SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 10
1
Black swans and white doves
In the past week European and global politics, strong US growth data, mixed global macro
numbers and eurozone, Chinese and Indian central bank policy have eclipsed Trump-
mania.
What is perhaps more remarkable is markets’ reasonably benign, “risk-on” reaction, bar
the euro’s sell-off in the wake of today’s ECB policy meeting.
One interpretation is that markets have become complacent to the risks presented by
President Trump’s constellation of pseudo-policies, surging nationalism in Europe, the
UK’s uncertain economic future and continued capital outflows from China.
I have a somewhat different take, namely that markets are rightly discounting some of the
more extreme and perverse scenarios, including:
1. Protectionist US policies coupled with higher US yields and a strong dollar
collapsing tepid emerging market, and eventually global, economic growth;
2. The “no” vote in the Italian referendum leading to the economic collapse of the
European Union’s third largest economy;
3. Surging European nationalism culminating in the collapse of the eurozone and/or
European Union;
4. The British government opting to sacrifice growth in exchange for a hard version of
Brexit and;
5. Capital outflows from China ultimately forcing policy-makers into accepting a
Renminbi collapse and shocking a corporate sector with significant dollar-debt.
Global news, data and events have eclipsed Trump-mania in past week
Donald Trump has enjoyed a near-monopoly on news headlines since being elected President a month
ago. But in the past week European politics, the surprise resignation of New Zealand Prime Minister John
Key and Mexican central bank governor Agustín Carstens – both highly regarded, strong US growth data,
mixed global macro numbers and eurozone, Chinese and Indian central bank policy, have for now eclipsed
Trump-mania (see Figure 9).
What is perhaps more remarkable is markets’ reasonably benign, “risk-on” reaction, bar the euro’s sell-off
in the wake of today’s ECB policy meeting. Emerging market currencies, which had stabilised against the
dollar in late-November, have appreciated in the past week (see Figure 1), global yields have stabilised,
global equities are within touching distance of a two-month high and European markets have on the whole
taken Italy’s “no” referendum result in their stride.
2
Figure 1: Emerging market currencies – off the
floor
Figure 2: Global manufacturing PMI points to
global GDP growth of 3% yoy or more in Q4 2016
Source: investing.com, BIS Source: IMF, national statistics offices
One interpretation is that markets have become complacent to the risks presented by President Trump’s
constellation of pseudo-policies, surging nationalism in Europe, the UK’s uncertain economic future and
continued capital outflows from China which the media has focused on intensively. I have a somewhat
different take, namely that markets are rightly discounting some of the more extreme and perverse
scenarios, including:
1. Protectionist US policies coupled with higher US yields and a strong dollar collapsing tepid
emerging market, and eventually global, economic growth;
2. The “no” vote in the Italian referendum leading to the economic collapse of the European Union’s
third largest economy;
3. Surging European nationalism culminating in the collapse of the eurozone and/or European Union;
4. The British government opting to sacrifice growth in exchange for a hard version of Brexit and;
5. Capital outflows from China ultimately forcing policy-makers into accepting a Renminbi collapse,
which would shock a corporate sector with significant dollar-debt and jilt emerging market asset
prices and global risk appetite (a de-facto repeat of August 2015).
I will explore the first three themes in this research note and return to themes 4 and 5 in my forthcoming
pieces.
64
65
66
67
68
69
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
Aug 16 Sep 16 Oct 16 Nov 16 Dec 16
Including CNY, left scale
Excluding CNY
GDP-weighted basket of Emerging Market
currencies vs USD (23 April 2010 = 100)
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
2012Q4 2013Q4 2014Q4 2015Q4 2016Q4
Global manufacturing PMI, left scale
Global real GDP, % year-on-year
(IMF methodology)
3
1. Renewed fears of collapse in global economic growth once again overdone
In the past couple of years I have played down the risk of an imminent collapse in global economic growth,
pointing to the reflationary impact of years of monetary easing by the world’s major central banks (see The
global growth story – cause for concern, not panic, 17 December 2014). And indeed global GDP growth
bottomed out in H1 2016 at around 2.8% year-on-year and rebounded to around 2.9% yoy in Q3 2016,
broadly in line with my forecast (see Global central bank easing nearing important inflexion point, 16
September 2016).
Moreover, the latest indicators, including the up-tick in global manufacturing PMI to 52.0 in October-
November from 50.9 in Q3, suggest that global GDP growth may hit or even slightly exceed 3.0% yoy in Q4
2016 (see Figure 2), again broadly line with my expectations (see Be careful what you wish for, 1
November 2016).
Modest rebound in global GDP growth but still some (different) ammunition
This pace of growth is still modest compared to average GDP growth of 3.6% per annum in the past
decade. Moreover, the foundations of global growth could be compromised if, as I expect, developed
central banks refrain from cutting policy rates further and if nationalist and protectionist policies take hold in
the US and globally. However, I think there is a tendency to over-state this dual risk to global growth.
First, bar the US Federal Reserve, developed central banks are unlikely to start tightening monetary policy
any time soon. The ECB’s decision today – a nine-month extension to its QE program until December 2017
with monthly bond purchases of €60bn – is a prime example of a very dovish tapering of central bank
monetary policy. Ultimately the ECB has committed to another €540bn of bond purchases, rather than the
€480bn which analysts had expected (a six-month extension with monthly purchases unchanged at €80bn).
Second, while the room for developed central banks to cut policy rates further and/or extend QE programs
may be limited, a number of emerging central banks will next year likely revisit the possibility of rate cuts.
The Reserve Bank of India left its policy rate unchanged at 6.25% on 7th
December, contrary to analyst
expectation of a 25bp cut. Its decision was in line with my view that “the RBI may stay on hold until market
conditions stabilise" (see Fast and Furious - Market drift, 15 November 2016) but I still see scope for further
rate cuts in India and Indonesia, amongst others, given still high real central bank policy rates.
Third, there is mounting evidence that governments in both developed and emerging economies are willing
and able to loosen fiscal policy in a bid to compensate for the diminishing returns from monetary policy
stimulus. US President Trump has committed to a significant increase in infrastructural spending and
Chinese fixed investment growth, which had slowed over the summer, has picked up in recent months (see
Figure 3). British Chancellor Philip Hammond announced in his mid-year October budget a £14.2bn
increase in capital spending over five years, focussing on science, innovation, digital infrastructure, housing
and transport (see EM currencies, Fed, French elections and UK reflation “lite”, 25 November 2016).
4
Figure 3: Chinese new loans and fixed investment
growth has picked up in recent months
Figure 4: Global trade has been flat-lining year-to-
date
Source: PBoC Source: CPB World Trade Monitor
Trump protectionism – Bark worst than bite
US President Trump’s penchant for protectionist policies and dismantling of international trade agreements
alongside a stronger dollar and rising US yields have understandably fuelled concerns about already
modest growth in emerging markets saddled with dollar-denominated debt. GDP growth remains lacklustre
in some of the largest emerging economies, including Brazil, Russia and South Africa. Moreover, a number
of Non-Japan Asian economies, including Singapore, Thailand and Taiwan, are experiencing a growth
slowdown (see EM currencies, Fed, French elections and UK reflation “lite”, 25 November 2016). The
erection of US trade barriers would undoubtedly act as a headwind to these open economies.
Higher US tariffs and protectionist barriers may eventually, at the margin, stimulate the beleaguered US
manufacturing sector. But there would also likely be a clear cost to the US, at least in the near and
medium-term, and for that reason I ultimately expect Trump’s bark to be worst than his bite.
Greater tariffs would increase the cost of US imports of goods, which in 2015 amounted to $2.3trn or 13%
of GDP, given the difficulty of substituting imported goods for domestically-produced goods in the short-run
(the UK’s recent experience is telling – despite Sterling’s collapse in the past year, the trade deficit on
goods and services has actually widened due to the increase in the value of imports outstripping that of
exports). At the same time it would be naïve to expect the United States’ trading partners not to retaliate
with protectionist measures of their own, putting a brake on US exports worth 8.5% of GDP. The net result
is that global trade, which has flat-lined in the past year according to the CPB (see Figure 4), would likely
go backwards and act as a drag on global growth.
So the price the US would likely have to be willing to pay is more expensive and/or weaker imports, higher
imported inflation and/or weaker domestic consumption, less competitive exports and potentially weaker
global demand for US goods – a tough sell to a consumer brought up on reasonably cheap imports.
6
8
10
12
14
16
18
-30
-20
-10
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
Jun-14 Jan-15 Aug-15 Mar-16 Oct-16
New bank loans (left scale)
Fixed invesment
China - YoY % change in 3-month moving
102
104
106
108
110
112
114
116
118
Jan-12 Jan-13 Jan-14 Jan-15 Jan-16
World trade
Volumes, seasonally adjusted (2010=100)
5
2. Italian referendum “no” vote – an Italian challenge, not a European disaster
Italian President Matteo Renzi officially tendered his resignation yesterday in the wake of Sunday’s
referendum result but European markets continue to be orderly. Specifically, the euro appreciated versus
the dollar and in nominal effective exchange rate terms in the days following the referendum (see Figure 5),
Italian government bond yields have fallen across the maturity curve (see Figure 6) and the share price of
Italian banks has surged (albeit from historically depressed levels).
Figure 5: Euro stronger post Italian “no”
referendum but losing ground post ECB meeting
Figure 6: Italian yields have tightened versus
bunds
Source: investing.com, ECB Source: investing.com
This is broadly in line with my expectation that “The worst-case-scenario advanced centres on reformist
Prime Minister Renzi’s resignation, the rise to power of the euro-sceptic Five Star Movement (M5S), a jump
in Italian bond yields, the fragile banking sector and economy’s collapse and Italy’s eventual exit from the
eurozone and EU. But the more likely political, financial and economic outcome from a “no” vote is perhaps
less dramatic, in my view […].” (see Renzi referendum frenzy – storm in a broken tea cup, 2 December
2016).
Prime Minister Renzi’s resignation may well usher in a less reform-minded technocratic government, led by
a senior member of Renzi’s ruling Democratic Party, and convince President Mattarella to bring forward to
next year general elections currently pencilled in for May 2018. The populist Five Star Movement (M5S),
led by Beppe Grillo, is currently enjoying 30% support in opinion polls. In the event of early elections it
would likely increase its number of seats in the lower house of parliament from 109, particularly if current
electoral rules remain in place. But the path to the top for M5S and Beppe Grillo may not be as
straightforward as currently assumed, with the Democratic Party still likely to be the largest party in the 630-
seat Chamber of Deputies.
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
98.0
98.5
99.0
99.5
100.0
100.5
101.0
101.5
102.0
Aug 16 Sep 16 Oct 16 Nov 16 Dec 16
Euro Nominal Effective
Exchange Rate
EURUSD (right scale)
Euro indices (23 April 2010 = 100)
40
60
80
100
120
140
160
180
2yr 5yr 10yr Average
01-Dec-16
08-Dec-16
Italy-German government bond yield spread
(basis points)
6
The Italian banking sector, riddled with bad-loans and planning a recapitalisation of its balance-sheet, can
ill afford the negative press a “no” vote brings. But both Italian and eurozone policy-makers have a strong
incentive to shore up Italian banks and the economy, even if posturing may precede an eventual solution.
Finally, while the future of the eurozone and EU has been written off many times, I don’t envisage Italy
being the trigger for a break-up of either.
3. Rising nationalism in Europe is wake-up call, not a revolution
Only tell time will tell whether and how fast nationalist parties in Western Europe rise to the upper echelons
of power, but I would argue that there is currently a tendency to over-estimate their reach and certainly their
ability to dismantle the eurozone and/or EU. Put differently, by end-2018, the political landscape in West
Europe may not have changed as dramatically as commentators anticipate, with the traditional old guard
still largely in place, including in Germany, France, Sweden and Austria.
European nationalism riding a powerful wave
There is little doubt that nationalism and populist parties have been in the ascendancy in Western Europe
in recent years1
. They have performed well in EU Parliamentary elections, in regional elections (e.g. Front
National in France) and State elections (e.g. Alternative for Germany) and their ratings are going up in
opinion polls. In Greece, where the economic dislocation has been the greatest, the Coalition of the Radical
