SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 4
Download to read offline
August 12, 2010


U.S. Department of Health and Human Services
Office of the Assistant Secretary for Planning and Evaluation
Office of Planning and Policy Support
200 Independence Avenue, S.W.
Room 408-B
Washington D.C. 20201

Attn: Strategic Plan Comments


To Whom It May Concern:

The National Council for Community Behavioral Healthcare (National Council) is pleased to
respond to the Department of Health and Human Services’ (HHS) Draft Strategic Plan for
Fiscal Years 2010-2015.

The National Council, a non-profit association representing over 1700 community mental health
centers and other community-based mental health and addiction providers, is dedicated to
fostering clinical and operational innovation and promoting policies that ensure more than 6
million low-income children, adults, and families our members serve have access to high quality
services. We appreciate the opportunity to provide the following comments, and we commend
the Department on its willingness to be open and seek comments in the interest of improving
the nation's health and wellbeing.

Goal 1: Transforming Healthcare

Objective A: Make coverage more secure for those who have insurance, and extend
affordable coverage to the uninsured.
The draft strategic plan states that “this increased oversight of the insurance industry will help
insure that individuals are getting what they pay for and will make the health care system more
responsive to the needs of patients, health care providers, and other stakeholders.”

It took the passage of the Paul Wellstone and Pete Domenici Mental Health Parity and
Addictions Equity Act in 2008 to establish once and for all that substance use disorders and
mental health benefits need to be treated equally with medical/surgical benefits. The Affordable
Care Act goes a long way towards extending this understanding. However, despite the issuance
of federal regulations outlining how the MHPAEA must be implemented, there has so far been
no appreciable change in insurer behavior. In fact, early evidence indicates that insurers are
managing mental health and substance use disorders even more as a result of the law. If the
MHPAEA and the Affordable Care Act are to have their intended effect, we must monitor and
enforce this new standard.

The strategies outlined for achieving Objective A are good, but they are not enough. It is
estimated that 25% of individuals who are currently uninsured have a substance use disorder
(SUD) or mental health (MH) disorder, and that large numbers of persons will remain
uninsured in 2019. In Massachusetts’ early experience with health reform, the state found that
while only 2% of the general population remains uninsured, approximately 30% of persons
reporting to the specialty SUD system are uninsured. The introduction to Goal 1 mentions the
importance of ensuring access to care for persons with special needs – but there is nothing in
this section that describes how the health insurance exchange enrollment process will target
vulnerable populations like those with MH and SUD needs, who are likely to make up a
disproportionate share of individuals remaining uninsured under health reform. HHS should
work to financially support safety net SUD and MH organizations to do education, outreach, and
enrollment of these individuals.

Objective B: Improve health care quality and patient safety
Recent studies have consistently shown that persons with serious mental illnesses who are
clients of the public mental health system die sooner than other Americans, and have an average
age of death at 52 – largely as a result of untreated, chronic medical conditions. A 2007 federal
report found that one in fourteen stays in U.S. community hospitals involved substance
disorders, accounting for about 2.3 million hospitalizations, average stays of 4.6 days and a cost
of $2 billion nationally in 2004. According to a recently released report, Faces of Medicaid III,
49% of Medicaid beneficiaries with disabilities have a psychiatric condition (52% of dual
eligibles) and psychiatric illness is represented in three of the top five most prevalent dyads
among the highest-cost 5% of beneficiaries with disabilities.

We suggest that HHS implement specific quality improvement efforts targeting these
populations.

Objective C: Emphasize primary and preventive care linked with community
prevention services.
The National Council believes that it is not sufficient for individuals to be “informed of existing
community services that support health promotion, such as exercise programs, educational
classes, self-management training, and nutrition counseling.” The stigma surrounding mental
illness, along with cognitive impairments that may occur in individuals with mental illness,
hamper these populations from taking full advantage of these resources.

The proposed strategy of “expand[ing] community-based prevention programs to help improve
the health and quality of life of individuals with, and at risk for, chronic diseases and conditions,
and to build resilience and skills to cope with risk factors for behavioral health disorders” needs
to include targeted programs for individuals with SUD and MH disorders.

Additionally, the proposed strategy of “increase[ing]...medical homes for children, youth and
adults” needs to include elements to ensure that all medical homes take proactive steps to
explicitly identify, and coordinate treatment for SUD and MH conditions. We also encourage
HHS to promote the development of specialty medical homes for persons with severe mental
illness and chronic addiction disorders.

Objective D: reduce the growth of health care costs while promoting high-value,
effective care
The strategies outlined for achieving Objective D are sound, but we would recommend specific
attention be paid in the implementation of each strategy to the needs of persons with MH and
SUD conditions. Additionally, the introduction to this section mentions the meaningful use of
health information technology, but health IT is not mentioned as a component of the strategies.
We encourage HHS to work to ensure that SUD and MH providers are included in federal and
state efforts to support the adoption and implementation of health IT.
Objective E: ensure access to quality, culturally competent care for vulnerable
populations
The proposed strategies for achieving Objective E include: “improve access to quality care
through the prevention and correction of discriminatory actions and practices.” In accordance
with our comments on p. 1 about MH/SUD parity, the National Council urges HHS to
assertively monitor and enforce the implementation of this new standard.

