SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 23
Oregon State University
College of Business
Honor System
-Term Paper-
Hallie Exall & Tessa McGill
Professor Leavitt
MGMT 459: Managing Ethics and Corporate Social Responsibility
Section 001
June 06, 2014
1
Contents
Introduction..................................................................................................................................... 2
Section One: Business Schools and Best Practice .......................................................................... 2
Notre Dame: Mendoza College of Business............................................................................... 2
Overview ................................................................................................................................. 2
School Practices...................................................................................................................... 3
The University of Texas at Austin: McCombs School of Business............................................ 3
Overview ................................................................................................................................. 3
School Practices...................................................................................................................... 4
University of Oregon: Lundquist College of Business ............................................................... 4
Overview ................................................................................................................................. 4
School Practices...................................................................................................................... 5
University of Arizona: Eller College of Management................................................................ 5
Overview ................................................................................................................................. 5
School Practices...................................................................................................................... 6
Empty Practices........................................................................................................................... 6
Best Practices .............................................................................................................................. 7
Section Two: Faculty, Student, and Potential Employer Input....................................................... 8
Student Input............................................................................................................................... 8
Faculty Input............................................................................................................................... 9
Potential Employer’s Input ......................................................................................................... 9
Section Three: Components of Honor Code and Best Practices................................................... 10
Students..................................................................................................................................... 10
Faculty ...................................................................................................................................... 12
Curriculum and University Based ............................................................................................ 14
Overall Best Practices .............................................................................................................. 16
Conclusion .................................................................................................................................... 17
Appendix....................................................................................................................................... 18
Resources ...................................................................................................................................... 19
Endnotes........................................................................................................................................ 22
2
Introduction
Oregon State University’s College of Business has entered into a time where faculty,
administration, students, and professionals are questioning the current honor system. In order to
increase the credibility and reputation of the College of Business, we have formulated an honor
system to be implemented within the next year. This system comprises faculty, student, and
professional input, while drawing from other school’s practices and theoretical concepts. With
this honor system in place, the value of degrees given from the College of Business at Oregon
State University will increase, and students will be more prepared to enter the professional
world.
SectionOne: Business Schoolsand BestPractice
Notre Dame: Mendoza College ofBusiness
Overview
Reverend Edward Sorin started Notre Dame in 1842.1 It is a private, Catholic college,
and today, 172 years later, Notre Dame’s Mendoza College of Business is ranked the best
undergrad business school for the fifth straight year in a row, according to Bloomberg
BusinessWeek.2 Notre Dame’s Mendoza College of Business’ mission statement is, “To build a
premier Catholic business school that fosters academic excellence, professional effectiveness and
personal accountability in a context that strives to be faithful to the ideals of community, human
development and individual integrity.”3
3
School Practices
The University of Notre Dame has three leading values that are dispersed throughout the
college. These three values are, honesty, integrity, and honor.4 It is mandatory for all students to
read, and also sign, an Academic Code of Honor for the Mendoza College of Business Graduate
program. It is easy to read and summarizes both the expectations of the students, and also the
procedures that follow when expectations are not met. Many faculty at Notre Dame Mendoza
College of Business continuously remind their students of the code of honor through the use of
their course syllabus. Not only does the code of honor include students living up to the core
values of the college, but it also includes the faculty and staffs’ responsibility and expectations.5
Including the faculty helps to further create a cohesive community working towards the same
goal of honesty, integrity, and honor.
In the mission statement for the Mendoza College of Business, Management Department,
they say, “We place particular emphasis on moral decision making within the context of rapid
change and increased competition.”6 The Mendoza College of Business also has a Center for
Ethical Leadership, Notre Dame Deloitte Center for Ethical Leadership, which is used as a center
for ethics research.7
The University of Texas at Austin: McCombs School of Business
Overview
The University of Texas at Austin was opened in 1883.8 Today, 131 years later, it is
ranked sixth on the list of the best undergraduate business schools, according to Bloomberg
BusinessWeek.9 The University of Texas at Austin combines their mission, core purpose, and
honor code into one. Their student honor code is, “As a student of The University of Texas at
Austin, I shall abide by the core values of the University and uphold academic integrity.”10
4
School Practices
The University of Texas at Austin has a code of conduct for all to follow, “The core
values of The University of Texas at Austin are learning, discovery, freedom, leadership,
individual opportunity, and responsibility. Each member of the university is expected to uphold
these values through integrity, honesty, trust, fairness, and respect toward peers and
community.”11 The students and faculty in McCombs School of Business work together to keep
their reputation of having a high level of excellence throughout the college by allowing no room
for academic dishonesty whatsoever.
McCombs School of Business has a Code of Ethics that details the students’
responsibilities, faculty responsibilities, and also gives a definition of scholastic dishonesty for
all to see.12 The first of four outlined responsibilities expected of students is that they must
understand the definition of scholastic dishonesty.13 This gives students a detailed explanation of
what is and is not allowed and expected of them. The faculty has five outlined responsibilities,
but it is not mandatory that these responsibilities are met in order for students to behavior
ethically, which is important to mention so students do not just blame their unethical behavior on
their perceptions of their professors acting unethically.14 The University of Texas at Austin
makes it clear that each individual involved in the McCombs School of Business is responsible
to uphold a high level of academic integrity and avoid any temptations they may face.
Universityof Oregon: Lundquist College ofBusiness
Overview
The University of Oregon was established in 1876. Today, 138 years later, it is ranked 121st on
the list of best undergraduate business schools, according to Bloomberg BusinessWeek.15
Lundquist College of Business is part of the state’s flagship AAU University and their mission
5
for undergraduate education is, “Provide outstanding undergraduate education that combines a
strong foundation in the liberal arts, excellence in traditional business disciplines, and
experiential opportunities drawing on the strengths of Oregon’s distinctive qualities.”16
School Practices
The University of Oregon Lundquist College of Business has “taught its students the
critical skills they need to think for themselves, to be leaders in a dynamic world, and to make
better decisions on behalf of the people and resources they manage.”17 The Lundquist College of
Business has a Code of Professional Business Conduct and also places a large responsibility on
faculty of the college to grade students in a way that will benefit them and society as well. The
Code of Professional Business Conduct defines how those involved in Lundquist College of
Business should act, and what it means to act like a professional. The five core values that are
defined include, integrity, respect, openness, responsibility, and teamwork.18 There is not any
information readily available to see what the repercussions are to any type of academic
dishonesty within the college.
Universityof Arizona: Eller College ofManagement
Overview
The University of Arizona was founded in 1885. Today, 129 years later, it is ranked 71st
on the list of best undergraduate business schools, according to Bloomberg BusinessWeek.19 The
Eller College of Management’s mission statement is, “The Eller College of Management’s
Undergraduate Program is committed to building and maintaining working relationships with our
students, faculty, recruiters, alumni, and volunteers predicted on mutual respect and
responsibility. We strive to nurture student success through innovation and value-added
6
personalized programs. The following core competencies are emphasized within our program:
knowledge, skills, ethical behavior, positive attitude, and creativity.”20
School Practices
The Eller College of Management not only has a mission statement that includes
emphasizing ethical behavior, it also has goals on how to reach their mission. These goals
include, curriculum, community, career, character, academic advising, globalization, diversity,
leadership, and talent.21 The College also has a Center for Leadership Ethics where “…scholars
with diverse interest pertaining to leadership ethics who are committed to improving the ethical
culture of organization. The Center rests on the three pillars of research, education, and
outreach.”22
The Eller College of Management has policies and codes, including a voluntary oath for
students in the college, codes of conduct and integrity, and guidelines that outline the
disciplinary action that will take place in cases of academic dishonesty.23 There are also student
guides that outline life in the Eller College of Management, tips for success, different types of
academic dishonesty, and gives them a list of helpful resources and where to access them.24 The
Eller College of Management also has a “GoodCat Hotline” where students have the ease,
anonymity, and power to report any kind of questionable behaviors, misconduct, or any other
concerns regarding academic integrity, honesty, and other ethical behavior.25 It is an online
process that is all done through an independent third party to ensure that the individual will
remain anonymous if that is what they want.
Empty Practices
After researching the four colleges above, it seems that there are a couple empty
practices, as with most institutions. The Lundquist College of Business at the University of
7
Oregon has a Code of Professional Business Conduct, but there is no core value, besides
integrity, that deals directly with acting ethically and upholding a higher standard for the college.
This Code of Professional Business Conduct is an empty practice because it does not give well
defined and outlined guidelines and procedures on how to act within the college. The Eller
College of Management at the University of Arizona has a voluntary oath for students within the
college. Since it is voluntary, there is no binding contract the students are tied too. Since there is
nothing binding students to the oath, it is an empty practice.
BestPractices
In order to create a well-structured honor code and system for maintaining ethical
