The document discusses Gulf Island Fabrication Inc., an oil and gas field services firm specialized in offshore drilling platforms. It notes that plummeting oil prices from $110 to $50 per barrel have severely impacted offshore rig activity. This represents a threat to Gulf Island as its backlog decreases and projects may be halted or suspended. However, the company's debt-free status provides flexibility to adapt to changing conditions. The document maintains a market perform rating for Gulf Island with a target price of $18, citing its diversification efforts and management's focus on improving margins.
Gulf Island Fabrication INC. Burkenroad Analyst Report
1. March 24, 2015
GULF ISLAND FABRICATION INC.
GIFI/NASDAQ
Continuing Coverage: Watch Your Backlog!
Investment Rating: Market Perform
PRICE: $ 15.69 S&P 500: 2,091.50 DJIA: 18,011.14 RUSSELL 2000: 1,263.46
The oil free fall from $110 to $50 per barrel slams offshore rig activity.
No long term debt helps Gulf Island endure industry headwinds.
New wind projects help blow in a new era.
Diminishing backlog poses new threat.
New management opens new doors, business segments, projects.
Our 12‐month target price is $18.00.
Valuation 2014 A 2015 E 2016 E
EPS $ 1.05 $ 1.03 $ 1.13
P/E 14.9x 15.2x 13.8x
CFPS $ 3.97 $ 2.71 $ 2.72
P/CFPS 4.0x 5.8x 5.8x
Market Capitalization Stock Data
Equity Market Cap (MM): $ 227.66 52‐Week Range: $12.32 ‐ $24.01
Enterprise Value (MM): $ 191.58 12‐Month Stock Performance: ‐24.66%
Shares Outstanding (MM): 14.51 Dividend Yield: 2.06%
Estimated Float (MM): 13.09 Book Value Per Share: $ 19.70
6‐Mo. Avg. Daily Volume: 68,639 Beta: 1.40
Company Quick View:
Gulf Island Fabrication is churning up the bayou. Located in Houma, Louisiana, with
headquarters in Houston, Texas, the Company is a diversified oil and gas field services
firm with a specialization in deep water drilling platforms. As part of the offshore oil rig
and platform construction industry, the Company fabricates, repairs, and maintains
deepwater drilling modules, living quarters, jackets, marine vessels, and skids through
its five subsidiaries.
Company Website: www.gulfisland.com
Analysts: Investment Research Manager:
Kelly M. Aucoin J. Brad Bauguss
Emma A. Brons
Edward L. Brucculeri
Katherine M. Gillespie
Ethyn J. Samuels
The BURKENROAD REPORTS are produced solely as a part of an educational program of Tulane University's
Freeman School of Business. The reports are not investment advice and you should not and may not rely on
them in making any investment decision. You should consult an investment professional and/or conduct your
own primary research regarding any potential investment.
Wall Street's Farm Team
BURKENROADREPORTS
4. Gulf Island Fabrication Inc. (GIFI) BURKENROAD REPORTS (www.burkenroad.org) March 24, 2015
4
Table 1: Historical Burkenroad Ratings and Prices
Date Rating Price*
03/14/14 Market Perform $24.00
04/02/13 Market Outperform $26.00
04/03/12 Market Outperform $37.00
03/23/11 Market Perform $34.10
04/06/10 Market Perform $25.49
04/02/09 Market Outperform $13.79
04/15/08 Market Perform $37.19
04/13/07 Market Outperform $43.14
04/10/06 Market Perform $23.63
03/15/05 Market Perform $23.70
03/26/04 Market Outperform $19.03
11/22/02 Market Outperform $16.09
02/15/02 Buy $12.50
*Price at time of report date
INVESTMENT THESIS
Gulf Island’s near future is clouded by the effect of the sharp decline in oil price on offshore
rig activity, but decisions by new management and diversification efforts indicate a more
favorable long‐term outlook. The oil price plunge in the last quarter brings into question the
fiscal feasibility of the expensive deep water drilling industry, a main component to Gulf Island
operations. This is already impacting rig activity in the Gulf of Mexico, which is a critical
revenue source for the Company. Additionally, the Company’s backlog has been steadily
decreasing and, paired with possible suspensions or terminations of existing projects because
of low oil prices, could cause trouble. Gulf Island’s lack of long‐term debt cushions the blow of
rough industry conditions and allows the Company to focus more on adapting rather than
merely surviving. As such, the Company is expanding into alternative energy wind projects in
order to diversify operations. Additionally, new management is very experienced in the oilrig
and platform construction industry and is already making an impact by focusing on improving
margins.
