3. Contents
:
Meaning and Importance of Research
Design
Important Concepts Concering
Research Design
Features of Good Research Design
Forms/Classifications of Research
Design
Research Approaches
5/11/2022 3
4. 1. Meaning and Importance of Research Design
Once the researcher has determined the specific question to be
answered and research question into a clear, measurable
objectives, it is time to consider a suitable research design.
Design is a means/key for research
Design refers to the over all strategy that you choose
A research design –is a grand plan of approach to a research topic.
is a master plan/a blue print or conceptual structure/ that
specifies the methods and procedures for collecting, measuring and
analyzing the needed information.
5/11/2022 4
5. Meaning …
A research design provides a framework for the collection and
analysis of data.
Research design represents a structure that guides the execution
of a research method and the analysis of the subsequent data.
A choice of research design reflects decisions about the priority
being given to a range of dimensions of the research process.
These include the importance attached to:
expressing causal connections between variables;
generalizing to larger groups of individuals than those actually forming
part of the investigation;
understanding behavior and the meaning of that behavior in its
specific social context;
having a temporal (i.e. over time) appreciation of social phenomena
and their interconnections.
5/11/2022 5
6. Meaning...
Research design is the blueprint for fulfilling research
objectives and answering research questions.
In other words, it is a master plan specifying the
methods and procedures for collecting and
analyzing the needed information
it must ensure that the information collected is
appropriate for solving a problem.
“A research design is the arrangement of conditions for
collection and analysis of data in a manner that aims
to combine relevance to the research purpose with
economy in procedure.”
5/11/2022 6
7. Importance of Research Design
The research design is the conceptual structure
within which research is conducted;
constitutes the blueprint for the collection,
measurement and analysis of data.
Research design specifies:
the data collection process,
the instrument development process,
the sampling process, and
The analysis proces
5/11/2022 7
8. Importance of…
More specifically, research design is helpful in
addressing the following issues in research
What is the study about?
Why is the study being made?
Where will the study be carried out?
What type of data is required?
Where can the required data be found?
What periods of time will the study include?
What will be the sample design?
What techniques of data collection will be used?
How will the data be analyzed?
In what style will the report be prepared?
5/11/2022 8
9. Importance of…
In a nutshell, research design:
Maximizes control over factors to increase the
validity of the findings
Guides the researcher in planning and
implementing a study
5/11/2022 9
10. Components of research design
In attempting to address the above issues, a research
design can have the following components.
the sampling design which deals with the method of
selecting items to be observed for the given study;
the observational design which relates to the conditions
under which the observations are to be made;
the statistical design which concerns with the question of
how many items are to be observed and how the information
and data gathered are to be analyzed; and
the operational design which deals with the techniques by
which the procedures specified in the sampling, statistical
and observational designs can be carried out.
5/11/2022 10
11. 2. Features of Good Research Design
The design that clearly stated the objective of the problem to be
studied,
A good research design often possesses the qualities such as
being flexible, suitable, efficient, economical, and so on
The design which minimizes bias and maximizes the reliability
of the data collected and analyzed;
5/11/2022 11
12. Features of…
The design which gives the smallest experimental error;
The design which yields relevant information and provides an opportunity for
considering many aspects of a problem;
The design that assumes the availability and skills of the
researcher
The design that considers the availability of time and money for
the research work
5/11/2022 12
13. 3. Important Concepts Relating to Research
Design
There are several concepts related to research design. These
are:
Dependent and Independent variables
Extraneous variable
Control
Confounded relationship
Research hypothesis
Experimental and control groups
Treatments
Experiment
Experimental unit(s)
5/11/2022 13
14. Dependent and Independent Variables
A concept which can take on different quantitative
values is called a variable. As such the concepts like
weight, height, income are all examples of variables.
Qualitative phenomena (or the attributes) are also
quantified on the basis of the presence or absence of
the concerning attribute(s).
