SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 7
Download to read offline
1
APT Lifting Articles Series
The controversial role of the
lifting belt
January 2008
Marilia Coutinho, Ph.D.*
Introduction
Lifters have rituals, or at least most do. And one high point in lifters’ rituals is equipment.
Apart from the rationale behind their role and utility, lifters develop a certain irrational
relation to their equipment. In some cases, you can just ignore feelings and impressions and
measure the equipment’s effect over the lift (which is rarely done by academics). This is the
case for the bench shirt, for example. However much attachment Jane or John have for their
black Inzer Phenom, you can usually just subtract their maximum non-equipped (or raw)
lift from their equipped lift and you are pretty close to the value of the shirt’s carry-over for
that specific shirt, for that specific lifter. As we have seen, measuring a knee-wrap carry-
over introduces other methodological complications, as the unequipped deep squat tends to
display such mechanical differences as to make the 1RM to 1RM comparison more
equivocal.
When we get to the lifting belt, we have additional problems. Unlike other lifting
equipment, we have a much larger scientific production and most of it contradicts
consensual or “quasi-consensual” assumptions among lifters. A close examination of this
literature indicates measurements are done in such a way that the application of the
experiment or observation’s results to real life, competitive lifting is at least arguable or in
most cases unlikely.
In this article, I will give an overview of this literature according to one recent review
(Renfro & Ebben 2006, which basically covers the most important articles in the field),
point out evidence that may be useful for us, lifters, show a little of what has been the
technological development of this equipment and offer some practical tips from the
platform.
What the literature says
A recent review of the literature by Renfro & Ebben (2006) attempted to organize the
apparent contradictory results obtained with experimentation/observation of weight belt
effect on lifting safety and efficiency. First of all, whether they are done under occupational
tasks context or on athletic weight lifting makes all the difference. Apparently, the
equipment’s effect over repetitive relatively light weight tasks is qualitatively different than
that observed with high loads and few to one repetition. On page 69, there is a table
summarizing the results of Occupational Weight Belt Research Studies. The benefits, if
any, are marginal and refer mainly to a reduced range of motion at the lumbar area. On
2
page 70, a similar table summarizes the results obtained from Sports Science Weight Belt
Research Studies. Most studies point to possible benefits from the use of belts. This effect
is usually associated to the higher IAP (intra abdominal pressure), which is thought to
decrease disc compressive forces on the spine and stabilize the spine. Both are critical on
the exertion of maximum effort.
It has also been proposed in more than one study, revised by Renfro & Ebben (2006), that
the use of the weight belt may affect the movement’s velocity. EMG activity shows
controversial results, some pointing out to no effect over spinal erector muscles, but an
increase in activity of prime movers such as vastus lateralis and biceps femoris. A direct
measure of an increase in strength has never been accomplished.
All such studies indicated that there is scientific basis to back the long standing assumption
by athletes that the weight belt is beneficial during the execution of lifts. However, studies
attribute much less importance to this equipment for the lift than the subjective experience
of competitive lifters indicates.
The development of the lifting belt
Weight lifting belts have been industrial items for a long time, as can be observed by the
patenting activity involved. The first patented inventions for supportive belts date from
early in the XXth century, such as the “design for a belt” (fig. 1).
Fig. 1 – “Design for a Belt” (1900)
3
Fig 1. Wasserstrom, W. “Design for a Belt”. USPatent 33,621. Patented November 27,
1900.
Still early in the century, another invention that addresses the need for extra lumbar support
appeared in the late thirties:
Fig. 2 “Design for a body belt”
4
Fig. 2. Medearis, L.C. “Design for a Body Belt”. US Patent no. 109,092. Patented March
29, 1938.
None of these inventions either mentioned occupational or sports weight lifting, although
they are cited by patents of inventions related to both, being thus their precursors (“state of
the art”).
The number weight lifting belts proper increases in the 1980’s, when probably there was a
mature market both on occupational injury prevention and sports performance. A variety of
new designs and materials began to appear, such as belts made of nylon (Newlin 1987).
One illustration of the commercialization concern is Daniels 1986 invention (figure 3),
where the central claim is concerned with optimal utilization of a single leather hide, a
direct industrial perspective.
Figure 3: Weight Lifting Belt emphasizing the optimal use of a single hide
5
Daniels, J. Weight Lifting Belt. US Patent 4,689,833. Sep. 1, 1987.
Still more complex and sophisticated designs evolved, such as Smith and Greenbarg’s
invention (1992), which focuses both lumbar support and IAP increase effects in the lifting
belt by creating a “double belt” (fig. 4)
Figure 4: Lifting “double” belt
6
Smith, N. & Greenbarg, G.M. Lifting Belt. US Patent Number 5,147,261. Sep. 15, 1992.
Today, the number and variety of lifting belts can accommodate about any special comfort,
health or competitive need.
What lifters say
I have inquired 14 experienced Brazilian powerlifters (more than two years of competitive
activity, at least one national title – most are also South American Champions). The reason
I have chosen to restrict my survey to lifters from my country is, ironically, the difficulty
they have in obtaining imported material. Therefore, many local lifters have their belts
manufactured by shoemakers. In spite of the restrictions imposed by federation’s rules, this
behavior allows for much greater variation according to the lifter’s preference as to
toughness, fastening system, etc. The result is an interesting perspective on subjective
perceptions of the belt’s function and comfort for each lift.
One consensus among all lifters is that, for the Bench Press, the belt’s only function is to
hold the bench shirt in place. Some of them have special belts made for this purpose,
thinner than the usual powerlifting belt (two lifters), and some use ordinary trouser’s belts
(two lifters). The rest of them employ their usual powerlifting belt for the equipped bench
press, but not for raw lifting.
When inquired about the subjective perception of the benefits provided by the belt use,
most mention safety (against injury), stability and, only if specifically asked so, carry-over.
As to toughness, some people have a hard time finding the ideal resistance for their
equipment. An excessively tough belt is seen as uncomfortable to some, while belts that are
too soft provide insufficient support. Diego Fernando, South American powerlifting
champion, pointed out that his solution was to treasure very old tough belts (belts that were
once too tough, but with the years acquired the right resistance). Gilberto Silva, today’s
7
record bearer in South America for the Bench Press, points out that he sees no use for the
belt besides holding the bench shirt. He considers belts essential for the Squat, though.
Heavier lifters seem to prefer thicker, wider and tougher belts for the Squat. Interestingly,
many lifters, even the heavy ones, decline using a belt for the deadlift, claiming the
discomfort is too great to provide any benefit. Gilson Clemente (national champion and
team coach) pointed out he uses a different belt for the deadlift – softer and looser – than
the one he uses for the Squat.
Concluding Remarks
There still seems to be insufficient research concerning the actual performance effects of
the lifting belt for the different lifts. In international forums, I have read claims by benchers
who can swear belts do provide them with extra stability for the arch. They are a minor
population, which doesn’t mean they may not represent an actual phenomenon not
sufficiently understood, involving lumbar support specific for the mechanics of their
movement.
In any stance, manufacturers should be aware that the actual demands from lifters require a
variety of designs and textures. Tougher, softer, wider and thinner belts all have their place
in powerlifting. As lifters come in all sizes and weights, likes and dislikes, types of
movement and rituals, so must equipment adjust to them.
Acknowledgements
The author is indebted to: Diego Fernando, Gilberto Silva, Marcelo Picolli, Denílson Costa,
Marcello Melquior, Leandro Maccari, Renato Rocha, Gilson Clemente, Eric Oishi, Luciano
Duarte, Fernando Canteli, Gabriel Torezan, Daniel Nacle and Ana Rosa Castellain for their
invaluable input and comments about their experience with the use of lifting belts.
References
Renfro, G.J. & Ebben, W.P. 2006. A Review of the Use of Lifting Belts. National Strength
and Conditioning Association. Volume 28, Number 1, pages 68–74
Wasserstrom, W. “Design for a Belt”. USPatent 33,621. Patented November 27, 1900.
Medearis, L.C. “Design for a Body Belt”. US Patent no. 109,092. Patented March 29, 1938.
Smith, N. & Greenbarg, G.M. Lifting Belt. US Patent Number 5,147,261. Sep. 15, 1992.
Daniels, J. Weight Lifting Belt. US Patent 4,689,833. Sep. 1, 1987.
Newlin, T.L. Weightlifting Belt. US Patent 4,685,668. Aug 11, 1987.
* Marilia Coutinho is a 121lbs APTProWristStraps sponsored powerlifter.

