This case report describes how goal-directed acupuncture improved the performance of a top modern pentathlete over 7 years. The acupuncture points were chosen based on symptoms that were limiting performance in each event, and verified using thermography. Stimulation of points relieved symptoms and improved the athlete's ranking from 10th to top positions. While training effects and placebo cannot be ruled out, the report reviews literature supporting specific physiological effects of acupuncture for enhanced endurance, recovery, and oxygen intake in athletes. However, the potential for acupuncture to be considered doping is discussed.
2. 2 Evidence-Based Complementary and Alternative Medicine
Acupuncture program for modern pentathlon
GB21
1
2
LI14 3
4
5
Ranking
GB34
LI11 6
ST36
LI10
7
8
9
TH5
10
LI4 Below 10
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Years in national team
(a) (b) Figure 2: Performance success of the athlete through his sportsā
career. x-axis means the years of sportsā performance in national
team, y-axis means the ranking at the international competitions as
black stars (World Cup, World Championships, Olympic games).
H7
GV26 in 3000-m cross-country running from 10 minutes to <9
minutes and 25 seconds, because epigastric pain and knee
(c) (d)
weakness, which had been the major limiting factors during
running were successfully relieved. Other symptoms (arm
Figure 1: Acupuncture points, used for stimulation to improve fatigue during fencing, stiļ¬ness of the shoulder muscles
the sportsā performance in top modern pentathlon athlete. during swimming and general excitement and tremor of
(a) Acupuncture points ST36 and GB34, situated on the proximal dominant arm during shooting) could be also successfully
latero-anterior surface of the lower leg, were stimulated before treated with the stimulation of acupuncture points.
running. (b) Acupuncture points of the upper extremities LI4, Figure 2 shows the increased ranking in international
10, 11; TH 5 and GB21 were used to relieve arm fatigue during competitions (World Cup, World Championships, Olympic
fencing and stiļ¬ness of the shoulder muscles during swimming.
games) from the age of 20 years until the end of his sports
(c) Acupuncture point H7, situated on the distal ulnar part of
the forearm was used to treat general excitement and tremor of
career. During that time the athlete was among the best in
dominant arm during shooting. (d) Acupuncture point GV26, the national MP team.
situated in the midline of the upper lip, was used, as the point The increased success of athleteās performance was
for general toniļ¬cation. For precise anatomical landmarks of attributed to the acupuncture program, although his coach
acupuncture points please consult [4]. reported a strong psychological eļ¬ect of the treatment.
2.1. Literature Review. Here we present a case report
(i) arm fatigue during fencingāLI4, 10, 11; TH 5; where the stimulation of acupuncture points in a talented
(ii) stiļ¬ness of the shoulder muscles during swimmingā young athlete was strongly associated with rapid signiļ¬-
LI4, 11, 14; TH5; GB21; cant improvement of his performance. This improvement
(iii) general excitement and tremor of dominant arm remained stable under the program during his entire sports
during shootingāH7 and LI4. career. The choice of the acupuncture points for stimulation
was directed to relieve the symptoms, which prevented
In addition, before running and swimming, and during him from achieving the desired results and was based
the fencing contest GV26 was stimulated, as the point for on the expertsā recommendations taken from a standard
general toniļ¬cation (Figure 1(d)). Acupuncture points were acupuncture textbook [4] and enhanced by the diagnostics
eventually stimulated by pressure and by electromagnetic using distant computed scan thermography [2].
millimeter waves [5]. The time of stimulation ranged from 5 We cannot rule out that the improvement of the overall
to 30 min, depending on the goal of treatment. After several performance described in this case report may have been due
applications by an experienced acupuncturist, the athlete to the pure eļ¬ect of training. However, the possible eļ¬ects
himself and his coach were taught to perform the treatment. of acupuncture therapy deserve to be further explored, since
Immediately after the beginning of the acupuncture several experienced athletes and coaches whom we contacted
support program, the athlete improved his performance hesitate to explain the rapid and afterwards continuous
3. Evidence-Based Complementary and Alternative Medicine 3
improvement of his time in 3000 m cross-country running conļ¬rms the hypothesis of improved sports performance
from 10 minutes to <9 minutes 25 seconds as being due to due to increased oxygen intake in competitive athletes. The
training eļ¬ect alone. This improvement was achieved mainly authors found out that stimulation of auricular acupuncture
due to complete relief from epigastric pain, which had been points in male boxing athletes led to the enhanced recovery
the main burden to the athlete during previous competitions. after exercise oxygen consumption using track treadmill in
The relief other symptoms, which were considered to be the comparison with control condition [18]. Another investi-
limiting factors (arm fatigue during fencing, stiļ¬ness of the gation, performed by So et al. in a crossover manner in
shoulder muscles during swimming and general excitement healthy volunteers, demonstrated the site-speciļ¬c eļ¬ect of
and tremor of dominant arm during shooting) enabled the TEAS, where stimulation of speciļ¬c acupuncture points
stable performance in these kinds of sports. of the calf enhanced the rate of muscle force recovery in
It is known that a single stimulation of acupuncture comparison with stimulation of non-acupuncture sites [19].
