SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 12
Download to read offline
PA 645 NON-PROFIT FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT AND BUDGETING
FINAL EXAMINATION - SPRING 2014
This examination should represent your own work and not that of others or the product of group work. If you
have questions about the exam, you should contact the instructor and not others in the class. This examination
consists of three parts: Part I is worth 30 points toward the grade on the examination; Part II is worth 40 points;
and Part III is worth 30 points.
PART I. -- ESSAY QUESTION (30 points). Answer only one of the following essay questions. The essay
question should be able to be answered in 2-3 typed, double-spaced pages. Your response to the question
should integrate concepts covered in the course, be well organized, and indicate a logical development of
your arguments. Be sure to cite examples from the readings, articles, cases and analyses discussed in the
course to support points raised in your response.
1. Discuss the usefulness of management control concepts discussed in the course for financial management
in nonprofit organizations. Be sure to discuss how planning and budgeting fit into the management
control process to create a more integrated financial management system.
As the nonprofit sector has developed, professionalization within the field has created an
opportunity to capitalize on the momentum driven by increased support from both public and
private donors. In keeping step with this development, the demand on management of nonprofit
organizations and good stewardship of donated funds, has increased. Meeting this demand has
highlighted the importance of healthy, accountable systems within management control
processes, motivated by the organization's mission and guided by both the professionals and
volunteers within the organization.
One of the most important systems extant in management control process is the budget cycle
as outlined by Finkler (2010): budget preparation, budget review and adoption, budget
implementation and evaluation of results/feedback. As was noted in the analysis of Hamilton
Hospital (Case Study 1), the budget cycle can guide the necessary changes in administrative and
communication processes. Taking the necessary time to use the cycle as an organizational
process allows managers to garner relevant financial data from units and departments as well as
anecdotal and qualitative data from employees, clients and community constituents. Each phase
of the cycle allows for an eye toward strategic planning--assessing the efficacy of current
strategies, identifying emergent strategies and relating the information to the current and future
financial state of the organization.
As the budget is implemented, the working capital management cycle, defined in Finkler
(2010) as collecting cash, paying for supplies, paying workers and issuing invoices, begins to
govern daily operations. This increases the necessity for management control processes focused
on accountability and security as mentioned in Gallagher & Radcliffe (2002); such procedures
include background checks, separation of duties and systems of authorizations. These controls
maintain the integrity of the capital management cycle as it serves two purposes: actualizing the
mission and maintaining daily operations.
While there are a plethora of considerations within the budget implementation phase,
including grappling with capital investments as in the Yoland Research Institute (Case Study 5),
operating reserves and liquidity management (McLaughlin, 2009; Calabrese, 2012; Mundy,
1990) and cost allocation as in Harbor City Children's Center (Case Study 4), the primary focus
centers around program administration. The stewardship of funds continues to play a large role,
examining how revenue moves through the organization as a function of operations; this function
relates back to the budget review and feedback phase, which, in a healthy organization, runs
concurrent to operations prior to moving into the planning phase for the upcoming fiscal year.
Utilizing the budget cycle as a framework provides an effective manager and leader with
important checkpoints to maintain organizational health. As the organization circles around to
planning the budget for the upcoming year, Finkler's (2010) variance analysis can be used to
evaluate performance of specific programs, units, departments and even managers. While not
encouraging micromanagement, this focus on what went well and what could be improved can
guide decisions across the entire organization.
This sets the stage for implementing additional processes designed to mediate problems like
ratio analysis or increase outputs and outcomes like breakeven analyses. While a complete focus
on management control processes cannot be the only focus an effective manager and leader
utilizes, an integrated financial management process--one which serves as a guide and
culmination of other important organizational efforts--is pivotal to maintain the health and
viability of organizations driven to provide valued and necessary public services.
2. Based on your experience performing a financial statement analysis of your group’s nonprofit agency and
discussing another group’s financial statement analysis, what role can ratio analysis play in assessing the
financial situation of a nonprofit organization? Be sure to explain how such reviews are accomplished
through the use of ratio analysis and its value in formulating a financial assessment of a nonprofit
organization.
PART II. -- SHORT ANSWER QUESTIONS (ANSWER ONLY 4 OUT OF THE FOLLOWING 6
QUESTIONS!!!!) Choose 4 of 6 short answer questions at 10 points each--40 points total on short answer
questions. The short answer questions should be able to be answered in one typed, double-spaced page or
less. Indicate clearly the question to which you are responding. Be sure to cite readings, articles, cases,
and analyses discussed in the course to support points raised in your response.
1. Describe how the process of recording financial transactions and generating financial statements works
with respect to the fundamental accounting equation and GAAP requirements for nonprofit organizations.
2. Discuss the purpose and use of required financial statements and how they result from the process of
recording financial information for nonprofit organizations.
3. Identify at least two aspects of accounting for nonprofit organizations that are unique and discuss why
they are an issue.
While it can be argued that nonprofit organizations and for-profit organizations share
many best practices, accounting within the nonprofit sector differs slightly to that of for-profits.
There are unique restrictions and requirements based upon the makeup of nonprofit revenue--a
conglomeration of publicly donated funds, granted funds and so on. This revenue stream requires
nonprofits to account for funds in a more specific manner than that of the for-profit sector. In
doing this, nonprofit organizations generally use fund accounting to track revenue categories,
particularly those which are donor-generated.
In addition to the recording of transactions and fund balances, nonprofits are required to
provide financial statements of financial position, statements of activities, and statements of cash
flows (Finkler, 2010); these are much more specific statements than the for-profit statements of
profits & losses (P&L's). These statements track the relationship of direct and indirect costs, cash
inflows and outflows as well as specific activities performed by the organization. Within these
statements, nonprofit organizations facilitate an understanding of how the organization is
