SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 20
The Open
Data Delusion Lessons from an open
data journey
Jay Bhalla
@jaybhalla
February 2014
OPEN INSTITUTE
We work every day to build an
open society managed by
informed fact driven citizens
Lessons and challenges have not been
restricted to the developing world
LACK OF COOPERATION AND
COORDINATION
Yankees outfielders confused by defensive substitution / gif
FOCUS ON SUPPLY + DATA
LITERACY
Releasing
data is not
enough
Square peg, round hole | Simon Peg / flickr
BUILDING HUMAN CAPITAL
NYSAT2 | MoreInterpretations / flickr
UNSTRUCTURED HACKATHONS
Code it and
they will
come
MHacks 2012 | Kelly Bracha / flickr
CREATING USEFUL APPLICATIONS
http://donteat.at
DRIVING LEGISLATION
Berlin 1936 | cszar / flickr
Open data
initiatives can
survive when
the right
champions are
in place
INSTITUTIONALISING OPEN DATA
MOVEMENTS
old books... | mariusz kluzniak / flickr
Open data
initiatives
need
legislative
backing
Timely, relevant and proactive disclosure of
data
PROACTIVE DISCLOSURE
VANCOUVER HEALTH AUTHORITY
http://www.inspections.vcha.ca/Main
No API
FRASER HEALTH
http://www.healthspace.ca/fha/food
Can’t
download
data
MEASURING METRICS
Thumbs up | AdWeek / tumblr
INVEST IN MARKETING
Pachube stickers | Rain Rabbit / flickr
COMMUNITY-BASED INITIATIVES
Mailboxes | tanakawho / flickr
GRASSROOTS IMPACT
Get Creative! |JD Hancock / flickr
TAKE AN ITERATIVE APPROACH
1 - 5 iterations | Windell Oskay / flickr
SHAMELESS PLUG
Canadian Open Data Institute
http://opendatainstitute.ca
Jay Bhalla
@jaybhalla
www.openinstitute.com
@Open_Institute
facebook.com/TheOpenInstitute

More Related Content

What's hot

Can We Do It? Yes, We Can! Developing Digitally Capable Libraries
Can We Do It? Yes, We Can! Developing Digitally Capable LibrariesCan We Do It? Yes, We Can! Developing Digitally Capable Libraries
Can We Do It? Yes, We Can! Developing Digitally Capable LibrariesCILIP Ireland
 
Social Innovation Hacktivism
Social Innovation HacktivismSocial Innovation Hacktivism
Social Innovation Hacktivismdan mcquillan
 
Can we do it yes we can: developing digitally capable libraries
Can we do it yes we can: developing digitally capable librariesCan we do it yes we can: developing digitally capable libraries
Can we do it yes we can: developing digitally capable librariesLis Parcell
 
Open Data in Design and Civic Governance
Open Data in Design and Civic GovernanceOpen Data in Design and Civic Governance
Open Data in Design and Civic GovernanceFingal Open Data
 
Knowledge economy urban hub crucible fairfax va
Knowledge economy urban hub crucible fairfax vaKnowledge economy urban hub crucible fairfax va
Knowledge economy urban hub crucible fairfax vaAvi Dey
 
Stakeholder Engagement Sucks
Stakeholder Engagement SucksStakeholder Engagement Sucks
Stakeholder Engagement Sucksdan mcquillan
 
Public Service Media In The Digital Age?
Public Service Media In The Digital Age?Public Service Media In The Digital Age?
Public Service Media In The Digital Age?dan mcquillan
 
Potential and Impact of Open Data in Europe
Potential and Impact of Open Data in EuropePotential and Impact of Open Data in Europe
Potential and Impact of Open Data in EuropeState of the Net
 
Potential and Impact of Open Data in Europe
Potential and Impact of Open Data in EuropePotential and Impact of Open Data in Europe
Potential and Impact of Open Data in EuropeePSI Platform
 
4thfloor tampa
4thfloor tampa4thfloor tampa
4thfloor tampaNate Hill
 
open data and advocacy - eu datahon november 2017
open data and advocacy - eu datahon november 2017open data and advocacy - eu datahon november 2017
open data and advocacy - eu datahon november 2017Peter Wells
 
