SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 18
Peer Review Process
Introduction to peer review
What is Peer Review Process?
Peer review process is the system used to assess the quality of a
manuscript before it is published online. Independent
professionals/experts/researchers in the relevant research area
are subjected to assess the submitted manuscripts for originality,
validity and significance to help editors determine whether a
manuscript should be published in their journal.
This Peer review process helps in validating the research works,
establish a method by which it can be evaluated and increase
networking possibilities within research communities. Despite
criticisms, peer review is still the only widely accepted method for
research validation
Only the articles that meet good scientific standards,
explanations, records and proofs of their work presented with
Bibliographic reasoning (e.g., acknowledge and build upon other
work in the field, rely on logical reasoning and well-designed
studies, back up claims with evidence etc.) are accepted for
publication in the Journal.
Peer Review Process
Types of Peer Review Process
Single Blind
In a single-blind peer review process, authors are unaware of who
reviewed their paper, but reviewers are aware of the authors’
identity. While this method serves to reduce chances of bias or
conflict of interest, there is a possibility that making the author’s
identity known could influence the review.
Double Blind
In a double-blind peer review both the author and peer reviewers
are not aware of each other’s identity. Peer-reviewed articles
provide a trusted form of scientific communication as it is
scrutinized only based on the content provided irrespective of the
submitted person or the area of submission.
There is also another type of Review process:
Many journals have adopted even open peer review. In this
model, the author's and reviewers' identities are known to each
other.
What We follow?
We generally follow Double blind peer review process, in which
both the authors and the editors who are going to review the
papers submitted and approve for publication are unaware of
each other’s identity. In this Process the Managing Director of the
journal assigns the articles, received from the researchers to the
Reviewers along with an Electronic review form, in which the
Reviewers are initially supposed to check the scope of the
manuscript whether fits to the journal or not then, they need to
fill the form of a questionnaire and at the end they will provide
their comments or any suggestions/edits in the paper (if required)
(sometimes may ask for the results that they have got with
proofs) to approve the manuscript for publication in the journal.
This forms the basis for deciding whether the work should be
accepted, considered acceptable with revisions, or rejected.
Submissions with serious failings will be rejected, though they can
be re-submitted once they have been thoroughly revised.
If a work is rejected, this does not necessarily mean it is of poor
quality. A paper may also be rejected because it doesn't fall within
the journal's area of specialization or because it doesn't meet the
high standards of novelty and originality required by the journal in
question.
The journal will publish the paper if the reviewer suggests only
minor edits but before that the author is asked to make those
corrections.
How Does It Work?
For authors, peer review policy provides a patina of respectability
on their work. A scientist who publishes in his field's most
prestigious journal gets to bask in the glow of the publication's
reputation. He may get called for more interviews and may have
future research viewed more favorably by funding bodies.
For journal editors, peer review informs their decision-making
process. An editor can publish a paper with much greater
confidence if he knows that paper has been thoroughly vetted by
a team of qualified referees. The editor's management of the
peer-review process is directly related to the reputation of the
journal. If he consistently selects papers of the highest quality, he
will enhance the reputation of his journal. If, on the other hand,
he allows the occasional substandard paper to be published, he
can erode the journal's credibility.
For other Readers, peer review process acts as a mechanism to
help prioritize what they read. By focusing only peer reviewed
journals in their field, a reader can assume they are reading the
most important papers of the highest quality. It's sort of like using
the New York Times bestseller list to determine which novel
you're going to read next.
Current Top Journals.
Lupine Publishers peer review process
Lupine Publishers peer review process
Lupine Publishers peer review process
Lupine Publishers peer review process
Lupine Publishers peer review process
Lupine Publishers peer review process
Lupine Publishers peer review process
Lupine Publishers peer review process
Lupine Publishers peer review process
Lupine Publishers peer review process
Lupine Publishers peer review process
Lupine Publishers peer review process
Lupine Publishers peer review process

More Related Content

What's hot

Peer reviewed journals 2013
Peer reviewed journals 2013Peer reviewed journals 2013
Peer reviewed journals 2013
BSCLibrary
 

What's hot (20)

Salami Publication
Salami PublicationSalami Publication
Salami Publication
 
Avoid salami slicing and duplicate publication
Avoid salami slicing and duplicate publicationAvoid salami slicing and duplicate publication
Avoid salami slicing and duplicate publication
 
The pitfalls of “salami slicing” focus on quality and not quantity of publica...
The pitfalls of “salami slicing” focus on quality and not quantity of publica...The pitfalls of “salami slicing” focus on quality and not quantity of publica...
The pitfalls of “salami slicing” focus on quality and not quantity of publica...
 
