SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 1389
Download to read offline
A risk-based decision-making
game relevant to water
management.
Try it yourself!
2013. This game was prepared by Louise Crochemore (IRSTEA), Florian Pappenberger (ECMWF),
Schalk Jan van Andel (UNESCO-IHE), Maria-Helena Ramos (IRSTEA) and Andy Wood (NOAA).
If you use this game, the authors would be grateful for feedback on your usage and results so as to
help improve future versions of the game and justify further development efforts. Special thanks to
Kevin Werner (NWS), a key designer of the original game on which this one is based.
Contact: maria-helena.ramos@irstea.fr
This game is part of HEPEX activities: www.hepex.org

START

General instructions: use full screen mode. Always click on the appropriate links in each slide.
Do not use Page Up, Page Down or arrow keys for scrolling.
Water management game: instructions
You are the newly appointed water manager for Lake Dual
It is a reservoir that serves two primary functions:
1. Water supply for Swof Town
2. Flood control for Safe Town
Swof Town

Water Supply

Reservoir
“Lake Dual”

Flood Control
Safe Town

NEXT
Water management game: instructions
1. Swof Town: would like to see the reservoir full on August 1st (500 Mm3)
so that its residents can count on water all summer.
2. Safe Town: residents are interested in keeping releases below 60 Mm3
each month (anything more causes flood damage to their homes)

Swof Town

Water Supply

Reservoir
“Lake Dual”

Flood Control
Safe Town

NEXT
Water management game: instructions
You are going to be the water manager for Lake Dual during the season
running from April to August:
- you will be presented with probabilistic forecasts of inflows, and
- at the beginning of each month you have to decide on the reservoir
releases for the remaining months.
Swof Town

Water Supply

Reservoir
“Lake Dual”

Flood Control
Safe Town

NEXT
Water management game: remember!
 your aim is to have the reservoir level as close as possible to 500 Mm3 on
August 1st, but you can never exceed this level.
You have to maintain a minimum release of 15 Mm3 for environmental flow and
your maximum release cannot exceed 60 Mm3.

If you fail to meet these constraints, you will be fired! The WINNER of the game is
the manager that has the highest level on August 1st (but < 500 Mm3)
Swof Town

Water Supply

Reservoir
“Lake Dual”

Flood Control
Safe Town

NEXT
Water management game: worksheet
You have a worksheet to mark your decisions!
Remember to return it after the game!
NOW LET’S DO AN EXAMPLE BEFORE WE START !

NEXT
Water management game: example
Its March 1st:
this is the probabilistic forecast of inflows
issued on March 1st for the next months

NEXT
Water management game: example
You have to decide on your releases for all the next months…
Mark the releases in your worksheet!

NEXT
Water management game: example
At the end of the month, you will be informed of the actual inflow
And you can update your reservoir volume for the next month

NEXT
Water management game: example
Update your worksheet and check if you still have a job!
You’re ready to go to the next forecast and decision

NEXT
Water management game: let’s play!
Worksheets shall be used to indicate your own releases

To represent the group….

We need a VOLUNTEER !

Who in the room?

NEXT
Water management game: let’s play!

Game Start

Swof Town
Water Supply

Reservoir

“Lake Dual”

Flood Control

Safe Town
It is April 1st.
The reservoir is at 450 M m3
You are given the inflow forecasts on April 1st.
Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3
140

130

Forecast inflow volume

110
100
80
70
58

60
40

42

36

28
20
q

0
M

19

12
10
8

5

A

10

M

J

Forecast issued on the previous month

120
max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)

J

Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st.
If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired.

NEXT
140

It is April 1st.

130

Forecast issued on the previous month

120

Forecast inflow volume

110

And our volunteer?
Let’s see which release option
our volunteer will choose.

100
80
70
58

60
40

36

28
20
q

0
M

Option A
37

Release

38

35

Reservoir volume

700

55

58

5

A

60

M

57

J

J

17

23

29

25

A

M

J

J

700

500
q

10

Option C

700

500

19

12
10
8

Option B
45

42

500
q

q

300

300

300

100

100

100

A

M
q

J

J

A

M

J

J

Current reservoir volume
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)
April has gone by.
April inflow was: 18 M m3
You can update your reservoir volume:
The volume on May 1st is:
April 1 volume + 18 M m3 - April release = ?

Did you overtop your reservoir?
NO, I still have my job.
YES, I got fired...

What about our volunteer?
April has gone by.
April inflow was: 18 M m3
Our volunteer’s April release was: 37 M m3
The volume on May 1st is therefore:
450 M m3 +18 M m3 -37 M m3 = 431 M m3

No overtop!

The volunteer still has a job!
Let’s go to the next forecast!
Previous decisions: A

It is May 1st.
The reservoir is at 431 M m3
You are given the inflow forecasts on May 1st.
Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3

Forecast inflow volume

100
92
85

80

60

65

56

40

36

20

q

q

0
M

35

22

18

18

Forecast issued on the previous month

120

120

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)

5

A

M

J

J

Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st.
If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired.

NEXT
Previous decisions: A

Forecast inflow volume

It is May 1st.
And our volunteer?
Let’s see which release option
our volunteer will choose.

100
92
85

80

60

40

36

20

q

q

M

59

Release

56

45

A

22

18

18

M

J

J

Option C
46

39

26

700
Reservoir volume

35

5

Option B
60

65

56

0

Option A

Forecast issued on the previous month

120

120

700

500

25

M

J

J

700

500

24

500

q

q

q

300

300

300

100

100

100

M
q

J

J

M

J

J

Current reservoir volume
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)
May has gone by.
May inflow was: 55 M m3
You can update your reservoir volume:
The volume on June 1st is:
May 1 volume + 55 M m3 - May release = ?

Did you overtop your reservoir?
NO, I still have my job.
YES, I got fired...

What about our volunteer?
May has gone by.
May inflow was: 55 M m3
Our volunteer’s May release was: 59 M m3
The volume on June 1st is therefore:
431 M m3 +55 M m3 -59 M m3 = 427 M m3

No overtop!

The volunteer still has a job!
Let’s go to the next forecast!
Previous decisions: A A

It is June 1st.
The reservoir is at 427 M m3
You are given the inflow forecasts on June 1st.
Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3
110

Forecast inflow volume

92
80

79

60
q

55

52

40
35
20

q

q

23

18

5

Forecast issued on the previous month

100
max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)

0
M

A

M

J

J

Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st.
If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired.

NEXT
Previous decisions: A A
110

It is June 1st.

100

Let’s see which release option
our volunteer will choose.

80

Forecast issued on the previous month

And our volunteer?

Forecast inflow volume

92
79

60
55

q

52

40
35
20

q

q

23

18

5

0
M

Option A

A

Option B
28

Release

30

J

J

Option C
60

50

45

700
Reservoir volume

M

700

500

J

J

700

500

35

500

q

q

q

300

300

300

100

100

100

J
q

J

J

J

Current reservoir volume
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)
June has gone by.
June inflow was: 120 M m3
You can update your reservoir volume:
The volume on July 1st is:
June 1 volume + 120 M m3 - June release = ?

Did you overtop your reservoir?
NO, I still have my job.
YES, I got fired...

What about our volunteer?
June has gone by.
June inflow was: 120 M m3
Our volunteer’s June release was: 28 M m3
The volume on July 1st is therefore:
427 M m3 +120 M m3 -28 M m3 = 519 M m3

Overtop!

The volunteer got fired!
Can it be fixed?
Previous decisions: A A A

It is July 1st.
The reservoir is at 519 M m3
You are given the inflow forecasts on July 1st.
Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3
q

120

100

80

60
q

55

40
28
20

q

q

0
M

21
19

18

Forecast issued on the previous month

Forecast inflow volume

120

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)

5

A

M

J

J

Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st.
If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired.

NEXT
Previous decisions: A A A

And our volunteer?
Let’s see which release option
our volunteer will choose.

Forecast inflow volume

It is July 1st.

q

100

80

60

40
28
20

q

q

M

Reservoir volume

q

M

J

J

25
700

500

A

Option C

60

700

21
19

18

5

Option B

Release

55

q

0

Option A

120

500

Forecast issued on the previous month

120

40
700

q

500

300

300

300

100

100

q

100

J
q

J

Current reservoir volume
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast

J

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)
July has gone by.
July inflow was: 22 M m3
You can update your reservoir volume:
The volume on August 1st is:
July 1 volume + 22 M m3 - July release = ?

Did you overtop your reservoir?
NO, I still have my job.
YES, I got fired...

What about our volunteer?
July has gone by.
July inflow was: 22 M m3
Our volunteer’s July release was: 60 M m3
The volume on August 1st is therefore:
519 M m3 +22 M m3 -60 M m3 = 481 M m3

No overtop!

The volunteer got the job back!
NEXT
Previous decisions: A A A A

GAME OVER
August 1st has arrived.
If you did not overtop the reservoir, you still have a job and you are hired for the next season!

Observed inflows

Forecast on April 1

Our volunteer's results

q

120

100
80
60

q

55

40
20

q

q

0
M

q

18

5

22

120

80
70

60

58

40

36

q

M

J

J

42
28

20
0

A

700

110

100

M

A

q

500

q

300

19

12
10
8

5

Reservoir volume

120

Forecast inflow volume

Inflows in the reservoir

130

10

M

J

J

100
A

How did you like this experience as a decision-maker?

M

J

August
1st
It is April 1st.
The reservoir is at 450 M m3
You are given the inflow forecasts on April 1st.
Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3
140

130

Forecast inflow volume

110
100
80
70
58

60
40

42

36

28
20
q

0
M

19

12
10
8

5

A

10

M

J

Forecast issued on the previous month

120
max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)

J

Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st.
If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired.

NEXT
140

It is April 1st.

130

Forecast issued on the previous month

120

Forecast inflow volume

110

And our volunteer?
Let’s see which release option
our volunteer will choose.

100
80
70
58

60
40

36

28
20
q

0
M

Option A
37

Release

38

35

Reservoir volume

700

55

58

5

A

60

M

57

J

J

17

23

29

25

A

M

J

J

700

500
q

10

Option C

700

500

19

12
10
8

Option B
45

42

500
q

q

300

300

300

100

100

100

A

M
q

J

J

A

M

J

J

Current reservoir volume
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)
April has gone by.
April inflow was: 18 M m3
You can update your reservoir volume:
The volume on May 1st is:
April 1 volume + 18 M m3 - April release = ?

Did you overtop your reservoir?
NO, I still have my job.
YES, I got fired...

What about our volunteer?
April has gone by.
April inflow was: 18 M m3
Our volunteer’s April release was: 55 M m3
The volume on May 1st is therefore:
450 M m3 +18 M m3 -55 M m3 = 413 M m3

No overtop!

The volunteer still has a job!
Let’s go to the next forecast!
Previous decisions: B

It is May 1st.
The reservoir is at 413 M m3
You are given the inflow forecasts on May 1st.
Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3

Forecast inflow volume

100
92
85

80

60

65

56

40

36

20

q

q

0
M

35

22

18

18

Forecast issued on the previous month

120

120

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)

5

A

M

J

J

Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st.
If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired.

NEXT
Previous decisions: B

Forecast inflow volume

It is May 1st.
And our volunteer?
Let’s see which release option
our volunteer will choose.

100
92
85

80

60

40

36

20

q

q

M

59

Release

56

45

A

22

18

18

M

J

J

Option C
46

39

26

700
Reservoir volume

35

5

Option B
60

65

56

0

Option A

Forecast issued on the previous month

120

120

700

500

25

M

J

J

700

500

24

500

q

q

q

300

300

300

100

100

100

M
q

J

J

M

J

J

Current reservoir volume
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)
May has gone by.
May inflow was: 55 M m3
You can update your reservoir volume:
The volume on June 1st is:
May 1 volume + 55 M m3 - May release = ?

Did you overtop your reservoir?
NO, I still have my job.
YES, I got fired...

What about our volunteer?
May has gone by.
May inflow was: 55 M m3
Our volunteer’s May release was: 59 M m3
The volume on June 1st is therefore:
413 M m3 +55 M m3 -59 M m3 = 409 M m3

No overtop!

The volunteer still has a job!
Let’s go to the next forecast!
Previous decisions: B A

It is June 1st.
The reservoir is at 409 M m3
You are given the inflow forecasts on June 1st.
Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3
110

Forecast inflow volume

92
80

79

60
q

55

52

40
35
20

q

q

23

18

5

Forecast issued on the previous month

100
max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)

0
M

A

M

J

J

Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st.
If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired.

NEXT
Previous decisions: B A
110

It is June 1st.

100

Let’s see which release option
our volunteer will choose.

80

Forecast issued on the previous month

And our volunteer?

Forecast inflow volume

92
79

60
55

q

52

40
35
20

q

q

23

18

5

0
M

Option A

A

Option B
28

Release

30

J

J

Option C
60

50

45

700
Reservoir volume

M

700

500

J

J

700

500

35

500

q

q

q

300

300

300

100

100

100

J
q

J

J

J

Current reservoir volume
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)
June has gone by.
June inflow was: 120 M m3
You can update your reservoir volume:
The volume on July 1st is:
June 1 volume + 120 M m3 - June release = ?

Did you overtop your reservoir?
NO, I still have my job.
YES, I got fired...

What about our volunteer?
June has gone by.
June inflow was: 120 M m3
Our volunteer’s June release was: 28 M m3
The volume on July 1st is therefore:
409 M m3 +120 M m3 -28 M m3 = 501 M m3

Overtop!

The volunteer got fired!
Can it be fixed?
Previous decisions: B A A

It is July 1st.
The reservoir is at 501 M m3
You are given the inflow forecasts on July 1st.
Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3
q

120

100

80

60
q

55

40
28
20

q

q

0
M

21
19

18

Forecast issued on the previous month

Forecast inflow volume

120

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)

5

A

M

J

J

Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st.
If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired.

NEXT
Previous decisions: B A A

And our volunteer?
Let’s see which release option
our volunteer will choose.

Forecast inflow volume

It is July 1st.

q

100

80

60

40
28
20

q

q

M

Reservoir volume

q

M

J

J

25
700

500

A

Option C

60

700

21
19

18

5

Option B

Release

55

q

0

Option A

120

500

Forecast issued on the previous month

120

40
700

q

500

300

300

300

100

100

q

100

J
q

J

Current reservoir volume
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast

J

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)
July has gone by.
July inflow was: 22 M m3
You can update your reservoir volume:
The volume on August 1st is:
July 1 volume + 22 M m3 - July release = ?

Did you overtop your reservoir?
NO, I still have my job.
YES, I got fired...

What about our volunteer?
July has gone by.
July inflow was: 22 M m3
Our volunteer’s July release was: 60 M m3
The volume on August 1st is therefore:
501 M m3 +22 M m3 -60 M m3 = 463 M m3

No overtop!

The volunteer got the job back!
NEXT
Previous decisions: B A A A

GAME OVER
August 1st has arrived.
If you did not overtop the reservoir, you still have a job and you are hired for the next season!

Observed inflows

Forecast on April 1

Our volunteer's results

q

120

100
80
60

q

55

40
20

q

q

0
M

q

18

5

22

120

80
70

60

58

40

36

q

M

J

J

42
28

20
0

A

700

110

100

M

A

500

q

q

300

19

12
10
8

5

Reservoir volume

120

Forecast inflow volume

Inflows in the reservoir

130

10

M

J

J

100
A

How did you like this experience as a decision-maker?

M

J

August
1st
It is April 1st.
The reservoir is at 450 M m3
You are given the inflow forecasts on April 1st.
Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3
140

130

Forecast inflow volume

110
100
80
70
58

60
40

42

36

28
20
q

0
M

19

12
10
8

5

A

10

M

J

Forecast issued on the previous month

120
max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)

J

Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st.
If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired.

NEXT
140

It is April 1st.

130

Forecast issued on the previous month

120

Forecast inflow volume

110

And our volunteer?
Let’s see which release option
our volunteer will choose.

100
80
70
58

60
40

36

28
20
q

0
M

Option A
37

Release

38

35

Reservoir volume

700

55

58

5

A

60

M

57

J

J

17

23

29

25

A

M

J

J

700

500
q

10

Option C

700

500

19

12
10
8

Option B
45

42

500
q

q

300

300

300

100

100

100

A

M
q

J

J

A

M

J

J

Current reservoir volume
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)
April has gone by.
April inflow was: 18 M m3
You can update your reservoir volume:
The volume on May 1st is:
April 1 volume + 18 M m3 - April release = ?

Did you overtop your reservoir?
NO, I still have my job.
YES, I got fired...

What about our volunteer?
April has gone by.
April inflow was: 18 M m3
Our volunteer’s April release was: 17 M m3
The volume on May 1st is therefore:
450 M m3 +18 M m3 -17 M m3 = 451 M m3

No overtop!

The volunteer still has a job!
Let’s go to the next forecast!
Previous decisions: C

It is May 1st.
The reservoir is at 451 M m3
You are given the inflow forecasts on May 1st.
Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3

Forecast inflow volume

100
92
85

80

60

65

56

40

36

20

q

q

0
M

35

22

18

18

Forecast issued on the previous month

120

120

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)

5

A

M

J

J

Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st.
If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired.

NEXT
Previous decisions: C

Forecast inflow volume

It is May 1st.
And our volunteer?
Let’s see which release option
our volunteer will choose.

100
92
85

80

60

40

36

20

q

q

M

59

Release

56

Reservoir volume

700

500

45

500

22

18

18

A

M

J

J

Option C
46

39

700

q

35

5

Option B
60

65

56

0

Option A

Forecast issued on the previous month

120

120

26

24

25

M

J

J

700

500

q

300

300

300

100

100

q

100

M
q

J

J

M

J

J

Current reservoir volume
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)
May has gone by.
May inflow was: 55 M m3
You can update your reservoir volume:
The volume on June 1st is:
May 1 volume + 55 M m3 - May release = ?

Did you overtop your reservoir?
NO, I still have my job.
YES, I got fired...

What about our volunteer?
May has gone by.
May inflow was: 55 M m3
Our volunteer’s May release was: 59 M m3
The volume on June 1st is therefore:
451 M m3 +55 M m3 -59 M m3 = 447 M m3

No overtop!

The volunteer still has a job!
Let’s go to the next forecast!
Previous decisions: C A

It is June 1st.
The reservoir is at 447 M m3
You are given the inflow forecasts on June 1st.
Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3
110

Forecast inflow volume

92
80

79

60
q

55

52

40
35
20

q

q

23

18

5

Forecast issued on the previous month

100
max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)

0
M

A

M

J

J

Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st.
If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired.

NEXT
Previous decisions: C A
110

It is June 1st.

100

Let’s see which release option
our volunteer will choose.

80

Forecast issued on the previous month

And our volunteer?

Forecast inflow volume

92
79

60
55

q

52

40
35
20

q

q

23

18

5

0
M

Option A

Option B
28

Release

30

700
Reservoir volume

A

60

J

50

45

35

J

J

700

500
q

J

Option C

700

500

M

500
q

q

300

300

300

100

100

100

J
q

J

J

J

Current reservoir volume
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)
June has gone by.
June inflow was: 120 M m3
You can update your reservoir volume:
The volume on July 1st is:
June 1 volume + 120 M m3 - June release = ?

Did you overtop your reservoir?
NO, I still have my job.
YES, I got fired...

What about our volunteer?
June has gone by.
June inflow was: 120 M m3
Our volunteer’s June release was: 28 M m3
The volume on July 1st is therefore:
447 M m3 +120 M m3 -28 M m3 = 539 M m3

Overtop!

The volunteer got fired!
Can it be fixed?
Previous decisions: C A A

It is July 1st.
The reservoir is at 539 M m3
You are given the inflow forecasts on July 1st.
Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3
q

120

100

80

60
q

55

40
28
20

q

q

0
M

21
19

18

Forecast issued on the previous month

Forecast inflow volume

120

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)

5

A

M

J

J

Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st.
If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired.

NEXT
Previous decisions: C A A

And our volunteer?
Let’s see which release option
our volunteer will choose.

Forecast inflow volume

It is July 1st.

q

100

80

60

40
28
20

q

q

M

Reservoir volume

q

M

J

J

25
700

500

A

Option C

60

700

21
19

18

5

Option B

Release

55

q

0

Option A

120

500

Forecast issued on the previous month

120

40
700

q

500

300

300

300

100

100

q

100

J
q

J

Current reservoir volume
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast

J

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)
July has gone by.
July inflow was: 22 M m3
You can update your reservoir volume:
The volume on August 1st is:
July 1 volume + 22 M m3 - July release = ?

Did you overtop your reservoir?
NO, I still have my job.
YES, I got fired...

What about our volunteer?
July has gone by.
July inflow was: 22 M m3
Our volunteer’s July release was: 60 M m3
The volume on August 1st is therefore:
539 M m3 +22 M m3 -60 M m3 = 501 M m3

Overtop!

The volunteer did not get the job back!
NEXT
Previous decisions: C A A A

GAME OVER
August 1st has arrived.
If you did not overtop the reservoir, you still have a job and you are hired for the next season!

Observed inflows

Forecast on April 1

Our volunteer's results

q

120

100
80
60

q

55

40
20

q

q

0
M

q

18

5

22

120

80
70

60

58

40

36

q

M

J

J

42
28

20
0

A

700

110

100

M

A

q

500

q
q

300

19

12
10
8

5

Reservoir volume

120

Forecast inflow volume

Inflows in the reservoir

130

10

M

J

J

100
A

How did you like this experience as a decision-maker?

M

J

August
1st
It is April 1st.
The reservoir is at 450 M m3
You are given the inflow forecasts on April 1st.
Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3
140

130

Forecast inflow volume

110
100
80
70
58

60
40

42

36

28
20
q

0
M

19

12
10
8

5

A

10

M

J

Forecast issued on the previous month

120
max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)

J

Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st.
If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired.

NEXT
140

It is April 1st.

130

Forecast issued on the previous month

120

Forecast inflow volume

110

And our volunteer?
Let’s see which release option
our volunteer will choose.