Open Knowledge Foundation Edinburgh meet-up #3
Open Knowledge Foundation Edinburgh meet-up #3Open Knowledge Foundation Edinburgh meet-up #3
Open Knowledge Foundation Edinburgh meet-up #3Gill Hamilton
 
Spreading Waste Line
Spreading Waste LineSpreading Waste Line
Spreading Waste LineIan Henshaw
 
A Year in Open Data - OGD 2012 Key-note
A Year in Open Data - OGD 2012 Key-noteA Year in Open Data - OGD 2012 Key-note
A Year in Open Data - OGD 2012 Key-noteePSI Platform
 
Presentation final
Presentation finalPresentation final
Presentation finallyonka02
 
American Libraries Live—Libraries and COVID-19: Using 3D Printing to Make Per...
American Libraries Live—Libraries and COVID-19: Using 3D Printing to Make Per...American Libraries Live—Libraries and COVID-19: Using 3D Printing to Make Per...
American Libraries Live—Libraries and COVID-19: Using 3D Printing to Make Per...ALAeLearningSolutions
 
Open Data and Public Space
Open Data and Public SpaceOpen Data and Public Space
Open Data and Public SpaceFingal Open Data
 
OpenStreetMap open data ecosystem between opportunities and legal conundrums
OpenStreetMap open data ecosystem between opportunities and legal conundrumsOpenStreetMap open data ecosystem between opportunities and legal conundrums
OpenStreetMap open data ecosystem between opportunities and legal conundrumsMaurizio Napolitano
 

What's hot (20)

Can We Do It? Yes, We Can! Developing Digitally Capable Libraries
Can We Do It? Yes, We Can! Developing Digitally Capable LibrariesCan We Do It? Yes, We Can! Developing Digitally Capable Libraries
Can We Do It? Yes, We Can! Developing Digitally Capable Libraries
 
Social Innovation Hacktivism
Social Innovation HacktivismSocial Innovation Hacktivism
Social Innovation Hacktivism
 
Can we do it yes we can: developing digitally capable libraries
Can we do it yes we can: developing digitally capable librariesCan we do it yes we can: developing digitally capable libraries
Can we do it yes we can: developing digitally capable libraries
 
Open Data in Design and Civic Governance
Open Data in Design and Civic GovernanceOpen Data in Design and Civic Governance
Open Data in Design and Civic Governance
 
Knowledge economy urban hub crucible fairfax va
Knowledge economy urban hub crucible fairfax vaKnowledge economy urban hub crucible fairfax va
Knowledge economy urban hub crucible fairfax va
 
Stakeholder Engagement Sucks
Stakeholder Engagement SucksStakeholder Engagement Sucks
Stakeholder Engagement Sucks
 
Public Service Media In The Digital Age?
Public Service Media In The Digital Age?Public Service Media In The Digital Age?
Public Service Media In The Digital Age?
 
Potential and Impact of Open Data in Europe
Potential and Impact of Open Data in EuropePotential and Impact of Open Data in Europe
Potential and Impact of Open Data in Europe
 
Potential and Impact of Open Data in Europe
Potential and Impact of Open Data in EuropePotential and Impact of Open Data in Europe
Potential and Impact of Open Data in Europe
 
4thfloor tampa
4thfloor tampa4thfloor tampa
4thfloor tampa
 
open data and advocacy - eu datahon november 2017
open data and advocacy - eu datahon november 2017open data and advocacy - eu datahon november 2017
open data and advocacy - eu datahon november 2017
 
Evidence informed activism & data-based deliberations
Evidence informed activism & data-based deliberationsEvidence informed activism & data-based deliberations
Evidence informed activism & data-based deliberations
 
Open Knowledge Foundation Edinburgh meet-up #3
Open Knowledge Foundation Edinburgh meet-up #3Open Knowledge Foundation Edinburgh meet-up #3
Open Knowledge Foundation Edinburgh meet-up #3
 
Spreading Waste Line
Spreading Waste LineSpreading Waste Line
Spreading Waste Line
 
Digital Activism examples
Digital Activism examplesDigital Activism examples
Digital Activism examples
 
A Year in Open Data - OGD 2012 Key-note
A Year in Open Data - OGD 2012 Key-noteA Year in Open Data - OGD 2012 Key-note
A Year in Open Data - OGD 2012 Key-note
 
Presentation final
Presentation finalPresentation final
Presentation final
 
American Libraries Live—Libraries and COVID-19: Using 3D Printing to Make Per...
American Libraries Live—Libraries and COVID-19: Using 3D Printing to Make Per...American Libraries Live—Libraries and COVID-19: Using 3D Printing to Make Per...
American Libraries Live—Libraries and COVID-19: Using 3D Printing to Make Per...
 