meeting its mission and maintaining solvency.
4. What is the purpose of working capital management and how should it be accomplished in nonprofit
organizations?
Working capital management as outlined by Finkler (2010) is the process by which an organization's
current assets and liabilities are used to maximum financial effect. Incorporated into the process is the
acquisition of liquid assets, paying for supplies and inventory, paying employees and invoicing for
services--a cycle of inflows and outflows in an organization. To manage this process effectively,
consideration must be given to investing and collections in both the long-range and short-term health of
the organization.
Mundy (1990) suggests a ladder-step structure to short-term investing; managers should create a
calendar which allows access to short-term resources; comfortable windows of time can be established,
based upon revenue inflows, with short-term investments that release according to a staggered timeline.
An organization might look at CD's that release in 6-month increments with short-term mutual fund
investments occurring between major release times. Working with these marketable securities allows an
organization to make its money work while it waits to be used. As Finkler (2010) points out, an eye
toward legality, risk, yield and liquidity are important factors to consider, but there is a larger push for
organizations to activate working capital beyond daily operations.
While it is important that working capital management include an understanding of operating
reserves (Calabrese, 2012) and necessary cash for daily operations (Finkler, 2010), maximizing the
impact of liquid assets is a matter of understanding when to apply heat to assets (McLaughlin, 2009);
investment can be an action which includes renewing capital assets or even eliminating such assets if the
need is there. In managing this liquidity, accounts receivable plays a large role in keeping cash flowing
into the organization. In this regard, additional control processes are activated; managing both the billing
and collections process are vital to the organization. If these processes are disjointed and inefficient, the
organization risks depleting its working capital and its operating reserves in such a manner that business
can no longer be done. All of these components play an important role in managing the working capital of
an organization.
5. Explain how variance analysis fits into the context of management control to achieve accountability and
control in nonprofit organizations.
Variance analysis is used to understand the results of processes within the organization; Finkler
(2010) identifies that variance analysis serves to assist in improving the budgeting process, implementing
appropriate control measures in the current year and evaluating the performance of departments and
managers. With these pieces of information, an executive officer and the board can begin to implement
strategies which contribute to the overall health of the organization, particularly as pertains to the
financial bottom line.
Finkler (2010) and McLuaughlin (2009) identify multiple areas where variance can occur: total
output, departmental, and within a single line-item. Once identified, the reason for the variance can be
connected to the result and rationale can be evaluated. In some cases, variance can be a positive value,
due to effective cost analysis or improved administrative processes. Variance can also intimate
organizational challenges in production or over-spending on particular line-items.
Maintaining an eye toward understanding variance analyses allows for managers to pinpoint
specific problems and highlight opportunities, a powerful theme in the study of financial management;
with an understanding of how to interpret variance, managers can be more effective in managing the
relationship between inputs and outputs. While nonprofits differ from for-profit organizations, the
principle of efficiency still plays a large role in the success of the organization.
6. What cautions should apply to the use of ratio analysis and why?
In utilizing ratio analysis to interpret data from nonprofit organizations, there are several
considerations which must be made: how the organization produced the financial statements
used as the basis for comparison, the scope of the comparison and whether it will include
mimetic organizations or industry standard ratios and, finally, the value of ratios used to assess
the organization.
Though each nonprofit organization is required to supply statements of financial position,
activities and cash flows, these statements may be specific to the organization or industry; it is
important to include financial statement notes in compiling ratios as well as interpreting them.
These attachments to financial statements serve to supplement the information presented in
efforts to clarify the method and rationale for reporting. This is a critical consideration to
facilitate the understanding of the values to be used to compute the initial ratios.
Once ratios have been calculated, an agreement should be made regarding the scope of the
comparison: will the comparison simply focus on industry standard ratio behavior? Will the
comparison sample include organizations with similar size, scope and purpose? Without this in
place, ratio analysis is confined to the historical behaviors of the organization which may not
serve the purpose of the analysis. Additionally, allowing the organization to self-select its sister
organizations may skew results of any analysis.
Though there are commonly used classes of ratios, outlined in Finkler (2010) like common
ratios or leverage ratios, it is important to identify ratios which actually reflect the life and
purpose of the organization being analyzed. While asset turnover ratios might be important for
working capital management in an inventory-driven organization, intangible service providers
like cultural or educational organizations may not find much value in focusing on that class of
ratios. Additionally, there are other ratios from various sources including the Urban Institute
and researchers in various fields which may need to be considered or possibly create more
accurate depictions of organizations.
While ratio analysis can be a valuable internal and external tool when considering the
financial health of an organization, it is important to understand how the organization sees what
it does, the methodology behind the comparison and areas of focus within the analysis itself. As
these areas are addressed, the ratio analysis moves toward being an accurate reflection of the
organization as it is positioned within itself, its industry and the nonprofit sector.
III. -- Problem and Application Questions (15 points each, Total of 30 points). Answer only two of
the following three problems. Clearly show all of your calculations. Label your work
appropriately.
1. Breakeven Analysis
The Children’s Museum is considering catering birthday parties for members as a way to
generate revenue. The costs are as follows:
Staff $90
Cake and Food $60
Decorations $30
In addition, party favors have a variable cost of $5 per child.
a. Find the break-even price per child assuming that 12 children (the break-even quantity)
attend
each party.
b. If the Museum expects to make a profit of $300 on every party (treat profit as an additional
fixed cost), find the price per child to break even and produce the $300 profit on every party
(again assume 12 children attend each party).
c. Discuss managerial implications and other considerations of the break-even analysis results.
For components 1a & 1b, please see table below:
Expenses	 	
	 	