In response to the proposed strategy of “support[ing] concentrated approaches to quality
improvement in service delivery programs, and build comparable focus on improvement in the
quality of behavioral health services,” the National Council also encourages HHS to support
SAMHSA in taking the lead on development of quality measures and concrete quality
improvement initiatives for the field.

Additionally, in response to the proposed strategy of “work[ing] with the Departments of
Defense and Veterans Affairs, the National Guard, and states to improve access to needed
behavioral health and supportive services for active, guard, reserve, and veteran men and
women and their families,” the National Council notes that Sec. 306 of the Caregivers and
Veterans Omnibus Health Services Act of 2010 allows the VA to contract with community
behavioral health organizations to provide care in rural areas. We suggest that HHS work with
the other federal agencies to make better use of existing SUD and MH treatment capacity in all
communities.

Objective F: Promote the adoption and meaningful use of health information
technology
Because SUD and MH agencies are not currently eligible for federal Medicare and Medicaid
incentive payments for the adoption and meaningful use of health IT, they are being excluded by
many states from health information exchanges and other efforts related to health IT. HHS
should encourage the explicit inclusion of SUD and MH agencies in evolving health IT efforts.


Goal 3: Advance the Health, Safety, and Well-Being of Our People

The National Council thanks HHS for recognizing that “substance abuse and mental illness
contribute to many of the nation's social and economic problems, as well as other health
concerns.”

Objective A: Ensure the safety, well-being, and healthy development of children
In response to the proposed strategy of “encourage[ing] healthy behaviors and reduc[ing] risky
behaviors among children and youth,” the National Council suggests that HHS mention SUD
use/misuse prevalence and specifically mention community and clinical prevention for
substance use/misuse.

Objective B: Promote economic and social well-being for individuals, families, and
communities
The National Council thanks HHS for including MH and SUD in many of the strategies for this
section. However, the strategies do not explicitly address the importance of re-entry for
incarcerated populations, despite mentioning this issue in the introduction. Populations with
mental illness and SUD face particular challenges. For example, regarding restoration of
benefits upon release, HHS could encourage states to suspend, rather than terminate, Medicaid
eligibility when an individual is incarcerated. Additionally, many policies discriminate against
persons with addictions disorders in public housing and access to benefits. The National Council
encourages HHS to address these issues with re-entry in the strategies for achieving Objective B.

Objective C: Improve the accessibility and quality of supportive services for people
with disabilities and older adults
Persons with SUD and mental illness are not mentioned at all in this section, nor is there any
mention of SAMHSA. The National Council encourages HHS to add behavioral health to
Strategies #1 and #4.

Objective D: Promote prevention and wellness
In the first strategy for this section, we encourage HHS to mention the high rate of smoking
among persons with mental illness and SUD. We suggest that these individuals be explicitly
mentioned in this strategy.

Objective E: Reduce the occurrence of infectious disease
One of the strategies included in this section is to “prevent the spread of HIV infection and
increase efforts to make people aware of their status and enable them to access HIV care and
treatment.” Given the high correlation between substance use and HIV, this section should
mention that SUD prevention and treatment are needed to reduce HIV rates in the population.


Goal 5: Strengthen the Nation's Health and Human Service Infrastructure and
Workforce

The National Council commends HHS for its plan to “fund scholarships and loan repayment
programs to increase the number of primary care physicians, nurses, physician assistants,
mental health providers, and dentists in the areas of the country that need them most.” We
suggest that addictions treatment providers be added to this list. Addiction specialty providers
should have access to loan repayment through federal programs to enhance the capacity of the
healthcare workforce.

The National Council for Community Behavioral Healthcare would like to thank the Department
of Health and Human Services the opportunity to provide comments on the Draft Strategic Plan
for Fiscal Years 2010-2015. We hope the commentary we have provided will be helpful as you
evaluate and revise the document. Please let us know if you have any questions.