The oil free fall from $100 to $50 per barrel slams offshore rig activity
Although Gulf of Mexico rig count is remaining relatively steady, rig activity has been severely
impacted by the plunge in oil prices. Marketed utilization measures the percentage of oil rigs
in use compared to the marketed supply of oil rigs available. According to IHS Petrodata, the
marketed utilization for Gulf of Mexico Rigs changed from 95.3% in 2013 to 79% as of January
2015. The sharp decrease in marketed utilization is a concerning trend for Gulf Island and the
entire oil rig and platform construction industry. If companies are not using rigs that are
already deployed, then increased demand for existing rigs and fabrication of more rigs is
unlikely. Oil prices in the $65 to $75 per barrel range would likely stimulate more deep water
drilling activity, but prices as of February 2015 were below $50 per barrel.
17. Gulf Island Fabrication Inc. (GIFI) BURKENROAD REPORTS (www.burkenroad.org) March 24, 2015
17
Table 4: ROIC Analysis
Year
Gulf Island
Fabrication, Inc.
(GIFI)
McDermott
International, Inc.
(MDR)
Dril‐Quip
(DRQ)
Conrad
Industries, Inc.
(CNRD)
Peer
Average
2014 4.82% ‐‐ 16.28% 24.11% 20.20%
2013 2.43% ‐‐ 14.32% 24.11% 19.22%
2012 ‐‐ ‐‐ 11.71% 19.04% 15.38%
2011 ‐‐ 7.48% 10.68% 19.31% 12.49%
2010 3.05% 16.10% 13.08% 11.85% 13.68%
2009 6.99% 17.02% 16.38% 16.41% 16.60%
Average 4.19% 13.53% 13.23% 18.24% 15.00%
Source: Bloomberg February 12, 2015
Kirk J. Meche
President, Chief Executive Officer, and Director (51)
Kirk J. Meche was recently appointed CEO at the beginning of 2013. He has also served as the
President of Gulf Island since 2009. Meche previously worked as the COO from 2009 to the
end of 2012 and Executive Vice President of Operations from 2001 to 2009. He has worked
with many of Gulf Island’s subsidiaries, including Gulf Marine, Gulf Island, L.L.C. and
Southport. Meche began working with Gulf Island in 1996 as a Project Manager after leaving
McDermott International, where he worked as an engineer.
Jeffrey M. Favret
Chief Financial Officer, Treasurer, and Vice President (52)
Jeffrey M. Favret joined Gulf Island as CFO in April of 2013. He previously worked at FMC
Technologies as the Director of Finance within the Energy Infrastructure before leaving for
Gulf Island. Favret has also served as the Chief Accounting Officer at Trico Marine Services,
Inc. Favret started his career with Ernst & Young as a Certified Public Accountant before
joining Postlethwaite & Netterville in 2007 as an Associate Director.
Todd F. Ladd
Chief Operating Officer (47)
Todd F. Ladd was named COO in February 2014. Ladd has over 25 years of offshore platform
fabrication industry experience. He previously served as Gulf Island’s Vice President and
General Manager from July 2013 until he began serving as COO. Prior to his employment at
Gulf Island, Ladd served as a partner and Senior Project Manager at Paloma Energy
Consultants for 12 years. Ladd’s introduction to the Company occurred in April 1996, when
he was hired as Project Manager for Gulf Island, L.L.C. Additionally, Ladd served as
Production Engineer and Facility Engineer at McDermott Marine Construction for eight years,
beginning in January 1988.
