A Naturalistic Study Of Dissociative Identity Disorder And Dissociative Disor...
SWPA Presentation
1. WOULD YOU SPEND TIME WITH
JUSTIN? PERCEPTIONS OF
VETERANS WITH PTSD.
Ellie Becker and Jenny Dyson
Sterling College
2. Introduction
Research indicates that the stigma associated
with receiving mental health treatment may
prevent veterans from seeking treatment
(American Public Health Association, 2014).
There are now a significant number of soldiers
returning from Iraq and Afghanistan with PTSD
symptoms (Britt et al., 2007).
3. Literature Review
Related Research:
Participants in one study reported veterans
avoiding treatment early due to a known label of
mental illness and difficulties with reintegration
(Mitt et al., 2013).
90% of soldiers returning from Iraq encounter
stressors that define PTSD. Of the 90% of
soldiers who experience PTSD symptoms only
45% of them are interested in receiving help.
Furthermore, only 40% of those actively seek
professional help (Britt et al., 2007).
Given the prevalence of PTSD and associated
stigma, this study examines current social
4. Method
Participants: Students from two state
universities and one private liberal arts
college.
Procedure: Created two hypothetical scenarios
involving an individual with PTSD symptoms.
Symptoms were obtained from the DSM-V.
Two scenarios had identical descriptions of a
veteran with the exact same PTSD symptoms:
Professionally diagnosed vs. Non-diagnosed.
Responses were randomly assigned to one of the
two scenarios.
5. Hypothesis
ONE: Non-diagnosed individuals experience
less stigma.
Even with known PTSD symptoms
TWO: Diagnosed individuals experience more
stigma.
6. Method Cont.
Questions: Rated on a 10-point Likert Scale
Please rate the following:
Desire to work on the same shift with this person.
Safety working alone with this person.
Desire to spend time with this person outside of
work.
How dangerous do you consider this person?
How positively do you view this person?
Desire to introduce this person to your family.
7. Results
Data analysis was conducted on 286
responses.
Demographics
University of Southern Indiana (67.1%) Sterling
College (17.8%) Henderson State University
(15%)
Gender: 70.3% female; 29% male
Race: 83.2% White, 9.4% African American, 2.8%
Asian, 1.4% American Indian or Alaskan Native,
12.6% Native Hawaiian or other Pacific Islander
8. Results
Independent samples t-test conducted on each
dependent variable
Alpha level set at .05
Only one of six dependent variables reached
statistical significance.
People preferred to introduce the formally
diagnosed veteran to their family.
Formally diagnosed (M=4.847, SD = 2.213)
Non-diagnosed (M=4.257, SD 2.201)
t(284) = 2.255, p = 0.025
9. Results
A 2x2 ANOVA revealed two significant
interaction effects.
Females preferred to spend time with the officially
diagnosed veteran, whereas males preferred to
spend time with with the non-diagnosed veteran.
F (1, 277) = 7.500, p = .007.
Females preferred to introduced the formally
diagnosed veteran to their families, whereas
males preferred to introduce the non-diagnosed
veteran to their families.
F (1, 280) = 4.147, p = .043
10. Results
0
0.05
0.1
0.15
0.2
0.25
0.3
small medium large
Effect Size: Eta Squared
Significant
Difference
s in this
study had
small
effect
sizes.
The experimental manipulation did not account for
a large part of the effect. Values were
approximately .01
11. Discussion
Overall, the study suggests that veterans
formally diagnosed with PTSD may not be
subject to stigma.
There is a history of stigma. Perhaps this is
changing?
12. Discussion Cont.
Limitations
Gender diversity was small.
Create more questions, specifically regarding
personal safety.
Relating to what we found significant.
Directions for future research
Concentrate on matters of personal safety.
Examine the stigmas of other mental illnesses
Establish a more diverse sample size.
13. References
Blais, R. M. (2014). Posttraumatic Stress and Stigma in Active-Duty
Service Members Relate to Lower Likelihood of Seeking
Support. Journal Of Traumatic Stress, 27(1), 116-119.
Britt, T. W., & Castro, C. A., Greene-Shortridge. (2007). The stigma
of mental health problems in the military. Military medicine,
172(2), 157- 161.
CORRIGAN, P. W., & WATSON, A. C. (2002). Understanding the
impact of stigma on people with mental illness. World
Psychiatry, 1(1), 16–20.
Locke, C. R. (2011). Public attitudes toward mental illness: An
experimental design examining the media's impact of crime
on stigma. Dissertation Abstracts International Section A, 71,
4182.
Mittal, D., Drummond, K. L., Blevins, D., Curran, G., Corrigan, P., &
Sullivan, G. (2013). Stigma associated with PTSD: perceptions
of treatment seeking combat veterans. Psychiatric rehabilitation
journal, 36(2), 86.
Editor's Notes
Justin is a 25-year-old male. He has just moved to your area and is looking for a job. He was in active duty for a year and witnessed several traumatic events throughout his tour. After his service he worked in a local deli where he would often experience distressing memories and flashbacks. He would often walk to work because driving could arouse distressing memories. Within months of working at the deli he had lost interest in many of his favorite activities and became pessimistic and detached from his coworkers. For months he would complain of lack of sleep and problems concentrating. A professional psychologist diagnosed Justin with posttraumatic stress disorde