Phenomena which can take on quantitatively different
values even in decimal points are called ‘continuous
variables
5/11/2022 14
15. Dependent and Independent Variables
But all variables are not continuous. If they can only be
expressed in integer values, they are non-continuous
variables or in statistical language ‘discrete variables’.**
Age is an example of continuous variable, but the
number of children is an example of non-continuous
variable
If one variable depends upon or is a consequence of
the other variable, it is termed as a dependent variable,
and the variable that is antecedent to the dependent
variable is termed as an independent variable.
5/11/2022 15
16. Dependent and Independent Variables
For instance, if we say that height depends upon age,
then height is a dependent variable and age is an
independent variable
Further, if in addition to being dependent upon age,
height also depends upon the individual’s sex, then
height is a dependent variable and age and sex are
independent variables.
Similarly, readymade films and lectures are examples
of independent variables, whereas behavioural
changes, occurring as a result of the environmental
manipulations, are examples of dependent variables.
5/11/2022 16
17. Extraneous variable
Independent variables that are not related to the
purpose of the study, but may affect the dependent
variable are termed as extraneous variables.
Suppose the researcher wants to test the hypothesis
that there is a relationship between children’s gains in
social studies achievement and their self-concepts
.
5/11/2022 17
18. Extraneous variable
In this case self-concept is an independent variable
and social studies achievement is a dependent
variable. Intelligence may as well affect the social
studies achievement, but since it is not related to
the purpose of the study undertaken by the
researcher, it will be termed as an extraneous
variable
Whatever effect is noticed on dependent variable as a
result of extraneous variable(s) is technically described
as an ‘experimental error’
5/11/2022 18
19. Control
One important characteristic of a good research design
is to minimize the influence or effect of extraneous
variable(s).
The technical term ‘control’ is used when we design
the study minimising the effects of extraneous
independent variables. In experimental researches, the
term ‘control’ is used to refer to restrain experimental
conditions
5/11/2022 19
20. Confounded relationship
When the dependent variable is not free from the
influence of extraneous variable(s), the relationship
between the dependent and independent variables is
said to be confounded by an extraneous variable(s).
5/11/2022 20
21. Research hypothesis
When a prediction or a hypothesised relationship is to
be tested by scientific methods, it is termed as
research hypothesis
The research hypothesis is a predictive statement that
relates an independent variable to a dependent
variable
Usually a research hypothesis must contain, at least,
one independent and one dependent variable.
Predictive statements which are not to be objectively
verified or the relationships that are assumed but not
to be tested, are not termed research hypotheses
5/11/2022 21
22. Experimental and non-experimental
hypothesis-testing research
When the purpose of research is to test a research
hypothesis, it is termed as hypothesis-testing research
It can be of the experimental design or of the non-
experimental design. Research in which the
independent variable is manipulated is termed
‘experimental hypothesis-testing research’
and a research in which an independent variable is not
manipulated is called ‘non-experimental hypothesis-
testing research’.
5/11/2022 22
23. Experimental and non-experimental
hypothesis-testing research
For instance, suppose a researcher wants to study
whether intelligence affects reading ability for a group
of students and for this purpose he randomly selects
50 students and tests their intelligence and reading
ability by calculating the coefficient of correlation
between the two sets of scores.
This is an example of non-experimental hypothesis-
testing research because herein the independent
variable, intelligence, is not manipulated
5/11/2022 23
24. Experimental and non-experimental
hypothesis-testing research
But now suppose that our researcher randomly selects
50 students from a group of students who are to take a
course in statistics and then divides them into two
groups by randomly assigning 25 to Group A, the usual
studies programme, and 25 to Group B, the special
studies programme.
At the end of the course, he administers a test to each
group in order to judge the effectiveness of the training
programme on the student’s performance-level.
This is an example of experimental hypothesis-testing research
because in this case the independent variable, viz., the type of training
programme, is manipulated.
