SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 22
Download to read offline
Measuring Quality

       Michael J. Kurtz

Harvard-Smithsonian Center for
         Astrophysics
Outline
1. Journals
   Bollen
   Reads
2. People
3. Departments
4. Countries
Individuals
• Age is critical

•   Citations
•   Reads
•   SumProd
•   Read10
Departments
• Departments are the sum of their
  members

• Linear measures, such as total cites, are
  inadequate. Sandage = 25 times average
  tenured faculty at top 10
Countries
• Scientific Productivity is proportional to
  GDP squared divided by population
• SP is proportional to the number of
  scientists times the per capita GDP

• Downloads in astronomy are a more
  stable indicator of SP than citations or
  papers
Literature
• Bollen, et al “Journal Status”
  arXiv:cs.DL/0601030 (2006)
• Kurtz, et al “The Bibliometric Properties of
  Article Readership Information”, JASIST
  56, 111 (2005)
• Kurtz, et al “Worldwide Use and Impact of
  the NASA Astrophysics Data System
  Digital Library”, JASIST 56, 36 (2005)

More Related Content

Viewers also liked

Paul Biya - Cameroun - Programme de célébration de la 42ème édition de la Fêt...
Paul Biya - Cameroun - Programme de célébration de la 42ème édition de la Fêt...Paul Biya - Cameroun - Programme de célébration de la 42ème édition de la Fêt...
Paul Biya - Cameroun - Programme de célébration de la 42ème édition de la Fêt...Paul Biya
 
Heartbreak Hotel (Pp Tminimizer)
Heartbreak Hotel (Pp Tminimizer)Heartbreak Hotel (Pp Tminimizer)
Heartbreak Hotel (Pp Tminimizer)Marco Belzoni
 
Aanbestedingswet - Gemeentedagen 2016
Aanbestedingswet - Gemeentedagen 2016Aanbestedingswet - Gemeentedagen 2016
Aanbestedingswet - Gemeentedagen 2016AKD
 
Estudios de conservatorio para guuitarra
Estudios de conservatorio para guuitarraEstudios de conservatorio para guuitarra
Estudios de conservatorio para guuitarraCristian Fajardo
 
життєвий шлях тараса шевченко
життєвий шлях тараса шевченкожиттєвий шлях тараса шевченко
життєвий шлях тараса шевченкоvalia1971
 
Curso de Guitarra Básica
Curso de Guitarra BásicaCurso de Guitarra Básica
Curso de Guitarra BásicaEducagratis
 

Viewers also liked (11)

Antoine griezmann
Antoine griezmannAntoine griezmann
Antoine griezmann
 
steven spilberg
steven spilbergsteven spilberg
steven spilberg
 
Paul Biya - Cameroun - Programme de célébration de la 42ème édition de la Fêt...
Paul Biya - Cameroun - Programme de célébration de la 42ème édition de la Fêt...Paul Biya - Cameroun - Programme de célébration de la 42ème édition de la Fêt...
Paul Biya - Cameroun - Programme de célébration de la 42ème édition de la Fêt...
 
Top todo incluido esp
Top todo incluido espTop todo incluido esp
Top todo incluido esp
 
Heartbreak Hotel (Pp Tminimizer)
Heartbreak Hotel (Pp Tminimizer)Heartbreak Hotel (Pp Tminimizer)
Heartbreak Hotel (Pp Tminimizer)
 
Miami 3
Miami 3Miami 3
Miami 3
 
Aanbestedingswet - Gemeentedagen 2016
Aanbestedingswet - Gemeentedagen 2016Aanbestedingswet - Gemeentedagen 2016
Aanbestedingswet - Gemeentedagen 2016
 
PadKaKa_全球版_完整使用教學
PadKaKa_全球版_完整使用教學PadKaKa_全球版_完整使用教學
PadKaKa_全球版_完整使用教學
 
Estudios de conservatorio para guuitarra
Estudios de conservatorio para guuitarraEstudios de conservatorio para guuitarra
Estudios de conservatorio para guuitarra
 
життєвий шлях тараса шевченко
життєвий шлях тараса шевченкожиттєвий шлях тараса шевченко
життєвий шлях тараса шевченко
 
Curso de Guitarra Básica
Curso de Guitarra BásicaCurso de Guitarra Básica
Curso de Guitarra Básica
 

Similar to 175 sspcc2 b_kurtz

What is your h-index and other measures of impact
What is your h-index and other measures of impactWhat is your h-index and other measures of impact
What is your h-index and other measures of impactBerenika Webster
 
Prof. sp singh.ph d.course work.2020-21.citation index, journal impact factor...
Prof. sp singh.ph d.course work.2020-21.citation index, journal impact factor...Prof. sp singh.ph d.course work.2020-21.citation index, journal impact factor...
Prof. sp singh.ph d.course work.2020-21.citation index, journal impact factor...Saurashtra University
 