points in trained athletes may substantially improve their These investigations encouraged us to report the case of goal-
results in light athletics, swimming and cycling. Kaada directed acupuncture in the modern pentathlon, in order
reported a mean improvement of 2.3 seconds in 800 m track to propose to verify the suggested eļ¬ects of acupuncture in
racing (n = 5) and 4.3 seconds in 1000 m road racing (n appropriate randomized controlled trials.
= 9) after electric stimulation of LI4 acupuncture point It is interesting, that sports physicians in China treat at
compared to placebo stimulation in a crossover investigation least 70% of top athletes using traditional Chinese medicine
in competitive track-and-ļ¬eld athletes [6]. including acupuncture, where both athletes and medical
Regarding the fact that the site-speciļ¬c acupuncture is doctors believe in the energetic nature of acupuncture
eļ¬ective only for a few conditions in clinical medicine [7, 8] meridians [20]. Regarding the increasing popularity of com-
it is plausible to explain the observed eļ¬ects by non-speciļ¬c plementary and alternative medicine (CAM) among Western
physiological and psychological eļ¬ects of acupuncture. Espe- athletesā56% of athletes consume CAM in comparison with
cially the placebo eļ¬ect might play a great role, since placebo, 36% of normal population [21], the question concerning
in addition to physiological eļ¬ects, may constitute 30ā50% the putative doping aspect of acupuncture and other CAM
of the entire clinical eļ¬ect of acupuncture [8ā10]. methods might be raised due to the existing criteria of doping
On the other hand, competitive athletes are extraordi- deļ¬nition. So far, acupuncture or other CAM methods are
nary sensitive to placebo eļ¬ects. Thus a survey among 48 not on the list of substances and methods prohibited by
top professional athletes showed that the majority of them World Anti-Doping Agency (WADA) at all times in and out
(97%) believe that the placebo eļ¬ect inļ¬uences the success of of competition [22]. According to existing WADA criteria,
sports performance. Seventy-three percent had experienced a formally acupuncture has a potential to be included in this
placebo eļ¬ect during their career and 10 athletes (33%) in the list. Indeed, according to the World Anti-Doping Code 2009,
study oļ¬ered explanations of the nature of the placebo eļ¬ect a substance or method shall be considered for inclusion on
[11]. The expectancy-based placebo eļ¬ect has been shown the prohibited list if WADA determines that the substance
to produce the same performance improvement in trained or method meets any two of the following three criteria:
athletes, as could be achieved using various pharmacological (i) medical or other scientiļ¬c evidence, pharmacological
agentsācaļ¬eine and sodium bicarbonate in cyclists [12, 13] eļ¬ect or experience that the substance or method, alone
and anabolic steroids in weight lifting [14, 15], thus even or in combination with other substances or methods, has
challenging the speciļ¬c eļ¬ect of these drugs. the potential to enhance or enhances sport performance;
The enhanced motivation might be the other potential (ii) medical or other scientiļ¬c evidence, pharmacological
psychological mechanism, resembling the reward framework eļ¬ect or experience that the use of the substance or method
of placebo pre-conditioning and even acting through the represents an actual or potential health risk to the athlete;
dopaminergic system of basal ganglia, considered now as one (iii) WADAās determination that the use of the substance
of the main mechanisms of placebo [16, 17]. or method violates the spirit of sport described in the
However, there are several reports on speciļ¬c eļ¬ects Introduction to the Code [23].
of transcutaneous electric acupuncture point stimulation We presume that criterion 2 would be irrelevant for
(TEAS). In a series of experimental crossover investigations acupuncture since rare serious complications, prospectively
in competitive athletes, Kaada has shown that the runners monitored in thousands of patients, were mainly due to
(800 and 1000 m races) and swimmers (100, 200 and 400 m needling procedure itself [24], which can be prevented
swimming) improved their personal results after TEAS using other non-invasive stimulation modalities. Neverthe-
in comparison with sham procedure where sub threshold less, according to existing WADA deļ¬nition of doping,
electric stimuli were applied to acupuncture point LI4 [6]. the combination of criteria 1 and 3 might be relevant
The cause of the increased physical endurance in athletes in for acupuncture and other CAM methods. However, if
this investigation was suggested to be the result of reduced acupuncture has the potential to enhance or enhances sport
muscular tension, increased capacity of oxygen transport performance (criterion 1 is fulļ¬lled), we do not believe that
to the working muscles, increased capacity of the muscles the stimulation of acupuncture points violates the spirit of
to utilize oxygen and increased muscular microcirculation Olympic movement (criterion 2).
