17. 40% of 125 species missing wind ratings
Drawing from Bloemndaal et al 2020 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41597-020-0381-2
Florida
species
18. Wind ratings were developed by Duryea et al.
145 tree & palm species
Based on damage surveys
and expert opinions
https://www.gettyimages.com/detail/photo/aerial-view-of-tampa-florida-royalty-free-image/86539297
20. Conceptual wind resistance model
Characteristic 1 x
Coefficient 1
Characteristic 2 x
Coefficient 2
Etc. …
Wind Resistance
Rating
Species or
environmental data
Generated based on
training data
How to choose
characteristics?
21. Go fishing for research with a literature review
https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Fishing_in_the_haor_with_Seine_net.jpg
1) Studied characteristics that
predicted hurricane wind
resistance
2) Reported hurricane damage
at the species level
22. Initial search turned up 5,449 papers
Predictor Studies = 64
Species Damage Studies = 66
https://nara.getarchive.net/media/a-tree-is-uprooted-outside-the-naval-air-
station-nas-key-west-navy-lodge-as-882596
28. Mitigating hurricane damage to urban trees
https://www.stlouis-mo.gov/government/departments/public-safety/emergency-management/about/Steps-
of-Emergency-Management.cfm
Steps of emergency
management
29. CREDITS: This presentation template was created by Slidesgo, including
icons by Flaticon, and infographics & images by Freepik
THANKS!
asalisbury@ufl.edu
www.allysonsalisbury.com
CREDITS: This presentation template was created
by Slidesgo, including icons by Flaticon, and
infographics & images by Freepik
Collaborators
Andrew Koeser
Richard Hauer
Michael Andreu
Yujuan Chen
Zachary Freeman
Adriana Herrera-Montes
Chai-Shian Kua
Jake Miesbauer
Cara Rockwell
Hunter Thorn
Benyao Wang
38. education
@arbutusarme |
research | BMPs
conservation
range of species
tree health | seed | plant
connection
researchers and amateur
madrone enthusiasts
46. • Natalie van Doorn, PhD
• USDA Forest Service, Pacific Southwest Research Station
Climate-Ready Trees Study: a 5-year update
Co-PIs: Alison Berry, Greg McPherson, Janet Hartin,
Jim Downer, Darren Haver
47. Objective
Help create a more resilient urban forest by
shifting the palate of tree species, to those that
perform well when exposed to climate stressors
http://www.ecosacramento.net/2016/01/changes-to-sacramento-city-tree-ordinance/
48. Approach
• Five-step process: to
identify and evaluate the
performance of seldom
used but promising tree
species
McPherson, E.G., A.M. Berry, and N.S. van
Doorn. 2018. Performance testing to identify
climate-ready trees. Urban Forestry & Urban
Greening 29: 28-39.
