SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 18
Running Head: MENTAL ILLNESS PORTRAYAL IN THE MEDIA 1
College Students Attitudes Towards Mental Illness Portrayed in the Media
Samantha Kienemund
Marymount Manhattan College
MENTAL ILLNESS PORTRAYAL IN THE MEDIA 2
Abstract
The presentstudyisdesigned toevaluate mental illnessandthe media.The followingquestionsare
addressed:1.) What isthe correlationbetweenexposuretomental illnessinthe mediaandattitudes
towardsmental illnessesincollegestudents? 2.) Whatisthe correlationbetweenempathyandthe
influenceof mediatowardsmental illnesses?3.) Will filmswithpositive portrayalsof mentalillnesses
leadto a higherrecall rate?4.) What isthe correlationbetweenthe presence of mental illnessone'slife
and recall ratesof filmthat portrayal a mental illness?Asseeninthe article Publicattitudestowards
people withchronicmental illness,Yankelovich,1990, the mass mediawhichincludestelevisionand
broadcast newsare primarysourcesof informationaboutmental illnessformany Americans.Mental
illnessisstigmatizedbyoursociety.Thisleadstothe viewersreactingtosuchstigmasportrayedonfilm
and formulatingtheirownviewsonmental illnesses.
Keywords:mental illness,media,film, stigma,influence
MENTAL ILLNESS PORTRAYAL IN THE MEDIA 3
College StudentsAttitudesTowardsMental IllnessPortrayedinthe Media
Mediahas a strong influence onthe general public, andreflectschangesinthe valuesof the
society.Societytodayvaluesmediaas anessential partof realityand a majortool to obtainknowledge.
Mediathrough mediumssuchas the news,music,television showsandfilmsare all sourcesthatpeople
draw onwhenthey subconsciouslyformulateanopinion. The audience canlearnfromthe mediawith
or withoutthe intentionsof gainingknowledge. Maieret.al. (2014), suggestedthat,persistentlong
termexposure tomediacontenthasa small butmeasurable effectonthe perceptionof the audience.
People of all ageshave unlimitedaccesstoall typesof media.
Maier et.al. (2014), described cultivationtheory asproposingthatthe collectivemessages seen
inthe mediaandthe figures seencangreatly influence perceptionsof the worldandoursubsequent
behaviors. People are greatlyinfluencedbythingstheysee throughmedia. Social ActionTheory
developedbyAndersonandMeyer (1988),proposes thatthe audience are active inthe constructionof
meaningfromthe contenttheyperceive.The meaningsare createdinthree ways:the intentionsof the
producer,the portrayal of the content,andthe interpretationsof the audience. Filmsare amediumin
mediathathas a developedplot,characters,andmanyinfluentialaspects. Characterscanbe usedas
toolsforpeople torelate to,and empathize with. Plotscanbe usedtodisplaya message,orconveya
theme.Influential aspectsare the idealsof change,motivation,butcanalsobe stigmas.
People withmentalillnessesexperiencestigmatization.Oursocietyhasmade mental illnessone
of the moststigmatizedconditionsandthis isreflectedinourmedia. Insocietyexposure tomediais
inevitable.People of all ageshave unlimitedaccesstoall typesof media. Yankelovich, (1990) suggested
that the mass media(whichincludestelevision,andbroadcastnews) are the primarysourcesof
informationaboutmental illnessfor manyAmericans.The mediaplays animportantrole inthe creation
of the stigmasassociatedwithmental illnesses.Wahl (1995) suggestedthatthe media’suse of
MENTAL ILLNESS PORTRAYAL IN THE MEDIA 4
misinformation,inaccurate use of psychiatricterms,andnegative stereotypesof peoplewithmental
illnessesall leadtothe growingstigmasof people withmentalillness.Stigmascreate manybarriersfor
people livingwithmentalillnesses.There are manynegativeeffectsof these stigmassuchasinfluence in
all areas of life, suchas placesof living,learning,work,andsocializing.People withmentalillnesses who
are viewedtobe dangerousare alsohighlystigmatized,feared,andalone.
Mental Illnessisoftenportrayedin films.Manyfilmsreflectpopularbelief andstereotypes. This
continuesthe cycle because itleavesanimpressiononthe audience.Slasherfilms,suchas Halloween,
have a theme of an escapedmentallyillpatientwhogoesona killingspree. Filmshave atendencyto
portray criminal masterminds inamore glamourizedfashionthantheytrulyare,suchas the character
Hannibal Lectorin The Silence of the Lambs. Inthe film,SilverLining Playbook, the maincharacterPat
dealswithbipolardisorder.Hisfirstepisode isextremelyviolent, where he physicallyattackshiswife
and herloveraftercatchingthemin bedtogether andcauseshimto be institutionalized.Beforethis
violentpsychoticbreak episodehe wasanormal average guy. This addson to the stigmathat every
personwitha mental illnessisviolent. In the filmindustry,revenue isthe ultimate endgame. Buda
(2010) foundthat directorsandproducers,inorderto sell theirproducts, willoftenadapttheirfilmsto
reflectpopularbelief.
Through filmsstigmasare portrayedthatreflect society’svaluesandideas. Dependingonthe
depictionof the mental illness,people’sattitudeswill oftenalignwiththe portrayal. The portrayalsof
mental illnessesthatare seenthroughmediaare ingrained withinourculture. Popularfilmsinthe
mediamaypresentstereotypesormisinformationandthusgenerate falseimpressions. Thisportrayal
oftenreflects bothpositive andnegative attitudes,andstigmasmirroredsociety.Inthe Movie GoneGirl,
a wife AmyElliotDunne hascharacteristicthatcouldbe viewedaspsychopathic. Dunne hadseenher
husbandcheaton her,and to enactvengeance onhimshe fakedherowndeathto frame him. This
character’spersonalityisportrayedasnarcissism.
MENTAL ILLNESS PORTRAYAL IN THE MEDIA 5
Buda (2010) foundthatfilms can alsoinspire hope andmotivationforchange andprovide
contextsfortherapeuticcommunicationandencounters. Thiscanbe seeninthe film, TheNotebook,
where a husbandcaresfor hiswife whohasAlzheimer’sdisease. The disease is portrayedinthe film
withaccuracy and sympathy.Itreflectsthe difficultyof the personaffected,the caregiver,andthe
family. Filmscanalsobe usedto liftstigmasandbringawarenesstoitsaudience.The film TheKing’s
Speech portrayedstutteringwithnotonlyaccuracybut sympathy.Thisbroughtawarenesstothe nature
of stutteringandgave lighttoit as a physical andmental disability.
The presentstudywasdesignedtotestthe influence of mediaonthe attitudesof itsviewers.
The presentstudytestthe knowledge of mentalillness fromthe media,empathy,exposuretomedia,
and attitudestowardsmental illness. The purpose of the presentstudywastotest a four-fold
hypothesis.1.The correlationbetweenthe exposure of mental illnessthroughthe mediaandthe
attitudestowardsmental illnessof collegestudents. 2.The correlationof empathyandthe influence of
media3. The correlationbetweenfilmswithpositiveportrayalsof mental illness,andrecall rates. 4. If
havingexposure tomental illnessleadstoahigherrecall rate of filmswithmental illness.
Methods
Design
The presentstudywasdesignedtotestfour hypothesis. It is a correctional study. The variables
tested are knowledge of mental illness from the media, empathy, recall rates of films, exposure to
media, and attitudes towards mental illness.
Materials
The presentstudywasconductedthroughtwosurveys.The first survey was conducted through
an online website. (SeeAppendix A) Itwasdistributedbyonlinesocial mediasitessuchasFacebook,and
Instagram. The secondsurveywasdistributedonpaper. (SeeAppendix B) Demographicswere askedlast
MENTAL ILLNESS PORTRAYAL IN THE MEDIA 6
inboth surveys.Forthe firstsurveythe demographics were age, gender, occupation, and highest level
of education.Forthe secondsurveythe demographicsaskedwere age,gender,majorand/orminor,and
school status.In the firstsurvey,there were atotal of twelve questionsthataskedaboutthe perception
of the givenmental illness, in a film. (Ex. Amnesia in 50 First Dates) There were three possible answer
choices: positively, negatively, or did not see. In the second survey, there were a total of eighteen
statements,onaLikert5-pointscale.Participantswere askedtochoose the answerthattheyalign with.
The nextsectioncontainedthree open-endedquestions.The firstquestion asked participants to check-
off filmsthattheyhad seenfroma listof 34 films.The secondquestionaskedif there were any films on
the listthat theywere unaware containedthe portrayal of mental illnesses.The final question required
participants to recall films that they associated with eight given mental illnesses.
Participants
The firstsurvey wasdistributedto of thirty-seven(n=37) total participants.The surveywas
distributedto peopleof all ages,genders,occupations,andlevelsof education.The agesof the
participants rangedfrom18 – 67, mean= 31; gendervariedaswell withtwenty-sevenfemales,eight
males,andone other.
The secondsurvey wasdistributedto seventy-four(n=74) total participants.The surveywas
distributedtoonlypeople currentlyenrolledincollege.The agesof the participants rangedfrom 18-27,
mean=21, gendervariedaswell withsixty-onefemales,twelve males,andone other. Participantswere
students fromdifferentinstitutions suchasMarymountManhattan College,Universityof Albany,and
