlines the importance of preventing deception, which means presenting the research as something different to what it is (Bryman, 2012). Prevention for ethical issues Having in mind the ethics above, I composed two documents, an information sheet and a consent form, based on the examples that were presented by Bryman (2012). The information sheet (Appendix, p. 63) was sent by e-mail to the participants that showed interest after reading the e-mail I sent to their Headmaster/Headmistress. It included details regarding the content and the procedure of the research and participants’ role in it. I tried to give enough information so that a teacher could decide if she/he wanted to participate but not too much in order not to affect their future answers during the interviews. In that sheet I also ensured the participants that their identities and records were confidential and that I would make all the actions needed so that no one could identify them in the final result of the research. Finally, I mentioned their rights to skip any question they would like to, leave the research at any stage for any reason without any explanation and take back any information they would have shared with me until then, as well as their right to get informed about the findings of the research. The consent form (Appendix, p. 62) was given at a later stage, when I met each participant for the needs of the interview. Each participant was asked to read and sign it before the realization of the interview. I kept the signed forms and I provided the participants with a copy. By signing it, the participants were confirming that they were informed on crucial issues of the procedure such as the recording of interviews and anonymous publication of extracts as quotes, as well as on their rights mentioned above.
  • 30. 24 Ethical problem Despite the actions to prevent ethical issues, an ethical problem came up. During the process of collecting the data, I had to deal with an ethical dilemma, as a result of my inexperience. During a telephone conversation in order to arrange the place for meeting with a participant, I revealed the name of the school of another participant. After realizing my mistake, I started thinking about the ethical and practical issues of informing the other participant about that incident. Finally, I decided to admit my mistake to the participant. When we had our meeting and before the beginning of the interview, I explained to the participant what had happened, I apologized and I asked if she still wanted to participate in the research. Her answer was positive.
  • 31. 25 CHAPTER 4: RESULTS Summary This chapter presents the results of the thematic analysis conducted on the data. I tracked down four main themes in the answers of the interviewees and those are a) E.E.-E.S.D. as part of the school reality, b) The annual topic of the school for E.E.-E.S.D, c) Implementation of a cross-curriculum approach and d) Persistence of students’ interest for the course. Each of those themes consists of subthemes which will be described below. Quotes4 of the interviews are used in order to support and complete the presentation of the findings. The action plans of the schools have been studied too and here are presented basic comments regarding the content, the similarities and differences between them. Theme 1: E.E.-E.S.D. as part of the school reality The data exposed a common tendency across the participants to express their opinion on nodal issues regarding the structure of the course of E.E.-E.S.D.. Basically, they argued on who should be the responsible teacher for the course, what support is essential for the teacher in charge and how much time in needed for the course. The choice of the teacher in charge for the course Interviews exposed a matter of discussion that assailed the majority of participants and that is the choice of teacher in charge for the course E.E.-E.S.D.. A number of interviewees described a general avoidance to undertake the teaching of the course. Interviewee 7 undertook the course to complete her working hours, even if for her, the course should be taught by the principal teachers: E.E.-E.S.D. occurred due to the need of covering the last 40 minutes of my working time, so which course is 40 minutes? (...) It is the second year I teach the course and last year happened the same, the teachers of sixth grade, the principal teachers, did not want the course. We were discussing who would take it but nobody volunteered to engage with the course, and I got upset and I said ‘I will be responsible for it’. (…) The course should be entrusted to someone 4 The interviews were in Greek and therefore the quotes had to be translated to English. During this procedure there was a high attention to the translation and presentation of the actual meaning of the original sayings.
