Using English Language
    Learner's Native
Language: Bringing their
     World into the
      Classroom
         Dr. C. Allen Lynn
           lynna@uncw.edu
        Dr. N. Pappamihiel
        pappamihieln@uncw.edu
Why use a student’s native
         language in class?
 Accelerates their English language acquisition
 Bridges cultural barriers
 Advances content mastery
 Increases global awareness for native English
  speakers who might otherwise not have such exposure
  to other cultures and languages
L1 Study Buddies
 Students who speak the
  same language are allowed
  to have 2-3 discussions with
  each other prior to
  discussing a topic

 Helps vocabulary
  development

 Native English kids who
  speak some Spanish (former
  dual language kids) can join
  in
For example, a 3rd grade teacher is introducing the
concept of Fahrenheit and Celsius in a science lesson. This
teacher, Mr. Jones, can allow his three Spanish speaking
ELLs the opportunity to discuss the topic in Spanish for a
few minutes if he knows that one of the
students, Jesus, has a high enough English proficiency to
understand Mr. Jones’ explanation. Jesus can then have a
fairly in-depth conversation with his lower proficiency level
classmates (Marta and Alvaro), helping them to build
schema for these two new vocabulary terms. When the
class comes together to complete a hands-on project, not
only has Jesus further developed his knowledge by
teaching something to his peers, but Marta and Alvaro are
able to take better advantage of the demonstration and
hands-on activity done by Mr. Jones. The important part of
this strategy is the extended discussion.
L1 Dialog Journals
          Students write in their L1 using
            some English as they can
          Drawings are acceptable as
            well
          Builds rapport between the
            teacher and the student since it
            allows the student more
            freedom of expression
          Teacher and student meet and
            negotiate meaning
          Journals can be displayed with
            student permission
For example, in Mrs. Williams’ 5th grade language arts
class there is a student from Burkina Faso who has low
literacy skills in English but has a high proficiency in
French. Mrs. Williams does not speak or write French.
However, twice a week she and Ismael sit down and
discuss his dialog journal entry using the limited English
language skills that Ismael possesses at the moment.
Through rough sketches, a bilingual dictionary, hand
gestures and mimicking they are able to discuss the dialog
journal entry. Mrs. Williams later prepares a feedback
response to their exchange, providing new vocabulary as
well as clarification of any misunderstandings that arose.
Ismael is able to review Mrs. Williams’ comments later at
his own pace and use those comments in his next dialog
journal entry.
Coding the Text
 Students make L1 sticky
  notes and put thought
  bubbles in the text that
  they’re working with
 Allows students to
  negotiate a text using their
  native language
 Allows students
  opportunities to negotiate
  meaning between
  themselves
In this classroom example Mr. Fiveash teaches a fifth grade
social studies class. Yadira, a new arrival from the
Dominican Republic, has a limited working proficiency of
English. While she is able to function in the classroom
without much difficulty, she does not completely understand
some of the more demanding texts. With this in mind, Mr.
Fiveash prepares a copy of the chapter on exploration of
the Americas by Europeans for Yadira using thought bubble
notes above the most pertinent passages. Yadira, knowing
that these sections are important, is able to fill in the
bubbles with notes in her L1. Later she can use these
notes to create graphic organizers and other helpful notes.
Cognates
     Vocabulary that is similar
       between languages
        costa=coast
        circulo=circle
     Can help with vocabulary
       development for both ELLs and
       native English speakers
     For many ELLs, including
       Spanish speakers, many
       cognates are highly academic
       words
        sίntesis= synthesis
        tectόnico=tectonics
        acerlerar= accelerate
There are two students from Mexico City in Ms. Dowdy’s
fifth grade science class, and the lesson is one in which
students are studying Newton’s First and Second Laws of
Motion. Coming from a school known for academic
excellence, the twins, Manuela and Ricardo, are very
familiar with the material in their L1. However, English still
tends to give them trouble. Manuela and Ricardo are
already familiar with some of the academic vocabulary
because many of the words have direct Spanish cognates
that they use quite often
(object=objetos, accelerate=acelerar, dependent=dependie
nte, etc.). Putting Manuela and Ricardo into separate small
groups with 3 to 4 native English speaker students who are
also having trouble with the assignment, Ms. Dowdy
instructs the group to look for cognates in the reading.
Discussion of the vocabulary allows both the language
learners and the native speakers to flesh out the gist of the
class assignment.
Word Walls
 Word Walls are common
  enough in elementary
  classrooms, but are very
  useful for ELLs as well

 Word Walls can be in any
  language

 Exposes all students to
  different linguistic codes
Hanna is a fourth grader from Korea. She arrived in Mr.
Brown’s science class halfway through the spring
semester. Hanna has studied English grammar.
However, she is shy and struggles with speaking. Mr.
Brown puts Hanna in a group with 3 native English
speakers working on a word wall project. Using the text as
a guide, the students create a glossary for a unit on the
solar system using both English and Korean. Hanna is able
to participate with the other students while having little
pressure to speak in front of a large audience. Other
students in class ask her how to pronounce the words in
Korean.
Conclusions
 Teachers should not be hesitant to use a student’s
  native language in the classroom