doi:10.1016/j.ufug.2017.09.003
• 3 climate zones in CA
• 20-year evaluation period
49. CalAdapt Climate Model, Next 75 Years
Temperature: In each climate zone, model projects ~5°F
increase in avg. min temps & ~6-9°F increase in avg. max
temps
http://cal-adapt.org/tools/
pcm1
Precipitation: increased variability, more precipitation during
each storm event, stronger winds but also mega-droughts
50. Australia
Acacia aneura Mulga
Acacia stenophylla Shoestring acacia
Eucalyptus papuana Ghost gum
Ghost gum
Southwest US
Chilopsis linearis Desert willow
Hesperocyparis forbesii Tecate cypress
Mariosousa willardiana Palo blanco
Parkinsonia x 'Desert Museum' Desert Museum palo
verde
Prosopis glandulosa x 'Maverick' Thornless honey
mesquite
Prunus ilicifolia subsp. lyonii Catalina cherry
Quercus fusiformis Escarpment live oak
Quercus tomentella Island oak
Thornless honey mesquite
Palo Verde “Desert Museum”
Selected Finalists
Corymbia
51. Oklahoma-Texas-Western US
Celtis reticulata Netleaf hackberry
Ebenopsis ebano Texas ebony
Maclura pomifera 'White
Shield' White Shield osage orange
Quercus canbyi Canby's oak
Canby’s oak
Asia
Dalbergia sissoo Rosewood
Pistacia ‘Red Push’ Red Push pistache
Ulmus propinqua Emerald sunshine elm
South America
Cedrela fissilis Brazilian cedarwood
‘Emerald Sunshine’ elm
Dutch elm disease & elm
leaf beetle resistance
Selected Finalists
52. In Each Climate Zone:
4 Park Sites
• 2 reps per species
• 96 trees total
1 Reference Site
• 4 reps per species
• 48 trees total
Experimental Design
Red Push Palo Blanco Island Oak Escarpment
Pistache Live Oak
Tecate Escarpment Maverick Palo Blanco
Cypress Live Oak Mesquite
Rosewood Island Oak Red Push Mulga
Pistache
Escarpment Tecate Maverick Palo Blanco
Live Oak Cypress Mesquite
Mulga Netleaf Brazilian Ghost Gum
Hackberry Cedarwood
Ghost Gum Maverick Rosewood Catalina Cherry
Mesquite
Netleaf Hackberry Mulga Palo Blanco Brazilian
Cedarwood
Tecate Netleaf Island Oak Red Push
Cypress Hackberry Pistache
Maverick Red Push Catalina Cherry Escarpment
Mesquite Pistache Live Oak
Rosewood Brazilian Ghost Gum Tecate
Cedarwood Cypress
Catalina Cherry Rosewood Netleaf Ghost Gum
Hackberry
Island Oak Braizilian Catalina Cherry Mulga
Cedarwood
Tree Cultivars:
Mulga Acacia aneura
Brazilian
Cedarwood
Cedrela fissilis
Netleaf Hackberry Celtis reticulata
Ghost Gum Corymbia
papuana
Rosewood Dalbergia sissoo
Tecate Cypress Hesperocyparis
forbesii
Palo Blanco Mariosousa
willardiana
Red Push Pistache Pistacia 'Red
Push'
Maverick
Mesquite
Propospis
glandulosa
‘Maverick’
Catalina Cherry Prunus
ilicifolia subsp.
lyonii
Escarpment Live
Oak
Quercus
fusiformis
Island Oak Quercus
Dimensions and Layout:
Four rows running NW to SE with 12 trees
in each row. Approximately 25 ft. x 25 ft.
per tree. Total plot: 150 ft. x 325 ft.
Climate-Ready Trees for
Southern California
Coastal Communities:
Trial Planting Map
at South Coast Research and
Extension Center, Irvine, CA
U.C. Davis &
Pacific Southwest Research Station
USDA Forest Service
150 ft.
Bottom-left hand corner: 33.69219608 N° 117.71679171 W°
Top-right corner: 33.69251042 N° 117.71646796 W°
54. Acacia stenophylla
Inland Valleys Reference Site Inland Valleys Park Site
Quercus canbyi
Inland Valleys Reference Site Inland Valleys Park Site
55. Prosopis glandulosa x Maverick
Inland Valleys Reference Site Inland Valleys Park Site
56. Chilopsis linearis ‘Bubba’
Inland Valleys Reference Site Inland Valleys Park Site
Inland Valleys Reference Site Inland Valleys Park Site
Maclura pomifera ‘White Shield’