Fixed	Cost	 	
Staff	 $90	
Cake	and	Food	 $60	
Decorations	 $30	
	 $180	
Variable	Cost	 	
Favors	 $5	 	
#	of	Attendees	 12	
	 $60	
	 	
Breakeven	 	
Cost/child	 $20	
	 	
Breakeven	+	$300	profit	 $45	
Cost/child	 	
1c. Narrative Response:
Breakeven analysis as a function provides managers information regarding when or at what
point, an investment will be returned. According to Finkler (2010), organizations utilizing breakeven
analysis gain valuable insight into necessary price point, investment turnover and cost opportunities.
Breakeven analyses can be used to determine an appropriate price for services rendered to reduce
or eliminate risk in service-based programming. Inversely, breakeven analysis can be used to determine
the maximum units of service to be provided while avoiding additional costs to the organization. This
indicates that breakeven analysis can be utilized to establish limits or maximums for price of service to
the consumer, cost of service to the organization and the volume of services rendered, positive or
negative. In the example provided, The Children’s Museum is given an idea of what fixed costs are as a
specific category, what variable costs are and the end results; this information then becomes malleable
as program needs and goals are discussed.
Breakeven analysis can also be tied to investment or asset turnover timelines, providing a longer
view of organizational function; the analysis nominally predicts cash flow as relates to volume.
Understanding when and how a breakeven point exists, allows for managers to make determinations
regarding both volume and price as controllable qualities in organizational work flow (Finkler, 2010).
The example analysis provides insight into budgeted amounts, guiding the event planning process and at
what price point the desired 12 guests will return the initial investment to the Museum.
Utilizing this knowledge, managers can realize cost opportunities: can this program support
itself? Are program goals realistic (e.g. can the necessary volume be achieved?) and is the organization
in a financial position to zero out its obligations? While there are additional considerations in financial
decision-making like contribution margin (Finkler, 2010), breakeven analysis is a starting point for
determining the financial capacity of an organization and its ability to keep its feet on the ground.
2. Cost Accounting Problem
The table below provides the costs associated with running community health clinics by a
nonprofit agency. The agency has two mission centers (primary activities) and two general
service (supporting) departments. Assume the nonprofit agency is attempting to determine the
full costs of providing the services in the two primary activities. The direct expenses charged
to the centers are as indicated in the table. The floor space in square feet occupied by the centers,
the number of client visits, and the number of billing and payment documents processed per
center are indicated in the table. Centers should be allocated based on data provided in the
table. Determine the full costs of the primary mission centers by using the step-down method.
Calculate and indicate the full costs and the unit costs for each primary mission center. Show
the complete step-down analysis and associated calculations.
Required narrative comments: What might the agency do with the information obtained? What
price should the agency charge in reimbursement billing for the two services provided based on
this analysis. Why? What other considerations might enter into the pricing decision? Show
all calculations and clearly mark your work for reference.
Sq. Ft. Facility Space Client Visits Documents Processed
Adult Clinic 35,000 (43.75%) 9,000 75,000
Children’s Clinic 30,000 (37.5%) 6,000 50,000
Doc. Processing 15,000 (18.75%)
80,000 15,000 125,000
Mission Centers Service Centers
_______________________________________________________________________________________
Adult Clinic Children’s Clinic Maintenance Document Total
Processing
Direct Costs $920,000 $890,000 $700,000 $800,000 $3,310,000
Step-down	Cost	Distribution	of	Healthcare	Nonprofit	Agency	 	
	 	 	 	 	 	 	
Support	 	 Maint	 Subtotal	 Processing	 Total	 	
Maintenance	 $700,000	 -$700,000	 $0	 $0	 $0	 	
	 Processing	 $800,000	 $131,250	 $931,250	 -$931,250	 $0	 	
Mission	 	 	 	 	 	 	
Adult	Clinic	 $920,000	 $306,250	 $1,226,250	 $558,750	 $1,785,000	 	
Children's	Clinic	 $890,000	 $262,500	 $1,152,500	 $372,500	 $1,525,000	 	
	 $3,310,000	 $0	 $3,310,000	 $0	 $3,310,000	 	
	 	 	 	 	 	 	
Allocation	Ratios	 Space	(sq.	ft.)	 %	 Client	Visits	 %	 Processing	 %	
Adult	Clinic	 35000	 43.75%	 9000	 60.00%	 75000	 60.00%	
Children's	Clinic	 30000	 37.50%	 6000	 40.00%	 50000	 40.00%	
Processing	 15000	 18.75%	 0	 	 0	 	
Maintenance	 0	 	 0	 	 0	 	
	 80000	 	 15000	 	 125000	 	
	 	 	 	 	 	 	
Fee	Structure	(in	avg	cost	per	visit)	 	 	 	 	
	 	 	 	 	 	 	
Utilizing	Step-Down	Cost	Distribution	 Utilizing	Client	Volume	Ratio	 	
	 	 	 	 Direct	Cost	 Per	Visit
Adult	Clinic	 $198.33	 	 Adult	Clinic	 $1,986,000	 $220.67	 	
Children's	Clinic	 $254.17	 	 Children's	Clinic	 $1,324,000	 $220.67	 	
	 	 	 	 $3,310,000	 	 	
Narrative Response:
The information obtained from the step-down cost distribution analysis of this healthcare
organization can be used in several ways, alluding to the fluid nature of cost allocation Finkler (2010)
and McLaughlin (2009) use to guide their discussion of financial reporting. The information garnered
helps to determine strategies for enhancing noted opportunities and diminishing demonstrated
deficiencies within the organizational programming; this is particularly important when considering
direct and indirect costs associated with accomplishing the mission of an organization.
In the case of this healthcare agency, step-down distribution is achieved through allocating
maintenance expenses experienced by both mission and support centers, followed by allocating
processing center costs which serve to support the two mission centers—the Adult Clinic and the
Children’s Clinic. In this process, the organization understands what actual costs (in aggregate) the
mission centers are incurring. This process can provide valuable information for financial statements
and Form 990 reporting.
Some of the value of the knowledge ties directly to for-fee services rendered in mission centers;
with the knowledge gained from evaluating the step-down cost distribution, accurate prices for break
even points can be established. Utilizing the step-down method, it has been determined that the Adult
Clinic should charge, on average, $198.33 per visit and the Children’s Clinic should be around $254.17
per visit, based upon current volume and costs within the organization. Using a ratio determined by
client volume, all visits should be priced at an average $220.67. While both numbers are accurate, they
illustrate the power of the lens utilized to analyze financial figures. These prices can then be used for
upcoming budget projections and estimates for grant writing. Depending upon how the information
needs to be used, managers have standing with all three prices. This may impact how pricing is
determined, but may also influence decisions surrounding where to aim program development; if
children’s visits can be justifiably scaled higher than adult visits as exhibited in step-down distribution,
it would be reasonable to aim marketing and outreach efforts toward that targeted population. If the
organization were writing for sponsorship or grants, the higher price could be utilized to justify
increased support to defray client cost and potentially increase liquidity and profit ratios in the
organization.
3. Net Present Value/Cost-Benefit Analysis Problem.
The following table contains data prepared for two capital investment projects. (a) Use these data
to compute for each project the Net Present Value at discount rates of 10 and 4 percent. Clearly
show your calculations and how you arrived at your answers; (b) Describe the facts about the
projects that determine which project is preferable under each circumstance and why. What other
considerations might enter into a decision?
Project Year Capital Costs
($)
Maint. Costs
($)
Benefits ($)
0 2,000,000 0 0
1 1,000,000 10,000 0
2 500,000 70,000 120,000
3 90,000 600,000
A 4 90,000 800,000
5 90,000 800,000
6 90,000 800,000
7 90,000 800,000
8 90,000 800,000
9 100,000 800,000
10 100,000 500,000
0 2,500,000 0 0
1 500,000 50,000 750,000
2 100,000 750,000
3 100,000 750,000
B 4 100,000 750,000
5 100,000 750,000
6 100,000 750,000
7 100,000 750,000
8 100,000 750,000
9 100,000 750,000
10 100,000 300,000