More Related Content

What's hot

Postrel_Inservice_Minimalist Running
Postrel_Inservice_Minimalist RunningPostrel_Inservice_Minimalist Running
Postrel_Inservice_Minimalist Running
Tina Postrel
 
Power Strength 2015 Products Brochure
Power Strength 2015 Products BrochurePower Strength 2015 Products Brochure
Power Strength 2015 Products Brochure
David Shaw
 
Downhill Running as an Eccentric Exercise and its effect of Muscle Strength a...
Downhill Running as an Eccentric Exercise and its effect of Muscle Strength a...Downhill Running as an Eccentric Exercise and its effect of Muscle Strength a...
Downhill Running as an Eccentric Exercise and its effect of Muscle Strength a...
3050999
 
Musculoskeletal system update
Musculoskeletal system updateMusculoskeletal system update
Musculoskeletal system update
KiranK77
 
Treadmill usage.doc
Treadmill usage.docTreadmill usage.doc
Treadmill usage.doc
Shama
 

What's hot (20)

Postrel_Inservice_Minimalist Running
Postrel_Inservice_Minimalist RunningPostrel_Inservice_Minimalist Running
Postrel_Inservice_Minimalist Running
 
How to assess and improve ankle dorsiflexion once and for all….
How to assess and improve ankle dorsiflexion once and for all….How to assess and improve ankle dorsiflexion once and for all….
How to assess and improve ankle dorsiflexion once and for all….
 
