Overview of Social Media During Disaster and Crowd Power in Disaster Response
Prepared for Middlebury Institute of International Studies (MIIS) Disaster Response/Resilience Seminar
Presented by Catherine Graham
May 6, 2016
VIP Model Call Girls Hinjewadi ( Pune ) Call ON 8005736733 Starting From 5K t...
Middlebury Institute May 2016
1. May 6, 2016
Presented by: Cat Graham, Vice President Humanity Road
The Power of the CrowdThe Power of the Crowd
Overview of Social Media During Disaster
and Crowd Power in Disaster Response
Prepared for Middlebury Institute of International Studies (MIIS) Disaster Response/Resilience Seminar
Presented by Catherine Graham
May 6, 2016
Hashtag #HRHow
2. May 6, 2016
Presented by: Cat Graham, Vice President Humanity Road
About Us
Disaster Response – Information as Aid:
Disaster intelligence – situation reporting & special activations
Urgent Needs - public and partner requests for information.
Surge Support - community needs digital surge support assistance
Disaster Preparedness
Exercise development, Crowd simulation
Social Media Training and Support services
Process Improvement
Tools testing, subject matter expertise
Global 501c3 NGO public charity
Digital Disaster Response
Force Multipliers
Hashtag #HRHow
3. May 6, 2016
Presented by: Cat Graham, Vice President Humanity Road
a. Social Media Emergency Management
An overview on how information emerges in social media
b. Social Media and Disasters Volume and Velocity
An overview on Information and Knowledge Management
i. USA – Sandy
ii. Philippines - Typhoon Yolanda
iii. Nepal – Earthquake
iv. Tools and Technology – Data in Motion
c. Crowd Dynamics
The Power of The Crowd
Hashtag #HRHow
4. May 6, 2016
Presented by: Cat Graham, Vice President Humanity Road
Self Directed Work Team
Self Directed Work TeamSelf Directed Work Team
Hashtag #HRHow
5. May 6, 2016
Presented by: Cat Graham, Vice President Humanity Road
What is Social Media Emergency
Management?
SMEM
Hashtag #HRHow
6. May 6, 2016
Presented by: Cat Graham, Vice President Humanity Road
Still being defined
Hashtag #HRHow
Task – Search for any disaster
In progress today
Is there a hashtag?
Tacit Knowledge and Explicit KnowledgeTacit Knowledge and Explicit Knowledge
SMEM
7. May 6, 2016
Presented by: Cat Graham, Vice President Humanity Road
Citizens in the impact zone
Relatives & Friends outside the impact
zone relaying info
How Information Emerges in Social media
Absence of power does not mean, absence of communications or technology,
Emergency Management needs to be in social media even if its just to direct traffic to official pages.
Absence of power does not mean, absence of communications or technology,
Emergency Management needs to be in social media even if its just to direct traffic to official pages.
Accurate
information
SMEM
Hashtag #HRHow
8. May 6, 2016
Presented by: Cat Graham, Vice President Humanity Road
Mission
4636
launched
ICE SAR
Team Lands 23 Hrs
DAY 0
Social Media
Text to Canada
saves woman
under rubble
26 SAR teams
rescued 154 ppl
72 Hour Window of Survival
DAY 3 DAY 4 DAY 5 DAY 6DAY 1 DAY 2
Milot
Hospital
begins
receiving
patients
Case Study – Haiti First Days
ICE SAR
Arrives in
Leogane
Local
rescues
Month 1
Text Messages
Month 2
Month 3
Social Media
Milot Hospital
sends emails
Social Media
Tweet: ppl
alive under
rubble crying
for help
The 7.0 Quake that struck Haiti dramatically impacted how technology and social media can be used for disasterThe 7.0 Quake that struck Haiti dramatically impacted how technology and social media can be used for disaster
Mainstream
Media
Milot Hospital
need patients
SMEM
Hashtag #HRHow
9. May 6, 2016
Presented by: Cat Graham, Vice President Humanity Road
Evolution of Crisismapping
Cell Phone Battery Life
72 Hour of Survival
Voice lines saturated or broken
Philippines (Project Agos & eBanyihan by Ateneo University)
USA Hurricane Sandy
Nepal (Quake Map Kathmandu Living Labs + HOT OSM)
Christ Church NZ (EQNZ)
DAY 0 DAY 3 DAY 4 DAY 5DAY 1 DAY 2DRR Plan
2015
2014
2013
2012
2011
2010Haiti 4636
Disaster
IMKM
Hashtag #HRHow
10. May 6, 2016
Presented by: Cat Graham, Vice President Humanity Road
Christchurch
Earthquake
Feb 2011
New Zealand
•Infrastructure damage
•Evacuation Zones
•Medical Related
•Services Available
Chicago Snow
Map
Blizzard
Feb 2011
Chicago, IL USA
•Stranded people
•Blocked roads
•Abandoned vehicles
•Shovel brigades
Recovery
Alabama
Tornado Outbreak
May 2011
Alabama, USA
•Infrastructure damage
•Assistance Needed
•Solutions Offered
Early Days Crowdmap & Crisismapping
Good awareness but can create donation management issues if the lifecycle of the need isn’t managedGood awareness but can create donation management issues if the lifecycle of the need isn’t managed
SMEM
Hashtag #HRHow
11. May 6, 2016
Presented by: Cat Graham, Vice President Humanity Road
Good News NoGood News No
Casualties – Bad newsCasualties – Bad news
No Relief goodsNo Relief goods
Good News NoGood News No
Casualties – Bad newsCasualties – Bad news
No Relief goodsNo Relief goods
The public, operating through social media such as Twitter,
Facebook, YouTube become a source of information.
