SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 23
Business Valuation Boot Camp
Curtis A. Farrow, CPA, MBA
Senior Financial Analyst, Valuation Services
(720) 839-6130
cfarrow@gbq.com
Agenda 2
• Introduction & Reasons for a Valuation
•What is Value?
• Valuation Principles & Methodologies
Business Valuation Boot Camp
Introduction & Reasons for a Valuation
What is Business Valuation?
• Business Valuation involves estimating/appraising the
value of a business or business interest
• Business valuation analysis is a surrogate for public market
• Business valuation is most prevalent in hard-to-value
assets such as stock in privately held businesses
• BV is analogous to real estate appraisal
4
When are Valuations Needed? 5
“Magnificent Seven” Questions to Ask when
Selecting a Valuation Advisor
1. What % of your career is dedicated to BV (100% is the correct answer)
and how many BV professionals are on your staff?
2. How many BVs have you/your firm completed?
3. How many BVs for this purpose have you/your firm completed?
4. Professional certifications related to BV (e.g., CFA, ASA, ABV)?
5. Have you given presentations/written articles on BV?
6. Can I have references from former clients, advisors, etc.?
7. Fee structure and expected turnaround time
6
Typical Valuation Process
1. Scoping Out the Engagement
• Confirm Purpose/Standard of Value/Valuation Date
• Fee Quote/Timing
• Complexity/Intended Audience
2. Review & Analyze Requested Information
• Business and Industry
• Historical/Projected Financial Performance
3. Due Diligence Meetings/Management Interviews
4. Select & Apply Appropriate Valuation Methodologies
5. Present Conclusions
7
Business Valuation Boot Camp
What is Value?
What Standard of Value?
Liquidation Value
• “Fire sale” of assets; lowest type of value
Fair Market Value
• The price at which an asset would change hands between a willing
buyer and a willing seller, when the former is not under any
compulsion to buy and the latter is not under any compulsion to
sell, both parties being able, as well as willing, to trade and well-
informed about the asset and the market for the asset.
• Assumes a financial buyer…no acquirer synergies are considered
• This is the typical definition for regulatory purposes (e.g., IRS, DOL,
etc.)
Strategic Value
• Value to strategic buyer, considering add-backs, synergies, etc.
• Value is buyer-specific (i.e., different buyers will have different
perceived values)
9
Enterprise Value vs. Equity Value
Enterprise Value the value of the business
as a whole; may be viewed as:
• Total invested capital (equity + debt – cash)
Equity Value = Enterprise Value – Debt +
Cash
• Represents shareholder value (i.e., stock value)
• Zero-sum game: $1 more of debt = $1 less of equity
• Analogous to home value less mortgage
10
Business Valuation Boot Camp
Valuation Principles & Methodologies
Valuation Methodologies
Asset Approach
• Going Concern
• Liquidation
Income Approach
• Multiple-Period Discounting Method (e.g., discounted cash
flow)
• Single-Period Capitalization Method (e.g., capitalized cash
flow)
Market Approach
• Guideline Public Company Method
• Guideline Transaction (M&A) Method
12
Overview of Valuation Principles
Valuation Must be Forward-Looking
•Must consider anticipated future performance
•Historical performance may help predict the future
Future Cash Flow is Key Driver of Value
•Future cash flow is king
•Must consider risk in realizing projected cash flow
Factors Considered in Valuations
•Historical and expected future performance & trends
•Market multiples of comparable companies and transactions
•Economic, industry, and company-specific factors
13
Asset Approach Overview
Premise: The value of a business can be estimated based
on the value of its underlying assets and liabilities
Adjust ALL assets and liabilities to FMV
• Must include booked and un-booked assets and liabilities
• Must include tangible and intangible assets and liabilities
When is the Asset Approach Most Appropriate?
• Generally appropriate for holding companies or asset-
intensive companies with modest profitability
• Generally less appropriate for profitable operating entities
14
Income Approach Overview
Premise: The value of a business can be estimated based on
the present value of the future economic benefits it generates
Steps in performing the income approach:
• Select & Determine Earnings Stream