5/11/2022 24
25. Experimental and control groups
In an experimental hypothesis-testing research when a
group is exposed to usual conditions, it is termed a
‘control group’,
but when the group is exposed to some novel or special
condition, it is termed an ‘experimental group’.
5/11/2022 25
26. Treatments
The different conditions under which experimental
and control groups are put are usually referred to as
‘treatments’.
5/11/2022 26
27. Experiment:
The process of examining the truth of a statistical
hypothesis, relating to some research problem, is
known as an experiment
For example, we can conduct an experiment to
examine the usefulness of a certain newly developed
drug
Experiments can be of two types viz., absolute
experiment and comparative experiment
5/11/2022 27
28. Experimental unit(s):
The pre-determined plots or the blocks, where
different treatments are used, are known as
experimental units.
Such experimental units must be selected (defined)
very carefully.
5/11/2022 28
29. 4. Classifications of Research Design
The various designs have been classified by
examining them from three different perspectives:
purpose of the study
the number of contacts with the study population;
the reference period of the study;
the nature of the investigation
Other classifications
5/11/2022 29
30. Classifications …
1) Based on purpose of investigation, research
design is classified into:
Descriptive design
Exploratory design
Explanatory design
5/11/2022 30
31. Classifications …
i) DESCRIPTIVE: investigator attempts to describe a group of
individuals/organizations on a set of variables or characteristics.
Involves surveys & fact-finding enquiries
State of affairs as it exists
Enables classification and understanding
No control over variables
Tries to discover causes (i.e., ex-post facto)
METHODS: survey research, case study, qualitative, developmental (natural history
of something, patterns of growth and change), normative, evaluation
APPLIED: Finding a solution for an immediate problem & not rigorous / flexible in
application of the conditions
5/11/2022 31
32. Classifications …
Researchers who choose to apply descriptive study should:
Identify the problem accurately
Demarcate the population
Take representative sample from the population
Record what has been perceived
Organize and present the report
E.g.
Stating the status of organizational performance
Investigating attitude of consumers towards a given brand
Survey on community’s attitude and perception towards
corruption
5/11/2022 32
33. Classifications …
ii) EXPLORATORY
gaining some familiarity with a topic, discovering some of its
main dimensions, and possibly planning more structured
research
Its purpose is to shed light on the issue at hand.
METHODS: observation, interview, discussions, document
review
E.g.
Exploring whether there is conflict in the workplace.
Need assessment to develop infrastructure in a given locality
5/11/2022 33
34. Classifications …
iii) EXPLANATORY
Investigates the degree to which two or more variables are
associated with each other;
Examines the cause-effect relationships between variables
This is more advanced design than the previous designs
METHODS: survey questionnaire, recorded data, interviews
E.g.
What are the causes of conflict in the workplace?
Is there relationship between organizational climate and
employee commitment?
5/11/2022 34
35. Classifications …
2) Based on the number of contacts with the study
population, research design is classified into:
Cross-sectional studies;
Before-and-after studies;
Longitudinal studies.
5/11/2022 35
36. Classifications …
i) Cross-sectional Study
Researcher studies a stratified group of subjects at one point in
time; also known as one-shot or status studies
Well-suited to describing variables and their distribution patterns
They are useful in obtaining an overall `picture' as it stands at the
time of the study.
Such studies are cross-sectional with regard to both the study
population and the time of investigation.
Can be used for examining associations; determination of which
variables are predictors and which are outcomes depends on the
hypothesis
5/11/2022 36
37. Classifications …
E.g. what does the monthly spending composition of
households in X locality look like?
Select a sample of 100 households participating in a
market (on a market day) in the locality.
Identify items purchased by households
Measure the amount spent on each item
A questionnaire may be used to gather information
about items and the amount spent on each item.