StonyBrook. Participantswere focusingonvariousmajorsandhelddifferentschool statuses.
Procedure
Participantsgave theirinformedconsentandwere toldthatall informationwouldbe kept
confidential.Allparticipantsinbothsurveyswere giventhe same surveyswithstatementsandquestions
inthe same order.
MENTAL ILLNESS PORTRAYAL IN THE MEDIA 7
Analysis
Data forboth surveys were analyzedusingSPSS16.0.In analyzingthe resultsaCronbach’s
Alpha,andPearson’srwere usedto determineif valueswere significant.Answersfromsurvey#1 were
out of three choices:positively,negatively,anddidnotsee.The “didnot see”categorywas later
eliminatedandthe participantswhoansweredpositively,andnegativelybecame the new sample size.
Answersfromsurvey#2 were scaled1 to 5 withanswerchoicesrangingfrom“StronglyAgree,”
to StronglyDisagree.”Answerswere interpretedinahightolow scale,making5 the “ideal”answerfora
positive statement,andthe “ideal”answerfora negative statementwas1.Answershadto be reversed
for a negative statement. The Cronbach’sAlphawascalculatedbyusingsubgroupsforeachcategory
that wastested.
The firsthypothesis istestingthe correlationbetweenthe exposure of mental illnessthrough
the mediaandthe attitudestowardsmental illnessof college students.Thiswastestedbycorrelating
the exposure tofilmsasindicatedbyknowledge,andthe attitudestowardsmentalillnessof college
students. Togeta Cronbach’sAlphaforexposure tofilmsasindicatedbyknowledge the subgroupthat
was createdwasQuestions7,8, 10, 11, and 12. To geta Cronbach’sAlphaforthe attitudestowards
mental illnessthe subgroupthatwascreatedwasQuestions3,4, and 5. Cronbach’salphaforthe 5
knowledge and3attitude itemswere .726and .716 respectively. Next,aPearson’srwas usedto
determine bycorrelatingknowledge andattitudes.
The second hypothesis was the correlation of empathy and the influence of media. The
participantsoverall empathyscore byan overall exposure to media score, which was both determined
by a Cronbach’s Alpha. To get a Cronbach’s Alpha for empathy, the subgroup that was created was
Questions 1, 2, 6, and 13. To get a Cronbach’s Alpha for the influence of media, the subgroup that was
created was Questions 9, 10, and 12.
MENTAL ILLNESS PORTRAYAL IN THE MEDIA 8
The third hypothesis was the correlation between films with positive portrayals of mental
illness,andrecall rates.ThiswastestedbyusingaPearson’srto correlate the raw score of filmsrecalled
in survey #2 and to question # 13 which was, “Mental illness is present in my life.”
The final hypothesis was exposure to mental illness leads to a higher recall rate of films with
mental illness This was done by conceptualizing the data collected in survey #1, and the recall section
fromsurvey#2 where eightmental illnesses where listed and participants were asked to recall movies
associated with those mental illnesses.
Results
The firsthypothesistested knowledge andattitudes.A Pearson’srindicatedthatthere asa
significantcorrelationbetweenknowledge andattitudes,r(72) = .652, p=.000.
The secondhypothesistestedempathy andexposure tomedia.A Pearson’srwas determined
by correlatingempathy,andexposure tomedia. A Pearson’srindicatedthatthere asa significant
correlationbetweenempathy,andexposure tomedia,r (72) = .367, p<0.001.
The third hypothesiswastestedusingaPearson’sr. A Pearson’sr indicatedthatthere asa
significantcorrelationbetween filmswithpositive portrayalsof mental illness,andrecall rates,r(72) =
232, p<0.047.
The final hypothesisrequireddatafrombothsurvey#1 andsurvey# 2. The data from the first
trial were collectedfromthe onlinewebsite.The data wasgivenas percentage foreachquestion.
Participantswhochose the answerchoice “didnot see”were laterremovedfromthe analysis.The film
and portrayal of mental illnessportrayedinthe filmwere givenapercentage forpositive,andnegative.
(SeeTable 2) Insurvey#2 a questionaskedthe participantstorecall moviesbasedonagivenmental
illness.The mentalillnessesgivenwere Alzheimer’sdisease, Amnesia,AnxietyDisorder,PostTraumatic
StressDisorder,Social Anxiety,Autism,DepressionandDelusional Disorder. The answers thatreflected
MENTAL ILLNESS PORTRAYAL IN THE MEDIA 9
the twelve filmsinsurvey#1were recorded(SeeTable 3) , and checkedforcorrespondence tothe
answerstosurvey# 1. The data were checkedtosee if there wasa correspondence betweenmovies
that had a positive portrayal andrecall rate.
Discussion
The resultsforthe firsthypothesis,totestthe correlationbetweenthe exposure of mental
illnessthroughthe mediaandthe attitudestowardsmental illnessof college students,showeda
significantcorrelationbetweenknowledge andattitude. Thissuggeststhatexposure to mental illness
throughthe media,whichleadstoknowledge,doeshave aneffectonpeople’sattitudestowardsmental
illnesses.Thiswas meaningful inthe sample of college students, eventhoughthey have exposure to
otherresourcessuchas literature,professors,andaccesstoprimarysourceshowevertheystillrelyon
the mediaas one source for theirknowledge.
The resultsfromthe secondhypothesis, totestthe correlationof empathyandthe exposure to
media,showedasignificanteffect of exposureon empathy.Thissuggeststhatmediahave aneffectona
person’sempathy.Empathyplaysavital role inthe interpretationsof the audience whentheyare being
exposedtofilm. If apersonshowsempathytowardsacharacter, itis more likelythatthe mediatheyare
exposedtowill have aneffect.
The third hypothesiscorrelatedhavingexposure tomental illnesstoahigherrecall rate of films
withmental illness.The resultssuggestedthatthere wasacorrelationbetweenexposure tomental
illnessandrecall rates.Thissuggestsacorrelationbetweenhavingaprimarysource of knowledge,
meaningthe firsthandexposure tomental illnesses,andrecall ratesof filmsportrayingmentalillnesses.
MENTAL ILLNESS PORTRAYAL IN THE MEDIA 10
The final hypothesistest havingexposure tomental illnessleadstoa higherrecall rate of films
withmental illness.The qualitative datafromthisstudysuggestthatthe filmswithapositive portrayal
didhave a higherrecall rate,howeverthispositive,andnegative portrayalsare notthe onlydetermining
factors.
The limitationsinthe presentstudyincludeasmall sample size,andlimitedpopulation.The first
surveyhada limitedpopulationbecauseanyone whowasnotconnectiontothe researchercouldnot
participantinthe study.The secondsurveyhada limitedsample sizehaswell becauseitwasonlygiven
to college studentsinNewYork.If thisstudywasto be done again,itshouldbe giventoa larger sample
size.
Anotherlimitationinthe studywasthe amountof filmsandmental illnessesineachsurvey.If
the presentstudywasto be replicatedthensurvey#1shouldcontainmore twelve films,survey#2
shouldcontaina listof more than thirtyfour films,andeightmental illnesses.
Conclusion
From the findingsinthe presentstudy,itissuggestedthatthe media’sportrayal of mental
illnesshasaneffect.Those withafirsthandprimarysource such as a lovedone withamental illness,
can recall filmswithapositive portrayal.Forothers,filmsthatportraymental illnessespositivelyhave a
betterchance of recall thenfilmsthatportraymental illnessesnegatively.Itwasalsofoundthat college
studentsdonot have a clearunderstandingof general mental illness.There wasalotof confusion
amongstAlzheimer’sandAmnesia,andDepressionandDelusionalDisorder.Manyparticipants
answeredthatthe mental illnessin Finding Nemo wasAlzheimer’sdisease,whenitwasAmnesia. This
findingwasthe same forthe filmsportrayingAmnesia.Participantsansweredthatthe filmportrayed
Alzheimer’sdisease.Itwasthe same for Depression,andDelusional Disorder.
MENTAL ILLNESS PORTRAYAL IN THE MEDIA 11
Tables
Table 1 -Cronbach’sAlpha
Variable Cronbach’sAlpha Numberof Items
Attitude .716 3
Feelings .887 3
Media
Empathy 4
Knowledge .726 5
Table 2 : Viewsof Movieswith MentalIllnesses
Film IllnessPortrayed Positive View Negative View
FindingNemo Amnesia 76% 24%
50 FirstDates Amnesia 67% 33%
The Notebook Alzheimer’sDisease 72% 28%
The King’sSpeech Social Anxiety 50% 50%
Lars and The Real Girl Delusional Disorder 72% 28%
Brothers Post-Traumatic
StressDisorder
36% 64%
The Lion King Post-Traumatic
StressDisorder
69% 31%
The Virgin Suicides Clinical Depression 33% 66%
Winter’sBones Clinical Depression 0% 100%
SilverLiningsPlaybook AnxietyDisorder 75% 25
I Am Sam LearningDisorder 47% 53%
RainMan Autism 83% 17%
Table 3 – Recall Ratesof Films in Survey #2
Film Mental Illness(from
Survey#1)
OtherAnswersGiven Total
FindingNemo Amnesia Autism, Post-Traumatic
StressDisorder,
Delusional Disorder,
AnxietyDisorder,
Alzheimer’sdisease
37
50 FirstDates Amnesia Delusional Disorder,
Alzheimer’sdisease
18
The Notebook Alzheimer’sdisease Clinical Depression 31
The King’sSpeech Social AnxietyDisorder Clinical Depression 6
Lars and the Real Girl Delusional Disorder Social AnxietyDisorder 4
Brothers Post-TraumaticStress
Disorder
1
The Lion King Post-TraumaticStress
Disorder
1
VirginSuicides Clinical Depression Delusional Disorder 6
Winter’sBones Clinical Depression 0
SilverLiningsPlaybook AnxietyDisorder Clinical Depression, 17
MENTAL ILLNESS PORTRAYAL IN THE MEDIA 12