• root stock suckers
58. Parkinsonia x ‘Desert Museum’
Inland Valleys Reference Site Inland Valleys Park Site
• branch splitting
• blow over
Corymbia papuana
Inland Valleys Reference Site Inland Valleys Park Site
59. Thank you!
natalie.vandoorn@usda.gov
climatereadytrees.ucdavis
Tree Planting and Maintenance
• Sacramento Tree Foundation, Los
Angeles Beautification Team & the
many volunteers
• City of Sacramento; LA Dept. of Rec and
Parks
• UC Riverside Citrus Research Center;
South Coast Research and Extension
Center; UC Davis
Trees graciously donated by:
• Mountain States Wholesale Nursery
Funding
• The Britton Fund
• LA Center for Urban Natural Resources
Sustainability
• ISA Western Chapter
• US Forest Service, Pacific Southwest
Research Station
Editor's Notes
This is the Dish openspace at Stanford University, Here we see the namesake radiotelescope juxtaposed with a magnificent mature Blue Oak. Because of climate destabilization, this tree’s progeny will likely never reach this age in this place. Steve Jobs and I walked here and discussed this as he formed his vision for Apple’s new headquarters. Steve was a quick study. As we’ll see shortly, once he understood how climate change threatened trees, he came to view them as a technology for climate adaptation.
Earth is warming ten to a hundred times more rapidly than it did at the end of the most recent Ice Age. Trees are poorly evolved to migrate as quickly as this requires. Here in eastern San Diego County we see the carcasses of dead giant Coast Live Oaks next to thriving Engelman Oaks. In this area, summer monsoons are strengthening, weakening Coast Live Oak, favoring Engelmann. Might this be a clue to how to fill the ecological function of Coast Live Oak in other parts of its range where it’s destined to fail?
Humans have been moving plants from one place to another for millennia. We’ve many names for this process: agriculture, silviculture, gardening, landscaping. All of these are variants of assisted migration. Maybe this is the time to think about it more broadly. Maybe cities can be testbeds for assisted migration of tree species. This splendid Silverleaf Oak, native to the American Southwest and Mexico,is growing beautifully 1,000 miles north of its current native range in the Hoyt Arboretum in Portland.
Steve initially envisioned the Apple Park landscape as a mosaic of two nearby landscapes dear to him: the apricot and plum orchards of his younger years, and the oak woodland and savanna where he walked to reflect. Once he understood the challenge of climate change, he agreed to use Apple Park to assist migration of dozens of tree taxa. Roughly 5,000 oaks of more than 60 types grow in 60 acres of planted oak woodland. Many are of species absent elsewhere in California. Almost all have shown exceptionally rapid growth.
In many ecosystems, oak trees are a foundation for biodiversity. By moving them, we provide opportunity to follow for organisms dependent on them. Apple Park was a biodiversity wasteland of buildings and pavement. It now teems with diverse wildlife and employees love that. With studies comparing current biodiversity with baselines established in pre-project surveys, we may learn how well introduced tree taxa are providing habitat for organisms living in association with them in their native ranges and for others native to the Apple Park locale.
After two decades of participating in trials of assisted migration, I’m directly observing and learning from others that many “non-native” taxa are in their new environments growing as well as, or better than trees commonly planted, native and non-native alike. Here you see the first Engleman Oaks from Southern California planted as street trees in the Bay Area. Though nearly 500 miles north of their existing native range, they’re flourishing. Unlike many exotic plants, oaks are highly unlikely to become pest species.
Growing numbers of arborists, urban foresters and landscape architects are recognizing a connection between climate destabilization and die-off and clearly visible stress to many commonly planted tree species. Here in the Stanford University Arboretum, century-old Coast Live Oaks are dying without apparent cause, just as they are elsewhere. Coast Live Oaks are central ecological and visual elements of the landscape. With more warming and volatility ahead, tree professionals and others are wondering how to adapt.
Several of the oak taxa previously absent from the Apple Park site and its extended environs and planted there en masse are earning recognition, being produced in quantity, and being planted into the landscape by the thousands in a host of California cities. Here we see 15,000 oaks of a dozen taxa growing at Devil Mountain Nursery in California in response to a rapidly growing demand for varieties potentially better suited to the climate in those places a few decades from now during the middle years of their normal lifespan.
An example of exceptional success to date is Island Oak (Quercus tomentella). Ironically, it’s the rarest of all California oaks, normally confined to five relatively small islands off the California coast. The nursery industry, which first produced these in 2013, now sells thousands each year and continues to ramp up production to meet exponentially growing demand. This beautiful specimen, the champion Island Oak, grows in the Santa Barbara Botanical Garden and demonstrates how well the species can adapt to a new environment.