100
80
70
58

60
40

36

28
20
q

0
M

Option A
37

Release

38

35

Reservoir volume

700

55

58

5

A

60

M

57

J

J

17

23

29

25

A

M

J

J

700

500
q

10

Option C

700

500

19

12
10
8

Option B
45

42

500
q

q

300

300

300

100

100

100

A

M
q

J

J

A

M

J

J

Current reservoir volume
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)
April has gone by.
April inflow was: 18 M m3
You can update your reservoir volume:
The volume on May 1st is:
April 1 volume + 18 M m3 - April release = ?

Did you overtop your reservoir?
NO, I still have my job.
YES, I got fired...

What about our volunteer?
April has gone by.
April inflow was: 18 M m3
Our volunteer’s April release was: 37 M m3
The volume on May 1st is therefore:
450 M m3 +18 M m3 -37 M m3 = 431 M m3

No overtop!

The volunteer still has a job!
Let’s go to the next forecast!
Previous decisions: A

It is May 1st.
The reservoir is at 431 M m3
You are given the inflow forecasts on May 1st.
Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3

Forecast inflow volume

100
92
85

80

60

65

56

40

36

20

q

q

0
M

35

22

18

18

Forecast issued on the previous month

120

120

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)

5

A

M

J

J

Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st.
If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired.

NEXT
Previous decisions: A

Forecast inflow volume

It is May 1st.
And our volunteer?
Let’s see which release option
our volunteer will choose.

100
92
85

80

60

40

36

20

q

q

M

59

Release

56

45

A

22

18

18

M

J

J

Option C
46

39

26

700
Reservoir volume

35

5

Option B
60

65

56

0

Option A

Forecast issued on the previous month

120

120

700

500

25

M

J

J

700

500

24

500

q

q

q

300

300

300

100

100

100

M
q

J

J

M

J

J

Current reservoir volume
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)
May has gone by.
May inflow was: 55 M m3
You can update your reservoir volume:
The volume on June 1st is:
May 1 volume + 55 M m3 - May release = ?

Did you overtop your reservoir?
NO, I still have my job.
YES, I got fired...

What about our volunteer?
May has gone by.
May inflow was: 55 M m3
Our volunteer’s May release was: 45 M m3
The volume on June 1st is therefore:
431 M m3 +55 M m3 -45 M m3 = 441 M m3

No overtop!

The volunteer still has a job!
Let’s go to the next forecast!
Previous decisions: A B

It is June 1st.
The reservoir is at 441 M m3
You are given the inflow forecasts on June 1st.
Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3
110

Forecast inflow volume

92
80

79

60
q

55

52

40
35
20

q

q

23

18

5

Forecast issued on the previous month

100
max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)

0
M

A

M

J

J

Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st.
If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired.

NEXT
Previous decisions: A B
110

It is June 1st.

100

Let’s see which release option
our volunteer will choose.

80

Forecast issued on the previous month

And our volunteer?

Forecast inflow volume

92
79

60
55

q

52

40
35
20

q

q

23

18

5

0
M

Option A

Option B
28

Release

30

700
Reservoir volume

A

60

J

50

45

35

J

J

700

500
q

J

Option C

700

500

M

500
q

q

300

300

300

100

100

100

J
q

J

J

J

Current reservoir volume
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)
June has gone by.
June inflow was: 120 M m3
You can update your reservoir volume:
The volume on July 1st is:
June 1 volume + 120 M m3 - June release = ?

Did you overtop your reservoir?
NO, I still have my job.
YES, I got fired...

What about our volunteer?
June has gone by.
June inflow was: 120 M m3
Our volunteer’s June release was: 28 M m3
The volume on July 1st is therefore:
441 M m3 +120 M m3 -28 M m3 = 533 M m3

Overtop!

The volunteer got fired!
Can it be fixed?
Previous decisions: A B A

It is July 1st.
The reservoir is at 533 M m3
You are given the inflow forecasts on July 1st.
Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3
q

120

100

80

60
q

55

40
28
20

q

q

0
M

21
19

18

Forecast issued on the previous month

Forecast inflow volume

120

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)

5

A

M

J

J

Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st.
If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired.

NEXT
Previous decisions: A B A

And our volunteer?
Let’s see which release option
our volunteer will choose.

Forecast inflow volume

It is July 1st.

q

100

80

60

40
28
20

q

q

M

Reservoir volume

q

M

J

J

25
700

500

A

Option C

60

700

21
19

18

5

Option B

Release

55

q

0

Option A

120

500

Forecast issued on the previous month

120

40
700

q

500

300

300

300

100

100

q

100

J
q

J

Current reservoir volume
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast

J

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)
July has gone by.
July inflow was: 22 M m3
You can update your reservoir volume:
The volume on August 1st is:
July 1 volume + 22 M m3 - July release = ?

Did you overtop your reservoir?
NO, I still have my job.
YES, I got fired...

What about our volunteer?
July has gone by.
July inflow was: 22 M m3
Our volunteer’s July release was: 60 M m3
The volume on August 1st is therefore:
533 M m3 +22 M m3 -60 M m3 = 495 M m3

No overtop!

The volunteer got the job back!
NEXT
Previous decisions: A B A A

GAME OVER
August 1st has arrived.
If you did not overtop the reservoir, you still have a job and you are hired for the next season!

Observed inflows

Forecast on April 1

Our volunteer's results

q

120

100
80
60

q

55

40
20

q

q

0
M

q

18

5

22

120

80
70

60

58

40

36

q

M

J

J

42
28

20
0

A

700

110

100

M

A

q

500

q

300

19

12
10
8

5

Reservoir volume

120

Forecast inflow volume

Inflows in the reservoir

130

10

M

J

J

100
A

How did you like this experience as a decision-maker?

M

J

August
1st
It is April 1st.
The reservoir is at 450 M m3
You are given the inflow forecasts on April 1st.
Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3
140

130

Forecast inflow volume

110
100
80
70
58

60
40

42

36

28
20
q

0
M

19

12
10
8

5

A

10

M

J

Forecast issued on the previous month

120
max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)

J

Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st.
If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired.

NEXT
140

It is April 1st.

130

Forecast issued on the previous month

120

Forecast inflow volume

110

And our volunteer?
Let’s see which release option
our volunteer will choose.

100
80
70
58

60
40

36

28
20
q

0
M

Option A
37

Release

38

35

Reservoir volume

700

55

58

5

A

60

M

57

J

J

17

23

29

25

A

M

J

J

700

500
q

10

Option C

700

500

19

12
10
8

Option B
45

42

500
q

q

300

300

300

100

100

100

A

M
q

J

J

A

M

J

J

Current reservoir volume
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)
April has gone by.
April inflow was: 18 M m3
You can update your reservoir volume:
The volume on May 1st is:
April 1 volume + 18 M m3 - April release = ?

Did you overtop your reservoir?
NO, I still have my job.
YES, I got fired...

What about our volunteer?
April has gone by.
April inflow was: 18 M m3
Our volunteer’s April release was: 55 M m3
The volume on May 1st is therefore:
450 M m3 +18 M m3 -55 M m3 = 413 M m3

No overtop!

The volunteer still has a job!
Let’s go to the next forecast!
Previous decisions: B

It is May 1st.
The reservoir is at 413 M m3
You are given the inflow forecasts on May 1st.
Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3

Forecast inflow volume

100
92
85

80

60

65

56

40

36

20

q

q

0
M

35

22

18

18

Forecast issued on the previous month

120

120

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)

5

A

M

J

J

Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st.
If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired.

NEXT
Previous decisions: B

Forecast inflow volume

It is May 1st.
And our volunteer?
Let’s see which release option
our volunteer will choose.

100
92
85

80

60

40

36

20

q

q

M

59

Release

56

45

A

22

18

18

M

J

J

Option C
46

39

26

700
Reservoir volume

35

5

Option B
60

65

56

0

Option A

Forecast issued on the previous month

120

120

700

500

25

M

J

J

700

500

24

500

q

q

q

300

300

300

100

100

100

M
q

J

J

M

J

J

Current reservoir volume
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)
May has gone by.
May inflow was: 55 M m3
You can update your reservoir volume:
The volume on June 1st is:
May 1 volume + 55 M m3 - May release = ?

Did you overtop your reservoir?
NO, I still have my job.
YES, I got fired...

What about our volunteer?
May has gone by.
May inflow was: 55 M m3
Our volunteer’s May release was: 45 M m3
The volume on June 1st is therefore:
413 M m3 +55 M m3 -45 M m3 = 423 M m3

No overtop!

The volunteer still has a job!
Let’s go to the next forecast!
Previous decisions: B B

It is June 1st.
The reservoir is at 423 M m3
You are given the inflow forecasts on June 1st.
Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3
110

Forecast inflow volume

92
80

79

60
q

55

52

40
35
20

q

q

23

18

5

Forecast issued on the previous month

100
max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)

0
M

A

M

J

J

Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st.
If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired.

NEXT
Previous decisions: B B
110

It is June 1st.

100

Let’s see which release option
our volunteer will choose.

80

Forecast issued on the previous month

And our volunteer?

Forecast inflow volume

92
79

60
55

q

52

40
35
20

q

q

23

18

5

0
M

Option A

A

Option B
28

Release

30

J

J

Option C
60

50

45

700
Reservoir volume

M

700

500

J

J

700

500

35

500

q

q

q

300

300

300

100

100

100

J
q

J

J

J

Current reservoir volume
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)
June has gone by.
June inflow was: 120 M m3
You can update your reservoir volume:
The volume on July 1st is:
June 1 volume + 120 M m3 - June release = ?

Did you overtop your reservoir?
NO, I still have my job.
YES, I got fired...

What about our volunteer?
June has gone by.
June inflow was: 120 M m3
Our volunteer’s June release was: 28 M m3
The volume on July 1st is therefore:
423 M m3 +120 M m3 -28 M m3 = 515 M m3

Overtop!

The volunteer got fired!
Can it be fixed?
Previous decisions: B B A

It is July 1st.
The reservoir is at 515 M m3
You are given the inflow forecasts on July 1st.
Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3
q

120

100

80

60
q

55

40
28
20

q

q

0
M

21
19

18

Forecast issued on the previous month

Forecast inflow volume

120

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)

5

A

M

J

J

Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st.
If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired.

NEXT
Previous decisions: B B A

And our volunteer?
Let’s see which release option
our volunteer will choose.

Forecast inflow volume

It is July 1st.

q

100

80

60

40
28
20

q

q

M

Reservoir volume

q

M

J

J

25
700

500

A

Option C

60

700

21
19

18

5

Option B

Release

55

q

0

Option A

120

500

Forecast issued on the previous month

120

40
700

q

500

300

300

300

100

100

q

100

J
q

J

Current reservoir volume
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast

J

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)
July has gone by.
July inflow was: 22 M m3
You can update your reservoir volume:
The volume on August 1st is:
July 1 volume + 22 M m3 - July release = ?

Did you overtop your reservoir?
NO, I still have my job.
YES, I got fired...

What about our volunteer?
July has gone by.
July inflow was: 22 M m3
Our volunteer’s July release was: 60 M m3
The volume on August 1st is therefore:
515 M m3 +22 M m3 -60 M m3 = 477 M m3

No overtop!

The volunteer got the job back!
NEXT
Previous decisions: B B A A

GAME OVER
August 1st has arrived.
If you did not overtop the reservoir, you still have a job and you are hired for the next season!

Observed inflows

Forecast on April 1

Our volunteer's results

q

120

100
80
60

q

55

40
20

q

q

0
M

q

18

5

22

120

80
70

60

58

40

36

q

M

J

J

42
28

20
0

A

700

110

100

M

A

q

500

q

300

19

12
10
8

5

Reservoir volume

120

Forecast inflow volume

Inflows in the reservoir

130

10

M

J

J

100
A

How did you like this experience as a decision-maker?

M

J

August
1st
It is April 1st.
The reservoir is at 450 M m3
You are given the inflow forecasts on April 1st.
Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3
140

130

Forecast inflow volume

110
100
80
70
58

60
40

42

36

28
20
q

0
M

19

12
10
8

5

A

10

M

J

Forecast issued on the previous month

120
max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)

J

Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st.
If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired.

NEXT
140

It is April 1st.

130

Forecast issued on the previous month

120

Forecast inflow volume

110

And our volunteer?
Let’s see which release option
our volunteer will choose.

100
80
70
58

60
40

36

28
20
q

0
M

Option A
37

Release

38

35

Reservoir volume

700

55

58

5

A

60

M

57

J

J

17

23

29

25

A

M

J

J

700

500
q

10

Option C

700

500

19

12
10
8

Option B
45

42

500
q

q

300

300

300

100

100

100

A

M
q

J

J

A

M

J

J

Current reservoir volume
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)
April has gone by.
April inflow was: 18 M m3
You can update your reservoir volume:
The volume on May 1st is:
April 1 volume + 18 M m3 - April release = ?

Did you overtop your reservoir?
NO, I still have my job.
YES, I got fired...

What about our volunteer?
April has gone by.
April inflow was: 18 M m3
Our volunteer’s April release was: 17 M m3
The volume on May 1st is therefore:
450 M m3 +18 M m3 -17 M m3 = 451 M m3

No overtop!

The volunteer still has a job!
Let’s go to the next forecast!
Previous decisions: C

It is May 1st.
The reservoir is at 451 M m3
You are given the inflow forecasts on May 1st.
Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3

Forecast inflow volume

100
92
85

80

60

65

56

40

36

20

q

q

0
M

35

22

18

18

Forecast issued on the previous month

120

120

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)

5

A

M

J

J

Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st.
If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired.

NEXT
Previous decisions: C

Forecast inflow volume

It is May 1st.
And our volunteer?
Let’s see which release option
our volunteer will choose.

100
92
85

80

60

40

36

20

q

q

M

59

Release

56

Reservoir volume

700

500

45

500

22

18

18

A

M

J

J

Option C
46

39

700

q

35

5

Option B
60

65

56

0

Option A

Forecast issued on the previous month

120

120

26

24

25

M

J

J

700

500

q

300

300

300

100

100

q

100

M
q

J

J

M

J

J

Current reservoir volume
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)
May has gone by.
May inflow was: 55 M m3
You can update your reservoir volume:
The volume on June 1st is:
May 1 volume + 55 M m3 - May release = ?

Did you overtop your reservoir?
NO, I still have my job.
YES, I got fired...

What about our volunteer?
May has gone by.
May inflow was: 55 M m3
Our volunteer’s May release was: 45 M m3
The volume on June 1st is therefore:
451 M m3 +55 M m3 -45 M m3 = 461 M m3

No overtop!

The volunteer still has a job!
Let’s go to the next forecast!
Previous decisions: C B

It is June 1st.
The reservoir is at 461 M m3
You are given the inflow forecasts on June 1st.
Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3
110

Forecast inflow volume

92
80

79

60
q

55

52

40
35
20

q

q

23

18

5

Forecast issued on the previous month

100
max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)

0
M

A

M

J

J

Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st.
If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired.

NEXT
Previous decisions: C B
110

It is June 1st.

100

Let’s see which release option
our volunteer will choose.

80

Forecast issued on the previous month

And our volunteer?

Forecast inflow volume

92
79

60
55

q

52

40
35
20

q

q

23

18

5

0
M

Option A

Option B
28

Release

30

Reservoir volume

700

60

500

q

M

J

J

Option C
50

700

500

A

45

35

J

J

700

500

q

300

300

300

100

100

q

100

J
q

J

J

J

Current reservoir volume
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)
June has gone by.
June inflow was: 120 M m3
You can update your reservoir volume:
The volume on July 1st is:
June 1 volume + 120 M m3 - June release = ?

Did you overtop your reservoir?
NO, I still have my job.
YES, I got fired...

What about our volunteer?
June has gone by.
June inflow was: 120 M m3
Our volunteer’s June release was: 28 M m3
The volume on July 1st is therefore:
461 M m3 +120 M m3 -28 M m3 = 553 M m3

Overtop!

The volunteer got fired!
Can it be fixed?
Previous decisions: C B A

It is July 1st.
The reservoir is at 553 M m3
You are given the inflow forecasts on July 1st.
Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3
q

120

100

80

60
q

55

40
28
20

q

q

0
M

21
19

18

Forecast issued on the previous month

Forecast inflow volume

120

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)

5

A

M

J

J

Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st.
If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired.

NEXT
Previous decisions: C B A

And our volunteer?
Let’s see which release option
our volunteer will choose.

Forecast inflow volume

It is July 1st.

q

100

80

60

40
28
20

q

q

M

Reservoir volume

A

M

J

J

Option C

60

700

21
19

18

5

Option B

Release

55

q

0

Option A

120

25
700

q

Forecast issued on the previous month

120

40
700

q

q

500

500

500

300

300

300

100

100

100

J
q

J

Current reservoir volume
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast

J

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)
July has gone by.
July inflow was: 22 M m3
You can update your reservoir volume:
The volume on August 1st is:
July 1 volume + 22 M m3 - July release = ?

Did you overtop your reservoir?
NO, I still have my job.
YES, I got fired...

What about our volunteer?
July has gone by.
July inflow was: 22 M m3
Our volunteer’s July release was: 60 M m3
The volume on August 1st is therefore:
553 M m3 +22 M m3 -60 M m3 = 515 M m3

Overtop!

The volunteer did not get the job back!
NEXT
Previous decisions: C B A A

GAME OVER
August 1st has arrived.
If you did not overtop the reservoir, you still have a job and you are hired for the next season!

Observed inflows

Forecast on April 1

Our volunteer's results

q

120

100
80
60

q

55

40
20

q

q

0
M

q

18

5

22

120

80
70

60

58

40

36

q

M

J

J

42
28

20
0

A

700

110

100

M

A

q

500

q
q

300

19

12
10
8

5

Reservoir volume

120

Forecast inflow volume

Inflows in the reservoir

130

10

M

J

J

100
A

How did you like this experience as a decision-maker?

M

J

August
1st
It is April 1st.
The reservoir is at 450 M m3
You are given the inflow forecasts on April 1st.
Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3
140

130

Forecast inflow volume

110
100
80
70
58

60
40

42

36

28
20
q

0
M

19

12
10
8

5

A

10

M

J

Forecast issued on the previous month

120
max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)

J

Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st.
If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired.

NEXT
140

It is April 1st.

130

Forecast issued on the previous month

120

Forecast inflow volume

110

And our volunteer?
Let’s see which release option
our volunteer will choose.

100
80
70
58

60
40

36

28
20
q

0
M

Option A
37

Release

38

35

Reservoir volume

700

55

58

5

A

60

M

57

J

J

17

23

29

25

A

M

J

J

700

500
q

10

Option C

700

500

19

12
10
8

Option B
45

42

500
q

q

300

300

300

100

100

100

A

M
q

J

J

A

M

J

J

Current reservoir volume
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)
April has gone by.
April inflow was: 18 M m3
You can update your reservoir volume:
The volume on May 1st is:
April 1 volume + 18 M m3 - April release = ?

Did you overtop your reservoir?
NO, I still have my job.
YES, I got fired...

What about our volunteer?
April has gone by.
April inflow was: 18 M m3
Our volunteer’s April release was: 37 M m3
The volume on May 1st is therefore:
450 M m3 +18 M m3 -37 M m3 = 431 M m3

No overtop!

The volunteer still has a job!
Let’s go to the next forecast!
Previous decisions: A

It is May 1st.
The reservoir is at 431 M m3
You are given the inflow forecasts on May 1st.
Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3

Forecast inflow volume

100
92
85

80

60

65

56

40

36

20

q

q

0
M

35

22

18

18

Forecast issued on the previous month

120

120

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)

5

A

M

J

J

Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st.
If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired.

NEXT
Previous decisions: A

Forecast inflow volume

It is May 1st.
And our volunteer?
Let’s see which release option
our volunteer will choose.

100
92
85

80

60

40

36

20

q

q

M

59

Release

56

45

A

22

18

18

M

J

J

Option C
46

39

26

700
Reservoir volume

35

5

Option B
60

65

56

0

Option A

Forecast issued on the previous month

120

120

700

500

25

M

J

J

700

500

24

500

q

q

q

300

300

300

100

100

100

M
q

J

J

M

J

J

Current reservoir volume
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)
May has gone by.
May inflow was: 55 M m3
You can update your reservoir volume:
The volume on June 1st is:
May 1 volume + 55 M m3 - May release = ?

Did you overtop your reservoir?
NO, I still have my job.
YES, I got fired...

What about our volunteer?
May has gone by.
May inflow was: 55 M m3
Our volunteer’s May release was: 26 M m3
The volume on June 1st is therefore:
431 M m3 +55 M m3 -26 M m3 = 460 M m3

No overtop!

The volunteer still has a job!
Let’s go to the next forecast!
Previous decisions: A C

It is June 1st.
The reservoir is at 460 M m3
You are given the inflow forecasts on June 1st.
Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3
110

Forecast inflow volume

92
80

79

60
q

55

52

40
35
20

q

q

23

18

5

Forecast issued on the previous month

100
max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)

0
M

A

M

J

J

Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st.
If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired.

NEXT
Previous decisions: A C
110

It is June 1st.

100

Let’s see which release option
our volunteer will choose.

80

Forecast issued on the previous month

And our volunteer?

Forecast inflow volume

92
79

60
55

q

52

40
35
20

q

q

23

18

5

0
M

Option A

Option B
28

Release

30

Reservoir volume

700

60

500

q

M

J

J

Option C
50

700

500

A

45

35

J

J

700

500

q

300

300

300

100

100

q

100

J
q

J

J

J

Current reservoir volume
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)
June has gone by.
June inflow was: 120 M m3
You can update your reservoir volume:
The volume on July 1st is:
June 1 volume + 120 M m3 - June release = ?

Did you overtop your reservoir?
NO, I still have my job.
YES, I got fired...

What about our volunteer?
June has gone by.
June inflow was: 120 M m3
Our volunteer’s June release was: 28 M m3
The volume on July 1st is therefore:
460 M m3 +120 M m3 -28 M m3 = 552 M m3

Overtop!

