SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 12
Download to read offline
July 2015
A blueprint for Scottish general practice
A strategy for a safe, secure and strong
general practice in Scotland
General practice is central to the future of the NHS in
Scotland. This paper sets out a blueprint to reverse the
impacts of the increasing problems of workload and
recruitment on the ability of GPs to deliver excellent patient
care. These problems have become ever more apparent
over the last six months. The Royal College of General
Practitioners Scotland (RCGP Scotland) has been warning
for a year and a half now — through our Put patients first:
Back general practice campaign — that rising workloads,
a shortage of GPs and declining resources are putting
intolerable pressure on local practices and posing a threat
to patient care. As many people’s first point of contact with
the NHS, around 90% of patient interaction is with primary
care services. General practice is the cornerstone of
primary care, with Scottish GP surgery teams carrying out
an estimated 24.2 million consultations each year — an
11% rise over ten years1
.
At the same time, the share of NHS funding spent
on general practice in Scotland has been falling year
on year. The GP percentage has fallen from 9.8% in
2005/06 to a record low of 7.8% in 2012/13. This drop
has led to a real terms cumulative loss of investment of
£1.1 billion into Scottish general practice compared to a
scenario where funding had remained at 9.8%. General
practice is a cost-effective part of the healthcare system
in which to invest as it is more economical than other
parts of the system and can prevent worsening of
patient outcomes (see Box 2 page10). However, it will
not be able to deliver positive changes in the short,
medium and long-term without significant investment to
increase the size of the workforce.
RCGP Scotland has warmly welcomed and participates
in the review of out of hours primary care services
chaired by Professor Sir Lewis Ritchie and due to
report in September 2015. It is clear that many of
the measures called for in this document will impact
positively on out of hours care. This document in no
way seeks to pre-empt the review but recognises that
many of the constructive steps called for here will aid
in the provision of appropriate out of hours care. The
RCGP Scotland Green Light statement of February
2015 offers further information on the College’s
position but it bears repetition that the College sees
it as essential that GPs remain a central part of the
service to ensure safe, holistic patient care. Out of
hours care is an integral part of general practice.
This document builds on the solid foundations provided
by earlier work from the Royal College of General
Practitioners. Among others, RCGP Scotland’s The
Essence of General Practice2
, Developing a Quality
Framework for General Practice in Scotland3
, the Time
To Care health inequalities report4
and The Future
of General Practice in Scotland: A Vision5
have all
contributed to the thinking behind this blueprint. It is
intended as one for discussion with all stakeholders,
not least Scottish Government. Of course, any
changes undertaken must be evaluated appropriately
and this will require robust general practice academic
input, such as that provided by the Scottish School of
Primary Care. Changes must clearly also align with
the developing work on integration and on multiple
morbidities.
Introduction
A blueprint for Scottish general practice
2
In November 2014, the Scottish Government announced
an additional £40 million investment for general
practice and primary care in Scotland, to be used
in the 2015/16 financial year. However, since this
announcement there have been further developments
and the Cabinet Secretary has recently indicated
her intention that such a fund be spread
over three years. We urgently need a clear
strategy from the Scottish Government for investing in
Scottish general practice, ensuring that funding reaches
general practice in the coming year but also putting GP
services on a more sustainable footing for the long term
so that they may deliver effective, quality care to patients
appropriate to their needs 24 hours a day, seven
days a week. This document sets out a strategy
towards this.
JuLY 2015
3
Building
a properly
funded general
practice
hub
Ongoing,
sustained
investment
in general
practice
Investing
in
infrastructure
Promoting
integrated
care
Expanding
the wider
primary care
workforce
The
2020 Vision of
an integrated
Health and
Social Care
system
Expanding
the number
of GPs
A blueprint for ScottiSh generAl prActice
4
1. Expanding the number of GPs
Set a clear objective to increase the number of Whole
Time Equivalent GPs in Scotland. RCGP Scotland
is calling for the expansion of the GP workforce by 740
general practitioners in Scotland by 2020. This figure
is the midpoint between the previous range of WTE
estimates produced by RCGP in April 2015. This range
was based on reaching and maintaining the 2009 level
of GP coverage and projecting forward using Office
of National Statistics predicted population growth.
The Scottish Government should work with RCGP
Scotland and NHS Education for Scotland (NES) and
ensure progress against this aim is closely monitored.
This strand of work should include involving university
departments and foundation schools with the aim of
improving and promoting recruitment to meet the target of
at least 50% of medical students entering general practice.
Launch a high profile marketing campaign to
promote general practice as a career. The campaign
run by NES in 2015 should be reviewed with the aim
●
The Scottish Government’s NHS Information Services
Division (ISD) released a Primary Care Workforce Survey in
2013. Its Publication Summary reported that ‘The estimated
Whole Time Equivalent (WTE) number of GPs in post in
Scottish general practices (excluding Specialist Trainees) at
31 January 2013 was 3,735. This is only a little higher than
the estimate of 3,700 generated from a previous survey run
in 2009. ... The results of this survey suggest that the WTE
number has been fairly static over the past few years.’ This
is simply not enough to meet the changing needs of patients.
One in five GPs in Scotland is aged over 55 and, therefore,
20% of the GP workforce could feasibly and naturally retire
over the next five years. This figure is bolstered by the
alarming findings of the recent British Medical Association
(BMA) survey, published in April, which suggests that one in
three Scottish GPs were hoping to retire within the next five
years. We need greater investment in GP workforce capacity
so that Scotland can care for its growing, ageing population
at home, in a homely setting and in the community.
Whatever the shape of the 2017 GMS contract negotiations,
Scotland urgently needs a package of measures backed
by resources to increase the number of GPs, including
encouraging more doctors to choose general practice as
a career, doing more to retain our current GP workforce,
working to prevent GPs retiring when they are still able to
provide an excellent service to patients, and making it easier
for those who have left the profession to return to practice.
We urge the Scottish Government to take the following
actions to increase the GP workforce:
of setting up a fully resourced marketing campaign to
encourage foundation doctors and medical students
to choose general practice as a career. This should
include dedicated funding for recruitment roadshows to
showcase general practice as a career to foundation
doctors and medical students across Scotland.
Incentives to attract new doctors into general
practice, particularly in under-doctored areas.
A further package of enhanced, targeted, financial
incentives should be developed to encourage medical
graduates to train and practise as GPs in currently
under-doctored and deprived areas. These incentives
could include helping graduates to pay off their student
loans if they agree to practise in selected areas — an
approach that has already been pioneered in New
Zealand and is currently being explored in England.
A large scale campaign to promote the national GP
Induction and Returner Programmes will be important
in boosting the workforce in Scotland. Scotland has
had an established GP Returner Scheme delivered by
NES for many years and regional Health Boards have
provided inductions where appropriate. This requires
further publicity as uptake of these schemes has been
variable with an average of 7.5 GPs per year over the
past ten years entering the Returner scheme. It is now
known that some 259 GPs under the age of 50 have
left Scottish Performers Lists in the last five years, of
which 166 were aged less than 40 years old. The NES
GP Directors must be commended for their review
of the programmes in Scotland and for upgrading
the NES website to provide an easily accessible and
comprehensive resource to signpost and support GPs
into the workforce. However, further assurance of
recurring funding and resource is required to ensure a
sufficient boost to the number of trained GPs who are
able to return to general practice. These programmes
should be available for trained GPs from a variety of
backgrounds including Scottish GPs who have had
career breaks and those who wish to join the Scottish
GP workforce from both within and outside the uK.
Increased investment in the national retainer
programme, including a review to identify the most
effective measures to encourage experienced GPs
to remain within practice. Scotland already has a
successful and quality assured retainer scheme through
which GP retainers are well supported. However, GP
practices need further support and this scheme should
have its funding increased with incentives designed to
encourage more GP practices to take on GP retainers.
●
●
●
●
With GPs facing immense pressure due to rising
workloads and constrained finances, morale in Scottish
general practice is currently very low. A recent survey
of GPs found that over half (54%) feel their current
workload is unmanageable or unsustainable6
. The
significant contribution of other members of the primary
care team in delivering high quality patient care in the
primary care setting cannot be ignored. Whilst other
health professionals can never be a direct replacement
for general practitioners, and while the role of GPs in
being the first point of patient contact, in co-ordinating
comprehensive care and in providing continuity of care,
must be protected — the role the wider primary care
workforce has to play in delivering services is vital.
There are significant challenges facing other healthcare
professionals. For example, community nurses are
facing significant retirement challenges. Almost 50%
of NHS community nurses in NHS Scotland are aged
50 years or older. This means that the recruitment
challenge to safeguard services against this retirement
‘cliff’ will be extremely pronounced over the next five
years7
. Strengthening the capacity and capability of other
healthcare professionals in general practices is essential
to improve the quality of healthcare services in the
community.
To expand the wider primary care workforce to support
general practice, the Scottish Government could enact
the following:
2. Expanding the wider primary care workforce
to support general practice
JuLY 2015