  • 32. 26 that really wants it or otherwise, we should try to give it to the principal teachers, no matter if he wants or not. (I.7) 5 The teacher described a tense by the principal teachers to avoid undertaking the course of E.E.-E.S.D.. In addition, her own motivation was the completion of her working hours, and E.E.-E.S.D was the only option in terms of time. As she stated in the questionnaire, the teaching of the course was not a personal choice. Also, she believes that in cases where nobody volunteers for the course, it must be entrusted to the principal teacher. Another interesting statement came from Interviewee 6. Even if she belongs to the teachers that undertook the course to complete her working obligations rather than from a personal interest, she supported that the principal teacher has an advantage regarding the teaching of E.E.-E.S.D: (...) I consider the teaching of this course by the principal teacher as a significantly helpful fact. It is rather a course of attitudes than a course of knowledge. Therefore, the most suitable one to achieve cultivation of attitudes best is the teacher of the class. (…) you spend much more time with them; it is you that they consider as responsible for them, the acceptance to whatever you tell them, is bigger than to any other teacher who is visitor. (I.6) According to this participant, a principal teacher has the advantage of affecting the attitudes of students. This fact can help the teaching of E.E.-E.S.D, since, as she said, it is a course of attitudes. Finally, Interviewee 1 enhanced the need of changing the criteria of choosing the teacher in charge for the course: There must be an organization regarding who will teach the course because it is a course of only 40 minutes per week and mostly, the course is entrusted to teachers with only criterion the maintenance of the school schedule. Therefore, we end up entrusting E.E.-E.S.D to teachers who do not have any idea of environmental issues, teachers who do not like E.E.-E.S.D., and teachers who have practical difficulties to teach this course, like me this year, that I go only one day to the school and is very difficult to organize it. (I.1) Based on personal experience, this teacher claimed that in order to complete the time schedule, incompetent teachers can end up teaching the course. He places himself in those teachers as well, since the practical difficulties do not allow him to work as he would like to. Advisory support for the teachers The interviewees mentioned two main resources of support for a teacher who deals with the 5 . For purposes of better understanding, each quote is followed by a code. For example the code I.7, clarifies that the specific quote belongs to Interviewee 7.
  • 33. 27 course and those are: the guide book6 of the course and the seminars organized by the Ministry of Education and Culture (MOEC). The participants were critical about the existent resources and expressed their suggestions. In relation to the guide book, almost all the participants argued that there is a need for a more concrete book with the possibility of diversification and enrichment. Interviewee 2 expressed this opinion via a reference to her circumstances: (...) to have a guide book, to follow a series and maybe to add our own activities of enrichment. Something like this. Because it is very difficult. This year I teach this topic. The next year I will be doing another topic so this means that you have to start again from the beginning. (...) all this work is for 40 minutes of teaching. Here, we do 12 lessons; it is difficult to find material. (I.2) A guide book with the possibility to add things would make the annual preparation easier, argued the Interviewee 2. In addition, in her case, the need for more guidelines seems bigger, since her obligations are multiplied due to the multi-grade7 nature of the classes in her school. Interviewee 5 supported the creation of a more concrete book but at the same time she appeared to be sceptical regarding the degree of particularity of such a book: It would not be bad to have something more concrete, even for the students (…). (...) it is just that the philosophy does not help you to end up in something like this. The philosophy says that you should consider the needs of your school and then decide which your topic will be. That means that you cannot limit yourself to a book. (I.5) That teacher argued that the current philosophy of E.E.-E.S.D. does not leave much space for a concrete guide book since the whole topic of the school should be based on the needs of each school. Also, there was one participant, Interviewee 4, who believes that the current book is helpful enough, even for beginners: They have a book which gives directions (...) it helps. You can give it to someone that will teach it for the first time, that will have this topic for the first time and he will understand more or less towards which direction he should work. (I.4) For this teacher, the guide book, with the twelve suggested topics and the general goals can cover the needs and answer the questions of a teacher regarding the course, even if she/he teaches it for first time. However, this was the only interviewee to support that the current book is fully effective. 6 The current guidebook of E.E.-E.S.D. consists of some general guidelines regarding the procedures related to the course and a list of intended results for each of the twelve topics that are presented as suggestions. 7 The term “Multi-grade” class refers to situations where students of different grades are mixed in one class. That happens in situations where the number of students, usually in small villages, does not support the employment of many teachers.