Power Strength 2015 Products Brochure
Power Strength 2015 Products BrochurePower Strength 2015 Products Brochure
Power Strength 2015 Products Brochure
 
Modern trends in swimming
Modern trends in swimming Modern trends in swimming
Modern trends in swimming
 
Footwear Prescription Workshop (Fitness.Inc)
Footwear Prescription Workshop (Fitness.Inc)Footwear Prescription Workshop (Fitness.Inc)
Footwear Prescription Workshop (Fitness.Inc)
 
Downhill Running as an Eccentric Exercise and its effect of Muscle Strength a...
Downhill Running as an Eccentric Exercise and its effect of Muscle Strength a...Downhill Running as an Eccentric Exercise and its effect of Muscle Strength a...
Downhill Running as an Eccentric Exercise and its effect of Muscle Strength a...
 
Geoff Verrall Hamstring Injury Symposium presentation part 1
Geoff Verrall Hamstring Injury Symposium presentation part 1Geoff Verrall Hamstring Injury Symposium presentation part 1
Geoff Verrall Hamstring Injury Symposium presentation part 1
 
Research Paper
Research PaperResearch Paper
Research Paper
 
Healthy Shoe Design - How shoes affect joints
Healthy Shoe Design - How shoes affect jointsHealthy Shoe Design - How shoes affect joints
Healthy Shoe Design - How shoes affect joints
 
Shoe Types and Anatomy
Shoe Types and AnatomyShoe Types and Anatomy
Shoe Types and Anatomy
 
Walking canes pros and cons
Walking canes  pros and consWalking canes  pros and cons
Walking canes pros and cons
 
What's With All The Racket? An Introduction to Olympic Weightlifting
What's With All The Racket? An Introduction to Olympic WeightliftingWhat's With All The Racket? An Introduction to Olympic Weightlifting
What's With All The Racket? An Introduction to Olympic Weightlifting
 
Musculoskeletal system update
Musculoskeletal system updateMusculoskeletal system update
Musculoskeletal system update
 
Wse Gym Differentiators of 2014
Wse Gym Differentiators of 2014Wse Gym Differentiators of 2014
Wse Gym Differentiators of 2014
 
Hamstring Strain Injuries - Aspetar Experience Nicol van Dyk & Philipp Jacobsen
Hamstring Strain Injuries - Aspetar Experience Nicol van Dyk & Philipp JacobsenHamstring Strain Injuries - Aspetar Experience Nicol van Dyk & Philipp Jacobsen
Hamstring Strain Injuries - Aspetar Experience Nicol van Dyk & Philipp Jacobsen
 
Band stretching for baseball players
Band stretching for baseball playersBand stretching for baseball players
Band stretching for baseball players
 
Treadmill usage.doc
Treadmill usage.docTreadmill usage.doc
Treadmill usage.doc
 
The Art of Running: Part 1 - Technique
The Art of Running: Part 1 - TechniqueThe Art of Running: Part 1 - Technique
The Art of Running: Part 1 - Technique
 
Sproing Trainer Course
Sproing Trainer CourseSproing Trainer Course
Sproing Trainer Course
 
Fancy feet follies: High heels can hurt more than your feet
Fancy feet follies: High heels can hurt more than your feetFancy feet follies: High heels can hurt more than your feet
Fancy feet follies: High heels can hurt more than your feet
 

Similar to The controversial role of the lifting belt

Minimalist LS_Edited Version
Minimalist LS_Edited VersionMinimalist LS_Edited Version
Minimalist LS_Edited Version
Dange Wolf
 
Achilles Tendon Presentation2013
Achilles Tendon Presentation2013Achilles Tendon Presentation2013
Achilles Tendon Presentation2013
Kathryn Newark
 
Lackey_Prosthetic_Arm_Report_Nationals
Lackey_Prosthetic_Arm_Report_NationalsLackey_Prosthetic_Arm_Report_Nationals
Lackey_Prosthetic_Arm_Report_Nationals
George Jenkins
 
Biomechanical Approach to Footwear KZ
Biomechanical Approach to Footwear KZBiomechanical Approach to Footwear KZ
Biomechanical Approach to Footwear KZ
Kelsey Daniels
 
Stability vs Cushioning
Stability vs CushioningStability vs Cushioning
Stability vs Cushioning
James West
 