Running a journal club
Running a journal clubRunning a journal club
Running a journal club
 
Presentation on journal suggestion tool and journal finder
Presentation on journal suggestion tool and journal finderPresentation on journal suggestion tool and journal finder
Presentation on journal suggestion tool and journal finder
 
What is journal club an overview zoheb
What is journal club an overview zohebWhat is journal club an overview zoheb
What is journal club an overview zoheb
 
What is a literature review?
What is a literature review?What is a literature review?
What is a literature review?
 
Salami Slicing in Research Publications
Salami Slicing in Research PublicationsSalami Slicing in Research Publications
Salami Slicing in Research Publications
 
Peer reviewed journals 2013
Peer reviewed journals 2013Peer reviewed journals 2013
Peer reviewed journals 2013
 
Choosing the Right Journal
Choosing the Right JournalChoosing the Right Journal
Choosing the Right Journal
 
Does Social Psychology Really Have More Retractions?
Does Social Psychology Really Have More Retractions?Does Social Psychology Really Have More Retractions?
Does Social Psychology Really Have More Retractions?
 
Duplicate publications and simultaneous submissions
Duplicate publications and simultaneous submissionsDuplicate publications and simultaneous submissions
Duplicate publications and simultaneous submissions
 
Rmc0001 research publications & ethics - module 3 (5)
Rmc0001  research publications & ethics - module 3 (5)Rmc0001  research publications & ethics - module 3 (5)
Rmc0001 research publications & ethics - module 3 (5)
 
Refereed journal google scholar
Refereed journal google scholarRefereed journal google scholar
Refereed journal google scholar
 
Journal knowhows
Journal  knowhows Journal  knowhows
Journal knowhows
 
Why You Should Not Use The Journal Impact Factor To Evaluate Research
Why You Should Not Use The Journal Impact Factor To Evaluate ResearchWhy You Should Not Use The Journal Impact Factor To Evaluate Research
Why You Should Not Use The Journal Impact Factor To Evaluate Research
 
Journal Briefing Dr. Rangappa.S.Ashi, Associate professor SDM Institute of N...
Journal  Briefing Dr. Rangappa.S.Ashi, Associate professor SDM Institute of N...Journal  Briefing Dr. Rangappa.S.Ashi, Associate professor SDM Institute of N...
Journal Briefing Dr. Rangappa.S.Ashi, Associate professor SDM Institute of N...
 
Predatory publishers and journals
Predatory publishers and journalsPredatory publishers and journals
Predatory publishers and journals
 
Peer review presentation
Peer review presentationPeer review presentation
Peer review presentation
 
How to Initiate and Promote Research in Health V1
How to Initiate and Promote Research in Health V1 How to Initiate and Promote Research in Health V1
How to Initiate and Promote Research in Health V1
 

Similar to Lupine Publishers peer review process

As a system for advancing knowledge, science requires that investi.docx
As a system for advancing knowledge, science requires that investi.docxAs a system for advancing knowledge, science requires that investi.docx
As a system for advancing knowledge, science requires that investi.docx
fredharris32
 

Similar to Lupine Publishers peer review process (20)

How to Review a Manuscript (By Elesvier)
How to Review a Manuscript (By Elesvier)How to Review a Manuscript (By Elesvier)
How to Review a Manuscript (By Elesvier)
 
Academic manuscript to Publication
Academic manuscript to PublicationAcademic manuscript to Publication
Academic manuscript to Publication
 
L7.pptx
L7.pptxL7.pptx
L7.pptx
 
How to get peer reviewed
How to get peer reviewedHow to get peer reviewed
How to get peer reviewed
 
The future of peer review mariette enslin tand_f_indaba
The future of peer review mariette enslin tand_f_indabaThe future of peer review mariette enslin tand_f_indaba
The future of peer review mariette enslin tand_f_indaba
 
academic journals
academic journalsacademic journals
academic journals
 
What is peer review of a manuscript. benefits of peer-reviewing a manuscript ...
What is peer review of a manuscript. benefits of peer-reviewing a manuscript ...What is peer review of a manuscript. benefits of peer-reviewing a manuscript ...
What is peer review of a manuscript. benefits of peer-reviewing a manuscript ...
 