  • 34. 28 Regarding the seminars about the course of E.E.-E.S.D. organized by the Ministry of Education and Culture, data brought up different opinions, depending on the personal experience of each participant. A number of participants pointed out organizing problems. More specifically, and as Interviewee 1 explained, not all the teachers who teach E.E.-E.S.D. have attended seminars: There are seminars organized, but many times the teachers who participate in them, do not teach the course. They go because otherwise, the schedule of that day (the day of the seminar) should change. (...) when there will be a seminar organized, it is compulsory to send someone from each school. But (he laughs), for example if the seminar is on Wednesday, I will not go because I am at the school only on Thursdays. (…) I have not been to any seminar yet, I have not been asked to go to any seminar yet. (I.1) The Interviewee argued that the criterion for a school to send a teacher to a seminar is practical and not educational. His case is such an example, as he has not been to any seminar yet, even if he is expected to teach the course. However, the interviewees who did not face any organizational problems appeared to be satisfied with the seminars they have participated in. Interviewee 8 was one of them and as he commented, the seminars give the chance to the teachers to exchange ideas and discuss with their colleagues: I have been to a lot of lessons the last two years. Across these seminars, the two of them were sample lessons. So there, you can see the ideas as well, you can discuss with your colleagues who are there, because all of them are teachers of the Environmental Education, I mean they teach the course of Environmental (Education) too, so you can get ideas. (I.8) This teacher referred to the practical seminars he has participated in and claimed that there he can meet with other teachers that also teach the course, discuss all together and share their experiences and practices related to the course. There was only one critical comment regarding the content of the seminars, and that came from the Interviewee 2. As she said, even if she got some advice, she could not apply all of them in her school: (…) it was a sample lesson, it was quite helpful and also regarding the end, the evaluation, about what we do at the end. (…) It was more about giving us some ideas on how we should work with the course… But that does not change the fact that it was an 80 minute sample lesson, because it was in a school that they have 80 minutes, we, we just have 40 minutes, that was 80 minutes so there is a significant difference, even more with 25 students in a bigger school. (I.2) This interviewee pointed out that the content of the seminars referred to schools with 25 students in each class and an 80 minute lesson. In contrast, her school has 27 students in total and 40 minutes for the course. Therefore, she cannot use all the ideas in her class, as she said,
  • 35. 29 due to the differences. The suitability of the time dedicated to the course The presence of the course in the curriculum, in terms of time, appeared to assail the teachers, as all of them mentioned that they would like to have more time for it. Interviewees who teach in grades fifth and sixth, and that means a 40 minutes period per week, give more emphasis on it as a problem. Interviewee 3 claimed that the time dedicated to the E.E.-E.S.D. is too little and is something that should and could change: I think those 40 minutes, since we are speaking about the future because the environment is the future; I think that is too little time. I believe that this course should be taught at least in 80 minutes per week, the minimum. (I.3) For this interviewee, the course appears to be crucial enough for the future, to deserve more time than 40 minutes in the school time schedule. In fact, she suggested using one of the hours being offered for consolidation8 , for the needs of the course of E.E.-E.S.D. Something similar was mentioned by Interviewee 7 who believes that the distribution of time should change for the higher grades: For me, the distribution of time is not correct. For example in small grades it is 80 minutes. You will tell me that for them the time is shared between the courses E.E.-E.S.D. and the course Treatment of Life, ok I can understand it. But with the older, that we have more things to discuss with them and they can be productive, we should have more time, not only 40 minutes per week. For me the time is too little. (I.7) This teacher believes that especially with the older students the teachers should get more time for this course as there are many things to discuss and do with them. However, despite the full agreement of lack of time regarding the course, there were some teachers that mentioned that now environmental education at least exists as a lesson. Interviewee 5 was one of them: There is a lack of time. But the fact that now, at least, there are those 40 minutes per week and some things are emphasized during this time every week, is important, because before, it didn’t exist at all. It was a matter of personal interest if someone would do something similar. (I.5) The teacher characterized the official inclusion of the course in the curriculum as a significant progress even if this means a 40 minutes period per week. However, she would like to have 8 The term “Hour of Consolidation” refers to the last period of each school day which is used at the will of each teacher. The purpose of its existence is to work as spare hour where teachers have the chance to explain again parts of the daily lessons that perhaps where not fully understood by the students.