More Related Content

What's hot

Measuring performance of microfinance institutions a framework for reportin...
Measuring performance of microfinance institutions   a framework for reportin...Measuring performance of microfinance institutions   a framework for reportin...
Measuring performance of microfinance institutions a framework for reportin...snb9899
 
An Empirical Analysis on the Nature of Relationship between Capital Structure...
An Empirical Analysis on the Nature of Relationship between Capital Structure...An Empirical Analysis on the Nature of Relationship between Capital Structure...
An Empirical Analysis on the Nature of Relationship between Capital Structure...iosrjce
 
A Study on Performance Analysis of Nestle India Limited with Specific Referen...
A Study on Performance Analysis of Nestle India Limited with Specific Referen...A Study on Performance Analysis of Nestle India Limited with Specific Referen...
A Study on Performance Analysis of Nestle India Limited with Specific Referen...paperpublications3
 
Tips and Tools for Great Financial Management
Tips and Tools for Great Financial ManagementTips and Tools for Great Financial Management
Tips and Tools for Great Financial ManagementGreenlights
 
Finacial managment www.it-workss.com
Finacial managment   www.it-workss.comFinacial managment   www.it-workss.com
Finacial managment www.it-workss.comVarunraj Kalse
 
A gibson 12e_ch01
A gibson 12e_ch01A gibson 12e_ch01
A gibson 12e_ch01omasahudu
 
Citibank ratio analysis
Citibank   ratio analysisCitibank   ratio analysis
Citibank ratio analysisSoma Banik
 
Introduction to management accounting
Introduction  to management accountingIntroduction  to management accounting
Introduction to management accountingnikki yadav
 
intro to mgmt accounting
intro to mgmt accountingintro to mgmt accounting
intro to mgmt accountingnikki yadav
 
Financial Management
Financial ManagementFinancial Management
Financial Managementjo bitonio
 
Short term financial management notes
Short term financial management notesShort term financial management notes
Short term financial management notesRejaul Islam
 
2. financial statement analysis
2. financial statement analysis2. financial statement analysis
2. financial statement analysisJudy Ricamara
 

What's hot (17)

Measuring performance of microfinance institutions a framework for reportin...
Measuring performance of microfinance institutions   a framework for reportin...Measuring performance of microfinance institutions   a framework for reportin...
Measuring performance of microfinance institutions a framework for reportin...
 
An Empirical Analysis on the Nature of Relationship between Capital Structure...
An Empirical Analysis on the Nature of Relationship between Capital Structure...An Empirical Analysis on the Nature of Relationship between Capital Structure...
An Empirical Analysis on the Nature of Relationship between Capital Structure...
 
A Study on Performance Analysis of Nestle India Limited with Specific Referen...
A Study on Performance Analysis of Nestle India Limited with Specific Referen...A Study on Performance Analysis of Nestle India Limited with Specific Referen...
A Study on Performance Analysis of Nestle India Limited with Specific Referen...
 
Tips and Tools for Great Financial Management
Tips and Tools for Great Financial ManagementTips and Tools for Great Financial Management
Tips and Tools for Great Financial Management
 
Finacial managment www.it-workss.com
Finacial managment   www.it-workss.comFinacial managment   www.it-workss.com
Finacial managment www.it-workss.com
 
Ch 01
Ch 01Ch 01
Ch 01
 
A gibson 12e_ch01
A gibson 12e_ch01A gibson 12e_ch01
A gibson 12e_ch01
 
Citibank ratio analysis
Citibank   ratio analysisCitibank   ratio analysis
Citibank ratio analysis
 
Fm Intro.
Fm Intro.Fm Intro.
Fm Intro.
 
Chapter 1 - Overview of Financial Statement Analysis
Chapter 1 - Overview of Financial Statement AnalysisChapter 1 - Overview of Financial Statement Analysis
Chapter 1 - Overview of Financial Statement Analysis
 
Financial management for the ace school
Financial management for the ace schoolFinancial management for the ace school
Financial management for the ace school
 
Introduction to management accounting
Introduction  to management accountingIntroduction  to management accounting
Introduction to management accounting
 
intro to mgmt accounting
intro to mgmt accountingintro to mgmt accounting
intro to mgmt accounting
 
Financial management presentation
Financial management presentationFinancial management presentation
Financial management presentation
 
Financial Management
Financial ManagementFinancial Management
Financial Management
 
Short term financial management notes
Short term financial management notesShort term financial management notes
Short term financial management notes
 
2. financial statement analysis
2. financial statement analysis2. financial statement analysis
2. financial statement analysis
 

Viewers also liked

Проект з основи діловодства на тему види документів за функціональним признач...
Проект з основи діловодства на тему види документів за функціональним признач...Проект з основи діловодства на тему види документів за функціональним признач...
Проект з основи діловодства на тему види документів за функціональним признач...Vasil8
 
Diapositivas
DiapositivasDiapositivas
DiapositivasLECONRU
 
Delitos Informaticos- Convenio de Budapest
Delitos Informaticos- Convenio de BudapestDelitos Informaticos- Convenio de Budapest
Delitos Informaticos- Convenio de BudapestGeitheir Aldhair
 
Biopharmaceutical manufacturing instrument classification
Biopharmaceutical manufacturing instrument classificationBiopharmaceutical manufacturing instrument classification
Biopharmaceutical manufacturing instrument classificationDenny Walthers
 
Atanu Acharya Resume 2015
Atanu Acharya Resume 2015Atanu Acharya Resume 2015
Atanu Acharya Resume 2015atanu acharya
 

Viewers also liked (10)

Проект з основи діловодства на тему види документів за функціональним признач...
Проект з основи діловодства на тему види документів за функціональним признач...Проект з основи діловодства на тему види документів за функціональним признач...
Проект з основи діловодства на тему види документів за функціональним признач...
 