with NES to establish how the role of community
and practice nurses can be promoted in order to
boost numbers in Scotland.
Promote the role of practice-based and community
pharmacists. Both practice-based and community
pharmacists are uniquely placed to work with GPs
to improve patient care and safety, and can play an
important role in the long-term management of patients
with chronic disease. In March, the RCGP and Royal
Pharmaceutical Society (RPS) issued a joint statement,
RCGP and RPS Policy Statement on GP Practice
Based Pharmacists, highlighting the important role that
practice-based pharmacists can have based in general
practices8
. There should be investment in recruitment
and training of pharmacists based in general practice
who would be of considerable value in reviewing
patients’ medication, managing polypharmacy,
managing medication issues for the housebound within
the newly integrated health and social care teams,
linking effectively with community pharmacists and
medicines reconciliation across the interface, all with
significant benefit to patient safety. This could improve
care, save the NHS a significant amount of money and
alleviate pressures on GPs.
The RCGP and RPS also worked together regarding
community pharmacists via their statement, Breaking
down the barriers — how community pharmacists
and GPs can work together to improve patient
care9
. This sets out recommendations for benefits
to patients in improving liaison between community
pharmacists and general practitioners. In response
to Prescription for Excellence10
, there have been
a number of initiatives across Scotland. Current
projects regarding collaborative working with
community pharmacists include:
●
The Highland Community Pharmacy project where
the objective is to develop decision support between
community pharmacists and local GP practices.
Healthcare Improvement Scotland’s National Patient
Safety Programme in Primary Care, which includes
the Pharmacy in Primary Care Collaborative, which
aims to enhance communications between GPs and
Community Pharmacists in rural and urban settings.
●
5
Provide funding to enhance community nursing
and enable practices to recruit more practice
nurses. Community and practice nurses have a vital
role to play in delivering high quality patient care in
the community. Boosting the number of community
and practice nurses and widening their remit to take
on additional tasks will help free up time for GPs to
spend with patients with complex needs. NES has
a General Practice Nursing Programme and it is
currently examining ways in which to boost take
up. An expansion of that programme should allow
more places to be provided. In order to encourage
more nurses to become community or practice
nurses, national training standards and clear career
pathways for these nurses need to be developed.
RCGP Scotland would welcome a joint programme
●
●
A blueprint for Scottish general practice
The Integration of Health and Social Care seeks to
improve care for patients as well as ensuring GP services
are efficient and effective. RCGP Scotland believes that
the integration of care should be primary care led and
offered by multi-professional teams to deliver the best
possible health outcomes. Care planning for those with
complex conditions, redesigning services to provide
more services in the community and the establishment
of GP clusters are vital to achieving better outcomes for
patients. In Scotland, general practitioners are keen to
develop new models of care, in particular GP clusters,
which would allow skills and expertise to be shared across
practices. The following suggestions are forwarded in
the expectation that successful ongoing work, such as
Healthcare Improvement Scotland (HIS) and RCGP
Scotland’s Developing a Quality Framework for General
Practice in Scotland11
, and the National Clinical Lead
for Self Management and Health Literacy, Dr Graham
Kramer’s work on supported self management and the
House of Care development, will continue to be supported
and furthered.
We call on the Scottish Government to take the following
actions so that GPs may lead the development of new
integrated models of patient care:
3. Giving GPs the tools to lead the development
of new integrated models of patient care
●
●
6
Establishing a sustained package of support
and practical advice which GPs can access to
help them develop new models of care. Whilst
individual practices are excellent at developing
innovations for their specific localities, the system
has challenges in testing and spreading these
innovations to other general practices and the
aforementioned Developing a Quality Framework
for General Practice in Scotland’s concentration on
quality improvement has sought to mitigate against
these difficulties. In order to support the development
and replication of good practice, support packages
which provide practical implementation advice and
funding should be made available.
Ensuring that patient centred care is hardwired
into emerging new models by building on the
strengths of general practice. The doctor-patient
relationship must be protected. In the context of
rising levels of multiple morbidity, these new models
will need to move away from the traditional NHS
focus on single-disease pathways and individual
episodes of care. It is vital, therefore, that these
emerging models build on the strengths of general
practice, including the ‘local’ nature of GP services,
their generalist scope, the continuity of care they
provide to individuals and families and the population-
level perspective they are able to take through
the registered patient list. Patient feedback and
participation should be central to the development
of any new model. RCGP Scotland will, for its part,
continue to seek the input and guidance of its Patient
Partnership in Practice (P3) group and others. The
RCGP has developed five tests (see Box 1 page 7)
that we believe all new models of care should meet.
● Enable RCGP Scotland, NES and the Scottish
Social Services Council (SSSC) to develop general
practitioners’ leadership skills to work effectively
at locality level to implement the vision and values of
integration.
JuLY 2015
Box 1. RCGP Scotland’s five tests of new
integrated care:
Proposed models of integrated care should:
Ensure community-based services are led by
community-based clinicians with a person-centred
perspective.
underpin safe patient care by ensuring that GPs
can continue to act as independent advocates for
their patients, with the emphasis on the person not
the institution.
Be person focused, responding to the needs of
the individual and protecting them from over-
medicalisation, with general practitioners working
with specialists to contribute to the holistic care of
the individual.
Develop existing structures and resources to work
in an increasingly co-operative way, recognising
that primary care is a network of providers and
requires a network literacy in its management, with
the IT to support this.
Ensure that general practice and primary care
funding is sufficient to meet their unique and
vital role in delivering person centred care, with
investment in robust evaluation of new models of
integrated care.
1.
2.
3.
7
4.
5.
●
●
Setting aside specific funding to help embed care
and support planning in general practice for those
patients who would benefit most — particularly those
living with long term conditions. There is widespread
agreement that care and support planning — led by
teams of professionals working with patients and their
carers in the community — is effective in helping people
to take more control over their health and to stay well.
The current ongoing work on the House of Care model is
an excellent example of this. However, these teams need
practical support and training in order to scale up the use
of care and support planning across Scotland, and there
is a need in particular for training (across disciplines) in
this area to be developed and promoted. Further support
for general practice to develop strong and effective
links with the Health and Social Care Alliance Scotland
(the ALLIANCE), for example through the placement of
Community Links Practitioners in appropriate practices, is
crucial in developing integration of the services which will
facilitate self management.
Introduce an innovation allowance to allow GPs to
undertake service development. One of the largest
barriers to innovation across GP services is the lack of
time that GPs have to consider service improvement.
Daily workload pressures are a significant challenge to
driving advances in patient care. unlike secondary care,
practices do not have the benefit of staff members who
can focus solely on quality improvement. An innovation
allowance to protect GP time would enable more GPs to
focus on improvement in addition to delivery, therefore
placing them in a position to drive forward development
in GP practices and clusters. GPs will need the
assurance that funding for this work will continue in
some form in the proposed new contract for 2017.
●
8
4. Investing in general practice’s infrastructure
Improving GP premises. Many GPs feel that their
premises are not fit for patient care. Surgeries are
sometimes too small to cope with a growing number of
patients; some premises need upgrading and in certain
cases, brand new premises are needed. RCGP Scotland
is calling for a review of current premises in order to
determine the number of surgeries which need upgrading
or expanding. In addition, possible sharing of premises
with other primary care health providers and voluntary
sector organisations could be explored as one possible
solution to resolving the current situation facing many GP
premises.
In the Chancellor of the Exchequer’s Autumn Statement
of 2014, £1.1 billion funds were raised from fines
collected by the Financial Conduct Authority13
. If, as
announced, these funds are directed at the NHS in
England, that additional spend generates £123 million in
additional funding for the Scottish Government14
.
In England, the £1 billion allocated will be used to fund
advanced care in GP practices over four years (i.e.
£250 million per annum)15
. Comparably, the Scottish
Government should pledge either £24.6 million per year
over five years or £30.8 million per annum over four
●
In the 2014 British Medical Association GP Committee
Premises Survey of 4,720 GP premises, nearly 53.1%
of respondents stated that there had been no significant
refurbishments or developments to their premises within
the last ten years. Furthermore, the same survey found that
38.9% of practices felt that their premises weren’t adequate
for the provision of general practice services and 61.6%
felt that lack of space in their premises was a barrier to
GP education and/or training12
. Lack of physical space is
preventing some practices from expanding the services they
offer to their local communities, and the development of new
integrated services is likely to require investment in new
premises.
As well as funding for premises, there is an urgent need to
invest in IT infrastructure in general practice, to ensure that
practices are able to offer basic services such as online
booking to patients.
We urge the Scottish Government to take the following
actions to invest in general practice infrastructure:
years for the expansion, redevelopment and building of