  • 36. 30 more time as well. In conclusion, data showed that a more detailed book that would still offer the freedom to the teacher to make choices would be welcomed from the majority of participants. They also asked for better organization regarding the seminars since they mentioned that they can be very helpful. Finally, the time given for the course is appreciated by the teachers but it was clear that they all need more. Theme 2: The annual topic of the school for E.E.-E.S.D. When the participants were asked to speak about the annual topic of their school for the course of E.E.-E.S.D., their answers brought up some common lines regarding the decision of the topic, the role of the students in it and the planning of their actions. The influence of circumstances All of the interviewees mentioned the circumstances of the school as the main determinant factor in the decision of the topic. The school of Interviewee 5 for example, chose as topic the litter management and recycle due to the amount of rubbish they noticed in the school: It is very important that the topic will occur from the existent problems of the school. That means that we do not decide suddenly a topic and then ask the students to work on it. (…) it was decided that we had a problem with the management of trash. We are a big school with 400 students, so there is a lot of rubbish and there was a need to start recycling. Therefore, we chose that topic. (I.5) The teacher mentioned that the topic they chose at school is directly related to an actual problem that was noticed in the school. In her opinion, the large number of students is the main cause of that problem. Also, Interviewee 7 mentioned the independence of actions in addition to the circumstances of the school as a determinant factor: If there are problems which we can solve inside the area of the school, we chose those ones, in order not to implicate other services such as the municipality. If there were broken pavements for example, (…) we could not fix it by ourselves, so our topic would not have any progress. (...) We choose something that we can solve easily. We could buy a trash compactor, we did it (…) we could do recycling of paper in the class; we could reduce the use of paper. It is something that depends on us. (I.7)
  • 37. 31 In the case of that teacher, after they point out problems of the school, they try to see which of those problems they could solve by themselves as a school community. Interviewee 3 was the only interviewee that even if she mentioned dependence of the topic on the circumstances of the school, the focus was on its spatial characteristic and not on an existing problem: Since our school belongs to a community in a woodland area, and the surrounding environment is full of pine forests etc., we decided that it is something that could be optimized both by us in the course and by students. They could come closer to the forest, explore it deeper and in a greater extend. So the location of our school was determinant. (I.3) The interviewee explained that they tried to utilize the surrounding environment of the school for the purposes of the school, in order to achieve a connection between the students and the forest next to their school. In addition, another interesting finding was that while the teachers from the urban and semi- urban school focused on the solution of a problem in the area of the school, the 3 teachers of the rural schools added the broader area of the village in the targets for improvement. “The topic was decided considering the needs of the school as well as the needs of the village.” explained Interviewee 2. The role of the students regarding the topic Interviewees' descriptions regarding the procedure of choosing a topic, showed a variation in students' participation in it. The majority of the teachers argued that the students contribute with ideas on the content, after the topic has been decided by the teachers. More specifically, those interviewees mentioned that all the teachers of the school discuss to end up in a topic and then, another meeting is organized between the E.E.-E.S.D. teachers and the Environmental Council of Students9 . The teachers announce the topic and give guidelines to students and the students make suggestions. Interviewee 1 explained: There is a teacher as a responsible and there are a number of students that are chosen to constitute the Environmental Council of the school, together they decide the annual topic. (...) there is a discussion between the teachers, then the teachers decide and then there is another meeting with those students and two-three teachers that are responsible for the course, so that the students can participate in the procedure. (…) After that the topic is decided, they suggest several ideas. (I.1) 9 The Environmental Council of Students is a group of students with one or two representatives from each class of the school. The council is created with the occasion of the course E.E.-E.S.D. Their aim is to represent their classmates during the meetings with the teachers of E.E.-E.S.D.. According to the interviewees of this research, the Environmental Council of Students runs several actions in the schools such as check of the correct use of the