Diapositivas
DiapositivasDiapositivas
Diapositivas
 
Darling
DarlingDarling
Darling
 
201510131305
201510131305201510131305
201510131305
 
Email Marketing Plan for 30 days | icontact
Email Marketing Plan for 30 days | icontactEmail Marketing Plan for 30 days | icontact
Email Marketing Plan for 30 days | icontact
 
tugas soal fisika
tugas soal fisika tugas soal fisika
tugas soal fisika
 
Eva-Logo-1
Eva-Logo-1Eva-Logo-1
Eva-Logo-1
 
Delitos Informaticos- Convenio de Budapest
Delitos Informaticos- Convenio de BudapestDelitos Informaticos- Convenio de Budapest
Delitos Informaticos- Convenio de Budapest
 
Biopharmaceutical manufacturing instrument classification
Biopharmaceutical manufacturing instrument classificationBiopharmaceutical manufacturing instrument classification
Biopharmaceutical manufacturing instrument classification
 
Atanu Acharya Resume 2015
Atanu Acharya Resume 2015Atanu Acharya Resume 2015
Atanu Acharya Resume 2015
 

Similar to Nonprofit Financial Management Exam

A study on financial performance analysis at cee vee
A study on financial performance analysis at cee veeA study on financial performance analysis at cee vee
A study on financial performance analysis at cee veeAKHILHARIDAS
 
minor project on ratio analysis of "......"
minor project on ratio analysis of "......"minor project on ratio analysis of "......"
minor project on ratio analysis of "......"Kh Corporate
 
Nmp 650 e portfolio #1 gbwhite 11 7-2013
Nmp 650 e portfolio #1 gbwhite 11 7-2013Nmp 650 e portfolio #1 gbwhite 11 7-2013
Nmp 650 e portfolio #1 gbwhite 11 7-2013Trudiwhite
 
FINANCIAL PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS OF BHARTI AIRTEL LIMITED
FINANCIAL PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS OF BHARTI AIRTEL LIMITEDFINANCIAL PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS OF BHARTI AIRTEL LIMITED
FINANCIAL PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS OF BHARTI AIRTEL LIMITEDyashmin khatun
 
financial management project- ratio analysis
financial management project- ratio analysisfinancial management project- ratio analysis
financial management project- ratio analysisyogita varma
 
1 4. Describe the financial approach to strategic healthca.docx
1 4. Describe the financial approach to strategic healthca.docx1 4. Describe the financial approach to strategic healthca.docx
1 4. Describe the financial approach to strategic healthca.docxhoney725342
 
enu-fmd-bk-en-GB January 6, 2015 - 1522 141Chapter10
enu-fmd-bk-en-GB January 6, 2015 - 1522 141Chapter10enu-fmd-bk-en-GB January 6, 2015 - 1522 141Chapter10
enu-fmd-bk-en-GB January 6, 2015 - 1522 141Chapter10TanaMaeskm
 
Healthcare Finance HW.pdf
Healthcare Finance HW.pdfHealthcare Finance HW.pdf
Healthcare Finance HW.pdfsdfghj21
 
Homework 1 management accounting by Dr. ZackZaki
Homework 1 management accounting by Dr. ZackZakiHomework 1 management accounting by Dr. ZackZaki
Homework 1 management accounting by Dr. ZackZakiAhmad Zaki Bin Badruddin
 
International Financial Statement Analysis Workbook
International Financial Statement Analysis WorkbookInternational Financial Statement Analysis Workbook
International Financial Statement Analysis WorkbookMichelle Singh
 

Similar to Nonprofit Financial Management Exam (20)

Analytical Investigation of Financial Planning and Control Practices: A Case ...
Analytical Investigation of Financial Planning and Control Practices: A Case ...Analytical Investigation of Financial Planning and Control Practices: A Case ...
Analytical Investigation of Financial Planning and Control Practices: A Case ...
 
A study on financial performance analysis at cee vee
A study on financial performance analysis at cee veeA study on financial performance analysis at cee vee
A study on financial performance analysis at cee vee
 
Chapter 1
Chapter 1Chapter 1
Chapter 1
 
working capital management
 working capital management working capital management
working capital management
 
minor project on ratio analysis of "......"
minor project on ratio analysis of "......"minor project on ratio analysis of "......"
minor project on ratio analysis of "......"
 
Ijetr042103
Ijetr042103Ijetr042103
Ijetr042103
 
Nmp 650 e portfolio #1 gbwhite 11 7-2013
Nmp 650 e portfolio #1 gbwhite 11 7-2013Nmp 650 e portfolio #1 gbwhite 11 7-2013
Nmp 650 e portfolio #1 gbwhite 11 7-2013
 
FINANCIAL PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS OF BHARTI AIRTEL LIMITED
FINANCIAL PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS OF BHARTI AIRTEL LIMITEDFINANCIAL PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS OF BHARTI AIRTEL LIMITED
FINANCIAL PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS OF BHARTI AIRTEL LIMITED
 
financial management project- ratio analysis
financial management project- ratio analysisfinancial management project- ratio analysis
financial management project- ratio analysis
 
Raju plastic container
   Raju plastic container   Raju plastic container
Raju plastic container
 
1 4. Describe the financial approach to strategic healthca.docx
1 4. Describe the financial approach to strategic healthca.docx1 4. Describe the financial approach to strategic healthca.docx
1 4. Describe the financial approach to strategic healthca.docx
 
10120140504012
1012014050401210120140504012
10120140504012
 
BALANCE SCORECARD
BALANCE SCORECARDBALANCE SCORECARD
BALANCE SCORECARD
 
enu-fmd-bk-en-GB January 6, 2015 - 1522 141Chapter10
enu-fmd-bk-en-GB January 6, 2015 - 1522 141Chapter10enu-fmd-bk-en-GB January 6, 2015 - 1522 141Chapter10
enu-fmd-bk-en-GB January 6, 2015 - 1522 141Chapter10
 
Healthcare Finance HW.pdf
Healthcare Finance HW.pdfHealthcare Finance HW.pdf
Healthcare Finance HW.pdf
 
Money Management Essay
Money Management EssayMoney Management Essay
Money Management Essay
 