Genres without borders: Performative uptakes in science writing
Genres without borders: Performative uptakes in science writingGenres without borders: Performative uptakes in science writing
Genres without borders: Performative uptakes in science writingLisaChristian81
 
Analysis Of Publications And Citations From A Geophysics Research Institute
Analysis Of Publications And Citations From A Geophysics Research InstituteAnalysis Of Publications And Citations From A Geophysics Research Institute
Analysis Of Publications And Citations From A Geophysics Research InstituteAndrew Molina
 
Maybe ph.d.-students shouldn't do literature reviews ....
Maybe ph.d.-students shouldn't do literature reviews ....Maybe ph.d.-students shouldn't do literature reviews ....
Maybe ph.d.-students shouldn't do literature reviews ....Gina Bay
 
Love for science or Academic prostitution, 2019 update
Love for science or Academic prostitution, 2019 updateLove for science or Academic prostitution, 2019 update
Love for science or Academic prostitution, 2019 updateLourdes Verdes-Montenegro
 
Study on book purchasing reading behavior
Study on book purchasing reading behaviorStudy on book purchasing reading behavior
Study on book purchasing reading behaviorJuliane Ritt
 
Scholarly Communication - Not just for scholars anymore
Scholarly Communication - Not just for scholars anymoreScholarly Communication - Not just for scholars anymore
Scholarly Communication - Not just for scholars anymoreJoseph Kraus
 
Proving Your Value: The Librarians’ Contribution to the Promotion and Tenure ...
Proving Your Value: The Librarians’ Contribution to the Promotion and Tenure ...Proving Your Value: The Librarians’ Contribution to the Promotion and Tenure ...
Proving Your Value: The Librarians’ Contribution to the Promotion and Tenure ...Susan Ariew, Vera Lux, & Matt Torrence
 
Scholarly communication: Not just for scholars anymore
Scholarly communication: Not just for scholars anymoreScholarly communication: Not just for scholars anymore
Scholarly communication: Not just for scholars anymoreJoseph Kraus
 
Broad altmetric analysis of Mendeley readerships through the ‘academic status...
Broad altmetric analysis of Mendeley readerships through the ‘academic status...Broad altmetric analysis of Mendeley readerships through the ‘academic status...
Broad altmetric analysis of Mendeley readerships through the ‘academic status...Zohreh Zahedi
 
1, 2. Research proposal & Res. Article.pptx
1, 2. Research proposal & Res. Article.pptx1, 2. Research proposal & Res. Article.pptx
1, 2. Research proposal & Res. Article.pptxMansoorAhmed57263
 
Kos, D.; Špiranec, S. Understanding the field of critical information literac...
Kos, D.; Špiranec, S. Understanding the field of critical information literac...Kos, D.; Špiranec, S. Understanding the field of critical information literac...
Kos, D.; Špiranec, S. Understanding the field of critical information literac...Denis Kos
 
بنك المعرفة المصرى Egyptian knowledge bank
بنك المعرفة المصرى  Egyptian knowledge bankبنك المعرفة المصرى  Egyptian knowledge bank
بنك المعرفة المصرى Egyptian knowledge banksameh shalash
 
Vnsgu.pre ph d.course work.27aug2021.a talk on 'quality evaluation and ethic...
Vnsgu.pre ph d.course  work.27aug2021.a talk on 'quality evaluation and ethic...Vnsgu.pre ph d.course  work.27aug2021.a talk on 'quality evaluation and ethic...
Vnsgu.pre ph d.course work.27aug2021.a talk on 'quality evaluation and ethic...Saurashtra University
 

Similar to 175 sspcc2 b_kurtz (20)

What is your h-index and other measures of impact
What is your h-index and other measures of impactWhat is your h-index and other measures of impact
What is your h-index and other measures of impact
 
Prof. sp singh.ph d.course work.2020-21.citation index, journal impact factor...
Prof. sp singh.ph d.course work.2020-21.citation index, journal impact factor...Prof. sp singh.ph d.course work.2020-21.citation index, journal impact factor...
Prof. sp singh.ph d.course work.2020-21.citation index, journal impact factor...
 
Genres without borders: Performative uptakes in science writing
Genres without borders: Performative uptakes in science writingGenres without borders: Performative uptakes in science writing
Genres without borders: Performative uptakes in science writing
 
Analysis Of Publications And Citations From A Geophysics Research Institute
Analysis Of Publications And Citations From A Geophysics Research InstituteAnalysis Of Publications And Citations From A Geophysics Research Institute
Analysis Of Publications And Citations From A Geophysics Research Institute
 
Maybe ph.d.-students shouldn't do literature reviews ....
Maybe ph.d.-students shouldn't do literature reviews ....Maybe ph.d.-students shouldn't do literature reviews ....
Maybe ph.d.-students shouldn't do literature reviews ....
 