Extremity_Wear_Testing_-_Total_Ankle_and_Shoulder_Replacement_Testing_
Extremity_Wear_Testing_-_Total_Ankle_and_Shoulder_Replacement_Testing_Extremity_Wear_Testing_-_Total_Ankle_and_Shoulder_Replacement_Testing_
Extremity_Wear_Testing_-_Total_Ankle_and_Shoulder_Replacement_Testing_
Evan Guilfoyle
 
Duncan senior project paper
Duncan senior project paperDuncan senior project paper
Duncan senior project paper
DuncanIngram
 
Choice Lab Presentation (final)
Choice Lab Presentation (final)Choice Lab Presentation (final)
Choice Lab Presentation (final)
Thomas Cornette
 

Similar to The controversial role of the lifting belt (20)

Minimalist LS_Edited Version
Minimalist LS_Edited VersionMinimalist LS_Edited Version
Minimalist LS_Edited Version
 
WRIST WRAPS: EVERYTHING YOU NEED TO KNOW
WRIST WRAPS: EVERYTHING YOU NEED TO KNOWWRIST WRAPS: EVERYTHING YOU NEED TO KNOW
WRIST WRAPS: EVERYTHING YOU NEED TO KNOW
 
Achilles Tendon Presentation2013
Achilles Tendon Presentation2013Achilles Tendon Presentation2013
Achilles Tendon Presentation2013
 
Evolution of hip disarticulation prosthesis
Evolution of hip disarticulation prosthesisEvolution of hip disarticulation prosthesis
Evolution of hip disarticulation prosthesis
 
Lackey_Prosthetic_Arm_Report_Nationals
Lackey_Prosthetic_Arm_Report_NationalsLackey_Prosthetic_Arm_Report_Nationals
Lackey_Prosthetic_Arm_Report_Nationals
 
Biomechanical Approach to Footwear KZ
Biomechanical Approach to Footwear KZBiomechanical Approach to Footwear KZ
Biomechanical Approach to Footwear KZ
 
Stability vs Cushioning
Stability vs CushioningStability vs Cushioning
Stability vs Cushioning
 
Iris Publishers - Journal of Textile Science | A Systematic Selection Method ...
Iris Publishers - Journal of Textile Science | A Systematic Selection Method ...Iris Publishers - Journal of Textile Science | A Systematic Selection Method ...
Iris Publishers - Journal of Textile Science | A Systematic Selection Method ...
 
Knee Replacement Revision
Knee Replacement RevisionKnee Replacement Revision
Knee Replacement Revision
 
Prosthetic Limbs.pdf
Prosthetic Limbs.pdfProsthetic Limbs.pdf
Prosthetic Limbs.pdf
 
Extremity_Wear_Testing_-_Total_Ankle_and_Shoulder_Replacement_Testing_
Extremity_Wear_Testing_-_Total_Ankle_and_Shoulder_Replacement_Testing_Extremity_Wear_Testing_-_Total_Ankle_and_Shoulder_Replacement_Testing_
Extremity_Wear_Testing_-_Total_Ankle_and_Shoulder_Replacement_Testing_
 
Duncan senior project paper
Duncan senior project paperDuncan senior project paper
Duncan senior project paper
 
CD005260
CD005260CD005260
CD005260
 
Spine Orthotics-1.pdf
Spine Orthotics-1.pdfSpine Orthotics-1.pdf
Spine Orthotics-1.pdf
 
EVERYTHING YOU 'K'NEED TO KNOW ABOUT KNEE WRAPS AND KNEE SLEEVES
EVERYTHING YOU 'K'NEED TO KNOW ABOUT KNEE WRAPS AND KNEE SLEEVESEVERYTHING YOU 'K'NEED TO KNOW ABOUT KNEE WRAPS AND KNEE SLEEVES
EVERYTHING YOU 'K'NEED TO KNOW ABOUT KNEE WRAPS AND KNEE SLEEVES
 
Modified Posterior Approach to the Hip Joint, International Journal of Orthop...
Modified Posterior Approach to the Hip Joint, International Journal of Orthop...Modified Posterior Approach to the Hip Joint, International Journal of Orthop...
Modified Posterior Approach to the Hip Joint, International Journal of Orthop...
 
HIP DISARTICULATION
HIP DISARTICULATIONHIP DISARTICULATION
HIP DISARTICULATION
 
Finite Element Analysis of Human RIB Cage
Finite Element Analysis of Human RIB CageFinite Element Analysis of Human RIB Cage
Finite Element Analysis of Human RIB Cage
 
Choice Lab Presentation (final)
Choice Lab Presentation (final)Choice Lab Presentation (final)
Choice Lab Presentation (final)
 
SideStix / UBC / Mitacs Research Project
SideStix / UBC / Mitacs Research ProjectSideStix / UBC / Mitacs Research Project
SideStix / UBC / Mitacs Research Project
 

More from Marilia Coutinho

More from Marilia Coutinho (20)