behavior, there must be sold practices in place and upheld by everyone within the college.
Mendoza College of Business at Notre Dame has a code of honor that outlines and details what
is expected of students, and what the procedures are if they code of honor is not followed.
Students must read, understand, and sign the code of honor, which creates a binding contract
between the student and the college’s code of honor. McCombs School of Business at The
University of Texas at Austin has a code of ethics that outlines expectations and repercussions,
as well as include the faculty’s roles and expectations. Everyone involved in the college is held
to a higher ethical standard, and each individual is responsible for doing this. The Eller College
of Management at the University of Arizona has a “GoodCat Hotline” where a third party takes
in reports of complaints regarding questionable behaviors, misconduct, or any other concerns
regarding academic integrity, honesty, and other ethical behavior. This is a best practice because
students are able to remain anonymous, and are therefore more likely to be a whistleblower.
8
SectionTwo:Faculty, Student, and Potential Employer Input
After interviewing three students from the College of Business, Dean Ilene Kleinsorge,
and a prospective employer of OSU graduates, we formulated input and a set of perspectives that
can be used to help us understand what components need to be implemented into our new honor
code system.
StudentInput
The three students had similarities in their perspectives, and also some key differences
that we will highlight in this section. The first similarity, all the students were unaware of the
current honor code, and agree that if students are not aware of it, then nothing will get done to
highlight our policy on ethics. The second similarity, each of the students agreed the professors
are liable to uphold the honor code and to act in a way that models ethical behavior. The third
similarity, each student identifies that the major ethical issues in the College of Business involve
some sort of cheating and sharing of information that can give others an unfair advantage. This
has to do with the concept of fairness: if one person thinks that they are not being treated fairly
then they will retaliate or feel negatively about the processes in place that should prevent this
type of behavior.
Students experience cheating first-hand through observing others doing this during
exams, or even outside of the classroom. The reason most of the students we interviewed gave
for not wanting to ‘whistle blow’ for extra credit is because they feel that people should be held
accountable for themselves and that these extrinsic rewards could diminish the value of the honor
system in place. This is one issue that the new honor code system should seek to resolve. We
also believe that too often, students only view ethics as cheating, rather than including the
respect and responsibility aspects. This too will be integrated into the new system.
9
FacultyInput
After interviewing Dean Kleinsorge, we gained valuable insight towards what her
perspective is on what is currently lacking in the honor code system, ways to inform students,
and how to create an ethical culture. The main issues she observes in the College of Business
honor code system is that the students did not see the ethical values as an integral part of who
they are, and the repercussions resulting from unethical behavior while they are in college. She
believes that cheating, disrespecting others, and behaving irresponsibly are the major underlying
issues with the current honor code system. She has spoken to many students as she prepares to
implement the new honor system, and has heard from a student perspective what they think the
major ethical issues are. She has also spoken to College of Business graduates about a time that
they behaved unethically while at Oregon State. These facts show that, for the best interest of the
students, an ethical culture focusing on integrity, respect, and responsibility must be ingrained in
the new College of Business’ honor code system.
Potential Employer’sInput
Lastly, we interviewed a potential employer, Lynn, from Technology Across the
Curriculum, which is a department dedicated to improving the technology and learning
management system here at Oregon State. Lynn employs students in this department, and has
great insight towards the challenges students face in regards to ethics. She said that students need
more help and information regarding plagiarism and how to avoid it, and that it can become an
ethical concern when other students and instructors are negatively impacted. She also believes
that it can have indirect effects on others who do the work in that it may undervalue our
educational system and degrees. She also mentioned that out of the students she knows and
works with, they are very motivated, honest, and aware. The few that do behave unethically are
10
the ones that attract the most attention. When asking her if a strong culture of ethics could have a
positive influence on the students, she said that it would depend on how well the culture is
supported and maintained throughout the student’s academic career, and that a “carrot and stick”
approach may be needed to promote positive behavior and discourage the negative behavior.
This means the honor code would need to be reinforced throughout the university staff,
instructors, and curriculum with a heavy presence so that it does not get lost among other
numerous priorities.
SectionThree:Components of Honor Code and BestPractices
Students
Students are the main focus of the honor code, and also the best practices. In order for
students to do the best they can to uphold the expectations laid out in the honor code, they must
have a clear and well detailed honor code that explains what is expected of them, and what the
repercussions and procedures are in cases where they participate in unethical behavior. To make
the honor code known to students, the College of Business at Oregon State University needs to
create a packet with the honor code system detailed in it, have the students read and sign the
packet, and then return it to their department before being allowed to begin classes.
Notre Dame has a practice in place like this where their honor code system, including
expectations of students and faculty, repercussions and procedures for dealing with unethical
behavior, are outlined in these packets that students must sign and return. This creates a more
binding agreement, and the students are no longer anonymous. Creating a packet like this will
give the honor code higher moral intensity, bring about a higher moral attentiveness, which are
all drivers for higher ethical awareness. Along with the idea of this packet, students should also
11
have to take a quiz all about the honor code within the college in order to be allowed to register
for classes. There can be an academic hold placed on their account if they do not take the quiz, or
do not pass with at least an 80%. This forces students to review the honor code and re-associate
themselves with the rules and regulations put in place.
There should also be a sheet, like the one in the appendix, to be signed before the
beginning of each exam in all classes within the College of Business. This sheet promotes the
honor code system, and reminds students of the higher standard they are expected to perform at.
Reminding students of this higher ethical standard will help them live up to that standard, and
also give them no excuse about not knowing what is expected of them. All classes will use the
same sheet, thus making it uniform and a normative paradigm thought all majors within the
college.
A great practice of the Eller College of Management at the University of Arizona should
also be brought to OSU. They have a “GoodCat” hotline where students can go online and
whistle blow to any type of unethical behavior they have witnessed or any other concerns they
may have, and remain anonymous. The anonymity of the process creates a higher likelihood that
people will whistle blow about things they see taking place. An anonymous hotline like this
would give students the ability to self-regulate themselves without giving up their identity. They
would feel better about themselves because they voiced their concerns, but they are still
protected because no one will know it was them that reported the poor behavior.
Involving the students in fun and creative outlets that pertain to the honor code is
important. Students need to be aware, keyed in, and willing to promote the honor code in order
for it to be effective. Putting together creative outlets for students such as an honors code slogan
or poster competition with prizes, awards, and recognition for the top five or so slogans is a great
12
way to include the student body. These slogans and posters can be displayed in Austin Hall for
everyone to see. Not only does it give recognition and create a more binding relationship
between the honors code and the students, it also raise awareness a little more through what the
slogans and posters portray.
With all the research out there on how different things in the environment affect how
ethical people are, the College of Business should do students a favor and prep them for success.,
success in this situation being conducting themselves ethically. To prep students to act ethically,
a watermark of the three aspects of the College of Business honor code should be on all papers
and websites the honor code is written on, and also on tests given in all of the College of
Business classes. Making sure the rooms are clean smelling and have bright lighting may seem
like small, petty things, but in the bigger picture, they do play a significant role. Making sure the
environment is prepped as well as possible is the College of Business’ responsibility to all of its
students.
Faculty
We believe that the faculty should support the honors system in a majority of ways in
order for the students to fully understand the importance of it. Students interact with faculty
every day, and the honor code system should be seamlessly integrated into these interactions.
One thing that could be done is to have Ilene Kleinsorge focus the Dean’s Distinguished Lecture
series on the new honor code’s three core values: Integrity, Respect, and Responsibility. Each
term, she could select one of these values and bring a professional in to speak about their
experiences with a time that they dealt with that value. An example would be to focus a lecture
on integrity, where the professional would explain about a situation in which an employee was
not acting with integrity, and his or her response to the situation, with an application for us as
13
students. This would be a great way to incorporate outside people who have experience in the
business world, with students. It would also communicate the importance of having a strong
honor code system.
Another thing the Dean could implement is a lecture for all students accepted into Pro-
school. During the start of the term they are in pro-school, Ilene could give them an acceptance
speech, and talk about the honor system. While doing so, she could mention the fact that
unethical behavior now can decrease the value of their degrees later. This will hopefully increase
the ethical awareness of the situation, and will show the students how small acts of unethical
behavior can negatively impact them down the road. We believe that by doing so, ethics will be
at fresh in students’ minds once starting classes, and will give them more of a direct reason to act
with integrity, respect, and responsibility. One other small thing that the faculty could do to
communicate the importance of the honor system is to have the three core values at the end of
every email. This would remind both the students and faculty of the values indirectly.
With Austin Hall ready for students in Fall 2014, there will be many small rooms for
discussion, focus groups, etc. One of these rooms could be an area for faculty and student
meetings and discussions. Every few weeks, one of the faculty members or a student could be
responsible for hosting a “Coffee Hour Discussion” about some type of ethical issue in the
College of Business. This would both involve the students and faculty more, and give them an
area to vent their concerns and have a voice. Each week would be a different topic, and could
consist of activities and brainstorming sessions regarding the new honor code system. We
believe that this would be especially important to do during the first year of implementation,
because there will be many “bumps” along the way.
14
By setting time aside with regular meetings, faculty and students would be able to show their
support for the new honor system, and would also be able to use what they have learned from
these discussions, in class.
When speaking to the students, we gained feedback concerning the repetition of stating
the honor code at the beginning of every class. Instead of doing this, faculty could speak about
what the honor system means to them, and a personal experience when the honor system had
some influence on the situation. This would be a dynamic and effective way of engaging
students, while showing them the support from the faulty on the honor system.
At about the middle of the term, around midterms, professors should give feedback to
each student on how they are doing in class, their level of engagement, ethical behavior, etc. This
channel of communication is important for supporting the honor system in that speaking to the