The volunteer got fired!
Can it be fixed?
Previous decisions: A C A

It is July 1st.
The reservoir is at 552 M m3
You are given the inflow forecasts on July 1st.
Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3
q

120

100

80

60
q

55

40
28
20

q

q

0
M

21
19

18

Forecast issued on the previous month

Forecast inflow volume

120

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)

5

A

M

J

J

Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st.
If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired.

NEXT
Previous decisions: A C A

And our volunteer?
Let’s see which release option
our volunteer will choose.

Forecast inflow volume

It is July 1st.

q

100

80

60

40
28
20

q

q

M

Reservoir volume

A

M

J

J

Option C

60

700

21
19

18

5

Option B

Release

55

q

0

Option A

120

25
700

q

Forecast issued on the previous month

120

40
700

q

q

500

500

500

300

300

300

100

100

100

J
q

J

Current reservoir volume
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast

J

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)
July has gone by.
July inflow was: 22 M m3
You can update your reservoir volume:
The volume on August 1st is:
July 1 volume + 22 M m3 - July release = ?

Did you overtop your reservoir?
NO, I still have my job.
YES, I got fired...

What about our volunteer?
July has gone by.
July inflow was: 22 M m3
Our volunteer’s July release was: 60 M m3
The volume on August 1st is therefore:
552 M m3 +22 M m3 -60 M m3 = 514 M m3

Overtop!

The volunteer did not get the job back!
NEXT
Previous decisions: A C A A

GAME OVER
August 1st has arrived.
If you did not overtop the reservoir, you still have a job and you are hired for the next season!

Observed inflows

Forecast on April 1

Our volunteer's results

q

120

100
80
60

q

55

40
20

q

q

0
M

q

18

5

22

120

80
70

60

58

40

36

q

M

J

J

42
28

20
0

A

700

110

100

M

A

q

500

q
q

300

19

12
10
8

5

Reservoir volume

120

Forecast inflow volume

Inflows in the reservoir

130

10

M

J

J

100
A

How did you like this experience as a decision-maker?

M

J

August
1st
It is April 1st.
The reservoir is at 450 M m3
You are given the inflow forecasts on April 1st.
Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3
140

130

Forecast inflow volume

110
100
80
70
58

60
40

42

36

28
20
q

0
M

19

12
10
8

5

A

10

M

J

Forecast issued on the previous month

120
max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)

J

Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st.
If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired.

NEXT
140

It is April 1st.

130

Forecast issued on the previous month

120

Forecast inflow volume

110

And our volunteer?
Let’s see which release option
our volunteer will choose.

100
80
70
58

60
40

36

28
20
q

0
M

Option A
37

Release

38

35

Reservoir volume

700

55

58

5

A

60

M

57

J

J

17

23

29

25

A

M

J

J

700

500
q

10

Option C

700

500

19

12
10
8

Option B
45

42

500
q

q

300

300

300

100

100

100

A

M
q

J

J

A

M

J

J

Current reservoir volume
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)
April has gone by.
April inflow was: 18 M m3
You can update your reservoir volume:
The volume on May 1st is:
April 1 volume + 18 M m3 - April release = ?

Did you overtop your reservoir?
NO, I still have my job.
YES, I got fired...

What about our volunteer?
April has gone by.
April inflow was: 18 M m3
Our volunteer’s April release was: 55 M m3
The volume on May 1st is therefore:
450 M m3 +18 M m3 -55 M m3 = 413 M m3

No overtop!

The volunteer still has a job!
Let’s go to the next forecast!
Previous decisions: B

It is May 1st.
The reservoir is at 413 M m3
You are given the inflow forecasts on May 1st.
Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3

Forecast inflow volume

100
92
85

80

60

65

56

40

36

20

q

q

0
M

35

22

18

18

Forecast issued on the previous month

120

120

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)

5

A

M

J

J

Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st.
If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired.

NEXT
Previous decisions: B

Forecast inflow volume

It is May 1st.
And our volunteer?
Let’s see which release option
our volunteer will choose.

100
92
85

80

60

40

36

20

q

q

M

59

Release

56

45

A

22

18

18

M

J

J

Option C
46

39

26

700
Reservoir volume

35

5

Option B
60

65

56

0

Option A

Forecast issued on the previous month

120

120

700

500

25

M

J

J

700

500

24

500

q

q

q

300

300

300

100

100

100

M
q

J

J

M

J

J

Current reservoir volume
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)
May has gone by.
May inflow was: 55 M m3
You can update your reservoir volume:
The volume on June 1st is:
May 1 volume + 55 M m3 - May release = ?

Did you overtop your reservoir?
NO, I still have my job.
YES, I got fired...

What about our volunteer?
May has gone by.
May inflow was: 55 M m3
Our volunteer’s May release was: 26 M m3
The volume on June 1st is therefore:
413 M m3 +55 M m3 -26 M m3 = 442 M m3

No overtop!

The volunteer still has a job!
Let’s go to the next forecast!
Previous decisions: B C

It is June 1st.
The reservoir is at 442 M m3
You are given the inflow forecasts on June 1st.
Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3
110

Forecast inflow volume

92
80

79

60
q

55

52

40
35
20

q

q

23

18

5

Forecast issued on the previous month

100
max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)

0
M

A

M

J

J

Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st.
If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired.

NEXT
Previous decisions: B C
110

It is June 1st.

100

Let’s see which release option
our volunteer will choose.

80

Forecast issued on the previous month

And our volunteer?

Forecast inflow volume

92
79

60
55

q

52

40
35
20

q

q

23

18

5

0
M

Option A

Option B
28

Release

30

700
Reservoir volume

A

60

J

50

45

35

J

J

700

500
q

J

Option C

700

500

M

500
q

q

300

300

300

100

100

100

J
q

J

J

J

Current reservoir volume
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)
June has gone by.
June inflow was: 120 M m3
You can update your reservoir volume:
The volume on July 1st is:
June 1 volume + 120 M m3 - June release = ?

Did you overtop your reservoir?
NO, I still have my job.
YES, I got fired...

What about our volunteer?
June has gone by.
June inflow was: 120 M m3
Our volunteer’s June release was: 28 M m3
The volume on July 1st is therefore:
442 M m3 +120 M m3 -28 M m3 = 534 M m3

Overtop!

The volunteer got fired!
Can it be fixed?
Previous decisions: B C A

It is July 1st.
The reservoir is at 534 M m3
You are given the inflow forecasts on July 1st.
Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3
q

120

100

80

60
q

55

40
28
20

q

q

0
M

21
19

18

Forecast issued on the previous month

Forecast inflow volume

120

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)

5

A

M

J

J

Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st.
If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired.

NEXT
Previous decisions: B C A

And our volunteer?
Let’s see which release option
our volunteer will choose.

Forecast inflow volume

It is July 1st.

q

100

80

60

40
28
20

q

q

M

Reservoir volume

q

M

J

J

25
700

500

A

Option C

60

700

21
19

18

5

Option B

Release

55

q

0

Option A

120

500

Forecast issued on the previous month

120

40
700

q

500

300

300

300

100

100

q

100

J
q

J

Current reservoir volume
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast

J

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)
July has gone by.
July inflow was: 22 M m3
You can update your reservoir volume:
The volume on August 1st is:
July 1 volume + 22 M m3 - July release = ?

Did you overtop your reservoir?
NO, I still have my job.
YES, I got fired...

What about our volunteer?
July has gone by.
July inflow was: 22 M m3
Our volunteer’s July release was: 60 M m3
The volume on August 1st is therefore:
534 M m3 +22 M m3 -60 M m3 = 496 M m3

No overtop!

The volunteer got the job back!
NEXT
Previous decisions: B C A A

GAME OVER
August 1st has arrived.
If you did not overtop the reservoir, you still have a job and you are hired for the next season!

Observed inflows

Forecast on April 1

Our volunteer's results

q

120

100
80
60

q

55

40
20

q

q

0
M

q

18

5

22

120

80
70

60

58

40

36

q

M

J

J

42
28

20
0

A

700

110

100

M

A

q

500

q

300

19

12
10
8

5

Reservoir volume

120

Forecast inflow volume

Inflows in the reservoir

130

10

M

J

J

100
A

How did you like this experience as a decision-maker?

M

J

August
1st
It is April 1st.
The reservoir is at 450 M m3
You are given the inflow forecasts on April 1st.
Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3
140

130

Forecast inflow volume

110
100
80
70
58

60
40

42

36

28
20
q

0
M

19

12
10
8

5

A

10

M

J

Forecast issued on the previous month

120
max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)

J

Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st.
If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired.

NEXT
140

It is April 1st.

130

Forecast issued on the previous month

120

Forecast inflow volume

110

And our volunteer?
Let’s see which release option
our volunteer will choose.

100
80
70
58

60
40

36

28
20
q

0
M

Option A
37

Release

38

35

Reservoir volume

700

55

58

5

A

60

M

57

J

J

17

23

29

25

A

M

J

J

700

500
q

10

Option C

700

500

19

12
10
8

Option B
45

42

500
q

q

300

300

300

100

100

100

A

M
q

J

J

A

M

J

J

Current reservoir volume
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)
April has gone by.
April inflow was: 18 M m3
You can update your reservoir volume:
The volume on May 1st is:
April 1 volume + 18 M m3 - April release = ?

Did you overtop your reservoir?
NO, I still have my job.
YES, I got fired...

What about our volunteer?
April has gone by.
April inflow was: 18 M m3
Our volunteer’s April release was: 17 M m3
The volume on May 1st is therefore:
450 M m3 +18 M m3 -17 M m3 = 451 M m3

No overtop!

The volunteer still has a job!
Let’s go to the next forecast!
Previous decisions: C

It is May 1st.
The reservoir is at 451 M m3
You are given the inflow forecasts on May 1st.
Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3

Forecast inflow volume

100
92
85

80

60

65

56

40

36

20

q

q

0
M

35

22

18

18

Forecast issued on the previous month

120

120

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)

5

A

M

J

J

Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st.
If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired.

NEXT
Previous decisions: C

Forecast inflow volume

It is May 1st.
And our volunteer?
Let’s see which release option
our volunteer will choose.

100
92
85

80

60

40

36

20

q

q

M

59

Release

56

Reservoir volume

700

500

45

500

22

18

18

A

M

J

J

Option C
46

39

700

q

35

5

Option B
60

65

56

0

Option A

Forecast issued on the previous month

120

120

26

24

25

M

J

J

700

500

q

300

300

300

100

100

q

100

M
q

J

J

M

J

J

Current reservoir volume
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)
May has gone by.
May inflow was: 55 M m3
You can update your reservoir volume:
The volume on June 1st is:
May 1 volume + 55 M m3 - May release = ?

Did you overtop your reservoir?
NO, I still have my job.
YES, I got fired...

What about our volunteer?
May has gone by.
May inflow was: 55 M m3
Our volunteer’s May release was: 26 M m3
The volume on June 1st is therefore:
451 M m3 +55 M m3 -26 M m3 = 480 M m3

No overtop!

The volunteer still has a job!
Let’s go to the next forecast!
Previous decisions: C C

It is June 1st.
The reservoir is at 480 M m3
You are given the inflow forecasts on June 1st.
Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3
110

Forecast inflow volume

92
80

79

60
q

55

52

40
35
20

q

q

23

18

5

Forecast issued on the previous month

100
max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)

0
M

A

M

J

J

Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st.
If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired.

NEXT
Previous decisions: C C
110

It is June 1st.

100

Let’s see which release option
our volunteer will choose.

80

Forecast issued on the previous month

And our volunteer?

Forecast inflow volume

92
79

60
55

q

52

40
35
20

q

q

23

18

5

0
M

Option A

Option B
28

Release

30

Reservoir volume

700

60

500

q

M

J

J

Option C
50

700

500

A

45

35

J

J

700

500

q

300

300

300

100

100

q

100

J
q

J

J

J

Current reservoir volume
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)
June has gone by.
June inflow was: 120 M m3
You can update your reservoir volume:
The volume on July 1st is:
June 1 volume + 120 M m3 - June release = ?

Did you overtop your reservoir?
NO, I still have my job.
YES, I got fired...

What about our volunteer?
June has gone by.
June inflow was: 120 M m3
Our volunteer’s June release was: 28 M m3
The volume on July 1st is therefore:
480 M m3 +120 M m3 -28 M m3 = 572 M m3

Overtop!

The volunteer got fired!
Can it be fixed?
Previous decisions: C C A

It is July 1st.
The reservoir is at 572 M m3
You are given the inflow forecasts on July 1st.
Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3
q

120

100

80

60
q

55

40
28
20

q

q

0
M

21
19

18

Forecast issued on the previous month

Forecast inflow volume

120

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)

5

A

M

J

J

Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st.
If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired.

NEXT
Previous decisions: C C A

And our volunteer?
Let’s see which release option
our volunteer will choose.

Forecast inflow volume

It is July 1st.

q

100

80

60

40
28
20

q

q

M

Reservoir volume

A

M

J

J

Option C

60

700

21
19

18

5

Option B

Release

55

q

0

Option A

120

25
700

q

Forecast issued on the previous month

120

40
700

q

q

500

500

500

300

300

300

100

100

100

J
q

J

Current reservoir volume
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast

J

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)
July has gone by.
July inflow was: 22 M m3
You can update your reservoir volume:
The volume on August 1st is:
July 1 volume + 22 M m3 - July release = ?

Did you overtop your reservoir?
NO, I still have my job.
YES, I got fired...

What about our volunteer?
July has gone by.
July inflow was: 22 M m3
Our volunteer’s July release was: 60 M m3
The volume on August 1st is therefore:
572 M m3 +22 M m3 -60 M m3 = 534 M m3

Overtop!

The volunteer did not get the job back!
NEXT
Previous decisions: C C A A

GAME OVER
August 1st has arrived.
If you did not overtop the reservoir, you still have a job and you are hired for the next season!

Observed inflows

Forecast on April 1

Our volunteer's results

q

120

100
80
60

q

55

40
20

q

q

0
M

q

18

5

22

120

80
70

60

58

40

36

q

M

J

J

42
28

20
0

A

700

110

100

M

A

q

500

q
q

300

19

12
10
8

5

Reservoir volume

120

Forecast inflow volume

Inflows in the reservoir

130

10

M

J

J

100
A

How did you like this experience as a decision-maker?

M

J

August
1st
It is April 1st.
The reservoir is at 450 M m3
You are given the inflow forecasts on April 1st.
Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3
140

130

Forecast inflow volume

110
100
80
70
58

60
40

42

36

28
20
q

0
M

19

12
10
8

5

A

10

M

J

Forecast issued on the previous month

120
max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)

J

Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st.
If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired.

NEXT
140

It is April 1st.

130

Forecast issued on the previous month

120

Forecast inflow volume

110

And our volunteer?
Let’s see which release option
our volunteer will choose.

100
80
70
58

60
40

36

28
20
q

0
M

Option A
37

Release

38

35

Reservoir volume

700

55

58

5

A

60

M

57

J

J

17

23

29

25

A

M

J

J

700

500
q

10

Option C

700

500

19

12
10
8

Option B
45

42

500
q

q

300

300

300

100

100

100

A

M
q

J

J

A

M

J

J

Current reservoir volume
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)
April has gone by.
April inflow was: 18 M m3
You can update your reservoir volume:
The volume on May 1st is:
April 1 volume + 18 M m3 - April release = ?

Did you overtop your reservoir?
NO, I still have my job.
YES, I got fired...

What about our volunteer?
April has gone by.
April inflow was: 18 M m3
Our volunteer’s April release was: 37 M m3
The volume on May 1st is therefore:
450 M m3 +18 M m3 -37 M m3 = 431 M m3

No overtop!

The volunteer still has a job!
Let’s go to the next forecast!
Previous decisions: A

It is May 1st.
The reservoir is at 431 M m3
You are given the inflow forecasts on May 1st.
Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3

Forecast inflow volume

100
92
85

80

60

65

56

40

36

20

q

q

0
M

35

22

18

18

Forecast issued on the previous month

120

120

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)

5

A

M

J

J

Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st.
If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired.

NEXT
Previous decisions: A

Forecast inflow volume

It is May 1st.
And our volunteer?
Let’s see which release option
our volunteer will choose.

100
92
85

80

60

40

36

20

q

q

M

59

Release

56

45

A

22

18

18

M

J

J

Option C
46

39

26

700
Reservoir volume

35

5

Option B
60

65

56

0

Option A

Forecast issued on the previous month

120

120

700

500

25

M

J

J

700

500

24

500

q

q

q

300

300

300

100

100

100

M
q

J

J

M

J

J

Current reservoir volume
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)
May has gone by.
May inflow was: 55 M m3
You can update your reservoir volume:
The volume on June 1st is:
May 1 volume + 55 M m3 - May release = ?

Did you overtop your reservoir?
NO, I still have my job.
YES, I got fired...

What about our volunteer?
May has gone by.
May inflow was: 55 M m3
Our volunteer’s May release was: 59 M m3
The volume on June 1st is therefore:
431 M m3 +55 M m3 -59 M m3 = 427 M m3

No overtop!

The volunteer still has a job!
Let’s go to the next forecast!
Previous decisions: A A

It is June 1st.
The reservoir is at 427 M m3
You are given the inflow forecasts on June 1st.
Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3
110

Forecast inflow volume

92
80

79

60
q

55

52

40
35
20

q

q

23

18

5

Forecast issued on the previous month

100
max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)

0
M

A

M

J

J

Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st.
If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired.

NEXT
Previous decisions: A A
110

It is June 1st.

100

Let’s see which release option
our volunteer will choose.

80

Forecast issued on the previous month

And our volunteer?

Forecast inflow volume

92
79

60
55

q

52

40
35
20

q

q

23

18

5

0
M

Option A

A

Option B
28

Release

30

J

J

Option C
60

50

45

700
Reservoir volume

M

700

500

J

J

700

500

35

500

q

q

q

300

300

300

100

100

100

J
q

J

J

J

Current reservoir volume
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)
June has gone by.
June inflow was: 120 M m3
You can update your reservoir volume:
The volume on July 1st is:
June 1 volume + 120 M m3 - June release = ?

Did you overtop your reservoir?
NO, I still have my job.
YES, I got fired...

What about our volunteer?
June has gone by.
June inflow was: 120 M m3
Our volunteer’s June release was: 60 M m3
The volume on July 1st is therefore:
427 M m3 +120 M m3 -60 M m3 = 487 M m3

No overtop!

The volunteer still has a job!
Let’s go to the next forecast!
Previous decisions: A A B

It is July 1st.
The reservoir is at 487 M m3
You are given the inflow forecasts on July 1st.
Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3
q

120

100

80

60
q

55

40
28
20

q

q

0
M

21
19

18

Forecast issued on the previous month

Forecast inflow volume

120

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)

5

A

M

J

J

Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st.
If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired.

NEXT
Previous decisions: A A B

And our volunteer?
Let’s see which release option
our volunteer will choose.

Forecast inflow volume

It is July 1st.

q

100

80

60

40
28
20

q

q

M

Reservoir volume

500

q

M

J

J

25
700

500

A

Option C

60

700

21
19

18

5

Option B

Release

55

q

0

Option A

120
Forecast issued on the previous month

120

40
700

500

q

300

300

300

100

100

q

100

J
q

J

Current reservoir volume
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast

J

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)
July has gone by.
July inflow was: 22 M m3
You can update your reservoir volume:
The volume on August 1st is:
July 1 volume + 22 M m3 - July release = ?

Did you overtop your reservoir?
NO, I still have my job.
YES, I got fired...

What about our volunteer?
July has gone by.
July inflow was: 22 M m3
Our volunteer’s July release was: 60 M m3
The volume on August 1st is therefore:
487 M m3 +22 M m3 -60 M m3 = 449 M m3

No overtop!

The volunteer still has a job!
NEXT
Previous decisions: A A B A

GAME OVER
August 1st has arrived.
If you did not overtop the reservoir, you still have a job and you are hired for the next season!

Observed inflows

Forecast on April 1

Our volunteer's results

q

120

100
80
60

q

55

40
20

q

q

0
M

q

18

5

22

120

80
70

60

58

40

36

q

M

J

J

42
28

20
0

A

700

110

100

M

A

500

q

300

19

12
10
8

5

Reservoir volume

120

Forecast inflow volume

Inflows in the reservoir

130

10

M

J

J

100
A

How did you like this experience as a decision-maker?

M

J

August
1st
It is April 1st.
The reservoir is at 450 M m3
You are given the inflow forecasts on April 1st.
Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3
140

130

Forecast inflow volume

110
100
80
70
58

60
40

42

36

28
20
q

0
M

19

12
10
8

5

A

10

M

J

Forecast issued on the previous month

120
max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)

J

Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st.
If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired.

NEXT
140

It is April 1st.

130

Forecast issued on the previous month

120

Forecast inflow volume

110

And our volunteer?
Let’s see which release option
our volunteer will choose.

100
80
70
58

60
40

36

28
20
q

0
M

Option A
37

Release

38

35

Reservoir volume

700

55

58

5

A

60

M

57

J

J

17

23

29

25

A

M

J

J

700

500
q

10

Option C

700

500

19

12
10
8

Option B
45

42

500
q

q

300

300

300

100

100

100

A

M
q

J

J

A

M

J

J

Current reservoir volume
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)
April has gone by.
April inflow was: 18 M m3
You can update your reservoir volume:
The volume on May 1st is:
April 1 volume + 18 M m3 - April release = ?

Did you overtop your reservoir?
NO, I still have my job.
YES, I got fired...

What about our volunteer?
April has gone by.
April inflow was: 18 M m3
Our volunteer’s April release was: 55 M m3
The volume on May 1st is therefore:
450 M m3 +18 M m3 -55 M m3 = 413 M m3

No overtop!

The volunteer still has a job!
Let’s go to the next forecast!
Previous decisions: B

It is May 1st.
The reservoir is at 413 M m3
You are given the inflow forecasts on May 1st.
Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3

Forecast inflow volume

100
92
85

80

60

65

56

40

36

20

q

q

0
M

35

22

18

18

Forecast issued on the previous month

120

120

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)

5

A

M

J

J

Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st.
If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired.