• Develop Appropriate Required Rate of Return
• Select & Apply Multi-Period or Single-Period Model
15
Preferred Earnings Stream: Distributable Cash Flow
Normalized After-Tax Net Income
+ Depreciation and Amortization
- Capital Expenditures
+/- Additional Net Working Capital Requirements
= Distributable (Debt-Free) Cash Flow
16
Required Rate of Return
An investor’s required ROR is a function of the
perceived risk & potential of the investment
Cost of Equity (ke) = Rf + (ERP x β) +/- Company-
specific risk factors
WACC = ke*%e + kd*%d
Match Cash Flow with Rate of Return:
• Cash Flow Available to Debt & Equity – Use WACC
• Cash Flow Available to Equity Only – Use Cost of Equity
17
Selecting a Model: Discounted Cash Flow vs.
Capitalized Cash Flow
Multiple-Period Models (e.g., discounted future cash flow)
are often far more appropriate because:
• Can account for anticipated changes in the business such as
growth rates, margins, upcoming investments, business strategies,
etc.
Single Period Models:
• Only appropriate if growth in future cash flows is projected to be
constant
• Difficult to rely on single-period models during times of turbulent
economic conditions and/or volatile company performance
18
Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4 Year 5
Distributable Net Cash Flow 5,000,000$ 5,500,000$ 5,940,000$ 6,296,400$ 6,611,220$
Present Value Factor @ 18.0% 0.9206 0.7801 0.6611 0.5603 0.4748
Present Value of Distributable Cash Flow 4,602,873$ 4,290,814$ 3,927,186$ 3,527,811$ 3,139,154$
Present Value of Cash Flows (Years 1 to 5) 19,487,838$ Year 5 Cash Flow 6,611,220$
Present Value of Residual Cash Flow 25,354,703 Multiplied by: 1 + Growth Rate 1.05
Residual Cash Flow 6,941,781
Enterprise Value 44,842,541
Discount Rate 18.0%
Rounded 44,800,000$ Less: Residual Growth Rate -5.0%
Capitalization Rate 13.0%
Residual Cash Flow Value 53,398,315
Present Value Factor 0.4748
PV of Residual Cash Flow 25,354,703$
Discounted Cash Flow Example
19
Market Approach Overview
Premise: The value of a business can be estimated based on
comparisons to similar businesses
Guideline Public Company Method
• Stock market is the best and most accurate source of valuation
data; it is the source of rate of return data in income approach
• Compare fundamentals of subject company and peer group of
publicly traded companies
• Apply pricing multiples (e.g., price-to-earnings, enterprise value-
to-EBITDA, etc.) of publicly traded comparable companies
Guideline Transaction Method
• Identical to public company approach, except use transaction
multiples from M&A deals as basis for valuation
• Information about each transaction is typically limited since deals
often involve private companies
20
Guideline Public Company Method Example 21
Closing
Stock Price
(12/31/07)
ABC 5.00$ x 45.52 = 227.6$ + 221.8$ - 108.4$ = 341.0$ 8.5 9.3 0.42
DEF 25.50 x 22.18 = 565.6 + 305.8 - 78.4 = 793.0 7.4 8.6 0.34
GHI 38.75 x 31.54 = 1,222.2 + 751.8 - 45.0 = 1,929.0 10.7 13.1 0.75
JKL 8.00 x 18.95 = 151.6 + 0.0 - 3.6 = 148.0 6.2 7.8 0.33
MNO 9.50 x 24.64 = 234.1 + 18.5 - 8.4 = 244.2 5.4 6.4 0.55
PQR 18.25 x 41.84 = 763.6 + 106.9 - 24.7 = 845.8 6.8 8.5 0.68
STU 14.00 x 35.72 = 500.1 + 247.9 - 7.4 = 740.6 5.7 7.4 0.42
VWX 11.50 x 65.90 = 757.9 + 1,085.2 - 222.1 = 1,621.0 9.5 13.8 0.81
YZ 22.75 x 45.52 = 1,035.6 + 333.6 - 26.9 = 1,342.3 7.1 8.9 0.59
Low 25% 6.2 7.8 0.42
Median 7.1 8.6 0.55
High 25% 8.5 9.3 0.68
Variation 23.8% 26.9% 32.7%
Selected Multiple 6.5 8.1 0.45
Subject Company Results 6.7 5.1 89.6
Suggested Value 43.55 41.31 40.32
Concluded Enterprise Value: $42,000,000
EV /
EBITDA
EV /
EBIT
EV /
Sales
Pricing Multiples
Debt &
Preferred
Stock
Cash and
Equivalents
Enterprise
Value (EV)Co.
Derivation of Enterprise Value
Shares
Outstanding
(millions)
Market Value
of Equity (mil)
• Valuations should consider all methodologies and utilize the
appropriate ones; income and market approaches are most
common with strong, profitable companies
• Valuation opinions supported by multiple valuation methods
are preferable, more defensible, and often lead to more
stable, accurate, and sustainable valuation levels
Valuation Methodologies
Guideline Public
Company Method
Discounted Cash
Flow Method
Net Asset Value
Method
Guideline
Transaction
Method
Valuation
Conclusion
22
Key Valuation Concept: Valuation is Forward-
Looking
23
“It’s tough to
make
predictions,
especially
about the
future.”
-Yogi Berra