5/11/2022 37
38. Classifications …
Strengths
Fast and inexpensive
No loss to follow-up (no follow-up)
Ideal for studying prevalence of a phenomenon, situation,
problem, attitude or issue
Convenient for examining potential networks of causal links
Weaknesses:
Difficult to establish a causal relationship from data collected
in a cross-sectional time-frame (lack of a temporal relationship
between predictor variables and outcome variables - does not
establish sequence of events)
Not practical for studying rare phenomena
Cannot measure changes/stability
5/11/2022 38
39. Classifications …
ii) Before-and-after studies design (also known as the pre-
test/post-test design)
can be described as two sets of cross-sectional observations
on the same population
it can measure change in a situation, phenomenon, issue,
problem or attitude
it is the most appropriate design for measuring the impact or
effectiveness of a program
the change is measured by comparing the difference in the
phenomenon or variable(s) before and after the intervention
5/11/2022 39
40. Classifications …
A before-and-after study is carried out by adopting the same
process as a cross-sectional study except that it comprises two
cross-sectional observations, the second being undertaken after
a certain period.
Examples
The impact of administrative restructuring on the quality of the
services provided by government offices
The effect of televised advertisement on return on sales of a
certain brand
The effect of tax programs on awareness and voluntary payment
of tax
The effect of random breath testing on road accidents.
5/11/2022 40
41. Classifications …
Strengths
Can measure changes in phenomenon or situations etc
Limitations
It is more expensive and more difficult to implement
It is less helpful for studying the pattern of change
5/11/2022 41
42. Classifications …
iii) Longitudinal studies
Are used to determine the pattern of change and stability in
relation to time
In these studies, the study population is visited a number of
times at regular intervals, usually over a long period, to
collect the required information
They can be considered as repetitive cross-sections
Longitudinal studies could be panel, time series or cohort
type
Examples (the above examples can be taken)
5/11/2022 42
43. Classifications …
Strengths
it allows the researches to measure the pattern of change
Disadvantages
similar to before-and-after studies, in some instances to an
even greater degree.
it can suffer from the conditioning effect- lose interest for
repeated questions in the inquiry
5/11/2022 43
44. Classifications …
3) Based on the reference period of the study, research designs
are classified as:
Retrospective (reviewing past);
Prospective (reviewing future); and
Retrospective-prospective (both)
The reference period refers to the time-frame in which a
study is exploring a phenomenon, situation, event or
problem.
5/11/2022 44
45. Classifications …
a) Retrospective (reviewing past) study designs
They investigate a situation, problem or issue that has
happened in the past (historical design)
They are usually conducted either on the basis of the data
available for that period or on the basis of respondents’
recall of the situation
Examples
Migratory movements from East Africa to Arab countries in
the last two decades
FDI flow in the 27 years of the EPRDF regime
5/11/2022 45
46. Classifications …
b) Prospective (reviewing future) study designs
Prospective studies refer to the likely prevalence of a
phenomenon, situation, problem, attitude or outcome in the
future.
Such studies attempt to establish the outcome of an event or
what is likely to happen.
Experiments are usually classified as prospective studies as
the researcher must wait for an intervention to register its
effect on the study population
Examples
Prospects of Islamic banking in Tigray
The likelihood of rising inflation in the Ethiopian economy
5/11/2022 46
47. Classifications …
c) Retrospective-prospective (both) study designs
focus on past trends in a phenomenon and study it into the
future.
a study is classified under this category when you measure the
impact of an intervention without having a control group
In this study a part of the data is collected retrospectively from
the existing records before the intervention is introduced and
then the study population is followed to ascertain the impact
of the intervention.