Post-TraumaticStress
Disorder,Delusional
Disorder,Bipolar
I Am Sam LearningDisorder Autism 8
RainMan Autism 4
Appendix1:
http://app.evalandgo.com/s/?id=JTk5aSU5MWolOTk%3D&a=JTk5aSU5MXAlOTk%3D
1. How is Amnesiaportrayedinthe filmFindingNemo?
Positively
Negatively
Didnot see film
2. How is Amnesiaportrayedinthe film50FirstDates?
Positively
Negatively
Didnot see film
3. How is Alzheimer’sDiseaseportrayedinthe filmThe Notebook?
Positively
Negatively
Didnot see film
4. How is Social Anxietyportrayedinthe filmThe King’sSpeech?
Positively
Negatively
Didnot see film
5. How is DelusionalDisorderportrayedinthe filmLarsandthe Real Girl?
Positively
Negatively
Didnot see film
6. How is PostTraumaticStressDisorder(PTSD) portrayedinthe filmBrothers?
Positively
Negatively
Didnot see film
7. How is PostTraumaticStressDisorder(PTSD) portrayedinthe filmthe LionKing?
Positively
Negatively
Didnot see film
8. How is Clinical Depressionportrayedinthe filmVirginSuicides?
Positively
Negatively
Didnot see film
9. How is Clinical Depressionportrayedinthe filmWinter’sBones?
Positively
Negatively
Didnot see film
10. How isAnxietyDisorderportrayedinthe filmSilverLiningPlaybook?
MENTAL ILLNESS PORTRAYAL IN THE MEDIA 13
Positively
Negatively
Didnot see film
11. How isLearningDisorderportrayedinthe filmIAmSam?
Positively
Negatively
Didnot see film
12. How isAutismportrayedinthe filmRainMan?
Positively
Negatively
Didnot see film
13. What isyour age?
14. What isyour occupation?
15. What isyour gender?
16. HighestLevel of Educationcompleted
HighSchool Diploma/GED
Some College/CollegeCredit
Trade School
Associate Degree
Bachelor’sDegree
Master’sDegree
Doctoral Degree
Appendix 2 :
Survey Questionnaire
SurveyQuestionnaire
InformedConsent
Class:ExperimentalPsychology
Principal Investigators:SamanthaKienemund
FacultySupervisor:LindaSolomon
The policyof the Departmentof Psychologyisthatall researchparticipationinthe Departmentis
voluntary,andyouhave the right to withdraw atany time,withoutprejudice,shouldyouobjecttothe
nature of the research.Youare entitledtoaskquestionsandtoreceive anexplanationafteryour
participation.If youdecide noworat anypointto withdraw thisconsentorstop participating,youwill
not be penalized.All identifyinginformationwill be removedfromquestionnairesassoonasyour
participationiscomplete.Noone will be able toknow yourquestionnaire responses.
Descriptionof the Study:
Thisis a researchstudyaboutmediaand mental illness.
Possible Risks
MENTAL ILLNESS PORTRAYAL IN THE MEDIA 14
a) Whenfillingoutsurveyyoumaycome acrossa questionthatyoufindunpleasant,upsetting,or
otherwise objectionable.
b) You will be askedtoprovide confidentialinformationaboutyourself.
Possible Benefits:
a) Whenyourparticipationiscomplete,youwill be givenanopportunitytolearnaboutthisresearch,
whichmay be useful toyouinyour course or inunderstandingyourself andothers.
b) You will have anopportunitytocontribute topsychological sciencebyparticipatinginthisresearch.
There are no individual person’sresponsesthatinterestus;we are studyingthe usefulnessof the
survey inquestionforpeople ingeneral.
Anytechnical questionsaboutthisresearchmaybe directedto:
Samantha Kienemund skienemund@mmm.edu (347) 320-9919
Your signature belowindicatesthatyouvoluntarilyagree toparticipate inthisstudy.
_____________________________________
Signature of Participant&Date
Picka response thatbestreflectshowyoufeel aboutthe followingstatements:
1. I empathize with characters in movies.
Strongly Agree Agree Neutral Disagree Strongly Disagree
2. I attend events that are dedicated to mental health awareness. (i.e. Alzheimer’s Walk)
Strongly Agree Agree Neutral Disagree Strongly Disagree
3. People can learn from the media.
Strongly Agree Agree Neutral Disagree Strongly Disagree
4. People with mental illnesses should be locked away.
Strongly Agree Agree Neutral Disagree Strongly Disagree
5. People with mental illnesses are violent.
Strongly Agree Agree Neutral Disagree Strongly Disagree
6. I am an advocate for people with mental illnesses.
Strongly Agree Agree Neutral Disagree Strongly Disagree
7. I have a good working knowledge of mental illnesses.
Strongly Agree Agree Neutral Disagree Strongly Disagree
8.I am interested to see mental illness portrayed in the media.
Strongly Agree Agree Neutral Disagree Strongly Disagree
9.Media sheds a good light on mental illnesses.
MENTAL ILLNESS PORTRAYAL IN THE MEDIA 15
Strongly Agree Agree Neutral Disagree Strongly Disagree
10.Watching a movie where a mental illness is portrayed, adds to my knowledge of that illness.
Strongly Agree Agree Neutral Disagree Strongly Disagree
11. I enjoy seeing movies where a mental illness is highlighted.
Strongly Agree Agree Neutral Disagree Strongly Disagree
12.Media gives an accurate representation of mental illnesses, whether they are good or bad.
Strongly Agree Agree Neutral Disagree Strongly Disagree
13. Mental illness is present in my life.
Strongly Agree Agree Neutral Disagree Strongly Disagree
14.My knowledge and understanding of mental illness comes from the media.
Strongly Agree Agree Neutral Disagree Strongly Disagree
15.My knowledge and understanding of mental illness comes from primary sources.
Strongly Agree Agree Neutral Disagree Strongly Disagree
16.Media can affect my attitude towards certain groups of people.
Strongly Agree Agree Neutral Disagree Strongly Disagree
17.I would be afraid if a mentally ill patient was on the lose.
Strongly Agree Agree Neutral Disagree Strongly Disagree
18.All serial killers in movies have mental illnesses.
Strongly Agree Agree Neutral Disagree Strongly Disagree
19.People with mental illnesses should be locked away.
Strongly Agree Agree Neutral Disagree Strongly Disagree
20. People with mental illnesses are violent.
Strongly Agree Agree Neutral Disagree Strongly Disagree
Whichof the followingmoviesfeaturingthe portrayal of amental illnesshave youseen?
Checkall that apply
[ ] The Notebook
[ ] Silver Lining Playbook
[ ] 50 First Dates
[ ] The Vow
[ ] Shutter Island
[ ] The Village
[ ] I Am Sam
[ ] Forrest Gump
[ ] Saving Private Ryan
[ ] Speak
[ ] The King’s Speech
[ ] Rain Man
[ ] The Hours
[ ] The Perks of Being a Wallflower
MENTAL ILLNESS PORTRAYAL IN THE MEDIA 16
[ ] Side Effects
[ ] Lars and theRealGirl
[ ] Obsessed
[ ] Amour
[ ] Sybil
[ ] Psycho
[ ] Identity
[ ] Black Swan
[ ] Girl, Interrupted
[ ] Brothers
[ ] Mysterious Skin
[ ] Little Children
[ ] The Lovely Bones
[ ] Virgin Suicides
[ ] Hostel
[ ] Finding Nemo
[ ] Gone Girl
[ ] One Flew Over TheCukooNest
[ ] BeautifulMind
[ ] Winter’s Bone
From the listabove,whichmovieswere youunaware containedthe portrayal of amental illness?
Whichmovie/(s) doyouassociate withthe followingmental illnesses?
Alzheimer’sDisease
Amnesia
AnxietyDisorder
PostTraumatic StressDisorder
Social Anxiety
Autism
Depression
Delusional Disorder
Age:_________________ Gender:________________________
Major/(s) andMinor/ (s) :______________________School Status: ____________ (i.e freshmen)
MENTAL ILLNESS PORTRAYAL IN THE MEDIA 17
Reference:
Buda, B. (2010). Teaching Psychopathology Through Movies. Crisis, 3(4), 224-224.
Corrigan, P., River, L., Lundin, R., Penn, D., Uphoff- Wasowki, K., Campion, J., ... Kubiak, M. (2001).
Three Strategies for Changing Attributions about Severe Mental Illness. Schizophrenia
Bulletin, 27(2), 187-195.
Kondo, N. (2007). Speaking Out Mental Illness in Film. Psychiatric Rehabilitation Journal, 31(3),
250-252.
Maier, J., Gentile, D., Vogel, D., & Kaplan, S. (2013). Media Influences on Self-Stigma of Seeking
Psychological Services: The Importances of Media Portrayals and Person
Perception. Psychology of Popular Media Culture,3(4), 239-256.
McNulty, J. (2004). Commentary: Mental Illness, Society, Stigma, and Research. Schizophrenia
Bulletin, 30(3).
Media effects theories. (n.d.). Retrieved November 23, 2014, from
http://oregonstate.edu/instruct/comm321/gwalker/effectsmedia.htm
Miller, A. (2014, October 27). What 'Gone Girl' Does (and Doesn't) Tell Us About Mental Illness.
Retrieved from http://health.usnews.com/health-news/health-
wellness/articles/2014/10/27/what-gone-girl-does-and-doesnt-tell-us-about-mental-illness
Roskos-Ewoldsen, B., Davies, J., & Roskos- Ewoldsen, D. (2004). Implications of the Mental Models
Approach for Cultivation Theory. 345-363.
Spagnolo, A., Murphy, A., & Librera, L. (2008). Reducing Stigma by Meeting and Learning from
People with Mental Illness. Psychiatric Rehabilitation Journal, 31(3), 186-193.
Stout, P., Villegas, J., & Jennings, N. (2004). Images of Mental Illness in the Media: Identifying Gaps
in the Research. Schizophrenia Bulletin, 30(3), 543-561.
Tartakovsky, M. (n.d.). Media’s Damaging Depictions of Mental Illness. Retrieved November 23,
2014, from http://psychcentral.com/lib/medias-damaging-depictions-of-mental-
illness/0002220
Zipple ScD., A. (1996). Media Madness: Public Images of Mental Illness.Psychiatric Rehabilitation
Journal.
MENTAL ILLNESS PORTRAYAL IN THE MEDIA 18