Left (Syriza) is already in power (see Figure 7). In Finland, the Finnish Party is a member of a three-party
ruling coalition and in Denmark the Danish People's Party officially supports the three-party coalition which
gives it a degree of indirect influence.
Left-wing and right-wing nationalist parties are more effectively channelling popular discontent against the
political and status quo and increasingly influencing the direction of domestic policy. As a result, traditional
centrist or right-leaning parties have had little choice but to take this message on board in order to remain
politically relevant and increase their chances of re-election. For example, the ruling Conservative Party in
the UK has partly assimilated the anti-immigration rhetoric which is a cornerstone of the nationalist UK
Independence Party (UKIP). The Republican candidate for next year’s French presidential elections,
François Fillon, has traditionally adopted a conservative social and economic stance but has more recently
incorporated a more nationalist bias. Even German Chancellor Merkel has had to backtrack on her pledge
to allow up to one million immigrants per annum into Germany.
Moreover, Trump's victory in the November US presidential elections and the British electorate’s vote in
June in favour of the UK leaving the EU have clearly reinvigorated nationalist parties and their belief that
they can tap voters which have historically supported more traditional parties and politicians.
1 Admittedly the characteristics which define a party as nationalist and/or populist and left-wing or right-wing are
somewhat subjective, with some parties (e.g. Five Star Movement in Italy) rejecting such labelling.
7
Figure 7: Nationalist parties in Western Europe – current state of play
Source: National parliaments; Note: Nationalist parties in central and EasternEurope and in a number of smaller West
European countries (including Belgium) are excluded. Some of the smaller nationalist parties are also excluded.
Country % of EU
GDP
Nationalist
Party
Bias Leader Current seats in lower
house of parliament
Next parliamentary
elections
Presidency Note
Germany 20.4 Alternative for
Germany
Right-wing Frauke Petry &
Jörg Meuthen
No seats in 630-seat
Bundestag but represented in
10 of the 16 German state
parliaments.
Not applicable
National
Democratic Party
of Germany
Right-wing Frank Franz No seats in Bundestag or
state parliaments
UK 15.5 United Kingdom
Independence
Party (UKIP)
Right-wing 1 out of 650 seats (0.15%) in
House of Commons
No later than May 2020.
First-past-the-post
electoral system likely to
keep number of UKIP
seats very low
Not applicable
France 14.5 Front National Right-wing Marine Le Pen 2 out of 577 seats (0.35%) in
Assemblée Nationale
June 2017, over two
rounds. Front National
party expected to make
sizeable gains from 2
seats it currently holds
Le Pen very unlikely to
become President in
April-May elections.
Italy 10.8 Five Star
Movement (M5S)
Populist Beppe Grillo 109 out of 630 seats (17.3%)
in Chamber of Deputies
Elections due in
January 2022
Lega Nord Regionalist Matteo Salvini 18 out of 630 seats (2.9%)
Brothers of Italy Nationalist /
conservatism
Giorgia Meloni 9 out of 630 seats (1.4%)
Spain 7.3 Podemos Left-wing Pablo Iglesias Podemos, part of a left-wing
alliance, has 67 of 350 seats
(19.1%) in Congress of
Deputies
No later than 26 July
2020
Not applicable
Netherlands 4.5 Freedom Party Right-wing Geert Wilders 12 out of 150 seats (8%) in
House of Representatives
15 March 2017. Based
on latest polls Freedom
Party would win 33 seats
to become largest party
and Wilders prime
minister
Not applicable
Sweden 3.0 Swedish
Democrats
Right-wing Mattias
Karlsson
48 out of 349 seats (13.8%)
in Riksdag
No later than 9 Sept
2018. SD currently
polling third with around
20% which under
proportional
representation system
would give it about 70
seats.
Not applicable Unicameral
legislature (no
upper house)
Austria 2.3 Freedom Party Right-wing Norbert Hofer 40 out of 183 seats (21.9%)
in National Council
No later than Oct 2018 Hofer lost to
independent A. Van
der Bellen in
presidential elections
on 4 Dec 2016
Norway 2.2 Democrats in
Norway
Right-wing Vidar Kleppe No seats in 169-seat Storting 11-Sep-17 Not applicable
Denmark 1.8 Danish People's
Party
Right-wing 37 out of 179 seats (20.7%)
in Folketing. Party officially
supports the three-party
ruling coalition
No later than 17 June
2019
Not applicable Unicameral
legislature (no
upper house)
Finland 1.4 Finns Party Conservative/
populist
Timo Soini 37 out of 200 seats (18.5%)
in Eduskunta. Member of
three-party ruling coalition
April 2019 Sauli Niinistö Unicameral
legislature (no
upper house)
Portugal 1.2 National
Renovator Party
Right-wing José Pinto
Coelho
No seats in 230-seat
Assembly of the Republic
No later than 13 Oct
2019
Marcelo Rebelo de
Sousa
Greece 1.1 Coalition of the
Radical Left
(Syriza)
Left-wing Alexis Tsipras
(Prime
Minister)
144 of 300 seats (48%) in
Hellenic Parliament
No later than 20 Oct
2019
Prokopis Pavlopoulos,
mostly ceremonial role
Golden Dawn Right-wing Nikolaos
Michaloliakos
18 of 300 seats (6%)
No later than 23 May
2018. Possibility of
President Mattarella
calling early elections.
Unicameral
legislature (no
upper house).
Between 27 Aug and 22
Oct 2017. AfG expected
to clear 5% threshold
and gain a handful of
seats
8
Influence is not the same as true power
But, beyond Greece and Finland, which account for only 2.5% of the European Union’s GDP, nationalist
parties in Western Europe are still in opposition and often have only a small share of parliamentary seats
(see Figure 8). Ultimately they will only be able to shape the future of their countries and potentially the
eurozone and/or EU if they have true power, by holding a parliamentary majority, the presidency or both.
Even Syriza is seven seats short of a parliamentary majority while the Finnish Party only has 37 out of 200
seats in the Eduskunta. In other West European countries, no nationalist party currently has more than
22% of the seats in their lower houses of parliament. In Germany, UK and France, which in aggregate
account for half of the EU’s GDP – nationalist parties currently have only 3 seats out of 1,857 in the three
lower houses of parliament. In Germany and Sweden, nationalist parties are still very much fringe political
forces with no state-level representation and only modest regional-level representation. Moreover, none of
the nationalist parties in Western Europe currently occupy the presidency. The Austrian Freedom Party’s
candidate, Norbert Hofer, got close but lost last weekend’s presidential elections.
Figure 8: Majority of West European nationalist parties only have modest number of seats in parliament
Source: National parliaments
Note: Nationalist parties in central and EasternEurope and in a number of smaller West European countries (including
Belgium) are excluded. Some of the smaller nationalist parties are also excluded. * NDP: National Democratic Party of
Germany; ** National Renovator Party; *** Finns Party member of 3-party ruling coalition; **** Syriza is ruling party.
0
10
20
30
40
50
60 Nationalist parties - Current share of seats in lower house of parliament (%)
(red denotes party in power)
9
The seemingly broad-based assumption is that these parties will ultimately gain power and lead the
dissolution of the eurozone and/or the European Union. Nationalist parties will admittedly in all likelihood
increase their number of seats at elections for the lower houses of parliament in 2017-2018 in the
Netherlands, France, Germany, Italy, Sweden and Austria.
Nationalist parties will grow stronger but may struggle to become major political forces
However, based on recent polls, these parties, with the exception of the Freedom Party in Austria and
potentially the Five Star Movement in Italy, are very unlikely to win the largest number of seats let alone
secure parliamentary majorities. For example, Alternative for Germany is a minor political force and while
its anti-immigration policies are starting to resonate, it does not present a credible challenge to the
incumbent CDU-CSU coalition and Chancellor Merkel. At best, some of these European nationalist parties
may govern as part of broader coalitions and thus have to potentially dilute their more extreme policies.
There are number of reasons why these nationalist parties may struggle to become the major political
force. First, in many countries the electoral voting systems for the lower houses of parliament include
thresholds and multiple rounds of voting which work against these smaller parties securing a significant
number of seats.
Second, many of these smaller nationalist parties still do not have the political infrastructure in place at a
national level, financing or depth of personnel to effectively challenge the bigger parties. The messy and
reputation-sapping election of the relatively unknown Paul Nuttall as UKIP leader, following Nigel Farage’s
recent resignation, is a point in hand.
Third, voters are clearly rebelling against well-entrenched political players but may not always have fresh
faces to elect. In the US they elected an untested businessman with no political experience as President
and in Italy the increasingly popular leader of M5S, Beppe Grillo, is a former comedian. However, in France
for example, the two candidates most likely to compete in the second round of the French Presidential
elections next May are François Fillon – the Republican’s candidate and a former Prime Minister – and
Marine Le Pen who joined the Front National 30 years ago. They are both old-school politicians who do not
present a true break with the past.
Fourth, traditional centrist and centre-right parties are adapting to the new political, social and economic
realities which they face and are unlikely to go down without a fight. They will have also learnt valuable
lessons in the past 18 months, including the risk of calling a referendum. The demise of British Prime
Minister Cameron and Italian Prime Minister Renzi following unsuccessful referendums will likely have
made other EU leaders fearful of going down a similar route or of calling early elections. In particular, the
ruling Conservative Party’s loss in the recent Richmond by-election has likely reduced the probability of
Prime Minister Theresa May pushing for general elections, due in 2020, to be brought forward.
Finally, while electorates are clearly using their votes to express their dissatisfaction with the economic and
political status quo, there are still lines they seem unwilling to cross – namely the appointment of extreme-
right candidates to the highest echelons of power (the recent Austrian presidential election is a good
example). Europe’s history arguably acts as stark reminder of the implications of electing a far-right leader.
10
Similarly, leaders of nationalist parties are still very unlikely to win presidential elections. Specifically, Front
National leader Marine Le Pen would most likely lose a head-to-head vote against François Fillon in the
French presidential elections, assuming she even made it to the second round. As I argued in EM
currencies, Fed, French elections and UK reflation “lite” (25 November 2016) it is probably too early to rule
out the winner of the Socialist Party primaries, most likely Prime Minister Manuel Valls, making it to the
second round of the elections ahead of Le Pen. While the Socialist Party is clearly in disarray, Valls is more
popular than President Hollande who ruled himself out as a candidate for the presidential elections.
Figure 9: Focus has shifted from Trump to European politics, global data and central bank policy decisions
Source: National parliaments and statistical offices, Markit,European Central Bank, Reserve Bank of India
01-Dec-2016 Global Global manufacturing PMI Inches higher to 52.1 from 52.0 in October
01-Dec-2016 US November manufacturing ISM Jumps to 52.3 from 51.9 in October
01-Dec-2016 Mexico
01-Dec-2017 France
02-Dec-2016 US November labour market data Unemployment rate falls to 4.6% from 4.9% in October and
non-farm payrolls increase by 178,000
04-Dec-2017 Italy Constitutional referendum Victory of "no" note, Matteo Renzi announces resignation
04-Dec-2017 Austria Re-run of second (and final)
round of presidential elections
Freedom Party of Austria candidate Norbert Hofer loses to
Independent/Green Party candidate Alexander Van der
Bellen.
05-Dec-2016 Global November composite PMI Unchanged at 53.3
05-Dec-2016 NZ
05-Dec-2016 US November non-manufacturing
ISM
Jumps to 57.2 from 54.8 in October
5-8 Dec 2016 UK
07-Dec-2016 India Reserve Bank of India (RBI)
policy meeting
RBI leaves policy rate unchanged at 6.25%, contrary to
analyst expectations but in line with my forecast.
07-Dec-2016 Australia Q3 2016 GDP data GDP contracts 0.5% quarter-on-quarter, the first quarterly
contraction in more than 5 years
07-Dec-2016 China November central bank FX
reserves
Central bank FX reserves fell $70bn to $3.05trn, or about
$50bn accounting for estimated FX-valuation effects.
07-Dec-2016 UK October industrial output Industrial output falls 1.3% mom - largest monthly drop in
four years - and manufacturing output falls 0.9% mom
07-Dec-2016 UK
Supreme Court to consider government appeal of High Court's ruling that Parliament, not
government, should trigger Article 50
The well-regarded and experienced Central Bank Governor Augustin Carstens, who held the
post since 2010, announces he will step down in July 2017 to head up BIS
President Francois Hollande announces that he will not be in a candidate for the April-May
2017 French presidential elections
The well-regarded and experienced Prime Minister John Key surprises markets by announcing
that he will step down as of 12 December
Lower house of parliament (House of Commons) votes overwhelmingly in non-binding vote to
trigger Article 50 by 31 March 2017, as per the Prime Minister Theresa May's self-imposed
deadline, in exchange for the government agreeing to publish details of the government's plan
for leaving the EU by 31 March 2017. Government also agrees in principle to parliament voting
on the new terms and conditions of the UK's relationship with the EU.