Sincerely,




Linda Rosenberg, MSW
President and CEO

More Related Content

What's hot

'Wicked' Policy Challenges: Tools, Strategies and Directions for Driving Ment...
'Wicked' Policy Challenges: Tools, Strategies and Directions for Driving Ment...'Wicked' Policy Challenges: Tools, Strategies and Directions for Driving Ment...
'Wicked' Policy Challenges: Tools, Strategies and Directions for Driving Ment...Wellesley Institute
 
Health Care Reform and Harm Reduction: Laura Hanen, Rachel McLean - HRC 2010
Health Care Reform and Harm Reduction: Laura Hanen, Rachel McLean - HRC 2010Health Care Reform and Harm Reduction: Laura Hanen, Rachel McLean - HRC 2010
Health Care Reform and Harm Reduction: Laura Hanen, Rachel McLean - HRC 2010Harm Reduction Coalition
 
Health sector reforms
Health sector reformsHealth sector reforms
Health sector reformsVikash Keshri
 
Towards a Healthier Ontario: Social Determinants of Health as a Framework for...
Towards a Healthier Ontario: Social Determinants of Health as a Framework for...Towards a Healthier Ontario: Social Determinants of Health as a Framework for...
Towards a Healthier Ontario: Social Determinants of Health as a Framework for...Wellesley Institute
 
HCS 410(2) ACA Tittle IV-Prevention of Chronic diseases
HCS 410(2) ACA Tittle IV-Prevention of Chronic diseasesHCS 410(2) ACA Tittle IV-Prevention of Chronic diseases
HCS 410(2) ACA Tittle IV-Prevention of Chronic diseasesMaria Jimenez
 
Public private partnerships final report 2004
Public private partnerships final report 2004Public private partnerships final report 2004
Public private partnerships final report 2004apblair
 
WA DOH State Plan for Healthy Communities Recommended Changes - PowerPoint - ...
WA DOH State Plan for Healthy Communities Recommended Changes - PowerPoint - ...WA DOH State Plan for Healthy Communities Recommended Changes - PowerPoint - ...
WA DOH State Plan for Healthy Communities Recommended Changes - PowerPoint - ...James Harvey, Ed.S., BCPC, AAC
 
Social Health insurance of Nepal
Social Health insurance of NepalSocial Health insurance of Nepal
Social Health insurance of NepalSonali Shah
 
Universal health care in the United States
Universal health care in the United StatesUniversal health care in the United States
Universal health care in the United StatesHussain Al-ghawi
 
FQHC 101 What is a Community Health Center?
FQHC 101 What is a Community Health Center?FQHC 101 What is a Community Health Center?
FQHC 101 What is a Community Health Center?CFAHC
 
Population Health Management Presentation
Population Health Management PresentationPopulation Health Management Presentation
Population Health Management PresentationCANorfolk
 
Universal Healthcare - Dr. Srinath Reddy Report to Planning Commision
Universal Healthcare -  Dr. Srinath Reddy Report to Planning CommisionUniversal Healthcare -  Dr. Srinath Reddy Report to Planning Commision
Universal Healthcare - Dr. Srinath Reddy Report to Planning CommisionAnup Soans
 
Leicester - Patients in Control
Leicester - Patients in ControlLeicester - Patients in Control
Leicester - Patients in ControlNHSOpenHouse
 

What's hot (20)

Swastha
SwasthaSwastha
Swastha
 
'Wicked' Policy Challenges: Tools, Strategies and Directions for Driving Ment...
'Wicked' Policy Challenges: Tools, Strategies and Directions for Driving Ment...'Wicked' Policy Challenges: Tools, Strategies and Directions for Driving Ment...
'Wicked' Policy Challenges: Tools, Strategies and Directions for Driving Ment...
 
Health Care Reform and Harm Reduction: Laura Hanen, Rachel McLean - HRC 2010
Health Care Reform and Harm Reduction: Laura Hanen, Rachel McLean - HRC 2010Health Care Reform and Harm Reduction: Laura Hanen, Rachel McLean - HRC 2010
Health Care Reform and Harm Reduction: Laura Hanen, Rachel McLean - HRC 2010
 
Health sector reforms
Health sector reformsHealth sector reforms
Health sector reforms
 
Towards a Healthier Ontario: Social Determinants of Health as a Framework for...
Towards a Healthier Ontario: Social Determinants of Health as a Framework for...Towards a Healthier Ontario: Social Determinants of Health as a Framework for...
Towards a Healthier Ontario: Social Determinants of Health as a Framework for...
 
Final comments meaningful use
Final comments meaningful useFinal comments meaningful use
Final comments meaningful use
 
HCS 410(2) ACA Tittle IV-Prevention of Chronic diseases
HCS 410(2) ACA Tittle IV-Prevention of Chronic diseasesHCS 410(2) ACA Tittle IV-Prevention of Chronic diseases
HCS 410(2) ACA Tittle IV-Prevention of Chronic diseases
 
Public private partnerships final report 2004
Public private partnerships final report 2004Public private partnerships final report 2004
Public private partnerships final report 2004
 
PolicyMaker Case history: Clinton's health reform
PolicyMaker Case history: Clinton's health reformPolicyMaker Case history: Clinton's health reform
PolicyMaker Case history: Clinton's health reform
 
WA DOH State Plan for Healthy Communities Recommended Changes - PowerPoint - ...
WA DOH State Plan for Healthy Communities Recommended Changes - PowerPoint - ...WA DOH State Plan for Healthy Communities Recommended Changes - PowerPoint - ...
WA DOH State Plan for Healthy Communities Recommended Changes - PowerPoint - ...
 
