BIS Corporation is a paint manufacturing company with eight plants and 17 warehouses that supplies products to 2,000 retail stores. The CEO wants to reengineer production, inventory, and logistics as the current single-tier distribution system results in low truck utilization and high costs. Consultants recommend a two-tier system with primary and secondary warehouses to improve customer service. This would require establishing 34 secondary warehouses, increasing inventory levels but reducing transportation costs to customers. The production strategy options are to produce all products at each plant or concentrate high-volume products at two plants per zone to reduce costs.
1. BIS Corporation- Case
Submitted by:-
Group-03
Khurshid Alam (PGDMA-0912)
Mala Mankotia (PGDMA-0915)
G. Swetha Reddy (PGDMA-0920)
2. SALIENT POINTS OF THE CASE
Bis Corporation is paint manufacturing company established in 1964, It has
now eight manufacturing plants and sell to 2000 retail stores.
Distribution system is single tier where product is produced in plants, stored in
17 warehouse and then to retail outlets
It has 12 shareholders and newly appointed CEO
It produces and sells about 400 SKUs at similar price. Gross margin is 20%
All the production and distribution strategies were formed 20 years ago and
were never modified. So new CEO wanted the supply chain to be modified
Reengineering of production, inventory and logistics functions should be
done.
CEO and share holders are not willing to construct new manufacturing plant.
Main problems faced by BIS Corporation:
Single tier network which causes low truck utilization and high transport costs.
No clarity that how inventory should be positioned 4000 SKUs.
No clarity about which product /product family should be produced in which
plant.
Low customer service.
So the consultancy has suggested 2 tier systems with primary and secondary
warehoses.It collected data for following:
- Demand for each product family
- Annual Production capacity at each plant
- Maximum capacity of warehouse
- Transportation costs
- Set up costs
- Potential locations
BIS has also done market survey and identified growth in its markets for each
product family.
Case Analysis:
Production Strategy: - BIS can select among the following strategies:
A. All products can be produced at every plant.
Advantages: 1.It will reduce transportation cost.
2. High customer service level.
Disadvantages: 1.High inventory level to be maintained.
2. High overhead cost.
B.Two production units in one zone’s, high volume low cost products can be
produced in each plant and low volume/demand can be produced at one production
plant out of two in each zone.
Advantages: 1.Reduction in inventory level.
2. Less overhead cost.
Disadvantages: 1.Comparitively high transportation cost.
2. Lower customer service
3. Ware house and distribution strategy:-
Fig- Assumed location of Production unit and W.H. (original)
WH
Production
units
Geog. Production Primary State *Secondary Retail zone
Zone unit WH WH
4 8 17 50 34 550
Total states in USA are 50 divided in to 4 zones. So each zone contains
approximately 12 states.
So we can assume that each zone of USA consists of 2 production units.
Three zones contain 4 warehouses each and one with 5 so total 17 warehouses is
distributed.
So each production unit is connected to 2 warehouses and each WH serves three
states.
Each state contains about 11 retail zones. So one WH have to serve to about 33
retail zones.
So it is difficult to serve all 3 states (33 retail zones) from only one WH with
satisfactory level of customer service.
Suggested strategy:
1 2 3 4
Legend:
Secondary
Production WH
Primary WH
unit
4. BIS Corporation can go for 2 -tier distribution network by establishing 34
secondary WH’s. Total 51 WH will be there. So on average each state will get one
WH. All the present WH will serve as primary WH each for 2 secondary WH and
the local retail zones.
Advantage:
High customer service level.
Low transportation costs to customer.
Drawbacks:
High inventory.
High set up costs.
High inbound transportation costs.
High maintenance costs.