Chronic pain in sport is a problem. The modern understanding of pain sciences should be applied in the world of sport and exercise.
We looked at the contemporary science and thinking about pain including: pain is multi-system (e.g./ nervous, immune, autonomic), multi-dimensional (physical-cognitive-emotional); the meaning of pain to the individual; the context of the injury; the importance of the right early messages.
1. February 2015
Persisting pain in sport
Richmond Stace MCSP MSc (Pain) BSc (Hons) | Specialist Pain Physiotherapist
Thursday, 5 February 15
2. Behind every pain...
✤ ...is a story
✤ Know the person to know the pain
✤ “It’s as much about the person as the condition”. Oliver Sacks
✤ When a person gets better, their pain gets better
Thursday, 5 February 15
3. Picture this...
✤ 16 year old girl with pain in both shins
✤ 2 years; worsening
✤ continues to play sport at school most
days + training
✤ exquisitely tender to touch
✤ occasions when unable to walk
✤ first thoughts?
Thursday, 5 February 15
4. ..and then she
says this..
✤ 8 year h/o migraines
✤ disturbed sleep
✤ widespread tenderness
✤ high-flyer at school
✤ thoughts?
✤ who is this a case for?
Thursday, 5 February 15
5. Puzzled by a
lack of signs?
✤ is it an injury?
✤ is it sensitivity?
✤ hamstring ‘re-injury’
✤ damage or feels like damage?
Thursday, 5 February 15
6. Acute pain
✤ is it an injury?
✤ "I sincerely thought it was the
last ball I would be touching
for a long time because of the
pain," Messi (2012)
Thursday, 5 February 15
8. Pain is...
✤ normal
✤ unpleasant
✤ alerts us to danger in the body
✤ motivates action
✤ a vital survival device
Thursday, 5 February 15
9. My definition of pain is...
✤ _________________________
Thursday, 5 February 15
10. Pain definition
✤ IASP definition:
✤ An unpleasant sensory and emotional experience associated with
actual or potential tissue damage, or described in terms of such
damage.
Thursday, 5 February 15
11. Pain is a huge global health burden
✤ A systematic analysis for the Global Burden of Disease Study 2010
✤ Health systems will need to address the needs of the rising
numbers of individuals with a range of disorders that largely cause
disability but not mortality (Vos et al. 2012)
✤ Most burdensome global health issues
✤ Number 2 -- depression
✤ Number 1 -- chronic back pain
Thursday, 5 February 15
12. The problem
✤ Pain is poorly understood
✤ Pain is poorly communicated
✤ Chronic pain outcomes often
low
✤ Expectations low
✤ WE MUST CHANGE THE
UNDERSTANDING OF PAIN
Thursday, 5 February 15
13. ✤ A problem in sport -- yes!
✤ Professional vs amateur
✤ Stops return to full participation
✤ Financial/career
✤ Affects performance
✤ Playing with pain
✤ No pain, no gain
✤ Is this different to non-sporting
population?
✤ Context
✤ End goal
✤ Should we think differently
about pain in sport vs non-
sport?
✤ NO
Persisting pain in sport
Thursday, 5 February 15
14. What can we do?
✤ Understand pain
✤ Reconceptualise pain
✤ Neurobiology
✤ Neuroimmunobiology
✤ Neuroimmunoendobiology
✤ What influences pain biology?
Thursday, 5 February 15
15. What is pain?What does it involve?
✤ Protection in the body region deemed to be under threat
✤ Perception of threat + normal biological response
✤ Multi-system
✤ nervous, immune, autonomic, endocrine
✤ there’s no pain system, message, receptors...
✤ Multi-dimensional
✤ physical, cognitive, emotional
✤ Biopsychosocial model in sport
Thursday, 5 February 15
16. Reconceptualisation
story
✤ Melzack & Wall
✤ Melzack -- pain matrix theory
✤ Pain as an output
✤ Mature Organism Model
(Gifford)
✤ Pain is emergent
✤ Salient network
Thursday, 5 February 15
17. ✤ Consider:
✤ Pain is not an accurate
indicator of tissue damage --
phantom limb pain
✤ Pain is allocated a ‘space’ -
cross the midline
✤ Pain is dynamic
✤ Accuracy of recall -- how well
do we recall a pain?
Thursday, 5 February 15
18. Influences on pain
✤ Context/Situation
✤ ‘the meaning’
✤ Emotional state
✤ Anxiety
✤ Stress
✤ Fatigue
✤ Prior experience of pain and injury
(they are different)
✤ Environment
✤ Who we are with
✤ Attentional bias
✤ Beliefs
Thursday, 5 February 15
19. Pain in sport
✤ Normal
✤ Expected
✤ Part of training and playing
✤ Accepted risk of injuries that hurt, BUT....
✤ What about the pain that doesn’t get better?
Thursday, 5 February 15
21. Injury moment
✤ Context
✤ Mechanism
✤ Meaning to the person
✤ Body responses
✤ Pain intensity
✤ Stress/anxiety/traumatic
✤ Early care
✤ Treatment choice
✤ Messages given
✤ Investigations
✤ Others’ responses
✤ facial
✤ verbal
Thursday, 5 February 15
22. Injury -- not in isolation
✤ The story
✤ The person
✤ Circumstance
✤ Priming factors
✤ Genetics -- epigenetics, vulnerability
✤ Fitness
✤ Body sense -- e.g. hypermobility
✤ Pre-existing sensitivity
✤ Fatigue
✤ Inflammation
✤ General health
✤ Prior experience of injury
✤ CLIMB OUT OF THE TISSUES
Thursday, 5 February 15
23. Responses to tissue damage
✤ Thoughts
✤ Acts
✤ protective
✤ Pain
✤ Change in motor control
✤ Healing
✤ Autonomic responses
✤ Inflammation -- immune
✤ Behaviours based upon beliefs
✤ Normal to hurt
Thursday, 5 February 15
24. There is no
pain system
Or pain signals
Or pain receptors
Thursday, 5 February 15
25. Pain persists
✤ Why?
✤ On-going perception of threat
✤ What are the perceived threats?
✤ Tissues are healing but pain persists
✤ Pain is not an accurate indicator of tissue damage
✤ Biological mechanisms e.g./ neuropathic pain --> central sensitisation
✤ Influences upon pain biology
Thursday, 5 February 15
28. Persisting pain features
✤ Pain
✤ Altered body sense
✤ Altered motor control
✤ Beliefs - Behaviours
✤ Thinking
Thursday, 5 February 15
29. Modern approach
✤ Consider whole person
✤ Understanding
✤ Skill development
✤ Coaching
✤ Pain dimensions
✤ Physical - cognitive - emotional
✤ How they interact
✤ Adaptations
✤ Cortical
✤ Loss of precision (disinhibition)
✤ Body systems that protect:
✤ Sensorimotor
✤ Nervous - immune
✤ Autonomic
Thursday, 5 February 15
30. Summary
✤ Pain is not an accurate indicator of tissue damage
✤ The meaning and context are key
✤ Early messages are vital
✤ Biology of pain + influences = how much it hurts
✤ Whole person | multi-system | multi-dimensional
Thursday, 5 February 15