Social Health insurance of Nepal
Social Health insurance of NepalSocial Health insurance of Nepal
Social Health insurance of Nepal
 
Universal health care in the United States
Universal health care in the United StatesUniversal health care in the United States
Universal health care in the United States
 
Swimming upstream _patient_protection_and.2
Swimming upstream _patient_protection_and.2Swimming upstream _patient_protection_and.2
Swimming upstream _patient_protection_and.2
 
FQHC 101 What is a Community Health Center?
FQHC 101 What is a Community Health Center?FQHC 101 What is a Community Health Center?
FQHC 101 What is a Community Health Center?
 
Sanjeevani2
Sanjeevani2Sanjeevani2
Sanjeevani2
 
Population Health Management Presentation
Population Health Management PresentationPopulation Health Management Presentation
Population Health Management Presentation
 
Universal Healthcare - Dr. Srinath Reddy Report to Planning Commision
Universal Healthcare -  Dr. Srinath Reddy Report to Planning CommisionUniversal Healthcare -  Dr. Srinath Reddy Report to Planning Commision
Universal Healthcare - Dr. Srinath Reddy Report to Planning Commision
 
ACAIL-IDOC
ACAIL-IDOCACAIL-IDOC
ACAIL-IDOC
 
Health Insurance in Nepal
Health Insurance in NepalHealth Insurance in Nepal
Health Insurance in Nepal
 
Leicester - Patients in Control
Leicester - Patients in ControlLeicester - Patients in Control
Leicester - Patients in Control
 

Similar to Comments on the hhs strategic plan 2010

Strategic framework chronic conditions
Strategic framework chronic conditionsStrategic framework chronic conditions
Strategic framework chronic conditionsThe National Council
 
Universal Health Coverage: Frequently Asked Questions
Universal Health Coverage: Frequently Asked QuestionsUniversal Health Coverage: Frequently Asked Questions
Universal Health Coverage: Frequently Asked QuestionsHFG Project
 
Partnering with Patients, Families and Communities for Health: A Global Imper...
Partnering with Patients, Families and Communities for Health: A Global Imper...Partnering with Patients, Families and Communities for Health: A Global Imper...
Partnering with Patients, Families and Communities for Health: A Global Imper...EngagingPatients
 
National health policy_2017
National health policy_2017National health policy_2017
National health policy_2017Anil Pandey
 
Module 6- Policy Implications(1) (1).pptx
Module 6- Policy Implications(1) (1).pptxModule 6- Policy Implications(1) (1).pptx
Module 6- Policy Implications(1) (1).pptxDavidOsunde
 
Running Head MEDICARE POLICY Of 2019 MEDICARE POLIC.docx
Running Head MEDICARE POLICY Of 2019      MEDICARE POLIC.docxRunning Head MEDICARE POLICY Of 2019      MEDICARE POLIC.docx
Running Head MEDICARE POLICY Of 2019 MEDICARE POLIC.docxglendar3
 
Running Head MEDICARE POLICY Of 2019 MEDICARE POLIC.docx
Running Head MEDICARE POLICY Of 2019      MEDICARE POLIC.docxRunning Head MEDICARE POLICY Of 2019      MEDICARE POLIC.docx
Running Head MEDICARE POLICY Of 2019 MEDICARE POLIC.docxtodd581
 
NURS612 Population Health Essay.docx
NURS612 Population Health Essay.docxNURS612 Population Health Essay.docx
NURS612 Population Health Essay.docx4934bk
 
You should respond to at least two of your peers by extending- refutin.docx
You should respond to at least two of your peers by extending- refutin.docxYou should respond to at least two of your peers by extending- refutin.docx
You should respond to at least two of your peers by extending- refutin.docxjosee57
 
SOCW 6351 Wk 9 Discussion 1. Need Responses.Respond in one of t.docx
SOCW 6351 Wk 9 Discussion 1.  Need Responses.Respond in one of t.docxSOCW 6351 Wk 9 Discussion 1.  Need Responses.Respond in one of t.docx
SOCW 6351 Wk 9 Discussion 1. Need Responses.Respond in one of t.docxrosemariebrayshaw
 
PCG Human Services White Paper - Cross-System Approaches That Promote Child W...
PCG Human Services White Paper - Cross-System Approaches That Promote Child W...PCG Human Services White Paper - Cross-System Approaches That Promote Child W...
PCG Human Services White Paper - Cross-System Approaches That Promote Child W...Public Consulting Group
 
Assignment 1Public Administration – The Good, th.docx
Assignment 1Public Administration – The Good, th.docxAssignment 1Public Administration – The Good, th.docx
Assignment 1Public Administration – The Good, th.docxtrippettjettie
 
Running head WELLNESS EDUCATION PROGRAM 1 Copyright ©2017.docx
Running head WELLNESS EDUCATION PROGRAM 1 Copyright ©2017.docxRunning head WELLNESS EDUCATION PROGRAM 1 Copyright ©2017.docx
Running head WELLNESS EDUCATION PROGRAM 1 Copyright ©2017.docxrtodd599
 