  • 38. 32 According to the interviewee, after the specification of the topic by the teachers, students' opinion is taken into account as they express their ideas via the Environmental Council of students. There was also one participant, Interviewee 7, who mentioned students' participation in the decision of the topic as well, by pointing out problems in the school: Every teacher goes with his students outside and makes a field research 10 in the area of the school or around the school if it is possible. The students are asked to observe and write down a list of problems that they notice. After we make an evaluation of the issues of each problem (…). And at the end I go to the meeting with the teachers and say for example ‘my students suggested this topic for these reasons’ and the other teacher says ‘my students suggested this topic for those reasons’ (…) (I.7) The case of this interviewee differs because as she claimed, the topic is basically suggested by the students, even if the final decision is taken by the teachers. Also, in this case, it appeared that at least at the stage of indication of problems, all the students participate directly and not indirectly via the Environmental Council of students. The method of field research by the students was mentioned by other participants as well, but it was taking place after that the topic was decided. Interviewee 6 made a description: We made observations outside, in the area of the school. Students worked in teams, we separated the yard in four parts and as a team they went around in their square and wrote down whatever was disturbing for them, related to our topic. (I.6) This interviewee belonged to the cases, where the topic was decided clearly by teachers. Afterwards, students could specify the topic in the aspects they thought as more important, via the activity of the field research. The action plan Participants were asked to provide a copy of the action plan of their school. The action plans had several features in common but there were some differences as well. Almost all action plans included themes regarding a) the issues and problems in the school in relation to its location, b) the issue/problem that will be emphasized the current year c) the reasons why that specific issue was chosen, d) the general purpose of the topic, e) the goals for the students f) the subtopics being involved in the chosen topic. In some of them, the theme “Goals for the students” was described with the subthemes of knowledge, skills, attitudes, participation- recycling bins of the school. 10 Field research is an activity where the students go outside the class, usually in the school yard, with a specific purpose: to observe, to collect material or information, etc.
  • 39. 33 action and awareness. Also, some of the action plans had references to expected results regarding the school and the community. In all the cases, the action plan was mentioned as point of reference for a teacher who deals with the course of E.E.-E.S.D. in each school. As Interviewee 5 argued referring to her school: (…) each teacher has a copy of the action plan for purposes of guidance. But other than this, each one has the personal freedom to create his own activities, or change the order of the goals, or choose the way and the methods in use in order to achieve those goals. The point is to cover the goals (…). (...) other than this, the way in which a teacher will reach at that point differs, the student of 1st grade differs from the student of sixth grade. (I.5) Interviewee 5 explained that the action plan has a guiding role. It provides guidelines to each teacher of the school while at the same time it allows diversification in methods and practices. A similar situation was described by all the interviewees. Despite these structural patterns, there were some significant differences that are worth to be commented. To begin with, there were several action plans that consisted of some unique themes in addition to the above. There were a couple of action plans that included concrete activities to be done. Interviewee’s 8 action plan was a notable example as it included 54 brief activities related to the topic “Abatement of waste”. An example of such an activity is the following: “collection of used paper and other material or unused objects, in order to use them in the construction of artistic sculptures, music instruments, theatrical sceneries, curtains, etc.” (Photos 1 and 2). However, Interviewee 8 pointed out that he will not do all of those 54 activities. As he explained, those 54 activities have been included in their action plan in order to be used by other teachers too: From those 54, maybe you can substantiate ten of them; (...) you cannot do all of them. But they are ideas, for someone who will get this action plan; he could do some of them. (...) All of them are related to the topic, your choice depends on which of them both the teacher and the students can substantiate. (…) We send this action plan to the Advisor of Environmental Education 11 , it is not compulsory to send it but we do. It will be multiplied and given to other teachers too. If other teachers do the same, in one-two teachers will have in their hands ideas. (I.8) The teacher appeared to be aware that it is not possible to make all the 54 ideas happen in a year. In his school, they use their action plan as a reference point for their actions but it is something more, as he claimed. According to him, it is also a chance to share ideas and help 11 The Ministry of Education of Cyprus has placed an Advisor of Environmental Education in each province. The Advisor is responsible for the schools of his province. Her/his job is to offer support to the teachers in her/his province and supervise them regarding the teaching of the course E.E.-E.S.D. Her/his role is basically advisory.