Homework 1 management accounting by Dr. ZackZaki
Homework 1 management accounting by Dr. ZackZakiHomework 1 management accounting by Dr. ZackZaki
Homework 1 management accounting by Dr. ZackZaki
 
Accounting Practices
Accounting PracticesAccounting Practices
Accounting Practices
 
Performance Analysis through Financial Modelling
Performance Analysis through Financial ModellingPerformance Analysis through Financial Modelling
Performance Analysis through Financial Modelling
 
International Financial Statement Analysis Workbook
International Financial Statement Analysis WorkbookInternational Financial Statement Analysis Workbook
International Financial Statement Analysis Workbook
 

Nonprofit Financial Management Exam

  • 1. PA 645 NON-PROFIT FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT AND BUDGETING FINAL EXAMINATION - SPRING 2014 This examination should represent your own work and not that of others or the product of group work. If you have questions about the exam, you should contact the instructor and not others in the class. This examination consists of three parts: Part I is worth 30 points toward the grade on the examination; Part II is worth 40 points; and Part III is worth 30 points. PART I. -- ESSAY QUESTION (30 points). Answer only one of the following essay questions. The essay question should be able to be answered in 2-3 typed, double-spaced pages. Your response to the question should integrate concepts covered in the course, be well organized, and indicate a logical development of your arguments. Be sure to cite examples from the readings, articles, cases and analyses discussed in the course to support points raised in your response. 1. Discuss the usefulness of management control concepts discussed in the course for financial management in nonprofit organizations. Be sure to discuss how planning and budgeting fit into the management control process to create a more integrated financial management system. As the nonprofit sector has developed, professionalization within the field has created an opportunity to capitalize on the momentum driven by increased support from both public and private donors. In keeping step with this development, the demand on management of nonprofit organizations and good stewardship of donated funds, has increased. Meeting this demand has highlighted the importance of healthy, accountable systems within management control processes, motivated by the organization's mission and guided by both the professionals and volunteers within the organization. One of the most important systems extant in management control process is the budget cycle as outlined by Finkler (2010): budget preparation, budget review and adoption, budget implementation and evaluation of results/feedback. As was noted in the analysis of Hamilton Hospital (Case Study 1), the budget cycle can guide the necessary changes in administrative and communication processes. Taking the necessary time to use the cycle as an organizational process allows managers to garner relevant financial data from units and departments as well as anecdotal and qualitative data from employees, clients and community constituents. Each phase of the cycle allows for an eye toward strategic planning--assessing the efficacy of current strategies, identifying emergent strategies and relating the information to the current and future
  • 2. financial state of the organization. As the budget is implemented, the working capital management cycle, defined in Finkler (2010) as collecting cash, paying for supplies, paying workers and issuing invoices, begins to govern daily operations. This increases the necessity for management control processes focused on accountability and security as mentioned in Gallagher & Radcliffe (2002); such procedures include background checks, separation of duties and systems of authorizations. These controls maintain the integrity of the capital management cycle as it serves two purposes: actualizing the mission and maintaining daily operations. While there are a plethora of considerations within the budget implementation phase, including grappling with capital investments as in the Yoland Research Institute (Case Study 5), operating reserves and liquidity management (McLaughlin, 2009; Calabrese, 2012; Mundy, 1990) and cost allocation as in Harbor City Children's Center (Case Study 4), the primary focus centers around program administration. The stewardship of funds continues to play a large role, examining how revenue moves through the organization as a function of operations; this function relates back to the budget review and feedback phase, which, in a healthy organization, runs concurrent to operations prior to moving into the planning phase for the upcoming fiscal year. Utilizing the budget cycle as a framework provides an effective manager and leader with important checkpoints to maintain organizational health. As the organization circles around to planning the budget for the upcoming year, Finkler's (2010) variance analysis can be used to evaluate performance of specific programs, units, departments and even managers. While not encouraging micromanagement, this focus on what went well and what could be improved can guide decisions across the entire organization. This sets the stage for implementing additional processes designed to mediate problems like ratio analysis or increase outputs and outcomes like breakeven analyses. While a complete focus on management control processes cannot be the only focus an effective manager and leader
  • 3. utilizes, an integrated financial management process--one which serves as a guide and culmination of other important organizational efforts--is pivotal to maintain the health and viability of organizations driven to provide valued and necessary public services. 2. Based on your experience performing a financial statement analysis of your group’s nonprofit agency and discussing another group’s financial statement analysis, what role can ratio analysis play in assessing the financial situation of a nonprofit organization? Be sure to explain how such reviews are accomplished through the use of ratio analysis and its value in formulating a financial assessment of a nonprofit organization. PART II. -- SHORT ANSWER QUESTIONS (ANSWER ONLY 4 OUT OF THE FOLLOWING 6 QUESTIONS!!!!) Choose 4 of 6 short answer questions at 10 points each--40 points total on short answer questions. The short answer questions should be able to be answered in one typed, double-spaced page or less. Indicate clearly the question to which you are responding. Be sure to cite readings, articles, cases, and analyses discussed in the course to support points raised in your response. 1. Describe how the process of recording financial transactions and generating financial statements works with respect to the fundamental accounting equation and GAAP requirements for nonprofit organizations. 2. Discuss the purpose and use of required financial statements and how they result from the process of recording financial information for nonprofit organizations. 3. Identify at least two aspects of accounting for nonprofit organizations that are unique and discuss why they are an issue. While it can be argued that nonprofit organizations and for-profit organizations share many best practices, accounting within the nonprofit sector differs slightly to that of for-profits. There are unique restrictions and requirements based upon the makeup of nonprofit revenue--a conglomeration of publicly donated funds, granted funds and so on. This revenue stream requires nonprofits to account for funds in a more specific manner than that of the for-profit sector. In doing this, nonprofit organizations generally use fund accounting to track revenue categories, particularly those which are donor-generated. In addition to the recording of transactions and fund balances, nonprofits are required to provide financial statements of financial position, statements of activities, and statements of cash flows (Finkler, 2010); these are much more specific statements than the for-profit statements of profits & losses (P&L's). These statements track the relationship of direct and indirect costs, cash