More Related Content

What's hot

Business valuation 101
Business valuation 101Business valuation 101
Business valuation 101Dominic Brault
 
Goodwill & its valuation
Goodwill & its valuationGoodwill & its valuation
Goodwill & its valuationrahul aggarwal
 
Company valuation report sample
Company valuation report sampleCompany valuation report sample
Company valuation report sampleEquidam
 
Basic Company Valuation
Basic Company ValuationBasic Company Valuation
Basic Company ValuationFaizanization
 
Business Valuation Basics
Business Valuation BasicsBusiness Valuation Basics
Business Valuation Basicsdpharr
 
Business Valuation, Acquistion and Divestitures
Business Valuation, Acquistion and DivestituresBusiness Valuation, Acquistion and Divestitures
Business Valuation, Acquistion and DivestituresVeracap M&A International
 
Early Stage Valuation
Early Stage ValuationEarly Stage Valuation
Early Stage ValuationEd Usalis
 
Valuation models for early-stage knowledge-based/technology companies
Valuation models for early-stage knowledge-based/technology companiesValuation models for early-stage knowledge-based/technology companies
Valuation models for early-stage knowledge-based/technology companiesGregory Phipps
 
Valuation 2010 Final
Valuation 2010 FinalValuation 2010 Final
Valuation 2010 Finalguest3650df
 
Valuation in merger & aquiseation
Valuation in merger & aquiseation Valuation in merger & aquiseation
Valuation in merger & aquiseation Babasab Patil
 
Valuation Concepts And Overview
Valuation   Concepts And OverviewValuation   Concepts And Overview
Valuation Concepts And OverviewRick Warner, ASA
 
Business Valuation Basics
Business Valuation BasicsBusiness Valuation Basics
Business Valuation BasicsSkoda Minotti
 
Employee Share Schemes & Capital Raising | Wednesdays with Redchip August
Employee Share Schemes & Capital Raising | Wednesdays with Redchip AugustEmployee Share Schemes & Capital Raising | Wednesdays with Redchip August
Employee Share Schemes & Capital Raising | Wednesdays with Redchip AugustRedchip
 
Valuation methodology
Valuation methodologyValuation methodology
Valuation methodologyRod Medallon
 
Introduction to valuation and DCF
Introduction to valuation and DCFIntroduction to valuation and DCF
Introduction to valuation and DCFAditya Komaragiri
 

What's hot (20)

Business valuation 101
Business valuation 101Business valuation 101
Business valuation 101
 
Goodwill & its valuation
Goodwill & its valuationGoodwill & its valuation
Goodwill & its valuation
 
Company valuation report sample
Company valuation report sampleCompany valuation report sample
Company valuation report sample
 
Basic Company Valuation
Basic Company ValuationBasic Company Valuation
Basic Company Valuation
 
Business Valuation
Business ValuationBusiness Valuation
Business Valuation
 
Business Valuation Basics
Business Valuation BasicsBusiness Valuation Basics
Business Valuation Basics
 
Business Valuation, Acquistion and Divestitures
Business Valuation, Acquistion and DivestituresBusiness Valuation, Acquistion and Divestitures
Business Valuation, Acquistion and Divestitures
 
Early Stage Valuation
Early Stage ValuationEarly Stage Valuation
Early Stage Valuation
 
Valuation models for early-stage knowledge-based/technology companies
Valuation models for early-stage knowledge-based/technology companiesValuation models for early-stage knowledge-based/technology companies
Valuation models for early-stage knowledge-based/technology companies
 
Valuation 2010 Final
Valuation 2010 FinalValuation 2010 Final
Valuation 2010 Final
 
Valuation in merger & aquiseation
Valuation in merger & aquiseation Valuation in merger & aquiseation
Valuation in merger & aquiseation
 