From State to Service
From State to ServiceFrom State to Service
From State to Servicehughesl3
 
The High Achieving Governmental Health Department in 2020 as the Community Ch...
The High Achieving Governmental Health Department in 2020 as the Community Ch...The High Achieving Governmental Health Department in 2020 as the Community Ch...
The High Achieving Governmental Health Department in 2020 as the Community Ch...Tomas J. Aragon
 
AHF ACA Workshop: Dr. Haig, Clinicas de Salud del Pueblo
AHF ACA Workshop: Dr. Haig, Clinicas de Salud del PuebloAHF ACA Workshop: Dr. Haig, Clinicas de Salud del Pueblo
AHF ACA Workshop: Dr. Haig, Clinicas de Salud del PuebloAlliance Healthcare Foundation
 

Similar to Comments on the hhs strategic plan 2010 (20)

Health Reform in 2013
Health Reform in 2013Health Reform in 2013
Health Reform in 2013
 
Strategic framework chronic conditions
Strategic framework chronic conditionsStrategic framework chronic conditions
Strategic framework chronic conditions
 
Universal Health Coverage: Frequently Asked Questions
Universal Health Coverage: Frequently Asked QuestionsUniversal Health Coverage: Frequently Asked Questions
Universal Health Coverage: Frequently Asked Questions
 
Partnering with Patients, Families and Communities for Health: A Global Imper...
Partnering with Patients, Families and Communities for Health: A Global Imper...Partnering with Patients, Families and Communities for Health: A Global Imper...
Partnering with Patients, Families and Communities for Health: A Global Imper...
 
National health policy 2017
National health policy 2017 National health policy 2017
National health policy 2017
 
National health policy_2017
National health policy_2017National health policy_2017
National health policy_2017
 
CHAPTER THREE CH.docx
CHAPTER THREE CH.docxCHAPTER THREE CH.docx
CHAPTER THREE CH.docx
 
Module 6- Policy Implications(1) (1).pptx
Module 6- Policy Implications(1) (1).pptxModule 6- Policy Implications(1) (1).pptx
Module 6- Policy Implications(1) (1).pptx
 
Running Head MEDICARE POLICY Of 2019 MEDICARE POLIC.docx
Running Head MEDICARE POLICY Of 2019      MEDICARE POLIC.docxRunning Head MEDICARE POLICY Of 2019      MEDICARE POLIC.docx
Running Head MEDICARE POLICY Of 2019 MEDICARE POLIC.docx
 
Running Head MEDICARE POLICY Of 2019 MEDICARE POLIC.docx
Running Head MEDICARE POLICY Of 2019      MEDICARE POLIC.docxRunning Head MEDICARE POLICY Of 2019      MEDICARE POLIC.docx
Running Head MEDICARE POLICY Of 2019 MEDICARE POLIC.docx
 
NURS612 Population Health Essay.docx
NURS612 Population Health Essay.docxNURS612 Population Health Essay.docx
NURS612 Population Health Essay.docx
 
You should respond to at least two of your peers by extending- refutin.docx
You should respond to at least two of your peers by extending- refutin.docxYou should respond to at least two of your peers by extending- refutin.docx
You should respond to at least two of your peers by extending- refutin.docx
 
SOCW 6351 Wk 9 Discussion 1. Need Responses.Respond in one of t.docx
SOCW 6351 Wk 9 Discussion 1.  Need Responses.Respond in one of t.docxSOCW 6351 Wk 9 Discussion 1.  Need Responses.Respond in one of t.docx
SOCW 6351 Wk 9 Discussion 1. Need Responses.Respond in one of t.docx
 
PCG Human Services White Paper - Cross-System Approaches That Promote Child W...
PCG Human Services White Paper - Cross-System Approaches That Promote Child W...PCG Human Services White Paper - Cross-System Approaches That Promote Child W...
PCG Human Services White Paper - Cross-System Approaches That Promote Child W...
 
Assignment 1Public Administration – The Good, th.docx
Assignment 1Public Administration – The Good, th.docxAssignment 1Public Administration – The Good, th.docx
Assignment 1Public Administration – The Good, th.docx
 
Running head WELLNESS EDUCATION PROGRAM 1 Copyright ©2017.docx
Running head WELLNESS EDUCATION PROGRAM 1 Copyright ©2017.docxRunning head WELLNESS EDUCATION PROGRAM 1 Copyright ©2017.docx
Running head WELLNESS EDUCATION PROGRAM 1 Copyright ©2017.docx
 
From State to Service
From State to ServiceFrom State to Service
From State to Service
 
CHWs_Report_2016
CHWs_Report_2016CHWs_Report_2016
CHWs_Report_2016
 
The High Achieving Governmental Health Department in 2020 as the Community Ch...
The High Achieving Governmental Health Department in 2020 as the Community Ch...The High Achieving Governmental Health Department in 2020 as the Community Ch...
The High Achieving Governmental Health Department in 2020 as the Community Ch...
 