Journal Submission | Research journal | Qualitative research journal
Journal Submission | Research journal | Qualitative research journalJournal Submission | Research journal | Qualitative research journal
Journal Submission | Research journal | Qualitative research journal
 
As a system for advancing knowledge, science requires that investi.docx
As a system for advancing knowledge, science requires that investi.docxAs a system for advancing knowledge, science requires that investi.docx
As a system for advancing knowledge, science requires that investi.docx
 
How to select a journal to publish Article
How to select a journal to publish ArticleHow to select a journal to publish Article
How to select a journal to publish Article
 
PubMed peer reviewed | Manuscript peer review | illuminated manuscripts
PubMed peer reviewed | Manuscript peer review | illuminated manuscriptsPubMed peer reviewed | Manuscript peer review | illuminated manuscripts
PubMed peer reviewed | Manuscript peer review | illuminated manuscripts
 
Reviewing a journal article - Professor Jenny Rowley
Reviewing a journal article - Professor Jenny RowleyReviewing a journal article - Professor Jenny Rowley
Reviewing a journal article - Professor Jenny Rowley
 
Review process 2
Review process 2Review process 2
Review process 2
 
Scopus Journals
Scopus JournalsScopus Journals
Scopus Journals
 
Effects of Editorial Peer Review in Enhancing the Quality of Reports of Biome...
Effects of Editorial Peer Review in Enhancing the Quality of Reports of Biome...Effects of Editorial Peer Review in Enhancing the Quality of Reports of Biome...
Effects of Editorial Peer Review in Enhancing the Quality of Reports of Biome...
 
Breakthrough Discoveries Scopus Indexed Open Access Journal by IFERP
Breakthrough Discoveries  Scopus Indexed Open Access Journal by IFERPBreakthrough Discoveries  Scopus Indexed Open Access Journal by IFERP
Breakthrough Discoveries Scopus Indexed Open Access Journal by IFERP
 
Ethical Guidelines for Academic Publishing.pptx
Ethical Guidelines for Academic Publishing.pptxEthical Guidelines for Academic Publishing.pptx
Ethical Guidelines for Academic Publishing.pptx
 
APA Guide to Preparing Manuscripts
APA Guide to Preparing Manuscripts APA Guide to Preparing Manuscripts
APA Guide to Preparing Manuscripts
 
Get-Quick-Guide-of-Manusc-8939695.ppsx
Get-Quick-Guide-of-Manusc-8939695.ppsxGet-Quick-Guide-of-Manusc-8939695.ppsx
Get-Quick-Guide-of-Manusc-8939695.ppsx
 
Peer review and editorial decision making at journals
Peer review and editorial decision making at journalsPeer review and editorial decision making at journals
Peer review and editorial decision making at journals
 

Recently uploaded

❤️ Escorts Service in Bangalore ☎️81279-924O8☎️ Call Girl service in Bangalor...
❤️ Escorts Service in Bangalore ☎️81279-924O8☎️ Call Girl service in Bangalor...❤️ Escorts Service in Bangalore ☎️81279-924O8☎️ Call Girl service in Bangalor...
❤️ Escorts Service in Bangalore ☎️81279-924O8☎️ Call Girl service in Bangalor...
chandigarhentertainm
 
❤️ Zirakpur Call Girl Service ☎️9878799926☎️ Call Girl service in Zirakpur ☎...
❤️ Zirakpur Call Girl Service  ☎️9878799926☎️ Call Girl service in Zirakpur ☎...❤️ Zirakpur Call Girl Service  ☎️9878799926☎️ Call Girl service in Zirakpur ☎...
❤️ Zirakpur Call Girl Service ☎️9878799926☎️ Call Girl service in Zirakpur ☎...
daljeetkaur2026
 