Startup Valuation
Startup ValuationStartup Valuation
Startup Valuation
 
Valuation Concepts And Overview
Valuation   Concepts And OverviewValuation   Concepts And Overview
Valuation Concepts And Overview
 
Goodwill
GoodwillGoodwill
Goodwill
 
Business Valuation Basics
Business Valuation BasicsBusiness Valuation Basics
Business Valuation Basics
 
Employee Share Schemes & Capital Raising | Wednesdays with Redchip August
Employee Share Schemes & Capital Raising | Wednesdays with Redchip AugustEmployee Share Schemes & Capital Raising | Wednesdays with Redchip August
Employee Share Schemes & Capital Raising | Wednesdays with Redchip August
 
Valuation
ValuationValuation
Valuation
 
Valuation methodology
Valuation methodologyValuation methodology
Valuation methodology
 
Basic valuation concept final
Basic valuation concept finalBasic valuation concept final
Basic valuation concept final
 
Introduction to valuation and DCF
Introduction to valuation and DCFIntroduction to valuation and DCF
Introduction to valuation and DCF
 

Similar to Business Valuation Boot Camp: Essential Tools for Estimating a Company's Worth

Corporate Finance Fundamentals - Course Presentation.pdf
Corporate Finance Fundamentals - Course Presentation.pdfCorporate Finance Fundamentals - Course Presentation.pdf
Corporate Finance Fundamentals - Course Presentation.pdfJustmeHash
 
Angel investor valuation
Angel investor valuationAngel investor valuation
Angel investor valuationAnjana Vivek
 
Veterinary Practice Valuation
Veterinary Practice ValuationVeterinary Practice Valuation
Veterinary Practice ValuationOculus Insights
 
Be investment Ready: Valuation Simplified
Be investment Ready: Valuation SimplifiedBe investment Ready: Valuation Simplified
Be investment Ready: Valuation SimplifiedEkoInnovationCentre
 
9.14 TCN Calculate Financial Projections
9.14 TCN Calculate Financial Projections 9.14 TCN Calculate Financial Projections
9.14 TCN Calculate Financial Projections Leah Rogoff
 
9.14 TCN Calculate Financial Projections for Investment Presentations
9.14 TCN Calculate Financial Projections for Investment Presentations9.14 TCN Calculate Financial Projections for Investment Presentations
9.14 TCN Calculate Financial Projections for Investment PresentationsThe Capital Network
 
Accounting and Valuation Considerations in Business Transactions
Accounting and Valuation Considerations in Business TransactionsAccounting and Valuation Considerations in Business Transactions
Accounting and Valuation Considerations in Business TransactionsSkoda Minotti
 
Executive Compensation in Privately Held Companies: Attracting, Motivating an...
Executive Compensation in Privately Held Companies: Attracting, Motivating an...Executive Compensation in Privately Held Companies: Attracting, Motivating an...
Executive Compensation in Privately Held Companies: Attracting, Motivating an...CBIZ, Inc.
 
Calculate Financial Projections for Investment Presentations
Calculate Financial Projections for Investment PresentationsCalculate Financial Projections for Investment Presentations
Calculate Financial Projections for Investment PresentationsThe Capital Network
 
Business valuation imec7 22-14-final
Business valuation imec7 22-14-finalBusiness valuation imec7 22-14-final
Business valuation imec7 22-14-finalGlen Birnbaum
 
Business Valuation: Overview & Key Issues
Business Valuation: Overview & Key Issues Business Valuation: Overview & Key Issues
Business Valuation: Overview & Key Issues Corporate Professionals
 
TEDCO Portfolio Workshop: How To Create a Pro Forma That Will Woo Investors
TEDCO Portfolio Workshop: How To Create a Pro Forma That Will Woo InvestorsTEDCO Portfolio Workshop: How To Create a Pro Forma That Will Woo Investors
TEDCO Portfolio Workshop: How To Create a Pro Forma That Will Woo InvestorsTEDCO
 
If You Fail to Plan Will Your Plan Fail? by Jaroslav Trojan
If You Fail to Plan Will Your Plan Fail? by Jaroslav TrojanIf You Fail to Plan Will Your Plan Fail? by Jaroslav Trojan
If You Fail to Plan Will Your Plan Fail? by Jaroslav TrojanStartupYard
 