new premises in Scotland, following a thorough review.
Invest in general practice IT services. Practices are
crippled by the current level of IT systems, including
those which feed into general practice from other
services such as secondary care, and the inability to
link effectively with the systems of other healthcare
professionals in primary care, in particular Community
Nursing colleagues. Frequent ‘crashing’ of systems
stunts day-to-day operations in practice and connectivity
in certain areas of Scotland remains an unsolved
problem. This is a critical component of the quality
agenda.
With regard to specific, basic online services, RCGP
Scotland and Scottish Government suggested five years
ago that improvements could be made by developing
practice websites and other online tools, including online
appointment booking.
In addition to the resource required to address the
significant IT challenges, RCGP Scotland is therefore
also calling for an increase in investment in online
services over the next five years of over £500,000. At a
basic level, this investment could pay for the setting up
and running of websites for a further one third of the
GP surgeries across the country. It could cost £312,000
per annum to reimburse all practices for a standard GP
website.
The Scottish Government could work with Health
Boards to remove any impediments to developing
the full potential of web based patient-to-general
practice communications. This would include online
appointment setting, repeat prescriptions and other
online GP services for the public. However, it should be
remembered that this is not the right option for every
patient hoping to access general practice.
Invest in better access to diagnostic technology in
general practice. Providing more care in the community
and avoiding unnecessary hospital admissions could be
driven by facilitating more diagnostic tests conducted
in GP practices. The Scottish NHS should establish
a separate taskforce to investigate the potential
opportunities for community diagnostics.
●
●
●
●
A blueprint for Scottish general practice
The Scottish Government’s announcement to provide a
Primary Care Fund in the current financial year is a first
step in addressing some of the concerns currently facing
general practice. However, since its announcement there
has been little clarity on how this funding will be spent.
The government should use this fund as a starting point
for a continued and sustained shift in investment towards
the 11% called for by the RCGP’s Put patients first: Back
general practice campaign.
Such a shift in funding would enable GPs to improve
care for all patients — by tackling rising waiting times,
improving continuity of care and supporting those with
the most complex needs. Last year, over the course of
just a few months, more than 330,000 people signed a
5. Ongoing, sustained investment in general practice
JuLY 2015
9
petition calling for a larger proportion of NHS funding to be
spent on general practice16
. March 2014 polling conducted
by ComRes found that 61% of Scottish adults would
support the majority of additional funding for primary care
to go to general practice services17
.
A better resourced general practice would not only benefit
patients, but would also help put the NHS on a more
sustainable financial footing, with evidence suggesting that
investing in general practice could save the NHS nearly
£2 billion per year by 2020 through reducing pressure on
hospitals and other services (see Box 2 page 10). The
average cost of a face to face GP consultation is around
£45, compared to a range of £61 to £82 for a comparable
secondary care attendance18
.
GP funding as a percentage of total NHS Scotland budget
12.0%
10.0%
8.0%
6.0%
4.0%
2.0%
0.0%
2004/05
2005/06
2006/07
2007/08
2008/09
2009/10
2010/11
2011/12
2012/13
9.47% 9.78%
9.27%
8.31%
7.91% 7.84% 7.93% 7.78% 7.76%
GPfundingasashareofNHSexpenditure
A blueprint for ScottiSh generAl prActice
10
Shift NHS funding into general practice. RCGP
Scotland is calling for 11% of the total NHS budget to
be spent on general practice. Polling conducted by
ComRes in October 2014 found 71% support for this
shift among Scottish adults. The funding figure stood at
7.8% in 2012/13, compared with 9.8% in 2005/06.
Setting a clear target for increasing the proportion
of the NHS budget spent on general practice
to 11%, and putting in place a new primary care
investment plan to deliver this. Local decision makers
should be encouraged and empowered to work towards
this goal, with flexibility around how they achieve it.
●
●
●
●
RCGP Scotland calls on the Scottish Government to:
Publishing regular statistics monitoring how much
NHS funding is being directed towards primary
care, including specific figures on what proportion is
being invested in general practice.
Setting up a new five year transformation fund.
To realise the potential that general practice has to
transform patient care and help shift resources into
the community, additional resources will be needed
to transition work from secondary to primary care and
deliver change. This can be assessed by academic
evidence generated through the Scottish School of
Primary Care.
Box 2: Spend to save: the financial case for investing in general practice
Increased government spending on general practice
could lead to a saving of up to £1.9 billion to the NHS
across the uK as a whole by 2020.
Calculations by the RCGP show that increasing
spending on general practice consultations across the
uK by £72 million each year, could lead to a saving of
up to £375 million each financial year, rising to annual
savings of up to £708 million by the end of 2019/20.
The RCGP figures are based on research commissioned
from Deloitte in 201419
, which estimates that short-term
savings generated through increased spending on general
practice could amount to up to £447 million annually.
This annual saving is broken down into savings of up to:
Analysing three key patient groups — healthy patients,
frail and elderly patients, and those with long-term
conditions — Deloitte estimates that the current cost
of A&E visits is £1.58 billion. This bill could be reduced
to £1.44 billion generating annual savings of at least
£133.9 million in the uK.
Additional savings to the NHS could be made in the
medium and long-term, with additional savings of up
to £333 million annually over the course of the next
five years.
£133.9 million per year, through diverting up to 1.7
million patients away from Accident and Emergency
(A&E) departments,
●
£143.3 million per year, through reducing the
number of unnecessary ambulance call-outs, and
£170.1 million per year, through reducing the length
of hospital stays for patients aged over 65, by
providing greater primary care support at home.
greater primary care support at home.
●
●
JuLY 2015
11
References
1 ISD Scotland, Practice Team Information (PTI) Annual
Update, (2013). Available at: http://www.isdscotland.org/
Health-Topics/General-Practice/Publications/2013-10-
29/2013-10-29-PTI-Report.pdf
2 Gillies, Mercer, Lyon et al., Distilling the Essence of General
Practice, (2009). Available at http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/
pmc/articles/PMC2673184/
3 Healthcare Improvement Scotland and Royal College
of General Practitioners (Scotland), Developing a Quality
Framework for General Practice in Scotland, (2014).
Available at http://www.rcgp.org.uk/rcgp-near-you/rcgp-
scotland/~/media/Files/RCGP-Faculties/Scotland/RCGP-
Scotland/RCGP-Scotland-QFGP%20interactive.ashx
4 Royal College of General Practitioners (Scotland), Time To
Care: Health Inequalities, Deprivation and General Practice
in Scotland, (2010). Available at http://www.rcgp.org.uk/
rcgp-near-you/~/media/Files/RCGP-near-you-Do-Not-Use/
RCGP%20Scotland/Time%20to%20Care%20RCGP%20
Scotland%20report%20on%20Health%20Inequalities.ashx
5 Royal College of General Practitioners (Scotland), The
Future of General Practice in Scotland: A Vision, (2011).
Available at http://www.rcgp.org.uk/rcgp-near-you/~/media/
Files/Policy/A-Z-policy/RCGP-Scotland-The-Future-of-
General-Practice-in-Scotland-a-Vision.ashx
6 British Medical Association, GP Survey Omnibus report,
(2015). Available at: http://bma.org.uk/news-views-analysis/
news/2014/march/gp-morale-damaged-by-workload-says-
survey
7 Royal College of Nursing, Safe staffing levels – a national
Imperative: The UK nursing labour market review 2013,
(2013). Available at: http://www.rcn.org.uk/__data/assets/
pdf_file/0018/541224/004504.pdf
8 Royal College of General Practitioners and Royal
Pharmaceutical Society, RCGP and RPS Policy Statement
on GP Practice Based Pharmacists, (2015). Available at:
http://www.rpharms.com/promoting-pharmacy-pdfs/rcgp-joint-
statement-for-pharmacists-in-gp-surgeries-version-2.pdf
9 Royal College of General Practitioners and Royal
Pharmaceutical Society, Breaking down the barriers –
how community pharmacists and GPs can work together
to improve patient care, (2015). Available at: http://www.
rpharms.com/public-affairs-pdfs/RPSRCGPjointstatement.pdf
10 Scottish Government, Prescription for Excellence: A
Vision and Action Plan, (2013). Available at: http://www.
gov.scot/resource/0043/00434053.pdf
11 Healthcare Improvement Scotland and Royal College
of General Practitioners (Scotland), Developing a Quality
Framework for General Practice in Scotland, (2014).
Available at http://www.rcgp.org.uk/rcgp-near-you/rcgp-
scotland/~/media/Files/RCGP-Faculties/Scotland/RCGP-
Scotland/RCGP-Scotland-QFGP%20interactive.ashx
12 British Medical Association, General Practitioner
Committee, British Medical Association GP Committee
Premises Survey - UK Results, (2014). Available at: http://
bma.org.uk/working-for-change/your-gp-cares/premises-
survey-results
13 HM Treasury and The Rt Hon George Osborne
MP, Oral statement to Parliament Chancellor George
Osborne’s Autumn Statement 2014 speech, (2014).
Available at: https://www.gov.uk/government/speeches/
chancellor-george-osbornes-autumn-statement-2014-
speech
14 HM Treasury, Autumn Statement 2014, (2014).
Available at: https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/
system/uploads/attachment_data/file/382327/44695_
Accessible.pdf
15 Ibid.
16 Royal College of General Practitioners, ‘300,000
signatures strong’, campaign blog, (20 October 2014).
Available at: http://www.rcgp.org.uk/campaign-home/
news-and-blogs/2014/october/campaign-blog-300000-
signatures-strong.aspx
17 Royal College of General Practitioners, ‘Majority of
public believe GP workloads are threat to the level of
patient care’, press release (2014). Available at: http://
www.rcgp.org.uk/news/2014/march/majority-of-public-
believe-gp-workloads-threat-to-level-of-patient-care.aspx
18 Deloitte, Spend to save: The economic case for
improving access to general practice, a report for the
RCGP, (2014). Available at: http://www.rcgp.org.uk/
campaign-home/~/media/Files/PPF/2014-RCGP-Spend-
to-Save-Deloitte-report.ashx
19 Ibid.
Royal College of General Practitioners is a registered charity in England & Wales
(No. 223106) and Scotland (No. SC 040430).
RCGP Scotland
25 Queen Street, Edinburgh. EH2 1JX
Telephone: 020 3188 7730
Fax: 020 3188 7401
Email: policy@rcgp.org.uk
Website: www.rcgp.org.uk
Version Date: July 2015
© RCGP Scotland, 2015. All rights reserved.
Authors: David Webster, Jonathan Ware,
Matthew Chisambi & Catherine Witcombe.
Published by:

