SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 4
Download to read offline
July 3, 2017
Chicago, IL USA
For Immediate Release
WHY WE’RE OPEN-SOURCING CONTRAXSUITE™
LEGALTECH IN THE MODERN INFORMATION ECONOMY
I. OUR ANNOUNCEMENT
Over the last decade, we’ve spent many thousands of effort-hours developing the contract
analytics and document analytics tools that we use with clients. These tools, based on enterprise-
quality open source frameworks for natural language processing, machine learning, and optical
character recognition, have allowed us to quickly and easily attack many problems, from securities
filings and court opinions to articles of incorporation and lease agreements.
Today, we are proud to announce that we plan to open source the development of our core
platform for contract analytics and document analytics - ContraxSuite. Starting on August 1st, this
code base and our public development roadmap will be hosted on Github under a permissive
open-source licensing model that will allow most organizations to quickly and freely implement
and customize their own contract and document analytics. Like Redhat does for Linux, we will
provide support, customization, and data services to "cover the last mile" for those organizations
who need it.
We believe that a very important future for law lies in its central role in facilitating and regulating
the modern information economy. But unless we start treating law itself like the production of
information, we’ll never get there. Before we can solve big problems with smart contracts, we
need to start by structuring existing legacy contracts. We hope our actions today will help
lawyers, companies, and other LegalTech providers accelerate the pace of improvement and
innovation through more open collaboration.
II. THE RISE OF THE OPEN SOURCE ECONOMY
Over the course of human history, many models of economic development and innovation have
emerged. Some of these models, like the public stock company, are quite new in the scheme of
things. Others, like the community of "natural" philosophers (scientists) or mutual insurance, are
very old. But in all cases - whether intangible insurance or tangible iPad - there is a flow from idea
to execution to economic value.
One crude way of comparing these economic models is to examine how information is held -
publicly or privately. Information, not opposable thumbs, as Cesar Hidalgo elegantly explains, is
the secret weapon of our species – our only defense against the intrinsic chaos and decay of the
universe. And in the mode of economic analysis descended from Adam Smith, private information
is the key. Knowledge and know-how enable enterprises to produce and profit. This principle of
private information has guided most enterprises over the last few centuries, from the coveted
trade route maps of the 18th century to the modern Coca Cola recipe.
So why, especially in the last half-century, have we seen the "open source" or "peer-to-peer"
model of information grow? Google, Apple, and Facebook, three companies worth nearly two
trillion dollars combined, have given away thousands of software projects worth billions of dollars
in effort-hour cost. Have we all gone mad? Or is there something else going on – an emergent value
to holding knowledge more publicly in the modern world?
There are many attempts to answer this fascinating question, and these attempts both challenge
and enlighten our understanding of human behavior, economics, and law. However, especially as it
relates to software, we lean on the words of Prof. David Agarwal:
"For many [...], software is only a semi-finished good that generates little value until the
code has undergone revision by the user. Thus, creating the ultimate finished product will
require a sequence of motivating incentives."
III. LAW AS OPEN SOURCE AND THE LAST MILE PROBLEM
The first sentence above is as true of legal documents - articles of incorporation, operating
agreements, corporate filings, contracts and agreements - as it is of software. While there are
thousands of resources for corporate governance or contracting available online, none of these are
"finished" goods for another party. In some cases, "finishing" may simply required updating the
parties and dates, like a restaurant microwaving a pre-cooked cut of meat. In other cases,
"finishing" may actually involve novel structures or more creative redrafting, like a chef growing
his own produce or combining flavors in unexpected ways.
As to the second sentence - "[...] the ultimate finished product will require a sequence of
motivating incentives" - we arrive back to ContraxSuite. Software products designed to assist in
the drafting and analysis of legal documents are perfect examples of semi-finished goods. Alone,
no software product can incorporate an entity or enter into a sales agreement or manage the
geopolitical risk of supplier networks (let’s ignore Smart Contracts and DAO-like organizations, for
now). Only with the assistance of legal professionals can this semi-finished software deliver value
to the organization and its clients.
In our experience, few legal departments and law firms debate that their legal documents contain
valuable information. Analytics can provide insights into a wide array of opportunities and risks.
Standardization can remove frictions for core business operations and increase the rate and
quality of transactions.
But when you ask these organizations to pay a per-document fee for software that almost always
requires additional customization or produces "unfinished" results, their excitement turns into
hesitation. Contract analytic software, like Google’s TensorFlow or the Linux Kernel, does not
generate value by itself; human capital is required to "cover the last mile" that actually solves the
problem. This is why data scientists have not yet been put out of business by TensorFlow and why
Redhat and Oracle still "sell Linux" for billions of dollars per year.
We have a "last mile" problem in the legal arena. Much like Linux and data science, contract
analytics is largely about the combination of well-known practices with large-scale, high-quality
data. Contracts are natural language encoded in either analog or digital format, and this language
is unlocked and encoded with technologies like optical character recognition (OCR) and natural
language processing (NLP). These encodings are then mapped back to real-world business
problems through techniques like clustering or classification, two types of machine learning (ML)
algorithms. None of these technologies or techniques above are proprietary or novel, and some
version of these ideas have been available nearly as long as there have been digital computers.
The real challenge in contract or other related forms of document analytics is to develop the so -
called "training data" - the set of documents and labels used to "teach" the machine what separates
a lease agreement from a purchase/sale agreement from a retirement benefits plan. Herein lies
the true value of the current software and service providers. But, paradoxically, almost all
providers get their information from one of two sources - either public sources of agreements, like
the SEC’s EDGAR database or evidence from public courts, or private sources of agreements - their
clients. Many organizations have therefore paid for the privilege to give away their own
information so that someone else can profit.
By open-sourcing ContraxSuite, we hope to change this dynamic. The analysis and standardization
of contracts and corporate governance material is key to the transformation of our economy. But
blockchain and Smart Contracts aside, there are significant improvements in risk management,
compliance, and profitability that can be gained by treating contracts as valuable data. Until legal
departments and law firms can be "sequentially motivated," to borrow Professor Agarwal’s
language, we will not see this maturation of the industry.
In the near future, we’ll be revealing more details about this open source strategy - including more
detail on academic and industry partnerships, support and customization services, and our open-
source license model. In the meantime, we hope to get everyone thinking fundamentally about
how we do business in legal tech. What does the client really want - your software license or a
sustainable solution?
IV. A CHALLENGE TO PROVIDERS, DEVELOPERS & CUSTOMERS
While some in the legal technology community will certainly taut their ability to outperform our
open source framework on some use cases today, we believe that they will find themselves on the
wrong side of history. We encourage others in legal technology and related domains to follow our
lead and think hard about whether closed code is really the right strategy. By committing to open
source and allowing others to validate, improve, and maintain our shared infrastructure, any gaps
in quality or functionality will soon fade away.
More critically, the hype and "vaporware" that pervade legal technology do a disservice to the
overall efforts towards innovation. We would like to move the field forward through the hard
work of iterative, open methodological improvement. This hype and vaporware has been enabled
by a lack of transparency and, to be honest, a lack of sophistication on behalf of customers, but
going forward, both the consumer and developer community should be able inspect the quality of
any existing offering. Our co-founders, as leading educators of the next generation of attorneys,
have committed to making sure that the General Counsel and Managing Partner of the future
won’t be fooled. Others can chase the temporary rents of the middle game, but we’re here to make
moves that support the long-term maturation of the overall legal industry. We hope you will join
us.
Michael J. Bommarito Daniel Martin Katz
CEO @ LexPredict CSO @ LexPredict