More Related Content

Similar to Mental Illness and MediaFinal

Similar to Mental Illness and MediaFinal (17)

Week Three: Contemporary Media Research
Week Three: Contemporary Media ResearchWeek Three: Contemporary Media Research
Week Three: Contemporary Media Research
 
3. Moral panic
3. Moral panic3. Moral panic
3. Moral panic
 
Moral Panics Media Effects and Audience
Moral Panics Media Effects and AudienceMoral Panics Media Effects and Audience
Moral Panics Media Effects and Audience
 
Podcast transcript
Podcast transcriptPodcast transcript
Podcast transcript
 
Essay (Final)
Essay (Final)Essay (Final)
Essay (Final)
 
disability training
disability trainingdisability training
disability training
 
Media Moral Panic
Media Moral PanicMedia Moral Panic
Media Moral Panic
 
Media Violence
Media ViolenceMedia Violence
Media Violence
 
Media &Amp; Violence Essay
Media &Amp; Violence EssayMedia &Amp; Violence Essay
Media &Amp; Violence Essay
 
Mental Illness
Mental IllnessMental Illness
Mental Illness
 
Media violence presentation
Media violence presentationMedia violence presentation
Media violence presentation
 
Independent report 3000-4000 words
Independent report 3000-4000 wordsIndependent report 3000-4000 words
Independent report 3000-4000 words
 
I saw it in the movies (using films in education and training in Eating Disor...
I saw it in the movies (using films in education and training in Eating Disor...I saw it in the movies (using films in education and training in Eating Disor...
I saw it in the movies (using films in education and training in Eating Disor...
 