  • 4. inflows and outflows as well as specific activities performed by the organization. Within these statements, nonprofit organizations facilitate an understanding of how the organization is meeting its mission and maintaining solvency. 4. What is the purpose of working capital management and how should it be accomplished in nonprofit organizations? Working capital management as outlined by Finkler (2010) is the process by which an organization's current assets and liabilities are used to maximum financial effect. Incorporated into the process is the acquisition of liquid assets, paying for supplies and inventory, paying employees and invoicing for services--a cycle of inflows and outflows in an organization. To manage this process effectively, consideration must be given to investing and collections in both the long-range and short-term health of the organization. Mundy (1990) suggests a ladder-step structure to short-term investing; managers should create a calendar which allows access to short-term resources; comfortable windows of time can be established, based upon revenue inflows, with short-term investments that release according to a staggered timeline. An organization might look at CD's that release in 6-month increments with short-term mutual fund investments occurring between major release times. Working with these marketable securities allows an organization to make its money work while it waits to be used. As Finkler (2010) points out, an eye toward legality, risk, yield and liquidity are important factors to consider, but there is a larger push for organizations to activate working capital beyond daily operations. While it is important that working capital management include an understanding of operating reserves (Calabrese, 2012) and necessary cash for daily operations (Finkler, 2010), maximizing the impact of liquid assets is a matter of understanding when to apply heat to assets (McLaughlin, 2009); investment can be an action which includes renewing capital assets or even eliminating such assets if the need is there. In managing this liquidity, accounts receivable plays a large role in keeping cash flowing into the organization. In this regard, additional control processes are activated; managing both the billing and collections process are vital to the organization. If these processes are disjointed and inefficient, the
  • 5. organization risks depleting its working capital and its operating reserves in such a manner that business can no longer be done. All of these components play an important role in managing the working capital of an organization. 5. Explain how variance analysis fits into the context of management control to achieve accountability and control in nonprofit organizations. Variance analysis is used to understand the results of processes within the organization; Finkler (2010) identifies that variance analysis serves to assist in improving the budgeting process, implementing appropriate control measures in the current year and evaluating the performance of departments and managers. With these pieces of information, an executive officer and the board can begin to implement strategies which contribute to the overall health of the organization, particularly as pertains to the financial bottom line. Finkler (2010) and McLuaughlin (2009) identify multiple areas where variance can occur: total output, departmental, and within a single line-item. Once identified, the reason for the variance can be connected to the result and rationale can be evaluated. In some cases, variance can be a positive value, due to effective cost analysis or improved administrative processes. Variance can also intimate organizational challenges in production or over-spending on particular line-items. Maintaining an eye toward understanding variance analyses allows for managers to pinpoint specific problems and highlight opportunities, a powerful theme in the study of financial management; with an understanding of how to interpret variance, managers can be more effective in managing the relationship between inputs and outputs. While nonprofits differ from for-profit organizations, the principle of efficiency still plays a large role in the success of the organization. 6. What cautions should apply to the use of ratio analysis and why? In utilizing ratio analysis to interpret data from nonprofit organizations, there are several considerations which must be made: how the organization produced the financial statements used as the basis for comparison, the scope of the comparison and whether it will include mimetic organizations or industry standard ratios and, finally, the value of ratios used to assess
  • 6. the organization. Though each nonprofit organization is required to supply statements of financial position, activities and cash flows, these statements may be specific to the organization or industry; it is important to include financial statement notes in compiling ratios as well as interpreting them. These attachments to financial statements serve to supplement the information presented in efforts to clarify the method and rationale for reporting. This is a critical consideration to facilitate the understanding of the values to be used to compute the initial ratios. Once ratios have been calculated, an agreement should be made regarding the scope of the comparison: will the comparison simply focus on industry standard ratio behavior? Will the comparison sample include organizations with similar size, scope and purpose? Without this in place, ratio analysis is confined to the historical behaviors of the organization which may not serve the purpose of the analysis. Additionally, allowing the organization to self-select its sister organizations may skew results of any analysis. Though there are commonly used classes of ratios, outlined in Finkler (2010) like common ratios or leverage ratios, it is important to identify ratios which actually reflect the life and purpose of the organization being analyzed. While asset turnover ratios might be important for working capital management in an inventory-driven organization, intangible service providers like cultural or educational organizations may not find much value in focusing on that class of ratios. Additionally, there are other ratios from various sources including the Urban Institute and researchers in various fields which may need to be considered or possibly create more accurate depictions of organizations. While ratio analysis can be a valuable internal and external tool when considering the financial health of an organization, it is important to understand how the organization sees what it does, the methodology behind the comparison and areas of focus within the analysis itself. As these areas are addressed, the ratio analysis moves toward being an accurate reflection of the
  • 7. organization as it is positioned within itself, its industry and the nonprofit sector. III. -- Problem and Application Questions (15 points each, Total of 30 points). Answer only two of the following three problems. Clearly show all of your calculations. Label your work appropriately. 1. Breakeven Analysis The Children’s Museum is considering catering birthday parties for members as a way to generate revenue. The costs are as follows: Staff $90 Cake and Food $60 Decorations $30 In addition, party favors have a variable cost of $5 per child. a. Find the break-even price per child assuming that 12 children (the break-even quantity) attend each party. b. If the Museum expects to make a profit of $300 on every party (treat profit as an additional fixed cost), find the price per child to break even and produce the $300 profit on every party (again assume 12 children attend each party). c. Discuss managerial implications and other considerations of the break-even analysis results. For components 1a & 1b, please see table below: Expenses Fixed Cost Staff $90 Cake and Food $60 Decorations $30 $180 Variable Cost Favors $5 # of Attendees 12 $60 Breakeven Cost/child $20 Breakeven + $300 profit $45 Cost/child 1c. Narrative Response: Breakeven analysis as a function provides managers information regarding when or at what