Making Your Research Findable: Writing a great abstract
Making Your Research Findable: Writing a great abstractMaking Your Research Findable: Writing a great abstract
Making Your Research Findable: Writing a great abstract
 
Love for science or Academic prostitution, 2019 update
Love for science or Academic prostitution, 2019 updateLove for science or Academic prostitution, 2019 update
Love for science or Academic prostitution, 2019 update
 
Study on book purchasing reading behavior
Study on book purchasing reading behaviorStudy on book purchasing reading behavior
Study on book purchasing reading behavior
 
Scholarly Communication - Not just for scholars anymore
Scholarly Communication - Not just for scholars anymoreScholarly Communication - Not just for scholars anymore
Scholarly Communication - Not just for scholars anymore
 
Proving Your Value: The Librarians’ Contribution to the Promotion and Tenure ...
Proving Your Value: The Librarians’ Contribution to the Promotion and Tenure ...Proving Your Value: The Librarians’ Contribution to the Promotion and Tenure ...
Proving Your Value: The Librarians’ Contribution to the Promotion and Tenure ...
 
Vancouver
VancouverVancouver
Vancouver
 
Scholarly communication: Not just for scholars anymore
Scholarly communication: Not just for scholars anymoreScholarly communication: Not just for scholars anymore
Scholarly communication: Not just for scholars anymore
 
Broad altmetric analysis of Mendeley readerships through the ‘academic status...
Broad altmetric analysis of Mendeley readerships through the ‘academic status...Broad altmetric analysis of Mendeley readerships through the ‘academic status...
Broad altmetric analysis of Mendeley readerships through the ‘academic status...
 
Maccallum
MaccallumMaccallum
Maccallum
 
1, 2. Research proposal & Res. Article.pptx
1, 2. Research proposal & Res. Article.pptx1, 2. Research proposal & Res. Article.pptx
1, 2. Research proposal & Res. Article.pptx
 
Kochalko,"Why we should stop worrying about high impact journal indicators an...
Kochalko,"Why we should stop worrying about high impact journal indicators an...Kochalko,"Why we should stop worrying about high impact journal indicators an...
Kochalko,"Why we should stop worrying about high impact journal indicators an...
 
Kos, D.; Špiranec, S. Understanding the field of critical information literac...
Kos, D.; Špiranec, S. Understanding the field of critical information literac...Kos, D.; Špiranec, S. Understanding the field of critical information literac...
Kos, D.; Špiranec, S. Understanding the field of critical information literac...
 
بنك المعرفة المصرى Egyptian knowledge bank
بنك المعرفة المصرى  Egyptian knowledge bankبنك المعرفة المصرى  Egyptian knowledge bank
بنك المعرفة المصرى Egyptian knowledge bank
 
PBL and global competencies in science
PBL and global competencies in sciencePBL and global competencies in science
PBL and global competencies in science
 
Vnsgu.pre ph d.course work.27aug2021.a talk on 'quality evaluation and ethic...
Vnsgu.pre ph d.course  work.27aug2021.a talk on 'quality evaluation and ethic...Vnsgu.pre ph d.course  work.27aug2021.a talk on 'quality evaluation and ethic...
Vnsgu.pre ph d.course work.27aug2021.a talk on 'quality evaluation and ethic...
 

More from Society for Scholarly Publishing

04142015 ssp webinar_theworldisflatforscholarlypublishing_caitlinmeadows
04142015 ssp webinar_theworldisflatforscholarlypublishing_caitlinmeadows04142015 ssp webinar_theworldisflatforscholarlypublishing_caitlinmeadows
04142015 ssp webinar_theworldisflatforscholarlypublishing_caitlinmeadowsSociety for Scholarly Publishing
 
04142015 ssp webinar_theworldisflatforscholarlypublishing_bruceheterick
04142015 ssp webinar_theworldisflatforscholarlypublishing_bruceheterick04142015 ssp webinar_theworldisflatforscholarlypublishing_bruceheterick
04142015 ssp webinar_theworldisflatforscholarlypublishing_bruceheterickSociety for Scholarly Publishing
 

More from Society for Scholarly Publishing (20)

10052016 ssp seminar2_newsham
10052016 ssp seminar2_newsham10052016 ssp seminar2_newsham
10052016 ssp seminar2_newsham
 
10052016 ssp seminar2_rivera
10052016 ssp seminar2_rivera10052016 ssp seminar2_rivera
10052016 ssp seminar2_rivera
 
10052016 ssp seminar2_pesanelli
10052016 ssp seminar2_pesanelli10052016 ssp seminar2_pesanelli
10052016 ssp seminar2_pesanelli
 