NEXT
Previous decisions: B

Forecast inflow volume

It is May 1st.
And our volunteer?
Let’s see which release option
our volunteer will choose.

100
92
85

80

60

40

36

20

q

q

M

59

Release

56

45

A

22

18

18

M

J

J

Option C
46

39

26

700
Reservoir volume

35

5

Option B
60

65

56

0

Option A

Forecast issued on the previous month

120

120

700

500

25

M

J

J

700

500

24

500

q

q

q

300

300

300

100

100

100

M
q

J

J

M

J

J

Current reservoir volume
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)
May has gone by.
May inflow was: 55 M m3
You can update your reservoir volume:
The volume on June 1st is:
May 1 volume + 55 M m3 - May release = ?

Did you overtop your reservoir?
NO, I still have my job.
YES, I got fired...

What about our volunteer?
May has gone by.
May inflow was: 55 M m3
Our volunteer’s May release was: 59 M m3
The volume on June 1st is therefore:
413 M m3 +55 M m3 -59 M m3 = 409 M m3

No overtop!

The volunteer still has a job!
Let’s go to the next forecast!
Previous decisions: B A

It is June 1st.
The reservoir is at 409 M m3
You are given the inflow forecasts on June 1st.
Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3
110

Forecast inflow volume

92
80

79

60
q

55

52

40
35
20

q

q

23

18

5

Forecast issued on the previous month

100
max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)

0
M

A

M

J

J

Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st.
If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired.

NEXT
Previous decisions: B A
110

It is June 1st.

100

Let’s see which release option
our volunteer will choose.

80

Forecast issued on the previous month

And our volunteer?

Forecast inflow volume

92
79

60
55

q

52

40
35
20

q

q

23

18

5

0
M

Option A

A

Option B
28

Release

30

J

J

Option C
60

50

45

700
Reservoir volume

M

700

500

J

J

700

500

35

500

q

q

q

300

300

300

100

100

100

J
q

J

J

J

Current reservoir volume
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)
June has gone by.
June inflow was: 120 M m3
You can update your reservoir volume:
The volume on July 1st is:
June 1 volume + 120 M m3 - June release = ?

Did you overtop your reservoir?
NO, I still have my job.
YES, I got fired...

What about our volunteer?
June has gone by.
June inflow was: 120 M m3
Our volunteer’s June release was: 60 M m3
The volume on July 1st is therefore:
409 M m3 +120 M m3 -60 M m3 = 469 M m3

No overtop!

The volunteer still has a job!
Let’s go to the next forecast!
Previous decisions: B A B

It is July 1st.
The reservoir is at 469 M m3
You are given the inflow forecasts on July 1st.
Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3
q

120

100

80

60
q

55

40
28
20

q

q

0
M

21
19

18

Forecast issued on the previous month

Forecast inflow volume

120

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)

5

A

M

J

J

Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st.
If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired.

NEXT
Previous decisions: B A B

And our volunteer?
Let’s see which release option
our volunteer will choose.

Forecast inflow volume

It is July 1st.

q

100

80

60

40
28
20

q

q

M

Reservoir volume

500

q

M

J

J

25
700

500

A

Option C

60

700

21
19

18

5

Option B

Release

55

q

0

Option A

120
Forecast issued on the previous month

120

40
700

500

q

300

300

300

100

100

q

100

J
q

J

Current reservoir volume
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast

J

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)
July has gone by.
July inflow was: 22 M m3
You can update your reservoir volume:
The volume on August 1st is:
July 1 volume + 22 M m3 - July release = ?

Did you overtop your reservoir?
NO, I still have my job.
YES, I got fired...

What about our volunteer?
July has gone by.
July inflow was: 22 M m3
Our volunteer’s July release was: 60 M m3
The volume on August 1st is therefore:
469 M m3 +22 M m3 -60 M m3 = 431 M m3

No overtop!

The volunteer still has a job!
NEXT
Previous decisions: B A B A

GAME OVER
August 1st has arrived.
If you did not overtop the reservoir, you still have a job and you are hired for the next season!

Observed inflows

Forecast on April 1

Our volunteer's results

q

120

100
80
60

q

55

40
20

q

q

0
M

q

18

5

22

120

80
70

60

58

40

36

q

M

J

J

42
28

20
0

A

700

110

100

M

A

500

q
300

19

12
10
8

5

Reservoir volume

120

Forecast inflow volume

Inflows in the reservoir

130

10

M

J

J

100
A

How did you like this experience as a decision-maker?

M

J

August
1st
It is April 1st.
The reservoir is at 450 M m3
You are given the inflow forecasts on April 1st.
Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3
140

130

Forecast inflow volume

110
100
80
70
58

60
40

42

36

28
20
q

0
M

19

12
10
8

5

A

10

M

J

Forecast issued on the previous month

120
max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)

J

Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st.
If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired.

NEXT
140

It is April 1st.

130

Forecast issued on the previous month

120

Forecast inflow volume

110

And our volunteer?
Let’s see which release option
our volunteer will choose.

100
80
70
58

60
40

36

28
20
q

0
M

Option A
37

Release

38

35

Reservoir volume

700

55

58

5

A

60

M

57

J

J

17

23

29

25

A

M

J

J

700

500
q

10

Option C

700

500

19

12
10
8

Option B
45

42

500
q

q

300

300

300

100

100

100

A

M
q

J

J

A

M

J

J

Current reservoir volume
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)
April has gone by.
April inflow was: 18 M m3
You can update your reservoir volume:
The volume on May 1st is:
April 1 volume + 18 M m3 - April release = ?

Did you overtop your reservoir?
NO, I still have my job.
YES, I got fired...

What about our volunteer?
April has gone by.
April inflow was: 18 M m3
Our volunteer’s April release was: 17 M m3
The volume on May 1st is therefore:
450 M m3 +18 M m3 -17 M m3 = 451 M m3

No overtop!

The volunteer still has a job!
Let’s go to the next forecast!
Previous decisions: C

It is May 1st.
The reservoir is at 451 M m3
You are given the inflow forecasts on May 1st.
Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3

Forecast inflow volume

100
92
85

80

60

65

56

40

36

20

q

q

0
M

35

22

18

18

Forecast issued on the previous month

120

120

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)

5

A

M

J

J

Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st.
If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired.

NEXT
Previous decisions: C

Forecast inflow volume

It is May 1st.
And our volunteer?
Let’s see which release option
our volunteer will choose.

100
92
85

80

60

40

36

20

q

q

M

59

Release

56

Reservoir volume

700

500

45

500

22

18

18

A

M

J

J

Option C
46

39

700

q

35

5

Option B
60

65

56

0

Option A

Forecast issued on the previous month

120

120

26

24

25

M

J

J

700

500

q

300

300

300

100

100

q

100

M
q

J

J

M

J

J

Current reservoir volume
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)
May has gone by.
May inflow was: 55 M m3
You can update your reservoir volume:
The volume on June 1st is:
May 1 volume + 55 M m3 - May release = ?

Did you overtop your reservoir?
NO, I still have my job.
YES, I got fired...

What about our volunteer?
May has gone by.
May inflow was: 55 M m3
Our volunteer’s May release was: 59 M m3
The volume on June 1st is therefore:
451 M m3 +55 M m3 -59 M m3 = 447 M m3

No overtop!

The volunteer still has a job!
Let’s go to the next forecast!
Previous decisions: C A

It is June 1st.
The reservoir is at 447 M m3
You are given the inflow forecasts on June 1st.
Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3
110

Forecast inflow volume

92
80

79

60
q

55

52

40
35
20

q

q

23

18

5

Forecast issued on the previous month

100
max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)

0
M

A

M

J

J

Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st.
If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired.

NEXT
Previous decisions: C A
110

It is June 1st.

100

Let’s see which release option
our volunteer will choose.

80

Forecast issued on the previous month

And our volunteer?

Forecast inflow volume

92
79

60
55

q

52

40
35
20

q

q

23

18

5

0
M

Option A

Option B
28

Release

30

700
Reservoir volume

A

60

J

50

45

35

J

J

700

500
q

J

Option C

700

500

M

500
q

q

300

300

300

100

100

100

J
q

J

J

J

Current reservoir volume
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)
June has gone by.
June inflow was: 120 M m3
You can update your reservoir volume:
The volume on July 1st is:
June 1 volume + 120 M m3 - June release = ?

Did you overtop your reservoir?
NO, I still have my job.
YES, I got fired...

What about our volunteer?
June has gone by.
June inflow was: 120 M m3
Our volunteer’s June release was: 60 M m3
The volume on July 1st is therefore:
447 M m3 +120 M m3 -60 M m3 = 507 M m3

Overtop!

The volunteer got fired!
Can it be fixed?
Previous decisions: C A B

It is July 1st.
The reservoir is at 507 M m3
You are given the inflow forecasts on July 1st.
Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3
q

120

100

80

60
q

55

40
28
20

q

q

0
M

21
19

18

Forecast issued on the previous month

Forecast inflow volume

120

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)

5

A

M

J

J

Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st.
If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired.

NEXT
Previous decisions: C A B

And our volunteer?
Let’s see which release option
our volunteer will choose.

Forecast inflow volume

It is July 1st.

q

100

80

60

40
28
20

q

q

M

Reservoir volume

q

M

J

J

25
700

500

A

Option C

60

700

21
19

18

5

Option B

Release

55

q

0

Option A

120

500

Forecast issued on the previous month

120

40
700

q

500

300

300

300

100

100

q

100

J
q

J

Current reservoir volume
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast

J

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)
July has gone by.
July inflow was: 22 M m3
You can update your reservoir volume:
The volume on August 1st is:
July 1 volume + 22 M m3 - July release = ?

Did you overtop your reservoir?
NO, I still have my job.
YES, I got fired...

What about our volunteer?
July has gone by.
July inflow was: 22 M m3
Our volunteer’s July release was: 60 M m3
The volume on August 1st is therefore:
507 M m3 +22 M m3 -60 M m3 = 469 M m3

No overtop!

The volunteer got the job back!
NEXT
Previous decisions: C A B A

GAME OVER
August 1st has arrived.
If you did not overtop the reservoir, you still have a job and you are hired for the next season!

Observed inflows

Forecast on April 1

Our volunteer's results

q

120

100
80
60

q

55

40
20

q

q

0
M

q

18

5

22

120

80
70

60

58

40

36

q

M

J

J

42
28

20
0

A

700

110

100

M

A

q

500

q

300

19

12
10
8

5

Reservoir volume

120

Forecast inflow volume

Inflows in the reservoir

130

10

M

J

J

100
A

How did you like this experience as a decision-maker?

M

J

August
1st
It is April 1st.
The reservoir is at 450 M m3
You are given the inflow forecasts on April 1st.
Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3
140

130

Forecast inflow volume

110
100
80
70
58

60
40

42

36

28
20
q

0
M

19

12
10
8

5

A

10

M

J

Forecast issued on the previous month

120
max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)

J

Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st.
If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired.

NEXT
140

It is April 1st.

130

Forecast issued on the previous month

120

Forecast inflow volume

110

And our volunteer?
Let’s see which release option
our volunteer will choose.

100
80
70
58

60
40

36

28
20
q

0
M

Option A
37

Release

38

35

Reservoir volume

700

55

58

5

A

60

M

57

J

J

17

23

29

25

A

M

J

J

700

500
q

10

Option C

700

500

19

12
10
8

Option B
45

42

500
q

q

300

300

300

100

100

100

A

M
q

J

J

A

M

J

J

Current reservoir volume
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)
April has gone by.
April inflow was: 18 M m3
You can update your reservoir volume:
The volume on May 1st is:
April 1 volume + 18 M m3 - April release = ?

Did you overtop your reservoir?
NO, I still have my job.
YES, I got fired...

What about our volunteer?
April has gone by.
April inflow was: 18 M m3
Our volunteer’s April release was: 37 M m3
The volume on May 1st is therefore:
450 M m3 +18 M m3 -37 M m3 = 431 M m3

No overtop!

The volunteer still has a job!
Let’s go to the next forecast!
Previous decisions: A

It is May 1st.
The reservoir is at 431 M m3
You are given the inflow forecasts on May 1st.
Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3

Forecast inflow volume

100
92
85

80

60

65

56

40

36

20

q

q

0
M

35

22

18

18

Forecast issued on the previous month

120

120

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)

5

A

M

J

J

Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st.
If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired.

NEXT
Previous decisions: A

Forecast inflow volume

It is May 1st.
And our volunteer?
Let’s see which release option
our volunteer will choose.

100
92
85

80

60

40

36

20

q

q

M

59

Release

56

45

A

22

18

18

M

J

J

Option C
46

39

26

700
Reservoir volume

35

5

Option B
60

65

56

0

Option A

Forecast issued on the previous month

120

120

700

500

25

M

J

J

700

500

24

500

q

q

q

300

300

300

100

100

100

M
q

J

J

M

J

J

Current reservoir volume
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)
May has gone by.
May inflow was: 55 M m3
You can update your reservoir volume:
The volume on June 1st is:
May 1 volume + 55 M m3 - May release = ?

Did you overtop your reservoir?
NO, I still have my job.
YES, I got fired...

What about our volunteer?
May has gone by.
May inflow was: 55 M m3
Our volunteer’s May release was: 45 M m3
The volume on June 1st is therefore:
431 M m3 +55 M m3 -45 M m3 = 441 M m3

No overtop!

The volunteer still has a job!
Let’s go to the next forecast!
Previous decisions: A B

It is June 1st.
The reservoir is at 441 M m3
You are given the inflow forecasts on June 1st.
Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3
110

Forecast inflow volume

92
80

79

60
q

55

52

40
35
20

q

q

23

18

5

Forecast issued on the previous month

100
max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)

0
M

A

M

J

J

Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st.
If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired.

NEXT
Previous decisions: A B
110

It is June 1st.

100

Let’s see which release option
our volunteer will choose.

80

Forecast issued on the previous month

And our volunteer?

Forecast inflow volume

92
79

60
55

q

52

40
35
20

q

q

23

18

5

0
M

Option A

Option B
28

Release

30

700
Reservoir volume

A

60

J

50

45

35

J

J

700

500
q

J

Option C

700

500

M

500
q

q

300

300

300

100

100

100

J
q

J

J

J

Current reservoir volume
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)
June has gone by.
June inflow was: 120 M m3
You can update your reservoir volume:
The volume on July 1st is:
June 1 volume + 120 M m3 - June release = ?

Did you overtop your reservoir?
NO, I still have my job.
YES, I got fired...

What about our volunteer?
June has gone by.
June inflow was: 120 M m3
Our volunteer’s June release was: 60 M m3
The volume on July 1st is therefore:
441 M m3 +120 M m3 -60 M m3 = 501 M m3

Overtop!

The volunteer got fired!
Can it be fixed?
Previous decisions: A B B

It is July 1st.
The reservoir is at 501 M m3
You are given the inflow forecasts on July 1st.
Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3
q

120

100

80

60
q

55

40
28
20

q

q

0
M

21
19

18

Forecast issued on the previous month

Forecast inflow volume

120

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)

5

A

M

J

J

Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st.
If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired.

NEXT
Previous decisions: A B B

And our volunteer?
Let’s see which release option
our volunteer will choose.

Forecast inflow volume

It is July 1st.

q

100

80

60

40
28
20

q

q

M

Reservoir volume

q

M

J

J

25
700

500

A

Option C

60

700

21
19

18

5

Option B

Release

55

q

0

Option A

120

500

Forecast issued on the previous month

120

40
700

q

500

300

300

300

100

100

q

100

J
q

J

Current reservoir volume
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast

J

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)
July has gone by.
July inflow was: 22 M m3
You can update your reservoir volume:
The volume on August 1st is:
July 1 volume + 22 M m3 - July release = ?

Did you overtop your reservoir?
NO, I still have my job.
YES, I got fired...

What about our volunteer?
July has gone by.
July inflow was: 22 M m3
Our volunteer’s July release was: 60 M m3
The volume on August 1st is therefore:
501 M m3 +22 M m3 -60 M m3 = 463 M m3

No overtop!

The volunteer got the job back!
NEXT
Previous decisions: A B B A

GAME OVER
August 1st has arrived.
If you did not overtop the reservoir, you still have a job and you are hired for the next season!

Observed inflows

Forecast on April 1

Our volunteer's results

q

120

100
80
60

q

55

40
20

q

q

0
M

q

18

5

22

120

80
70

60

58

40

36

q

M

J

J

42
28

20
0

A

700

110

100

M

A

500

q

q

300

19

12
10
8

5

Reservoir volume

120

Forecast inflow volume

Inflows in the reservoir

130

10

M

J

J

100
A

How did you like this experience as a decision-maker?

M

J

August
1st
It is April 1st.
The reservoir is at 450 M m3
You are given the inflow forecasts on April 1st.
Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3
140

130

Forecast inflow volume

110
100
80
70
58

60
40

42

36

28
20
q

0
M

19

12
10
8

5

A

10

M

J

Forecast issued on the previous month

120
max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)

J

Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st.
If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired.

NEXT
140

It is April 1st.

130

Forecast issued on the previous month

120

Forecast inflow volume

110

And our volunteer?
Let’s see which release option
our volunteer will choose.

100
80
70
58

60
40

36

28
20
q

0
M

Option A
37

Release

38

35

Reservoir volume

700

55

58

5

A

60

M

57

J

J

17

23

29

25

A

M

J

J

700

500
q

10

Option C

700

500

19

12
10
8

Option B
45

42

500
q

q

300

300

300

100

100

100

A

M
q

J

J

A

M

J

J

Current reservoir volume
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast
Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast

max (95%)

75%
50%
25%

min (5%)
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3
IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3

More Related Content

Recently uploaded

+971581248768>> SAFE AND ORIGINAL ABORTION PILLS FOR SALE IN DUBAI AND ABUDHA...
+971581248768>> SAFE AND ORIGINAL ABORTION PILLS FOR SALE IN DUBAI AND ABUDHA...+971581248768>> SAFE AND ORIGINAL ABORTION PILLS FOR SALE IN DUBAI AND ABUDHA...
+971581248768>> SAFE AND ORIGINAL ABORTION PILLS FOR SALE IN DUBAI AND ABUDHA...
?#DUbAI#??##{{(☎️+971_581248768%)**%*]'#abortion pills for sale in dubai@
 

Recently uploaded (20)

The 7 Things I Know About Cyber Security After 25 Years | April 2024
The 7 Things I Know About Cyber Security After 25 Years | April 2024The 7 Things I Know About Cyber Security After 25 Years | April 2024
The 7 Things I Know About Cyber Security After 25 Years | April 2024
 
Deploy with confidence: VMware Cloud Foundation 5.1 on next gen Dell PowerEdg...
Deploy with confidence: VMware Cloud Foundation 5.1 on next gen Dell PowerEdg...Deploy with confidence: VMware Cloud Foundation 5.1 on next gen Dell PowerEdg...
Deploy with confidence: VMware Cloud Foundation 5.1 on next gen Dell PowerEdg...
 
Mastering MySQL Database Architecture: Deep Dive into MySQL Shell and MySQL R...
Mastering MySQL Database Architecture: Deep Dive into MySQL Shell and MySQL R...Mastering MySQL Database Architecture: Deep Dive into MySQL Shell and MySQL R...
Mastering MySQL Database Architecture: Deep Dive into MySQL Shell and MySQL R...
 
Bajaj Allianz Life Insurance Company - Insurer Innovation Award 2024
Bajaj Allianz Life Insurance Company - Insurer Innovation Award 2024Bajaj Allianz Life Insurance Company - Insurer Innovation Award 2024
Bajaj Allianz Life Insurance Company - Insurer Innovation Award 2024
 
Boost Fertility New Invention Ups Success Rates.pdf
Boost Fertility New Invention Ups Success Rates.pdfBoost Fertility New Invention Ups Success Rates.pdf
Boost Fertility New Invention Ups Success Rates.pdf
 
Powerful Google developer tools for immediate impact! (2023-24 C)
Powerful Google developer tools for immediate impact! (2023-24 C)Powerful Google developer tools for immediate impact! (2023-24 C)
Powerful Google developer tools for immediate impact! (2023-24 C)
 
Repurposing LNG terminals for Hydrogen Ammonia: Feasibility and Cost Saving
Repurposing LNG terminals for Hydrogen Ammonia: Feasibility and Cost SavingRepurposing LNG terminals for Hydrogen Ammonia: Feasibility and Cost Saving
Repurposing LNG terminals for Hydrogen Ammonia: Feasibility and Cost Saving
 
How to Troubleshoot Apps for the Modern Connected Worker
How to Troubleshoot Apps for the Modern Connected WorkerHow to Troubleshoot Apps for the Modern Connected Worker
How to Troubleshoot Apps for the Modern Connected Worker
 
AWS Community Day CPH - Three problems of Terraform
AWS Community Day CPH - Three problems of TerraformAWS Community Day CPH - Three problems of Terraform
AWS Community Day CPH - Three problems of Terraform
 
Real Time Object Detection Using Open CV
Real Time Object Detection Using Open CVReal Time Object Detection Using Open CV
Real Time Object Detection Using Open CV
 
Strategies for Unlocking Knowledge Management in Microsoft 365 in the Copilot...
Strategies for Unlocking Knowledge Management in Microsoft 365 in the Copilot...Strategies for Unlocking Knowledge Management in Microsoft 365 in the Copilot...
Strategies for Unlocking Knowledge Management in Microsoft 365 in the Copilot...
 
presentation ICT roal in 21st century education
presentation ICT roal in 21st century educationpresentation ICT roal in 21st century education
presentation ICT roal in 21st century education
 
From Event to Action: Accelerate Your Decision Making with Real-Time Automation
From Event to Action: Accelerate Your Decision Making with Real-Time AutomationFrom Event to Action: Accelerate Your Decision Making with Real-Time Automation
From Event to Action: Accelerate Your Decision Making with Real-Time Automation
 
+971581248768>> SAFE AND ORIGINAL ABORTION PILLS FOR SALE IN DUBAI AND ABUDHA...
+971581248768>> SAFE AND ORIGINAL ABORTION PILLS FOR SALE IN DUBAI AND ABUDHA...+971581248768>> SAFE AND ORIGINAL ABORTION PILLS FOR SALE IN DUBAI AND ABUDHA...
+971581248768>> SAFE AND ORIGINAL ABORTION PILLS FOR SALE IN DUBAI AND ABUDHA...
 