More Related Content

What's hot

Hellesdon Hospital Case Study
Hellesdon Hospital Case StudyHellesdon Hospital Case Study
Hellesdon Hospital Case StudyChabaz Chabuka
 
HTA training - Claire Gorry - July 26th 2016
HTA training - Claire Gorry - July 26th 2016HTA training - Claire Gorry - July 26th 2016
HTA training - Claire Gorry - July 26th 2016ipposi
 
Sarah khan-for-web-improving-mhcc-conference-15 1209.10.15
Sarah khan-for-web-improving-mhcc-conference-15 1209.10.15Sarah khan-for-web-improving-mhcc-conference-15 1209.10.15
Sarah khan-for-web-improving-mhcc-conference-15 1209.10.153GDR
 
The Forward View into action: planning for 2015/16
The Forward View into action: planning for 2015/16The Forward View into action: planning for 2015/16
The Forward View into action: planning for 2015/16NHS Confederation
 
AHSN-2015 Impact Report-web-EM
AHSN-2015 Impact Report-web-EMAHSN-2015 Impact Report-web-EM
AHSN-2015 Impact Report-web-EMHilary Rowell
 
Excel in Health webinar series: The NHS landscape
Excel in Health webinar series:  The NHS landscapeExcel in Health webinar series:  The NHS landscape
Excel in Health webinar series: The NHS landscapeInnovation Agency
 
Facts, figures and views on health and social care: A pack prepared for repor...
Facts, figures and views on health and social care: A pack prepared for repor...Facts, figures and views on health and social care: A pack prepared for repor...
Facts, figures and views on health and social care: A pack prepared for repor...Nuffield Trust
 
Creating successful partnerships in yorkshire and humber
Creating successful partnerships in yorkshire and humberCreating successful partnerships in yorkshire and humber
Creating successful partnerships in yorkshire and humberPM Society
 
Innovation Agency Annual Report 2015/16
Innovation Agency Annual Report 2015/16Innovation Agency Annual Report 2015/16
Innovation Agency Annual Report 2015/16Louise Roocroft
 
PRIMARY+HEALTH+CARE+IN+UK,+AUS+&+NZ
PRIMARY+HEALTH+CARE+IN+UK,+AUS+&+NZPRIMARY+HEALTH+CARE+IN+UK,+AUS+&+NZ
PRIMARY+HEALTH+CARE+IN+UK,+AUS+&+NZNitin Sukumaran
 
A vision for cheshire and mersey clrn
A vision for cheshire and mersey clrnA vision for cheshire and mersey clrn
A vision for cheshire and mersey clrnPM Society
 
Webinar slides: Personal health budgets and mental health: Getting ready and ...
Webinar slides: Personal health budgets and mental health: Getting ready and ...Webinar slides: Personal health budgets and mental health: Getting ready and ...
Webinar slides: Personal health budgets and mental health: Getting ready and ...In-Control Partnerships
 
Joint working the 7 step framework
Joint working the 7 step frameworkJoint working the 7 step framework
Joint working the 7 step frameworkPM Society
 
David Buck on improving the allocation of health resources in England
David Buck on improving the allocation of health resources in England David Buck on improving the allocation of health resources in England
David Buck on improving the allocation of health resources in England The King's Fund
 
Local health care expenditure plans and their opportunity costs
Local health care expenditure plans and their opportunity costsLocal health care expenditure plans and their opportunity costs
Local health care expenditure plans and their opportunity costsOffice of Health Economics
 
Martin Bardsley: integration and innovation in health
Martin Bardsley: integration and innovation in healthMartin Bardsley: integration and innovation in health
Martin Bardsley: integration and innovation in healthNuffield Trust
 
Malawi Mid-Year Review 2014-2015 Health Sector Overview
Malawi Mid-Year Review 2014-2015 Health Sector OverviewMalawi Mid-Year Review 2014-2015 Health Sector Overview
Malawi Mid-Year Review 2014-2015 Health Sector Overviewmohmalawi
 
Working Longer Board presentation
Working Longer Board presentationWorking Longer Board presentation
Working Longer Board presentationemmajlh
 

What's hot (20)

Hellesdon Hospital Case Study
Hellesdon Hospital Case StudyHellesdon Hospital Case Study
Hellesdon Hospital Case Study
 
HTA training - Claire Gorry - July 26th 2016
HTA training - Claire Gorry - July 26th 2016HTA training - Claire Gorry - July 26th 2016
HTA training - Claire Gorry - July 26th 2016
 
Sarah khan-for-web-improving-mhcc-conference-15 1209.10.15
Sarah khan-for-web-improving-mhcc-conference-15 1209.10.15Sarah khan-for-web-improving-mhcc-conference-15 1209.10.15
Sarah khan-for-web-improving-mhcc-conference-15 1209.10.15
 
The Forward View into action: planning for 2015/16
The Forward View into action: planning for 2015/16The Forward View into action: planning for 2015/16
The Forward View into action: planning for 2015/16
 
NHS 5 Year Forward View
NHS 5 Year Forward ViewNHS 5 Year Forward View
NHS 5 Year Forward View
 
AHSN-2015 Impact Report-web-EM
AHSN-2015 Impact Report-web-EMAHSN-2015 Impact Report-web-EM
AHSN-2015 Impact Report-web-EM
 
Excel in Health webinar series: The NHS landscape
Excel in Health webinar series:  The NHS landscapeExcel in Health webinar series:  The NHS landscape
Excel in Health webinar series: The NHS landscape
 
Facts, figures and views on health and social care: A pack prepared for repor...
Facts, figures and views on health and social care: A pack prepared for repor...Facts, figures and views on health and social care: A pack prepared for repor...
Facts, figures and views on health and social care: A pack prepared for repor...
 
Creating successful partnerships in yorkshire and humber
Creating successful partnerships in yorkshire and humberCreating successful partnerships in yorkshire and humber
Creating successful partnerships in yorkshire and humber
 
Innovation Agency Annual Report 2015/16
Innovation Agency Annual Report 2015/16Innovation Agency Annual Report 2015/16
Innovation Agency Annual Report 2015/16
 
PRIMARY+HEALTH+CARE+IN+UK,+AUS+&+NZ
PRIMARY+HEALTH+CARE+IN+UK,+AUS+&+NZPRIMARY+HEALTH+CARE+IN+UK,+AUS+&+NZ
PRIMARY+HEALTH+CARE+IN+UK,+AUS+&+NZ
 
A vision for cheshire and mersey clrn
A vision for cheshire and mersey clrnA vision for cheshire and mersey clrn
A vision for cheshire and mersey clrn
 
Gme fitzhugh mullan
Gme fitzhugh mullanGme fitzhugh mullan
Gme fitzhugh mullan
 
Webinar slides: Personal health budgets and mental health: Getting ready and ...
Webinar slides: Personal health budgets and mental health: Getting ready and ...Webinar slides: Personal health budgets and mental health: Getting ready and ...
Webinar slides: Personal health budgets and mental health: Getting ready and ...
 
Joint working the 7 step framework
Joint working the 7 step frameworkJoint working the 7 step framework
Joint working the 7 step framework
 
David Buck on improving the allocation of health resources in England
David Buck on improving the allocation of health resources in England David Buck on improving the allocation of health resources in England
David Buck on improving the allocation of health resources in England
 
Local health care expenditure plans and their opportunity costs
Local health care expenditure plans and their opportunity costsLocal health care expenditure plans and their opportunity costs
Local health care expenditure plans and their opportunity costs
 
Martin Bardsley: integration and innovation in health
Martin Bardsley: integration and innovation in healthMartin Bardsley: integration and innovation in health
Martin Bardsley: integration and innovation in health
 
Malawi Mid-Year Review 2014-2015 Health Sector Overview
Malawi Mid-Year Review 2014-2015 Health Sector OverviewMalawi Mid-Year Review 2014-2015 Health Sector Overview
Malawi Mid-Year Review 2014-2015 Health Sector Overview
 
Working Longer Board presentation
Working Longer Board presentationWorking Longer Board presentation
Working Longer Board presentation
 

Viewers also liked

MattDrohanResume_12-3-15
MattDrohanResume_12-3-15MattDrohanResume_12-3-15
MattDrohanResume_12-3-15Matt Drohan
 
Special offer
Special offerSpecial offer
Special offerEdnexa
 
El concierto solidario llenó el Kursaal
El concierto solidario llenó el KursaalEl concierto solidario llenó el Kursaal
El concierto solidario llenó el KursaalOpus Dei
 
soluciones
soluciones soluciones
soluciones Mar Tuxi
 
B orthognathic surgery results George Vilos
B orthognathic surgery results George VilosB orthognathic surgery results George Vilos
B orthognathic surgery results George VilosGeorge Vilos
 
People Photography | Coe Photographic
People Photography | Coe PhotographicPeople Photography | Coe Photographic
People Photography | Coe PhotographicPeter Coe
 
Ecosistemas
EcosistemasEcosistemas
EcosistemasNEJAPA5
 
Leading the library of the future: w(h)ither technical services?
Leading the library of the future: w(h)ither technical services?Leading the library of the future: w(h)ither technical services?
Leading the library of the future: w(h)ither technical services?Keith Webster
 