10052016 ssp seminar2_harley
10052016 ssp seminar2_harley10052016 ssp seminar2_harley
10052016 ssp seminar2_harley
 
10042016 ssp seminar1_session4_myers
10042016 ssp seminar1_session4_myers10042016 ssp seminar1_session4_myers
10042016 ssp seminar1_session4_myers
 
10042016 ssp seminar1_session4_demers
10042016 ssp seminar1_session4_demers10042016 ssp seminar1_session4_demers
10042016 ssp seminar1_session4_demers
 
10042016 ssp seminar1_session4_cochran
10042016 ssp seminar1_session4_cochran10042016 ssp seminar1_session4_cochran
10042016 ssp seminar1_session4_cochran
 
10042016 ssp seminar1_session3_stanley
10042016 ssp seminar1_session3_stanley10042016 ssp seminar1_session3_stanley
10042016 ssp seminar1_session3_stanley
 
10042016 ssp seminar1_session3_ranganathan
10042016 ssp seminar1_session3_ranganathan10042016 ssp seminar1_session3_ranganathan
10042016 ssp seminar1_session3_ranganathan
 
10042016 ssp seminar1_session3_odike
10042016 ssp seminar1_session3_odike10042016 ssp seminar1_session3_odike
10042016 ssp seminar1_session3_odike
 
10042016 ssp seminar1_session3_cochran
10042016 ssp seminar1_session3_cochran10042016 ssp seminar1_session3_cochran
10042016 ssp seminar1_session3_cochran
 
10042016 ssp seminar1_session2_walker
10042016 ssp seminar1_session2_walker10042016 ssp seminar1_session2_walker
10042016 ssp seminar1_session2_walker
 
10042016 ssp seminar1_session2_ivins
10042016 ssp seminar1_session2_ivins10042016 ssp seminar1_session2_ivins
10042016 ssp seminar1_session2_ivins
 
10042016 ssp seminar1_session2_holland
10042016 ssp seminar1_session2_holland10042016 ssp seminar1_session2_holland
10042016 ssp seminar1_session2_holland
 
10042016 ssp seminar1_session1_stanley
10042016 ssp seminar1_session1_stanley10042016 ssp seminar1_session1_stanley
10042016 ssp seminar1_session1_stanley
 
10042016 ssp seminar1_session1_keane
10042016 ssp seminar1_session1_keane10042016 ssp seminar1_session1_keane
10042016 ssp seminar1_session1_keane
 
10042016 ssp seminar1_session1_ivins
10042016 ssp seminar1_session1_ivins10042016 ssp seminar1_session1_ivins
10042016 ssp seminar1_session1_ivins
 
10042016 ssp seminar1_session1_asadilari
10042016 ssp seminar1_session1_asadilari10042016 ssp seminar1_session1_asadilari
10042016 ssp seminar1_session1_asadilari
 
04142015 ssp webinar_theworldisflatforscholarlypublishing_caitlinmeadows
04142015 ssp webinar_theworldisflatforscholarlypublishing_caitlinmeadows04142015 ssp webinar_theworldisflatforscholarlypublishing_caitlinmeadows
04142015 ssp webinar_theworldisflatforscholarlypublishing_caitlinmeadows
 
04142015 ssp webinar_theworldisflatforscholarlypublishing_bruceheterick
04142015 ssp webinar_theworldisflatforscholarlypublishing_bruceheterick04142015 ssp webinar_theworldisflatforscholarlypublishing_bruceheterick
04142015 ssp webinar_theworldisflatforscholarlypublishing_bruceheterick
 

175 sspcc2 b_kurtz

  • 1. Measuring Quality Michael J. Kurtz Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics
  • 2. Outline 1. Journals Bollen Reads 2. People 3. Departments 4. Countries
  • 3.
  • 4.
  • 5.
  • 6.
  • 7.
  • 8.
  • 9.
  • 10.
  • 11. Individuals • Age is critical • Citations • Reads • SumProd • Read10
  • 12.
  • 13.
  • 14.
  • 15.
  • 16. Departments • Departments are the sum of their members • Linear measures, such as total cites, are inadequate. Sandage = 25 times average tenured faculty at top 10
  • 17.
  • 18.
  • 19. Countries • Scientific Productivity is proportional to GDP squared divided by population • SP is proportional to the number of scientists times the per capita GDP • Downloads in astronomy are a more stable indicator of SP than citations or papers
  • 20.
  • 21.
  • 22. Literature • Bollen, et al “Journal Status” arXiv:cs.DL/0601030 (2006) • Kurtz, et al “The Bibliometric Properties of Article Readership Information”, JASIST 56, 111 (2005) • Kurtz, et al “Worldwide Use and Impact of the NASA Astrophysics Data System Digital Library”, JASIST 56, 36 (2005)