  • 8. point, an investment will be returned. According to Finkler (2010), organizations utilizing breakeven analysis gain valuable insight into necessary price point, investment turnover and cost opportunities. Breakeven analyses can be used to determine an appropriate price for services rendered to reduce or eliminate risk in service-based programming. Inversely, breakeven analysis can be used to determine the maximum units of service to be provided while avoiding additional costs to the organization. This indicates that breakeven analysis can be utilized to establish limits or maximums for price of service to the consumer, cost of service to the organization and the volume of services rendered, positive or negative. In the example provided, The Children’s Museum is given an idea of what fixed costs are as a specific category, what variable costs are and the end results; this information then becomes malleable as program needs and goals are discussed. Breakeven analysis can also be tied to investment or asset turnover timelines, providing a longer view of organizational function; the analysis nominally predicts cash flow as relates to volume. Understanding when and how a breakeven point exists, allows for managers to make determinations regarding both volume and price as controllable qualities in organizational work flow (Finkler, 2010). The example analysis provides insight into budgeted amounts, guiding the event planning process and at what price point the desired 12 guests will return the initial investment to the Museum. Utilizing this knowledge, managers can realize cost opportunities: can this program support itself? Are program goals realistic (e.g. can the necessary volume be achieved?) and is the organization in a financial position to zero out its obligations? While there are additional considerations in financial decision-making like contribution margin (Finkler, 2010), breakeven analysis is a starting point for determining the financial capacity of an organization and its ability to keep its feet on the ground. 2. Cost Accounting Problem The table below provides the costs associated with running community health clinics by a nonprofit agency. The agency has two mission centers (primary activities) and two general service (supporting) departments. Assume the nonprofit agency is attempting to determine the full costs of providing the services in the two primary activities. The direct expenses charged
  • 9. to the centers are as indicated in the table. The floor space in square feet occupied by the centers, the number of client visits, and the number of billing and payment documents processed per center are indicated in the table. Centers should be allocated based on data provided in the table. Determine the full costs of the primary mission centers by using the step-down method. Calculate and indicate the full costs and the unit costs for each primary mission center. Show the complete step-down analysis and associated calculations. Required narrative comments: What might the agency do with the information obtained? What price should the agency charge in reimbursement billing for the two services provided based on this analysis. Why? What other considerations might enter into the pricing decision? Show all calculations and clearly mark your work for reference. Sq. Ft. Facility Space Client Visits Documents Processed Adult Clinic 35,000 (43.75%) 9,000 75,000 Children’s Clinic 30,000 (37.5%) 6,000 50,000 Doc. Processing 15,000 (18.75%) 80,000 15,000 125,000 Mission Centers Service Centers _______________________________________________________________________________________ Adult Clinic Children’s Clinic Maintenance Document Total Processing Direct Costs $920,000 $890,000 $700,000 $800,000 $3,310,000 Step-down Cost Distribution of Healthcare Nonprofit Agency Support Maint Subtotal Processing Total Maintenance $700,000 -$700,000 $0 $0 $0 Processing $800,000 $131,250 $931,250 -$931,250 $0 Mission Adult Clinic $920,000 $306,250 $1,226,250 $558,750 $1,785,000 Children's Clinic $890,000 $262,500 $1,152,500 $372,500 $1,525,000 $3,310,000 $0 $3,310,000 $0 $3,310,000 Allocation Ratios Space (sq. ft.) % Client Visits % Processing % Adult Clinic 35000 43.75% 9000 60.00% 75000 60.00% Children's Clinic 30000 37.50% 6000 40.00% 50000 40.00% Processing 15000 18.75% 0 0 Maintenance 0 0 0 80000 15000 125000 Fee Structure (in avg cost per visit) Utilizing Step-Down Cost Distribution Utilizing Client Volume Ratio Direct Cost Per Visit
  • 10. Adult Clinic $198.33 Adult Clinic $1,986,000 $220.67 Children's Clinic $254.17 Children's Clinic $1,324,000 $220.67 $3,310,000 Narrative Response: The information obtained from the step-down cost distribution analysis of this healthcare organization can be used in several ways, alluding to the fluid nature of cost allocation Finkler (2010) and McLaughlin (2009) use to guide their discussion of financial reporting. The information garnered helps to determine strategies for enhancing noted opportunities and diminishing demonstrated deficiencies within the organizational programming; this is particularly important when considering direct and indirect costs associated with accomplishing the mission of an organization. In the case of this healthcare agency, step-down distribution is achieved through allocating maintenance expenses experienced by both mission and support centers, followed by allocating processing center costs which serve to support the two mission centers—the Adult Clinic and the Children’s Clinic. In this process, the organization understands what actual costs (in aggregate) the mission centers are incurring. This process can provide valuable information for financial statements and Form 990 reporting. Some of the value of the knowledge ties directly to for-fee services rendered in mission centers; with the knowledge gained from evaluating the step-down cost distribution, accurate prices for break even points can be established. Utilizing the step-down method, it has been determined that the Adult Clinic should charge, on average, $198.33 per visit and the Children’s Clinic should be around $254.17 per visit, based upon current volume and costs within the organization. Using a ratio determined by client volume, all visits should be priced at an average $220.67. While both numbers are accurate, they illustrate the power of the lens utilized to analyze financial figures. These prices can then be used for upcoming budget projections and estimates for grant writing. Depending upon how the information
  • 11. needs to be used, managers have standing with all three prices. This may impact how pricing is determined, but may also influence decisions surrounding where to aim program development; if children’s visits can be justifiably scaled higher than adult visits as exhibited in step-down distribution, it would be reasonable to aim marketing and outreach efforts toward that targeted population. If the organization were writing for sponsorship or grants, the higher price could be utilized to justify increased support to defray client cost and potentially increase liquidity and profit ratios in the organization. 3. Net Present Value/Cost-Benefit Analysis Problem. The following table contains data prepared for two capital investment projects. (a) Use these data to compute for each project the Net Present Value at discount rates of 10 and 4 percent. Clearly show your calculations and how you arrived at your answers; (b) Describe the facts about the projects that determine which project is preferable under each circumstance and why. What other considerations might enter into a decision? Project Year Capital Costs ($) Maint. Costs ($) Benefits ($) 0 2,000,000 0 0 1 1,000,000 10,000 0 2 500,000 70,000 120,000 3 90,000 600,000 A 4 90,000 800,000 5 90,000 800,000 6 90,000 800,000 7 90,000 800,000 8 90,000 800,000 9 100,000 800,000 10 100,000 500,000 0 2,500,000 0 0 1 500,000 50,000 750,000 2 100,000 750,000
  • 12. 3 100,000 750,000 B 4 100,000 750,000 5 100,000 750,000 6 100,000 750,000 7 100,000 750,000 8 100,000 750,000 9 100,000 750,000 10 100,000 300,000