Island Oaks have proven so popular that we may be near the moment when Island Oaks in California cities outnumber those that remain in nature. In addition, the area of their new range dwarfs that of their current range, providing a buffer against environmental change. Here’s the first major crop of specimen-size Island Oak grown in California. These particular trees are now thriving at Apple Park. Engelmann Oak (Quercus engelmannii) is next in line for mass urban testing, but it may prove the only other California native oak suitable for assisted migration.
Fortunately the roster of trees that may prove well-adapted to future California climate conditions extends well beyond the state’s borders. In the mountains of the American Southwest and Mexico grow a plethora of other candidates. Two of these, Silverleaf Oak (Quercus hypoleucoides) and Netleaf Oak (Quercus rugosa) are already being purchased and planted in substantial numbers. Here you see a Silverleaf Oak 4,500 feet above Tucson clinging with grace and tenacity to a near-vertical rock face of Mount Lemmon.
Advocates of assisted migration, including me, acknowledge its risks. Too often well-intentioned people have sought to improve upon nature and failed. Testing assisted migration in urban areas where ecosystems have already been substantially altered poses fewer and smaller risks than does testing in wildland areas. Here, growing near a sound wall along US 101 on the San Francisco Peninsula, one of the first Netleaf Oaks ever planted into a public right of way in California thrives without irrigation and despite repeated strikes by automobiles.
As climate conditions continue to worsen, wildland managers may be able to look to cities for the species that will serve as replacements for failing natives. Wholesale changes to vegetation appear certain. Multiple researchers have observed and projected climate-induced loss of habitat. Whatever the risks of assisted migration, trees like these Island Oaks thriving along a street in Santa Barbara represent some of the many possible benefits of starting now to gather information about possible ways to replenish depleted landscapes.
In 2003, realizing that despite the horrific consequences of doing so, humans were likely going to continue accelerating our climate disruption, I began chasing acorns. In the two decades since then I’ve grown my love for oaks and become ever more committed to their future. II'll welcome your partnership as intelligent seed dispersal agents entering an increasingly volatile future at a speed without precedent in 400,000 years of human tenure, in looking for ways to adapt more successfully by hedging our bets.
SET THE STAGE
Michael Yadrick, plant ecologist at Seattle Parks and Recreation.
I support Green Seattle Partnership in the effort to restore and maintain forested natural areas in the city.
I’m also a Certified Ecological Practitioner,
casual podcaster and
And co-creator of the Arbutus ARME
We celebrate all-things Pacific madrone, highlighting conservation and restoration efforts while connecting tree researchers and enthusiasts along the way
We celebrate all-things Pacific madrone, highlighting conservation and restoration efforts while connecting tree researchers and enthusiasts along the way
ORIGIN STORY
ḰEḰEIȽĆ (WSANEĆ) | qʷuqʷuƛəc (So. Lushootseed)
Tracking north of us in the Salish Sea, they refer to this trees as Arbutus – it is a fixture in the WSANEĆ origin story
When people forgot to follow the Natural Laws, The Creator brought a flood to the whole world.
Their people went in their canoes, tied the long Cedar rope to an Arbutus Tree at the top of the Mountain, and they tied our canoes together, side by side.
The tide kept rising and the mountain went underwater.
They were afraid, and were praying to survive.
They could see a mountain top emerge in the distance. The water was going down. It kept going down and so we untied the rope and thanked the tree, and to this day they don’t burn Arbutus trees in their fires.
My name Yadrick is from the Balkans, and my heritage is broadly European. We have traced some lineage back to Ireland. I would like to think it is possible that some of my ancestors interacted with other Arbutus, such as Arbutus unedo is indigenous to southern Europe and Ireland. This is a common tree in our landscapes that is related to madrone.