How to write business plan
How to write business planHow to write business plan
How to write business planSeta Wicaksana
 

Similar to Business Valuation Boot Camp: Essential Tools for Estimating a Company's Worth (20)

Corporate Finance Fundamentals - Course Presentation.pdf
Corporate Finance Fundamentals - Course Presentation.pdfCorporate Finance Fundamentals - Course Presentation.pdf
Corporate Finance Fundamentals - Course Presentation.pdf
 
Valuation
ValuationValuation
Valuation
 
Angel investor valuation
Angel investor valuationAngel investor valuation
Angel investor valuation
 
Veterinary Practice Valuation
Veterinary Practice ValuationVeterinary Practice Valuation
Veterinary Practice Valuation
 
Be investment Ready: Valuation Simplified
Be investment Ready: Valuation SimplifiedBe investment Ready: Valuation Simplified
Be investment Ready: Valuation Simplified
 
2010-Firm Valuation Masterclass
2010-Firm Valuation Masterclass2010-Firm Valuation Masterclass
2010-Firm Valuation Masterclass
 
9.14 TCN Calculate Financial Projections
9.14 TCN Calculate Financial Projections 9.14 TCN Calculate Financial Projections
9.14 TCN Calculate Financial Projections
 
9.14 TCN Calculate Financial Projections for Investment Presentations
9.14 TCN Calculate Financial Projections for Investment Presentations9.14 TCN Calculate Financial Projections for Investment Presentations
9.14 TCN Calculate Financial Projections for Investment Presentations
 
Valuation
ValuationValuation
Valuation
 
Accounting and Valuation Considerations in Business Transactions
Accounting and Valuation Considerations in Business TransactionsAccounting and Valuation Considerations in Business Transactions
Accounting and Valuation Considerations in Business Transactions
 
NCE - NISM Prep .pptx
NCE - NISM Prep .pptxNCE - NISM Prep .pptx
NCE - NISM Prep .pptx
 
Executive Compensation in Privately Held Companies: Attracting, Motivating an...
Executive Compensation in Privately Held Companies: Attracting, Motivating an...Executive Compensation in Privately Held Companies: Attracting, Motivating an...
Executive Compensation in Privately Held Companies: Attracting, Motivating an...
 
Calculate Financial Projections for Investment Presentations
Calculate Financial Projections for Investment PresentationsCalculate Financial Projections for Investment Presentations
Calculate Financial Projections for Investment Presentations
 
Business valuation imec7 22-14-final
Business valuation imec7 22-14-finalBusiness valuation imec7 22-14-final
Business valuation imec7 22-14-final
 
Nz workshop2017
Nz workshop2017Nz workshop2017
Nz workshop2017
 
Business Valuation: Overview & Key Issues
Business Valuation: Overview & Key Issues Business Valuation: Overview & Key Issues
Business Valuation: Overview & Key Issues
 
Buying and selling a business seminar part 1 slides
Buying and selling a business seminar part 1 slidesBuying and selling a business seminar part 1 slides
Buying and selling a business seminar part 1 slides
 
TEDCO Portfolio Workshop: How To Create a Pro Forma That Will Woo Investors
TEDCO Portfolio Workshop: How To Create a Pro Forma That Will Woo InvestorsTEDCO Portfolio Workshop: How To Create a Pro Forma That Will Woo Investors
TEDCO Portfolio Workshop: How To Create a Pro Forma That Will Woo Investors
 
If You Fail to Plan Will Your Plan Fail? by Jaroslav Trojan
If You Fail to Plan Will Your Plan Fail? by Jaroslav TrojanIf You Fail to Plan Will Your Plan Fail? by Jaroslav Trojan
If You Fail to Plan Will Your Plan Fail? by Jaroslav Trojan
 
How to write business plan
How to write business planHow to write business plan
How to write business plan
 