professor will give the student the opportunity to ask more questions and gain feedback on any
ethical issues that have arrived, while having time during the rest of the term to correct that
issue.26 Finally, there should be consistency among faculty expectations throughout the whole
year, and the entire College of Business. This would give the students a feeling that there is
strong procedural justice in the system, and that everyone is upheld to the same standards.27
Curriculum and UniversityBased
It is very important for the University and College of Business curriculum to be unified in
working towards the same goal, having a better honor system integrated and upheld among all
students. This honor system needs to be applied consistently and uniformly throughout all classes
in order to make it the expectation for all students during their time here at Oregon State, and in
their lives after college. The communication and expectations need to be applied both
consistently and uniformly.28 To further integrate a unified curriculum, there should be a basic
15
ethics class that is required as one of the Baccalaureate Core classes. This should at least be a
Bacc Core class for the College of Business, but to make an even more unified student body, it
should be mandatory for all colleges at Oregon State. Requiring a basic ethics class sets a
standard and foundation for everyone to follow and build off of, and creates an awareness of just
how prevalent ethics and morals are in our day-to-day lives.
Another thing that could be incorporated into the College of Business is to have
workshops on plagiarism, cheating, respect, and other things that students can improve upon to
support the honor system. These workshops could be provided as extra credit opportunities for
classes, and may be offered once each term. This would allow the faculty to engage the students
in something more tangible, while allowing them the opportunity to learn and grow. This would
be a positive thing because if a student is caught plagiarizing, the College of Business would
have evidence to show that it was not because they were uninformed.
One thing these events need to focus on is the fact that unethical behavior is not just
cheating. When focusing on conveying a message related to the honor system, the respect and
responsibility aspects must be given appropriate weight. The College of Business honor code is
also about how students treat each other, treat their professors, and the responsibility of coming
prepared to class and acting appropriately. In the lectures, workshops, and student-engaging
material, all three aspects must be mentioned to show the importance of integrating these aspects
into the student’s demeanor.
It is also important to have the honor code easily accessible on the college’s website. All
students we interviewed had no idea what the honor code was, and some said they were not able
to easily find it on Oregon State’s website. Most other colleges we researched had their ethics
code, honor code, or code of conduct easily accessible by putting it as another tab on the
16
college’s home page. By placing a tab that is strictly the honor code system on the homepage, it
raises awareness among all who visit the page, and also makes it easy to find and reference.
One of the most prevalent factors when researching other top business school programs
nationwide was that they all had a formal name for their business college: Mendoza College of
Business, McCombs School of Business, Lundquist College of Business, and Eller College of
Management. Currently Oregon State University business program is just the College of
Business. With so many different majors and tracks within the College of Business, there is a
very fragmented idea of what the goal is for the college, and also business in general. By giving
the current College of Business at Oregon State a name, such as Austin College of Business, it
sets a foundation for creating a normative paradigm throughout all majors and tracks.
Overall Best Practices
Overall, faculty and university-wide communication about the honor system needs to be
extremely clear and consistent in order to be effective.29 Mixed messages, including
inconsistency in actions among faculty, will only decrease the value of the honor code and
ethical culture that the College of Business is striving to create for it’s students. There will be a
heightened ethical awareness throughout the College of Business, because our honor system, (1)
will create an environment where peers will look to each other and find support for the honor
system, (2) will use clear and ethical language in all facets of communication, and (3) will make
it clear that unethical actions can severely damage the reputation of the students, and the value of
their degrees.30 By integrating the core values and honors code throughout all of the outlets
discussed above, students will be constantly engaged with the honor code system.
The main goal of creating this ethical culture is to hopefully move students from
operating in the pre-conventional stage, to the conventional or even post-conventional stage by
17
the time they graduate.31 Instead of behaving ethically in order to receive small rewards, the hope
is that they will act ethically because it is simply the right thing to do, and is ingrained in the
culture of the College of Business. We believe that by aggressively implementing all of the
things mentioned previously, this is a very realistic goal that can be achieved in the next five
years.
One of the most important factors to focus on is creating a normative paradigm
throughout all majors of the College of Business at Oregon State University. It is important to
have all students studying under the same core ethical honor code in order to work towards the
same goal. Unifying the college will help create a more binding relationship between students,
faculty, and the college in general. Having a clear and unified goal, along with fair and equal
procedures, will help create a more ethical environment for all tied to not only the College of
Business, but also Oregon State University.
Conclusion
To wrap it all up, the most important factor in creating a more ethical business school at
Oregon State University is to create a normative paradigm for all students, no matter what their
major, to follow and live up to. Integrity, respect, and responsibility are the core of what the
honor code is all about. Each student needs to be made aware of this, and also of his or her role
in upholding these core values. Once the school is unified under one common, core, normative
paradigm, we can begin to come together and work towards a unified goal, instead of being torn
in different directions because of different majors. If everyone is working towards the same goal,
there is a sense of unity, and students are then able to work more ethically, and together as a
team, to reach the same core goals as everyone else. With integrity, respect, responsibility.
18
Appendix
Example Honors Sheet to be Signed Before Exam:
Integrity, Respect, and Responsibility are the core values for the College of
Business at Oregon State University. Integrity is defined as the quality of being
honest and having strong moral principles. Respect is defined as valuing differing
viewpoints, accepting others, and consistently acting in a professional
demeanor. Responsibility is defined as holding yourself accountable for the
decisions you make.
By signing this, I pledge to act with these three core values at all times. I also
pledge my honor that I have neither received nor given unauthorized aid on this
examination, or have witnessed others doing so without reporting it.
SIGNATURE: ________________________________
NAME: ______________________________________
STUDENT ID #: ______________________________
19
Resources
"About the Lundquist College of Business." About. University of Oregon, n.d. Web. 17 May
2014. <https://business.uoregon.edu/about>.
"About Us." : Center for Leadership Ethics : Department of Management and Organizations :
Eller College of Management : The University of Arizona. The University of Arizona,
n.d. Web. 17 May 2014. <http://ethics.eller.arizona.edu/about/>.
Clark, Patrick. "Mendoza Students Really, Really Love Their School: Notre Dame Is the Best
Undergrad Business School for a Fifth Year."Bloomberg Business Week. Bloomberg, 4
Apr. 2014. Web. 17 May 2014. <http://www.businessweek.com/articles/2014-04-
04/mendoza-students-really-really-love-their-school-notre-dame-best-undergrad-
business-school-for-a-fifth-year>.
"Code of Ethics." . McCombs School of Business, The University of Austin at Texas, 15 May
2013. Web. 17 May 2014. <http://www.mccombs.utexas.edu/BBA/Code-of-Ethics>.
"Deloitte Center for Ethical Leadership." About // // University of Notre Dame. University of
Notre Dame, 1 Jan. 2014. Web. 17 May 2014. <http://ethicalleadership.nd.edu/about/>.
"GoodCat Hotline." University of Arizona -. EthicsPoint, Inc., n.d. Web. 17 May 2014.
<https://universityofarizona.ethicspointvp.com/custom/uaz_air/>.
"History & Traditions." Home. The University of Texas at Austin, 1 Jan. 2014. Web. 17 May
2014. <http://www.utexas.edu/about-ut/history-traditions>.
"History of the University." History // About ND //. University of Notre Dame, 1 Jan. 2007. Web.
17 May 2014. <http://www.nd.edu/about/history/>.
20
"Master of Science in Business." Academic Policies. Mendoza College of Business, University
of Notre Dame, 1 Jan. 2010. Web. 17 May 2014.
<http://business.nd.edu/msb/academics/academic_policies/>.
"Mission, Core Purpose and Honor Code." Home. The University of Texas at Austin, 1 Jan.
2014. Web. 17 May 2014. <http://www.utexas.edu/about-ut/mission-core-purpose-honor-
code>.
"Mission Statement." : About Us : Undergraduate Programs : Eller College of Management :
The University of Arizona. The University of Arizona, n.d. Web. 17 May 2014.
<http://ugrad.eller.arizona.edu/about/mission.asp>.
"Mission Statement Department of Management." . Mendoza College of Business, University of
Notre Dame, n.d. Web. 17 May 2014.
<http://business.nd.edu/uploadedFiles/Faculty_and_Research/PDF_and_Documents/Man
agement%20Mission%20Statement%207_14.pdf>.
"Our Ethics Standards." Policies and Guidelines : : Academics : Undergraduate Programs :
Eller College of Management : The University of Arizona. The University of Arizona,
n.d. Web. 17 May 2014.
<http://ugrad.eller.arizona.edu/academics/standards/policies.asp>.
"Our Ethics Standards." Student Guides : : Academics : Undergraduate Programs : Eller
College of Management : The University of Arizona. The University of Arizona, n.d.
Web. 17 May 2014. <http://ugrad.eller.arizona.edu/academics/standards/guides.asp>.
"Programs." Programs. Mendoza College of Business, University of Notre Dame, 1 Jan. 2010.
Web. 17 May 2014. <http://business.nd.edu/programs/>.
21
"The Complete Ranking: Best Undergraduate Business Schools 2014."Bloomberg Business
Week. Bloomberg, 4 Apr. 2014. Web. 17 May 2014.
<http://www.businessweek.com/articles/2014-04-04/the-complete-ranking-best-
undergraduate-business-schools-2014>.
"The Mendoza College of Business Graduate Academic Code of Honor." . Mendoza College of
Business, University of Notre Dame, n.d. Web. 17 May 2014.
<http://business.nd.edu/uploadedFiles/microsites/pdfs/mbacurrentstudents/Honor%20Co
de,%202013-14.pdf>.
Trevino, Linda K., and Katherine A. Nelson. Managing Business Ethics Straight Talk About
How To Do It Right. Sixth ed. Hoboken, New Jersey: John Wiley and Sons, Inc., 2014.
Print.
"Undergraduate Policies." Home. University of Oregon, 23 Jan. 2012. Web. 17 May 2014.
<https://business.uoregon.edu/ug/policies>.
22
Endnotes
1 http://www.nd.edu/about/history/
2 http://www.businessweek.com/articles/2014-04-04/mendoza-students-really-really-love-their-
school-notre-dame-best-undergrad-business-school-for-a-fifth-year
3 http://business.nd.edu/programs/
4 http://business.nd.edu/msb/academics/academic_policies/
5
http://business.nd.edu/uploadedFiles/microsites/pdfs/mbacurrentstudents/Honor%20Code,%2020
13-14.pdf
6
http://business.nd.edu/uploadedFiles/Faculty_and_Research/PDF_and_Documents/Management
%20Mission%20Statement%207_14.pdf
7 http://ethicalleadership.nd.edu/about/
8 http://www.utexas.edu/about-ut/history-traditions
9 http://www.businessweek.com/articles/2014-04-04/the-complete-ranking-best-undergraduate-
business-schools-2014
10 http://www.utexas.edu/about-ut/mission-core-purpose-honor-code
11 http://www.utexas.edu/about-ut/mission-core-purpose-honor-code
12 http://www.mccombs.utexas.edu/BBA/Code-of-Ethics
13 http://www.mccombs.utexas.edu/BBA/Code-of-Ethics
14 http://www.mccombs.utexas.edu/BBA/Code-of-Ethics
15 http://www.businessweek.com/articles/2014-04-04/the-complete-ranking-best-undergraduate-
business-schools-2014
16 https://business.uoregon.edu/about
17 https://business.uoregon.edu/about
18 https://business.uoregon.edu/ug/policies
19 http://www.businessweek.com/articles/2014-04-04/the-complete-ranking-best-undergraduate-
business-schools-2014
20 http://ugrad.eller.arizona.edu/about/mission.asp
21 http://ugrad.eller.arizona.edu/about/mission.asp
22 http://ethics.eller.arizona.edu/about/
23 http://ugrad.eller.arizona.edu/academics/standards/policies.asp
24 http://ugrad.eller.arizona.edu/academics/standards/guides.asp
25 https://universityofarizona.ethicspointvp.com/custom/uaz_air/
26 Chapter Seven, Trevino
27 Chapter Seven, Trevino
28 Chapter Seven, Trevino
29 Chapter Five, Trevino
30 Chapter Three, Trevino
31 Chapter Three, Trevino