  • 40. 34 other teachers who deal with the same topic. Another case of partly unrealistic action plan came with Interviewee 4. A noticeable part of her action plan, was underlying the need of changes such as the construction of a new school even if in her interview she said that: Students cannot change the actions of the Municipality. I mean, the Municipality will not listen to students and make a new school, even if we are in a difficult situation. (…) They cannot affect or change the factors of the Municipality (…) or of the Government to achieve what they want. (I.4) This teacher is convinced that the influence of students is limited when it comes to decisions related to the Municipality or the Government, in their case to the construction of a new school. However, the action plan points out problems that occur from the current situation of the building by referring to them in several of its themes. I also considered as interesting the significant brevity of some action plans. The action plan of Interviewee 6 for example was only one page long, while the rest were six to seven pages and one was three pages. Its content consisted of two themes, the general purpose of the topic and few general goals. Also, this interviewee mentioned a delay in the creation of the action plan: Our discussion about the topic started in the beginning of November. (…) there was a delay because we have to do and plan too many things at the beginning of the year. (…) at the same time there are also the difficulties of the inception of the new school year, (…) after two weeks we had a change in the stuff. All this disruption in the school in combination with other things that came up, didn’t give us the time to take care of Environmental Education. (I.6) As the teacher claimed, there were several technical problems which discouraged the teachers in her school to focus on the course of E.E.-E.S.D. and organize it properly. Interviewee 3 was the only one who did not present an action plan because, as she explained, in her school they did not make one. It should be remembered that this teacher was interviewed about her teaching experience from the course during the previous school year. However through her interview, there are clear references in most of the themes included in the action plans. In conclusion, firstly, all the teachers teaching the course this year had an action plan to present even if there were several differentiations between them, not only in content but in structure and in use of it as well. Also all of them took into account the special characteristics and problems of their school in order to end up with a topic. The decision on the topic however was mainly taken by the teachers in most of the cases.
  • 41. 35 Theme 3: Implementation of a cross-curriculum approach Connecting E.E.-E.S.D. with other courses was one of the topics brought up by the interviewees, either as a reality or as a desire. Data showed that this can be determined by several reasons. Some teachers mentioned the barriers they have, while some others spoke about auspicious factors in their school which promote a cross-curriculum approach. Barriers in implementation A number of participants claimed that even if they would like to follow a cross-curriculum approach, they face several barriers that stop them. For Interviewee 1, cross-curriculum approach is an actual need in the case of E.E.-E.S.D.. Despite that belief, his working conditions do not allow him to contribute to a cross-curriculum approach: It is important in the course of E.E.-E.S.D., since its only 40 minutes and since it can be taught with a cross-curriculum approach, we must work cooperatively. But how possible that is depends from the E.E.-E.S.D. teacher and the principal teachers. In my case, since I am going to the school for just one day, we do not. (...) The existence of cooperation is a matter of circumstances. (I.1) Interviewee 1 supported that the nature of the course, as well as its limited time in the schedule, demand a cross-curriculum approach of it, which requires cooperation. However, as an E.E.-E.S.D. teacher that goes to the school once per week, he does not have the time to cooperate and therefore to support a cross-curriculum approach for the course. Interviewee 5 pointed out the barrier of mentality. She claimed that in her school, there is a preference in keeping the courses separated: For example, when it was asked from each class to create an ecological code 12 (…) there was a colleague that told me ‘you are going to do it in E.E.-E.S.D., aren’t you?’ (…) Our topic as a school was Litter management – recycling, so those who teach E.E.-E.S.D., we undertake it. The philosophy was like that. (…) To work towards a cross-curriculum approach there must be cooperation and will for collaboration. (I.5) According to the teacher, the philosophy of her colleagues does not promote a cross- curriculum approach due to the belief that everything connected with E.E.-E.S.D., should be done during the hour of that course, by the teacher responsible for it. As a result, the teacher argued that the only way to achieve a cross-curriculum approach in her case would be if she was the principal teacher. 12 The ecological code is a list of advices related to behaviour and attitudes towards the environment, basically the environment of the school. The list is created by the students and teachers and it addresses to all of them.