Business Valuation Boot Camp: Essential Tools for Estimating a Company's Worth

  • 1. Business Valuation Boot Camp Curtis A. Farrow, CPA, MBA Senior Financial Analyst, Valuation Services (720) 839-6130 cfarrow@gbq.com
  • 2. Agenda 2 • Introduction & Reasons for a Valuation •What is Value? • Valuation Principles & Methodologies
  • 3. Business Valuation Boot Camp Introduction & Reasons for a Valuation
  • 4. What is Business Valuation? • Business Valuation involves estimating/appraising the value of a business or business interest • Business valuation analysis is a surrogate for public market • Business valuation is most prevalent in hard-to-value assets such as stock in privately held businesses • BV is analogous to real estate appraisal 4
  • 6. “Magnificent Seven” Questions to Ask when Selecting a Valuation Advisor 1. What % of your career is dedicated to BV (100% is the correct answer) and how many BV professionals are on your staff? 2. How many BVs have you/your firm completed? 3. How many BVs for this purpose have you/your firm completed? 4. Professional certifications related to BV (e.g., CFA, ASA, ABV)? 5. Have you given presentations/written articles on BV? 6. Can I have references from former clients, advisors, etc.? 7. Fee structure and expected turnaround time 6
  • 7. Typical Valuation Process 1. Scoping Out the Engagement • Confirm Purpose/Standard of Value/Valuation Date • Fee Quote/Timing • Complexity/Intended Audience 2. Review & Analyze Requested Information • Business and Industry • Historical/Projected Financial Performance 3. Due Diligence Meetings/Management Interviews 4. Select & Apply Appropriate Valuation Methodologies 5. Present Conclusions 7
  • 8. Business Valuation Boot Camp What is Value?
  • 9. What Standard of Value? Liquidation Value • “Fire sale” of assets; lowest type of value Fair Market Value • The price at which an asset would change hands between a willing buyer and a willing seller, when the former is not under any compulsion to buy and the latter is not under any compulsion to sell, both parties being able, as well as willing, to trade and well- informed about the asset and the market for the asset. • Assumes a financial buyer…no acquirer synergies are considered • This is the typical definition for regulatory purposes (e.g., IRS, DOL, etc.) Strategic Value • Value to strategic buyer, considering add-backs, synergies, etc. • Value is buyer-specific (i.e., different buyers will have different perceived values) 9
  • 10. Enterprise Value vs. Equity Value Enterprise Value the value of the business as a whole; may be viewed as: • Total invested capital (equity + debt – cash) Equity Value = Enterprise Value – Debt + Cash • Represents shareholder value (i.e., stock value) • Zero-sum game: $1 more of debt = $1 less of equity • Analogous to home value less mortgage 10
  • 11. Business Valuation Boot Camp Valuation Principles & Methodologies
  • 12. Valuation Methodologies Asset Approach • Going Concern • Liquidation Income Approach • Multiple-Period Discounting Method (e.g., discounted cash flow) • Single-Period Capitalization Method (e.g., capitalized cash flow) Market Approach • Guideline Public Company Method • Guideline Transaction (M&A) Method 12
  • 13. Overview of Valuation Principles Valuation Must be Forward-Looking •Must consider anticipated future performance •Historical performance may help predict the future Future Cash Flow is Key Driver of Value •Future cash flow is king •Must consider risk in realizing projected cash flow Factors Considered in Valuations •Historical and expected future performance & trends •Market multiples of comparable companies and transactions •Economic, industry, and company-specific factors 13
  • 14. Asset Approach Overview Premise: The value of a business can be estimated based on the value of its underlying assets and liabilities Adjust ALL assets and liabilities to FMV • Must include booked and un-booked assets and liabilities • Must include tangible and intangible assets and liabilities When is the Asset Approach Most Appropriate? • Generally appropriate for holding companies or asset- intensive companies with modest profitability • Generally less appropriate for profitable operating entities 14
  • 15. Income Approach Overview Premise: The value of a business can be estimated based on the present value of the future economic benefits it generates Steps in performing the income approach: • Select & Determine Earnings Stream • Develop Appropriate Required Rate of Return • Select & Apply Multi-Period or Single-Period Model 15