Open Data and Public Space
Open Data and Public SpaceOpen Data and Public Space
Open Data and Public Space
 
OpenStreetMap open data ecosystem between opportunities and legal conundrums
OpenStreetMap open data ecosystem between opportunities and legal conundrumsOpenStreetMap open data ecosystem between opportunities and legal conundrums
OpenStreetMap open data ecosystem between opportunities and legal conundrums
 

Similar to The Open Data Delusion

Social media eimear mcnally
Social media eimear mcnallySocial media eimear mcnally
Social media eimear mcnallyMakeHandstands
 
Civil Resistance 2.0: 198 Methods Upgraded
Civil Resistance 2.0: 198 Methods UpgradedCivil Resistance 2.0: 198 Methods Upgraded
Civil Resistance 2.0: 198 Methods UpgradedMer Joyce
 
Web 2.0 and a Changing World
Web 2.0 and a Changing WorldWeb 2.0 and a Changing World
Web 2.0 and a Changing WorldMichael Coghlan
 
Film 260 Flipbook assignment - Clicktivism
Film 260 Flipbook assignment - ClicktivismFilm 260 Flipbook assignment - Clicktivism
Film 260 Flipbook assignment - ClicktivismViana Lam
 
Film 260 Flipbook Assignment - Clicktivism
Film 260 Flipbook Assignment - ClicktivismFilm 260 Flipbook Assignment - Clicktivism
Film 260 Flipbook Assignment - ClicktivismViana Lam
 
Digital identities & citizenship: Leading in the Open
Digital identities & citizenship: Leading in the OpenDigital identities & citizenship: Leading in the Open
Digital identities & citizenship: Leading in the OpenBonnie Stewart
 
Open Data Durban Presentation - July, 2015
Open Data Durban Presentation - July, 2015Open Data Durban Presentation - July, 2015
Open Data Durban Presentation - July, 2015Code for South Africa
 
Code for Africa - Building Demand-driven + Citizen-focused Open Data Ecosystems
Code for Africa - Building Demand-driven + Citizen-focused Open Data EcosystemsCode for Africa - Building Demand-driven + Citizen-focused Open Data Ecosystems
Code for Africa - Building Demand-driven + Citizen-focused Open Data EcosystemsJustin Arenstein
 
20120904 open for change - kncv
20120904 open for change - kncv20120904 open for change - kncv
20120904 open for change - kncvpelleaardema
 
Open Science - overview part 2: open data
Open Science - overview part 2: open dataOpen Science - overview part 2: open data
Open Science - overview part 2: open dataElena Giglia
 
Against educational technology in the neoliberal University
Against educational technology in the neoliberal UniversityAgainst educational technology in the neoliberal University
Against educational technology in the neoliberal UniversityRichard Hall
 
Social Conscience
Social ConscienceSocial Conscience
Social ConscienceErin Labrie
 
The Digital Humanitarian Moment: New Practices, Knowledge Politics, and Phila...
The Digital Humanitarian Moment: New Practices, Knowledge Politics, and Phila...The Digital Humanitarian Moment: New Practices, Knowledge Politics, and Phila...
The Digital Humanitarian Moment: New Practices, Knowledge Politics, and Phila...Ryan Burns
 
Non-profits and social media: the nows and nexts
Non-profits and social media: the nows and nextsNon-profits and social media: the nows and nexts
Non-profits and social media: the nows and nextsMax St John
 
Day 2: Openness: making use of open data, Mr. Peter Reichstädter, CIO, Parlia...
Day 2: Openness: making use of open data, Mr. Peter Reichstädter, CIO, Parlia...Day 2: Openness: making use of open data, Mr. Peter Reichstädter, CIO, Parlia...
Day 2: Openness: making use of open data, Mr. Peter Reichstädter, CIO, Parlia...wepc2016
 