Examples
Fertilizer subsidies and farm productivity in the past and the
future
School feeding and student academic performance
5/11/2022 47
48. Classifications …
4) Based on the nature of the investigation, research designs are
classified as follows
Experimental design (True Experiment);
Quasi-experimental design; and
Non- experimental or observational design (one or more of the
previous types are of this nature)
This classification is based on the control method applied in the study
Efficacy: the benefit of an intervention compared to a control or standard
program under controlled, randomized conditions
Randomized controlled trial (RCT) design often used
Effectiveness: the benefit of an intervention under less controlled ‘real
world’ conditions
Quasi-experimental design often used
5/11/2022 48
49. Classifications …
a) Experimental (True Experiment) Design
study participants are randomly assigned to experimental
and control groups
Purpose is to compare 2 or more groups that are formed by
random assignment
The groups differ solely on the basis of what occurs between
measurements (i.e, intervention)
Changes from pretest to posttest can be reasonably
attributed to the intervention
Most basic is the pretest-posttest control group design
(randomized controlled trial, RCT)
5/11/2022 49
50. Classifications …
Two groups: experimental and control groups (with and without
‘treatment’)- should be equivalent
Randomization: participants are assigned at random to experimental
and control groups in the hope that this will result in equal
assignment of people to both groups (for small groups).
change in the experimental groups before and after ‘treatment’
compared with change in the control group
Matching is an alternative procedure to create equivalent groups
(large groups)
Pairs of subjects are formed on the basis of similarity on one or
more variables.
One subject is randomly assigned to the experimental group, the
other to the control group (i.e.: matched block design).
5/11/2022 50
51. Classifications …
Purpose of an experiment:
To investigate a causal relationship between two (or more) variables
Way of establishing a causal relationship:
Manipulation of the independent variable by the researcher
Random assignment of the research units to the groups
Control of all other conditions
Origin:
Natural sciences like chemistry, biology, etc.
Importance:
The course of reasoning in experimental designs has become the
basic logic for other research strategies
5/11/2022 51
53. Classifications …
Examples:
1) The Hawthorne effect is a good example in management
It refers to the tendency of people to work harder and perform
better when they participate in an experiment
2) Does school feeding improve students’ academic
achievement?
Dependent variable (academic achievement)
Independent variable (school feeding)
3) Does training on organizational health and safety reduce
accidents in textile factories?
Dependent variable (accidents)
Independent variable (training on OHS)
5/11/2022 53
54. Classifications …
Strengths
Controls the influence of confounding variables, providing more
conclusive answers
Randomization eliminates bias due to pre-randomization
confounding variables
Blinding the interventions eliminates bias due to unintended
interventions
Increased internally validity
Fewer rival hypotheses
Weaknesses
Costly in time and money
Many research questions are not suitable for experimental designs
Usually reserved for more mature research questions that have
already been examined by descriptive studies
Experiments tend to restrict the scope and narrow the study
question
5/11/2022 54
55. Classifications …
b) Quasi-experimental design
Quasi-experimental designs do not use randomized
assignments for comparisons
It is a mixed design where random and non-random
experiments are employed together
Usually this happens when the independent variable in
question is something that is an innate characteristic of the
participants involved
5/11/2022 55
56. Classifications …
Examples:
1) Does membership to farmer cooperatives increase
farmers’ market participation?
Outcome: market participation
Membership decision is affected by other factors and
farmers cannot be randomly assigned as members and
non-members.
2) Members of trade/workers’ union are less likely to
face sexual harassment in textile factories.
5/11/2022 56
57. Classifications …
Strengths
Q-E designs are a reasonable alternative to RCT
Useful where pre-selection and randomization of groups is difficult
Saves time and resources vs. experimental designs
Weaknesses
Nonequivalent groups may differ in many ways -- in addition to the
differences between treatment conditions, introducing bias
Non-blinding allows the possibility of unintended interventions;
blinding can be used in some Q-E studies
Must document participant characteristics extensively
Potential biases of the sample must be acknowledged when
reporting findings
Causal inferences are weakened by the potential for biases vs.
experimental designs
5/11/2022 57
59. Classifications …
a) Case Study Design
The basic case study entails the detailed and intensive
analysis of a single case
Often a description of a individual case’s condition or
response to an intervention
can focus on a group, institution, school, community,
family, etc.
data may be qualitative, quantitative, or both
Case series: observations of several similar cases are
reported
5/11/2022 59
60. Classifications …
The case study design is a very popular and widely used
research design in business research and some of the best-
known studies in business and management research are
based on this design.