TIME FOR ACTION: MAY 2024 Securing A Strong Nursing Workforce for North Carolina
TIME FOR ACTION: MAY 2024 Securing A Strong Nursing Workforce for North CarolinaTIME FOR ACTION: MAY 2024 Securing A Strong Nursing Workforce for North Carolina
TIME FOR ACTION: MAY 2024 Securing A Strong Nursing Workforce for North Carolina
Mebane Rash
 
🍑👄Ludhiana Escorts Service☎️98157-77685🍑👄 Call Girl service in Ludhiana☎️Ludh...
🍑👄Ludhiana Escorts Service☎️98157-77685🍑👄 Call Girl service in Ludhiana☎️Ludh...🍑👄Ludhiana Escorts Service☎️98157-77685🍑👄 Call Girl service in Ludhiana☎️Ludh...
🍑👄Ludhiana Escorts Service☎️98157-77685🍑👄 Call Girl service in Ludhiana☎️Ludh...
dilpreetentertainmen
 
👉Indore Call Girl Service👉📞 7718850664 👉📞 Just📲 Call Anuj Call Girls In Indor...
👉Indore Call Girl Service👉📞 7718850664 👉📞 Just📲 Call Anuj Call Girls In Indor...👉Indore Call Girl Service👉📞 7718850664 👉📞 Just📲 Call Anuj Call Girls In Indor...
👉Indore Call Girl Service👉📞 7718850664 👉📞 Just📲 Call Anuj Call Girls In Indor...
minkseocompany
 

Recently uploaded (19)

❤️ Call Girls service In Panchkula☎️9815457724☎️ Call Girl service in Panchku...
❤️ Call Girls service In Panchkula☎️9815457724☎️ Call Girl service in Panchku...❤️ Call Girls service In Panchkula☎️9815457724☎️ Call Girl service in Panchku...
❤️ Call Girls service In Panchkula☎️9815457724☎️ Call Girl service in Panchku...
 
💸Cash Payment No Advance Call Girls Nagpur 🧿 9332606886 🧿 High Class Call Gir...
💸Cash Payment No Advance Call Girls Nagpur 🧿 9332606886 🧿 High Class Call Gir...💸Cash Payment No Advance Call Girls Nagpur 🧿 9332606886 🧿 High Class Call Gir...
💸Cash Payment No Advance Call Girls Nagpur 🧿 9332606886 🧿 High Class Call Gir...
 
💸Cash Payment No Advance Call Girls Kanpur 🧿 9332606886 🧿 High Class Call Gir...
💸Cash Payment No Advance Call Girls Kanpur 🧿 9332606886 🧿 High Class Call Gir...💸Cash Payment No Advance Call Girls Kanpur 🧿 9332606886 🧿 High Class Call Gir...
💸Cash Payment No Advance Call Girls Kanpur 🧿 9332606886 🧿 High Class Call Gir...
 
Call Girls In Indore 💯Call Us 🔝 9987056364 🔝 💃 Independent Escort Service Ind...
Call Girls In Indore 💯Call Us 🔝 9987056364 🔝 💃 Independent Escort Service Ind...Call Girls In Indore 💯Call Us 🔝 9987056364 🔝 💃 Independent Escort Service Ind...
Call Girls In Indore 💯Call Us 🔝 9987056364 🔝 💃 Independent Escort Service Ind...
 
2024 PCP #IMPerative Updates in Rheumatology
2024 PCP #IMPerative Updates in Rheumatology2024 PCP #IMPerative Updates in Rheumatology
2024 PCP #IMPerative Updates in Rheumatology
 
❤️Amritsar Escort Service☎️98151-129OO☎️ Call Girl service in Amritsar☎️ Amri...
❤️Amritsar Escort Service☎️98151-129OO☎️ Call Girl service in Amritsar☎️ Amri...❤️Amritsar Escort Service☎️98151-129OO☎️ Call Girl service in Amritsar☎️ Amri...
❤️Amritsar Escort Service☎️98151-129OO☎️ Call Girl service in Amritsar☎️ Amri...
 
❤️ Escorts Service in Bangalore ☎️81279-924O8☎️ Call Girl service in Bangalor...
❤️ Escorts Service in Bangalore ☎️81279-924O8☎️ Call Girl service in Bangalor...❤️ Escorts Service in Bangalore ☎️81279-924O8☎️ Call Girl service in Bangalor...
❤️ Escorts Service in Bangalore ☎️81279-924O8☎️ Call Girl service in Bangalor...
 