AHF ACA Workshop: Dr. Haig, Clinicas de Salud del Pueblo
AHF ACA Workshop: Dr. Haig, Clinicas de Salud del PuebloAHF ACA Workshop: Dr. Haig, Clinicas de Salud del Pueblo
AHF ACA Workshop: Dr. Haig, Clinicas de Salud del Pueblo
 

More from The National Council

20100922 nccbh avalere employer webinar final
20100922 nccbh avalere employer webinar final20100922 nccbh avalere employer webinar final
20100922 nccbh avalere employer webinar finalThe National Council
 
National council live avalere responses
National council live avalere responsesNational council live avalere responses
National council live avalere responsesThe National Council
 
20100922 nccbh avalere employer webinar final
20100922 nccbh avalere employer webinar final20100922 nccbh avalere employer webinar final
20100922 nccbh avalere employer webinar finalThe National Council
 
Continuum of Care (CoC) Homeless Assistance Grant Program
Continuum of Care (CoC) Homeless Assistance Grant ProgramContinuum of Care (CoC) Homeless Assistance Grant Program
Continuum of Care (CoC) Homeless Assistance Grant ProgramThe National Council
 
Ccd prevention regulation comments draft
Ccd prevention regulation comments  draftCcd prevention regulation comments  draft
Ccd prevention regulation comments draftThe National Council
 
September 2010 draft preventive services comments
September 2010 draft preventive services commentsSeptember 2010 draft preventive services comments
September 2010 draft preventive services commentsThe National Council
 
Ccd prevention regulation comments draft
Ccd prevention regulation comments  draftCcd prevention regulation comments  draft
Ccd prevention regulation comments draftThe National Council
 
Hill briefing 9 22-10 rosenberg comments
Hill briefing 9 22-10 rosenberg commentsHill briefing 9 22-10 rosenberg comments
Hill briefing 9 22-10 rosenberg commentsThe National Council
 
Comments on modern addictions and mental health system
Comments on modern addictions and mental health systemComments on modern addictions and mental health system
Comments on modern addictions and mental health systemThe National Council
 
Community to fiscal commission september 2010 final 2
Community to fiscal commission september 2010 final  2 Community to fiscal commission september 2010 final  2
Community to fiscal commission september 2010 final 2 The National Council
 
Draft comments on external appeals
Draft comments on external appealsDraft comments on external appeals
Draft comments on external appealsThe National Council
 
Mh and addiction services for service members and veterans
Mh and addiction services for service members and veteransMh and addiction services for service members and veterans
Mh and addiction services for service members and veteransThe National Council
 
Mh and addiction services for service members and veterans
Mh and addiction services for service members and veteransMh and addiction services for service members and veterans
Mh and addiction services for service members and veteransThe National Council
 

More from The National Council (20)

TNC Meaningful Use Webinar
TNC Meaningful Use WebinarTNC Meaningful Use Webinar
TNC Meaningful Use Webinar
 
20100922 nccbh avalere employer webinar final
20100922 nccbh avalere employer webinar final20100922 nccbh avalere employer webinar final
20100922 nccbh avalere employer webinar final
 
National council live avalere responses
National council live avalere responsesNational council live avalere responses
National council live avalere responses
 
20100922 nccbh avalere employer webinar final
20100922 nccbh avalere employer webinar final20100922 nccbh avalere employer webinar final
20100922 nccbh avalere employer webinar final
 
Conference 2010 final program
Conference 2010 final programConference 2010 final program
Conference 2010 final program
 
Samhsa si paper
Samhsa si paperSamhsa si paper
Samhsa si paper
 
Toolkit final
Toolkit finalToolkit final
Toolkit final
 
Continuum of Care (CoC) Homeless Assistance Grant Program
Continuum of Care (CoC) Homeless Assistance Grant ProgramContinuum of Care (CoC) Homeless Assistance Grant Program
Continuum of Care (CoC) Homeless Assistance Grant Program
 
Cfp chl2010
Cfp chl2010Cfp chl2010
Cfp chl2010
 
Ccd prevention regulation comments draft
Ccd prevention regulation comments  draftCcd prevention regulation comments  draft
Ccd prevention regulation comments draft
 
September 2010 draft preventive services comments
September 2010 draft preventive services commentsSeptember 2010 draft preventive services comments
September 2010 draft preventive services comments
 
Ccd prevention regulation comments draft
Ccd prevention regulation comments  draftCcd prevention regulation comments  draft
Ccd prevention regulation comments draft
 
Hill briefing 9 22-10 rosenberg comments
Hill briefing 9 22-10 rosenberg commentsHill briefing 9 22-10 rosenberg comments
Hill briefing 9 22-10 rosenberg comments
 