  • 42. 36 The same hypothesis was mentioned by Interviewee 7 as well. She claimed that if she was the principal teacher she could make connections between her courses as the one described in the example bellow: Now we are making a small research regarding how many students bring a lunch box and a bottle. But if I was the principal teacher, I could do something in mathematics, create a graph about it, every day do something fast, I could dedicate just five minutes every day (…). Now in 40, not even 40, in 35 minutes I have to finish what I have planned. But it never finishes. (I.7) The interviewee explained that as a principal teacher, she would have the freedom to “borrow” some time from the other courses under her responsibility, in order to accomplish her goals for E.E.-E.S.D.. The time that she has as an E.E.-E.S.D. teacher is never enough. She also explained the reason that she does not collaborate with other teachers in order to achieve a cross-curriculum approach. In her opinion, collaboration for the purposes of E.E.- E.S.D. does not seem to be something feasible: It is difficult because the colleague has another program in his mind. And it is difficult because the colleague was not present while me and students were discussing and ended up in some things. So how could I burden him to do something that he did not hear? (I.7) Interviewee 7 would not ask a colleague to do a part of her work in another course. As she explained, each teacher has her/his own plans to accomplish and also if a teacher is not present during the planning of an idea, she/he would not be able or keen to help with it. Interviewee 2 cannot follow a cross-curriculum approach either but her reason has to do with the special character of her school. As teachers of multi-grade classes and speaking in terms of time, covering the syllabi of courses for two or three grades at the same time, does not give them the option of following a cross-curriculum approach, as she claimed: Something that normally should happen, but we don’t have the time to do it, theoretically, the course of E.E.-E.S.D. was constructed in addition to all the other courses.(...) We, since we do not have the same time as other schools, due to multi-grade classes, we hardly manage to do the compulsory syllabus. So whatever we do, it is done during the hour of the course. (I.2) This interviewee explained that even if E.E.-E.S.D. is organized in a way to coexist with the other courses, her working conditions do not allow her to entangle the goals of E.E.-E.S.D. with other courses. Cross-curriculum approach in practice As was mentioned before, there were a number of participants in the sample, both principal and E.E.-E.S.D. teachers, who claimed that they have managed to follow a cross-curriculum approach.
  • 43. 37 Interviewee 3, as a principal teacher, described the connection of E.E.-E.S.D. with two kinds of courses, those that she teaches in her class and those that are taught by others in her class. Regarding the first kind of courses, she mentioned the example of mathematics and argued that she was able to adapt it in the needs of the annual environmental topic, the forest: You can do the simplest thing, you can use vocabulary related to the forest in mathematical problems or exercises. So if a problem had to do with Euros for example you can replace Euros with pinecones (…) or you can show a picture of the forest and then the students can create problems based on the picture. (…) I was using this kind of techniques. (I.3) The teacher explained that she chose to combine the content of mathematics with the context of the forest, which was the topic of the course E.E.-E.S.D. by using relative vocabulary or pictures for the exercises. Similar practices were mentioned by all the interviewees that have the role of a principal teacher. Regarding the courses that are taught by other teachers in her class, the interviewee referred to a situation when she used the course “Design and Technology” for the purposes of E.E.-E.S.D.. After a visit in the forest sited behind the school, it was decided to create signposts with environmental messages which would be later placed in the forest. For that purpose, Interviewee 3 asked the help of the teacher responsible for the course of Technology and the signposts were created at its time. As she explained: I had to communicate with the teacher of technology and organize ourselves in order to have enough time to make all the preparations needed (…) we were finding common spare hours, or if I had a free hour when my colleague was teaching in my class, I would visit him for example to see how they work or he would come to my class to see if we have any problem and if he could help with any way. (I.3) The teacher said that they started organizing their action in advance, in order to have enough time and also they were both visiting each other’s classrooms whenever that was possible, in order to stay informed. Another teacher, Interviewee 8, also described the way of working in his school, in terms of cross-curriculum approach. In his case, as the E.E.-E.S.D. teacher, he gives advices and guidelines to the principal teachers: The teacher of the class, come to me and tells me ‘I have this text in the course of Greek. How can I optimize it in order to cover some aspects of Environmental Education too?’ We discuss together some things, he underlines them during his teaching and this is how the lesson is done. Usually, the teachers come and ask me, it’s not me the one to go and tell them do this because I cannot force them. (I.8) Interviewee 8 said that he has a good collaboration with the other teachers, as most of them try to connect their courses with the annual topic. However, he pointed out that he has the role of an advisor, without pressing the teachers to do more than they want.