More Related Content

Similar to MGMT 459 Term Paper

Please respond to the following discussion questionsDiscussion .docx
Please respond to the following discussion questionsDiscussion .docxPlease respond to the following discussion questionsDiscussion .docx
Please respond to the following discussion questionsDiscussion .docxblazelaj2
 
All Hands on Deck: An Integrated Approach to Career Development- Part I
All Hands on Deck: An Integrated Approach to Career Development- Part IAll Hands on Deck: An Integrated Approach to Career Development- Part I
All Hands on Deck: An Integrated Approach to Career Development- Part ILakeisha Mathews
 
Impact of-research-exploratory-study ( mba)
Impact of-research-exploratory-study ( mba)Impact of-research-exploratory-study ( mba)
Impact of-research-exploratory-study ( mba)John Pratheesh
 
what makes a good university education quality case study
what makes a good university education quality case studywhat makes a good university education quality case study
what makes a good university education quality case studyInternational advisers
 
How to Select the Best Co-ed boarding school for your kid.pdf
How to Select the Best Co-ed boarding school for your kid.pdfHow to Select the Best Co-ed boarding school for your kid.pdf
How to Select the Best Co-ed boarding school for your kid.pdfDivine International School
 
Internship Report on ILM College Sargodha
Internship Report on ILM College SargodhaInternship Report on ILM College Sargodha
Internship Report on ILM College SargodhaUsama Karim
 
2014 2015 Final Revised 05 2014
2014 2015 Final Revised 05 20142014 2015 Final Revised 05 2014
2014 2015 Final Revised 05 2014Valerie Felton
 
Student affairs boo k 2009
Student affairs boo k 2009Student affairs boo k 2009
Student affairs boo k 2009guest711656c
 
Conventionalities and answer ability in the teaching employment
Conventionalities and answer ability in the teaching employmentConventionalities and answer ability in the teaching employment
Conventionalities and answer ability in the teaching employmentIJERA Editor
 
The Personal and Intellectual Development of Students
The Personal and Intellectual Development of StudentsThe Personal and Intellectual Development of Students
The Personal and Intellectual Development of Studentsnoblex1
 
The edupreneur's ultimate guide to academic excellence and educational admini...
The edupreneur's ultimate guide to academic excellence and educational admini...The edupreneur's ultimate guide to academic excellence and educational admini...
The edupreneur's ultimate guide to academic excellence and educational admini...Dr. Trilok Kumar Jain
 
The edupreneur's ultimate guide to academic excellence and educational admini...
The edupreneur's ultimate guide to academic excellence and educational admini...The edupreneur's ultimate guide to academic excellence and educational admini...
The edupreneur's ultimate guide to academic excellence and educational admini...Dr. Trilok Kumar Jain
 
Professional Portfoilio Presentation
Professional Portfoilio PresentationProfessional Portfoilio Presentation
Professional Portfoilio PresentationTodd Barraco
 
Week 5 AssignmentIn each week the learning assignment is design.docx
Week 5 AssignmentIn each week the learning assignment is design.docxWeek 5 AssignmentIn each week the learning assignment is design.docx
Week 5 AssignmentIn each week the learning assignment is design.docxcockekeshia
 
Expanding the Help: Assessing the Effectiveness of Academic Mentors in Upperc...
Expanding the Help: Assessing the Effectiveness of Academic Mentors in Upperc...Expanding the Help: Assessing the Effectiveness of Academic Mentors in Upperc...
Expanding the Help: Assessing the Effectiveness of Academic Mentors in Upperc...Tom Durkee
 
april 22,2023 learning activities by KAMID.pdf
april 22,2023 learning activities by KAMID.pdfapril 22,2023 learning activities by KAMID.pdf
april 22,2023 learning activities by KAMID.pdfKamarudinKamid
 
1213 2016_GuideToBSchools_Full
1213 2016_GuideToBSchools_Full1213 2016_GuideToBSchools_Full
1213 2016_GuideToBSchools_FullTeresa Echeverria
 
Placement Brochure ,School of Management Studies,UoH 2014-15
Placement Brochure ,School of Management Studies,UoH 2014-15Placement Brochure ,School of Management Studies,UoH 2014-15
Placement Brochure ,School of Management Studies,UoH 2014-15smsuohyd
 

Similar to MGMT 459 Term Paper (20)

Please respond to the following discussion questionsDiscussion .docx
Please respond to the following discussion questionsDiscussion .docxPlease respond to the following discussion questionsDiscussion .docx
Please respond to the following discussion questionsDiscussion .docx
 
All Hands on Deck: An Integrated Approach to Career Development- Part I
All Hands on Deck: An Integrated Approach to Career Development- Part IAll Hands on Deck: An Integrated Approach to Career Development- Part I
All Hands on Deck: An Integrated Approach to Career Development- Part I
 
Salem International University Undergraduate Catalog 09 2010
Salem International University Undergraduate Catalog 09 2010Salem International University Undergraduate Catalog 09 2010
Salem International University Undergraduate Catalog 09 2010
 
Impact of-research-exploratory-study ( mba)
Impact of-research-exploratory-study ( mba)Impact of-research-exploratory-study ( mba)
Impact of-research-exploratory-study ( mba)
 
School2college.com
School2college.comSchool2college.com
School2college.com
 
what makes a good university education quality case study
what makes a good university education quality case studywhat makes a good university education quality case study
what makes a good university education quality case study
 
How to Select the Best Co-ed boarding school for your kid.pdf
How to Select the Best Co-ed boarding school for your kid.pdfHow to Select the Best Co-ed boarding school for your kid.pdf
How to Select the Best Co-ed boarding school for your kid.pdf
 
Internship Report on ILM College Sargodha
Internship Report on ILM College SargodhaInternship Report on ILM College Sargodha
Internship Report on ILM College Sargodha
 
2014 2015 Final Revised 05 2014
2014 2015 Final Revised 05 20142014 2015 Final Revised 05 2014
2014 2015 Final Revised 05 2014
 
Student affairs boo k 2009
Student affairs boo k 2009Student affairs boo k 2009
Student affairs boo k 2009
 
Conventionalities and answer ability in the teaching employment
Conventionalities and answer ability in the teaching employmentConventionalities and answer ability in the teaching employment
Conventionalities and answer ability in the teaching employment
 
The Personal and Intellectual Development of Students
The Personal and Intellectual Development of StudentsThe Personal and Intellectual Development of Students
The Personal and Intellectual Development of Students
 
The edupreneur's ultimate guide to academic excellence and educational admini...
The edupreneur's ultimate guide to academic excellence and educational admini...The edupreneur's ultimate guide to academic excellence and educational admini...
The edupreneur's ultimate guide to academic excellence and educational admini...
 