Data
Layers
Data
Layers
I-W
itness Reports
I-W
itness Reports
Crisismapping – Lifecycle of Synthesizing Data
SMEM
Hashtag #HRHow
Current data management is improving that lifecycle of informationCurrent data management is improving that lifecycle of information
12. May 6, 2016
Presented by: Cat Graham, Vice President Humanity Road
Nepal Crisismap Response
Verify x 2
SMEM
Lifecycle of
Synthesizing
Data
SUCCESS!
Hashtag #HRHow
In large scale events you are touching the same data points frequentlyIn large scale events you are touching the same data points frequently
13. May 6, 2016
Presented by: Cat Graham, Vice President Humanity Road
Information, Data and Process
Volume and Velocity
IMKM
Hashtag #HRHow
14. May 6, 2016
Presented by: Cat Graham, Vice President Humanity Road
Four V’s of #SMEM
IMKM
15. May 6, 2016
Presented by: Cat Graham, Vice President Humanity Road
Information, Data and Process
What is IM/KM
Information Management
and Knowledge Management
IMKM
16. May 6, 2016
Presented by: Cat Graham, Vice President Humanity Road
KM - SMEM
Response
IM- SMEM
Assessment
IMKM
Keeping the Human in Humanity
Hashtag #HRHow
17. May 6, 2016
Presented by: Cat Graham, Vice President Humanity Road
Effective IM/KM
IMKM
Hashtag #HRHow
Before After
18. May 6, 2016
Presented by: Cat Graham, Vice President Humanity Road
Data Mining – Time, Place, Event
Information is a vital form of aid
in itself. Disaster affected
people need information as
much as water, food, medicine,
or shelter.
IFRC World Disasters Report, 2005
Task – Search for __________
What Location?
What time & Date?
IMKM
19. May 6, 2016
Presented by: Cat Graham, Vice President Humanity Road
Twitter
Sandy
Social media management and listening becomes challenging in slow moving large scale events.Social media management and listening becomes challenging in slow moving large scale events.
Volume and Velocity –Sandy Twitter
Twitter saw a rise in
social media
beginning on Friday,
October 26th and
spiking on Monday,
October 29th with
up to 30,000 tweets
per hour as the
storm struck New
York and New
Jersey. Over
260,000 tweets
were recorded in the
New York Area
IMKM
Hashtag #HRHow
20. May 6, 2016
Presented by: Cat Graham, Vice President Humanity Road
Will always require human assistance to identify Gap Analysis in real time as well as low and no techWill always require human assistance to identify Gap Analysis in real time as well as low and no tech
Volume and Velocity – Local 211
Snapshot
31% (432 Cases) - resident is over 60 yrs old
17% (242 Cases) - at least one resident disabled
32% (454 Cases) - need mold remediation
22% (308 cases) – need drywall removed
Snapshot
31% (432 Cases) - resident is over 60 yrs old
17% (242 Cases) - at least one resident disabled
32% (454 Cases) - need mold remediation
22% (308 cases) – need drywall removed
The following anonymized
case samplings are presented
with permission and selected
from 1,400 cases that are
marked open as of March 20,
2013,
IMKM
Hashtag #HRHow
Local 211 - Saturation
21. May 6, 2016
Presented by: Cat Graham, Vice President Humanity Road
Report
Machine Assisted Monitoring – First 20 Days
Aggregate: In support of Typhoon YolandaPH
Humanity Road identified and aggregated,
1,000,000 tweets from the Philippines.