La pornografía causas y efectos
La pornografía causas y efectosLa pornografía causas y efectos
La pornografía causas y efectosDiffusor Fidei
 
HISTORY: Indian, Chinese, Japanese Architecture
HISTORY: Indian, Chinese, Japanese Architecture HISTORY: Indian, Chinese, Japanese Architecture
HISTORY: Indian, Chinese, Japanese Architecture ArchiEducPH
 

Viewers also liked (14)

Lucot2
Lucot2Lucot2
Lucot2
 
MattDrohanResume_12-3-15
MattDrohanResume_12-3-15MattDrohanResume_12-3-15
MattDrohanResume_12-3-15
 
Special offer
Special offerSpecial offer
Special offer
 
El concierto solidario llenó el Kursaal
El concierto solidario llenó el KursaalEl concierto solidario llenó el Kursaal
El concierto solidario llenó el Kursaal
 
soluciones
soluciones soluciones
soluciones
 
B orthognathic surgery results George Vilos
B orthognathic surgery results George VilosB orthognathic surgery results George Vilos
B orthognathic surgery results George Vilos
 
People Photography | Coe Photographic
People Photography | Coe PhotographicPeople Photography | Coe Photographic
People Photography | Coe Photographic
 
Maestra por 1 dia
Maestra por 1 diaMaestra por 1 dia
Maestra por 1 dia
 
Maestro por un dia
Maestro por un diaMaestro por un dia
Maestro por un dia
 
Ecosistemas
EcosistemasEcosistemas
Ecosistemas
 
Business 101.1 class 6 NYU ITP
Business 101.1 class 6 NYU ITPBusiness 101.1 class 6 NYU ITP
Business 101.1 class 6 NYU ITP
 
Leading the library of the future: w(h)ither technical services?
Leading the library of the future: w(h)ither technical services?Leading the library of the future: w(h)ither technical services?
Leading the library of the future: w(h)ither technical services?
 
La pornografía causas y efectos
La pornografía causas y efectosLa pornografía causas y efectos
La pornografía causas y efectos
 
HISTORY: Indian, Chinese, Japanese Architecture
HISTORY: Indian, Chinese, Japanese Architecture HISTORY: Indian, Chinese, Japanese Architecture
HISTORY: Indian, Chinese, Japanese Architecture
 

Similar to document(1)

Delivering clinical and financial sustainability, pop up uni, 2 september 2015
Delivering clinical and financial sustainability, pop up uni, 2 september 2015Delivering clinical and financial sustainability, pop up uni, 2 september 2015
Delivering clinical and financial sustainability, pop up uni, 2 september 2015NHS England
 
Delivering clinical and financial sustainability across a £6bn health economy...
Delivering clinical and financial sustainability across a £6bn health economy...Delivering clinical and financial sustainability across a £6bn health economy...
Delivering clinical and financial sustainability across a £6bn health economy...NHS England
 
Arvind Madan, NHS England
Arvind Madan, NHS England Arvind Madan, NHS England
Arvind Madan, NHS England Nuffield Trust
 
General Practice Transformation Champions: Transformation of Primary Care
General Practice Transformation Champions: Transformation of Primary CareGeneral Practice Transformation Champions: Transformation of Primary Care
General Practice Transformation Champions: Transformation of Primary CareNHS England
 
C_inetpubwwwrootmedicalcemUploaddocumentzCEM8691-RCEM Scotland & Scottish Gov...
C_inetpubwwwrootmedicalcemUploaddocumentzCEM8691-RCEM Scotland & Scottish Gov...C_inetpubwwwrootmedicalcemUploaddocumentzCEM8691-RCEM Scotland & Scottish Gov...
C_inetpubwwwrootmedicalcemUploaddocumentzCEM8691-RCEM Scotland & Scottish Gov...tim parke
 
Midlands and East GP Forward View update event May 2017
Midlands and East GP Forward View update event May 2017Midlands and East GP Forward View update event May 2017
Midlands and East GP Forward View update event May 2017NHS England
 
Ph gp london_training_day
Ph gp london_training_dayPh gp london_training_day
Ph gp london_training_dayAzeem Majeed
 
Bee-Wee-National-End-of-Life-Care-Update.pptx
Bee-Wee-National-End-of-Life-Care-Update.pptxBee-Wee-National-End-of-Life-Care-Update.pptx
Bee-Wee-National-End-of-Life-Care-Update.pptxzaqqiubaidillah
 
Connected Health & Me - Prof George Crooks - Nov 24th 2014
Connected Health & Me - Prof George Crooks - Nov 24th 2014Connected Health & Me - Prof George Crooks - Nov 24th 2014
Connected Health & Me - Prof George Crooks - Nov 24th 2014ipposi
 
BPF-Quality-Buildings-Quality-Care-Nov-15-web_0
BPF-Quality-Buildings-Quality-Care-Nov-15-web_0BPF-Quality-Buildings-Quality-Care-Nov-15-web_0
BPF-Quality-Buildings-Quality-Care-Nov-15-web_0Karen West
 
Efficiency Awards Winners Brochure 2011
Efficiency Awards Winners Brochure 2011Efficiency Awards Winners Brochure 2011
Efficiency Awards Winners Brochure 2011Simon Pace
 
P1-Healthcare and RD Landscape in Singapore.pptx
P1-Healthcare and RD Landscape in Singapore.pptxP1-Healthcare and RD Landscape in Singapore.pptx
P1-Healthcare and RD Landscape in Singapore.pptxtrilok bavishi
 
Ian Legg Nov14 CV(v4)
Ian Legg Nov14 CV(v4)Ian Legg Nov14 CV(v4)
Ian Legg Nov14 CV(v4)Ian Legg
 
YFG Pre Budget Submission 2016
YFG Pre Budget Submission 2016 YFG Pre Budget Submission 2016
YFG Pre Budget Submission 2016 YFineGael
 
Training and Up-skilling the Workforce to Deliver Effective 7-DayServices
Training and Up-skilling the Workforce to Deliver Effective 7-DayServicesTraining and Up-skilling the Workforce to Deliver Effective 7-DayServices
Training and Up-skilling the Workforce to Deliver Effective 7-DayServicesNHS Improving Quality
 

Similar to document(1) (20)

Delivering clinical and financial sustainability, pop up uni, 2 september 2015
Delivering clinical and financial sustainability, pop up uni, 2 september 2015Delivering clinical and financial sustainability, pop up uni, 2 september 2015
Delivering clinical and financial sustainability, pop up uni, 2 september 2015
 
Delivering clinical and financial sustainability across a £6bn health economy...
Delivering clinical and financial sustainability across a £6bn health economy...Delivering clinical and financial sustainability across a £6bn health economy...
Delivering clinical and financial sustainability across a £6bn health economy...
 
Arvind Madan, NHS England
Arvind Madan, NHS England Arvind Madan, NHS England
Arvind Madan, NHS England
 
Focus on cataract
Focus on cataractFocus on cataract
Focus on cataract
 
General Practice Transformation Champions: Transformation of Primary Care
General Practice Transformation Champions: Transformation of Primary CareGeneral Practice Transformation Champions: Transformation of Primary Care
General Practice Transformation Champions: Transformation of Primary Care
 
ClinMed1 52 Thomson1
ClinMed1 52 Thomson1ClinMed1 52 Thomson1
ClinMed1 52 Thomson1
 
Issue 6 - July 2016
Issue 6 - July 2016Issue 6 - July 2016
Issue 6 - July 2016
 
Briefing note
Briefing noteBriefing note
Briefing note
 
C_inetpubwwwrootmedicalcemUploaddocumentzCEM8691-RCEM Scotland & Scottish Gov...
C_inetpubwwwrootmedicalcemUploaddocumentzCEM8691-RCEM Scotland & Scottish Gov...C_inetpubwwwrootmedicalcemUploaddocumentzCEM8691-RCEM Scotland & Scottish Gov...
C_inetpubwwwrootmedicalcemUploaddocumentzCEM8691-RCEM Scotland & Scottish Gov...
 