  • 16. Preferred Earnings Stream: Distributable Cash Flow Normalized After-Tax Net Income + Depreciation and Amortization - Capital Expenditures +/- Additional Net Working Capital Requirements = Distributable (Debt-Free) Cash Flow 16
  • 17. Required Rate of Return An investor’s required ROR is a function of the perceived risk & potential of the investment Cost of Equity (ke) = Rf + (ERP x β) +/- Company- specific risk factors WACC = ke*%e + kd*%d Match Cash Flow with Rate of Return: • Cash Flow Available to Debt & Equity – Use WACC • Cash Flow Available to Equity Only – Use Cost of Equity 17
  • 18. Selecting a Model: Discounted Cash Flow vs. Capitalized Cash Flow Multiple-Period Models (e.g., discounted future cash flow) are often far more appropriate because: • Can account for anticipated changes in the business such as growth rates, margins, upcoming investments, business strategies, etc. Single Period Models: • Only appropriate if growth in future cash flows is projected to be constant • Difficult to rely on single-period models during times of turbulent economic conditions and/or volatile company performance 18
  • 19. Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4 Year 5 Distributable Net Cash Flow 5,000,000$ 5,500,000$ 5,940,000$ 6,296,400$ 6,611,220$ Present Value Factor @ 18.0% 0.9206 0.7801 0.6611 0.5603 0.4748 Present Value of Distributable Cash Flow 4,602,873$ 4,290,814$ 3,927,186$ 3,527,811$ 3,139,154$ Present Value of Cash Flows (Years 1 to 5) 19,487,838$ Year 5 Cash Flow 6,611,220$ Present Value of Residual Cash Flow 25,354,703 Multiplied by: 1 + Growth Rate 1.05 Residual Cash Flow 6,941,781 Enterprise Value 44,842,541 Discount Rate 18.0% Rounded 44,800,000$ Less: Residual Growth Rate -5.0% Capitalization Rate 13.0% Residual Cash Flow Value 53,398,315 Present Value Factor 0.4748 PV of Residual Cash Flow 25,354,703$ Discounted Cash Flow Example 19
  • 20. Market Approach Overview Premise: The value of a business can be estimated based on comparisons to similar businesses Guideline Public Company Method • Stock market is the best and most accurate source of valuation data; it is the source of rate of return data in income approach • Compare fundamentals of subject company and peer group of publicly traded companies • Apply pricing multiples (e.g., price-to-earnings, enterprise value- to-EBITDA, etc.) of publicly traded comparable companies Guideline Transaction Method • Identical to public company approach, except use transaction multiples from M&A deals as basis for valuation • Information about each transaction is typically limited since deals often involve private companies 20
  • 21. Guideline Public Company Method Example 21 Closing Stock Price (12/31/07) ABC 5.00$ x 45.52 = 227.6$ + 221.8$ - 108.4$ = 341.0$ 8.5 9.3 0.42 DEF 25.50 x 22.18 = 565.6 + 305.8 - 78.4 = 793.0 7.4 8.6 0.34 GHI 38.75 x 31.54 = 1,222.2 + 751.8 - 45.0 = 1,929.0 10.7 13.1 0.75 JKL 8.00 x 18.95 = 151.6 + 0.0 - 3.6 = 148.0 6.2 7.8 0.33 MNO 9.50 x 24.64 = 234.1 + 18.5 - 8.4 = 244.2 5.4 6.4 0.55 PQR 18.25 x 41.84 = 763.6 + 106.9 - 24.7 = 845.8 6.8 8.5 0.68 STU 14.00 x 35.72 = 500.1 + 247.9 - 7.4 = 740.6 5.7 7.4 0.42 VWX 11.50 x 65.90 = 757.9 + 1,085.2 - 222.1 = 1,621.0 9.5 13.8 0.81 YZ 22.75 x 45.52 = 1,035.6 + 333.6 - 26.9 = 1,342.3 7.1 8.9 0.59 Low 25% 6.2 7.8 0.42 Median 7.1 8.6 0.55 High 25% 8.5 9.3 0.68 Variation 23.8% 26.9% 32.7% Selected Multiple 6.5 8.1 0.45 Subject Company Results 6.7 5.1 89.6 Suggested Value 43.55 41.31 40.32 Concluded Enterprise Value: $42,000,000 EV / EBITDA EV / EBIT EV / Sales Pricing Multiples Debt & Preferred Stock Cash and Equivalents Enterprise Value (EV)Co. Derivation of Enterprise Value Shares Outstanding (millions) Market Value of Equity (mil)
  • 22. • Valuations should consider all methodologies and utilize the appropriate ones; income and market approaches are most common with strong, profitable companies • Valuation opinions supported by multiple valuation methods are preferable, more defensible, and often lead to more stable, accurate, and sustainable valuation levels Valuation Methodologies Guideline Public Company Method Discounted Cash Flow Method Net Asset Value Method Guideline Transaction Method Valuation Conclusion 22
  • 23. Key Valuation Concept: Valuation is Forward- Looking 23 “It’s tough to make predictions, especially about the future.” -Yogi Berra