Filter: 1,000,000 tweet records were refined
to 40,000 potentially actionable.
Triage: The 40,000 tweet records were further
refined to 4,000 potentially actionable.
Export: The 4,000 tweet records were
reviewed, and actionable relevant content
exported into our situation report..
Report: Actionable and relevant content was
reported three ways,
1. Directly to the public
2. Public Situation Reports
3. Private activation reports
Volume and Velocity – YolandaPH (Haiyan)
IMKM
Hashtag #HRHow
Big Data
Strategic
Tactical
Data
22. May 6, 2016
Presented by: Cat Graham, Vice President Humanity Road
Timeline
DAY 0
72 Hour Window of Survival
DAY 9 DAY 12 DAY 15 DAY 18DAY 3 DAY 6
Urgent Needs tracking: Outputs: APAN, Reliefweb , Activation Partners
Landfall Day 1
DAY 20
Day 20
7-Nov 8-Nov 9-Nov 10-Nov 11-Nov 12-Nov 13-Nov 14-Nov 15-Nov 16-Nov 17-Nov 18-Nov 19-Nov 20-Nov 21-Nov 22-Nov 23-Nov 24-Nov
Relaying Urgent Needs
continues
Monitoring Hospital
Responses
Day 10
Big Data Analytics – YolandaPH (Haiyan)
IMKM
Hashtag #HRHow
23. May 6, 2016
Presented by: Cat Graham, Vice President Humanity Road
Big DataBig Data
StrategicStrategic
AnalysisAnalysis
Targeted DataTargeted Data
TacticalTactical
AnalysisAnalysis
Tools and Technology – Data in Motion
IMKM
24. May 6, 2016
Presented by: Cat Graham, Vice President Humanity Road
Hashtag #HRHow
Roleplaying – you be the stakeholdersRoleplaying – you be the stakeholders
25. May 6, 2016
Presented by: Cat Graham, Vice President Humanity Road
So what do you need to know?
Hashtag #HRHow
Role Play Today’s Disaster
26. May 6, 2016
Presented by: Cat Graham, Vice President Humanity Road
Hashtag #HRHow
Roleplaying – you be the stakeholdersRoleplaying – you be the stakeholders
1. Who is the official agency or agencies for this event?
2. Is your stakeholder active for this event?
3. What hashtags are they using
4. What content would be useful to them or other stakeholders?
27. May 6, 2016
Presented by: Cat Graham, Vice President Humanity Road
QUESTIONS?
Volunteers@humanityroad.org
Join us – Activate Us
Activate@humanityroad.org
Editor's Notes
We were founded in 2010 as the first of its kind nonprofit.
We mobilize on behalf of the public to provide information when they need it most.Self Directed work team collective behavior with training and a mission
With training, individuals with different skills and talents combine to work without the usual supervision. They are guided toward a common mission.
We maintain a roster of about 100 but also have surge teams and addition reserves.
Introduce yourself and tell me what your interests are in social media.
Social Media is still being defined.
The art of emergency management is a mature field of study and operations but social media emergency management is still in its infancy. It was after 2010 that officials began to encourage their staff to be in social media.
Academic programs continue to seek ways they can enhance their academic programs to catch up. But academic is explicit knowledge you can teach methods but nothing compares to experience.
When disaster strikes, information flows quickly and usually New Media carries the broadest footprint of information with the highest and broadest amount of detail.
It’s fast, timely and unfiltered.
Traditional Mainstream media, collects the data – formerly in person and phone, now via social media – culls, synthesizes and reports, may not be as accurate
Official Channels release information at a much slower pace, smaller amount, culls, confirms and reports – its highly accurate
On January 12 a 7.0 earthquake struck Haiti. Texts began to emerge from beneath the rubble of citizens trapped
In the first three days social media and the cell phones of loved one were saturated with information.
A crisis mapping effort emerged after the first 72 hours, but it wasn’t until day 5 that they could receive text messages.
We were fielding information on a hospital in the hills of Haiti that was undamaged, had beds, doctors and no patients.
In 2010 Mission 4636 was launched on Day 5 of the Earthquake in Haiti, After the Christ Church earthquake it was launched late after the first day and within 48 hours was transitioned to the local community and proved effective locally.