Midlands and East GP Forward View update event May 2017
Midlands and East GP Forward View update event May 2017Midlands and East GP Forward View update event May 2017
Midlands and East GP Forward View update event May 2017
 
Ph gp london_training_day
Ph gp london_training_dayPh gp london_training_day
Ph gp london_training_day
 
Bee-Wee-National-End-of-Life-Care-Update.pptx
Bee-Wee-National-End-of-Life-Care-Update.pptxBee-Wee-National-End-of-Life-Care-Update.pptx
Bee-Wee-National-End-of-Life-Care-Update.pptx
 
Connected Health & Me - Prof George Crooks - Nov 24th 2014
Connected Health & Me - Prof George Crooks - Nov 24th 2014Connected Health & Me - Prof George Crooks - Nov 24th 2014
Connected Health & Me - Prof George Crooks - Nov 24th 2014
 
BPF-Quality-Buildings-Quality-Care-Nov-15-web_0
BPF-Quality-Buildings-Quality-Care-Nov-15-web_0BPF-Quality-Buildings-Quality-Care-Nov-15-web_0
BPF-Quality-Buildings-Quality-Care-Nov-15-web_0
 
Efficiency Awards Winners Brochure 2011
Efficiency Awards Winners Brochure 2011Efficiency Awards Winners Brochure 2011
Efficiency Awards Winners Brochure 2011
 
P1-Healthcare and RD Landscape in Singapore.pptx
P1-Healthcare and RD Landscape in Singapore.pptxP1-Healthcare and RD Landscape in Singapore.pptx
P1-Healthcare and RD Landscape in Singapore.pptx
 
Ian Legg Nov14 CV(v4)
Ian Legg Nov14 CV(v4)Ian Legg Nov14 CV(v4)
Ian Legg Nov14 CV(v4)
 
YFG Pre Budget Submission 2016
YFG Pre Budget Submission 2016 YFG Pre Budget Submission 2016
YFG Pre Budget Submission 2016
 
Training and Up-skilling the Workforce to Deliver Effective 7-DayServices
Training and Up-skilling the Workforce to Deliver Effective 7-DayServicesTraining and Up-skilling the Workforce to Deliver Effective 7-DayServices
Training and Up-skilling the Workforce to Deliver Effective 7-DayServices
 
Commercial Update May 2016 FINAL
Commercial Update May 2016 FINALCommercial Update May 2016 FINAL
Commercial Update May 2016 FINAL
 

document(1)