Childhood Violence
Childhood ViolenceChildhood Violence
Childhood Violence
 
Media Violence And Its Effect On Children Essay
Media Violence And Its Effect On Children EssayMedia Violence And Its Effect On Children Essay
Media Violence And Its Effect On Children Essay
 
Psychological Impacts Of Attachment Disorder
Psychological Impacts Of Attachment DisorderPsychological Impacts Of Attachment Disorder
Psychological Impacts Of Attachment Disorder
 
Running Head VIOLENCE 1Violence in the Media3Vi.docx
Running Head VIOLENCE 1Violence in the Media3Vi.docxRunning Head VIOLENCE 1Violence in the Media3Vi.docx
Running Head VIOLENCE 1Violence in the Media3Vi.docx
 

Mental Illness and MediaFinal

  • 1. Running Head: MENTAL ILLNESS PORTRAYAL IN THE MEDIA 1 College Students Attitudes Towards Mental Illness Portrayed in the Media Samantha Kienemund Marymount Manhattan College
  • 2. MENTAL ILLNESS PORTRAYAL IN THE MEDIA 2 Abstract The presentstudyisdesigned toevaluate mental illnessandthe media.The followingquestionsare addressed:1.) What isthe correlationbetweenexposuretomental illnessinthe mediaandattitudes towardsmental illnessesincollegestudents? 2.) Whatisthe correlationbetweenempathyandthe influenceof mediatowardsmental illnesses?3.) Will filmswithpositive portrayalsof mentalillnesses leadto a higherrecall rate?4.) What isthe correlationbetweenthe presence of mental illnessone'slife and recall ratesof filmthat portrayal a mental illness?Asseeninthe article Publicattitudestowards people withchronicmental illness,Yankelovich,1990, the mass mediawhichincludestelevisionand broadcast newsare primarysourcesof informationaboutmental illnessformany Americans.Mental illnessisstigmatizedbyoursociety.Thisleadstothe viewersreactingtosuchstigmasportrayedonfilm and formulatingtheirownviewsonmental illnesses. Keywords:mental illness,media,film, stigma,influence
  • 3. MENTAL ILLNESS PORTRAYAL IN THE MEDIA 3 College StudentsAttitudesTowardsMental IllnessPortrayedinthe Media Mediahas a strong influence onthe general public, andreflectschangesinthe valuesof the society.Societytodayvaluesmediaas anessential partof realityand a majortool to obtainknowledge. Mediathrough mediumssuchas the news,music,television showsandfilmsare all sourcesthatpeople draw onwhenthey subconsciouslyformulateanopinion. The audience canlearnfromthe mediawith or withoutthe intentionsof gainingknowledge. Maieret.al. (2014), suggestedthat,persistentlong termexposure tomediacontenthasa small butmeasurable effectonthe perceptionof the audience. People of all ageshave unlimitedaccesstoall typesof media. Maier et.al. (2014), described cultivationtheory asproposingthatthe collectivemessages seen inthe mediaandthe figures seencangreatly influence perceptionsof the worldandoursubsequent behaviors. People are greatlyinfluencedbythingstheysee throughmedia. Social ActionTheory developedbyAndersonandMeyer (1988),proposes thatthe audience are active inthe constructionof meaningfromthe contenttheyperceive.The meaningsare createdinthree ways:the intentionsof the producer,the portrayal of the content,andthe interpretationsof the audience. Filmsare amediumin mediathathas a developedplot,characters,andmanyinfluentialaspects. Characterscanbe usedas toolsforpeople torelate to,and empathize with. Plotscanbe usedtodisplaya message,orconveya theme.Influential aspectsare the idealsof change,motivation,butcanalsobe stigmas. People withmentalillnessesexperiencestigmatization.Oursocietyhasmade mental illnessone of the moststigmatizedconditionsandthis isreflectedinourmedia. Insocietyexposure tomediais inevitable.People of all ageshave unlimitedaccesstoall typesof media. Yankelovich, (1990) suggested that the mass media(whichincludestelevision,andbroadcastnews) are the primarysourcesof informationaboutmental illnessfor manyAmericans.The mediaplays animportantrole inthe creation of the stigmasassociatedwithmental illnesses.Wahl (1995) suggestedthatthe media’suse of
  • 4. MENTAL ILLNESS PORTRAYAL IN THE MEDIA 4 misinformation,inaccurate use of psychiatricterms,andnegative stereotypesof peoplewithmental illnessesall leadtothe growingstigmasof people withmentalillness.Stigmascreate manybarriersfor people livingwithmentalillnesses.There are manynegativeeffectsof these stigmassuchasinfluence in all areas of life, suchas placesof living,learning,work,andsocializing.People withmentalillnesses who are viewedtobe dangerousare alsohighlystigmatized,feared,andalone. Mental Illnessisoftenportrayedin films.Manyfilmsreflectpopularbelief andstereotypes. This continuesthe cycle because itleavesanimpressiononthe audience.Slasherfilms,suchas Halloween, have a theme of an escapedmentallyillpatientwhogoesona killingspree. Filmshave atendencyto portray criminal masterminds inamore glamourizedfashionthantheytrulyare,suchas the character Hannibal Lectorin The Silence of the Lambs. Inthe film,SilverLining Playbook, the maincharacterPat dealswithbipolardisorder.Hisfirstepisode isextremelyviolent, where he physicallyattackshiswife and herloveraftercatchingthemin bedtogether andcauseshimto be institutionalized.Beforethis violentpsychoticbreak episodehe wasanormal average guy. This addson to the stigmathat every personwitha mental illnessisviolent. In the filmindustry,revenue isthe ultimate endgame. Buda (2010) foundthat directorsandproducers,inorderto sell theirproducts, willoftenadapttheirfilmsto reflectpopularbelief. Through filmsstigmasare portrayedthatreflect society’svaluesandideas. Dependingonthe depictionof the mental illness,people’sattitudeswill oftenalignwiththe portrayal. The portrayalsof mental illnessesthatare seenthroughmediaare ingrained withinourculture. Popularfilmsinthe mediamaypresentstereotypesormisinformationandthusgenerate falseimpressions. Thisportrayal oftenreflects bothpositive andnegative attitudes,andstigmasmirroredsociety.Inthe Movie GoneGirl, a wife AmyElliotDunne hascharacteristicthatcouldbe viewedaspsychopathic. Dunne hadseenher husbandcheaton her,and to enactvengeance onhimshe fakedherowndeathto frame him. This character’spersonalityisportrayedasnarcissism.