💞 Safe And Secure Call Girls gaya 🧿 9332606886 🧿 High Class Call Girl Service...
💞 Safe And Secure Call Girls gaya 🧿 9332606886 🧿 High Class Call Girl Service...💞 Safe And Secure Call Girls gaya 🧿 9332606886 🧿 High Class Call Girl Service...
💞 Safe And Secure Call Girls gaya 🧿 9332606886 🧿 High Class Call Girl Service...
 
Making change happen: learning from "positive deviancts"
Making change happen: learning from "positive deviancts"Making change happen: learning from "positive deviancts"
Making change happen: learning from "positive deviancts"
 
❤️ Zirakpur Call Girl Service ☎️9878799926☎️ Call Girl service in Zirakpur ☎...
❤️ Zirakpur Call Girl Service  ☎️9878799926☎️ Call Girl service in Zirakpur ☎...❤️ Zirakpur Call Girl Service  ☎️9878799926☎️ Call Girl service in Zirakpur ☎...
❤️ Zirakpur Call Girl Service ☎️9878799926☎️ Call Girl service in Zirakpur ☎...
 
TIME FOR ACTION: MAY 2024 Securing A Strong Nursing Workforce for North Carolina
TIME FOR ACTION: MAY 2024 Securing A Strong Nursing Workforce for North CarolinaTIME FOR ACTION: MAY 2024 Securing A Strong Nursing Workforce for North Carolina
TIME FOR ACTION: MAY 2024 Securing A Strong Nursing Workforce for North Carolina
 
🍑👄Ludhiana Escorts Service☎️98157-77685🍑👄 Call Girl service in Ludhiana☎️Ludh...
🍑👄Ludhiana Escorts Service☎️98157-77685🍑👄 Call Girl service in Ludhiana☎️Ludh...🍑👄Ludhiana Escorts Service☎️98157-77685🍑👄 Call Girl service in Ludhiana☎️Ludh...
🍑👄Ludhiana Escorts Service☎️98157-77685🍑👄 Call Girl service in Ludhiana☎️Ludh...
 
💸Cash Payment No Advance Call Girls Pune 🧿 9332606886 🧿 High Class Call Girl ...
💸Cash Payment No Advance Call Girls Pune 🧿 9332606886 🧿 High Class Call Girl ...💸Cash Payment No Advance Call Girls Pune 🧿 9332606886 🧿 High Class Call Girl ...
💸Cash Payment No Advance Call Girls Pune 🧿 9332606886 🧿 High Class Call Girl ...
 
The Events of Cardiac Cycle - Wigger's Diagram
The Events of Cardiac Cycle - Wigger's DiagramThe Events of Cardiac Cycle - Wigger's Diagram
The Events of Cardiac Cycle - Wigger's Diagram
 
💸Cash Payment No Advance Call Girls Hyderabad 🧿 9332606886 🧿 High Class Call ...
💸Cash Payment No Advance Call Girls Hyderabad 🧿 9332606886 🧿 High Class Call ...💸Cash Payment No Advance Call Girls Hyderabad 🧿 9332606886 🧿 High Class Call ...
💸Cash Payment No Advance Call Girls Hyderabad 🧿 9332606886 🧿 High Class Call ...
 
👉Indore Call Girl Service👉📞 7718850664 👉📞 Just📲 Call Anuj Call Girls In Indor...
👉Indore Call Girl Service👉📞 7718850664 👉📞 Just📲 Call Anuj Call Girls In Indor...👉Indore Call Girl Service👉📞 7718850664 👉📞 Just📲 Call Anuj Call Girls In Indor...
👉Indore Call Girl Service👉📞 7718850664 👉📞 Just📲 Call Anuj Call Girls In Indor...
 
💞 Safe And Secure Call Girls Mysore 🧿 9332606886 🧿 High Class Call Girl Servi...
💞 Safe And Secure Call Girls Mysore 🧿 9332606886 🧿 High Class Call Girl Servi...💞 Safe And Secure Call Girls Mysore 🧿 9332606886 🧿 High Class Call Girl Servi...
💞 Safe And Secure Call Girls Mysore 🧿 9332606886 🧿 High Class Call Girl Servi...
 