Top 5 Benefits OF Using Muvi Live Paywall For Live Streams
Top 5 Benefits OF Using Muvi Live Paywall For Live StreamsTop 5 Benefits OF Using Muvi Live Paywall For Live Streams
Top 5 Benefits OF Using Muvi Live Paywall For Live Streams
 
MINDCTI Revenue Release Quarter One 2024
MINDCTI Revenue Release Quarter One 2024MINDCTI Revenue Release Quarter One 2024
MINDCTI Revenue Release Quarter One 2024
 
Axa Assurance Maroc - Insurer Innovation Award 2024
Axa Assurance Maroc - Insurer Innovation Award 2024Axa Assurance Maroc - Insurer Innovation Award 2024
Axa Assurance Maroc - Insurer Innovation Award 2024
 
Data Cloud, More than a CDP by Matt Robison
Data Cloud, More than a CDP by Matt RobisonData Cloud, More than a CDP by Matt Robison
Data Cloud, More than a CDP by Matt Robison
 
Apidays Singapore 2024 - Building Digital Trust in a Digital Economy by Veron...
Apidays Singapore 2024 - Building Digital Trust in a Digital Economy by Veron...Apidays Singapore 2024 - Building Digital Trust in a Digital Economy by Veron...
Apidays Singapore 2024 - Building Digital Trust in a Digital Economy by Veron...
 
Artificial Intelligence Chap.5 : Uncertainty
Artificial Intelligence Chap.5 : UncertaintyArtificial Intelligence Chap.5 : Uncertainty
Artificial Intelligence Chap.5 : Uncertainty
 

Featured

How Race, Age and Gender Shape Attitudes Towards Mental Health
How Race, Age and Gender Shape Attitudes Towards Mental HealthHow Race, Age and Gender Shape Attitudes Towards Mental Health
How Race, Age and Gender Shape Attitudes Towards Mental Health
ThinkNow
 
Social Media Marketing Trends 2024 // The Global Indie Insights
Social Media Marketing Trends 2024 // The Global Indie InsightsSocial Media Marketing Trends 2024 // The Global Indie Insights
Social Media Marketing Trends 2024 // The Global Indie Insights
Kurio // The Social Media Age(ncy)
 

Featured (20)

Product Design Trends in 2024 | Teenage Engineerings
Product Design Trends in 2024 | Teenage EngineeringsProduct Design Trends in 2024 | Teenage Engineerings
Product Design Trends in 2024 | Teenage Engineerings
 
How Race, Age and Gender Shape Attitudes Towards Mental Health
How Race, Age and Gender Shape Attitudes Towards Mental HealthHow Race, Age and Gender Shape Attitudes Towards Mental Health
How Race, Age and Gender Shape Attitudes Towards Mental Health
 
AI Trends in Creative Operations 2024 by Artwork Flow.pdf
AI Trends in Creative Operations 2024 by Artwork Flow.pdfAI Trends in Creative Operations 2024 by Artwork Flow.pdf
AI Trends in Creative Operations 2024 by Artwork Flow.pdf
 
Skeleton Culture Code
Skeleton Culture CodeSkeleton Culture Code
Skeleton Culture Code
 
PEPSICO Presentation to CAGNY Conference Feb 2024
PEPSICO Presentation to CAGNY Conference Feb 2024PEPSICO Presentation to CAGNY Conference Feb 2024
PEPSICO Presentation to CAGNY Conference Feb 2024
 
Content Methodology: A Best Practices Report (Webinar)
Content Methodology: A Best Practices Report (Webinar)Content Methodology: A Best Practices Report (Webinar)
Content Methodology: A Best Practices Report (Webinar)
 
How to Prepare For a Successful Job Search for 2024
How to Prepare For a Successful Job Search for 2024How to Prepare For a Successful Job Search for 2024
How to Prepare For a Successful Job Search for 2024
 
Social Media Marketing Trends 2024 // The Global Indie Insights
Social Media Marketing Trends 2024 // The Global Indie InsightsSocial Media Marketing Trends 2024 // The Global Indie Insights
Social Media Marketing Trends 2024 // The Global Indie Insights
 
Trends In Paid Search: Navigating The Digital Landscape In 2024
Trends In Paid Search: Navigating The Digital Landscape In 2024Trends In Paid Search: Navigating The Digital Landscape In 2024
Trends In Paid Search: Navigating The Digital Landscape In 2024
 
5 Public speaking tips from TED - Visualized summary
5 Public speaking tips from TED - Visualized summary5 Public speaking tips from TED - Visualized summary
5 Public speaking tips from TED - Visualized summary
 
ChatGPT and the Future of Work - Clark Boyd
ChatGPT and the Future of Work - Clark Boyd ChatGPT and the Future of Work - Clark Boyd
ChatGPT and the Future of Work - Clark Boyd
 
Getting into the tech field. what next
Getting into the tech field. what next Getting into the tech field. what next
Getting into the tech field. what next
 
Google's Just Not That Into You: Understanding Core Updates & Search Intent
Google's Just Not That Into You: Understanding Core Updates & Search IntentGoogle's Just Not That Into You: Understanding Core Updates & Search Intent
Google's Just Not That Into You: Understanding Core Updates & Search Intent
 
How to have difficult conversations
How to have difficult conversations How to have difficult conversations
How to have difficult conversations
 
Introduction to Data Science
Introduction to Data ScienceIntroduction to Data Science
Introduction to Data Science
 
Time Management & Productivity - Best Practices
Time Management & Productivity -  Best PracticesTime Management & Productivity -  Best Practices
Time Management & Productivity - Best Practices
 
The six step guide to practical project management
The six step guide to practical project managementThe six step guide to practical project management
The six step guide to practical project management
 
Beginners Guide to TikTok for Search - Rachel Pearson - We are Tilt __ Bright...
Beginners Guide to TikTok for Search - Rachel Pearson - We are Tilt __ Bright...Beginners Guide to TikTok for Search - Rachel Pearson - We are Tilt __ Bright...
Beginners Guide to TikTok for Search - Rachel Pearson - We are Tilt __ Bright...
 
Unlocking the Power of ChatGPT and AI in Testing - A Real-World Look, present...
Unlocking the Power of ChatGPT and AI in Testing - A Real-World Look, present...Unlocking the Power of ChatGPT and AI in Testing - A Real-World Look, present...
Unlocking the Power of ChatGPT and AI in Testing - A Real-World Look, present...
 
12 Ways to Increase Your Influence at Work
12 Ways to Increase Your Influence at Work12 Ways to Increase Your Influence at Work
12 Ways to Increase Your Influence at Work
 