Comunicacion y bien estar
Comunicacion y bien estarComunicacion y bien estar
Comunicacion y bien estar
 
Gratitud
GratitudGratitud
Gratitud
 
Sufrimiento mental
Sufrimiento mentalSufrimiento mental
Sufrimiento mental
 
Los ciclos viciosos y virtuosos
Los ciclos viciosos y virtuososLos ciclos viciosos y virtuosos
Los ciclos viciosos y virtuosos
 
Veterans Space
Veterans SpaceVeterans Space
Veterans Space
 
Stress and Physical Activity
Stress and Physical ActivityStress and Physical Activity
Stress and Physical Activity
 
RUM Sponsorship Project
RUM Sponsorship ProjectRUM Sponsorship Project
RUM Sponsorship Project
 
RUM 9 roster - November 10, 2015
RUM 9 roster - November 10, 2015RUM 9 roster - November 10, 2015
RUM 9 roster - November 10, 2015
 
Coaching your kCoaching your kid: how to manage being a parent and a coach id
Coaching your kCoaching your kid: how to manage being a parent and a coach idCoaching your kCoaching your kid: how to manage being a parent and a coach id
Coaching your kCoaching your kid: how to manage being a parent and a coach id
 
Coaching your spouse: is it possible?
Coaching your spouse: is it possible?Coaching your spouse: is it possible?
Coaching your spouse: is it possible?
 
Coaching mom and dad
Coaching mom and dadCoaching mom and dad
Coaching mom and dad
 
A brainstorm with strong women - docx version
A brainstorm with strong women - docx versionA brainstorm with strong women - docx version
A brainstorm with strong women - docx version
 
Marilia Coutinho - academic CV
Marilia Coutinho - academic CVMarilia Coutinho - academic CV
Marilia Coutinho - academic CV
 
Lecture and course subjects - Dr. Marilia Coutinho
Lecture and course subjects - Dr. Marilia CoutinhoLecture and course subjects - Dr. Marilia Coutinho
Lecture and course subjects - Dr. Marilia Coutinho
 
Marilia Coutinho's sports cv
Marilia Coutinho's sports cvMarilia Coutinho's sports cv
Marilia Coutinho's sports cv
 
Palestras corporativas - temas e conteúdo
Palestras corporativas - temas e conteúdoPalestras corporativas - temas e conteúdo
Palestras corporativas - temas e conteúdo
 
Portfolio de atleta: Marilia Coutinho
Portfolio de atleta: Marilia CoutinhoPortfolio de atleta: Marilia Coutinho
Portfolio de atleta: Marilia Coutinho
 
Programa Social "Comunidade Power"
Programa Social "Comunidade Power"Programa Social "Comunidade Power"
Programa Social "Comunidade Power"
 
Formolatria
FormolatriaFormolatria
Formolatria
 
IPL sanction certificate for the Brazilian National Championship
IPL sanction certificate for the Brazilian National ChampionshipIPL sanction certificate for the Brazilian National Championship
IPL sanction certificate for the Brazilian National Championship
 

Recently uploaded

+971565801893>>SAFE AND ORIGINAL ABORTION PILLS FOR SALE IN DUBAI AND ABUDHAB...
+971565801893>>SAFE AND ORIGINAL ABORTION PILLS FOR SALE IN DUBAI AND ABUDHAB...+971565801893>>SAFE AND ORIGINAL ABORTION PILLS FOR SALE IN DUBAI AND ABUDHAB...
+971565801893>>SAFE AND ORIGINAL ABORTION PILLS FOR SALE IN DUBAI AND ABUDHAB...
Health
 
Asli Kala jadu, Black magic specialist in Pakistan Or Kala jadu expert in Egy...
Asli Kala jadu, Black magic specialist in Pakistan Or Kala jadu expert in Egy...Asli Kala jadu, Black magic specialist in Pakistan Or Kala jadu expert in Egy...
Asli Kala jadu, Black magic specialist in Pakistan Or Kala jadu expert in Egy...
baharayali
 
🔝|97111༒99012🔝 Call Girls In {Delhi} Cr Park ₹5.5k Cash Payment With Room De...
🔝|97111༒99012🔝 Call Girls In  {Delhi} Cr Park ₹5.5k Cash Payment With Room De...🔝|97111༒99012🔝 Call Girls In  {Delhi} Cr Park ₹5.5k Cash Payment With Room De...
🔝|97111༒99012🔝 Call Girls In {Delhi} Cr Park ₹5.5k Cash Payment With Room De...
Diya Sharma
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Ramban Escorts ☎️8617697112 Starting From 5K to 15K High Profile Escorts In...
Ramban  Escorts ☎️8617697112  Starting From 5K to 15K High Profile Escorts In...Ramban  Escorts ☎️8617697112  Starting From 5K to 15K High Profile Escorts In...
Ramban Escorts ☎️8617697112 Starting From 5K to 15K High Profile Escorts In...
 