More Related Content

What's hot

Innovation in the Legal Services Industry - "The Future is Already Here, It i...
Innovation in the Legal Services Industry - "The Future is Already Here, It i...Innovation in the Legal Services Industry - "The Future is Already Here, It i...
Innovation in the Legal Services Industry - "The Future is Already Here, It i...Daniel Katz
 
Technology, Data and Computation Session @ The World Bank - Law, Justice, and...
Technology, Data and Computation Session @ The World Bank - Law, Justice, and...Technology, Data and Computation Session @ The World Bank - Law, Justice, and...
Technology, Data and Computation Session @ The World Bank - Law, Justice, and...Daniel Katz
 
Legal Analytics, Machine Learning and Some Comments on the Status of Innovat...
 Legal Analytics, Machine Learning and Some Comments on the Status of Innovat... Legal Analytics, Machine Learning and Some Comments on the Status of Innovat...
Legal Analytics, Machine Learning and Some Comments on the Status of Innovat...Daniel Katz
 
Building Your Personal (Legal) Brand - Some Thoughts for Law Students and Oth...
Building Your Personal (Legal) Brand - Some Thoughts for Law Students and Oth...Building Your Personal (Legal) Brand - Some Thoughts for Law Students and Oth...
Building Your Personal (Legal) Brand - Some Thoughts for Law Students and Oth...Daniel Katz
 
Fin (Legal) Tech – Law’s Future from Finance’s Past (Some Thoughts About the ...
Fin (Legal) Tech – Law’s Future from Finance’s Past (Some Thoughts About the ...Fin (Legal) Tech – Law’s Future from Finance’s Past (Some Thoughts About the ...
Fin (Legal) Tech – Law’s Future from Finance’s Past (Some Thoughts About the ...Daniel Katz
 
The Three Forms of (Legal) Prediction: Experts, Crowds and Algorithms -- Prof...
The Three Forms of (Legal) Prediction: Experts, Crowds and Algorithms -- Prof...The Three Forms of (Legal) Prediction: Experts, Crowds and Algorithms -- Prof...
The Three Forms of (Legal) Prediction: Experts, Crowds and Algorithms -- Prof...Daniel Katz
 
Introduction to artificial intelligence and law
Introduction to artificial intelligence and lawIntroduction to artificial intelligence and law
Introduction to artificial intelligence and lawLawScienceTech
 
Legal Analytics versus Empirical Legal Studies - or - Causal Inference vs Pre...
Legal Analytics versus Empirical Legal Studies - or - Causal Inference vs Pre...Legal Analytics versus Empirical Legal Studies - or - Causal Inference vs Pre...
Legal Analytics versus Empirical Legal Studies - or - Causal Inference vs Pre...Daniel Katz
 
Presentation @ 24th International Conference on Legal Knowledge and Informati...
Presentation @ 24th International Conference on Legal Knowledge and Informati...Presentation @ 24th International Conference on Legal Knowledge and Informati...
Presentation @ 24th International Conference on Legal Knowledge and Informati...Daniel Katz
 
Thoughts on Legal Prediction and Legal Metrics - Association of Corporate Cou...
Thoughts on Legal Prediction and Legal Metrics - Association of Corporate Cou...Thoughts on Legal Prediction and Legal Metrics - Association of Corporate Cou...
Thoughts on Legal Prediction and Legal Metrics - Association of Corporate Cou...Daniel Katz
 
Measuring the Complexity of the Law: The United States Code ( Slides by Danie...
Measuring the Complexity of the Law: The United States Code ( Slides by Danie...Measuring the Complexity of the Law: The United States Code ( Slides by Danie...
Measuring the Complexity of the Law: The United States Code ( Slides by Danie...Daniel Katz
 
Trends in legal tech 2018
Trends in legal tech 2018Trends in legal tech 2018
Trends in legal tech 2018Secure Privacy
 
What is Computational Legal Studies? Presentation @ University of Houston - ...
What is Computational Legal Studies?  Presentation @ University of Houston - ...What is Computational Legal Studies?  Presentation @ University of Houston - ...
What is Computational Legal Studies? Presentation @ University of Houston - ...Daniel Katz
 
ICPSR - Complex Systems Models in the Social Sciences - Lecture 6 - Professor...
ICPSR - Complex Systems Models in the Social Sciences - Lecture 6 - Professor...ICPSR - Complex Systems Models in the Social Sciences - Lecture 6 - Professor...
ICPSR - Complex Systems Models in the Social Sciences - Lecture 6 - Professor...Daniel Katz
 
Ai and Legal Industy - Executive Overview
Ai and Legal Industy - Executive OverviewAi and Legal Industy - Executive Overview
Ai and Legal Industy - Executive OverviewGraeme Wood
 
Susskind, 'A Manifesto for AI in the Law' ICAIL 2017, London, 2017
Susskind, 'A Manifesto for AI in the Law' ICAIL 2017, London, 2017Susskind, 'A Manifesto for AI in the Law' ICAIL 2017, London, 2017
Susskind, 'A Manifesto for AI in the Law' ICAIL 2017, London, 2017Richard Susskind
 
Legal Analytics - Introduction to the Course - Professor Daniel Martin Katz +...
Legal Analytics - Introduction to the Course - Professor Daniel Martin Katz +...Legal Analytics - Introduction to the Course - Professor Daniel Martin Katz +...
Legal Analytics - Introduction to the Course - Professor Daniel Martin Katz +...Daniel Katz
 
Artificial Intelligence and Law
Artificial Intelligence and LawArtificial Intelligence and Law
Artificial Intelligence and LawSamos2019Summit
 
HLS Students Harness Artificial Intelligence to Revolutionize How Lawyers Dra...
HLS Students Harness Artificial Intelligence to Revolutionize How Lawyers Dra...HLS Students Harness Artificial Intelligence to Revolutionize How Lawyers Dra...
HLS Students Harness Artificial Intelligence to Revolutionize How Lawyers Dra...Evisort
 
NICOLE SHANAHAN TOA Nov 4
NICOLE SHANAHAN TOA Nov 4NICOLE SHANAHAN TOA Nov 4
NICOLE SHANAHAN TOA Nov 4Nicole Shanahan
 

What's hot (20)

Innovation in the Legal Services Industry - "The Future is Already Here, It i...
Innovation in the Legal Services Industry - "The Future is Already Here, It i...Innovation in the Legal Services Industry - "The Future is Already Here, It i...
Innovation in the Legal Services Industry - "The Future is Already Here, It i...
 
Technology, Data and Computation Session @ The World Bank - Law, Justice, and...
Technology, Data and Computation Session @ The World Bank - Law, Justice, and...Technology, Data and Computation Session @ The World Bank - Law, Justice, and...
Technology, Data and Computation Session @ The World Bank - Law, Justice, and...
 
Legal Analytics, Machine Learning and Some Comments on the Status of Innovat...
 Legal Analytics, Machine Learning and Some Comments on the Status of Innovat... Legal Analytics, Machine Learning and Some Comments on the Status of Innovat...
Legal Analytics, Machine Learning and Some Comments on the Status of Innovat...
 