More Related Content

What's hot

Final Copy International Equities
Final Copy International EquitiesFinal Copy International Equities
Final Copy International EquitiesChad Craig
 
Olivier Desbarres - Its oh so quiet...for now
Olivier Desbarres - Its oh so quiet...for nowOlivier Desbarres - Its oh so quiet...for now
Olivier Desbarres - Its oh so quiet...for nowOlivier Desbarres
 
Fasanara Capital Investment Outlook | September 1st 2014
Fasanara Capital Investment Outlook | September 1st 2014Fasanara Capital Investment Outlook | September 1st 2014
Fasanara Capital Investment Outlook | September 1st 2014Fasanara Capital ltd
 
The Economic Outlook for 2017 by Kevin Lings
The Economic Outlook for 2017 by Kevin LingsThe Economic Outlook for 2017 by Kevin Lings
The Economic Outlook for 2017 by Kevin LingsSTANLIB
 
Non-farm Payrolls, tariffs and geopolitics to impact this week
Non-farm Payrolls, tariffs and geopolitics to impact this weekNon-farm Payrolls, tariffs and geopolitics to impact this week
Non-farm Payrolls, tariffs and geopolitics to impact this weekHantec Markets
 
Standpoint: Global Reflation by Kevin Lings
Standpoint: Global Reflation by Kevin Lings Standpoint: Global Reflation by Kevin Lings
Standpoint: Global Reflation by Kevin Lings STANLIB
 
Paradox of acute uncertainty and strong consensus views
Paradox of acute uncertainty and strong consensus viewsParadox of acute uncertainty and strong consensus views
Paradox of acute uncertainty and strong consensus viewsOlivier Desbarres
 
10 principal economic insights june 2015
10 principal economic insights june 201510 principal economic insights june 2015
10 principal economic insights june 2015123jumpad
 
How strong a comeback for inflation?
How strong a comeback for inflation?How strong a comeback for inflation?
How strong a comeback for inflation?Jurgen Vluijmans
 
Sticking to forecasts: Fed summer hike, Dollar hat-trick still on the cards, ...
Sticking to forecasts: Fed summer hike, Dollar hat-trick still on the cards, ...Sticking to forecasts: Fed summer hike, Dollar hat-trick still on the cards, ...
Sticking to forecasts: Fed summer hike, Dollar hat-trick still on the cards, ...Olivier Desbarres
 
Uncommon truths.....
Uncommon truths.....Uncommon truths.....
Uncommon truths.....Roland Marty
 
Gi French Connection
Gi French ConnectionGi French Connection
Gi French ConnectionDavid Apted
 
2 william blair global market outlook - december 2013
2 william blair global market outlook - december 20132 william blair global market outlook - december 2013
2 william blair global market outlook - december 2013123jumpad
 
The drivers of renewed euro and sterling weakness
The drivers of renewed euro and sterling weaknessThe drivers of renewed euro and sterling weakness
The drivers of renewed euro and sterling weaknessHantec Markets
 
Fixed Income Market Update (4-30-10)
Fixed Income Market Update (4-30-10)Fixed Income Market Update (4-30-10)
Fixed Income Market Update (4-30-10)Michael Matthews
 
Trump continues to be a driver of market sentiment
Trump continues to be a driver of market sentimentTrump continues to be a driver of market sentiment
Trump continues to be a driver of market sentimentHantec Markets
 
Private Capital Markets Spring 2018
Private Capital Markets Spring 2018Private Capital Markets Spring 2018
Private Capital Markets Spring 2018Duff & Phelps
 
Quarterly Economic Update from Cornerstone Wealth Management.
Quarterly Economic Update from Cornerstone Wealth Management.Quarterly Economic Update from Cornerstone Wealth Management.
Quarterly Economic Update from Cornerstone Wealth Management.Cornerstone Wealth Management MWP
 

What's hot (20)

Final Copy International Equities
Final Copy International EquitiesFinal Copy International Equities
Final Copy International Equities
 
Olivier Desbarres - Its oh so quiet...for now
Olivier Desbarres - Its oh so quiet...for nowOlivier Desbarres - Its oh so quiet...for now
Olivier Desbarres - Its oh so quiet...for now
 
Fasanara Capital Investment Outlook | September 1st 2014
Fasanara Capital Investment Outlook | September 1st 2014Fasanara Capital Investment Outlook | September 1st 2014
Fasanara Capital Investment Outlook | September 1st 2014
 
The Economic Outlook for 2017 by Kevin Lings
The Economic Outlook for 2017 by Kevin LingsThe Economic Outlook for 2017 by Kevin Lings
The Economic Outlook for 2017 by Kevin Lings
 
Non-farm Payrolls, tariffs and geopolitics to impact this week
Non-farm Payrolls, tariffs and geopolitics to impact this weekNon-farm Payrolls, tariffs and geopolitics to impact this week
Non-farm Payrolls, tariffs and geopolitics to impact this week
 
Standpoint: Global Reflation by Kevin Lings
Standpoint: Global Reflation by Kevin Lings Standpoint: Global Reflation by Kevin Lings
Standpoint: Global Reflation by Kevin Lings
 
Paradox of acute uncertainty and strong consensus views
Paradox of acute uncertainty and strong consensus viewsParadox of acute uncertainty and strong consensus views
Paradox of acute uncertainty and strong consensus views
 
10 principal economic insights june 2015
10 principal economic insights june 201510 principal economic insights june 2015
10 principal economic insights june 2015
 
How strong a comeback for inflation?
How strong a comeback for inflation?How strong a comeback for inflation?
How strong a comeback for inflation?
 
Sticking to forecasts: Fed summer hike, Dollar hat-trick still on the cards, ...
Sticking to forecasts: Fed summer hike, Dollar hat-trick still on the cards, ...Sticking to forecasts: Fed summer hike, Dollar hat-trick still on the cards, ...
Sticking to forecasts: Fed summer hike, Dollar hat-trick still on the cards, ...
 
Uncommon truths.....
Uncommon truths.....Uncommon truths.....
Uncommon truths.....
 