It is a research known for depth than breadth
Examples:
Employee loyalty in one organization
Organizational climate and employee commitment in company
X.
Financial ratio analysis of company Z.
5/11/2022 60
61. Classifications …
Strengths
Enables understanding of the totality of an individual’s (or
organization, community) experience
The in-depth examination of a situation or ‘case’ can lead to
discovery of relationships that were not obvious before
Useful for generating new hypotheses or for describing new
phenomena
Weaknesses
No control group
Prone to selection bias and confounding
The interaction of environmental and personal characteristics
make it weak in internal validity
Limited generalizability
5/11/2022 61
62. Classifications …
2) Comparative design
entails the study using more or less identical methods of two or
more contrasting cases.
It embodies the logic of comparison, in that it implies that we can
understand social phenomena better when they are compared in
relation to two or more meaningfully contrasting cases or
situations.
The comparative design may be realized in the context of either
quantitative or qualitative research.
There are at least two cases (which may be organizations,
nations, people, etc.) and that data are collected from each,
usually within a cross-sectional design format.
5/11/2022 62
63. Classifications …
Seeks to make comparisons between or within groups of
interest
Often associated with experimental research
Is there a difference between the control group and the experimental
group?
Comparison of one group to another on the basis of existing
characteristics
Examples:
Do employee motivation packages vary between private and
public banks in Ethiopia?
Comparison of academic achievement of students in private and
government schools in Mekelle city.
5/11/2022 63
64. 5. How to choose a research design?
There will be no one right/best way of conducting
business research- One single design cannot serve the
purpose of all types of research problems. this will
depend on a number of factors .
Does it adequately test the hypothesis?
Does it identify & control extraneous factors?
Are results generalizable?
Can the hypothesis be rejected or retained via statistical
means?
Is the design efficient in using available resources?
5/11/2022 64
65. How to Choose…
When selecting research design for your study, you
need to:
Identify the design
Name it specifically
Provide a map of the design
Discuss your rationale for using this design
Describe threats to the validity of the chosen
design
5/11/2022 65
66. 6. Problems with study designs
There are several problems/limitations in selecting
research design
Inappropriate for the study purpose or the research
framework
Poorly developed designs
The research methods were poorly implemented
Inadequate treatment, sample, or measurement
methods
5/11/2022 66
67. 7. Research approaches
There are three research approaches in the social
sciences.
Quantitative research approach
Qualitative research approach
Mixed research approach
5/11/2022 67
68. Research approaches
a) Quantitative research approach
Is based on the measurement of quantity or amount.
Expression of a property or quantity in numerical terms
Quantitative research helps:
Precise measurement
Knowing trends or changes overtime
Comparing trends or individual cases/ units
The objective of quantitative research is to develop
and employ mathematical models, theories and
hypotheses pertaining to natural phenomena.
5/11/2022 68
69. Research approaches
The process of measurement is central to quantitative
research because it provides the fundamental connection
between empirical observation and mathematical
expression of an attribute.
This approach typically concentrates on measuring or
counting and involves collecting and analyzing numerical
data and applying statistical tests.
It is guided by realist ontology and positivist paradigm
It works more with natural settings and natural sciences
5/11/2022 69
70. Research approaches
METHODS: questionnaires, secondary/numeric data,
mathematical and statistical models and equations,
numeric reporting tools such as tables, figures, graphs and
interpretations
Examples
Profitability analysis
Determinants of household economic welfare
5/11/2022 70
71. Research approaches
2) Qualitative research approach
Seeks to describe how individuals perceive their own
experiences within a social context
Emphasizes in-depth, nuanced understanding of human
experience and interactions
METHODS include in-depth interviews, direct
observations, examining documents, focus groups, case
studies
Data are often participants’ own words and narrative
summaries of observed behavior
5/11/2022 71
72. Research approaches
The goal of qualitative research is to look for
meaning, concepts, definitions, characteristics,
symbols, and descriptions of things.