Building Your Personal (Legal) Brand - Some Thoughts for Law Students and Oth...
Building Your Personal (Legal) Brand - Some Thoughts for Law Students and Oth...Building Your Personal (Legal) Brand - Some Thoughts for Law Students and Oth...
Building Your Personal (Legal) Brand - Some Thoughts for Law Students and Oth...
 
Fin (Legal) Tech – Law’s Future from Finance’s Past (Some Thoughts About the ...
Fin (Legal) Tech – Law’s Future from Finance’s Past (Some Thoughts About the ...Fin (Legal) Tech – Law’s Future from Finance’s Past (Some Thoughts About the ...
Fin (Legal) Tech – Law’s Future from Finance’s Past (Some Thoughts About the ...
 
The Three Forms of (Legal) Prediction: Experts, Crowds and Algorithms -- Prof...
The Three Forms of (Legal) Prediction: Experts, Crowds and Algorithms -- Prof...The Three Forms of (Legal) Prediction: Experts, Crowds and Algorithms -- Prof...
The Three Forms of (Legal) Prediction: Experts, Crowds and Algorithms -- Prof...
 
Introduction to artificial intelligence and law
Introduction to artificial intelligence and lawIntroduction to artificial intelligence and law
Introduction to artificial intelligence and law
 
Legal Analytics versus Empirical Legal Studies - or - Causal Inference vs Pre...
Legal Analytics versus Empirical Legal Studies - or - Causal Inference vs Pre...Legal Analytics versus Empirical Legal Studies - or - Causal Inference vs Pre...
Legal Analytics versus Empirical Legal Studies - or - Causal Inference vs Pre...
 
Presentation @ 24th International Conference on Legal Knowledge and Informati...
Presentation @ 24th International Conference on Legal Knowledge and Informati...Presentation @ 24th International Conference on Legal Knowledge and Informati...
Presentation @ 24th International Conference on Legal Knowledge and Informati...
 
Thoughts on Legal Prediction and Legal Metrics - Association of Corporate Cou...
Thoughts on Legal Prediction and Legal Metrics - Association of Corporate Cou...Thoughts on Legal Prediction and Legal Metrics - Association of Corporate Cou...
Thoughts on Legal Prediction and Legal Metrics - Association of Corporate Cou...
 
Measuring the Complexity of the Law: The United States Code ( Slides by Danie...
Measuring the Complexity of the Law: The United States Code ( Slides by Danie...Measuring the Complexity of the Law: The United States Code ( Slides by Danie...
Measuring the Complexity of the Law: The United States Code ( Slides by Danie...
 
Trends in legal tech 2018
Trends in legal tech 2018Trends in legal tech 2018
Trends in legal tech 2018
 
What is Computational Legal Studies? Presentation @ University of Houston - ...
What is Computational Legal Studies?  Presentation @ University of Houston - ...What is Computational Legal Studies?  Presentation @ University of Houston - ...
What is Computational Legal Studies? Presentation @ University of Houston - ...
 
ICPSR - Complex Systems Models in the Social Sciences - Lecture 6 - Professor...
ICPSR - Complex Systems Models in the Social Sciences - Lecture 6 - Professor...ICPSR - Complex Systems Models in the Social Sciences - Lecture 6 - Professor...
ICPSR - Complex Systems Models in the Social Sciences - Lecture 6 - Professor...
 
Ai and Legal Industy - Executive Overview
Ai and Legal Industy - Executive OverviewAi and Legal Industy - Executive Overview
Ai and Legal Industy - Executive Overview
 
Susskind, 'A Manifesto for AI in the Law' ICAIL 2017, London, 2017
Susskind, 'A Manifesto for AI in the Law' ICAIL 2017, London, 2017Susskind, 'A Manifesto for AI in the Law' ICAIL 2017, London, 2017
Susskind, 'A Manifesto for AI in the Law' ICAIL 2017, London, 2017
 
Legal Analytics - Introduction to the Course - Professor Daniel Martin Katz +...
Legal Analytics - Introduction to the Course - Professor Daniel Martin Katz +...Legal Analytics - Introduction to the Course - Professor Daniel Martin Katz +...
Legal Analytics - Introduction to the Course - Professor Daniel Martin Katz +...
 
Artificial Intelligence and Law
Artificial Intelligence and LawArtificial Intelligence and Law
Artificial Intelligence and Law
 
HLS Students Harness Artificial Intelligence to Revolutionize How Lawyers Dra...
HLS Students Harness Artificial Intelligence to Revolutionize How Lawyers Dra...HLS Students Harness Artificial Intelligence to Revolutionize How Lawyers Dra...
HLS Students Harness Artificial Intelligence to Revolutionize How Lawyers Dra...
 
NICOLE SHANAHAN TOA Nov 4
NICOLE SHANAHAN TOA Nov 4NICOLE SHANAHAN TOA Nov 4
NICOLE SHANAHAN TOA Nov 4
 

Similar to Why We Are Open Sourcing ContraxSuite and Some Thoughts About Legal Tech and the Modern Information Economy

The Internet of Things: Exploring revenue generating use cases
The Internet of Things: Exploring revenue generating use casesThe Internet of Things: Exploring revenue generating use cases
The Internet of Things: Exploring revenue generating use casesDeloitte United States
 
Business 2 Students: AI & de impact op de juridische wereld.
Business 2 Students: AI & de impact op de juridische wereld. Business 2 Students: AI & de impact op de juridische wereld.
Business 2 Students: AI & de impact op de juridische wereld. Matthias Dobbelaere-Welvaert
 
How Aerospace Manufacturers Can Achieve Exponential Growth-James A. Regenor, ...
How Aerospace Manufacturers Can Achieve Exponential Growth-James A. Regenor, ...How Aerospace Manufacturers Can Achieve Exponential Growth-James A. Regenor, ...
How Aerospace Manufacturers Can Achieve Exponential Growth-James A. Regenor, ...marcus evans Network
 
Legal Technology 3.0 | Oliver R. Goodenough
Legal Technology 3.0 | Oliver R. GoodenoughLegal Technology 3.0 | Oliver R. Goodenough
Legal Technology 3.0 | Oliver R. Goodenoughhesitantobstruc30
 
Deloitte the case for disruptive technology in the legal profession 2017
Deloitte the case for disruptive technology in the legal profession 2017 Deloitte the case for disruptive technology in the legal profession 2017
Deloitte the case for disruptive technology in the legal profession 2017 Ian Beckett
 
Technologies for Lawyers - Legal Sector
Technologies for Lawyers - Legal SectorTechnologies for Lawyers - Legal Sector
Technologies for Lawyers - Legal SectorSatya Pal
 
Over 70% of all acquisitions never realize their potential
Over 70% of all acquisitions never realize their potentialOver 70% of all acquisitions never realize their potential
Over 70% of all acquisitions never realize their potentialTom Rieger
 
Social networking brings power
Social networking brings powerSocial networking brings power
Social networking brings powerGregg Barrett
 
The Trouble With Enterprise SoftwareF A L L 2 0 0 7 .docx
The Trouble With Enterprise SoftwareF A L L  2 0 0 7    .docxThe Trouble With Enterprise SoftwareF A L L  2 0 0 7    .docx
The Trouble With Enterprise SoftwareF A L L 2 0 0 7 .docxssusera34210
 
