Sustainability in fashion
- reflections on the possibility of sustainability
       In fashion, inspired by OpenWear



               Oleg Koefoed
    Copenhagen Business School / Cultura21



     Presentation for OpenWear conference

             “Refashioning Fashion”
             Ljubljana June 2nd 2011
0 Challenge / question

    How can we understand a project such as
    OpenWear, so that it will make sense that it
    would be sustainable?

    What local actions could be frutiful to make
    this more probable?

    What overall changes in the
    environment/industry would be necessary?
1 status for the fashion industry

Public concern – talk – and some real interest in
sustainability

Mainly environmental issues and connections to CSR

Lots of greenwashing (=non-systemic single actions and
more or less pure propaganda)

Innovative experiences in micro-processes

BUT: need for experiments on a much bigger scale

AND: need for opening up of processes, production,
decisions, values
Examples of sustainable (?) practice


  Sustainable Textile development

  Slow fashion initiatives

  Cooperative / co-creative entreprises

  DIY /DIT etc

  ECO Brands

  Political measures, legislation

  New educational elements

  Fairs / un-fashion conferences etc
2.1 The pillars / dimensions

Environment         Sociality              Economic           Cultural

How does the        How does the           How does the       How does the
system build        system build           system create      system
resilience          social                 value through      facilitate the
through the         coherence by           the                emergence of
use of natural      forming groups         transformation     meaning
resources           and institutions       of resources       – and does it
– and does it       – and does it          – and does it      allow for the
allow for other     maintain               redistribute the   transformation
systems to co-      dynamic                value?             and evolution
evolve?             openness?                                 of meaning?


POWER: the fifth – political - pillar...
2.2 status re: the four pillars

Environment       Sociality        Economy           Culture

After 30 years,   Seat of some     Most of the       Many small
some progress     of the major     industry builds   alternatives –
is being made     weaknesses of    on exploitation   but overall
– more            the industry –   and               domination of
experience        lack of          obsolescense      images of fast
needed, more      transparency –   new business      fashion,
investment,       need for         models            obsolescence
need for new      education; and   needed – even     and
paradigm?         new              new economic      consumerism
                  organization     foundations       + issue of
                  models                             heritage vs
                                                     revolution

POWER: lack of transparency & big-scale responsible experiments
3 Definitions of sustainability

     Brundtland report (1987)
     Satisfying our present needs without jeopardizing
     the needs of future generations

     BETTER

     Morin/Kagan (2011)
     a search process for dynamic balance,
     that unfolds itself differently according
     to the specific contexts, allowing the
     emergence of resilient cultural-natural
     hypercomplex systems
4 Resilience and Emergence
   Resilience
   When open systems learn from their environments,
   transforming themselves

   Characterized by diversity and resilience
   and „autoecopoïetic“ sensibility: creative openness
   to disturbances, allowing for emergence



   Emergence
   The engine of complex, unpredictable
   evolutions in nature and in societies
   – leads creation and transformation in the systems

                                         Drawing on Kagan (2011)
5 A dynamic model: sustensivity

                                  NEW SYSTEM
System
/Life form A

                                  RESILIENCE

      SUSTENSION                  &            NON-EQUILIBRIUM
                                               DYNAMICS
                                  EMERGENCE

System
/Life form B


X Life intensity / potentiality
Y Time-space continuum
6 ...so what about “OpenWear”-projects
  3 crucial questions

Conditions of entry
                        Resilience potential   Outcome
8 The complex 'equation'


  Moments                                 Dimensions

  Conditions of entry                     Economic

                                          Environmental

                               x
  Resilience and
  emergence
                                          Social
  Dynamic outcome
                                          Cultural



         = potential for sustainability
9 Causes for concern: pitfalls

Environmental                    Economic
the planning pitfall             falling back into
planning tends to                durability
reduce and                       Sustainable=surviv
compartmentalize:                ing
the problems                     + lowering entry



                         *
return in much                   barriers
greater scale                    temporarily
                                 without changing
                                 the overall system
     Social
     sucking the juice   Cultural
     out of workers      Greenwashing/propaganda
     (project logic)     that deteriorates the
     + struggle for      reputation of sustainable
     justice > co-       change
     change              + compartmentalization
10 The unresolved question of OW etc




                                       }
Facilitating economic entry
Opening up to the discarded
Taking participation seriously
Creating open cultures

Sharing economy among creators             Complex?
Sustaining systemic diversity
Increasing transparency                    Impossible?
Bringing together past and future          Simple?
New forms of wealth
Non-destructive material production
Infinity in responsibility/care/love
Placing re-generation at the heart
X a philosophical comment


Eternity ?                  Infinity ?