The edupreneur's ultimate guide to academic excellence and educational admini...
The edupreneur's ultimate guide to academic excellence and educational admini...The edupreneur's ultimate guide to academic excellence and educational admini...
The edupreneur's ultimate guide to academic excellence and educational admini...
 
Professional Portfoilio Presentation
Professional Portfoilio PresentationProfessional Portfoilio Presentation
Professional Portfoilio Presentation
 
Week 5 AssignmentIn each week the learning assignment is design.docx
Week 5 AssignmentIn each week the learning assignment is design.docxWeek 5 AssignmentIn each week the learning assignment is design.docx
Week 5 AssignmentIn each week the learning assignment is design.docx
 
Expanding the Help: Assessing the Effectiveness of Academic Mentors in Upperc...
Expanding the Help: Assessing the Effectiveness of Academic Mentors in Upperc...Expanding the Help: Assessing the Effectiveness of Academic Mentors in Upperc...
Expanding the Help: Assessing the Effectiveness of Academic Mentors in Upperc...
 
april 22,2023 learning activities by KAMID.pdf
april 22,2023 learning activities by KAMID.pdfapril 22,2023 learning activities by KAMID.pdf
april 22,2023 learning activities by KAMID.pdf
 
1213 2016_GuideToBSchools_Full
1213 2016_GuideToBSchools_Full1213 2016_GuideToBSchools_Full
1213 2016_GuideToBSchools_Full
 
Placement Brochure ,School of Management Studies,UoH 2014-15
Placement Brochure ,School of Management Studies,UoH 2014-15Placement Brochure ,School of Management Studies,UoH 2014-15
Placement Brochure ,School of Management Studies,UoH 2014-15
 

More from Hallie Exall

Introduction to Puppet Enterprise 2016.4
Introduction to Puppet Enterprise 2016.4Introduction to Puppet Enterprise 2016.4
Introduction to Puppet Enterprise 2016.4Hallie Exall
 
Introduction to Puppet Enterprise 5/5
Introduction to Puppet Enterprise 5/5Introduction to Puppet Enterprise 5/5
Introduction to Puppet Enterprise 5/5Hallie Exall
 
Getting Up and Running with the Windows Module Pack
Getting Up and Running with the Windows Module PackGetting Up and Running with the Windows Module Pack
Getting Up and Running with the Windows Module PackHallie Exall
 
Introduction to Puppet Enterprise
Introduction to Puppet Enterprise Introduction to Puppet Enterprise
Introduction to Puppet Enterprise Hallie Exall
 
Introduction to Puppet Enterprise 2016.1 (UK)
Introduction to Puppet Enterprise 2016.1 (UK)Introduction to Puppet Enterprise 2016.1 (UK)
Introduction to Puppet Enterprise 2016.1 (UK)Hallie Exall
 
Setting Up Windows for Systems and Application Monitoring
Setting Up Windows for Systems and Application MonitoringSetting Up Windows for Systems and Application Monitoring
Setting Up Windows for Systems and Application MonitoringHallie Exall
 
INDUSTRY LTD PAPER
INDUSTRY LTD PAPERINDUSTRY LTD PAPER
INDUSTRY LTD PAPERHallie Exall
 

More from Hallie Exall (10)

Introduction to Puppet Enterprise 2016.4
Introduction to Puppet Enterprise 2016.4Introduction to Puppet Enterprise 2016.4
Introduction to Puppet Enterprise 2016.4
 
Introduction to Puppet Enterprise 5/5
Introduction to Puppet Enterprise 5/5Introduction to Puppet Enterprise 5/5
Introduction to Puppet Enterprise 5/5
 
Getting Up and Running with the Windows Module Pack
Getting Up and Running with the Windows Module PackGetting Up and Running with the Windows Module Pack
Getting Up and Running with the Windows Module Pack
 
Introduction to Puppet Enterprise
Introduction to Puppet Enterprise Introduction to Puppet Enterprise
Introduction to Puppet Enterprise
 
Introduction to Puppet Enterprise 2016.1 (UK)
Introduction to Puppet Enterprise 2016.1 (UK)Introduction to Puppet Enterprise 2016.1 (UK)
Introduction to Puppet Enterprise 2016.1 (UK)
 
Setting Up Windows for Systems and Application Monitoring
Setting Up Windows for Systems and Application MonitoringSetting Up Windows for Systems and Application Monitoring
Setting Up Windows for Systems and Application Monitoring
 