  • 44. 38 Finally, Interviewee 4 mentioned a different way of trying to connect E.E.-E.S.D. with other courses which are not under her responsibility. In her school they try to make an annual planning from the beginning of the year: There is collaboration between teachers. Teachers that do for example the course of geography or the course of history, they inform us which parts of their syllabus could be connected with E.E.-E.S.D.. (I.4) According to that teacher, all the teachers in her school discuss together in a meeting at the beginning of the year. During this meeting, each teacher is supposed to announce which aspects of the annual topic he could cover via the syllabus of the course or the courses of her/his responsibility. However she also pointed out a weak aspect of this kind of organization towards a cross-curriculum approach. She claimed that in case of a teacher that deals with a course for the first year or in case of a new curriculum, as it happens lately in Cyprus, it is possible that the teacher will not be prepared to present the annual actions required: If a teacher undertakes a course for the first time, he cannot know, especially now that there are changes being made, changes in the curriculums, he cannot know what he will do. He has to read the whole curriculum from the start and teachers usually don’t have the time or maybe they do not have the books from the start of the school year. (…) therefore we might exclude some chapters that normally would have been included or try to catch them up later. (I.4) Interviewee 4 argued that in cases where a teacher is not fully familiar from the beginning with the syllabus of the course or the courses that she/he teaches, the agreement over a concrete cross-curriculum approach can be difficult and deficient. Auspicious factors of Implementation The interviewees above gave their personal perspective regarding the auspicious factors that fostered a cross-curriculum approach of the annual topic. Interviewee’s 3 explanation had two dimensions, a practical and a mental one. Regarding the practical part, the interviewee claimed that the small numbers, both of students and teachers, made a cross-curriculum organization possible: Since it is a small school and there aren’t many teachers, I mean there are seven teachers now or eight, it is not difficult. If it was a big school with many teachers then maybe there would be a problem in coordination and programming. (...) also we speak about small numbers in classes, about 10-12 students so it is easier to coordinate them. (I.3) According to the interviewee, it was easy to communicate and cooperate with her colleagues because there were few comparing with bigger schools. Furthermore, the small number of students per class was enabling the organization and management. Regarding now the mental factors, the interviewee focused on two, the factor of personality and the factor of voluntary
  • 45. 39 contribution to a cross-curriculum approach: It is a matter of persons sometimes. (…) But there should be a good will. If someone wants to take responsibility for something he will accomplish it, if he does not want and he is pressed to do it then it is difficult. In our case the planning was commonly decided. (I.3) The interviewee believed that the personality of the teachers and their willing to devote part of their free time for the work, as well as the fact that all the actions were decided after a common agreement, promoted the cross-curriculum approach. Interviewee 8 had a similar opinion as he claimed that the auspicious factor in his school was the relationship between teachers: In this school, friendship has a very important role. I have been working here for seven years now and we have developed very strong relationships between us. So during a break or while we are drinking our coffee, someone might bring up an idea and we discuss it, that is how we work. (I.8) Interviewee 8 justified the ability to follow a cross-curriculum approach with the friendship that connects him with the other teachers after working together for a long time. In conclusion, there were some teachers in the sample, E.E.-E.S.D. teachers that do not manage to apply a cross-curriculum approach even if they want to. At the same time, there were teachers, both E.E.-E.S.D. and principal teachers that manage to follow a cross curriculum approach to some extent. That difference seems to exist due to the human factor and the interpersonal relationships. Theme 4: Persistence of students’ interest for the course During the interviews, all the participants referred to practices they use in the teaching of the course E.E.-E.S.D.. There was a variety of practices mentioned but here I chose to present the following three: active participation of students, invitations of visitors in the school and outdoor activities. All of the participants mentioned those three practices with the additional assertion that they are effective13 . 13 For the purposes of this research, the word “effective” is used to refer to practices that manage to attract the students and militate their enthusiasm.