                 OR
Thank you.

   Oleg Koefoed
oleg@cultura21.dk
  +45 5353 9572

Presentation ljubljana june 1st 2011 edufashion

  • 1.
    Sustainability in fashion -reflections on the possibility of sustainability In fashion, inspired by OpenWear Oleg Koefoed Copenhagen Business School / Cultura21 Presentation for OpenWear conference “Refashioning Fashion” Ljubljana June 2nd 2011
  • 2.
    0 Challenge /question How can we understand a project such as OpenWear, so that it will make sense that it would be sustainable? What local actions could be frutiful to make this more probable? What overall changes in the environment/industry would be necessary?
  • 3.
    1 status forthe fashion industry Public concern – talk – and some real interest in sustainability Mainly environmental issues and connections to CSR Lots of greenwashing (=non-systemic single actions and more or less pure propaganda) Innovative experiences in micro-processes BUT: need for experiments on a much bigger scale AND: need for opening up of processes, production, decisions, values
  • 4.
    Examples of sustainable(?) practice Sustainable Textile development Slow fashion initiatives Cooperative / co-creative entreprises DIY /DIT etc ECO Brands Political measures, legislation New educational elements Fairs / un-fashion conferences etc
  • 5.
    2.1 The pillars/ dimensions Environment Sociality Economic Cultural How does the How does the How does the How does the system build system build system create system resilience social value through facilitate the through the coherence by the emergence of use of natural forming groups transformation meaning resources and institutions of resources – and does it – and does it – and does it – and does it allow for the allow for other maintain redistribute the transformation systems to co- dynamic value? and evolution evolve? openness? of meaning? POWER: the fifth – political - pillar...
  • 6.
    2.2 status re:the four pillars Environment Sociality Economy Culture After 30 years, Seat of some Most of the Many small some progress of the major industry builds alternatives – is being made weaknesses of on exploitation but overall – more the industry – and domination of experience lack of obsolescense images of fast needed, more transparency – new business fashion, investment, need for models obsolescence need for new education; and needed – even and paradigm? new new economic consumerism organization foundations + issue of models heritage vs revolution POWER: lack of transparency & big-scale responsible experiments
  • 7.
    3 Definitions ofsustainability Brundtland report (1987) Satisfying our present needs without jeopardizing the needs of future generations BETTER Morin/Kagan (2011) a search process for dynamic balance, that unfolds itself differently according to the specific contexts, allowing the emergence of resilient cultural-natural hypercomplex systems
  • 8.
    4 Resilience andEmergence Resilience When open systems learn from their environments, transforming themselves Characterized by diversity and resilience and „autoecopoïetic“ sensibility: creative openness to disturbances, allowing for emergence Emergence The engine of complex, unpredictable evolutions in nature and in societies – leads creation and transformation in the systems Drawing on Kagan (2011)
  • 9.
    5 A dynamicmodel: sustensivity NEW SYSTEM System /Life form A RESILIENCE SUSTENSION & NON-EQUILIBRIUM DYNAMICS EMERGENCE System /Life form B X Life intensity / potentiality Y Time-space continuum
  • 10.
    6 ...so whatabout “OpenWear”-projects 3 crucial questions Conditions of entry Resilience potential Outcome
  • 11.
    8 The complex'equation' Moments Dimensions Conditions of entry Economic Environmental x Resilience and emergence Social Dynamic outcome Cultural = potential for sustainability
  • 12.
    9 Causes forconcern: pitfalls Environmental Economic the planning pitfall falling back into planning tends to durability reduce and Sustainable=surviv compartmentalize: ing the problems + lowering entry * return in much barriers greater scale temporarily without changing the overall system Social sucking the juice Cultural out of workers Greenwashing/propaganda (project logic) that deteriorates the + struggle for reputation of sustainable justice > co- change change + compartmentalization
  • 13.
    10 The unresolvedquestion of OW etc } Facilitating economic entry Opening up to the discarded Taking participation seriously Creating open cultures Sharing economy among creators Complex? Sustaining systemic diversity Increasing transparency Impossible? Bringing together past and future Simple? New forms of wealth Non-destructive material production Infinity in responsibility/care/love Placing re-generation at the heart
  • 14.
    X a philosophicalcomment Eternity ? Infinity ? OR
  • 15.
    Thank you. Oleg Koefoed oleg@cultura21.dk +45 5353 9572