+971565801893>>SAFE AND ORIGINAL ABORTION PILLS FOR SALE IN DUBAI AND ABUDHAB...
+971565801893>>SAFE AND ORIGINAL ABORTION PILLS FOR SALE IN DUBAI AND ABUDHAB...+971565801893>>SAFE AND ORIGINAL ABORTION PILLS FOR SALE IN DUBAI AND ABUDHAB...
+971565801893>>SAFE AND ORIGINAL ABORTION PILLS FOR SALE IN DUBAI AND ABUDHAB...
 
Spain Vs Albania- Spain at risk of being thrown out of Euro 2024 with Tournam...
Spain Vs Albania- Spain at risk of being thrown out of Euro 2024 with Tournam...Spain Vs Albania- Spain at risk of being thrown out of Euro 2024 with Tournam...
Spain Vs Albania- Spain at risk of being thrown out of Euro 2024 with Tournam...
 
Spain Vs Italy 20 players confirmed for Spain's Euro 2024 squad, and three po...
Spain Vs Italy 20 players confirmed for Spain's Euro 2024 squad, and three po...Spain Vs Italy 20 players confirmed for Spain's Euro 2024 squad, and three po...
Spain Vs Italy 20 players confirmed for Spain's Euro 2024 squad, and three po...
 
08448380779 Call Girls In Karol Bagh Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In Karol Bagh Women Seeking Men08448380779 Call Girls In Karol Bagh Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In Karol Bagh Women Seeking Men
 
ALL NFL NETWORK CONTACTS- April 29, 2024
ALL NFL NETWORK CONTACTS- April 29, 2024ALL NFL NETWORK CONTACTS- April 29, 2024
ALL NFL NETWORK CONTACTS- April 29, 2024
 
Sports Writing (Rules,Tips, Examples, etc)
Sports Writing (Rules,Tips, Examples, etc)Sports Writing (Rules,Tips, Examples, etc)
Sports Writing (Rules,Tips, Examples, etc)
 
08448380779 Call Girls In IIT Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In IIT Women Seeking Men08448380779 Call Girls In IIT Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In IIT Women Seeking Men
 
UEFA Euro 2024 Squad Check-in Who is Most Favorite.docx
UEFA Euro 2024 Squad Check-in Who is Most Favorite.docxUEFA Euro 2024 Squad Check-in Who is Most Favorite.docx
UEFA Euro 2024 Squad Check-in Who is Most Favorite.docx
 
Asli Kala jadu, Black magic specialist in Pakistan Or Kala jadu expert in Egy...
Asli Kala jadu, Black magic specialist in Pakistan Or Kala jadu expert in Egy...Asli Kala jadu, Black magic specialist in Pakistan Or Kala jadu expert in Egy...
Asli Kala jadu, Black magic specialist in Pakistan Or Kala jadu expert in Egy...
 
🔝|97111༒99012🔝 Call Girls In {Delhi} Cr Park ₹5.5k Cash Payment With Room De...
🔝|97111༒99012🔝 Call Girls In  {Delhi} Cr Park ₹5.5k Cash Payment With Room De...🔝|97111༒99012🔝 Call Girls In  {Delhi} Cr Park ₹5.5k Cash Payment With Room De...
🔝|97111༒99012🔝 Call Girls In {Delhi} Cr Park ₹5.5k Cash Payment With Room De...
 
Croatia vs Italy Euro Cup 2024 Three pitfalls for Spalletti’s Italy in Group ...
Croatia vs Italy Euro Cup 2024 Three pitfalls for Spalletti’s Italy in Group ...Croatia vs Italy Euro Cup 2024 Three pitfalls for Spalletti’s Italy in Group ...
Croatia vs Italy Euro Cup 2024 Three pitfalls for Spalletti’s Italy in Group ...
 
JORNADA 5 LIGA MURO 2024INSUGURACION.pdf
JORNADA 5 LIGA MURO 2024INSUGURACION.pdfJORNADA 5 LIGA MURO 2024INSUGURACION.pdf
JORNADA 5 LIGA MURO 2024INSUGURACION.pdf
 
08448380779 Call Girls In International Airport Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In International Airport Women Seeking Men08448380779 Call Girls In International Airport Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In International Airport Women Seeking Men
 
Unveiling the Mystery of Main Bazar Chart
Unveiling the Mystery of Main Bazar ChartUnveiling the Mystery of Main Bazar Chart
Unveiling the Mystery of Main Bazar Chart
 
Personal Brand Exploration - By Bradley Dennis
Personal Brand Exploration - By Bradley DennisPersonal Brand Exploration - By Bradley Dennis
Personal Brand Exploration - By Bradley Dennis
 