💞 Safe And Secure Call Girls Coimbatore 🧿 9332606886 🧿 High Class Call Girl S...
💞 Safe And Secure Call Girls Coimbatore 🧿 9332606886 🧿 High Class Call Girl S...💞 Safe And Secure Call Girls Coimbatore 🧿 9332606886 🧿 High Class Call Girl S...
💞 Safe And Secure Call Girls Coimbatore 🧿 9332606886 🧿 High Class Call Girl S...
 
👉Bangalore Call Girl Service👉📞 6378878445 👉📞 Just📲 Call Manisha Call Girls Se...
👉Bangalore Call Girl Service👉📞 6378878445 👉📞 Just📲 Call Manisha Call Girls Se...👉Bangalore Call Girl Service👉📞 6378878445 👉📞 Just📲 Call Manisha Call Girls Se...
👉Bangalore Call Girl Service👉📞 6378878445 👉📞 Just📲 Call Manisha Call Girls Se...
 

Lupine Publishers peer review process

  • 1. Peer Review Process Introduction to peer review What is Peer Review Process? Peer review process is the system used to assess the quality of a manuscript before it is published online. Independent professionals/experts/researchers in the relevant research area are subjected to assess the submitted manuscripts for originality, validity and significance to help editors determine whether a manuscript should be published in their journal. This Peer review process helps in validating the research works, establish a method by which it can be evaluated and increase networking possibilities within research communities. Despite criticisms, peer review is still the only widely accepted method for research validation Only the articles that meet good scientific standards, explanations, records and proofs of their work presented with Bibliographic reasoning (e.g., acknowledge and build upon other work in the field, rely on logical reasoning and well-designed studies, back up claims with evidence etc.) are accepted for publication in the Journal.
  • 2. Peer Review Process Types of Peer Review Process Single Blind In a single-blind peer review process, authors are unaware of who reviewed their paper, but reviewers are aware of the authors’ identity. While this method serves to reduce chances of bias or conflict of interest, there is a possibility that making the author’s identity known could influence the review. Double Blind
  • 3. In a double-blind peer review both the author and peer reviewers are not aware of each other’s identity. Peer-reviewed articles provide a trusted form of scientific communication as it is scrutinized only based on the content provided irrespective of the submitted person or the area of submission. There is also another type of Review process: Many journals have adopted even open peer review. In this model, the author's and reviewers' identities are known to each other. What We follow? We generally follow Double blind peer review process, in which both the authors and the editors who are going to review the papers submitted and approve for publication are unaware of each other’s identity. In this Process the Managing Director of the journal assigns the articles, received from the researchers to the Reviewers along with an Electronic review form, in which the Reviewers are initially supposed to check the scope of the manuscript whether fits to the journal or not then, they need to fill the form of a questionnaire and at the end they will provide their comments or any suggestions/edits in the paper (if required) (sometimes may ask for the results that they have got with proofs) to approve the manuscript for publication in the journal. This forms the basis for deciding whether the work should be
  • 4. accepted, considered acceptable with revisions, or rejected. Submissions with serious failings will be rejected, though they can be re-submitted once they have been thoroughly revised. If a work is rejected, this does not necessarily mean it is of poor quality. A paper may also be rejected because it doesn't fall within the journal's area of specialization or because it doesn't meet the high standards of novelty and originality required by the journal in question. The journal will publish the paper if the reviewer suggests only minor edits but before that the author is asked to make those corrections. How Does It Work? For authors, peer review policy provides a patina of respectability on their work. A scientist who publishes in his field's most prestigious journal gets to bask in the glow of the publication's reputation. He may get called for more interviews and may have future research viewed more favorably by funding bodies. For journal editors, peer review informs their decision-making process. An editor can publish a paper with much greater confidence if he knows that paper has been thoroughly vetted by a team of qualified referees. The editor's management of the peer-review process is directly related to the reputation of the
  • 5. journal. If he consistently selects papers of the highest quality, he will enhance the reputation of his journal. If, on the other hand, he allows the occasional substandard paper to be published, he can erode the journal's credibility. For other Readers, peer review process acts as a mechanism to help prioritize what they read. By focusing only peer reviewed journals in their field, a reader can assume they are reading the most important papers of the highest quality. It's sort of like using the New York Times bestseller list to determine which novel you're going to read next. Current Top Journals.