Enterprise blockchain| Blockchain as a Service| Blockchain Disruption| Blockc...
Enterprise blockchain| Blockchain as a Service| Blockchain Disruption| Blockc...Enterprise blockchain| Blockchain as a Service| Blockchain Disruption| Blockc...
Enterprise blockchain| Blockchain as a Service| Blockchain Disruption| Blockc...Fluence.sh
 
Packt publishing book proposal api and mobile access management
Packt publishing book proposal api and mobile access managementPackt publishing book proposal api and mobile access management
Packt publishing book proposal api and mobile access managementGluu
 
Concurrences 4-2013_Interview_Sivinski
Concurrences 4-2013_Interview_SivinskiConcurrences 4-2013_Interview_Sivinski
Concurrences 4-2013_Interview_SivinskiGreg Sivinski (CELA)
 
A new decade a new outsourcing challenge
A new decade a new outsourcing challengeA new decade a new outsourcing challenge
A new decade a new outsourcing challengeGavin Hall
 
Legal Education in the Blockchain Revolution de Mark Fenwick,* Wulf A. Kaal**...
Legal Education in the Blockchain Revolution de Mark Fenwick,* Wulf A. Kaal**...Legal Education in the Blockchain Revolution de Mark Fenwick,* Wulf A. Kaal**...
Legal Education in the Blockchain Revolution de Mark Fenwick,* Wulf A. Kaal**...eraser Juan José Calderón
 
Poročilo o obisku kongresa 2010 luksemburg 22062010
Poročilo o obisku kongresa 2010 luksemburg 22062010Poročilo o obisku kongresa 2010 luksemburg 22062010
Poročilo o obisku kongresa 2010 luksemburg 22062010Zeleno d.o.o.
 
Nowak & Grantham _ The virtual incubator managing human capital in the softwa...
Nowak & Grantham _ The virtual incubator managing human capital in the softwa...Nowak & Grantham _ The virtual incubator managing human capital in the softwa...
Nowak & Grantham _ The virtual incubator managing human capital in the softwa...Vasily Ryzhonkov
 
Industrializing Blockchain in ASEAN
Industrializing Blockchain in ASEANIndustrializing Blockchain in ASEAN
Industrializing Blockchain in ASEANVarun Mittal
 

Similar to Why We Are Open Sourcing ContraxSuite and Some Thoughts About Legal Tech and the Modern Information Economy (20)

Record Management
Record ManagementRecord Management
Record Management
 
The Internet of Things: Exploring revenue generating use cases
The Internet of Things: Exploring revenue generating use casesThe Internet of Things: Exploring revenue generating use cases
The Internet of Things: Exploring revenue generating use cases
 
Business 2 Students: AI & de impact op de juridische wereld.
Business 2 Students: AI & de impact op de juridische wereld. Business 2 Students: AI & de impact op de juridische wereld.
Business 2 Students: AI & de impact op de juridische wereld.
 
How Aerospace Manufacturers Can Achieve Exponential Growth-James A. Regenor, ...
How Aerospace Manufacturers Can Achieve Exponential Growth-James A. Regenor, ...How Aerospace Manufacturers Can Achieve Exponential Growth-James A. Regenor, ...
How Aerospace Manufacturers Can Achieve Exponential Growth-James A. Regenor, ...
 
Corda: An Introduction
Corda: An IntroductionCorda: An Introduction
Corda: An Introduction
 
Legal Technology 3.0 | Oliver R. Goodenough
Legal Technology 3.0 | Oliver R. GoodenoughLegal Technology 3.0 | Oliver R. Goodenough
Legal Technology 3.0 | Oliver R. Goodenough
 
Deloitte the case for disruptive technology in the legal profession 2017
Deloitte the case for disruptive technology in the legal profession 2017 Deloitte the case for disruptive technology in the legal profession 2017
Deloitte the case for disruptive technology in the legal profession 2017
 
Technologies for Lawyers - Legal Sector
Technologies for Lawyers - Legal SectorTechnologies for Lawyers - Legal Sector
Technologies for Lawyers - Legal Sector
 
Over 70% of all acquisitions never realize their potential
Over 70% of all acquisitions never realize their potentialOver 70% of all acquisitions never realize their potential
Over 70% of all acquisitions never realize their potential
 
Social networking brings power
Social networking brings powerSocial networking brings power
Social networking brings power
 
The Trouble With Enterprise SoftwareF A L L 2 0 0 7 .docx
The Trouble With Enterprise SoftwareF A L L  2 0 0 7    .docxThe Trouble With Enterprise SoftwareF A L L  2 0 0 7    .docx
The Trouble With Enterprise SoftwareF A L L 2 0 0 7 .docx
 
Enterprise blockchain| Blockchain as a Service| Blockchain Disruption| Blockc...
Enterprise blockchain| Blockchain as a Service| Blockchain Disruption| Blockc...Enterprise blockchain| Blockchain as a Service| Blockchain Disruption| Blockc...
Enterprise blockchain| Blockchain as a Service| Blockchain Disruption| Blockc...
 
Packt publishing book proposal api and mobile access management
Packt publishing book proposal api and mobile access managementPackt publishing book proposal api and mobile access management
Packt publishing book proposal api and mobile access management
 
Concurrences 4-2013_Interview_Sivinski
Concurrences 4-2013_Interview_SivinskiConcurrences 4-2013_Interview_Sivinski
Concurrences 4-2013_Interview_Sivinski
 
A new decade a new outsourcing challenge
A new decade a new outsourcing challengeA new decade a new outsourcing challenge
A new decade a new outsourcing challenge
 
Legal Education in the Blockchain Revolution de Mark Fenwick,* Wulf A. Kaal**...
Legal Education in the Blockchain Revolution de Mark Fenwick,* Wulf A. Kaal**...Legal Education in the Blockchain Revolution de Mark Fenwick,* Wulf A. Kaal**...
Legal Education in the Blockchain Revolution de Mark Fenwick,* Wulf A. Kaal**...
 
Hyperledger - MMA Impact Forum Brasil 2019
Hyperledger - MMA Impact Forum Brasil 2019Hyperledger - MMA Impact Forum Brasil 2019
Hyperledger - MMA Impact Forum Brasil 2019
 
Poročilo o obisku kongresa 2010 luksemburg 22062010
Poročilo o obisku kongresa 2010 luksemburg 22062010Poročilo o obisku kongresa 2010 luksemburg 22062010
Poročilo o obisku kongresa 2010 luksemburg 22062010
 
Nowak & Grantham _ The virtual incubator managing human capital in the softwa...
Nowak & Grantham _ The virtual incubator managing human capital in the softwa...Nowak & Grantham _ The virtual incubator managing human capital in the softwa...
Nowak & Grantham _ The virtual incubator managing human capital in the softwa...
 