Trossard's Message Bridging Celebrities and Sports in Euro Cup 2024.docx
Trossard's Message Bridging Celebrities and Sports in Euro Cup 2024.docxTrossard's Message Bridging Celebrities and Sports in Euro Cup 2024.docx
Trossard's Message Bridging Celebrities and Sports in Euro Cup 2024.docx
 
WhatsApp Chat: 📞 8617697112 Birbhum Call Girl available for hotel room package
WhatsApp Chat: 📞 8617697112 Birbhum  Call Girl available for hotel room packageWhatsApp Chat: 📞 8617697112 Birbhum  Call Girl available for hotel room package
WhatsApp Chat: 📞 8617697112 Birbhum Call Girl available for hotel room package
 
TAM Sports_IPL 17 Till Match 37_Celebrity Endorsement _Report.pdf
TAM Sports_IPL 17 Till Match 37_Celebrity Endorsement _Report.pdfTAM Sports_IPL 17 Till Match 37_Celebrity Endorsement _Report.pdf
TAM Sports_IPL 17 Till Match 37_Celebrity Endorsement _Report.pdf
 
Who Is Emmanuel Katto Uganda? His Career, personal life etc.
Who Is Emmanuel Katto Uganda? His Career, personal life etc.Who Is Emmanuel Katto Uganda? His Career, personal life etc.
Who Is Emmanuel Katto Uganda? His Career, personal life etc.
 

