A paper given at the "Towards a Philosophy of Life: Rethinking the Concept of Life in Continental Philosophy of Religion" conference at Liverpool Hope University (UK) on June 26 2009. I argue that Jack Caputo's weak theology is more thoroughly fictionalist than Jamie Smith's Reformed Radical Orthodoxy / catholic postmodernism. Caputo's theology therefore retains more fully the insights from a phenomenology of religion (undecidability of life, contingency of our interpretations of life) than Smith's theology does.