Yf econ update-2019-08_v1.0
Yf econ update-2019-08_v1.0Yf econ update-2019-08_v1.0
Yf econ update-2019-08_v1.0
 
Gi French Connection
Gi French ConnectionGi French Connection
Gi French Connection
 
2 william blair global market outlook - december 2013
2 william blair global market outlook - december 20132 william blair global market outlook - december 2013
2 william blair global market outlook - december 2013
 
The drivers of renewed euro and sterling weakness
The drivers of renewed euro and sterling weaknessThe drivers of renewed euro and sterling weakness
The drivers of renewed euro and sterling weakness
 
USIS Review March 2016
USIS Review March 2016USIS Review March 2016
USIS Review March 2016
 
Fixed Income Market Update (4-30-10)
Fixed Income Market Update (4-30-10)Fixed Income Market Update (4-30-10)
Fixed Income Market Update (4-30-10)
 
Trump continues to be a driver of market sentiment
Trump continues to be a driver of market sentimentTrump continues to be a driver of market sentiment
Trump continues to be a driver of market sentiment
 
Private Capital Markets Spring 2018
Private Capital Markets Spring 2018Private Capital Markets Spring 2018
Private Capital Markets Spring 2018
 
Quarterly Economic Update from Cornerstone Wealth Management.
Quarterly Economic Update from Cornerstone Wealth Management.Quarterly Economic Update from Cornerstone Wealth Management.
Quarterly Economic Update from Cornerstone Wealth Management.
 

Viewers also liked

Texas wildfire exhibits - The Lufkin News: Local & State
Texas wildfire exhibits  - The Lufkin News: Local & StateTexas wildfire exhibits  - The Lufkin News: Local & State
Texas wildfire exhibits - The Lufkin News: Local & StateMichael Douglas
 
REPORT TEMPLATE__EMILIANA
REPORT TEMPLATE__EMILIANAREPORT TEMPLATE__EMILIANA
REPORT TEMPLATE__EMILIANAEmiliana Alves
 
Spomen muzej „21
Spomen muzej „21Spomen muzej „21
Spomen muzej „21aanikolov
 
13a brandontrimble Portfolio
13a brandontrimble Portfolio13a brandontrimble Portfolio
13a brandontrimble PortfolioBrandon Trimble
 
STUDYING ACADEMIC INDICATORS WITHIN VIRTUAL LEARNING ENVIRONMENT USING EDUCAT...
STUDYING ACADEMIC INDICATORS WITHIN VIRTUAL LEARNING ENVIRONMENT USING EDUCAT...STUDYING ACADEMIC INDICATORS WITHIN VIRTUAL LEARNING ENVIRONMENT USING EDUCAT...
STUDYING ACADEMIC INDICATORS WITHIN VIRTUAL LEARNING ENVIRONMENT USING EDUCAT...IJDKP
 
Phân tích tình hình tài chính tại công ty tnhh thương mại và xây dựng tân nhậ...
Phân tích tình hình tài chính tại công ty tnhh thương mại và xây dựng tân nhậ...Phân tích tình hình tài chính tại công ty tnhh thương mại và xây dựng tân nhậ...
Phân tích tình hình tài chính tại công ty tnhh thương mại và xây dựng tân nhậ...https://www.facebook.com/garmentspace
 
IMPROVED MICRO-BLOG CLASSIFICATION FOR DETECTING ABUSIVE ARABIC TWITTER ACCOUNTS
IMPROVED MICRO-BLOG CLASSIFICATION FOR DETECTING ABUSIVE ARABIC TWITTER ACCOUNTSIMPROVED MICRO-BLOG CLASSIFICATION FOR DETECTING ABUSIVE ARABIC TWITTER ACCOUNTS
IMPROVED MICRO-BLOG CLASSIFICATION FOR DETECTING ABUSIVE ARABIC TWITTER ACCOUNTSIJDKP
 
PRIVACY PRESERVATION IN SOCIAL MEDIA BY IMAGE PROCESSING
PRIVACY PRESERVATION  IN  SOCIAL MEDIA BY IMAGE PROCESSINGPRIVACY PRESERVATION  IN  SOCIAL MEDIA BY IMAGE PROCESSING
PRIVACY PRESERVATION IN SOCIAL MEDIA BY IMAGE PROCESSINGAM Publications
 
Personajes destacados de la educacion fisica
Personajes destacados de la educacion fisicaPersonajes destacados de la educacion fisica
Personajes destacados de la educacion fisicaAndres Cardenas
 
Los pronombres
Los pronombresLos pronombres
Los pronombresApuntes300
 
Securing Water & Food: Opportunities in Irrigation by Dr. Peter McCornick
Securing Water & Food: Opportunities in Irrigation by Dr. Peter McCornickSecuring Water & Food: Opportunities in Irrigation by Dr. Peter McCornick
Securing Water & Food: Opportunities in Irrigation by Dr. Peter McCornickicidciid
 

Viewers also liked (19)

Texas wildfire exhibits - The Lufkin News: Local & State
Texas wildfire exhibits  - The Lufkin News: Local & StateTexas wildfire exhibits  - The Lufkin News: Local & State
Texas wildfire exhibits - The Lufkin News: Local & State
 
REPORT TEMPLATE__EMILIANA
REPORT TEMPLATE__EMILIANAREPORT TEMPLATE__EMILIANA
REPORT TEMPLATE__EMILIANA
 
Opening scenes
Opening scenesOpening scenes
Opening scenes
 
Spomen muzej „21
Spomen muzej „21Spomen muzej „21
Spomen muzej „21
 
13a brandontrimble Portfolio
13a brandontrimble Portfolio13a brandontrimble Portfolio
13a brandontrimble Portfolio
 
energia
energiaenergia
energia
 
La reina roja - Coty
La reina roja - CotyLa reina roja - Coty
La reina roja - Coty
 
Amit Singh CV 2016.
Amit Singh CV 2016.Amit Singh CV 2016.
Amit Singh CV 2016.
 
Chapter07
Chapter07Chapter07
Chapter07
 
STUDYING ACADEMIC INDICATORS WITHIN VIRTUAL LEARNING ENVIRONMENT USING EDUCAT...
STUDYING ACADEMIC INDICATORS WITHIN VIRTUAL LEARNING ENVIRONMENT USING EDUCAT...STUDYING ACADEMIC INDICATORS WITHIN VIRTUAL LEARNING ENVIRONMENT USING EDUCAT...
STUDYING ACADEMIC INDICATORS WITHIN VIRTUAL LEARNING ENVIRONMENT USING EDUCAT...
 
Phân tích tình hình tài chính tại công ty tnhh thương mại và xây dựng tân nhậ...
Phân tích tình hình tài chính tại công ty tnhh thương mại và xây dựng tân nhậ...Phân tích tình hình tài chính tại công ty tnhh thương mại và xây dựng tân nhậ...
Phân tích tình hình tài chính tại công ty tnhh thương mại và xây dựng tân nhậ...
 
Quien quiere ser millonario1
Quien quiere ser millonario1Quien quiere ser millonario1
Quien quiere ser millonario1
 
IMPROVED MICRO-BLOG CLASSIFICATION FOR DETECTING ABUSIVE ARABIC TWITTER ACCOUNTS
IMPROVED MICRO-BLOG CLASSIFICATION FOR DETECTING ABUSIVE ARABIC TWITTER ACCOUNTSIMPROVED MICRO-BLOG CLASSIFICATION FOR DETECTING ABUSIVE ARABIC TWITTER ACCOUNTS
IMPROVED MICRO-BLOG CLASSIFICATION FOR DETECTING ABUSIVE ARABIC TWITTER ACCOUNTS
 
RxAndroid
RxAndroidRxAndroid
RxAndroid
 
PRIVACY PRESERVATION IN SOCIAL MEDIA BY IMAGE PROCESSING
PRIVACY PRESERVATION  IN  SOCIAL MEDIA BY IMAGE PROCESSINGPRIVACY PRESERVATION  IN  SOCIAL MEDIA BY IMAGE PROCESSING
PRIVACY PRESERVATION IN SOCIAL MEDIA BY IMAGE PROCESSING
 
Ciberacoso
CiberacosoCiberacoso
Ciberacoso
 
Personajes destacados de la educacion fisica
Personajes destacados de la educacion fisicaPersonajes destacados de la educacion fisica
Personajes destacados de la educacion fisica
 
Los pronombres
Los pronombresLos pronombres
Los pronombres
 
Securing Water & Food: Opportunities in Irrigation by Dr. Peter McCornick
Securing Water & Food: Opportunities in Irrigation by Dr. Peter McCornickSecuring Water & Food: Opportunities in Irrigation by Dr. Peter McCornick
Securing Water & Food: Opportunities in Irrigation by Dr. Peter McCornick
 

Similar to Black swans and white doves

To the Point, November 26 2009
To the Point, November 26 2009To the Point, November 26 2009
To the Point, November 26 2009Swedbank
 
Global economy in charts
Global economy in chartsGlobal economy in charts
Global economy in chartsDeloitte UK
 
Olivier Desbarres - Be careful what you wish for
Olivier Desbarres - Be careful what you wish forOlivier Desbarres - Be careful what you wish for
Olivier Desbarres - Be careful what you wish forOlivier Desbarres
 
Valuation Insights - Q3 2016
Valuation Insights - Q3 2016Valuation Insights - Q3 2016
Valuation Insights - Q3 2016Duff & Phelps
 
PwC Global Economy Watch (oct. 2013)
PwC Global Economy Watch (oct. 2013)PwC Global Economy Watch (oct. 2013)
PwC Global Economy Watch (oct. 2013)PwC France
 
07.2015 TCH - Rumor of bonds’ demise greatly exaggerated... again
07.2015 TCH - Rumor of bonds’ demise greatly exaggerated... again07.2015 TCH - Rumor of bonds’ demise greatly exaggerated... again
07.2015 TCH - Rumor of bonds’ demise greatly exaggerated... againAdam Phillips
 
JSA RMF February 2018 UPDATE
JSA RMF February 2018 UPDATEJSA RMF February 2018 UPDATE
JSA RMF February 2018 UPDATEchris10martin
 
Stanford Endowment Fund - Asset Allocation
Stanford Endowment Fund - Asset AllocationStanford Endowment Fund - Asset Allocation
Stanford Endowment Fund - Asset AllocationKUN YANG
 
The Global Economy – No. 8/2010
The Global Economy – No. 8/2010The Global Economy – No. 8/2010
The Global Economy – No. 8/2010Swedbank
 
Eurozone falling chickens choice internal or external devaluation
Eurozone falling chickens choice   internal or external devaluationEurozone falling chickens choice   internal or external devaluation
Eurozone falling chickens choice internal or external devaluationMarkets Beyond
 