Industrializing Blockchain in ASEAN
Industrializing Blockchain in ASEANIndustrializing Blockchain in ASEAN
Industrializing Blockchain in ASEAN
 

More from Daniel Katz

Can Law Librarians Help Law Become More Data Driven ? An Open Question in Ne...
Can Law Librarians Help Law Become More Data Driven ?  An Open Question in Ne...Can Law Librarians Help Law Become More Data Driven ?  An Open Question in Ne...
Can Law Librarians Help Law Become More Data Driven ? An Open Question in Ne...Daniel Katz
 
{Law, Tech, Design, Delivery} Observations Regarding Innovation in the Legal ...
{Law, Tech, Design, Delivery} Observations Regarding Innovation in the Legal ...{Law, Tech, Design, Delivery} Observations Regarding Innovation in the Legal ...
{Law, Tech, Design, Delivery} Observations Regarding Innovation in the Legal ...Daniel Katz
 
Legal Analytics Course - Class 11 - Network Analysis and Law - Professors Dan...
Legal Analytics Course - Class 11 - Network Analysis and Law - Professors Dan...Legal Analytics Course - Class 11 - Network Analysis and Law - Professors Dan...
Legal Analytics Course - Class 11 - Network Analysis and Law - Professors Dan...Daniel Katz
 
Legal Analytics Course - Class 12 - Data Preprocessing using dPlyR - Professo...
Legal Analytics Course - Class 12 - Data Preprocessing using dPlyR - Professo...Legal Analytics Course - Class 12 - Data Preprocessing using dPlyR - Professo...
Legal Analytics Course - Class 12 - Data Preprocessing using dPlyR - Professo...Daniel Katz
 
Legal Analytics Course - Class 10 - Information Visualization + DataViz in R ...
Legal Analytics Course - Class 10 - Information Visualization + DataViz in R ...Legal Analytics Course - Class 10 - Information Visualization + DataViz in R ...
Legal Analytics Course - Class 10 - Information Visualization + DataViz in R ...Daniel Katz
 
Legal Analytics Course - Class #4 - Github and RMarkdown Tutorial - Professor...
Legal Analytics Course - Class #4 - Github and RMarkdown Tutorial - Professor...Legal Analytics Course - Class #4 - Github and RMarkdown Tutorial - Professor...
Legal Analytics Course - Class #4 - Github and RMarkdown Tutorial - Professor...Daniel Katz
 
Legal Analytics Course - Class 9 - Clustering Algorithms (K-Means & Hierarch...
Legal Analytics Course - Class 9 -  Clustering Algorithms (K-Means & Hierarch...Legal Analytics Course - Class 9 -  Clustering Algorithms (K-Means & Hierarch...
Legal Analytics Course - Class 9 - Clustering Algorithms (K-Means & Hierarch...Daniel Katz
 
Legal Analytics Course - Class 8 - Introduction to Random Forests and Ensembl...
Legal Analytics Course - Class 8 - Introduction to Random Forests and Ensembl...Legal Analytics Course - Class 8 - Introduction to Random Forests and Ensembl...
Legal Analytics Course - Class 8 - Introduction to Random Forests and Ensembl...Daniel Katz
 
Legal Analytics Course - Class 7 - Binary Classification with Decision Tree L...
Legal Analytics Course - Class 7 - Binary Classification with Decision Tree L...Legal Analytics Course - Class 7 - Binary Classification with Decision Tree L...
Legal Analytics Course - Class 7 - Binary Classification with Decision Tree L...Daniel Katz
 
Legal Analytics Course - Class 6 - Overfitting, Underfitting, & Cross-Validat...
Legal Analytics Course - Class 6 - Overfitting, Underfitting, & Cross-Validat...Legal Analytics Course - Class 6 - Overfitting, Underfitting, & Cross-Validat...
Legal Analytics Course - Class 6 - Overfitting, Underfitting, & Cross-Validat...Daniel Katz
 
Legal Analytics Course - Class 5 - Quantitative Legal Prediction + Data Drive...
Legal Analytics Course - Class 5 - Quantitative Legal Prediction + Data Drive...Legal Analytics Course - Class 5 - Quantitative Legal Prediction + Data Drive...
Legal Analytics Course - Class 5 - Quantitative Legal Prediction + Data Drive...Daniel Katz
 
Legal Analytics Course - Class #2 - Introduction to Machine Learning for Lawy...
Legal Analytics Course - Class #2 - Introduction to Machine Learning for Lawy...Legal Analytics Course - Class #2 - Introduction to Machine Learning for Lawy...
Legal Analytics Course - Class #2 - Introduction to Machine Learning for Lawy...Daniel Katz
 
Quantitative Methods for Lawyers - R Boot Camp Bonus Module - Professor Danie...
Quantitative Methods for Lawyers - R Boot Camp Bonus Module - Professor Danie...Quantitative Methods for Lawyers - R Boot Camp Bonus Module - Professor Danie...
Quantitative Methods for Lawyers - R Boot Camp Bonus Module - Professor Danie...Daniel Katz
 
Quantitative Methods for Lawyers - Class #15 - Chi Square Distribution and Ch...
Quantitative Methods for Lawyers - Class #15 - Chi Square Distribution and Ch...Quantitative Methods for Lawyers - Class #15 - Chi Square Distribution and Ch...
Quantitative Methods for Lawyers - Class #15 - Chi Square Distribution and Ch...Daniel Katz
 
Quantitative Methods for Lawyers - Class #14 - Power Laws, Hypothesis Testing...
Quantitative Methods for Lawyers - Class #14 - Power Laws, Hypothesis Testing...Quantitative Methods for Lawyers - Class #14 - Power Laws, Hypothesis Testing...
Quantitative Methods for Lawyers - Class #14 - Power Laws, Hypothesis Testing...Daniel Katz
 
Quantitative Methods for Lawyers - Class #22 - Regression Analysis - Part 5
Quantitative Methods for Lawyers - Class #22 - Regression Analysis - Part 5Quantitative Methods for Lawyers - Class #22 - Regression Analysis - Part 5
Quantitative Methods for Lawyers - Class #22 - Regression Analysis - Part 5Daniel Katz
 

More from Daniel Katz (16)

Can Law Librarians Help Law Become More Data Driven ? An Open Question in Ne...
Can Law Librarians Help Law Become More Data Driven ?  An Open Question in Ne...Can Law Librarians Help Law Become More Data Driven ?  An Open Question in Ne...
Can Law Librarians Help Law Become More Data Driven ? An Open Question in Ne...
 
{Law, Tech, Design, Delivery} Observations Regarding Innovation in the Legal ...
{Law, Tech, Design, Delivery} Observations Regarding Innovation in the Legal ...{Law, Tech, Design, Delivery} Observations Regarding Innovation in the Legal ...
{Law, Tech, Design, Delivery} Observations Regarding Innovation in the Legal ...
 
Legal Analytics Course - Class 11 - Network Analysis and Law - Professors Dan...
Legal Analytics Course - Class 11 - Network Analysis and Law - Professors Dan...Legal Analytics Course - Class 11 - Network Analysis and Law - Professors Dan...
Legal Analytics Course - Class 11 - Network Analysis and Law - Professors Dan...
 
Legal Analytics Course - Class 12 - Data Preprocessing using dPlyR - Professo...
Legal Analytics Course - Class 12 - Data Preprocessing using dPlyR - Professo...Legal Analytics Course - Class 12 - Data Preprocessing using dPlyR - Professo...
Legal Analytics Course - Class 12 - Data Preprocessing using dPlyR - Professo...
 
Legal Analytics Course - Class 10 - Information Visualization + DataViz in R ...
Legal Analytics Course - Class 10 - Information Visualization + DataViz in R ...Legal Analytics Course - Class 10 - Information Visualization + DataViz in R ...
Legal Analytics Course - Class 10 - Information Visualization + DataViz in R ...
 