  • 5. MENTAL ILLNESS PORTRAYAL IN THE MEDIA 5 Buda (2010) foundthatfilms can alsoinspire hope andmotivationforchange andprovide contextsfortherapeuticcommunicationandencounters. Thiscanbe seeninthe film, TheNotebook, where a husbandcaresfor hiswife whohasAlzheimer’sdisease. The disease is portrayedinthe film withaccuracy and sympathy.Itreflectsthe difficultyof the personaffected,the caregiver,andthe family. Filmscanalsobe usedto liftstigmasandbringawarenesstoitsaudience.The film TheKing’s Speech portrayedstutteringwithnotonlyaccuracybut sympathy.Thisbroughtawarenesstothe nature of stutteringandgave lighttoit as a physical andmental disability. The presentstudywasdesignedtotestthe influence of mediaonthe attitudesof itsviewers. The presentstudytestthe knowledge of mentalillness fromthe media,empathy,exposuretomedia, and attitudestowardsmental illness. The purpose of the presentstudywastotest a four-fold hypothesis.1.The correlationbetweenthe exposure of mental illnessthroughthe mediaandthe attitudestowardsmental illnessof collegestudents. 2.The correlationof empathyandthe influence of media3. The correlationbetweenfilmswithpositiveportrayalsof mental illness,andrecall rates. 4. If havingexposure tomental illnessleadstoahigherrecall rate of filmswithmental illness. Methods Design The presentstudywasdesignedtotestfour hypothesis. It is a correctional study. The variables tested are knowledge of mental illness from the media, empathy, recall rates of films, exposure to media, and attitudes towards mental illness. Materials The presentstudywasconductedthroughtwosurveys.The first survey was conducted through an online website. (SeeAppendix A) Itwasdistributedbyonlinesocial mediasitessuchasFacebook,and Instagram. The secondsurveywasdistributedonpaper. (SeeAppendix B) Demographicswere askedlast
  • 6. MENTAL ILLNESS PORTRAYAL IN THE MEDIA 6 inboth surveys.Forthe firstsurveythe demographics were age, gender, occupation, and highest level of education.Forthe secondsurveythe demographicsaskedwere age,gender,majorand/orminor,and school status.In the firstsurvey,there were atotal of twelve questionsthataskedaboutthe perception of the givenmental illness, in a film. (Ex. Amnesia in 50 First Dates) There were three possible answer choices: positively, negatively, or did not see. In the second survey, there were a total of eighteen statements,onaLikert5-pointscale.Participantswere askedtochoose the answerthattheyalign with. The nextsectioncontainedthree open-endedquestions.The firstquestion asked participants to check- off filmsthattheyhad seenfroma listof 34 films.The secondquestionaskedif there were any films on the listthat theywere unaware containedthe portrayal of mental illnesses.The final question required participants to recall films that they associated with eight given mental illnesses. Participants The firstsurvey wasdistributedto of thirty-seven(n=37) total participants.The surveywas distributedto peopleof all ages,genders,occupations,andlevelsof education.The agesof the participants rangedfrom18 – 67, mean= 31; gendervariedaswell withtwenty-sevenfemales,eight males,andone other. The secondsurvey wasdistributedto seventy-four(n=74) total participants.The surveywas distributedtoonlypeople currentlyenrolledincollege.The agesof the participants rangedfrom 18-27, mean=21, gendervariedaswell withsixty-onefemales,twelve males,andone other. Participantswere students fromdifferentinstitutions suchasMarymountManhattan College,Universityof Albany,and StonyBrook. Participantswere focusingonvariousmajorsandhelddifferentschool statuses. Procedure Participantsgave theirinformedconsentandwere toldthatall informationwouldbe kept confidential.Allparticipantsinbothsurveyswere giventhe same surveyswithstatementsandquestions inthe same order.
  • 7. MENTAL ILLNESS PORTRAYAL IN THE MEDIA 7 Analysis Data forboth surveys were analyzedusingSPSS16.0.In analyzingthe resultsaCronbach’s Alpha,andPearson’srwere usedto determineif valueswere significant.Answersfromsurvey#1 were out of three choices:positively,negatively,anddidnotsee.The “didnot see”categorywas later eliminatedandthe participantswhoansweredpositively,andnegativelybecame the new sample size. Answersfromsurvey#2 were scaled1 to 5 withanswerchoicesrangingfrom“StronglyAgree,” to StronglyDisagree.”Answerswere interpretedinahightolow scale,making5 the “ideal”answerfora positive statement,andthe “ideal”answerfora negative statementwas1.Answershadto be reversed for a negative statement. The Cronbach’sAlphawascalculatedbyusingsubgroupsforeachcategory that wastested. The firsthypothesis istestingthe correlationbetweenthe exposure of mental illnessthrough the mediaandthe attitudestowardsmental illnessof college students.Thiswastestedbycorrelating the exposure tofilmsasindicatedbyknowledge,andthe attitudestowardsmentalillnessof college students. Togeta Cronbach’sAlphaforexposure tofilmsasindicatedbyknowledge the subgroupthat was createdwasQuestions7,8, 10, 11, and 12. To geta Cronbach’sAlphaforthe attitudestowards mental illnessthe subgroupthatwascreatedwasQuestions3,4, and 5. Cronbach’salphaforthe 5 knowledge and3attitude itemswere .726and .716 respectively. Next,aPearson’srwas usedto determine bycorrelatingknowledge andattitudes. The second hypothesis was the correlation of empathy and the influence of media. The participantsoverall empathyscore byan overall exposure to media score, which was both determined by a Cronbach’s Alpha. To get a Cronbach’s Alpha for empathy, the subgroup that was created was Questions 1, 2, 6, and 13. To get a Cronbach’s Alpha for the influence of media, the subgroup that was created was Questions 9, 10, and 12.
  • 8. MENTAL ILLNESS PORTRAYAL IN THE MEDIA 8 The third hypothesis was the correlation between films with positive portrayals of mental illness,andrecall rates.ThiswastestedbyusingaPearson’srto correlate the raw score of filmsrecalled in survey #2 and to question # 13 which was, “Mental illness is present in my life.” The final hypothesis was exposure to mental illness leads to a higher recall rate of films with mental illness This was done by conceptualizing the data collected in survey #1, and the recall section fromsurvey#2 where eightmental illnesses where listed and participants were asked to recall movies associated with those mental illnesses. Results The firsthypothesistested knowledge andattitudes.A Pearson’srindicatedthatthere asa significantcorrelationbetweenknowledge andattitudes,r(72) = .652, p=.000. The secondhypothesistestedempathy andexposure tomedia.A Pearson’srwas determined by correlatingempathy,andexposure tomedia. A Pearson’srindicatedthatthere asa significant correlationbetweenempathy,andexposure tomedia,r (72) = .367, p<0.001. The third hypothesiswastestedusingaPearson’sr. A Pearson’sr indicatedthatthere asa significantcorrelationbetween filmswithpositive portrayalsof mental illness,andrecall rates,r(72) = 232, p<0.047. The final hypothesisrequireddatafrombothsurvey#1 andsurvey# 2. The data from the first trial were collectedfromthe onlinewebsite.The data wasgivenas percentage foreachquestion. Participantswhochose the answerchoice “didnot see”were laterremovedfromthe analysis.The film and portrayal of mental illnessportrayedinthe filmwere givenapercentage forpositive,andnegative. (SeeTable 2) Insurvey#2 a questionaskedthe participantstorecall moviesbasedonagivenmental illness.The mentalillnessesgivenwere Alzheimer’sdisease, Amnesia,AnxietyDisorder,PostTraumatic StressDisorder,Social Anxiety,Autism,DepressionandDelusional Disorder. The answers thatreflected