Olivier DEsbarres: What to expect in 2016 – same, same, but worse
Olivier DEsbarres: What to expect in 2016 – same, same, but worseOlivier DEsbarres: What to expect in 2016 – same, same, but worse
Olivier DEsbarres: What to expect in 2016 – same, same, but worseOlivier Desbarres
 
Mid-year Market Review 2019
Mid-year Market Review 2019Mid-year Market Review 2019
Mid-year Market Review 2019Amir Khan
 
Main Streets Across the World 2015-2016
Main Streets Across the World 2015-2016Main Streets Across the World 2015-2016
Main Streets Across the World 2015-2016David Bourla
 
The Low Interest Rate Dilemma for Corporate Investors Presentation 5-12 CCA V...
The Low Interest Rate Dilemma for Corporate Investors Presentation 5-12 CCA V...The Low Interest Rate Dilemma for Corporate Investors Presentation 5-12 CCA V...
The Low Interest Rate Dilemma for Corporate Investors Presentation 5-12 CCA V...Mike Betty
 
Olivier Desbarres: Brexit what happens next?
Olivier Desbarres: Brexit what happens next?Olivier Desbarres: Brexit what happens next?
Olivier Desbarres: Brexit what happens next?Olivier Desbarres
 
To the Point, October 27 2009
To the Point, October 27 2009To the Point, October 27 2009
To the Point, October 27 2009Swedbank
 
Why the us economy will substantially outperform the eu for the long run
Why the us economy will substantially outperform the eu for the long runWhy the us economy will substantially outperform the eu for the long run
Why the us economy will substantially outperform the eu for the long runMarkets Beyond
 
Quarterly Report. Perspectives on Global and Spanish economy Q2-2019
Quarterly Report. Perspectives on Global and Spanish economy Q2-2019Quarterly Report. Perspectives on Global and Spanish economy Q2-2019
Quarterly Report. Perspectives on Global and Spanish economy Q2-2019Círculo de Empresarios
 

Similar to Black swans and white doves (20)

To the Point, November 26 2009
To the Point, November 26 2009To the Point, November 26 2009
To the Point, November 26 2009
 
Global economy in charts
Global economy in chartsGlobal economy in charts
Global economy in charts
 
Olivier Desbarres - Be careful what you wish for
Olivier Desbarres - Be careful what you wish forOlivier Desbarres - Be careful what you wish for
Olivier Desbarres - Be careful what you wish for
 
Valuation Insights - Q3 2016
Valuation Insights - Q3 2016Valuation Insights - Q3 2016
Valuation Insights - Q3 2016
 
PwC Global Economy Watch (oct. 2013)
PwC Global Economy Watch (oct. 2013)PwC Global Economy Watch (oct. 2013)
PwC Global Economy Watch (oct. 2013)
 
07.2015 TCH - Rumor of bonds’ demise greatly exaggerated... again
07.2015 TCH - Rumor of bonds’ demise greatly exaggerated... again07.2015 TCH - Rumor of bonds’ demise greatly exaggerated... again
07.2015 TCH - Rumor of bonds’ demise greatly exaggerated... again
 
JSA RMF February 2018 UPDATE
JSA RMF February 2018 UPDATEJSA RMF February 2018 UPDATE
JSA RMF February 2018 UPDATE
 
Stanford Endowment Fund - Asset Allocation
Stanford Endowment Fund - Asset AllocationStanford Endowment Fund - Asset Allocation
Stanford Endowment Fund - Asset Allocation
 
The Global Economy – No. 8/2010
The Global Economy – No. 8/2010The Global Economy – No. 8/2010
The Global Economy – No. 8/2010
 
Eurozone falling chickens choice internal or external devaluation
Eurozone falling chickens choice   internal or external devaluationEurozone falling chickens choice   internal or external devaluation
Eurozone falling chickens choice internal or external devaluation
 
Olivier DEsbarres: What to expect in 2016 – same, same, but worse
Olivier DEsbarres: What to expect in 2016 – same, same, but worseOlivier DEsbarres: What to expect in 2016 – same, same, but worse
Olivier DEsbarres: What to expect in 2016 – same, same, but worse
 
Mid-year Market Review 2019
Mid-year Market Review 2019Mid-year Market Review 2019
Mid-year Market Review 2019
 
Main Streets Across the World 2015-2016
Main Streets Across the World 2015-2016Main Streets Across the World 2015-2016
Main Streets Across the World 2015-2016
 
The Low Interest Rate Dilemma for Corporate Investors Presentation 5-12 CCA V...
The Low Interest Rate Dilemma for Corporate Investors Presentation 5-12 CCA V...The Low Interest Rate Dilemma for Corporate Investors Presentation 5-12 CCA V...
The Low Interest Rate Dilemma for Corporate Investors Presentation 5-12 CCA V...
 
Mid year update
Mid year updateMid year update
Mid year update
 
Olivier Desbarres: Brexit what happens next?
Olivier Desbarres: Brexit what happens next?Olivier Desbarres: Brexit what happens next?
Olivier Desbarres: Brexit what happens next?
 
To the Point, October 27 2009
To the Point, October 27 2009To the Point, October 27 2009
To the Point, October 27 2009
 
Why the us economy will substantially outperform the eu for the long run
Why the us economy will substantially outperform the eu for the long runWhy the us economy will substantially outperform the eu for the long run
Why the us economy will substantially outperform the eu for the long run
 
Quarterly Report. Perspectives on Global and Spanish economy Q2-2019
Quarterly Report. Perspectives on Global and Spanish economy Q2-2019Quarterly Report. Perspectives on Global and Spanish economy Q2-2019
Quarterly Report. Perspectives on Global and Spanish economy Q2-2019
 
Globalization, Protectionisms and New International Relations
Globalization, Protectionisms and New International RelationsGlobalization, Protectionisms and New International Relations
Globalization, Protectionisms and New International Relations
 

Recently uploaded

SBP-Market-Operations and market managment
SBP-Market-Operations and market managmentSBP-Market-Operations and market managment
SBP-Market-Operations and market managmentfactical
 
Andheri Call Girls In 9825968104 Mumbai Hot Models
Andheri Call Girls In 9825968104 Mumbai Hot ModelsAndheri Call Girls In 9825968104 Mumbai Hot Models
Andheri Call Girls In 9825968104 Mumbai Hot Modelshematsharma006
 
Log your LOA pain with Pension Lab's brilliant campaign
Log your LOA pain with Pension Lab's brilliant campaignLog your LOA pain with Pension Lab's brilliant campaign
Log your LOA pain with Pension Lab's brilliant campaignHenry Tapper
 
High Class Call Girls Nashik Maya 7001305949 Independent Escort Service Nashik
High Class Call Girls Nashik Maya 7001305949 Independent Escort Service NashikHigh Class Call Girls Nashik Maya 7001305949 Independent Escort Service Nashik
High Class Call Girls Nashik Maya 7001305949 Independent Escort Service NashikCall Girls in Nagpur High Profile
 
Instant Issue Debit Cards - High School Spirit
Instant Issue Debit Cards - High School SpiritInstant Issue Debit Cards - High School Spirit
Instant Issue Debit Cards - High School Spiritegoetzinger
 
Quantitative Analysis of Retail Sector Companies
Quantitative Analysis of Retail Sector CompaniesQuantitative Analysis of Retail Sector Companies
Quantitative Analysis of Retail Sector Companiesprashantbhati354
 
BPPG response - Options for Defined Benefit schemes - 19Apr24.pdf
BPPG response - Options for Defined Benefit schemes - 19Apr24.pdfBPPG response - Options for Defined Benefit schemes - 19Apr24.pdf
BPPG response - Options for Defined Benefit schemes - 19Apr24.pdfHenry Tapper
 
VIP Call Girls LB Nagar ( Hyderabad ) Phone 8250192130 | ₹5k To 25k With Room...
VIP Call Girls LB Nagar ( Hyderabad ) Phone 8250192130 | ₹5k To 25k With Room...VIP Call Girls LB Nagar ( Hyderabad ) Phone 8250192130 | ₹5k To 25k With Room...
VIP Call Girls LB Nagar ( Hyderabad ) Phone 8250192130 | ₹5k To 25k With Room...Suhani Kapoor
 
High Class Call Girls Nagpur Grishma Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur Escorts
High Class Call Girls Nagpur Grishma Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur EscortsHigh Class Call Girls Nagpur Grishma Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur Escorts
High Class Call Girls Nagpur Grishma Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur Escortsranjana rawat
 
20240417-Calibre-April-2024-Investor-Presentation.pdf
20240417-Calibre-April-2024-Investor-Presentation.pdf20240417-Calibre-April-2024-Investor-Presentation.pdf
20240417-Calibre-April-2024-Investor-Presentation.pdfAdnet Communications
 
letter-from-the-chair-to-the-fca-relating-to-british-steel-pensions-scheme-15...
letter-from-the-chair-to-the-fca-relating-to-british-steel-pensions-scheme-15...letter-from-the-chair-to-the-fca-relating-to-british-steel-pensions-scheme-15...
letter-from-the-chair-to-the-fca-relating-to-british-steel-pensions-scheme-15...Henry Tapper
 
Attachment Of Assets......................
Attachment Of Assets......................Attachment Of Assets......................
Attachment Of Assets......................AmanBajaj36
 
Vip B Aizawl Call Girls #9907093804 Contact Number Escorts Service Aizawl
Vip B Aizawl Call Girls #9907093804 Contact Number Escorts Service AizawlVip B Aizawl Call Girls #9907093804 Contact Number Escorts Service Aizawl
Vip B Aizawl Call Girls #9907093804 Contact Number Escorts Service Aizawlmakika9823
 
Monthly Market Risk Update: April 2024 [SlideShare]
Monthly Market Risk Update: April 2024 [SlideShare]Monthly Market Risk Update: April 2024 [SlideShare]
Monthly Market Risk Update: April 2024 [SlideShare]Commonwealth
 
call girls in Nand Nagri (DELHI) 🔝 >༒9953330565🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️
call girls in  Nand Nagri (DELHI) 🔝 >༒9953330565🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️call girls in  Nand Nagri (DELHI) 🔝 >༒9953330565🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️
call girls in Nand Nagri (DELHI) 🔝 >༒9953330565🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️9953056974 Low Rate Call Girls In Saket, Delhi NCR
 
The Triple Threat | Article on Global Resession | Harsh Kumar
The Triple Threat | Article on Global Resession | Harsh KumarThe Triple Threat | Article on Global Resession | Harsh Kumar
The Triple Threat | Article on Global Resession | Harsh KumarHarsh Kumar
 