Legal Analytics Course - Class #4 - Github and RMarkdown Tutorial - Professor...
Legal Analytics Course - Class #4 - Github and RMarkdown Tutorial - Professor...Legal Analytics Course - Class #4 - Github and RMarkdown Tutorial - Professor...
Legal Analytics Course - Class #4 - Github and RMarkdown Tutorial - Professor...
 
Legal Analytics Course - Class 9 - Clustering Algorithms (K-Means & Hierarch...
Legal Analytics Course - Class 9 -  Clustering Algorithms (K-Means & Hierarch...Legal Analytics Course - Class 9 -  Clustering Algorithms (K-Means & Hierarch...
Legal Analytics Course - Class 9 - Clustering Algorithms (K-Means & Hierarch...
 
Legal Analytics Course - Class 8 - Introduction to Random Forests and Ensembl...
Legal Analytics Course - Class 8 - Introduction to Random Forests and Ensembl...Legal Analytics Course - Class 8 - Introduction to Random Forests and Ensembl...
Legal Analytics Course - Class 8 - Introduction to Random Forests and Ensembl...
 
Legal Analytics Course - Class 7 - Binary Classification with Decision Tree L...
Legal Analytics Course - Class 7 - Binary Classification with Decision Tree L...Legal Analytics Course - Class 7 - Binary Classification with Decision Tree L...
Legal Analytics Course - Class 7 - Binary Classification with Decision Tree L...
 
Legal Analytics Course - Class 6 - Overfitting, Underfitting, & Cross-Validat...
Legal Analytics Course - Class 6 - Overfitting, Underfitting, & Cross-Validat...Legal Analytics Course - Class 6 - Overfitting, Underfitting, & Cross-Validat...
Legal Analytics Course - Class 6 - Overfitting, Underfitting, & Cross-Validat...
 
Legal Analytics Course - Class 5 - Quantitative Legal Prediction + Data Drive...
Legal Analytics Course - Class 5 - Quantitative Legal Prediction + Data Drive...Legal Analytics Course - Class 5 - Quantitative Legal Prediction + Data Drive...
Legal Analytics Course - Class 5 - Quantitative Legal Prediction + Data Drive...
 
Legal Analytics Course - Class #2 - Introduction to Machine Learning for Lawy...
Legal Analytics Course - Class #2 - Introduction to Machine Learning for Lawy...Legal Analytics Course - Class #2 - Introduction to Machine Learning for Lawy...
Legal Analytics Course - Class #2 - Introduction to Machine Learning for Lawy...
 
Quantitative Methods for Lawyers - R Boot Camp Bonus Module - Professor Danie...
Quantitative Methods for Lawyers - R Boot Camp Bonus Module - Professor Danie...Quantitative Methods for Lawyers - R Boot Camp Bonus Module - Professor Danie...
Quantitative Methods for Lawyers - R Boot Camp Bonus Module - Professor Danie...
 
Quantitative Methods for Lawyers - Class #15 - Chi Square Distribution and Ch...
Quantitative Methods for Lawyers - Class #15 - Chi Square Distribution and Ch...Quantitative Methods for Lawyers - Class #15 - Chi Square Distribution and Ch...
Quantitative Methods for Lawyers - Class #15 - Chi Square Distribution and Ch...
 
Quantitative Methods for Lawyers - Class #14 - Power Laws, Hypothesis Testing...
Quantitative Methods for Lawyers - Class #14 - Power Laws, Hypothesis Testing...Quantitative Methods for Lawyers - Class #14 - Power Laws, Hypothesis Testing...
Quantitative Methods for Lawyers - Class #14 - Power Laws, Hypothesis Testing...
 
Quantitative Methods for Lawyers - Class #22 - Regression Analysis - Part 5
Quantitative Methods for Lawyers - Class #22 - Regression Analysis - Part 5Quantitative Methods for Lawyers - Class #22 - Regression Analysis - Part 5
Quantitative Methods for Lawyers - Class #22 - Regression Analysis - Part 5
 

Recently uploaded

Commercialization of IPR – From Lawyerperspective Strategies and Challenges...
Commercialization of IPR – From Lawyerperspective   Strategies and Challenges...Commercialization of IPR – From Lawyerperspective   Strategies and Challenges...
Commercialization of IPR – From Lawyerperspective Strategies and Challenges...vijuchowbe
 
16902_2015_Order_12-Apr-2019.pdfp;kp;kpodk
16902_2015_Order_12-Apr-2019.pdfp;kp;kpodk16902_2015_Order_12-Apr-2019.pdfp;kp;kpodk
16902_2015_Order_12-Apr-2019.pdfp;kp;kpodkbhavenpr
 
Public Health and Intellectual Property Rights
Public Health and Intellectual Property RightsPublic Health and Intellectual Property Rights
Public Health and Intellectual Property RightsPratiksha Mishra
 
Biography Presentation of Manoj sharma [IPS]
Biography Presentation of Manoj  sharma [IPS]Biography Presentation of Manoj  sharma [IPS]
Biography Presentation of Manoj sharma [IPS]theunheardstories45
 
The Concept of Rule of law : origin, development & Indian Constitution.
The Concept of  Rule of law : origin, development & Indian Constitution.The Concept of  Rule of law : origin, development & Indian Constitution.
The Concept of Rule of law : origin, development & Indian Constitution.legalpuja22
 
Exploring the Essential Elements Included in eSports Licensing Agreements
Exploring the Essential Elements Included in eSports Licensing AgreementsExploring the Essential Elements Included in eSports Licensing Agreements
Exploring the Essential Elements Included in eSports Licensing AgreementsFinlaw Consultancy Pvt Ltd
 
GS Holistic Court Opinion in Trademark Dispute
GS Holistic Court Opinion in Trademark DisputeGS Holistic Court Opinion in Trademark Dispute
GS Holistic Court Opinion in Trademark DisputeMike Keyes
 
VIETNAM - LEGAL ALERT ON CIRCULAR PROVIDING REGULATIONS ON METHOD TO FORMULAT...
VIETNAM - LEGAL ALERT ON CIRCULAR PROVIDING REGULATIONS ON METHOD TO FORMULAT...VIETNAM - LEGAL ALERT ON CIRCULAR PROVIDING REGULATIONS ON METHOD TO FORMULAT...
VIETNAM - LEGAL ALERT ON CIRCULAR PROVIDING REGULATIONS ON METHOD TO FORMULAT...Dr. Oliver Massmann
 
Digital Forensics and Evidence Gathering: A Lawyer's Approach to Phishing and...
Digital Forensics and Evidence Gathering: A Lawyer's Approach to Phishing and...Digital Forensics and Evidence Gathering: A Lawyer's Approach to Phishing and...
Digital Forensics and Evidence Gathering: A Lawyer's Approach to Phishing and...Finlaw Associates
 
legal-Complaint-emery-unified-assault.pdf
legal-Complaint-emery-unified-assault.pdflegal-Complaint-emery-unified-assault.pdf
legal-Complaint-emery-unified-assault.pdfE'ville Eye
 