IRSTEA - june 2013 - annex 3

  • 1. A risk-based decision-making game relevant to water management. Try it yourself! 2013. This game was prepared by Louise Crochemore (IRSTEA), Florian Pappenberger (ECMWF), Schalk Jan van Andel (UNESCO-IHE), Maria-Helena Ramos (IRSTEA) and Andy Wood (NOAA). If you use this game, the authors would be grateful for feedback on your usage and results so as to help improve future versions of the game and justify further development efforts. Special thanks to Kevin Werner (NWS), a key designer of the original game on which this one is based. Contact: maria-helena.ramos@irstea.fr This game is part of HEPEX activities: www.hepex.org START General instructions: use full screen mode. Always click on the appropriate links in each slide. Do not use Page Up, Page Down or arrow keys for scrolling.
  • 2. Water management game: instructions You are the newly appointed water manager for Lake Dual It is a reservoir that serves two primary functions: 1. Water supply for Swof Town 2. Flood control for Safe Town Swof Town Water Supply Reservoir “Lake Dual” Flood Control Safe Town NEXT
  • 3. Water management game: instructions 1. Swof Town: would like to see the reservoir full on August 1st (500 Mm3) so that its residents can count on water all summer. 2. Safe Town: residents are interested in keeping releases below 60 Mm3 each month (anything more causes flood damage to their homes) Swof Town Water Supply Reservoir “Lake Dual” Flood Control Safe Town NEXT
  • 4. Water management game: instructions You are going to be the water manager for Lake Dual during the season running from April to August: - you will be presented with probabilistic forecasts of inflows, and - at the beginning of each month you have to decide on the reservoir releases for the remaining months. Swof Town Water Supply Reservoir “Lake Dual” Flood Control Safe Town NEXT
  • 5. Water management game: remember!  your aim is to have the reservoir level as close as possible to 500 Mm3 on August 1st, but you can never exceed this level. You have to maintain a minimum release of 15 Mm3 for environmental flow and your maximum release cannot exceed 60 Mm3. If you fail to meet these constraints, you will be fired! The WINNER of the game is the manager that has the highest level on August 1st (but < 500 Mm3) Swof Town Water Supply Reservoir “Lake Dual” Flood Control Safe Town NEXT
  • 6. Water management game: worksheet You have a worksheet to mark your decisions! Remember to return it after the game! NOW LET’S DO AN EXAMPLE BEFORE WE START ! NEXT
  • 7. Water management game: example Its March 1st: this is the probabilistic forecast of inflows issued on March 1st for the next months NEXT
  • 8. Water management game: example You have to decide on your releases for all the next months… Mark the releases in your worksheet! NEXT
  • 9. Water management game: example At the end of the month, you will be informed of the actual inflow And you can update your reservoir volume for the next month NEXT
  • 10. Water management game: example Update your worksheet and check if you still have a job! You’re ready to go to the next forecast and decision NEXT
  • 11. Water management game: let’s play! Worksheets shall be used to indicate your own releases To represent the group…. We need a VOLUNTEER ! Who in the room? NEXT
  • 12. Water management game: let’s play! Game Start Swof Town Water Supply Reservoir “Lake Dual” Flood Control Safe Town
  • 13. It is April 1st. The reservoir is at 450 M m3 You are given the inflow forecasts on April 1st. Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3 140 130 Forecast inflow volume 110 100 80 70 58 60 40 42 36 28 20 q 0 M 19 12 10 8 5 A 10 M J Forecast issued on the previous month 120 max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%) J Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st. If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired. NEXT
  • 14. 140 It is April 1st. 130 Forecast issued on the previous month 120 Forecast inflow volume 110 And our volunteer? Let’s see which release option our volunteer will choose. 100 80 70 58 60 40 36 28 20 q 0 M Option A 37 Release 38 35 Reservoir volume 700 55 58 5 A 60 M 57 J J 17 23 29 25 A M J J 700 500 q 10 Option C 700 500 19 12 10 8 Option B 45 42 500 q q 300 300 300 100 100 100 A M q J J A M J J Current reservoir volume Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%)
  • 15. April has gone by. April inflow was: 18 M m3 You can update your reservoir volume: The volume on May 1st is: April 1 volume + 18 M m3 - April release = ? Did you overtop your reservoir? NO, I still have my job. YES, I got fired... What about our volunteer?
  • 16. April has gone by. April inflow was: 18 M m3 Our volunteer’s April release was: 37 M m3 The volume on May 1st is therefore: 450 M m3 +18 M m3 -37 M m3 = 431 M m3 No overtop! The volunteer still has a job! Let’s go to the next forecast!
  • 17. Previous decisions: A It is May 1st. The reservoir is at 431 M m3 You are given the inflow forecasts on May 1st. Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3 Forecast inflow volume 100 92 85 80 60 65 56 40 36 20 q q 0 M 35 22 18 18 Forecast issued on the previous month 120 120 max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%) 5 A M J J Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st. If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired. NEXT
  • 18. Previous decisions: A Forecast inflow volume It is May 1st. And our volunteer? Let’s see which release option our volunteer will choose. 100 92 85 80 60 40 36 20 q q M 59 Release 56 45 A 22 18 18 M J J Option C 46 39 26 700 Reservoir volume 35 5 Option B 60 65 56 0 Option A Forecast issued on the previous month 120 120 700 500 25 M J J 700 500 24 500 q q q 300 300 300 100 100 100 M q J J M J J Current reservoir volume Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%)
  • 19. May has gone by. May inflow was: 55 M m3 You can update your reservoir volume: The volume on June 1st is: May 1 volume + 55 M m3 - May release = ? Did you overtop your reservoir? NO, I still have my job. YES, I got fired... What about our volunteer?
  • 20. May has gone by. May inflow was: 55 M m3 Our volunteer’s May release was: 59 M m3 The volume on June 1st is therefore: 431 M m3 +55 M m3 -59 M m3 = 427 M m3 No overtop! The volunteer still has a job! Let’s go to the next forecast!
  • 21. Previous decisions: A A It is June 1st. The reservoir is at 427 M m3 You are given the inflow forecasts on June 1st. Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3 110 Forecast inflow volume 92 80 79 60 q 55 52 40 35 20 q q 23 18 5 Forecast issued on the previous month 100 max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%) 0 M A M J J Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st. If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired. NEXT
  • 22. Previous decisions: A A 110 It is June 1st. 100 Let’s see which release option our volunteer will choose. 80 Forecast issued on the previous month And our volunteer? Forecast inflow volume 92 79 60 55 q 52 40 35 20 q q 23 18 5 0 M Option A A Option B 28 Release 30 J J Option C 60 50 45 700 Reservoir volume M 700 500 J J 700 500 35 500 q q q 300 300 300 100 100 100 J q J J J Current reservoir volume Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%)
  • 23. June has gone by. June inflow was: 120 M m3 You can update your reservoir volume: The volume on July 1st is: June 1 volume + 120 M m3 - June release = ? Did you overtop your reservoir? NO, I still have my job. YES, I got fired... What about our volunteer?
  • 24. June has gone by. June inflow was: 120 M m3 Our volunteer’s June release was: 28 M m3 The volume on July 1st is therefore: 427 M m3 +120 M m3 -28 M m3 = 519 M m3 Overtop! The volunteer got fired! Can it be fixed?
  • 25. Previous decisions: A A A It is July 1st. The reservoir is at 519 M m3 You are given the inflow forecasts on July 1st. Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3 q 120 100 80 60 q 55 40 28 20 q q 0 M 21 19 18 Forecast issued on the previous month Forecast inflow volume 120 max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%) 5 A M J J Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st. If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired. NEXT
  • 26. Previous decisions: A A A And our volunteer? Let’s see which release option our volunteer will choose. Forecast inflow volume It is July 1st. q 100 80 60 40 28 20 q q M Reservoir volume q M J J 25 700 500 A Option C 60 700 21 19 18 5 Option B Release 55 q 0 Option A 120 500 Forecast issued on the previous month 120 40 700 q 500 300 300 300 100 100 q 100 J q J Current reservoir volume Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast J max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%)
  • 27. July has gone by. July inflow was: 22 M m3 You can update your reservoir volume: The volume on August 1st is: July 1 volume + 22 M m3 - July release = ? Did you overtop your reservoir? NO, I still have my job. YES, I got fired... What about our volunteer?
  • 28. July has gone by. July inflow was: 22 M m3 Our volunteer’s July release was: 60 M m3 The volume on August 1st is therefore: 519 M m3 +22 M m3 -60 M m3 = 481 M m3 No overtop! The volunteer got the job back! NEXT
  • 29. Previous decisions: A A A A GAME OVER August 1st has arrived. If you did not overtop the reservoir, you still have a job and you are hired for the next season! Observed inflows Forecast on April 1 Our volunteer's results q 120 100 80 60 q 55 40 20 q q 0 M q 18 5 22 120 80 70 60 58 40 36 q M J J 42 28 20 0 A 700 110 100 M A q 500 q 300 19 12 10 8 5 Reservoir volume 120 Forecast inflow volume Inflows in the reservoir 130 10 M J J 100 A How did you like this experience as a decision-maker? M J August 1st
  • 30. It is April 1st. The reservoir is at 450 M m3 You are given the inflow forecasts on April 1st. Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3 140 130 Forecast inflow volume 110 100 80 70 58 60 40 42 36 28 20 q 0 M 19 12 10 8 5 A 10 M J Forecast issued on the previous month 120 max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%) J Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st. If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired. NEXT
  • 31. 140 It is April 1st. 130 Forecast issued on the previous month 120 Forecast inflow volume 110 And our volunteer? Let’s see which release option our volunteer will choose. 100 80 70 58 60 40 36 28 20 q 0 M Option A 37 Release 38 35 Reservoir volume 700 55 58 5 A 60 M 57 J J 17 23 29 25 A M J J 700 500 q 10 Option C 700 500 19 12 10 8 Option B 45 42 500 q q 300 300 300 100 100 100 A M q J J A M J J Current reservoir volume Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%)
  • 32. April has gone by. April inflow was: 18 M m3 You can update your reservoir volume: The volume on May 1st is: April 1 volume + 18 M m3 - April release = ? Did you overtop your reservoir? NO, I still have my job. YES, I got fired... What about our volunteer?
  • 33. April has gone by. April inflow was: 18 M m3 Our volunteer’s April release was: 55 M m3 The volume on May 1st is therefore: 450 M m3 +18 M m3 -55 M m3 = 413 M m3 No overtop! The volunteer still has a job! Let’s go to the next forecast!
  • 34. Previous decisions: B It is May 1st. The reservoir is at 413 M m3 You are given the inflow forecasts on May 1st. Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3 Forecast inflow volume 100 92 85 80 60 65 56 40 36 20 q q 0 M 35 22 18 18 Forecast issued on the previous month 120 120 max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%) 5 A M J J Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st. If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired. NEXT
  • 35. Previous decisions: B Forecast inflow volume It is May 1st. And our volunteer? Let’s see which release option our volunteer will choose. 100 92 85 80 60 40 36 20 q q M 59 Release 56 45 A 22 18 18 M J J Option C 46 39 26 700 Reservoir volume 35 5 Option B 60 65 56 0 Option A Forecast issued on the previous month 120 120 700 500 25 M J J 700 500 24 500 q q q 300 300 300 100 100 100 M q J J M J J Current reservoir volume Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%)
  • 36. May has gone by. May inflow was: 55 M m3 You can update your reservoir volume: The volume on June 1st is: May 1 volume + 55 M m3 - May release = ? Did you overtop your reservoir? NO, I still have my job. YES, I got fired... What about our volunteer?
  • 37. May has gone by. May inflow was: 55 M m3 Our volunteer’s May release was: 59 M m3 The volume on June 1st is therefore: 413 M m3 +55 M m3 -59 M m3 = 409 M m3 No overtop! The volunteer still has a job! Let’s go to the next forecast!
  • 38. Previous decisions: B A It is June 1st. The reservoir is at 409 M m3 You are given the inflow forecasts on June 1st. Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3 110 Forecast inflow volume 92 80 79 60 q 55 52 40 35 20 q q 23 18 5 Forecast issued on the previous month 100 max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%) 0 M A M J J Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st. If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired. NEXT
  • 39. Previous decisions: B A 110 It is June 1st. 100 Let’s see which release option our volunteer will choose. 80 Forecast issued on the previous month And our volunteer? Forecast inflow volume 92 79 60 55 q 52 40 35 20 q q 23 18 5 0 M Option A A Option B 28 Release 30 J J Option C 60 50 45 700 Reservoir volume M 700 500 J J 700 500 35 500 q q q 300 300 300 100 100 100 J q J J J Current reservoir volume Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%)
  • 40. June has gone by. June inflow was: 120 M m3 You can update your reservoir volume: The volume on July 1st is: June 1 volume + 120 M m3 - June release = ? Did you overtop your reservoir? NO, I still have my job. YES, I got fired... What about our volunteer?
  • 41. June has gone by. June inflow was: 120 M m3 Our volunteer’s June release was: 28 M m3 The volume on July 1st is therefore: 409 M m3 +120 M m3 -28 M m3 = 501 M m3 Overtop! The volunteer got fired! Can it be fixed?
  • 42. Previous decisions: B A A It is July 1st. The reservoir is at 501 M m3 You are given the inflow forecasts on July 1st. Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3 q 120 100 80 60 q 55 40 28 20 q q 0 M 21 19 18 Forecast issued on the previous month Forecast inflow volume 120 max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%) 5 A M J J Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st. If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired. NEXT
  • 43. Previous decisions: B A A And our volunteer? Let’s see which release option our volunteer will choose. Forecast inflow volume It is July 1st. q 100 80 60 40 28 20 q q M Reservoir volume q M J J 25 700 500 A Option C 60 700 21 19 18 5 Option B Release 55 q 0 Option A 120 500 Forecast issued on the previous month 120 40 700 q 500 300 300 300 100 100 q 100 J q J Current reservoir volume Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast J max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%)
  • 44. July has gone by. July inflow was: 22 M m3 You can update your reservoir volume: The volume on August 1st is: July 1 volume + 22 M m3 - July release = ? Did you overtop your reservoir? NO, I still have my job. YES, I got fired... What about our volunteer?
  • 45. July has gone by. July inflow was: 22 M m3 Our volunteer’s July release was: 60 M m3 The volume on August 1st is therefore: 501 M m3 +22 M m3 -60 M m3 = 463 M m3 No overtop! The volunteer got the job back! NEXT
  • 46. Previous decisions: B A A A GAME OVER August 1st has arrived. If you did not overtop the reservoir, you still have a job and you are hired for the next season! Observed inflows Forecast on April 1 Our volunteer's results q 120 100 80 60 q 55 40 20 q q 0 M q 18 5 22 120 80 70 60 58 40 36 q M J J 42 28 20 0 A 700 110 100 M A 500 q q 300 19 12 10 8 5 Reservoir volume 120 Forecast inflow volume Inflows in the reservoir 130 10 M J J 100 A How did you like this experience as a decision-maker? M J August 1st
  • 47. It is April 1st. The reservoir is at 450 M m3 You are given the inflow forecasts on April 1st. Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3 140 130 Forecast inflow volume 110 100 80 70 58 60 40 42 36 28 20 q 0 M 19 12 10 8 5 A 10 M J Forecast issued on the previous month 120 max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%) J Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st. If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired. NEXT
  • 48. 140 It is April 1st. 130 Forecast issued on the previous month 120 Forecast inflow volume 110 And our volunteer? Let’s see which release option our volunteer will choose. 100 80 70 58 60 40 36 28 20 q 0 M Option A 37 Release 38 35 Reservoir volume 700 55 58 5 A 60 M 57 J J 17 23 29 25 A M J J 700 500 q 10 Option C 700 500 19 12 10 8 Option B 45 42 500 q q 300 300 300 100 100 100 A M q J J A M J J Current reservoir volume Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%)
  • 49. April has gone by. April inflow was: 18 M m3 You can update your reservoir volume: The volume on May 1st is: April 1 volume + 18 M m3 - April release = ? Did you overtop your reservoir? NO, I still have my job. YES, I got fired... What about our volunteer?
  • 50. April has gone by. April inflow was: 18 M m3 Our volunteer’s April release was: 17 M m3 The volume on May 1st is therefore: 450 M m3 +18 M m3 -17 M m3 = 451 M m3 No overtop! The volunteer still has a job! Let’s go to the next forecast!
  • 51. Previous decisions: C It is May 1st. The reservoir is at 451 M m3 You are given the inflow forecasts on May 1st. Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3 Forecast inflow volume 100 92 85 80 60 65 56 40 36 20 q q 0 M 35 22 18 18 Forecast issued on the previous month 120 120 max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%) 5 A M J J Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st. If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired. NEXT
  • 52. Previous decisions: C Forecast inflow volume It is May 1st. And our volunteer? Let’s see which release option our volunteer will choose. 100 92 85 80 60 40 36 20 q q M 59 Release 56 Reservoir volume 700 500 45 500 22 18 18 A M J J Option C 46 39 700 q 35 5 Option B 60 65 56 0 Option A Forecast issued on the previous month 120 120 26 24 25 M J J 700 500 q 300 300 300 100 100 q 100 M q J J M J J Current reservoir volume Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%)
  • 53. May has gone by. May inflow was: 55 M m3 You can update your reservoir volume: The volume on June 1st is: May 1 volume + 55 M m3 - May release = ? Did you overtop your reservoir? NO, I still have my job. YES, I got fired... What about our volunteer?
  • 54. May has gone by. May inflow was: 55 M m3 Our volunteer’s May release was: 59 M m3 The volume on June 1st is therefore: 451 M m3 +55 M m3 -59 M m3 = 447 M m3 No overtop! The volunteer still has a job! Let’s go to the next forecast!
  • 55. Previous decisions: C A It is June 1st. The reservoir is at 447 M m3 You are given the inflow forecasts on June 1st. Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3 110 Forecast inflow volume 92 80 79 60 q 55 52 40 35 20 q q 23 18 5 Forecast issued on the previous month 100 max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%) 0 M A M J J Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st. If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired. NEXT
  • 56. Previous decisions: C A 110 It is June 1st. 100 Let’s see which release option our volunteer will choose. 80 Forecast issued on the previous month And our volunteer? Forecast inflow volume 92 79 60 55 q 52 40 35 20 q q 23 18 5 0 M Option A Option B 28 Release 30 700 Reservoir volume A 60 J 50 45 35 J J 700 500 q J Option C 700 500 M 500 q q 300 300 300 100 100 100 J q J J J Current reservoir volume Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%)
  • 57. June has gone by. June inflow was: 120 M m3 You can update your reservoir volume: The volume on July 1st is: June 1 volume + 120 M m3 - June release = ? Did you overtop your reservoir? NO, I still have my job. YES, I got fired... What about our volunteer?
  • 58. June has gone by. June inflow was: 120 M m3 Our volunteer’s June release was: 28 M m3 The volume on July 1st is therefore: 447 M m3 +120 M m3 -28 M m3 = 539 M m3 Overtop! The volunteer got fired! Can it be fixed?
  • 59. Previous decisions: C A A It is July 1st. The reservoir is at 539 M m3 You are given the inflow forecasts on July 1st. Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3 q 120 100 80 60 q 55 40 28 20 q q 0 M 21 19 18 Forecast issued on the previous month Forecast inflow volume 120 max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%) 5 A M J J Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st. If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired. NEXT
  • 60. Previous decisions: C A A And our volunteer? Let’s see which release option our volunteer will choose. Forecast inflow volume It is July 1st. q 100 80 60 40 28 20 q q M Reservoir volume q M J J 25 700 500 A Option C 60 700 21 19 18 5 Option B Release 55 q 0 Option A 120 500 Forecast issued on the previous month 120 40 700 q 500 300 300 300 100 100 q 100 J q J Current reservoir volume Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast J max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%)
  • 61. July has gone by. July inflow was: 22 M m3 You can update your reservoir volume: The volume on August 1st is: July 1 volume + 22 M m3 - July release = ? Did you overtop your reservoir? NO, I still have my job. YES, I got fired... What about our volunteer?
  • 62. July has gone by. July inflow was: 22 M m3 Our volunteer’s July release was: 60 M m3 The volume on August 1st is therefore: 539 M m3 +22 M m3 -60 M m3 = 501 M m3 Overtop! The volunteer did not get the job back! NEXT
  • 63. Previous decisions: C A A A GAME OVER August 1st has arrived. If you did not overtop the reservoir, you still have a job and you are hired for the next season! Observed inflows Forecast on April 1 Our volunteer's results q 120 100 80 60 q 55 40 20 q q 0 M q 18 5 22 120 80 70 60 58 40 36 q M J J 42 28 20 0 A 700 110 100 M A q 500 q q 300 19 12 10 8 5 Reservoir volume 120 Forecast inflow volume Inflows in the reservoir 130 10 M J J 100 A How did you like this experience as a decision-maker? M J August 1st
  • 64. It is April 1st. The reservoir is at 450 M m3 You are given the inflow forecasts on April 1st. Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3 140 130 Forecast inflow volume 110 100 80 70 58 60 40 42 36 28 20 q 0 M 19 12 10 8 5 A 10 M J Forecast issued on the previous month 120 max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%) J Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st. If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired. NEXT
  • 65. 140 It is April 1st. 130 Forecast issued on the previous month 120 Forecast inflow volume 110 And our volunteer? Let’s see which release option our volunteer will choose. 100 80 70 58 60 40 36 28 20 q 0 M Option A 37 Release 38 35 Reservoir volume 700 55 58 5 A 60 M 57 J J 17 23 29 25 A M J J 700 500 q 10 Option C 700 500 19 12 10 8 Option B 45 42 500 q q 300 300 300 100 100 100 A M q J J A M J J Current reservoir volume Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%)
  • 66. April has gone by. April inflow was: 18 M m3 You can update your reservoir volume: The volume on May 1st is: April 1 volume + 18 M m3 - April release = ? Did you overtop your reservoir? NO, I still have my job. YES, I got fired... What about our volunteer?
  • 67. April has gone by. April inflow was: 18 M m3 Our volunteer’s April release was: 37 M m3 The volume on May 1st is therefore: 450 M m3 +18 M m3 -37 M m3 = 431 M m3 No overtop! The volunteer still has a job! Let’s go to the next forecast!
  • 68. Previous decisions: A It is May 1st. The reservoir is at 431 M m3 You are given the inflow forecasts on May 1st. Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3 Forecast inflow volume 100 92 85 80 60 65 56 40 36 20 q q 0 M 35 22 18 18 Forecast issued on the previous month 120 120 max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%) 5 A M J J Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st. If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired. NEXT
  • 69. Previous decisions: A Forecast inflow volume It is May 1st. And our volunteer? Let’s see which release option our volunteer will choose. 100 92 85 80 60 40 36 20 q q M 59 Release 56 45 A 22 18 18 M J J Option C 46 39 26 700 Reservoir volume 35 5 Option B 60 65 56 0 Option A Forecast issued on the previous month 120 120 700 500 25 M J J 700 500 24 500 q q q 300 300 300 100 100 100 M q J J M J J Current reservoir volume Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%)
  • 70. May has gone by. May inflow was: 55 M m3 You can update your reservoir volume: The volume on June 1st is: May 1 volume + 55 M m3 - May release = ? Did you overtop your reservoir? NO, I still have my job. YES, I got fired... What about our volunteer?
  • 71. May has gone by. May inflow was: 55 M m3 Our volunteer’s May release was: 45 M m3 The volume on June 1st is therefore: 431 M m3 +55 M m3 -45 M m3 = 441 M m3 No overtop! The volunteer still has a job! Let’s go to the next forecast!
  • 72. Previous decisions: A B It is June 1st. The reservoir is at 441 M m3 You are given the inflow forecasts on June 1st. Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3 110 Forecast inflow volume 92 80 79 60 q 55 52 40 35 20 q q 23 18 5 Forecast issued on the previous month 100 max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%) 0 M A M J J Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st. If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired. NEXT
  • 73. Previous decisions: A B 110 It is June 1st. 100 Let’s see which release option our volunteer will choose. 80 Forecast issued on the previous month And our volunteer? Forecast inflow volume 92 79 60 55 q 52 40 35 20 q q 23 18 5 0 M Option A Option B 28 Release 30 700 Reservoir volume A 60 J 50 45 35 J J 700 500 q J Option C 700 500 M 500 q q 300 300 300 100 100 100 J q J J J Current reservoir volume Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%)
  • 74. June has gone by. June inflow was: 120 M m3 You can update your reservoir volume: The volume on July 1st is: June 1 volume + 120 M m3 - June release = ? Did you overtop your reservoir? NO, I still have my job. YES, I got fired... What about our volunteer?
  • 75. June has gone by. June inflow was: 120 M m3 Our volunteer’s June release was: 28 M m3 The volume on July 1st is therefore: 441 M m3 +120 M m3 -28 M m3 = 533 M m3 Overtop! The volunteer got fired! Can it be fixed?
  • 76. Previous decisions: A B A It is July 1st. The reservoir is at 533 M m3 You are given the inflow forecasts on July 1st. Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3 q 120 100 80 60 q 55 40 28 20 q q 0 M 21 19 18 Forecast issued on the previous month Forecast inflow volume 120 max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%) 5 A M J J Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st. If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired. NEXT
  • 77. Previous decisions: A B A And our volunteer? Let’s see which release option our volunteer will choose. Forecast inflow volume It is July 1st. q 100 80 60 40 28 20 q q M Reservoir volume q M J J 25 700 500 A Option C 60 700 21 19 18 5 Option B Release 55 q 0 Option A 120 500 Forecast issued on the previous month 120 40 700 q 500 300 300 300 100 100 q 100 J q J Current reservoir volume Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast J max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%)
  • 78. July has gone by. July inflow was: 22 M m3 You can update your reservoir volume: The volume on August 1st is: July 1 volume + 22 M m3 - July release = ? Did you overtop your reservoir? NO, I still have my job. YES, I got fired... What about our volunteer?
  • 79. July has gone by. July inflow was: 22 M m3 Our volunteer’s July release was: 60 M m3 The volume on August 1st is therefore: 533 M m3 +22 M m3 -60 M m3 = 495 M m3 No overtop! The volunteer got the job back! NEXT
  • 80. Previous decisions: A B A A GAME OVER August 1st has arrived. If you did not overtop the reservoir, you still have a job and you are hired for the next season! Observed inflows Forecast on April 1 Our volunteer's results q 120 100 80 60 q 55 40 20 q q 0 M q 18 5 22 120 80 70 60 58 40 36 q M J J 42 28 20 0 A 700 110 100 M A q 500 q 300 19 12 10 8 5 Reservoir volume 120 Forecast inflow volume Inflows in the reservoir 130 10 M J J 100 A How did you like this experience as a decision-maker? M J August 1st