It is based on ontological idealism and intepretivist
paradigm
Works more in the social, humanity and historical
sciences
Examples:
Employees’ perception of leadership styles of their
supervisors
5/11/2022 72
73. Research approaches
Strengths
Data based on the participants’ own categories of meaning
Useful for studying a limited number of cases in depth or describing complex
phenomena
Provides understanding and description of people’s personal experiences of phenomena
Can describe in rich detail phenomena as they are embedded in local contexts
The researcher can study dynamic processes (i.e., document sequential patterns/change)
Weaknesses
Knowledge produced might not generalize to other people or other settings
It is difficult to make quantitative predictions
It might have lower credibility with some administrators and commissioners of programs
Takes more time to collect and analyze the data when compared to quantitative research
The results are more easily influenced by the researcher’s personal biases and
idiosyncrasies
5/11/2022 73
74. Research approaches
Research designs
Quantitative sampling methods
Research tools/instruments
Validity & reliability of the
tools/instruments
Possible biases
Minimizing possible errors
Dealing with narrow but large data
sets
Statistical methods
How to play with figures
How to report statistically
A qualitative researcher must be
familiar with
A quantitative researcher must be familiar
with:
Element/case/unit of analysis
Qualitative sampling methods
Dealing with deep but small data
set
Coding/de-coding/re-coding
techniques
Abstract constructing
How to play with the abstracts
How to report narratively
5/11/2022 74
75. Research approaches
3) Mixed research approach
It mixes quantitative and qualitative approaches and
methods.
Its is based on the assumption that methodological
‘purism’ or ‘monoism’ does not provide complete picture
of social reality.
It is based on ‘pragmatist’ paradigm.
‘whatever works better’ is better in addressing research
questions in the social sciences
5/11/2022 75
76. Research approaches
The following questions are raised while using mixed
research approach
Are the quantitative and qualitative data collected simultaneously
or sequentially?
Which has priority – the quantitative or the qualitative data?
What is the function of the integration – for example,
triangulation, explanation, or exploration?
At what stage(s) in the research process does multi-strategy
research occur? (research question formulation, data
collection, data analysis, or data interpretation)
Is there more than one data strand?
5/11/2022 76
77. Research approaches
Five justifications for combining quantitative and
qualitative research
Triangulation: convergence, corroboration, correspondence
or results from different methods.
Complementarity: ‘seeks elaboration, enhancement,
illustration, clarification of the results from one method with
the results from another’
Development: ‘seeks to use the results from one method to
help develop or inform the other method, where
development is broadly construed to include sampling and
implementation, as well as measurement decisions’
5/11/2022 77
78. Research approaches
Five justifications for combining…
Initiation: ‘seeks the discovery of paradox and
contradiction, new perspectives of [sic]
frameworks, the recasting of questions or results
from one method with questions or results from the
other method’
Expansion: ‘seeks to extend the breadth and range
of enquiry by using different methods for different
inquiry components’
5/11/2022 78
79. Types of mixed methods designs
I. Triangulation mixed methods Design
II. Explanatory mixed methods Design
III. Exploratory mixed methods Design
QUAN
Data and Results
QUAN
Data and Results
+
QUAL
Data and Results
QUAL
Data and Results
qual
Data and Results
quan
Data and Results
Interpretation
Follow-up
Building
80. Research approaches
Outcomes of mixing different methods
Triangulation
Offset
Completeness
Different research questions
Explanation
Unexpected results
Instrument development
Credibility
Illustration
Confirm and discover
Diversity of views
Enhancement
5/11/2022 80