Jeremey Tevebaugh Indicted for Check Forgery
Jeremey Tevebaugh Indicted for Check ForgeryJeremey Tevebaugh Indicted for Check Forgery
Jeremey Tevebaugh Indicted for Check ForgeryAbdul-Hakim Shabazz
 
Doctrine of Part Performance in Transfer of property.pptx
Doctrine of Part Performance in Transfer of property.pptxDoctrine of Part Performance in Transfer of property.pptx
Doctrine of Part Performance in Transfer of property.pptxjanayana1
 
1038220242024-03-11-527359.pdfKIpokpikfkkovk
1038220242024-03-11-527359.pdfKIpokpikfkkovk1038220242024-03-11-527359.pdfKIpokpikfkkovk
1038220242024-03-11-527359.pdfKIpokpikfkkovkbhavenpr
 
Planned Giving Presentation for Ottawa County Parks Foundation
Planned Giving Presentation for Ottawa County Parks FoundationPlanned Giving Presentation for Ottawa County Parks Foundation
Planned Giving Presentation for Ottawa County Parks FoundationP. Haans Mulder, JD, MST, CFP®
 
Canada PR_ Top 10 Eligibility, Requirements, and Criteria.pdf
Canada PR_ Top 10 Eligibility, Requirements, and Criteria.pdfCanada PR_ Top 10 Eligibility, Requirements, and Criteria.pdf
Canada PR_ Top 10 Eligibility, Requirements, and Criteria.pdfvisa gurukul
 
UAE Labour Law - Brief Presentation PPT - 2017.pptx
UAE Labour Law - Brief Presentation PPT - 2017.pptxUAE Labour Law - Brief Presentation PPT - 2017.pptx
UAE Labour Law - Brief Presentation PPT - 2017.pptxhrlestars
 
tort pptx by Abebayehu .pdf extra contractual
tort pptx by Abebayehu .pdf extra contractualtort pptx by Abebayehu .pdf extra contractual
tort pptx by Abebayehu .pdf extra contractualHananAmdemariam
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Commercialization of IPR – From Lawyerperspective Strategies and Challenges...
Commercialization of IPR – From Lawyerperspective   Strategies and Challenges...Commercialization of IPR – From Lawyerperspective   Strategies and Challenges...
Commercialization of IPR – From Lawyerperspective Strategies and Challenges...
 
16902_2015_Order_12-Apr-2019.pdfp;kp;kpodk
16902_2015_Order_12-Apr-2019.pdfp;kp;kpodk16902_2015_Order_12-Apr-2019.pdfp;kp;kpodk
16902_2015_Order_12-Apr-2019.pdfp;kp;kpodk
 
Public Health and Intellectual Property Rights
Public Health and Intellectual Property RightsPublic Health and Intellectual Property Rights
Public Health and Intellectual Property Rights
 
Biography Presentation of Manoj sharma [IPS]
Biography Presentation of Manoj  sharma [IPS]Biography Presentation of Manoj  sharma [IPS]
Biography Presentation of Manoj sharma [IPS]
 
The Concept of Rule of law : origin, development & Indian Constitution.
The Concept of  Rule of law : origin, development & Indian Constitution.The Concept of  Rule of law : origin, development & Indian Constitution.
The Concept of Rule of law : origin, development & Indian Constitution.
 
Exploring the Essential Elements Included in eSports Licensing Agreements
Exploring the Essential Elements Included in eSports Licensing AgreementsExploring the Essential Elements Included in eSports Licensing Agreements
Exploring the Essential Elements Included in eSports Licensing Agreements
 
GS Holistic Court Opinion in Trademark Dispute
GS Holistic Court Opinion in Trademark DisputeGS Holistic Court Opinion in Trademark Dispute
GS Holistic Court Opinion in Trademark Dispute
 
Report Centre of Policy and Legal Reform 2022.pdf
Report Centre of Policy and Legal Reform 2022.pdfReport Centre of Policy and Legal Reform 2022.pdf
Report Centre of Policy and Legal Reform 2022.pdf
 
VIETNAM - LEGAL ALERT ON CIRCULAR PROVIDING REGULATIONS ON METHOD TO FORMULAT...
VIETNAM - LEGAL ALERT ON CIRCULAR PROVIDING REGULATIONS ON METHOD TO FORMULAT...VIETNAM - LEGAL ALERT ON CIRCULAR PROVIDING REGULATIONS ON METHOD TO FORMULAT...
VIETNAM - LEGAL ALERT ON CIRCULAR PROVIDING REGULATIONS ON METHOD TO FORMULAT...
 
Digital Forensics and Evidence Gathering: A Lawyer's Approach to Phishing and...
Digital Forensics and Evidence Gathering: A Lawyer's Approach to Phishing and...Digital Forensics and Evidence Gathering: A Lawyer's Approach to Phishing and...
Digital Forensics and Evidence Gathering: A Lawyer's Approach to Phishing and...
 
legal-Complaint-emery-unified-assault.pdf
legal-Complaint-emery-unified-assault.pdflegal-Complaint-emery-unified-assault.pdf
legal-Complaint-emery-unified-assault.pdf
 
Jeremey Tevebaugh Indicted for Check Forgery
Jeremey Tevebaugh Indicted for Check ForgeryJeremey Tevebaugh Indicted for Check Forgery
Jeremey Tevebaugh Indicted for Check Forgery
 
Aggressive Advocate for Assault Charges
Aggressive Advocate for Assault ChargesAggressive Advocate for Assault Charges
Aggressive Advocate for Assault Charges
 
Doctrine of Part Performance in Transfer of property.pptx
Doctrine of Part Performance in Transfer of property.pptxDoctrine of Part Performance in Transfer of property.pptx
Doctrine of Part Performance in Transfer of property.pptx
 
1038220242024-03-11-527359.pdfKIpokpikfkkovk
1038220242024-03-11-527359.pdfKIpokpikfkkovk1038220242024-03-11-527359.pdfKIpokpikfkkovk
1038220242024-03-11-527359.pdfKIpokpikfkkovk
 
Project Esther Qualifications for Kairos Capital
Project Esther Qualifications for Kairos CapitalProject Esther Qualifications for Kairos Capital
Project Esther Qualifications for Kairos Capital
 
Planned Giving Presentation for Ottawa County Parks Foundation
Planned Giving Presentation for Ottawa County Parks FoundationPlanned Giving Presentation for Ottawa County Parks Foundation
Planned Giving Presentation for Ottawa County Parks Foundation
 
Canada PR_ Top 10 Eligibility, Requirements, and Criteria.pdf
Canada PR_ Top 10 Eligibility, Requirements, and Criteria.pdfCanada PR_ Top 10 Eligibility, Requirements, and Criteria.pdf
Canada PR_ Top 10 Eligibility, Requirements, and Criteria.pdf
 
UAE Labour Law - Brief Presentation PPT - 2017.pptx
UAE Labour Law - Brief Presentation PPT - 2017.pptxUAE Labour Law - Brief Presentation PPT - 2017.pptx
UAE Labour Law - Brief Presentation PPT - 2017.pptx
 
tort pptx by Abebayehu .pdf extra contractual
tort pptx by Abebayehu .pdf extra contractualtort pptx by Abebayehu .pdf extra contractual
tort pptx by Abebayehu .pdf extra contractual
 

Why We Are Open Sourcing ContraxSuite and Some Thoughts About Legal Tech and the Modern Information Economy