Final Round RFP
Final Round RFPFinal Round RFP
Final Round RFP
 
PAPER FINAL
PAPER FINALPAPER FINAL
PAPER FINAL
 
INDUSTRY LTD PAPER
INDUSTRY LTD PAPERINDUSTRY LTD PAPER
INDUSTRY LTD PAPER
 
KusalaMopeds
KusalaMopedsKusalaMopeds
KusalaMopeds
 

MGMT 459 Term Paper

  • 1. Oregon State University College of Business Honor System -Term Paper- Hallie Exall & Tessa McGill Professor Leavitt MGMT 459: Managing Ethics and Corporate Social Responsibility Section 001 June 06, 2014
  • 2. 1 Contents Introduction..................................................................................................................................... 2 Section One: Business Schools and Best Practice .......................................................................... 2 Notre Dame: Mendoza College of Business............................................................................... 2 Overview ................................................................................................................................. 2 School Practices...................................................................................................................... 3 The University of Texas at Austin: McCombs School of Business............................................ 3 Overview ................................................................................................................................. 3 School Practices...................................................................................................................... 4 University of Oregon: Lundquist College of Business ............................................................... 4 Overview ................................................................................................................................. 4 School Practices...................................................................................................................... 5 University of Arizona: Eller College of Management................................................................ 5 Overview ................................................................................................................................. 5 School Practices...................................................................................................................... 6 Empty Practices........................................................................................................................... 6 Best Practices .............................................................................................................................. 7 Section Two: Faculty, Student, and Potential Employer Input....................................................... 8 Student Input............................................................................................................................... 8 Faculty Input............................................................................................................................... 9 Potential Employer’s Input ......................................................................................................... 9 Section Three: Components of Honor Code and Best Practices................................................... 10 Students..................................................................................................................................... 10 Faculty ...................................................................................................................................... 12 Curriculum and University Based ............................................................................................ 14 Overall Best Practices .............................................................................................................. 16 Conclusion .................................................................................................................................... 17 Appendix....................................................................................................................................... 18 Resources ...................................................................................................................................... 19 Endnotes........................................................................................................................................ 22
  • 3. 2 Introduction Oregon State University’s College of Business has entered into a time where faculty, administration, students, and professionals are questioning the current honor system. In order to increase the credibility and reputation of the College of Business, we have formulated an honor system to be implemented within the next year. This system comprises faculty, student, and professional input, while drawing from other school’s practices and theoretical concepts. With this honor system in place, the value of degrees given from the College of Business at Oregon State University will increase, and students will be more prepared to enter the professional world. SectionOne: Business Schoolsand BestPractice Notre Dame: Mendoza College ofBusiness Overview Reverend Edward Sorin started Notre Dame in 1842.1 It is a private, Catholic college, and today, 172 years later, Notre Dame’s Mendoza College of Business is ranked the best undergrad business school for the fifth straight year in a row, according to Bloomberg BusinessWeek.2 Notre Dame’s Mendoza College of Business’ mission statement is, “To build a premier Catholic business school that fosters academic excellence, professional effectiveness and personal accountability in a context that strives to be faithful to the ideals of community, human development and individual integrity.”3
  • 4. 3 School Practices The University of Notre Dame has three leading values that are dispersed throughout the college. These three values are, honesty, integrity, and honor.4 It is mandatory for all students to read, and also sign, an Academic Code of Honor for the Mendoza College of Business Graduate program. It is easy to read and summarizes both the expectations of the students, and also the procedures that follow when expectations are not met. Many faculty at Notre Dame Mendoza College of Business continuously remind their students of the code of honor through the use of their course syllabus. Not only does the code of honor include students living up to the core values of the college, but it also includes the faculty and staffs’ responsibility and expectations.5 Including the faculty helps to further create a cohesive community working towards the same goal of honesty, integrity, and honor. In the mission statement for the Mendoza College of Business, Management Department, they say, “We place particular emphasis on moral decision making within the context of rapid change and increased competition.”6 The Mendoza College of Business also has a Center for Ethical Leadership, Notre Dame Deloitte Center for Ethical Leadership, which is used as a center for ethics research.7 The University of Texas at Austin: McCombs School of Business Overview The University of Texas at Austin was opened in 1883.8 Today, 131 years later, it is ranked sixth on the list of the best undergraduate business schools, according to Bloomberg BusinessWeek.9 The University of Texas at Austin combines their mission, core purpose, and honor code into one. Their student honor code is, “As a student of The University of Texas at Austin, I shall abide by the core values of the University and uphold academic integrity.”10
  • 5. 4 School Practices The University of Texas at Austin has a code of conduct for all to follow, “The core values of The University of Texas at Austin are learning, discovery, freedom, leadership, individual opportunity, and responsibility. Each member of the university is expected to uphold these values through integrity, honesty, trust, fairness, and respect toward peers and community.”11 The students and faculty in McCombs School of Business work together to keep their reputation of having a high level of excellence throughout the college by allowing no room for academic dishonesty whatsoever. McCombs School of Business has a Code of Ethics that details the students’ responsibilities, faculty responsibilities, and also gives a definition of scholastic dishonesty for all to see.12 The first of four outlined responsibilities expected of students is that they must understand the definition of scholastic dishonesty.13 This gives students a detailed explanation of what is and is not allowed and expected of them. The faculty has five outlined responsibilities, but it is not mandatory that these responsibilities are met in order for students to behavior ethically, which is important to mention so students do not just blame their unethical behavior on their perceptions of their professors acting unethically.14 The University of Texas at Austin makes it clear that each individual involved in the McCombs School of Business is responsible to uphold a high level of academic integrity and avoid any temptations they may face. Universityof Oregon: Lundquist College ofBusiness Overview The University of Oregon was established in 1876. Today, 138 years later, it is ranked 121st on the list of best undergraduate business schools, according to Bloomberg BusinessWeek.15 Lundquist College of Business is part of the state’s flagship AAU University and their mission
  • 6. 5 for undergraduate education is, “Provide outstanding undergraduate education that combines a strong foundation in the liberal arts, excellence in traditional business disciplines, and experiential opportunities drawing on the strengths of Oregon’s distinctive qualities.”16 School Practices The University of Oregon Lundquist College of Business has “taught its students the critical skills they need to think for themselves, to be leaders in a dynamic world, and to make better decisions on behalf of the people and resources they manage.”17 The Lundquist College of Business has a Code of Professional Business Conduct and also places a large responsibility on faculty of the college to grade students in a way that will benefit them and society as well. The Code of Professional Business Conduct defines how those involved in Lundquist College of Business should act, and what it means to act like a professional. The five core values that are defined include, integrity, respect, openness, responsibility, and teamwork.18 There is not any information readily available to see what the repercussions are to any type of academic dishonesty within the college. Universityof Arizona: Eller College ofManagement Overview The University of Arizona was founded in 1885. Today, 129 years later, it is ranked 71st on the list of best undergraduate business schools, according to Bloomberg BusinessWeek.19 The Eller College of Management’s mission statement is, “The Eller College of Management’s Undergraduate Program is committed to building and maintaining working relationships with our students, faculty, recruiters, alumni, and volunteers predicted on mutual respect and responsibility. We strive to nurture student success through innovation and value-added
  • 7. 6 personalized programs. The following core competencies are emphasized within our program: knowledge, skills, ethical behavior, positive attitude, and creativity.”20 School Practices The Eller College of Management not only has a mission statement that includes emphasizing ethical behavior, it also has goals on how to reach their mission. These goals include, curriculum, community, career, character, academic advising, globalization, diversity, leadership, and talent.21 The College also has a Center for Leadership Ethics where “…scholars with diverse interest pertaining to leadership ethics who are committed to improving the ethical culture of organization. The Center rests on the three pillars of research, education, and outreach.”22 The Eller College of Management has policies and codes, including a voluntary oath for students in the college, codes of conduct and integrity, and guidelines that outline the disciplinary action that will take place in cases of academic dishonesty.23 There are also student guides that outline life in the Eller College of Management, tips for success, different types of academic dishonesty, and gives them a list of helpful resources and where to access them.24 The Eller College of Management also has a “GoodCat Hotline” where students have the ease, anonymity, and power to report any kind of questionable behaviors, misconduct, or any other concerns regarding academic integrity, honesty, and other ethical behavior.25 It is an online process that is all done through an independent third party to ensure that the individual will remain anonymous if that is what they want. Empty Practices After researching the four colleges above, it seems that there are a couple empty practices, as with most institutions. The Lundquist College of Business at the University of