since the potential psychological factors (like placebo and Another target for doping suspect might be the potential
motivation) were excluded by suļ¬cient blinding of the analgesic mechanism of acupuncture, which is known to
study participants. The recent investigation of Lin et al. be associated with the activation of endogenous opioid
4. 4 Evidence-Based Complementary and Alternative Medicine
system [25]. Interestingly, placebo-induced analgesia is Diploma Thesis, Department of Optics, Physical Faculty, Taras
also mediated through the enhanced neurotransmission of Shevchenko University, Kyiv, Ukraine, 1994.
endogenous opioids [26]. Recently it was shown that placebo [4] X. Cheng, Chinese Acupuncture and Moxibustion, Foreign
produces measurable opioid-mediated increase of physi- Languages Press, Beijing, China, 1988.
cal performance. Benedetti et al. [27] demonstrated that [5] T. I. Usichenko, H. Edinger, V. V. Gizhko, C. Lehmann,
application of placebo injection on the day of competition M. Wendt, and F. Feyerherd, āLow-intensity electromagnetic
millimeter waves for pain therapy,ā Evidence-Based Comple-
induced an opioid-mediated increase of pain endurance and
mentary and Alternative Medicine, vol. 3, no. 2, pp. 201ā207,
thus enhanced physical performance in healthy volunteers, 2006.
who were conditioned with only two injections of morphine [6] B. Kaada, āImprovement of physical performance by tran-
(one injection per week) before. This eļ¬ect could be scutaneous nerve stimulation in athletes,ā Acupuncture and
blocked by the administration of opioid-receptor antagonist Electro-Therapeutics Research, vol. 9, no. 3, pp. 165ā180, 1984.
naloxone. Alone these morphine-like eļ¬ects of placebo raised [7] A. Lee and L. T. Y. Fan, āStimulation of the wrist acupuncture
the question whether the application of placebo is ethically point P6 for preventing postoperative nausea and vomiting,ā
acceptable in sports competitions, formally throwing the Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, no. 2, Article ID
shadow of suspicion on all forms of mental training, psy- CD003281, 2009.
chological interventions and mindābody CAM techniques, [8] H. G. Endres, āAcupuncture: speciļ¬c and non-speciļ¬c eļ¬ects,ā
which can enhance sport performance. However, we believe Forschende Komplementarmedizin, vol. 15, no. 1, pp. 6ā8, 2008.
[9] G. T. Lewith and D. Machin, āOn the evaluation of the clinical
that precisely deļ¬ned WADA criteria concerning CAM ther-
eļ¬ects of acupuncture,ā Pain, vol. 16, no. 2, pp. 111ā127, 1983.
apies, which can be used to enhance sports performance, will [10] T. Lundeberg, I. Lund, A. Sing, and J. NĀØ slund, āIs placebo
a
relieve these techniques from suspicion of doping potential acupuncture what it is intended to be?ā Evidence-Based
in the future. Complementary and Alternative Medicine. In press.
Acupuncture and other CAM techniques, eventually [11] T. H. Trojian and C. J. Beedie, āPlacebo eļ¬ect and athletes,ā
used to enhance the sports performance, should be clearly Current Sports Medicine Reports, vol. 7, no. 4, pp. 214ā217,
distinguished from the methods with doping potential. For 2008.
this purpose the existing WADA criteria concerning CAM [12] C. J. Beedie, E. M. Stuart, D. A. Coleman, and A. J. Foad,
methods should be clearly deļ¬ned based on the experts āPlacebo eļ¬ects of caļ¬eine on cycling performance,ā Medicine
opinion, involving clinicians, physiologists and specialists on and Science in Sports and Exercise, vol. 38, no. 12, pp. 2159ā
ethics. 2164, 2006.