  • 9. MENTAL ILLNESS PORTRAYAL IN THE MEDIA 9 the twelve filmsinsurvey#1were recorded(SeeTable 3) , and checkedforcorrespondence tothe answerstosurvey# 1. The data were checkedtosee if there wasa correspondence betweenmovies that had a positive portrayal andrecall rate. Discussion The resultsforthe firsthypothesis,totestthe correlationbetweenthe exposure of mental illnessthroughthe mediaandthe attitudestowardsmental illnessof college students,showeda significantcorrelationbetweenknowledge andattitude. Thissuggeststhatexposure to mental illness throughthe media,whichleadstoknowledge,doeshave aneffectonpeople’sattitudestowardsmental illnesses.Thiswas meaningful inthe sample of college students, eventhoughthey have exposure to otherresourcessuchas literature,professors,andaccesstoprimarysourceshowevertheystillrelyon the mediaas one source for theirknowledge. The resultsfromthe secondhypothesis, totestthe correlationof empathyandthe exposure to media,showedasignificanteffect of exposureon empathy.Thissuggeststhatmediahave aneffectona person’sempathy.Empathyplaysavital role inthe interpretationsof the audience whentheyare being exposedtofilm. If apersonshowsempathytowardsacharacter, itis more likelythatthe mediatheyare exposedtowill have aneffect. The third hypothesiscorrelatedhavingexposure tomental illnesstoahigherrecall rate of films withmental illness.The resultssuggestedthatthere wasacorrelationbetweenexposure tomental illnessandrecall rates.Thissuggestsacorrelationbetweenhavingaprimarysource of knowledge, meaningthe firsthandexposure tomental illnesses,andrecall ratesof filmsportrayingmentalillnesses.
  • 10. MENTAL ILLNESS PORTRAYAL IN THE MEDIA 10 The final hypothesistest havingexposure tomental illnessleadstoa higherrecall rate of films withmental illness.The qualitative datafromthisstudysuggestthatthe filmswithapositive portrayal didhave a higherrecall rate,howeverthispositive,andnegative portrayalsare notthe onlydetermining factors. The limitationsinthe presentstudyincludeasmall sample size,andlimitedpopulation.The first surveyhada limitedpopulationbecauseanyone whowasnotconnectiontothe researchercouldnot participantinthe study.The secondsurveyhada limitedsample sizehaswell becauseitwasonlygiven to college studentsinNewYork.If thisstudywasto be done again,itshouldbe giventoa larger sample size. Anotherlimitationinthe studywasthe amountof filmsandmental illnessesineachsurvey.If the presentstudywasto be replicatedthensurvey#1shouldcontainmore twelve films,survey#2 shouldcontaina listof more than thirtyfour films,andeightmental illnesses. Conclusion From the findingsinthe presentstudy,itissuggestedthatthe media’sportrayal of mental illnesshasaneffect.Those withafirsthandprimarysource such as a lovedone withamental illness, can recall filmswithapositive portrayal.Forothers,filmsthatportraymental illnessespositivelyhave a betterchance of recall thenfilmsthatportraymental illnessesnegatively.Itwasalsofoundthat college studentsdonot have a clearunderstandingof general mental illness.There wasalotof confusion amongstAlzheimer’sandAmnesia,andDepressionandDelusionalDisorder.Manyparticipants answeredthatthe mental illnessin Finding Nemo wasAlzheimer’sdisease,whenitwasAmnesia. This findingwasthe same forthe filmsportrayingAmnesia.Participantsansweredthatthe filmportrayed Alzheimer’sdisease.Itwasthe same for Depression,andDelusional Disorder.
  • 11. MENTAL ILLNESS PORTRAYAL IN THE MEDIA 11 Tables Table 1 -Cronbach’sAlpha Variable Cronbach’sAlpha Numberof Items Attitude .716 3 Feelings .887 3 Media Empathy 4 Knowledge .726 5 Table 2 : Viewsof Movieswith MentalIllnesses Film IllnessPortrayed Positive View Negative View FindingNemo Amnesia 76% 24% 50 FirstDates Amnesia 67% 33% The Notebook Alzheimer’sDisease 72% 28% The King’sSpeech Social Anxiety 50% 50% Lars and The Real Girl Delusional Disorder 72% 28% Brothers Post-Traumatic StressDisorder 36% 64% The Lion King Post-Traumatic StressDisorder 69% 31% The Virgin Suicides Clinical Depression 33% 66% Winter’sBones Clinical Depression 0% 100% SilverLiningsPlaybook AnxietyDisorder 75% 25 I Am Sam LearningDisorder 47% 53% RainMan Autism 83% 17% Table 3 – Recall Ratesof Films in Survey #2 Film Mental Illness(from Survey#1) OtherAnswersGiven Total FindingNemo Amnesia Autism, Post-Traumatic StressDisorder, Delusional Disorder, AnxietyDisorder, Alzheimer’sdisease 37 50 FirstDates Amnesia Delusional Disorder, Alzheimer’sdisease 18 The Notebook Alzheimer’sdisease Clinical Depression 31 The King’sSpeech Social AnxietyDisorder Clinical Depression 6 Lars and the Real Girl Delusional Disorder Social AnxietyDisorder 4 Brothers Post-TraumaticStress Disorder 1 The Lion King Post-TraumaticStress Disorder 1 VirginSuicides Clinical Depression Delusional Disorder 6 Winter’sBones Clinical Depression 0 SilverLiningsPlaybook AnxietyDisorder Clinical Depression, 17
  • 12. MENTAL ILLNESS PORTRAYAL IN THE MEDIA 12 Post-TraumaticStress Disorder,Delusional Disorder,Bipolar I Am Sam LearningDisorder Autism 8 RainMan Autism 4 Appendix1: http://app.evalandgo.com/s/?id=JTk5aSU5MWolOTk%3D&a=JTk5aSU5MXAlOTk%3D 1. How is Amnesiaportrayedinthe filmFindingNemo? Positively Negatively Didnot see film 2. How is Amnesiaportrayedinthe film50FirstDates? Positively Negatively Didnot see film 3. How is Alzheimer’sDiseaseportrayedinthe filmThe Notebook? Positively Negatively Didnot see film 4. How is Social Anxietyportrayedinthe filmThe King’sSpeech? Positively Negatively Didnot see film 5. How is DelusionalDisorderportrayedinthe filmLarsandthe Real Girl? Positively Negatively Didnot see film 6. How is PostTraumaticStressDisorder(PTSD) portrayedinthe filmBrothers? Positively Negatively Didnot see film 7. How is PostTraumaticStressDisorder(PTSD) portrayedinthe filmthe LionKing? Positively Negatively Didnot see film 8. How is Clinical Depressionportrayedinthe filmVirginSuicides? Positively Negatively Didnot see film 9. How is Clinical Depressionportrayedinthe filmWinter’sBones? Positively Negatively Didnot see film 10. How isAnxietyDisorderportrayedinthe filmSilverLiningPlaybook?
  • 13. MENTAL ILLNESS PORTRAYAL IN THE MEDIA 13 Positively Negatively Didnot see film 11. How isLearningDisorderportrayedinthe filmIAmSam? Positively Negatively Didnot see film 12. How isAutismportrayedinthe filmRainMan? Positively Negatively Didnot see film 13. What isyour age? 14. What isyour occupation? 15. What isyour gender? 16. HighestLevel of Educationcompleted HighSchool Diploma/GED Some College/CollegeCredit Trade School Associate Degree Bachelor’sDegree Master’sDegree Doctoral Degree Appendix 2 : Survey Questionnaire SurveyQuestionnaire InformedConsent Class:ExperimentalPsychology Principal Investigators:SamanthaKienemund FacultySupervisor:LindaSolomon The policyof the Departmentof Psychologyisthatall researchparticipationinthe Departmentis voluntary,andyouhave the right to withdraw atany time,withoutprejudice,shouldyouobjecttothe nature of the research.Youare entitledtoaskquestionsandtoreceive anexplanationafteryour participation.If youdecide noworat anypointto withdraw thisconsentorstop participating,youwill not be penalized.All identifyinginformationwill be removedfromquestionnairesassoonasyour participationiscomplete.Noone will be able toknow yourquestionnaire responses. Descriptionof the Study: Thisis a researchstudyaboutmediaand mental illness. Possible Risks