19. Gulf Island Fabrication Inc. (GIFI) BURKENROAD REPORTS (www.burkenroad.org) March 24, 2015
19
Figure 5: Ownership by Investment Style
Source: Thompson One February 2, 2015
Table 6: Gulf Island Shareholder Investment Styles
Investment Style
% Shares
Outstanding
Investors Shares Value ($)
Index 15.66 98 2,274,967 38,765,437.68
Core Value 14.22 24 2,067,515 35,230,455.60
GARP 13.40 27 1,947,225 33,180,714.00
Deep Value 4.91 3 721,886 12,300,937.44
Core Growth 3.08 24 449,235 7,654,964.40
Growth 1.55 6 225,591 3,844,070.64
Yield 0.51 3 73,647 1,254,944.88
Specialty 0.35 1 51,310 874,322.40
Aggressive Growth 0.05 7 7,369 125,567.76
Equity Hedge 0.04 1 5,882 100,229.28
Income Value 0.01 1 1,519 25,883.76
Source: Thompson One February 1, 2015
Table 7 lists the top‐ten shareholders of Gulf Island. T. Rowe Price Associates, Inc. is the
number one shareholder, holding 1.8 million shares, which is 12.54% of all outstanding
shares. In the past year, T. Rowe sold 4,100 as the stock price climbed to $23.50 in April of
2014. The number two shareholder is Heartland Advisors, Inc., holding 1.54 million shares
constituting 10.64% of total shares outstanding. After Heartland, BlackRock holds the third
largest amount of outstanding shares of the Company. Blackrock increased its position in Gulf
Island by 7.87% from last year, from 1.13 million shares up to 1.22 million shares. These large
investment companies include Gulf Island holdings as part of value and index funds, which
account for 20% of Gulf Island ownership.
Index, 15.66%
Core Value,
14.22%
GARP, 13.40%
Deep Value,
4.91%
Core Growth,
3.08%
Growth, 1.55%
Other, 0.96%
20. Gulf Island Fabrication Inc. (GIFI) BURKENROAD REPORTS (www.burkenroad.org) March 24, 2015
20
Table 7: Gulf Island Top‐Ten Shareholders
No. Holder Name Shares Held
% of Shares
Outstanding
1 T. Rowe Price Associates, Inc. 1,819,380 12.54
2 Heartland Advisors, Inc. 1,543,805 10.64
3 BlackRock Institutional Trust Company, N.A. 1,127,320 7.77
4 Dimensional Fund Advisors, L.P. 950,806 6.55
5 Starboard Enterprises, L.L.C. 884,700 6.10
6 Royce & Associates, LLC 746,025 5.14
7 The Vanguard Group, Inc. 617,092 4.25
8 Killen Group, Inc. 508,057 3.50
9 DePrince, Race & Zollo, Inc. 438,680 3.02
10 Columbia Management Investment Advisers, LLC 349,936 2.41
Source: Thompson One February 2, 2015
Insider Analysis
As shown below in Table 8, Gulf Island insiders own just less than 1% of Gulf Island’s stock.
Kirk Meche is the largest insider owner of Gulf Island stock. Meche, the President and CEO of
Gulf Island, owns roughly 0.43% of Gulf Island stock, which is equal to 62,265 shares and is
valued at $1,063,486 as of February 2015. Joseph Gallagher, former Chief Financial Officer of
Gulf Island, owns the second largest portion of Gulf Island stock with 31,200 shares. The
remaining top insider shareholders are all major executives at Gulf Island.
Table 8: Gulf Island Top‐Five Shareholders
No. Holder Name Shares Held
% of Shares
Outstanding
Value of
Holdings ($)
1 Meche (Kirk J) 62,265 0.43 1,060,996
2 Gallagher (Joseph P. III) 31,200 0.21 531,648
3 Blanchard (William G.) 16,398 0.11 279,422
4 Smith (Francis A. Jr.) 15,320 0.11 261,053
5 Ladd (Todd F.) 15,000 0.10 255,600
Source: Thompson One, February 2, 2015
RISK ANALYSIS AND INVESTMENT CAVEATS
Operational Risks
Gulf Island Fabrication is subject to various risks that can affect the Company and its
operations. Risks include fluctuating commodity prices of both steel and oil, the impacts of
seasonality and weather, the small customer base, competition in the labor market, and
backlog.
28. Gulf Island Fabrication Inc. (GIFI) BURKENROAD REPORTS (www.burkenroad.org) March 24, 2015
28
ANOTHER WAY TO LOOK AT IT
ALTMAN Z‐SCORE
The Altman Z‐Score Analysis, created by Edward Altman in 1968, measures the probability
that a company will go bankrupt in the following two years. This analysis takes into
consideration five financial ratios including working capital to total assets, retained earnings
to total assets, earnings before interest and taxes to total assets, market value of equity to
book value of total liabilities, and sales to total assets. The Analysis weights the five financial
ratios according to the relative importance within the Z‐Score and the final Z‐Score falls into
one of three groupings; a low risk of default with a Z‐Score above 2.99, a high risk of default
with a Z‐Score of below 1.8, and a moderate risk of default with a Z‐Score between 1.8 and
2.99.
