This document discusses the effects of soft drinks on teeth. It notes that soft drinks are highly cariogenic due to their high sugar content, with a typical can containing over 40g of sucrose. The acids in soft drinks also cause dental erosion. Studies have found that children who increased their consumption of soft drinks over time had higher rates of tooth decay. Teenagers are especially at risk due to their immature enamel. While modifications could potentially make soft drinks less harmful, such as removing caffeine and acids or replacing sugar, it is best to minimize soft drink consumption to reduce risks to dental health.
2. Introduction
The high cariogenicity of soft drinks is recognized by
all dental professionals as well as dieticians, and
follows on from the accepted role of refined
carbohydrates, particularly when sucrose, in caries
process
3. Definition
Dental caries is defined as an “irreversible disease
of calcified tissues of teeth, characterized by
demineralization of the inorganic portion and
destruction of the organic substance of the tooth,
which often leads to cavitation”.
-Shafer’s Textbook of Oral Pathology
6. When sucrose intake exceeds 15 to 20kg per
person per year, such intake is directly associated
with increasing caries prevalence, particularly
when sucrose is consumed between meals
With a sucrose content typically in the range of 10-
12%, a 375ml can contains in excess of 40g of
sucrose, thus one can of sugared soft drink per
day for one year will itself account for 15kg of
sucrose per year
8. Caffeine
Caffeine is added to soft drinks generally to contribute to the
complex flavor
9. Health Issues
The combination of caffeine with erosive acids and
either sucrose or artificial intense sweeteners
raises a number of issues beyond an elevated risk
of dental caries and dental erosion
Caffeine also increases secretion of gastric acid
and increase urine output, giving a diuresis which
can impact negatively on fluid balance and thus
lower resting salivary flow, ph. and buffer capacity,
with consequential effects on oral health
10. It is worth remembering that drinks which are
consumed slowly over a longer time period will
warm from refrigerator temperature to room
temperature and then to body temperature.
As this temperature increase occurs, enamel
mineral loss per unit time will increase, and enamel
hardness will decrease, approximately linearly with
temperature
11.
12. Susceptibility
With the consumption of acidic, carbohydrate rich
soft drinks, teenagers are at high risk for caries
development, which can be quite aggressive. 8 to
17-year-old children are at greatest risk
13. The newly erupted enamel in teenagers is
immature, and the crystalline structure is porous,
chalky, and easily penetrated and dissolved by
acids
Even in the absence of carbohydrates, soft drinks
can be destructive to teeth. These acidic, or low
pH, beverages can contribute to the
demineralization of dental hard tissues
15. Soft drinks have ortho-phosphoric acid while diet
soft drinks contain both ortho-phosphoric acid and
citric acid
Ortho-phosphoric acid will dissolve the protective
pellicle layer deposited by saliva onto teeth, and
will etch both enamel and dentine
Citric acid sequesters calcium ions from saliva,
preventing re-mineralization, etches dentine, and
causes dental erosion. The combination of these
various acids give a low ph.
16. Study (Marshal et al, 2008)
Trained dentists and interviewers examined a
representative sample of 369 children, aged 3 to 5
years, in 2002-2003 and again two years later. They
assessed caries by using the International Caries
Detection and Assessment System
Soft drinks, 100 percent fruit juice and milk represented
the sugared beverages consumed. A cluster analysis of
the relative proportion of each drink at baseline and
follow-up revealed four consumption patterns
17. The authors found that children who changed from
being low consumers of soft drinks at baseline to
high consumers after two years had a 1.75 times
higher mean number of new decayed, missing and
filled tooth surfaces compared with low consumers
of soft drinks
18.
19. The Future- Dentally safe
drinks?
Chemical Modifications
Removal of caffeine
Reduction in the levels of acidity
Replacement of sucrose with low glycemic index
non-cariogenic sucrose replacements like
Isomalt
If it is possible to supplement with as much as
40mmol/L calcium and 30mmol/L phosphate ion,
then despite their ph. Being below the critical ph.
threshold they should not erode the enamel and
dentine because the calcium and phosphate will
saturate the drink with respect to apatite mineral
20. To achieve significant concentrations of these ions,
a phosphor-protein stabilizer is essential. Casein
phosphopeptide-stabilized amorphous calcium
phosphate (CPP-ACP) can produce high levels of
bio-available calcium and phosphate
This has already been shown with sports drinks
such as PowerAde, where adding CPP-ACP
reduced beverage’s erosivity without affecting its
taste
21. Precautions
Rinsing with water may help reduce the risk of
decay and erosion as well. If you are very thirsty
after playing sport or working outdoors, drink some
water first. This will replenish your saliva which in
turn will help to dilute and neutralize the acid.
Use a straw where possible
However, it is always best to minimize the amount
and number of times per day you drink soft drinks
22. Conclusion
Soft drinks are potentially cariogenic; however,
young children still can consume them more safely
if the exposure is reduced and dental plaque is
removed regularly with a fluoridated dentifrice
As dental professionals, we need to educate our
patients about the consequences of soft drink
consumption and provide suggestions to minimize
the risk
23. References
Marshall and Amid I. Ismail Anita M et al;
Cariogenicity of Soft Drinks, Milk and Fruit
Juice in Low-Income African-American
Children : A Longitudinal Study; JADA 2008;
139(7): 959-967
Pamela R. Erickson, D.D.S., Ph.D., Deanna
L.Alevizos, D.D.S., M.S. and Darcy J.
Rindelaub, D.D.S.; Soft Drinks: Hard on Teeth
Professor Laurence J. Walsh; Black cola
drinks, oral health and general health: An
evidence based approach; School of dentistry,
University of Queensland