Presentation on status of Oceanic Blue Carbon science and knowledge gaps. Presented at the Global Ocean Commission's High Seas Symposium, 12 November 2015.
1. Oceanic Blue Carbon
GOC High Seas Symposium, 12 - 13 November 2015, Somerville College, Oxford
Doug Perrine
2. GabrielBarathieu
Chris Pincetich-Marine Photobank Øystein Paulsen - MAR-ECO
KeithEllenbogenOceana
Oceanic Blue Carbon explores a potential
connection between marine conservation and
climate change, with broad global relevance:
the conservation and restoration of the
marine environment – including populations
of sea turtles, whales, krill and tuna – as part
of the solution to the global climate challenge.
3. The concept was supported by three publications from late 2014.
4. The GOC report estimated amount and value of the biological carbon-
sequestering activity provided by the high seas to be:
• Almost half a billion tonnes of carbon per year
• Valued between USD $74 billion to $222 billion per year
AllenShimadaNOA
So what we are exploring now is understanding
the concept and refining that value.
5. LutzandMartin2014
For example, eight natural carbon pathways, pumps and trophic
cascades associated with marine vertebrates have been identified.
6. LutzandMartin2014
The primary apparatus used
in carbon flux research the
sediment trap, which sits on
the sea bed & collects
particles that drift to the
ocean floor.
One possible reason
that marine organisms
beside plankton have
largely been excluded
from carbon cycling
models.
Does not capture the movement of
carbon associated with marine
organisms, including deposition via
faecal events and sinking carcasses.
7. Heithaus et al. 2014
1. Trophic Cascade Carbon
E.g. natural predation by sharks controls sea turtle
populations, whose grazing behaviour maintains
optimal carbon function of seagrass meadows.
Food web dynamics help
to maintain carbon storage
& sequestration by coastal
ecosystems.
Disruption of marine vertebrate populations impacts natural
cycles; where this includes the role of marine ecosystems it
can reduce the oceans capacity to capture & store carbon.
8. 2. Biomixing carbon
Keith Ellenbogen, Oceana
Turbulence & drag associated
with movement of marine
animals mixes nutrient rich
water from deep to surface
waters, enhancing primary
production by phytoplankton &
thus uptake of atmospheric CO2.
This mechanism has been reported for all
sizes of marine including krill and whales.
9. 3. Bony fish carbonate
Wilsonetal.2009
As a by-product of their
metabolism, bony fish
secrete calcium carbonate,
which is alkaline.
Restoration of bony fish
populations can potentially
help to buffer against
increased acidity of the
ocean and protect some of
the organisms that are
susceptible to ocean
acidification.
10. Tony Wu4. Whale Pump
Some whales excrete nutrient rich, flocculent faecal plumes. These can fertilize
surface waters & nutrient-limited oceans to stimulate primary production by
phytoplankton, thus uptake of atmospheric carbon dioxide into oceans.
11. 5. Twilight Zone Carbon
SwedishMuseumofNaturalHistory
Deep water (twilight zone) fish feed on organisms in the upper ocean &
transport consumed organic carbon to deeper waters, where it is stored in
biomass or released as fish poop.
12. Amount and value of carbon sequestration by twilight zone fish off the UK-Irish
continental slope, from Trueman et al.:
• Over 1 million tonnes of carbon per year
• Between USD $12.4 and $21.8 million per year
Trueman et al. 2014
NOAA
NOAANOAA
NOAA
14. 8. Marine Vertebrate Mediated CarbonCatlin Seaview Survey
Marine vertebrates transfer organic carbon through marine food webs
and transport it to deep waters via rapidly sinking faecal material
Carbon particles associated with fish, e.g. tuna, are orders of magnitude larger
than those associated with plankton, & can rapidly sink to depth, providing an
efficient mechanism to export carbon from surface waters.
15. WWF2015
What is the biological-carbon sequestration
value of a living ocean versus a depleted one?
16. Gap analysis and targeted research
needed to advance scientific, policy
and economic understanding
NOAA
18. PeterProkosch
We also think it is important to keep a
connection to the other ocean
ecosystem values vital for coastal
communities:
• Sustainable development
• Food security
• Connections to EEZs
19. RebeccaWeeks-MarinePhotobank
Fish Carbon report: www.grida.no/publications/fish-carbon
Follow on twitter: #FishCarbon
Steven Lutz
GRID-Arendal
steven.lutz@grida.no
Angela Martin
Blue Climate Solutions
angela.martin@bluecsolutions.org
Thank you!
Questions?
Hello there, my name is Steven Lutz and i represent GRID-Arendal, a Norwegian foundation and a centre collaborating with the United Nations Environment Programme.
I’m going to talk about Oceanic Blue Carbon, a concept which explores the role of living marine life - marine vertebrates and invertebrates - in the global climate challenge.
The concept was supported by three publications from late last year; the
‘Fish Carbon - Exploring Marine Vertebrate carbon Services’ report produced by GRID-Arendal and Blue Climate Solutions, the
‘The Significance and Management of Natural Carbon Stores in the Open Ocean’ report produced by the IUCN and the
‘The High Seas and US’ produced by the GOC.
The concept explores a potential connection between marine conservation and climate change, with broad global relevance: the conservation and restoration of the marine environment – including populations of sea turtles, whales, krill and tuna – as part of the solution to the global climate challenge.
As you know that the value of the carbon-sequestering activity provided by the life in the high seas to be worth from USD $74 billion to $222 billion annually.
So what we are exploring now is the understanding the concept and refining that value.
Define Fish Carbon
Sediment trap
For example, eight mechanisms have been identified where marine vertebrates have roles to play in mitigating the effects of global carbon pollution via natural carbon pathways, pumps and trophic cascades.
Define Fish Carbon
Sediment trap
Our first example is Trophic Cascade Carbon. This mechanism highlights how food web dynamics help maintain the carbon storage and sequestration function of coastal Blue Carbon ecosystems. The natural predation of sharks helps maintain healthy populations of sea turtles which in turn helps maintain optimal carbon function of seagrass meadows through grazing behaviour. However if sharks are overfish it potentially upsets nature’s balance including the role of seagrasses in fixing and storing carbon.
Biomixing Carbon describes how turbulence and drag mixes nutrient rich water from deep to surface waters, enhancing primary production by phytoplankton and thus the uptake of dissolved CO2
This mechanism has been reported for all sizes of marine including krill and whales.
Research into this mechanism has estimated that the value of carbon sequestration of bentho-pelagic fish of the UK continental slope to be between USD $12.4 and 21.8 million annually.
What we don’t know, or what is needed to advance our understanding of Oceanic Blue Carbon, includes gap analysis and targeted research projects that will advance scientific, policy, economic understanding of the concept.
Key questions include what is the total significance of Oceanic Blue Carbon and do we have the ability to value it?
We also think it is important to keep a connection to the other ocean ecosystem values vital for coastal communities such as sustainable development and food security and to acknowledge the connections to EEZs.
If you are interested in learning more about the concept, please contact me, Steven or Angela, through the details shown here, or come speak to us after.
We also have Fish Carbon flyers and reports available. You can also follow the development of this concept on twitter thought the fish carbon hashtag and graphics and diagrams are available.
Thank you.