El Oso y el Madroño (The Bear and the Strawberry Tree) is the official city crest of Madrid since at least the year 1212
The first European note of madrone was in the diary Missionary Juan Crespi during the Portolá expedition of 1769-1770 in the Californias.
The latin name for the tree is named for Archibald Menzies, the Scottish physician and naturalist who collected in the Pacific Northwest during the Vancouver Expeditions in early 1790s..
It was Frederick Traugott Pursh who named the tree in honor of Archibald Menzies in his 1814 work, A systematic arrangement and description of the plants of North America.
GIFTS
Below are some basics about the gifts madrone provides. The information is primarily derived from the North American Ethnobotany Database and other sources that are linked. These are historical AND contemporary cultural uses of the tree. disruption of knowledge transfer about people-madrone relationship
Arbutus ARME also wishes to protect the cultural heritage and intellectual property rights of First Peoples while also developing accountability to racially oppressed communities. While we want to celebrate knowledge about the tree, we don't just want to talk about how humans use the tree. Learning about madrone is done by observing, listening, and following, and it takes time. Further, traditional ecological knowledge should not be easily accessed or taken without reciprocity and an understanding of the complex relationship between humans and the plants.
Containers, furniture, carving, decoctions fuel/firewood skin aid preservative, bee pollination, food for birds, beverage, bait, decoration, fishhooks utensils, tools, toys, fuel/firewood, animal forage food, smoked, burn dressing teas, coverings
MADRONE MYTHS:beautiful, but bound to failhard to growfragile and dyingobserve, don’t touchsubstitute
sunken black spots, blisters, rusts, molds, blotchy, brown lesions, branches burned or sooty, leaves silvery, cankers
-----
Choose well-drained sites, compatible vegetation & mycorrhizal associations
Avoid soil compaction, irrigation, fertilization, pollution, and physical damage
Madrone is drought tolerant, consider infrequent deep watering during extended drought periods
The wide-spreading root system is associated with ericoid mycorrhiza. The fungus is characterized by “coils” that form in the epidermal cells of the fine hair roots of ericaceous species. The fungi colonize the root cells and establish hyphal networks around the roots, providing increased water and nutrient absorption while the plant in turn provides the fungus with carbohydrates through photosynthesis.
Ericoid mycorrhizal fungi also have hydrolytic and oxidative enzymes that are important in mobilizing nutrients from organic matter and leaf litter. This is a big reason for madrone’s ability to persist through drought and thrive in relatively harsh conditions such as rocky bluffs or soils we may characterize as "nutrient deficient."
There has also been investigation into the symbiotic associations between the madrone soil community and links to nearby Douglas-fir that may assist with disease resistance in madrone.
ADAPTIVE
Navigating constant change
RESEARCH
EDUCATION
The madrone range is the area where the species can be found.
Community science
CONSERVATION/RESTORATION
CONNECTION
We celebrate all-things Pacific madrone, highlighting conservation and restoration efforts while connecting tree researchers and enthusiasts along the way
Good morning everyone! My name is Natalie van Doorn, I’m a research urban ecologist working for the Forest Service out of Albany, California.
The Climate-Ready Trees research project is a collaborative effort with our principal investigators from the Forest Service, UC Davis, and UC Cooperative Extension. There are also many other folks from other organizations that are contributing to this study, as seen on this slide.
Our common objective is to help create a more resilient urban forest by shifting the palate of tree species,
to those proven to perform well when exposed to a changing climate and other stressors
such as heat, drought, high winds, pests, disease, and soil salinity.
Essentially, we want to minimize the risk of tree loss.
And for that, we need to know which species work and which ones won’t.
And that’s because what did well in the past might not do well in the future.
To accomplish this, we are evaluating the survival and growth of seldom used but promising tree species, in 3 climate zones in CA: Inland Valleys, Inland Empire, and Southern CA Coast.
We will be determining if they have qualities that make a good urban tree and have the potential to be resilient as
droughts become more extensive, temperatures change, and pressure from pest and disease increases.