 Even if the ELL speaks English well, using his/her L1 in
  class helps to bring different cultures into the classroom
  that moves beyond superficial treatments of
  multiculturalism

Using ELLS's native language

  • 1.
    Using English Language Learner's Native Language: Bringing their World into the Classroom Dr. C. Allen Lynn lynna@uncw.edu Dr. N. Pappamihiel pappamihieln@uncw.edu
  • 2.
    Why use astudent’s native language in class?  Accelerates their English language acquisition  Bridges cultural barriers  Advances content mastery  Increases global awareness for native English speakers who might otherwise not have such exposure to other cultures and languages
  • 3.
    L1 Study Buddies Students who speak the same language are allowed to have 2-3 discussions with each other prior to discussing a topic  Helps vocabulary development  Native English kids who speak some Spanish (former dual language kids) can join in
  • 4.
    For example, a3rd grade teacher is introducing the concept of Fahrenheit and Celsius in a science lesson. This teacher, Mr. Jones, can allow his three Spanish speaking ELLs the opportunity to discuss the topic in Spanish for a few minutes if he knows that one of the students, Jesus, has a high enough English proficiency to understand Mr. Jones’ explanation. Jesus can then have a fairly in-depth conversation with his lower proficiency level classmates (Marta and Alvaro), helping them to build schema for these two new vocabulary terms. When the class comes together to complete a hands-on project, not only has Jesus further developed his knowledge by teaching something to his peers, but Marta and Alvaro are able to take better advantage of the demonstration and hands-on activity done by Mr. Jones. The important part of this strategy is the extended discussion.
  • 5.
    L1 Dialog Journals  Students write in their L1 using some English as they can  Drawings are acceptable as well  Builds rapport between the teacher and the student since it allows the student more freedom of expression  Teacher and student meet and negotiate meaning  Journals can be displayed with student permission
  • 6.
    For example, inMrs. Williams’ 5th grade language arts class there is a student from Burkina Faso who has low literacy skills in English but has a high proficiency in French. Mrs. Williams does not speak or write French. However, twice a week she and Ismael sit down and discuss his dialog journal entry using the limited English language skills that Ismael possesses at the moment. Through rough sketches, a bilingual dictionary, hand gestures and mimicking they are able to discuss the dialog journal entry. Mrs. Williams later prepares a feedback response to their exchange, providing new vocabulary as well as clarification of any misunderstandings that arose. Ismael is able to review Mrs. Williams’ comments later at his own pace and use those comments in his next dialog journal entry.
  • 7.
    Coding the Text Students make L1 sticky notes and put thought bubbles in the text that they’re working with  Allows students to negotiate a text using their native language  Allows students opportunities to negotiate meaning between themselves
  • 8.
    In this classroomexample Mr. Fiveash teaches a fifth grade social studies class. Yadira, a new arrival from the Dominican Republic, has a limited working proficiency of English. While she is able to function in the classroom without much difficulty, she does not completely understand some of the more demanding texts. With this in mind, Mr. Fiveash prepares a copy of the chapter on exploration of the Americas by Europeans for Yadira using thought bubble notes above the most pertinent passages. Yadira, knowing that these sections are important, is able to fill in the bubbles with notes in her L1. Later she can use these notes to create graphic organizers and other helpful notes.
  • 9.
    Cognates  Vocabulary that is similar between languages  costa=coast  circulo=circle  Can help with vocabulary development for both ELLs and native English speakers  For many ELLs, including Spanish speakers, many cognates are highly academic words  sίntesis= synthesis  tectόnico=tectonics  acerlerar= accelerate
  • 10.
    There are twostudents from Mexico City in Ms. Dowdy’s fifth grade science class, and the lesson is one in which students are studying Newton’s First and Second Laws of Motion. Coming from a school known for academic excellence, the twins, Manuela and Ricardo, are very familiar with the material in their L1. However, English still tends to give them trouble. Manuela and Ricardo are already familiar with some of the academic vocabulary because many of the words have direct Spanish cognates that they use quite often (object=objetos, accelerate=acelerar, dependent=dependie nte, etc.). Putting Manuela and Ricardo into separate small groups with 3 to 4 native English speaker students who are also having trouble with the assignment, Ms. Dowdy instructs the group to look for cognates in the reading. Discussion of the vocabulary allows both the language learners and the native speakers to flesh out the gist of the class assignment.
  • 11.
    Word Walls  WordWalls are common enough in elementary classrooms, but are very useful for ELLs as well  Word Walls can be in any language  Exposes all students to different linguistic codes
  • 12.
    Hanna is afourth grader from Korea. She arrived in Mr. Brown’s science class halfway through the spring semester. Hanna has studied English grammar. However, she is shy and struggles with speaking. Mr. Brown puts Hanna in a group with 3 native English speakers working on a word wall project. Using the text as a guide, the students create a glossary for a unit on the solar system using both English and Korean. Hanna is able to participate with the other students while having little pressure to speak in front of a large audience. Other students in class ask her how to pronounce the words in Korean.
  • 13.
    Conclusions  Teachers shouldnot be hesitant to use a student’s native language in the classroom  Even if the ELL speaks English well, using his/her L1 in class helps to bring different cultures into the classroom that moves beyond superficial treatments of multiculturalism