Regarding this case report as the ļ¬rst step in the [13] M. McClung and D. Collins, āāBecause i know it will!ā:
placebo eļ¬ects of an ergogenic aid on athletic performance,ā
āladderā of an evidence-based approach in clinical medicine
Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology, vol. 29, no. 3, pp. 382ā
[28], we suggested the idea of goal-directed stimulation of 394, 2007.
acupuncture points in athletes. As a logical next step the [14] G. Ariel and W. Saville, āAnabolic steroids: the physiological
expected āperformance-improvingā eļ¬ects of acupuncture eļ¬ects of placebos,ā Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise,
and suggested speciļ¬city of acupuncture for this applica- vol. 4, pp. 124ā126, 1972.
tion should be veriļ¬ed using appropriate methodology of [15] C. N. Maganaris, D. Collins, and M. Sharp, āExpectancy eļ¬ects
randomized controlled trials including the updated expertās and strength training: do steroids make a diļ¬erence?ā Sport
guidelines on developing research of complex interventions Psychologist, vol. 14, no. 3, pp. 272ā278, 2000.
[29]. [16] Y. Niv, āCost, beneļ¬t, tonic, phasic: what do response rates tell
us about dopamine and motivation?ā Annals of the New York
Academy of Sciences, vol. 1104, pp. 357ā376, 2007.
Funding [17] F. Benedetti, āMechanisms of placebo and placebo-related
eļ¬ects across diseases and treatments,ā Annual Review of
Institutional sources of the Department of Anesthesiology Pharmacology and Toxicology, vol. 48, pp. 33ā60, 2008.
and Intensive Care Medicine, Ernst Moritz Arndt University [18] Z.-P. Lin, C.-Y. Wang, T.-R. Jang et al., āEļ¬ect of auricular
of Greifswald. acupuncture on oxygen consumption of boxing athletes,ā
Chinese Medical Journal, vol. 122, no. 13, pp. 1587ā1590, 2009.
[19] R. C. H. So, J. K.-F. Ng, and G. Y. F. Ng, āEļ¬ect of transcu-
Acknowledgment taneous electrical acupoint stimulation on fatigue recovery of
the quadriceps,ā European Journal of Applied Physiology, vol.
The authors thank Dr Dragan Pavlovic for his valuable
100, no. 6, pp. 693ā700, 2007.
comments to manuscript and ļ¬gures. [20] J. Watts, āFeature: olympian pins and needles,ā tHE Lancet,
vol. 366, supplement 1, pp. S62āS63, 2005.
References [21] A. W. Nichols and R. Harrigan, āComplementary and alterna-
tive medicine usage by intercollegiate athletes,ā Clinical Journal
[1] C. L. Baker Jr., āComments on Olympic Sports medicine. The of Sport Medicine, vol. 16, no. 3, pp. 232ā237, 2006.
Modern Pentathlon,ā American Journal of Sports Medicine, vol. [22] http://www.wada-ama.org/rtecontent/document/2009 Pro-
11, no. 1, pp. 42ā45, 1983. hibited List ENG Final 20 Sept 08.pdf.
[2] W. Weber, Standardisierte Punktthermographie, Haug, Heidel- [23] http://www.wada-ama.org/rtecontent/document/code v2009
berg, Germany, 1984. En.pdf.
[3] Y. V. Krasyuk, Investigation of local thermophysical characteris- [24] D. Melchart, W. Weidenhammer, A. Streng et al., āProspective
tics of the skin in vivo using the method of optic thermography, Investigation of Adverse Eļ¬ects of Acupuncture in 97 733
5. Evidence-Based Complementary and Alternative Medicine 5
Patients,ā Archives of Internal Medicine, vol. 164, no. 1, pp.
104ā105, 2004.
[25] S. X. Ma, āNeurobiology of acupuncture: toward CAM,ā
Evidence-Based Complementary and Alternative Medicine, vol.
1, pp. 41ā47, 2004.
[26] T. D. Wager, D. J. Scott, and J.-K. Zubieta, āPlacebo eļ¬ects
on human Āµ-opioid activity during pain,ā Proceedings of the
National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America,
vol. 104, no. 26, pp. 11056ā11061, 2007.
[27] F. Benedetti, A. Pollo, and L. Colloca, āOpioid-mediated
placebo responses boost pain endurance and physical per-
formance: is it doping in sport competitions?ā Journal of
Neuroscience, vol. 27, no. 44, pp. 11934ā11939, 2007.
[28] D. L. Sackett, āRules of evidence and clinical recommenda-
tions on the use of antithrombotic agents,ā Chest, vol. 95, pp.
2Sā4S, 1989.
[29] P. Craig, P. Dieppe, S. Macintyre, S. Michie, I. Nazareth, and
M. Petticrew, āDeveloping and evaluating complex interven-
tions: the new Medical Research Council guidance,ā British
Medical Journal, vol. 337, article a1655, 2008.