We developed a five-step process to identify and evaluate the vulnerability of tree species. They are described in this paper led by McPherson in 2018.
This approach is repeatable and can serve as a model for organizations and cities interested in climate adaptation through urban forestry.
Based on climate model projections,
In each of our climate zones, we’re expecting 5 deg. F warming of the average minimum temperatures in the next 75 years.
By 2100, average annual maximum daily temperature is projected to increase by 5.6 – 8.8 deg. F (CCCA).
Precipitation:
In general, stronger winter storms with more precip during each event and stronger winds
12 species were selected for each climate zone. There’s some repetition across climate zones, so 19 species were selected in total.
In general, the species are native to hotter parts of the world compared to the three climate zones chosen for this study.
Here are the species from Australia and Southwest US
We have species from the Oklahoma-Texas-Western US area. (e.g. Canby’s oak)
As well as from Asia and South America, like the rosewood from India and the Brazilian cedarwood from Brazil.
4 parks in each climate zone.
With 2 reps per spp, that’s 24 trees/park, total of 96 trees in each climate zone.
1 reference site per zone. We chose UC research plots.
With 4 reps per spp, that’s 48 trees/site.
Park vs. reference sites:
We’re interested in seeing what is the potential of each species under optimal maintenance/care but also how they grow in the real world, with all the ad-hoc care they tend to receive in public parks and the harsher urban environment.
Our metrics for success are: high survivorship, low invasiveness, community buy-in, and eventually nursery uptake.
Today I’ll talk about survivorship and invasiveness – just in the Inland Valleys climate zone, that’s the one in the middle of the state centered around Sacramento.
The general trend is that, except for Parkinsonia, the species in the reference site have equal or better survival than in park sites.
Many haven’t had any mortality.
One of the species that has had no mortality is Acacia stenophylla, shoestring acacia. It’s a native to Australia. It has very long narrow, drooping leaves, small yellow flowers, and clusters of brown seed pods.
==
However, it has grown root suckers in the last few years and grows vigorously from seed.
==
Another tree that had no mortality and is growing well is Quercus canbyi, which is native to Texas and Mexico. It’s a very drought tolerant red oak species. It has slender, glossy leaves and attracts birds & squirrels.
Maverick mesquite is a grafted thornless cultivar of the Texas Honey Mesquite. It is a deciduous tree with lacy bright green foliage and smooth grey bark.
Thus far, all of them are all alive although in varying conditions.
It’s multi-stemmed and its natural growth habit is rather open and irregular; so probably best suited to parks or wide-open areas where it can spread out. And may require pruning.
Desert willow ‘Bubba’, is a more upright, less shrubby, selection of desert willow, originating in Texas. It produces large, fragrant, pink flowers.
All the ones in the reference site are alive, but we’ve had some losses in the park sites.
Similarly, ‘White Shield’ osage orange has had no mortality in the reference sites but some losses in the park sites.
We’re seeing it has vigorous root stock suckers which are thorny because of the grafting.
The rosewood is experiencing dieback in the Inland Valley sites (but doing well in Southern CA) and there’s been some mortality in park sites.
We’ve now started tracking the dieback to see if it tracks with freezing temperatures. Just a few cold nights might make the difference with this tree.
Unfortunately the rosewood is also growing root suckers at a few sites.
In the reference sites only 2 species have had mortality, one of which is the Desert Museum palo verde. In the summer is has tons of yellow flowers and the canopy is buzzing with bees.
The canopy grows rapidly which appears to lead to branch splitting and blow over. So the canopy needs to be brought in and up, and lodge poles used for support.
And lastly for today, the ghost gum is the other species that’s had some mortality in the reference site. But the survivors are looking pretty good.
In addition to all the cooperators I listed in the first slide,
there are so many others that have become involved
and without whom this project would not have gone in the ground.
We have a website if you’d like to learn more, and please don’t hesitate to email me with any questions or comments.
Thank you!