Unveiling the Top Chartered Accountants in India and Their Staggering Net Worth
Unveiling the Top Chartered Accountants in India and Their Staggering Net WorthUnveiling the Top Chartered Accountants in India and Their Staggering Net Worth
Unveiling the Top Chartered Accountants in India and Their Staggering Net WorthShaheen Kumar
 
VIP High Class Call Girls Saharanpur Anushka 8250192130 Independent Escort Se...
VIP High Class Call Girls Saharanpur Anushka 8250192130 Independent Escort Se...VIP High Class Call Girls Saharanpur Anushka 8250192130 Independent Escort Se...
VIP High Class Call Girls Saharanpur Anushka 8250192130 Independent Escort Se...Suhani Kapoor
 
Interimreport1 January–31 March2024 Elo Mutual Pension Insurance Company
Interimreport1 January–31 March2024 Elo Mutual Pension Insurance CompanyInterimreport1 January–31 March2024 Elo Mutual Pension Insurance Company
Interimreport1 January–31 March2024 Elo Mutual Pension Insurance CompanyTyöeläkeyhtiö Elo
 

Recently uploaded (20)

SBP-Market-Operations and market managment
SBP-Market-Operations and market managmentSBP-Market-Operations and market managment
SBP-Market-Operations and market managment
 
Andheri Call Girls In 9825968104 Mumbai Hot Models
Andheri Call Girls In 9825968104 Mumbai Hot ModelsAndheri Call Girls In 9825968104 Mumbai Hot Models
Andheri Call Girls In 9825968104 Mumbai Hot Models
 
Log your LOA pain with Pension Lab's brilliant campaign
Log your LOA pain with Pension Lab's brilliant campaignLog your LOA pain with Pension Lab's brilliant campaign
Log your LOA pain with Pension Lab's brilliant campaign
 
High Class Call Girls Nashik Maya 7001305949 Independent Escort Service Nashik
High Class Call Girls Nashik Maya 7001305949 Independent Escort Service NashikHigh Class Call Girls Nashik Maya 7001305949 Independent Escort Service Nashik
High Class Call Girls Nashik Maya 7001305949 Independent Escort Service Nashik
 
Instant Issue Debit Cards - High School Spirit
Instant Issue Debit Cards - High School SpiritInstant Issue Debit Cards - High School Spirit
Instant Issue Debit Cards - High School Spirit
 
Quantitative Analysis of Retail Sector Companies
Quantitative Analysis of Retail Sector CompaniesQuantitative Analysis of Retail Sector Companies
Quantitative Analysis of Retail Sector Companies
 
BPPG response - Options for Defined Benefit schemes - 19Apr24.pdf
BPPG response - Options for Defined Benefit schemes - 19Apr24.pdfBPPG response - Options for Defined Benefit schemes - 19Apr24.pdf
BPPG response - Options for Defined Benefit schemes - 19Apr24.pdf
 
VIP Call Girls LB Nagar ( Hyderabad ) Phone 8250192130 | ₹5k To 25k With Room...
VIP Call Girls LB Nagar ( Hyderabad ) Phone 8250192130 | ₹5k To 25k With Room...VIP Call Girls LB Nagar ( Hyderabad ) Phone 8250192130 | ₹5k To 25k With Room...
VIP Call Girls LB Nagar ( Hyderabad ) Phone 8250192130 | ₹5k To 25k With Room...
 
High Class Call Girls Nagpur Grishma Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur Escorts
High Class Call Girls Nagpur Grishma Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur EscortsHigh Class Call Girls Nagpur Grishma Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur Escorts
High Class Call Girls Nagpur Grishma Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur Escorts
 
20240417-Calibre-April-2024-Investor-Presentation.pdf
20240417-Calibre-April-2024-Investor-Presentation.pdf20240417-Calibre-April-2024-Investor-Presentation.pdf
20240417-Calibre-April-2024-Investor-Presentation.pdf
 
letter-from-the-chair-to-the-fca-relating-to-british-steel-pensions-scheme-15...
letter-from-the-chair-to-the-fca-relating-to-british-steel-pensions-scheme-15...letter-from-the-chair-to-the-fca-relating-to-british-steel-pensions-scheme-15...
letter-from-the-chair-to-the-fca-relating-to-british-steel-pensions-scheme-15...
 
Attachment Of Assets......................
Attachment Of Assets......................Attachment Of Assets......................
Attachment Of Assets......................
 
Vip B Aizawl Call Girls #9907093804 Contact Number Escorts Service Aizawl
Vip B Aizawl Call Girls #9907093804 Contact Number Escorts Service AizawlVip B Aizawl Call Girls #9907093804 Contact Number Escorts Service Aizawl
Vip B Aizawl Call Girls #9907093804 Contact Number Escorts Service Aizawl
 
Monthly Market Risk Update: April 2024 [SlideShare]
Monthly Market Risk Update: April 2024 [SlideShare]Monthly Market Risk Update: April 2024 [SlideShare]
Monthly Market Risk Update: April 2024 [SlideShare]
 
call girls in Nand Nagri (DELHI) 🔝 >༒9953330565🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️
call girls in  Nand Nagri (DELHI) 🔝 >༒9953330565🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️call girls in  Nand Nagri (DELHI) 🔝 >༒9953330565🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️
call girls in Nand Nagri (DELHI) 🔝 >༒9953330565🔝 genuine Escort Service 🔝✔️✔️
 
The Triple Threat | Article on Global Resession | Harsh Kumar
The Triple Threat | Article on Global Resession | Harsh KumarThe Triple Threat | Article on Global Resession | Harsh Kumar
The Triple Threat | Article on Global Resession | Harsh Kumar
 
Unveiling the Top Chartered Accountants in India and Their Staggering Net Worth
Unveiling the Top Chartered Accountants in India and Their Staggering Net WorthUnveiling the Top Chartered Accountants in India and Their Staggering Net Worth
Unveiling the Top Chartered Accountants in India and Their Staggering Net Worth
 
Monthly Economic Monitoring of Ukraine No 231, April 2024
Monthly Economic Monitoring of Ukraine No 231, April 2024Monthly Economic Monitoring of Ukraine No 231, April 2024
Monthly Economic Monitoring of Ukraine No 231, April 2024
 
VIP High Class Call Girls Saharanpur Anushka 8250192130 Independent Escort Se...
VIP High Class Call Girls Saharanpur Anushka 8250192130 Independent Escort Se...VIP High Class Call Girls Saharanpur Anushka 8250192130 Independent Escort Se...
VIP High Class Call Girls Saharanpur Anushka 8250192130 Independent Escort Se...
 
Interimreport1 January–31 March2024 Elo Mutual Pension Insurance Company
Interimreport1 January–31 March2024 Elo Mutual Pension Insurance CompanyInterimreport1 January–31 March2024 Elo Mutual Pension Insurance Company
Interimreport1 January–31 March2024 Elo Mutual Pension Insurance Company
 