Table 9 shows Gulf Island Fabrication’s Z‐Scores for the past eight years. The Company’s Z‐
Score for 2014 is 3.91, which puts Gulf Island well within the low‐risk range. This Z‐Score
means that the Company is unlikely to experience a bankruptcy within the next two years.
The 2014 Z‐Score is an improvement on 2013’s Z‐Score of 2.21, which was in the moderate
risk range. The Company’s recurring debt, which inflates the Z‐Score, makes the Company’s
future look bright.
Table 9: Z Scores
Year Z Score
2007 5.51
2008 3.75
2009 5.31
2010 7.26
2011 3.94
2012 3.62
2013 2.21
2014 3.91
Source: Bloomberg March 25, 2015
30. Gulf Island Fabrication Inc. (GIFI) BURKENROAD REPORTS (www.burkenroad.org) March 24, 2015
30
WWBD?
What Would Ben (Graham) Do?
Ben Graham was a legendary investor who championed the method of “Value Investing”
throughout his career. Graham used his experience to craft a formula for choosing which
stocks to invest in, which was published by Graham in Forbes Magazine in 1977 as “Last Will &
Testament.” The formula focuses on evaluating eight specific hurdles that identify
undervalued stocks with growth potential. The first four hurdles distinguish stocks with low
price to operation ratios, while the second four hurdles assess risk.
Gulf Island Fabrication, Inc. passes five of the hurdles outlined by Graham in his formula and
should therefore be seriously considered as a good investment (see Figure 10). Gulf Island
successfully meets four of the first five hurdles, suggesting that the market may be
undervaluing the stock. The Company meets three of these hurdles considerably, with a P/E
ratio significantly lower than half of its highest over the past five years and a stock price $15
lower than one and half times its book value. Most notably, Gulf Island has no debt, so its
total debt is far below its book value. However, Gulf Island fails to meet either of Graham’s
last hurdles that identify growth stocks. This result is unsurprising as Gulf Island is a mature,
asset heavy company whose earnings depend heavily on the price of oil. Nonetheless, Gulf
Island is an attractive investment under Graham’s methodology.
Figure 10: Ben Graham Analysis
31. Gulf Island Fabrication Inc. (GIFI) BURKENROAD REPORTS (www.burkenroad.org) March 24, 2015
31
Earnings per share (ttm) 1.06$ Price: 15.69$
Earnings to Price Yield 6.73%
10 Year Treasury (2X) 3.85%
P/E ratio as of 2010 29.3
P/E ratio as of 2011 (211.7)
P/E ratio as of 2012 (68.0)
P/E ratio as of 2013 45.2
P/E ratio as of 2014 18.3
Current P/E Ratio 14.9
Dividends per share (ttm) 0.40$ Price: 15.69$
Dividend Yield 2.55%
1/2 Yield on 10 Year Treasury 0.96%
Stock Price 15.69$
Book Value per share as of 12/31/14 19.70$
150% of book Value per share as of 12/31/14 29.56$
Interest‐bearing debt as of 12/31/14 ‐$
Book value as of 12/31/14 285,798$
Current assets as of 12/31/14 172,495$
Current liabilities as of 12/31/14 72,765$
Current ratio as of 12/31/14 2.4
EPS for year ended 2014 1.05$
EPS for year ended 2013 0.50$
EPS for year ended 2012 (0.28)$
EPS for year ended 2011 (0.13)$
EPS for year ended 2010 0.90$
EPS for year ended 2014 1.05$ 110%
EPS for year ended 2013 0.50$ ‐277%
EPS for year ended 2012 (0.28)$ 118%
EPS for year ended 2011 (0.13)$ ‐114%
EPS for year ended 2010 0.90$
Stock price data as of M arch 24, 2015
No
Hurdle # 3: A Dividend Yield of 1/2 the Yield on 10 Year Treasury
Yes
Hurdle # 4: A Stock Price less than 1.5 BV
Yes
Hurdle # 5: Total Debt less than Book Value
Yes
Hurdle # 6: Current Ratio of Two or More
Yes
Hurdle # 7: Earnings Growth of 7% or Higher over past 5 years
No
Hurdle # 8: Stability in Growth of Earnings
Yes
GULF ISLAND FABRICATION INC. (GIFI)
Ben Graham Analysis
Hurdle # 1: An Earnings to Price Yield of 2X the Yield on 10 Year Treasury
No
Hurdle # 2: A P/E Ratio Down to 1/2 of the Stocks Highest in 5 Yrs