Nepal and the Philippines have both adopted digital platforms for information management of crowd contributed reports.
For Humanity Road part of our mission includes crisismapping – which helps improve situational awareness but can contribute to Donation Management Issues.
Chicago Snow map – Main stream media (Chicago Tribune) in partnership with the public & CERT
Recovery Alabama – Main stream media (Tuscaloosa News) won a Pulitzer
Christ Church – Technology Citizens – worked to combine two maps – SVArmy Born
Hurricane Irene – Broad effort, many states, multiple maps emerged
In real time, the public is sharing key information that is relevant and useful to disaster response agencies, aid agencies, civ-mil and humanitarians locally as well as globally.
Philippines have mastered the art of social media emergency management.
After Haiti, crowdsourcing was used by day four, after Sandy more than 30 crowdsourcing maps and efforts emerged. Philippines has Project Agos. They work in conjuction with the ETC cluster and under the PIO urgent needs are routed for solution.
Quakemap.org is an initiative led by Kathmandu Living Labs with onsite coordination support from NepalMonitor.org and remote support from Humanity Road.
The goal: match needs with ongoing relief efforts. As of Monday May 18, 2015 there were over 1800 reports on quakemap.org which have been processed and routed to more than 50 military and civilian aid organizations.
Disasters are local but have international complexities. A total of 65,462 people from 89 countries have visited the map and have accessed and viewed pages 206,751 times.
On today’s talk we’re focusing only on two areas – volume and velocity. Other areas include Variety and veracity.
Information is a vital form of aid in itself. Disaster affected people need information as much as water, food, medicine, or shelter.
Getting this information through the response chain is not always easy, verification is possible but it takes long hours of diligent research and verification steps.
What is Information management and knowledge management?
Social Media Emergency Management requires the ability to find the signal in the noise. But to find that signal you need to understand what your question is or what problem you are trying to solve. Information management relies on your ability to clearly state your knowledge management goal.
know before you go data diving what your knowledge goals are. Through discovery of data, information is identified, and knowledge builds. Eventually you achieve wisdom of the situation. When you have assessed enough you achieve a decision for your response and it helps to have others looking at the data at the same time.
Effective IM/KM management can influence the crowd.
Information is a vital form of aid in itself. Disaster affected people need information as much as water, food, medicine, or shelter.
Getting this information through the response chain is not always easy, verification is possible but it takes long hours of diligent research and verification steps and sometimes the help of technology tools. But don’t let the tools get in the way of the goal.
Sandy was a slow moving long term event with a large footprint.
Traffic built up slowly in social media across many states but when it hit landfall traffic spiked quickly. Social media mgt and listening becomes challenging in slow moving large scale events.
What would be your saturation point? Tweets averaged about 70,000 per day but spiked to 500k at landfall.
Twitter was not the only saturated communication channel – 211 was overwhelmed with case calls. They made a groundbreaking move to use Crisis Cleanup a tool created by Aaron Titus of Mormon Helping hands.
Finding data elements within your data stream depends on what you are looking for, examples would be
Private Sector data – what businesses are functioning
Vulnerable Population needs
Let’s take a look at Machine assisted monitoring.
This helps manage large quantities of data. I’m a SMEM archeologist – I’m looking for individual and specific pieces of information.
We currently are using a prototype tool (SBIR N121-092) being developed by Progeny Systems. which provided critical filtering capabilities that eliminated much of the noise.
Under this program, we have machine studied nearly 300 events including 49 hurricanes, 40 earthquakes and 22 tornadoes. We have analyzed approximately 100 Million tweets
But you can lift other useful data from SMEM – including patterns of saturation, or absence of communications.
Philippines have mastered the art of social media emergency management but for Haiyan they needed help with communications.
We work with with Philippines and 20 other nations under a Multinational Communications Interoperability program to help improve the disaster response model.
Effective IMKM involves both tactical response and strategic analysis. The communications footprint map we did for the Phillipines was the first of its kind. Social media contributes to highly useful data. For Vanuatu for Cyclone Pam it helped us create the first early impacts map.
On the tactical side we are searching for the signal or the absence of signal as you saw on the Haiyan research. But achieving this daily takes practice and not losing site of the everyday conversations in social media. Are you ready to give it try?
For our disaster de jour
Find your stakeholder in social media
Assign them a stakeholder card
Write a post (msg)
Find your stakeholder in social media