Black swans and white doves

  • 1. 1 Black swans and white doves In the past week European and global politics, strong US growth data, mixed global macro numbers and eurozone, Chinese and Indian central bank policy have eclipsed Trump- mania. What is perhaps more remarkable is markets’ reasonably benign, “risk-on” reaction, bar the euro’s sell-off in the wake of today’s ECB policy meeting. One interpretation is that markets have become complacent to the risks presented by President Trump’s constellation of pseudo-policies, surging nationalism in Europe, the UK’s uncertain economic future and continued capital outflows from China. I have a somewhat different take, namely that markets are rightly discounting some of the more extreme and perverse scenarios, including: 1. Protectionist US policies coupled with higher US yields and a strong dollar collapsing tepid emerging market, and eventually global, economic growth; 2. The “no” vote in the Italian referendum leading to the economic collapse of the European Union’s third largest economy; 3. Surging European nationalism culminating in the collapse of the eurozone and/or European Union; 4. The British government opting to sacrifice growth in exchange for a hard version of Brexit and; 5. Capital outflows from China ultimately forcing policy-makers into accepting a Renminbi collapse and shocking a corporate sector with significant dollar-debt. Global news, data and events have eclipsed Trump-mania in past week Donald Trump has enjoyed a near-monopoly on news headlines since being elected President a month ago. But in the past week European politics, the surprise resignation of New Zealand Prime Minister John Key and Mexican central bank governor Agustín Carstens – both highly regarded, strong US growth data, mixed global macro numbers and eurozone, Chinese and Indian central bank policy, have for now eclipsed Trump-mania (see Figure 9). What is perhaps more remarkable is markets’ reasonably benign, “risk-on” reaction, bar the euro’s sell-off in the wake of today’s ECB policy meeting. Emerging market currencies, which had stabilised against the dollar in late-November, have appreciated in the past week (see Figure 1), global yields have stabilised, global equities are within touching distance of a two-month high and European markets have on the whole taken Italy’s “no” referendum result in their stride.
  • 2. 2 Figure 1: Emerging market currencies – off the floor Figure 2: Global manufacturing PMI points to global GDP growth of 3% yoy or more in Q4 2016 Source: investing.com, BIS Source: IMF, national statistics offices One interpretation is that markets have become complacent to the risks presented by President Trump’s constellation of pseudo-policies, surging nationalism in Europe, the UK’s uncertain economic future and continued capital outflows from China which the media has focused on intensively. I have a somewhat different take, namely that markets are rightly discounting some of the more extreme and perverse scenarios, including: 1. Protectionist US policies coupled with higher US yields and a strong dollar collapsing tepid emerging market, and eventually global, economic growth; 2. The “no” vote in the Italian referendum leading to the economic collapse of the European Union’s third largest economy; 3. Surging European nationalism culminating in the collapse of the eurozone and/or European Union; 4. The British government opting to sacrifice growth in exchange for a hard version of Brexit and; 5. Capital outflows from China ultimately forcing policy-makers into accepting a Renminbi collapse, which would shock a corporate sector with significant dollar-debt and jilt emerging market asset prices and global risk appetite (a de-facto repeat of August 2015). I will explore the first three themes in this research note and return to themes 4 and 5 in my forthcoming pieces. 64 65 66 67 68 69 79 80 81 82 83 84 85 Aug 16 Sep 16 Oct 16 Nov 16 Dec 16 Including CNY, left scale Excluding CNY GDP-weighted basket of Emerging Market currencies vs USD (23 April 2010 = 100) 2.0 2.5 3.0 3.5 4.0 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 2012Q4 2013Q4 2014Q4 2015Q4 2016Q4 Global manufacturing PMI, left scale Global real GDP, % year-on-year (IMF methodology)
  • 3. 3 1. Renewed fears of collapse in global economic growth once again overdone In the past couple of years I have played down the risk of an imminent collapse in global economic growth, pointing to the reflationary impact of years of monetary easing by the world’s major central banks (see The global growth story – cause for concern, not panic, 17 December 2014). And indeed global GDP growth bottomed out in H1 2016 at around 2.8% year-on-year and rebounded to around 2.9% yoy in Q3 2016, broadly in line with my forecast (see Global central bank easing nearing important inflexion point, 16 September 2016). Moreover, the latest indicators, including the up-tick in global manufacturing PMI to 52.0 in October- November from 50.9 in Q3, suggest that global GDP growth may hit or even slightly exceed 3.0% yoy in Q4 2016 (see Figure 2), again broadly line with my expectations (see Be careful what you wish for, 1 November 2016). Modest rebound in global GDP growth but still some (different) ammunition This pace of growth is still modest compared to average GDP growth of 3.6% per annum in the past decade. Moreover, the foundations of global growth could be compromised if, as I expect, developed central banks refrain from cutting policy rates further and if nationalist and protectionist policies take hold in the US and globally. However, I think there is a tendency to over-state this dual risk to global growth. First, bar the US Federal Reserve, developed central banks are unlikely to start tightening monetary policy any time soon. The ECB’s decision today – a nine-month extension to its QE program until December 2017 with monthly bond purchases of €60bn – is a prime example of a very dovish tapering of central bank monetary policy. Ultimately the ECB has committed to another €540bn of bond purchases, rather than the €480bn which analysts had expected (a six-month extension with monthly purchases unchanged at €80bn). Second, while the room for developed central banks to cut policy rates further and/or extend QE programs may be limited, a number of emerging central banks will next year likely revisit the possibility of rate cuts. The Reserve Bank of India left its policy rate unchanged at 6.25% on 7th December, contrary to analyst expectation of a 25bp cut. Its decision was in line with my view that “the RBI may stay on hold until market conditions stabilise" (see Fast and Furious - Market drift, 15 November 2016) but I still see scope for further rate cuts in India and Indonesia, amongst others, given still high real central bank policy rates. Third, there is mounting evidence that governments in both developed and emerging economies are willing and able to loosen fiscal policy in a bid to compensate for the diminishing returns from monetary policy stimulus. US President Trump has committed to a significant increase in infrastructural spending and Chinese fixed investment growth, which had slowed over the summer, has picked up in recent months (see Figure 3). British Chancellor Philip Hammond announced in his mid-year October budget a £14.2bn increase in capital spending over five years, focussing on science, innovation, digital infrastructure, housing and transport (see EM currencies, Fed, French elections and UK reflation “lite”, 25 November 2016).
  • 4. 4 Figure 3: Chinese new loans and fixed investment growth has picked up in recent months Figure 4: Global trade has been flat-lining year-to- date Source: PBoC Source: CPB World Trade Monitor Trump protectionism – Bark worst than bite US President Trump’s penchant for protectionist policies and dismantling of international trade agreements alongside a stronger dollar and rising US yields have understandably fuelled concerns about already modest growth in emerging markets saddled with dollar-denominated debt. GDP growth remains lacklustre in some of the largest emerging economies, including Brazil, Russia and South Africa. Moreover, a number of Non-Japan Asian economies, including Singapore, Thailand and Taiwan, are experiencing a growth slowdown (see EM currencies, Fed, French elections and UK reflation “lite”, 25 November 2016). The erection of US trade barriers would undoubtedly act as a headwind to these open economies. Higher US tariffs and protectionist barriers may eventually, at the margin, stimulate the beleaguered US manufacturing sector. But there would also likely be a clear cost to the US, at least in the near and medium-term, and for that reason I ultimately expect Trump’s bark to be worst than his bite. Greater tariffs would increase the cost of US imports of goods, which in 2015 amounted to $2.3trn or 13% of GDP, given the difficulty of substituting imported goods for domestically-produced goods in the short-run (the UK’s recent experience is telling – despite Sterling’s collapse in the past year, the trade deficit on goods and services has actually widened due to the increase in the value of imports outstripping that of exports). At the same time it would be naïve to expect the United States’ trading partners not to retaliate with protectionist measures of their own, putting a brake on US exports worth 8.5% of GDP. The net result is that global trade, which has flat-lined in the past year according to the CPB (see Figure 4), would likely go backwards and act as a drag on global growth. So the price the US would likely have to be willing to pay is more expensive and/or weaker imports, higher imported inflation and/or weaker domestic consumption, less competitive exports and potentially weaker global demand for US goods – a tough sell to a consumer brought up on reasonably cheap imports. 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 -30 -20 -10 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 Jun-14 Jan-15 Aug-15 Mar-16 Oct-16 New bank loans (left scale) Fixed invesment China - YoY % change in 3-month moving 102 104 106 108 110 112 114 116 118 Jan-12 Jan-13 Jan-14 Jan-15 Jan-16 World trade Volumes, seasonally adjusted (2010=100)
  • 5. 5 2. Italian referendum “no” vote – an Italian challenge, not a European disaster Italian President Matteo Renzi officially tendered his resignation yesterday in the wake of Sunday’s referendum result but European markets continue to be orderly. Specifically, the euro appreciated versus the dollar and in nominal effective exchange rate terms in the days following the referendum (see Figure 5), Italian government bond yields have fallen across the maturity curve (see Figure 6) and the share price of Italian banks has surged (albeit from historically depressed levels). Figure 5: Euro stronger post Italian “no” referendum but losing ground post ECB meeting Figure 6: Italian yields have tightened versus bunds Source: investing.com, ECB Source: investing.com This is broadly in line with my expectation that “The worst-case-scenario advanced centres on reformist Prime Minister Renzi’s resignation, the rise to power of the euro-sceptic Five Star Movement (M5S), a jump in Italian bond yields, the fragile banking sector and economy’s collapse and Italy’s eventual exit from the eurozone and EU. But the more likely political, financial and economic outcome from a “no” vote is perhaps less dramatic, in my view […].” (see Renzi referendum frenzy – storm in a broken tea cup, 2 December 2016). Prime Minister Renzi’s resignation may well usher in a less reform-minded technocratic government, led by a senior member of Renzi’s ruling Democratic Party, and convince President Mattarella to bring forward to next year general elections currently pencilled in for May 2018. The populist Five Star Movement (M5S), led by Beppe Grillo, is currently enjoying 30% support in opinion polls. In the event of early elections it would likely increase its number of seats in the lower house of parliament from 109, particularly if current electoral rules remain in place. But the path to the top for M5S and Beppe Grillo may not be as straightforward as currently assumed, with the Democratic Party still likely to be the largest party in the 630- seat Chamber of Deputies. 78 79 80 81 82 83 84 85 98.0 98.5 99.0 99.5 100.0 100.5 101.0 101.5 102.0 Aug 16 Sep 16 Oct 16 Nov 16 Dec 16 Euro Nominal Effective Exchange Rate EURUSD (right scale) Euro indices (23 April 2010 = 100) 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 2yr 5yr 10yr Average 01-Dec-16 08-Dec-16 Italy-German government bond yield spread (basis points)