Hhsgovernorlettermfp
HhsgovernorlettermfpHhsgovernorlettermfp
Hhsgovernorlettermfp
 
Comments on modern addictions and mental health system
Comments on modern addictions and mental health systemComments on modern addictions and mental health system
Comments on modern addictions and mental health system
 
Community to fiscal commission september 2010 final 2
Community to fiscal commission september 2010 final  2 Community to fiscal commission september 2010 final  2
Community to fiscal commission september 2010 final 2
 
Draft comments on external appeals
Draft comments on external appealsDraft comments on external appeals
Draft comments on external appeals
 
Nc mag veterans final
Nc mag veterans finalNc mag veterans final
Nc mag veterans final
 
Mh and addiction services for service members and veterans
Mh and addiction services for service members and veteransMh and addiction services for service members and veterans
Mh and addiction services for service members and veterans
 
Mh and addiction services for service members and veterans
Mh and addiction services for service members and veteransMh and addiction services for service members and veterans
Mh and addiction services for service members and veterans
 

Comments on the hhs strategic plan 2010

  • 1. August 12, 2010 U.S. Department of Health and Human Services Office of the Assistant Secretary for Planning and Evaluation Office of Planning and Policy Support 200 Independence Avenue, S.W. Room 408-B Washington D.C. 20201 Attn: Strategic Plan Comments To Whom It May Concern: The National Council for Community Behavioral Healthcare (National Council) is pleased to respond to the Department of Health and Human Services’ (HHS) Draft Strategic Plan for Fiscal Years 2010-2015. The National Council, a non-profit association representing over 1700 community mental health centers and other community-based mental health and addiction providers, is dedicated to fostering clinical and operational innovation and promoting policies that ensure more than 6 million low-income children, adults, and families our members serve have access to high quality services. We appreciate the opportunity to provide the following comments, and we commend the Department on its willingness to be open and seek comments in the interest of improving the nation's health and wellbeing. Goal 1: Transforming Healthcare Objective A: Make coverage more secure for those who have insurance, and extend affordable coverage to the uninsured. The draft strategic plan states that “this increased oversight of the insurance industry will help insure that individuals are getting what they pay for and will make the health care system more responsive to the needs of patients, health care providers, and other stakeholders.” It took the passage of the Paul Wellstone and Pete Domenici Mental Health Parity and Addictions Equity Act in 2008 to establish once and for all that substance use disorders and mental health benefits need to be treated equally with medical/surgical benefits. The Affordable Care Act goes a long way towards extending this understanding. However, despite the issuance of federal regulations outlining how the MHPAEA must be implemented, there has so far been no appreciable change in insurer behavior. In fact, early evidence indicates that insurers are managing mental health and substance use disorders even more as a result of the law. If the MHPAEA and the Affordable Care Act are to have their intended effect, we must monitor and enforce this new standard. The strategies outlined for achieving Objective A are good, but they are not enough. It is estimated that 25% of individuals who are currently uninsured have a substance use disorder (SUD) or mental health (MH) disorder, and that large numbers of persons will remain uninsured in 2019. In Massachusetts’ early experience with health reform, the state found that while only 2% of the general population remains uninsured, approximately 30% of persons
  • 2. reporting to the specialty SUD system are uninsured. The introduction to Goal 1 mentions the importance of ensuring access to care for persons with special needs – but there is nothing in this section that describes how the health insurance exchange enrollment process will target vulnerable populations like those with MH and SUD needs, who are likely to make up a disproportionate share of individuals remaining uninsured under health reform. HHS should work to financially support safety net SUD and MH organizations to do education, outreach, and enrollment of these individuals. Objective B: Improve health care quality and patient safety Recent studies have consistently shown that persons with serious mental illnesses who are clients of the public mental health system die sooner than other Americans, and have an average age of death at 52 – largely as a result of untreated, chronic medical conditions. A 2007 federal report found that one in fourteen stays in U.S. community hospitals involved substance disorders, accounting for about 2.3 million hospitalizations, average stays of 4.6 days and a cost of $2 billion nationally in 2004. According to a recently released report, Faces of Medicaid III, 49% of Medicaid beneficiaries with disabilities have a psychiatric condition (52% of dual eligibles) and psychiatric illness is represented in three of the top five most prevalent dyads among the highest-cost 5% of beneficiaries with disabilities. We suggest that HHS implement specific quality improvement efforts targeting these populations. Objective C: Emphasize primary and preventive care linked with community prevention services. The National Council believes that it is not sufficient for individuals to be “informed of existing community services that support health promotion, such as exercise programs, educational classes, self-management training, and nutrition counseling.” The stigma surrounding mental illness, along with cognitive impairments that may occur in individuals with mental illness, hamper these populations from taking full advantage of these resources. The proposed strategy of “expand[ing] community-based prevention programs to help improve the health and quality of life of individuals with, and at risk for, chronic diseases and conditions, and to build resilience and skills to cope with risk factors for behavioral health disorders” needs to include targeted programs for individuals with SUD