  • 1. July 3, 2017 Chicago, IL USA For Immediate Release WHY WE’RE OPEN-SOURCING CONTRAXSUITE™ LEGALTECH IN THE MODERN INFORMATION ECONOMY I. OUR ANNOUNCEMENT Over the last decade, we’ve spent many thousands of effort-hours developing the contract analytics and document analytics tools that we use with clients. These tools, based on enterprise- quality open source frameworks for natural language processing, machine learning, and optical character recognition, have allowed us to quickly and easily attack many problems, from securities filings and court opinions to articles of incorporation and lease agreements. Today, we are proud to announce that we plan to open source the development of our core platform for contract analytics and document analytics - ContraxSuite. Starting on August 1st, this code base and our public development roadmap will be hosted on Github under a permissive open-source licensing model that will allow most organizations to quickly and freely implement and customize their own contract and document analytics. Like Redhat does for Linux, we will provide support, customization, and data services to "cover the last mile" for those organizations who need it. We believe that a very important future for law lies in its central role in facilitating and regulating the modern information economy. But unless we start treating law itself like the production of information, we’ll never get there. Before we can solve big problems with smart contracts, we need to start by structuring existing legacy contracts. We hope our actions today will help lawyers, companies, and other LegalTech providers accelerate the pace of improvement and innovation through more open collaboration. II. THE RISE OF THE OPEN SOURCE ECONOMY Over the course of human history, many models of economic development and innovation have emerged. Some of these models, like the public stock company, are quite new in the scheme of things. Others, like the community of "natural" philosophers (scientists) or mutual insurance, are very old. But in all cases - whether intangible insurance or tangible iPad - there is a flow from idea to execution to economic value. One crude way of comparing these economic models is to examine how information is held - publicly or privately. Information, not opposable thumbs, as Cesar Hidalgo elegantly explains, is the secret weapon of our species – our only defense against the intrinsic chaos and decay of the
  • 2. universe. And in the mode of economic analysis descended from Adam Smith, private information is the key. Knowledge and know-how enable enterprises to produce and profit. This principle of private information has guided most enterprises over the last few centuries, from the coveted trade route maps of the 18th century to the modern Coca Cola recipe. So why, especially in the last half-century, have we seen the "open source" or "peer-to-peer" model of information grow? Google, Apple, and Facebook, three companies worth nearly two trillion dollars combined, have given away thousands of software projects worth billions of dollars in effort-hour cost. Have we all gone mad? Or is there something else going on – an emergent value to holding knowledge more publicly in the modern world? There are many attempts to answer this fascinating question, and these attempts both challenge and enlighten our understanding of human behavior, economics, and law. However, especially as it relates to software, we lean on the words of Prof. David Agarwal: "For many [...], software is only a semi-finished good that generates little value until the code has undergone revision by the user. Thus, creating the ultimate finished product will require a sequence of motivating incentives." III. LAW AS OPEN SOURCE AND THE LAST MILE PROBLEM The first sentence above is as true of legal documents - articles of incorporation, operating agreements, corporate filings, contracts and agreements - as it is of software. While there are thousands of resources for corporate governance or contracting available online, none of these are "finished" goods for another party. In some cases, "finishing" may simply required updating the parties and dates, like a restaurant microwaving a pre-cooked cut of meat. In other cases, "finishing" may actually involve novel structures or more creative redrafting, like a chef growing his own produce or combining flavors in unexpected ways. As to the second sentence - "[...] the ultimate finished product will require a sequence of motivating incentives" - we arrive back to ContraxSuite. Software products designed to assist in the drafting and analysis of legal documents are perfect examples of semi-finished goods. Alone, no software product can incorporate an entity or enter into a sales agreement or manage the geopolitical risk of supplier networks (let’s ignore Smart Contracts and DAO-like organizations, for now). Only with the assistance of legal professionals can this semi-finished software deliver value to the organization and its clients. In our experience, few legal departments and law firms debate that their legal documents contain valuable information. Analytics can provide insights into a wide array of opportunities and risks. Standardization can remove frictions for core business operations and increase the rate and quality of transactions. But when you ask these organizations to pay a per-document fee for software that almost always requires additional customization or produces "unfinished" results, their excitement turns into
  • 3. hesitation. Contract analytic software, like Google’s TensorFlow or the Linux Kernel, does not generate value by itself; human capital is required to "cover the last mile" that actually solves the problem. This is why data scientists have not yet been put out of business by TensorFlow and why Redhat and Oracle still "sell Linux" for billions of dollars per year. We have a "last mile" problem in the legal arena. Much like Linux and data science, contract analytics is largely about the combination of well-known practices with large-scale, high-quality data. Contracts are natural language encoded in either analog or digital format, and this language is unlocked and encoded with technologies like optical character recognition (OCR) and natural language processing (NLP). These encodings are then mapped back to real-world business problems through techniques like clustering or classification, two types of machine learning (ML) algorithms. None of these technologies or techniques above are proprietary or novel, and some version of these ideas have been available nearly as long as there have been digital computers. The real challenge in contract or other related forms of document analytics is to develop the so - called "training data" - the set of documents and labels used to "teach" the machine what separates a lease agreement from a purchase/sale agreement from a retirement benefits plan. Herein lies the true value of the current software and service providers. But, paradoxically, almost all providers get their information from one of two sources - either public sources of agreements, like the SEC’s EDGAR database or evidence from public courts, or private sources of agreements - their clients. Many organizations have therefore paid for the privilege to give away their own information so that someone else can profit. By open-sourcing ContraxSuite, we hope to change this dynamic. The analysis and standardization of contracts and corporate governance material is key to the transformation of our economy. But blockchain and Smart Contracts aside, there are significant improvements in risk management, compliance, and profitability that can be gained by treating contracts as valuable data. Until legal departments and law firms can be "sequentially motivated," to borrow Professor Agarwal’s language, we will not see this maturation of the industry. In the near future, we’ll be revealing more details about this open source strategy - including more detail on academic and industry partnerships, support and customization services, and our open- source license model. In the meantime, we hope to get everyone thinking fundamentally about how we do business in legal tech. What does the client really want - your software license or a sustainable solution? IV. A CHALLENGE TO PROVIDERS, DEVELOPERS & CUSTOMERS While some in the legal technology community will certainly taut their ability to outperform our open source framework on some use cases today, we believe that they will find themselves on the wrong side of history. We encourage others in legal technology and related domains to follow our lead and think hard about whether closed code is really the right strategy. By committing to open source and allowing others to validate, improve, and maintain our shared infrastructure, any gaps in quality or functionality will soon fade away.
  • 4. More critically, the hype and "vaporware" that pervade legal technology do a disservice to the overall efforts towards innovation. We would like to move the field forward through the hard work of iterative, open methodological improvement. This hype and vaporware has been enabled by a lack of transparency and, to be honest, a lack of sophistication on behalf of customers, but going forward, both the consumer and developer community should be able inspect the quality of any existing offering. Our co-founders, as leading educators of the next generation of attorneys, have committed to making sure that the General Counsel and Managing Partner of the future won’t be fooled. Others can chase the temporary rents of the middle game, but we’re here to make moves that support the long-term maturation of the overall legal industry. We hope you will join us. Michael J. Bommarito Daniel Martin Katz CEO @ LexPredict CSO @ LexPredict