  • 81. It is April 1st. The reservoir is at 450 M m3 You are given the inflow forecasts on April 1st. Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3 140 130 Forecast inflow volume 110 100 80 70 58 60 40 42 36 28 20 q 0 M 19 12 10 8 5 A 10 M J Forecast issued on the previous month 120 max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%) J Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st. If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired. NEXT
  • 82. 140 It is April 1st. 130 Forecast issued on the previous month 120 Forecast inflow volume 110 And our volunteer? Let’s see which release option our volunteer will choose. 100 80 70 58 60 40 36 28 20 q 0 M Option A 37 Release 38 35 Reservoir volume 700 55 58 5 A 60 M 57 J J 17 23 29 25 A M J J 700 500 q 10 Option C 700 500 19 12 10 8 Option B 45 42 500 q q 300 300 300 100 100 100 A M q J J A M J J Current reservoir volume Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%)
  • 83. April has gone by. April inflow was: 18 M m3 You can update your reservoir volume: The volume on May 1st is: April 1 volume + 18 M m3 - April release = ? Did you overtop your reservoir? NO, I still have my job. YES, I got fired... What about our volunteer?
  • 84. April has gone by. April inflow was: 18 M m3 Our volunteer’s April release was: 55 M m3 The volume on May 1st is therefore: 450 M m3 +18 M m3 -55 M m3 = 413 M m3 No overtop! The volunteer still has a job! Let’s go to the next forecast!
  • 85. Previous decisions: B It is May 1st. The reservoir is at 413 M m3 You are given the inflow forecasts on May 1st. Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3 Forecast inflow volume 100 92 85 80 60 65 56 40 36 20 q q 0 M 35 22 18 18 Forecast issued on the previous month 120 120 max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%) 5 A M J J Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st. If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired. NEXT
  • 86. Previous decisions: B Forecast inflow volume It is May 1st. And our volunteer? Let’s see which release option our volunteer will choose. 100 92 85 80 60 40 36 20 q q M 59 Release 56 45 A 22 18 18 M J J Option C 46 39 26 700 Reservoir volume 35 5 Option B 60 65 56 0 Option A Forecast issued on the previous month 120 120 700 500 25 M J J 700 500 24 500 q q q 300 300 300 100 100 100 M q J J M J J Current reservoir volume Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%)
  • 87. May has gone by. May inflow was: 55 M m3 You can update your reservoir volume: The volume on June 1st is: May 1 volume + 55 M m3 - May release = ? Did you overtop your reservoir? NO, I still have my job. YES, I got fired... What about our volunteer?
  • 88. May has gone by. May inflow was: 55 M m3 Our volunteer’s May release was: 45 M m3 The volume on June 1st is therefore: 413 M m3 +55 M m3 -45 M m3 = 423 M m3 No overtop! The volunteer still has a job! Let’s go to the next forecast!
  • 89. Previous decisions: B B It is June 1st. The reservoir is at 423 M m3 You are given the inflow forecasts on June 1st. Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3 110 Forecast inflow volume 92 80 79 60 q 55 52 40 35 20 q q 23 18 5 Forecast issued on the previous month 100 max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%) 0 M A M J J Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st. If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired. NEXT
  • 90. Previous decisions: B B 110 It is June 1st. 100 Let’s see which release option our volunteer will choose. 80 Forecast issued on the previous month And our volunteer? Forecast inflow volume 92 79 60 55 q 52 40 35 20 q q 23 18 5 0 M Option A A Option B 28 Release 30 J J Option C 60 50 45 700 Reservoir volume M 700 500 J J 700 500 35 500 q q q 300 300 300 100 100 100 J q J J J Current reservoir volume Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%)
  • 91. June has gone by. June inflow was: 120 M m3 You can update your reservoir volume: The volume on July 1st is: June 1 volume + 120 M m3 - June release = ? Did you overtop your reservoir? NO, I still have my job. YES, I got fired... What about our volunteer?
  • 92. June has gone by. June inflow was: 120 M m3 Our volunteer’s June release was: 28 M m3 The volume on July 1st is therefore: 423 M m3 +120 M m3 -28 M m3 = 515 M m3 Overtop! The volunteer got fired! Can it be fixed?
  • 93. Previous decisions: B B A It is July 1st. The reservoir is at 515 M m3 You are given the inflow forecasts on July 1st. Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3 q 120 100 80 60 q 55 40 28 20 q q 0 M 21 19 18 Forecast issued on the previous month Forecast inflow volume 120 max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%) 5 A M J J Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st. If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired. NEXT
  • 94. Previous decisions: B B A And our volunteer? Let’s see which release option our volunteer will choose. Forecast inflow volume It is July 1st. q 100 80 60 40 28 20 q q M Reservoir volume q M J J 25 700 500 A Option C 60 700 21 19 18 5 Option B Release 55 q 0 Option A 120 500 Forecast issued on the previous month 120 40 700 q 500 300 300 300 100 100 q 100 J q J Current reservoir volume Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast J max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%)
  • 95. July has gone by. July inflow was: 22 M m3 You can update your reservoir volume: The volume on August 1st is: July 1 volume + 22 M m3 - July release = ? Did you overtop your reservoir? NO, I still have my job. YES, I got fired... What about our volunteer?
  • 96. July has gone by. July inflow was: 22 M m3 Our volunteer’s July release was: 60 M m3 The volume on August 1st is therefore: 515 M m3 +22 M m3 -60 M m3 = 477 M m3 No overtop! The volunteer got the job back! NEXT
  • 97. Previous decisions: B B A A GAME OVER August 1st has arrived. If you did not overtop the reservoir, you still have a job and you are hired for the next season! Observed inflows Forecast on April 1 Our volunteer's results q 120 100 80 60 q 55 40 20 q q 0 M q 18 5 22 120 80 70 60 58 40 36 q M J J 42 28 20 0 A 700 110 100 M A q 500 q 300 19 12 10 8 5 Reservoir volume 120 Forecast inflow volume Inflows in the reservoir 130 10 M J J 100 A How did you like this experience as a decision-maker? M J August 1st
  • 98. It is April 1st. The reservoir is at 450 M m3 You are given the inflow forecasts on April 1st. Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3 140 130 Forecast inflow volume 110 100 80 70 58 60 40 42 36 28 20 q 0 M 19 12 10 8 5 A 10 M J Forecast issued on the previous month 120 max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%) J Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st. If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired. NEXT
  • 99. 140 It is April 1st. 130 Forecast issued on the previous month 120 Forecast inflow volume 110 And our volunteer? Let’s see which release option our volunteer will choose. 100 80 70 58 60 40 36 28 20 q 0 M Option A 37 Release 38 35 Reservoir volume 700 55 58 5 A 60 M 57 J J 17 23 29 25 A M J J 700 500 q 10 Option C 700 500 19 12 10 8 Option B 45 42 500 q q 300 300 300 100 100 100 A M q J J A M J J Current reservoir volume Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%)
  • 100. April has gone by. April inflow was: 18 M m3 You can update your reservoir volume: The volume on May 1st is: April 1 volume + 18 M m3 - April release = ? Did you overtop your reservoir? NO, I still have my job. YES, I got fired... What about our volunteer?
  • 101. April has gone by. April inflow was: 18 M m3 Our volunteer’s April release was: 17 M m3 The volume on May 1st is therefore: 450 M m3 +18 M m3 -17 M m3 = 451 M m3 No overtop! The volunteer still has a job! Let’s go to the next forecast!
  • 102. Previous decisions: C It is May 1st. The reservoir is at 451 M m3 You are given the inflow forecasts on May 1st. Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3 Forecast inflow volume 100 92 85 80 60 65 56 40 36 20 q q 0 M 35 22 18 18 Forecast issued on the previous month 120 120 max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%) 5 A M J J Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st. If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired. NEXT
  • 103. Previous decisions: C Forecast inflow volume It is May 1st. And our volunteer? Let’s see which release option our volunteer will choose. 100 92 85 80 60 40 36 20 q q M 59 Release 56 Reservoir volume 700 500 45 500 22 18 18 A M J J Option C 46 39 700 q 35 5 Option B 60 65 56 0 Option A Forecast issued on the previous month 120 120 26 24 25 M J J 700 500 q 300 300 300 100 100 q 100 M q J J M J J Current reservoir volume Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%)
  • 104. May has gone by. May inflow was: 55 M m3 You can update your reservoir volume: The volume on June 1st is: May 1 volume + 55 M m3 - May release = ? Did you overtop your reservoir? NO, I still have my job. YES, I got fired... What about our volunteer?
  • 105. May has gone by. May inflow was: 55 M m3 Our volunteer’s May release was: 45 M m3 The volume on June 1st is therefore: 451 M m3 +55 M m3 -45 M m3 = 461 M m3 No overtop! The volunteer still has a job! Let’s go to the next forecast!
  • 106. Previous decisions: C B It is June 1st. The reservoir is at 461 M m3 You are given the inflow forecasts on June 1st. Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3 110 Forecast inflow volume 92 80 79 60 q 55 52 40 35 20 q q 23 18 5 Forecast issued on the previous month 100 max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%) 0 M A M J J Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st. If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired. NEXT
  • 107. Previous decisions: C B 110 It is June 1st. 100 Let’s see which release option our volunteer will choose. 80 Forecast issued on the previous month And our volunteer? Forecast inflow volume 92 79 60 55 q 52 40 35 20 q q 23 18 5 0 M Option A Option B 28 Release 30 Reservoir volume 700 60 500 q M J J Option C 50 700 500 A 45 35 J J 700 500 q 300 300 300 100 100 q 100 J q J J J Current reservoir volume Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%)
  • 108. June has gone by. June inflow was: 120 M m3 You can update your reservoir volume: The volume on July 1st is: June 1 volume + 120 M m3 - June release = ? Did you overtop your reservoir? NO, I still have my job. YES, I got fired... What about our volunteer?
  • 109. June has gone by. June inflow was: 120 M m3 Our volunteer’s June release was: 28 M m3 The volume on July 1st is therefore: 461 M m3 +120 M m3 -28 M m3 = 553 M m3 Overtop! The volunteer got fired! Can it be fixed?
  • 110. Previous decisions: C B A It is July 1st. The reservoir is at 553 M m3 You are given the inflow forecasts on July 1st. Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3 q 120 100 80 60 q 55 40 28 20 q q 0 M 21 19 18 Forecast issued on the previous month Forecast inflow volume 120 max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%) 5 A M J J Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st. If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired. NEXT
  • 111. Previous decisions: C B A And our volunteer? Let’s see which release option our volunteer will choose. Forecast inflow volume It is July 1st. q 100 80 60 40 28 20 q q M Reservoir volume A M J J Option C 60 700 21 19 18 5 Option B Release 55 q 0 Option A 120 25 700 q Forecast issued on the previous month 120 40 700 q q 500 500 500 300 300 300 100 100 100 J q J Current reservoir volume Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast J max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%)
  • 112. July has gone by. July inflow was: 22 M m3 You can update your reservoir volume: The volume on August 1st is: July 1 volume + 22 M m3 - July release = ? Did you overtop your reservoir? NO, I still have my job. YES, I got fired... What about our volunteer?
  • 113. July has gone by. July inflow was: 22 M m3 Our volunteer’s July release was: 60 M m3 The volume on August 1st is therefore: 553 M m3 +22 M m3 -60 M m3 = 515 M m3 Overtop! The volunteer did not get the job back! NEXT
  • 114. Previous decisions: C B A A GAME OVER August 1st has arrived. If you did not overtop the reservoir, you still have a job and you are hired for the next season! Observed inflows Forecast on April 1 Our volunteer's results q 120 100 80 60 q 55 40 20 q q 0 M q 18 5 22 120 80 70 60 58 40 36 q M J J 42 28 20 0 A 700 110 100 M A q 500 q q 300 19 12 10 8 5 Reservoir volume 120 Forecast inflow volume Inflows in the reservoir 130 10 M J J 100 A How did you like this experience as a decision-maker? M J August 1st
  • 115. It is April 1st. The reservoir is at 450 M m3 You are given the inflow forecasts on April 1st. Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3 140 130 Forecast inflow volume 110 100 80 70 58 60 40 42 36 28 20 q 0 M 19 12 10 8 5 A 10 M J Forecast issued on the previous month 120 max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%) J Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st. If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired. NEXT
  • 116. 140 It is April 1st. 130 Forecast issued on the previous month 120 Forecast inflow volume 110 And our volunteer? Let’s see which release option our volunteer will choose. 100 80 70 58 60 40 36 28 20 q 0 M Option A 37 Release 38 35 Reservoir volume 700 55 58 5 A 60 M 57 J J 17 23 29 25 A M J J 700 500 q 10 Option C 700 500 19 12 10 8 Option B 45 42 500 q q 300 300 300 100 100 100 A M q J J A M J J Current reservoir volume Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%)
  • 117. April has gone by. April inflow was: 18 M m3 You can update your reservoir volume: The volume on May 1st is: April 1 volume + 18 M m3 - April release = ? Did you overtop your reservoir? NO, I still have my job. YES, I got fired... What about our volunteer?
  • 118. April has gone by. April inflow was: 18 M m3 Our volunteer’s April release was: 37 M m3 The volume on May 1st is therefore: 450 M m3 +18 M m3 -37 M m3 = 431 M m3 No overtop! The volunteer still has a job! Let’s go to the next forecast!
  • 119. Previous decisions: A It is May 1st. The reservoir is at 431 M m3 You are given the inflow forecasts on May 1st. Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3 Forecast inflow volume 100 92 85 80 60 65 56 40 36 20 q q 0 M 35 22 18 18 Forecast issued on the previous month 120 120 max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%) 5 A M J J Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st. If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired. NEXT
  • 120. Previous decisions: A Forecast inflow volume It is May 1st. And our volunteer? Let’s see which release option our volunteer will choose. 100 92 85 80 60 40 36 20 q q M 59 Release 56 45 A 22 18 18 M J J Option C 46 39 26 700 Reservoir volume 35 5 Option B 60 65 56 0 Option A Forecast issued on the previous month 120 120 700 500 25 M J J 700 500 24 500 q q q 300 300 300 100 100 100 M q J J M J J Current reservoir volume Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%)
  • 121. May has gone by. May inflow was: 55 M m3 You can update your reservoir volume: The volume on June 1st is: May 1 volume + 55 M m3 - May release = ? Did you overtop your reservoir? NO, I still have my job. YES, I got fired... What about our volunteer?
  • 122. May has gone by. May inflow was: 55 M m3 Our volunteer’s May release was: 26 M m3 The volume on June 1st is therefore: 431 M m3 +55 M m3 -26 M m3 = 460 M m3 No overtop! The volunteer still has a job! Let’s go to the next forecast!
  • 123. Previous decisions: A C It is June 1st. The reservoir is at 460 M m3 You are given the inflow forecasts on June 1st. Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3 110 Forecast inflow volume 92 80 79 60 q 55 52 40 35 20 q q 23 18 5 Forecast issued on the previous month 100 max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%) 0 M A M J J Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st. If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired. NEXT
  • 124. Previous decisions: A C 110 It is June 1st. 100 Let’s see which release option our volunteer will choose. 80 Forecast issued on the previous month And our volunteer? Forecast inflow volume 92 79 60 55 q 52 40 35 20 q q 23 18 5 0 M Option A Option B 28 Release 30 Reservoir volume 700 60 500 q M J J Option C 50 700 500 A 45 35 J J 700 500 q 300 300 300 100 100 q 100 J q J J J Current reservoir volume Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%)
  • 125. June has gone by. June inflow was: 120 M m3 You can update your reservoir volume: The volume on July 1st is: June 1 volume + 120 M m3 - June release = ? Did you overtop your reservoir? NO, I still have my job. YES, I got fired... What about our volunteer?
  • 126. June has gone by. June inflow was: 120 M m3 Our volunteer’s June release was: 28 M m3 The volume on July 1st is therefore: 460 M m3 +120 M m3 -28 M m3 = 552 M m3 Overtop! The volunteer got fired! Can it be fixed?
  • 127. Previous decisions: A C A It is July 1st. The reservoir is at 552 M m3 You are given the inflow forecasts on July 1st. Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3 q 120 100 80 60 q 55 40 28 20 q q 0 M 21 19 18 Forecast issued on the previous month Forecast inflow volume 120 max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%) 5 A M J J Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st. If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired. NEXT
  • 128. Previous decisions: A C A And our volunteer? Let’s see which release option our volunteer will choose. Forecast inflow volume It is July 1st. q 100 80 60 40 28 20 q q M Reservoir volume A M J J Option C 60 700 21 19 18 5 Option B Release 55 q 0 Option A 120 25 700 q Forecast issued on the previous month 120 40 700 q q 500 500 500 300 300 300 100 100 100 J q J Current reservoir volume Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast J max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%)
  • 129. July has gone by. July inflow was: 22 M m3 You can update your reservoir volume: The volume on August 1st is: July 1 volume + 22 M m3 - July release = ? Did you overtop your reservoir? NO, I still have my job. YES, I got fired... What about our volunteer?
  • 130. July has gone by. July inflow was: 22 M m3 Our volunteer’s July release was: 60 M m3 The volume on August 1st is therefore: 552 M m3 +22 M m3 -60 M m3 = 514 M m3 Overtop! The volunteer did not get the job back! NEXT
  • 131. Previous decisions: A C A A GAME OVER August 1st has arrived. If you did not overtop the reservoir, you still have a job and you are hired for the next season! Observed inflows Forecast on April 1 Our volunteer's results q 120 100 80 60 q 55 40 20 q q 0 M q 18 5 22 120 80 70 60 58 40 36 q M J J 42 28 20 0 A 700 110 100 M A q 500 q q 300 19 12 10 8 5 Reservoir volume 120 Forecast inflow volume Inflows in the reservoir 130 10 M J J 100 A How did you like this experience as a decision-maker? M J August 1st
  • 132. It is April 1st. The reservoir is at 450 M m3 You are given the inflow forecasts on April 1st. Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3 140 130 Forecast inflow volume 110 100 80 70 58 60 40 42 36 28 20 q 0 M 19 12 10 8 5 A 10 M J Forecast issued on the previous month 120 max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%) J Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st. If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired. NEXT
  • 133. 140 It is April 1st. 130 Forecast issued on the previous month 120 Forecast inflow volume 110 And our volunteer? Let’s see which release option our volunteer will choose. 100 80 70 58 60 40 36 28 20 q 0 M Option A 37 Release 38 35 Reservoir volume 700 55 58 5 A 60 M 57 J J 17 23 29 25 A M J J 700 500 q 10 Option C 700 500 19 12 10 8 Option B 45 42 500 q q 300 300 300 100 100 100 A M q J J A M J J Current reservoir volume Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%)
  • 134. April has gone by. April inflow was: 18 M m3 You can update your reservoir volume: The volume on May 1st is: April 1 volume + 18 M m3 - April release = ? Did you overtop your reservoir? NO, I still have my job. YES, I got fired... What about our volunteer?
  • 135. April has gone by. April inflow was: 18 M m3 Our volunteer’s April release was: 55 M m3 The volume on May 1st is therefore: 450 M m3 +18 M m3 -55 M m3 = 413 M m3 No overtop! The volunteer still has a job! Let’s go to the next forecast!
  • 136. Previous decisions: B It is May 1st. The reservoir is at 413 M m3 You are given the inflow forecasts on May 1st. Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3 Forecast inflow volume 100 92 85 80 60 65 56 40 36 20 q q 0 M 35 22 18 18 Forecast issued on the previous month 120 120 max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%) 5 A M J J Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st. If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired. NEXT
  • 137. Previous decisions: B Forecast inflow volume It is May 1st. And our volunteer? Let’s see which release option our volunteer will choose. 100 92 85 80 60 40 36 20 q q M 59 Release 56 45 A 22 18 18 M J J Option C 46 39 26 700 Reservoir volume 35 5 Option B 60 65 56 0 Option A Forecast issued on the previous month 120 120 700 500 25 M J J 700 500 24 500 q q q 300 300 300 100 100 100 M q J J M J J Current reservoir volume Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%)
  • 138. May has gone by. May inflow was: 55 M m3 You can update your reservoir volume: The volume on June 1st is: May 1 volume + 55 M m3 - May release = ? Did you overtop your reservoir? NO, I still have my job. YES, I got fired... What about our volunteer?
  • 139. May has gone by. May inflow was: 55 M m3 Our volunteer’s May release was: 26 M m3 The volume on June 1st is therefore: 413 M m3 +55 M m3 -26 M m3 = 442 M m3 No overtop! The volunteer still has a job! Let’s go to the next forecast!
  • 140. Previous decisions: B C It is June 1st. The reservoir is at 442 M m3 You are given the inflow forecasts on June 1st. Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3 110 Forecast inflow volume 92 80 79 60 q 55 52 40 35 20 q q 23 18 5 Forecast issued on the previous month 100 max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%) 0 M A M J J Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st. If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired. NEXT
  • 141. Previous decisions: B C 110 It is June 1st. 100 Let’s see which release option our volunteer will choose. 80 Forecast issued on the previous month And our volunteer? Forecast inflow volume 92 79 60 55 q 52 40 35 20 q q 23 18 5 0 M Option A Option B 28 Release 30 700 Reservoir volume A 60 J 50 45 35 J J 700 500 q J Option C 700 500 M 500 q q 300 300 300 100 100 100 J q J J J Current reservoir volume Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%)
  • 142. June has gone by. June inflow was: 120 M m3 You can update your reservoir volume: The volume on July 1st is: June 1 volume + 120 M m3 - June release = ? Did you overtop your reservoir? NO, I still have my job. YES, I got fired... What about our volunteer?
  • 143. June has gone by. June inflow was: 120 M m3 Our volunteer’s June release was: 28 M m3 The volume on July 1st is therefore: 442 M m3 +120 M m3 -28 M m3 = 534 M m3 Overtop! The volunteer got fired! Can it be fixed?
  • 144. Previous decisions: B C A It is July 1st. The reservoir is at 534 M m3 You are given the inflow forecasts on July 1st. Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3 q 120 100 80 60 q 55 40 28 20 q q 0 M 21 19 18 Forecast issued on the previous month Forecast inflow volume 120 max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%) 5 A M J J Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st. If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired. NEXT
  • 145. Previous decisions: B C A And our volunteer? Let’s see which release option our volunteer will choose. Forecast inflow volume It is July 1st. q 100 80 60 40 28 20 q q M Reservoir volume q M J J 25 700 500 A Option C 60 700 21 19 18 5 Option B Release 55 q 0 Option A 120 500 Forecast issued on the previous month 120 40 700 q 500 300 300 300 100 100 q 100 J q J Current reservoir volume Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast J max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%)
  • 146. July has gone by. July inflow was: 22 M m3 You can update your reservoir volume: The volume on August 1st is: July 1 volume + 22 M m3 - July release = ? Did you overtop your reservoir? NO, I still have my job. YES, I got fired... What about our volunteer?
  • 147. July has gone by. July inflow was: 22 M m3 Our volunteer’s July release was: 60 M m3 The volume on August 1st is therefore: 534 M m3 +22 M m3 -60 M m3 = 496 M m3 No overtop! The volunteer got the job back! NEXT
  • 148. Previous decisions: B C A A GAME OVER August 1st has arrived. If you did not overtop the reservoir, you still have a job and you are hired for the next season! Observed inflows Forecast on April 1 Our volunteer's results q 120 100 80 60 q 55 40 20 q q 0 M q 18 5 22 120 80 70 60 58 40 36 q M J J 42 28 20 0 A 700 110 100 M A q 500 q 300 19 12 10 8 5 Reservoir volume 120 Forecast inflow volume Inflows in the reservoir 130 10 M J J 100 A How did you like this experience as a decision-maker? M J August 1st
  • 149. It is April 1st. The reservoir is at 450 M m3 You are given the inflow forecasts on April 1st. Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3 140 130 Forecast inflow volume 110 100 80 70 58 60 40 42 36 28 20 q 0 M 19 12 10 8 5 A 10 M J Forecast issued on the previous month 120 max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%) J Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st. If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired. NEXT
  • 150. 140 It is April 1st. 130 Forecast issued on the previous month 120 Forecast inflow volume 110 And our volunteer? Let’s see which release option our volunteer will choose. 100 80 70 58 60 40 36 28 20 q 0 M Option A 37 Release 38 35 Reservoir volume 700 55 58 5 A 60 M 57 J J 17 23 29 25 A M J J 700 500 q 10 Option C 700 500 19 12 10 8 Option B 45 42 500 q q 300 300 300 100 100 100 A M q J J A M J J Current reservoir volume Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%)
  • 151. April has gone by. April inflow was: 18 M m3 You can update your reservoir volume: The volume on May 1st is: April 1 volume + 18 M m3 - April release = ? Did you overtop your reservoir? NO, I still have my job. YES, I got fired... What about our volunteer?
  • 152. April has gone by. April inflow was: 18 M m3 Our volunteer’s April release was: 17 M m3 The volume on May 1st is therefore: 450 M m3 +18 M m3 -17 M m3 = 451 M m3 No overtop! The volunteer still has a job! Let’s go to the next forecast!
  • 153. Previous decisions: C It is May 1st. The reservoir is at 451 M m3 You are given the inflow forecasts on May 1st. Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3 Forecast inflow volume 100 92 85 80 60 65 56 40 36 20 q q 0 M 35 22 18 18 Forecast issued on the previous month 120 120 max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%) 5 A M J J Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st. If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired. NEXT
  • 154. Previous decisions: C Forecast inflow volume It is May 1st. And our volunteer? Let’s see which release option our volunteer will choose. 100 92 85 80 60 40 36 20 q q M 59 Release 56 Reservoir volume 700 500 45 500 22 18 18 A M J J Option C 46 39 700 q 35 5 Option B 60 65 56 0 Option A Forecast issued on the previous month 120 120 26 24 25 M J J 700 500 q 300 300 300 100 100 q 100 M q J J M J J Current reservoir volume Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%)
  • 155. May has gone by. May inflow was: 55 M m3 You can update your reservoir volume: The volume on June 1st is: May 1 volume + 55 M m3 - May release = ? Did you overtop your reservoir? NO, I still have my job. YES, I got fired... What about our volunteer?
  • 156. May has gone by. May inflow was: 55 M m3 Our volunteer’s May release was: 26 M m3 The volume on June 1st is therefore: 451 M m3 +55 M m3 -26 M m3 = 480 M m3 No overtop! The volunteer still has a job! Let’s go to the next forecast!
  • 157. Previous decisions: C C It is June 1st. The reservoir is at 480 M m3 You are given the inflow forecasts on June 1st. Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3 110 Forecast inflow volume 92 80 79 60 q 55 52 40 35 20 q q 23 18 5 Forecast issued on the previous month 100 max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%) 0 M A M J J Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st. If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired. NEXT
  • 158. Previous decisions: C C 110 It is June 1st. 100 Let’s see which release option our volunteer will choose. 80 Forecast issued on the previous month And our volunteer? Forecast inflow volume 92 79 60 55 q 52 40 35 20 q q 23 18 5 0 M Option A Option B 28 Release 30 Reservoir volume 700 60 500 q M J J Option C 50 700 500 A 45 35 J J 700 500 q 300 300 300 100 100 q 100 J q J J J Current reservoir volume Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%)