  • 8. 7 Oregon has a Code of Professional Business Conduct, but there is no core value, besides integrity, that deals directly with acting ethically and upholding a higher standard for the college. This Code of Professional Business Conduct is an empty practice because it does not give well defined and outlined guidelines and procedures on how to act within the college. The Eller College of Management at the University of Arizona has a voluntary oath for students within the college. Since it is voluntary, there is no binding contract the students are tied too. Since there is nothing binding students to the oath, it is an empty practice. BestPractices In order to create a well-structured honor code and system for maintaining ethical behavior, there must be sold practices in place and upheld by everyone within the college. Mendoza College of Business at Notre Dame has a code of honor that outlines and details what is expected of students, and what the procedures are if they code of honor is not followed. Students must read, understand, and sign the code of honor, which creates a binding contract between the student and the college’s code of honor. McCombs School of Business at The University of Texas at Austin has a code of ethics that outlines expectations and repercussions, as well as include the faculty’s roles and expectations. Everyone involved in the college is held to a higher ethical standard, and each individual is responsible for doing this. The Eller College of Management at the University of Arizona has a “GoodCat Hotline” where a third party takes in reports of complaints regarding questionable behaviors, misconduct, or any other concerns regarding academic integrity, honesty, and other ethical behavior. This is a best practice because students are able to remain anonymous, and are therefore more likely to be a whistleblower.
  • 9. 8 SectionTwo:Faculty, Student, and Potential Employer Input After interviewing three students from the College of Business, Dean Ilene Kleinsorge, and a prospective employer of OSU graduates, we formulated input and a set of perspectives that can be used to help us understand what components need to be implemented into our new honor code system. StudentInput The three students had similarities in their perspectives, and also some key differences that we will highlight in this section. The first similarity, all the students were unaware of the current honor code, and agree that if students are not aware of it, then nothing will get done to highlight our policy on ethics. The second similarity, each of the students agreed the professors are liable to uphold the honor code and to act in a way that models ethical behavior. The third similarity, each student identifies that the major ethical issues in the College of Business involve some sort of cheating and sharing of information that can give others an unfair advantage. This has to do with the concept of fairness: if one person thinks that they are not being treated fairly then they will retaliate or feel negatively about the processes in place that should prevent this type of behavior. Students experience cheating first-hand through observing others doing this during exams, or even outside of the classroom. The reason most of the students we interviewed gave for not wanting to ‘whistle blow’ for extra credit is because they feel that people should be held accountable for themselves and that these extrinsic rewards could diminish the value of the honor system in place. This is one issue that the new honor code system should seek to resolve. We also believe that too often, students only view ethics as cheating, rather than including the respect and responsibility aspects. This too will be integrated into the new system.
  • 10. 9 FacultyInput After interviewing Dean Kleinsorge, we gained valuable insight towards what her perspective is on what is currently lacking in the honor code system, ways to inform students, and how to create an ethical culture. The main issues she observes in the College of Business honor code system is that the students did not see the ethical values as an integral part of who they are, and the repercussions resulting from unethical behavior while they are in college. She believes that cheating, disrespecting others, and behaving irresponsibly are the major underlying issues with the current honor code system. She has spoken to many students as she prepares to implement the new honor system, and has heard from a student perspective what they think the major ethical issues are. She has also spoken to College of Business graduates about a time that they behaved unethically while at Oregon State. These facts show that, for the best interest of the students, an ethical culture focusing on integrity, respect, and responsibility must be ingrained in the new College of Business’ honor code system. Potential Employer’sInput Lastly, we interviewed a potential employer, Lynn, from Technology Across the Curriculum, which is a department dedicated to improving the technology and learning management system here at Oregon State. Lynn employs students in this department, and has great insight towards the challenges students face in regards to ethics. She said that students need more help and information regarding plagiarism and how to avoid it, and that it can become an ethical concern when other students and instructors are negatively impacted. She also believes that it can have indirect effects on others who do the work in that it may undervalue our educational system and degrees. She also mentioned that out of the students she knows and works with, they are very motivated, honest, and aware. The few that do behave unethically are
  • 11. 10 the ones that attract the most attention. When asking her if a strong culture of ethics could have a positive influence on the students, she said that it would depend on how well the culture is supported and maintained throughout the student’s academic career, and that a “carrot and stick” approach may be needed to promote positive behavior and discourage the negative behavior. This means the honor code would need to be reinforced throughout the university staff, instructors, and curriculum with a heavy presence so that it does not get lost among other numerous priorities. SectionThree:Components of Honor Code and BestPractices Students Students are the main focus of the honor code, and also the best practices. In order for students to do the best they can to uphold the expectations laid out in the honor code, they must have a clear and well detailed honor code that explains what is expected of them, and what the repercussions and procedures are in cases where they participate in unethical behavior. To make the honor code known to students, the College of Business at Oregon State University needs to create a packet with the honor code system detailed in it, have the students read and sign the packet, and then return it to their department before being allowed to begin classes. Notre Dame has a practice in place like this where their honor code system, including expectations of students and faculty, repercussions and procedures for dealing with unethical behavior, are outlined in these packets that students must sign and return. This creates a more binding agreement, and the students are no longer anonymous. Creating a packet like this will give the honor code higher moral intensity, bring about a higher moral attentiveness, which are all drivers for higher ethical awareness. Along with the idea of this packet, students should also
  • 12. 11 have to take a quiz all about the honor code within the college in order to be allowed to register for classes. There can be an academic hold placed on their account if they do not take the quiz, or do not pass with at least an 80%. This forces students to review the honor code and re-associate themselves with the rules and regulations put in place. There should also be a sheet, like the one in the appendix, to be signed before the beginning of each exam in all classes within the College of Business. This sheet promotes the honor code system, and reminds students of the higher standard they are expected to perform at. Reminding students of this higher ethical standard will help them live up to that standard, and also give them no excuse about not knowing what is expected of them. All classes will use the same sheet, thus making it uniform and a normative paradigm thought all majors within the college. A great practice of the Eller College of Management at the University of Arizona should also be brought to OSU. They have a “GoodCat” hotline where students can go online and whistle blow to any type of unethical behavior they have witnessed or any other concerns they may have, and remain anonymous. The anonymity of the process creates a higher likelihood that people will whistle blow about things they see taking place. An anonymous hotline like this would give students the ability to self-regulate themselves without giving up their identity. They would feel better about themselves because they voiced their concerns, but they are still protected because no one will know it was them that reported the poor behavior. Involving the students in fun and creative outlets that pertain to the honor code is important. Students need to be aware, keyed in, and willing to promote the honor code in order for it to be effective. Putting together creative outlets for students such as an honors code slogan or poster competition with prizes, awards, and recognition for the top five or so slogans is a great
  • 13. 12 way to include the student body. These slogans and posters can be displayed in Austin Hall for everyone to see. Not only does it give recognition and create a more binding relationship between the honors code and the students, it also raise awareness a little more through what the slogans and posters portray. With all the research out there on how different things in the environment affect how ethical people are, the College of Business should do students a favor and prep them for success., success in this situation being conducting themselves ethically. To prep students to act ethically, a watermark of the three aspects of the College of Business honor code should be on all papers and websites the honor code is written on, and also on tests given in all of the College of Business classes. Making sure the rooms are clean smelling and have bright lighting may seem like small, petty things, but in the bigger picture, they do play a significant role. Making sure the environment is prepped as well as possible is the College of Business’ responsibility to all of its students. Faculty We believe that the faculty should support the honors system in a majority of ways in order for the students to fully understand the importance of it. Students interact with faculty every day, and the honor code system should be seamlessly integrated into these interactions. One thing that could be done is to have Ilene Kleinsorge focus the Dean’s Distinguished Lecture series on the new honor code’s three core values: Integrity, Respect, and Responsibility. Each term, she could select one of these values and bring a professional in to speak about their experiences with a time that they dealt with that value. An example would be to focus a lecture on integrity, where the professional would explain about a situation in which an employee was not acting with integrity, and his or her response to the situation, with an application for us as
  • 14. 13 students. This would be a great way to incorporate outside people who have experience in the business world, with students. It would also communicate the importance of having a strong honor code system. Another thing the Dean could implement is a lecture for all students accepted into Pro- school. During the start of the term they are in pro-school, Ilene could give them an acceptance speech, and talk about the honor system. While doing so, she could mention the fact that unethical behavior now can decrease the value of their degrees later. This will hopefully increase the ethical awareness of the situation, and will show the students how small acts of unethical behavior can negatively impact them down the road. We believe that by doing so, ethics will be at fresh in students’ minds once starting classes, and will give them more of a direct reason to act with integrity, respect, and responsibility. One other small thing that the faculty could do to communicate the importance of the honor system is to have the three core values at the end of every email. This would remind both the students and faculty of the values indirectly. With Austin Hall ready for students in Fall 2014, there will be many small rooms for discussion, focus groups, etc. One of these rooms could be an area for faculty and student meetings and discussions. Every few weeks, one of the faculty members or a student could be responsible for hosting a “Coffee Hour Discussion” about some type of ethical issue in the College of Business. This would both involve the students and faculty more, and give them an area to vent their concerns and have a voice. Each week would be a different topic, and could consist of activities and brainstorming sessions regarding the new honor code system. We believe that this would be especially important to do during the first year of implementation, because there will be many “bumps” along the way.