The controversial role of the lifting belt

  • 1. 1 APT Lifting Articles Series The controversial role of the lifting belt January 2008 Marilia Coutinho, Ph.D.* Introduction Lifters have rituals, or at least most do. And one high point in lifters’ rituals is equipment. Apart from the rationale behind their role and utility, lifters develop a certain irrational relation to their equipment. In some cases, you can just ignore feelings and impressions and measure the equipment’s effect over the lift (which is rarely done by academics). This is the case for the bench shirt, for example. However much attachment Jane or John have for their black Inzer Phenom, you can usually just subtract their maximum non-equipped (or raw) lift from their equipped lift and you are pretty close to the value of the shirt’s carry-over for that specific shirt, for that specific lifter. As we have seen, measuring a knee-wrap carry- over introduces other methodological complications, as the unequipped deep squat tends to display such mechanical differences as to make the 1RM to 1RM comparison more equivocal. When we get to the lifting belt, we have additional problems. Unlike other lifting equipment, we have a much larger scientific production and most of it contradicts consensual or “quasi-consensual” assumptions among lifters. A close examination of this literature indicates measurements are done in such a way that the application of the experiment or observation’s results to real life, competitive lifting is at least arguable or in most cases unlikely. In this article, I will give an overview of this literature according to one recent review (Renfro & Ebben 2006, which basically covers the most important articles in the field), point out evidence that may be useful for us, lifters, show a little of what has been the technological development of this equipment and offer some practical tips from the platform. What the literature says A recent review of the literature by Renfro & Ebben (2006) attempted to organize the apparent contradictory results obtained with experimentation/observation of weight belt effect on lifting safety and efficiency. First of all, whether they are done under occupational tasks context or on athletic weight lifting makes all the difference. Apparently, the equipment’s effect over repetitive relatively light weight tasks is qualitatively different than that observed with high loads and few to one repetition. On page 69, there is a table summarizing the results of Occupational Weight Belt Research Studies. The benefits, if any, are marginal and refer mainly to a reduced range of motion at the lumbar area. On
  • 2. 2 page 70, a similar table summarizes the results obtained from Sports Science Weight Belt Research Studies. Most studies point to possible benefits from the use of belts. This effect is usually associated to the higher IAP (intra abdominal pressure), which is thought to decrease disc compressive forces on the spine and stabilize the spine. Both are critical on the exertion of maximum effort. It has also been proposed in more than one study, revised by Renfro & Ebben (2006), that the use of the weight belt may affect the movement’s velocity. EMG activity shows controversial results, some pointing out to no effect over spinal erector muscles, but an increase in activity of prime movers such as vastus lateralis and biceps femoris. A direct measure of an increase in strength has never been accomplished. All such studies indicated that there is scientific basis to back the long standing assumption by athletes that the weight belt is beneficial during the execution of lifts. However, studies attribute much less importance to this equipment for the lift than the subjective experience of competitive lifters indicates. The development of the lifting belt Weight lifting belts have been industrial items for a long time, as can be observed by the patenting activity involved. The first patented inventions for supportive belts date from early in the XXth century, such as the “design for a belt” (fig. 1). Fig. 1 – “Design for a Belt” (1900)
  • 3. 3 Fig 1. Wasserstrom, W. “Design for a Belt”. USPatent 33,621. Patented November 27, 1900. Still early in the century, another invention that addresses the need for extra lumbar support appeared in the late thirties: Fig. 2 “Design for a body belt”
  • 4. 4 Fig. 2. Medearis, L.C. “Design for a Body Belt”. US Patent no. 109,092. Patented March 29, 1938. None of these inventions either mentioned occupational or sports weight lifting, although they are cited by patents of inventions related to both, being thus their precursors (“state of the art”). The number weight lifting belts proper increases in the 1980’s, when probably there was a mature market both on occupational injury prevention and sports performance. A variety of new designs and materials began to appear, such as belts made of nylon (Newlin 1987). One illustration of the commercialization concern is Daniels 1986 invention (figure 3), where the central claim is concerned with optimal utilization of a single leather hide, a direct industrial perspective. Figure 3: Weight Lifting Belt emphasizing the optimal use of a single hide
  • 5. 5 Daniels, J. Weight Lifting Belt. US Patent 4,689,833. Sep. 1, 1987. Still more complex and sophisticated designs evolved, such as Smith and Greenbarg’s invention (1992), which focuses both lumbar support and IAP increase effects in the lifting belt by creating a “double belt” (fig. 4) Figure 4: Lifting “double” belt
  • 6. 6 Smith, N. & Greenbarg, G.M. Lifting Belt. US Patent Number 5,147,261. Sep. 15, 1992. Today, the number and variety of lifting belts can accommodate about any special comfort, health or competitive need. What lifters say I have inquired 14 experienced Brazilian powerlifters (more than two years of competitive activity, at least one national title – most are also South American Champions). The reason I have chosen to restrict my survey to lifters from my country is, ironically, the difficulty they have in obtaining imported material. Therefore, many local lifters have their belts manufactured by shoemakers. In spite of the restrictions imposed by federation’s rules, this behavior allows for much greater variation according to the lifter’s preference as to toughness, fastening system, etc. The result is an interesting perspective on subjective perceptions of the belt’s function and comfort for each lift. One consensus among all lifters is that, for the Bench Press, the belt’s only function is to hold the bench shirt in place. Some of them have special belts made for this purpose, thinner than the usual powerlifting belt (two lifters), and some use ordinary trouser’s belts (two lifters). The rest of them employ their usual powerlifting belt for the equipped bench press, but not for raw lifting. When inquired about the subjective perception of the benefits provided by the belt use, most mention safety (against injury), stability and, only if specifically asked so, carry-over. As to toughness, some people have a hard time finding the ideal resistance for their equipment. An excessively tough belt is seen as uncomfortable to some, while belts that are too soft provide insufficient support. Diego Fernando, South American powerlifting champion, pointed out that his solution was to treasure very old tough belts (belts that were once too tough, but with the years acquired the right resistance). Gilberto Silva, today’s
  • 7. 7 record bearer in South America for the Bench Press, points out that he sees no use for the belt besides holding the bench shirt. He considers belts essential for the Squat, though. Heavier lifters seem to prefer thicker, wider and tougher belts for the Squat. Interestingly, many lifters, even the heavy ones, decline using a belt for the deadlift, claiming the discomfort is too great to provide any benefit. Gilson Clemente (national champion and team coach) pointed out he uses a different belt for the deadlift – softer and looser – than the one he uses for the Squat. Concluding Remarks There still seems to be insufficient research concerning the actual performance effects of the lifting belt for the different lifts. In international forums, I have read claims by benchers who can swear belts do provide them with extra stability for the arch. They are a minor population, which doesn’t mean they may not represent an actual phenomenon not sufficiently understood, involving lumbar support specific for the mechanics of their movement. In any stance, manufacturers should be aware that the actual demands from lifters require a variety of designs and textures. Tougher, softer, wider and thinner belts all have their place in powerlifting. As lifters come in all sizes and weights, likes and dislikes, types of movement and rituals, so must equipment adjust to them. Acknowledgements The author is indebted to: Diego Fernando, Gilberto Silva, Marcelo Picolli, Denílson Costa, Marcello Melquior, Leandro Maccari, Renato Rocha, Gilson Clemente, Eric Oishi, Luciano Duarte, Fernando Canteli, Gabriel Torezan, Daniel Nacle and Ana Rosa Castellain for their invaluable input and comments about their experience with the use of lifting belts. References Renfro, G.J. & Ebben, W.P. 2006. A Review of the Use of Lifting Belts. National Strength and Conditioning Association. Volume 28, Number 1, pages 68–74 Wasserstrom, W. “Design for a Belt”. USPatent 33,621. Patented November 27, 1900. Medearis, L.C. “Design for a Body Belt”. US Patent no. 109,092. Patented March 29, 1938. Smith, N. & Greenbarg, G.M. Lifting Belt. US Patent Number 5,147,261. Sep. 15, 1992. Daniels, J. Weight Lifting Belt. US Patent 4,689,833. Sep. 1, 1987. Newlin, T.L. Weightlifting Belt. US Patent 4,685,668. Aug 11, 1987. * Marilia Coutinho is a 121lbs APTProWristStraps sponsored powerlifter.