  • 159. June has gone by. June inflow was: 120 M m3 You can update your reservoir volume: The volume on July 1st is: June 1 volume + 120 M m3 - June release = ? Did you overtop your reservoir? NO, I still have my job. YES, I got fired... What about our volunteer?
  • 160. June has gone by. June inflow was: 120 M m3 Our volunteer’s June release was: 28 M m3 The volume on July 1st is therefore: 480 M m3 +120 M m3 -28 M m3 = 572 M m3 Overtop! The volunteer got fired! Can it be fixed?
  • 161. Previous decisions: C C A It is July 1st. The reservoir is at 572 M m3 You are given the inflow forecasts on July 1st. Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3 q 120 100 80 60 q 55 40 28 20 q q 0 M 21 19 18 Forecast issued on the previous month Forecast inflow volume 120 max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%) 5 A M J J Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st. If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired. NEXT
  • 162. Previous decisions: C C A And our volunteer? Let’s see which release option our volunteer will choose. Forecast inflow volume It is July 1st. q 100 80 60 40 28 20 q q M Reservoir volume A M J J Option C 60 700 21 19 18 5 Option B Release 55 q 0 Option A 120 25 700 q Forecast issued on the previous month 120 40 700 q q 500 500 500 300 300 300 100 100 100 J q J Current reservoir volume Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast J max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%)
  • 163. July has gone by. July inflow was: 22 M m3 You can update your reservoir volume: The volume on August 1st is: July 1 volume + 22 M m3 - July release = ? Did you overtop your reservoir? NO, I still have my job. YES, I got fired... What about our volunteer?
  • 164. July has gone by. July inflow was: 22 M m3 Our volunteer’s July release was: 60 M m3 The volume on August 1st is therefore: 572 M m3 +22 M m3 -60 M m3 = 534 M m3 Overtop! The volunteer did not get the job back! NEXT
  • 165. Previous decisions: C C A A GAME OVER August 1st has arrived. If you did not overtop the reservoir, you still have a job and you are hired for the next season! Observed inflows Forecast on April 1 Our volunteer's results q 120 100 80 60 q 55 40 20 q q 0 M q 18 5 22 120 80 70 60 58 40 36 q M J J 42 28 20 0 A 700 110 100 M A q 500 q q 300 19 12 10 8 5 Reservoir volume 120 Forecast inflow volume Inflows in the reservoir 130 10 M J J 100 A How did you like this experience as a decision-maker? M J August 1st
  • 166. It is April 1st. The reservoir is at 450 M m3 You are given the inflow forecasts on April 1st. Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3 140 130 Forecast inflow volume 110 100 80 70 58 60 40 42 36 28 20 q 0 M 19 12 10 8 5 A 10 M J Forecast issued on the previous month 120 max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%) J Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st. If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired. NEXT
  • 167. 140 It is April 1st. 130 Forecast issued on the previous month 120 Forecast inflow volume 110 And our volunteer? Let’s see which release option our volunteer will choose. 100 80 70 58 60 40 36 28 20 q 0 M Option A 37 Release 38 35 Reservoir volume 700 55 58 5 A 60 M 57 J J 17 23 29 25 A M J J 700 500 q 10 Option C 700 500 19 12 10 8 Option B 45 42 500 q q 300 300 300 100 100 100 A M q J J A M J J Current reservoir volume Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%)
  • 168. April has gone by. April inflow was: 18 M m3 You can update your reservoir volume: The volume on May 1st is: April 1 volume + 18 M m3 - April release = ? Did you overtop your reservoir? NO, I still have my job. YES, I got fired... What about our volunteer?
  • 169. April has gone by. April inflow was: 18 M m3 Our volunteer’s April release was: 37 M m3 The volume on May 1st is therefore: 450 M m3 +18 M m3 -37 M m3 = 431 M m3 No overtop! The volunteer still has a job! Let’s go to the next forecast!
  • 170. Previous decisions: A It is May 1st. The reservoir is at 431 M m3 You are given the inflow forecasts on May 1st. Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3 Forecast inflow volume 100 92 85 80 60 65 56 40 36 20 q q 0 M 35 22 18 18 Forecast issued on the previous month 120 120 max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%) 5 A M J J Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st. If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired. NEXT
  • 171. Previous decisions: A Forecast inflow volume It is May 1st. And our volunteer? Let’s see which release option our volunteer will choose. 100 92 85 80 60 40 36 20 q q M 59 Release 56 45 A 22 18 18 M J J Option C 46 39 26 700 Reservoir volume 35 5 Option B 60 65 56 0 Option A Forecast issued on the previous month 120 120 700 500 25 M J J 700 500 24 500 q q q 300 300 300 100 100 100 M q J J M J J Current reservoir volume Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%)
  • 172. May has gone by. May inflow was: 55 M m3 You can update your reservoir volume: The volume on June 1st is: May 1 volume + 55 M m3 - May release = ? Did you overtop your reservoir? NO, I still have my job. YES, I got fired... What about our volunteer?
  • 173. May has gone by. May inflow was: 55 M m3 Our volunteer’s May release was: 59 M m3 The volume on June 1st is therefore: 431 M m3 +55 M m3 -59 M m3 = 427 M m3 No overtop! The volunteer still has a job! Let’s go to the next forecast!
  • 174. Previous decisions: A A It is June 1st. The reservoir is at 427 M m3 You are given the inflow forecasts on June 1st. Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3 110 Forecast inflow volume 92 80 79 60 q 55 52 40 35 20 q q 23 18 5 Forecast issued on the previous month 100 max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%) 0 M A M J J Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st. If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired. NEXT
  • 175. Previous decisions: A A 110 It is June 1st. 100 Let’s see which release option our volunteer will choose. 80 Forecast issued on the previous month And our volunteer? Forecast inflow volume 92 79 60 55 q 52 40 35 20 q q 23 18 5 0 M Option A A Option B 28 Release 30 J J Option C 60 50 45 700 Reservoir volume M 700 500 J J 700 500 35 500 q q q 300 300 300 100 100 100 J q J J J Current reservoir volume Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%)
  • 176. June has gone by. June inflow was: 120 M m3 You can update your reservoir volume: The volume on July 1st is: June 1 volume + 120 M m3 - June release = ? Did you overtop your reservoir? NO, I still have my job. YES, I got fired... What about our volunteer?
  • 177. June has gone by. June inflow was: 120 M m3 Our volunteer’s June release was: 60 M m3 The volume on July 1st is therefore: 427 M m3 +120 M m3 -60 M m3 = 487 M m3 No overtop! The volunteer still has a job! Let’s go to the next forecast!
  • 178. Previous decisions: A A B It is July 1st. The reservoir is at 487 M m3 You are given the inflow forecasts on July 1st. Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3 q 120 100 80 60 q 55 40 28 20 q q 0 M 21 19 18 Forecast issued on the previous month Forecast inflow volume 120 max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%) 5 A M J J Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st. If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired. NEXT
  • 179. Previous decisions: A A B And our volunteer? Let’s see which release option our volunteer will choose. Forecast inflow volume It is July 1st. q 100 80 60 40 28 20 q q M Reservoir volume 500 q M J J 25 700 500 A Option C 60 700 21 19 18 5 Option B Release 55 q 0 Option A 120 Forecast issued on the previous month 120 40 700 500 q 300 300 300 100 100 q 100 J q J Current reservoir volume Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast J max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%)
  • 180. July has gone by. July inflow was: 22 M m3 You can update your reservoir volume: The volume on August 1st is: July 1 volume + 22 M m3 - July release = ? Did you overtop your reservoir? NO, I still have my job. YES, I got fired... What about our volunteer?
  • 181. July has gone by. July inflow was: 22 M m3 Our volunteer’s July release was: 60 M m3 The volume on August 1st is therefore: 487 M m3 +22 M m3 -60 M m3 = 449 M m3 No overtop! The volunteer still has a job! NEXT
  • 182. Previous decisions: A A B A GAME OVER August 1st has arrived. If you did not overtop the reservoir, you still have a job and you are hired for the next season! Observed inflows Forecast on April 1 Our volunteer's results q 120 100 80 60 q 55 40 20 q q 0 M q 18 5 22 120 80 70 60 58 40 36 q M J J 42 28 20 0 A 700 110 100 M A 500 q 300 19 12 10 8 5 Reservoir volume 120 Forecast inflow volume Inflows in the reservoir 130 10 M J J 100 A How did you like this experience as a decision-maker? M J August 1st
  • 183. It is April 1st. The reservoir is at 450 M m3 You are given the inflow forecasts on April 1st. Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3 140 130 Forecast inflow volume 110 100 80 70 58 60 40 42 36 28 20 q 0 M 19 12 10 8 5 A 10 M J Forecast issued on the previous month 120 max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%) J Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st. If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired. NEXT
  • 184. 140 It is April 1st. 130 Forecast issued on the previous month 120 Forecast inflow volume 110 And our volunteer? Let’s see which release option our volunteer will choose. 100 80 70 58 60 40 36 28 20 q 0 M Option A 37 Release 38 35 Reservoir volume 700 55 58 5 A 60 M 57 J J 17 23 29 25 A M J J 700 500 q 10 Option C 700 500 19 12 10 8 Option B 45 42 500 q q 300 300 300 100 100 100 A M q J J A M J J Current reservoir volume Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%)
  • 185. April has gone by. April inflow was: 18 M m3 You can update your reservoir volume: The volume on May 1st is: April 1 volume + 18 M m3 - April release = ? Did you overtop your reservoir? NO, I still have my job. YES, I got fired... What about our volunteer?
  • 186. April has gone by. April inflow was: 18 M m3 Our volunteer’s April release was: 55 M m3 The volume on May 1st is therefore: 450 M m3 +18 M m3 -55 M m3 = 413 M m3 No overtop! The volunteer still has a job! Let’s go to the next forecast!
  • 187. Previous decisions: B It is May 1st. The reservoir is at 413 M m3 You are given the inflow forecasts on May 1st. Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3 Forecast inflow volume 100 92 85 80 60 65 56 40 36 20 q q 0 M 35 22 18 18 Forecast issued on the previous month 120 120 max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%) 5 A M J J Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st. If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired. NEXT
  • 188. Previous decisions: B Forecast inflow volume It is May 1st. And our volunteer? Let’s see which release option our volunteer will choose. 100 92 85 80 60 40 36 20 q q M 59 Release 56 45 A 22 18 18 M J J Option C 46 39 26 700 Reservoir volume 35 5 Option B 60 65 56 0 Option A Forecast issued on the previous month 120 120 700 500 25 M J J 700 500 24 500 q q q 300 300 300 100 100 100 M q J J M J J Current reservoir volume Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%)
  • 189. May has gone by. May inflow was: 55 M m3 You can update your reservoir volume: The volume on June 1st is: May 1 volume + 55 M m3 - May release = ? Did you overtop your reservoir? NO, I still have my job. YES, I got fired... What about our volunteer?
  • 190. May has gone by. May inflow was: 55 M m3 Our volunteer’s May release was: 59 M m3 The volume on June 1st is therefore: 413 M m3 +55 M m3 -59 M m3 = 409 M m3 No overtop! The volunteer still has a job! Let’s go to the next forecast!
  • 191. Previous decisions: B A It is June 1st. The reservoir is at 409 M m3 You are given the inflow forecasts on June 1st. Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3 110 Forecast inflow volume 92 80 79 60 q 55 52 40 35 20 q q 23 18 5 Forecast issued on the previous month 100 max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%) 0 M A M J J Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st. If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired. NEXT
  • 192. Previous decisions: B A 110 It is June 1st. 100 Let’s see which release option our volunteer will choose. 80 Forecast issued on the previous month And our volunteer? Forecast inflow volume 92 79 60 55 q 52 40 35 20 q q 23 18 5 0 M Option A A Option B 28 Release 30 J J Option C 60 50 45 700 Reservoir volume M 700 500 J J 700 500 35 500 q q q 300 300 300 100 100 100 J q J J J Current reservoir volume Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%)
  • 193. June has gone by. June inflow was: 120 M m3 You can update your reservoir volume: The volume on July 1st is: June 1 volume + 120 M m3 - June release = ? Did you overtop your reservoir? NO, I still have my job. YES, I got fired... What about our volunteer?
  • 194. June has gone by. June inflow was: 120 M m3 Our volunteer’s June release was: 60 M m3 The volume on July 1st is therefore: 409 M m3 +120 M m3 -60 M m3 = 469 M m3 No overtop! The volunteer still has a job! Let’s go to the next forecast!
  • 195. Previous decisions: B A B It is July 1st. The reservoir is at 469 M m3 You are given the inflow forecasts on July 1st. Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3 q 120 100 80 60 q 55 40 28 20 q q 0 M 21 19 18 Forecast issued on the previous month Forecast inflow volume 120 max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%) 5 A M J J Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st. If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired. NEXT
  • 196. Previous decisions: B A B And our volunteer? Let’s see which release option our volunteer will choose. Forecast inflow volume It is July 1st. q 100 80 60 40 28 20 q q M Reservoir volume 500 q M J J 25 700 500 A Option C 60 700 21 19 18 5 Option B Release 55 q 0 Option A 120 Forecast issued on the previous month 120 40 700 500 q 300 300 300 100 100 q 100 J q J Current reservoir volume Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast J max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%)
  • 197. July has gone by. July inflow was: 22 M m3 You can update your reservoir volume: The volume on August 1st is: July 1 volume + 22 M m3 - July release = ? Did you overtop your reservoir? NO, I still have my job. YES, I got fired... What about our volunteer?
  • 198. July has gone by. July inflow was: 22 M m3 Our volunteer’s July release was: 60 M m3 The volume on August 1st is therefore: 469 M m3 +22 M m3 -60 M m3 = 431 M m3 No overtop! The volunteer still has a job! NEXT
  • 199. Previous decisions: B A B A GAME OVER August 1st has arrived. If you did not overtop the reservoir, you still have a job and you are hired for the next season! Observed inflows Forecast on April 1 Our volunteer's results q 120 100 80 60 q 55 40 20 q q 0 M q 18 5 22 120 80 70 60 58 40 36 q M J J 42 28 20 0 A 700 110 100 M A 500 q 300 19 12 10 8 5 Reservoir volume 120 Forecast inflow volume Inflows in the reservoir 130 10 M J J 100 A How did you like this experience as a decision-maker? M J August 1st
  • 200. It is April 1st. The reservoir is at 450 M m3 You are given the inflow forecasts on April 1st. Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3 140 130 Forecast inflow volume 110 100 80 70 58 60 40 42 36 28 20 q 0 M 19 12 10 8 5 A 10 M J Forecast issued on the previous month 120 max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%) J Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st. If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired. NEXT
  • 201. 140 It is April 1st. 130 Forecast issued on the previous month 120 Forecast inflow volume 110 And our volunteer? Let’s see which release option our volunteer will choose. 100 80 70 58 60 40 36 28 20 q 0 M Option A 37 Release 38 35 Reservoir volume 700 55 58 5 A 60 M 57 J J 17 23 29 25 A M J J 700 500 q 10 Option C 700 500 19 12 10 8 Option B 45 42 500 q q 300 300 300 100 100 100 A M q J J A M J J Current reservoir volume Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%)
  • 202. April has gone by. April inflow was: 18 M m3 You can update your reservoir volume: The volume on May 1st is: April 1 volume + 18 M m3 - April release = ? Did you overtop your reservoir? NO, I still have my job. YES, I got fired... What about our volunteer?
  • 203. April has gone by. April inflow was: 18 M m3 Our volunteer’s April release was: 17 M m3 The volume on May 1st is therefore: 450 M m3 +18 M m3 -17 M m3 = 451 M m3 No overtop! The volunteer still has a job! Let’s go to the next forecast!
  • 204. Previous decisions: C It is May 1st. The reservoir is at 451 M m3 You are given the inflow forecasts on May 1st. Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3 Forecast inflow volume 100 92 85 80 60 65 56 40 36 20 q q 0 M 35 22 18 18 Forecast issued on the previous month 120 120 max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%) 5 A M J J Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st. If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired. NEXT
  • 205. Previous decisions: C Forecast inflow volume It is May 1st. And our volunteer? Let’s see which release option our volunteer will choose. 100 92 85 80 60 40 36 20 q q M 59 Release 56 Reservoir volume 700 500 45 500 22 18 18 A M J J Option C 46 39 700 q 35 5 Option B 60 65 56 0 Option A Forecast issued on the previous month 120 120 26 24 25 M J J 700 500 q 300 300 300 100 100 q 100 M q J J M J J Current reservoir volume Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%)
  • 206. May has gone by. May inflow was: 55 M m3 You can update your reservoir volume: The volume on June 1st is: May 1 volume + 55 M m3 - May release = ? Did you overtop your reservoir? NO, I still have my job. YES, I got fired... What about our volunteer?
  • 207. May has gone by. May inflow was: 55 M m3 Our volunteer’s May release was: 59 M m3 The volume on June 1st is therefore: 451 M m3 +55 M m3 -59 M m3 = 447 M m3 No overtop! The volunteer still has a job! Let’s go to the next forecast!
  • 208. Previous decisions: C A It is June 1st. The reservoir is at 447 M m3 You are given the inflow forecasts on June 1st. Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3 110 Forecast inflow volume 92 80 79 60 q 55 52 40 35 20 q q 23 18 5 Forecast issued on the previous month 100 max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%) 0 M A M J J Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st. If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired. NEXT
  • 209. Previous decisions: C A 110 It is June 1st. 100 Let’s see which release option our volunteer will choose. 80 Forecast issued on the previous month And our volunteer? Forecast inflow volume 92 79 60 55 q 52 40 35 20 q q 23 18 5 0 M Option A Option B 28 Release 30 700 Reservoir volume A 60 J 50 45 35 J J 700 500 q J Option C 700 500 M 500 q q 300 300 300 100 100 100 J q J J J Current reservoir volume Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%)
  • 210. June has gone by. June inflow was: 120 M m3 You can update your reservoir volume: The volume on July 1st is: June 1 volume + 120 M m3 - June release = ? Did you overtop your reservoir? NO, I still have my job. YES, I got fired... What about our volunteer?
  • 211. June has gone by. June inflow was: 120 M m3 Our volunteer’s June release was: 60 M m3 The volume on July 1st is therefore: 447 M m3 +120 M m3 -60 M m3 = 507 M m3 Overtop! The volunteer got fired! Can it be fixed?
  • 212. Previous decisions: C A B It is July 1st. The reservoir is at 507 M m3 You are given the inflow forecasts on July 1st. Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3 q 120 100 80 60 q 55 40 28 20 q q 0 M 21 19 18 Forecast issued on the previous month Forecast inflow volume 120 max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%) 5 A M J J Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st. If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired. NEXT
  • 213. Previous decisions: C A B And our volunteer? Let’s see which release option our volunteer will choose. Forecast inflow volume It is July 1st. q 100 80 60 40 28 20 q q M Reservoir volume q M J J 25 700 500 A Option C 60 700 21 19 18 5 Option B Release 55 q 0 Option A 120 500 Forecast issued on the previous month 120 40 700 q 500 300 300 300 100 100 q 100 J q J Current reservoir volume Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast J max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%)
  • 214. July has gone by. July inflow was: 22 M m3 You can update your reservoir volume: The volume on August 1st is: July 1 volume + 22 M m3 - July release = ? Did you overtop your reservoir? NO, I still have my job. YES, I got fired... What about our volunteer?
  • 215. July has gone by. July inflow was: 22 M m3 Our volunteer’s July release was: 60 M m3 The volume on August 1st is therefore: 507 M m3 +22 M m3 -60 M m3 = 469 M m3 No overtop! The volunteer got the job back! NEXT
  • 216. Previous decisions: C A B A GAME OVER August 1st has arrived. If you did not overtop the reservoir, you still have a job and you are hired for the next season! Observed inflows Forecast on April 1 Our volunteer's results q 120 100 80 60 q 55 40 20 q q 0 M q 18 5 22 120 80 70 60 58 40 36 q M J J 42 28 20 0 A 700 110 100 M A q 500 q 300 19 12 10 8 5 Reservoir volume 120 Forecast inflow volume Inflows in the reservoir 130 10 M J J 100 A How did you like this experience as a decision-maker? M J August 1st
  • 217. It is April 1st. The reservoir is at 450 M m3 You are given the inflow forecasts on April 1st. Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3 140 130 Forecast inflow volume 110 100 80 70 58 60 40 42 36 28 20 q 0 M 19 12 10 8 5 A 10 M J Forecast issued on the previous month 120 max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%) J Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st. If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired. NEXT
  • 218. 140 It is April 1st. 130 Forecast issued on the previous month 120 Forecast inflow volume 110 And our volunteer? Let’s see which release option our volunteer will choose. 100 80 70 58 60 40 36 28 20 q 0 M Option A 37 Release 38 35 Reservoir volume 700 55 58 5 A 60 M 57 J J 17 23 29 25 A M J J 700 500 q 10 Option C 700 500 19 12 10 8 Option B 45 42 500 q q 300 300 300 100 100 100 A M q J J A M J J Current reservoir volume Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%)
  • 219. April has gone by. April inflow was: 18 M m3 You can update your reservoir volume: The volume on May 1st is: April 1 volume + 18 M m3 - April release = ? Did you overtop your reservoir? NO, I still have my job. YES, I got fired... What about our volunteer?
  • 220. April has gone by. April inflow was: 18 M m3 Our volunteer’s April release was: 37 M m3 The volume on May 1st is therefore: 450 M m3 +18 M m3 -37 M m3 = 431 M m3 No overtop! The volunteer still has a job! Let’s go to the next forecast!
  • 221. Previous decisions: A It is May 1st. The reservoir is at 431 M m3 You are given the inflow forecasts on May 1st. Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3 Forecast inflow volume 100 92 85 80 60 65 56 40 36 20 q q 0 M 35 22 18 18 Forecast issued on the previous month 120 120 max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%) 5 A M J J Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st. If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired. NEXT
  • 222. Previous decisions: A Forecast inflow volume It is May 1st. And our volunteer? Let’s see which release option our volunteer will choose. 100 92 85 80 60 40 36 20 q q M 59 Release 56 45 A 22 18 18 M J J Option C 46 39 26 700 Reservoir volume 35 5 Option B 60 65 56 0 Option A Forecast issued on the previous month 120 120 700 500 25 M J J 700 500 24 500 q q q 300 300 300 100 100 100 M q J J M J J Current reservoir volume Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%)
  • 223. May has gone by. May inflow was: 55 M m3 You can update your reservoir volume: The volume on June 1st is: May 1 volume + 55 M m3 - May release = ? Did you overtop your reservoir? NO, I still have my job. YES, I got fired... What about our volunteer?
  • 224. May has gone by. May inflow was: 55 M m3 Our volunteer’s May release was: 45 M m3 The volume on June 1st is therefore: 431 M m3 +55 M m3 -45 M m3 = 441 M m3 No overtop! The volunteer still has a job! Let’s go to the next forecast!
  • 225. Previous decisions: A B It is June 1st. The reservoir is at 441 M m3 You are given the inflow forecasts on June 1st. Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3 110 Forecast inflow volume 92 80 79 60 q 55 52 40 35 20 q q 23 18 5 Forecast issued on the previous month 100 max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%) 0 M A M J J Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st. If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired. NEXT
  • 226. Previous decisions: A B 110 It is June 1st. 100 Let’s see which release option our volunteer will choose. 80 Forecast issued on the previous month And our volunteer? Forecast inflow volume 92 79 60 55 q 52 40 35 20 q q 23 18 5 0 M Option A Option B 28 Release 30 700 Reservoir volume A 60 J 50 45 35 J J 700 500 q J Option C 700 500 M 500 q q 300 300 300 100 100 100 J q J J J Current reservoir volume Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%)
  • 227. June has gone by. June inflow was: 120 M m3 You can update your reservoir volume: The volume on July 1st is: June 1 volume + 120 M m3 - June release = ? Did you overtop your reservoir? NO, I still have my job. YES, I got fired... What about our volunteer?
  • 228. June has gone by. June inflow was: 120 M m3 Our volunteer’s June release was: 60 M m3 The volume on July 1st is therefore: 441 M m3 +120 M m3 -60 M m3 = 501 M m3 Overtop! The volunteer got fired! Can it be fixed?
  • 229. Previous decisions: A B B It is July 1st. The reservoir is at 501 M m3 You are given the inflow forecasts on July 1st. Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3 q 120 100 80 60 q 55 40 28 20 q q 0 M 21 19 18 Forecast issued on the previous month Forecast inflow volume 120 max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%) 5 A M J J Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st. If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired. NEXT
  • 230. Previous decisions: A B B And our volunteer? Let’s see which release option our volunteer will choose. Forecast inflow volume It is July 1st. q 100 80 60 40 28 20 q q M Reservoir volume q M J J 25 700 500 A Option C 60 700 21 19 18 5 Option B Release 55 q 0 Option A 120 500 Forecast issued on the previous month 120 40 700 q 500 300 300 300 100 100 q 100 J q J Current reservoir volume Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast J max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%)
  • 231. July has gone by. July inflow was: 22 M m3 You can update your reservoir volume: The volume on August 1st is: July 1 volume + 22 M m3 - July release = ? Did you overtop your reservoir? NO, I still have my job. YES, I got fired... What about our volunteer?
  • 232. July has gone by. July inflow was: 22 M m3 Our volunteer’s July release was: 60 M m3 The volume on August 1st is therefore: 501 M m3 +22 M m3 -60 M m3 = 463 M m3 No overtop! The volunteer got the job back! NEXT
  • 233. Previous decisions: A B B A GAME OVER August 1st has arrived. If you did not overtop the reservoir, you still have a job and you are hired for the next season! Observed inflows Forecast on April 1 Our volunteer's results q 120 100 80 60 q 55 40 20 q q 0 M q 18 5 22 120 80 70 60 58 40 36 q M J J 42 28 20 0 A 700 110 100 M A 500 q q 300 19 12 10 8 5 Reservoir volume 120 Forecast inflow volume Inflows in the reservoir 130 10 M J J 100 A How did you like this experience as a decision-maker? M J August 1st
  • 234. It is April 1st. The reservoir is at 450 M m3 You are given the inflow forecasts on April 1st. Please fill in your release schedule. Remember: 15 M m3 ≤ Release ≤ 60 M m3 140 130 Forecast inflow volume 110 100 80 70 58 60 40 42 36 28 20 q 0 M 19 12 10 8 5 A 10 M J Forecast issued on the previous month 120 max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%) J Reservoir should be close to 500 M m3 on August 1st. If the volume exceeds 500 M m3 , you are fired. NEXT
  • 235. 140 It is April 1st. 130 Forecast issued on the previous month 120 Forecast inflow volume 110 And our volunteer? Let’s see which release option our volunteer will choose. 100 80 70 58 60 40 36 28 20 q 0 M Option A 37 Release 38 35 Reservoir volume 700 55 58 5 A 60 M 57 J J 17 23 29 25 A M J J 700 500 q 10 Option C 700 500 19 12 10 8 Option B 45 42 500 q q 300 300 300 100 100 100 A M q J J A M J J Current reservoir volume Reservoir volume assuming inflow is median forecast Reservoir volume assuming inflow is min/max forecast max (95%) 75% 50% 25% min (5%)