and MH disorders. Additionally, the proposed strategy of “increase[ing]...medical homes for children, youth and adults” needs to include elements to ensure that all medical homes take proactive steps to explicitly identify, and coordinate treatment for SUD and MH conditions. We also encourage HHS to promote the development of specialty medical homes for persons with severe mental illness and chronic addiction disorders. Objective D: reduce the growth of health care costs while promoting high-value, effective care The strategies outlined for achieving Objective D are sound, but we would recommend specific attention be paid in the implementation of each strategy to the needs of persons with MH and SUD conditions. Additionally, the introduction to this section mentions the meaningful use of health information technology, but health IT is not mentioned as a component of the strategies. We encourage HHS to work to ensure that SUD and MH providers are included in federal and state efforts to support the adoption and implementation of health IT.
  • 3. Objective E: ensure access to quality, culturally competent care for vulnerable populations The proposed strategies for achieving Objective E include: “improve access to quality care through the prevention and correction of discriminatory actions and practices.” In accordance with our comments on p. 1 about MH/SUD parity, the National Council urges HHS to assertively monitor and enforce the implementation of this new standard. In response to the proposed strategy of “support[ing] concentrated approaches to quality improvement in service delivery programs, and build comparable focus on improvement in the quality of behavioral health services,” the National Council also encourages HHS to support SAMHSA in taking the lead on development of quality measures and concrete quality improvement initiatives for the field. Additionally, in response to the proposed strategy of “work[ing] with the Departments of Defense and Veterans Affairs, the National Guard, and states to improve access to needed behavioral health and supportive services for active, guard, reserve, and veteran men and women and their families,” the National Council notes that Sec. 306 of the Caregivers and Veterans Omnibus Health Services Act of 2010 allows the VA to contract with community behavioral health organizations to provide care in rural areas. We suggest that HHS work with the other federal agencies to make better use of existing SUD and MH treatment capacity in all communities. Objective F: Promote the adoption and meaningful use of health information technology Because SUD and MH agencies are not currently eligible for federal Medicare and Medicaid incentive payments for the adoption and meaningful use of health IT, they are being excluded by many states from health information exchanges and other efforts related to health IT. HHS should encourage the explicit inclusion of SUD and MH agencies in evolving health IT efforts. Goal 3: Advance the Health, Safety, and Well-Being of Our People The National Council thanks HHS for recognizing that “substance abuse and mental illness contribute to many of the nation's social and economic problems, as well as other health concerns.” Objective A: Ensure the safety, well-being, and healthy development of children In response to the proposed strategy of “encourage[ing] healthy behaviors and reduc[ing] risky behaviors among children and youth,” the National Council suggests that HHS mention SUD use/misuse prevalence and specifically mention community and clinical prevention for substance use/misuse. Objective B: Promote economic and social well-being for individuals, families, and communities The National Council thanks HHS for including MH and SUD in many of the strategies for this section. However, the strategies do not explicitly address the importance of re-entry for incarcerated populations, despite mentioning this issue in the introduction. Populations with mental illness and SUD face particular challenges. For example, regarding restoration of benefits upon release, HHS could encourage states to suspend, rather than terminate, Medicaid eligibility when an individual is incarcerated. Additionally, many policies discriminate against
  • 4. persons with addictions disorders in public housing and access to benefits. The National Council encourages HHS to address these issues with re-entry in the strategies for achieving Objective B. Objective C: Improve the accessibility and quality of supportive services for people with disabilities and older adults Persons with SUD and mental illness are not mentioned at all in this section, nor is there any mention of SAMHSA. The National Council encourages HHS to add behavioral health to Strategies #1 and #4. Objective D: Promote prevention and wellness In the first strategy for this section, we encourage HHS to mention the high rate of smoking among persons with mental illness and SUD. We suggest that these individuals be explicitly mentioned in this strategy. Objective E: Reduce the occurrence of infectious disease One of the strategies included in this section is to “prevent the spread of HIV infection and increase efforts to make people aware of their status and enable them to access HIV care and treatment.” Given the high correlation between substance use and HIV, this section should mention that SUD prevention and treatment are needed to reduce HIV rates in the population. Goal 5: Strengthen the Nation's Health and Human Service Infrastructure and Workforce The National Council commends HHS for its plan to “fund scholarships and loan repayment programs to increase the number of primary care physicians, nurses, physician assistants, mental health providers, and dentists in the areas of the country that need them most.” We suggest that addictions treatment providers be added to this list. Addiction specialty providers should have access to loan repayment through federal programs to enhance the capacity of the healthcare workforce. The National Council for Community Behavioral Healthcare would like to thank the Department of Health and Human Services the opportunity to provide comments on the Draft Strategic Plan for Fiscal Years 2010-2015. We hope the commentary we have provided will be helpful as you evaluate and revise the document. Please let us know if you have any questions. Sincerely, Linda Rosenberg, MSW President and CEO