  • 6. 6 The Italian banking sector, riddled with bad-loans and planning a recapitalisation of its balance-sheet, can ill afford the negative press a “no” vote brings. But both Italian and eurozone policy-makers have a strong incentive to shore up Italian banks and the economy, even if posturing may precede an eventual solution. Finally, while the future of the eurozone and EU has been written off many times, I don’t envisage Italy being the trigger for a break-up of either. 3. Rising nationalism in Europe is wake-up call, not a revolution Only tell time will tell whether and how fast nationalist parties in Western Europe rise to the upper echelons of power, but I would argue that there is currently a tendency to over-estimate their reach and certainly their ability to dismantle the eurozone and/or EU. Put differently, by end-2018, the political landscape in West Europe may not have changed as dramatically as commentators anticipate, with the traditional old guard still largely in place, including in Germany, France, Sweden and Austria. European nationalism riding a powerful wave There is little doubt that nationalism and populist parties have been in the ascendancy in Western Europe in recent years1 . They have performed well in EU Parliamentary elections, in regional elections (e.g. Front National in France) and State elections (e.g. Alternative for Germany) and their ratings are going up in opinion polls. In Greece, where the economic dislocation has been the greatest, the Coalition of the Radical Left (Syriza) is already in power (see Figure 7). In Finland, the Finnish Party is a member of a three-party ruling coalition and in Denmark the Danish People's Party officially supports the three-party coalition which gives it a degree of indirect influence. Left-wing and right-wing nationalist parties are more effectively channelling popular discontent against the political and status quo and increasingly influencing the direction of domestic policy. As a result, traditional centrist or right-leaning parties have had little choice but to take this message on board in order to remain politically relevant and increase their chances of re-election. For example, the ruling Conservative Party in the UK has partly assimilated the anti-immigration rhetoric which is a cornerstone of the nationalist UK Independence Party (UKIP). The Republican candidate for next year’s French presidential elections, François Fillon, has traditionally adopted a conservative social and economic stance but has more recently incorporated a more nationalist bias. Even German Chancellor Merkel has had to backtrack on her pledge to allow up to one million immigrants per annum into Germany. Moreover, Trump's victory in the November US presidential elections and the British electorate’s vote in June in favour of the UK leaving the EU have clearly reinvigorated nationalist parties and their belief that they can tap voters which have historically supported more traditional parties and politicians. 1 Admittedly the characteristics which define a party as nationalist and/or populist and left-wing or right-wing are somewhat subjective, with some parties (e.g. Five Star Movement in Italy) rejecting such labelling.
  • 7. 7 Figure 7: Nationalist parties in Western Europe – current state of play Source: National parliaments; Note: Nationalist parties in central and EasternEurope and in a number of smaller West European countries (including Belgium) are excluded. Some of the smaller nationalist parties are also excluded. Country % of EU GDP Nationalist Party Bias Leader Current seats in lower house of parliament Next parliamentary elections Presidency Note Germany 20.4 Alternative for Germany Right-wing Frauke Petry & Jörg Meuthen No seats in 630-seat Bundestag but represented in 10 of the 16 German state parliaments. Not applicable National Democratic Party of Germany Right-wing Frank Franz No seats in Bundestag or state parliaments UK 15.5 United Kingdom Independence Party (UKIP) Right-wing 1 out of 650 seats (0.15%) in House of Commons No later than May 2020. First-past-the-post electoral system likely to keep number of UKIP seats very low Not applicable France 14.5 Front National Right-wing Marine Le Pen 2 out of 577 seats (0.35%) in Assemblée Nationale June 2017, over two rounds. Front National party expected to make sizeable gains from 2 seats it currently holds Le Pen very unlikely to become President in April-May elections. Italy 10.8 Five Star Movement (M5S) Populist Beppe Grillo 109 out of 630 seats (17.3%) in Chamber of Deputies Elections due in January 2022 Lega Nord Regionalist Matteo Salvini 18 out of 630 seats (2.9%) Brothers of Italy Nationalist / conservatism Giorgia Meloni 9 out of 630 seats (1.4%) Spain 7.3 Podemos Left-wing Pablo Iglesias Podemos, part of a left-wing alliance, has 67 of 350 seats (19.1%) in Congress of Deputies No later than 26 July 2020 Not applicable Netherlands 4.5 Freedom Party Right-wing Geert Wilders 12 out of 150 seats (8%) in House of Representatives 15 March 2017. Based on latest polls Freedom Party would win 33 seats to become largest party and Wilders prime minister Not applicable Sweden 3.0 Swedish Democrats Right-wing Mattias Karlsson 48 out of 349 seats (13.8%) in Riksdag No later than 9 Sept 2018. SD currently polling third with around 20% which under proportional representation system would give it about 70 seats. Not applicable Unicameral legislature (no upper house) Austria 2.3 Freedom Party Right-wing Norbert Hofer 40 out of 183 seats (21.9%) in National Council No later than Oct 2018 Hofer lost to independent A. Van der Bellen in presidential elections on 4 Dec 2016 Norway 2.2 Democrats in Norway Right-wing Vidar Kleppe No seats in 169-seat Storting 11-Sep-17 Not applicable Denmark 1.8 Danish People's Party Right-wing 37 out of 179 seats (20.7%) in Folketing. Party officially supports the three-party ruling coalition No later than 17 June 2019 Not applicable Unicameral legislature (no upper house) Finland 1.4 Finns Party Conservative/ populist Timo Soini 37 out of 200 seats (18.5%) in Eduskunta. Member of three-party ruling coalition April 2019 Sauli Niinistö Unicameral legislature (no upper house) Portugal 1.2 National Renovator Party Right-wing José Pinto Coelho No seats in 230-seat Assembly of the Republic No later than 13 Oct 2019 Marcelo Rebelo de Sousa Greece 1.1 Coalition of the Radical Left (Syriza) Left-wing Alexis Tsipras (Prime Minister) 144 of 300 seats (48%) in Hellenic Parliament No later than 20 Oct 2019 Prokopis Pavlopoulos, mostly ceremonial role Golden Dawn Right-wing Nikolaos Michaloliakos 18 of 300 seats (6%) No later than 23 May 2018. Possibility of President Mattarella calling early elections. Unicameral legislature (no upper house). Between 27 Aug and 22 Oct 2017. AfG expected to clear 5% threshold and gain a handful of seats
  • 8. 8 Influence is not the same as true power But, beyond Greece and Finland, which account for only 2.5% of the European Union’s GDP, nationalist parties in Western Europe are still in opposition and often have only a small share of parliamentary seats (see Figure 8). Ultimately they will only be able to shape the future of their countries and potentially the eurozone and/or EU if they have true power, by holding a parliamentary majority, the presidency or both. Even Syriza is seven seats short of a parliamentary majority while the Finnish Party only has 37 out of 200 seats in the Eduskunta. In other West European countries, no nationalist party currently has more than 22% of the seats in their lower houses of parliament. In Germany, UK and France, which in aggregate account for half of the EU’s GDP – nationalist parties currently have only 3 seats out of 1,857 in the three lower houses of parliament. In Germany and Sweden, nationalist parties are still very much fringe political forces with no state-level representation and only modest regional-level representation. Moreover, none of the nationalist parties in Western Europe currently occupy the presidency. The Austrian Freedom Party’s candidate, Norbert Hofer, got close but lost last weekend’s presidential elections. Figure 8: Majority of West European nationalist parties only have modest number of seats in parliament Source: National parliaments Note: Nationalist parties in central and EasternEurope and in a number of smaller West European countries (including Belgium) are excluded. Some of the smaller nationalist parties are also excluded. * NDP: National Democratic Party of Germany; ** National Renovator Party; *** Finns Party member of 3-party ruling coalition; **** Syriza is ruling party. 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 Nationalist parties - Current share of seats in lower house of parliament (%) (red denotes party in power)
  • 9. 9 The seemingly broad-based assumption is that these parties will ultimately gain power and lead the dissolution of the eurozone and/or the European Union. Nationalist parties will admittedly in all likelihood increase their number of seats at elections for the lower houses of parliament in 2017-2018 in the Netherlands, France, Germany, Italy, Sweden and Austria. Nationalist parties will grow stronger but may struggle to become major political forces However, based on recent polls, these parties, with the exception of the Freedom Party in Austria and potentially the Five Star Movement in Italy, are very unlikely to win the largest number of seats let alone secure parliamentary majorities. For example, Alternative for Germany is a minor political force and while its anti-immigration policies are starting to resonate, it does not present a credible challenge to the incumbent CDU-CSU coalition and Chancellor Merkel. At best, some of these European nationalist parties may govern as part of broader coalitions and thus have to potentially dilute their more extreme policies. There are number of reasons why these nationalist parties may struggle to become the major political force. First, in many countries the electoral voting systems for the lower houses of parliament include thresholds and multiple rounds of voting which work against these smaller parties securing a significant number of seats. Second, many of these smaller nationalist parties still do not have the political infrastructure in place at a national level, financing or depth of personnel to effectively challenge the bigger parties. The messy and reputation-sapping election of the relatively unknown Paul Nuttall as UKIP leader, following Nigel Farage’s recent resignation, is a point in hand. Third, voters are clearly rebelling against well-entrenched political players but may not always have fresh faces to elect. In the US they elected an untested businessman with no political experience as President and in Italy the increasingly popular leader of M5S, Beppe Grillo, is a former comedian. However, in France for example, the two candidates most likely to compete in the second round of the French Presidential elections next May are François Fillon – the Republican’s candidate and a former Prime Minister – and Marine Le Pen who joined the Front National 30 years ago. They are both old-school politicians who do not present a true break with the past. Fourth, traditional centrist and centre-right parties are adapting to the new political, social and economic realities which they face and are unlikely to go down without a fight. They will have also learnt valuable lessons in the past 18 months, including the risk of calling a referendum. The demise of British Prime Minister Cameron and Italian Prime Minister Renzi following unsuccessful referendums will likely have made other EU leaders fearful of going down a similar route or of calling early elections. In particular, the ruling Conservative Party’s loss in the recent Richmond by-election has likely reduced the probability of Prime Minister Theresa May pushing for general elections, due in 2020, to be brought forward. Finally, while electorates are clearly using their votes to express their dissatisfaction with the economic and political status quo, there are still lines they seem unwilling to cross – namely the appointment of extreme- right candidates to the highest echelons of power (the recent Austrian presidential election is a good example). Europe’s history arguably acts as stark reminder of the implications of electing a far-right leader.
  • 10. 10 Similarly, leaders of nationalist parties are still very unlikely to win presidential elections. Specifically, Front National leader Marine Le Pen would most likely lose a head-to-head vote against François Fillon in the French presidential elections, assuming she even made it to the second round. As I argued in EM currencies, Fed, French elections and UK reflation “lite” (25 November 2016) it is probably too early to rule out the winner of the Socialist Party primaries, most likely Prime Minister Manuel Valls, making it to the second round of the elections ahead of Le Pen. While the Socialist Party is clearly in disarray, Valls is more popular than President Hollande who ruled himself out as a candidate for the presidential elections. Figure 9: Focus has shifted from Trump to European politics, global data and central bank policy decisions Source: National parliaments and statistical offices, Markit,European Central Bank, Reserve Bank of India 01-Dec-2016 Global Global manufacturing PMI Inches higher to 52.1 from 52.0 in October 01-Dec-2016 US November manufacturing ISM Jumps to 52.3 from 51.9 in October 01-Dec-2016 Mexico 01-Dec-2017 France 02-Dec-2016 US November labour market data Unemployment rate falls to 4.6% from 4.9% in October and non-farm payrolls increase by 178,000 04-Dec-2017 Italy Constitutional referendum Victory of "no" note, Matteo Renzi announces resignation 04-Dec-2017 Austria Re-run of second (and final) round of presidential elections Freedom Party of Austria candidate Norbert Hofer loses to Independent/Green Party candidate Alexander Van der Bellen. 05-Dec-2016 Global November composite PMI Unchanged at 53.3 05-Dec-2016 NZ 05-Dec-2016 US November non-manufacturing ISM Jumps to 57.2 from 54.8 in October 5-8 Dec 2016 UK 07-Dec-2016 India Reserve Bank of India (RBI) policy meeting RBI leaves policy rate unchanged at 6.25%, contrary to analyst expectations but in line with my forecast. 07-Dec-2016 Australia Q3 2016 GDP data GDP contracts 0.5% quarter-on-quarter, the first quarterly contraction in more than 5 years 07-Dec-2016 China November central bank FX reserves Central bank FX reserves fell $70bn to $3.05trn, or about $50bn accounting for estimated FX-valuation effects. 07-Dec-2016 UK October industrial output Industrial output falls 1.3% mom - largest monthly drop in four years - and manufacturing output falls 0.9% mom 07-Dec-2016 UK Supreme Court to consider government appeal of High Court's ruling that Parliament, not government, should trigger Article 50 The well-regarded and experienced Central Bank Governor Augustin Carstens, who held the post since 2010, announces he will step down in July 2017 to head up BIS President Francois Hollande announces that he will not be in a candidate for the April-May 2017 French presidential elections The well-regarded and experienced Prime Minister John Key surprises markets by announcing that he will step down as of 12 December Lower house of parliament (House of Commons) votes overwhelmingly in non-binding vote to trigger Article 50 by 31 March 2017, as per the Prime Minister Theresa May's self-imposed deadline, in exchange for the government agreeing to publish details of the government's plan for leaving the EU by 31 March 2017. Government also agrees in principle to parliament voting on the new terms and conditions of the UK's relationship with the EU.