  • 15. 14 By setting time aside with regular meetings, faculty and students would be able to show their support for the new honor system, and would also be able to use what they have learned from these discussions, in class. When speaking to the students, we gained feedback concerning the repetition of stating the honor code at the beginning of every class. Instead of doing this, faculty could speak about what the honor system means to them, and a personal experience when the honor system had some influence on the situation. This would be a dynamic and effective way of engaging students, while showing them the support from the faulty on the honor system. At about the middle of the term, around midterms, professors should give feedback to each student on how they are doing in class, their level of engagement, ethical behavior, etc. This channel of communication is important for supporting the honor system in that speaking to the professor will give the student the opportunity to ask more questions and gain feedback on any ethical issues that have arrived, while having time during the rest of the term to correct that issue.26 Finally, there should be consistency among faculty expectations throughout the whole year, and the entire College of Business. This would give the students a feeling that there is strong procedural justice in the system, and that everyone is upheld to the same standards.27 Curriculum and UniversityBased It is very important for the University and College of Business curriculum to be unified in working towards the same goal, having a better honor system integrated and upheld among all students. This honor system needs to be applied consistently and uniformly throughout all classes in order to make it the expectation for all students during their time here at Oregon State, and in their lives after college. The communication and expectations need to be applied both consistently and uniformly.28 To further integrate a unified curriculum, there should be a basic
  • 16. 15 ethics class that is required as one of the Baccalaureate Core classes. This should at least be a Bacc Core class for the College of Business, but to make an even more unified student body, it should be mandatory for all colleges at Oregon State. Requiring a basic ethics class sets a standard and foundation for everyone to follow and build off of, and creates an awareness of just how prevalent ethics and morals are in our day-to-day lives. Another thing that could be incorporated into the College of Business is to have workshops on plagiarism, cheating, respect, and other things that students can improve upon to support the honor system. These workshops could be provided as extra credit opportunities for classes, and may be offered once each term. This would allow the faculty to engage the students in something more tangible, while allowing them the opportunity to learn and grow. This would be a positive thing because if a student is caught plagiarizing, the College of Business would have evidence to show that it was not because they were uninformed. One thing these events need to focus on is the fact that unethical behavior is not just cheating. When focusing on conveying a message related to the honor system, the respect and responsibility aspects must be given appropriate weight. The College of Business honor code is also about how students treat each other, treat their professors, and the responsibility of coming prepared to class and acting appropriately. In the lectures, workshops, and student-engaging material, all three aspects must be mentioned to show the importance of integrating these aspects into the student’s demeanor. It is also important to have the honor code easily accessible on the college’s website. All students we interviewed had no idea what the honor code was, and some said they were not able to easily find it on Oregon State’s website. Most other colleges we researched had their ethics code, honor code, or code of conduct easily accessible by putting it as another tab on the
  • 17. 16 college’s home page. By placing a tab that is strictly the honor code system on the homepage, it raises awareness among all who visit the page, and also makes it easy to find and reference. One of the most prevalent factors when researching other top business school programs nationwide was that they all had a formal name for their business college: Mendoza College of Business, McCombs School of Business, Lundquist College of Business, and Eller College of Management. Currently Oregon State University business program is just the College of Business. With so many different majors and tracks within the College of Business, there is a very fragmented idea of what the goal is for the college, and also business in general. By giving the current College of Business at Oregon State a name, such as Austin College of Business, it sets a foundation for creating a normative paradigm throughout all majors and tracks. Overall Best Practices Overall, faculty and university-wide communication about the honor system needs to be extremely clear and consistent in order to be effective.29 Mixed messages, including inconsistency in actions among faculty, will only decrease the value of the honor code and ethical culture that the College of Business is striving to create for it’s students. There will be a heightened ethical awareness throughout the College of Business, because our honor system, (1) will create an environment where peers will look to each other and find support for the honor system, (2) will use clear and ethical language in all facets of communication, and (3) will make it clear that unethical actions can severely damage the reputation of the students, and the value of their degrees.30 By integrating the core values and honors code throughout all of the outlets discussed above, students will be constantly engaged with the honor code system. The main goal of creating this ethical culture is to hopefully move students from operating in the pre-conventional stage, to the conventional or even post-conventional stage by
  • 18. 17 the time they graduate.31 Instead of behaving ethically in order to receive small rewards, the hope is that they will act ethically because it is simply the right thing to do, and is ingrained in the culture of the College of Business. We believe that by aggressively implementing all of the things mentioned previously, this is a very realistic goal that can be achieved in the next five years. One of the most important factors to focus on is creating a normative paradigm throughout all majors of the College of Business at Oregon State University. It is important to have all students studying under the same core ethical honor code in order to work towards the same goal. Unifying the college will help create a more binding relationship between students, faculty, and the college in general. Having a clear and unified goal, along with fair and equal procedures, will help create a more ethical environment for all tied to not only the College of Business, but also Oregon State University. Conclusion To wrap it all up, the most important factor in creating a more ethical business school at Oregon State University is to create a normative paradigm for all students, no matter what their major, to follow and live up to. Integrity, respect, and responsibility are the core of what the honor code is all about. Each student needs to be made aware of this, and also of his or her role in upholding these core values. Once the school is unified under one common, core, normative paradigm, we can begin to come together and work towards a unified goal, instead of being torn in different directions because of different majors. If everyone is working towards the same goal, there is a sense of unity, and students are then able to work more ethically, and together as a team, to reach the same core goals as everyone else. With integrity, respect, responsibility.
  • 19. 18 Appendix Example Honors Sheet to be Signed Before Exam: Integrity, Respect, and Responsibility are the core values for the College of Business at Oregon State University. Integrity is defined as the quality of being honest and having strong moral principles. Respect is defined as valuing differing viewpoints, accepting others, and consistently acting in a professional demeanor. Responsibility is defined as holding yourself accountable for the decisions you make. By signing this, I pledge to act with these three core values at all times. I also pledge my honor that I have neither received nor given unauthorized aid on this examination, or have witnessed others doing so without reporting it. SIGNATURE: ________________________________ NAME: ______________________________________ STUDENT ID #: ______________________________
  • 20. 19 Resources "About the Lundquist College of Business." About. University of Oregon, n.d. Web. 17 May 2014. <https://business.uoregon.edu/about>. "About Us." : Center for Leadership Ethics : Department of Management and Organizations : Eller College of Management : The University of Arizona. The University of Arizona, n.d. Web. 17 May 2014. <http://ethics.eller.arizona.edu/about/>. Clark, Patrick. "Mendoza Students Really, Really Love Their School: Notre Dame Is the Best Undergrad Business School for a Fifth Year."Bloomberg Business Week. Bloomberg, 4 Apr. 2014. Web. 17 May 2014. <http://www.businessweek.com/articles/2014-04- 04/mendoza-students-really-really-love-their-school-notre-dame-best-undergrad- business-school-for-a-fifth-year>. "Code of Ethics." . McCombs School of Business, The University of Austin at Texas, 15 May 2013. Web. 17 May 2014. <http://www.mccombs.utexas.edu/BBA/Code-of-Ethics>. "Deloitte Center for Ethical Leadership." About // // University of Notre Dame. University of Notre Dame, 1 Jan. 2014. Web. 17 May 2014. <http://ethicalleadership.nd.edu/about/>. "GoodCat Hotline." University of Arizona -. EthicsPoint, Inc., n.d. Web. 17 May 2014. <https://universityofarizona.ethicspointvp.com/custom/uaz_air/>. "History & Traditions." Home. The University of Texas at Austin, 1 Jan. 2014. Web. 17 May 2014. <http://www.utexas.edu/about-ut/history-traditions>. "History of the University." History // About ND //. University of Notre Dame, 1 Jan. 2007. Web. 17 May 2014. <http://www.nd.edu/about/history/>.
  • 21. 20 "Master of Science in Business." Academic Policies. Mendoza College of Business, University of Notre Dame, 1 Jan. 2010. Web. 17 May 2014. <http://business.nd.edu/msb/academics/academic_policies/>. "Mission, Core Purpose and Honor Code." Home. The University of Texas at Austin, 1 Jan. 2014. Web. 17 May 2014. <http://www.utexas.edu/about-ut/mission-core-purpose-honor- code>. "Mission Statement." : About Us : Undergraduate Programs : Eller College of Management : The University of Arizona. The University of Arizona, n.d. Web. 17 May 2014. <http://ugrad.eller.arizona.edu/about/mission.asp>. "Mission Statement Department of Management." . Mendoza College of Business, University of Notre Dame, n.d. Web. 17 May 2014. <http://business.nd.edu/uploadedFiles/Faculty_and_Research/PDF_and_Documents/Man agement%20Mission%20Statement%207_14.pdf>. "Our Ethics Standards." Policies and Guidelines : : Academics : Undergraduate Programs : Eller College of Management : The University of Arizona. The University of Arizona, n.d. Web. 17 May 2014. <http://ugrad.eller.arizona.edu/academics/standards/policies.asp>. "Our Ethics Standards." Student Guides : : Academics : Undergraduate Programs : Eller College of Management : The University of Arizona. The University of Arizona, n.d. Web. 17 May 2014. <http://ugrad.eller.arizona.edu/academics/standards/guides.asp>. "Programs." Programs. Mendoza College of Business, University of Notre Dame, 1 Jan. 2010. Web. 17 May 2014. <http://business.nd.edu/programs/>.
  • 22. 21 "The Complete Ranking: Best Undergraduate Business Schools 2014."Bloomberg Business Week. Bloomberg, 4 Apr. 2014. Web. 17 May 2014. <http://www.businessweek.com/articles/2014-04-04/the-complete-ranking-best- undergraduate-business-schools-2014>. "The Mendoza College of Business Graduate Academic Code of Honor." . Mendoza College of Business, University of Notre Dame, n.d. Web. 17 May 2014. <http://business.nd.edu/uploadedFiles/microsites/pdfs/mbacurrentstudents/Honor%20Co de,%202013-14.pdf>. Trevino, Linda K., and Katherine A. Nelson. Managing Business Ethics Straight Talk About How To Do It Right. Sixth ed. Hoboken, New Jersey: John Wiley and Sons, Inc., 2014. Print. "Undergraduate Policies." Home. University of Oregon, 23 Jan. 2012. Web. 17 May 2014. <https://business.uoregon.edu/ug/policies>.
  • 23. 22 Endnotes 1 http://www.nd.edu/about/history/ 2 http://www.businessweek.com/articles/2014-04-04/mendoza-students-really-really-love-their- school-notre-dame-best-undergrad-business-school-for-a-fifth-year 3 http://business.nd.edu/programs/ 4 http://business.nd.edu/msb/academics/academic_policies/ 5 http://business.nd.edu/uploadedFiles/microsites/pdfs/mbacurrentstudents/Honor%20Code,%2020 13-14.pdf 6 http://business.nd.edu/uploadedFiles/Faculty_and_Research/PDF_and_Documents/Management %20Mission%20Statement%207_14.pdf 7 http://ethicalleadership.nd.edu/about/ 8 http://www.utexas.edu/about-ut/history-traditions 9 http://www.businessweek.com/articles/2014-04-04/the-complete-ranking-best-undergraduate- business-schools-2014 10 http://www.utexas.edu/about-ut/mission-core-purpose-honor-code 11 http://www.utexas.edu/about-ut/mission-core-purpose-honor-code 12 http://www.mccombs.utexas.edu/BBA/Code-of-Ethics 13 http://www.mccombs.utexas.edu/BBA/Code-of-Ethics 14 http://www.mccombs.utexas.edu/BBA/Code-of-Ethics 15 http://www.businessweek.com/articles/2014-04-04/the-complete-ranking-best-undergraduate- business-schools-2014 16 https://business.uoregon.edu/about 17 https://business.uoregon.edu/about 18 https://business.uoregon.edu/ug/policies 19 http://www.businessweek.com/articles/2014-04-04/the-complete-ranking-best-undergraduate- business-schools-2014 20 http://ugrad.eller.arizona.edu/about/mission.asp 21 http://ugrad.eller.arizona.edu/about/mission.asp 22 http://ethics.eller.arizona.edu/about/ 23 http://ugrad.eller.arizona.edu/academics/standards/policies.asp 24 http://ugrad.eller.arizona.edu/academics/standards/guides.asp 25 https://universityofarizona.ethicspointvp.com/custom/uaz_air/ 26 Chapter Seven, Trevino 27 Chapter Seven, Trevino 28 Chapter Seven, Trevino 29 Chapter Five, Trevino 30 Chapter Three, Trevino 31 Chapter Three, Trevino