  • 1. July 2015 A blueprint for Scottish general practice A strategy for a safe, secure and strong general practice in Scotland
  • 2. General practice is central to the future of the NHS in Scotland. This paper sets out a blueprint to reverse the impacts of the increasing problems of workload and recruitment on the ability of GPs to deliver excellent patient care. These problems have become ever more apparent over the last six months. The Royal College of General Practitioners Scotland (RCGP Scotland) has been warning for a year and a half now — through our Put patients first: Back general practice campaign — that rising workloads, a shortage of GPs and declining resources are putting intolerable pressure on local practices and posing a threat to patient care. As many people’s first point of contact with the NHS, around 90% of patient interaction is with primary care services. General practice is the cornerstone of primary care, with Scottish GP surgery teams carrying out an estimated 24.2 million consultations each year — an 11% rise over ten years1 . At the same time, the share of NHS funding spent on general practice in Scotland has been falling year on year. The GP percentage has fallen from 9.8% in 2005/06 to a record low of 7.8% in 2012/13. This drop has led to a real terms cumulative loss of investment of £1.1 billion into Scottish general practice compared to a scenario where funding had remained at 9.8%. General practice is a cost-effective part of the healthcare system in which to invest as it is more economical than other parts of the system and can prevent worsening of patient outcomes (see Box 2 page10). However, it will not be able to deliver positive changes in the short, medium and long-term without significant investment to increase the size of the workforce. RCGP Scotland has warmly welcomed and participates in the review of out of hours primary care services chaired by Professor Sir Lewis Ritchie and due to report in September 2015. It is clear that many of the measures called for in this document will impact positively on out of hours care. This document in no way seeks to pre-empt the review but recognises that many of the constructive steps called for here will aid in the provision of appropriate out of hours care. The RCGP Scotland Green Light statement of February 2015 offers further information on the College’s position but it bears repetition that the College sees it as essential that GPs remain a central part of the service to ensure safe, holistic patient care. Out of hours care is an integral part of general practice. This document builds on the solid foundations provided by earlier work from the Royal College of General Practitioners. Among others, RCGP Scotland’s The Essence of General Practice2 , Developing a Quality Framework for General Practice in Scotland3 , the Time To Care health inequalities report4 and The Future of General Practice in Scotland: A Vision5 have all contributed to the thinking behind this blueprint. It is intended as one for discussion with all stakeholders, not least Scottish Government. Of course, any changes undertaken must be evaluated appropriately and this will require robust general practice academic input, such as that provided by the Scottish School of Primary Care. Changes must clearly also align with the developing work on integration and on multiple morbidities. Introduction A blueprint for Scottish general practice 2
  • 3. In November 2014, the Scottish Government announced an additional £40 million investment for general practice and primary care in Scotland, to be used in the 2015/16 financial year. However, since this announcement there have been further developments and the Cabinet Secretary has recently indicated her intention that such a fund be spread over three years. We urgently need a clear strategy from the Scottish Government for investing in Scottish general practice, ensuring that funding reaches general practice in the coming year but also putting GP services on a more sustainable footing for the long term so that they may deliver effective, quality care to patients appropriate to their needs 24 hours a day, seven days a week. This document sets out a strategy towards this. JuLY 2015 3 Building a properly funded general practice hub Ongoing, sustained investment in general practice Investing in infrastructure Promoting integrated care Expanding the wider primary care workforce The 2020 Vision of an integrated Health and Social Care system Expanding the number of GPs
  • 4. A blueprint for ScottiSh generAl prActice 4 1. Expanding the number of GPs Set a clear objective to increase the number of Whole Time Equivalent GPs in Scotland. RCGP Scotland is calling for the expansion of the GP workforce by 740 general practitioners in Scotland by 2020. This figure is the midpoint between the previous range of WTE estimates produced by RCGP in April 2015. This range was based on reaching and maintaining the 2009 level of GP coverage and projecting forward using Office of National Statistics predicted population growth. The Scottish Government should work with RCGP Scotland and NHS Education for Scotland (NES) and ensure progress against this aim is closely monitored. This strand of work should include involving university departments and foundation schools with the aim of improving and promoting recruitment to meet the target of at least 50% of medical students entering general practice. Launch a high profile marketing campaign to promote general practice as a career. The campaign run by NES in 2015 should be reviewed with the aim ● The Scottish Government’s NHS Information Services Division (ISD) released a Primary Care Workforce Survey in 2013. Its Publication Summary reported that ‘The estimated Whole Time Equivalent (WTE) number of GPs in post in Scottish general practices (excluding Specialist Trainees) at 31 January 2013 was 3,735. This is only a little higher than the estimate of 3,700 generated from a previous survey run in 2009. ... The results of this survey suggest that the WTE number has been fairly static over the past few years.’ This is simply not enough to meet the changing needs of patients. One in five GPs in Scotland is aged over 55 and, therefore, 20% of the GP workforce could feasibly and naturally retire over the next five years. This figure is bolstered by the alarming findings of the recent British Medical Association (BMA) survey, published in April, which suggests that one in three Scottish GPs were hoping to retire within the next five years. We need greater investment in GP workforce capacity so that Scotland can care for its growing, ageing population at home, in a homely setting and in the community. Whatever the shape of the 2017 GMS contract negotiations, Scotland urgently needs a package of measures backed by resources to increase the number of GPs, including encouraging more doctors to choose general practice as a career, doing more to retain our current GP workforce, working to prevent GPs retiring when they are still able to provide an excellent service to patients, and making it easier for those who have left the profession to return to practice. We urge the Scottish Government to take the following actions to increase the GP workforce: of setting up a fully resourced marketing campaign to encourage foundation doctors and medical students to choose general practice as a career. This should include dedicated funding for recruitment roadshows to showcase general practice as a career to foundation doctors and medical students across Scotland. Incentives to attract new doctors into general practice, particularly in under-doctored areas. A further package of enhanced, targeted, financial incentives should be developed to encourage medical graduates to train and practise as GPs in currently under-doctored and deprived areas. These incentives could include helping graduates to pay off their student loans if they agree to practise in selected areas — an approach that has already been pioneered in New Zealand and is currently being explored in England. A large scale campaign to promote the national GP Induction and Returner Programmes will be important in boosting the workforce in Scotland. Scotland has had an established GP Returner Scheme delivered by NES for many years and regional Health Boards have provided inductions where appropriate. This requires further publicity as uptake of these schemes has been variable with an average of 7.5 GPs per year over the past ten years entering the Returner scheme. It is now known that some 259 GPs under the age of 50 have left Scottish Performers Lists in the last five years, of which 166 were aged less than 40 years old. The NES GP Directors must be commended for their review of the programmes in Scotland and for upgrading the NES website to provide an easily accessible and comprehensive resource to signpost and support GPs into the workforce. However, further assurance of recurring funding and resource is required to ensure a sufficient boost to the number of trained GPs who are able to return to general practice. These programmes should be available for trained GPs from a variety of backgrounds including Scottish GPs who have had career breaks and those who wish to join the Scottish GP workforce from both within and outside the uK. Increased investment in the national retainer programme, including a review to identify the most effective measures to encourage experienced GPs to remain within practice. Scotland already has a successful and quality assured retainer scheme through which GP retainers are well supported. However, GP practices need further support and this scheme should have its funding increased with incentives designed to encourage more GP practices to take on GP retainers. ● ● ● ●
  • 5. With GPs facing immense pressure due to rising workloads and constrained finances, morale in Scottish general practice is currently very low. A recent survey of GPs found that over half (54%) feel their current workload is unmanageable or unsustainable6 . The significant contribution of other members of the primary care team in delivering high quality patient care in the primary care setting cannot be ignored. Whilst other health professionals can never be a direct replacement for general practitioners, and while the role of GPs in being the first point of patient contact, in co-ordinating comprehensive care and in providing continuity of care, must be protected — the role the wider primary care workforce has to play in delivering services is vital. There are significant challenges facing other healthcare professionals. For example, community nurses are facing significant retirement challenges. Almost 50% of NHS community nurses in NHS Scotland are aged 50 years or older. This means that the recruitment challenge to safeguard services against this retirement ‘cliff’ will be extremely pronounced over the next five years7 . Strengthening the capacity and capability of other healthcare professionals in general practices is essential to improve the quality of healthcare services in the community. To expand the wider primary care workforce to support general practice, the Scottish Government could enact the following: 2. Expanding the wider primary care workforce to support general practice JuLY 2015 with NES to establish how the role of community and practice nurses can be promoted in order to boost numbers in Scotland. Promote the role of practice-based and community pharmacists. Both practice-based and community pharmacists are uniquely placed to work with GPs to improve patient care and safety, and can play an important role in the long-term management of patients with chronic disease. In March, the RCGP and Royal Pharmaceutical Society (RPS) issued a joint statement, RCGP and RPS Policy Statement on GP Practice Based Pharmacists, highlighting the important role that practice-based pharmacists can have based in general practices8 . There should be investment in recruitment and training of pharmacists based in general practice who would be of considerable value in reviewing patients’ medication, managing polypharmacy, managing medication issues for the housebound within the newly integrated health and social care teams, linking effectively with community pharmacists and medicines reconciliation across the interface, all with significant benefit to patient safety. This could improve care, save the NHS a significant amount of money and alleviate pressures on GPs. The RCGP and RPS also worked together regarding community pharmacists via their statement, Breaking down the barriers — how community pharmacists and GPs can work together to improve patient care9 . This sets out recommendations for benefits to patients in improving liaison between community pharmacists and general practitioners. In response to Prescription for Excellence10 , there have been a number of initiatives across Scotland. Current projects regarding collaborative working with community pharmacists include: ● The Highland Community Pharmacy project where the objective is to develop decision support between community pharmacists and local GP practices. Healthcare Improvement Scotland’s National Patient Safety Programme in Primary Care, which includes the Pharmacy in Primary Care Collaborative, which aims to enhance communications between GPs and Community Pharmacists in rural and urban settings. ● 5 Provide funding to enhance community nursing and enable practices to recruit more practice nurses. Community and practice nurses have a vital role to play in delivering high quality patient care in the community. Boosting the number of community and practice nurses and widening their remit to take on additional tasks will help free up time for GPs to spend with patients with complex needs. NES has a General Practice Nursing Programme and it is currently examining ways in which to boost take up. An expansion of that programme should allow more places to be provided. In order to encourage more nurses to become community or practice nurses, national training standards and clear career pathways for these nurses need to be developed. RCGP Scotland would welcome a joint programme ● ●
  • 6. A blueprint for Scottish general practice The Integration of Health and Social Care seeks to improve care for patients as well as ensuring GP services are efficient and effective. RCGP Scotland believes that the integration of care should be primary care led and offered by multi-professional teams to deliver the best possible health outcomes. Care planning for those with complex conditions, redesigning services to provide more services in the community and the establishment of GP clusters are vital to achieving better outcomes for patients. In Scotland, general practitioners are keen to develop new models of care, in particular GP clusters, which would allow skills and expertise to be shared across practices. The following suggestions are forwarded in the expectation that successful ongoing work, such as Healthcare Improvement Scotland (HIS) and RCGP Scotland’s Developing a Quality Framework for General Practice in Scotland11 , and the National Clinical Lead for Self Management and Health Literacy, Dr Graham Kramer’s work on supported self management and the House of Care development, will continue to be supported and furthered. We call on the Scottish Government to take the following actions so that GPs may lead the development of new integrated models of patient care: 3. Giving GPs the tools to lead the development of new integrated models of patient care ● ● 6 Establishing a sustained package of support and practical advice which GPs can access to help them develop new models of care. Whilst individual practices are excellent at developing innovations for their specific localities, the system has challenges in testing and spreading these innovations to other general practices and the aforementioned Developing a Quality Framework for General Practice in Scotland’s concentration on quality improvement has sought to mitigate against these difficulties. In order to support the development and replication of good practice, support packages which provide practical implementation advice and funding should be made available. Ensuring that patient centred care is hardwired into emerging new models by building on the strengths of general practice. The doctor-patient relationship must be protected. In the context of rising levels of multiple morbidity, these new models will need to move away from the traditional NHS focus on single-disease pathways and individual episodes of care. It is vital, therefore, that these emerging models build on the strengths of general practice, including the ‘local’ nature of GP services, their generalist scope, the continuity of care they provide to individuals and families and the population- level perspective they are able to take through the registered patient list. Patient feedback and participation should be central to the development of any new model. RCGP Scotland will, for its part, continue to seek the input and guidance of its Patient Partnership in Practice (P3) group and others. The RCGP has developed five tests (see Box 1 page 7) that we believe all new models of care should meet. ● Enable RCGP Scotland, NES and the Scottish Social Services Council (SSSC) to develop general practitioners’ leadership skills to work effectively at locality level to implement the vision and values of integration.