Rob Leckie Flip Book
Rob Leckie Flip BookRob Leckie Flip Book
Rob Leckie Flip BookRob Leckie
 
Offline Activism - How successful activism facilitate social media
Offline Activism - How successful activism facilitate social mediaOffline Activism - How successful activism facilitate social media
Offline Activism - How successful activism facilitate social mediaWilson Fung
 
Film 260 Flip Book
Film 260 Flip BookFilm 260 Flip Book
Film 260 Flip BookRob Leckie
 

Similar to The Open Data Delusion (20)

Social media eimear mcnally
Social media eimear mcnallySocial media eimear mcnally
Social media eimear mcnally
 
Civil Resistance 2.0: 198 Methods Upgraded
Civil Resistance 2.0: 198 Methods UpgradedCivil Resistance 2.0: 198 Methods Upgraded
Civil Resistance 2.0: 198 Methods Upgraded
 
Web 2.0 and a Changing World
Web 2.0 and a Changing WorldWeb 2.0 and a Changing World
Web 2.0 and a Changing World
 
Pier webinar
Pier webinarPier webinar
Pier webinar
 
Film 260 Flipbook assignment - Clicktivism
Film 260 Flipbook assignment - ClicktivismFilm 260 Flipbook assignment - Clicktivism
Film 260 Flipbook assignment - Clicktivism
 
Film 260 Flipbook Assignment - Clicktivism
Film 260 Flipbook Assignment - ClicktivismFilm 260 Flipbook Assignment - Clicktivism
Film 260 Flipbook Assignment - Clicktivism
 
Digital identities & citizenship: Leading in the Open
Digital identities & citizenship: Leading in the OpenDigital identities & citizenship: Leading in the Open
Digital identities & citizenship: Leading in the Open
 
Open Data Durban Presentation - July, 2015
Open Data Durban Presentation - July, 2015Open Data Durban Presentation - July, 2015
Open Data Durban Presentation - July, 2015
 
Code for Africa - Building Demand-driven + Citizen-focused Open Data Ecosystems
Code for Africa - Building Demand-driven + Citizen-focused Open Data EcosystemsCode for Africa - Building Demand-driven + Citizen-focused Open Data Ecosystems
Code for Africa - Building Demand-driven + Citizen-focused Open Data Ecosystems
 
20120904 open for change - kncv
20120904 open for change - kncv20120904 open for change - kncv
20120904 open for change - kncv
 
Open Science - overview part 2: open data
Open Science - overview part 2: open dataOpen Science - overview part 2: open data
Open Science - overview part 2: open data
 
Against educational technology in the neoliberal University
Against educational technology in the neoliberal UniversityAgainst educational technology in the neoliberal University
Against educational technology in the neoliberal University
 
Social Conscience
Social ConscienceSocial Conscience
Social Conscience
 
Platform Cooperativism
Platform CooperativismPlatform Cooperativism
Platform Cooperativism
 
The Digital Humanitarian Moment: New Practices, Knowledge Politics, and Phila...
The Digital Humanitarian Moment: New Practices, Knowledge Politics, and Phila...The Digital Humanitarian Moment: New Practices, Knowledge Politics, and Phila...
The Digital Humanitarian Moment: New Practices, Knowledge Politics, and Phila...
 
Non-profits and social media: the nows and nexts
Non-profits and social media: the nows and nextsNon-profits and social media: the nows and nexts
Non-profits and social media: the nows and nexts
 
Day 2: Openness: making use of open data, Mr. Peter Reichstädter, CIO, Parlia...
Day 2: Openness: making use of open data, Mr. Peter Reichstädter, CIO, Parlia...Day 2: Openness: making use of open data, Mr. Peter Reichstädter, CIO, Parlia...
Day 2: Openness: making use of open data, Mr. Peter Reichstädter, CIO, Parlia...
 
Rob Leckie Flip Book
Rob Leckie Flip BookRob Leckie Flip Book
Rob Leckie Flip Book
 
Offline Activism - How successful activism facilitate social media
Offline Activism - How successful activism facilitate social mediaOffline Activism - How successful activism facilitate social media
Offline Activism - How successful activism facilitate social media
 
Film 260 Flip Book
Film 260 Flip BookFilm 260 Flip Book
Film 260 Flip Book
 

The Open Data Delusion