  • 14. MENTAL ILLNESS PORTRAYAL IN THE MEDIA 14 a) Whenfillingoutsurveyyoumaycome acrossa questionthatyoufindunpleasant,upsetting,or otherwise objectionable. b) You will be askedtoprovide confidentialinformationaboutyourself. Possible Benefits: a) Whenyourparticipationiscomplete,youwill be givenanopportunitytolearnaboutthisresearch, whichmay be useful toyouinyour course or inunderstandingyourself andothers. b) You will have anopportunitytocontribute topsychological sciencebyparticipatinginthisresearch. There are no individual person’sresponsesthatinterestus;we are studyingthe usefulnessof the survey inquestionforpeople ingeneral. Anytechnical questionsaboutthisresearchmaybe directedto: Samantha Kienemund skienemund@mmm.edu (347) 320-9919 Your signature belowindicatesthatyouvoluntarilyagree toparticipate inthisstudy. _____________________________________ Signature of Participant&Date Picka response thatbestreflectshowyoufeel aboutthe followingstatements: 1. I empathize with characters in movies. Strongly Agree Agree Neutral Disagree Strongly Disagree 2. I attend events that are dedicated to mental health awareness. (i.e. Alzheimer’s Walk) Strongly Agree Agree Neutral Disagree Strongly Disagree 3. People can learn from the media. Strongly Agree Agree Neutral Disagree Strongly Disagree 4. People with mental illnesses should be locked away. Strongly Agree Agree Neutral Disagree Strongly Disagree 5. People with mental illnesses are violent. Strongly Agree Agree Neutral Disagree Strongly Disagree 6. I am an advocate for people with mental illnesses. Strongly Agree Agree Neutral Disagree Strongly Disagree 7. I have a good working knowledge of mental illnesses. Strongly Agree Agree Neutral Disagree Strongly Disagree 8.I am interested to see mental illness portrayed in the media. Strongly Agree Agree Neutral Disagree Strongly Disagree 9.Media sheds a good light on mental illnesses.
  • 15. MENTAL ILLNESS PORTRAYAL IN THE MEDIA 15 Strongly Agree Agree Neutral Disagree Strongly Disagree 10.Watching a movie where a mental illness is portrayed, adds to my knowledge of that illness. Strongly Agree Agree Neutral Disagree Strongly Disagree 11. I enjoy seeing movies where a mental illness is highlighted. Strongly Agree Agree Neutral Disagree Strongly Disagree 12.Media gives an accurate representation of mental illnesses, whether they are good or bad. Strongly Agree Agree Neutral Disagree Strongly Disagree 13. Mental illness is present in my life. Strongly Agree Agree Neutral Disagree Strongly Disagree 14.My knowledge and understanding of mental illness comes from the media. Strongly Agree Agree Neutral Disagree Strongly Disagree 15.My knowledge and understanding of mental illness comes from primary sources. Strongly Agree Agree Neutral Disagree Strongly Disagree 16.Media can affect my attitude towards certain groups of people. Strongly Agree Agree Neutral Disagree Strongly Disagree 17.I would be afraid if a mentally ill patient was on the lose. Strongly Agree Agree Neutral Disagree Strongly Disagree 18.All serial killers in movies have mental illnesses. Strongly Agree Agree Neutral Disagree Strongly Disagree 19.People with mental illnesses should be locked away. Strongly Agree Agree Neutral Disagree Strongly Disagree 20. People with mental illnesses are violent. Strongly Agree Agree Neutral Disagree Strongly Disagree Whichof the followingmoviesfeaturingthe portrayal of amental illnesshave youseen? Checkall that apply [ ] The Notebook [ ] Silver Lining Playbook [ ] 50 First Dates [ ] The Vow [ ] Shutter Island [ ] The Village [ ] I Am Sam [ ] Forrest Gump [ ] Saving Private Ryan [ ] Speak [ ] The King’s Speech [ ] Rain Man [ ] The Hours [ ] The Perks of Being a Wallflower
  • 16. MENTAL ILLNESS PORTRAYAL IN THE MEDIA 16 [ ] Side Effects [ ] Lars and theRealGirl [ ] Obsessed [ ] Amour [ ] Sybil [ ] Psycho [ ] Identity [ ] Black Swan [ ] Girl, Interrupted [ ] Brothers [ ] Mysterious Skin [ ] Little Children [ ] The Lovely Bones [ ] Virgin Suicides [ ] Hostel [ ] Finding Nemo [ ] Gone Girl [ ] One Flew Over TheCukooNest [ ] BeautifulMind [ ] Winter’s Bone From the listabove,whichmovieswere youunaware containedthe portrayal of amental illness? Whichmovie/(s) doyouassociate withthe followingmental illnesses? Alzheimer’sDisease Amnesia AnxietyDisorder PostTraumatic StressDisorder Social Anxiety Autism Depression Delusional Disorder Age:_________________ Gender:________________________ Major/(s) andMinor/ (s) :______________________School Status: ____________ (i.e freshmen)
  • 17. MENTAL ILLNESS PORTRAYAL IN THE MEDIA 17 Reference: Buda, B. (2010). Teaching Psychopathology Through Movies. Crisis, 3(4), 224-224. Corrigan, P., River, L., Lundin, R., Penn, D., Uphoff- Wasowki, K., Campion, J., ... Kubiak, M. (2001). Three Strategies for Changing Attributions about Severe Mental Illness. Schizophrenia Bulletin, 27(2), 187-195. Kondo, N. (2007). Speaking Out Mental Illness in Film. Psychiatric Rehabilitation Journal, 31(3), 250-252. Maier, J., Gentile, D., Vogel, D., & Kaplan, S. (2013). Media Influences on Self-Stigma of Seeking Psychological Services: The Importances of Media Portrayals and Person Perception. Psychology of Popular Media Culture,3(4), 239-256. McNulty, J. (2004). Commentary: Mental Illness, Society, Stigma, and Research. Schizophrenia Bulletin, 30(3). Media effects theories. (n.d.). Retrieved November 23, 2014, from http://oregonstate.edu/instruct/comm321/gwalker/effectsmedia.htm Miller, A. (2014, October 27). What 'Gone Girl' Does (and Doesn't) Tell Us About Mental Illness. Retrieved from http://health.usnews.com/health-news/health- wellness/articles/2014/10/27/what-gone-girl-does-and-doesnt-tell-us-about-mental-illness Roskos-Ewoldsen, B., Davies, J., & Roskos- Ewoldsen, D. (2004). Implications of the Mental Models Approach for Cultivation Theory. 345-363. Spagnolo, A., Murphy, A., & Librera, L. (2008). Reducing Stigma by Meeting and Learning from People with Mental Illness. Psychiatric Rehabilitation Journal, 31(3), 186-193. Stout, P., Villegas, J., & Jennings, N. (2004). Images of Mental Illness in the Media: Identifying Gaps in the Research. Schizophrenia Bulletin, 30(3), 543-561. Tartakovsky, M. (n.d.). Media’s Damaging Depictions of Mental Illness. Retrieved November 23, 2014, from http://psychcentral.com/lib/medias-damaging-depictions-of-mental- illness/0002220 Zipple ScD., A. (1996). Media Madness: Public Images of Mental Illness.Psychiatric Rehabilitation Journal.
  • 18. MENTAL ILLNESS PORTRAYAL IN THE MEDIA 18