  • 7. JuLY 2015 Box 1. RCGP Scotland’s five tests of new integrated care: Proposed models of integrated care should: Ensure community-based services are led by community-based clinicians with a person-centred perspective. underpin safe patient care by ensuring that GPs can continue to act as independent advocates for their patients, with the emphasis on the person not the institution. Be person focused, responding to the needs of the individual and protecting them from over- medicalisation, with general practitioners working with specialists to contribute to the holistic care of the individual. Develop existing structures and resources to work in an increasingly co-operative way, recognising that primary care is a network of providers and requires a network literacy in its management, with the IT to support this. Ensure that general practice and primary care funding is sufficient to meet their unique and vital role in delivering person centred care, with investment in robust evaluation of new models of integrated care. 1. 2. 3. 7 4. 5. ● ● Setting aside specific funding to help embed care and support planning in general practice for those patients who would benefit most — particularly those living with long term conditions. There is widespread agreement that care and support planning — led by teams of professionals working with patients and their carers in the community — is effective in helping people to take more control over their health and to stay well. The current ongoing work on the House of Care model is an excellent example of this. However, these teams need practical support and training in order to scale up the use of care and support planning across Scotland, and there is a need in particular for training (across disciplines) in this area to be developed and promoted. Further support for general practice to develop strong and effective links with the Health and Social Care Alliance Scotland (the ALLIANCE), for example through the placement of Community Links Practitioners in appropriate practices, is crucial in developing integration of the services which will facilitate self management. Introduce an innovation allowance to allow GPs to undertake service development. One of the largest barriers to innovation across GP services is the lack of time that GPs have to consider service improvement. Daily workload pressures are a significant challenge to driving advances in patient care. unlike secondary care, practices do not have the benefit of staff members who can focus solely on quality improvement. An innovation allowance to protect GP time would enable more GPs to focus on improvement in addition to delivery, therefore placing them in a position to drive forward development in GP practices and clusters. GPs will need the assurance that funding for this work will continue in some form in the proposed new contract for 2017.
  • 8. ● 8 4. Investing in general practice’s infrastructure Improving GP premises. Many GPs feel that their premises are not fit for patient care. Surgeries are sometimes too small to cope with a growing number of patients; some premises need upgrading and in certain cases, brand new premises are needed. RCGP Scotland is calling for a review of current premises in order to determine the number of surgeries which need upgrading or expanding. In addition, possible sharing of premises with other primary care health providers and voluntary sector organisations could be explored as one possible solution to resolving the current situation facing many GP premises. In the Chancellor of the Exchequer’s Autumn Statement of 2014, £1.1 billion funds were raised from fines collected by the Financial Conduct Authority13 . If, as announced, these funds are directed at the NHS in England, that additional spend generates £123 million in additional funding for the Scottish Government14 . In England, the £1 billion allocated will be used to fund advanced care in GP practices over four years (i.e. £250 million per annum)15 . Comparably, the Scottish Government should pledge either £24.6 million per year over five years or £30.8 million per annum over four ● In the 2014 British Medical Association GP Committee Premises Survey of 4,720 GP premises, nearly 53.1% of respondents stated that there had been no significant refurbishments or developments to their premises within the last ten years. Furthermore, the same survey found that 38.9% of practices felt that their premises weren’t adequate for the provision of general practice services and 61.6% felt that lack of space in their premises was a barrier to GP education and/or training12 . Lack of physical space is preventing some practices from expanding the services they offer to their local communities, and the development of new integrated services is likely to require investment in new premises. As well as funding for premises, there is an urgent need to invest in IT infrastructure in general practice, to ensure that practices are able to offer basic services such as online booking to patients. We urge the Scottish Government to take the following actions to invest in general practice infrastructure: years for the expansion, redevelopment and building of new premises in Scotland, following a thorough review. Invest in general practice IT services. Practices are crippled by the current level of IT systems, including those which feed into general practice from other services such as secondary care, and the inability to link effectively with the systems of other healthcare professionals in primary care, in particular Community Nursing colleagues. Frequent ‘crashing’ of systems stunts day-to-day operations in practice and connectivity in certain areas of Scotland remains an unsolved problem. This is a critical component of the quality agenda. With regard to specific, basic online services, RCGP Scotland and Scottish Government suggested five years ago that improvements could be made by developing practice websites and other online tools, including online appointment booking. In addition to the resource required to address the significant IT challenges, RCGP Scotland is therefore also calling for an increase in investment in online services over the next five years of over £500,000. At a basic level, this investment could pay for the setting up and running of websites for a further one third of the GP surgeries across the country. It could cost £312,000 per annum to reimburse all practices for a standard GP website. The Scottish Government could work with Health Boards to remove any impediments to developing the full potential of web based patient-to-general practice communications. This would include online appointment setting, repeat prescriptions and other online GP services for the public. However, it should be remembered that this is not the right option for every patient hoping to access general practice. Invest in better access to diagnostic technology in general practice. Providing more care in the community and avoiding unnecessary hospital admissions could be driven by facilitating more diagnostic tests conducted in GP practices. The Scottish NHS should establish a separate taskforce to investigate the potential opportunities for community diagnostics. ● ● ● ● A blueprint for Scottish general practice
  • 9. The Scottish Government’s announcement to provide a Primary Care Fund in the current financial year is a first step in addressing some of the concerns currently facing general practice. However, since its announcement there has been little clarity on how this funding will be spent. The government should use this fund as a starting point for a continued and sustained shift in investment towards the 11% called for by the RCGP’s Put patients first: Back general practice campaign. Such a shift in funding would enable GPs to improve care for all patients — by tackling rising waiting times, improving continuity of care and supporting those with the most complex needs. Last year, over the course of just a few months, more than 330,000 people signed a 5. Ongoing, sustained investment in general practice JuLY 2015 9 petition calling for a larger proportion of NHS funding to be spent on general practice16 . March 2014 polling conducted by ComRes found that 61% of Scottish adults would support the majority of additional funding for primary care to go to general practice services17 . A better resourced general practice would not only benefit patients, but would also help put the NHS on a more sustainable financial footing, with evidence suggesting that investing in general practice could save the NHS nearly £2 billion per year by 2020 through reducing pressure on hospitals and other services (see Box 2 page 10). The average cost of a face to face GP consultation is around £45, compared to a range of £61 to £82 for a comparable secondary care attendance18 . GP funding as a percentage of total NHS Scotland budget 12.0% 10.0% 8.0% 6.0% 4.0% 2.0% 0.0% 2004/05 2005/06 2006/07 2007/08 2008/09 2009/10 2010/11 2011/12 2012/13 9.47% 9.78% 9.27% 8.31% 7.91% 7.84% 7.93% 7.78% 7.76% GPfundingasashareofNHSexpenditure
  • 10. A blueprint for ScottiSh generAl prActice 10 Shift NHS funding into general practice. RCGP Scotland is calling for 11% of the total NHS budget to be spent on general practice. Polling conducted by ComRes in October 2014 found 71% support for this shift among Scottish adults. The funding figure stood at 7.8% in 2012/13, compared with 9.8% in 2005/06. Setting a clear target for increasing the proportion of the NHS budget spent on general practice to 11%, and putting in place a new primary care investment plan to deliver this. Local decision makers should be encouraged and empowered to work towards this goal, with flexibility around how they achieve it. ● ● ● ● RCGP Scotland calls on the Scottish Government to: Publishing regular statistics monitoring how much NHS funding is being directed towards primary care, including specific figures on what proportion is being invested in general practice. Setting up a new five year transformation fund. To realise the potential that general practice has to transform patient care and help shift resources into the community, additional resources will be needed to transition work from secondary to primary care and deliver change. This can be assessed by academic evidence generated through the Scottish School of Primary Care. Box 2: Spend to save: the financial case for investing in general practice Increased government spending on general practice could lead to a saving of up to £1.9 billion to the NHS across the uK as a whole by 2020. Calculations by the RCGP show that increasing spending on general practice consultations across the uK by £72 million each year, could lead to a saving of up to £375 million each financial year, rising to annual savings of up to £708 million by the end of 2019/20. The RCGP figures are based on research commissioned from Deloitte in 201419 , which estimates that short-term savings generated through increased spending on general practice could amount to up to £447 million annually. This annual saving is broken down into savings of up to: Analysing three key patient groups — healthy patients, frail and elderly patients, and those with long-term conditions — Deloitte estimates that the current cost of A&E visits is £1.58 billion. This bill could be reduced to £1.44 billion generating annual savings of at least £133.9 million in the uK. Additional savings to the NHS could be made in the medium and long-term, with additional savings of up to £333 million annually over the course of the next five years. £133.9 million per year, through diverting up to 1.7 million patients away from Accident and Emergency (A&E) departments, ● £143.3 million per year, through reducing the number of unnecessary ambulance call-outs, and £170.1 million per year, through reducing the length of hospital stays for patients aged over 65, by providing greater primary care support at home. greater primary care support at home. ● ●
  • 11. JuLY 2015 11 References 1 ISD Scotland, Practice Team Information (PTI) Annual Update, (2013). Available at: http://www.isdscotland.org/ Health-Topics/General-Practice/Publications/2013-10- 29/2013-10-29-PTI-Report.pdf 2 Gillies, Mercer, Lyon et al., Distilling the Essence of General Practice, (2009). Available at http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/ pmc/articles/PMC2673184/ 3 Healthcare Improvement Scotland and Royal College of General Practitioners (Scotland), Developing a Quality Framework for General Practice in Scotland, (2014). Available at http://www.rcgp.org.uk/rcgp-near-you/rcgp- scotland/~/media/Files/RCGP-Faculties/Scotland/RCGP- Scotland/RCGP-Scotland-QFGP%20interactive.ashx 4 Royal College of General Practitioners (Scotland), Time To Care: Health Inequalities, Deprivation and General Practice in Scotland, (2010). Available at http://www.rcgp.org.uk/ rcgp-near-you/~/media/Files/RCGP-near-you-Do-Not-Use/ RCGP%20Scotland/Time%20to%20Care%20RCGP%20 Scotland%20report%20on%20Health%20Inequalities.ashx 5 Royal College of General Practitioners (Scotland), The Future of General Practice in Scotland: A Vision, (2011). Available at http://www.rcgp.org.uk/rcgp-near-you/~/media/ Files/Policy/A-Z-policy/RCGP-Scotland-The-Future-of- General-Practice-in-Scotland-a-Vision.ashx 6 British Medical Association, GP Survey Omnibus report, (2015). Available at: http://bma.org.uk/news-views-analysis/ news/2014/march/gp-morale-damaged-by-workload-says- survey 7 Royal College of Nursing, Safe staffing levels – a national Imperative: The UK nursing labour market review 2013, (2013). Available at: http://www.rcn.org.uk/__data/assets/ pdf_file/0018/541224/004504.pdf 8 Royal College of General Practitioners and Royal Pharmaceutical Society, RCGP and RPS Policy Statement on GP Practice Based Pharmacists, (2015). Available at: http://www.rpharms.com/promoting-pharmacy-pdfs/rcgp-joint- statement-for-pharmacists-in-gp-surgeries-version-2.pdf 9 Royal College of General Practitioners and Royal Pharmaceutical Society, Breaking down the barriers – how community pharmacists and GPs can work together to improve patient care, (2015). Available at: http://www. rpharms.com/public-affairs-pdfs/RPSRCGPjointstatement.pdf 10 Scottish Government, Prescription for Excellence: A Vision and Action Plan, (2013). Available at: http://www. gov.scot/resource/0043/00434053.pdf 11 Healthcare Improvement Scotland and Royal College of General Practitioners (Scotland), Developing a Quality Framework for General Practice in Scotland, (2014). Available at http://www.rcgp.org.uk/rcgp-near-you/rcgp- scotland/~/media/Files/RCGP-Faculties/Scotland/RCGP- Scotland/RCGP-Scotland-QFGP%20interactive.ashx 12 British Medical Association, General Practitioner Committee, British Medical Association GP Committee Premises Survey - UK Results, (2014). Available at: http:// bma.org.uk/working-for-change/your-gp-cares/premises- survey-results 13 HM Treasury and The Rt Hon George Osborne MP, Oral statement to Parliament Chancellor George Osborne’s Autumn Statement 2014 speech, (2014). Available at: https://www.gov.uk/government/speeches/ chancellor-george-osbornes-autumn-statement-2014- speech 14 HM Treasury, Autumn Statement 2014, (2014). Available at: https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/ system/uploads/attachment_data/file/382327/44695_ Accessible.pdf 15 Ibid. 16 Royal College of General Practitioners, ‘300,000 signatures strong’, campaign blog, (20 October 2014). Available at: http://www.rcgp.org.uk/campaign-home/ news-and-blogs/2014/october/campaign-blog-300000- signatures-strong.aspx 17 Royal College of General Practitioners, ‘Majority of public believe GP workloads are threat to the level of patient care’, press release (2014). Available at: http:// www.rcgp.org.uk/news/2014/march/majority-of-public- believe-gp-workloads-threat-to-level-of-patient-care.aspx 18 Deloitte, Spend to save: The economic case for improving access to general practice, a report for the RCGP, (2014). Available at: http://www.rcgp.org.uk/ campaign-home/~/media/Files/PPF/2014-RCGP-Spend- to-Save-Deloitte-report.ashx 19 Ibid.
  • 12. Royal College of General Practitioners is a registered charity in England & Wales (No. 223106) and Scotland (No. SC 040430). RCGP Scotland 25 Queen Street, Edinburgh. EH2 1JX Telephone: 020 3188 7730 Fax: 020 3188 7401 Email: policy@rcgp.org.uk Website: www.rcgp.org.uk Version Date: July 2015 © RCGP Scotland, 2015. All rights reserved. Authors: David Webster, Jonathan Ware, Matthew Chisambi & Catherine Witcombe. Published by: